Blue Union set to resume protests

, 5 June, 250comments  |  Jump to most recent
Nothing has changed despite finishing 7th
Following their suspension of any further matchday protest during the 2011-12 season back in March, after the team performances had improved significantly, the Blue Union has announced it intends to resume peaceful protests with immediate effect.

The Blue Union remains totally committed to continuing their campaign for change in terms of the senior management team and ownership of Everton FC, a change that they believe is essential in safeguarding both the present and the future of the club.

The financial situation at the club remains a precarious one. All the signs are that once again the manager is going to be forced to operate on a ?sell-to-buy-with-a-limited-percentage-of-the-proceeds' strategy this summer — a modus operandi the Blue Union consider to be completely unacceptable, unsustainable and ultimately of potentially disastrous consequence.

The BU believes the pressure needs to be cranked up, the tough questions once again need to be asked, and the custodians of Everton Football Club need to be held to account on their performance of the previous decades, a ?performance' that is seeing Everton fall further and further away from the Premier League elite with each passing season.

Despite a lack of tangible success over the last 20 years, Everton Football Club remains one of the biggest in the country. Biggest in terms of success, biggest in terms of heritage, biggest in terms of global recognition, biggest in terms of some of the legends that have graced the shirt, and, most importantly of all? biggest in terms of support.

As Evertonians, the BU believe that it is their duty to do all they can in attempting to ensure that the club is once again able to compete with the best and at very least halt the financial mismanagement that is inevitably going to lead to the manager running out of miracles at some point in the non-too-distant future.

Restating Aims

To avoid any further confusion, the BU are also taking this opportunity to restate their aims.

The Blue Union are totally opposed to selling the club to the first or just ?any' individual or group who shows an interest in purchase, which is a commonly peddled fallacy. Their view is, and always has been, that the search for new ownership and the subsequent decision on who the club should be sold to should be taken out of the hands of the current board of directors, a board who, it shouldn't be forgotten, are adamant that the club is for sale.

Over a period of a decade, this is a board who have FAILED to secure investment, FAILED to find a buyer, and have consistently failed to deliver schemes that they had previously heralded as ?deliverable' and ?viable'. The BU now call on the Board of Directors to place on public record a statement of intent outlining the sale process, with caveat to protect the history and traditions of Everton Football Club's past and its vision for the future.

In place of the Everton Board — assuming of course that they are genuine in their intention to sell the club — BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton — an ownership that can demonstrate a viable plan to secure the financial and cultural future of the club.

Enough is enough. Nothing has changed in terms of the financial predicament of the club. Nothing has moved forward in terms of finding a solution to deliver a modern fit-for-purpose facility through which we can increase matchday revenue streams. Nothing has changed in terms of the spin, disdain and pure contempt aimed towards the fans from the senior management team outlined by the hacked and leaked email scandal which rocked the club in November. Nothing has changed in terms of finding the new owners or investment that we are expected to believe that our Chairman has desperately been seeking for the last 10 years. Nothing will ever change unless the fans come together and show a courage and unity to do something about these things and demand better.

The BU believe that this season they need to step their protests up, in size and frequency, and they need to let their voices be heard louder than ever, under the clarion call, ?It's time for change?.

The BU plan to resume the fight to rid the club of the managed decline and failures that have blighted the current board's tenure.

The Blue Union urge all Evertonians to ?Stand Together' with them as they seek to lift Everton Football Club back up to where it belongs at the peak of English football.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Blue Union



Reader Comments (250)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


James Cadwaladr
1 Posted 05/06/2012 at 15:10:48
Let's start a sweep on when they give up this season. I'll start ? Mid-September.

I agree with what they stand for but how they have gone about things so far has been awful.

Stop blowing smoke up your and everyone's arses, get a strategy, plan it, execute what you plan communicate what's going on. Public meetings behind four walls are all well and good but get nowhere when nothing is done outside of those walls.

Despite the enemy being the Board, respect them rather than offend and patronise them try and communicate effectively with them rather than getting their backs up. Whatever you think of them, they are bigger and more powerful than the Blue Union and thus will make fools out of BU a bit like they did last season.

Hope the BU learnt their lesson but I doubt it.

Ciarán McGlone
2 Posted 05/06/2012 at 15:24:55
Respect the board James?

Respect is earned.

James Cadwaladr
3 Posted 05/06/2012 at 15:37:22
Yes, respect them. treat them with some respect. We do not want to become what Blackburn supporters were last season. That was bang out of order.

By treating them with some respect maybe the BU will get further than they did last year, when, when all is said and done the BU were put in their place. I started off as a supporter of the BU but over time disagreed with how they went about things. I am not the only one. The BU lost plenty of support.

Michael Kenrick
4 Posted 05/06/2012 at 15:41:37
The original source is well-written call to arms. It will be interesting to see if they can rekindle interest to the same levels as before... when really they need to ramp it up significantly beyond those levels to get past the critical mass.

I can't see that a strategy of appeasement with the Board would work at all, James. You are right that the Board has more power, and that will always be the case until a more significant proportion of Evertonians actively and vocally back the BU cause.

The key sentence for me is: "Nothing has changed in terms of the spin, disdain and pure contempt aimed towards the fans from the senior management team." It will clearly take only something massive to change that.

Liam Reilly
5 Posted 05/06/2012 at 15:54:10
Although I understand and agree with the BU in principle, they have to be realistic in their aspirations, where forming a group of individuals with a mission to sell the club is just not practical.

I cannot think of one solitary reason why the board would agree to such a request. Who are these individuals, what qualifies them and what's in it for them (no one works for nothing)? If they are to travel to meet or to host potential investors, who picks up the expenses (maybe other operating costs)? How long should the club pick up the tab before deciding it's not working out?

Like it or not the current custodians hold the key to any sale, so the BU need to work with them, not alienate them. Work towards a voice at the table, towards understanding the current failings and work collectively to secure the investment required.

Mark Riding
6 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:41:02
Next seasons team:
1, Howard
2, Neville / Hibbert
3, Distin
4, Jags
5, Duffy
6, Gibson
7, Pienaar
8, Rodwell / Barkley
9, Jelavic
10, Hoilett
11, Osman
Bench: Coleman, Gueye, ones not used above.

NOT Included, Fellani, Baines, Heitinga, Cahill.
£50m in transfers OUT - IN around £6m spent on Pienaar. Hoilett on virtually a free..
£200k at least saved on wages...

Watch this space !

Karl Howard
7 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:51:44
Spot on, James.
Carl Sanderson
8 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:46:20
I hope The Blue Union is successful. I hope they press their case in an articulate and convincing way. I hope they won't go quiet if the team goes on a good run in the league or Cup. I hope they get a fair hearing from the support and a fair crack of the whip from the media. And I hope they can convince some of the people who applauded the Chairman at Goodison last season ? something I still can't quite believe I witnessed.
Barry Rathbone
9 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:22:13
I admire the BU; the morass of apathy makes it a thankless task.

The countless junior management wallahs among our fans sniping with platitudes and condescension without doing anything themselves makes me sick.

Read "that interview"; Kenwright is not a man for running this club (or any club)... if you can't see it and think he's up for genuine dialogue with fans, you're delusional.

It is a real David-and-Goliath task the BU have delivering the message that Kenwright and this board are doing nothing other than damage. Evertonians who know the score should be ashamed for criticising them.

Richard Reeves
10 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:36:33
There must be a lot of resentment towards the Blue Union from the Board, and particularly Kenwright, so I'm not so sure there will be any sitting round tables and working together... but I don't understand the negativity towards the Blue Union from our own supporters.

They may have made mistakes but ultimately they have been trying to expose the failures of the Board and force a sale to someone with a bussiness plan who is capable of running the club. It's a difficult job getting everyone on side ? as we witnessed on sheep-clapping day.
Richard Reeves
11 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:59:23
Barry Rathbone, Agree 100%.
Gary Carter
12 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:53:32
Personally I find the Blue Union quite tiresome now. Any credibility they had was lost when they leaked the meeting they had with Billy Liar.

They squawk on about the club needing to answer difficult questions when they seem to offer no solution to the problem we have (being skint), no plan as to how they will achieve anything that the current imbeciles can't seem to. They also choose to ignore the fact that most of the teams in the Premier League sell their best players unless they have sugar daddy owners.

The way they ambushed Billy Liar outside Goodison and childishly heckled him was pathetic and nothing short of schoolboy bully tactics! They are basically like the board but quite frighteningly seem to offer even less... Other than romantic notions of what they perceive the clubs stature to be, and telling the world we are skint, and will have to sell our best players, I'm not sure they offer anything positive whatsoever.
Liam Reilly
13 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:57:35
No ones suggesting change isn't required Barry, but trying to replace a failed business model with a weak alternative won't get anywhere. The custodians won't give up their investment without a return and why should they? Don't give me if BK was a true Blue blah blah ? it's a business and one where they won't let it go cheaply.

Because of what happened last season, the BU lost a lot of its credibility; that needs to be rebuilt, with a fresh approach to the problem ? and maybe fresh faces too.

Gareth Humphreys
14 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:04:08
Is it fair to say that Man Utd, Liverpool and Blackburn have better supporters than Everton? I think Aston Villa at home last season suggested that that is the case.

Bill Kenwright's picture was put on the screen and, instead of there being 30,000 people letting him know what they feel, the majority of the people who did anything, applauded him. That is the apathy and downright stupidity that the Blue Union are up against: not only is the fight against the crooks in the boardroom, it is also against the sheep in the stands.
Gareth Humphreys
15 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:13:52
James Cadwallader ? what could they have done differently?
Ged Alexander
16 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:14:33
Or, Gareth, the fans are not apathetic at all. Rather, they disagree with BU.
Gareth Humphreys
17 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:15:44
Gary Carter ? why do you suggest the meeting was leaked? As I understand it there was never any confidentiality agreement in place. The BU's job isn't to answer difficult qustions that the board can't answer ? it's so ask why the board can't answer them and what the long term plans are for a club with 130 years of history, £80m turnover and being outspent by Rushden & Diamonds. The "ambush" outside Goodison was simple questions being asked ? why are you trying to dress it up any differently?
Roberto Birquet
18 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:09:36
BU view is that the search for new ownership and the subsequent decision on who the club should be sold to should be taken out of the hands of the board of directors, a board who are adamant that the club is for sale.
----------------
The way to do that is surely to buy out the shares temporarily, and then find a buyer yerselves.

-------------
....
The Blue Union urge all Evertonians to ?Stand Together' with them as they seek to lift Everton Football Club back up to where it belongs at the peak of English football.
------------------
But you don't speak for me.
And to "stand together" would surely require some democracy in which you prove yourselves as representing the majority of fans.

Get a manifesto together, then put yourselves forward as an alternative to the board, and on the basis of the manifesto then raise the readies from fans to buyout the current one. Then - assuming the manifesto states you will seek out a rich so and so - you can go look for the elusive billionaire.

But the idea that a self-appointed group just takes over a board - a board that has invested its own dosh - is nonsense. Yeah, I know all the arguments - even platitudes that another accuses others of - that the board is NOT Club, that we all are.

But until. you stump up the cash and show you are US, you simply don't have the right to takeover the club, as you frankly ridiculously suggest.

Alan Maher
19 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:12:02
Gary Carter, I couldn't agree with you more. They bring absolutely nothing to the table, let alone offer any realistic plans. In all fairness, what club is going to solely listen to a minority of their supporters anyway? ? especially if they feel they are being bullied into it?

Don't get me wrong: the need for investment is a must if we are to challenge for Champions League places but to start all this nonsense before we have even started pre-season is ludicrous. Other than the top 5 clubs from last season, the rest of Premier League teams are in the same boat of having to sell to get players in.
Nick Waters
21 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:36:16
Jesus guys! The BU are fans ? not an alternative board ? and fans that are prepared to work hard at putting pressure on the incompetent barnacles that are running the club down, investing nothing of their own, selling anything that's fixed and borrowing against future income streams.

What ? may I ask James, Gary, Liam and Alan ? do you expect a group of fans to do beyond highlighting the incompetence of these directors and rallying support?

What has changed at the club to make the BU now the enemy? What are you guys doing as an alternative? Is carping and sniping at fellow fans the answer to halting the slide?
Jamie Barlow
22 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:42:14
Alan, we're having to sell to keep the club going, not to buy new or other players. That's the difference between us and other clubs. Unless Moyes keeps pulling gems out of the bag, we'll have fuck all else to sell in 3 to 4 years time.

Still, the majority will be sat on their arses doing nothing.

Liam Reilly
23 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:48:47
Nick,
I've stated twice above that I agree with the need for change but with a sensible alternative. The board won't agree to letting a group of individuals who have no shareholding or stake in the business, to sell the club on their behalf and to finance their expenditure whilst they do it. It's madness to suggest otherwise.

The BU is a good idea, but its solution to the problem doesn't hold water.

Roberto Birquet
24 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:46:51
Nick 431
This for me means they want to be the new board: In place of the Everton Board, BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton.
----------------------------------------------
And borrowing against income streams is for the running of the club: players' wages etc. It's called borrowing. We'd love to earn the dosh not to require that, but don't.

Whatever else ? and I do recognise big failures (the huge wasted opportunity that was King's Dock rather than not finding a buyer) ? the board/club is not asset stripping; it's not profiteering. The accounts are available. The club makes a loss. We sold players net last year to pay some of that back to the banks, which are in general far worse run than our club. And that is likely the main reason for calling time on our debts last year.

Gareth Humphreys
25 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:54:12
Roberto, have you had too much Pimms? Where do they state they are going to take over the club?
Philip Quilliam
26 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:46:02
Who will the Blue Union point to as examples of getting it right when the backers of City and Chelsea decide they need new toys or when the massive debts hanging round Man Utd kill any semblance of a sensible business plan?

I think that Arsenal are the only club getting it anywhere sensible and look what their fans think of their "lack of success".

One possible solution for the Blue Union ? why not do what Utd supporters did and start your own new "Everton" from scratch then you can run it any way that you want.
Gareth Humphreys
27 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:59:31
Alan Maher, their role is to highlight that that there is nothing on the table. Some people like easting with their eyes shut though at Goodison.

Stoke, QPR & Sunderland. Just 3 clubs for you to consider that don't need to sell to purchase.
Gareth Humphreys
28 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:04:08
Ged Alexander - I think that's the same thing.
Nick Waters
29 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:55:47
Roberto, finding ways of increasing revenue rather than finding loans at eye watering rates of interest is where the board should be devoting their energies.

How can you write that the BU wanting to find an independent and autonomous board equates to them wanting to be the board? That's quite simply twisting words.

In any case are you in favour of no voice of protest against Kenwright and his fellow directors and other interested parties? That's not a snide remark - your position isn't clear, that's all.

Gerry Morrison
30 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:09:05
Stoke, QPR and Sunderland. Which one of them would you want to trade places with?
Gareth Humphreys
31 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:05:03
Liam Reilly, you state "The board won't agree to letting a group of individuals who have no shareholding or stake in the business, to sell the club on their behalf and to finance their expenditure whilst they do it. It's madness to suggest otherwise."

The scenario above accurately describes administration and in this parlous financial state is not a million miles away.
Gareth Humphreys
32 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:10:21
Roberto, have you just sat down and typed that the board is not asset stripping? I doubt they are doing it to line their own pockets but there are no assets left. None.
Gareth Humphreys
33 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:13:48
Gerry, if you are asking that question in a financial sense then my answer is Stoke, QPR and Sunderland.
Liam Reilly
34 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:16:11
Gareth,
The club is not in administration and until it is (which is unlikely when you look a the onfield assets), why would the board consider financing someone else to sell it for them?

The facts are clear, we need to sell to stay afloat at present and that is not attractive for an investor. As I stated above, this is a time for creating dialog with the board and working with them to establish where the issues are with investment, not to alienate them, because there is only one winner there.

Steve Cotton
35 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:57:26
The apologists on here for the current regime are the reason that this club will keep falling down the table. DM can only do miracles for so long, as long as good young players are coming through the Academy etc.

We don't want to see the board go the way of the RS by spending £110 million in 15 months just to win the Carling Cup on penalties against a lower league team; we can never be a Chelsea, Man Utd, Man City, Arsenal... but we can be a Spurs or a Newcastle.

The BU have no well recognised public names associated with them and the apathy of the idiots clapping Kenwright on the Goodison screen must have made them feel like giving up. I don't want a millionaire owner, I just want the club run properly: I just want a shirt deal that netts us par with the top ten clubs; I just want a bit of hope every season not a deep-down feeling that Bill is working 24/7 to keep the banks happy and make sure his fellow investors get their bumper payout when it happens.

Anyone here who seriously is happy with the buffoon Kenwright, please hold your hand up... Yes, Gary, you start the slow handclap.....
Paul Thompson
36 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:05:33
No-one is calling the Blue Union 'the enemy'. However, its sometimes clumsy tactics have succeeded in making an enemy of much of the fan base ? who, for their pains, are then written off as apathetic, fools or stooges.

As a number of posters have already noted, the central demand ? that the sale of the club be handed over to 'a completely autonomous group of professionals' is absurd and simply will not happen. That's not a good start for a new strategy.

Pressure from the BU and elsewhere would be best achieved by keeping the 'time for change message' simple and avoiding the temptation to indulge in ill-thought-out business plans.

Liam Reilly
37 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:26:22
Who are the apologists for the current regime Steve; some folk are just stating the facts?

I want a change in ownership just like the next man, but the board will never agree to the BU terms because they are protecting their investment and don't make any sense. The fact that they have put no money in is immaterial, they own the club and it is a business, so are looking for no doubt an inflated price for their piece of the the Premier League gravy train.

Do you thinik Philip Green gives a shit about what the supporters think? Only by working with them, will we ever oust them.

Anthony Manning
38 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:36:38
Gary Carter, I find it confusing that you say the BU lost it`s credibility when they leaked the meeting with "Billy Liar" ? if he`s a liar like you say, then why do you have a problem with the BU trying to expose him as one!?!
Gareth Humphreys
39 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:37:26
Liam, let's work on the assumption that they can't be worked with. Where does that leave anyone who is still not happy with the situation?

Gareth Humphreys
40 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:45:58
Paul Thomson, I agree with you in that I think the BU's hope that someone will be brought in to sell the club is folly. That would only happen at the request of the creditors and, as BK said less than 12 months ago though, he is working with the bank "not to kill us". Begs the question: How long before that happens?

I know the BU's heart is in the right place and, to be fair to them, it is not a closed shop ? anyone who wants to put forward an idea is more than welcome to do so.

Tom Owen
41 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:37:38
I really don't understand the criticism the BU receives. It is astonishing that Evertonians still to this day support the board of directors. And then there's one Evertonian who says "Despite the enemy being the Board, respect them rather than offend and patronise them try and communicate effectively with them rather than getting their backs up."

Respect the board of directors? For starters, it's up for debate whether they should do? Have they earned the right to be respected? And it's also another debate do the board respect the fans?
Communicate effectively? Are you being serious. I'm not even going to go into detail about that.

It'll be too late before the majority of Evertonians wake up and notice what a shambles the whole thing is.

Steve Smith
42 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:20:41
To expect the current board to hand over control of the sale of the club to a third party (á la H&G and the epic swindle) is pie in the sky, especially coming from a group that has little credibility with the vast majority of match-going supporters.

You can say that majority are sheep or apathetic, but that's bollocks imo: a large part of our fanbase dislikes the mob mentality (perceived or real) that seems to emanate from BUs antics last season, and was probably one of the reasons that Kenwright was applauded when his mug appeared on screen.
Christopher Kelly
43 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:35:19
I have been off TW for a bit but the BU and The Board always make my blood boil because I feel like this board has wasted many years of my life and probably has shaved a few more off at the end from relentess stress and agony...

Regardless, the board have no OBLIGATION to talking with the BU (esp. after the way the BU began their shrouded approach to derailing the regime). The only way forward for them is to make an open, honest, public approach, and hope to get the media and the fans on their side...

The issue is of course the apathy of the fans to really put pressure on the board. I'll tell you what, if the season started today, we'd have literally a 0.1% chance of winning the league (esp. if we can't re-sign Pienaar and rely on strange loan mercenaries). The ONLY exciting stuff that could happen would be a cup run of some sort. I personally don't get off on fighting for 7th or 8th or beating Liverpool although that is fun (it is a little sick at how excited I get at seeing them fail. And talking shit to strangers wearing their jersey is fun too).

The apathy comes from the board literally grinding down the fan base and lowering expectations of the whole club. 12 going on 13 years of the same BS will do that to anyone. And also, just as importantly, they will never leave because they don't have to. They're not losing money personally, in fact they're in the black. Plus, there is NO buyer in the world who will buy this team with no assets, that loses money and can't lower their asking price because Kenwright and his puppet handlers are leveraged to the hilt. Everton are a used, 2008 Volvo that needs a tuneup with the ticket price of a brand new Porsche. Would you buy it?

The only solution that I see is that the financial fair play thing actually holds water (sort of like a salary cap that we have here in the US for some sports). A boycott sure would work but that will never happen because the fans can't stay away. Otherwise, get geared up for the cups and hope that we can make a run in one of them. Other than that, get a dog and start enjoying Saturdays again!

Edward Boyd
45 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:00:42
Didn't the Redshite get outside help to sell their club? And rescue them from Hicks & Gilette... or was that the banks? If so please let the banks rescue Everton.
Kevin Tully
46 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:58:01
Nick #341 ? spot on. If anyone dares to highlight the failings of the bluff-merchants running the club, they are then asked to publish their own business plan to turn the club around.

Guess what, guys: some businesses are basket cases; unless the club can unearth an investor or "sugar daddy", we might be heading for the Championship ? look how quickly Leeds sank.

All I know is that we cannot borrow from high street lenders, and we have to go abroad for funds for the day-to-day running of the club. We have a board who will not invest or put up their own collateral for loans; we have mortgaged future revenues on the back of Sky TV payments.

The manager cannot plan for next season ? and none of us know the financial reality of the situation, or who else is involved with the club?

It is all a murky financial shambles, and their detractors want the BU to come up with the answer.

When the public found out what the Banks were up to, did you say "Don't crtiticise unless you have the answers"? ? This is the same situation in my view: we know the club is being run into the ground, but please don't expect the solution in a few paragraphs on a fans forum.

Steve Cotton
47 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:04:55
Spot on, Chris, we are not all demanding the next billionaire; all we want is to not have to sell our best players every year to:

a) keep the banks happy;
b) compensate for falling attendances;
c) give the manage some leverage to bring hopefully a bargain player in or a couple of last minute freebees.

The spiral is self-perpetuating: if we sell our best players, we will not perform as well, the young fans won't have an idol, and shirt sales and attendances will keep falling.

Last year, people were saying the only way to get our message to Kenwright that we are unhappy is to vote with our feet... which we did; the fall in revenue then results in more pressure to sell the assets.

It doesn't take much to kick-start a bit of excitement, but it takes a huge effort to keep a sinking boat afloat.

To everyone who thinks the BU are wasting their time... then please tell us what YOU would do?
No AGMs anymore... no fan liaison team... no incentive to listen to the fans or keep them informed. This apathy is probably too far gone...

Roberto Birquet
48 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:20:17
Gareth 347
No, can't stand the stuff. And already answered the second question at the top of 346.
Jay Harris
49 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:09:47
Let's be honest here: if any of you critics of the BU would have put the time and energy in to try and improve the running of EFC, we would not even be having this debate.

Q1: IS there anybody who is happy with the running of a football club which is making between £5 and 20 million a year losses and has been since the day Kenwright took over (having previously made a profit, BTW)?

Q2: Can anybody be happy with a Chairman who claims he does not know where £24 million a year is going (up from 1 million a year when he took over)?

Q3: Does anybody honestly believe that Kenwright and the "Friends of Everton" are really trying to sell their shares in the club at a fair price?

Q4: Does anybody believe Kenwright is honest?

Nobody ? not even the BU ? are asking the board to relinquish their control of the club; they are simply being asked to allow a specialist team to find a buyer for the club on reasonable terms.

I wrote to the BU this morning suggesting that, rather than protest, they draw up a petition for supporters to sign asking for the changes that I believe most of us would like to see. And, if the board will not listen to that, present it to the media.

We cannot go through another 10 years of this board.

Danny Broderick
50 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:08:18
I'd have hated to have been on the Titanic with some of you lot ? you'd have been playing the violin while the ship was sinking.

Some of you disagree with the BU 'leaking' details of the initial meeting. What were they supposed to do? Have a meeting but then not tell anyone about it? It was never meant to be confidential.

At the end of the day, this board is not serious about selling the club. That is why the BU has (correctly) laid down the gauntlet to them. The board maintain that Everton can't be sold ? there's a recession, we share a city with LFC, people aren't buying football clubs any more, etc. All of this justifies why they have FAILED to find investment / a buyer these last 12 years. Believe all that if you want. But I certainly don't... and nor do the BU.

So consequently they are bang on the money in challenging the board to appoint independent agents to sell the club. Of course they will never do it, because it would only highlight their incompetence if such agents found a buyer within 6 months, when the board have not managed to do so in over a decade.

We need a sustained 'Kenwright Out' protest throughout the summer friendlies for starters. But sadly, it will only truely add pressure on the board when the majority of fans wake up and smell the coffee.
Gareth Humphreys
51 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:31:46
Roberto, I think if you believe the BU want to become the board then you are completely missing what they are trying to achieve.
Joe McMahon
52 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:38:09
I'd be interested to know if anyone on this thread clapped Kenwright when his face was shown on the screen. If you did please can you explain why?
Steve Smith
53 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:44:48
Jay 378:
A petition is an excellent idea and one that I feel that I could support, if BU concentrated it's efforts on getting a mandate from a majority of supporters, then the board have to act. IMO, it will also give BU a perspective on what the supporters really think... maybe?
James Cadwaladr
55 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:20:05
Barry, Gareth, I support neither the board or Blue Union. As I stated originally I was a supporter but the group is too fallible.

IT is very apparent that there was a lack of any clear strategy once the groups joined. Yes, there are the quotes about supporting the team and opposing stagnation and trying to find an interim group of executives to run as an interim board in order to sell the club.

But how on earth is a meeting, falling out with the board almost on day one, and a couple of badly organised protests going to do that? The Blue Union keep pointing out that Liverpool got an interim board in place to sell the club.

THERE IS ONE MAJOR DIFFERENCE HERE: LIVERPOOL'S AMERICAN OWNERS WANTED TO SELL THE CLUB.

EVERTON'S BOARD DO NOT WANT TO / ARE NOT IN A FEASIBLE POSITION TO SELL THE CLUB (due to being hamstrung by Green and Earl). For this reason, The Blue Union's raison d'etre is a non-starter.

As for condemming me for criticising and being "middle management" ? no answer required; what or who I am doesn't matter. Should I be ashamed for criticising??? NO!!!! I do not support our board in any way, I did not cheer Kenwright when he came on the big screens (that I supplied to the club in my middle management position). I, like anyone else is allowed an opinion and everyone's opinion is valid.

The fact of the matter is The Blue Union failed last season, for several reasons, and they need to make some consideration into what they are trying to achieve and how they go about doing that. If they do and I feel that they are not wasting time, bringing our club into disrepute, and I agree with their manifesto, I shall be very keen to lend my support again.

Gareth, what would I do differently? As I've said, an interim board will not happen; in my opinion, The Blue Union should concentrate on gaining popularity and a sympathetic ear with the media. That is a far more powerful vehicle that can put greater pressure on the board. To do this, The Blue Union have to be seen as credible ? cancelling protests, not communicating outcomes of meetings, and taking action from these meetings is amateurish at best.

I would concentrate on being seen in a far more positive light by Evertonians, Board, media, the wider football community. If we do a Blackburn, it will affect the team on the pitch (I blame their fans for their relegation); 3,000 people walking up Goodison Road won't get rid of the board. 3,000 people protesting with a sympathtic wider audience just might.

Getting rid of the board requires a huge wave of public support from the non-Evertonian communty making the board's position untenable. I would concentrate on this and, at the same time as this grew, I would be trying like hell to get the likes of David Conn (@david_conn on Twitter), Andy Green (@andersred on Twitter) and many of the other investigate football journalists to look deep into what has been going on at the club. Again the likes of whom can do far more damage to a board than we match-going fans can.

I quote The Blue Union verbatim:

"As a group we have consistently stressed that we exist in order to represent the fans, to listen to their views and to provide the vehicle that can bring our collective ideas together and create a positive, all-inclusive, platform."

Andy Walker
56 Posted 05/06/2012 at 18:57:07
Tom, the criticism comes from the reality that any upheaval in the Board will create significant risk to our club, just as board changes to any business does. Risks such as who would form the new Board? (Other Board members will go if BK goes as, again, that's just business.)

Will replacements be a UK or overseas nationals, competent, knowledgeable, in it for long term, etc etc? From where if overseas? US, India etc, so loads of risk there simply because it's an unknown.

Next, there would be a significant chance of losing DM as manager (and some players who are loyal to DM). So if we are to get rid of BK, there needs to be a clear alternative put forward to manage the reprecussions, ie, who would take over the club and who would be our next manager if DM decided he can't work with the new board?

A clear alternative proposal is needed before BK can be replaced; just getting rid and then trying to figure out what to do next is obviously not a sensible approach.

Assuming Stage 1 of BU plan is get rid of BK, I would like to hear more about what the second stage of the plan would be if BK was got rid of... i.e.

1) Who would replace BK?

2) What steps would be taken to retain DM, or if DM was to go as well (or he decided to go) who would be our new manager?

3) How do BU believe they can have any influence over 1 and 2?

BU refer to a fully autononous group of professionals taking over in the interim post BK departure, ie a Board? Who would appoint these people? What qualifications would they need, who would they report to, how would the current creditors be managed, ie, would they accept BU's plan? Who would carry out due dilligence on the professionals' status to be fit a proper both financially and morally? How much would they be paid? For how long? How would DM be managed during this period?

I can see how BU could potentially create enough support to get rid of BK, its pressure, criticism, demos, PR/spin, good timing, eg, it could coincide with poor team performance. That's the realtively easy bit though, compared to the second part of the plan that's needed, ie, answers to 1,2 and 3.

Just defaulting to saying they would propose putting the future of my club in the hands of some as yet unknown mystic 'group of professionals' doesn't fill me with confidence, it just looks like a cop-out to avoid answering the real and very difficult questions that will need answering quickly if BK goes.

At the moment, BU don't think BK has done enough for EFC; I get that. But they have adopted the core message of "let's get rid of BK". If BU concentrated on a positive alternative proposal for our club, with supporting detail, instead of simply peddling a negative message, I'd be more inclined to take them seriously instead of presuming they have a personal vendetta against BK ? note the use of the word 'presume'. If you want to influence others, perception is the key.

EFC needs more investment, no doubt. BU could play an important role in the process of change but not, in my opinion, until they put forward a detailed positive alternative plan. Any takers?

Eugene Ruane
57 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:55:02
The human being is a strange and wonderful creature.
We human beings are odd and wonderful creatures.

We are blinkered and blessed/cursed with the ability to ignore anything and everything, as long as things are ok, right THIS minute.

For instance, right THIS minute, if your leg is ok, what's the problem?

Right?

"Yeah, there's no pain, I can walk, maybe even run a little, it's fine, what do you want me to fucking do?"

"Well..er..you could exercise a bit more, maybe get a check up for thrombosis - preventative medicine type of thing"

"Behave yourself!"

As individuals, it's kind of a good thing we're this way, otherwise life would be spent worrying about all the things that could go wrong.

Basically, we'd never leave the house if we spent time thinking about what MIGHT go wrong.

The problem with this fatalistic approach though, is that eventually your leg, heart, lungs or whatever WILL pack up.

Then you'll scream and shout and demand something to relieve the pain.

Now you might get lucky but.....you might not.

I see those applauding BK this way.

It's alright THIS minute so...fuck it.

A couple of pints, curry and chips, BK on screen and "Ahh come on he's a good blue (applause)" etc

And if you don't think about what MIGHT go wrong, it's..

"Stop fuckin' moaning ? we finished 7th, we didn't go down, the football's improved, if we can keep Pien...." etc.

Kind of fair enough and as I suggest, very human.

The problem with football clubs though, is that it seems when the financial shit DOES hit the fan, the pain-killers rarely seem to do much good and death is often slow and painful.

That's why the BU and KEIOC have/had my support.

Not because they can guarantee change, or because they have the right strategy, but because they are attempting to address things BEFORE it's too late.

To do something most of us don't.

(Fact: Once it's too late it's.......too late).

Like a lot of males of my generation, I have a healthy/unhealthy interest in WWII.

Churchill was imo a very odd human being, due to an upbringing devoid of emotion or warmth.

He basically fucked up in WWI and was a political outcast by the 1930s.

However he appeared to be just about the only MP in Britain who could see what was happening in Germany between wars (ie: re-arming, rebuilding, completely ignoring the Treaty of Versailles etc)

Each time he mentioned this he was shouted down as a 'war-monger'.

And why not?

"We're not being bombed right THIS minute are we? Well fucking behave yourself! ? Lord Halifax 1936

(or something like that)

So what am I saying?

That imo, the majority need to wise up... fast!

If they don't want the BU, fine - organize something else.

But as each season goes by and we have less and less to flog, the situation is NOT getting easier and it is NOT remaining the same, it is getting worse, MUCH worse.

(nb: It might FEEL the same but it DEFINITLY isn't).

This board NEED to feel pressure from someone, they NEED to feel scrutiny and they NEED to feel accountable.

Polite applause and polite questions is playing into their hands and imo, potential suicide.

I am convinced that if this 'board' are not challenged and they're left to their own devices, there is a very good chance that something really, REALLY fucking horrible will happen and if it does, we won't see it coming until it's too late.

Oh and IF it does, a hypodermic needle the size of a drain-pipe, full of pure morphine, won't dull the pain for a second.

Ged Alexander
58 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:02:09
All. The BU doesn't represent me... and how can it? No votes to elect the BU 'board'; no shares issued to become a stakeholder in BU Ltd.... the BU is a group of passionate no-hopers. True Blues with good motivation, however, don't add up to a hill of beans in the scheme of things.

Gareth, you say all assets have gone. They have not. EFC is in the Premier League ? an asset worth a lot.
Mike Green
59 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:58:15
Good for you, Jay Harris, a really good post. Q2 in particular.

Christopher Kelly
60 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:22:46
It's all very cyclical really. Makes me feel likes it's been a 12 year Ground hog day with EFC... you could name the date on the calendar and I could probably tell you what we'd be talking about.

Aug/Sept: upset at board, no new players/sell-to-buy, one star sold, one or two loans and a purchase of a mediocre player.

Sept/Dec: Slow start, Moyes moaning, no new players. we're 14th

Jan/Mar:Maybe a new player in. Scramble for an effective loan, team comes together and now we're 9th. Out of one cup early and a run in another

Mar/Apr: Continued team revival now we're 7th and feeling good. Cup burnout in qtrs or semi's

Apr/May: team is tired and we slip a bit, finish 8th or 9th but still "exceeding" expectations!

Summer: Board out! Why can't we find a buyer? Some Indian consortium linked, silly transfer season with next to no incoming talent, where's the next Rooney coming from? Is Moyes finally going to leave/give up??

Board members laughing at us and running to the bank. We keep writing shit posts on TW but nothing changes LOL

Ciarán McGlone
61 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:38:53
"But the idea that a self-appointed group just takes over a board"

Why can't people read what's in front of them ? at least as a very minimum, before offering criticism.

John Daley
62 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:58:18
"Get a manifesto together, then put yourselves forward as an alternative to the board, and on the basis of the manifesto then raise the readies from fans to buyout the current one. Then - assuming the manifesto states you will seek out a rich so and so - you can go look for the elusive billionaire.

But the idea that a self-appointed group just takes over a board - a board that has invested its own dosh - is nonsense."

"until. you stump up the cash.....you simply don't have the right to takeover the club, as you frankly ridiculously suggest."


The only person to put forward the ridicolous suggestion that the BU takeover the
club seems to be you though doesn't it?

Gavin Ramejkis
63 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:48:51
Andy Walker, I've asked this before in other posts of a similar nature and have yet to read any response whatsoever:

Can you name the existing board members and by each one of them list their documented, credible, beneficial input to the running of Everton Football Club? ? Namely what have they done since they have been on the board? What skills have they brought, what on- or off-field gains have the club made through their existence? Failing the ability to name any benefit any of them bring to the table, you would fail to create a cause for their retention.

Ged, the membership of the EPL isn't exactly a worthy benefit right now as the membership fund has already been loaned against. Right now, the club is in hock to that very membership and as such it brings nothing other than an ability to service a debt into the future; if the club were to drop out of the EPL it would be even worse off. A massive gamble and one which smacks of poor financial control and running out of ideas/avenues to continue to fund its existence.

Ian Bennett
64 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:55:57
Nothing will change... demo or not. We are awaiting a painful death, a lucky buyer, or the banks get nervous and pull the plug.

One solution, if people had the balls for it, is that Blue Union or a representative fans group hold the season ticket monies in trust until they obtain a voting seat or seats on the board.

The current board can either grant the request and receive the sum, or the fans have to follow through and not go the match / keep the funds in trust with a poker face.

Demos achieve nothing. It's my suggestion and to date I haven't seen better.

Lyndon Lloyd
65 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:29:33
True Blues with good motivation, however, don't add up to a hill of beans in the scheme of things.
They said that about KEIOC, too, "Ged" and that inconsequential group of Evertonians probably did more to expose the sham that was Destination Kirkby than anybody else.

The Blue Union have a couple of large hurdles to overcome:

  1. The loyalty factor: We Evertonians like to stick together with our "us against the world" siege mentality that has been epitomised so well by the players on the pitch for so much of David Moyes's tenure.

    No surprise that, the day after Martin Samuel's nauseating puff piece on Kenwright ahead of the second BU march, a section of the crowd clapped Bill's face when it appeared on the big screen. A Blue was being attacked and Samuel's sycophancy ? assuming, of course, he even wrote most of it ? hit all the right notes to draw sympathy.

  2. The expectation factor: There seems to be an element in the fanbase who are demanding that if the BU have the temerity to take the Board on, they have to have a fully-baked strategy, have a concrete alternative to the Kenwright Board, and behave in utterly exemplary fashion ? otherwise they're apt to be torn to shreds.

    Those expectations are unrealistic for what is, essentially, a group of passionate, well-meaning supporters scared to death that they are witnessing the slow death of their football club; but that is, unfortunately what they will always face unless they can provide every answer.

EFC is in the Premier League... an asset worth a lot.
Near-sighted thinking if ever I saw it. With half of the first team approaching retirement age and no funds to replace them, how long exactly are we supposed to a) keep our manager? and b) stay in the Premier League? And, if we can't retain our top-flight status and all the players have been sold,, what assets will remain then?
Roberto Birquet
66 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:32:32
Ged390
"The assets have not gone. EFC is in the Premier League ? an asset worth a lot."
------------------------
My addendum: the ground, the players, the brand, the fans, the tradition, past players... enormous intangibles... Plenty of assets...
Eugene Ruane
67 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:42:47
Roberto - I tried to pay my leccy bill with Everton's tradition, the said they wanted cash.
Carl Sanderson
68 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:40:02
Roberto,

The brand, the tradition and past players, even the fans, will mean nothing to an administrator. EFC cannot continue to operate like this for much longer, losing money hand over fist and selling players, not to buy but to survive. Even if Moyes stays, the squad is ageing and losing value and he cannot keep pulling rabbits out of hats. If Moyes went... well, I would genuinely fear for EFC's future.

Lyndon Lloyd
69 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:42:05
My addendum: the ground, the players, the brand, the fans, the tradition, past players....enormous intangibles.... Plenty of assets....

We're lucky if the ground is worth more than £10m.

Let's assume that most of Baines, Fellaini, Jagielka, Jelavic, Rodwell and Barkley have been sold, perhaps towards the end of their contracts, so for small money. What players will form a collective asset of any worth then?

If we're faced with a winding-up order with net liabilities north of £90m, none of that is going to save the club.

Wolves, Chelsea, Man City, Nottingham Forest... they all had a brand, a tradition, fans, past players ? all, as you say, "intangibles" and of no real monetary value ? but they've all been relegated from the top flight in the last two decades. Some recovered (thanks to unprecedented money sunk into them without a realistic expectation of return); others haven't.

To expect this club ? namely Moyes, really ? to keep up the level of performance to which we've been accustomed on ever-decreasing resources is dangerous.

Gareth Humphreys
70 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:30:47
Ged, you are obviously struggling now by stating being in the Premier League is an asset. I presume what you are getting at is the Sky money for being in it? Well, sorry to break it to you but that has also been borrowed against. Like every other asset.
James Cadwaladr
71 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:48:09
Has anyone heard anything from Tony I'anson and the Trust Everton brigade? I also recall a similar trust trying to get off the ground regarding the financing and ownership of a new stadium a few years back.

I would be interested to hear what Tony has to say...

Andy Walker
72 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:24:38
Gavin ? that's a very naive view in my opinion. There is one very obvious and extremely valuable asset that the existing board bring and that is a proven track record of stability. Stability in business is worth millions.

I don't know the individual qualifications of the EFC Board, but then again, I don't know what qualifications of my own doctor has (which uni, degree level, additional quals, specialisms and training etc). However, he's done a good job for years so I'm happy to trust my own and my family's health to him.

So BK and the current Board, as they are the incumbents, just like in any other business, will be judged on their track record. Whether they have brilliant CVs or not is irrelevant; it's their track record that's important. If you are an advocate for change, it is harder as you have to put your own case ? not simply try and undermine the incumbents. If you pitch to win new business, you don't slag off the incumbents or your other competitors; you make your own case. If you are a corporation making a hostile take over bid for another business, you don't simple say the other directors need to justify their own existence... and, if they can't, then we should take over their business. That would come across as arrogance and have no credibility in the business world. You have to make an alternative case.

That's the way of commerce; it's not up to BK and the current Board to justify their existence, it's for others to scutinise and ask why don't we do things this way instead? (And then support their arguments with a detailed alternative.) In other words, put together a cogent, persuasive argument, as opposed to coming across to me like an as a group who simply have an axe to grind and have no detailed positive alternative.

Getting rid of BK would create instability and uncertainty, that's a given. Sacrificing these very valuable benefits can only be done if a clear alternative is presented in a persuasive manner.

Gavin Ramejkis
73 Posted 05/06/2012 at 22:22:27
Andy, you use the word 'naive' and then use 'stability' in the same sentence as the current board ? a real misnomer there.

During the tenure of BK and his board, the club has gradually increased its debt levels way beyond the realms of any previous board and not one single member of the board or major shareholder has invested a single penny of their own money beyond purchasing their shareholding, and appear to all intents and purposes to be holding out for a bumper pay day on their shares.

In business terms, Andy, this is nothing more than carpetbagging and shows no acumen or benefit to the business. You decry the danger of changing a board in any business as a potentially terminal decision for said business, thus I challenged you to a very simple question: What is it that the club/business would lose with their departure?

1. If they sold their shares and the new incumbents did nothing regarding further investment, the club/business would be no worse off.

2. If the new incumbents bought the shares and continued to sell the remaining assets (player registrations) for the company to remain afloat, the club/business would be no worse off as that's exactly what the current board have done for many seasons now.

3. If the new incumbents only bought the shares but decided to address the primary business failings such as marketing, sponsorship and non-matchday revenue streams to align them to our peers, then the club/business balance sheet and EBITDA would improve.

4. If the new incumbents bought the shares, invested in the infrastructure through their own funds, looking for a return or sought external business partners and didn't address the primary business failings, again the club/business would improve. Finally, if the new incumbents bought the shares and invested in both infrastructure and addressed the marketing, sponsorship and non match day revenue streams again the EBITDA would improve and the club/business benefit.

Now seriously, Andy, hand on heart and dropping this poor fallacy of naivety in "stability" ? which has come about through the team performance retaining membership of the EPL ? which was funded through Sky money anyone in the role of Chairman would have received together with player sales.

A private company also doesn't need to respond to the masses asking them to run their business a specific way, which is niave; they should be responsible to their shareholders but another blatantly arrogant display changed the Articles of Association and removed AGMs, thus rendering even that responsibility a moot point.

Again, as it's still not been answered but rather body-swerved with spin, what "stability" or benefit do each or any of the board bring, given they don't bring any investment, have failed to grow the business and instead shrunk it, increased the debt, shun shareholders and appear to have no short-term strategy... never mind any medium- to long-term ones.

Roberto Birquet
74 Posted 05/06/2012 at 22:38:57
Eugene
You can'y pay yer leccy with tradition, but banks actually can estimate a worth on tradition. It's what they call intangibles or good sth or other. Am a bit tired and can't remember the term. But it has value.

For example, they know there'll be customers always coming thru. But, aye, I know. We need more income... Hence KD has always been the great loss of the past ten years... worse than losing cup finals or semis.

Drew O'Neall
75 Posted 05/06/2012 at 17:15:06
Gareth 334

That doesn't necessarily demonstrate apathy to me but what it does demonstrate is the Blue Union not having a mandate from the majority of fans.

They've gone about things the wrong way and their goals are unachievable and naive.

The best thing the BU can do is concentrate on publicising this board's failures and, where provable, lies.

Kenwright's ego is the key here, I personally don't think he wants to sell. If you want change, Everton has to become a burden to Kenwright rather than the source of his affirmation.

Drew O'Neall
76 Posted 05/06/2012 at 22:47:00
That's weird, about 20 posts popped up in front of mine when I posted...
Kevin Tully
77 Posted 05/06/2012 at 22:46:21
Andy #419

Stable businesses do not need to borrow money from off-shore tax dodging companies to fund their operations.

Stable companies do not have to sell their assests built up over many years.

A stable company does not have to beg. the banks "not to kill us."

Any stable company has a long- term fiancial model.

You then ask anyone who has audacity to point to this Board's failings to offer the following;

"(and then support their arguments with a detailed alternative). In other words put together a cogent, persuasive argument, as opposed to coming across to me like an as a group who simply have an axe to grind and have no detailed positive alternative."

Words fail me.

Mark Riding
78 Posted 06/06/2012 at 00:30:03
In words Blue Bill may understand, "Tell me it's not true? Say it's just some clowns who couldn't get their lines right!"
Jay Harris
79 Posted 06/06/2012 at 00:41:50
Andy #419 ? Do you really believe we have had stability under this board?

Five chief executives in 10 years with chief executive's salary rising from £50,000 a year when Kenwright took over to £500,000 a year when Wyness was in charge is hardly stability.

The board upheaval when Paul and Anita Gregg cottoned on to Bill's lies and incompetence is hardly stability.

Lord Grantchester's disdain for Bill and "Friends of Everton" is hardly stability.

Pisssing off and giving LCC the runaround over Kings Dock while claiming the contribution was ring-fenced is hardly stability.

Selling off a number of the squad every year is NOT stability.

In fact lies, incompetence and deceit are NOT the basis for stability.

Martin Mason
80 Posted 06/06/2012 at 03:50:54
Rather than just wave their hands and demand change of ownership and "investment", they should start to realistically think where this is going to come from. As far as I can see, they have been trying to sell the dead horse for years now without success and there aren't enough idiots around to find one to throw his money away at the basket case that is EFC.

OK, I wave my magic wand and BK and the board walk away and allow an interim board to take over; what could they possibly do to solve the club's structural problems?
Martin Mason
81 Posted 06/06/2012 at 04:04:22
Apologies if my last post is misconstrued as unconditional support for the board. Like all Evertonians, I want success for the club and a nice billionaire benefactor would be great but it ain't going to happen.

I also don't believe that the current board is the sole architect of Everton's downfall, only the latest caretakers in a process of managed decline that's been going on for 40 years now. For me, the last half of last season was a great reason to be positive about the club and to get behind it.
Eric Myles
82 Posted 06/06/2012 at 03:09:36
Andy #386, if BK sells the Club, then all those things you say will come to pass also, so you can't use those scare tactics as a reason why the BU shouldn't propose a change of owner.
Eric Myles
83 Posted 06/06/2012 at 04:16:47
Andy #419 "So BK and the current Board as they are the incumbents, just like in any other business, will be judged on their track record."

And do you judge their track record to be a good one?

Steve Carter
84 Posted 06/06/2012 at 04:54:48
I have a question (preceded by a statement): OK, Blue Union have a right to form an association (if that's what they've done) and, as such, protest and to proffer their ? or, more accurately, if it's an incorporated association, its ? opinion as to what the present Board should or should not do, what can and can't be done, etc. However, have they (or it) ever thought about putting their / its expertise, time and money into doing this: going off and either finding a buyer or sourcing capital themselves, and then putting a proposal to purchase the shares of the existing shareholders (either through the new buyer or themselves) along with a business plan of how they / the new buyer(s) propose to put the new found money to use?

If the answer to that question is either (a) No or (b) Yes, we have but we haven't been able to make it all happen, then...
Paul Andrews
85 Posted 06/06/2012 at 06:27:01
Roberto,

"WE'D like to earn more dosh"?

Chad Schofield
87 Posted 06/06/2012 at 08:05:59
Christ there's some pretty remedial reading comprehension going on alongside the ?they don'’t represent me?. Demands that BU basically become the board, solve all the problems that the board face, have a democratically formed manifesto that shares the views of each and every Everton fan to grace the Earth seems like a little bit of a big ask?

Alternatively the current paid members of the board who do ?represent you? could form a proper team to sell/seek investment as a statement of intent ? unless of course you buy the fact Bill has not slept 24/7 (for how many years now?) and just been unlucky.

You know the BU could represent your views... but, rather than gnashing your teeth at them or others who are looking to push for some active change, perhaps you could write/meet with them and get to grips with what they are trying to achieve? maybe even help mould them into something that does represent you ? after all, isn?t this really what the BU are trying to do with the board?

Rather than picking further on Roberto or Ged, Drew, 423, they already had a backlash because they released the information straight from Bill?s mouth? how exactly would the BU simply trying to highlight faults/lies be any different from any number of individuals from this site?

I agree with your point 425: ?Kenwright's ego is the key here, I personally don't think he wants to sell.? But ?If you want change, Everton has to become a burden to Kenwright rather than the source of his affirmation.? ? how does this happen without it becoming detrimental to the club and therefore polarising the fans further?

Andy Riley
88 Posted 06/06/2012 at 08:26:48
I think most Evertonians want change for something better rather than just change for it's own sake. I'm not actually convinced that there is anyone or any consortium out there that is:-

a) Genuinely interested in purchasing EFC at any price;
b) Likely to offer genuine improvement on the current incumbents.

Further, I find it strange that in all these years no-one has ever come forward, identified themselves and said I've got real interest, real funding but my offer broke down because of x, y or z if such a person or entity really existed.
Andy Walker
89 Posted 06/06/2012 at 08:24:03
Some still don't get it. The reality of any attempt to overthrow an existing Board is to put forward a clear alternative and win the hearts and minds of the fans. Simply resorting to slagging off the existing Board and anyone who dares to no accept the word of the detractors is not a convincing argument.

What is BU's detailed proposal? I genuinely don't know and no one appears to be able to answer this question without resorting to talking negatively about the existing Board. How do you expect BU to win me and many others over when they will not put forward a detailed alternative of what the future could look like and how they would deliver it?

The only plan I understand they have is to constitute an 'autonomous body of professionals'. All this does is make me think of the technocrats running Greece and the EU, that is, non-elected mandarins and I dont like the idea of handing over the future of my club to them on the chance they might do a better job. It just looks like a MASSIVE gamble which could well send our club into the depths of the lower leagues. That is a genuine an REAL fear and to simply brush it under the carpet as scare mongering does BU supporters no favours.

The biggest block to change is fear, fact. If BU want to win the argument, they need to wake up to this basic human instinct and start addressing it with reasoned argument as opposed to just slagging off those who dare to have a different opinion to them. I would accept a new owner and board if I thought their future plans where better than the current incumbents.

To persuade me in that direction though will require a detailed manifesto of future proposals starting with the consitution of this somewhat mysterious autonomous body of professionals. That scares the shit out of me when I have no information to help me understand its constitution, legal status, powers, remuneration, reporting lines, timescales, succession plans, qualifications, etc etc. I can not possibly be convinced without this detail.

Simply trying to use a negative campaign, ie concentrate on the incumbents not the solution, will NEVER convince me and I suspect the vast majority of fans. In fact, this approach only makes me more suspicious of the motives behind the change. BU needs to wake up to this basic strategic point if they want to stand any chance of winning the argument. Over to BU to convince me and not just slag me off for having a different opinion.

Matt Traynor
90 Posted 06/06/2012 at 08:54:45
Andy #458, you are right in that any change has to be for something better. I am firmly of the opinion that there would be investors out there who could see the possibility of a return on the investment required to get Everton to where it needs to be to compete, with an up-to-date stadium, and better commercial exploitation.

BK and the board have not had the money to deliver that ? and they've never hidden that (apart from maybe 'ring-fenced' comments).

I do believe the problem is the price. It's been leaked by enough different sources publicly that they are looking for £150m-£180m. It's simply not worth that. The smart group of buyers that we and supposedly the board want are not going to pay £180m for a business that isn't worth remotely that, as it will rather fuck up the business case of how they will make their return.

Of course BK could choose to come out and state exactly how much the club is for sale for, and how that valuation was arrived at. He chooses not to, which is his right.

Therefore the situation goes on. No buyers come forward, because there's not a realistic seller. Stagnation continues. It will only change when it's forced upon them by a creditor.

Andy Riley
91 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:02:01
We do need to give the current regime some credit. I think they are looking to sell but only to what they consider the right purchaser. We have probably upwards of £60 million in assets on the pitch so selling for any less than that merely presents an asset stripping opportunity to someone with an eye for the main chance.

Please recall that David Moores sold out our city rivals to what appeared to be American multi billionaires with very deep pockets in preference to an Arab investment bank and look what happened then. Any change of ownership has to be for the long term benefit of the club not just ABK (anyone but Kenwright) which appears to be the current aim of some.
Matt Traynor
92 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:14:12
Andy #461, the assets on the pitch are also liabilities due to the enormous wages they are on, so that argument is a fallacy in the modern game.

We also have at least £45m of debt, and possibly more. Compounding this is that much of the debt was borrowed against future revenue and the longer term debts will have most of their costs front-loaded, thereby making early settlement of limited benefit.

We don't want to be sold to someone on a leveraged buyout but someone using soft loans prior to an equity swap when the major investment is secured. That is the one thing above all else that BK has to do. And remember, there are those who speculate that the leveraged buyout is what happened to us when debt suddenly jumped from £5m to £25m in the year after purchase. The Bear Stearns (as was) mortgage on season tickets is not dissimilar to what Craig Whyte did at Rangers.

But I believe he (and the other major shareholders) is only interested in profit.

Andy Riley
93 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:20:56
Matt #462 ? I accept your argument in some ways but the likes of Leighton Baines, Nikica Jelavic and many others at Everton still have a large net asset value even when the liability of their outstanding wages over the remainer of their contact is taken into account.

I agree that the price sought is key to any sale but it could be that prospective buyers are being asked to prove the availability of liquid funds of £150 million upwards for investment after purchase rather than that being the net asking price sought. Such an approach would scare off potential asset strippers.

Some explanation and communication from the current regime around the price being sought and the reasoning behind it would be helpful and assist in unifying supporters.
Lee Preston
94 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:35:09
I personally agree with the sentiments of the BU, but have to admit they made mistakes along the way. However, they are just a group of fans like all of us, who want the best for the club, so mistakes are inevitable.

The trouble stems from the fact that half the fans are on a different page from the other half; evidence of this was half the crowd cheering Bill Kenwright, the other half booing.

While there is this divide, there will be no real pressure on the board; everyone needs to be on the same page if we really want to see the back of this board, but I fear that too many people are blindly supporting them.

I've had enough of this 'sell our best players' policy, with very little funds to re-invest; it's becoming rather depressing now. I'm not particularly bothered about having billions from an oil rich arab, I'd settle for £5million a year on transfers plus all of the money raised from sales being allowed to be re-invested. I don't think that's asking too much.

Eric Myles
95 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:40:40
Andy W #459, it seems you are the one that doesn't get it.

If BK sells the Club we will have a new board.

Your "better the devil you know" scaremongering is therefore irrelevant as you will still be faced with the same questions:

1) Who would replace BK?
2) What steps would be taken to retain DM, or if DM was to go as well (or he decided to go), who would be our new manager?

And do you expect any potential buyer to come out and tell the fans that and ask their approval? You might not like the idea of handing over the future of the Club to them on the chance they might do a better job but you will have no choice in the matter.

Eric Myles
96 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:57:07
Andy R #461 "We have probably upwards of £60 million in assets on the pitch" and a net debt of £45 million making the Club net worth £15 million.

I'm sure they could find a buyer at that price. Then you needn't be worried about asset strippers because if they sold all the players then they would only break even after paying off the debt.

But any buyer is unlikely to sell off his only assets and make the club worthless as he'd never get a return on his money.

Matt Traynor
97 Posted 06/06/2012 at 10:25:22
Andy #465 you are right to a degree about scaring off asset strippers. These carpet baggers are not really looking for the likes of EFC though. They're more interested in a Sheff Wed, Sheff Utd, or a similar Championship team that doesn't require much investment, and isn't saddled with debt.

The promotion to the Premier League and the revenue streams that brings in is what they're after to increase their value. The Italians who had QPR couldn't wait to get out of there as soon as they got promotion.

Andy Walker
98 Posted 06/06/2012 at 10:07:41
Eric, yes obvously BK and the current board decide whether they sell, I think we all know that, it's no revelation, they are in control. You are endorsing the point I have been making, ie, the current board are in control and they call the shots, so that's a degree of comfort, like it or not.

If BU want another group in control who will call the shots, BU need to make a case as to why this new group would do any better than the current incumbents. Who will these people be? Who will control the future of my club? At the moment, I know that if new owners come in, they will only do so with the blessing of the current board.

Under the BU proposal, new owners will come in with the blessing of an autonomous group of professionals, at present unknown, yet to be determined... by who? ? we don't know; with what backgrounds? ? we dont know; with what vested interests? ? we don't know; with what consequences for the future of our club? ? we don't know; being paid how much? ? we don't know; accountable to who? ? we don't know; from what countries? ? we don't know; for how long? ? we don't know.

Let's just take a gamble with the future of our grand old club and and hope for the best? No thanks, I want detail, plans, strategy, a future vision mapped which I believe is achievable having been persuaded by a positive argument in favour of change.

However, BU don't seem to be able to get past Stage 1, ie, what will this mysterious group of automonous (auotmotons?) professionals look like? Will they all be Herman van Rompuys?

You need to be aware that insulting, patronising or belittling people who recognise the inevitable risk that will come with change within our club will not win you support or respect. I am not saying we shouldn't take any risk, I am open to change and think we probably need it, BUT ONLY if it's considered change and based on a thoroughly persuasive alternative plan. That way, we minimise risk and maximise the chance of success and avoid what appears to me to be BU's cavalier approach of change at all costs cos we don't like who's in charge at the moment.

Eric Myles
99 Posted 06/06/2012 at 11:22:16
Andy "BU need to make a case as to why this new group would do any better than the current incumbents"

Because the current incumbants have been working 24/7 for the last 10 years and have failed and have repeatedly failed with everything they've touched.

Eric Myles
100 Posted 06/06/2012 at 11:27:48
Andy "Lets just take a gamble with the future of our grand old club and and hope for the best? No thanks, I want detail, plans, strategy, a future vision mapped which I believe is achievable having be pursuaded by a positive argument in favour of change"

But again, you won't get that if BK finds a buyer... so you seem to be saying you don't want change, and then contracdicting yourself saying you would welcome it.

Unfortunately, the only way we will get change is if it's forced upon the board.

Jamie Freeman
101 Posted 06/06/2012 at 10:27:43
I'm going to ask 'certain' journalists (on Twitter) if they believe the EFC board's performance and their dealings needs further investigating/exposure.

My problem is how I word it. You're help would be appreciated... In 120 letters/characters.

Brian Harrison
102 Posted 06/06/2012 at 11:43:54
There is no denying that this board have made some bad mistakes, the most obvious being the loss of the Kings Dock as our new home. Having said that, how much credibility can you give to a group who decide that they would suspend their protest as the team is doing so well?

What I do know is that where there is a group of fans protesting inside the ground against their club, then we only need to look at Blackburn and Villa to see how bad the consequences can be. I know so far the protests have happened outside the ground, but there were calls last year from some BU supporters to protest inside the ground.

Andy Riley
103 Posted 06/06/2012 at 11:45:27
I think where Andy Walker and I are both coming from is that we (like most Evertonians) want positive change for the better, not just ABK. It seems to me that if there was (or had been) anyone in these last ten years who was credible and could offer a properly financed more positive future than the present owners but were being obstructed then I think they would have raised their head above the parapet by now. Therefore I can only conclude that there is no-one out there that fulfills such criteria and being a wishful thinker is probably futile.
Tom Hughes
104 Posted 06/06/2012 at 10:53:22
Matt (#474),

"Scaring off asset strippers".................?

What do you think we have got running us now? These people have stripped the place bare just to keep themselves in position, in the faint hope that DM can polish the turd to its max value, and they can get their payoff. BK (and his old-pals act) only paid for their shares...... and got ownership for a song. Since then, they have sold everything off, and farmed out every aspect of the operation that they possibly could (look at the increased operating costs and the ridiculously low kit deal). Ask yourself what value they have added, but first differentiate that from what DM has achieved with zero investment from them. DM has carried the club (and them) for long enough.

You also mention QPR..... they were sold even as we were all being told that such sales were no longer happening. How can that be? A club with only a fraction of our fanbase in a tiny outdated ground, surrounded by much richer competition. EVERY club has changed hands in the time that we have supposedly been looking...

If BK was to announce the sale of his shares today, at the current share price, then he would almost certainly have a long queue at his door...... if he persists with fanciful notions of over-inflated figures with several hundred percent profit despite zero added value, then suitable buyers will be in very short supply.

Anyone hear how the previous 3 or 4 in supposed advanced discussions got on? Or has he still got them locked in the cupboard to bring out in time for the next dip in form or protest?

The list of this lot's cock-ups and failures is almost endless. Unfortunately though, LFC's panto act for most of the past 2 decades has deluded some into thinking that we are somehow okay.

This club has missed the opportunity to reclaim the ground lost during their glory years...... our fanbase has aged and shrunk, and theirs has grown exponentially. If/when they get the right manager and expand their stadium, they will fill it easily and move on, and leave us behind forever.

Go in any school on Merseyside and do a head count of blues to reds. We are now massively outnumbered (3 or 4:1)..... hence the reason why we sell kids season tickets for less than $100 while theirs are the same as for adults with a waiting list heading north of 100k by some counts.

If we had built the Kings Dock then perhaps more heads would've been turned and more young hearts won by now... Perhaps too DM would've benefitted directly from the resultant increased turnover... but we all know what happened there... failure, as per usual.

The bottom line is that the whole future of EFC is a stake. It is simply not possible for us to carry on the way we have, whether you love BK or hate the BU or whatever... that is the only "given". We operate right on the edge, and by some measures not even the healthy side of viability. Cardboard cut-outs literally could've achieved what BK and his cronnies have. They have invested and delivered nothing, and never can or will, as demonstrated by all the empirical evidence to date!!!

No real plan... no real future!

If you accept that to be an accurate assessment, then please back the BU... offer them your support and help. They are just ordinary Evertonians working in their spare time. They are not well-paid, full-time employees tasked with the salvation of our club..... just concerned Blues who originally frequented several different websites, but were brought together by a common cause. They are very open to suggestions, and only want to act as a platform to help air and address the obvious issues.

Matt Traynor
105 Posted 06/06/2012 at 12:02:04
Tom #487 I have posted previously what I think the problem is and where it lies. I've also acknowledged the contribution DM has made in keeping them in their comfort zone. He is very much their heat shield.

I do broadly support the BU, and have attended a couple of the meetings after returning from a long stint overseas. I do think they are pissing in the wind with their objective of getting an interim board. That would only happen if a major creditor was to come calling, and even then I think our headstrong board would choose administration. I do think the BU has done a sterling job in bringing the issues into the public domain, although some of the discussion has shown a lack of understanding in some quarters.

That's the nub of problem though. A large proportion of the fan-base don't want to get involved with off-the-field issues and just want to support the team (either the don't understand or don't care to understand the ownership issues).

Some fans think that we are not attractive to investors, and therefore that's why we haven't been sold. Some (like myself) actually think that EFC is incredibly attractive if the price was right, although a lot of work would be needed (another reason why we wouldn't appeal to carpet baggers).

The truth is none of us really know until the info comes out into the public domain. And that situation suits the board just fine. BK has got the BU exactly where he wants them ? on the sidelines shouting, and being shouted down by other fans more concerned about the noise than the real nub of the problem.

What was it he said? No AGMs whilst the BU controls the Shareholders Association? And people lapped it up...

Chris Matheson
106 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:49:46
Nobody has yet come up with a reason to support the Board. Not on here, not anywhere, aside from a kind of "better the devil you know" argument, which is an excuse to do nothing; or "Bill's a Blue like us" which is a comfort blanket and irrelevant.

Martin Mason at 449 came closest, by correctly pointing to a long-term decline at the club, but this decline has been caused by poor management at Board level.

I can point to two good things that the Club has done under Kenwright's tenure: The opening of Everton 2, and the free coaches for the Sundarland replay this year. I would also like to say the appointment of David Moyes but I am of the belief that BK wanted to appoint someone else till persuaded otherwise.

The evidence of mismanagement by the current board is surely overwhelming and the lack of any concrete rebuttal of fact-based criticism only increases this feeling for me. There are plenty of Blues who don't want to worry about the state of the club, they just want to turn up and watch a footy match. I am not one of them, I genuinely worry for the future of our club. Therefore in the absence of any better ideas I am right behind the BU. Sitting back and doing nothing is not an option.

Give me a reason to support Kenwright that demolishes all the BU's fact-based arguments and I will back him. Give me something pertinent that does not refer to side issues and irrelevancies such as whether conversations may have been taped or about clowns with cakes, but actually rebuts the detailed analysis that the BU lads undertook, and I will listen and heed.

But so far I have seen nothing that validates this Board's tenure, that refutes allegations of stagnation and incompetence, or that rebuts the analysis made by the BU.

Peter Davies
107 Posted 06/06/2012 at 12:30:19
The BU are skipping through the woods with the faries! Oh, hang on, they've just seen a signpost pointing the way to cloud cuckoo land and have decided to follow that instead!
Christine Foster
108 Posted 06/06/2012 at 12:15:27
The lack of foresight displayed by some supporters is only surpassed by their refusal to acknowledge that Everton Football Club is more than the game played on the pitch. The games played in the boardroom detract from the ability to acheive as a team on the park.

1. Where is your plan, Bill?

That's the question fans should be asking. Just looking for investment doesn't cut it in any way shape or form.

2. What's going to happen if you can't find investment?

You're charged with the responsibility of securing the future of this club, how are you going to do this if you cannot find investment? No Plan B?

3. Doing nothing is not an option; if you cannot find a buyer will YOU step down?

4. If Moyes leaves (just a matter of time), what is seen by many as the club's greatest asset (not mine) will be gone. What's the plan Bill?

5. Have you any succession plan for the board to improve its performance (what performance is that exactly?)

Key questions not for the BU or any fan to answer. It's Bill Kenwright's responsibility. One I believe he has been dreadfully neglegent in.

He is not alone: Earl and Green are I believe pulling his strings. They are the masters of Goodison ? not Kenwright; perhaps protests at retail stores would hit them where it hurts...

They have made the disgusting mess that is the business of Everton Football Club. The tab will be paid by many of the supporters of this and the next generation until change happens.

BU may not have all the answers, few of us do, but with silence and arrogance as the only bedfellows, they are at least nailing their (blue) colours to the mast.

I for one stand firmly with them. Not because they do everything right, but because they refuse to accept the current status. They refuse to trust what they are told by those whose only plan is "trust me".

Shameful that so many of you are so blind that they cannot see.

Richard Reeves
109 Posted 06/06/2012 at 12:30:52
Eugene, #388, spot on as ever.
Martin Mason
110 Posted 06/06/2012 at 12:25:34
Chris @ 490

It could be said, and is said by many outside of the club, that our position is far better than a club with our financial clout should be in. It is also absolutely possible that there is not a board out there that would do better than this one with the limited resources that it has available.

BK is a terrible front man but that doesn't make him incompetent and some of the so-called fails like KD weren't fails because they were never going to happen because we didn't have the finances. DK was a desperate measure to solve some of the club's problems on the back of a retail development. A disaster in the end but not in the best interests of the club?

The board not piling in their own money isn't a fail because they would be lunatics to invest in an unrestructured club. I've been watching the club since the early 60s and I saw a pinnacle in 1970 when we were the best team on the planet. To everybody's amazement, the team went on a downhill path the following year and broke up and we have been downhill ever since with the exception of that glorious blip in the 1980s.

I don't believe that this board is any worse than any board since then... in fact you could say that they have actually worked miracles to assemble such a good squad and survive in the EPL on such meagre income compared with many other clubs. Remember, we should have been relegated twice before the current management came along; in that respect we have improved beyond recognition.

I'm sure that the BU are very well meanining but they represent only a minority of Everton fans most of whom don't see the current Everton situation in the same shades of blacks and whites but many complex areas of grey. It is a very modern thing though where minorities of activists and advocates believe that they should dictate the agenda on the basis that they are "doing something" while a stupid majority do nothing.

That is anything but the case in our situation. Everton is a dying (not slumbering) giant based in a very poor part of a relatively small and poor City with no brand name, competing with a large, once successful but now also crumbling neighbour for fans. Remember also that, in this day and age, we are competing against the Manchester clubs from all areas except the hard core city support. This current board is guilty of not meeting the expectations of many of our supporters, expectations based in the main on our history but it is possible that the expectations are unrealistic.

Anthony Hawkins
111 Posted 06/06/2012 at 12:10:24
In the current evolution of Unions in the modern world, I've never fully supported any form of union ? professional or otherwise. I just don't see the need for a body which pushes their own agenda above and beyond the real desires or realistic desires of the people they intend to represent.

Unions often come in at key points to say "you could have EVEN MORE", latching onto the fundamental desire for change or a reasonable level of "more". At their grass roots, Unions are good and worthy. At their extreme and most fired-up, they are their own worst enemy.

Strangely, this 'union' is appears to be the opposite of the generally accepted unions by accepting less than the minimum.

The initial Blue Union piece was a great idea and I backed them. I understood their desires, reflecting my own hopes and opinions.

Since then, a lot has happened. They've morphed beyond a force for good, being a bridge between fans and the board or even a challenge to the board. Where the BU stands now is a group which is vocal when they feel like it and accept the board at their word.

The previous bout of action which was cancelled due to "board rumblings" points firmly to the very reason I have lost faith in what the BU truly stands for. Some individuals cited background events within the board as reasons to cancel, others that the board had splashed the cash. Either way, the team did improve but that was never the point for the protests in the first instance.

The protest should have gone ahead until there was proof of board activity beyond the amount outlaid for Gibson and Jelavic. Yes, Gibson and Jelavic have helped to transform the team; however, I can't help feeling the BU were hoodwinked into cancelling a still valid protest.

The board needs to go ? that's it. We're beyond the point where appeasing the fans an acceptable solution. Bill Kenwright has paid his dues to the club and has reached his limit. Even in his own words, he can not provide anything more. The fans need a board who are able ? not just willing or wanting ? to provide funds. We can all want to provide the funds but most of us don't have the means. The team need an owner who does have the means.

A few months ago, there were a number of interested parties which have all appeared to dissolve ? yet again.

Personally, I've reached the point where bashing Kenwright just doesn't do it anymore. I don't hate the man and I don't dislike him. He's done all he can and is able. Now's the time to let the club move on ? it is you, the biggest fan, who is now holding back the club!!

Back to the Blue Union... to have an effect, you have to remember what you're protesting about. Getting drawn into "give us time" or befriending the board is not where it's at. Yes, be sensible but we've got to stick to our guns or we're doing nobody a favour.

If the BU want my backing, they now have to show they're committed and worth it ? otherwise they may as well not exist.

Christine Foster
112 Posted 06/06/2012 at 13:03:26
Martin, is it unrealistic to expect a business to be run well? Is it unrealistic to question the performance of a business that has taken us to the brink? Is it unrealistic to question thos who have no plan?

No it isn't.

One has to question not where we are but what got us here. The current board actually. One has to question how we are to survive, not excel, not a peep from those charged with its future.

What we do see is a lack of investment from a board with sufficient wealth amongst them to eliminate our short term debt and secure our immediate future.

What we do not see is a way out of the mess they have left us in. Nothing to do with expectations. Its all about the future and how its secured. Its NOT about the boards future or their security.

Its about price, its about wealth, its about money. Its not about Everton FC

Anthony Hawkins
113 Posted 06/06/2012 at 13:07:50
@Martin 495 - it's not what the board do or whether we punch above our financial weight. That we may well do on regular occassion. It's all about where we should be aiming and increasing the resources which we can do them with.

Are we happy to accept £8m worth of transfers and a number of loanees each season?

Martin Mason
114 Posted 06/06/2012 at 13:16:09
Christine, as I said, it is very possible that the club is being run well within the limitations of its revenue? I completely disagree that it's this board that has taken us to the brink. In team terms this board has recovered the club from the depths and it has done no worse than every board since 1970 apart from a brief flurry in the 1980s. That was also pre-EPL and EFC are simply not geared to be a successful EPL side, we are tiny financially compared to the sides that can compete.

Does the board have an obligation to put its own money into the club? I'd simply ask why should they?

What this board has "left us" is being a moderately successful club in the top league in the world with a reasonable squad that has at times played top class football and which is well respected everywhere outside of our own support base.

Of course you want better but why should we realistically expect better?

Martin Mason
115 Posted 06/06/2012 at 13:26:14
Anthony at 499

Is all we have to do to be successful to aim higher and increase our resources? If it is only to aim higher then every club in the league could be EPL champions.

But then you come to the real nub of the argument. How do we increase our resources? We are where we are now because we've increased our resources on the playing side by selling assets and borrowing. The only way we will improve our success is, as you correctly say, by increasing our resources... but how?

Eugene Ruane
116 Posted 06/06/2012 at 13:23:19
Peter Davies (491) You say..

"The BU are skipping through the woods with the faries! Oh, hang on, they've just seen a signpost pointing the way to cloud cuckoo land and have decided to follow that instead!"

Well, THAT'S one in the eye for those who say satire is dead!

(fuck me, Syd Little suddenly seems like Bill Hicks)

What IS funny though is that, as sure as eggs is eggs, if/when the shit DOES hit the fan, it'll be people you who'll no doubt scream the loudest.

"WHO APPLAUDED HIM!? I SAID THEY SHOULD HAVE FUCKED BILL OFF..." etc.

Christine Foster
117 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:11:05
Martin, l am a pole and a few light years away from your logic; l cannot applaud or praise a board that has failed to deliver a future and is bereft of any ideas. That's their job, Martin. No-one is asking for their money but, like any director of a business in trouble, you assist if you can. When the mist over Kirkby dissipated, so did the underwriting of guarantees for transfers and debt.

Everyday we are all asked in our working lives to put our money where our mouth is. The board keeps its own mouth shut, and its wallets.

It's not about high expectations, it's about realistic questions that deserve answers. As l said, what's the plan Bill?

Roberto Birquet
118 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:22:18
Jay
Q1: IS there anybody who is happy with the running of a football club which is making between £5 and 20 million a year losses and has been since the day Kenwright took over (having previously made a profit, BTW)?
------------------
Go on, what's your source for this? £20 m a year loss. When?

We were making a profit before Bill Kenwright? Again what source of yours denies we were forced to sell Duncan Ferguson, that the mighty Everton perrenially fighting relegation was some fighting fit pre-2000 business success?

This seems dodgier than press rumours on potential transfers.

Roberto Birquet
119 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:25:50
Lyndon
Let's assume that most of Baines, Fellaini, Jagielka, Jelavic, Rodwell and Barkley have been sold, perhaps towards the end of their contracts, so for small money. What players will form a collective asset of any worth then?

--------------
That is just silly. Most of those have three to five years left on their deals. We rarely allow top players' contracts roll down to a year left: I can remember Pienaar. I am struggling to think of even one more. I've not bothered with the rest of the post, and I usually do to you, Lyndon. But that is a poor intro.

I mean, why don't we assume that an earthquake rips though Merseyside followed by nuclear leaks from nearby station and kiils half of Everton's support. What would our collective assets be then? Oh my God! Sack the board!

The facts are: those players are assets that sit on our balance sheet as such. You mention the low price of the stadium ? though I would guess £10M is wrong, although without Everton Football Club, it would not fetch much, L4 happens to be THE cheapest urban real estate in the UK. Little the board can do about that.

Unfortunately, that is a major part of our problem as a business. Investors know the ground is in poor real estate land (notice how QPR finds more interest than Everton), and that our fanbase is about the poorest (wealth, not committed footballing support) in the country. And that makes us less interesting to buyers.

Martin Mason
120 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:21:22
Christine, that the the club has failed to deliver a future, that its bereft of ideas or that they don't have a plan is just one opinion, I would say for EFC at the moment survival of the club (it is that serious) and hopefully remaining in the EPL are the only issues on the table and that they are working hard on achieving that. As I have said it is also possible to paint a much more rosy picture that we are actually doing incredibly well for such a small club in terms of resources. As always the reality lies somewhere between the extremes.

The board and management actually turned a very bad situation around last year by raising some money and with astute buys and loans and surely we should give credit where it is due for that? The likelihood is also that this board is all that we are going to have and that nobody is going to come along and put in the half billion that is needed to solve our problems and lead us to a sutainable future. I believe that far from being the board that has dragged the club down this board has arrested what has been long term decline and it is highly likely that it is anything other than a very temporary respite. The future for EFC could be extremely grim and I believe that we should be offering support for the club in what must be difficult times.

Andy Riley
121 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:38:42
I think the main difference on here is between realists and others. Most, including myself, are dissatisfied with the current owners but realistically what are the alternatives. As I recall when the Moores family wanted to sell out there was hardly a queue of buyers despite the realistic price. There were two interested parties, Peter Johnson and Bill Kenwright. Johnson won and I was hopeful that with an apparently astute businessman at the helm things would improve. I was wrong - Johnson fairly quickly lost interest and wanted his money back. Again the queue of buyers was then just Bill Kenwright. He scraped the money together to buy Everton mainly I think because he was a fan. It now appears that having failed to find investment (probably conditional in him remaining in some sort of capacity) he would like his money back but finds there are no interested parties. In those circumstances it may that BK is actually doing the best he can I'm not sure. In any event protests are not going to change that situation if it is the reality.
Ciarán McGlone
122 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:20:40
"I just don't see the need for a body which pushes their own agenda above and beyond the real desires or realistic desires of the people they intend to represent."
------------------------------

Maybe you don't understand unions. They don't have an independent agenda pursued by their executive committees ? they have an agenda set by their membership.

Perhaps you should research the concepts you intend to use as the premise to your point.

Anthony Hawkins
123 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:45:00
@Martin 503 - if by selling off the assets to gain an increased on field presence, we have not truly increased our resources - we've traded them. It costs money (arguably a different type of resource) to increase resources, money which the club does not currently have.

I fully agree with how well the club have performed where we are currently at. Very few could or would argue that. The current end performance and finishing position are right up there. The issue is deeper than that. We SHOULDN'T have to fight to purchase a player worth £5m because a banks come calling when we sell a player. All clubs sell to balance a level of the books but it shouldn't be that the club CAN NOT buy players or have to grovel to the banks to free up funds. The board should already have those funds available.

It's like buying a car - its not just the car you have to afford - its the servicing and repairs also. The board have the car on hire purchase but keep re instigating the full loan to service the car but can't afford the repairs. Other than pure dumb luck, there's only ever one likely outcome.

Neil Kudrycz
124 Posted 06/06/2012 at 15:20:10
I support the B U's aims, but if we start next season well then there will be very little dissent from the terraces. Along with the meetings and protests, maybe if the crowd sang "sack the board" all as one, as we did to get rid of Johnson this might get the message through to black bill and his cronies. I have moaned about the mismanagment of this club for years and even tried to start a "sack the board" chant in the street end a few years back when we got battered by the arse 6-1, but it fell on very deaf ears.
In my opinion, if the board are removed and someone installed who has an ounce of business acumen, then our great club will once again be able to compete and make us all proud.
Andy Walker
125 Posted 06/06/2012 at 15:06:09
Q. Why would an autonomous group of professionals be a far better bet for EFC than BK and the Board? A. Because BK is useless and must go.
Q. OK but why should we entrust our club's future into the the hands of group of unknown technocrates? A. Because BK is useless.
Q But the new lot may be even worse mighten they? A. Who knows, but BK is rubbish and we need to get rid of him. BK out BK out!
Q But there will be potentially serious represcussions of a change in the Board such as the creditors' responses, the manager's response, who will control our club, a list as long as your arm in fact. Surely there's lots to consider so we need to thoroughly interogate any proposed solution and the people proposing the solution. A. Oh yea but BK is useless, he needs to go, whoever takes over has gotto be better than BK, he's useless dont you know.
Q. What about putting together a detailed plan setting out the future vision for our club without BK? A. Why should we keep useless BK, what has he ever done for us?
Q. But don't you need to put forward a positive alternative, a plan that's, considered, viable, achievable, you know something that can inspire the fans to jump on board and support it. A. Yea but BK and the Board are useless arent they so they need to go.

Roberto Birquet
127 Posted 06/06/2012 at 15:54:23
Chris Kelly
You're right. We'd have no chance of winning the league with our players, despite having a very good squad by our prem era standards, at least if we have Pienaar back.
And I wish so much it weren't so. But this is the terrible consequence of unfair competition - as defined by Uefa chief Platini. Teams such as Chelsea and Man City are getting the equivalent of betablockers to gain an unfair advantage. This is to a level beyond those of pre-Prem League.
I tire of those who say Liverpool dominated - almost monopolised - success in the mid 70s to mid-80s. Take the 60s, when no club won back-to-back titles, then the 70s, when Derby and Forest won titles, and check out the clubs in the top four from 76-84. They included the likes of West Brom, QPR, Southampton, Ipswich, Watford, and even Villa won the European Cup. I pray such days return.
Until three years ago, everyone knew the top four for each season and had done for years. Now Man City have leapfrogged Liverpool, and Spurs compete with Liverpool financially - and on the pitch beat them.
But if we have to compete with Man City paying players £200k a week, or offer Lescott £94K a week, then it is bankruptcy or find someone who does not care losing hundreds of millions of pounds. The truth is we CANNOT EVER compete in this environment. And nor can the vast majority - ever. Yes, a better board could have improved matters - I turn again to KD. We would also have a far better chance of maybe, just maybe, competing on at least an occasional basis with a ground share scheme on the park. Many bury their heads in the sand and refuse to accept the real when rejecting this.
And which brings us all back for looking for that billionaire. And we tear ourselves apart over it.
John Keating
128 Posted 06/06/2012 at 15:42:05
Martin
why would whoever - if ever - takes the reigns from the present board need half a billion to get us up and running ??
You seem to have an extremely low opinion of the City, have you been there in the last few years ??
How long should any board of directors be given to turn the business around, over ten years seems more than fair, doesn't it ??
Gavin Ramejkis
129 Posted 06/06/2012 at 14:02:01
Brian Harrison - looking at the fan protests at Blackburn and Villa as directly responsible for those team's poor performances is utter twaddle, the paucity of those teams and their managers caused their on field problems. Its like saying do you remember man City fans clamouring for the departure of their own BK in the form of Peter Swayles all those years ago - look what happened to those lot.
Anthony Hawkins
130 Posted 06/06/2012 at 16:30:00
@Andy 523 - I doubt many, if any, are calling blindly for BK and board to leave. What we are callin for is a much more propriate level of sale - one where the club REALLY IS for sale to someone who cares and has the funds to move Everton forward. BK and the board DO NOT have any funds and the only way to provide more is to sell key quality players for a price and buy newer riskier players for less. What should be happening is buying quality players and building a lasting team encourporating them. Under the current board, we can not do that.

How many times does BK have to say "I don't have the money" until people actually listen. Look at the words and look at the facts. It's one of the rare occasions the truth has been spoken!

Andy Walker
131 Posted 06/06/2012 at 17:15:42
Anthony, fine, you dont rate BK, I understand, I get it. I really dont need anymore people telling me why they think the current board are no good. That's the rationale established for why change should be on the agenda - agreed, big tick, accept I dont dispute it ..... So nows the hard bit ie what's the positive alternative side of BU's argument look like? (other than the autonomous body of professionals, cos if thats all they have to offer, if that's the cunning plan, it aint up to much).

Can someone please explain what the alternative looks like, without just reverting to why the current board are no good in their opinion. What's the plan, someone, anyone.......please.

Richard Reeves
132 Posted 06/06/2012 at 17:12:52
History will show that this board have borrowed money and stripped assets without putting in a single penny. A few people are going to make a lot of money when the club is sold and that includes Bill "I mortgaged my house to save Everton" Kenwright.

The trouble is, Kenwright might be long gone before a lot of people wake up. I want him to be held accountable for his actions now, while he thinks he's some kind of saviour.
Martin Mason
133 Posted 06/06/2012 at 17:25:27
John @530

I'm sorry, I didn't mean to put the city of Liverpool down, I'm an exile but I was born there and my parents are/were real scousers. All I'll point out is that Walton isn't Mayfair or Sheperds Bush.

I say we need half a billion to resolve EFCs structural problems and unless we do this no board can bring success. That is pay off debt, increase revenue, build a new ground and strngthen the squad so that it can compete with those who can spend J200MM a year. It isn't going to happen for us of course .

For anybody who says the board should unconditionally put money into the club I'll throw down a challenge, put your money into the club to improve it. I'll collect the funds and put some in myself but I reckon there'll be no takers. What happened to Trust Everton btw? I thought that was a very good idea.

Andy Walker
134 Posted 06/06/2012 at 17:55:53
Richard Reeve have you any actual evidence to support your accusation?(which I don't want to repeat as I dont want to risk being sued!) If that were true it would indeed be a scandal. How do you know this?
Martin Mason
135 Posted 06/06/2012 at 18:01:05
Richard @538

You are sailing very close to the area where you and this board could be sued. Perhaps you could share your evidence with us.

John Keating
136 Posted 06/06/2012 at 17:59:16
Martin
couldn't an individual or group of individuals have the business accumen to buy the shares from Bill and his mates - at a reasonable price - possibly increase revenue by renegotiating the give aways the present board have made. Plan a phased rebuild of Goodison. Give Moyes even a couple of million a year to spend. Talk to the banks etc etc etc. Without having anywhere near a half a billion ??
The present board have not put in 1p of their own money so wouldn't someone putting in 50 quid at least be an improvement.
Ciarán McGlone
137 Posted 06/06/2012 at 18:05:18
Martin,

One defence to defamation is 'truth'..

Tell us which part of Richards statement isn't verifiable or in the public domain?

Borrowed money ..... Tick.

Stripped assets.... We have less assets than before Kenwright arrived....tick.

Haven't put any money in...big tick.

Steve Smith
139 Posted 06/06/2012 at 18:05:01
Ciaran McGlone 513:

"Maybe you don't understand unions. They don't have an independent agenda pursued by their executive committees ? they have an agenda set by their membership."

Perhaps you've hit the nail on the head, it's not really a union is it? and even if it is, it represents a minuscule percentage of the fan base it seems, I don't remember them advertising for members, or electing officials etc. etc. in fact the one essential part of forming a union is to sign up a sizeable majority, otherwise it's a toothless non entity.

Phil Martin
140 Posted 06/06/2012 at 18:55:48
@ Martin Mason,

"You are sailing very close to the area where you and this board could be sued. Perhaps you could share your evidence with us."

How about the accounts for the last 9 years? See numerous loans from Barclays and other offshore sources.

Brian Harrison
141 Posted 06/06/2012 at 18:57:08
Gavin 531

I didnt say that the protests at Blackburn and Villa, were the reason both teams had bad seasons. I was merely pointing out that it was a contributable factor, and to say it had no effect was to quote you twaddle.

I also said it you bothered to read it properly that so far our protests have been outside the ground, but I feared what would happen if the protests were held inside the ground as some BU supporters had suggested.

Funny how everytime the BU are mentioned on this site, it attracts such polarised positions amongst fans. Maybe they need to ask themselves is it the majority of fans who are out of touch or the BU.

Anthony Hawkins
142 Posted 06/06/2012 at 19:21:40
@Andy 537 - mate, you have me wrong. BK has done a lot for the club. Some great stuff and some I disagree with, but he's stabilised the club and done what is in his power to do. You can not ask any more. Now is his time to move aside and let another person step in who has the clout even he admits he lacks. That's what I'm saying.
Andy Crooks
143 Posted 06/06/2012 at 19:20:44
Anthony @497. Well, that's unions sorted out then.
Eugene Ruane
144 Posted 06/06/2012 at 18:58:59
Andy/Martin.

I'm no lawyer so I'm curious.

Re Richard's post (538), sued for what exactly?

If you're suggesting (as I presume from your concern you must be) that his accusations are false, specifically, WHICH bits do you believe aren't true?

You think the board HAVE put in their own money?

If so, who?

And when?

And how much?

You think assets HAVEN'T been sold?

You think this board are NOT looking to make on any sale?

BK might be useless, but I doubt even HE isn't daft enough to put himself in a position where he might be publicly questioned on the club's finances and his relationship with the truth.

Mike Green
145 Posted 06/06/2012 at 19:54:29
Essentially the Blue Union are a union of fan groups, not a union of fans, aren't they? So, maybe you need to have a rethink yourself Ciaron McGlone? Where there's power there's potential for abuse of that power, and trust me union leadership are more than capable of it.
Eugene Ruane
146 Posted 06/06/2012 at 19:35:50
Mike (567) - you state...

"Essentially the Blue Union are a union of fan groups, not a union of fans, aren't they?"

Right...and who are these fan groups made up of?

(think there's a fairly good clue in there).

You also state "where there's power there's potential for abuse of power".

And?

Fact, there's 'potential' for all sorts of things.

Where there's power, there's POTENTIAL for amazing and wonderful change.

Isn't there?

Isn't that JUST as valid?

And you don't explain WHY anyone should 'trust' you, re union leadership.

Sorry but innuendo, suggestion and NO facts just sounds like the Daily Mail.

Andy Walker
147 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:25:38
Eugene, I dont know if BK has or hasnt put any of his own money into the club, although I have always assumed he has, but this assumption is not based on any evidence. But to state he definitely hasnt put money in and then should it turn out that he actually had put his own money in, could potentially be liable in my opinion, although I am not a legal expert so don't rely on me! I do though speak as someone who has been threatened with legal action by lawyers for posting on a blog that I thought a certain company was 'going down the pan' - I quote exactly - that was all I posted yet I received legal papers threatening to sue me for liable. In the end the company accepted a written apology from me. Some folks are very sensitive to this sort of stuff!
Eugene Ruane
148 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:35:53
Andy (570), Finance I am ignorant on, but wouldn't he have to declare it if he had?

Wouldn't it appear on balance-sheets or...something?

(if there's someone who knows, I'd like to know).

By the way, if there are ever libel hearings, they should hold them inside Goodison.

I'd part with 50 nicker to see BK quizzed (might help with the debt)

Andy Walker
149 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:35:10
Anthony #559. I agree completely and I guess BK may do as well. For me its about how we get to the position were we have a wealthy owner with the best interests of our club as the no. 1 priority.
If BU could actually come up with some constructive ideas it would help me understand what a possible solution could look like. All I can see at the moment is that we have to pray for a very wealthy person, who happens to have a passion for EFC, to come along and to put their hand in their pocket, invest £100m + and be prepared to loose a lot of it. Not good odds.

What I dont want to happen though is that we throw away the stability that the club has at the moment with BK as this enables us to buy some time to find the right person. This is a globally crap time to find anyone who prepared to invest in serious commercial projects with decent potential returns, let alone invest in a football club which is inherently high risk. Buying time will help us see the golbal storm out, or at least die down (could be a year or 2 though).

Handing the club over at this time to a group of yet unknown autonomous professionals as BU suggest, fills me with dread particularly as it seems impossible to find out any detail about how such an arrangement could come about, operate and then be succeeded.

Jay Harris
150 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:02:51
Roberto
if you care to check EFC accounts for 2009/2010 you will see :
Earnings before interest and tax (excluding players sales) of 17.658 million and interest of 4.487 million.

According to my maths that makes over 22 million lost before player sales and tax.

Furhther more if you care to check the 1998 accounts posted in 1999 you wil see that an operating profit of 1.85 million was made and furthermore PJ announced that a ground move was planned and that "a small number of preferred sites have been identified and assessed.At my own insistence they are all in the Liverpool area".!!!!!!
At least PJ made a profit , put his own money into the club and had plans which is a darn site more than the current clown and his buddies.

Andy Walker
151 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:56:06
Eugene, simple answer is I just dont know for sure, which is why I would never want to make any definitive statements about such matters either way.
Jay Harris
152 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:02:02
andy # 570,
forgive me for saying this but
your ignorance astounds me.

Elstone came out last year and confirmed the NO Everton director had put a PENNY of their own money into EFC.

Ian Bennett
153 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:51:52
Eugene - you can put money into the club in 4 ways.

1. Increase the share capital by issuing more shares - no change since Johnson pumped in cash ages ago after buying out the moores.

2. Make director loans to the company ala John moores. I.e loans will be repaid with interest.

3. Go as guarantor on the loans that the club make with other institutions. I.e club takes the debt and if it goes pear shaped claim is made against the guarantor.

4. Pump money in via crazy naming rights see the Russian clubs, or Ethan deal.

Based on the accounts all assets have been sold or pledged as collateral to new loans. Bill, the board, or a unknown party may be acting as guarantor, but the other 3 situations I don't think have happened.


Andy Walker
154 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:09:34
Good grief Jay, you're a tough task master. The fact that I was unaware of an Elstone statement from last year qualifies me as 'astoundingly ignorant'. Wow. To help me get up to speed then could you guide me to where I can find this statement? I know I am probably the only person on the planet who doesnt know but think of it as a charitable action on your part to help someone who isn't blessed with your powers of recall and knowledge.

You'll be telling me the earth's round next.

Lyndon Lloyd
155 Posted 06/06/2012 at 17:06:34
Roberto:
That is just silly. Most of those have three to five years left on their deals. We rarely allow top players' contracts roll down to a year left
It was an exaggeration to make a point about the ephemeral nature of players' value but I would say that if the Club were forced into a fire sale ? and Kenwright's "don't kill us" plea to Barclays suggests that's not so far-fetched ? the values of those players would be severely undercut.
Anthony Hawkins
156 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:16:59
This thread also proves exactly what I wa saying - that Blue union are easily distracted into other paths and fall short on follow through. I was under the impression the protests were because the club wasnt being run appropriately and that needed to change. Are the BU really that short term in their views that they think a small amount of cash resolves the whole issue?
Jay Harris
157 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:08:27
What part if thsi dont people understand:

The BU are not looking to take control of the club.

They are simply asking for a team of experienced professionals (Yes experienced professionals!!) to be given the job of finding a suitable buyer the club on fair commercial terms.

While "The best salesman Everton have" takes a well earned break from the 24/7 routine he has conducted with abject failure for the last 12 years.

Whatever way you look at it Kenwright has failed.

FAILED to set out a plan for the club.

FAILED on 2 ground moves.

FAILED by significantly increasing the club's debt.

FAILED to have any semblance of commercialism.

FAILED to communicate with small shareholders and longstanding fans.

FAILED to secure investment.

FAILED to sell the club

FAILED to tell the truth on countless occasions.

IMO he is actually the "Worst salesman Everton have".

Eugene Ruane
158 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:49:37
Cheers Ian, I genuinely have a blindness with anything to do with finance and numbers.

There is a 'condition' called dyscalculia - like a number version of dyslexic.

I'm claiming I have it (better than 'thick at sums')

Paul Carr
159 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:32:17
BK stated on Sky a few months ago that he had put everything he owned into the club.
However the annual accounts show that this was a blatent lie as there are no loans shown from any of the Directors. It would be interesting to know how much he has invested in his Theatre Company.
Andy Walker
160 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:31:55
Jay we know the BU are not trying to take over the club, they want an autonomous group of professionals to take it over for an indeterminate period.

The problem is a soon as anyone asks for detail of what this means they just get exactly the response that you have once again repeated ie an attack as to why BK and the current Board must go, thats it, every time the same response. If it wasnt so important it would be Monty Pythonesque.

Every time someone asks for detail of BUs plan, like: so how would it work, who would be in this group of autonomous professionals, how long would they be in authority, who would they report to, how much would they be paid, what qualifications and interests would they have, what impact would it have on current creditors and the manager etc etc, we simply get the 'because BK and the Board are rubbish response'. Nothing constructive about what BU proposition, to be frank its just not good enough.

Ian Bennett
161 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:40:53
Paul - he must have meant he bought his own season ticket, £800 has probably wiped him out.

I think he has claimed he has never received a salary or expenses as well. I'll let the mob round on him whether he has brought any value to the club to deserve owt.

John Keating
162 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:34:03
Andy
you say that Bill offers us "stability" in these challenging times " globally crap times " " global storm "
So I take it you mean since the recession hit 3 or so years ago ?
He says that he's been looking for a buyer 24/7 since he took over the club 12 years ago.
That being the case how couldn't he find a buyer in the times of milk and honey ?
Could it possibly be that he wasn't ?
Could it possibly be that it's just been another of his - I was gonna say lies but it appears theres a storm tonight about being brought up for libel so best not say the word, but you know what I mean !!
Andy Walker
163 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:56:08
John we just dont know do we, only BK knows the full story. All we can do is look at the reality and take a view. As I have stated several times I have no problem with change, I just wish we could concentrate on the solution and not on why we need to consider change, I get the argument for change 100% and as I keep repeating I dont need anymore reminding, its been done to death.

Just look back at this thread, dozens of posts repeatedly highlighting reasons why in posters opinions a new Board is needed, yet not one setting out any details on what BUs alternative approach is. If we are to bring change then we need a persuasive plan in order to be act as a credible voice. Specialising in 1001 reasons why BK must go, on its own will achieve nothing and will only be counter productive as those undecided on the best solution, like me, consider the alternatives. I am suspicious of BU motives but only because I can not find any detail of what their solution is and their continuous harking back to attacking the current board.

Please move on and concentrate on what you can do, not what you think others cant do.

Andy Walker
164 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:13:24
John, just to be clear the reference to 'you' in my final para of my last post is referenced to BU, not yourself.
Peter Laing
165 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:08:12
The one question that Kenwright and Elstone continually evade is this - how much is Everton Football Club on the market for ? I've seen Kenwright duck this question many, many times, most recently if I recall when he was interviewed on the Sunday Supplement or whatever its called on SKY with David Moyes. He was asked directly by Ben Sheppard and answered with the usual bull of the price changes from day to day. The only person that I know who has broken this cover is Keith Harris who suggested a figure in the region of £150 million, although we all know that this guy is a fantasist like Kenwright - hence his alleged involvement in Everton.
Kevin Sparke
166 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:21:11
Walter Smith has said that Everton were close to administration twice during his time as manager and I'd be willing to bet we've been close to the wire a few times since whilst Moyes has been manager. I've no love of the current board - in fact they've proven that they're not just inept, they're not beyond telling a few untruths if it serves their purpose

It's absolutely clear that in order to compete at the top level Everton either need investment or a buyer - more likely the latter; though the world of global finance is much different than it was in 2008 when Manchester City scored their second big takeover... We look like we're entering very shaky times and whole nation states and trading blocs look like entering a long drawn out period of financial uncertainty - can a provincial club, with a museum of a stadium, limited support and obscure history (to all but purists) attract this much needed investment/buyer? - I'm very pessimistic that they can; though the 'quick buck' spivs and barrow boys who make a lot of noise but don't have the collateral will be a-buzzing around like flies around a dirty shithouse.

However, I don't back Blue Union. Here's why - In secretly taping a meeting and then releasing it to the whole world they demonstrated just how deep in the shit we were to every club manager looking to buy one of our assets - they scored a howler of a 'Sandy Brown' and probably lost a huge amount of people who'd otherwise have been on board... you're Everton supporters - why weaken our position in the transfer market? Apart from that, it made them come across as devious, untrustworthy and much, much worse unprofessional - do I want people like that representing my interests? - no... I don't think so.

Do I want protests inside the ground? If it's going to have a detrimental effect on team performances - no... I don't think so. In fact, I can think of no better way of alienating other Evertonians by disrupting games... it won't work, and will in all probability lead to animosity and even blue on blue violence - as sure a way as any I can think of, of marginalising a worthy cause.

So, what is to be done?

Ditch protest - it doesn't work. Be smart - raise awareness through 'positive campaigning' and humour - not through anger... stand around shouting slogans and people just mark you down as disaffected bully boy knobheads and switch off from you; advertise, lobby, use the local and national media - become creative in your campaigning, use propaganda by deed by individuals and small groups not mass marches - in short, do something different - make people like you; if they like you; they begin to listen and then begin to hear your point.

I know some of you blokes have links with KEIOC - take a leaf from their Anti-Kirkby campaign; especially their work on the 'Football Quarter' - they're not just pointing out the negative - they're proposing solutions.

Dennis Stevens
167 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:11:00
Andy W, I thought these professionals were to be tasked with finding a suitable buyer for the club, not with running the club. Where did that idea come from?
John Daley
168 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:01:49
"..we know the BU are not trying to take over the club, they want an autonomous group of professionals to take it over for an indeterminate period."

No they don't. Where do people keep getting this 'they want to takeover the club' bullshit from? It's clearly stated that:

"BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton"

See the words 'sole remit' smack bang in the middle of that sentence? Why do you keep ignoring them?

Steve Smith
169 Posted 06/06/2012 at 21:59:36
Jay # 597

Maybe you've quoted it wrong but based on the way you have put it, your maths is wrong, those two figures are not added together to total the loss, the interest is deducted from the EBIT as far as I know, which would show earnings of Plus £13M before tax.

Nick Waters
170 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:19:12
Kevin, you'd rather not know what's going on at the club would you? Because without the releasing of the words coming out of Kenwright's own mouth, we would not be able to have even this discussion at the level we are. Instead we'd have rumour, innuendo, people 'in the know', irrefutable claims and counter claims, and basically a verbal custard pie fight. At least we're all able to put forward our views in an informed context - whatever our views might be. Well done the BU for that at least.
Peter Laing
171 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:24:39
Agree John Daley # 606 "BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton", the starting point would be the price, minus the debt, plus the profit that Kenwright, Woods and Earl appear to be seeking with their unrealistic, over-inflated valuation.
Kevin Sparke
172 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:30:43
"Kevin, you'd rather not know what's going on at the club would you?"

I'd rather the manager of Manchester United/Arsenal/Chelsea etc didn't know the precise details of our finances prior to making bids for our players...

Ian Bennett
173 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:21:49
Kevin - our financial records are open to everyone, I don't think blue union have told the footballing world anything new.

The point on administration will alarm many, but what does it mean. Basically we don't have the cash flow to continue. I would suggest most clubs are in that situation as they always spend budgets signing that player to take them to the next level, retaining that player for more wages, or missing that up run or league placing. The key part is that administration has been avoided by player trading out of the situation.

It sounds sensational from Walter, but the reality is bill would not risk his equity by letting the business go into administration and risk losing his equity stake whilst he has assets being players or other. The issue for bill is the assets are getting less as everything is under hock or the squd have aged. The chances of barkley getting a testimonial at everton are as great as me scoring the winner in the euro finals.

Peter Laing
174 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:32:41
Kevin do you remember the wall of silence last Summer prior to the Blue Union blowing Kenwright's cover ? The e-mail transcripts from Prince Rupert's tower are fairly telling wouldnt you say ? The fact that Everton appeared to be days away from administration ? The fact that Arteta saved Everton from financial meltdown ? The fact that Elstone appeared incapable of stewardship ? The fact that we had a gaping hole in the Park End wall which represented the state of Everton's financial affairs with the proposed Goodison place development lying in tatters ?
Kevin Sparke
175 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:34:42
Ian - they taped a private meeting and then released the contents to the press; some of which contained sensitive information about very current financial matters (at that time).

If you cannot see what's wrong with that - do you fancy a game of poker some time?

Bobby Thomas
176 Posted 06/06/2012 at 20:56:38
Martin Mason: I believe that far from being the board that has dragged the club down, this board has arrested what has been long term decline and it is highly likely that it is anything other than a very temporary respite.

Quite.

Martin, I agree the decline of Everton has been a long one, probably as far back as Labby goýng off in the 1971 FA Cup Semi at Old Trafford.

But that does not absolve the board of blame, they are not heros swimming against the tide of decline. There was a point when they were a good holding board after a traumatic period, steadied the ship. But that point has long since passed and they have been actively selling parts of the ship to pay for fuel to keep it sailýng for a long time now.

Let's try some brief, rushed, context:

In 1988, we broke the British transfer record. 4 years later, we were one of the 5 teams that formed the breakaway Premier League as we were one of the Big 5 teams in the country. The club was only 4/5 years out of the most successful period in its history.

Since then, in the last 20 years, unparalleled amounts of money has come into the game. Many clubs have used the football boom to to transfrom their grounds and progress their clubs... riding the wave of the Premier League, harnessing the boom in football to transform their infrastructure, attract a generation of new fans. Nurtue their clubs, grow their fanbases.

In the period following the start of the Premier League Everton was being VERY poorly ran, was out of ideas and financially in very poor shape (sound familiar?). Yes, they were possibly even worse than THIS board.

The best/worst example of this I can think of is the single tier, executive box free, cramped/limited hospitality Park End, symobolic of the lack of foresight/short termism that has been symptomatic of this club for years. There is validity in what you say. Ownership Era of the Prem Number 1.

We were taken over and, in the first 18 months of his reign I think Johnson actually drove the club forward quite powerfully. Share rights issue, money for transfers, built some momentum. This was done in conjunction with Joe Royle having a very good first year and a half in the job. Pitch and board innovation need to be in harness to progress a club to its optimum level. Kenwright has benefitted from consistency and, until the self mutilation of the last couple of seasons, on pitch progression, bear that in mind.

The sacking of Joe was a watershed and from there it was all downhill and the club was mismanaged. I am no fan of Johnson for how things turned out; it was unacceptable. That was Ownership Era Number 2.

But I make the Johnson point because it CAN be done. The club CAN be progressed, even now, more than15 year later and with the football growth boom virtually over, inflated to complete distortion.

After Johnson, the club was basically put on ice as the ownership was resolved, eventually bringing in Ownership Era Number 3 and the initial period of BK, True Blue Holdings or whatever being a safe pair of hands.

But really, its been carnage for years now. The summer with Gregg and the club being absolutely brassed, Rooney money to keep us afloat and making do with Marcus Bent on a £450k. This was nearly 10 years ago, Moyes has rýghtly been referred to as the heat shield. He PERSONALLY saved Kenwright's bacon that year.

They have had a long enough spell to ride the Premier League boom. The history of their ownership extends too long for them to be hostages of the club's decline; they have actively hastened it.

I've asked you this before; I will ask you again:

WHAT HAVE THEY DONE TO MAKE EVERTON BETTER? HOW HAVE THEY HELPED EVERTON? HOW HAVE THEY IMPROVED OUR CLUB? WHAT PLANS HAVE THEY PUT IN PLACE THAT WILL BENEFIT EVERTON IN THE FUTURE?

Their chronic short termism is KILLING Everton.

In 1995 Everton, finished 6th in the league. Arsenal finished 5th. We missed out on a Uefa Cup place due to a very late Ian Wright goal I think.

We were still, even then, VERY similar clubs.

Not any more.

Look at Newcastle's ground, Villa's, Sunderland's... Liverpool have done 3 sides and need to move, and if they ever do by the way, forget it: it's game over for us. Spurs, United, look at how Celtic pulled themselves out of decline... in fact, pretty much fucking anyone's ground!!! Celtic were in a very similar situation to us 25 or so years ago, ground and financially. But they did it. They harnessed their fans, they didn't push them away, they were innovative and they got on with it.

I am sick of bullshit, lies, smoke and mirrors and incompetence dressed up as the best we can expect, all we can hope for. It doesn't have to be like this.

I can understand your fatigue, Martin. They have us where they want us... tired, split and most of all afraid... afraid of change.

Example. You excuse the fact this board have not come up with a viable, workable ground move in the 10 YEARS since the Kings Dock. What plans do they have in place to change this? Any? This is paramount. This club first aired the issue getting on 30 years ago. Why have we not even redeveloped some of the ground? Why have we done nothing? How have we reached a situation where the board have failed, 100%, completely and utterly failed to help, aid, progress and safeguard the future of this club for generations.

THERE'S BEEN NOTHING.

One example. Even now there are ways out. There is so much love for the club, even with our aging shrinking fanbase. Share rights issue? No chance. They just will not do it.

You cannot keep slapping your fans in the face and expect them to show up unconditionally. People know when they are having the piss taken out of them. You have to give them something. Share rights issue for... Moyes's kýtty, Park End development... Do something... If the board showed they were making an effort to progress the club, people would WANT to get behind the club. Even today, there is loads of latent support for the club out there.

You know what, Martin, it's nearly 1 am here, I sense I should probably shut up anyway.

But think about it.

Think about the failures that blight the club. The tone for any club is set from the top. Look at our finances. Look at the failure of every significant venture (good ideas or not, they viewed them as worthwhile) to take the club forward. Look at the disenchantment and melancholy. Look at our ground. Look at where the Bellfield money went. Look at the murky ownershýp issues. Look at our debt. Look at Moyes's transfer pot for the last 4 seasons, or in fact since he arrived. Look at Darron Gibson and realise he cost £100k more than Martin Dobson over 35 years ago. And on, and on and on.........

Look at the club you used to know... and look at it now.

It doesn't have to be like this...
and it shouldn't.

Peter Laing
177 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:40:33
Kevin I would say that the Manager of Manchester United knows exactly the precise details of Everton's finances, cast your mind back to the Summer of 2004, Trevor Birch lasted 6 weeks in his post as CEO, the state of Everton's books clearly alarmed him and he advised Kenwright to cash in on Rooney. Kenwright went on TV and stated that Rooney wasnt for sale, not even for £50 million. A couple of weeks later Ferguson came calling and snatched Rooney away for a down-payment of £10 million, the rest on the drip as we are led to believe, or throw in a Neville, Howard etc
Ian Bennett
178 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:40:11
Kevin I would never turn a game down.

Was it damaging, potentially yes. But let's not kid ourselves, clubs are not aware of publicly available information, or private information from sales documents, agents, players, insiders, bankers, journalists. This is football where everyone knows everything. Do you know the wages of your 11 colleagues, where as everyone knows who earns what in the premier league.

Carl Sanderson
179 Posted 06/06/2012 at 22:45:05
I cannot see anything changing at EFC unless and until David Moyes leaves. In my opinion he is the single reason that we remain in the top flight; when he leaves we are going to see an almighty shit-storm.
Jason Heng
180 Posted 06/06/2012 at 23:09:38
"BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton "

- BU will gain much credibility if it first produces its "fully autonomous group of professionals". Until then, the ball remains on the court of the Board.

Ste Traverse
181 Posted 06/06/2012 at 23:31:38
Our club is being crippled by a bunch of amauters in the boardroom, yet we still have some complete beaut called Kevin Sparke banging on about a coversation that was alleged to have been taped. Unbelievable.
Dennis Stevens
182 Posted 06/06/2012 at 23:40:38
Jason, the ball will remain in the Board's court as they own the shares. However, I'm sure I recall BU putting forward names of individuals/organisations that might be suitable for the role.
Kevin Sparke
184 Posted 06/06/2012 at 23:46:55
Ste - Anything constructive in your argument, or is wanky ad-hominem the best we can expect?

I don't expect this will penetrate the layers of tosserdom you seem to have spent a lifetime refining... but if a group want to be taken seriously and perhaps achieve respect amongst supporters who it should be trying to get on board to further its aims - alienating potential recruits to its cause by behaving like amateurs (that's A-M-A-T-E-U-R-S) is not going to be clever.

I suspect you realise this - hence the use of defensive ad-hominen.

Ste Traverse
186 Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:08:35
The rubbish you spout Kevin regarding the so-called 'taped conversation' and it weakening our posistion regarding transfers can simply be laughed at.

Since the infamous meeting with our 'brilliant' Chairman we've sold...

Arteta for £10m
Beckford for £3.5m
Yakubu for £1.5m
Bily for £5.5m

Now,I don't really see those prices as being unvalued. (Yak maybe). They certainly wasn't players sold by a club who everyone suddenly knew was desperate because of some alleged 'leaked conversation'. Everyone in English football knew we were hard up years ago.

In anycase,if it was true the coversation was taped without knowledge (I don't believe it was),who fucking cares? BK has been using underhand tactics during his whole tenure. What goes around etc etc.

Peter Laing
187 Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:25:51
Kevin do you have proof that the Blue Union meeting with Kenwright was taped ? Unless you can provide proof I would suggest your argument and assertions regarding Blue Union are flawed on the premise of 'hearsay'
Mark Riding
188 Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:24:35
Kevin #632. I can relate to your 'potential recruits' comment.
I agree with a lot thats been said here, I know change is needed, and I think its needed quicker than we think !
Alarm bells are sounding already this summer.
I heard Jeremy Vine today on 5 live talking about his style of journalism. He said that he had many instances of where the cameras were running ( without the persons knowledge ) and they recorded comments made by politicians that could totally change peoples opinions of the people involved. As much as he wanted to air the footage, he was not allowed to.
Releasing 'secretly recorded' comments made by Bill, didnt do the BU any favours, although I believe they thought they had to get it out into the public.
Shouting across the car park and recording an agressive response from Bill got some more publicity..

Amateurs, maybe.. but what else is there right now ?

Jay Harris
189 Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:40:36
Steve #607 The EBIT was negative 17.5 million which when you add the interest of over 4.5 million totals a loss of c. 22 million.

Roberto was claiming Kenwright had not made a loss of up to 20 million during his tenure and asked for proof.

Well there it is.

In fact Roberto it is over 20 million.

Kevin Sparke
190 Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:30:02
Ste - I know logic isn't your strong point, but try and stick with me...

What if without the taped conversation and leaking to the press a meeting that was behind closed doors, the true state of the finances of our club were broadcast for all managers to see - they flipped our hand, they exposed our cards, they let our competitors see our weakness (BU - that is)

Call themselves Evertonians?

So - Arteta £10 million might have been Arteta £12 million
.... Beckford £3,5 million might have been Beckford £5 million

Do you see where we are going with this Stevie baby... or do I need to spell it out to you some more?...

Secondly, releasing this information to the media had other implications. Now, you have to use your imagination for this bit (hard work for a fella of your obvious limitations - but again bear with me).

BU have stated that they want:

"In place of the Everton Board ? assuming of course that they are genuine in their intention to sell the club ? BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton ? an ownership that can demonstrate a viable plan to secure the financial and cultural future of the club."

Now, given their past history of unprofessional behaviour in dealing with confidential information in the past, let me tell you something - no professionals will come anywhere near them... they're damned by their past record! Do you really expect Kenwright to have any dealings with them? The only way they will ever achieve any of the aims they profess to want to achieve is if they begin again with a whole new organisation.

And get this Ste - I want rid of Kenwright too.. desperately. But I'm not going to throw my support behind this bunch of clowns - why? Because their past actions demonstrate to me that they've not a clue how to run a campaign and I don't fucking trust them and what is more I don't trust the interests of Everton FC with them!

Don't take my word for it - have a listen to the lack of approbation they get at the next home game. We should all be as one in wanting the best for the club - they've lost the respect and the trust of the very people they should be getting on board.

Christine Foster
191 Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:57:58
The first and most important question is:

Bill, whats the plan?

Why, because no one knows, its not up to BU or any fan to come up with solutions although many have to no response. Its the boards remit. By law.

Anthony Hawkins
192 Posted 07/06/2012 at 01:02:13
Where I personally think the BU 'bid' falters is that the board should NOT be given a choice or control. Yes they have the shares but a proper protest with crowd pressure soon removes the ability to do anything else. Currently BK is acting like a dictator - its his club and he's not letting go despite not having the funding to run it accordingly.

BU seem to think a few "Bill, would you mind awfully giving us a bit

Anthony Hawkins
193 Posted 07/06/2012 at 01:15:07
Hit post too early...

The BU are taking the approach of "we're going to protest but Bill, if you wouldn't mind bunging a fiver in the kitty, we'll go away until a time thats more appropriate for you".

That's just not going to work.

If you're going to protest - protest until you get the results you wanted, not just some bread crumbs to feed off.

Can anyone tell me why the protests were cancelled? Some say it was because the on field displays got better or that some new players arrived. How does any of that resolve the fundamental problem of he board with m

Anthony Hawkins
194 Posted 07/06/2012 at 01:21:29
...and again - I'm on my mobile...

...how does that solve the fundamental problem of a board without any money? Or a club which isn't actually for sale?

If the BU are trying to get an independent group together to purchase the club, the approach as got to be stronger than "Bill, don't you think you should have others looking at it - oh wait, you've bought a couple of players, we'll go away for a whole. No, no, it doesn't matter what we we're just saying - advisers? What advisers? Pah, we can have that chat in the summer!!"

Yes, Bill and the board are trying their best to run the club with no cash but they certainly aren't trying to get a proper investor or to sell the club - which is what is needed.

James Flynn
195 Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:17:25
From the American cultural anthropologist Margaret Mead:

"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has".


BU. Do your thing. All support to you.

I was raised in a workers Union by my dad. Our equivalent of Thatcher was Reagan; mirror images really, from an American point of view. When Ronnie had his big union-busting moment to our unionized Air Traffic Controllers, "You're fired", I watched with gritted teeth.

Without Unions the most of us would still be leading our 10-year old children, naked, back into the mines to pull sledges full of coal to the surface. The sledges we filled for them at the same pay rate.

Now, we're here talking about a sports team we love and support, its way forward, and the BU's part in it. Hardly the same as fighting for a fair wage and safe working conditions. But we know no business conceded anything to employees without pressure apllied to their handling of said business. We know this.

Our ownership has failed (beyond lucking into Moyes) to get us a new stadium and failing that, to generate revenue streams routine to the sports world. The BU is putting pressure based on these undeniable facts.

I care the BU is going forward with their protests and keep them going. Don't worry, BU, about all of us side-liners watching you.

"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has".

Keep going.

Eric Myles
196 Posted 07/06/2012 at 02:22:12
" so-called fails like KD weren't fails because they were never going to happen because we didn't have the finances"

Un fucking believable.

It's like saying we didn't lose to United because we were never going to win so it wasn't really a defeat!!

If we didn't have the finances then why play the charade that "the money's ringfenced"

Eric Myles
197 Posted 07/06/2012 at 02:37:17
Dennis #605 "Andy W, I thought these professionals were to be tasked with finding a suitable buyer for the club, not with running the club. Where did that idea come from?"

It's just the usual anti-BU people either not wanting to understand what is actually being said or deliberately twisting what is said to suit their argument.

Didn't the board a few months ago start talks with just such a professional company capable of finding a buyer for the club. It was reported on these pages and ironically it was a company the the BU had recommended!

Martin Mason
198 Posted 07/06/2012 at 03:26:34
Ciaron@546

There is nothing illegal or in any way underhand about any of these actions. All companies borrow to operate, all buy and sell assets to continue operating and no directors put their own money into companies especially basket cases like EFC unless they can be sure of getting a return on that investment. There are no returns for anybody at EFC now and probably forever
Selling assets to buy other assets (players) isn?t asset stripping either; it?d be asset stripping only if the sale of assets had been to their personal benefit and it wasn?t. The board sold assets to buy players and maintain our status.
There are a lot of opinions stated here on how the board has ?failed? in every respect. It?d be easy to list as many or more cases in which the board has clearly succeeded despite being hampered by low revenues compared to its competitors. We demand success even though it is unrealistic, we demand new players so the board borrow and sell fixed assets to buy new players, we then castigate them for borrowing; they try to buy a ground on the back of a retail development (the only way we are ever going to do it as we have no cash) and offer a vote on it and it fails so we castigate them again. The common thread here is that whatever they do there?ll be some who will immediately get on their backs for doing it.
After what I saw last season the board and manger have my support and BU don?t, they are an unnecessary and to me an irrelevant distraction at a time when the club is in desperate trouble and struggling to survive.

Eric Myles
199 Posted 07/06/2012 at 04:41:58
"The board sold assets to buy players and maintain our status."

The greater amount of monies from the sale of players went to pay off the board's debt eg. the Arteta 10 mill.

Not to mention the money from Bellefield.

"it?d be asset stripping only if the sale of assets had been to their personal benefit and it wasn?t" The definition of asset stripping doesn't have to be for their personal benefit.

Tom Hughes
201 Posted 07/06/2012 at 07:16:39
Martin Mason..... you are a serial revisionist of our club's recent history.

Last season we had to sell simply to stay afloat, how many other prem clubs have had to do this? Not just players but the systematic selling of every piece of real estate to preserve ownership is asset stripping by definition.... we can never get that back. Hiking up "operational costs" by a few thousand percent to cover various unknown new costs in the accounts.... and or directors charging the club extortionate interest on loans may also be construed similarly.

BTW an out of town retail development will never pay for a new stadium.... has clearly proven already. Firstly, it would've had to be several times the size of the Trafford centre to get even close to yielding the amounts claimed..... and secondly there is nowhere in Merseyside or reasonably beyond that will ever receive planning permission for such. This was stated from day 1 by KEIOC who had asked all the relevant bodies..... yet the club continued spending money we apparently don't have on a complete farce..... wasting several years in the process. Failure!
Kings Dock.....complete abject failure. The park end development....laughable failure! Feel free to list our successes!

Despite the fact that this board and the previous one inherited the stadium that needed the least done to be fully compliant with the Taylor report..... they still managed to do nothing to address the urgent issues that we're still suffering from now. There are conference league clubs with more boxes than us.... We have just 11.... Villa and Spurs have over 100 each, and had to invest far more to achieve it than we ever would have done. Similar for Sunderland and Newcastle..... Even the Sheffield clubs in the lower leagues on tiny crowds have all achieved far more...... Only Pompey have achieved less in this regard, and you can practically go through the whole league to see similar ambition and investment on lesser revenues than ours. Our net spend over the past 10yrs is miniscule.... and combined with the mysterious operating costs shows quite clearly that the club has been subsidising the current ownership which has injected nothing, and delivered nothing.

We have been outspent repeatedly by several clubs with lower revenue than ours.... our commercial performance produces a lower return than all our immediate peers..... all, or at least partially because we have failed to achieve what ALL other clubs have regarding investment and development of our infrastructure.

None of this is the BU's fault..... all these multiple failures have been this board's.... simple as that really! Stop attempting to shoot the messengers for stating the bloody obvious!! The simple fact is we cannot carry on like we are..... whether you're hell bent on backing the board or not..... it's a bust flush, and always was. They have had over 10yrs, and the good fortune to have had Moyes carrying them on a 3rd tier budget...... time's well and truly up!

How protesting against this situation is an irrelevance is completely beyond me.

Thomas Lennon
203 Posted 07/06/2012 at 09:08:55
This article has an interesting statement about how Man City was sold - http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/18248444

"We built a prospectus to sell the club," he continued. "They were interested in other football clubs and we had to sell the idea that Manchester City was a good investment.
"They liked the vision and we started to meet the key stakeholders. We then realised that we'd got it right and we knew that we were going to make a big, bold statement in the world of sport, not just football.
"It was about getting someone who cared for the football club. They are passionate about it, they want to win and they're ambitious. They knew how passionate the fans were about the club - there was nothing plastic about this.
"I am proud of what I've done, but it's not me alone. What I feel I managed to do was build a team of people who believed and could see the vision."

Our board have appointed several people to try to sell the club - I wonder if we could see what their 'vision' is? Our board and many of our fans are conservative or at least have been for as long as I can remember (back to the 1970's) - that means they don't seek change unless they have to. We are not a club that aggressively seeks success, we hope it will happen, we look down our noses at those who do. That is essentially what BU are arguing against.

If BU succeed in moving this mass of opinion - and there are few who would say they are at the moment - we must accept that we are entering a phase of higher risk (the club might be on less stable footing) and active change, uncomfortable for many.

We can only assume that one of the clubs the Dubai people looked at was Everton. Man City made out a better case to buy them than we did because of their vision - and no doubt a new stadium had something to do with it. Why not Everton? Why wasn't it Newcastle? Man City board sold the club to them with visions of the future, not memories of the past.

KEIOC & BU have a history of rejecting change. They now tread a very fine line between opposing change that they don't like (who decides what this is by the way?) and supporting change that they do like (ditto). If a tough unpopular decision is to be made (such as moving to a new stadium as part of a vision of the future) are they the right people to promote what is good for the club?

To summarise:

What is the vision we are currently using to sell the club?

Will BU support aggressive unpopular change to achieve the sale of our club?

Eric Myles
204 Posted 07/06/2012 at 10:36:06
Thomas, here's an extract from our prospectus to indicate what 'vision' we are selling to propsective buyers.

Goodison has "inadequate capacity, limited and low quality hospitality facilities, poor sightlines and limited accessibility".

What history of rejecting change do KEIOC and BU have? Desperation Kirkby?

Matt Traynor
205 Posted 07/06/2012 at 10:51:52
Eric #698, I had a brief sight of that prospectus, and the impression I got was it certainly wasn't trying to sell the club.
Mark Wilson
206 Posted 07/06/2012 at 10:19:29
If you eliminate the stupid and distracting name calling, another strong thread about the problems our club faces and yet another close season "discussion" that manages to be passionate, frustrating, angry, and deeply deeply depressing all at the same time. But even though my heart sinks at yet more BU debate, more name calling and schoolyard argument, more stuff that drags us through the mud and has the rest of the football world writing us off as impoverished clowns, part of me keeps begging, yes begging, for some form of reality check.

Reality : it is crystal clear, or it should be, that we face another shameful, appalling close season unless we sell one, possibly two, players who are the heart of the club. This is NOT about wheeling and dealing. In no football world I recognise would Moyes at this time think its right to sell Baines or Fellaini. They are 100% pivotal to any future success on the field. I suspect Fellani will be the one to go because there is a small chance money could buy a reasonable if clearly not as good replacement. Baines is in my view, at this time, not replaceable. If he is sold no amount of wheeling and dealing will address his loss at this stage. Cahill could be sold to (mostly) support the crucial purchase of Piennar. Yobo to partly cover the annual £5m operational loss. Jags could, and in my view should, be the player who leaves but we will not get anything like the £17m that was discussed 18m ago. However, if he and a couple of others like Victor left we could see £14m arrive in total and Moyes might see £10m of that. This IS the only wheeling and dealing that will allow DM to enhance the squad, a little, and maybe, just maybe, give us a better start next season.

But I fear this won't happen and we face a grim and squad destroying close season because, whatever your views on the BU, their basic assessment remains horribly realistic..... We are utterly broke, lose more and more money each and every year and even the CEO gives a financial assessment that may be emotionally different than the BU but is scarily similar in terms of the bottom line. WE CANNOT MAKE ENDS MEET DAY TO DAY MONTH TO MONTH UNLESS WE SHORT TERM BORROW AND THEN SELL PLAYERS TO PART FUND THE DEFICIT AND BUY LESS VALUABLE REPLACEMENTS. IS THIS NOT THE REALITY ?

I find the criticism of the CEO to be based on personal dislike rather than, again, reality. He is not the person to blame in all this and frankly I think it's amazing he does what he does to keep the operation as afloat as it has been. Only those who have never held leadership positions can fail to see that expecting him to declare we are crap, we are broke, we are without hope is, well, unrealistic and unreasonable. He will never give the BU or other critics what they seem to seek, though in truth I think he came rather close in his recent financial analysis. I am though disappointed that he defends our commercial record quite so rigorously when that defence is based on improvements against even worse starting point ten years ago, yet it is the current comparators that beg the questions about Kitbag and Nike etc. But then I also feel that many have a rose tinted view of Everyons commercial value. I don't think we are seen as offering a good return on marketing investment, for a whole raft of reasons that include still being in the shadow of the shite, the poor stadium, a much more localised fan base, lack of tv coverage etc etc.

Reality. : many are tired and fed up with the debate and yes the BU was right to suspend its campaigning last season. There could have been a Kevin Brock moment had we won the cup, who knows. Instead we shamed ourselves at Wembley and no amount of finishing above the worst RS squad in living memory makes that Wrmbley debacle ok.

Reality. : I and I suspect many others, listen to debates, read the BU statements, but fail totally to understand how they propose to force the Board to do what they want without some form of horrendous violent conflict inside the ground ? And even then I think this unacceptable approach would backfire in spectacular fashion. The majority will not go along with attacking the chairman like that regardless of our anger at the clubs pathetic financial mess. So, reality check, isn't it the case that, even though it shouldn't happen this way, the only real way the BU make a difference IS to publicly go out and find these group of professionals willing to take interim charge and who passionately believe they can sell the club ?

Of course it's a bit the wrong way around, well a lot actually, but surely the BU and others who feel like this should put aside their frustration and agree on a strategy that sees them PUBLICLY demonstrate what might be possible and not just by baseless statements or angry opinion, but by showing everyone that such a group of professionals exists and is willing to do the job ? It would then be for the Board to publicly reject the offer, so to speak. I feel that it is this type of approach, this strategy, that will change the views of the vast majority of fans who, strangely as far as the BU see things, remain steadfastly unmoved by our current dire financial state and it's gradually worsening impact.

In the meantime there is still a glimmer, just a bare glimmer, of hope that by wheeling and dealing around the fringes of the squad, by selling Jags, DM can do just enough to actually significantly improve the squad, get us a good start to the new season and use that impetus to get the playing side doing what the clubs finances suggest should never happen.....from there it's again "who knows" but frankly I feel that this scenario looks less and less likely as the close season progresses. What is it about Everton that always means this is our lot ? It drives you mad, it really does.

Eric Myles
207 Posted 07/06/2012 at 11:24:56
"Yobo to partly cover the annual £5m operational loss"

But remember Mark, that £5m operational loss was only £5m because we sold Bellefield and received £10m for that. We don't have another Bellefield to sell this year so we really need £15m for Yobo.

Gavin Ramejkis
208 Posted 07/06/2012 at 11:22:22
Kevin #643, its pretty much standard business process globally and has been for some time for an aggressor (buyer) would seek credit reports and copies of public domain available information regarding its target. The release of the minutes of the meeting with BK have illustrated nothing whatsoever to clubs interested in buying our players at its financial plight that wasn't already available in black and white from said reports over the last few years. A club that hadn't bought a first team player for several seasons, a club that was outspent in several transfer windows by non-league sides, a club whose squad had shrunk to the smallest in the EPL. To top those fairly obvious in your face actuals you also have the behind closed doors knowledge within the sport where I'd bet my last pound the majority of agents and managers also know the perilous state of Everton's finances.

You can beat whatever drum you like about disliking the BU but to use that particular stick to beat them with as blame for the price the club got for players sold doesn't hold water. Like KEIOC before them the BU aren't a bucnh of professional venture capitalists or such like but a group of like minded Evertonians, just as in all walks of life and lines of arguments people will disagree and in this instance rather than veer to a miltant display the group chose different options, some right some clearly wrong but thats what you get with people, they all make mistakes.

Phil Martin
209 Posted 07/06/2012 at 12:27:05
The BU leaking that taped recording was a necessarry evil. Yes it was underhand but as they were setting up the biggest bull shitter in Everton's recent history. I'd say it was justified.
Every club already knew how skint we are. All the recording did was highlight what was then a minority were already stating. Kenwright is out of his depth and dangerously deluded,

For 12 years - during the boom and boost he's searched "24/7" and found no-one.

I actually believe the kitbag deal is also a massive deterrent to new investment. Shirt and Merchandising deals are a big revenue % of any club. Yet EFC sold its future streams for the next 6 years at a very low level. Currently earning less than Fulham - and in 6 years from now perhaps closer to Barnsley or Leicester.

A new owner would either have to buy us out of the deal (very expensive) or just put up with a 3rd rate Merchandise income for at least 5 years.

Which leads to the question - is this not another example of bad financial management? Sacrificing future growth for a quick fix.

Everton FC as a club, huge fanbase, massive potential, definite room for significant business improvements = worth a look for a long term investor.

Everton FC as a business, no accountable assets, already sold off forthcoming TV revenue for the next 2 years, locked into a lengthy mediocre merchandising deal, stubborn ownership, unrealistic asking price = sinking ship.

Matt Traynor
210 Posted 07/06/2012 at 12:44:15
Phil #713, my recollection is the BU steadfastly and repeatedly denied tape recording the meeting, and the minutes produced were written down immediately afterwards from their own recollections and notes during the meeting (I recall at one point BK actually saying words to the effect of "make sure you write this down..")

You are right in decrying the KitBag deal as a bad deal for EFC. It's a good deal for KitBag of course, who no doubt new about Everton's parlous financial state when negotiating.

Regarding the TV revenue, your statement is incorrect - they haven't sold off the TV revenue, they have borrowed against it. If I recall, the Vibrac loan (which was a replacement of an existing facility) was around £12m. Everton's income from the Premier League TV/merit/placement money would be in excess of £50m.

Christine Foster
211 Posted 07/06/2012 at 12:39:08
We can,t even decide if we are looking for investment or we are for sale. We can,t even get that vision across so what hope is there of a board promoting a vision to anyone?

What is that vision Bill?

What's the plan Bill?

As fragmented, hopeful, wistful to some, BU at least have a plan, more than the board do. Sure it may not tick every box but it's one more box than the board has.

No AGM to be accountable to, an absolute disgrace. Pressure for change is better than just being arrogantly dismissed by a greedy, self righteous group of people claiming theybhave the clubs best interests at heart. Why do so many people believe them?

It's foolish to ignore where we are and how we got there just as it is to support the idiotds who got you there by trusting their judgement to put it right.
Their arrogance is complemented by the sheer stupidity of those who actually believe they have done a good job. Unbelievable.

It's no wonder we are where we are, right where Kenwright wants us. Arguing not about them but amongst ourselves. Wake up for Christs sake!

Chad Schofield
212 Posted 07/06/2012 at 13:06:25
Bobby Thomas... great post!

Kevin Tully
213 Posted 07/06/2012 at 13:15:40
I believe some supporters see an attack against the Board as an attack against the club itself. They refuse to see what exactly is happening to the club.

I suggest they forget about where we finish in the League, and look at what could be achieved if we didn't have to sell our best players, and if we had developed Goodison.

I used to defend Kenwright and the Board, but some refuse to admit they were wrong - get over it.

This Board are corrupted by the thought of a big pay - day. They don't care where we are in ten years, we are the fans who will be left in the shit - do you really think they give a fuck about us ?

Ste Traverse
215 Posted 07/06/2012 at 13:25:54
Kevin 'not very bright' Sparke.

Can you please confirm for a fact you know the conversations were recorded without permisssion? Cheers.

And secondly, if you think we were ever going to get £12m for Arteta, or £5m for a 4th rate striker in Beckford, you are an even bigger fuckwit than I thought.

Peter Laing
216 Posted 07/06/2012 at 13:38:48
Ste, he conveniently evaded that question when I put it to him as it clearly does not fit with his agenda, i.e. blaming Blue Union for Everton not receiving £12 million for Arteta or £5 million for Beckford when there is clearly no substance whatsover for such an allegation.
Andy Crooks
217 Posted 07/06/2012 at 20:04:41
James Flynn,@649. stirring stuff.

Financial discussions make me whitey so I tend to stay out of such debates, However, people I respect have got through to me just how precarious our finances are.To me, the Blue Union have the aim of saving this club. They'll get things wrong sometimes but if and when they get it right we'll all thank them.

Supporters of Kenwright say that he's a fan with the best interests of the club at heart. So am I but I am aware that I cannot afford to live that particular dream. The Blue Union are also fans with the best interests of the club at heard but they don't want to run the club ; they want someone who can do it better. Who can disagree with that?

Thomas Windsor
218 Posted 07/06/2012 at 20:21:14
The Blue Union have to keep it up because otherwise it means Kenwright and his mates can do what they want ? but let's wait to see how much they give the manager first to buy players; if he sells a big name player for a big profit and just gives Moyes £6 million, we have to have a voice.
Ian Bennett
219 Posted 07/06/2012 at 19:53:43
Michael K

Any chance of getting the official Everton stats on the website? The OS seems to have taken them down.

My understanding is a little different to Eric's when he says we are losing £15m. The below is a cut of the only P&L I can find.

Excluding player trading, amortisation and depreciation of the lawnmowers, I have us down that we lost £3.7m from the business before player trading/amortisation but after interest for 2011.

As a business this is the immediate need to narrow the gap as this is the pure burn rate of cash we are going through without paying down debt or selling down assets be it training grounds or players. This has probably been achieved by the sales of players on wages that were not replaced at the same level (Arteta, Yak ?? although we will have received some loan fee / wage save, Beckford, Turner and Vaughan). But certainly leaves us with no free operating cashflows to invest organically ? be it players, stands, or stadia.

The rest doesn't excite me that much. Horse trading players and selling bellefield, and amortising player contracts that we will probably sell for a profit 9 times out of 10 in any case, exaggerate the P&L doesn't reflect the core business. This is sure to upset some, but it's only reporting previous/future gaps between historical book cost and true realised value.

So, yes we could lose £15m, but it's not £15m from day to day activities.

Revenue £82m
Operating costs £(81.6)m
Day to day operating Profit £0.4m

Interest charges £(4.1)m
Current year Loss £(3.7)m

Exceptionals, prior spending and depreciation
Depreciation £(1.0)m
Player Sales £7.4m
Bellefield sale £8.4m
Amortisation of Player contracts £(16.6)m

Profit before tax £(5.5)m


Martin Mason
220 Posted 08/06/2012 at 03:28:32
Andy@775

Who can disagree with that?

BK, he owns the club and the decision is his.

Eugene Ruane
221 Posted 08/06/2012 at 07:16:45
Martin Mason (814) - "he owns the club and the decision is his".

Thanks for this incredible insight.

You could have made that your first post and left it at that couldn't you?

Or did you post it simply because all your other 'arguments' had been shown to be nonsense and you thought 'ah, I know, I'll post one that they CAN'T dispute making me the winner - hurrah for me!'.

A genuinely desperate response.

And remember Hicks and Gillette 'owned' the other shower....until they were fucked off sharpish.

Eric Myles
222 Posted 08/06/2012 at 07:57:55
Ian #781 read 'em and weep

http://www.toffeeweb.com/club/business/finances_11.pdf

As I said £5.4m loss BUT that was cusioned by the sale of Bellefiled at £8.4m so without that fixed asset sale loss would have been £13.8m.

Note the report where it says RECORD operating losses and increase in net liabilities (gross liabilities increased to £95m)

Alan Williams
224 Posted 08/06/2012 at 08:16:08
Martin 814, Eugene 817. BK doesn?t own EFC never has, he officially has 27% and by a tiny margin is the major share holder. Agreed his pals (Woods, Earl) allow this stake to rise collectively but board alliances can be broken and have been on this board and many others before. I see the statement from BU doesn?t mention BK which I believe is the correct way to approach as you are wasting your time attacking him, achieves absolutely nothing he is the patsy that will take it for the others and if you want to crack the egg either go for the others on the board or start buying up shares in EFC either direct or via Trust Everton, become a player. If you devise some sort of trust so that people don?t lose either their donation or shares then shareholders can pass their individual shares to the Fans trust without risk but the shares are controlled by the trust and the trust grows depending on its attractiveness to the fans be that in money or actually shares it?s the only positive way to do this, if the trust fails then the shares/money are passed back to the original owners. The statement from BU ?club should be sold or should be taken out of the hands of the current board of directors? is pathetic as is the BU statement ?In place of the Everton Board ? assuming of course that they are genuine in their intention to sell the club ? BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton ? an ownership that can demonstrate a viable plan to secure the financial and cultural future of the club? The BU has so many intelligent people on its committee yet it issues statement like this which seriously lack so much creditability that it actually weakens the whole position of the BU. Stop acting like a mob at the gates and get some panache about yourselves and tackle what?s ahead with positive plans to get what we all want which is new ownership with external investment. As side issue maybe some fans should view the fans website of Cardiff City who had new owners and decided to change their home kit to RED, they are called the ?Blue Birds? the owner did it because that is what he wanted and said I?m making the investment so I decided what colour we play in! This is too important to get wrong, Good Luck
Matt Traynor
225 Posted 08/06/2012 at 09:24:15
Alan #822 is correct. Of interest is that BK has increased his personal shareholding recently (in the last 2 years or so). He's always claimed that he, Woods and Earl would vote together, and alluded to in the meeting he had with the BU members.

He claimed in that video when he was in the car park that he wouldn't re-introduce AGM's (the question he was asked) "whilst the BU control the Shareholders Association".

Alan may be onto something. It's been fairly well documented that Lord Grantchester is not a fan of the way the club has been run, and I am sure that some of the ESA would sympathise. Given that it is believed that Green and Earl were only in it for the retail opportunities tied to a new stadium, it's possible that Earl's shareholding could be a weak point in that triumvirate.

Eugene Ruane
226 Posted 08/06/2012 at 11:02:15
Alan Williams (822) - You advise the BU...

"get some panache about yourselves"

Three things.

1) What

2) The

3) Fuck?

Seriously, who do you think they are?

And I have to ask - are YOU involved?

Are YOU attempting to help in any way?

Fact: The BU are a group of disparate (and desperate) Evertonians.

Fact: They care about the club and because they do, are prepared to do whatever they can to stop it (ie: US!) vanishing up the Swanee forever.

Fact: They are NOT a professional body (so will make mistakes).

Panache!!?

(drinks Martini) "The namesh U.......BU"

Seriously, if you feel you have the 'panache' or know how the BU can..er.. get hold of a load, why not offer your services?

Or are you one of those obsessed with pointing out what's wrong with those attempting to address the problem, rather than addressing those who ARE the problem?

Martin Mason
227 Posted 08/06/2012 at 11:21:15
Sorry, BK doesn't own the club. I mean that he is the owners' representative.

Eugene, Hicks and Gillette were easily overthrown and it wasn't the fans that did it. BK is a completely different proposition and he won't be budged by a group that he has nothing but contempt for and who represent only a minority of our fans. So, how do you plan to get the ogre out of his cave?

Alan@822, I'm very interested in the concept of the Everton Trust as an avenue for actually doing something rather than just talking about it. I agree with your comments on the BU too, well said

Christine Foster
228 Posted 08/06/2012 at 12:12:18
Sadly just. Because we are Evertonians does not mean we share the same views, we should embrace diversity alas the only extremists are those who smugly believe they are the majority.they may be, but that doesn,t make them right.

No amount of words will change the view that they are right. We have seen the same people spout the same views in relation to Kirkby, what happened to that is an example of what change can do.

The change will come from within the board when one or two break ranks and sell their shares, and that will happen when people pressure.

What will it take?

What's the plan Bill?

Tony J Williams
229 Posted 08/06/2012 at 12:38:38
I have a question that is niggling me. If we manage to oust Kenwrong and his mate and get this board in place to sell us. If they don't find anyone with a specified amount of time, say a year, do they start thinking, we need to drastically reduce the price and maybe doe away with due diligence on a couple of points to get the sale? WHo will be paying them? What are their instructions? Sell at any cost, just as long as you sell?
Tony J Williams
230 Posted 08/06/2012 at 12:49:02
Sorry, that was a couple of questions
Anthony Hawkins
231 Posted 08/06/2012 at 12:14:40
It's not the getting involved that counts - it's getting involved in the right way. It's easy to be critical and more difficult to actually do something - and it's unlikely to please everyone.

...that being said, the lack of financial clout is what damages the board and the club. BK and co have done well to keep heads above water without the cash required to build properly so they've re-jigged the funds and been creative.

I'm not an immense fan of BK but I don't wish him harm - just that he and the others would let go of the reigns and let someone else buy the club who has the funds to do a complete job.

Anthony Hawkins
232 Posted 08/06/2012 at 12:52:53
@Tony 836 - The issue with the current "sales" policy appears to centre around a couple of points.

#1 The club is not 100% for sale - they are looking for investment only.
#2 The price being requested appears (from an outside perspective) to be too high. The board would like a positive return on their investment in a climate where their investment has more than likely deminished.

What this means is any prospective buyer will likely be put off because:
#1 They would not have full ownership and therefore control
#2 There is a gap between what is the true value of the club and the value the board places on the club.

It's possible to sell anything for an inflated price in a time of high demand or limited availabilty. Trouble is, we're in a place where neither is applicable.

Matt Traynor
233 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:01:32
Tony #836, BK has gone on record as saying he has given several outside agents a mandate to sell the club. From memory, I think PCP Partners, Leon Angell, Duetsche Bank, Keith Harriss are all involved, and I think there are a couple of others.

Traditionally (accepting an EPL club is not traditional) you would expect a commission to be payable of 3-5% of the price to cover all costs. Like an estate agent, you get a better commission as a seller (i.e. lower) if you go with an exclusive agent. The commission would be payable by the seller. In this case I would expect the agents to roll this to the buyers, rather than expect EFC to cough it up.

Now, this raises the question, if so many different agents are involved (I think there are 6, at least), why would the BU's idea of an interim board tasked with selling the club be any different? It could go part of the way to explain why all these different agents haven't delivered.
1) They aren't that arsed about pushing it as they're not exclusive, and they may lose out to another agent if their client offers a couple of mill more.
2) The asking price is unrealistic, so why bother wasting time/incurring costs when no-one would be interested.

My understanding is that an interim board would be independently able to set an acceptable price. I think that's what happened over the road when Stadtler and Waldorf tried to stop the sale process as they felt the FSG offer undervalued the club (and was going to lead to them being out of pocket).

Therefore, you can see why the EFC board might be wary of following such a path. I think the problem, as ever, is in the price being sought for the club, and point to the oft-quoted figures as £150-180m. It is unlikely in the extreme an independent board would arrive at that figure as a valuation. In effect it's similar in some regards to a repossession. The house is sold for the market price, the seller still owes money on it. Sad faces all round.

So this begs the question, if the board haven't invested their own money into it, aren't looking to make a killing out of it, have borrowed / sold all they can asset-wise to operate the club, is there other borrowing not on the books that we don't know about? Might explain a bit.

Personally, I think it's a bit of both - unexplained borrowing, and looking for their lotto win.

John Keating
234 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:01:37
Anthony
I agree with you to a certain extent and obviously it is a financial " thing "
However, what I find totally objectionable is those people who say we need Half a billion ! A billion !! 8 billion !!
Why ? Why can't we have in place people who not only love the club but who can also have a long term sustainable plan ?
Admittedly any prospective new owners will need the funds to buy out the present clowns, talk to the bank, Kitbag etc etc. but surely if new owners came in openly and honestly and laid out everything in front of the support we would give them the time they needed to improve matters.
Nobody, including the BU, are asking Bill et al to sell to the first purchaser but surely given the right sale price there must be someone out there interested, apart from the guy in the Manchester bedsit.
Matt Traynor
235 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:25:38
John #842 you old romantic.
Sorry, but with the scale of money that will be required, there'll need to be a period of due diligence both on the existing state of the club (including all the messed up commercial deals and loans), and a view on what could be done (redevelop Goodison, new site), over what timescale, at what cost, and with what revenue impacts.

Only then will these new Knights know whether it's £200m over 5 years, or a £billion over 10, and whether there's any prospect of getting a return on that.

I'm all for a degree of transparency, but wouldn't want the fans consulted on everything as to some it'll be a vote (consultation isn't a referendum), and the memory of DK will live long.

Paul Jamieson
236 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:19:48
Martin -post number 830 - "I'm very interested in the concept of the Everton Trust as an avenue for actually doing something rather than just talking about it."

I don't see trust everton doing anything, talked a lot, asked some questions over 18 months or more and then nothing. The BU proposed a group of professionals be brought in, they named one such group, Inner Circle, and Everton have spoken with them. Like it or not they raised awareness in the fanbase, they don't claim anything else, have read people on here asking for business plans!!!

In my opinion the only way a trust will get off the ground is by having keioc organise it, they are the only doers the fans have, they have the knowledge and the track record and the people to make it happen. Trust Everton is clearly going nowhere apart from talking about it.

Phil Walling
237 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:17:37
I guess we have to face the reality that without player sales,the club as we know it,is done for.With everything of value,including future revenues mortgaged to the hilt ,the players are the sale of last resort.
Of course,Moyes knows and accepts this and it will be the outcome a further test of his resourcefulness which will determine for how long Everton can maintain a top-half place-or indeed remain in the Prem.
I have long believed that chairman and manager are joined at the hip although I have to concede that the manager has proved much cleverer than his paymaster.
Frankly,I can`t see the possibility of any buyer/investor coming to our rescue so we can only look forward to ( hope for) a SLOW lingering demise.As for the prospect of some magic formula being hit upon by business orientated Evertonians,I think BU are whistling in the wind.
Martin Mason
238 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:19:27
Christine, the majority doesn't need to be smug and doesn't believe that it is "right" or "wrong" as there is no right or wrong in these circumstances only alternatives. We all have the same wishes regarding the future of the club but simply getting the current board out is not the solution unless the incoming board has not only substantial funding to pay off debt, solve the ground problem and strengthen the squad but a credible business plan that will give a sustainable future.

For some fans this sustainable future can only be challenging for CL places but for me the reality is that Everton will never attract such a buyer and short of developing a batch of home grown stars it will never again have the income to compete at the very highest level in the EPL. The reason for this is that EFC has nothing to offer a potential monied buyer and nobody with half a brain cell would "invest" in a basket case business that gives no returns. I really doubt that they could give the club away given its liabilities.

We can all raise opinions about what this board has or hasn't done but all I see is that they gambled by borrowing to the hilt and selling the silverware to try to buy "success" and failed. Having said that they have rebuilt and produced a fine side but one that does not quite have the skill nor depth of squad to challenge for CL places. I'm still very pleased at what the club has done recently and this is not an acceptance of mediocrity, all we can ask is that the club achieves it's potential given its resources and for me they have done that.

To take the next step we need nothing short of a miracle and I believe that our chances of imploding and losing status are far, far higher than that of us being bought by the right buyer and becoming more successful. If we have to sell players like Fellaini and Baines and/or we lose our exceptional manager the implosion could happen quickly.
John Keating
239 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:38:19
Matt
agree.
I don't believe the fans should be consulted on everything as the new owners will have a right to do what they see fit.
What I meant was for any new owner to put everything out there in black and white - which I do not believe the present lot have done.
Only then will we all know the true scale of the situation and allow the new owners the time to possibly turn things around.
When the Venkys went in to Rovers the support expected a new Man City scenario, a Chelski. They didn't appreciate the full situation both on the clubs side or the owners ability to fund.
I just can't understand the reasoning behind some supporters expecting a City situation where we get a sugar daddy funding the takeover, debt, new squad, new ground etc all in a year or two - it ain't gonna happen ! Hence I don't understand why we need a billion to buy out the present mob.
Alan Williams
240 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:14:26
Eugene, your reply just sums up most of the arguments around this subject, hot air with no substance. I?m not involved with the BU but I have had some minor dialogue privately with a senior member of BU and if I?m honest he was very warm and welcoming and my opinion of the group has changed considerably since the dialogue. Nevertheless, the recent statement in my opinion undersells the intelligence that is running the group and it pounders to the stereotype as apposed to what I honestly believe can be achieved. If fans collectively including current shareholders got together and consolidated their shares as one via a trust of some kind then we have an alternative form of negotiation and the pressure from within will break the major shareholders to at least be more transparent and subject to money raised possibly even influential. I?m not and have no intentions getting involved in any group due to my work, location and family commitments but I?m willing given the correct terms donate money to such a group. I use the word panache, as they need to sell it better to both the fans and the board but currently they are making statements that in my opinion are confrontational and they know deep down these terms will never be agreed unless the creditors force them too, and if that is the case we are in deeper shit that we are now. I suppose I?m trying to be constructive in opposition, never forget that everybody?s end goal is the same which is unique so use that as a point of bringing people together, this is not an industrial dispute.
Matt Traynor
241 Posted 08/06/2012 at 13:58:13
John #849, more open-ness with fans would be a good thing after the last few years. Re-instating AGMs would be a start.

Of course there needs to be a degree of commercial sensitivity with certain aspects related to current agreements, possible future agreements.

But actually having owners who don't appear on every football chat show, tearing up reminiscing about the good old days, when things are going well would be a good start.

I still think the way the DK move was "sold" to fans was the worst piece of consultation I have ever seen. It was also a shit-houses move. They didn't have the conviction of the plan to go out and say, we're the board, we're in charge, and this is the right move for us. If it had gone ahead, and years from now we're in financial mess, they could just pin it on the fans for voting for it. Although I also believe they would've sold up as soon as permission was granted.

Peter Laing
242 Posted 08/06/2012 at 14:04:03
Alan, you must have a painful arse with all those splinters from sitting on the fence, ever the neo-con with the statement "constructive in opposition". The only group who have bothered to get off their arse and raise awareness regarding Everton's disastrous financial plight and the lack of appropriate stewardship demonstrated by the Chairman and his board of directors is Blue Union. There is plenty of talk and hot air on these pages but little action. Without Blue Union we would likely still be subject to the spin and lies from the odious Ian Ross, they have raised awareness and at least put pressure on Kenwright to remind him of his duty and obligations to the good name of Everton.
Eric Myles
243 Posted 08/06/2012 at 14:15:07
Anthony #838 "that being said, the lack of financial clout is what damages the board and the club."

You forget that all our board members are multi-millionaires, as are their 'friends' so why is there a lack of financial clout?

Maybe if the BU could figure out a way to use investment in the Club as a tax dodge one of the 'friends' might be a bit more interested in coming forth?

John Keating
244 Posted 08/06/2012 at 14:21:21
Peter
I think you are spot on !
Like them, hate them or just ignore them. The fact is that people, supporters, ordinary guys like those at KEIOC and the BU have given up their spare time and lives for something they love in order to raise awareness with what is going on within OUR club !
Look at the debates we are having and the things that are coming out into the public domain.
Would the average non interested supporter have known about the shady loans and deals, ground moves etc if not for groups such as the above ??
Forums such as this thrive on such information and more importantly, far more importantly, groups like KEIOC and the BU have checked the unlimited, headlong pursuit into oblivion that the present board were headed.
Like them or hate them pressure groups such as the above should not be ridiculed but should be applauded for the fact that they do what we only wish we could do.
Brian Denton
245 Posted 08/06/2012 at 14:36:27
Eric #853, you could be on to something there. The fact that we have Sir P Greene (by all accounts one of the most aggressive tax avoiders in the UK - all perfectly legal I know) on the Board is an embarrassment, especially since he does not appear to put any of his money into the club.

And before anyone tells me off, the condemnation of 'aggressive tax avoidance' (his phrase, not mine) comes from our Coalition's Chancellor, Mr Gideon Osborne.

Eric Myles
246 Posted 08/06/2012 at 14:51:51
Brian, he's not on the board, he's just a friend of Everton's!!
Brian Denton
247 Posted 08/06/2012 at 14:57:15
Eric, my mistake - but he soon would be if we could make it 'tax-efficient' !
Eric Myles
248 Posted 08/06/2012 at 15:01:12
Yeah Brian, surely all the losses could be written off against tax?
Eugene Ruane
249 Posted 08/06/2012 at 15:27:44
Alan Williams (850). You state - "Eugene, your reply just sums up most of the arguments around this subject, hot air with no substance".

Well Alan, what can I say - not everyone can be as intelligent or perceptive as you.

I actually thought I had posted a few entirely legitimate questions and a few indisputable facts.

But fair enough, happy to be proved wrong.

Copied and pasted below is my offending post - you tell me which SPECIFIC bits are 'hot air' (bullshit or whatever) _________________________________________________

"Alan Williams (822) - You advise the BU...

"get some panache about yourselves"

Three things.

1) What

2) The

3) Fuck?

Seriously, who do you think they are?

And I have to ask - are YOU involved?

Are YOU attempting to help in any way?

Fact: The BU are a group of disparate (and desperate) Evertonians.

Fact: They care about the club and because they do, are prepared to do whatever they can to stop it (ie: US!) vanishing up the Swanee forever.

Fact: They are NOT a professional body (so will make mistakes).

Panache!!?

(drinks Martini) "The namesh U.......BU"

Seriously, if you feel you have the 'panache' or know how the BU can..er.. get hold of a load, why not offer your services?

Or are you one of those obsessed with pointing out what's wrong with those attempting to address the problem, rather than addressing those who ARE the problem?
_______________________________________________________

Peter Laing (825) imo has it and you pegged - a fence-sitter.

But please, don't let me stop you waffling on about how nobody is doing it properly...while doing fuck-all yourself.

You say..

"Nevertheless, the recent statement in my opinion undersells the intelligence that is running the group and it pounders to the stereotype as apposed to what I honestly believe can be achieved".

Two things.

1) The 'stereotype' imo is YOURS

2) Fine go and achieve it!

(by the way before you remark on the perception of the 'intelligence' of the group leadership, you might want to learn the correct spelling of pander and oppose).

Gavin Ramejkis
250 Posted 08/06/2012 at 15:36:39
Tony #826 Due diligence is performed by the buyer not the seller to confirm what they are getting isn't a complete basket case, has undisclosed liabilities and is worth the price being asked, the only thing BK and his merry cronies will be interested in is the colour of their money - don't believe for one second given their track record that "the best interest of the club and fans" bollocks.

As far as dropping the price to get a buyer goes well that's all within the realm of the original remit given to the folk appointed to make a sale, you'd hope they would be involved in the complete process; creating the prospectus and marketing the sale in the right circles - a key component of creating the prospectus is agreeing the sale figure. The sale figure may well start out with the fanciful pipe dreams of the carpetbaggers on the board but be negotiated to an achievable figure given the debt, EBITDA, business plan, business strategy and subsequent business forecast for the next 5 to 10 years.

Jonathan Stockdale
251 Posted 08/06/2012 at 15:55:49
Paul Jamieson (845) you say "In my opinion the only way a trust will get off the ground is by having keioc organise it, they are the only doers the fans have, they have the knowledge and the track record and the people to make it happen. Trust Everton is clearly going nowhere apart from talking about it."

I just checked and the www.trusteverton.com website is still live and their last tweet was 41 days ago. Have you contacted them directly, or do you know something we don't?

Alan(822) their website also says they are not looking to buy shares either. Look on the FAQ page.

Ian Smitham
252 Posted 08/06/2012 at 16:39:42
Martin @830, That BK does not own the club can not be disputed. He owns a portion, and in the most recent Accounts he bought/acquired more shares ( I raised an unanswered question on here as to why he would bother). He is, indeed the owners representative, elected by the Shareholders. After extensive research of my house I have concluded that I have lost the last set of accounts, but for sure he is what is treated as a controlling director, by nature of his holding exceeding 20% of the available shares. He also is clearly in a concert party with the Directors and it seems to me that to remove one , all will have to be removed.

I read this site a lot, and am mystified as to reference to Sir Phillip Green. Can someone help with some FACTS please?

Anthony Hawkins
253 Posted 08/06/2012 at 17:28:10
To cover a couple of points including @853:

The club lacks the financial clout because no one is putting any (sufficient) money into the club. It's like owning a Ferrari and putting cheap oil in the engine - It'll do the job but there's better products out there which will protect the car and make it perform much better.

...which leads me nicely onto the next piece which is that the ' investment' doesn't have to be immense, the purchase of 4 or 5 quality players would be enough.

Which leads me onto the third point - even BK has stated that whilst the club IS for sale, it's for investment only and NOT a full sale. Eg. The sale of some shares or a part of the club. It's a play on words which doesn't quite reflect the whole truth...

Kevin Freaney
254 Posted 08/06/2012 at 18:59:06
Can I just be the fool in the room and ask a few questions to clear things up for me:

1- Has Kenwright actually invested any money in Everton or has his money been in shares which go to the shareholder selling the stock rather than the club?

2- If so, has Kenwright invested anywhere near as much as Peter Johnson during his reign?

3- Have any of the board actually invested in the club in Kenwrights tenure, again, not just in shares bought?

Sorry if these have been asked before. I just find it very difficult to understand how a board with amount of money these guys have behind them is letting the club very slowly drain away financially.

I also worry that certain board members are jeopardising the sale by holding out for a substantial profit on their shares, hence question no.1. If it is the case, extolling your love for the club and your concern for it's future while holding out for a profit on 0 investment and 10 years mis-management is a very poor state of affairs.

John Keating
255 Posted 08/06/2012 at 19:30:33
Kevin
NO
NO
NO
Steve Smith
256 Posted 08/06/2012 at 21:18:31
Some really good debate on this thread for and against, in spite of some half truths and complete untruths {is that a word?} creeping in that have been repeated so often on here, that now they are excepted as fact by some, I'm willing to bet my mortgage that this;

"In place of the Everton Board ? assuming of course that they are genuine in their intention to sell the club ? BU would like to see the appointment of a fully autonomous group of professionals with the sole remit of finding new ownership for Everton"

Will never happen no matter how big the protest is, forget it, and start building bridges with the board with a view to securing the future of the club, the above statement only serves to strengthen the resolve of the current incumbents and perversely {some might say} gains Kenwright support that he doesn't deserve.

And this;

"an ownership that can demonstrate a viable plan to secure the financial and cultural future of the club."

You could do as many checks as you like and still end up with shite, just ask Liverpool, Blackburn, Rangers, Pompy etc.etc.etc.

Steve Smith
257 Posted 08/06/2012 at 21:43:23
Or us !
Ian Bennett
258 Posted 08/06/2012 at 21:50:05
Thanks Eric. Again it proves my point that £15m could be the pbt, but most is amortisation. I am trying to work out the real amount we might need to raise is it really 10 to 15m?

It will be interesting seeing the accounts later in the year, as some articles suggest that a number of previous signings will be paid down, Fellaini,Heitinga etc.

I still can't find the accts, and would think that £95m will contain a fair bit of deferred income from season tickets etc.

Eric Myles
259 Posted 09/06/2012 at 01:08:32
Ian, GIYF.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/75210260/Everton-FC-Accounts

If £95m in liabilities includes deferred income then we're really in deeper do-do than we think. That's ENRON Country.

Eric Myles
260 Posted 09/06/2012 at 01:25:24
^total liabilities should include no income, that would be in net liabilities?
Ian Bennett
261 Posted 09/06/2012 at 09:54:22
Okay then. Total liabilities are 88m, 56m due in one year and 32m greater than one year.

Included in the 56m, is 18m of accruals and deferred income. My expectation is fair slug of this is deferred income for the coming season being amounts like season ticket season sales (April renewal against a may year end - this needs to be remembered why the renewal date has moved forward a couple of years ago in terms boosting the balance sheet, and potentially protecting banking covenants) and the kit bag deal, and may be Chang sponsorship.

Included with the 56m is a loan and an overdraft. The overdraft of around 10m, and a loan presumably repayable during 2011/12 of 14m. The same 14m that we found from the summer sales of arteta, yak, Vaughan, turner,beck ford. This is presumably what bill was screaming about when the banks must have refused to roll over the loan.

Liabilites over 1 year is the interesting one at 32m. A loan was taken out which repays 1m per annum over the next 24 years, whilst we had 3m of trade creditors which I assume is transfer fees on the drip.

So what does this tell you. Well last may we had a ticking time bomb of a 14m loan that had to be repaid. The books don't point to the same situation, although we will presumably have a bigger overdraft depending on how much cost was reduced from the player sales. However.

On a previous post I speculated that in cash terms we were burning cash at around 5m a season, assuming a 1m loan repayment on the new facility and a similar sum on the season ticket loan, and may be another 1m paying down transfer fees on the drip, we are probably looking to find something like 5m, assuming costs were reduced, or 8m if the havent. I would be surprised if the bank will allow that to be added to the overdraft, so that points to player sales of around that sum before we can even think of bringing in pienaar.

Moyes can have as many chats with Kenwrights as he likes but it's a fairly big sell, before a buy. Sorry folks.

Eric Myles
262 Posted 10/06/2012 at 01:24:49
Ian, looks like you ut a lot of work into analysing the accounts, only to come to a conclusion which was already foregone.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads