Redknapp admits Pienaar would prefer Goodison

, 5 June, 26comments  |  Jump to most recent
Tottenham boss Harry Redknapp acknowledges that Steven Pienaar would prefer to stay at Goodison rather than return to White Hart Lane but stressed that the deal will have to be right for Spurs.

"Steven Pienaar is a good player," Redknapp says. ?I would think in all honestly he's going to want to stay at Everton. He seems to have produced his best form there. He was unlucky at Tottenham. ?He's a good player, a very very good player. It's just I had Gareth Bale playing on the left-hand side and you can't dislodge Gareth Bale. He's one of the best left-sided players in the world, without a shadow of a doubt.

?If he's going to want to stay at Everton and Everton want him then obviously the deal is going to have to be right for Tottenham, otherwise he comes back to Tottenham.?

There has been speculation this week that Redknapp is eager to move Pienaar on so he can address his own squad-building needs but his valuation of Pienaar differs from that of Spurs chairman, Daniel Levy, perhaps by as much as £3m.

Quotes or other material sourced from ESPN



Reader Comments (26)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Laing
1 Posted 05/06/2012 at 16:58:00
Hawwy seems to be having a war of words at the moment regarding his contract and his valuation of Pienaar, watch this space ? Moyes or Martinez ?
Ray Robinson
2 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:15:00
Doesn't Redknapp's contract allow for him to take a cut on any profit made on buying / selling a player?
Keith Glazzard
3 Posted 05/06/2012 at 19:48:28
Spurs are obviously going to try to get as much cash for him as they can, and a deal may not happen as a result. But at least Redknapp has said that he knows the player wants away, which is helpful to us. And it confirms that there is likely to be a negotiation, so I take this as a positive.
Jay Harris
4 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:44:01
Every day it seems we are getting linked with players who are "out of our range" according to the media.

And everyday we are being told one of our stars will have to be sold to refinance the squad-building.

Now besides the fact our finances should have been improved considerably by the savage wage cutting of the last 12 months and the gate receipts from the "unexpected" cup run and improved league position receipts, we are still being portrayed as the total paupers of the Premier League.

I am sure Moyesy and most of our supporters feel it is pretty important to tie up a deal for Steven Pienaar as a minimum.

Now if Spurs are holding out for a £6 million fee as reported and we dont have the funds (never mind the will) to pay their asking price, why don't we just take him on loan for next season and take time out to find a "younger" up-and-coming replacement.
Dan Parker
5 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:49:18
Perhaps if we make a donation to his dogs favorite charity, we'll get Steven back for peanuts.
Denis Richardson
6 Posted 05/06/2012 at 20:46:30
Jay, am not sure Spurs would agree to a loan deal. If Redknapp needs to get some cash in then a loan deals not going to help him much. Also if its public knowledge that Spurs are looking to off load him and a club like Sunderland offers 5m and we dont, its going to be up to the player to force the transfer through and say he only wants to come to us.

Personally, I think we'll get him as its obvious we want him and he wants to come back. if we're offering 3 and they want 6, we'll presumably meet in the middle somewhere you'd think - although this is everton and unfortunately spurs seem to he holding the cards.

Just annoying that this could not have been sorted out weeks ago.

Dave Roberts
7 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:07:03
It's bleedin' annoying that he was allowed to go in the first place. The additional fee payable to Spurs over and above what we got for him in the first place would more than have covered the increase in wages he wanted. This increase was 'reportedly' parity with Arteta who was playing shite at the time anyway.

There seems to be a deficiency of forward planning here by the powers that be at the club.....is that unusual!

If he comes back to us he is bound to get the increased pay he was asking for in the first place. I have as much of a problem with players being unreasonably 'greedy' as anybody else but if Everton are going to pay him the market rate now ....why didn't they pay him the market rate last year and save all this fucking hassle. If he is worth it now he was worth it then, perhaps more so as his absence in the first half of the season may have cost us a European place and his being cup-tied may have cost us a final appearance and, who knows given Chelsea's poor form this season, even a win.

A bit of forwrad thinking and less crisis management please Everton. This is just another of those totally rediculous 'transfer sags' we are becoming too accutomed to.

I think we need a more 'tuned in' CEO as that level is responsible for this kind of negotiation.

Sort it or I'm off.

Dave Roberts
8 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:21:55
Sorry about that. I'll never be 'off' whatever the shambles at the club regarding transfer matters. I've got one fucking hell of a wisdom toothache at the moment and I know I am stuck with it for at least 5 weeks until the hospital take the bugger out. I think the toothache was talking.

Any dentists on Toffeeweb who do foreigners? Be happy to pay the going rate....just as we should have done for Pienaar in the first palce!

Dave Roberts
9 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:28:11
.....fuck me my toothache affecting my spelling as well....
Roberto Birquet
10 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:25:38
Dave R
It's all very well saying it woulda cost us less to pa the higher wages. But what if we did that more often? We would have to sell some players not in order to buy, but in order to keep the others.
We'd be killing ourselves.
We need a wage structure. Never mind morally they (PremLgu footballers in general) are a bunch of overpaid primas, we have to live within our means not for one player, but a squad.
Dan Parker
11 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:34:20
On another note, Arteta is asking Arsenal for a pay rise after one good season with them. Essentially I assume he wants to go back to the wage he was on with us or more. If we'd kept him, he'd have had one less year left on his contract and be worth less in transfer fees plus we'd have had to pay him for a season at 75k. Prob. a good thing we sold with hindsight.

Follow the Jelavic road.

John Crook
12 Posted 05/06/2012 at 21:48:09
At the end of the day Spurs are not being hard work over Pienaar's valuation. They paid £3m for a player they could of took for free 6 months later. I think £5m to £6m is a realistic value for a top player who is at a bad age (the big 30). If Pienaar was 25 you would be looking at £10-£13m I would say.

The bad side from EFC's point of view and business strategy, the player will not have much of a sell on value (persuming he signs a 3 year contract say). It is pleasing to hear Redknapp admit he expexts Pienaar to come back more or less emphazing there is only 1 club he wants to join.

I would expect the 2 clubs to meet half way in their valuations at around £4 to £4.5m. Lets hope the Yobo deal is pushed through asap to help speed the Pienaar transfer up. Pienaar is an absolute must for EFC.
Guy Hastings
13 Posted 05/06/2012 at 22:34:58
Looks like we'll be dealing with Harry's successor anyway.
James Flynn
14 Posted 05/06/2012 at 22:41:17
Keith (387) - Dead on. Loved reading Harry's comments. Negotiations are happening. Hope we get it done soon.

Hope the Club realizes getting Piennar in as soon as possible could mean more ticket sales.

Walid El-Saleh
16 Posted 05/06/2012 at 23:26:11
Spurs fan here. Pienaar is a very good player...way too good to be left rotting on the bench (or not even making the bench, at Tottenham). So is Niko Kranjcar. Both of them are leading international players. Of course, there's no-one in the Premier League capable of "dislodging" Gareth Bale, as Harry says - but that's not the point. The two Manchester sides and Chelsea, who between themselves have had virtually all the success in the past half dozen years, have great players, too.

The difference between them and Spurs is that their managers are not afraid to use the full depth of their squads, whilst ours is stuck in the (admittedly great) days of Bobby Moore. His claims that "Bobby Moore [read Gareth Bale] was never rotated" is meaningless in today's football. When Bobby began his career, there were not even substitutes. When he finished it (substantially finished), there was ONE. The "bench" really WAS a bench (not a full set of Recaro racing seats) and the sub sat with the manager and the guy with the bucket and sponge!

Pienaar and Kranjcar and dos Santos, just to name three players, have been shafted since they joined our club. As a fan, I'd love to keep all of them and see them feature - but I have to admit it will never happen under the manager we've got. Not because he's a bad manager but because his philosophy on the game comes from a different era and I don't think the mentality of a 65 year old coach is going to change any time soon. So, as much as I wish Pienaar could be accommodated in our set-up (even to keep Gareth Bale fresh), it's never going to happen unless we have a change of manager, then I hope a deal ( a reasonable deal) can be done, so that Steven Pienaar gets the chance to enjoy his football and you fans get to enjoy his performances.

Whatever happens, you can't allow a club like SUnderland outbid you for his services. Finishing as high up the table as you did, apart from being semi-miraculous, must have put a few bob in the kitty. You can't be top-seven, having spent almost nothing and be broke. Bill Kenwright needs to make this happen for you. I wish you all the best for the new season and hope, once again, that you fish above the red half of town.

Richard Dodd
17 Posted 06/06/2012 at 09:25:31
This will run to the very last minute of the window when a compromise will be reached which will see Pienaar back here for around £4M.
Kevin Day
19 Posted 06/06/2012 at 10:25:03
Well said walid!! Could you possibly apply to be pienaars agent? That aside tho, we have 3 despensible players in my view, anichebe, cahill, yobo, all for around an average of 2.5 million gives us 7.5 million give or take 500.00.
4.5 mill should secure pienaar with 3 mill going to barclays, add a few loanees and freebies and that will be our summer with no one else leaving.
Mike Gaynes
20 Posted 06/06/2012 at 11:59:26
Appreciate your input, Walid. I've been a little mystified by Harry's rotation policy as well... I watched dos Santos develop for Mexico (I'm a Yank) and expected him to have a considerable impact for you, but Harry keeps loaning him out. At 23, he should be in his prime.

However, I must admit that I never really expected Pienaar to crack your lineup. He's a perpetual motion machine but not a talent on the level of the players he had to beat out for playing time, and I wasn't at all surprised that his move to Spurs turned out to be overly optimistic for him. He's more our style than yours, and we're delighted that both he and Harry have recognized that. Hope the deal can be completed soon.

And if dos Santos ever gets fed up with being left out, you guys should feel free to send him our way as well!

Martin Mason
21 Posted 06/06/2012 at 12:54:30
Well said Walid and welcome to the board. I agree with your views on how well we really do as a club considering our terrible financial situation but we have good ongoing debate on that. SP has been brilliant since returning to Everton so I very much hope to see him back. Krnjcar too if we had the means, he would be a great buy for anybody.
Anto Byrne
22 Posted 06/06/2012 at 16:10:56
Has Piennar put in a transfer request yet and if not why not? Does he get a slice of any transfer fee? Then wages 75k a week? Cant see it happening. Need change at Everton new owner new manager new breath of fresh air?
Dave Roberts
23 Posted 06/06/2012 at 18:39:39
Roberts

I agree with most of what you say except that whether we like it or not football is now a marketplace and individual clubs will suffer if they choose to try to live outside of it....Arsenal?

Yes all clubs need a wage structure but they need to be couched in general terms with general intentions and financial targets rather than being carved in stone never to be transcended. When they are carved in stone you end up with a player like Arteta doing practically nowt for the two seasons after his injury earning more than Pienaar (who had assumed his mantle of our most creative midfielder) leaving because he wasn't granted the wage parity he probably deserved in terms of performance.

Wage structures have to allow for the odd exception, otherwise they act like a lead weight on a club's ambition. This is how the game has gone I'm afraid and it doesn't show any signs of changing soon.

Dave Roberts
24 Posted 06/06/2012 at 19:05:21
Sorry that should have been 'Roberto'.
Anto Byrne
25 Posted 07/06/2012 at 06:29:21
Does anyone know what we got for Monsewer Sarhar? He must have been worth £3m. There are similar players to Pienaar on the market and no one player is bigger than the club. Players come they go and what about McAleny and Mageye getting games and showing what they can do? When will Baxter and Wallace come through?

Where do we fit Barkley into the team as he has to get game time next time around. We need another capable striker as the jury is out on Anichebe and Vellios has had no real game time.

Don't forget it took Pienaar a good season and a bit to come good. Was pretty shite for a while when he first came and now at 31 he has all the experience of a seasoned pro. Not sure we should be spending £6m or anywhere near that for him unless we get rid of Cahill for silly money.

Sam Hoare
26 Posted 07/06/2012 at 07:49:10
How much can we afford to spend on a 30 year old? 3m? 4m maybe? But then again can we afford not to have Pienaar after his impact last season? Would he be as good if he came back permanently? For 5m, which I what I expect him to cost is there someone else out there who is younger and just as good if not better?

Difficult one. I say under 4m or under makes sense. Any more and we look elsewhere...

Tony J Williams
27 Posted 07/06/2012 at 08:21:42
We paid over £5m for a 30+ Distin so expect it to be at least as much as that.
Ben Howard
28 Posted 07/06/2012 at 15:04:29
I'm concerned that now Hawwy has sold Kranjcaar to Dynamo Kiev it might make them more reluctant to hold on to Pienaar. He'd be more likely to get a game as I expect he's been bumped up the pecking order now too. What do you think?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads