Season › 2011-12 › News
Why Kit Deals Leave Everton Begging
Searching questions on the Kitbag partnership
At the Keeping Everton in the City website, interest in last week's Kitbag revelations has prompted a follow-up article in response to fans demanding to know why the club's shirt sponsorship, merchandise sales and kit supply deal seem to pale in comparison to the Blues' peers in the Premier League.Some excerpts from the KEIOC article:
Merchandise Sales revenue is more difficult to determine as usually only the total commercial income is revealed in clubs accounts. One club that does itemise this is Spurs, last year receiving £10m from merchandise sales. Following repeated losses, Everton outsourced this income stream in 2007 and their current outsourcing partner, Kitbag, pay Everton up to £3m per annum to control every aspect of our merchandise operation. For Everton this was an ideal solution, no need to invest in a complete overhaul of the commercial operation, no need to run a series of shops or operate an e-commerce website, no staff, no stock, in fact no costs whatsoever and best of all the payment goes straight to the bottom line, it's pure profit.
Since outsourcing their retail and catering operations Everton's total commercial income has seen a £5m improvement over the last five years; in 2007 it was £7m, 2008 £9m, 2009 £9m, 2010 £10m and £12m in 2011. By comparison Aston Villa has seen an £11m increase [£6m in 2007, £11m in 2008, £12m in 2009, £14m in 2010 and £17m in 2011] and Tottenham Hotspur a £20m increase since 2006 whilst Liverpool, despite something of a financial and footballing odyssey in recent years, has seen their commercial revenues increase by £34m [£43m in 2007, £51m 2008, £60m in 2009, £62m in 2010 and £77m in 2011] with at least an additional £13m to come from their Warrior kit supply deal in 2012, which will astonishingly take their commercial income alone past Everton's total turnover.
The growth of these kit supply deals and the importance given to them, by both clubs and manufacturers, cannot be underestimated... Adidas and Nike account for a massive 44% of the total spend on these supply deals yet remarkably Everton received nothing when they recently switched suppliers from Le Coq Sportif to Nike; nothing in an era where their peers in the premiership are receiving record deals, nothing in an era when the manufacturers are spending hundreds of millions with clubs to secure these deals, nothing in the era of outsourcing our business to Kitbag.
Everton's fans and shareholders were led to believe that the Kitbag deal consisted of running the retail operation which had previously haemorrhaged money and required urgent attention by 2006. We were told that the ten year £32m deal related to the operation of the shops and the online business. We're concerned over Kitbags actual role in Everton's kit supply agreement and we're concerned over what the £7m sponsorship, advertising and merchandising revenue figure in Everton's accounts is comprised of.
We would like to ask the board some pertinent questions on this subject; for example, have we forfeited the right to negotiate an independent kit supply agreement over to Kitbag as part of the ten year deal? Why, in an era of multi-million pound deals, have Everton received nothing from one of the world's major kit manufacturers who are one of the leading proponents of making payments to secure kit supply agreements? Are Kitbag in effect in receipt of these manufacturers' payments, making Everton's ten year agreement effectively self-financing for Kitbag thereby making them the recipients of all revenue from the clubs retail operations? If this is not the case why has the Everton brand been so dramatically undersold in terms of the kit supply agreement?
Quotes or other material sourced from Keeping Everton in Our City
Reader Comments (68)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 09/06/2012 at 07:43:49
3 Posted 09/06/2012 at 07:54:45
On a serious note, the more I read about this, the more I realise why we aren't sold. As well as the off-putting asking price, it's because they've fucked up the revenue for the next god knows how many years.
He's like a gambling addict, or dodgy stock broker. Constantly borrowing to hide mistakes, until one day the house of cards collapses.
The day of reckoning will hit. He can sell a couple of players here and there, but that'll run out. Moyes will soon enough realise it, and be off, and with his heat shield gone the dominoes will start falling.
Where this will leave us I dread to think.
4 Posted 09/06/2012 at 08:14:01
5 Posted 09/06/2012 at 08:33:22
6 Posted 09/06/2012 at 08:26:27
Sadly "But he's a blue, he's one of, us leave him alone" will satisfy around 80% of fans.
Worse for me (almost) is the total lack of communication from the Top of Everton to the fans since 2008. They see us as nothing but sheep and ? until Moyes and his end-of-season points run goes ? it will always stay the same.
Bill, Woods, Earl et al are untouchable. Everton FC is a financial disaster from Top to Bottom
7 Posted 09/06/2012 at 08:38:59
Since Kitbag took over there has been zero risk to the club and sales have been climbing - many would say because there is so much more worth buying. I now make regular purchases at the outlet store.
Attitudes are changing but it all takes time. Once we have proven record of spending then the bigger deals will come. We are 7th best team in the richest league in the world - the bigger deals will have to come and I agree income agreements need to rise rapidly. Is the Chang deal worth selling low for the additional revenue we might be getting in Thailand? This kind of thing needs closely monitoring.
Again perhaps we have a problem with how we are seen in the wider world - what is our image - Chang present us to Asia but how widely?? We seem to rely on sponsors to do this - again a no risk policy.
Everton board have set us up to minimise financial risk to the club (something we also have a long history of), concentrating expenditure on football alone and I think that is right for us up till now. Our recovery cannot however be led by football alone (Champions League?? I think those hopes are fading completely), we are going to need risk takers to push us forward & new strategies. Risks might include cutting team costs, increasing ticket prices, cutting expenditure (all the community work for example) while boosting a new stadium fund or improving our future vision for growth - all highly unpopular stuff. If all that was done by a new owner would that meet with universal approval?
8 Posted 09/06/2012 at 08:58:00
This from a paper that hounded Royle out of a job. Does Kenwright really have such influence? I have yet to read an article that criticizes his running of the club.
9 Posted 09/06/2012 at 09:13:41
Given that the Blue Union are contemplating more action - would a march or two to the Echo's offices not seem appropriate to kick start some reaction?
10 Posted 09/06/2012 at 09:21:01
I have received email replies in the past off Prentice and it shall be interesting to read what he has to say about this, I won't waste my time with the ultimate yes-man at our local press (O'Keefe).
11 Posted 09/06/2012 at 09:46:30
I'd suggest people don't buy the Echo.
Not in protest, because it really is shite.
12 Posted 09/06/2012 at 10:33:47
It's about Everton's ability to sell the value of the brand of a leading Premier League club, it's nothing to do with how many shirts we sell, that's related to the deal we have with Kitbag, or should I say the deal we all thought we had with Kitbag. Villa and Fulham, even Manchester City don?t sell any more shirts than Everton, the brand value link tells you Everton, Newcastle and Villa have similar standings but Everton receive two parts of nothing in the kit supply stakes.
That article has opened my eyes; Elstone adding £6m to the turnover to explain the low income is bullshit. Other clubs are receiving payments that are just profit through sponsorship and advertising; in my opinion, I think KEIOC ask some perfectly valid questions ?particularly on the role of Kitbag. But of course no doubt some with other agendas will want to talk about the role of outsourcing instead. It?s back to deflect, deflect, deflect.
13 Posted 09/06/2012 at 09:55:24
Another point I'd like to raise, while on the theme of red comparisons: unlike them, we NEVER protest. We NEVER organise (especially) spontaneously like they do over big or small issues. The Blue Union tried in their own way but I remember the fans on those matchdays that they protested on, seemed to treat them / the situation in the background, as thouigh they where Hari Krishnas on the beg!
Face it, guys, most of us are soooo conservative; this board and chairman suck, a lot of fans are finally starting to see the light, as the pieces of the puzzle start to connect.
So, unless the master shyster implodes up his own backside, and the circling billionaire board members finally grab the reins, which trust me, is what Green, Elstone and Grantchester are waiting for, we really do have to start SCREAMING ? with or without the Blue Union.
Over to you, BU.
14 Posted 09/06/2012 at 10:41:04
He has explained a good few things in admitting the shambles the club is and why Grantchester won't ever buy the club, but he still is a yes man and it is a sad state of affairs that only KEIOC can get things out in the open and question the club. The really sad thing is that most Blues just don't give a shit and cannot be arsed getting up from their pub, chair and pint and do something about this. Sadly, relegation would be the only thing that would do this.
One week (QPR) we have Billy Liar's face getting booed on the screen at Goodison Park; the next week, after a goal (Villa), he gets cheered ? that summed it up for me.
15 Posted 09/06/2012 at 11:48:24
The fact that the inevitable financial meltdown that would accompany relegation would likely leave BK potless is only mild consolation. Then again, he'd probably be able to slip that responsibility.
Barry #927, I read Thomas musings and couldn't make head nor tail of what he was on about, and it's still too early in the weekend to try!
16 Posted 09/06/2012 at 11:38:26
17 Posted 09/06/2012 at 11:47:46
Thomas Lennon ? ''our sales record has always been poor'' ? I remember the Club announcing they had sold over 100,000 home shirts one season back in the late 90s when we weren't exactly setting the world on fire on the pitch.
Everton is a good name for Nike to get on board, but our 'negotiating team' have failed again.
18 Posted 09/06/2012 at 12:16:12
19 Posted 09/06/2012 at 12:25:40
Last year Villa were "hoping" to secure £5m per season for a sponsor, but were open to offers according to market conditions. Using figures provided by the company that monitors brand value for sponsors for the broadcasts, they were able to secure more than that.
I've said before we're run like a corner shop still, whilst everyone else has moved towards a global operation.
So some people believe that the club should be sold for the value of the debt. But, if you also see that your income streams are hampered due to long-term unfavourable commercial deals, how do you put a value on that? Any new owner wouldn't be able to start to turn around parts of the commercial operation for 3/5/7 years. Why would you bother? I've always believed BK would never sell, but I think he's now made the club unsellable.
20 Posted 09/06/2012 at 14:18:08
The reason why we have the Kitbag deal and we apparently don't participate in negotiating 'brand' is that we don't spend money on marketing ? we allow Kitbag to do that in exchange for a safe no-risk income. There are one or two other 'low risk' deals that are apparent too.
One effect of allowing Kitbag to do this is for them to build our brand and income for us ? the two are highly linked. After a period of time we may find that it is more profitable to take back parts of this business in house, but for now we may well be effectively paying them for this service in the ways mentioned by KEIOC.
Everton will never go out of business like this but it will never compete at the top again either. Like I said ? safe, conservative management of the club.
21 Posted 09/06/2012 at 14:01:54
"Again perhaps we have a problem with how we are seen in the wider world - what is our image - Chang present us to Asia but how widely??"
One of the biggest (of many) problems with this board is, imo, a complete lack of imagination.
Our image in the wider world is something that, with a little imagination, could I think be improved without spending fortunes.
I DON'T believe we could change our fortunes entirely, but I do believe things could be improved (how could they be worse?).
Years ago, Stella Artois was considered expensive, so they had a choice.
Bring the price down or...use some imagination.
They came up with the line 'reassuringly expensive'.
It worked brilliantly.
They targeted those with more money than sense (it was the 80's, there was plenty of them about) and it became the beer of choice for a generation of city boys and loadsamonies.
During the late 70's, I was at college in Bolton (yeah, the ivy covered walls, punting up the..er..Manchester ship canal etc) and used to bevvy in Manchester quite a bit.
At the time I think there were five breweries in Manchester.
I can remember Joseph Holts (my favourite) and Robinsons and Boddingtons (can't remember the others)
None of them appeared any bigger than the others to me.
Anyway, someone at Boddingtons (nb: with a bit of imagination!) obviously decided this wasn't enough.
Long story short, within five years you could buy 'Boddies' all over the UK and within ten years, you could buy draught Boddingtons in bars in New York.
They took the idea of Manchester/'the north', made funny, engaging ads and the rest..
As for the other breweries, don't know if they exist anymore or not.
So how does this (or could this) apply to Everton.
Well, it's VERY difficult as (apart from Liverpool and Utd) team's supporters tend to be from where the team is from, so getting new supporters isn't easy.
Given this, you have to ask, ok how do we maximise sales among EXISTING supporters?
My answer would be 'Well, the prouder they feel, the more stuff they'll probably buy'.
But that throws up a problem - we don't win stuff so it's hard (and getting harder) to feel proud.
So what DO we have to feel proud about?
Well..
We are a PL side.
We have a longer history than most.
We have a long list of legendary players.
We have set records.
We have won trophies (so have a lot of anniversaries)
We have one of the few original grounds.
We are founder members.
For me, there is the possibility (nb: with a bit of imagination!) to use this 'real' football idea.
To utilise and promote our 'difference'.
To be the anti-sky team.
'Real football played in a real ground in a real area in front of real supporters' (there aren't many left)
Think about it, how many ads do we see that show pricks on sofas, or disinfected families wearing spanking new scarves, driving to the game in spanking new cars?
We should run an Everton campaign that is the opposite of this.
We should use photos from the last 130 years.
Actually.....I'll stop there.
You know what, I'm not sure EXACTLY what we should do (because I'm thinking as I'm typing).
I simply believe if someone with real imagination took a week to think about how (perceived?) negatives could be turned into positives, we COULD be seen in a more positive way.
To be seen as 'different' (never underestimate the need of millions around the world to be seen as 'different' - that's why there are Goths, punks, Skins etc etc)
One thing I honestly think we she SHOULD have (I know, I keep going on about this) is a beautifully embroidered 'FM' or 'Founder Member' (in gold) on our shirts.
There are only 12 (or 11 now?) teams who can have this and WE are one of them.
In short (I know, too late now) I'm saying, ok we may not have as much as some, but we're not making the most of what we have.
(nb: obviously, if a gazilionaire comes in and buys us a flash new ground and a flash new team/title, we'll drop all that 'old is good' shit in a heartbeat)
22 Posted 09/06/2012 at 15:02:46
If what you?re saying is a fact it?s proves that what is going on is ridiculous and KEIOC are right to have brought this to peoples attention. I?m no expert here but looking at Everton, at our position, at what other clubs are receiving from these deals and what Nike's targets are, I would say a deal between £5 ? 8m a season would be a representative ballpark figure for a kit deal and even if half of that went on advertising we?d be so much better off than being the recipients of nothing, wouldn't we? Are there any business types on here who know the answers?
To be honest though I don?t believe for one minute that clubs are spending any of their fees on advertising, but as I sad earlier, I'm no expert but neither apparently are the people employed by Everton. Elstone seems to talk the talk but little else.
cheers
23 Posted 09/06/2012 at 16:03:24
24 Posted 09/06/2012 at 16:15:25
Pricks on sofas - they summarise everything about the Sky era. High-fiving each other as 'their' team scores, but never dreaming of actually GOING to the fucking match. Sky has convinced a generation of people that watching football is first and foremost a television event, not a live spectator sport.
25 Posted 09/06/2012 at 17:38:35
Accounts and computers make simply taking money very hard to do in any business without it showing up somewhere, but as we know from the grubby world of Agents, Transfers, dogs with Bank Accounts etc, there is more than one way to skin a cat.
Backhanders, brown envelopes on doorsteps, etc, etc. Nice little earners written all over this one to me. Just a personal opinion, and of course I could be wrong. But either that or gross incompetence are the only conclusions I can come to ? depressingly.
26 Posted 09/06/2012 at 23:25:54
I agree with your sentiments, I have mentioned before on here that we should concentrate on some positives ie:
Goodison, The first purpose built football stadium in the World. Let's try and make it a listed building or, at least, emphasis it's history. If we can't afford to improve it, why not?
The FM idea is also worth trying, in fact, ANYTHING that takes some of the limelight away from the RS or Utd. and onto us.
27 Posted 09/06/2012 at 23:46:47
28 Posted 09/06/2012 at 23:49:44
£3M a year seems a paltry figure to me when we're knocking out replica tops at £50 a pop.
29 Posted 10/06/2012 at 00:20:38
Okay I got a bit carried away but anti-marketing could make us the most exclusive brand in football.
30 Posted 10/06/2012 at 02:12:13
I tried that already but recieved the response that it's the owners that have to apply for listing and as the current owners want to tear it down there's no chance it will happen.
31 Posted 10/06/2012 at 03:22:32
Good 'negative' advertising or a clever slant or tagline works wonders. Play a bit of Sibelius and we all think of Hovis. And who was the dude on the Queens concert singing about Cornetto's. Leonard Rossiter tipping Martini into Joan Collins lap.
You don't sell the sausage, you sell the sizzle.
32 Posted 10/06/2012 at 06:48:45
The only 'FM' the PL would ever allow is FMPL, and even then I think their attitude would be 'so what?'. The FL is a complete irrelevance to them and why advocate a move to make their own members - especially he ones creating the most revenue - appear in some way inferior to the likes of Notts and Derby County, Burnley, Preston and Wolves?
History means nothing to this lot unless it suits them. Just as LFC fans think football began in 1964 the PL would love to erase anything pre-1992 in what for them is essentially a rival competition. We should hang our heads in shame for our major involvement in he breakaway in the first place, our own greed has come back to bite us royally on the arse. Besides, should we even be allowed to have FM on our shirts for a competition we instigated in completely fucking up?
33 Posted 10/06/2012 at 07:33:24
Paul - I wrote 'we don't spend money on marketing' and NOT advertising. Marketing builds a brand which allows successful advertising of products and not the other way round. Money spent building the brand is well spent for us and we have a deal whereby rather than spend money trying to do it ourselves we pay the top company in the world to do it for us. Not a bad idea.
Kitbag are taking a proportion of the income generated and have guaranteed a certain income. They are entitled to keep some of the profits for themselves as they spend the equivalent of many millions building our presence in the market and do it extremely well.
Remember the 'free' Park End development? That was one example of them spending and taking a risk for us for our long term benefit. If that is ruled out there will be others.
At the end of the deal we will have (already do have) a much improved brand image & much improved merchandising operation and we can renegotiate - as could any new owner.
We cannot compare ourselves with the likes of Man U, Liverpool etc. who are already MASSIVE brands obviously - but we are positioning ourselves to take maximum advantage of any future success on the field.
This is precisely what many accuse the club of never doing - we have affectively and profitably (merchandising now earns a proprotion of £7 million?) addressed a loss making area - still a long way behind some but year on year improvement in the bottom line at no risk is a comfortable strategy.
34 Posted 10/06/2012 at 08:29:49
I'm assuming you understand what a brand is, and understand the commercial opportunities that Image Rights can offer.
Brand as you know in football is an emotive issue, but the reason a lot of overseas brands wish to associate themselves with English Premier League teams is purely and simply due to the overseas TV broadcasting deal. That is the growth area in the Premier League, with many territories now screening all games live.
There's a company called Repucom who use proprietary software developed in collaboration with Group M (part of WPP) that measures the exposure during a live televised event (they do all major sports, globally) and gives a $ value of that.
Sponsoring a football club in the EPL is cheaper, and more effective, than buying ad slots (which many of these brands will still do).
Now are you seriously suggesting that EFC are capitalising on their appeal globally? Because they haven't got a pot to piss in, they have invited in commercial "partners" to do it for them.
By turning a merchandise loss of £750k into a profit of £3.2m a year looks great doesn't it? To this analyst, it looks like they were doing something drastically wrong in the first place. But the fact that they are turning a profit is good in your eyes, even though others are suggesting it's still not earning what it ought to compared to what our peers are earning. (And I don't mean the Man U or even Liverpools of this world).
Oh, and that Everton Place development was "free"? It was free in the same way Kirkby was "effectively free". KitBag and Sodexo were investing that money to an agreed variation in the contracts. Our outsource partners are not charities Thomas, they would've made their commercial return comfortably off that.
I'm surprised we don't outsource the frigging team. All these commercial partners seem to be doing something right.
35 Posted 10/06/2012 at 09:19:11
36 Posted 10/06/2012 at 10:02:58
37 Posted 10/06/2012 at 10:08:43
38 Posted 10/06/2012 at 11:35:34
39 Posted 10/06/2012 at 11:26:32
40 Posted 10/06/2012 at 12:19:27
41 Posted 10/06/2012 at 12:28:35
You can market History and tradition to the outside world (for god sakes you only have to look at the Royal Family). Maybe we shoud piggy back on that and be known as the Royal Blue Family and see if that attracts some dumb yanks to invest. As a left wing republican I am only joking with the last comment but the dearth of creativitiy at the club pisses me off.
42 Posted 10/06/2012 at 12:25:53
IF that is the case I am pointing out that you might be underestimating the degree of investment Kitbag are making in long term building of our brand & merchandising.
Kitbag did announce this as the largest investment they had ever undertaken:
"Our capital investment into the Everton retail business is the single largest club partner investment in the history of our company. We are very much looking forward to revealing our plans and commitments to this business over the coming weeks."
They are revolutionising this side of our clubs business and appear to be involved in more of Everton's operation than any other. NOTE that income from this side of the business appears to have increased 80% over 5 years, still sadly lagging behind top 6 but long term things look much better that they have for years.
43 Posted 10/06/2012 at 12:53:06
Someone, as suggested, with a bit of marketing nous and a budget greater than penny jellies could do a lot for our image.
44 Posted 11/06/2012 at 02:17:46
45 Posted 11/06/2012 at 16:10:00
I think the issue is that, unfortunately, the new generation of fans and corporate sponsors aren?t all that interested in history ? they want success now. Also you have the problem that, although we (rightly) believe we?re special, to the outside world there isn?t actually that much difference between us and most other 'old school' teams. Villa, for example, are able to claim pretty much all of the selling points mentioned here about Everton.
Finally, while Eugene?s tale of little old Boddingtons conquering the world due to somebody having a bit of imagination would be heartwarming and worthy of a Hollywood film if it was true, it didn?t happen. The reality is that Boddingtons was a fairly well recognised brand anyway and had been taken over by one of the major brewing corporations (can?t remember which one sorry)in the 80s, they were therefore given a huge advertising budget which was about the same size as the overall annual turnover of the other breweries mentioned. After a brief period of success in the nineties on the back of the advertising campaign, the brand shrank back to it?s previous level and has now ceased producing it?s famous cask ale altogether after 200 years, while the Manchester connection it sold itself on has disappeared entirely due to the production of it?s cream brew being moved outside of the city.
Meanwhile Joseph Holt and Robinsons (as well as Hydes who may be one of the others you recall) are still successful family owned breweries, retaining their ties to the community and reaping the benefits of the increase in popularity of cask ale. Ammunition for the ?careful what you wish for? brigade I suppose.
46 Posted 11/06/2012 at 17:00:31
You confidently state - "Finally, while Eugene?s tale of little old Boddingtons conquering the world due to somebody having a bit of imagination would be heartwarming and worthy of a Hollywood film if it was true, it didn?t happen".
Well that would wonderfully witty and sarcastic Jimmy...if only YOU were right.
But (WHAT a surprise!) you're wrong.
Arguing who EXACTLY had/showed imagination is (desperate) semantics.
The point is SOMEONE did and it worked (nb: you'll note I didn't say 'It was Reggie Boddington').
Or do you you think the major brewery ("BOOOO!!") thought 'We'll buy these, then..put no money behind them'?
Imagination comes in all sorts of ways, not just coming up with a nice line.
It comes in planning (ahead!), in backing something, spending the right amount, on the right thing, at the right time and coming up with the right campaign/agency/idea etc.
Get it right, you have a chance of winning, get it wrong, you lose.
The brewery (in this case) got it right and the brand became a success.
Imagination = success, that was all I was suggesting.
"Aha!" you crow triumphantly..
"After a brief period of success in the nineties on the back of the advertising campaign, the brand shrank back to it?s previous level and has now ceased producing it?s famous cask ale altogether after 200 years".
Well firstly it was not 'on the back of the advertising campaign' (inferring 'because of') that they went tits up.
(or are you suggesting The Cream Of Manchester campaign that MADE their name, suddenly started working against the brand?)
That it DID go tits up I don't dispute because this backs MY point, not whatever yours is (Eugene's wrong?).
Fact is, this happened with Boddingtons (and many other brands), partly to due to a world recession that kicked off around 89-90 and affected all advertising budgets, but was mainly due to something feared throughout the business world - the 'new broom'.
The wanker who comes in and changes a winning formula because.....he wants to show how clever he is.
Happens to most brands in the end.
Remember "Heineken refreshes the parts...."?
So does everyone else of a certain vintage, but NOBODY knows their line now.
Anyway, however you try to paint it, the undeniable fact is imagination took a brand that was just another Manchester beer and made it a world beer.
And you can dress up the others as.."Successful family owned breweries, retaining their ties to the community and reaping the benefits of the increase in popularity of cask ale" all you want (google-copy-paste!) but IN RELATION TO THE POINT, apart from Mancs and a few real-ale nobs, nobody has ever heard of them.
Bit like Everton..in the wider world!
47 Posted 11/06/2012 at 18:41:39
You could just relpace your word 'imagination' for the word MONEY ! and then the word 'beer' for FOOTBALL TEAM !!!!
I totally get the heritage idea though... Do foreign footy fans know where Everton is ? Do they know why were called ' The Toffees ' ? I really dont know.
IYKYH - yep, WE do.. but the t-shirts being punted out here which list the title winning years look a little desperate in this day in age ?
48 Posted 11/06/2012 at 19:27:30
You could also replace the word imagination with cheese but..that wouldn't make sense either.
Sorry but the comparison doesn't work.
I agree the word 'beer' and 'football team' can be changed as, in this context, they are 'the product'.
But imagination does not replace money, it replaces LACK of imagination.
Money of course CAN be used creatively and/or with imagination, but they are not the same thing and I certainly haven't suggested they are.
As for the heritage thing, certainly anything I suggest does NOT, as is, stand up to scrutiny.
I admit (nb: and admitted in the post) it was top of my head stuff.
But I can't believe for a second that if the RIGHT marketing people 'got hold of us', we wouldn't increase revenue.
Problem is, it takes someone with imagination, to hire someone with imagination, so personally, I'm not sweating over it.
49 Posted 11/06/2012 at 19:52:21
Does the fact that I cannot buy the new Everton home shirt for myself and my 3 lads, during a summer of football show lack of imagination or just awful business sense ?
50 Posted 11/06/2012 at 20:33:05
Just thought the 'money = imagination' part wasn't accurate.
As for the shirts for your three boys, if you want to buy them and can't, this shows the club have the business-sense of an insane, bladdered, drugged ape and the imagination of plankton.
51 Posted 11/06/2012 at 21:01:10
52 Posted 11/06/2012 at 20:59:25
The point I was making is that you were saying all of the breweries were of a similar size, this is wrong - as I said - because Boddingtons were ALREADY a bigger company with much bigger budgets. You appeared to be suggesting that just a bit of creativity lead to the expansion, when in actual fact it was the expansion that lead to the creativity. Boddingtons market share was always going to get bigger, they went from being an independent local company to being backed by a brewing giant who wanted them to get a national profile. A bit like Man City if you like. Do you follow? Funnily enough, Mark appears to have grasped this quite easily.
If I said that Everton were a similar size to Tranmere and it's only a bit of creativity from Kenwright that makes us better than them you'd take me to task, no? That's basically what you were claiming. It wasn't a good example, get over it.
You may also the notice the strategic and not entirely accidental placing of a comma in the sentence you have highlighted. This comma means that rather than stating they shrank BECAUSE of the marketing, I'm simply saying that they shrank back after the original growth of the advertising campaign. In other words the growth was not sustained for any length of time and therefore in real terms was negligible. If you will insist on trying to take the piss then try to ensure the point you're making is valid.
53 Posted 11/06/2012 at 21:31:40
54 Posted 11/06/2012 at 22:47:48
And if my kids dont behave themselves tomorrow.. I will make them watch it again !
55 Posted 12/06/2012 at 08:54:32
"They went from being an independent local company to being backed by a brewing giant who wanted them to get a national profile".
Yes, we've established that.
The point (of difference) is, imo, THIS shows imagination.
You appear to be saying it wasn't imagination, they just threw money at it.
If you see it that way, fine, nothing I'm going to say is going to make any difference.
One more thing.
You say..
"Eugene, you appear to have taken my stating that you were incorrect as a personal insult when it wasn't at all. We're not all here to make sarky comments and argue".
Two things.
1) For reasons I have given, I see you stating I was incorrect as..you being incorrect.
2) I took your sarcasm for sarcasm because..it was sarcasm.
For the record, you said..
"Finally, while Eugene?s tale of little old Boddingtons conquering the world due to somebody having a bit of imagination would be heartwarming and worthy of a Hollywood film if it was true, it didn?t happen".
Sorry are you saying this was NOT sarcastic?
And as I have said before, sarky is absolutely fine with me, I use it all the time, but I'm allowed to respond to it SURELY.
(nb: If you give it out, don't whine and give it 'What!? I never said nuffink!" when you get some back)
And again, I repeat, it DID happen.
WHY it happened, it appears we won't agree on.
One more thing, again you say Boddingtons were ALREADY a bigger brand.
Fine, let's see some evidence.
(nb: not calling into question your integrity, but you would accept I can't just agree to stuff because you put it in caps)
My memory (nb: no, I don't actually know) is that in the late 70s, Boddingtons were not a national brand and IF they were bigger than the other breweries it was nothing significant.
Accept I could be dead wrong on this.
56 Posted 12/06/2012 at 09:38:34
You stated "By turning a merchandise loss of £750k into a profit of £3.2m a year looks great doesn't it? To this analyst, it looks like they were doing something drastically wrong in the first place."
I completely agree - before the dissolution of True Blue Holdings (2004?) our merchandising was utterly pathetic & loss making. At that point the current board started to try to turn things round and outsourced.
The reason why we made losses back then were apparently the difficulties of predicting demand and consequently being left with unsold stock. Why was that? Have those problems gone away? I doubt it.
We HAVE made progress since then BUT does not yet put us on a par with the raw earning power of some of our comparable competitors. I do not understand why but can only suggest there are deep seated problems selling to our fanbase that are now finally being addressed.
Am I happy, can we rest with that achievement? NO, but let us recognise progress and hope that it continues year on year.
I too think we should be making more from businesses keen to ally their brand with ours - why we don't I don't know. I do think we have some of the finest business brains in the UK at our disposal so competence isn't obviously the cause - perhaps our dealmakers are too soft? Again, unlikely.
It is obvious that it takes more than a couple of years to turn this situation around. There are signs this is happening, long may it remain so.
57 Posted 12/06/2012 at 09:40:47
We are trying to promote a football club is there anything more basic than that ? right now I`d swap all the half arsed, imaginative, sizzle selling, blue sky promoting, bollocks for a simple, simple desire to meet demand.
People like Mark Riding dont need to hear Sibelius`s Karelia suite playing in the background in order to buy his lads club shirts, he just needs somebody who cares enough to make sure they are on the shelf when he wants them.
But failure to meet demand isnt our only problem.
We as a club have too many people who want to enjoy the privilage of calling themselves Evertonians, but dont want to pay for it.
How many watch the match in the ale house, choosing to spend their money there instead of at GP ? How many adults get into Goodison with junior tickets ?
How many times do you see people buying cheap alternatives to official merchandise ? How many of the many thousands of people who watch the matches on internet free, regularly send a contribution to the club ?
Kenwrights is overseeing a shambles, no doubt about that . .but he doesnt half come in handy giving the non contributing malcontent a ready made excuse.
How many times do you hear someone say "I wont spend another penny while he`s in charge" ? or " I wont step foot inside GP until he gets rid of this manager" ?
Its rock solid, being an Evertonian will ALWAYS be free for these people, because even if by some Miracle a rich Billionaire does buy Kenwright out, they`ll simply say "well he certainly doesnt need my tenner"
Its a two way thing, You cant market the brand without the drive and the determination, but what chance have you got of capturing a new market if the exisiting one consist of people who would`nt buy a Ticket if Melanie Sykes was selling them in her nack ?
58 Posted 12/06/2012 at 10:36:31
Billy Smart, Jr (15 October 1934 ? 23 May 2005) was widely known in Britain as a circus performer and impresario.
Smart, whose real name was Stanley, was the tenth child and third son of Billy Smart Sr. His father was a showman and fairground proprietor, who bought a circus in 1946. The first appearance of the Billy Smart circus was on 5 April at Southall Park in Middlesex. The circus toured alongside Smart's funfair; the tents blow down and the circus did 2 days in the open air. Smart made his circus debut with "Billy Smart?s New World Circus" as assistant ringmaster aged 12. He was soon performing with ponies and horses, but became best known later for his elephant acts. In one famous incident, he tamed a herd of performing elephants when they stampeded in the ring. At its peak, in the days before animal rights were a popular issue, Billy Smart's four-masted Big Top could hold over 6,000 people, with a show including hundreds of animals and performers.
Smart, together with his brothers, Ronald Smart and David Smart, took over management of the circus when their father died in 1966 at Ipswich. The circus ceased touring in 1971, but televised performances continued until 1983, drawing audiences of up to 22 million at its height. The Smart Brothers also developed Guernsey Zoo, selling it in 1972, and opened Windsor Safari Park in 1969 before selling it in 1977 (it is now the site of Lego land Windsor). He lost the sight in his right eye in 1978 after cosmetic surgery severed the optic nerve, ending his career as an animal trainer.
The "Billy Smart's" touring circus was revived by his brother Ronald and nephew Gary in 1993, but Smart concentrated on a second career as a property developer, based in Spain.
Maybe we could get Billy Smart to take over our club ! His clowns would do a Much better job than Blue Billy`s Clowns... Or we could at least find out who did their marketing promotions, and hire them...
59 Posted 12/06/2012 at 13:14:15
60 Posted 12/06/2012 at 13:28:40
Winning the League is costing Man City Fans an average of 15% or more on increases over the last 2 years
It doesn't matter how much is invested in the team, there is a limit to how much many in Merseyside can apparently afford to spend attending a match as evidenced by falling attendances - or is there?
61 Posted 12/06/2012 at 14:02:21
The quotes
'None of them appeared any bigger than the others to me.'
and
'Anyway, someone at Boddingtons (nb: with a bit of imagination!) obviously decided this wasn't enough.'
Helped me form this opinion.
The point I was making in return was that I disagreed. I believe that Boddingtons were able to improve their position because they were backed by Whitbread (I checked the company who had taken them over). Whitbread were one of the ?big 6? breweries (sound familiar?) and they had bought Boddingtons specifically to add a cask ale to their portfolio. They ran an extensive advertising campaign at some cost (their advertising budget in the mid 90s was £10m+) which undoubtedly had a big impact on the brand recognition, and Whitbread also started to sell the beer in their 3,000 tied houses across the country, so it?s fairly unsurprising that the brand grew substantially. In my opinion this isn't really someone 'showing imagination', but a concentrated effort, at substantial cost (the takeover was valued at £51m in 1989) by a massive corporation to increase their market share
Joseph Holts and Robinsons continued to brew locally and own pubs in the area. They didn?t expand quickly like Boddingtons, and you evidently never hear of them anymore. But they?re still going strong, winning awards, now selling their beers in supermarkets across the country and online and still appealing to their target market. Meanwhile Boddingtons no longer make the brew they became famous for and the production of the brews they do make has been moved out of Manchester.
You, I thought, were trying to make the point that Everton may not have the means to market themselves to all and sundry across the world (like Man City for example) but just with 'a bit of creativity? could really take off as a brand and become globally recognised without spending a shedload or actually achieving anything. You appeared to be using Boddingtons as an example of how this could happen. In my opinion though, Boddingtons would be more comparable to City in the story (a reasonably well known brand with a decent supporter base able to expand quickly due to their financial backing) while we would be more like the other brewers (reasonably well known, decent supporter base, unable to expand due to lack of financial backing)
Many apologies if I came across as sarky with the ?little old boddingtons? line but it genuinely wasn?t my intention. I have a bit of a work related issue at the moment with large conglomerates masquerading as small local businesses and so this example got my goat a little. Also sorry but I?m not going to spend my lunch hour trawling through company records to find the exact turnovers and market shares of the companies involved but I can tell you that there?s some information on Boddingtons Wikipedia page with regards to the relative size of the company (thats where I checked who had taken them over). I believe that the information I?m giving is correct, if you doubt it feel free to check yourself.
62 Posted 12/06/2012 at 14:19:21
63 Posted 12/06/2012 at 12:45:03
Thomas #378.
I feel you're misleading TW readers when, in relation to turning the commercial situation around, you say, "There are signs this is happening, long may it remain so." There are no signs; our income from this is clearly flat, diminishing according to the 2011 accounts over the 2010 figures, and will continue to be flat at best.
What Everton did, on the second attempt in 2009, was put in place a temporary fix which addressed the losses but at what cost? No solution has been applied because Everton cannot afford to do so. After the initial prevention of losses in 2007 and the increase in profit, when Kitbag replaced JJB, there are now no signs of progress whatsoever, unless you just accept the spin emanating from the club, an area in which they excel.
However, as I pointed out when the earlier article was published, the KEIOC article isn't about outsourcing, it isn't the problem, so why talk about it?
Potentially the problem that requires some understanding is the terms and scope of the deal that has been brokered with and by Kitbag vis-à-vis the retail operation, which, with seven years left to run, shows all the signs of delivering diminishing returns in relation to the direction the marketplace; this is what should be of concern and this is the subject on which answers and discussions should be forthcoming.
The FACT that we have changed kit supplier to one of the world?s leading brands and have received no payment whatsoever when all other leading premiership clubs have negotiated and received these payments tells you that the situation should be of concern and is one that merits explanation. It has nothing to do with our level of sales; Kitbag are happy with us for a reason, Nike are happy to supply Everton for a reason and Everton are receiving less for our kit and merchandise for a reason. It's not the brand value so KEIOC have raised the question.
Nike is actively targeting football on a global scale and has a budget to do so; here?s an article on what they?re attempting to achieve. http://football.uk.reuters.com/football/news/2012/06/09/350DBC56-B1E3-11E1-A349-8A148033923B.php
64 Posted 12/06/2012 at 14:02:21
The quotes
'None of them appeared any bigger than the others to me.'
and
'Anyway, someone at Boddingtons (nb: with a bit of imagination!) obviously decided this wasn't enough.'
Helped me form this opinion.
The point I was making in return was that I disagreed. I believe that Boddingtons were able to improve their position because they were backed by Whitbread (I checked the company who had taken them over). Whitbread were one of the ?big 6? breweries (sound familiar?) and they had bought Boddingtons specifically to add a cask ale to their portfolio. They ran an extensive advertising campaign at some cost (their advertising budget in the mid 90s was £10m+) which undoubtedly had a big impact on the brand recognition, and Whitbread also started to sell the beer in their 3,000 tied houses across the country, so it?s fairly unsurprising that the brand grew substantially. In my opinion this isn't really someone 'showing imagination', but a concentrated effort, at substantial cost (the takeover was valued at £51m in 1989) by a massive corporation to increase their market share
Joseph Holts and Robinsons continued to brew locally and own pubs in the area. They didn?t expand quickly like Boddingtons, and you evidently never hear of them anymore. But they?re still going strong, winning awards, now selling their beers in supermarkets across the country and online and still appealing to their target market. Meanwhile Boddingtons no longer make the brew they became famous for and the production of the brews they do make has been moved out of Manchester.
You, I thought, were trying to make the point that Everton may not have the means to market themselves to all and sundry across the world (like Man City for example) but just with 'a bit of creativity? could really take off as a brand and become globally recognised without spending a shedload or actually achieving anything. You appeared to be using Boddingtons as an example of how this could happen. In my opinion though, Boddingtons would be more comparable to City in the story (a reasonably well known brand with a decent supporter base able to expand quickly due to their financial backing) while we would be more like the other brewers (reasonably well known, decent supporter base, unable to expand due to lack of financial backing)
Many apologies if I came across as sarky with the ?little old boddingtons? line but it genuinely wasn?t my intention. I have a bit of a work related issue at the moment with large conglomerates masquerading as small local businesses and so this example got my goat a little. Also sorry but I?m not going to spend my lunch hour trawling through company records to find the exact turnovers and market shares of the companies involved but I can tell you that there?s some information on Boddingtons Wikipedia page with regards to the relative size of the company (thats where I checked who had taken them over). I believe that the information I?m giving is correct, if you doubt it feel free to check yourself.
65 Posted 12/06/2012 at 16:36:19
An idea ( off the top of my head ):The first 200 people who pre-order the new kit get a guaranteed ticket for the first leg of the league cup at Goodison for just a fiver ? Could be a top side we play or a lower league side who we wouldnt sell out the ground for anyway ? May create a bit of interest.
The thing that I cannot get my head round is the way we go about selling out Goodison Park. The performances towards the end of last season created a demand for the product. Keep the momentum going ticket sales wise. Last year, season ticket holders could buy an extra ticket for the Liverpool game on the Monday before the game. We bought two. Then on the Friday, we recieved text messages offering additional tickets again. Totally bloody amateurish. Cant even sell out Liverpool at Goodison properly.
Why not sell out the games early ? I realise it may effect certain supporters descision to buy season tickets, if you could pick and choose games, so why not charge more ? By that I mean, for example, as soon as the fixtures come out, put Liverpool, United Etc at home on sale and add a tenner onto the ticket price. If they sell out more money is made for the club.
Thinking out loud a bit, I know, but surely getting as much money into the club, as soon as possible cant be a bad thing ?
66 Posted 13/06/2012 at 09:03:58
The club swapped a loss making merchandising business for something like £3 million over 3 years, then swapped that for £3 million a year - its not actually reducing is it.
The Echo quote "Reports elsewhere today that the deal will result in David Moyes being handed a £10m transfer war-chest are wide of the mark, with the Blues set to prosper more in marketing opportunities than by an immediate up-front influx of cash." suggest the idea is to increase the brand and thus the long term benefit to the club is better - but official figures have not been released so all we are doing is speculating.
Our nearest comparitor is probably Aston Villa who recently dumped Nike for a similar deal (in financial terms) to that which we have with Kitbag/Nike - so Nike are not apparently offering large amounts of money to clubs like ourselves.
IF the club fail to see investment and profits over the next 3-5 years then I agree with you - questions have to be asked, but at the moment these are signs that the club is developing the business, something we are all wanting to see - maybe we will even see signs of this in 6-18 months when we can see the accounts.
In answer to your comments on spin - as with most people I take your (BU) spin and the clubs spin and make my own mind up.
67 Posted 13/06/2012 at 19:41:21
?Aston Villa who recently dumped Nike for a similar deal (in financial terms) to that which we have with Kitbag/Nike - so Nike are not apparently offering large amounts of money to clubs like ourselves.?
No Thomas, again for some reason you?re attempting to mislead the readers of TW. Villa?s annual £3.75m payment from Macron is in addition to their income on merchandise sales not the total of it. KEIOC are questioning what the Kitbag deal is meant to encompass, we were told quite clearly that it was retail sales through the shops and the website. KEIOC are asking a legitimate question here, it has nothing to do with turning a loss making arm of the business around; it concerns what has been included in this deal, is it what we were told, the retail only or does it somehow include payments from kit manufacturers or do we just not get any payment from the Kit manufacturer? It?s a simple enough question; I wonder why some are intent on clouding the issue?
To me it appears a lot of people know the price of everything but the value of nothing. If Baines, who cost £6m from Wigan, was sold for £12m, when his value was £20m, some people would view this as a good deal, as we made £6m, whilst others would see it for what it was.
Asking questions in five years? time will achieve nothing, too many autopsies on football clubs take place, ask Blackburn?s fans! The time to ask these questions is right now, just like it was right to ask about the £52m scam towards building the Kirkby stadium and the Park End development, which reading through your posts you appear to believe Kitbag and Sodexo were actually paying for because the club told you. You?re not alone in believing what gets put out there; some people just can?t distinguish spin from truth ;-)
68 Posted 13/06/2012 at 20:52:23
If Baines decided to 'do a Lescott' and make things really awkward for the club then their hands are tied, they've got to sell him for the most they can. If the most anyone will pay is £12m then what can they do? A transfer value is only ever as high as one club wants to offer and the other is wiling to accept. I'm sure that Rangers thought Jelavic was 'worth' more than £5.5m when they sold him to us but nobody offered them any more so they had to take it.
Somebody in a senior position at the club told me that there was similar logic behind the decision not to give Pienaar the £75k he wanted. They were aware that giving Arteta and Fellaini this sort of money would put them in a strong bargaining position to sell for big money if necessary, whereas with Pienaar his value wouldn't be increased as he wasn't 'desirable' for the top clubs.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 09/06/2012 at 07:34:30