An explanation for the Slow-Start Syndrome?

, 16 June, 66comments  |  Jump to most recent
Hellish bootcamp in prospect...
Everton head coach Jimmy Lumsden has been proudly talking up the greulling regime of pre-season training Everton players have in prospect when they return to the care and keeping of Finch Farm in a couple of weeks. Could this be a factor in Everton's now notorious Slow-Start Syndrome or a key to their success late in matches?

Excerpts from the Jimmy Lumsden interview:

David Moyes's pre-season: Think special forces commando bootcamp, mixed with a boxer's pre-fight training regime, and you're close to the back-breaking, leg-wearying, vomit-inducing slog that Everton's players endure each summer to ensure they are among the fittest in the league.

Moyes's methods have become legendary, and even his most experienced players like Phil Neville and Sylvain Distin fear the physical intensity they must undergo every pre-season. But for Jimmy Lumsden, Moyes's first team coach, the ends justify the means, even if he does have a little sympathy for those dread-filled players currently trying to forget about July's imminent exertions.

?To be fair to the gaffer he does sometimes admit it might be a little bit old school, but he does it mostly for mental reasons rather than physical,? says the Glaswegian, who marked a decade at Goodison in March.

?If they can do these runs they can do anything. They drag each other through them and that's an important aspect too. Coming to the last 10 minutes of a game, if you can drive yourself that little bit harder, go again that tiny bit quicker, than the seeds were sown in pre-season. It's mental training.

?If you can be sharper in the last phases of most games, you have a better chances of getting more points. Our stats tend to show that.

?Luckily the lads we have around Finch Farm are consummate professionals like Hibbo and Ossie. They are players that drive themselves on all the time, and it's no coincidence that they often come on strong towards the end of seasons.?

?The boys had a good end to the season which was to their immense credit because it would have been easy to think it was over and start thinking of the beach towards the end,? he continued.

"It's usually the same teams getting into the Champions League. Nevertheless we can still match these teams in games. It's down to fitness and the way the gaffer keeps on top of the players right throughout the season. Those training sessions are tough; he allows them to get away with nothing. He never accepts anything but their best.?

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (66)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Simon Watts
1 Posted 16/06/2012 at 18:44:41
Said this every year in these forums. Who gives Everton their pre season advice. It is just bonkers. Its obviously not come from a sport or nutrition scientist. It comes from two old school Glaswegians. I think not so long ago, after being in places like Barcelona, Arteta said the after training meal was pie and chips, so he had to go and make his own dinner in the canteen. Its astonishing. They are completely out of touch and burning the players out. Its about maintaining fitness, and operating at 100 % not letting players become exhausted. Its well known that exhaustion affects people for 2 to 3 months. Its just completely crazy, and no other team in the world does it like us.
Barry Rathbone
2 Posted 16/06/2012 at 19:05:49
Agreed Simon, it's not just we don't get results we look knackered.

It's as plain as the nose on Phil Thomsons gob.

Keith Glazzard
3 Posted 16/06/2012 at 18:54:31
Simon - totally agree. Sports science? More like the Spanish Inquisition. Except, of course, the Spanish wouldn't believe that this kind of thing still happens.

I've been in touch with advances in cycling over the last 30 years and have seen Brits from Boardman to Hoy beating the world - always in perfect condition at the right time. And mental preparation - teamwork? Listen to Mark Cavendish praising his team mates who made his victories possible.

Will Fellaini and Jelavic come back needing to work til they puke to be great athletes? I do think this is one of Moyes' blind spots.

Kevin Sparke
4 Posted 16/06/2012 at 19:34:51
It might also help us get off to a decent start if we got in our quality new signings in pre-season and not panic loans at 10 to midnight on the last day of the transfer deadline. I'd suggest that this was as big a factor than a 'gruelling' training regime in our slow starts - didn't we start one game a few seasons ago with half the youth team on the bench and a couple on the field.

Incidentally - Moyes isn't the only manager to do this - both Ferguson and Bobby Robson were/are legendary for their spartan pre season training methods - as were Shankly and Clough.

Jay Harris
5 Posted 16/06/2012 at 19:29:58
I have a totally different perspective.

We end every season (almost) on a high as players and supporters.

Davie gives his list of recommended additions to Bill.

Bill gives him assurances that whatever they can give him they will but it wont be a lot.

4 weeks later after much questioning Davie gets told the cupboard is bare and finances are tight so we have to get loan players if he can reduce the wage bill a touch.

day before deadline day Davie gets told there is a big bid in for one of the squad that is too good to refuse.

Davie gets a titty lip,goes around with his angry head on, the players feel depressed too. The supporters get disillusioned which compounds the players feeling.

a third of the season gone things are really bad the pressure comes on Billy and there are cries for Davies head.

Davie gets his Mojo stick out starts to motivate the team, results get better, supporters get motivated and the whole situation starts to get better.

And so the cycle starts again.

Jeremy Benson
6 Posted 16/06/2012 at 19:44:49
It's a tough call. You only need to look at the england team at the moment to see that they aren't fit enough compared to other teams in the tournament.

Is it not being worked or prepared enough? or is it because they've been over-worked?

Difficult to judge or say. Same scenario.

Kev Prytherch
7 Posted 16/06/2012 at 19:57:30
Didn't we score one of the highest number of goals in the last 10 minutes last season? And I'm sure this is a regular occurance.

I don't think many can argue that were not one of the fittest in the league the problem is that we've been unable to score the last couple of years despite playing decent football for the first 3-4 games, confidence has gone and were in the same slippery slope as we always are.

Ray Said
8 Posted 16/06/2012 at 20:11:05
In this city we have one of the world's leading sports science departments at JMU. Surely we should be tapping in to that resource which is on the front doorstep?
Kev Prytherch
9 Posted 16/06/2012 at 20:14:03
In fact, 50% of our goals came in the last 30 minutes, over 33% in the last 15 minutes.

Okay, the Moyes dour defensive tactics will contribute to this, constantly chasing the game and only playing with any attacking intent in the last 15 minutes, but we couldn't do this without decent fitness levels.

I honestly think this has far less to do with our poor starts than people think and our tactics and lack of goals at the start of the season are far bigger factors.

Chris Owens
10 Posted 16/06/2012 at 20:45:57
If this preparation is what we do every year in pre-season, then it?s time to change it. It doesn?t help us get off to a good start. Get some points in the bag early on, and then players can safely be ?rested? later.
Ian Edwards
11 Posted 16/06/2012 at 20:58:45
The slow start is solely due to the negative tactics of keep it tight and scratch out points until we reach 40 pts.
Chris Dooley
12 Posted 16/06/2012 at 21:18:19
Another possible reason for the slow start is that actually our players aren't as good as they appear to be in the second half of the season.

In the first half of the season, they face fresh opposition with equal fitness. In the second half of the season, our fitness shines through when everyone else is flagging and we pick up a string of results because we train harder than the opposition and so still have gas in the tank at the end of the season.

Lloyd Farrell
13 Posted 16/06/2012 at 22:11:36
Maybe, just maybe, the reason for our slow start has been the lack of a genuine goalscorer, who cannot only score goals, but can pull defenders & create more space for attacking midfielders, to either score or win a corner from a deflected shot.

This coming season will soon tell us if the reason for a our slow start has been the pre-season training or the lack of a genuine goalscorer.

For me, I can't wait to see Jelly pick up where he left off last season and bag 10 goals in the first 10 games. This will not only put points on the board early on, but give us a great platform to build on and have a successfull season ? the complete reverse of the comment made by Jay Harris #399.

Mark Stone
14 Posted 16/06/2012 at 22:17:13
Ray, they are doing, and have been doing for many years.
Mark Stone
15 Posted 16/06/2012 at 22:22:55
In fact, Ray, the model Everton have used with JMU other clubs have copied. That was really groundbreaker for our great club. Tom Reilly was an Evertonian.
James Flynn
16 Posted 17/06/2012 at 00:31:42
A combination of Chris (447) and Lloyd (467). Let's say 70-30 Lloyd.

My main game-in game-out memory of the first half season was our disastrous final third. Wasn't the weekly, repeated lament along the lines of Saha and Cahill being terrible at scoring? And why Moyes still kept sending them out?

Not sure why the pre-season training regimen would be anything other than a topic of praise from all of us. Don't recall being outplayed or the boys running out of gas. We couldn't score.

Whatever stars aligned or Gods took mercy on us, we tripped and fell over a genuine predator and we'll start the season with him. Hopefully we keep everyone and get Stevie back in. Then let's see the first half of the season.

But Moyes' "Boot Camp"? Lumsden got it right, "he does it mostly for mental reasons rather than physical,?.

More of the same please Mister Moyes.

Mike Green
17 Posted 17/06/2012 at 00:55:54
Jay Harris 399 - I reckon you're about right, throw in 'shot in he arm' from Jan transfer additions and we're there!
Eddie McBride
18 Posted 17/06/2012 at 02:09:32
How dare anybody criticise anything our Scottish coaches do in pre-season or at any other time! It is very well known in soccer circles that anyone north of the border knows far more than us simple albions. If testimony is needed, watch any football show and notice the amount of Caledonian experts. I'm pretty sure I tuned in to ESPN the other day and Lulu was telling us how bad we are at football.
Eddie McBride
19 Posted 17/06/2012 at 02:43:37
I'm sorry, I forgot to mention: What about the excrutiating pain every Evertonian has to endure for the first five months of the season???
Peter Barry
20 Posted 17/06/2012 at 03:19:16
Ian Edwards # 435 - Hammer - Nail - Head
Ian Linn
21 Posted 17/06/2012 at 03:44:16
Complete bollocks.

I race a dirt bike. The more I train pre-season, the fitter I get, the faster I get, it's that simple.

Derek Thomas
22 Posted 17/06/2012 at 03:32:08
Lance Armstrong not withstanding, sports training, preparation, conditioning (and diet)... call it what you will, has been well researched for years, it's all out there and, again outside of drugs, blood doping and all that, there are no magic formulas, secret methods.

Do we think Moyes's Methods are outdated, they don't work? Maybe yes, maybe no. The point is what do all the others, in comparable circumstances do.

Footballers and to an extent RU, RL, AFL, are all stop-start middle distance runners. You can put stamina onto sprint, but not sprint on to stamina. None of this info is top secret, it just needs gathering in and compared.

Or in the march to the perfect season's start, is everybody out of step but our Davey?

Jem Traynor
23 Posted 17/06/2012 at 04:05:36
I know this coming season will be interesting as far as this subject goes because, IF we keep our good players and bring Pienaar back, then we should start off like we left off in the last season because any other return to bad form can only point to the pre-season being too much and the player's not being able to cope with the fact that they have basically been worn out.

When that happens, your confidence drops, and then the slide begins... thus the bad form kicks in and... Don't forget, this happens to everyone at different times, I do know it's more scientific than a mindless ego exercise and should be treated as such, I mean pie and chips!! That doesn't sound right to me!
Ian Linn
24 Posted 17/06/2012 at 05:52:18
Jem #506, are you from Sandiway or Cuddington?
Peter Laing
25 Posted 17/06/2012 at 09:48:15
The reason we have started so badly in recent years in my opinion is due to the mental fragility of the Manager as he encounters summer after summer of no support from his Chairman when it comes to providing the funds to freshen up the squad. The bounce we witnessed from January onwards was no coincidence, Jelavic, Pienaar, and Donovan provided the impetus for revival and they evidently inspired those around them and with Gibson allowing Fellaini to push forward we witnessed a more offensive approach. If I was Moyes I would not be signing any contract extension and I would let Kenwright sweat on the problem that he creates for Moyes year on year due to his poor financial acumen.
Kevin Sparke
26 Posted 17/06/2012 at 09:59:03
Mark Stone - indeed, you're correct, there are very strong links between Everton FC and the Sports Science Faculty at JMU.
Paul Mitchell
27 Posted 17/06/2012 at 10:04:53
Is not our pre-season friendlies a problem? I mean it's okay to get the players physically fit but what about mentally? If we play teams that don't stretch them mentally, they are not prepared for when Premier League sides come out all guns blazing at the start of the season.
Jem Traynor
28 Posted 17/06/2012 at 10:44:16
Ian Linn #510,
Neither ? I'm living in Liverpool.
Wayne Smyth
29 Posted 17/06/2012 at 11:19:21
Jeremy(402) how can you say the england team are not fit enough? Can't pass, lack of movement, general inability to beat a man I can understand, but I've not seen any indication of any lack of fitness. What I think we have are mental issues due to historical results and pressures and a lack of technical skills/composure.

As for Everton's pre-season, Moyes has to take a lot of the blame. He knows we've got no more money and need to trade to get new blood in. If he's not prepared to do that then he only has himself to blame if an offer comes in at the 11th hour leaving him with no time to make any purchases.

If I were him now, I'd be ensuring that suitors of Fellaini, Baines or Cahill or any other of our players, are aware now what our acceptable price is then get them moved on early doors for good money and get cheaper replacements in.

We have the budget that we have, unfortunately virtually all our money is tied up in our existing players and their contracts. Behaving like a spoilt brat and complaining in October that you're taking a knife to a gunfight because you weren't prepared to manage with a £60M budget just doesn't cut it in my opinion.

Ray Said
30 Posted 17/06/2012 at 11:43:10
Mark Stone (470) good to hear that the club have links with JMU. Thanks for the info
Mike Gaynes
31 Posted 17/06/2012 at 15:48:45
Peter Laing #534, there's not much that can make me laugh out loud at 8 in the morning. You did it with this:

"The reason we have started so badly in recent years in my opinion is due to the mental fragility of the Manager..."

Congratulations. That's the looniest, loopiest thing I have read here in a long time, and on TW, that's really saying something.

Kevin Day
32 Posted 17/06/2012 at 16:05:53
It's really not that difficult to explain our slow starts. For the last two seasons we have actually been playing teams off the park at the start of the season. It's plain to say there is no scientific reason other than not having a player up front to convert the chances into goals.

Now, providing we keep our best players and get Pienaar, then having Jelavic upfront at the start will put all this scientific nonense to bed.
Ged Simpson
33 Posted 17/06/2012 at 16:14:07
Exactly Kevin. Agree totally.
Ged Simpson
34 Posted 17/06/2012 at 16:14:53
"Lance Armstrong not withstanding.........."

"The reason we have started so badly in recent years in my opinion is due to the mental fragility of the Manager..."

Enough beer for now.

Ian Bennett
35 Posted 17/06/2012 at 16:42:31
My theory, for what's its worth, is that during pre-season we only have handful of players because of injuries from the prior season or international tournaments which causes issues to us getting up to speed.

I am sure it was in the above piece that at times we have under 11 players training. Big clubs handle it by bigger squads, smaller clubs have less players away.

Throw in no new faces from financial constraints, and poor opposition in friendlies and its a receipe for disaster.

Kevin Tully
36 Posted 17/06/2012 at 18:06:22
Instead of playing Morecambe, Dundee, Motherwell & Blackpool pre-season, why not play some real opposition ?

James McGlone
37 Posted 17/06/2012 at 18:16:48
Folks, to blindly blame Moyes's pre-season on our slow starts is idiotic. Moyes himself has stated many times how he has tried different things, and got different people in with different ideas.

The team is known for being one of the fittest in the league, so I'd give Moyes credit for that one. I believe that the problem lies more with the transfer policy that the club operates and the sense of despair that everyone feels come August.

Andy Walker
38 Posted 17/06/2012 at 20:50:31
I dont get it. Why would being fitter than most/all of the other teams at the beginning of the season be a bad thing?

Total red herring.

How about loosing key players at the last minute in the summer, like Lescott and Arteta, and not having sufficient time (and money) to bring in replacements and get them settled in the team before the start of the season? Not much of a story, a bit of a dull explanation really, unlike the headline grabbing idea that the Glaswegian fitness mafia our killing our bouys, but it's far more plausible.

Colin Southern
39 Posted 17/06/2012 at 22:53:27
Quite a laughable article this one had me holding my sides. 20 years as a fitness coach, I've never heard anyone critising another coach for trying to get their players fitter than the opposing team. Normally fatigue will play a part mid-way or near the end of a season ? never at the start.

Listen guys, don't buy into this over-training theory because, out of all the clubs in the EPL, Everton are the club who use the most advanced sports science and technology to get the most out of their squad due to its small size. As a coach, Moyes is a real student of the game and to criticise him for pushing his players to high fitness levels is stretching credibility.

There is a real reason for our slow starts and we all know why: If Moyes's plan is to use his existing meagre resources to push for the top four and he has to sell one of his players without a replacement, this will obviously affect the squad and how you can play to that squad's strengths. No wonder Moyes sees his arse every August!

I teach fellow coaches and I hope Lyndon and Michael won't mind if I reproduce this article for them during one of my lectures.

Michael Kenrick
40 Posted 17/06/2012 at 23:49:59
Sure, Colin, let's see what you've got. Post it as a Fan Comment.

I trust it refutes any suspicion that driving the human body to the absolute limit of back-breaking, leg-wearying, vomit-inducing slog is actually of some real value, rather than perhaps working through joined-up plays and combo moves with players who have something left in the tank, that could perhaps lead to greater cohesion and creating more options going forward when attacking the opposition penalty area as a team?

Just saying...

Mark Riding
41 Posted 18/06/2012 at 00:04:44
Rooney, Zidane, Ginola, Cryuff, Socrates, Gascoine, Bilic, Berbatov, Ardiles, Zoff.. All smokers.. Training problems solved.. 20 Bensons for Ossie !
Kevin Sparke
42 Posted 18/06/2012 at 00:36:09
Mark - can any of them jump over a Mini?

(Duncan Mckenzie 20 cigs before breakfast could)

Mick Davies
43 Posted 18/06/2012 at 03:54:23
"The team is known for being one of the fittest in the league," ?Says who? The best way to get a team sharp is not running up and down mountains, carrying and tossing cabers or ballet lessons: it's working with a ball, which is what they have to do on a matchday for the next 9 months.

Looking at our team in August/September, we look lost tactically and ball control and passing ability seem painfully amiss. For pass and shot, replace the vowels with an i, because until around Xmas time, when they get the feel of the ball at their feet, 3 months after everyone else, stamina and muscle build-up mean nothing.

An early post quotes Shankly as pushing his players in close season through some 'Krypton factor'-style punishment. Wrong; he liked to keep things simple and apparently, his former players have all commented on how he instilled the future success of passing and moving which won so many trophies, by playing 5-a-side one- and two-touch football matches almost every training session.

I reckon that's what our players should do during the pre season sessions. Then, by the time we kick off the season, they're all comfortable with the ball and with passing to a colleague, instead of just lumping the hot potato up field more in hope than expectation.
Colin Southern
44 Posted 18/06/2012 at 11:21:22
Mick (689), you cannot be seriously comparing the way Shankly trained his players 40 years ago to how modern players train. If I can remember top class sprinters used to have a couple of drags on a cigarette before a race as it improved their run time, would you say this is a good idea now?

No, in general terms all coaches and trainers know that you should always 'get fit to play - not play get fit', which is what some of you guys are wrongly advocating.

I can see the methodology in the way Moyes works with the players, working on fitness sessions and then moving onto skill work and then shape and tactics. Its they way all top coaches train their teams in most team sports around the world, so what makes Moyes any different.

No the issue is really down to lack of funds and personnel. Imagine, you worked all summer setting up your team to play in a certain way and then you lost a player who is pivotal to this system. Furthermore, if this said player was not replaced, would this then not upset the balance that you have been working on.

Michael, I'm not sure what your point is to be honest, I was really going to show the article and the comments to our students to prove what an old mentor of mine used to say - a little bit of knowledge is a dangerous thing!

Andrew Ellams
45 Posted 18/06/2012 at 11:52:30
Totall agree with Kevin @615. If Jelavic had been in last season's starting XI from August, there is every chance that we would have finished above Chelsea. We were plenty of effort and no end product for most of the first 4/5 months.

If we can keep Pienaar, maybe bring in somebody to l play with or behind Jelavic then we might just surprise a few people this season.

Phil Martin
46 Posted 18/06/2012 at 12:03:18
I've posted this many times before here...

Pre-season is vital not just because players can prepare for the season. But it also allows new faces to come and freshen up and improve the squad.
No new faces often results in a stale atmosphere with no new competition for places.

SAF has said many times, even title winners need to bring in new faces to help prepare and kick start the exiting squad for the new season.

We haven't bought anyone of any note since 2009 (and that was because we sold Lescott first).
If we had Jella and Pienaar in August instead of January, 6th place and European football wouldve been there for the taking.

Every club has bad spells in the season. Blaming a tough training regime for a slow start is nonesense. If anything surely it would take its toll later in the season - not the start?

Mark Riding
47 Posted 18/06/2012 at 13:35:33
Well, its that time of year again, and having read the fixtures... another slow start looks on the cards !
Andrew Ellams
48 Posted 18/06/2012 at 13:52:57
On the plus side Mark, we go to Anfield in May (don't ever remember a Derby game scheduled for the last 3 weeks of the season before), so we should be doing our customary roaring conclusion to the season and will win there comfortably.....................
Mark Riding
49 Posted 18/06/2012 at 14:01:53
If the 'slow start syndrome' is to be reversed this season, a tough home game to start off with maybe the way to do it. ( although Arsenal / Lescott game ) is still fresh in the memory for me.
3 points on the opening day this year would have us flying.
Ernie Baywood
50 Posted 18/06/2012 at 16:24:44
I have thought for a while that we deliberately overtrained leading to slow starts, but became a different side once released from the burden of overtraining midway through the season.

I always thought Benitez did it at Liverpool too.

Si Cooper
51 Posted 18/06/2012 at 16:43:38
Interested in input from Colin (679) on this subject, as he would appear to have the knowledge to compare different styles of training. Through my own experience of rugby pre-seasons I have seen alternative regimes from a variety of coaches.

I have suggested before on TW that there are different types of fitness and Everton's may be currently more focussed on endurance rather than speed / acceleration ? leading to the ability to outlast other teams in games and over the course of the season... but lacking the attacking edge that comes from quick movement on and off the ball ? and I also wondered if it was a deliberate attempt to try to get the most out of a small squad.

I don't agree that we were better than our results suggested at the start of last season, thought we pretty much got what we deserved overall. Lack of a cutting edge was a factor and the arrival of Pienaar and Jelavic certainly helped overcome that, but the poor start / good finish pattern has been around for a while now and can't simply be explained by the influx / egress of a couple of players.
Colin Southern
52 Posted 18/06/2012 at 18:01:00
Si, good points but it still ignores a major factor in our good starts to the season in that we've been able to buy in players in early and start pre-season preparations.

Being a good coach is not just knowing the training systems but the players personalities too. Knowing this can help you plan and implement sessions and how they respond to particular sessions. Does anyone remember how he was able to get the best out of Kevin Campbell by bringing in French fitness coaches working 1-2-1 with him? You can clearly see Moyes is always looking for the edge in getting the maximum of all his players.

Everton's coaching system is light years ahead of our rivals. Recently I watched the Everton coaches in action, some of the kids were in Liverpool strips and I spoke to the parents who said they had pulled their kids out of Liverpools Academy because it was so poorly run with the sessions very amateurish and old fashioned.

Micheal, from personal experience my company run bootcamp style training sessions too and we've just trained a women's football team, any guesses how they did ? Yep - topped the league and won the cup.

Going back to the original point of the article, it is flawed, and it appears a lack of knowledge is going a long way to score negative points against Moyes for trying to get the best out of a small squad of players.

Bobby Thomas
53 Posted 18/06/2012 at 18:47:51
Colin thanks for the input on this thread interesting stuff.

I thought that a lot of the endurance long distance stuff was a thing of the past, so when I read this for example I was surprised, especially as I have read that Moyes does look for every angle and is always looking for new techniques.

I mean, you obviously have to do some running in pre-season, that's unavoidable, and I'm sure there are lots of things that go toward, stamina, strength, conditioning etc. But I thought that there was less of an emphasis on it as there was in the past, such as this "old school" style.

Could you clear this up for me? Are there different ways of building endurance? I presume if a manager had a squad with more athletic, footballing tendencies than ours, say Arsenal, they may train for speed or quickness, lateral movement, than us? Different players need different qualities although they will all have their personal drills as well I suppose?

I ask cos I read an interview with Lee Dixon once about when Wenger took over. They had done a lot of the long distance running under George Graham. Wenger had taken over and it was completely different and concerned senior pros Dixon and Tony Adams went to see him, expressing their concerns that they didn't feel right, they weren't doing the running (or to the level they had previously, I can't remember) and were concerned they weren't going to be right for the start of the season.

Wenger basically asked them to trust him and that, come the start of the season, they would be right. Lee Dixon said, come the start of the season, he had never felt better.

I also remember when United got beat at the Emirates a few years ago, very late Henry header, that one of the players mentioned Wenger had told then to keep going as they were fitter and he had noticed that United dropped off in the last 10 minutes of games. Maybe that's just good psychological management, but it makes me wonder how those two clubs go about things, or the differences. I have no idea if you would know, it just got me thinking.............

So I was wondering what the prevailing thoughts were on long, heavy running sessions pre-season and if there was less emphasis on it now?

Colin Southern
54 Posted 18/06/2012 at 19:31:03
Bobby, the latest research has come up with press-ups, sit-ups, burpees and squats as the best exercises to get you fit - hence what they mean by old school.

Personally, I very much doubt there are any long, heavy running sessions. If there were they would be more likely sports specific. Shorts burst and interval style running routines, combined with plymetric type exerices to break up the monotony and to add elements of team building. We've done this style of training with Rugby teams like Wigan Warriors ourselves more as means to build teamwork rather than fitness.

Its still a very good point that you brought up and I wish I had explained this more thoroughly regarding psychological management. People view bootcamps as an army style beasting, but what they don't see is that the coaches are really using this as means of team building and communication - something I find the most fascinating. When you push players to their limits you can see all their character qualities coming through. Who are the natural leaders and followers. The players have to rely on each other throughout and this is the thing that pushes the team mentality and togetherness. Essentially the players learn to trust each other and bond during the sessions. Jimmy Lumsden, even says "he (Moyes) does it mostly for mental reasons rather than physical,?.

Essentially you can do this with anyone - we've been able to do the same thing with a very unfit group of young mum's. Put them into mentally and physically challenging style training and they bond and push each other on. At the end they were able to tackle a 10 mile endurance run. The main obstacle really, was in their heads.

Mick Davies
55 Posted 19/06/2012 at 03:37:55
Colin @760 Some good points against my argument there, but I have to disagree about players being injured and upsetting the balance. Teams like Arsenal and Man Utd play a system right through the whole club, so if a player moves into the first team from the reserves, or even the youth team, he is 100% familiar with the system, and slots in with the team seamlessly.

In Moyes's case, he likes to replace players with versatile make-dos, and this upsets the fluency. Instead of coaching the whole club with one way of playing, and each player knowing his role in the system, a midfielder suddenly finds himself as a second striker, when we've been playing with a lone striker most of the season.

Coleman, a right back, in his first senior game, in the cauldron of a European game at Benfica was thrown into the left back spot and we were hammered. What has that done to his confidence as a defender? And ever since, he's been predominantly on the right wing. Take Neville, Jags, Distin, Fellaini, Cahill, Osman, Heitinga, Bilyaledinov, Anichebe, McFadden, Gueye etc. who have all been played in various positions over the last couple of years. This is disruption to the system, to the detriment of players and their performance, the team and the frustration of the fans. It's not rocket science, it's common sense. Army officers don't put artillery men in tanks, or have infantry flying helicopters in the midst of battle. Keep it simple and familiar and that breeds a trust and confidence in where a team mate is going to be, and what he is expected to do.
Colin Southern
56 Posted 19/06/2012 at 09:32:21
Mick, you've really answered your own question about disrupting the balance of a team because clubs like Man U and Arsenal have far greater resources and better players. If we can't replace players or get new ones in before the season starts then there disruption.

Hence why Moyes must replace 'players with versatile make-dos', as a coach if you play to a certain system you buy players to fit it - not the other way round. Look what happened to Barca, by buying Fabregas it disrupted their system. In the past you could build a system around a great player, this would be suicidal for Everton at this moment in time because clubs with greater resources can easily come in and take that player. Then what happens to your playing system, you either buy another player who is similar (very unlikely) or struggle until you can find a way to play to your existing players strengths - sounds very familiar to the last couple of seasons.

You are right its not rocket science - its called sports science. Having taken the time to reply and give the correct information on how training systems work and the effect on groups and individuals, it was difficult to answer you as your point seems to be all over the place, as you have cobbled bits together including a reference to young players, right wingers and the military. Having been in the Military myself the point about the army, is not relevant at all. Comparing the army and the RAF to football coaching is nonesense.

The training methods at the club are some best in the world. You have clubs like Real Madrid coming over to to see how they can use it themselves. However, I think the point about Coleman is interesting and made me smile though as I'm sure the same thing happened to Colin Harvey too.

Brian Waring
57 Posted 19/06/2012 at 17:56:01
I can remember some lads on here questioning our pre - season regime for the start of last season, because in some of the games early on, we looked absolutely knackered.
Colin Southern
58 Posted 19/06/2012 at 19:23:54
Nice try Brian but a very transparent point, maybe our fitness trainers should come on here and get some tips then from some of the lads then.
Mick Davies
59 Posted 20/06/2012 at 00:36:27
Colin, you really are sitting in an ivory tower, and us lesser mortals should cease posting our views and bow to your obviously superior intellect and experience. Just one point though that you may have overlooked: ANALOGY

Maybe you should be at the Euros working for one of the major broadcasting companies, giving the world your erudite and infallible opinions. Or maybe even sorting out the Euro crisis while you're out there. Or then again, maybe Euronly a narrow-minded megalomaniac who needs to take a long hard look at himself.
Mark Riding
60 Posted 20/06/2012 at 01:21:28
Should a professional footballer, who is paid shit loads of money, really need telling how to keep fit?
Colin Southern
61 Posted 20/06/2012 at 09:09:27
Mick, yes it seems like you've reverted to type. If you can't win the argument attack the person. I've only ever tried in the article to point out errors and give some good info on Everton's training techniques.

Mark, that a terrible point because all sports persons from amateurs to professional get told how to get fit. Remember everyone is looking to be better fitter and faster than everyone else, its an innate human quality. Its got nothing to do with money, although it does help.

Mark Riding
62 Posted 20/06/2012 at 20:47:52
Colin, a terrible point maybe, but if I paid you £70k a week, before long (if not already) you would be able to run as long, hard, fast as Fellani, Cahill etc..

It's the fact that the skills make a professional footballer, and I refer to my terrible point again; If a Premier League footballer cannot get motivated to get fit, then whats the point?

The 'Beastings' on the training ground ( yep, Im ex-forces as well ) hasnt got us a good start in years.. Would it be so crazy to try a different approach?
Colin Southern
63 Posted 20/06/2012 at 20:55:43
Mark, by that analogy does that mean Steven Gerard and Frank Lampard are fitter than Cahill and Fellani because they are paid more money?

Your point appears to be that they are paid all this money so should automatically be motivated and in some ways you are right, I agree with you whole heartedly. However, If only human's worked this way then it would be all too easy for us coaches. No-one can maintain 100% motivation, its not possible and don't forget some of these guys have been training since they were 5 or 6 years of age. Some of these players are well off or even millionaires before they are even in their 20s.

A good example is if you won £100 million on the lottery would you still be motivated to go into work. Or would you have just trained yourself in the military by going over the assault course willingly, or done a log or stretcher run? I can't honestly say I would have done it on my own, unless there was a PTI making me do it.

Mark Riding
64 Posted 20/06/2012 at 22:26:18
Colin, really I do see your points, and I'm glad you see mine. This isn't a TW slagging off excercise on this thread.

Military style training is multi-purpose, I guess much like its supposed to be in a football scenario. Yes, it's team building, and as I'm sure you know, the less fit/able guys either get faster quick or become a bit of a liabliy. I say, so please don't jump down my throat, from my own experiences, that certain aspects of training are designed to make you think ? once you have got through them ? that whatever else gets thrown at you 'well its not as bad a the beasting I had at... such and such. A bit of mental toughness.

On a football pitch, I guess that after 80 mins chasing the ball against Barca, a player is meant to mentally refer to his 120 mins chasing around the training field. I do get it.

I also think that practising skill and technique is just as important as the fitness side, and why not tactics. Im not daft enough to think this does not happen already, but the emphasis on the running etc always seems to be the focus of negativity.

Oh, and as for your 'If you won the lottery would you do it?' ? we won the lottery once every month, and spent it ! Payday millionaires..
Colin Southern
65 Posted 20/06/2012 at 23:22:43
You're dead right, especially the bit about Payday Millionaires.

Mark Riding
66 Posted 20/06/2012 at 23:35:15
Glad it made sense Colin, we play Malaga in a few weeks... Now thats a night out IYKYH !!!!!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads