Rodwell omitted from GB Olympic squad

, 28 June, 63comments  |  Jump to most recent
As expected, Jack Rodwell has not been included in Stuart Pearce's Team GB squad for the London Olympics after Everton advised the midfielder to continue his recuperation from a succession of hamstring problems that significantly disrupted his 2011-12 season.

The 21 year-old helped spearhead the marketing campaign for Great Britain's new Olympic football team but he won't play any part in the Games.

That will come as good news for David Moyes who will want Rodwell fit and raring to go when the new Premier League season kicks off in mid-August.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Guardian



Reader Comments (63)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Gerry Quinn
1 Posted 28/06/2012 at 18:55:17
Great news - truly sad for Jack, but chuffed in relation to all Evertonians who want THEIR team to benefit from a fit and raring to go Rodders!
Ian Bennett
2 Posted 28/06/2012 at 19:04:29
Can Duffy and velios go?
Martin Paice
3 Posted 28/06/2012 at 19:17:33
Surely he needs games? can't help think he'd be better playing in something vaguely competitive rather than some 3rd gear pre season game?

No one can argue he's better off looked after by our medical team with the amount of injuries he's had.

Bob Willis
4 Posted 28/06/2012 at 21:15:36
GB Olympic squad

Don't agree with this 'GB squad' at all.

However, so pleased that CYR Beckingham is excluded but why on earth
has S Pearce included RS Bell-ami?

Giggs yes - well deserved - Jack? well he has a lot to prove imho.

Mark Stone
5 Posted 28/06/2012 at 23:02:20
What wrong with the Team GB, Bob? We compete in the Olympics as GB, football is an Olympic sport. 2+2 =4. I couldn't give a crap about England at the euros, but I'll certainly be backing 'our greatest team' this summer.
Anthony Martin
6 Posted 28/06/2012 at 23:21:01
I for one am looking forward to following team GB. My biannual love affair is over; back to the Mrs. There is only room for one team with seven letters, first one E. Till Brazil 2014 that is. But the Olympics should help the withdrawal symptoms till Man Utd on opening day.
Si Cooper
7 Posted 28/06/2012 at 23:24:28
Good way for youngsters and top-class players from all parts of GB to compete in a meaningful international tournament. Should be like how everyone gets behind the British Lions when they go up against the southern hemisphere superstars. Only argument against that ever worried me was the idea that used to be touted that Fifa would be able to do away with the autonomy of the home nations in all international competitions. Go Team GB. Good luck Jack for the coming season.
Seamus Murphy
8 Posted 29/06/2012 at 02:41:46
Are you serious Ian Bennett? Duffy is Irish and Vellios is Greek, how the hell could they play for GB?
Sam Hoare
9 Posted 29/06/2012 at 08:11:19
Sad for Jack but good for us I feel.

Jack needs time to recover from those hamstring problems that plagued him last season and hopefully can contribute more this season as he's no longer a kid and the time has come for him to step it up if he can....

Thomas Windsor
10 Posted 29/06/2012 at 08:22:21
Big season for Rodwell... time to see what he is made of. He needs to be injury free though to really judge him.
Barry Rathbone
11 Posted 29/06/2012 at 08:46:01
Wonder if the jingoistic bollocks, happily now consigned to history, about Ingerland will be transferred to to this GB olympic baloney.

The signs are there, although the binning of the celebrity underpant salesman Beckham is a positive call.

Colin Evans
12 Posted 29/06/2012 at 09:02:31
Rodders needs to be fit for EFC next season so best he doesn't play in this "exhibition" tournament.

We have tickets for the Team BG game in Cardiff on 1st Aug - My daughter was really looking forward to seeing Lord Beckham.

How they can choose that thug Bellami over him mystifies me??? If you want a welshman Giggs deserves it much more: choose a lover not a fighter...

Eugene Ruane
13 Posted 29/06/2012 at 09:20:08
Colin (452) - Why Bellamy over Beckham?

Because if they want to win, there's more chance of that happening with Bellamy than Beckham.

Beckham is 37 and plays in league that is somewhere between championship and div two.

His inclusion imo would have made the thing an even bigger joke than it already is.

The Victims were shite last season but Bellamy was probably one of the few players there who did alright and actually looked dangerous.

A thug he might (nb: but on paper, less so than Big Duncan) but it's not about who is the most popular, it's about winning.

Still don't worry, seems Lord Coe is going to find Lord thick a 'substantial role' (although if he's not playing and he's not manager, that only leaves 'Director of Football' or Chairman....of er the British Olympic football team).

Or maybe, like Fr Ted with Fr Dougal, they've convinced him that making sure nobody steals the corner flags is very important.


John Ford
14 Posted 29/06/2012 at 09:39:17
Indeed Eugene, and Beckhams sponsors - Samsung and Adidas, have insisted Lord Underpants has a prominant olympic role.............fully support Pierce's decision not to play him, but money dictates we'll see plenty of this self promoting, media concoction.

The reaction of some football fans seems bizarre to me. Im hearing the defence of Bechams non selection expressed the oddest terms - 'this can raise his profile,' 'he is an icon' 'he's worked hard for the olympics' . What has this to do with anything?

Clearly Pierce has upset the corporate applecart, but for people to be so naive and to fall for this media manipulated bullshit ...........

Rodders should relax, get fit and watch videos of Pirlo.

Matt Traynor
15 Posted 29/06/2012 at 09:58:46
John #455, listening to some people on the phone in, Beckham won the right to stage the Olympics.

Some wonderful conspiracy theorists. Beckham is bessie mates with Gary Neville, who basically took Pearce's position with the England team. Others pointing out that Giggs shouldn't be there because of his infidelity (conveniently over-looking Beck's own long-rumoured and numerous dalliances). Radio phone-ins are great entertainment.

Am I missing something here, because I can't find the final 18 listed anywhere? I know Bellamy broke ranks a while ago to say he was in, but it seems this has been leaked all over.

Barry Rathbone
16 Posted 29/06/2012 at 10:04:20
John Ford

Like yourself I am completely bemused by fans utterances about Beckham, it seems "big brother" and "x factor" thinking has taken over rational thought.

Beckham is 103 yrs old and hasn't played football since SAF realised defenders had sussed him out.

With neither the pace or skill to go past people he was off loaded to Madrid to sell shirts before transplanting himself to the greatest market place of all - the USA.

All of which ludicrously guaranteed his england place, and people wonder why the england team has never won anything since '66.

Kieran Fitzgerald
17 Posted 29/06/2012 at 10:53:46
I find it funny that all the hype surrounds the fact that Beckham has been omitted. Is his PR machine really that prominent or is he just that desperate to sell aftershave and underpants and razors and suits and watches and every other bit of tat known to man. Why doesn't he just get himself one of those shopping channels and be done with it.

In footballing terms what has the guy actually done? A couple of good seasons at Utd and that's about it. At least with the rest of the golden generation, such as Lampard, Terry, Gerrard and Ferdinand, they all continued to play proper top flight football. Bet you won't see any of those clowns putting themselves about the way Beckham is at the moment. If he's not managing the England team at the 2010 world cup, he's bringing the Olympics to London. Maybe next year he can prove the existance of extra terrestrials and play in the Martian first division. It's proper football that.

Jamie Barlow
18 Posted 29/06/2012 at 11:19:55
Kieran, "In footballing terms what has the guy actually done"?

Are you having a laugh?

Ray Roche
19 Posted 29/06/2012 at 11:22:12
So.


Real Madrid.

Not proper football.


Where are the Reality Check Police when you need them?

Gavin Ramejkis
20 Posted 29/06/2012 at 11:37:26
Can't understand why everyone is getting a boner for who is or isn't playing this meaningless excuse to screw some money for the FA coffers. The new season can't start soon enough.
Kieran Fitzgerald
21 Posted 29/06/2012 at 11:41:14
Jamie, how long was he at Madrid for? And at the time the club was more interested in signing galacticos and egos than actually building a proper squad. Going to Madrid suited both Beckham's ego as well as his pocket. Do you think the Beckham of then would get into the Madrid squad now? While I wouldn't bet against it I would doubt that it would have very short odds.

Every career move Beckham has ever made since Utd has never been for footballing reasons, even when he was still considered to be in his prime. The whole olympic gig is the same. Footballing swansong my backside. For Beckham, it's all about longer contracts with Addidas and Co. to cover his leaving football.

Ray Roche
22 Posted 29/06/2012 at 11:55:46
Beckham was a good player. Nothing more. He could cross a ball and was good at free kicks but everyone in the luvved up media thought the sun rose and set via his well publicised skiddies. The best thing about squeeky voiced D'artagnán lookalike Beckham is his PR team. If he farts it's in the news. I was sick to the back teeth about the newspapers efforts to have him become the most capped player of all time. His engine ran out of oil some years ago, but to say that he's done NOTHING in football is a bit silly.
Brian Denton
23 Posted 29/06/2012 at 12:31:37
Gavin, it's "hard-on", not "boner". We are not Americans......
John Ford
24 Posted 29/06/2012 at 12:24:36
.........and awfully nice of Beckhams PR company to 'announce'' ickle Davids non selection ahead of the manager doing same.

Is there actually a definition of what constitutes 'news'?

Andrew Ellams
25 Posted 29/06/2012 at 12:43:57
Beckham won a league championship at Real Madrid under Capello, remember him
Kris Boner
26 Posted 29/06/2012 at 12:49:49
Love the idea of Moyes sitting Rodwell down with tapes of Pirlo for the next six weeks to try and make him pass forwards.
Tom Bowers
27 Posted 29/06/2012 at 12:49:06
The EPL and England will benefit next season from the full fitness of Rodwell and Wilshere. It can only benefit Rodders by not being part of the Olympic squad. His chance will come again but I am sure the Everton and England squads are more important in his mind.
Eugene Ruane
28 Posted 29/06/2012 at 12:21:14
Agree Ray (467), he WAS a good player and ABOVE average, but as you suggest, these days that gives you God status (especially if you're married to a clothes horse with a voice like an X-factor reject)

If you forgot what the commentators were telling you and just trusted your own eyes, there were a million bum crosses from Beckham.

Yet when someone got on the end of a decent cross, it was THAT one that was 'typical Beckham'.

I always felt the same way about Bryan 'Captain Fantastic' Robson.

Again a good player and above average, but there were parts of his game that were woeful.

For one, he couldn't tackle properly (I'm fairly sure I heard George Best saying this too)

His body shape was all wrong going in, off-balance, studs up, he gave away loads of fouls towards the end of his career and had he been playing for anyone else would, I believe, have ended up with a load more red cards.

To be honest, it's not just a football thing.

Elevating the average seems to be a peculiarly British thing

All my life I've see the British ('we' British) set themselves up to fail.

Anyone with a bit of talent is world-beater

I follow boxing almost as closely as I follow football and the times I've seen an average British fighter elevated to ridiculous heights, then come a cropper, is incredible.

Mark Kaylor, Vernon Sollis, Dave 'Boy' Green, Tony Sibson..

All decent fighters but if you took off the Brit-blinkers and looked at who they were up against, you knew there was virtually no chance

Frank Bruno was one of the most manufactured fighters I've ever seen (Don King said Bruno was the only black man he'd ever seen with no rhythm).

Lawless/Duff set him up against 20 puddins who all got sparked in a round or two.

"He's a genius - a knockout machine!"

Yeah..Until he met someone with a fucking pulse (Smith)

Ok he won a VERSION of a 'world' title and good luck to him, but against anyone decent, he looked shite.

(nb: rarely do bookies get sentimental but they made Bruno favourite against Witherspoon - I won just over 300 nicker).

I honestly think the same thing applies right across the board - reward the average.

Sean Connery and Michael Caine are considered great actors.

Well..I've seen them in some great films but they can't do accents.

I mean they hardly 'transform' themselves.

(take away the celeb element and David Thewlis' performance in Mike Leigh's Naked is better than anything the above mentioned have EVER done)

"Greatest actor ever Laurence Olivier".

Really? Why? Name me five GREAT performances?

For me Steve Buscemi or John C Rielly piss all over him.

There's Dame This and Sir That, titles handed out to a load of old thesps who couldn't hold a candle to the late (Kiwi) actor Bruno Lawrence, yet nobody has ever heard of him.

In America, the idea of only being as good as your last performance keeps everyone on their toes.

Here it's more a case of "Well not his best game tonight but let' not forget what he has done for England in the pas..." blah

Fuck that - I believe in the exact opposite, that If you want to raise standards, we SHOULD forget - fast!

(oops...that went on a bit)

Ian Bennett
29 Posted 29/06/2012 at 13:12:03
Seamus - No shit. I meant with their nations obviously, and assume Duffy's would be Ireland now.
Mike Green
30 Posted 29/06/2012 at 12:21:35
Keiran #466 - between him and his missus I think the Beckham's might just about be "covered" for his leaving football already.

Beckham was a decent player who's made the best - and some - of his lot. Good luck to him.

Should there be a football competition at all in the Olympics? Not for me. Not when the pinnacle is a World Cup medal, a bit like tennis and Wimbledon. This argument falls down when you consider boxing, which I'm all for being in the Olympics even though there are World Championship belts. Just doesnt feel right, seems like their football trying to muscle in on someone else's party.

Should Beckham be there? Again, not for me. Giggs? Yeah, I think he's a great choice, mainly because I think he's genuinely earned it and has a lot to offer the squad. His being Welsh is another plus too to be honest.

Should we care what sports people do in their private lives? Not really, IMO. Personally I'd rather watch a team like Italy who look like and play like a bunch of pickpockets than 11 David Beckhams who look nice, play nice but dont get the pulse racing. I want to see what they can do on the field, not off it.

Mike Green
31 Posted 29/06/2012 at 13:15:38
Oh - on topic, should Rodwell be in the Olympics squad? No.
Bobby Thomas
32 Posted 29/06/2012 at 13:33:42
Eugene, Naked was on the Beeb again a few months back I caught the last three quaters of it, first saw it by chance when I was in my teens. Awsome film and a lead performance of a man tearing himself apart that is off the scale in brilliance.
Brian Denton
33 Posted 29/06/2012 at 15:34:34
Eugene, I think you may be falling into the trap of drawing the assumption that if a British actor/footballer is praised, he CANNOT by definition be any good. There's a high-fallutin word for this type of logic, but I can't remember what it is.

Richard Burton was a bloody good actor. And lauded.

Mike Green
34 Posted 29/06/2012 at 17:09:25
Brian - you could be thinking inverted or reverse snobbery....? (I'm not agreeing with you that Eugene's guilty of it by the way).

I think at the end of the day people establish awards, gongs, trinkets, prizes, memberships, titles, etc etc for lots of different reasons, some laudable, some not and the people that get them can be equally deserving, or undeserving, depending on the eye of the beholder and often the agenda of the person who's established the award in the first place.

Eugene Ruane
35 Posted 29/06/2012 at 17:14:17
Brian (500) the point (I stated as clearly as I could), is NOT about whether someone is 'praised' - praise is good, praise is fine, I'm all for praise, not knocking it, ok?

The POINT is when people (footballers/boxers/actors) are praised to a totally ludicrous extent.

When the level of praise is COMPLETELY undeserved (ie: Beckham)

You say Richard Burton was a 'bloody good actor'.

Good choice, a PERFECT example!

WHY was he?

I mean rather than just make EXACTLY the kind of statement I'm talking about, why not analyse a little more?

Forget the reputation - what do YOU see?

What EXACTLY makes him so 'bloody good'?

His films?

Here is a list of Burton"s films.

Tell me which one's you think he was great in or which performances were memorable and/or scintillating

1984 - Nineteen Eighty-Four
1983 - Wagner
1980 - Circle of Two
1978 - The Medusa Touch
1978 - Absolution
1977 - The Wild Geese
1977 - Equus
1977 - Exorcist II: The Heretic
1974 - The Klansman
1973 - Massacre in Rome
1972 - The Assassination of Trotsky
1971 - Villain
1971 - Under Milk Wood
1969 - Anne of the Thousand Days
1969 - Staircase
1968 - Boom
1968 - Where Eagles Dare
1968 - Candy
1967 - The Comedians
1966 - Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
1965 - What's New Pussycat
1965 - The Spy Who Came In From the Cold
1965 - The Sandpiper
1964 - The Night of the Iguana
1963 - Cleopatra
1963 - The V.I.P.s
1962 - The Longest Day
1960 - Ice Palace
1959 - Look Back in Anger
1959 - The Bramble Bush
1957 - Seawife
1955 - The Rains of Ranchipur
1955 - Alexander the Great
1953 - The Robe
1952 - My Cousin Rachel
1951 - Green Grow the Rushes.

It's subjective but I can see two ('Night Of The Iguana' and 'Who's Afraid Of Virgina Woolf?') where you think 'Wow that guy can act'

A couple of other films early on were decent enough, but nothing you'd say "Only Burton could have played that".

We could argue about a couple more, but there is LOT of dross/average stuff in there.

Imo, apart from '1984', everything he was involved in after (and including) Villain, total shite.

He was pissed for much of the second half of his life and basically going through the motions to keep himself in bevvy.

The film 'Villain' is beyond laughable, so is 'Klansman' and 'Wild Geese' - the scripts AND his performance.

Yes he COULD act and he could act well, but his reputation far exceeds his talents, which was (and is) my point.

For me Nicol Williamson was EVERY bit as good an actor, but got nowhere near the same accolades or fame as Burton

Why not?

See David Beckham, see the British press, see the British, see who you know, who you don't know, who are you going out with, etc etc.

(and you think I'M falling into a trap?)

Peter Warren
36 Posted 29/06/2012 at 18:21:34
Morgan freeman has the best talking voice , a far superior voice than beckham's football skills
Eugene Ruane
37 Posted 29/06/2012 at 19:17:20
Peter (512) Shawshank ruined coz of those fucking ads.
Brian Denton
38 Posted 29/06/2012 at 19:09:34
Sorry Eugene - I didn't expect the Spanish Inquisition (nobody does).

Burton is brilliant as Wagner, by the way. All 7 hours of it (when he's hardly off screen).

I think with actors, if they produce ONE film in which they are brilliant, then they are brilliant actors. Usually a need to keep the boodle rolling in means crap roles are taken sometimes. So what? I think your revisionist view of Olivier wouldn't find too many takers either.

However, on the plus side I can now boast that I have had the honour of a broadside from Eugene !

Chris Leyland
39 Posted 29/06/2012 at 19:39:07
Personally I though the guy playing Gordon Clegg in Corrie recently is the best actor I've see for a long time.
Eugene Ruane
40 Posted 29/06/2012 at 19:20:19
Brian (516) not a broadside at all, just trying to point out how and why people become elevated to levels WAY beyond their capabilities or talents.

The question of why England (football team) fuck up or don't achieve what they might is, I believe, linked to this.

'Pick him he MUST be picked. Come on he's GOT to go, he's brillia......meh he was shite the useless twat"

My view on Olivier is DEFINITELY simplistic and you're right, I don't give him credit for the actor he undoubtedly was.

But this is the whole point, in Britain you're not allowed to say he was a GOOD actor or a DECENT actor, he has to be the best or one of the best or a genius or whatever.

A revisionist view is only a bad thing if it is absolutely a lie.

Whether Burton was good/great/shite is subjective so why should I (or anyone) buy into a previously-formed (subjective!) opinion, as though it is a carved in stone fact?

Attempt anything approaching rational analysis and you're immediately met by people on the defensive (who often haven't listened properly)

"So you're saying he's shit!? You're talking out your arse lad"

Er...well if I'd said that, I would be, but...I didn't

But go too far the OTHER way and in Britain, no problem, hype away.

"He's brilliant, he's a genius, he's the best ever" etc etc.

I just feel if we (you, me, the media, Roy Hodgson) stopped buying into what is 'accepted wisdom' and did a bit more analysis for ourselves, and started seeing things how they REALLY are (rather than through patriot-specs), we might have a chance of actually improving all kinds of things and probably avoid a fair bit of disappointment.

Brian Denton
41 Posted 29/06/2012 at 19:54:39
The funny thing is Eugene, I largely agree with you. One thing that always amazes me is how often our institutions are 'the envy of the world'; off the top of my head I can recall that being said about our banking institutions and our voting system for example.

If there was a Cup for self-preening, we'd win hands down. Or am I 'bigging-up' our self-preening ability? A man could go mad like this......

Bobby Thomas
42 Posted 29/06/2012 at 20:12:01
Broadsword calling Danny boy, Broadsword calling Danny boy........
Gareth Humphreys
43 Posted 29/06/2012 at 20:42:54
I like you Eugene, but good god I couldn't live with you.
Eugene Ruane
44 Posted 29/06/2012 at 20:14:06
Self-preening Brian?

I'm not really sure, but we know all the other stuff.

British Police?

Best in the world!

British Legal system?

Best in the world!

EPL?

Best league in the world!

(voice from back) "Says who?"

(voice from the front) "Shut up!....carry on"

British Bangers, British beer, British..er..curry..British paedophiles .. British TV..British comedy...it goes on and on and if none of it is ever questioned (and it rarely is) it (and we) just stagnate.

One glimmer - It looks like FINALLY some attempt will be made to change the coaching of kids so that a lot of the pressure is removed (ie: leagues, full-size pitches etc) and more skills can be developed, but it's going to take a while.

My mate's lad is 12.

He's a decent little player (has trained with Everton, Liverpool, Man City etc) but when I've been to watch him play games, the whole thing depresses me.

Basically hairy-arse, shaven headed lunatics screaming at kids

I went to watch him play a year ago in Belle Vale.

It was a semi-final of...some cup.

They won two nil and at the end I said to my mate "let's get off" he said hold on the manager gives them a talk afterwards.

The boys sat in a semi-circles while some fat twat in trackie read the riot act (this after they'd won!)

When I was his age, I played every single day of my life but (apart from school teams) never saw an adult.

Now there's fat Fergie wannabes all over the country giving 11 year olds the benefit of their 'wisdom' .

Anyway, hopefully this wlll change and there will be (somewhere down the line) one or two kids produced who don't need five touches to get the ball down.

Peter Warren
45 Posted 29/06/2012 at 20:50:45
English have the best strawberries
Gareth Humphreys
46 Posted 29/06/2012 at 20:54:19
I couldn't live with you Eugene (not that the offer was ever on the table) but you are bang on the money with this.
Dean Adams
47 Posted 29/06/2012 at 20:47:41
Eugene Ruane 515

Those bloody ads could not ruin Shawshank, although they have muddied the waters. Now that film was great and no over-hyping needed!!

Eugene Ruane
48 Posted 29/06/2012 at 21:51:15
Gareth, I'll leave the postcard in the newsagents window then - "Everton supporter with room to rent, looking for smoker with GSOH. Must be prepared to do share of housework and argue the toss over every fucking thing"
Sam Hoare
49 Posted 29/06/2012 at 21:57:49
Eugene, agree that Thewlis is superb in Naked and that praise is often dolloped out in patriotic excess to certain 'treasures' but Burton was a GREAT actor. They guy got 7 oscar noms, plus his stage work was phenomenal as well.
Mike Green
50 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:10:44
Sam - how many Oscar nominations has Kate Winslett had?
Sam Hoare
51 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:34:25
6 I believe Mike.
Roman Sidey
52 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:14:39
Mike, she's had six. She is a great actress.

Eugene, as an Australian, I feel it is very similar here for our stars. A lot of people like things "because they're Australian" without actually thinking for themselves. Down under, a lot of people will claim that Angus Young is the best guitarist of all time, citing the riff from Thunderstruck as an example of his prowess. If anyone has ever played the guitar, it's one of the first licks you learn, and is comparable to under 7s football. They don't realise that a short, Scottish import had to dress as a school-boy as gimmick because he was a three-chord wonder, accompanying a bloke who can't sing.

Mike Green
53 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:46:05
Roman - I've played guitar for 30 years, the first riff I ever learnt to play was 'Highway to Hell'. Angus Young might not be 'the best' but he's easily my favourite - I'd put the live solo on Bad Boy Boogie up against almost anything. If you're debating over the merits ofthe riff from 'Thunderstruck' and you're judging if Bon Scott can 'sing' my guess is you're missing the point.
Mike Green
54 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:56:33
And Kate Winslet's on par with the riff from 'Thunderstruck' by the way.
Mike Green
55 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:57:32
AND they're three wonderful chords! Played by his brother, not him any way!

How long till the season starts......?

Eugene Ruane
56 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:46:21
The Oscars - another a good example.

Winning one doesn't mean you're shite but it doesn't mean you're great either.

Kate Winslett has 6/7 occars?

Well I think she's a decent enough actress but she'll never give a performance to match the one given Kathy Burke in 'Nil By Mouth'.

Sam, you say Burton's stage work was 'phenomenal'.

Quite a claim but absolutely legitimate if you saw a lot of it.

If not, it's just (as I've suggested a couple of times) accepting the received wisdom.

Mike Green
57 Posted 29/06/2012 at 23:15:35
Eugene - she's had 6 nominations, think she won one for 'The Reader'. But, your case in point; does Titanic, hits stardust, edges her way into the establishment, divorces, marries equal rising stardom, divorces, plays nice, says the right things, plays her part - next stop Damehood. Call me cynical. Long live the Ballotelli's of this world.
Si Cooper
58 Posted 29/06/2012 at 22:52:43
The sort of thread that reminds me why I love TW. Roman (538) when has heavy metal ever been about skilful riffing and melodic voices. Like punk, it is all about the image and the emotions it evokes. There are many great rock bands, but that ain't metal.

Hope all the current hype is only because the Olympics are in London and future ones will not be over-exposed. Have always enjoyed them but they used to have an understated elan that made them special. Blinkin' media idiots are ruining everything these days.
Roman Sidey
59 Posted 30/06/2012 at 00:08:51
Mike, I said people Down Under think he's "the best", not "their favourite". "The best" means talent and ability, of which he wouldn't be in the top 20.

Si, since this is a football thread, I'm not going to judge you for thinking that metal isn't about riffs and melodic singing, and that it is comparable to punk. It is, in essence, the exact opposite of what you described.

For the record, I don't think team sports (except for those that are extensions of solo sports e.g. rowing, swimming, running etc) should be in the Olympics at all.

Mike Green
60 Posted 30/06/2012 at 00:13:42
Roman - depends on your definition of 'the best'. I take back what I said, he's my favorite and therefore in my eyes, also the best. Peter Green's pretty good too mind....
Roman Sidey
61 Posted 30/06/2012 at 00:24:42
Fair enough, Mike. My favourite is probably Adam Jones, but he is by no means the best. A bit like Everton being my favourite club, but far off being the best at anything.
Si Cooper
62 Posted 30/06/2012 at 00:39:24
You may be more of an expert on this subject than me Roman, but to me (and it may only be to me I guess) heavy metal, and the likes of AC/DC, was more to do with the whole being greater than the sum of the parts. It was about feeling the music on a very visceral level and enjoying the raw emotions it brought forth without over-analysing what it was made up of. It didn't matter if it was technically brilliant or not as long as it came together in the right way. I suspect a lot of people who enjoy it are like me; couldn't tell you if the musicians are maestros or the vocallist bang on key, but if it sounds 'right' it'll do for me.

(To an early teen in the early eighties, it was also very much about being a rebel, and proud to display it, which allies it to punk in that regard.)

In a way my enjoyment of football (and sport in general) is very similar. Sometimes you can be captivated by the simplest of moves when it all comes together perfectly. You don't need step-overs, back heels, mazy runs and over-head kicks into the top corner all the time to be royally entertained.

Nigel Tufnell
63 Posted 30/06/2012 at 02:56:58
Angus Young copied his style from me.

My solos are my trademark. Anyone who disagrees should listen to Shark Sandwich, Intravenus-de-milo or The Gospel according to Spinal Tap.

Me, Smallsey and Hubbo are starting a comeback tour coinciding with the charity shield, it's called the "Charity begins with Rock" tour which is a clever twist on words as we are rasing money for Derek's new zeroscape garden at Smalls Mansion. Not sure how much money we'll raise - maybe just enough to deliver a truckload of gravel - but at least Derek will be able to try out his new wheelbarrow.

According to Derek, the wheelbarrow was originally used to teach the Scottish how to walk upright.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads