Interest in Jelavic from Hamburg

, 21 July, 113comments  |  Jump to most recent
'[He] would be exactly the right player for us'

Hamburg SV have revived their interest in signing Nikica Jelavic based on comments attributed to the Bundesliga club's sporting director.

Sky Sports quote Oliver Kreuzer as saying that his club have "been offered an opportunity" to sign the Croatian striker whom he almost signed three years ago before he joined Rangers.

Kreuzer told Hamburger Morgenpost that he thinks Jelavic is "a great player. I know him very well. I wanted to get him out of Rapid Vienna and to Graz in 2010 before he went to Rangers. That transfer only just failed."

"We have been offered an opportunity. We will deal with it."

It does not look as though it will involve a big up-front payment for Roberto Martinez to use for transfers, however.

Kreuzer added: "If we manage that [to sell two or three players] we could work out if a loan or a payment in instalments would be possible."

Kreuzer is quoted further by Hamburg-based writer, Daniel Busch, on Twitter:

UAE-based journalist, Andy Lewis, formerly of Everton's communications department, initially broke the news of Kreuzer's comments over Twitter yesterday:

The Daily Mail then picked up the story, claiming that Hamburg will lodge a £6m bid for Jelavic, and also lent their questionable weight to speculation linking the Blues with France U19 defender, Mory Kone.

Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports



Reader Comments (113)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Eugene Kearney
1 Posted 21/07/2013 at 18:51:34
Not sure if this is good news. He's had his second season syndrome. I was hoping that he'd just find form again under Roberto.
Colin Glassar
2 Posted 21/07/2013 at 18:58:10
I don't know about this one. If we could get £7m for him but then, who could we buy?
Phil Walling
3 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:00:29
The Executioner`s Bong suggests he`s suffering from `Under Arousal`syndrome so I`ve slipped some `Blues` in the post for him.Should make him harder to stop scoring!
David Chait
4 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:17:03
I hope not.... He was so unreal in everything he did first season I am wanting to give him this season to see if he can replicate. I feel he will as he has done his whole career...
Colin Glassar
5 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:26:16
David, if you believe the rumours, we apparently turned down £8m (from Besiktas) for Saha after his first season and we all know how he turned out don't we? I am inclined to agree with you and give Jelavic another chance but if they offer something silly.....
Mike Gaynes
6 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:28:28
I'd hate to see Jelavic become a Hamburger. If he's mustard out it would leave us in a pickle up front.
Derek Knox
7 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:24:56
Difficult one this! What if he stays and has a repeat (hope not) of last season?
It would be not easy to sell him on,plus he would be a year older! Like Colin said who would we buy/ I am sure there is a player out there somewhere, with Roberto's knowledge and contacts I'm sure he could unearth something!
Barry Rathbone
8 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:38:20
Mike, I agree not something I'd relish.

(it really is hot)

Eugene Ruane
9 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:32:08
Cut to McDonald's, Hamburg.

Customer: "I vud like ze Jelavic Burger meal"

Counter assistant "Jah, nein problem mein herr.....KARL! EIN KRAPPY-MEAL MIT ZE FRIZE!!"

James Martin
10 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:55:05
Even after a bad season he's still a big name on the team sheet. One good run of form and defenders everywhere would be fearing him again in a way that they will never fear Anichebe or Kone. if we sell him and bring in some no mark then that will be disappointing.
John Shepherd
11 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:47:51
I would like to see him given another season. He could do no wrong in his first season, and would probably have smashed the 20 goal mark if we had bought him at the start of that season.

Last season, he suffered because of the big fella's early form and Moyes's stubbornness to persist with the same tactic all season. Under a new manager with hopefully more than one idea when it comes to the final third... who knows? Roberto would be wiser to at least give him till Xmas.

James Stewart
13 Posted 21/07/2013 at 19:55:30
I find it really interesting how patient our fans on the whole have been with Jelavic. I have not seen an Everton striker as useless as Jelavic was last season since Beattie and yet many are keen to give him yet more time.

Beckford/Bent/Saha and even Cahill came under a hell of a lot more stick for not finding the net than Jelavic has despite him being ten times worst. He contributes nothing. His technique is atrocious. One of the most embarrassing divers around. Didn't even look like scoring against lower league opposition. Displaced by Vic. If someone makes a bid I would snap their bloody hand off.

Paul Ellam
14 Posted 21/07/2013 at 20:32:20
I think it would be a mistake to sell him.
Sam Hoare
15 Posted 21/07/2013 at 20:30:50
I think I agree with James. As good as Jelavic was in his first season he was really atrocious last season and not just in his finishing but his all round game. I find it hard to believe that a top striker would play that badly for such a prolonged period.

Although this is most likely pure rumour and fabrication I would be sorely tempted to accept a bid over £7m if it came in and look to Europe for the next Michu/Benteke/RVP.

Guy Hastings
16 Posted 21/07/2013 at 20:56:00
A crash course in the offside law and he should be okay. This season's offside law, of course, which, as all-knowing experts of every facet of the game, any one of us will be happy to advise him on.
Peter Mills
17 Posted 21/07/2013 at 21:20:43
Hamburg are apparently looking for someone with a good touch on the ball, someone who can bring others into play, and who is good in the air.

Move along, there's nothing to see here.

I would be quite happy to see Jelavic stay. He's a one trick pony, but it's a damned lethal trick when he's confident and played where he can perform it.

Andrew Yates
18 Posted 21/07/2013 at 21:44:47
Would him moving on give some of our young gun strikers a chance of first team action?
Barry Rathbone
19 Posted 21/07/2013 at 21:40:49
James, it might be because he proved himself from day1 showing himself to be real deal notching almost at will.

Even the renowned strikers kryptonite of Finch Farm and Moyes coaching seemed incapable of ruining this goal machine.

I would laugh at myself for joining in with such thoughts if it wasn't so damned sad.

Hope he gets a chance under RM.

Freddy Maldonado
20 Posted 21/07/2013 at 21:40:00
I would rather keep Jelavic. He was absolutely out of gas last season and his legs weren't even moving correctly towards the end of the campaign. He is not a top shelf striker but with proper rest and a new system, he could flourish again.

Interest will always be there for him. Martinez needs another year to scout. I'm not sure if we have someone else in mind who can play in England right away unless you grab him from our Under-21's.

Mark Frere
21 Posted 21/07/2013 at 22:11:35
If there's any truth in this rumour its a really tough call weather to sell Jelevic or not.

The Jelevic that we saw in his first season surpassed any of our expectations, he was a goal machine and looked like the striker we'd all been craving for, for so many years.

The first 10 games of last season he looked decent, but not quite at the level we expected. Then his performances got progressively worse until it got to the point where his performances were embarrassing. Eventually DM was left with no choice, he got replaced with the substandard Big Vic.

I think everyone is a bit confused on who is the real Jelevic, is he a half a season wonder, is he dire the dire player we saw most of last season, or is he actually the top striker we thought he was at first?

I personally, aren't sure he will ever reach the dizzy heights of his first season again, so I think we should cut our losses and sell him

Keith Glazzard
22 Posted 21/07/2013 at 22:19:43
Jelavic came into a team set up for Saha to score (stop laughing at the back). He was given one job and did it superbly. Therefore, we (the Man U coaching team as is) having had a good look, changed all that.

Next season, instead of lurking around the box waiting for a pull-back from eg Baines, he was sent out to both wings to collect and then centre/pull-back for ... himself? Fellaini, of course, was doing powerful stuff further forward, but Jelavic's natural game and talent were squandered as he was ordered to fetch and carry and make the tea.

I hope he gets another chance.

Phil Sammon
23 Posted 21/07/2013 at 22:45:13
Keith

I don't disagree with that...but the lad couldn't even control a football. He was just so incredibly bad it wouldn't have mattered where he played.

Anyway, I think he's worth keeping. There's a player there somewhere obviously. Maybe it's just a confidence thing. Hopefully a few preseason goals will get the ball rolling.

James Elworthy
24 Posted 21/07/2013 at 23:24:03
Jelavic was played out if position he is an out and out striker Moyes will ruin Van Persie next making him track back and go wide.

If he goes how about Cisse but the fact we advertise beer on our shirts may put him off.

Colin Glassar
25 Posted 21/07/2013 at 23:33:00
We should've gotten ridden of that piss poor (pardon the pun) sponsorship deal with Chang years ago James. One of the lowest paying shirt deals in prem history. Typical of our nonexistent commercial dept.
Andonis Paleocrassas
26 Posted 22/07/2013 at 00:25:28
If Martinez is going to play the Barcelona system, as all the reports in the media claim, then that means 1 striker up top with the two supporting wing forwards. That means that with Kone, Anichebe and Vellios, we are covered in the striking department. We need to sell Naismith and Jelavic and reinvest that cash in other areas.
Andrew Cutler
27 Posted 22/07/2013 at 00:37:06
6 million quid??!! Are the hamburgers mad? have they not watched the bumbling, under aroused uncoordinated player masquerading as a footie striker last season? Sell him at once...'ein krappy meal' indeed?
Jason Heng
28 Posted 22/07/2013 at 00:35:20
Moyes has had the wonderful ability to destroy strikers after a first decent season - Beattie, AJ, Saha, Yakubu, Jo.... Don't think Jelavic is beyond redemption.
James Stewart
29 Posted 22/07/2013 at 00:52:18
It wasn't a change of system or Moyes that made him skew the ball wide of an open goal from 2 yards. His technique was simply awful. On many occasion going totally with the wrong foot. Constantly offside and on the rare occasion he wasn't there was no chance of him escaping being caught by the defender even with a head start.

There is more chance of Dixie Dean rising from the dead and knocking in 20 goals than Jelavic getting anywhere near that many.

Harold Matthews
30 Posted 22/07/2013 at 00:12:51
I'm not keen on slow strikers with limited ball control.

Full marks for effort and I wish him well, wherever he ends up.

Next season promises to be very special and it was interesting to hear an ex- professional chatting on the radio about Evertonians being very unrealistic. Apparently he had spoken to fans who were confident of a top 6 finish.

With so many changes going on, how people can think like this is beyond me. Yes, we're all excited but let's not get carried away. Martinez will need time.

Mark Stewart
31 Posted 22/07/2013 at 01:38:31
He's pretty much scored a goal every other match throughout his career up until last season when he was worse than gash and looked all out of sorts for all but the first few weeks. If the jury is out on Kone then surely we'd start the season with him and flog him in Jan if he's still a dud.

It's not like we're a team packed full of goals...

James Wilson
32 Posted 22/07/2013 at 01:48:52
Personally I hope he stays but if we get maybe £8-10 mil (I know it's a longshot) I would think that's a good deal, then bring in a new striker who fits Everton's new style of play.
Jay Harris
33 Posted 22/07/2013 at 04:35:28
Its hard to know what went wrong with Jelavic last season but I don't subscribe to the view Moyes ruined him.

Moyes did not coach him to miss open goals or miscontrol the ball every time.

He showed all the signs of someone with a very troubled personal life.

I would unload him at any price at his wage level and contribution or rather lack of it..

Pat Finegan
34 Posted 22/07/2013 at 05:45:51
I think we have to keep him until January. The player we saw in that first half season he was with us was a £20 million player, not a £7 million one. I'd say keeping him is worth the gamble that he just might come good.
Jamie Armstrong
35 Posted 22/07/2013 at 07:20:16
No way can we afford to let Jelavic go. He is the best finisher we have at the club. I agree last sseason at times he was nothing short of disasterous. But I believe his lack of confidence and in turn lack of touch was hugely down to the job he was asked to do for the team.

Not being the focal point of our attack and the emphasis on Fellaini led to a confidence crisis and in turn the goals dried up. Im not saying it was Moyes or the coaching but we hardly have a glowing reputation for brining the best out of strikers. Beattie, AJ, Yak, Saha (to a degree) all had solid goal scoring records prior to joining us, Yak and Saha did have injury problems but they all have one thing in common they hit the ground running and then faded away. Coincidence ? Im hoping Roberto can get the best out of Jelavic and restore his confidence and bring us that 20 goal a season striker we know we have!

Steve Edwards
36 Posted 22/07/2013 at 09:03:00
Yeh, it was all Moyes fault. Get him sold, snap there hand off, he's shite.
Sam Hoare
37 Posted 22/07/2013 at 09:05:56
I do
Denis Richardson
38 Posted 22/07/2013 at 09:33:41
He proved in his first 5 months with us that he's a class striker. Something happened last season and he looked a completely different player - totally lacked any confidence whatsoever.

If RM can get him firing and his confidence up then we may get the old Jelly back - class is permanent after all...

Still 7m would be temptingif RM has a couple of replacements in mind.

Sam Hoare
39 Posted 22/07/2013 at 09:05:56
I doubt RM will get the best out of Jelavic because I doubt he will be starting him. He spent the majority of our transfer budget on Kone for a reason, he will be the main striker most likely with some combination of Mirallas/Deulofeu/ Pienaar out wide.

Expect to see Jelavic on the bench unless Kone struggles.

If we can get anywhere near 10m then I would shift and look to cover the two holding midfield spots where at present we only have Gibson and fellaini or,god forbid, heitinga.

Jon Withey
40 Posted 22/07/2013 at 09:48:59
He is probably on very high wages, so I guess 7m isn't the whole picture.

It would be worth waiting until Jan to see if he does better with RM and the new system.

You simply don't get international strikers for £7m, so why let him go until we are sure that he needs to move on.

I really doubt he'll go down in value over 6 months and has enough experience to keep his value for someone ho is desperate for a striker in January (everyone outside the top 4 generally).

He lost it once Cahill went I reckon, perhaps with another battler (Kone) he can focus on his finishing game rather than holding up play etc.

Andrew Ellams
41 Posted 22/07/2013 at 10:03:30
I'm not sure how Jelavic would fit into Martinez game plan. With Kone, Miralles and Delofeu, and even Vic to a lesser degree you have forwards who are going to run at opposition defences and put them on the back foot and generally cause mayhem. I can see Baines scoring a few from freekicks and penalties next year on the back of this but I can't see how Jelavic, who's biggest asset is being in the box and sniffing out chances will fit in.
Paul Kennedy
42 Posted 22/07/2013 at 10:22:36
The latest report on Sky is the agent has approached Hamburg.

And I thought Everton were paying his wages.

Mark Frere
43 Posted 22/07/2013 at 10:22:28
Sam Hoare

I would like to think if Jelevic is at the level we saw him at in his first season - he should be our main striker, because iv'e always seen Kone as a second striker, and he's not really a out and out striker. I always remember Kone playing slightly withdrawn from the main striker at Wigan which was usually DI Santo.

I agree with you that we need another holding midfielder. Gibson often struggles with injuries, Fellaini (if still here) Gets his fair share of suspensions and the dire Neville has retired.

I think M. Holden at Bolton would be perfect, if we haven't got much money left after only selling Heitinga - I think Holden is our man. I work with a Bolton fan and he's raved about Holden for many years. Iv'e seen him play a few times and this lads top drawer - all action midfielder he is. Yes, he's been injured for the most part of the last 2 years....but he looked back to his best when playing for the USA recently.

I know many people have suggested Holden on TW recently....so i'm not trying to steel their thunder, I just think he would Holden ticks all the boxes

Steve King
44 Posted 22/07/2013 at 10:01:36
I'd be happy if he stays, but also think the money could be put to good use if we let him go.
Maybe it would allow the likes of Vellios to play a more prominent role? If he doesn't break through this year I can't imagine he'll be around much longer! At 22 he will no longer be a "young player with potential".

There are still affordable quality players out there as well, if you look hard enough. So £7million could go a long way! (Chadli and Mirallas are good examples I think, not to mention Michu).

Colin Glassar
45 Posted 22/07/2013 at 11:10:26
I'm inclined to leave him till January but if Roberto sells him then it will mean he doesn't fit into his system. So I trust in Roberto.
Ben Dyke
46 Posted 22/07/2013 at 11:17:38
Its an interesting one this. His head went last year for whatever reason and with that went all his ability pretty much. Will the yips last for ever or can he shake them? Is it anything to do with the club or personalities at the club? Will he be OK under a fresh start under new management?

You can see why a club would come in for him given his track record and how he proved himself in his early Everton form.

Its all down to what's going on in his head. We would be stupid to sell that initial form Jelavic but bonkers to hold on to last season Jelavic.

My gut feeling is he'll leave. Its his temperament that's dodgy and I don't mean he has a bad attitude to hard work, I just mean he didn't appear to have mental consistency last season and to escape that he's the kind of player that will move on.

Colin Glassar
47 Posted 22/07/2013 at 11:29:59
I remember reading, when he joined us, that his career has been a series of stepping stones going from club to bigger club always trying to improve. If he plays like he did last season he'll end up in league 1.
Steven Telford
48 Posted 22/07/2013 at 11:35:55
Fair sounding price, would be a tough decision, but on balance I'd air on the side of first seeing what he can under a Martinez.
Steve Brown
49 Posted 22/07/2013 at 12:10:30
Let's see how he does without the challenge of running himself ragged down the wing and trying to get on the end of his own crosses.
Andrew Ellams
50 Posted 22/07/2013 at 12:16:37
Interesting that the press in Germany seem to be suggesting that an agent approached Hamburg about Jelavic rather than Hamburg coming in of their own accord. Are Everton touting him around Europe to get rid?
Mark Tanton
51 Posted 22/07/2013 at 12:38:50
Or is Jelavic touting himself around? I thought he was desperately unlucky on ocassion last season (especially Chelsea at home) and I respected the fact he continued to work hard and look for the ball. I do think, perhaps, as someone else mentioned, his confidence and mental strength might be lacking.
Ernie Baywood
52 Posted 22/07/2013 at 12:37:59
I make him 50/50 to be a top performer this year... simply based on having one good season and one shit one.

If we get 6M and reinvest it what are the odds of them being top drawer for us?

I'd give him until January.

David Donnellan
54 Posted 22/07/2013 at 12:37:33
His first season with us, his touch, technique & finishing were top notch, he couldnt do no wrong & like others on here, I thought we had a genuine goal machine on our hands & was looking forward to the following season with him.
However, the beginning of last season started fairly promising for him, but after that, he was unrecognizable as the goal machine we had all seen previously. It reminded me of that film space jam, where the basketball players bodies are taken over & they can't play basketball anymore. He just seemed to lose all the things that made him good. His touch was poor, technique non-existent & he couldnt hit the proverbial barn door with a banjo. He just looked like an imposter half the time. Sad to see, after such a great start. I do think it is a confidence thing though, the more chances he missed, the worse he became.
Personally, I would like to see him given another chance & see what Martinez can do with him, as others have said, wait until January & review it again then.
Robert Collins
56 Posted 22/07/2013 at 12:50:52
We paid nothing for him (or not much by today's prices) and I think Roberto should keep him and see if he finds his form again under the new regime.

When we first bought him, we had a RVP on our hands (until, DM like he did with all our other decent forwards, manage to crock him psychologically),

If he moves away and finds his form for a whole season, he'll be worth 㾻m - 20m at current silly money (Suarez, Cavani etc) prices.

Roberto, take the gamble and keep him!

Paul Kelly
57 Posted 22/07/2013 at 12:34:02
Book him a one way ticket please.

Why is everyone prepared to give him another chance? The same courtesy is definately not being offered to JH ( previous player of the season),who, in a different position is suffering the same sort of fate, though in JH defence he was dropped when playing well, unlike Jelly who had chance after chance, literally, and screwed up.

The change in 'fortune' for Mr Jelavic is one I can't recall happening to any other player (can anyone?). Think his time is up, and 'if' there is 7million reasons to let him go, auf Wiedersehen.

Robert Collins
58 Posted 22/07/2013 at 13:15:14
Paul Kelly @ 629

Good point Paul, but forwards will always get that extra chance (goals win games), if he does find the back of the net again, you'll forgive him just like the rest of us.

Jarrod O'Neill
59 Posted 22/07/2013 at 13:18:44
Never have I thought we might have a RVP on our hands as you say Robert Collins.Jelavic was a great one touch scorer but his overall game is average at best.
Sur Jo
60 Posted 22/07/2013 at 13:24:01
This is what the sporting director of Hamburg is saying (quoted from espn.co.uk)
"Jelavic would be exactly the right player for us. He is a really dangerous striker," he said. "But we have to scrutinise whether it is financially possible."

Jelavic, 27, who scored seven goals last season, could be allowed to leave Goodison Park by new Toffees manager Roberto Martinez, Kreuzer said, adding: "I have heard that Everton's new manager wants to sell him."

However, before making a move for the striker - likely to cost around €7 million - Hamburg would need to offload some fringe players.

"Day in, day out, I talk to all the agents, but nothing has come up yet," Kreuzer said. "If we manage that [to sell two or three players] we could work out if a loan or a payment in instalments would be possible."
Hamburg conceded five goals and failed to score any during a pre-season tournament in Monchenglabach at the weekend, losing to Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund.

Their strikers, Latvia international Artjoms Rudnevs, 25, and summer signing Jacques Zoua, 21, played 60 minutes each, and Hamburg coach Thorsten Fink said: "They both have certain strengths and certain weaknesses."

BASICALLY, HE IS SAYING IF EVERTON CAN LOAN THEM NIKICA JELAVIC!!!

He is not saying that he will be paying €7 million!

Now that's unsettling; isn't it? Trying to get someone on the cheap.

Kunal Desai
61 Posted 22/07/2013 at 13:30:57
No point selling Jelavic if we don't have a replacement lined up. We'd need someone proven who can find the back of the net in the PL. How about going back our old gaffer and letting us have Javier Hernandez
Colin Glassar
62 Posted 22/07/2013 at 13:40:00
Sounds like the hamburgers are planning to repeat our Turkish delight.
Greg Mckerracher
63 Posted 22/07/2013 at 13:42:00
I would have taken that little Korean playmaker Son Heung Min if they hadn't sold him to Leverkusen last month. Their squad is awful though so no swapsies.

Max Murphy
64 Posted 22/07/2013 at 15:31:18
If the rumour is true and we are offered a couple of million for Jelavic, then the club should take it. This player had so many opportunties to prove himself and regain some kind of form last season, that it became embarassing to watch. It also prevented other promising bench players from getting a chance in the first team. The sooner he goes the better
John Daley
65 Posted 22/07/2013 at 15:49:26
Jelavic? (Slow, rueful shake of the head). I haven't seen such a horrific loss of form since Kathleen Turner got her fucking kit off in The Graduate.

If we could recoup anywhere near what we paid for him then I would sell straightaway. It's not just the fact he stopped scoring that suggests he's a busted flush, he was struggling badly to do even the basics by the end of the season.

John Mckay
66 Posted 22/07/2013 at 17:28:43
I think we should keep him for at least one more season see how he gets on. I've always had the impression Moyes ruins strikers, I was a big fan of the Yak before we signed him, fast, powerful and knew where the net was. Not saying Moyes ruined him as his attitude dropped and he got fat and lazy like Beattie.

I'd give Jelavic one last chance to shine see if RM can bring back that early form, we wouldn't be able to bring in anyone decent like him for the price Hamburg are quoting so a keeper in my eyes.

Not sure how Kone will do up front next season be good to have Jelavic there just in case, competition for places might make him up his game.

I remember a lot of Rangers fans saying that he is a journey man who hops from one club to another.... I believe Jelavic is the type of player who needs the boss to put an arm around him now and again and I think Roberto's man management of him will be a lot better than Moyes.

Hoping for a good season this year either way, good luck Roberto hope you do well.

Mark Frere
67 Posted 22/07/2013 at 17:46:32
So it doesn't look like RM fancies Jelevic that much. I'm not over the moon on the idea of accepting a small upfront fee, with installments to follow. I want Martinez to have ready made cash to spend on replacement players
Patrick Murphy
68 Posted 22/07/2013 at 17:51:59
Sounds like the German equivalent of our methodology. If we sell Jelavic - which I hope we don't - we need cash on the nail and it has to be given direct to RM to find a replacement. Mind you we probably haven't paid Rangers for him yet.
Tony Waring
69 Posted 22/07/2013 at 17:52:20
We should keep him at least until January and if he has'nt rediscovered his goal scoring ability by then maybe, just maybe we should think of selling him. He certainly deserves another chance when you think of some of the no-marks we've had in the past who have had far more playing time.
Phil Walling
70 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:00:29
Well,given that we no doubt still owe Rangers a few payments on the guy,we could just get Hamburg them to pay them on our behalf.
At least we`ll be saving further wages on a guy who has turned out to be a flop like all the Moyes strikers.
Tom Dodds
71 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:05:48
Loan??... Fuck that!

Seeing how he plays under Martinez is a no-brainer. Plus the fact his sheer fitness as a striker whether he scores or not, is worth £6+mill min.

Phil Walling
72 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:05:11
Meant to say,Mark @ 680,I don`t think the mere change of manager will suddenly result in Everton paying up front for players rather than `on the drip`.
With nearly £5M in interest to cover each year ,`managing cashflow `is the name of the game!
Andrew Bone
73 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:00:29
Not sure payment for installments is an option here. Sell a striker and buy one in for a replacement. We will be in difficulty and always in second place to an upfront purchase if we go down this route.
Mark Frere
74 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:09:59
This payment deal for Jelevic sounds a bit like the one we offered FC Twente for Leroy Fer. If we decline this offer, I wonder if Hamberg will claim Jelevic has got a dodgy knee?
John Reece
75 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:04:26
Like someone else said, against Chelsea at home he was one of our best players and should have got and was unlucky not to get two goals; he seemed like the Jelavic that burst on the scene in his first season. That player who had a burst of pace, great strength and great finishing....

With our new formation and more attacking play, I would hope we give him another chance. I think Martinez's positive psychology will have a positive affect on him.

Jim Knightley
76 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:39:22
This is a difficult one... Jelavic is pretty much definitely going to be on the bench next season (behind Kone), so 1) will he be happy with that, in a world cup year? 2) Is he a good bench striker?

I don't think last season was representative of his abilities...just as the Feb to May period of the season before wasn't. He is a confidence striker, and I expect will have about a 1 in 3 scoring rate for us, if played regularly. However, I'm not sure that confidence strikers are great from the bench. He is also 28 next month.

Personally, id take 6million in a moment (a newspaper estimation..not an all reliable). I think we could better use the money to invest in another winger, and kept Mirallas as a back up striker and/or a centre mid (I'm assuming Heitinga money will help with the cm too). I'd also prefer going for a younger striker, who would probaly be more inclined to take a back up role. Whatever happens though, we shouldn't loan him. Either keep, or sell so we can re-invest.

Jim Knightley
77 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:39:22
This is a difficult one... Jelavic is pretty much definitely going to be on the bench next season (behind Kone), so 1) will he be happy with that, in a world cup year? 2) Is he a good bench striker?

I don't think last season was representative of his abilities...just as the Feb to May period of the season before wasn't. He is a confidence striker, and I expect will have about a 1 in 3 scoring rate for us, if played regularly. However, I'm not sure that confidence strikers are great from the bench. He is also 28 next month.

Personally, id take 6million in a moment (a newspaper estimation..not an all reliable). I think we could better use the money to invest in another winger, and kept Mirallas as a back up striker and/or a centre mid (I'm assuming Heitinga money will help with the cm too). I'd also prefer going for a younger striker, who would probaly be more inclined to take a back up role. Whatever happens though, we shouldn't loan him. Either keep, or sell so we can re-invest.

Ross Edwards
78 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:43:48
Mein God, ze Jairmans heff gone mad!!! £6 million for Jelavic, maybe ze Bratworsts are off...
Kristian Boyce
79 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:43:47
If his agent is shopping him around, then that's probably an indication from the club that they and the player himself are planning his departure. If we can get the 6-7 Million quoted then I would take it. Wouldn't mind replacing him with Bafétimbi Gomis, who's supposedly going cheap.
Peter Cummings
80 Posted 22/07/2013 at 18:57:10
Jeli should stay, he had a poor last season but, if he is given another go, I think he'll come good again. I definitely prefer him to Kone who has yet to prove himself a 100% 90-minute performer, the squad would be even smaller, even the £6M quoted won't buy a quality replacement.
John Mckay
81 Posted 22/07/2013 at 19:31:04
How old is Darren Bent? I heard he was going for around £5m? He might be an ideal replacement; he has lacked form recently but on his day he is as good as anyone else in the PL.

Out of favour at Aston Villa

Paul Gladwell
82 Posted 22/07/2013 at 19:35:50
Ye blame Moyes people say, well he certainly never helped him with this get out wide and chase bollocks.
AJ was turned into a virtual winger and allegedly complained about this, Anichebe another one and he even somehow managed to get the Yak whipping crosses over in his final season, you don't go from looking like a £20m striker to a pile of shite for nothing, yes he must shoulder blame, but that fella had a lot to do with it too, when do you see RVP chase endless balls to the corner flag?
Sean Patton
83 Posted 22/07/2013 at 19:49:51
All those who want him to go should wait and see who Martinez gets as a replacement it could well be Di Santo at this rate.
Jim Knightley
84 Posted 22/07/2013 at 19:52:15
Paul...Suarez chased down many balls out wide last season, and he did alright.

People go through form periods... Look at Cisse. 13 goals in 14 matches for Newcastle in the half season after signing...and then 8 in 36. But Jelavic's opening few months was never going to be reflective of his ability.

Paul Gladwell
85 Posted 22/07/2013 at 19:55:35
Jim, he did and so did Tevez and Bellamy, different players, but your Bob latchfords your Teddy Sheringhams your Gary Linekers never, they stayed at what they were best at and that was in and around the penalty box, that was Jelavics strength in his first season, one touch goal and all of a sudden, he was getting stuck out wide whipping balls over to thin air, his confidence drained and his first touch became four.
Tony Christian
86 Posted 22/07/2013 at 19:56:30
Rumour had it that Moyes wanted to cash in on him last summer. It appears that the Jelavic is your typical European journeyman who has a two year shelf life at any club. Sell him now as we won't be getting any better offers soon.
Mike Hughes
87 Posted 22/07/2013 at 19:54:46
No - don't sell Jelavic.
I'd like to see him get on board with RM's new system (whatever that may be).
A more positive approach should play into a prolific striker's hands.
Competition with Kone may also bring out the best in him.

Having said that I can't believe the turnaround with this guy.
Talk about hero to zero.
I'm hopeful his class will shine through because he seemed to really enjoy himself in those first 6 months.

Brin Williams
88 Posted 22/07/2013 at 20:18:54
Unless we can sell him for a straight £7M cash we should hang on to him.

No loans , no drips no long drawn out deals.

`Cash or FO.

Colin Glassar
89 Posted 22/07/2013 at 20:21:28
I'd give him another chance but if £7m in cash was offered.........that's decent money tbh.
Tony Marsh
90 Posted 22/07/2013 at 20:33:04
We can't afford to lose Jelly under any circumstances. I don't think it was a case of a one season wonder with Jelavic; more like Moyes working the talent out of him in his second season. You don't lose what Nikita showed us overnight and he will come good again under Roberto the King of attacking football.

It's not as if Hamburg are slapping a huge wad on the table that we can't refuse. No, they want to loan him from us with a view to buy in installments if he does the business. That's not the type of deal we can afford to get involved in.

Keep Jelavic here and partner Kone in a dangerous looking attack... unless you think Kone & Anichebe are the answer.

Gavin Ramejkis
91 Posted 22/07/2013 at 21:14:49
Jelavic didn't turn into a bad player overnight, his ammunition supply dried up and Gollum turned him not a chaser of lost causes and shadows. I can't believe anyone would rather have Anichebe over him.
Paul Kennedy
92 Posted 22/07/2013 at 21:24:02
I agree if we can get decent money let go and now it looks like Gollum has lost out on Fabregas he may pay a pretty penny for Fellani and get us a season-long midfield performer.
John Connor
93 Posted 22/07/2013 at 21:36:36
I support any player who is happy to wear the blue shirt, but the cold fact is, if Jelavic scored some of the goals he was expected to last season, we would be in Europe.
Chris Leyland
94 Posted 22/07/2013 at 21:28:46
Gav - would that be the same ammunition supply that created 480 chances in the league making us the 4th highest creators of chances? Incidentally, 102 more chances that the year before when Jelavic scored all his goals.

Oh and by the way, Jelavic's shooting accuracy declined from 47.2% on target to 37.6% season on season too. He also scored once every 4 shots in 2011/12 compared to once in 12.1 shots in the season just gone.

One more thing, guess which year he had more touches in the box on average per game? Yep-, 2012/13 he touched the ball more times in the box than outside compared to 2011/12 when far more of his touches were outside the box than in. Strange that when you think Moyes supposedly had him playing out wide in his second season?

Still, clearly all "Gollum's" fault hey and nothing to do with Jelavic himself?

Chris Leyland
95 Posted 22/07/2013 at 21:45:11
Oh and one more thing the lazy get was also caught offside the second most times in the Premier League last season. Only Benteke was offside more but at least he was actually scoring some goals in between time
Gavin Ramejkis
96 Posted 22/07/2013 at 22:04:03
Chris, if you are solely reliant on stats more than actually watching the guy coming back to the hallway line to get the ball or chasing the ball to the corner flag week in week out and the odd occasion in the box with the ball played to his side or behind him then I suppose you would have a reason to blow the old tired shite trumpet of Gollum never ruined a single striker. I will openly admit to some of his misses towards the end of the season on a par with the worst I have seen in a blue shirt but a striker with his head down as far as it can get isn't the same as the one we all saw in his first season.
Viv Sharma
97 Posted 22/07/2013 at 21:42:57
Stats can be misleading. Most of Jellys touches in his first stint were facing goal where he could shoot but since Felli was moved up he found himself more and more receiving the ball and needing to create himself space as far as I can tell.
As far as I'm concerned he's still a great forward (you don't unlearn that talent!) but he needs to be more cleverly deployed. I am personally excited by the arrival of Kone but I don't think he's going to be able to do it all alone all season and if we sell Jelly, and/or if Kone is a flop, then where would that leave us!?
Dont sell him! He was fantastic. Give RM a chance to work with him and then unload him if he's still not fitting into El Plan.
Chris Leyland
98 Posted 22/07/2013 at 22:14:11
Gav - I'm not solely relying on stats as we all saw him play last year but the fact remains that the man had more shots per game, was caught off side more, had less shots on target and was upfront in a side which created more chances overall than the year before. Because of this, to blame Jelavic's decline solely on Moyes does seem to be a bit blinkered as it doesn't take account of the fact that Jelavic himself seemed to be disinterested and has apparently lost the ability to shoot on target.

As for Moyes ruining strikers well he certainly hasn't improved any of them to be extent be has with other positions, but I actually don't think we've had a goal scorer since Sharp and Lineker in the mid 80's. Cottee flattered to deceive and most of the others pre Moyes and during his time have not been good enough. Yakubu for me was the only real one who had the potential to be a consistent goal scorer but his record at previous clubs followed a similar path to what happened at Everton. Beattie was never the answer and Johnson didn't score consistently in the top flight before we signed him or indeed after he left.

Si Cooper
99 Posted 22/07/2013 at 22:42:59
Surely this discussion is academic if RM is keen to off-load the player? That would mean he doesn't rate him or think he can utilize him effectively (horses for courses).

I think it is stretching a point to make out Jelavic was cocking-up a shed-load of sitters last season, and his touch simply got worse throughout the season as his obvious anxiety grew. He missed a few simple chances when he first arrived but then seemed to have at least a couple more chances in each game to make amends. He may have had more touches in the box than the previous season, but how many of them were the run-onto and slot home opportunites that he actually thrives on.

Not a complete player, but I side with those who think he could be potent again. It depends on whether he would really fit into the style of play that the manager is planning, so I guess we will have to rely on Martinez making the right call on this one.

Chris Cumisky
100 Posted 22/07/2013 at 23:37:50
Gavin you wool, do you wear a replica shirt for home homes? yes you do.
he stunk the place out last season and vic was better,
Barry Lambert
101 Posted 22/07/2013 at 23:22:39
It's admirable that so many fans want to give Jela the benefit of the doubt and give him another chance. I personally think he had a fairytale baptism when everything he touched went in. I think the Jela we saw last season was closer to what we can expect to see in the future.

Talk of playing out of positon is just one of numerous lame excuses. He had enough clear cut chances to convert the mind-numbing number of draws into wins and given us a very very good chance of competing in the Champions League.

I have never seen such a technically inept player get so much sympathy and encouragement from the fans, his team mates and management. He did a decent job in the Mickey Mouse Premier north of the border. He even stated that Naismith was the best strike partner he's ever played with.

I think one of his main problems is that he's not as good as he thinks he is. He's had enough wet nursing for me and it's time he stopped feeling sorry for himself, stopped crying, put his boots on the right feet, showed some backbone and proved his doubters wrong!

How he has the audacity to request a "clear the air " discussion (if this is true) with RM when all he has to do is replay the recordings of his numerous embarrassing performances... If he"s not prepared to toe the line like all his team mates and EARN just a fraction of the ridiculous amount of money average players like him are picking up, then show him the door!

Mike Corcoran
102 Posted 22/07/2013 at 23:46:29
Give him a decent pass to passin facing goal and hey presto........I blame Naismith....maybe Jela was pleased to get away from him and then he turns up stinking the place out
Jackie Barry
103 Posted 23/07/2013 at 01:10:53
Vic was better? I wouldn't go as far as that, yes he was bad but crikey he did end up out wide a lot. I was often left wondering what was going on, I mean either he was being told to do it or he just didn't listen. Back to Vic, well as much as I have always wanted him to come good the fact is he never will, the titanic could turn faster than Vic can.
Jackie Barry
104 Posted 23/07/2013 at 01:14:33
Well, Chris there is something wrong with strikers and Moyes because all of them have pretty much stunk and quite often they are left running around like headless chickens. I gave Moyes a lot of praise over the years and have a certain unnerving feeling about the season ahead; however, when it came to strikers, it was not one of Moyes's strong points. Blimey, I don't really want to talk about the ginger one again.
Steven Telford
105 Posted 23/07/2013 at 01:48:38
Come on, considering the start he got off too, the club/Martinez should gave him another chance to prove himself. We have all seen he has got it in him to be a great striker.

Give him another chance!

Steven Telford
106 Posted 23/07/2013 at 01:52:15
At his worst, he is at least as good a Vic
Jackie Barry
107 Posted 23/07/2013 at 02:48:03
They can go take a running jump if they think they are loaning him, or paying by installments.
Jason Lam
108 Posted 23/07/2013 at 07:07:46
We will be playing 3 up with Kone, Kevin and that Barca lad. No place for Jelly.
Steven Telford
109 Posted 23/07/2013 at 10:55:22
Jason,
Injuries and squad rotation.
Kieran Fitzgerald
110 Posted 23/07/2013 at 11:02:49
Jelavic took most of his chances in his first season from inside the box. Last season he didn't get the chance to sit in the box as much. Maybe that is his whole game. A little one dimensional but hey, leave him there and supply him with the chances. Why expect of him what he can't do?
Matt Traynor
111 Posted 23/07/2013 at 13:06:46
Colin #492, you really believe that bid for Saha was true?
Can I ask, do you still believe in Santa Claus?

Joking aside, I hope we keep Jelavic. Whilst he's not the quickest, his first touch was great, as evidenced by his ridiculous 26 or 27 run of first touch finishes (obviously including for Rangers).

We haven't had a natural finisher in the team since (and I will put on my tin hat for this) Tony Cottee.

There. Said it. I rated him. Obviously Howard didn't.

James Marshall
113 Posted 23/07/2013 at 13:58:44
We should keep Jelavic. We were desperately short of strikers last season, so to buy one and sell one would seem pointless to me because we'd just be back in the same situation were were before.

Keep him, use him and Kone in rotation and Anichebe (if we must) as long as he carries on not falling over and beating the ground every time anyone goes near him.

3 strikers minimum is required next year, not 2 with one unlikely to score more than about 7 or 8 (Anichebe) and another an unknown quantity (Kone). Plus Hamburg are only offering part-payments or a loan anyway and we need cash.

This all sounds crazy to me.

Ryan Sloan
114 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:48:26
No way would we take that deal. Who would have the cheek?

Wait a minute...

Harold Matthews
115 Posted 24/07/2013 at 02:18:24
We need to sell a few players but, like Arsenal and City, we'll find it hard to get rid of those on high wages.

With only 5 weeks of the window left we're in a right old mess. God knows what's going to happen with Fellaini and Baines. We need strong, trustworthy midfield cover and the present strike force is not much above Championship standard.

Let's hope Martinez can work a bit of Spanish magic.

Brian Wilkinson
116 Posted 25/07/2013 at 05:00:04
John704, spot on about Darren Bent, he was my choice ahead of Kone, if we can get 6 million for Jelavic what a forward line that could be Kone and bent aka sharp and Gray, baines and Coleman Gary Stevens and psycho pat, Morrelles and pienar sheedy and Steven fellaini the Peter Reid and Gibson the bracewell, ok different era but similar stles, as Martin Luther King once said, I have a dream. Yip fairy style post but you just never know could be a big season this one.
Brian Wilkinson
117 Posted 25/07/2013 at 05:18:58
Sure I just spotted Jones saying to Martinez, its the plane boss it's the plane.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb