No joy for Everton against belligerent Baggies

, 24 August, 259comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 0 - 0 West Bromwich Albion

Roberto Martinez is still waiting for his first victory as Everton manager following a frustrating goalless draw in his first home game in charge.

Employing his patient possession-based approach, the Blues dominated a resolute West Brom side but lacked urgency, particularly in the second half, and failed to create enough chances until Fellaini was denied agonisingly by the post late on and Coleman's cross came off the crossbar in stoppage time.

Match Summary

For Roberto Martinez's first competitive home match in charge of Everton, he selected an unchanged side to start against West Bromwich Albion at Goodison Park.

The patient passing game soon gave way to scrappy stuff and head tennis once West Brom got possession. The Baggies were squaling for a penalty early on when Long appeared to trip over with Distin in attendance. Some good play down the right side ended withh a nice diving header from Pienaar, who the fired in a good low shot as Everton turned on their attacking intent.

After another spell of fruitless passing across the back (PATB), Fellaini launched a long ball for Jelavic but he had made his move a fraction early, his third time offside in the early exchanges. The Baggies were doing an effective job of closing Everton down and limiting opportunities for forward play that was beginning to frustrate the Everton crowd. But Barkley got them cheering with a dribble and shot-cross that bobbled wide.

Mirallas was all at sea, with a few strange balls showing a lack of understanding or poor execution. Coleman was having to work hard against Dorens to make space for his crosses as the gameplan seemed thwarted by West Brom's solidity.

Mulumbu gave away a stupid handball, earning a clear yellow card and a good free-kick that Mirallas executed poorly, putting it lamely into the wall and Baines fired the rebound wide. Barkley looked to have space for a drive but spooned it well over. But some great football set up Mirallas for a zinger that stung Foster's glove as he tipped it over.

A steal by Fellaini off Molumbu after excellent harrying by Barkley came so close to setting up the first goal but the WBA defence gave him no room to make a decent shot. Pienaar was getting more room and played in Coleman for a shot that Foster stopped well, but it was all really hard work against a very disciplined Baggies defence determined to stiffle Everton's strucured advances.

Olson was bear-hugging Fellaini with impugnity on every corner, one headed in by Osman causing barelyba half-chance that summed up a difficult half for The Blues.

The physical battle continued after the break, morrison getting a fortunate decision in a tussle with Coleman and the delivery almost crept in, Jelavic hacking it away. Everton got a better move down the left but the cross was just ahead of Jelavic, and Baines's corner was poor.

More good pressure led to some feirce shots and more corners, ending in a vicious Osman volley that careened off. Defenders head... No corner!! Unbelievable. Jelavic was then deliberatly blocked by Olson. No yellow card.

Some shocking reverse play by Jelavic let Mulumbu go on an unhindered run that almost saw WBA score. Everton were getting a little stretched at the back as they tried to apply pressure but it was West Brom who put together a neat move with Jacob forcing Howard to make a save. Surely Kone would provide something fresh but Martinez refused to make any chnges well past the hour mark.

subs , 72'

With 15 mins left, Foster developed some problem and Luke Daniels had to replace him, but creating real chaces was still very much ar a premium, with far too few Everton players getting into the WBA penalty area.

Everton were trying their best, and it looked like it would be good enough when Jagielka chipped a perfect ball for Fellaini to chest down at the far post, and sidefoot his shot past Foster... Only for it to smack the far post!

It was heart-in-mouth stuff as the end approached, WBA breaking in again. More corners at the other end, with Fellani getting close to a tipping point, such was his justified frustration over the unpunished illegal attention of the West Brom animals.

A fantastic cross by Coleman almost caught out Daniels, it hitting the bar. A Jagielka mistake almost spoiled the plot as an extremely determined West Brom side denied Roberto Martinez his first Everton victory in an extremely frustrating game that perhaps typifies how difficult it can be to win in the Premier League.

Everton: Howard, Baines, Jagielka (c), Distin, Coleman, Osman, Fellaini, Pienaar, Barkley Y:85', Mirallas, Jelavic.
Subs: Joel, Heitinga, Kone, Deulofeu, Naismith, Stones, Anichebe. West Brom: Foster, Olsson (c), Yacob, Ridgewell, Morisson, Rosenberg (67' Vydra) , Long, Dorrans, Mulumbu, McAuley, Jones.
Subs: Popov, Sinclair, Brunt, Lugano, Daniels, Berahino.
Kick off: 3pm
Referee: Roger East

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (259)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Derek Knox
2 Posted 24/08/2013 at 14:38:02
Just seen the team sheet via several sources, and all are the same, so I am curious, for the second week running, as to why Bryan Oviedo, has been omitted yet again. He had, in my opinion, an excellent pre-season, provides cover for more than position, and is popular among the fans.

I am also wondering why Ossie, who has generally been found wanting recently, and is definitely not the player he was, gets a starting spot.

Anyway, I am certain Roberto knows what he's doing, and I hope this game not only provides a positive result (a good win) but cements his Goodison baptism, and provides a template for the future.

Brian Roberts
3 Posted 24/08/2013 at 15:46:06
And the Osman love affair goes on and on and on and on...WTF is this guy undroppable.
Jay Harris
4 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:02:33
Difficult first half.

Looks like a game where we will have to grind out a result.

James Kirrane
5 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:37:23
Is RM the new DM? Naismith for Mirallas on about 70 mins? Even though Mirallas was shite today, he is always a threat!
Gary Carter
6 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:40:51
Got to be beating teams like WBA at home!!!
James Kirrane
7 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:38:44
Same old same old. Is Tim Howard related to Nicolas Anelka??
Charles Brewer
10 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:57:42
Pretty disappointing. That's two matches totally dominated and no decent return. It would seem that the service was there but all too often there was no-one to make the most of crosses, odd bounces, stuff off the post or crossbar.

If the chance to goal ration doesn't improve this could be a very grim season, especially once we start to play teams which are not expected to be in the relegation battle at the end of the season.

Kristian Boyce
11 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:57:50
Waiting for the excuse that Baines & Felliani have been unsettled, that's why we were so poor.

Infact we were really poor, no creativity, and completely toothless upfront. Lucky that WBA were worse.

James Byrne
12 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:57:42
Poor game and an even worst result against an average WBA!

Quick thoughts, Mirallas was not on form and I think we need to see Kone (and / or) big Victor start the next game.

Frustrating.................

Jay Harris
13 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:00:42
Even slower build-up than under Judas. Too few players in the box and no commitment.
Phil Walling
14 Posted 24/08/2013 at 16:58:36
So PATB replaces KITAHTNO — I think I preferred the former... it was occasionally exciting!

Our transformation into Wigan took a massive step forward this afternoon. Imagine our two 'stars' can't wait to move...

Think I'll drop in on Doddy at the Freshy on me way home. He'll put a brave spin onit!

Phil Rodgers
16 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:06:03
Optimism-draining result and performance.
Nick Entwistle
17 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:05:28
Pass pass pass pass pass... then into the final third and WBA have everyone marked up.

That's the difference with a high tempo passing game. But the close control of some of the players was extremely good, the cut backs and passes chosen were great to see.

But with the players hardly creative round the box last season, the same ones aren't going to do much better when they take so long to make an approach.

I love how Chelsea play in the final third, we're well below that.

Anyway... all eyes on Benteke tonight!

Mark Frere
18 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:05:50
Absolute garbage of the highest order! No penetration what-so-ever. Jelavic needs to be dropped until he learns the offside rule, not enough bodies in the box, never looked like scoring from set pieces.

Fellaini and Barkley did okay, I would of liked to of seen Deulofeu instead of Naismith.

Massive improvements drasticly needed!

Jim Knightley
19 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:09:06
If we are that reticent all season, it's going to be a long year.

Mirallas couldnt get in the game, attacking changes needed to be made earlier, Fellaini should have been pushed up a bit in the second half and too much was going down the left, when the right hand side looked more open.

We need a dm, and we need a passing midfielder. We also need to be more attacking. The corner tactics were a joke from us (i.e 4/5 in the box), esp when we have the best set piece guy in the division imo, and great height in Jags, Fellaini and Distin. It does not make sense to ignore our strengths.

Phil Sammon
20 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:11:20
Phil Walling

You're talking bollocks again.

Clarence Yurcan
21 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:11:41
Pathetic. Might as well sell Fellaini and Baines and rebuild. Different manager, same results. Never gonna win anything with this crop. Might as well play youngsters, get new players in. Everton'll finish 12th with our without Fellaini and Baines.
Susong Hermawan
22 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:14:43
Dear oh dear.... Martinez oh Martinez... Love your smile 'Senor'!
Patrick Murphy
23 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:07:00
Well what can you say about that? I can't remember the first home game of the season being so lacking in intent.

First half was like an end of season meaningless game and although the second half saw an improvement it was still well below standard. Forget Moyes, he doesn't live here anymore, but his legacy does in the shape of Osman, Jelavic and Naismith. None of those three should be anywhere near the first team and with them in it we'll continue to struggle against ordinary hard-working teams.

We lack a leader on the pitch and have done for a long while, whether MF and LB are still here or not, BK had better find some money from somewhere, cos we are so lacking in pace and guile it's becoming embarrassing.

I said we wouldn't make Europe this season and I haven't witnessed anything to change my mind on that. RM has to ship a few players out of the squad and bring in player(s) who will give us something different, otherwise, we might have a long and difficult season ahead.

Pass me the Brandy — I'm off to a darkened room for a few hours.

Mike Hughes
24 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:09:03
Well, a good start was needed and 2 points after 2 winnable games wasn't it.

Drop the RM march, the media spin / sound bites and the redesign of club badge.

Back to basics.

Perfectly prepared to give RM a chance but scabby 1-0 wins please - at least until everything has settled down.

And for those about to quote possession stats and corners won - save it because it counts for jack shit.

James Kirrane
25 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:13:51
Agree Mark, the performance was pedestrian. No clear cut chances created. One man up top and very little support. I thought RM had style. Blue suit and brown shoes??
Paul Mackie
28 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:17:09
Same shit, different manager. I'm sure someone will be along in a minute to say how we dominated the game and were just unlucky.
Phil Davies
29 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:12:07
neither Jelavic or Kone fit into Martinez's formation both come short looking for the ball and then aren't up front where they need to be, Anichebe seems to be best suited so the ball can be played to his feet with his back to goal and he can lay it off to someone else.

The reason Osman isn't being dropped is because we only have 4 central midfielders, 1 is injured and we play with 3, I'm not Osman's biggest fan but even I can see we don't have much choice right now, plus he's playing in a deeper role spreading the ball around the pitch something he's never really done in his career before.

Tahir Abdullah
30 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:19:50
Clarence 188; agree 100%. What use is hanging on to your so-called best players and having them play to a gameplan based on statistical averages? RM should revert to playing to our key players strengths!
Michael Kenrick
31 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:16:46
WBA made that really difficult for Roberto, successfully stifling all our talent. I can't help thinking there was more he might have done once the pattern of the game became obvious, after about 15 mins.

I know that's too early for almost any manager to switch to Plan B.... but sadly there was no Plan B: Late and ineffective like-for-like substitutions; No attempt to change tactics or alter the approach during the game.

Definitely NOT what I wanted to be saying after the first home game against a bottom-half side.

Steve Brown
32 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:23:27
We are short of central midfielders and need to buy another, not sell one. Perhaps we can move Pienaar inside to replace Osman and bring Deulofeu into the team.
Bill Gall
33 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:10:28
Did not see the game but the lineup tells the story .
No doubt that if Gibson was fit it would have been the same team as last year.
Why is it only the supporters can see, a quality midfielder is needed or is the manager aware of this and this early in the season has realised that the funds he was told was available, is only enough to buy someone that is no better than we have.

Tony J Williams
34 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:21:32
Bag of shite that, bored to tears. They started time wasting from ten minutes in and we couldn't do anything about it
Jamie Barlow
35 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:24:13
I thought Kone did okay when he came on.

Positives - Roberto's first clean sheet and Kone looks better than the lazy Jelavic.

Negatives - Baines and I can't be arsed listing the rest. Too many.

Stuart Eaton
36 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:25:39
Same old crap, sell Felliani NOW!!! for as much as we can and buy a creative midfielder plus a goal scorer with the money before we find ourselves hovering around the bottom and cant get out. very very frustrating watching the same style of play even with a new manager.
Sam Hoare
37 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:28:13
Very similar to last season. Lots of posession but very few clear cut chances created. We rely on the likes of Mirallas and Pienaar to make things happen in the final third and they were both off key today.
Richard Reeves
39 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:01:05
After today's game, I have come to the conclusion that Kone IS a good signing, probably Roberto's most important in his first season.

I thought the build-up play was very much left to right and back again. Frustrating really,but this is the beginning of a building process .I love it that Martinez is getting the team to hold onto the ball and keep in control but I hope and do actually think that the willingness to attack will become a lot quicker.

At the moment, we are too slow in our build-up. I'm sure Roberto will address this but the first task he is trying to do is the most important to him which is keeping hold of the ball and being able to make accurate passes — and I agree.

I think it is the main building block which he is trying to build everything around, the next steps (being more penetrative in the final third will hopefully fall into place with time and more understanding of each other... that's the way I see it anyway.

Phil Walling
40 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:27:05
Phil Sammon-did you go to the match? If so,and you thought that we wern't crap,I wonder how you see a game.
Tommy Coleman
41 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:30:06
I don't think a change of tactics was the problem today. The players kept making poor decisions at crucial times. The passing was off and the players didn't gel as well as they could. Really frustrating.
Phil Walling
42 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:27:05
Phil Sammon — did you go to the match?

If so, and you thought that we weren't crap, I wonder how you see a game.
Tom Bowers
43 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:34:50
Typical isn't it. Albion brought the Blues down to earth early last season.
RM is learning the hard way about some of the failings with this squad.
He had better get his act together soon as draws are no good especially against average teams like Norwich and Albion which I suppose underlines the fact that Everton are still an average outfit having now dropped 4 points.
Simon Harris
44 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:31:11
Poor game with no urgency. He can't blame jet lag for that display - a few of them need a rocket up their arse and quick, cos if that half arsed slow tempo play persists it's gonna be a long season.

We need a holding midfielder with some bite cos Felli didn't cut it today and Jags was all at sea.

At least we managed to keep a clean sheet and Kone looked lively.

MotM — Baines (if his head's been turned, it definitely didn't show...)

Kunal Desai
45 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:37:30
I think this game was crying out for someone just to hold the ball up. Could have done with big Vic coming on.
James Morgan
46 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:33:52
No excuses, that was poor. But if we so much has had the money even of a Swansea or Southampton maybe we would have a 20 goal season striker and a top midfielder.
The buck stops with the manager on the performance but if the clowns at the top invested some coin for him to spend, maybe we wouldn't be struggling against dross.
Responses without mentioning you know who.
Graham Lloyd
47 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:41:38
I thought we played ok quite well balanced Fellaini had a quiet game as did baines so something is obviously brewing there.. thought mirralles Coleman and piennar played well but west brom where solid we always looked the more likely hitting the post and bar if that had been last year we would be ok with it I thought he could have bought victor on with kone but he didnt that may be something for him to think about in future
Ian Bennett
48 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:48:57
Just in. You've got to say if Fellaini and Baines are sold, we would certainly need to spend it on the midfield.
Zaid Omar
49 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:41:29
We will never ever move forward as a team if we continue to start games with Jelavic and Osman in the team. Jelavic was awful in the first half, running around like a headless chicken with no clue. Kone looked much more competent and direct when he came on.

As for the crab-like Rodwell passing in midfield; the less said the better!! It's gonna be a long long season...

Max Murphy
50 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:44:50
We should not be too disheartened. Let's look at the positives:
• We're keeping up our impressive 'games drawn' sequence from last season
• Jelavic's goal-scoring drought continues
• We had a tough start - Norwich away and West Brom at home
• We're only 4 points behind the leaders after 2 games
• There are only 36 more games of this crap to witness
Clive Lewis
51 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:52:38
Graham, Mirallas played well... did you watch the game?
Mike Powell
52 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:44:55
Piss poor.

I said after the Norwich game we will struggle this season; after that, I think we will be in a relegation battle. Pass, pass, pass, lose the ball, pass, pass, have a fucking shot.

I'm waiting for all the these people to tell me we had loads off the ball — we did fuck all with it. Anyone who is happy with that is deluded.
Mike Oates
53 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:55:05
Too many players just off the boil, Mirallas, Baines, Barkley - our creative players were completely stifled by WBA's midfield lads. Whereas last week Norwich as the home team had to come at us which gave Barkley time and space, but today it wasn't there and he struggled to make any impact
Thought Fellaini was head and shoulders above the rest of them, all best moves stemmed from him and unfortunately we miss his presence up top - where Jelavic cut a lonely figure.

Just couldn't understand why only 3-4 players in box for free kicks and corners, at one point Distin didn't go up for 2 corners ?? . Also when we did get any width again only Jelavic in box , were the hell was Mirallas and Barkley.

Will take some time to get used to this slower tempo, because the players don't look comfortable with it, neither mind us.

Paul Ferry
54 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:55:13
Does Osman do something good week-in-and-week-out that I simply fail to see?
Barry Rathbone
55 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:31:22
Admittedly only saw a few segments of the early second half but looked like we had them pinned back!

As with Norwich patently we were the better side but disturbingly Felli has developed an "after you claude" trick standing like a lampost letting players run through just outside our box.

Reckon getting injured and blowing his move to Moyes FC is featuring.

Early days and RM will still be figuring who can play proper football (or wants to) and who can't.

You can see the ideas are progressive though I suspect Baines and Felli have had their heads turned but Pienaar and Osman won't cope cos their legs have gone.

Painful as it is major surgery is required meaning the sales of you know who to you know where.

Eggs breaking and omelettes etc

Jon Withey
56 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:54:33
Apart from our lack of cutting edge, not sure what the whingeing is about. Some wayward passing at times and Mirallas/Jelavic was dreadful IMO.

Not sure why Naismith came on, thought it was time to bring on Ani and Kone.

We are going to miss Fellaini, he is still our biggest threat.

On a positive note, Barkley was great and protected the ball better.

Ian Bennett
57 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:06:10
I thought Pienaar and Mirallas were fairly poor. A lot of stray passes on the left hand side.
Darren Hind
58 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:50:58
A harsh first lesson for RM. This is not Wigan and nobody comes to The Old lady for a game of you play /we play. The last manager was often slaughtered for his teams inabiliy to break down stubborn resistance. RM will get (rightly so) a honeymoon period, but negativity on this scale wont be tolerated for long. THREE people in their box for our corners ? FFS Robbie lad sort it. TGT looked like Ossie Ardiles in comparison. You promised entertainment, don't letus down, Right now we could really do with hero
Oliver Molloy
59 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:59:00
Two games, two draws, one clean sheet.

So, we need a win to get us going, the longer it takes for us to get the more pressure our new manager will be under. We also have had no luck go our way against Norwich & West Brom today.

Next up it is Cardiff away...! I think we will score more goals away this season than we will at our place, so as long as we score more than the home team then!

Gavin Ramejkis
60 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:14:33
Just back from the game and lacklustre pretty much sums up the display, some poor ref decisions which were epitomised when Osman's volley clearly deflecting big time off a West Brom player was given as a goal kick. Felt like watching an end of season game with nothing to play for.

If a team has aspirations it needs to be putting dross like West Brom to the sword home and away, they had very little to offer in response.

Paul David
61 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:17:25
Howard 6
Coleman 7
Jag 7
Distin 6
Baines 8
Mirallas 4
Osman 4
Barkley 7
Fellaini 4
Pienaar 4
Jelavic 5

The build up was too slow and not enough bodies in the box.

Peter Laing
62 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:22:17
Find it hard that you afforded Baines the luxury of an 8 David, his mind looked elsewhere for long periods of that game. We only appeared to get going when Kone replaced Jelavic up front and we seemed to then be more direct and have a go at them. Also a very poor game from Mirallas IMO.
Wayne Smyth
63 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:16:17
RM needs time. 1 pre-season and a couple of games isn't really worth whining about, given that the last manager had 11 years and still won fuck all. For most of those years we would spend the first 4 months of the season wondering if we'd get sucked into a relegation dogfight.

I thought today we certainly lacked an edge and a few players seemed to lack form(particularly Mirallas). I liked the look of kone when he came on and we could've had a few goals on a different day if we had a small amount of luck. We won't play many teams that work as hard as WBA, thats for sure.

Don't forget RM has come from a team where they were attacked week in week out, to a team where we're expected to do the attacking and break down 11 men behind the ball most weeks. That will take time to come to terms with and we may find his plan changes somewhat.

Certainly it was good to keep a clean sheet today; something people have a go at him about constantly.

Brian Denton
64 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:22:14
Just back. Uninspiring, with no speed of thought (or speed full stop) despite plenty of possession. Thought Barkley did ok, and I am at least pleased to see that we seem to have overturned that unwillingness to shoot from outside the box which was a feature of Everton under Moyes.

It's going to take time is obvious.............

Graham Mockford
65 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:20:08
I said pre season that the over the top optimism was misplaced. I predicted bottom six after six games, and I'm not thinking any different after two games.

Of course it is far too early to judge what the season may bring but what is worrying is that the desire to maintain possession seems to be slowing us down and easier to defend against. This is more likely to happen when teams like West Brom set themselves up defensively, and that is where over the previous seasons we have gained most points.

Changing styles is always difficult and the PL is a tough school to do it in.

Steve Pugh
66 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:02:49
Those people slating Osman were obviously oblivious to the number of little dinked passes he played forward to the likes of Barkley and Mirallas. I admit that apart from the header and the volley he didn't do a lot in the opposition box but in the deeper role that he had been asked to fill he did a reasonably good job, and he gave the ball away an awful lot less than a couple of the younger players did today.
Jamie Barlow
67 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:28:23
Fellaini 4. Nonsense. Baines 8. Even more nonsense. Think you got those two mixed up. Baines was shit. I can't remember the last good cross from him in an Everton shirt.
Ralph Basnett
68 Posted 24/08/2013 at 17:26:49
I am normally the worlds worst moaner when it comes to Everton but there was a lot there today I thought was good.

Okay, WBA are shit and we should've buried them but all-in-all I thought not such a bad result.

Barkley showed again and they never really tested us. I don't mind passing football at all, just don't like it if there isn't an end product and Martinez still seems to have Jelavic running the channels, swaps him for Kone who runs the channels?

We needed a goal and we do a like-for-like change.

And once again Osman starts and then Naismith on for Mirallas who still can't complete a full game?

Hodges on at the game meant Jagielka runs around like man possessed, fortunately we had Distin to clean up after him.

Still, always next week......

Tom Bowers
69 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:23:37
Okay the same starting eleven for 2 games and 4 points down the swannee.
It's time for changes and I don't mean the Stevenage game where we know changes will be made.
The squad players must be used in the next Prem game and that means the likes of Oviedo etc.
Jelavic, Mirallas, Osman etc.must get the message that they need to be better and giving other players the chance is the way to get that message across.
Does RM have the guts to do what Moyes wouldn't do? I'm not so sure...
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
70 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:36:39
Ralph, Who the hell is Hodges?

I know that old bloke at the start looked a bit Dad's Army but WTF?

And come on, lad — you should be old enough to know where to use 'there' instead of 'their' (now corrected)!

Phil Walling
71 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:23:24
I've been saying it since America,Martinez has a Wigan mentality and is determined to have us playing in their style and to their standards.

Did not BK tell him this is Everton. We expect more.Pretty-pretty passing only means anything if it leads to goalscoring opportunities at pace.We are not blessed with the skills of his beloved Barcelona and never will be. So bring the best out of what we've got and can afford.Ossie isn't Messi but I almost thought he was our best player today. That's how crap we were!

So FFS, Roberto, stop pissing about ,do the transfer business-in and out-and show us that you are worthy of the great and honourable job bestowed upon you. Otherwise,you'll find Goodison to be an unforgiving place.

Tony Bell
72 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:15:51
Just back from the game and saw it the same as most. Awful. Pass, pass, pass, pass (by this stage 10 WBA players behing the ball) then the usual struggle in the final third. No penetration again.

Was it me or were we even more defensive than last season? Both DM's hardly got forward, 2/3 in the box for our corners and countless times Baines, coleman (insert any name here) got to the byline or a decent crossing position, only for1 player to be in the box

Very unhappy and ruined my "buzz" which is always present at the first home game. Was expecting the shackles to be let off, not more added.

Patrick Murphy
73 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:29:50
I watched Parker for Fulham today and even though he was playing against a good side in Arsenal, he just kept feeding the ball to his forwards time and time again, head and shoulders above Osman, who is now a spent force in the PL.

As for the Felli factor it only proves that we have to play two up front at home, because it was only when the big Fella started to move further forward that we looked at all dangerous.

Paul David
74 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:39:35
Was anyone else impressed with Mulumbu? He seemed to be everywhere.
Colin Williams
75 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:30:12
Jamie, agree with you!! Baines very poor, felli, steady performance. Robbie needs a plan B! Our game was crying out for changes EARLY!
Half time would have been great, why waste 25mins before changing what was very obvious? Central m/f players are the game changers when the team needs momentum and leadership. I really can't see Ossie being that leader!
It's very difficult trying to win a game of football at this level if, one or two players are not up to it!!!!!

Sam Hoare
76 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:49:08
Fellaini won the ball alot in midfield and came closest to scoring a goal for us. Baines...did nothing.

Kone or Anichebe have to start the next game. Jelavic's all round game is staggeringly poor.

Paul David
77 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:44:46
I think Martinez's way of playing will see us get results away cos the home side have to attack but at Goodison i'm yet to be convinced. Wigan could do it cos every teams goes there looking for a win but at Goodison most teams will put men behind the ball. By the time we've played our 50th pass to get to the final third there is 10 organised men behind the ball.

The times we did get behind their defence we only had one player in the box. Why don't we play with 2 strikers at home?

James Martin
78 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:42:52
Even more negative than last season. No good passing around the back if the hoof comes anyway. We'll never win anything with Fellaini in the team. Another woeful game from him slowing everything down.
John Gee
79 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:48:13
I thought Osman was good today. He worked hard to play the Gibbo role and I can't recall any big mistakes. He doesn't deserve any of the stick he's getting here tonight.

We will struggle if Fellaini goes. He was constantly nicking possession off WBA midfielders. He's the only MF we have who can do that well.

Jelavic can't start another game for us. It's heart breaking to see him trying so hard for the team without being able to hit the heights again. We have options now for the lone front man and he should only come off the bench until his form improves.

Ross Barkley is genuinely exciting. The new Rooney... there, I said it.

Baines is going next week. The haircut is because he knows he'll be in the papers all next week. DON'T GO BAINSEY, WE LOVE YOU AND MOYES HAS GOT NITS!

Naismith is so far out of his depth that he's running the risk of getting the bends when the game finishes.

Richard Dodd
80 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:49:19
My goodness, so much gloom and doom and only two matches played -and no defeats.

Of course, we all know that had just one of those shots that hit the woodwork gone in, this mailbox would be a far different place tonight.

From my perspective – and possibly at the suggestion of BK – Roberto has chosen not to change much early doors. It was Moyes's team he sent out today and the formation-one up front and pressing full-backs had OFM all over it. Even the withdrawal of Mirallas and the c70min substitutions screamed 'Moyes'!

Now somebody ought to tell him that we expected more. We wanted Martinez the innovator – not Martinez the Davey clone. Because the fact is that the original looked more effective than the copy.

What we want him to know is that OFM is just a dirty smell around here, so forget him, Roberto, and whatever BK has told you about building on the Scotsman's strengths, DO IT YOUR WAY. Then prepare to be judged. As I promise, you will be.

Peter Thistle
81 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:43:57
That's the first 0-0 I can remember Everton being in for ages. Tedious and disappointing result. That's what ya get when you don't invest in the team, a complete lack of ideas and inspiration.
Christopher Kelly
82 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:45:49
Anyone that thinks/suggests the Osmans, Nevilles Hibberts, and Jelavics of this world are good enough for Everton need to find a new team to support or watch some videos on the School of Science.

Mirallas thinks he's hot shit but he's really just shit for far too much of the time. I think the sooner he stops believing the hype, the sooner he'll become the players he's meant to be!

Felli needs to be sold straight away for anything over 20 and Baines will be fine.

Even the strip looks crap!!!!!!!! Fuck My Life that was shit today

Graham Mockford
83 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:07:42
#273 Richard Dodd

A classic even by your high standards. Our poor start season is actually David Moyes fault. You really couldn't make it up.

Paul Dark
84 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:10:34
I wouldn't say we 'dominated'. WBA closed us down well - and there were a lot of misdirected passes. There was less evidence of the possession-based football which Martinez has been boasting of - and we looked a bit toothless (again!).

The continuation of Osman in the first team is inexcusable. He's an utter disgrace, no less.

Patrick Murphy
85 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:10:56
Peter the last 0-0 was Swansea at Goodison in the last transfer window quickly followed by Southampton away and 2 more in the latter stages of last season at Arsenal and the Dark Side, doesn't make this one feel any better though.

Chris I also agree with your views re RM, I think he might be a bit of big-time charlie and we can't afford to have those around this squad unless they are producing the goods.

Paul Dark
86 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:15:45
If manager smarming people in press conferences and feeding supporters with (false confidence) won points, we'd be CL qualifiers this season, no sweat.

If having a golden-mouthed manager whose reward for relegation was a top job is a substitute for results and slow conversion to the Wigan way, then I'm worried, very worried.

I really hope we keep Marouane and Leighton.

Clive Rogers
87 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:15:02
Well now we know. Poor performance with some shocking individual displays and one or two with their mind elsewhere. If F and B leave we are a relegation team if not adequately replaced.
Where's the extra £24M TV money gone Kenshite?
Andy Walker
88 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:38:49
WBA and Norwich and no wins and no surprises. We have the wrong manager for the players we have. I have seen nothing to change my pre season view that we will do well to be in the top half of the table. At least we haven't lost yet, that and Barkley are the only positives and it will only get worse when we loose Baines and Fellaini.
Patrick Murphy
89 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:20:05
Paul I think we all get the message that RM wasn't your first choice or even possibly the last man on Earth to be your manager, but come on what are you achieving by constantly repeating the same crap over and over again. I and I pretty certain all TW's have got the message you don't like the guy and you never will, but like a marriage we are stuck with him so until he walks or is relieved of his duties can you please refrain from bringing up the Wigan connections. BTW a certain Bill Shankly was accused of turning LFC into PNE (His former club) oh if only he had!
Andy Walker
90 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:23:00
We haven't spent money because the only reason we used to spend it was because Moyes was trusted by the money men to spend the credit. He was a good risk. Think of Moyes as AAA and Martinez as BBB credit rating. This is the critical problem we now have.
Sam Hoare
91 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:27:10
Great. The RS are second, my fantasy football team bombed (cheers Mirallas!) and I see poor old Conor Mcaleny got stretchered off. Bad day at the football office.
Gavin McGarvey
92 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:15:31
Poor stuff to be honest. Players seemed to be a bit off the pace. I can't imagine Roberto Martinez enjoyed watching that either, but no doubt he'll try and take the positives (which will be a bit of a struggle).

I thought WBA played well for an away side. They played to their strengths and made life difficult for us. In my opinion they could quite easily have nicked it but their main striker was out.

I think it's going to be difficult for Roberto to change the style of play and get results at the same time. Also if he doesn't start winning games soon then the crowd will start getting nervous and that won't make things easier. What he really needs is a bit of luck, because once he gets that the players will find it that much easier to buy into his ideas more wholeheartedly.

I agree with those saying we need to add players not sell players. Fellaini and Baines didn't have particularly great games but still looked like two of our best players. Hopefully our new manager will talk BK into loosening the purse strings before the transfer deadline passes.

Gavin McGarvey
93 Posted 24/08/2013 at 18:15:31
Poor stuff to be honest. Players seemed to be a bit off the pace. I can't imagine Roberto Martinez enjoyed watching that either, but no doubt he'll try and take the positives (which will be a bit of a struggle).

I thought WBA played well for an away side. They played to their strengths and made life difficult for us. In my opinion they could quite easily have nicked it but their main striker was out.

I think it's going to be difficult for Roberto to change the style of play and get results at the same time. Also if he doesn't start winning games soon then the crowd will start getting nervous and that won't make things easier. What he really needs is a bit of luck, because once he gets that the players will find it that much easier to buy into his ideas more wholeheartedly.

I agree with those saying we need to add players not sell players. Fellaini and Baines didn't have particularly great games but still looked like two of our best players. Hopefully our new manager will talk BK into loosening the purse strings before the transfer deadline passes.

Ciarán McGlone
94 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:25:01
I thought that it was a decent performance despite Osman, Mirrallas, Jelavic and Naismith... who were all poor. None of them should in the starting eleven and Naismith should not get in the squad.

Ben Foster was MOTM and that just about covers it.

I was well pleased with Barkley who I can't remember making a single mistake..

Martinez needs to start dropping those who don't perform and use the better squad players...

Phil Sammon
95 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:12:31
Phil Walling

Yeah, I've just got back from the game. It wasn't great, but some of the stuff on here makes it look like we got stuffed 3-0.

Can't really bash Fellaini, he was probably our best player today. God knows what game some people were watching.

Baines was distinctly average but I'm a bit disappointed at those asserting that he's got his mind elsewhere. Just about the best crosser in the league and we refuse to give him a target in the box. Cue him stalling and waiting for Pienaar.

Coleman was good. I might be a bit old to have a favourite player...but fuck it, he's great!

Very disappointed to see Naismith on for Mirallas and again stuck out on the wing. The guy is not a wide player. I don't know how many bad performances he has to put in before the manager notices.

Martinez bangs on about 'flexibility' and being able to adapt. I wish we'd see some of it on the pitch. We played the same for 90 minutes and it wasn't working.

Clearly I'm not happy with the performance, but can we criticise without throwing in bollocks about us 'being the next Wigan'.

Colin Glassar
96 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:31:32
Ciaran, apart from Mirallas I can't see the other three you mentioned still being with us next season.
Paul Dark
98 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:31:52
Patrick 290: 'I and I'? - I thought you were a bit schizoid :-)

Sorry if my view on Martinez is at variance from yours - but this kind of thing happens in life, especially in football (as you know). To ask me not to mention the Wigan connection is a bit much, in my view.

Today was not a good day.

Mark Griffiths
99 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:32:43
Thought we played good in parts today and had we of got that first goal it could have been 2 or 3 for us as I thought West Brom played for a draw. Coleman, Peanuts and Barkley were stand outs. Too many to feet passes on break aways and not enough bodies in the box at the right moments. The ball just would not go on second half, just one of those games.
Phil Walling
100 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:16:55
Graham @ 280: I don't think Doddy was blaming Moyes at all. In fact, he indicates that Moyes would have directed the same team a lot better –and I agree with him.

Mirallas is a flash fucker – witness his 'gold, modified' Bentley in today's papers – who flits in and out of games and always feels he's done enough after 70 mins. The lazy bugger has never seen out a single game for us.

The nonsense over the transfers means that the season has got off to a false start and, as ever, it will be late November before we can make any meaningful forecast of success or failure.

Personally, the spectre of Wigan lies over Martinez's every move. I just hope I'm wrong.

Al Reddish
101 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:24:20
The big worry about Fellaini and Baines going is there are only 4 players in that team that can collect and hold onto the ball under pressure. Them two, Barkley and Pienaar (though his decision making can be shocking at times!).

I thought Fellaini had a really good game but did pull out of a few 50/50s. It wasn't one of Baines better days and it looks like the speculation may have got to him, however he never went missing and got better as the game went on. Osman did better than last week and looked good when he played it simple. Barkley was good. Jags can't jump anymore and some of the tactics were shocking (3 up for our corners, all back in the box for theirs).

As for Jelavic.....this guy plays like he doesn't want his first team place. He was moaning, falling over, being caught offside and had the touch of a constipated cow. Get rid and get Vic/Kone in.

James Martin
102 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:40:18
Lets be honest before Barkley belted a pearler in we didn't look like scoring against Norwich either. That's two first haves in a row we've just allowed to be wasted without mounting any serious threat on goal. Fellaini can't turn around on the ball. Contrary to what some thing OFM wasn't a complete idiot and there was a reason he got shoved off upfront because he sets a slow crab like tempo if he ever plays in the middle. The sooner Darron Gibson gets back and Fellaini is sold the better. Perhaps Man U will do us a favour and take the grand crab off our hands. Towards the end it was like the cup game against WIgan all over again with him not even running, attempting flicks that just have the ball away and just fouling that wastes time. Awful performance but the usual suspects will just go on about how we'll be relegated without him and how he's the stand out performer every single game.
Phil Sammon
103 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:48:59
And the other lot will slag him off regardless of how he plays.
Patrick Murphy
104 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:46:06
Paul I'm not Schizoid but the bloke doing all the miss-typing might be! :)
I see you let me know twice! Which one is for me?

Tom Bowers
105 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:39:27
Albion were up for the test today and plotted accordingly. Stop Coleman and Baines and your halfway there. Everton's prowess comes down the flanks and when that is thwarted the midfielders just don't have the skills nor incisiveness to trouble many defences. Sometimes one or two of the right decisions from the officials can get things going but not today. We desperately need that classy midfielder if one is out there and hopefully something happens in the next week or so.
Mirallas can be good but not often enough as with several other players.
It's time for changes.
Mike Green
106 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:53:15
Richard Dodd #273 - stunning stuff....and who said football fans were fickle!
John Malone
107 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:41:59
Frustration is the word of the day!

Felt like last year some good play getting up to the final third but no killer ball or strike. Have to say I feel sorry for Jelavic he never gets a decent cross or pass to pounce on it's starting to piss me off how much Pienaar and Baines over do it on the left instead of lashing the early ball in, it must be so frustrating for the forwards and needs to be sorted.

Kone look decent when he came on good control and passed the ball quickly, Mirallas stunk and needs to work harder, even still not too down stiil looked the better team and have quality in there just need to find a way to make it count.

Brian Harrison
108 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:52:19
Our build up play was slow and allowed West Brom to get men behind the ball. Cant understand seeing how the game was panning out that RM didnt push Fellani into a more advanced role. Without him up front we won very few balls when played in the air. Yes we all want to see a passing game but not one that has the back four making 10 or 15 passes between themselves.

Also what has happened to Mirallas looks like his twin brother has come back from pre-season. Last season he ran at sides and created chances today he was way off the pace. I hope that this is an early season blip and we can start to play like the top 6 side we were last year.

Richard Dodd
109 Posted 24/08/2013 at 19:54:44
And changes there will be, Tom. I suspect Felli and Baines are already gone and half the money will end up in DW's coffers!

Did you hear the whispers today about Mirallas wanting back to 'mainland Europe' and Jelavic going to Russia?

By the time we play our next home Prem match we could have a new side!

Patrick Murphy
110 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:02:50
I would think that most of those whispers will be accurate Richard, I can't see how we can gamble on Jelavic for another season and I think Mirallas will have had his head turned by his agent and the fact that his compatriot is likely to be playing elsewhere next month. I think some posters are worried that the next time we play at home in the League that new team you mention will be very athletic so to speak.


Paul Dark
111 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:11:25
Patrick 312: one was for you - and the other was for you. :-)
Gary Reeves
112 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:09:26
When fans of my age get asked "What do we need?" the name of Peter Reid invariably gets thrown in the hat. Never did that apply as much as today. And I'm not talking about the combative, tackling player that he was; I'm talking about his intelligence on the field. Top players don't always pass to feet, they play the ball to the space where they want the man to go! Too often today passes weren't "inviting the player on" they were too static, especially in midfield.
We need some cleverness. Any suggestions?
Ralph Basnett
113 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:18:10
Michael being, dyslexic and short sighted affords me the fucking opportunity to not do proper English.

One word I can spell though is Tit!!!!

Mark Frere
114 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:18:44
I thought the game was crying out for Deulofeu - someone with a bit of imagination, a bit of trickery and something to unlock a stubborn defence. A lacklustre Mirrallas comes off only to be replaced by the sub-standard Naismith. When are the powers that be going to realise Naismith is not a RW, and he is shite full stop? Why can everyone else apart from our present and former manager see this?

Neil Pickering
115 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:27:05
I can't believe some of the negativity on here! IMO we're playing better football than we ever have, and the two games we have played could have easily been two wins if the rub of the green had gone our way.

People moaned last season we were playing hoofball under the man whose name I can't even bear to say now... and now, because we have drawn our first two games, we are playing too much football!

Have a bit of perspective, people; this transition is going to take a bit of time. I am happy with the signs so far....

Colin Malone
116 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:30:13
If Felli does leave (I hope he does not), West Brom's Mulumbu in my opinion would be a good buy.
Bill Gall
117 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:09:13
All of last season the most comments about Everton were Osman and Naismith were not good enough for the team and we should look to replace them before this season started.

Nothing has been done to strengthen the midfield and the new Manager is trying to introduce a new system that requires a creative midfielder to make it successful.

With no help seeming to come from the worst board in Everton's history I believe Everton's manager is going to receive an awful lot of criticism.
Any supporter who thinks that selling Baines and Fellaini will release funds for new players shake your head.

Unless someone is already lined up, by next Monday there will be no time to do any transfers and we will be left without two of our best players.

As a number of people have stated before, Everton's main stumbling block is the board.

Kevin Rowlands
118 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:34:14
It pains me to say this but our Scottish imports are simply not good enough, Naismith isn't a big surprise but I had such high hopes for Jelavic, his first touch makes Torres look like a world beater, both need to be moved on asap!
Derek Knox
119 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:26:38
Ralph (#334)
You have spelt it backwards!
Must be the myopic dyslexia!
Andy Crooks
120 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:34:52
That show deserved a bollocking and I just can't picture nice guy Robbie delivering it.If the appalling Moyes had served this up we'd be calling for his head.

Mark, players are often shite when played out of position. A new coach usually brings a lift, something new, inspiration, a feel good factor. What we've had are lovely soundbites and two points against two woeful sides. This promises to be one hell of a fucking transition period.

James Martin
121 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:46:55
Today Kevin, like at Norwich are Belgian imports weren't good enough either - much as it pians everyone to say it on here. Had Naismith given the ball away as often as Mirallas did in the first hal with as little end product then I'm not sure he would have got applauded off like Mirallas did when he went for his usual early bath.
Darren Hind
122 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:41:00
"Ben Foster was MotM and that just about covers it" ... Isn't it customary for a goalie to make a few saves before he's nominated as MotM?
Ralph Basnett
123 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:48:45
Fuck me Derek, Michael avin a go is bad enough,can we get back onto the subject matter!!!!!

Peter Cummings
125 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:39:57
Told you about 'must win against teams like WBA' situations and so it proved. Shades of last season, battering our heads against brick wall defenders with, as usual, no help from the ref. Jeli offside time and again; no use saying we should have won – we didn't... and they're already crowing across the park. Gloomy prospects ahead, methinks.
Kevin Rowlands
126 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:51:43
James, I think we can all agree no one was good enough today, but the difference is Naismith and unfortunately Jelavic will never be good enough, the other two you refer to most certainly are when they're on they're game!
Robert Pierpoint
127 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:50:50
Surprised with the level of criticism that Felliani is getting here. He broke up quite a lot of play defensively. It was interesting to note that the best chance where he hit the post came from a longer pass from Jagielka. He controlled it with his chest perfectly. However, what I found really odd was that after this, he reverted to being stationed in front of Jags and Distin. Felli needed to be supporting the striker late on in the game and we needed to make greater use of the longer ball in to him in my opinion.

I was surprised that at home, Martinez didn't go to two up top with twenty mins to go. I think that we were crying out for Anichebe to replace Barkley for the final quarter. I've a lot of time for Martinez, but I think that a more direct plan B was needed when they continued to drop deeper in the second half.

Bill Gall
128 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:00:48
Kevin 346.
I don't think Jelivic has been seen in a kilt.
Ciarán McGlone
129 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:01:46
Take Barkley off??..and leave Osman on the pitch, Robert?

Seriously?

I thought Barkley was our most effective and consistent player today..closely followed by Coleman..

Mike Gwyer
130 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:38:31

Well, that was interesting.

Jelavic - the guy run around like a headless chicken because the players behind him insisted on 400 fucking passes before putting the ball anywhere near the opposition goal. Hence, he was caught offside, because a) he was fucking bored or b) he lost apathy with the continuous passing.

Is there something I don't know about this type of football that maybe Arsenal or Barcelona hide deep in their archives. Can anyone tell me, in layman terms, why you have to pass the fucking ball 90000000 times before doing something useful - I've I just watch the fucking RS twats pass the ball about 5 times before sticking it into the onion bag.

Blame Jelavic if you like, blame Osman as well, I mean he must have touched the ball about 10000000 times today and completed about 100000000000 passes (OPTA will be wanking in joy at his quota's) but if we have no idea as to why we are passing the ball to death then neither does Jelavic.

Robert Pierpoint
131 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:10:51
Ciaran

I thought that Barkley faded a little bit during the second half, although he was still a threat; during the first half he was excellent. I think that if we go to four in the midfield to play two up front when chasing a game, Osman offers a little more discipline, obvious because of his experience. Of course Barkley is our most threatening midfielder when playing in a five-man midfield.
Giacomo Trifoglio
133 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:12:15
Optimism levels ride when Barkley has the ball, felt he should have played further forward and had the ball threaded to him more often.

Naismith for Mirallas? Solo lo mejor? Il mio culo!

Alan Smith
134 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:15:49
By discipline do you mean, weak cant tackle, no pace, can't run and not as strong as Barkley?
Ray Said
136 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:15:48
Jelavic didnt have a poor game-he has had a string of at leaste 25 poor games out of 30. That tells me that he is shit and needs to go. His movement is poor, hist attitude is poor, he folds like a cheap tent and his touch is worse than poor-Coco the Clown wearing the size 30 clown shoes still has a better touch than this prick, I say move him on but which stupid bastard would buy him.
Bill Gall
137 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:22:42
When Everton brought Jelavic to the club I believe at that time there was a couple of comments from Glasgow Rangers fans who said he started like a house on fire and then his next season was lucky to hit a barn door.
Looks like the form is continuing.
But in his defence he is the type of player who will struggle in this Managers system
Patrick Murphy
138 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:40:27
Bill, I think Jelavic will struggle in any system, he just ain't got it, I was willing to give him a chance but he does more moaning than Victor, less work than Miralas and his touch is worse than Naismith's but obviously he's not getting the service he requires, i.e having the ball laid on a plate so he can put it in the net, every striker in the PL can do that much.

His purple patch came at a time when the whole team was on song and under no pressure, he can't handle the pressure, unfortunately and if we are going to be in a fight for every available point, he's not the guy I would like on board. We need a forward who can make space for others as well as himself. I'm hoping that Kone can at least hold the ball up for others to join in or else we are going to really struggle.

Raymond Fox
139 Posted 24/08/2013 at 20:09:17
Same old prejudicies being sprouted again!
Two games and its slash your wrist time?

Last week unlucky, fluke cross, right on his nut, 2-2.
Today, ok wasn't great, but we've hit the post, hit the crossbar, shot straight at keeper 3 times (Mirallas) when should have done better.
Not easy to break down 10 men behind the ball, but we knew what to expect.

Baines was quiet, I thought Fellaini had a decent game, we would miss them both,
Jelavic crap, Kone did well, might have been a different result if he had started, Mirallas poorish, Distin his usual assured match, Barkley good in parts but not finding space enough, Osman indifferent, Coleman better 2nd half, Pienaar decent game, Howard competent game.
Nothing that £20m-£30m wouldn't sort, but hey this is Everton, we all know were skint as usual!
Talk of Europe pre season, was cloud cuckoo land, top half more like.

Jamie Barlow
140 Posted 24/08/2013 at 21:42:21
Darren@350, he must have made a few saves, we had 8 shots on target. Either that or the other 25 were really shit.
Joe McMahon
141 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:01:52
We are stuck with ageing now average players such as Osman and Pienaar, Naismith is just not a prem player, he needs to be at Barnsley or Preston and Jelavic is also not good enough. I thgought Kone looked sharp when he came on, but also disappointed Baines didn't seem urgent enough (not enough energy). If he wants to go let him. Roberto requires time, as the like of Osman are not gonna be snapped up, and we need better players now. It is worrying though watching Southampton et al outspending us, once again back to you Kenwright.
Tom Bowers
142 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:09:31
RM say he's happy about 2 positive draws so that means after 38 positive draws we have 38 points. That's BS in any language RM.
Okay we have to give him time so let's see what steps he takes towards getting some Premiership wins. He has players to draw upon and he must use them and not always as subs. There are signs that some things have changed but other changes later don't want to come about as desperation.
Nick Entwistle
143 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:08:57
That's pretty harsh Joe. You don't finish 6th with average players.

For a club of our means, even some with deep pockets, we have a good number of players. Its a well balanced side so they shouldn't be finishing less than 7th this season and should be thinking an outside chance of top 4.

The first XI is as good as anyone bar the Oil rich clubs. The left flank will come good again, and the right is catching up fast.

Jags, Fellaini, Barkley, Gibson are quality players, Distin too... only the Jags Dinstin axis isn't exactly Jags and Lescott.

Jelavic was making all the right moves today but the laboured build up didn't help him. Wouldn't help anyone.

Over to Robby Martins.

Joe McMahon
144 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:10:44
Mike (363 - what difference does the passing make? Jelavic was terrible last season too. He won't be able to do it in the English Premiership.

On the whole good strikers cost money (why Liverpool always get them). Sadly Moyes blasted away a 10 million loss on Yakubu, and wasted 11.5 million on Billy (who we didn't need). I don't think our new manager will get any funds to spend such sums even when (we will) sell Felliani.

Al Reddish
145 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:20:50
Bobby gets angry.......
Roberto Martínez claimed he wanted to avoid "a media war with a manager I respect greatly", yet angrily condemned David Moyes for saying Everton were stalling the careers of Leighton Baines and Marouane Fellaini by refusing to sell the pair to Manchester United.

Everton have rejected a joint £28m bid for the players from the Premier League champions and were further angered by comments from Moyes on Friday, when he claimed he would not have stood in the way of the deal during his 11 years at Goodison Park.

But Martínez responded: "If managers start talking about players who are registered with other clubs it's the end of the whole thing. People should look after their own things internally. I am sure they have their own issues. I could come out and give my opinions about his players, but I will be a bit more respectful than that.

"The Everton manager admitted "every player has got a price" but insisted he had no valuation in mind for Fellaini and Baines. "We don't want to sell, that's our position," he added.

"Everyone can have an opinion on a player's worth but when you offer below what a club paid for a player, after five years of development [Fellaini], then it is a nonsense.It is a bit of a farce really."Martínez also denied Moyes's suggestion that Everton had leaked details of United's bid, which valued Fellaini at £16m and Baines at £12m. "The bid appeared in the paper before it arrived to us," he said.

"And I heard that in the past Everton never sold cheap. The last thing I want is to get into a war with a manager I really respect. But the business should be done more quietly. It's unfortunate when you read it in the papers and people talk about your players. I could give you half an hour about my views about how other clubs are being run and how they have not been able to do any deals despite looking all over the world."
Nick Entwistle
146 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:29:13
Col. Hans Landa: I love rumors! Facts can be so misleading, where rumors, true or false, are often revealing.

Unless confirmed by either club, anything reported in the press is just transfer bananas. Its impossible to differentiate between the 1% accurate and 99% made up.

Phil Sammon
147 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:24:16
Really don't get why Pienaar gets lumped in with Ossie and Naismith. The guy is a very good player. He had a spell last season where he was out on his arse and DM still ran him for 90 mins every game. He always gives 100% going back as well as forward.

Pienaar works space for Baines at every opportunity. If we ever actually had a man in the box we might see a trademark Baines cross and some of the more numb-minded fans may finally see Pienaar's worth.

Andrew Cutler
148 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:36:55
Howard 7
Coleman 7
Jags 6
Distin 7
Baines 6
Fellaini 7
Osman 5
Pienaar 6
Barkley 7
Mirallis 4
Jelavic 4

MotM?... no-one

Raymond Fox
150 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:22:16
Tom, he's going to put on a positive face for the cameras, but you can bet he's not happy about it!

They are positives, in that the best side last week should have won away. A poor game today but we were the best side again.

Who's he going to change, Tom? Kone for Jelavic yes; Gibson when fit... Heitinga maybe. But not much more choice.

Peter Anthony
151 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:41:37
Mulumbu was immense in the middle of the park for them. Without his massive input for WBA today I feel we'd have overrun them. We definitely need more cutting edge though, over to you Roberto to find the keys to unlock the tight back lines we need to to have the penetration in terms of goals we so obviously need.
Mike Hughes
152 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:26:32
Mike#363
My thoughts exactly.

The "philosophy" should be to play our game and adapt to plan b, c and so on accordingly. As mentioned above there was no plan b - no Fellini up front or even 20 mins for deulofeu - just like for like changes.

An uninspiring start to a campaign that seems to have the in-built excuse of transition requiring time.

Given it's virtually the same team, why not transition to a more passing style more gradually? Get the basics right with a few wins on the board.

does rm think there are marks for artistic interpretation?

My main fear pre-season and posted on tw was this insistence on passing footy. it's nice as a means to an end but the end is what matters.

Still, it might come good. Jury's out but I'm a bit concerned by the uncertain start. And by the uncertainty to come in the transfer window in the next week.

Andrew Cutler
153 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:40:15
The squad is a year older then last season (yeah, I know...no kidding!!) but it shows. Jags looking tired and his post match interview consists solely of 'yes definitely'. Osman too old, Pienaar aging, Baines aging, Howard aging (but playing well still), Distin aging.

Then there is outright crap...Jelavic, Naismith. Hell, we are going to struggle this year... but I suspected we would, and I am not negative about that. It is an inevitable part of the transition process. I think things will improve a lot after the inevitable clear out.

Derek Knox
154 Posted 24/08/2013 at 23:18:35
Slightly off thread here, but being positive and thinking ahead, does anyone know why Bryan Oviedo has not been on the bench either today, or at Norwich last week?
I thought he would have been a good option, instead of Naismith and although hypothetical, could have delivered a few crosses for Kone.
Colin Williams
155 Posted 24/08/2013 at 23:24:56
Derek,God know's, he deserves to be playing, not watching. Strange that he's not even in the squad, don't get it! Robbie likes good technical players in his squad and Oviedo is certainly one of the strongest in that department.
Max Fine
156 Posted 24/08/2013 at 22:54:23
Jesus. Can't believe some of the comments on here... and I bet most of the strongest and most negative and righteous opinions have been formed after watching two grainy streams over the internet.

West Brom employed EXACTLY the same tactics this season as last season with 10 men behind the ball,- however this year they weren't considerate enough to score an own goal and have an internal barny on the pitch.

Osman CAN have his moments were he is ineffectual and anonymous. Today was not one of them. Felliani had a good first half and a poor second where he sat deeper, although this was not inconsistant with his consistant inconsitancy... and Baines was his usual dependable self going forward whilst employing his usual heart in mouth defending at the back.

Yes the build up play is slower, but our usual hoof-ball culprits are adjusting to playing it out from the defence - you can't play in a league as fast paced as the Premiership and learn these things in a couple of games.. We also seem to be taking far more chances pressing forward and some of the more ambitious forward play isn't always coming off yet. I can only imagine this is why Mirallas / Pienaar seem to be looking a little off compared to the previous campaign. However this could be attributed to the fact that our players knew that under Moyes any 'mistake' was often punished with an omission from the starting line-up, hence they rarely tried anything that deviated much from 'plan A'. Ask ross barkley. In fact, for the majority of Moyes' time in charge it was like watching table football our play was so predictable and static.

Does anyone remember Moyes' first 7 years in charge? Where we yo-yo'd between 7th and 17th for the majority of the time? No? Does anyone remeber the most appalling 'football' he employed for most of his tenure? I do. But it was all part of the 'transition'.

The only time Moyes started to play football was the beginning of last season, after NINE YEARS in charge. And we've since learnt that was most likely due to him realising that if he was going to play moneyball for the mancs he's better start trying to WIN a match rather than play not to loose.

Mike (409).you states it's; "An uninspiring start to a campaign that seems to have the in-built excuse of transition requiring time." Er, that's exactly what it is - yet another transition. This time to playing attractive possession football that will attract football playing players. And in the premiership you can't make that transition in two f**king games.

Ste Traverse
157 Posted 24/08/2013 at 23:47:34
Mirallas had a complete off day, everything he tried didn't come off. Osman stunk the place out. The only times I noticed Jelavic was when he was yet again being constantly caught offside, Kone got into better positions in the 20 mins or so he was on.

Why was Naismith brought on?? He offers nothing. Get rid.

Jack Cross
158 Posted 24/08/2013 at 23:15:33
Well what as changed from last season? Nowt. Lot of possession, lots of chances and no one seems to be able to put it away.

I wouldn't put major blame on Jeli. I still think he will turn it around. For god sake we've played 2 matches and haven't been beat. It's not as if either of the teams have over powered us and weve just scraped through, we've fully controlled both matches. Ok we want to win and maybe we should have more points but we've got to stay behind them and RM and I feel it will come good.

But I can't for the life of me fathom why Oviedo isn't even on the bench. And what's wrong with victor?

Tony J Williams
159 Posted 24/08/2013 at 23:52:40
I don't remember the yo-yoing at all, one 17th place, one 11th, the rest top 8.
Barry Rathbone
160 Posted 24/08/2013 at 23:35:14
Oviedo? ...... There's been no first team change other than the Neville vacancy, possibly RM is keeping the senior pros onside till closure of the transfer window.

Potentially being a Baines and a Felli down within the coming week alters everything.

He dare not show his hand till he knows his position squad-wise possibly this is why Oviedo isn't getting a sniff.

Just imagine if he'd dropped Baines and given Oviedo a go citing Baines indifferent form ....

The forked tongued madmen would be -

"HE'S INVITING UTD TO COME AND GET HIM"

Ste Traverse
161 Posted 24/08/2013 at 23:53:47
Slightly off topic, but how did the 'Martinez March' go? How many pitched up for it?

No way was I going to that!

Andy Connor
162 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:03:05
So #201 Kenrick, Martinez made NO attempts at tactical changes? You didn't see him attempt (albeit to no avail) to switch (the poorly performing) Mirallas up front, then left wing, right wing, back up front? But this didn't work, because it meant Barkley went wide right (cue massive gaps second half) so he had to change it back... They seem to me to be attempts at tactical changes...

Might not suit your narrative though...

Overall, a frustrating day but I felt we were unlucky. Early days, it could've been better...

Paul David
163 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:13:18
I seen Mirallas and Pienaar switch but at no point was Barkley on the right.
Phil Sammon
164 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:18:24
You *saw* that, Paul.
Max Fine
165 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:25:23
Tony (434) - Moyes season finishes from joining EFC: 15th (ok, not full season), 7th, 17th, 4th, 11th, 6th.

Hardly consistent.

Tony Twist
166 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:19:49
Hopeless Everton. Martinez needs to up his game, two easier games and no wins is just not good enough. I think we are going to be waiting a while for the first league win. I am undecided whether I want Fellaini and baines to be sold, some new young blood may make all the difference but can we afford to lose two quality players after todays performance.
Patrick Murphy
167 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:22:50
My worry now is if we get turned over at Cardiff. Our next home league game is Chelesa and we might be facing them without Felli and Baines which will make a poor start to the season into what could easily become a crisis start; we really needed to win today.

I still for the life of me can't understand why the players didn't go for it from the off. Yes, the transfer stuff will affect them a little, but that desire to do well was absent – rewind to last home game at Goodison against West Ham and all the players were up for it.

This is the problem that RM and Everton have, I'm afraid; they are all David Moyes' players and, judging by the ex-gaffers veiled threats in the media, it would seem that he still has or thinks he has influence on our club and, who knows, some of our players.

RM has his work cut out in the next week and I don't envy him one iota, not all the crowd are on his side, he doesn't have the money to radically alter the squad and perhaps more crucially some of the players at the club are forgetting (like BK) that David Moyes is no longer our manager.

I always had sympathy for DM as he had to operate with one hand tied behind his back, but Roberto has both hands tied and a queue of people ready to put a noose around his neck.

What is that old phrase about rats deserting a sinking ship? It certainly looks like a few have left the good ship Goodison in the last few months; it's a pity that King Rat won't do the same.

Mike Hughes
168 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:29:47
Max #427

No you can't make the transition in two fucking games.

Read my post with your brain intact and you'll see that's exactly my point.

Tony J Williams
170 Posted 25/08/2013 at 02:34:24
First seven "seasons" you said Max, so add two 5ths to that set of numbers and you will see some consistency
Max Fine
171 Posted 25/08/2013 at 00:44:03
Mike (447): Yeah, I read your post with my brain intact thanks. Deulofeu might be the answer to our payers and RM really should have thought about "transitioning to a more passing style more gradually. Get the basics right with a few wins on the board.".

Difference is I'm not jumping on the FM bandwagon and worrying too much that after only 2 competative matches RM is yet to combine accurate passing and possesion football with a more direct approach, or even that he hasn't thought of it.

I saw many positives today that didn't come across on the TV; namely how much better the movement of the players is already (well, in the first half) and how our more creative players are trying to be a little more selfish (and creative) than under Moyes' military line-ups.
Moyes was an excellent manager, and despite the dire football and the lack of any trophies I'll always be grateful that he turned us into a more professional and consistent outfit on a comparitively limited budget. However he wasn't without his faults - one of them being his failure to ever instill the type of belief and swagger into our players that has the opposition team beaten in the tunnel before kick-off. Today I saw, albeit briefly, something that I've rarely if ever seen under Moyes' management: a passage of play during the second half that saw West Brom have possession and plenty of space and opportunity to attack... however instead of pressing forward like they should and could have done, they shat out and played it back to the keeper. It looked like they just couldn't predict what we might be capable of if they committed people forward, so decided not to chance it.

Even in tight situations during the first half, our players weren't afraid to pass to teammates under pressure, and more often than not we were coming out with the ball. We were hardly Barcelona, and this was only West Brom, but if the opposition fear you aren't scared of playing the difficult pass it makes you far less predictable to defend against. Moyes would never have trusted the players we have to attempt to play like that...

I don't know how RM will do this season but I'm not going to slate (or even get worried by) his style of play yet, as it's clearly in its infancy. And at the moment I'm vastly preferring it to the '100 yard diagonal pass followed by chasing the ball to the corner flag' mode that was employed by Moyes for about 8 years.

Moyes was a wise and risk-averse manager and our team under him gradually improved in-line with the increasing money in the premiership. For that I'll always be grateful. But much like people who bought their houses at the right time, diligantly paid the mortgage and gradually refurbished the place to then find they'd made 300% on their original investment... I don't think too much genius can be attributed to his tenure.

Max Fine
172 Posted 25/08/2013 at 02:44:58
Tony (459): if we're playing the nit-picking game I said we yo-yo'd between 7th and 17th for "the majority of the time". I'd still call six or even five consecutive seasons of not finishing within 5 places of where you did the year before, a majority.
Max Fine
176 Posted 25/08/2013 at 03:05:56
To "yo-yo": To undergo frequent abrupt shifts or reversals.

Moyes first seven seasons, in date oder: 15th, 7th, 17th, 4th, 11th, 6th, 5th.

Majority of seven: Anything over three and a half

I'll let you try and fit it all together yourself... or I could just repeat it three times if you'd rather

Max Fine
177 Posted 25/08/2013 at 03:12:40
And but for a superb performance in the West Brom goal by Ben Foster, we'd have won comfortably yesterday.

Paul Ward
178 Posted 25/08/2013 at 03:33:31
I endorse Richard Dodd's (273) comments about yesterdays game being a David Moyes team and display. The quicker RM stamps his own style on the team, the better for all of us.

What Moyes and Man Utd have done is disgusting but, as I said weeks ago, it will once again suite bullshit Bill. Baines and/or Fellaini will go and as usual it will be too late to buy anyone of note.

Andrew Cutler
179 Posted 25/08/2013 at 05:06:28
We have drawn 17 of our last 40 games... that's 17 points out of a possible 51... enough said.
Paul Andrews
180 Posted 25/08/2013 at 07:03:18
Two games Martinez has had to impose his style on the players.
TWO GAMES
Steve Pugh
181 Posted 25/08/2013 at 08:15:38
Ross Barkley didn't make a single mistake Ciaran, FFS the kid did ok that's it. Not as good as the Norwich game, missed passes, dwelt on the ball too long at times. Some dodgy tackles and I can't recall a shot on target.
Raymond Fox
182 Posted 25/08/2013 at 08:46:53
Barkley has a lot to learn, he was good in patches but hes a long way short of the finished article.
If you kept your eyes on him, instead of the ball, you'd see hes not making himself available, hes not finding space when off the ball.
That was key to match yesterday, too many players were too static, who ever had the ball were finding it difficult to make any telling passes.
Mike Hughes
183 Posted 25/08/2013 at 08:41:41
Max #461

Cold light of day and all that.

I'm now about to watch the game on MoTD. You are right that it can look very different with edited highlights of the match. I've just observed that we're only second last on MoTD so the BBC must have seen positives as well. My obstructed view in the TB isn't that bad though so not that hopeful.

We're saying the same thing - 2 games not enough for transition - but with a different slant. My wider point is that the Prem is an expensive place for radical experiments especially with 4 points already dropped from winnable games. He's effectively putting out the same DM team (with the exception of RB) with a different mandate (i.e. pass, pass, pass) and it's cost us. A more gradual change required.

It's early days. RM does need time but it has not been a good start IMHO. I didn't see as many positives in the game as you did I'm afraid. I hope it does come good.

(On my previous response to you in the early hours, I blanked out the swearing to mirror your note to me. However, it's magically appeared in full this morning making it look more aggressive than intended. I'm not getting into an on-line handbag fight as life's too short.)

Sam Hoare
184 Posted 25/08/2013 at 08:58:51
I have a feeling that we may see Martinez best results this season against the better teams. Wigan frequently pulled off good results against the top teams only to drop points to the less adventurous ones and perhaps that pattern will continue initially at Everton.

Against teams that are happy to sit back and be well organised we definitely need a bit more spark in the final third. Barkley may get there but it is alot to ask him to provide it consistently at his age. Really we rely on Pienaar and Mirallas as Jelavic can finish (supposedly) and that is it. I think Kone will give us more movement and hopefully Deulofeu can add something when he is a bit more settled.

If we had a forward three of say Mirallas, Deulofeu and Kone then that would certainly give us pace to counter with but then that requires less patience and a more direct approach at times.

Paul Andrews
185 Posted 25/08/2013 at 09:14:22
Raymond,

He is a long way sort of the finished article because he is 19 and played a handful of games.
I disagree with your thoughts re him finding space.
The hardest way to find space is by sometimes standing still.
I thought he did that several times yesterday

Mick Long
186 Posted 25/08/2013 at 09:29:37
Raymond if you watched him yesterday he was the only player making himself available from throw ins and regulary had to come deep to collect the ball from defence as Fellaini and osman were often missing...

We should sell felli and baines and build a team around this kid

Ciarán McGlone
187 Posted 25/08/2013 at 09:42:33
Raymond and Pugh.. both wrong.

He was always making himself available.. had shots on target and the tackle he got carded for was a good tackle.

Open your eyes.

Ciarán McGlone
188 Posted 25/08/2013 at 09:42:33
Raymond and Pugh.. both wrong.

He was always making himself available.. had shots on target and the tackle he got carded for was a good tackle.

Open your eyes.

Paul Smith
189 Posted 25/08/2013 at 09:56:37
Have to agree with #523: I thought (and I'm paraphrasing here) that 'Barkley was our best player yesterday'.

There where a lot of players stood about not looking for the ball especially from throw in's. Ross made himself available always, and a few of the more,so called, senior players should take note.

The positives: we never got beat, clean sheet and Ross Barkley is immense. Oh and it was great to be back at Goodison.

COYB

Phil Sammon
190 Posted 25/08/2013 at 10:36:19
Incredible that people can have a go at Barkley after yesterday's performance. Laughable really.

He's 19 and this is maybe the second time he's started consecutive games.

As for him not finding space. He spent 90 minutes finding it and demanding the ball.

He's 19!

Kieran Fitzgerald
191 Posted 25/08/2013 at 10:20:49
West Brom came to play for a draw yesterday and we gave it to them on a plate. My biggest fear with Martinez pre season was that he would learn anything about adaptability after being relegated with Wigan. I was prepared to be patient with him implementing a new style if he was ready to change things if it wasn't working. Yesterday, against a team playing for a draw, he didn't change anything. Instead of changing to two up front, and being a bit more direct, he stuck to the same tactic and got nowhere.

Paul Merson covered the game on Gillette soccer Saturday yesterday. His analysis at the end was that Felliani wasn't used at all in the game. His ability to hold the ball up last season was what made him such a great player. Our one clear cut chance came when a cross field ball was played into his chest in the box towards the end of the game and he hit the post. This highlighted Merson's point for me.

Martinez had the chance to revert back to a tactic like playing quality ball to Felliani playing in an advanced position, and he ignored it. That's criminal.

Also, if one up front clearly wasn't working against a team set up for a draw, change it. Did he, no.

I won't continue to give the guy slack if he is this inflexible and one dimensional. If we gave Moyes crap for this, why should we treat a different manager any differently?

Thomas Windsor
192 Posted 25/08/2013 at 10:28:48
The pace of the first half was like a practise match, it was far to slow.

What we are used to at Goodison is getting the ball in the box as fast as we can, which gets the crowd up for it, but this slow, slow, slow football I'm convinced will not work for Everton supporters. The Old Lady won't be rocking very often under this type of football if Martinez continues playing it.

Chris Morris
193 Posted 25/08/2013 at 10:41:43
Barkley stood out whilst doing 3 jobs yesterday. His own, Fellaini's and Osman's. At times they got into the game& Fellaini got better as it went on but right from the start Barkley was picking up their pieces.

Osman, in this system simply doesn't work. I have always liked his ability at controlling a football and shifting it with either foot (even scoring the odd goal) but under Moyes he was allowed to do that. Under Martinez he's finding it more difficult to be that player because everybody else is doing the same thing. I suspect when Gibson comes back he'll be dropped.

As for Fellaini, if he wants out then accept the right offer and use the money to secure Barkley & a replacement. He can be unplayable at times, but at other times he can be incredibly average. Yesterday for the most part he was the latter. If we could replace him with a McCarthy type midfielder (who I thought last year was one of the best in the league again) then it's got to be worth considering.

It's Coleman I dread leaving the most

Brent Stephens
194 Posted 25/08/2013 at 11:15:37
Cant make a real judgement on Roberto after 2 games. We'll wait and see. Curate's egg - I was reet bored at times; at other times, esp with some Ross touches, it looked good. Very slow build up from back - we need somebody who can deliver that quick pass that breaks the gain line.

Giving Ross a run is great. I'm excited by him - strength, good touch, some pace,and willing to shoot on sight of goal. He had a really good first half, I thought. Coleman also excites. Mirallas and Jelli, very poor. I don't know why for some Osman is the only one getting it in the neck. Very few decent performances there today.

Interesting that Roberto did some things like Moyes. All back at corners - Jelli cleared at least once from the box. Nais on a sub. There has to be more to this guy than we can see (do don't know what the new DeI boy is like but would be interested to see. Interesting Oviedo not on bench - injured? Or is Del boy even better? If so, why no Del boy as sub instead of Nais?

But three up for our corners?!


Paul Andrews
195 Posted 25/08/2013 at 11:37:33
Kieran,

You are prepared to be patient but have lost patience after 2 games?

To play the style of football we play we need a centre forward who can hold the ball up.
Jelavic is not that player

Mike Powell
196 Posted 25/08/2013 at 11:33:26
If a Moyes team played like that, he would've got slated. I don't want to slag Martinez yet but, after their first two games, we have been piss poor. We need to be quicker and get down the wings, get more players in the box. Three players in their box at a corner, ffs!!!
Kevin Tully
198 Posted 25/08/2013 at 11:55:26
Definitely a case of players not properly drilled. They didn't know when to go forward or sit back. Terrible presence in the box when attacking, crosses were coming over to one man vs four.

Changes needed to be made earlier in the game, as we were clearly toothless, can't understand why he left it so late.

Poor, poor performance 5/10.

Dan McKie
199 Posted 25/08/2013 at 12:07:51
Think I echo what a few have already said, we were slow, there was no urgency until about the 85th minute and we were no threat from set pieces. I don't want a manager to play the nice guy all the time, but I just can't picture anything else from Martinez.

A few have said Foster was man of the match, but for what? Making a few very routine saves? People mention 20 odd shots, but most were no threat whatsoever to the goal. Apart from the Fellaini chance, were there many, or any clear-cut goal scoring opportunities?

Possession stats, and number of shots from 25 yards get you nothing. The shite had 3 shots all game yesterday and won. We can't let silly stats cloud something that just wasn't good enough.

Steve Pugh
200 Posted 25/08/2013 at 14:29:10
Ciaran, why am I wrong for saying he wasn't perfect? I never said he was poor, I was simply pointing out that your comment about him not making a single mistake was misguided. Do you honestly not remember a single mistake in the entire game, or did you only watch the highlights?

Be realistic about the kid, he is a really big talent but he isn't there yet.

Ciarán McGlone
201 Posted 25/08/2013 at 16:33:51
Steve,

You're wrong in your analysis...the most obviously erroneous conclusion you make is not seeing a single shot on target from him..

I didn't say he was the finished article...I said he was my MOTM...

You on the other hand said he was 'ok' and then crticised most facets of his game - shooting, passing, tackling and dribbling..

James Martin
202 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:06:35
After a while its time stop blaming the manager. How many good positions did Baines and Coleman get into in the match? How many good crosses did we see from either of them? None that I can remember. How many chances did our players pass up to shoot from distance or shoot at the wrong times? How many corners did we have that Baines underhit or floated right to the keeper?

Martinez can only do so much but ultimately he's facing exactly the same problems Moyes faced trying to make a silk purse out of a sows ear. A lot of the players including some that we would class as our better ones are just not good enough to win with the regularity we want them to. That is a fact that has been borne out countless times. They just don't have enough end product either in terms of making assists or finishing chances. The problem is there's always someone to blame, its always Moyes' fault or Osman's fault or Martinez's fault. Ever thought that its just a collective fault? Better than average players with a better than average manager surprise surprise end up in a better than average league position. The harsh reality is that at one time you could say we had maybe 2 or 3 class players in the team in Lescott and Arteta ably supported by Jagielka and Pienaar in their primes. Now you look round the 11 and you struggle to think of many that would get in the top sides. Perhaps Barkley one day and maybe Baines if he could ever get back to his form of 2 seasons ago. None of our strikers would which when you consider that teams like Villa and Swansea could boast that is rather disconcerting.

I think Martinez will do a good job here but ultimately how far do people realistically expect him to go in his first season when you consider what he's got to work with. I'm not saying its a bad squad, I'm just saying as a fan base we might consider them to be better than they really are which might be why we're so often disappointed.

Dick Brady
203 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:25:54
I'm watching Cardiff against Man City now and let me tell you Cardiff are no push overs. City are really struggling to break them down. I think Cardiff away is going to be a very difficult fixture for every Premier League team.

So anyway Everton's next League game is Cardiff away. If we come unstuck there then the next game after that is Chelsea. And we all know only too well how much Chelsea (and Frank Lampard) love playing against Everton.

We are in a position where we could easily find ourselves winless after 4 games. It's most worrying if Roberto wants to do as well as last year and finish in the Top 6.

Mark Tanton
204 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:32:22
I agree Dick, but I was thinking while watching - at least they'll play football, like Norwich and unlike WBA. Cardiff could be a more enjoyable and more winnable game in my eyes. Cardiff are clearly a decent side, unlike the utterly woeful Palace.
Ross Edwards
205 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:37:35
Cardiff leading 2-1.
Dick Brady
206 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:36:50
Cardiff are on the verge of beating Man City!!

I bet Roberto cannot wait till next weekend now.

Cardiff (a), Chelsea (h) and then West Ham (a). Will we be in the relegation zone after 5 games??

How much will Roberto regret the points lost to Norwich and West Brom?

Phil Sammon
207 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:33:52
...then it's West Ham away and Newcastle at home. That's followed by a trip to Man City and then a tie with Hull. Villa away will be tough and then its CL hopefuls Spurs....lets just write the whole season off because we've drawn our first two games.

*The above may contain traces of sarcasm.

Dick Brady
208 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:39:06
It's all very well justifying a bad result due to teething problem's and transitional problems.

But Moyes set the bar establishing Everton a Top 6 side.

The chances of Roberto maintaining that Top 6 expectations are slowly slipping away one disappointing game after another.

Dick Brady
209 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:42:35
I am not anti-Roberto. I really hope he does well but make no mistake I'll be pissed if Everton start slipping down the league.

Moyes led Everton to a Top 6 finish and that wasn't good enough in many fans eyes because many of you wanted him out.

So if a Top 6 finish isn't good enough why should we accept anything less from Roberto??

Ross Edwards
210 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:45:53
3-1 Cardiff now. Next week could be tough indeed.
Dick Brady
211 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:45:58
Cardiff City 3-1 Man City.

Roberto just shit himself.

Phil Sammon
212 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:44:00
Did Moyes often get our seasons off to a flyer Dick?

I know we have some belters on this site, but you are far and away the most delusional fellow to grace the pages of ToffeeWeb. Everything points to impending doom doesn't it?

Ross Edwards
213 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:48:33
You say you aren't Anti Roberto Dick, but you are having a damn good go at slagging him off.
Ross Edwards
214 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:51:03
Spot on Phil. You say you are worried about Cardiff Dick but didn't His Moyesyness lose to Reading last season and QPR the season before when they were promoted?
Michael Kenrick
215 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:48:36
Dick,

Latest news: Everton are already slipping down the table:

6th, 10th, 14th if Cardiff win...

Do the maths!!!

Dick Brady
216 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:49:26
No Phil we did not always get off to a remarkable start under David Moyes. In fact sometimes we were bloody awful. But Moyes had an uncanny knack of inspiring Everton to terrific form in the second half of the season.

What are the chances of Roberto also having that knack??

Everything doesn't point to impending doom at all. Just midseason mediocracy.

I'm sorry if I seem down on Roberto. I genuinely don't want him to fail. I want him to succeed and better Moyes.

But I love Everton and seeing the Top 6 standard starting to slip worries me. I supported Everton through the Walter Smith year's and I don't want to go back to a middle-to-lower league finish.

Barry Rathbone
217 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:49:53
Dick 710, because he's trying to change things so we don't endure another 11 years pathetically frothing about the useless, potless "best of the rest" and win something.

Thinking such monumental change comes overnight and is without risk is great fun as a parlour game but bears no relationship to reality.

Yeh, you are one of the beauts if you think otherwise.

Ross Edwards
218 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:56:21
Roberto had the knack with Wigan Dick to have a strong finish to the season and stay up against all odds.
Ian Glassey
219 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:48:38
FFS people we are two games in to the new season and everyone wants
Roberto out give the man a chance.

Who else do you think would take this job,working under a shit chairman.
No money no chance of getting any money players being pinched from us, just give the man till January at least.

Ross Edwards
220 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:57:38
Sam, have you entered the TW league? If so, how are you getting on?
Phil Sammon
221 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:55:39
Look at that stupid bastard in charge at Cardiff. He's on the pitch now taking in the applause. Cringe! For a millisecond I actually thanked my stars that our chairman is only every caught gushing in the stands.
James Stewart
222 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:54:43
We have a top 6 defence.

A mid table midfield.

And bottom six strikers if you can even call them that.

Dick Brady
223 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:57:43
Barry I'm all for Roberto making changes and winning something but surely we should expect him to make those changes over time. The important thing is not to let the standards slip while those changes are being introduced.

Roberto has all the players at his disposal (except Phil Neville) and knows they are capable of a Top 6 finish. Should we not expect him to lead this team to the Top 6 once again?

What worries me about Roberto so far is that all his decisions have not added anything to Everton.

He's added four players to the squad who are unable to get into the side. And his tippy tappy football seems to make it more difficult to score then the direct style we saw under Moyes, which while not particulary easy on the eyes (although at times Everton were sublime under Moyes) was at least effective.

I think we all hoped Jelavic would rediscover his form under Martinez. Many believed Moyes was to blame for Jelavic's poor form last season but watching Jelavic yesterday he was as ineffective as he's ever been.

Dick Brady
224 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:05:19
Ian Glassey, I totally agree we need to give Roberto more time.

But Everton were a Top 6 when Moyes quit. Are you seriously telling me a Top 6 English Premier League Club was not an attractive opportunity for many managers around the world?

How many managers would love to get their hands on a Top 6 English Premier League team??

But Kenwright never looked and seemed only to have eyes for Roberto Martinez. Apparently there was a short list of three but let's be honest, Roberto was a shoe-in from Day 1.

I wish Kenwright had sold the "Top 6 English Premier League side" angle to top managers around Europe instead of just giving the job to a guy who lead his team to relegation last season.

Patrick Murphy
226 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:05:16
Dick exactly what are these changes that he has made in the first two games? Yes he's playing Felli depper, but that is what we bought him for in the first place it's his natural position.

Most recognise that without Gibson, Everton just don't tick properly. So perhaps that is also why Felli is playing deeper.

I hope you don't get what you want which by the sound of it despite your protestations is for Everton to be in a relegation battle. But remember if we go down we may never ever come back up again.

We didn't get carried away by our good start last season so why should we push the panic button just yet. I watched Spurs and they were all huff and puff but didn't really create many chances but they had that little bit of luck we haven't yet had this season which saw them win 1-0 via a penalty - two weeks running.

Lack of financial clout is Everton's problem not whoever is the manager.

Daniel Lawrence
227 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:12:05
We may have been top 6 last season but as per usual, the manager gas been woefully let down by a truly inept board at a time when the cash is flowing in and all around have or certainly will have spent millions and millions to improve
James Martin
228 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:09:03
Dick lots of people believed that all the problems at Everton were down to Moyes. Jelavic was poor yesterday because the same problem remains as last season, the build up play is so slow that Jelavic is congested in the box with all 11 of the opposition team whilst we pass it around them like some sort of ice hockey power play. Its exactly what we used to do under Moyes as well (contrary to popular belief). The only outlet then becomes a full back crossing in its just a shame that both of our full backs have lost the ability to put in a decent ball (Don't think one was hit first time yesterday).

It will be intriguing to see how Martinez goes about solving these but at the moment he seems to be doing similar things. Same players, same formation, same substitutions at the same time, same route to goal (either a long ball or releasing the full back, we've still seen nothing through the middle regardless of how many passes along the back we do). I long for the days when we see a creaitve mid get on the ball, turn a man and thread a through ball to a fast forward who breaks the trap and bangs it in. None of this getting to the by line and hanging balls up at the back post nonsense.

Ross Edwards
229 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:14:57
Dick, even Guardiola would struggle to change our philosophy overnight.
Dick Brady
230 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:13:52
I don't want Everton relegated Patrick. I still get cold sweats thinking back to that day we were 2-0 down at half time at Selhurst Park.

I just don't want the standards to slip. I be disappointed if we don't finish in the Top 6 again but anything outside the Top 8 would be a disaster this season.

I think what Roberto needs is to give Stevenage a good stuffing on Wednesday. And I'd start Kone and drop Jelavic. Get Kone his first Everton goal and hope it kickstarts the goals for Cardiff and Chelsea.

Patrick Murphy
231 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:19:19
Did they have a big screen at Selhurst Park Dick?
Dick Brady
232 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:18:56
James you claim 'I long for the days when we see a creaitve mid get on the ball, turn a man and thread a through ball to a fast forward who breaks the trap and bangs it in.'

Is that not what Ross Barkley is supposed to be doing?

It's not fair to put too much pressure on the young lad but surely that's why he's in the team?

Barry Rathbone
233 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:08:34
Dick, you're coming from a position of our standards were good - I don't agree.

Based on predominantly defensive, dour football with a craven attitude to certain managers and teams we were built to fail and when it mattered didn't we just.

You say give him time ... for what? Ring the changes without a mistake?

Time means accepting we will have downs as well as ups criticism based upon sanctifying the lying get who preceded RM (which is happening) is treacherous and plain unfair.

Not acknowledging the disgusting manoeuvrings resultant of Moyes desperation at utd in all this is head right in the sand.

Give the guy a fair go - Rome wasn't built in a day (Wimpeys weren't paying cash in hand then)

Ross Edwards
234 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:22:24
" Rome wasn't built in a day....

but then again I wasn't on that particular job" (Brian "Old Big 'Ead Clough)

Ian Glassey
235 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:14:00
Dick I agree that Kenwright did not push the top six angle properly but do you honestly think a top manager would take the job?.
The first thing they would want to know is how much they had to spend, and that would be the end of the job interview.
We have got what we can afford which is not much, but lets give him are support..
Jamie Barlow
236 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:20:56
Very good Patrick.

James, I wouldn't mind a cross from either Baines or Coleman being hung up at the back post every now and again. Every cross seems to be a cut back. No variations. It like watching a load of robots play football. I thought Martinez might have let them off the leash a bit more than I've seen. Early days yet though.

Dick Brady
237 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:21:27
Patrick I never went to the game. I was only 15 back then.

But that was when I was at my most passionate about Everton. I never supported Everton harder then I did when I was 15.

I used to avoid cracks in the pavement because I was scared walking on them would make Everton lose. I was obsessed with Everton back then.

I remember that weekend very well and it was frightening and then pure bliss.

Dick Brady
238 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:25:17
If we couldn't get a Top Manager then my choice for the job was always Phil Neville.

But your all correct. Its early days yet. I will try to be more positive and give Roberto a fair and decent chance.

Love to see him do something Man City couldn't and take all 3 points from Cardiff.

Ross Edwards
239 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:30:26
And you thought Phil Neville would have done a better job Dick?

I've seen it all now.

Colin Glassar
240 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:32:22
Phil Neville? What a dick!!

Sorry dick, I couldn't avoid that.

Sam Hoare
241 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:43:35
Ross, was that to me? If so the answer is no. Whats the pin? Had a disastrous weekend.
Ross Edwards
242 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:48:55
Your name's Sam isn't it?
Sam Hoare
243 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:52:14
Yeah, just that I posted the FF reference along time ago and I know there are other sams on here. Been a long day.
Ross Edwards
244 Posted 25/08/2013 at 18:54:35
Sorry if that sounded a tad sarcastic there Sam.
Raymond Fox
245 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:59:32
Re Barkley I know he's only 19, that's my point, he had a excellent game at Norwich so I'm told (only seen highlights) scored an outstanding goal as well, and he becomes a star that can do no wrong.
The lad will become a very good player in time, he shows flashes of brilliance but there's aspects of his game that are lacking.
I purposely kept my eyes on him for most of the game, and if some of you judged that he was finding space consistently well, I would test your eyesight (is there anywhere to see a full recording of the match)?
Do you think RM and his staff will not point out to him what he needs to improve!

He might be our big hope for the future, but don't make him beyond criticism.

Sam Hoare
246 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:01:09
Think i've joined it now. Equal 30th. Dunno out of how many...
Ross Edwards
247 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:04:29
Sam

Very good. I'm 228th!! Mid table mediocrity.

James Martin
248 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:10:07
He is Dick and that is what Barkley would be capable of, but who is he going to play the balls through to? Mirallas just seems to be taking a holiday on his touchline. Pienaar never ventures into the box and Jelavic won't be running past anyone any time soon. He's also not going to play someone in with his back to goal waiting for Fellaini to find him (which he never does) rather than going sideways all the time.
Richard Dodd
249 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:18:00
I'm hearing two clubs want to take Oviedo off our hands so let's hope Bainsey is staying!

Interest also in Mirallas and Jelavic and if they and ' The Manyou 2' disappear it looks like Roberto will have a busy 48 hours next weekend!

Ross Edwards
250 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:34:16
Is Moyes FC one of them Doddy?
Mark Tanton
251 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:35:25
I don't know why we wasted two years of Oviedo's career - the amount of playing time he's had is pathetic, even for a player playing understudy to a world class lad like Baines. Did Moyes sign him when Bayern where sniffing around Baines?
Richard Dodd
252 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:37:47
No idea,Ross but I can't see OFM being interested in Oviedo.I don't think he ever gave him a Premier start.

We may learn more from Monday's papers.

Mark Frere
253 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:36:36
I really hope Oviedo is staying put and will be given a few opportunities this season. Oviedo's continual absence from our match day squad has always confused me. All I can think of is he must look look terrible in training, because he's always impressed when out on the pitch.

Naismith must look like one hell of a player in training

Ross Edwards
254 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:43:38
You never know Doddy, he might make a Quintuple bid for Jela, Baines, Felli, Super Kev and Oviedo for £30 million.

He's panicking.

Richard Dodd
255 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:48:30
......and he's got to be keen to sign Naismith !
Phil Walling
256 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:51:37
Bloody hell, Ross if all that lot go to OT, your hero will be able to sign the complete Wigan team!

ps: The only one I rate is the big centre-forward, Holt, and his successor signed him!

Ross Edwards
257 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:56:02
He's not my hero Phil. I'm just doing what every other Evertonian is doing. Getting behind him and supporting him. You should try it some time.
Ross Edwards
258 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:57:07
And Osman Doddy!
Richard Dodd
259 Posted 25/08/2013 at 19:50:33
No,he's my fave !
Ross Edwards
260 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:04:04
Richard

Ok, not Ossie then. Anichebe? And flog him for £35 million?

Richard Dodd
261 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:07:09
Victor would look ace alongside Van Persie !
Ross Edwards
262 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:13:41
Doddy

Maybe we should make a £10 million plus Naismith bid for Rooney to annoy OFM

Phil Walling
263 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:00:15
Cut it out,you two ! You are dissing our players !
Ross Edwards
264 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:19:15
And you are dissing our manager after 2 games.
Dick Brady
265 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:18:05
Its weird how you all assume Oviedo is such a good player. How can you judge how good he is from the few cameos he's made?

Personally I have no idea how good Oviedo either is or isn't.

I prefer to trust the judgement of the manager who sees the player every single day. And both Moyes and Martinez feel Oviedo isn't good enough to make the team.

Is that coincidence? Could the talk backers on ToffeeWeb know more about Oviedo then both Moyes and Martinez?

Jamie Crowley
266 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:17:01
A day later...

We dominated (basically)
Ben Foster stood on his head - we shoulda won 2 or 3-0
We need a CM desperately
We have been very unlucky our first two games
We need an end-product

It's not the end of the world, and we've not looked that bad frankly. We've outplayed our two opponents and I believe the goals will come. On our budget and with our personnel they won't come as much as any of us will want, but they will come.

And so will a very deserved three points.

Raymond Fox
267 Posted 25/08/2013 at 21:06:55
What small amount of play I've seen of Oviedo, I agree he's looked excellent.

May be the reason he's not in RMs plans is his behaviour/attitude off the pitch.
If it is, he wont be the first sportsman to have bags of talent, but spoil his career because of a lack of dedication.

Just a guess, I've absolutely no evidence that above is true.

Tony Draper
268 Posted 25/08/2013 at 20:47:45
Jamie C, that's pretty much where my thinking is... and my biggest draw of breath is "The Goals", 'cos I genuinely am not confident that (in order) Tolos, Vic, Steven, Kevin, Arouna or Nikica are going to burst into life. And the reason that I fear that is threefold:

First, other clubs just aren't siffing them up, and I'm not convinced that any of them are a possible Bob Latchford, not even for a season.

Second, the supply we deliver today just would not get Bob his 30, probably not 15 (he never took penalties, apart from #30).

Third, and the harshest goal scoring rule of all, the more that scorers score, the more that scorers can score.

Our tactics of "folding our hand" when we had our noses in front didn't affect Jelavic at first, 'cos in Scotland scoring was a piece of piss and he expected to score. The reason DM's strikers all started on fire then stalled was because they were all allowed, maybe even encouraged to fall into bad (ie, non-scoring) habits. Case in point: strikers back defending corners? (No-one left up). So therefore no possibility of them scoring on the break... Meaning no match practice of carrying the ball and creating pressure the other end (but also creating that fearful uncertainty in the opposition). Meaning no subsequent "breakaway" corner complete with "opportunity & threat" for a striker.

Continual tracking back for set pieces requiring prize striker to make their way back up front from 18 yards, draining their energy for that magical extra yard when needed in the pay zone.

I do not want our strikers back defending, I want 'em scoring bloody hat-tricks

If I wanted "versatility" then get Howard to get himself into their box at the next free kick and corner. I do not want versatility, that's a euphemism for "compromise".

Mark Tanton
269 Posted 25/08/2013 at 21:53:45
He had a good pre-season though Raymond?
Phil Walling
270 Posted 25/08/2013 at 22:31:06
If you think back,he was good last pre-season.too,Mark ! It's when the real thing starts that he becomes an embarrassment.
Back to his homeland soon,I hope. He'll be a star in the new Scottish Conference.
Mark Tanton
271 Posted 25/08/2013 at 22:40:33
I was talking Oviedo not Naismith. I don't think there's anything left to say about Naismith apart from, to quote Blackadder "Please please, stop."
Ross Edwards
272 Posted 25/08/2013 at 22:50:12
"He'll be a star in the new Scottish Conference."

The Scottish Conference is too high a level for him.

Phil Walling
273 Posted 25/08/2013 at 23:10:08
As Elvis used to sing,Ross 'Don't be cruel'.
Steve Pugh
274 Posted 26/08/2013 at 08:57:25
Ciaran 675, what you actually said was that you couldn't remember him making a single mistake (#296). That is what I was arguing against. He did make mistakes, quite a few, he might still have been your man of the match but he was nowhere near as good as he was a Carrow Road and he made mistakes.

If you feel I was unclear I apologise but I don't think he played as well as you obviously do.

Drew Shortis
275 Posted 26/08/2013 at 10:50:41
I was even more disappointed by this result than the Norwich one as I thought we should have taken all three points. Early on we had a lot of possession but didn't make use of it enough to get shots in on goal. We were not brave enough. The problem with not gambling a little early on to get ourselves in front is that teams like West Brom will smell the possibility of a point away at Goodison and fight like hell for what they see as a good result. We may often think of ourselves as underdogs in this league due to our financial constraints, but after consistently finishing in the top seven over the past few years other teams see us a big scalp and will take a 0-0. We need to find a ruthlessness in our game, especially at home.

For me Osman is not good enough in the deeper midfield role and we need Gibson fit again asap and we need another midfielder who is a natural in that role. I don't see Jelavic as the lone striker. He either needs a partner to play alongside or we need to put Vic or Kone in that riole. Mirallas is not up to speed yet and we miss his flair and direct running. The sooner he improves the better.

On the positive side we never really looked like losing either game and should have taken six points by now. It will take a little time to adapt to Roberto's methods and he is still learning as much as the players are. Once the transfer window closes the off field distractions will be gone until January. We are probably doing better after two games than we did for a majority of seasons under Moyes (bar last year) and it is too early to over react. Keep the faith and the results will come.

I think I have wangled a ticket for the Cardiff game, the only problem is that its from a Bluebirds season ticket holder who sits in the Canton end. If we score the winner and I go mental I may end up posting comments from the hospital, eek!

Drew Shortis
276 Posted 26/08/2013 at 10:50:41
I was even more disappointed by this result than the Norwich one as I thought we should have taken all three points. Early on we had a lot of possession but didn't make use of it enough to get shots in on goal. We were not brave enough. The problem with not gambling a little early on to get ourselves in front is that teams like West Brom will smell the possibility of a point away at Goodison and fight like hell for what they see as a good result. We may often think of ourselves as underdogs in this league due to our financial constraints, but after consistently finishing in the top seven over the past few years other teams see us a big scalp and will take a 0-0. We need to find a ruthlessness in our game, especially at home.

For me Osman is not good enough in the deeper midfield role and we need Gibson fit again asap and we need another midfielder who is a natural in that role. I don't see Jelavic as the lone striker. He either needs a partner to play alongside or we need to put Vic or Kone in that riole. Mirallas is not up to speed yet and we miss his flair and direct running. The sooner he improves the better.

On the positive side we never really looked like losing either game and should have taken six points by now. It will take a little time to adapt to Roberto's methods and he is still learning as much as the players are. Once the transfer window closes the off field distractions will be gone until January. We are probably doing better after two games than we did for a majority of seasons under Moyes (bar last year) and it is too early to over react. Keep the faith and the results will come.

I think I have wangled a ticket for the Cardiff game, the only problem is that its from a Bluebirds season ticket holder who sits in the Canton end. If we score the winner and I go mental I may end up posting comments from the hospital, eek!

Frida Ericsson
277 Posted 26/08/2013 at 21:07:44
We needed to bring in a couple of pacey midfielders. Instead we have the same usual suspects, who so far seem to have a lack of creativity.

Ross has been magnificent for Everton so far, yes there are some elements of his game he needs to improve on, but for me he is going to be a really top player.


Jelly, Kone and Anichebe.. If thats all we have available because RM won't sell other players, I already fear for the rest of the season.

Osman needs to be moved on, should have buggered off with Neville in my opinion. I just don't think he is good enough anymore.

This is a really serious question. Does Tim Howard suffer from a lack of spatial awareness? He has a player in front of him, instead of passing it to him, and building from the back, he just hoofs right up the pitch and usually to the opposition. All he does is invite them to attack us all over again. I know at times he has passed the ball out to players, but I don't understand why he more or less always seems to hoof the ball up the park, inviting the opposition back on to us?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb