Tentative Everton still lack cutting edge

, 31 August, 311comments  |  Jump to most recent
Cardiff City 0 - 0 Everton

Everton ground out a second successive goalless draw as they again failed to turn impressive dominance into the goals needed to claim their first victory under Roberto Martinez.

They were let down by typically awful refereeing by Anthony Taylor who waved away a stonewall penalty by Gary Medel on Leighton Baines but a lack of incisiveness and directness resulted in just two real chances for Nikica Jelavic who saw a header brilliantly saved by Marshall and a stabbed effort fly over the bar.

Match Summary

Everton's quest for a first Premier League win of the season moves to South Wales and a top-flight clash with Cardiff City for the first time in 52 years. The first-team regulars who watched from the bench or the stands in midweek — Seamus Coleman, Sylvain Distin, Tim Howard, Kevin Mirallas and Steven Pienaar — all return to the starting line-up with Fellaini and Baines on the teamsheet in an unchanged side. Darron Gibson resumed full training but wouldn't be risked after recovering from a knee injury and Victor Anichebe still out of contention. Arouna Kone started on the substitute's bench again leaving Nikica Jelavic trying to break his duck so far this season.

The game started in the now expected fashion, with Everton retaining possession from the kick-off and passing across the back until Jagielka hoofed it upfield and Everton lost possession! But a couple of free-kicks saw them mount the first attack that should have brought a corner. And on the second attack, Jelavic was in an all-too-familiar offside position.

More excruciatingly slow PATB saw possession lost as soon as the ball crossed into Cardiff's half, Bellamy then getting away with a blatant elbow on Baines. But a great move and a brilliant rollback by Pienaar put Barkley in. From the corner, Fellaini got boxed in and then another corner decision was called against Everton, much to the delight of the noisy home crowd.

Cardiff threatened with a couple of excellent corners, Howard clawing out the second whipped in under the Everton bar by Whittingham. Everton then won a corner off a blatant hand-ball, with a few decent crosses played in from the right but all defended away.

Coleman picked up a yellow for a 'professional' foul on Kim, surely his first offence in the game. At least the linesman flagged for a very obvious Campbell offside... Jelavic was fouled as was Kim but no similar punishment; Mirallas headed well over from the free-kick.

An unbelievable sequence with Kim and Barkley evenly vying for a loose ball, Barkley winning it in the end with a superbly executed sliding tackle, saw play stopped by the linesman! and then Barkley booked!!! Then, a blatant trip of Baines inside the box by the animal that is Medel waved away, with Everton not even appealing.

Some more excellent play saw a Jelavic header deflected by Turner and then stopped by Marshall, Jelavic looked to get behind the Cardiff defence but he was offside and still could not finish. A hugely frustrating half with some shockingly one-sided refereeing.

Everton escaped a scare after the break, Kim breaking in to the area and firing across but thankfully no-one could follow up for Cardiff. The ref final;lay booked a Cardiff player for a blatant block on Baines

Barkley played in Jelavic nicely but the Croatian spooned his shot horribly. Fellaini and Campbell then tangled, Fellaini coming across a little too strong but no card. Howard stood strong behind Bellamy's free-kick.

Cardiff upped their work rate, snapping at Everton heels and pushing on but Bellamy was called offside. Everton looked ragged as Bellamy got wide of Howard, but then Everton pushed forward and Barkley tried everything he could to make space for a shot in a tight crowd of red shirts.

Jelavic looked to get played in but his ball control was shocking. An excellent set piece, Barkley drove lamely into the wall. Very poor. Mirallas then won another goo free-kick chance, dinked in by Baines, as Kone replaced the hapless Jelavic but his first touch was to give the ball away.

Some Cardiff pressure won a corner, with Kim elbowing Pienaar in the face, forcing the South African off as the kick was fired in well by Whittingham and headed out by Barkley, then forward but again possession relinquished as Everton were allowing Cardiff to pressurize them. Bout Barkley got in a run and was fouled. However, Everton still struggled to fashion that final ball that again eluded them.

Baines intercepted a Cardiff pass and looked to set up an pen move but Barkley, pulling wide, slipped over in the area and the chance evaporated. Everton had another spell of fantastic possession around the Cardiff area without manufacturing a single shot, as Bellamy was substituted.

Another attack looked to get closer, Baines crossing well and Fellaini getting the ball forward to Kone who had ventured offside. Fellaini then teed up Baines who smacked it just wide with his right foot. Kim, who had been Cardiff's best player, was then replaced by Menard.

Into the last 10 mins, and Everton showing signs of tiredness and running out of ideas, Martinez leaving it terribly late to bring on Gerard Deulofeu, with Mirallas having something of a nightmare game, the Barca lad finally getting just 5 mins for starters in the Premier League. His first contribution was to make space and whip in a shot that was at least on target, but his next poke was poor, passing it back to Marshall in the Cardiff goal.

Connolly blatantly blocked Baines again but of course no second yellow for an identical second offence. Good defending by Jagielka stopped Campbell doing anything. Ronaldoesque work by Deulofeu won an Everton corner that He whipped in, then it came back to him and he put the most amazing ball across the Cardiff goal... where was Kone? Where was ANYBODY?!?! Unbelievable opportunity just thrown away... Just maddening stuff from a toothless Everton attack, with Martinez once again failing to change things up early enough.

Another incredibly frustrating game from Everton, who once again dominated play and once again failed to create or take chances against a Cardiff team playing well beyond themselves, thanks to a very boisterous crowd and a shockingly biased bunch of homer officials.

Everton: Howard; Coleman Y:20', Distin, Jagielka, Baines; Mirallas (86' Deulofeu), Osman, Fellaini, Barkley Y:38', Pienaar; Jelavic (75' Kone).
Subs not used: Robles, Heitinga, Oviedo, Naismith, Stones.

Cardiff City: Marshall, Connolly Y:49', Taylor, Caulker, Turner, Whitts, Medel (88' Mutch), Campbell, Kim (82' Maynard), Gunnarsson, Bellamy (79' Cowie). Subs not used: Lewis, Hudson, Gestede, Noone.

Attendance: 27,344
Referee: Anthony Taylor

 

Reader Comments (311)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Anto Byrne
1 Posted 31/08/2013 at 12:33:12
I would like RM to play a more tactical game. They will be looking to keep it tight and hit us on the break. Let's keep possession and let them chase the ball and if Gibbo is fit to play defence splitting balls to our pacy forwards. Hmmm... that ain't gonna work, is it?
Derek Knox
2 Posted 31/08/2013 at 14:16:48
I have just seen team selection for today — amazingly he has stuck with the same starters as at Norwich and West Brom, I can't believe how bad Ossie has to get before he get's jettisoned.

I thought after the midweek game he may have started with that set-up, but no, it's same old. I hope not, but something tells me this is going to be harder than it need be.

Kevin Rowlands
3 Posted 31/08/2013 at 14:44:49
Uncle Cyrils nephew is going to bricking it the next couple of hours incase of injuries to you know who, why oh why couldn't Cyril have supported the RS? COYB!
Dan Parker
4 Posted 31/08/2013 at 15:15:19
Everton the only team with no decent striker season in season out. Rubbish so far.
Dan Parker
5 Posted 31/08/2013 at 15:17:10
What a clown the referee is
Nick Entwistle
6 Posted 31/08/2013 at 15:50:46
Slow and ponderous. Doesn't matter if its top flight or Stevenage, I could mark Jely out the game played like this.

Pienaar and Mirallas are not being allowed to run so they're more or less nullified.

Ref is a shocker! 45 to go... quite enjoyable though.

Raymond Fox
7 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:15:03
How/where are you watching this game lads?
Jim Harrison
8 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:45:41
This is fucking atrocious. Fellaini is a terrible deep midfielder. The ref is a complete cock.
John Malone
10 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:45:29
Getting annoyed with Martinez already can't understand why he's leaving it so late to change things when were not scoring. He's stated in the press this week how valuable Fellaini is as a number 10 aswel as a number 4 so why on earth when teams are parking the bus does he not stick him up top and see if we can break the deadlock.
Scott Mongomery
12 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:52:48
So glad we hired an attack-minded manager who would get us playing like Barcelona and scoring loads of goals.

We just look like fecking Wigan. 3 points against Norwich, Brommies, Cardiff.... What a bloody joke.

Robin Cannon
13 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:55:21
We're so completely toothless it's unreal.
Michael Parrington
14 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:34:55
F'in useless...
1. We need a striker
2. Why the hell wasn't Delefeu on for more than 7 mins? With the exception of Barkley, Delefeu did more in 7 mins than the rest did around the box for the preceding 83...

This is as frustrating as watching a Moyes team!

Nick Entwistle
15 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:54:37
I'm not entirely sure where Martinez takes Everton from here. They seem to be playing as instructed, but by abandoning the overlapping play on the flanks and splaying the ball across the back and bossing our own half, goals will be... no, chances will be at a premium.
Karan Oza
16 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:53:11
Really? What a pathetic display. We dominate possession, but can't do anything with the ball at all when it matters. All we do is knock the ball around outside the box. No one wants to take the shot, or make the run that will get us a goal. Martinez's strategy of play in midfield doesn't work, because we're not Barcelona and we can't pass like they do. If he doesn't change something after the international break, then he's a bigger idiot than he looks. This looks like it could be a long season, and I wouldn't blame either Fella or Banies for leaving for a team that can actually do something with the ball.
Paul Mackie
17 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:54:19
You can talk as much as you want about how the ref was terrible and we should have had a penalty but at the end of the day we just didn't create enough chances and the ones we did create we made an utter hash of.

Pienaar, Mirallas and Jelavic were all atrocious today. Kone looked ok when he came on.

As for Martinez, he's playing the same players as we did under Moyes and yet we're playing far worse. 3 games now we've had this tippy tappy bollocks with no end product. If the players we have aren't good enough for the style he wants to play then he's had all summer to sort it out.

Not looking forward to playing some of good teams in the league if we can't even beat the 3 crap teams we've played so far. It's gonna be a long season.

Stuart Eaton
18 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:57:45
This getting serious now 3 of our easiest games and we cant even get a win, sell now and get 3 to 4 new faces in before its too late.
Andy Walker
19 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:58:49
This type of performance should not be a surprise to anyone. Its RM's tradmark at Wigan. It was a massive mistake appointing him.

He is clearly coaching out the instinct to be direct from the players, just look at Mirallas he is overthinking like many others. It is old style european garbage football, and will get us relegated if we arent careful.

Tony I'Anson
20 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:01:02
Hmmm. Worried. Expected 6 or 7 points by now.
Craig Mills
21 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:58:16
So, 4 games in and things are starting to look very worrying. Okay, we haven't lost, but how are we not top of the league with 9 points??? if RM and BK do not see how desperate we are for creation in midfield and a goal scorer, we will be fighting relegation because we cannot score.
Kevin Rowlands
22 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:55:48
Another very frustrating game, this is no longer a slump for Jelavic, he's fucking dog shite, and why was Delo only given 7 minutes? If we do lose F/B in the next 2 days I fear its going to be a long season.
Andy Walker
23 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:01:52
This team finished 6th last year, what a complete reversal. Why.............?
Ross Edwards
24 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:55:49
I know I was one who wanted Moyes out, but I will get one thing straight, I didn't want Martinez, Bielsa, Laudrup and De Boer were my three, but I guess we have to support him.

I know this is a season of transition but he still persists with Moyes' favourites, Jelavic who can't hit a barn door, Osman who is just crap and Pienaar who is rubbish as well.

We are in for a long, tough season. If Martinez says that he is pleased with that then he doesn't understand the principles of Everton. NSNO? Don't think so.

Ref was rubbish as well.

Deulofeu did more in a 7 minute cameo than Mirallas, Barkley, Jelavic, Baines and Pienaar did in 80 minutes.

We need to bring players in or we could be down there scrapping.

Criticise me if you like for being negative after 3 games, but if we keep playing like that, then we are in trouble.

2 goals in 3 games against mid table opposition? Even Moyes didn't reach that nadir.

There is no Plan B, we are so predictable and slow, and when we eventually get there you have 50p heads like Mirallas and Jelavic wasting them.

We desperately need to bring on a striker on Monday. Defoe and Vossen should be considered. We need Gibson back, and we need some creativity in midfield.

Peter Jamieson
26 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:00:24
What happened to all these goals that Martinez's attacking play was going to get us.

3 points, we should 5 as an absolute minimum, but really should be on 7.

It's going o be another long, long season.

Once again per-season hope is turning into apathy.

" meet the new boss, same as the old boss"........................

Stuart Eaton
27 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:02:41
Did we mis hear Martinez when he said Champions league football or was it Championship football he ment. GET IT SORTED
Tony Draper
30 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:56:55
Moyes 11 years and no improvement

Martinez 9 weeks and no deterioration

Not saying that I'm overjoyed at not having managed 3 points so far, but realistically today we were robbed of a pen and should also have been playing 10 men

Those outcomes were not down to any action which Roberto could have affected

But we do need a striker who shoves the ball into the onion bag regardless of whether they are onside/offside

Jon Withey
31 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:56:41
Bizarre watching us, we can pass it around the box all day but teams can just sit in the box and there's no way we'll get through. And they have plenty of time to get back there too !

Deulofeu made a huge difference and Kone made a moderate difference.

Mirallas is actually getting worse each game. Jelavic just isn't the striker for this style.

Sell Fellaini and Baines and we are odds-on for an honorable relegation - with the best possession stats in the league.

In fact, if BK sells those two he's going to relegate us, i'm certain of it.

Positives ? Deulofeu, Howard, Barkley. Osman much tidier than he has been recently.

Phil Davies
32 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:04:49
Anything over £15 million for Baines and I'd be happy to let him go, looks completely uninterested and like he didn't really want to be playing today.

This Formation/Style of play doesn't suit either Kone or Jelavic, both are coming looking for the ball and aren't getting many balls played into them.

Bob Hannigan
33 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:08:31
What has happened to Victor ?
Sean Patton
34 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:06:08
Just no attacking intent at all and if people think there is no cutting edge now just wait until Monday when the top scorer and most creative player we have from last season are sold down the river
Anto Byrne
35 Posted 31/08/2013 at 16:55:41
Look on the bright side: unbeaten, three draws, three points, looked solid at the back and Howard played well.

Baines was our best player by a mile, thought Barkley was okay. Ossie was absent and Mirallas showed glimpses and had two clear cut headers he should have done better with. We really must put these chances away.

I think Kone is more suited to the RM style. As for Fellaini, he was nothing special today.

Patrick Murphy
36 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:09:53
Jelavic has one goal in 25 games, it's got absolutely nothing to do with formations.
Andy Walker
37 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:04:10
I an so fucking frustrated by the situation at our club and the denial of certain fans. Last season when we were winning more often than not, this site was full of the 'ginger tosser' etc brigade who as soon as we didnt win would be on here whinging about the sytle of play. 'We may have won but....'

Well where the fuck are they all now when we really are shit and in trouble and can legitimately whinge? Double standards.

Conn Prosser
38 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:06:58
Relegation form.
Robert Pierpoint
39 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:06:21
Ross- couldn't agree more. I think that Pienaar still has a place, but the whole midfield were missing today. Worrying is the fact that Mirallas and Jelavic are clearly lacking in confidence and belief and this is the beginning of the season.

Relative successes of previous years were built on teams not wanting to play Everton. I sincerely don't believe that this is the case now. If in doubt, get men behind the ball, because we are blunt in the final third.

My biggest annoyance is the positioning of Fellaini. We are clearly struggling, so plan B HAS to be Felliani playing as an advanced 'playmaker'. Hitting balls up to him and playing from there. Why is he just sitting in front of Jagielka at 75 mins when we are chasing the game? It simply means that we are wasting a great attacking threat. I find it absurd. I hate the word 'philosophy' It is hollow. We need to win

Derek Knox
40 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:00:36
Watched as best as I could through livestreaming, (kept stopping and box on screen obscuring centre..........anyway) my main concern, for another game we have dominated, is the lateness of substitutions. Kone and Deulofeu should have been on with 30 mins left, the game was there for the taking, and shocking as the referee was, can't really make that the excuse of not producing in the last third.
Looking positive, if we can, we are still unbeaten, although against teams, we would have been expected to get maximum points, or at least, more than three!
Michael Parrington
42 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:05:28
Sell Jelavic while we can still get £2.50 for him. I've never seen anyone fall over the ball as much. Perhaps he needs glasses because he gets caught offside far too often as well.

Fellaini looked like he was trying not to get injured. I heard he's off on Monday for £26m raising to £30 on appearances. Baines staying.... Although after the start to the season they might want to abandon the sinking ship!

Spend the money on a quick, well balanced striker, please!

Patrick Murphy
43 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:11:32
Andy the fans didn't offer the Ginger Genius the Man United job Alex did, he took it and we had to replace him. Now if you don't like the choice that the board of directors made to replace him, fair enough, but stop blaming fans for what has happened.

Michael Kenrick
45 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:08:15
Very very disappointing on so many levels.

Unless something changes, then by extrapolation, it is going to be a very frustrating transition.

Martinez has shown a maddening reluctance to change things now in three almost identical games with identical starting line-ups, identical gameplans, almost identical and maddeningly late substitutions...

Tearing my hair out after that!!!

Bernard West
46 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:11:35
To me, its a striker we need after today's performance . It seems Martinez is all about statistics than results. There was no Plan B. We are gonna end up in deep trouble if this carries on. If he can't keep hold of Baines and Fellaini, we will be lucky to stay up.
Andy Walker
48 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:13:46
Patrick I am not blaming fans for what has happened, reread what I have written, it wasnt that. I am blaming certain fans who hammered Moyes for being strangley silent when clearly there is now far more reason to be critical than there was last season.
James Martin
49 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:04:33
People are just annoyed that Martinez is not the instant messiah everyone wanted him to be. People want pretty football but won't allow any time for that to be implemented. Ultimately you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.

Some of the players are very poor yet Moyes built a structure within they could win and got lambasted for it. Martinez is trying to implement a way of playing that will allow us to win any game but with the quality of players will not bring consistency. There will be greater highs and lows. Thought that was what everyone wanted. "I don't care what the result is as long as the football's good" hmm... Maybe everyone really wanted the mythical manager who won every game effortlessly.

It wasn't that long ago we lost six games in a row under Moyes. Where is our resilience as fans? We've been through worse, stop crying about a few 0-0s and lets get behind Martinez for better or for worse.

Phil Walling
50 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:07:14
If I was Baines,I'd walk to OT rather than have my game ruined by this clown of a manager.

Anybody he brings in now will be from bloody Wigan where all the Pie eaters were glad to see the back of him !

Ken Finch
51 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:15:25
Dreadful game, only Howard, Jags and Distin get any credit, the rest were poor and not performing. Whilst the ref got the penalty decision wrong, we shouldn't be hanging our hopes on things like that.

As for the next few games......

As for transfers, it could be nail biting stuff to see if we can land anybody better if the Mancs are actually still interested in our 2 best(!) players.

Brent Stephens
52 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:16:04
I'm prepared to see what happens through a "transition period". But I have a few thoughts...

e.g. IF ossie is so bad (I'm no great fan but think many give him stick when unwarranted and ignore others' faults), and IF he should never start as some argue, then why oh why does Roberto start him?! What transition period is needed and why to sort that one?

Second, we're having a lot of possession and territory but not getting decent crosses in, early enough and incisive enough to make clear-cut not half chances and half shots. Again, why is a transition period needed to sort that one? It's not a new tactic, is it?

Brent Stephens
54 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:20:59
James, I think you write wise words, there. My concern is that we won't see the new signings of players who can lay Roberto's system.
Kevin Rowlands
55 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:15:32
Please no more Jelavic is lacking in confidence, he's fucking garbage, makes Vic look like Dixie Dean, we need a new forward badly.
Robert Pierpoint
56 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:19:05
James- Of course Martinez needs to be given time- but a couple of things:

1) If anything, Martinez has brought consistency, and this is the annoying point. He is consistent in the fact that he seems to be sticking blindly to a set up and a philosophy that isn't working. Of course, it should not be scrapped- but there doesn't see, to be a plan B.

2) If we haven't got the players to implement a strategy, then surely the easy solution is to postpone the strategy. He has to work with the players he has got, until players change. With this in mind, until we get a striker who can hold up play, I believe that he has to revert back to Fellaini as a second striker (or he should have!) If he does go, we need to replace his physical power.

Harold Matthews
57 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:19:21
No more Wigan players please.
Patrick Murphy
58 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:16:41
What I'm hoping for in the International break and after the Window closes is that RM stamps his authority on the group as he is in danger of being a bystander while the players dictate what is happening out on the pitch. To my mind the only difference is that the players were frightened to death of DM and are a little less wary of the new guy.
He's given the old-guard their chances and they haven't taken them. I would shift Mirallas out of the club immediately and the same with Jelavic they don't have the right mentality when things aren't going their way. The back four is ok but the attacking side of the midfield and forward line are hardly busting a gut to make things happen.

RM needs his own General out on the park who will enforce the urgency required from the rest of the team. Our away win ratio is very poor over the last 2 years for a team that dominates so many of those games. DM didn't address it because he was on his way anyway, RM has to address it because the pressure in home games is too much if you don't get the odd win away from home.

Ste Traverse
59 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:21:21
I didn't buy into all the optimism on here at the appointment of Martinez. He just took Wigan down.

There certainly didn't appear to be a plan B today.

God help us if we lose Fellaini and Baines in the next few days. Thanls BK.

The alarm bells are ringing already for me.

Brent Stephens
60 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:26:50
Robert - logical comment for me.
Brent Stephens
61 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:27:49
Moyes lambasted for no Plan B.

Roberto's Plan B? Probably just the CD

Sean Patton
62 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:25:41
Patrick

' The group ', you are starting to sound like Martinez there you are just one step away from describing everything as either outstanding or phenomenal

David Pearl
63 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:17:25
Last season Moyes finally had us playing the way I wanted. We were fast paced, dynamic, lots of possession & shots, we attacked down both wings and through the middle.. plus the long ball for Feli to chest down and bring us forward. Now... we piss about. Kone will never be worth what we paid for him - that money should of been wisely spent. A striker and centre midfielder are needed to push us on... but we haven't got the funds to do it. 6th or 7th again. Negredo would of made a huge difference to us if we got him last January. For now - I would sell Jelavic... and kone - do we have a money back guarantee?? Perhaps we can sell him back to Wigan in exchange for McCarthy
Jim Harrison
64 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:23:39
Transition? Looked more toothless than ever! Moyes may be a cunt now but at least he recognised on the whole his players' strengths. It seems Berto cant bring himself to compromise. Still, I love how Barkley is playing, more games and less stupid giveaways and he will be class
Brent Stephens
65 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:32:30
David - Kone - Sale of Goods Act - fit for purpose etc.
Amit Vithlani
67 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:28:19
I thought we did ok. We might have played with a slow tempo, but we did get the ball wide. 14 crosses in the first half, and a few decent chances.

What was clear, however, was that we were playing a shite team, and how Cardiff beat Shitteh is beyond me.

Disappointed we did not win, but am enjoying our domination of matches. The set up also looks to suit Barkley. He will become an important player for us this season, especially if we lose Baines/Felli.

Brent Stephens
68 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:33:39
Stones to RB, push Coleman up.
Andy Walker
69 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:27:44
Brent, it should not come as a surprise to anyone that we havent got the players to deliver the style of play RM requires. Everyone in the game knew his style. Thats why his appointment was so bizarre, we cant afford to buy in the players who can play that style and we havent the players insitu. Its ridiculous, he was a mismatch for our club in this league. Give him a lower league side where it could work as its different to how lowere league teams play, but trying to match up to some of the best teams in the world in the PL with the best players and take them on at thier own game is only going to end in disaster.
Steve Nico
70 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:23:30
Goodness me, top team for possession, in transition, with players distracted or off form, we are unbeaten and with a bit of luck and a better ref today, we would have several points more. Fucking doom and gloom yet I repeat, undefeated and for me, keeping the ball better than others is better than fucking aimless shite aka West Ham and the like! We lost to Norwich last year, we lost to WBA as well under Moyea so give the new man a fucking chance! It's not his fault that Moyes has turned heads and yes he's still giving Jela and Osman chances but I suspect if we do lose Fellini then expect a faster, slicker midfield by the Chelsea match. I might be alone but I enjoy watching us 'try' to play and pass as we evolve and slagging and slaughtering the manager this early, unbelievable.
Brent Stephens
71 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:34:37
Andy, pretty much my position.
Sam Fitzsimmons
73 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:18:19
Like everyone, I'm genuinely frustrated that RM's reputation for playing football hasn't been that much different from what we've had for a long time, lots of posession no cutting edge. It's bit like deja vu. Same problem as last season and the season before that and before that... we need a striker that can score 20 goals a season.
Kevin Rowlands
74 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:30:55
Harold, the only 'Wigan' player out there today was Kone and that was for the last 20 minutes where he looked much better than that yard dog Jelavic, stop using stupid excuses, Andy Walker can you please put your Moyes blow up doll away, he's gone, his choice, and to constantly harp on about how Moyes would have done this, that and the other is boring and ridiculous.
Ray Roche
75 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:34:09
Derek Knox @ 255

Derek, have you tried watching on a "full screen". That usually gets rid of the advert.

Brent Stephens
76 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:35:25
Steve - "Keeping the ball". I think the lads are taking it too literally - they won't fucking shoot.
Patrick Murphy
77 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:30:55
I hope Martinez walks and we get another Moyes clone in that should re-unite the fan base.

Were we playing like Brazil or Spain under Moyes because I think I must have missed it, never has a newly appointed manager taken so much stick in such a short space of time.

I suppose it would be better to be a fan of Cardiff or WBA defend like crazy for 90 minutes and get a goal-less draw.

James Carlisle
78 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:20:20
FFS Bill give the man some money. If you were willing to appoint him as manager at least back him. Problem is Moyes built a team of functional players with very little flair. This worked under Moyes's system but under Martinez's they're getting really shown up.

Any chairmen with a brain would've given the new man money to buy players more suited to his style. The likes of Osman and Pienaar are average at best and really shouldn't be in the first team any more.

Midfield is the weakness. There is zero creativity and pace in there. We need creative midfielders, then the strikers may be a little sharper instead of having to wait a ridiculously long time for the ball to come to them.

Unfortunately the only way I see anyone coming in is if Baines and Fellaini go. We'll probably just buy replacements for those two which would leave the aforementioned deadwood still in the team. Nothing will have improved.

Jim Harrison
79 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:33:35
Patrick 276, Given the old guard their chances? 6th last season. Why should they prove their abilities all over again? Perhaps he needs to recognise that you need to play to your strengths and look to make changes gradually? Wigan played nice football, but got shit on for 3 years. Everton have played average football, and consistently finished in the top 8.
Ross Norman
80 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:00:11
The tempo of the football seems to be too slow and hence allowed Cardiff to pull all their players back to defend. If the tempo can be increased Martinez’s brand of football could work. Our next match against Chelsea we will find it impossible to break down their defence if our build up play is slow.

However the following must be noted about today’s match,

1. Fellaini can’t play in the deep-lying defensive midfielder position. He moves to slow and can be a liability due to some clumsy challenges (especially the challenge on Campbell in the second half).

2. Jelavic and then Kone didn’t really show any real threat. Jelavic did try but it wasn’t good enough, the highlight being an awful attempt after being set up by Barkley. Kone then baffled me with a lack of determination and work rate especially when Deulofeu rocketed the ball across the 6 yard box and Kone doesn’t attack the ball instead he seems to move back towards back to the penalty spot??

3. Deulofeu should start the next match and replace Mirallas who played sh*t today. For someone who gets paid to play football he can’t head the ball to save his life.

If Fellaini is still at Everton for the match against Chelsea he should maybe play up top. He’s far more effective there opposed to doing nothing in his own half.

Tony Draper
81 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:30:27
I'm off for now

Gunna poke next doors cat off the wall with a stick


And Harold, I think that "extrapolation" may be something that happens in "the adult industry", not sure though and I have a cat poking stick to prepare

Simon Harris
82 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:26:57
Patrick #276 Great summary.

We're playing like the man himself - nicey nicey.

And whilst early days, his calm demeanour (at least on the outside) and lack of animation on the sidelines could be perceived as lacking in passion and authority. In stark contrast to Moyes, and his teams..in the main.

It certainly isn't the sin miedo football I had hoped for (yet) but at least it's another point - only 37 more required.

Andy Walker
84 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:34:29
Amit, please tell me what is the point in playing the ball around for 20 passes at the back before putting a cross in? If you play the passing style, you play that style, ie, it doesn't finish with a cross. But this highlights the fact we do not have the players to play the RM way, they are trying but can't do it.

They can do the easier part of the style, ie keep the ball at the back and in the middle but then the key to the style is being able to pick the opportunity to turn the slow build up into an incisive attack, that quick pass or subtle distraction of a defender. that's were real high quality players make the difference. We haven't got that, so a good manager would recognise this and would not play this style of football with our players. Instead he'd play more directly, with a high tempo.

Brent Stephens
85 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:40:13
Simon - does lack of animation equate to dour?
John Malone
86 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:24:19
Can't agree more with Robert and Derek a manger's job is to get the best out of his team in order to win the game. I just can't understand why you would bring a sub on with 5 mins left, what is that all about?

Surely in the third game of posession dominance without the goals he'd of realised the need to change it up to get the goal. I always thought Davey was a ditherer with his subs but this guy has got me worried.

Deulofeu showed midweek what he's got to offer so why not give him a good 20 mins to get the goal.

Robert Pierpoint
87 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:34:10
Amit- Does the 'set up' suit Barkley? Not sure that it does. He will be a good player and good players do not need a set up to be 'good'. Think back to the best performances last year, and Barkley would fit into that system too.

I'm in the opposite camp about 'enjoying the domination of matches. I enjoyed the counter attacking football that we played at times last season- when we looked actually threatening. I don't think that we are dominating anything; the players look scared to me.

It brings to mind something I heard Collymore talking about on TalkSport last year. He was talking about Joe Allen at the time and argued that hitting 90 5 yard passes to a team mate every game does not make you a good midfielder. The stats will make you seem great, but it is not having a positive attacking impact on the game.

Sorry Amit, I saw no domination of the match.Our attacking play was akin to playing out time.

Richard Lyons
88 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:37:55
Four games, all against teams we should be slaughtering. 83 shots, 4 goals.
No more questions, your honour...
Jim Harrison
89 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:39:56
Ross Norman, with you on every point
Carl Sanderson
90 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:22:58
I definitely did not want Martinez, who I think was a unimaginative, unambitious appointment. Three league games are not enough in which to base a judgement, however, and it will be the end of October before things will be clear.

At the start (and end) of the season all sorts of odd results can occur: Cardiff beating Man City last week was a perfect example. They never looked remotely capable of beating us today. I am concerned, however, about the impotence of our attacking play.

The Chelsea game may be significant, I think, in telling us where we are likely to go with this manager. But we will be a quarter of the way into the season before we will know for sure.

Drew Shortis
91 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:30:30
Another dominant display of possession football away to a team that did Man City last week. Where is the cutting edge going to come from though?

I'm regretting my comments about Jelavic last month when Hamburg showed an interest. I figured the change in manager might lead to an improvement in his fortunes, but I was so wrong. I fear he has lost his magic touch for good and he offers very little besides. At least Kone's hold up play contributes to our attacks. At one stage Mirallas was in loads of space just past halfway and he looked up for a cross into the box, but there was nobody there, not even close. Jelavic should be busting a lung to be getting in there! I'm not suggesting Kone is a great goalscorer, but he does get involved and he will get into double figures if he keeps trying hard. At times today it felt like we had ten men on the pitch when Jelavic was wandering around deep on the wing. If Fellaini leaves I think a striker may actually be a bigger priority now than a midfielder.

I was disappointed Deulofeu only got five minutes on the pitch as he looked like he could create something, either with a shot on goal himself, or with a shot / cross that even our miss-firing strikers could have tapped in. He should have had at least half an hour.

Mirallas really needs to improve. He is a quality attacker with pace to burn and flair, but today he just wanted too many touches, as did a lot of our attackers. He can only improve and I'm confident he will.

The rest of the team looked Ok, but we are definitely lacking in the final third. Its interesting that many believed Martinez would bring attractive attacking play but we would be vulnerable at the back. The opposite seems to be the case. We look hard to beat, but desperately need to find a way to unlock stubborn defences. A bit of luck and some better refereeing would help us no end. They say a solid defence is what success is built on so I'm going to remain philosophical and focus on the positives from our opening four matches. Hopefully the international break and the end of the transfer window will allow Roberto and the team time to analyse where we are falling short and work on improving our attacking play.

Marc Sansum
92 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:45:11
Well said Steve @ 288
Jeremy Benson
93 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:46:36
We are unlikely to get anything from the Chelsea game given our current goal-scoring predicament.

This will probably mean bottom 3 with just 3 points from 4 games. Not good at all. The first 3 teams we have played will all be lower-half table teams this season, we should have picked up plenty of points.

Very disappointed, and if we lose Fellaini and/or Baines and don't strengthen, I am going to start to get nervous about what this season holds.

Mike Hughes
94 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:34:33
Listening to RM interview: yada, yada, yada, yawn. Same insipid cack. Difficult place to come, patronise the opposition, positive draw. Nice guy, media training master class. Yawn. Stretch. Ho-hum.

Another draw. Dullsville.

Concerned. Even jags didn't seem convinced we deserved to win.

Anyway, "Godzilla" is on 5* and at least he has some bite......

Andy Walker
95 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:41:37
Patrick I didnt see us against WBA but today there is no way Cardiff were 'defending like crazy'. You are reinventing history to try to support your argument. Cardiff sat back and just cleared up the ineveitable breakdown of our attacks which only very rarely caused them any sort of trouble.
If an opposition side sets out to retain the ball for long periods at the back or in areas of the pitch which present no danger, so what, let them get on with it. The game isn't won on possession stats, it won by scoring goals.
Mike Keating
96 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:43:43
Why was Delafeu on the bench and why was Osman on the bus? We have dropped 6 points against shite opposition and now face Chelsea to get our first win – possibly without Baines and the other Fellah.

Today's game had the hallmarks of Dithering Davie all over it: Complete shite.

And why did Jelly and Mirallas pull such faces when pulled off – they were both hopeless, against one of the worst Prem sides I have ever seen.

Mark Fitzgerald
97 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:35:19
I'm with you Steve. Yes, of course I see the issues and share the frustration of others but let's get some perspective; Only the new manager's third league game so lets not rush to judgement just yet. Remember we are unbeaten and two clean sheets the last two games is a positive. Early days and our first victory will make all the difference. Hopefully we'll add to our options before the window closes and if Felli or Baines moves then I would hope that the additions would be quality. Its encouraging watching our possession game rather than some of the dreaded hoof-ball of before And if we can just conjure up a regular goal scorer then it could still be a great season.
Steve Nico
98 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:41:43
Just 3 games in. The point of possession football is you tire teams out and for the last 20 mins of both halves, they were on the back foot and with quality finishing, we would have won comfortably.

Oh by the way, he's playing Ross as every expert says he should. Moyes never. He's got the lad from Barca that Moyes never could have, he is trying to coach us to play the type of football we've always clamoured for.... but bollocks – let's just be "direct" cos that'll have guaranteed us 9 points... would it fuck!

Give the man and the way he's going to try and get us playing a damned chance, lads!

Brent Stephens
99 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:50:10
Mark, I think the judgement people are making (not rushing to) is about the games we have seen and the tactics etc therein. I don't see much rushed judgement about how it will all end up after the required transition period - however long that might be.
Mohammed Horoub
100 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:41:24
Can someone tell RM it's 'he shoots he scores' and not 'he passes he scores' another frustrating draw and I hope the intensity picks up after the break... Felli and Baines are going through the motions, really disappointed with Jelavic and Mirallas's approach. RM needs to start using the hair dryer before he loses the team. How does Barkley the youngest player on the team pull rank over Baines for the free kick. RM needs to sort this out because it's going to be a long season if he doesn't stamp his authority on the team. Can't wait for Gibson to get back in there and never thought I'd say this but I wouldn't even mind Barton in on loan because we need some intensity and passion in the team...
Andy Walker
101 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:48:38
I totally agree Robert, it takes no great skill to keep the ball for long periods in positions that pose no threat to the opposition. This is RMs teams' trademark, I think of it as the emporers new cloths, so many fans can see it but don't like to say it.
Dave Lynch
102 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:50:06
Really annoyed by Graham Sharpe's comment after the game on City Talk.

"I'm sorry to say this but under Moyes we would have won that game".

What a snide undermining comment to make about the new manager, everyone connected with the club should be supporting him.

Not! Making comments like that......

Barry Rathbone
103 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:26:07
What a gang of tarts, and I don't mean the team.

Laughable people can't see the predicament the lad is in with this transfer saga hitting him square in the chops as he walked in.

He's trying a revolution with players who really aren't all that.

Our so called great players would be at CL clubs if they really were "the dog's"; as it is the dynamic duo upon which all hopes are pinned are being bid for by just their previous manager.

The amounts bid indicate just how good they really are - these days players with a pulse go for no less than 20 million yet just Moyes is knocking - doesn't it tell you something?

But if you're happy with another 11 years like the last, content to muddle on boring the arse of all and sundry with talk of 6th or whatever best of the rest is these days you must be off your skull.

But as fans if you can't grumble about a new everton manager 3 league games in while he has one hand tied behind his back when can you eh?

Oh, and quoting names no-one REALLY knows 2 fucks about is another corker.

Blockheaded talk.

Kev Prytherch
104 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:35:15
Last season.......

Away to Norwich, lost 2-1
Home to West Brom, won 2-1
Away to a newly promoted team, take your pick from 2 defeats and a draw, both defeats coming from scoring early and defending a lead.
We all knew this would take a few months but I for one didn't expect us to look as comfortable, albeit painfully slow, so early.

In short, all those bashing those who wanted Moyes out, check exactly how much better we were doing after 11 years. We currently have 1 point less (if we're kind to Moyes and take the draw against to promoted sides) 1 less goal scored, 1 less goal conceded, 1 more clean sheet and at least 1 match where we haven't thrown the game away trying to defend a ridiculous 1 goal lead.

Brent Stephens
105 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:51:50
Steve, those positives which we are seeing now we can acknowledge. And those negatives we can see now we have the right to acknowledge. And that in no way necessarily means a judgement about the future nor Roberto in the future.
Jim Harrison
106 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:52:46
Questions, questions, questions...

Why are we playing Fellaini deep? He became rated as one of the best players in Europe last year playing in an advanced role. He gets easily bypassed when playing deeper, he looks off the pace. Logic would suggest...?

Why pass so much around the back, allowing the opposition to reform their defence? Last season, Jags mocked the Shite for making tons of passes but going nowhere; now it's us. It seems that, as feared, the team has completely abandoned the old style. Perhaps a bit too soon?

85 mins? The Deulofeu kid is good enough for Barca!!! San Miedo? Scared of playing someone who can create 3 scoring chances in 5 minute on the pitch???

Kone? Just why? He saw more of the ball than Jelavic, just did it in midfield. What's the point in playing a lone striker if they can only get touches deep? Jelavic doesn't look good, but he hardly gets a clear chance.

Barkley? Why can't every Everton player be like him? A couple of sloppy moments, but what a kid!

When do we get a decent ref?

Why do I bother?

Robert Pierpoint
107 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:49:58
Mark- Two clean sheets is a positive. In my mind, it is the only positive that we have seen so far, because I haven't seen much in the attacking play.

I understand that it is difficult when you play a team that put a lot of bodies behind the ball, but much of the play is ponderous and insipid.

I am willing to give Martinez time (a good couple of seasons in fact) but it isn't only a regular goalscorer that we need to conjure up, but it seems a number of players to play in the only system that Martinez seems willing to play.

'The dreaded hoof-ball of before'- If you tell yourself something happened enough times, you start believing that it did! One team played hoof ball in the premiership last year: Stoke City. We didn't play hoofball. We played counter attacking football, based on pace and power but also with guile and precision. A style of football that suited the players that we have.

Graham Mockford
108 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:46:57
As ever TW seems to be the home of knee jerk comments.

We have gone from "won't it be great to play attacking cultured football" and my favourite, "at least we won't draw too many games" to doom and despair in three weeks. Changing a footballing style is a hard thing to do especially when a completely different philosophy has been hammered home for eleven years.

That is why I predicted bottom 6 after 6 games. Now I certainly don't think we will finish bottom 6 but some patience is called for. Martinez needs to show he can work it out and start getting results from what still is (Monday permitting) a quality squad. We have been the better side in all three games and we have not really had the rub of the green. However the lack of a quality striker is obvious and we need to mix it up a little more to prevent us being predictable and easy to defend against.

Kev Prytherch
109 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:58:56
Sorry, that should be 2 less goals conceded, 2 less goals scored and 2 more clean sheets. I had West Brom as 1-1 in my head!!!!!
Steve Nico
110 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:57:19
Brent, I agree mate but take a loom at the comments so far, almost all negative hence my frustration and comments. A balance would be great but the amount of comments slaughtering the way RM is TRYING to embed is way over the top.
Andy Walker
111 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:56:11
Barry so on the one hand you think we haven't got any great players but finishing 6th was not any sort of an achievement? Seems contrary to me, finishing 6th was a great achievement with no great players.
Brent Stephens
113 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:02:00
Steve, OK. I just think the negative comments are about what we've seen where the feeling is it can't be defended (matters of judgement, I know) rather than crit about the trying as such or the future.
Barry Rathbone
114 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:03:10
Andy, you clearly didn't get the bit about CL teams - then again why would you from such an entrenchment?

We didn't come 6th every year we finished best of the rest wherever that maybe which in my opinion really needs changing.

Paul Gladwell
115 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:02:29
Sorry, Jim most people on here wanted Fellaini deep he was part of the Jelavic problem, we cannot keep harping back to Man Utd at home as the lad is actually not as good as he is made out to be, no one knows his best position, that sums him up to me.
Brian Williams
116 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:05:17
...don't know about bottom six after six games. I predict that if we don't make a couple of additions, one in midfield, and a striker at least...it'll be bottom six full stop!
Ross Edwards
117 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:05:36
"The decision is hard to explain really because we all had a clear view and there are probably moments where the referee gets blocked.

"But when the Cardiff player goes to ground and loses control of his body and doesn't touch the football, obviously you are going to impede the player. Clearly it's a penalty.

"Leighton was as shocked as anyone in the ground and it was unfortunate because that would have been a big break.

"But overall, the way we defended and the way we stopped Cardiff having any influence on the game, that was very pleasing.

"We were strong, we kept Cardiff very, very quiet and this is a difficult place to do that.

"On the other side, when you get the amount of moments in the final third that we did, we need to be clinical and start scoring goals - because that was the difference that stopped us getting three points."

The gaffer's verdict.

Andy Walker
118 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:02:21
Graham, keeping the ball for long periods at the back and in non threatening areas does not make us the better team. It flatters to deceive and it is what RM has built his PL reputation on.
Any manager could get their team to play this way but most don't because its ineffectual unless you have the quality in your team to deliver the final ball. A manager should recognise what his players strengths and weaknesses are and obviuosly play to their strengths. It is poor management to do anything other.
Kunal Desai
119 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:58:48
Hopefully Martinez will get it right in the next 48 hours with the incomings and outgoings. Two clean sheets, and this from a manager who has emphasised more on the attacking play rather than the defensive side. We are no points worse or better off from the sides we played last season

Norwich - 0 points
WBA - 3 points
Reading - 0 points

If Martinez can get in a couple of midfielders and maybe another striker, that should hopefully start moving us in the right direction. If anyone is to blame surely the finger again should be point at Bungling Bill. Where are the funds for Martinez to strengthen? and where has the New TV money deal gone?

Carl Sanderson
120 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:05:04
Andy 330,

Quite right. Unfortunately, some people's dislike of Moyes is blinding them to his achievements. The same people correctly deplore the prospective departures of Baines and Fellaini whilst apparently forgetting that Moyes spotted their talent and nurtured it at Everton.

Bill Gall
122 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:54:46
We have been without a midfielder that can create chances for the forewards since Arteta left.

We have not had a scoring foreward since Jelevic stopped scoring over nearly a season.

We have not had any help from Kenwright since he took over.

We have not got a hope in hell of finishing in the top 10 with the players we have.

We need more than a new system if we are to survive.

We can blame the manager but he must now realise that he was lied to when he was hired.

Paul Mackie
123 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:06:11
So then Barry, why, in your opinion has Martinez not brought in players to fit his vision? Why is he trying to force it with players that are obviously not up to it instead of adapting his vision to the players he has?

You talked all last season about square pegs in round holes and other such bollocks. Martinez is essentially doing that with an entire team.

Michael Kenrick
125 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:06:02
I disagree with your concerns about the majority of the comments, Steve (#329) and others. Most are reacting to what we have seen in three games, and what we have seen forms more than a consistent pattern with no positive result (I don't consider a draw a 'result' — it's two points dropped) — it is a clearly ineffective way of winning football matches.

Is that going to change going forward? No-one can predict that reliably, but looking at those three Premier League games is entirely within our remit as fans. It is not 'knee-jerking' to reach a confirmed impression on how Everton are playing under Martinez to this point. He's had opportunity to change things; he hasn't done that, and many of us rightly find that worrying.

Geoff Freeman
126 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:34:04
By most of the posts on this site you would have thought we had been stuffed today not that at the end of the match the Cardiff supporters were cheering because they had managed to get a point. For goodness sake, people were saying under Roberto we would leak goals — well we're not and we will start to score as we are making chances. In all 3 games we have been the better team so let's get behind the lads.
Brent Stephens
127 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:09:42
Kunai "Two clean sheets, and this from a manager who has emphasised more on the attacking play rather than the defensive side".

I'm not sure about that, Kunai. The slow possession build-up allows our defensive set-up to be organised before the opposition can come back at us. Unlike quicker sorties from out of our own final third, when we can lose it more easily and put the defence under greater pressure more quickly. If anything this all seems more defensive and less attacking.

Graham Mockford
128 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:09:34
Andy, I sort of agree but that doesn't change the fact that – on the balance of all three games – we have, whilst not being outstanding, been the better side and the team most likely to win.

Martinez is going to need to show some flexibility to start turning that into three points. My point is that three games is not enough to judge whether he can.

Steve Nico
129 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:12:42
Paul 342, where does he get the money from to do that? If Felli goes then expect McCarthy and Ince and it starts to look more like his team. When Alcarez is fit, it will start to look like his team. Until then, he has to use what he's got to play the way he would like to.
Barry Rathbone
130 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:12:10
Paul Mackie the reason is he's doing a Wenger sitting on the spare 75million we have sitting in the bank!

Get a grip lad....

and "square pegs in round holes" isn't one of mine I'm a big advocate of lateral thinking I think Oviedo would be effective in Ossies role.

Moyes was just an idea free zone.

Mike Green
131 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:11:07
Still unbeaten in the Martinez era - get in there! There's no pleasing some people, nothing a few goals wont sort out.

IMWT.

Brent Stephens
132 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:15:58
Steve, I wonder if he should hang fire on his preferred system until he does get a critical mass of players in who can play his system?
Brent Stephens
133 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:17:17
Graham "My point is that three games is not enough to judge wether he can".

I suspect we are all with you on that. I certainly am.

Graham Mockford
134 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:17:10
Barry I remember your lateral thinking. Anichebe in central midfield if I remember correctly.
Barry Rathbone
135 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:19:46
Graham, still hasn't been disproven!
Andy Walker
136 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:15:46
The irony is we might do just as well against better sides as we may have more non effectual possession,and by default limit the opposition's possession more so they don't have as many opportunities to attack us. Not a great strategy but could be a conseqeunce of this style of play.
Steve Nico
137 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:17:49
Brent, I'm not sure he knows anything other than possession football via 352 or as we are now. I like everyone want us to win every game but we have not lost, we are getting some plaudits for the way we are trying to change and come next Wednesday morning, he might have more of the squad he needs to deliver more goals to go with the possession. One step at a time.......?
Amit Vithlani
138 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:04:02
Andy Walker:

"Amit, please tell me what is the point in playing the ball around for 20 passes at the back before putting a cross in? If you play the passing style, you play that style ie it doesn't finish with a cross."

Eh? Passing and crossing are not mutually exclusive. We passed the ball around at the back quite abit, this is true. But we had a decent number of crosses and got the ball wide several times. What was disappointing was our finishing and a lack of cutting edge.

Robert Pierpoint

"Good players do not need a set up to be good". Sorry, but that is shite. Perhaps a Pele or Maradona can shine in a turgid set-up, but young Barkley is not in their league. That said, the lad has talent, and being played behind the striker is bringing out the best in him. He looks confident and dangerous, and has been our best player in the games against Norwich and Stevenage.

Graham Mockford
139 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:22:53
Barry I suspect it never will
Drew Shortis
140 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:59:41
I'm in total agreement with all those who have called for a little perspective and patience. Its a new manager trying to play a new style but with no real money to spend. It will take some time before everyone is either up to speed or is replaced. It is not Martinez's fault that players like Mirallas are playing so badly right now. Sure some of the squad may not be ideally suited to the new style, but Mirallas showed last year what a quality attacker he is, he is just suffering a slump in form and that will pass.

I hope Martinez takes the time in the break to really analyse these games and that he has the nous to find pragmatic solutions. However, it is also the players responsibility to up their game. I agree that we need to get the ball forwards more quickly as it is difficult to break down teams once they get back into position. It will be interesting to see how we do against a team like Chelsea who won't just sit deep and be disciplined. They will come at us and then our counter attacking game can come into effect. For the past few years we have done well when playing the role of the underdog but struggled when playing against 'lesser' sides who play to frustrate us.

Now we just need to get Monday out of the way and see how the land lies. Part of me hopes we retain our two best players, whilst another part of me thinks it would be good for Martinez to have money to bring in the players he feels he needs to suit his system. Can he get those players in at such short notice if one or both leave? Its going to be very tricky.

Brent Stephens
141 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:21:52
Steve " I'm not sure he knows anything other than possession football via 352 or as we are now".

If that is true, that frightens the death out of me. It says there will never be a Plan B in any game or between games depending on the opposition?

Phil Rodgers
142 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:06:54
As poor as we were we should have had a stonewall pen. I have seen some poor refs but this Anthony Taylor is a bad as any of them.
Carl Sanderson
143 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:20:12
Brent 352:

So am I. Three games is premature.

Graham 353:

Now that's funny.

Andrew Cutler
144 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:06:21
The Cardiff keeper only had to make one save... off a deflection... enough said!
Mike Oates
145 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:16:34
Mirallas wont fit into this system at all, his strength on is counter attack at speed – remember Spurs and Stoke last season – and we will not counter quick with Martinez favouring a keep the ball approach. It means that the opposition will have time to pack their box, and there is no way Mirallas will find a way through 5-6 players around the box.

On the same theme, even when our full backs get round the back, there is just no way they can pick out an Everton player. We have been found out that our full backs will get round the back so they are defending the 18 yard box with piles of bodies.

Our way forward in Martinez's system is the little dinky through ball which worked at Norwich for our 2nd goal but failed today with both Jelavic and Mirallas wasting glorious chances. The 2nd way forward is the ticky-tacky keep ball with sudden 20-yard shot – Barkley's strength, but again not today.

Our only hope is that Kone comes good.

Trevor McKinlay
146 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:49:58
Before everybody jumps on Martinez, can we at least consider the possibility that what he's trying to do with the team and the playing style hasn't actually been achieved yet? Swansea played some magnificent stuff under him, and while there isn't much of it on YouTube, take a look at this from 26.00 in - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EoLT_0LH51I

Evolving a new style takes time, perseverance and maybe even some new players. Swansea are still reaping the rewards, and although Wigan had ups and downs, at the end of 2011-12 they won 7 out of 9 games, including at Anfield, the Emirates and against Man Utd at home. They actually outplayed these sides, not just KITANO.

So, yes, it's bad at the moment, but can we please just take a step back and see it as a work in progress, and that the movement, the tempo and the goals will come as the players get used to the system and the style? We're three games in, and it's three draws for christ's sake. Give the team and manager some time and get behind them.

Steve Pugh
147 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:57:38
The simple way to improve this team is to say shoot early.

How many times today where the likes of Mirallas, Jelavic, Pienaar, Kone and dare I say it Barklay in a position to shoot but instead try to turn inside, get past one more player or worse still play it wide for somebody to cross.

It was good to see Ossie getting more involved today, winning tackles, incredibly winning headers and missing very few passes, sadly too many of those passes went to Mirallas who was useless.

I fear that Ross is starting to lose faith in some of the people around him because he was regularly trying to take on one too many defenders when the pass was on, he passed more against Norwich than he did today.

Martinez has to take a fair share of the blame, Jelavic should have been subbed at half time, Mirallas should have been subbed after an hour at the latest.

Mike Gwyer
148 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:57:55

Just a ditto.

Having just watched the blues complete their 1,0000,0000,000 pass so far this season, one thing that did stand out was the post match hand shaking by both Baines and Fellaini. Long hand shakes with all fellow blue players, even hugs between Fellaini and Jags. Is this their goodbyes before fucking off????

Additionally, say what the fuck you like in his defense but Jelavic is super duper fucking shit - so hopefully he fucks off as well.

For me Martinez is playing the passing game but obviously needs some cash for a (1) a striker (is Kone a striker or someone who has had their position nicked by Mirallas or Barkley) and (2) a MF dynamo creator. So its probably ciao to Fellaini and fucking hopefully we will see someone who can put the ball into the pen box and a striker who can put the same ball into the net unlike Jelavic who is either offside, moaning, on his ass or just so shit that his first touch is better than my full on kick.

James Martin
149 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:07:24
If the Norwich guy hadn't mishit it, if Fellaini's had bounced in off the post, if the pen had been given, we could very easily be sat here on 9 points. These are the fine margins that we are dealing with, we can't make a judgement on a manager after three games. We look sound defensively but are just lacking upfront. Chelsea will be the real test of how good we are in possession. I'd back this system to give us a better chance of winning that game than the one last season. Dominating possession like we are home and away against decent teams gives us the foundationn to win more than we'll lose. All Martinez needs to do is unlock the offensive formulae. He nneeds time and backing in the transfer market as well as performance from key players. At the minute he's not getting the first from us, he's not getting the second from bill, and just like they did under the last manager the players are once again putting all the responsibility onto the manager rather than just performing like they are capable of. It was never Moyes who misssed glaring chances, overhit corners, missed lonng balls, and it won't be Martinnez either. You can only do so much for players in terms of formations but if they can't be bothered to stick it in the net or find a blue shirt with a pass or defend for 90 minutes thenn this group of losers will undermine Martinez just like they did Moyes.
Tony Twist
151 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:13:46
What did we honestly expect from Martinez, this is how it was at Wigan, draws against teams that had to be beaten. I can't see where the next league win is coming from, I will be surprised if we get anywhere near double figures for wins this season. Funnily enough though I don't think it would take much to turn it around. We need a goal scorer plain and simple, someone who only needs one chance to score and I expect the others to improve with less pressure on them to score. A reliable goal scorer is tricky to find but for this season with no other loses in personnel this is all we need. Without this I honestly think that this is our purple patch, just wait till we start losing! Changing the subject slightly, I am total torn regarding what result I want for the match tomorrow, I despise Man U and RS but probably Man U even more now that Moyes is there.
Harold Matthews
152 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:28:35
Patrick. Spot on. Jags is a good, media friendly club captain but on the pitch he's hardly Roy Keane. Jelavic with one goal in 24 appearances has to go. Mirallas has to have things all his own way or he chucks in the towel.

Nobody making an effort to get to the Deulofeu cross at the end was inexcusable, especially when he had made an identical cross against Stevenage. No wonder he was annoyed. What Kone was doing dropping back to the penalty spot is anyone's guess.

As for the extra passes when the ball needed to be centred.. words fail me.

For positives, I didn't expect us to be so dominant but we were. Despite all our failings, we seem to force teams to go very defensive. How we will fare if Baines and the giant Belgium go is something I'd rather not think about till it happens.

Jamie Barlow
153 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:30:34
Come on, we're only 4 points off the top, and unbeaten.
Andy Walker
154 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:30:48
Fuck me Amit so its better to pass 20 times and cross than pass twice and cross?
Kevin Hudson
155 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:27:25
We couldn't hit a pig in an entry today...

Or last week.

..and again against the mighty Stevenage.

Here's an idea Bobby: why not go two up-top when your team is dominating the play?

...rather than following the Moyes template, and NOT giving us this "sin miedo," attacking football style your acolytes promised..??

Andy Walker
156 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:31:53
By the way, I'm not making judgement on three games on RM, I'm making it on 3 years at Wigan in the PL. It shouldnt be a case of wait to see, you've seen it, thats it, it is what it is, head out of sand, it aint going to change. Now are you happy with it?
Carl Sanderson
157 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:24:26
Brent,


"If that is true, that frightens the death out of me. It says there will never be a Plan B in any game or between games depending on the opposition?"

Exactly. It was this adherence to his principles, come what may, that ultimately got Wigan relegated. If the team was hit with defensive injuries or if they were just spanked there was no suggestion of shutting up shop for a few weeks, grinding out a couple of 0-0 draws and restoring defensive resilience that way.

Bill Gall
158 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:23:04
Has anybody got an idea where we are going to get a 15-20-goals-per-season striker in the next couple of days?

My personal opinion is not to sell either Baines or Fellaini to anybody but I have to admit that I would not be surprised if they asked to leave seeing the lack of ambition by the board.

Bill Kenwright stated that funds are available for players, if required. This raises the question: Does the manager think the players we have are good enough? Or, as we suspect, it is just more of Kenwright's bluster.

This Everton team need someone to provide leadership .

Ben Jones
159 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:32:57
What can Martinez do, seriously?

The players underperformed us AGAIN. The only thing he could have done, was put on Deulofeu a lot earlier, as he did more in 10 minutes, than Mirallas in the whole game.

Mirallas, Pienaar, Barkley are all capable of playing a hell of a lot better, and they're letting the manager down at the moment.

We need better and can hopefully get better in the transfer window. At least just to put Pienaar and Mirallas under pressure.

I'd also suggest start with Kone, because Jelavic looks clumsy.

Michael Brooks
160 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:35:03
Tony Draper #245

"Moyes 11 years and no improvement."

So taking a bottom three side heading for relegation to top six is no improvement? Are you having a laugh?

Ian Riley
161 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:55:17
Goals win matches, it's that simple! I don't give a wild shite about how many passes we have and good football. Its good football, when winning.
Jelavic works hard, great I am pleased, however he is payed to score goals, his goal ratio per game is shocking. In the end Moyes left him out last season. Roberto puts a another striker alongside him or drop him. Why not start with kone, then take him off when tired?

Some of these players need a kick up the arse as the these three teams we have played are average at best.

Is it me, but do we need new players?

P.S I hate the international break, but feel we need it.

Three points from our next game, its chelsea at home!

Graham Mockford
162 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:36:20
On a positive note I thought Osman had a decent game!
Derek Knox
163 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:16:16
Ray Roche (#293)
I tried that, and ended up with just a white screen, had commentary, but no picture. The box says, you need Media Player 12.7 to view this content. The last time I pressed yes, I got every bit of crap imaginable, browser hijacked, security warning messages from Avast, so from experience will not do that again. It took me a while to get everything back to normal!

Mind you I'm no PC whiz, so if you know of a safe way, I'd be more than grateful. Thanks mate!
I can't believe some of the comments on here, you'd think we had been beaten 5-0 in every game we had played.

We all want success, but having waited over 30 years (apart from FA Cup -95) I think we should realise, that in this money orientated Prem, we can't just go out, like Chelski, City and the likes and buy instant results. Even then, they are not guaranteed that, have some faith, and more importantly, some patience!

Andy Walker
164 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:36:58
Ben, very simply, play more direct football. You must be able to see what he's done to our team, he has changed the style, he can change it back.
Michael Brooks
165 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:36:36
This is not the start we were all hoping for but don’t you think we, well not me but the rest of might have got a bit carried away when Martinez was appointment. So lets all calm down and see where we are after what could be ten long painful games.
Mike Hughes
166 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:36:30
Tony #370
Wash your mouth out, mate.
That's the most vile and disgusting thing I've ever read on TW. Ever.
Despising someone more than the rs?
Even as low as the ginger minge has sunk I hope he at least gets a draw tomorrow. Then the sack.
Andy Walker
167 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:39:45
Derek funny isn't it, when people were defending Moyes from criticism on here about only finishing 6th and above the shite for the past 2 years (who have spend £100m+) by saying we didnt have the money to compete with the very best, this argument was dismissed by the anti Moyes fans. Now RM cant win against relegation fodder its down to lack of investment. Bizarre agenda going on here.
James Martin
168 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:40:56
Even the RS gave Brenda longer and that was after a far worse start. I always thought we were the more patient fans. Everything will be better after the first win and it will come.
Darren Hind
169 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:32:11
Barry Rathbone
It still hasnt been disproven that if Red Bull were to stick a zuzuki swift 1.00 under the bonnet, their F1 domination wouldnt continue
Andy Crooks
170 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:41:32
There is a difference between giving Roberto a chance and turning a blind eye to three dreadful results. To me, not being Moyes is all he is offering at present.He simply doesn't have the players for his project but ,sadly, he seems to think he has.
Brent Stephens
171 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:47:58
If Roberto's system is to work, what would the first team look like? Who gets a pick and where are the blanks to be filled? I'll start it off..

Howard

Darren Hind
172 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:46:16
Kevin Hudson

The temptation must be hard to resist son. . . But resist you must

Ajay Gopal
173 Posted 31/08/2013 at 17:58:37
I am disappointed at the comments against RM, to be frank. We haven't yet lost a game - 4 games into the season with a new manager, our net investment in players is close to the lowest in the league, 2 of our most important players have been targeted by our former manager in full media glare, upsetting the whole team and today's refereeing was a total disgrace.

What do people expect? This transition will take time – Moyes had 11 years and he won ZERO, and played attractive football for exactly 2 half seasons (1st half last year, and then a few years ago coinciding with Donovan's loan spell).

Calm down... we drew with a team that had just the previous week hammered the most expensively assembled team in the premiership. If the referee wasn't a total muppet, we would have got 3 points. IMIT...

Carl Sanderson
174 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:48:26
Michael 385,

"don’t you think we, well not me but the rest of might have got a bit carried away when Martinez was appointment..."

No; far from it. I remain of the view that it is a bad appointment. You are right about the ten games, though. It's still early days.

Mark Tanton
175 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:49:38
Andy, 'dreadful results' for two draws away from home and frustrating blank at home is a bit much isn't it? It's been a steady, solid start and one in which we have identified a problem - we cannot score goals. Kone might turn out to be a good signing - on today's evidence he is far more mobile than Jelavic, he has quick feet and brings others into the game.

It's been a frustrating start, but not a dreadful one. Moyes had mainly dreadful starts, remember.

Phil Walling
176 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:39:02
Well by the next game he will have one,possibly two more of his ex-players available for selection along with Kone.This transmogrification of Everton into the Wigan of yesteryear will ensure that the Martinez way is more familiar and enable us to claim the 'Most Passes in our Own Half Award'week after week.

The kindest thing I have read about the post fasting Kone is that 'he holds up the ball well'.And Roberto is pleased with the way our defence does that as well.

The man's obsession for keeping possession is probably why he leaves it to the last five minutes to give Gerard a run.The bugger might just screw it all up by actually scoring!

Jon Withey
177 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:38:55
Well, one thing is for sure, we need some transfer action.
Gary Carter
178 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:54:33
"We did well to nullify the Cardiff threat."

Well done, Mr Martinez, spoken like a true loser!
Harold Matthews
179 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:49:19
Terrific stuff lads. A real entertaining thread.
Mark Tanton
180 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:57:01
Gerard is one reason to be hopeful, for a start. He is no doubt going to play himself into the starting eleven over the next few weeks if he keeps learning.

I wouldn't say Kone just holds it up, he looks quick and he linked the play so well that you suddenly realised that Jelavic just doesn't do that.

One last point, Di Canio is struggling at Sunderland too; their start is very similar to ours but at least we're unbeaten.

Darren Hind
181 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:56:18
BTW Where IS Vic? And why does he get so much stick? He was much improved last season and has GOT to be a better option than the other two
Peter Thistle
182 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:51:41
Why has Martinez managed to stop Everton's best attacking option, the fullbacks overlapping the wingers with fast paced football. Now it's all slow boring useless passing that goes nowhere. Speed it up Roberto, you are boring the fans to death.
Raymond Fox
183 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:52:37
Andy 391.

Dreadful results?

● Norwich away 11th last year, spent plenty, very unlucky with their equaliser;

● WBA 8th last year, easily the best side;

● Cardiff today, stone wall penalty, they were restricted to 1 shot on target.

We deserve to be on 7pts. You don't always get what you deserve, thats the way it goes sometimes. Hardly dreadful!

Jeremy Benson
184 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:06:38
I'm a bit concerned that people are saying "give it time to change the style of play". Why? Why change to a style of play that won't work?

Possession football works if you are Barcelona or other top 6 European side with the pedigree of having 6+ £20 million players in your team who have the technical touch, skill and creativity to make things happen.

We don't have that, Wigan didn't, and that's what happens. Even Arsenal gave up on it when they had a much stronger team than we have...

Jim Harrison
185 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:07:31
Paul 334, I am sorry, but I don't remember a mass call for Fellaini to be played deep. From my point of view he contributes more assists and goals in an advanced role than Jelavic does as a striker. Logic suggests........
Phil Walling
186 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:10:28
Ray, have a word with the Prem office for us — they'll be delighted to adjust the results and league table to accommodate the points you make above!
Andy Walker
187 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:14:35
Remember when Feli was used just behind the front man at home to Man U last season to such devastating effect? It required the ball played quite long and in the air. This is just one example of tactical variety which appears to beyond RMs capabilities.
David Greenwood
188 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:08:38
Another frustrating day. We need the transfer window closed and out the way. All the hooha with Felli and Baines has definitely affected things. The sooner it's Tuesday, the better.

I am sure there are new players coming in, I think we might end up with four or five new faces in, probably on loan. No, I've not been smoking anything...

Felli is definitely off, Baines as well sadly. Rumours up here in Glasgow that Izaguirre at Celtic is on his way to replace him.

Early days, Bobby, but please can we have some competition for places, players getting picked on form, not reputation.

Jon Withey
191 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:15:06
Mood swing.

2 prem clean sheets. 2 exciting up and coming players (Barkley, Deulofeu). A bit more penetrative play and we could murder someone.

Week off for internationals, still time to make decisive signings.

Peter Laing
192 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:17:13
Couldn't believe the same unchanged line-up for today's game and expected a similar result to last week. Toothless up front, after the WBA game I would have gone with power and pace in the form of Kone and Anichebe who always performs well away from home. Worryingly has been the form of Mirallas and Pienaar.

A must-win game coming up next against Chelsea or Martinez may start to begin to look a bit worried.

Drew Shortis
193 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:55:50
I may be going off tangent a bit here but after reading some of the comments I feel obliged to counter.

Since Moyes departure I would no longer consider myself a fan, especially after the revelations over the way he was approached and the way they have gone about the pursuit of Baines and Fellaini, just make a decent offer FFS! However, during his time with us he did turn our fortunes around, turning a struggling side flirting with relegation to a regular fixture in the top of the table. He built a squad of players who made us one of the mos respected teams in the League and got us into Europe on many occasions. Towards the end of his reign I became frustrated with his tactics, although we played great stuff on our day, and felt that he had taken Everton as far as he could without an increase in funding. Now he is the Man Utd manager and I have little more interest in him than any other manager in the League. It is time to move on and look forward to the future and not continually over our shoulders, whether you were pro or anti Moyes..

Martinez has come in with new ideas but faces the same problems as Moyes with the finances. He needs time to implement his changes and without money it will be tough. We are not going to be in a relegation scrap, but it is quite possible we could drop down into a safe mid table position this term as we transition. Obviously our results so far have been disappointing in that we have missed the opportunity to win three matches we have dominated. The collapse of our defence that many predicted has not happened and this is down to him sticking with the tried and tested players Moyes brought in. He hasn't thrown away Moyes legacy by making sweeping changes that will upset the balance of our team. Given time and some resources he will adapt the squad to his philosophy and in the meantime he will have to adapt to utilize what he has at his disposal. Like him or not he is our new manager, and unless we go into total meltdown Kenwright will give him the time he needs. Please, lets give the guy a bit of time before rubbishing him. If we are in the same position this time next season I will be the first to admit that I was wrong, but in the meantime a wave of negativity won't help us. Lets get behind the team and try and keep things in perspective.

I know this sounds preachy, but I have typed it now so I'm going to post it!

Rupert Morrison
194 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:20:11
It wasn't great today, but being positive we could have lost all three and we didn't.

The kids are getting played and will keep getting better so that's another positive. Once we're all back to full game pace and fitness then players who are getting slammed could well win us games. Jelavic is a real shame but seems like he's been given enough opportunities to turn his game around. Lets hope we brining in a real poacher before Monday night.

Have faith, it's early and we're still the best of the rest. A good place for RM to build from.

Raymond Fox
195 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:17:23
Phil, of course they wont, just trying to give a little balance to some doom mongering.

I think you and a few others have simply took exception to the appointment of Martinez, and are looking with your one eye at the action.
Lets have some fair and balanced comments!

Lewis Barclay
196 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:19:34
Lots of possession, can't score goals, too many draws.

As we were.

Drew Shortis
197 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:24:26
Oof, didn't realise how long that last post was. Will try and be more succinct in future and avoid posting under the influence of alcohol. Soz!
Andy Walker
198 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:21:11
Lots of legit criticism from rightly concerned fans. From my perspective it's because at present we are a replica of Wigan with slightly better players. We know what to expect with RM and he's delivering it. He must learn to adapt and quickly or it will be our team that suffers.
John Moors
199 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:33:06
I think we are all thinking very negative! We have to give RM a chance... we haven't got purse strings that overflow like other clubs. We haven't lost yet, which is a positive but, like you all I, feel we should've taken advantage against the lesser teams in this league.
John Daley
200 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:35:48
I think more patience is definitely required from some, allied to an understanding that any change of playing style is obviously going to take time before it clicks into gear.

Martinez isn't a magician. He can't walk through the door, wave a magic wand and have the team functioning exactly as he wants within a couple of weeks. He's inherited a team that have played, in the main, one way under one man for a large chunk of their careers. The players are clearly still adapting to the new managers 'possession' game and you can tell it doesn't come naturally to some, hence the slightly hesitant, meandering, approach play.

Martinez, taking over a side that has been rigidly consistent over recent years, has quite reasonably decided not to try and change everything all at once. That's why he's started the season with basically the exact same side Moyes was selecting last year (Barkley being the only change). At the moment it's a mishmash: a Moyes team, trying to play the Martinez game.

He needs time to decide which of the current crop are incapable of cutting it under his more Catalan style and then he's got to figure out how the fuck he's going to replace them considering the financial restraints at the club.

He definitely hasn't been helped by the continuing piss poor form of some of his more senior squad members. Three players in particular were coasting long before Martinez ever set foot through the door:

● Osman has been atrocious since the turn of the year.

● Pienaar has spent six months refusing to release the ball and spends more time staggering around in circles and turning back on himself like a pissed up dwarf trying to gain entry into The Phoenix Club.

● Then there's Jelavić. He just needs to start wearing a duffle coat and a pair of PE plimsolls with the sole hanging off, and his transformation into that kid from school who nobody wanted to pick because he just spent all game running around like the Scorpio killer from Dirty Harry and falling face first into white dog shit will be complete.

It amazes me that the majority of Evertonians still seem to think that the deadly form Jelavi displayed upon his arrival is his default mode and the dismal form he's displayed ever since is merely an unlucky barren spell. Admittedly, I'm a bit of a cynic but John Wayne Bobbit has got more chance of 'coming good' than our Croatian marksman has.

Derek Knox
201 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:27:38
David(#410)
Funny you should mention Izaguirre, I thought I had imagined it, that he was a possible incoming target, and had almost resigned it to my memory playing tricks with me. If Leighton goes, we could do a lot worse, than get him in. From what I have seen of Celtic, he plays in a similar style, without being quite as good.
Kevin Rowlands
202 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:30:35
Andy Walker, seeing your beloved Moyes can do no wrong and Martinez no right, and the fact that you want to keep boring us all with what happened last season, could you explain to us why Phil Neville was repeatedly picked over Barkley last season and in our biggest game of the season Neville was 'running' our midfield whilst Barkley and Gibson warmed the bench, I suppose that was RM's fault right? Come to think of it maybe it was as his team twatted us 3:0, and actually went on to win the trophy.
Tony Draper
203 Posted 31/08/2013 at 18:36:26
I'm not even bothering reading the majority of "post match postings", as they follow a depressive or defensive pattern, though had we won the tone would have been euphoric.

As some brave, realistic and dare I say "wise" posters have advised, it's very very, very, early days yet for a new manager who has not been handed a thick book of open cheques (or box or whatever)

Our style is radically different, the teamsheet yet, whilst not identical, is different, with Ross Barkley & Gerard Deulofeu. These two 19-year-olds were DM's regulars, were they? Well, were they or were they not?

Never in 111 years would DM have managed to arrange a loan for an exciting (if capricious) Barcelona prospect. More likely, "James McFadden returns to Finch Farm to train on paid as played" etc....

Deulofeu ... McFadden — Complete world of difference in my opinion

11 Years... 9 Weeks... 3 pts from 3? Hardly the worst start in PL history, is it?

Keep your powder dry, stand strong and do not flinch!

Ian Bennett
204 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:42:08
Three shots on target by a striker never mind an entire team is a big worry. Continuing with only one up top, or this obsession with extremely slow passing against 4 crap to mediocre sides.

Can't help but think next week will see spanked at home by Chelsea, lost our 2 best players, and bottom of the league. O' to be a blue.

David Greenwood
205 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:41:27
Derek, agreed, very similar in style, just not as good. But then who is, LB is the best in the world in his position!

The one we should have signed from Celtic was Wanyama... anyway, no point opening that wound up again.

Richard Dodd
206 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:36:44
At least we haven't taken a pasting yet and haven't looked like doing so. I imagine that our line-up will look somewhat different for the next game and I do so hope funds will have enabled RM to bring in an additional striker.

Otherwise, with Fellaini gone, Mirallas a shadow of his former self, and set pieces no longer a part of our armoury, it's difficult to see where goals are coming from.

Brian Harrison
207 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:29:45
Not the start to the season we hoped for especially playing teams that may be towards the bottom of the leagues come the end of the season. I think RM would have been better starting with the pattern of play the team were used to playing and gradually make the change in style. Playing Fellaini in a deeper role seemed to have nullified some of attacking outlets, and maybe the reason for the clean sheets is because he has kept last seasons back 4 in tact.

I think any good manager going to a team that finished in the top 6 wouldn't need to change drastically and has all season to improve the overall play. I just feel that RMs approach is the equivalent of a cricket coach going into take over a new team and finding his top 6 batsmen are left handed and telling them from now on he wants them to play right handed immediately, then wondering why they are getting bowled out for low scores.

Barry Rathbone
208 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:59:40
Tony Draper 426, Brilliant.
Paul Ferry
209 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:52:57
Good grief quite a lot of sloppy dogsbollocks not least from diddum’s weepy Moyes-boys snipers taking pot-shots because Bobby is not ginger.

Three Prem games – dear Lord – three! Not three months but three matches! Get the image: AB and CD, two Moyes-mong-mourners, rubbing hands in evident glee after erm three draws, hammering away at the keys in righteous high-horse pique.

Yes there are myriad teething-problems – what else did you expect? – and here’s one: it was Osman in the conservatory with the lead piping; Jesus wept, Bobby, dump this lightweight feather once and for all, so many reasons, so many reasons . . . . .

Listen it was always my hunch that the Bobby-doubters would scramble for any shred of anything to take a swipe at him but three games Jesus, Mary, and Joseph! Have at least a bare ounce of dignity and decency, and discretion and self-discipline! You – you/we know who you are – have become a laughing-stock in merely three games: not Bobby at all but you you sad crew – oh and don’t forget that Bobby/Everton have behaved exactly like Moyes/Manure this transfer window, shame on you Bobby/Everton!

• Looking better in possession
• Contrary to the Doubting Thomas’s we are not bad at the back
• Imperious Distin
• Barkley oozes class – natural talent plus physique
• Deulofeu – must start – great crosser – great touch – just great
• Must MUST turn possession into crosses and goals
• 80 odd shots in 4 games and 4 goals does not lie
• If we just pass all the time we will not score or go anywhere
• We need at least one striker tomorrow or Monday
• We need at least one creative midfielder tomorrow or Monday
• Fingers crossed Bob has ‘em lined up if Felli hits the East Lancs
• Bainesy Lord be praised will be in the team to play Chelski
• Nothing now wrong cannot be fixed
• Osman to Wigan as a sweetener in McCarthy deal
• Show Jelly videos of his 1st 15 games with us
• Remind Kev how good he is
• Give Bobby erm 3 games: pic of sides splitting and head shaking
• Treat Andy Walker’s of this world with the disdain they deserve
• A time of transition is not precisely 2 weeks
• Aim arrows at Teary Billy and his board misers not the gaffer
• The next two days are crucial
• IMWT
• COYB

Please wish me happy birthday for Tuesday and here’s hoping that I get a nice present (presents) on Monday.

Love

Paul Ferry

Michael Ward
210 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:01:08
I was watching on al jaseera... I think at the end of the game Richard keys said Fellaini had tweeted "this time on Monday I will no longer be a blue" I can't find any news for it though, anyone?

On the game we deserved to win and a definite pen and Bellamy should have been off for an elbow on baines

Alan Smith
211 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:46:23
Osmans not my favourite player but I think he has done his job well. Dont know why he gets so much criticism.The obvious weakness to me is the lack of support to the striker. Pienaar doesn't get into the box and Mirralas has been awful. We don't have a world class striker or get enough players into the box. The midfield and defence have been excellent. The three forward players never look like scoring.

How about starting Deulofeu wide left, buying a winger and dropping mirralas until he finds his form and playing Barkley CM. he could move Pienaar to number 10 or play two strikers. Then we might actually have a team that looks like scoring. Not just another Moyes side with slightly more possession.

Moyes never trusted Barkley, RM only half trusts him. Wilshire CM at 18, fabregas CM at 16.

The best player we have at taking people on and shooting is probably Deulofue, so if we are dominating possession and getting people on the ball around the area, he's the man you want in the ball.

Jonas Eriksson
212 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:02:26
Hi.
Everton fan from Sweden here. I thought the opening of the season looked kinda "easy" – before the season started. But, with only 3 points, and a very weak striking force, I wonder if it would be OK to sell Fellaini, and use the money on a quality striker!??
I have so much hope for my Everton this season, but the start of the season so far is just awful...
Neal Kernohan
214 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:05:13
I feel sorry for Kelly and Kone and any other potential striker for that matter....no service, few opportunities, slow build up play, isolated etc etc etc
Paul Ferry
215 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:01:36
It's beyond belief that John has to say this but thank goodness he is in the mass majority:

John Daley - 423 - I think more patience is definitely required from some

Tony Draper
216 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:01:08
Someone has their dm's and RM's confused

Left handed's asked to play right handed ? That really was very much a dm trait wasn't it ?

Mark Tanton
219 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:07:32
I'll tell you what, I actually think bringing Thomas Ince and McCarthy in will really soften the blow of losing our two lads, and might improve our cutting edge. I saw Thomas Ince's goal today, and we could well do with that penetration.
Patrick Murphy
221 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:51:43
Have a good look at Everton's away record in the league over the last couple of years, 4 wins last season, the last one being at the start of January. Five the season before, how is it that some expect the team to win well away from home with that poor record.

I think that record has more to do with the players mentality as opposed to systems, styles, manager's personalities etc. I also believe it is almost a free-ride at Goodison for the players as they are under very little pressure to improve their attitude or skill sets. To my mind in all four games so far many of the players have just been going through the motions, with very minimal commitment.

If the board are not ambitious why should they pull their tripe out? The players are happy as long as the Chairman is happy and he's just happy to govern a premier league team in the most cost efficient way.

I was disappointed to hear that Sharpy had said that Everton under Moyes would have won a game like today's, when it is blatantly obvious that they probably wouldn't have.

If Sharp's not behind Martinez, then it smacks of the board or Kenwright not being behind him either, which can only result in the early demise of a promising young manager from the Everton job. I wager that Kenwright is none too happy with RM for refusiing to tow the party line by being BK's human shield during this shambles of a transfer window, and that BK will have Duncan or Stubbs in charge by Christmas.

A little on the fanciful side I admit, but as I said earlier this week the mood surrounding Goodison is not at all what it should be in the first few weeks of the season under the stewardship of a new manager.

Neal Kernohan
222 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:06:44
I mean Jelly lol
Tony Draper
225 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:07:53
Paul Ferry
I'm still re-reading that epic and probably well aimed posting (yet to be confirmicated)

(Yes you passed the "first 3 lines" test)

Matthew Williams
226 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:45:56
As far as I see it, if we lose Fellaini & Baines, then they should be sold for £30 million with Rooney coming back to us... at least we then have a quality striker who knows where the goal is. £10 million of the sale can be used to pay his wages.

We then need a left-back who will defend first and foremost, but likes getting forward to help attacks. Aidy White from Leeds fits the bill perfectly, only 21 years old too.

As for a leader & midfield general, it has to be Joey Barton, a great passer of a ball, good vision, can tackle, and of course is a narky, nasty fuck to boot. We're too lightweight in the midfield and still way too nice: no fight, no graft ,players playing soft tippy-tappy shite and failing.

Finally, a striker to partner Wayne, a man who scores goals for fun in Belgium, uses BOTH FEET, good with his head too, clever, deadly one-touch finisher,would be worshiped at the Old Lady, along with a fit and firing Rooney. I believe these two forwards would scare shitless most back fours in the world.

So only four players to turn our club around... now does our board have my vision and love for Everton Football
Club??!!!

Ben Jones
227 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:15:43
Andy

Most people on here, me included, were wanting a better style of football, as in the majority of Moyes' reign, bar last season, the style of football was almost unwatchable at times.

Then you're suggesting to change it back?

Good grief. It has only taken 3 games from the new manager to call back direct football.

Alan Smith
228 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:10:57
Are midfielders still allowed to break into the box and get ahead of their striker?
Paul Ellam
229 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:14:44
I think it’s pretty obvious we need somebody to finish off all these chances we create.

Hopefully we will keep Fellaini and Baines and buy in a top quality striker who consistently scores goals. My choice is Jelle Vossen or Graziano Pelle, both of who would cost less than £10m I’m sure. Maybe we should have tried to get Bony when he was available.

John Malone
230 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:00:01
Looks like we badly need a new dimension to our attack, hopefully come tuesday nght Victor Moses and more!
Raymond Fox
231 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:08:52
Paul, well written pal, amusing as well as logical.
Robbie Muldoon
232 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:16:06
A lot of blues need to relax and be patient with this new side under a new manager. I feel as though Mrtinez has arrived and decided to take an approach that doesn't involve rocking the boat too much from the stable ship left for him to take over. 3 games in and it's obvious a ball retentive focus is being drilled in to the players and they're adapting to this. I personally think Martinez should just now be bolder, especially after the transfer window closes and we know our squad for the rest of the year.

His biggest calls has been spot on, Barkley. He should go further and play Deleulofeu too. Then drop the dead weight that is Osman. I don't know about anybody else but I don't see Pienaar fitting into things too well as we go on.

As for Kone, this looks like a strange buy... he's not the striker we're after. I really wonder if he was brought in as anticipation of a departing Jelavic, which of course, didn't go through.

Tony Draper
233 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:17:39
Paul Ferry 2 points:

Yes, I've now read & digested and it's overall bloody good stuff
Happy Birthday for Tuesday BlueBlood !

Paul Ferry
235 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:26:16
Cheers Tony mate!
Carl Sanderson
236 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:24:08
Paul 453,

"I think it's pretty obvious we need somebody to finish off all these chances we create."

What chances? Yes, we had a lot of the ball but how many clear-cut openings did we create today?

Derek Knox
237 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:24:13
John (#454)
It looks like the RS are lining up Moses with a Porto defender and another young defender in a triple swoop. We'll know soon enough!
I would have liked Moses and or Tom Ince, may happen yet!
Paul Ferry
238 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:27:22
I've been undodded!
Andy Walker
239 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:17:50
Paul Ferry, I have been critical before we kicked a ball, not 3 games. My opinion is based on his record in the PL. Oh and you missed the very obvious point off your list:

Play more direct, attacking, purposeful, football.

Shame you have to make it personal, by trying to undermine an alternative view, but then that's what you do isn't it when people have the nerve to have a different view to you?
I called this from pre-season, matey, did you?

David Pearl
240 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:01:14
Well I agree with Brian. Surely it's plain for all to see that if RM wanted to change our style it should be gradual and not forced. In moving Fellaini back he has taken away one of our main attacking threats and left us toothless.

I had hopes that Jelavic would find his feet again after looking better in pre-season but the service to him is poor and the chances he gets he rushes. It's time for him to move on sadly and we need to invest in a top class striker. We have some of the poorest strikers in the Prem.

As for Arouna... we would've been better off spending £6m on a traffic kone ... If Gibson is out injured, we should play Heitinga who hasn't done much wrong lately.

John Ford
241 Posted 31/08/2013 at 19:51:25
References to Moyes taking 11 years to do 'whatever' are meaningless. He brought us to a standard within a couple of seasons which broadly speaking he was able to maintain throughout his tenure. He was unable, along with every other manager, to go to the next level and break the glass ceiling above which the money clubs exist.

The real question is whether Martinez can improve our position or is it more realistic for him to maintain a reasonable challenge for European football, ala Moyes. A cup would be great but if they're not quite hens teeth, they're still a rarity without big bucks.

Can anyone give me an example of any non money club in the last ten years which has played good attractive football on anything like a consistent basis? I certainly can't. I don't think they exist. Depressing isn't it.

So what realistically can we expect from our new manager? How can he change things if he's unable to bring in players In his own image? Two seasons then I hope to see something different and worthwhile, and this assumes he will have the resources to affect the change.

Raymond Fox
242 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:24:25
Where does this idea come from that we've played poor teams? 'Poor teams' is open to interpretation I suppose.

Norwich 11th last season away, bought big; WBA 8th last season; Cardiff away, beat Man City 3- 2 last week.

Don't think you can call them 'poor', in my opinion that is.

Patrick Murphy
243 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:34:31
There would be little point in moving Felli further forward if his future lies elsewhere. Seeing as a fit Gibson will occupy the role that Felli is currently playing and if Felli leaves we would have to buy another 6'4" player to replace MF, therefore RM has to find a way of solving our goalscoring problem without resorting to using MF as an auxiliary forward. If MF is still here this time next week then I would probably agree to him being moved into a more forward position, where in our team he is very effective.

Anthony Manning
246 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:49:32
Everton fans who are whinging after 3 games need to get a grip. You sound like fickle Liverpool supporters. Last week and today the Man of the Match was their keeper. Would Moyes have given Barkley, our best player so far, his chance? Enough said!
Kevin Rowlands
248 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:41:37
Andy Walker, what is it exactly that you 'called'?

The fact that we dominated against Norwich and should have won except for 2 lousy goals and also got a better result there than last season?

That we dominated our ONLY home game against WBA and were unlucky not to win?

Went to Cardiff today, a team with momentum having beat MC only last week, again dominated, should have won if not for some ridiculous refereeing decisions?

Yet all your spouting is gloom and doom, perhaps if you stopped posting shite, people wouldn't be having a go.

Colin Wainwright
249 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:51:48
James Martin @265........totally agree.
Tony Draper
250 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:00:14
Yes Paul F, you were deffo "undiddley doddified" !!
Phil Sammon
252 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:54:08
Yes Ross, it must be said, that was a shite post.

He seems to be a target for the 'boo boys' at the moment but Pienaar was actually good today. If you remember him at his best - he would take the ball from Baines - hold it - then release to the best one-touch crosser in the division. The problem as I see it, is that Baines WILL NOT put in a cross anymore. Has he been told not to? Is there nobody in the box? Or has he lost his touch?

Pienaar had a massive dip last year and still got dragged through 90 mins every game. He looks fresh now and I don't have any concerns about him starting games.

Mirallas was terrible again. I can't even begin to understand why he wasn't hooked and replaced with Deulofeu after 70 minutes. It was like watching Dithering Dave all over again.

My biggest disappointment with the season so far is Martinez's philosophy. Everybody focuses on this 'attractive' football - but Martinez has done little to hype that up. However his two promises were 1. Play without fear. 2. Flexibility.

Bollocks.

We are the most ridged we've ever looked. Regardless of the situation we play the same way. It's BORING!

Colin Wainwright
253 Posted 31/08/2013 at 20:56:21
I thought we played....very fuckin' well, tbh. Mirallas's ten bob head and a cheat of a ref cost us the points. We battered a team that has just beaten City. I'm looking forward to this season as long as we don't lose Felli and Baines. We'll destroy someone soon, trust me.
Tony Draper
254 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:01:43
And rightly so Paul
It was personal, unfunny and worst of all

Un-Evertonian

'Fraid so

More "Brett Angel" than water walking "Bobby Latch" mate

Ross Edwards
255 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:06:39
"Yes Ross, it must be said, that was a shite post."

You can't please them all Phil.

Tony Draper
256 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:07:02
477 Anthony Manning
More than just a scrap of truth there mate

I'm already enjoying Barkley's and Deulofeu's contributions, I've seen Stones take the cheekiest penalty EVER by a player in an Everton jersey !

These "YoungBloods" have careers ahead of them, and strike me down if they're not almost as exciting as a Phil Neville strike on goal (once per season).

I do accept that we do seem to "fanny about" a lot, rather that "twat the leather off it", neither are the answer. But one has taken 9 weeks to take hold, the other was persistent after 11 years...

Prefer fiddling with the fannying meself.

Nicholas Ryan
257 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:00:56
So far: One draw, in a fixture we lost last year [Norwich]. One draw to a team who had just beaten, and put 3 past, Manchester City; and a draw, in a game we totally dominated, and could easily have won.

It's not great, and it is frustrating; but: My God, it could be an awful lot worse!!

ps: Who was Norwich's MotM today... the famously injured Leroy Fer!

Andy Walker
260 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:14:15
Kevin

I called that we would struggle from the off, he would introduce a style of football that wasnt suited to our players, we would be Wigan reincarnated and he would not be able to adapt the style to the situation. It other words my comments are not in hindsight.

Its not to say RM cant adapt but my god he has to and quick. He always stuck to his own style at Wigan even though it got them relegated so I don't hold out much hope (I still remember Wigans shambles of a performance at Arsenal at the end of last season when they took the lead and instead of trying to shut up shop and hold out for a win which could have kept them up, he didnt and Arsenal thrashed them - v poor tactically).

Andy Walker
261 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:26:07
We seem to have gone into the twilight zone now with our success this season in some peoples eye, not being measured by points in a league table but by what ifs, maybes and should haves where we are now fighting for a Champions Excuses Place

Maybe somebody can put together the appropiate table, but then we would need to look at every other clubs what ifs and should haves. Fucking incredible.

Mark Jones
262 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:16:57
We're unbeaten. We've kept two clean sheets out of three league games. We've only played once at home. We've dominated all three games in terms of possession, passing, chances and territory.

We only drew with Norwich thanks to their squiffy goals. We only drew with WBA thanks to a brilliant performance by Foster. We only drew today thanks to a terrible refereeing decision.

We're only one win away from second place. We're finding our feet under a new manager. We're almost certainly going to see some kind of action before the transfer window shuts.

Like everybody else I'm not pleased that we only have three points so far. I was hoping for more. A lot more. And I feel more nervous the longer it takes to find a win, and the worse our finishing seems to get.

But it's very early days and I'm convinced that we are only a couple of steps away from being a really good team. Regardless of our manager, we can put a starting eleven out that can compete with anybody, and once we get our goal scoring knack we're going to pick up a lot of points fast - we've not looked in any danger if defeat, even when we were behind at Norwich.

Look at the table at this link here: http://www.transferleague.co.uk/league-tables/transfer-league-table-last-five-seasons.html and realise we're performing miracles in the scheme of things.

As fans, our job isn't to bitch and moan when things don't go perfectly. It's to pull our weight, get behind the team and push them on to success. So rather than crying, get down to Goodison and support your team. Buy the shirt and put some money in the club coffers. Do something about it.

Kevin Rowlands
263 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:27:58
Andy, do you also remember them playing us off the park and twatting us 3:0? (you still haven't answered my Neville playing question BTW) give the bloke a chance ffs, were only three games into the season and for the most. part have played very well.
Mark Tanton
264 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:35:47
Sorry to change subject a little but someone mentioned Celtic's leftback coming to us in replacement for Baines - well SSN are saying that Celtic are trying to get Butner in on loan. Very interesting, in the whole transfer jigsaw. So much is going to kick into place once one signature goes on a contract at one club.
Toby Smith
266 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:37:54
Mark Jones #501 Absolutely spot on. Especially the bit about getting down to Goodison. One home game we've played, Citeh lost at Cardiff last week, Big spending Southampton lost at Norwich today, we dominated Cardiff today as we've done in every game so far this season. I've lost count of the times I've watched us in last 36 years (specifically the last 11) and shouted 'Keep the ball' - It's going to come right. The next 2 days are obviously vital but FFS Keep the faith and think a little bit longer term. You can't seriously tell me any of you would rather have Moyes than Roberto? COYB
Andy Walker
267 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:40:25
Course I do Kevin, a game thrown away by Neville, I posted that very day that Neville would immediately retire. Got that wrong.

On Barkley he's the big postive of the season, hope he stays fit.
To repeat yet again this is not a judgement based on 3 games. I had this opinion of RM before he became our manager. I want him to prove me wrong, but if he doesnt we are in deep shit.

Tony Draper
269 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:37:25
Calling that we'd struggle early doors is hardly the forecast of a soothsayer is it ?
We haven't had a managerial change for 11 years

Personally, I reckon 2 seasons is fair time before I start jabbing my finger
Unless utter catastrophe befalls us

After all "babytears and the shortpockets" are hardly going to drown El Bob in cash to splash are they ?

Also, our striker(s) have hardly been overwhelmed with opportunities have they ? (And by that I mean prior to the last 3 PL games)

FFS keep some perspective, we're Evertonians

Mark Griffiths
270 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:46:16
Mark 506. I thought Butner has gone to turkey or russia or somewhere already? To be honest, as I have said on another thread, I don't think fell or baines will be going anywhere.
Adam Smith
271 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:38:59
Hi guys,

random one here; does anyone have an email contact address for Alan Myers? I know that there has been a lot of contact between him and fans lately and I'm not into twittertwattering so can't get him there.

I just want to badger him and the club to at least have a go at getting Lewis Holtby on loan from Spurs. Apparently he is available for loan and he would be a perfect fit for us - tenacious, excellent engine, great passer, two good feet - can play as holding mid, in the middle or behind the striker. He is young and an Evertonian and needs games if he is to stand a hope in hell of making the Germany world cup team. It is a mark of how much better than us Spurs now are, that he can't get into their team. He would be perfect for a Martinez style team.

Now I know how childish it may appear to write to the club about this - like a kid writing to santa or something - but I am getting so fed up of everyone out maneuvering us in the transfer market this year. And that is whilst still accepting that we don't have a pot to piss in! Gareth Barry would give us little and it just appears to me that we don't even ATTEMPT these things - Ki who has just gone to Sunderland from Swansea would improve us for example - yet it worked for Deulofeu; why not others?

I just thought Myers might be the best bet to at least get it looked at - if you don't try, you don't get - as true of this email as potential transfer targets.

Alternatively, if someone does have a way of contacting him and agrees with me feel free to forward it yourself.

And breathe! ( sound of me dismounting my soap box!)

Andy Walker
272 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:53:06
Funny, Tony, how hindsight can be so useful. At the time, no-one agreed with my view when I posted it. Quite a hostile reaction in fact, you obviously were of the same view then but just kept it to yourself, eh?
Ross Edwards
273 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:54:43
Adam, while you're at it mate, badger him about Defoe as well.
David Greenwood
275 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:01:38
Celtic rumoured to be after Buttner, as a replacement for Izaguirre, who is on his way to us, as a replacement for LB.

Hope we keep LB, but I suspect lots of deals already in place, just waiting for Ross's 1st September bonus/loyalty clauses to kick in and then we are off and running.

Kevin Rowlands
276 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:53:34
3 games in and making ridiculous assumptions is not giving RM a fair chance Andy, personally I will be very happy when this Transfer Window ends, and that ginger twat hero of yours certainly hasn't made things easy for RM with his snide and underhand tactics, at least then we'll know what we have going forward.
Mark Taylor
277 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:53:31
Obviously RM has to have some time beyond 3 games but I think it is reasonable to have some kind of prognosis by 10-12 games. Actually I think the day of reckoning for us will come sooner, early next week, when we will discover the extent of our boards ambition or lack thereof.

If the best RM can do is sign McCarthy for an inflated fee and/or bring in Barry on loan, my patience will be stretched to the point where after 10-12 games, I had better see the sunny uplands.

It is not helping at the moment that so many of our key players are off form- Mirallas, Osman (though a bit improved today), Pienaar- and also that there is a strong sense that Fella and/or Baines are off and this is affecting their play and the morale of the team.

I feel we're on a bit of a knife edge right now. I wouldn't even rule out a relegation dogfight. Certainly we face far stiffer opposition over the next month or two than to date.

One big upside appears to be Delboy. Given the form of some other team members, he is surely worth more than a 7 minute cameo?

Amit Vithlani
278 Posted 31/08/2013 at 21:54:24
Paul Ferry enjoyed your post 429. Brought a tear to my eye, then I realised the tears were already there from reading the missus credit card statement.

Happy birthday fella.

Andy Walker, I think you undermine yourself without needing others to do so. Saying we would struggle before a ball had been kicked is even worse than being judgmental after 3 games. Give our new manager a break and try and analyze the performances for what they really are, instead of picking out the only negatives to suit your pre-conceptions on how the season would turn out.

Andy Walker
279 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:05:35
Barry 333

Yes got the bit about the CL teams:

'Our so called great players would be at CL clubs if they really were "the dog's"; as it is the dynamic duo upon which all hopes are pinned are being bid for by just their previous manager'

Clearly you don't think are players are good enough to be in CL teams. And on the other hand you think 6th isn't any sort of achievement with a team of players which by your own admission arent good enough for CL clubs.

So whats your point you are arguing with yourself.

Tony Draper
281 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:14:17
Adam Smith
No-one who ever tried guaranteed that they would fail

Go for it
I think it's a neat call, TBH I was kind of choked when he went to "the white tarts", as you say.
Lewis is a BlueBlood

Do it
I will too

Andy Walker
282 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:16:53
Amit how does having an opinion of a manager's ability's based on 3 years of watching his performance undermine anything? Were you unable to form your own opinion of him (if so why?) or did you think he is a great manager?

Andy Walker
283 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:24:06
...oh and Amit its no pre-conception, its an opinion formed based on actual hard evidence over 3 years.
Patrick Murphy
284 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:25:17
I could only base an opinion on Everton's manager as I had little idea of how Wigan performed in their games over a full 90 minutes unless they were playing Everton, same as I had little idea of how most of the other managers fared. You must have had a fascination with RM from the day he stepped into football management Andy.
Amit Vithlani
285 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:26:16
Sorry Andy but 3 years of watching whose performance? Roberto Martinez at Wigan? How does that tell you anything about what he will do at Everton, with a different squad of (better quality) players?

If I extended your logic, Manure were wrong to appoint Moyes as he never won a trophy and never challenged for the title. Or indeed, Everton should not have appointed Moyes 11 years ago as had only ever managed in the lower leagues.

Utter tosh.

Andy Walker
286 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:28:14
Patrick if he goes we are still in the shit, we should never have apppointed him but we are were we are. My solution is that he realises that he needs to compromise his views and recognises he cant play the style of football he wants with the personnel he has. How he might realise this is the question for me, could it be by via self awarenss (unlikley) or maybe by listening to the coaches, players around him and starting to appreciate what the tradition of our club has always been, ie passionate, quality, pacy, sometimes direct but ultimatley effect football that get the passionate Goodison crowd behind the team. I cant see our crowd putting up with cross field passing for half the game for many games, they will get on the back of the team in my view and what has always been one of our greatest strengths ie our support, could become the opposite.
Andy Walker
289 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:38:53
Amit I agree that I don't think Man Utd should have appointed Moyes, big risk. I cant see any other way of deciding whether you think a manager is good enough to manage your team than by looking at their past performance. Not always a guarantee but better than tea leaves, dowsers , tossing a coin, etc.

Any average football fan knows what you get with RM, the way he likes playing, (pass pass pass) sets his team up (one up front), his type of players (technically good with the ball). That's what he's done his whole career and its no surprise he continued to do it at our club. Don't get me wrong, he could be great with a load of money where he can buy the best players who can deliver his ideas on the pitch. I actually think he would have done better at Man Utd than Moyes. It's about matching your manager to your club and RM just isn't a good fit for us in my opinion.

Barry Rathbone
293 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:47:53
Andy Walker 524, What on earth are you blustering about?

You seem to be equating 6th with being a CL qualifying club, you appear to have no idea what you're talking about.

Your attack on our new manager deciding the Wigan escapes season upon season and trouncing of us en route to winning the cup are of no merit.

Thus concluding his methods are not effective - one eyed in the extreme and I daresay I can guess why.

Patrick Murphy
294 Posted 31/08/2013 at 22:55:21
Right Andy now I get your drift, he's too good for Everton as we can't afford the type of players that he needs to play the type of football that he likes to play.

Obviously Everton and some of its supporters have changed over the years, because all the time I have watched them, most of the people I know who go to the game want to see good football. Obviously they want Everton to win but they also want to see us do it in style.

I wonder if Pulis is still available as he would have had the Goodison faithful roaring their approval, if your assessment of the fans desires are correct.

Jamie Crowley
296 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:00:40
I had soccer tournaments all day long with the kids and I watched on delay.

I can't believe the amount of negativity on here frankly.

We have completely and thoroughly outplayed our opponents the first 3 games. Yes, there's some sorting out to do to be sure:

Jelavic is not suited to play in this system. Kone is a much better option.
Osman is woeful. I've always backed him but it's definitely time for him to become a squad player.
Delo needs more time on the pitch - he's an exciting player and attacks relentlessly. But he did play quite a bit mid-week so I'll forgive the late substitution today.

Watching the first 3 games you can see what Martinez is trying to do. And frankly despite the build-up play clocked on a fucking sundial, it's still much easier on the eyes in my opinion.

FFS, Spurs are on 6 points and only scored 2 goals - and I think both were from the spot?! A rightful Baines penalty and Felliani not hitting a post and we'd be on 7 points.

Again, we're frankly battering the opposition. Results will come.

Then there's this whole losing our two best players dark cloud looming...

I say keep the faith.

It sure as fuck beats watching a Moyes team set up not to lose!! (Andy....) Unless you like insurance seminars and watching paint dry. Or maybe a conference on the joys of a timeshare?

Jesus! Really?

COYB

Simon Harris
298 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:33:17
Jamie - I hear what you're saying, but having sat through 120 mins against Stevenage, an insurance seminar would have been light relief.
Suresh Gill
299 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:26:52
Martinez in post match conference said "The goals will come."


But he didn't say when. Talk the talk but very soon he needs to walk the walk.

I'm still calm.

Barry Rathbone
300 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:42:34
Suresh, He probably left his crystal ball in the living room otherwise he could have given dates and time couldn't he?
Patrick Murphy
301 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:47:22
I bought a Golden Goal ticket last week and my time was 14.11.2013 03.57 must have a chance (guffaw)
Jamie Crowley
302 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:43:18
I know Simon... but we still kept the ball for silly periods of time (progress).

Delo looked superb.

Fellaini still looked up for it despite all the distractions.

Barkley looked very good.

And we didn’t play even close to our first 11 - all this in the Stevenage game.

All I’m saying is this is going to take time. And there’s a hell of a lot of positives to still draw on. And most importantly you can see what the end game is under RM and it’s NOT sitting back protecting a lead.

Oh, and I doubt very highly we’ll ever go to Anfield and give up before a ball is kicked.
Can’t ever forgive or forget "The Capitulation Game."

Our new manager is an improvement from the past in my opinion.

Now if we’re still timing our speed of play with a sundial come Christmas... I reserve the right to do a 180.

Si Cooper
303 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:32:30
Some massively over the top assessments of our current form / possible finishing position.

The results have obviously been disappointing and our lack of bite is a concern (though not really anything new) but we are not playing badly and have not been seriously threatened by three teams who will trouble plenty of others this season.

I am surprised people thought Baines lacked commitment today but a couple of other players are letting the team down at the moment.

Mirallas is well below his best (but he should be more effective countering against the stronger sides who are more likely to commit their fullbacks forward) and Jelavic appears to have lost any finishing prowess he did possess. Jelavic was very unlucky with his headed attempt, however, which had the keeper beaten until the deflection off Turner's outstretched arm (missed by everyone if the lack of comment is anything to go by) actually made it possible for Marshall to effect a very good save.

I would agree that RM perhaps could have tried something different earlier in the game today; pushing Fellaini further forward and / or bringing on Deulofeu much earlier, but these are minor moans in my opinion. I believe that Fellaini routinely plays the defensive midfield role for Belgium and it is what he prefers,

Suresh Gill
304 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:47:39
Barry RM's press conference always brings fresh outtake of things and I can see us only improving with him.

Whatever said we still need to finish better. IMO

Patrick Murphy
305 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:56:44
Si I can't believe that nearly all the comments from the professionals mentioned it hit the guy's hand but nobody said it should have been a penalty. The more I see of the Baines incident the more I can't believe that a penalty wasn't given.
Brent Stephens
306 Posted 31/08/2013 at 23:45:55
Paul Ferry #432 "it was Osman in the conservatory with the lead piping; Jesus wept, Bobby, dump this lightweight feather once and for all, so many reasons, so many reasons".

And that just shows your colours, Paul. Because Osman today had a reasonable game but you don't mention alongside the reference to him the poor games by others.

Start Del Boy? On what basis? Some time against minnows Stevenage and a few minutes today. The guy might turn out well but too early to say. I think he's predictable in what I've seen so far - you can see which way he'll go by his body shape.

Disdain indeed, friend. Disdain indeed.

Si Cooper
307 Posted 01/09/2013 at 00:03:11
Patrick, the commentary on Sky mentioned a deflection but seemed to shy away from saying it hit his arm (which it clearly did!) and made out it made the keeper's save more remarkable (which it clearly didn't as he was going the wrong way and would never have reached the ball on its original trajectory!).

The local radio commentators (City or Merseyside) mentioned two clear penalty shouts at half-time so I presume they spotted it and called it correctly.

Andrew Cutler
308 Posted 01/09/2013 at 00:06:12
If the RS and Manure draw (likely) and Arse beat spud (or draw)...again likely, the top team in the EPL is on 7 points...we are on 3. Hardly a breakaway differential. And Norwich and Cardiff at home will be no easy beats this season
Suresh Gill
309 Posted 01/09/2013 at 00:09:21
Patrick 551: there was pun intended when.i mentioned "But he didn't say when." but thanks for the laugh anyway. Cheers
Adam Smith
310 Posted 01/09/2013 at 00:11:43
Ross #516 - can put it on the message if I ever get an address! Might be tougher to swing by Spurs as they don't have much back up there do they?

Tony #526 - Go for it mate! I will definitely send it in if I can find his email address - not listed on the OS.

C'mon guys as futile as it is someone must know how to contact Alan Myers. A thousand ripples from a single stone and all that!

I would try to contact BK but he'd probably just try to buy me off with Blood Brothers tickets whilst he had Jenny make me eggs on toast. Plus I'm too busy to hear a weepy tale of the fucking boy's pen!

Ernie Baywood
311 Posted 01/09/2013 at 00:32:25
Of course he gets time... but we are allowed to judge what we're seeing... and I just can't imagine how this setup is ever going to produce goals. The build up is so slow that it becomes centred around the attacking midfielder 30 yards out from goal with 5/6/7 players in front of him. People on the live forum where talking about Baines/Coleman/Mirrallas/Pienaar - well the fact is that every time they get it they are confronted with a full back and wide midfielder as they have all the time in the world to drop back. Osman Fellaini have the easiest job in the world - no commitment to get forward - just keep recycling the ball.

The forward has no chance - he just runs around the middle. No angled balls available as the wide players are marked out of the game. The only position that gets any time and space is the attacking mid (Ross). And he's facing half the opposition and one forward looking for a straight pass.

We have to get the wide attackers closer to the forward and move the ball quicker. It's not long ball, it's just common sense.

Michael Winstanley
314 Posted 01/09/2013 at 02:22:01
The criticism of Martinez on here is laughable.

In Del Boy (the one trick pony!?!) and Barkley we have two fantastic players with pace, skill and the desire to score goals. Del Boy knows he's good enough for a starting place and Barkley will continue to develop into the football genius he is.

When we're scoring goals all this keep ball we're playing will become far more attractive to watch because it will be effective. We're toothless up front at the moment, there doesn't appear to be any set way of playing around the box to create chances. It's as though we're relying on individual brilliance to create chances.

Mirallas hasn't played well but could easily have 3 or 4 goals this season. He missed two great chances today. He appears to be ineffective playing wide right, I can't remember him beating his man and bursting forward. With Jeli not firing I'd be tempted to play Kone up top with Del Boy on the right.

Fellaini played deep midfield today otherwise it would have been Osman, so you see why he played there yeah?

Martinez has said he's not happy with our finishing, Del Boy put a great cross in at the end which everyone watched. We can only improve in that department.

The ref today was a shocker in that first half, how that wasn't a penalty is beyond me and the bookings of Coleman and Barkley were a joke.

Whilst I'm here...every team we play defends the 18 yard line. They know they're not going to have loads of possession against us, although Norwich did play some football. Cardiff were at home today and largely played us on the break, I like watching us play, we don't look like getting beat and we offer an attacking threat.

The goals will come, against Chelsea we'll need three as Lampard will bag a couple as usual, Fellaini to get the winner in the 90th minute.

Harold Matthews
315 Posted 01/09/2013 at 02:16:07
Adam. Forget the e.mail. A few letters to a few people, including Martinez, via Finch Farm will get a result.
Paul Ferry
316 Posted 01/09/2013 at 04:27:59
#599 – Fellaini to get the winner in the 90th minute (at Chelski).

Hmmmm...

Tahir Abdullah
317 Posted 01/09/2013 at 04:36:47
Agree wholeheartedly with the observation that many on here are overly negative on the performances to date. Some of the doomsayers are even yearning for the "glory days" under OFM; this despite the reality that Gollum shafted EFC and jumped ship to Manure and is forever gone.

Re. the complaints about Roberto's suitability, I would ask the doubters who they think would have been a better appointment? Surely not Malky Mackay, Mark Hughes or any of the other candidates touted on earlier threads. For once we have a manager with more than two functioning brain cells (hoof it or cross it ala OFM) between his ears.

Looking forward to the Chelsea match; at least we will not be rolling over before the first whistle as we have done in all games against Chelski under OFM. NSNO, COYB!
Stuart Gray
318 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:11:52
2 away games, undefeated, dominating possession. Unlucky against Norwich, could easily have 9 points. And this is a manager who is trying to reverse 11 years of another style of play. I'd say he's done a pretty remarkable job so far. Some of these players have only ever known hoof ball.

I suspect we'll have a couple of new players in tomorrow with money got for Fellaini and I doubt Martinez will be too disappointed with that. Let's not forget, when Moyes had a similar situation with Lescott as Martinez has had with Fellaini and Baines we were so unsettled we were shite so maybe Martinez deserves some credit for it not affecting the team so much.

Ian Bennett
319 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:58:04
Just for 10 minutes, can we not try two up top at end of the match? You score goals by getting men in the box, and it looks to me as if we still don't do it nearly enough.

Sam Hoare
320 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:30:20
Still very early days. Fortune has not really favoured us. As ever!

My one disappointment is that I hoped Martinez would make us more incisive in attack and quicker on the break and there is definitely no sign of that yet.

Transfer madness ending and another couple of weeks to get the players moving the ball around quicker. Gibson back too. Chelsea will be a good test of where we are.

Al Reddish
321 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:01:39
The big miss is Gibson. He is one player who can spot and execute a 'creative' pass from midfield. Heitinga is another who can do a similar job (in this system).
Maybe it is time to try Mirallas up front with Del Boy on the wings. Mirallas hasn't set the world on fire this season, but he has the pace and skill to create his own chances if he is getting short supply from his team mates. McCarthy (if he came) would probably add a bit more enthusiasm and running from the middle of the park than Fellaini does, though we will definitely miss the big Belgian further up the field.
Failing this, it's got to be worth a shot playing Big Vic upfront. Faster than Jelavic (and seems to know the offside rule), more presence than we have seen so far from Kone and can hold the ball up long enough for our slow midfield to catch up with it.
Michael Brooks
322 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:00:32
Carl Sanderson #396

I never wanted Martinez, I have always through we was a poor manage and the FA cup win was pure luck. Managers must be judged on whether they take a team forward and he took Wigan down. However, he is here now and the right minded (not the ones who chap Billy Bullshit) Everton fans who have him on a very short leash must give him a litte time.

Paul Gladwell
323 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:13:40
Sam, to be fair with the quicker on the break shout, we haven't hardly had the chance to break as be three games we have played has saw the opposition camped deep in their own half virtually all game as we try to unravel them, sadly the poor performances from Mirralas and shite centre forwards when the chances come begging has led to the boo boys targeting our manager, we have had well enough chances to win all three games, we should be looking at a striker in the £10m plus range to solve this issue.
James Marshall
324 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:32:44
The problem we have, and will continue to have (as Wigan did to a lesser degree) is that we murder teams possesion-wise but lack the cutting edge of a top team.

We can keep the ball all day, but without anyone to put the ball through, or create real clear-cut chances, we'll keep on struggling.

It's all very well knocking it about, but we take such a long time that teams simply drop back, all file into position and we never get anywhere. Barcelona get away with it because they have Iniesta, Xavi & Messi at all all making runs, and threading balls through on every angle imaginable.

We have Leon Osman and Steven Pienaar trying to do the same jobs (thankfully not Fellaini any more alledgedly) so we struggle. Mirallas looks to me to be unsettled by all the Fellaini leaving nonsense and isn't playing well at all, and Barkley is still a kid. Deolofeu looks classy but again, bit-part player and so young & inexperienced.

If things don't happen early for us, we run out of ideas and even keeping the ball the way we do, we're always going to be ripe for the counter attack. Always.

Jelavic is shockingly terrible, so bad it's painful and embarrassing to watch him. What the hell was that effort with the outside of his foot yesterday? Just a terrible footballer for some reason now, and I have to say I can't see it changing.

At the end of the day, Martinez has a way of playing that while admirable, it's not effective and he got Wigan relegated by playing it, and sticking to his guns playing it. I just hope that it doesn't continue because here we are, 3 games in and he's already giving the exact same interviews he gave all last season - talking about 'the wins will come' and 'I'm confident' etc.

I was never confident in him, and so far have not changed my view much. I like the way we play, I like the passing game - what I don't like is the Wigan-esque results so far witnessed.

We should never have bought Kone - we should have sold Fellaini and bought another midfield player and a quality striker.

Al Reddish
325 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:52:15
James #775. You are right that we should never have bought Kone. However, when your chairman gives you a transfer budget of £5m before disappearing in a theatrical puff of smoke, and you are desperate for a centre forward, there is not a lot else you can do.
As for Fellaini, Billy should have said 'this is the price and you have til this date to sign him!'
James Marshall
326 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:37:23
True Al, though much like Kone in the 6yd box, I think Martinez snatched at the signing....
Ste McNally
327 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:21:57
Well, three games played and the knives are already being sharpened. I seem to recall that both Howard Kendall and Sir Alex Ferguson were close to the sack with their respective fans baying for their blood. I'm not suggesting that a trophy winning spree is imminent, under the guidance of RM; however, it seems to be a modern-day trait, that fans expect their team to be playing attractive football while winning every single contest.

Without the finances that are available at certain other clubs, Everton will always need to work smart – in the transfer market and in getting 110% out of every player – to stand any chance of remaining in the upper echelons of the EPL.

In my opinion, given time, I feel that RM has the ability to maintain Everton's recent top-six league placing or perhaps better it. It can't be underestimated, the influence the fans can have on bringing the club forward and that's why it is crucial that RM should be afforded time to stamp his own footballing philosophies on the team.

The biggest concern at Everton isn't the manager; or current playing staff – it's the serious lack of investment – which has held the club back since the inception of the EPL.

In RM we SHOULD trust.

Kevin Tully
328 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:38:44
Q. Did anyone seriously expect that we would be able to change the way we play and a seamless transition would take place?

We have basically cut out 90% of long balls from our approach play. Sometimes that was successful - Fellaini would knock it down, and we would gain territory in the opposition half, but that's not how the new boss wants us to play is it?

I can see mistakes, I can see Martinez should have made sub's earlier yesterday. But I will wait until this transfer window is closed, we have had a chance to play this system for 10-12 games before I can reasonably say it will, or will not work.


One thing though, if it does come off, it will be joy to watch if we are winning games, and speeding up our play. Frustrating as hell if you are watching a goalless draw.

All those who want to write him off already should really take a deep breath, or do you have the patience of a 5 year old child?

James Marshall
329 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:39:11
I have the patience of a 7 yr old ;-)

Wigan were a joy to watch at times last season.

Jim Lloyd
330 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:21:24
Well said Kevin.
Eugene Ruane
331 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:44:52
We had one manager for 11 years, we now have a new manager attempting something a little different.

The new manager has had four competitive games and while these games have all provided frustration in one form or another, we have lost none of them, are through to the next round of the league cup and are a win off second place.

To be moaning at this stage of the game is beyond fucking ridiculous.

Jim Lloyd
332 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:11:34
It's odd to me that some posters have said how poor Martinez is and,I assume, how good Moyes was.

Well, I saw Wigan wipe the floor with us at our place with fast attacking football. I saw them give City a game and deservedly beat them at Wembley.I saw us capitulate at Wembley and I thank the gods I wasn't there to see us against Liverpool.

Yeah, only two games but he's only had 4 competitive games in charge of us, and I think we have bossed every one of them. It is right that we are slow building up an attack. He's trying to instil keeping possession and frankly, some of our layers are not good at it. I think he sees this but is trying to give them some time to get used to this change.

I don't argue with criticisms such as him bringing on players at very late stages of a game and maybe he's got things to learn and has to adjust to a new set of players.

But let's see who we're left with after Monda and who he's able to bring in. He's had about £mill s far, probably thew lowest in the whole bloody Division.

So cut the man some slack

Andy Walker
333 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:25:51
High possession football only works if you have technically gifted high quality players. We generally do not have this style or quality of player particularly in midfield and up front.

It is tactically naive to play in this style without the right personnel. No one should require any matches or extended time frame to figure this out, and certainly not a PL manager.

Andy Walker
334 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:39:08
By the way presume some will be watching the RS v Manure game. have you seen the speed its being played at? Light years away from our current game play.
Jim Lloyd
335 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:44:19
It took BR at least half a season to work out how to use his players and they have much better resources than us. I don't think it's tactically naive, as we have had much the better of these games. What we haven't got is a forward who can finish off moves at the moment.
James Marshall
336 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:56:13
Andy Walker#876 - exactly mate. This is absolutely what I see and have been saying. Spot on.

Barcelona we ain't, stop trying to play like them until you have players who can play like them.

Amit Vithlani
337 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:26:03
The high tempo football preached by so many sees Moyes fail (yet again) at Anfield. There are more ways to win a football match than 100-mile-an-hour huff and puff.
Max Fine
339 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:32:37
We're only 1 point behind Man U - calm down people. The premiership is a much tougher competition than last year and we're not far off the points we had from the same teams last season (although WBA weren't generous enough to score for us this time unfortunately). We have two exciting "new" players in Ross and the Barca lad, and our defense is looking solid.

Yes I'll be slightly gutted to see Fellaini leave tomorrow, but if the figures of £28 million being mentioned are acurate we have absolutely mugged them... if we can swap our sometimes imperious sometimes indifferent belgian for two £15 million players (hopefully one of them a forward) I'll be quite happy. Whether it's the speculation gettting to the Mo-fro or Martinez's tactics, the ironing-board-chested one just hasn't been with it so far this season.

Gary Russell
340 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:08:12
Some people have very short memories.... chill out FFS. Early days and give the man and his team some time before ya start burning him at the stake!
Andy Walker
341 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:22:21
Amit 902, you are aware that there were 2 sides on the pitch arent you ;). if not here are now 2 sides playing in North London demonstrating similar pace and power.
Andy Walker
342 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:22:21
Amit 902, you are aware that there were 2 sides on the pitch arent you ;). if not here are now 2 sides playing in North London demonstrating similar pace and power.
Brent Stephens
343 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:36:04
Amit, RS won playing high tempo football.
Jim Lloyd
344 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:46:26
It won't matt what tempo we play at if we don't put the ball in the net
Brent Stephens
345 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:54:52
Jim, precisely. And / but we'll be less likely to put the ball in the net at the moment at the slow tempo we're playing.
Jim Lloyd
346 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:57:04
No Brent, I don't agree with that. We had 4 good chances to score and didn't take them. The young Barca lad put a beauty cross in and no one went for it. Ross could've given Jelly a free shot when almost in the six yard box but chose to shoot. Mind you, Jelly might have missed it.

Not sure if it was a penalty or not, so we can't count that but against a defensive set up we made enough chances to score. If we scored, they'd have had to come out. As it is, I don't see that the tempo is the major factor. It seems to me that Miralles, Jelavic, Pienaar and Osman are not performing,

Amit Vithlani
347 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:56:02
Andy and Brent. The comparison I was making was with OFM. Moyes turns up at Anfield and still loses, playing a high tempo game with a better side than Everton. It was much more direct than he had us playing last season. There is more than one way to win a game.

To emphasise the point, have a read of the Executioner’s Bong and the deconstruction of the Cardiff game


"The problem as I see it is twofold; the speed of moving the ball from midfield to attack is too slow and when chances are created we simply don’t have the personnel to finish things.

This isn’t really a new problem.

Looking at the passing tempo first, a look at yesterday’s touches per pass showed we averaged 1.38 touches per pass. This is in fact quicker than the 1.42 touches per pass from Moyes last game in charge against Chelsea but a fair bit slower than the 1.26 that Barcelona – the benchmark quick passing tempo side – recorded in their last game against Atlético Madrid."

Yes we are slow going back to front, but no slower than last season. We aren’t Barcelona, but we are creating chances and getting the ball wide into dangerous positions. Its the lack of a cutting edge which is currently costing us wins.

Brent Stephens
348 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:04:19
Jim #"As it is, I don't see that the tempo is the major factor. It seems to me that Miralles, Jelavic, Pienaar and Osman are not performing".

Jim,those two don't have to be mutually exclusive. I agree that some ain't performing (which includes the problem of not providing the killer pass or converting when the chance did come). And I also think that we would have produced more chances had we played at a higher tempo...

...watching the games today what was noticeable so often was the crosses coming into the box with a few defenders running desperately towards their own goal - so hard to defend. Contrast that with most of our crosses this season - made after such a slow build-up that they are made into a packed defence who have had time to organise, read the situation and are facing upfield - so much easier to defend. Some have commented how few quality crosses Baines is getting in this season.

Brent Stephens
349 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:11:13
Amit I can't agree that our build-up is no slower than last year.

And I'm not sure what your suggesting as alternative ways to play other than high tempo? Not saying it's the only way just that I'm not sure what your point is, what you are suggesting as alternatives.

Jim Lloyd
350 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:27:26
SorryBrent, I'll have to go for my tea! I think there's two separate points here. One is the speed of attack and the the is whether we can score no matter whart the tempo. Interesting pointsbut all in all my major argument is that it isa different style of play. The managern eeds time I think and |I hope we give him that time.

Now me tea calls. I'm off...in quick tempo!

Brent Stephens
351 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:35:08
Jim, should you race back from tea any time, I think we're probably seeing things the same way - two points not one; and Roberto needs some time to get it right.
Ross Edwards
352 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:45:58
Adam Smith, the emails for all the staff at Everton are all similar.

firstname.surname@evertonfc.com.

So Alan Myers would be alan.myers@evertonfc.com, Martinez would be Roberto.Martinez@evertonfc.com and so on.

Ross Edwards
353 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:48:30
Roberto and Martinez in lower case.
Barry Rathbone
354 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:01:22
Tempo comes with practice - ask any musician.
Amit Vithlani
355 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:43:31
My points, Brent, are several.

First, there is more than one way to win a game, slow tempo, high tempo, KITAP1 (which is what RS did to Manure today ) or Hoofball. Being quicker in your approach play does not guarantee that you will be able to turn the oppo's defence and create chances. OFM tried, but Liverpool defended deep and still shut United out.

Second, Martinez' chosen philosophy of slow tempo, passing style is fine by me. We did ok against Cardiff, dominating possession which I really enjoyed. You seem to think our slow tempo was the primary reason we did not create chances and I disagree. We got the ball into wide areas many times and worked good cross positions.

Third, the problem with our results is a failure to finish our chances. We are creating chances and getting crosses in. Baines had a clear penalty denied and Jela missed a very good chance. Worse, I think we have a lost a cutting edge. This is not just putting chances away. Its also about beating players one on one (Mirallas last season, sadly not this season) or making clever runs. Deulofeu and Barkley are the only two players to have shown a cutting edge so far.

Fourth, our style is not much different to last season. The stat from Executioner's Bong showed us playing at a slow passing tempo against Chelsea last season. I recall a similar style when we played Norwich away and Reading away. We lost all three games having created a host of chances.

Finally, it is far too early to be passing judgement on Martinez and his style of play. We have started no worse than many of the seasons under OFM. Moyes was given breathing space even though we came close to relegation in 2003-2004, lest we forget.

Brent Stephens
356 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:21:39
Amit, you're making more points than I think you did originally. Para by para...

First para. We agree.

Second para. Where we might see things differently. Yes, we got the ball into wide areas, good crossing positions. But given the slowness of the build-up, by that time the defence was back in numbers, organised, facing out to see the breadth of the threat. So Baines now seems to get fewer quality passes in because of packed defences which have had time to organise.

Third para. We agree. We have lost the cutting edge. As well as the problems of slow build-up, not as an alternative explanation.

Fourth para. I admit it's only my impression that we are playing slower tempo. Though that's in all our games so far as opposed to a selected few from last season.

Fifth para. We agree. He should be allowed time. Too early to pass judgement on where it will end. But not too early to comment on how each game, and all games so far, have gone (as we are all doing).

Good to talk, mate.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb