Everton stumble to shock Palace defeat

, 16 April, 83comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 2 - 3 Crystal Palace

Everton's top-four hopes took a hammer blow under the Goodison lights this evening as Crystal Palace inflicted on them only their second home defeat of the season.

A first-half goal by Jason Puncheon and then another early in the second period from Scott Dann stunned the Blues who needed a win or a draw to reclaim fourth place from Arsenal.

Half-time substitute Steven Naismith looked to have sparked a badly-needed fight-back with an hour played when he prodded in from close range but a killer third goal from Cameron Jerome left Roberto Martinez's side with too much to do in the final 17 minutes, even though Kevin Mirallas gave them hope with a second goal late on.

Everton, starting with an attacking line-up boasting Gerard Deulofeu, Mirallas and Aiden McGeady, started well with Gareth Barry heading over from an early corner and McGeady letting fly with a powerful drive that also narrowly cleared the crossbar.

For all their dominance, though, the Blues were struggling to carve out clear-cut chances and Palace showed them the way midway through the first half when Yannick Bolasie skinned Leighton Baines down the right channel. His low cross was pushed out by Tim Howard but the visitors had bodies on hand in the box and Puncheon turned Marouane Chamakh's knock-on inside the far post to make it 1-0.

Everton tried to rally in response for the remainder of the half, Mirallas whipping a shot inches over from the angle, McGeady curling over from 25 yards and Romelu Lukaku forcing a smart save from Julian Speroni at the near post but it was Palace and Bolasie who went closer to scoring again, the Congolese international hammering a shot off the post 10 minutes before half time.

In the final action of the first half, another corner fom the right eluded the Blue jerseys in the box but McGeady clipped a cross onto the roof of the net.

Perhaps not surprisingly, Martinez elected to make a change at half time, withdrawing Deulofeu and introducing Naismith but things would get worse within three minutes of the start of the second half. Howard pushed Joe Ledley's shot behind for a corner but Dann was allowed a free header from the resulting set-piece to rise and power home a downward header to double Palace's lead.

The Blues were temporarily stunned but McGeady raked a shot agonisingly wide from distance before being replaced by James McCarthy, rested due to a slight muscle strain, in a double change that also saw Barry make way for the more offensively-minded Leon Osman.

It was Martinez's first substitution who brought Everton back into the game with an hour gone, though. Persistence from Mirallas on the right ended with the Belgian putting in a cross to the back post that Baines headed back across goal for Naismith to score.

And the Baines-Mirallas combination came very close to levelling the match in what would perhaps prove in the final reckoning to be the first of two crucial moments. The left back's deep cross found the Belgian arriving late at the far post but he could only sky it over first time and when Speroni tipped Osman's terrific shot acrobatically over the bar, it looked as though it wasn't going to be Everton's day.

Two minutes later, the Blues were caught cold again when Jerome profited from good work by Puncheon and a slight slip by John Stones to plant a right-foot shot beyond Howard into the Park End goal to make it 3-1 and leave the home side with a mountain to climb.

It was Speroni who denied Barkley the chance of halving the deficit with 10 minutes left, the Argentine diverting the 20 year-old's shot inches past the post with his foot, but Mirallas did plunder a second goal for Everton in the 86th minute when he seized on Barkley's deflected pass to round the 'keeper and slot home.

Four minutes of regulation time and another six for stoppages would not prove to be enough for the Blues but Mirallas had a gilt-edged chance to tie things up four minutes into added time when Barkley cleverly scooped the ball over the massed wall of yellow shirts but the forward failed to make contact and the chance evaporated, perhaps taking Everton's Champions League hopes with it.

Full coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (83)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick West
1 Posted 16/04/2014 at 22:59:19
When I saw the team my first thought was 'lack of respect'. It was as if Martinez thought we were going to blow them away. It was either going to be champagne football or sucker punch(eon). Sometimes you can have too many attacking players. Gary Lineker always said he hated it when a manager brought on loads of forwards to save a game as all the space disappeared.

That's what happened tonight. And then when we had them camped in the last third it was crying out for Deulofeu or someone to get round the back but he was in the shower by then.

Still... we criticised Moyes for caution. So let's stay positive. it ain't over yet.

Paul Ferry
3 Posted 16/04/2014 at 23:13:45
Bobby has made itsy-bitsy mistakes... only rarely does he make howling dogsbollocks clangers – but he made two today: not playing McCarthy from the start and taking Gerry off at half-time.

Like everyone else, nearly two hours on, I am in a world of hurt – and, to cap it all, just had an epic Clash of the Titans spat with female Ferry to boot who's like a Nazi war criminal on speed when she gets going... But, when all is said and done, this will still be a great season for us and the future looks bright and blue.

My hunch is that we will spank Moyes's Man Utd and then finish the season for the lily-livered sheik-shits in a couple of weeks. We will finish strong and, wherever we finish, it will be our best-ever points haul in the prem.

We have an awful lot to be grateful for.

Now... anyone know the number of a decent florist? Hang on, no – I was in the right, she started it .......

Peter Murray
4 Posted 16/04/2014 at 23:26:33
Lack of concentration, basic defensive errors and failure to take chances all contributed to a miserable ant-climax. And to make it worse City have all but gifted the Premier League title to the other lot.The victory against Arsenal is already a distant memory. Let's make sure that game was not the one where our season peaked and get back on track on Sunday. 4th place is still there to play for.
Bill Gall
5 Posted 16/04/2014 at 23:37:56
Another low blow being an Everton supporter. They just seem to build up your hopes and expectations then kick you in the balls.

Why do we pull out all the stops against the top teams and then expect the lower teams to just lay down and loose.

With still 12 points to play for all is not lost but I think some of the comments of Arsenal having the players with more experience plus a supposibly easier run in- last nights defeat may just be the turning point in thier favor.

Karan Oza
6 Posted 16/04/2014 at 23:41:44
It's a loss and it hurt. I'm still extremely proud of this team and all they've accomplished. We're not out of this yet by any means. I hope we learn from this mistake and not try to underestimate our opponents for the rest of the season.
Kieran Riding
7 Posted 16/04/2014 at 23:49:51
McCarthy had muscle strain.
Fair enough not risking him starting.

I'm off to The Winchester, to wait until this all blows over.

Mike Keating
8 Posted 16/04/2014 at 23:53:32
The set up of the team was all wrong and they took us.
Referee was useless in ignoring typical Pulis time-wasting but we gave them three goals FFS and had a fight on our hands against a team that played like one.
Absolutely gutted – didn't even go to the pub after the game: "Build me up buttercup ... Just to let me down"

And I'm renewing my fucking season ticket tomorrow; at least there won't be a queue! Donate your bloody wages to charity the lot of you.

Mike Gaynes
9 Posted 17/04/2014 at 01:35:14
If Kieran's information about McCarthy not being fully fit is true, then fair enough that he was left out of the starting lineup, but it sure does show how very important that young man has become to this team. He's the steel beam in the structure. I see some of the carping about him from some TW critics and I just shake my head. Today should shut them up for good.

On merit, it's Barry who really needs a rest... he looked plumb tuckered out today, and that didn't help either. Neither did Baines's nightmare show. Or the fact that we couldn't score off a corner if the keeper was a ten-dollar hooker.

But credit where it's due to Palace... they played their asses off for 95 minutes, gave everything they had, and Bolasie was unplayable, as he was a few weeks back against City. He's come out of nowhere to become a rising star.

Brian Wilkinson
10 Posted 17/04/2014 at 02:35:48
Barry will get a rest against Man City; right or wrong, had Martinez started with McCarthy then he went off injured then the same people would be saying "Why the fuck did we play McCarthy against Palace? – Now he's out of the Man Utd game."

Thankfully he wasn't risked from the start and Martinez has learned from the derby defeat to not play players not fully fit.

Thank god he didn't start with the local whipping boy Osman who's been blamed for everything on here by some.

We are 1 point behind with 12 points to play for. There's no easy games in the Premier League, who would hand on heart would have seen Palace winning at Goodison and Sunderland drawing at Man City.

The title is far from over and also 4th spot, so although it's points dropped we are still there. 8 weeks ago we were 8 points behind, now it's just a single point, keep the faith.

Paul Ferry
11 Posted 17/04/2014 at 03:09:26
The right note to sound exactly Karan - 798 - and Brian - 813 - a wonderful season so far thank you very much Bobby and every reason to think that it will end on a positive note
Jay Harris
12 Posted 17/04/2014 at 05:22:56
Thought the real mistake was not playing Naismith.

We look much more dangerous when he is alongside Lukaku especially at home.

Kudos to Ossie too for the energy he put into trying to pull us back.

Guess we need to realize we are not as good as we hoped.

Tim Locke
13 Posted 17/04/2014 at 06:41:17
Was a heart breaking night. It's easy to point out what Bobby should have done, but as Brian said this was not a recipe for success. If a player got injured etc then we would all be crying out what a bad decision it was.

If we had own last night and it had taken us to a point of Ars then I would be very happy and thinking we can do this. It's only because the golden chance has gone that I am annoyed. So chin up time, the boys need us. I think 10 points from last 12 should be enough, 76. Pressure back on Ars now.

Dan McKie
15 Posted 17/04/2014 at 07:37:23
When I saw the team last night I thought 'very attacking' and was looking forward to see how it would work. It didn't. We were basically all pace and no brains. McGeady, Mirallas and Deulofeu (who I'm starting to think is very over rated) can all skin a player, before time and time again making the wrong decision, and even then executing it poorly. One time Del speeds down the wing, looks up, no Everton player in the box, crosses it anyway, off for a goal kick! The 3 of them shouldn't start games together, as none of them know what each other are going to do, and often don't even know what themselves are going to do. We looked a lot better when he brought on smarter players. Martinez got it wrong.
David Waugh
16 Posted 17/04/2014 at 07:41:39
Disappointed with the result obviously. But, given the significance and opportunity I was also disappointed by the lack of atmosphere. Okay, I was seated above the away supporters who were on song, but until we went a goal down there was hardly a whisper from us in a full house.

On the playing side of things, Palace looked like they wanted it more, had more pace and were gutsy on the ball. We lacked tenacity.

Sharabi Singh
17 Posted 17/04/2014 at 08:11:10
Palace played well but baines should have done better for the first goal. If we go in level at half time it would have made all the difference. Can complain about certain decisions and tactics all day but this was our first defeat in eight games. We got Utd on Sunday so we have to forget this game and forget fourth place (which the pressure of clearly got to the players yesterday) just concentrate on doing the best in the next four games and wherever we finish great. We'd all have taken fifth at the beginning of the season. COYB IMWT
Jermaine Jennings
18 Posted 17/04/2014 at 08:11:32
I don't see the point in all these wingers as we never get men in the box when we cross the ball and Lukaku doesn't know what Del is going to do half the time and doesn't commit to making the forward runs!!

I am so downhearted today and I thought RM bottled it when he said the pressure got to the lads!!! I don't think it did they just didn't know what to do when faced against ten men behind the ball which is difficult but no one was making the forward runs to split there defensive unit all the football was played in front of palace.. tbh we just couldn't pass the ball slow and ponderous which was like the beginning of the season..

Arsenal are not under any pressure as they've been there and done it and they're getting there best players back as well which will really takes us out of fourth unless Arsenal really make a mess of things but they won't as the players could get a new manager and they wouldn't want that!!!!

Just beat Utd and all will be forgiven!!!

Denis Richardson
19 Posted 17/04/2014 at 08:20:22
Well so much for my prediction of a comfortable win! Missed the game as was on a plane, the whole time thinking will we win by one goal or two, landed, checked the score and WTF!!

Why does this club keep doing this. We pull out all the stops to give ourselves a chance and then blow it at the final hurdle. I guess the season isn't over yet and it's been a great run.....but it was palace at home ffs.

My main worry now is that the players are going to be on a real downer, can they pick themselves up for manure?

Gutted!

Brent Stephens
20 Posted 17/04/2014 at 08:44:12
Brian #813 "Barry will get a rest against Man City; right or wrong, had Martinez started with McCarthy then he went off injured then the same people would be saying "Why the fuck did we play McCarthy against Palace? – Now he's out of the Man Utd game.""

Exactly what I suggested to the guy next to me at GP last night - Roberto with an eye on the MC game.

Tony Christian
21 Posted 17/04/2014 at 09:05:46
Without wishing to sound offensive or devalue the Justice for Hillsborough campaign, the decision to send RM to Anfield and force the entire first team squad to attend the memorial service at Goodison was wrong and undoubtedly had affect on game preparation. Although it's correct to send sympathy and show unity I'm sure that if the boot was on other foot Liverpool would have at best sent an ambassador 24 hours prior to a major league game such as ours.
John O'Toole
22 Posted 17/04/2014 at 09:29:12
As a lifelong Evertonian, I just knew this would happen last night. I'm still in a state of shock but what guts me is the knowledge that Arsehole Wenger and Arteta are wetting their pants with laughter and Red Brenda has probably been up all night changing his. Our new Spanish magician got the team selection wrong last night but to be fair, he has given us a cracking season for a change. I hope we show Mr Moyes some respect this weekend (before the game) and then show him how the game should be played.
Barry Morrison
23 Posted 17/04/2014 at 09:29:29
Tony, 873 - that's just nonsense. What an excuse!
Mike Hughes
24 Posted 17/04/2014 at 09:55:46
Given the breaking news this morning, has anyone else heard the rumour that our team sheet was circulated to Tony Pulis BEFORE the match last night?

(Reaches across to clutch at a straw ......)

Tony Christian
25 Posted 17/04/2014 at 09:49:55
Barry 884 - Far from nonsense - do you think Liverpool or for that matter any other team would disrupt pre-match preparations to attend a memorial service for another club's fans? At best they would send a representative of that club. We however feel this need to go that one step further and for me enough is enough.

Similarly this seemingly perpetual minutes silence / applause at GP is becoming too much to bear. Yes, we sympathise and are united in our disgust at the travesty of justice but why do we feel the need to sacrifice our match preparations? Maybe it was just me but I felt that the ill-conceived minutes silence / applause took the fire out of an already apprehensive crowd yesterday.

Matthew Correal
26 Posted 17/04/2014 at 10:28:01
Anybody else think Baines had the worst game he's had in a few seasons?
Barry Morrison
27 Posted 17/04/2014 at 10:55:05
Really Tony, you think that an hour the day before the game is the reason we lost to Palace?? Come on, that's just clutching straws in the extreme. Do you not think Palace's travel from London would've at least evened the playing field on the disruption front?

We had a bad night and lost; to blame the Hillsborough memorial is just silly.

Eoin Kenny
28 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:08:57
A horrible result. We got sucker punched for the third goal when at that point I thought we were going to win the game. We missed McCarthy hugely but I can see why Roberto rested him. It easy to say its a mistake in hindsight. Lukaku was very poor last night.

We should not give up on 4th yet. Sunday means everything now. Let's get behind the lads and stay positive.

Tony Christian
29 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:10:45
Barry 884 - Of course the memorial wasn't the only reason that we lost against Palace but it certainly didn't help things. My point being is that it was an unwelcome distraction and it is something we shouldn't be doing to the extent of which we are doing it. I sincerely hope that last night's minutes applause for Hillsborough is the last one for another 25 years. Enough is enough.
Max Murphy
30 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:06:31
The sooner Baines loses the bicycle shorts and starts wearing football shorts then he may start playing his normal game. As well as strangling his bollocks, they seem to be stifling his defensive play, and his corners and free kicks have been terrible. OK he headed the pass for the first goal, but his main job is in defense.

The whole team needs shooting practise. And Lukaku can play a blinder one week, and just forgets how to play football the next. Last night, the most effective player was Deulofeu – so Roberto takes him off at HT. Can't figure that one out...

Sadly, top 4 is out of our hands now.

Jim Knightley
31 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:15:43
Ridiculous comments, Tony.

Aside from the important symbolism of the act, you are over-complicating an albeit more complex than often recognized football. The pressure got to the players tonight, and perhaps the manager too. There was nothing to it but that. Not because we lost a few hours prep time. Palace's Pulis are at the moment a horrible team to play, and the loss of McCarthy was massive.

Fourth is gone I think, but that said, I fancy Arsenal to drop points once. We will need to win all four. Can we? Yes. Will we? I don't think so. Time and time again during Moyes reign, we saw the little bit lacking when it mattered. We could say that again for last night, and to an extent for the Sunderland match before the turn of the year.

That may just be retrospect... it may just be that we lost, because we were going to lose eventually, because that is the nature of the Premier League. But I think what separates one team from another sometimes is that genuine belief which surges through a team, when it matters. It's what Sir Alex could inspire, and others can't. And importantly, there are certain players which come to the fore at such moments.

As much as I hate to say it, I remember that Gerrard did it on numerous occasions. That the £80million plus Bale did it last night. Maybe we lack that? Maybe we don't, and are just a little bit off Arsenal, who despite their relative lack of spending, still have a team worth many more millions than ours, and wages over twice the amount.

But then maybe Barkley will crack in a 30-yard winner against Man Utd when it matters, and we will leapfrog the Arsenal who were held to a 1-1 at Hull. There are many maybes to play for yet though... and importantly, it is the 17th of April, and the dream is still on, even if it is fading. It is the 17th of April and we have hope, good football, and a summer of genuine potential to look forward.

It is the 17th of April, and we will be playing in Europe next year I think. It will probably be against the likes of Lille and Kalou, but it could still be against a Real Madrid with Ronaldo, or a Barcelona with Messi. It is nice to still be able to dream, even if it is only for a bit longer.

Iain Thomson
32 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:37:59
Can we stop taking wanky outswinging corners.

In my opinio,n against a team defending like that, if you are going to have a ton of wingers running around then you play Naismith who will be in the middle and make little runs into space, giving them someone to cross to...

Dave Horne
33 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:40:46
Max #914

If you really believe that Deulofeu was "the most effective player last night", then you weren't at the game? I would have hooked him off after half-an-hour (and McGeady wasn't much better). He is an extremely overrated player, in my opinion, and does not play for the team.

Michael Penley
34 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:44:30
Our complacency with set pieces is really something I find hard to understand. Baines used to take corners from the right side - what happened? We scored plenty from corners before, surely someone has noticed that's changed. Floating in a ball isn't what we need, nor is all our players waiting on the edge of the box. Every other team regards headers from corners as a valuable source of goals except us.

Another thing we have failed to utilise is Deulofeu's ability to get the ball across goal. When he makes a run towards the goal line, Roberto should have designated a runner make a run towards the back post to slot it in. It's sheer negligence not to do so. Gerard must be thinking the same thing.

John Ford
35 Posted 17/04/2014 at 12:01:57
Michael...surely you mean front post? Forwards are taught to take a front post spot for the quick wide ball in. The point being - to be the first player the ball reaches.
Dan McKie
36 Posted 17/04/2014 at 12:02:57
Max 914, you thought Deulofeu was effective? How? Yes, he can beat a man or two, but follows it up time and time again with a nothing cross or shot, and as for tracking back, don't be silly. The problem with last night is that we had 3 of those kind of players playing behind Lukaku.

On their day, brilliant; not their day, awful. Lukaku just didn't know where and when to run, didn't know if a pass was likely to come, or if McGeady, Del or Mirallas were going to try and take on somebody else before messing up the final ball. We looked much better when players with some nouce came on, Osman, Naismith and McCarthy, players who think.

I get the feeling Martinez thought we could just fly at Palace, with Barry and the defence dealing with their attack. We were left exposed, and it wasn't helped by Baines having a shocker again. He was beaten for the first goal like he wasn't even there.

Conn Prosser
37 Posted 17/04/2014 at 11:49:21
Yesterday I started typing some negative bullshit about how we'll probably bottle it and scrape a draw. I stopped because it's not good to put those vibes out there. Jeez, I'd have taken a draw!

We were going to lose at some point; it's okay. Before every single one of the previous seven games, I had this overriding feeling that we'd tank it.

I'm still buzzing off the Arsenal win, but now I will need a repeat performance against Man Utd to get that feeling back. I can't see the Gunners screwing up now. Fifth is great!

Keith Young
38 Posted 17/04/2014 at 12:04:42
Crystal Palace had three stars who turned up in good form: importantly, one of them was a goalkeeper. Our three stars didn't turn up: importantly, one of them was our goalkeeper.

RM gave our team a chance to perform with stacks of goals from the start. It now looks like he should not have underestimated the CP players who are riding high on their Chelsea victory. But what the hell, at least RM was being positive from the start.

Robbie Muldoon
39 Posted 17/04/2014 at 12:38:55
913 Tony Christian... Ah, the internet. Where the worst opinions in the world can always be found waving around like a dirty flasher in the woods.

Yesterday was always going to be a banana skin, I'm pretty sure we would have struggled to beat them when the match was originally supposed to be played. I was thankful it got postponed because of our form and injury list. Let's just blow Man Utd away now and hope Hull make a statement against Arsenal ahead of the Cup Final.

Tony J Williams
40 Posted 17/04/2014 at 12:43:25
Del Boy, Mirallas & McGeady cannot/won't defend and therefore it was left to Barry and Barkley to do all the defending.

That's why Barry had possibly his worst game in a Blue shirt because he had to be everywhere to cover the three lazy fuckers in front of him.

Max 924, Del Boy was shite last night, they way he was shite against Sunderland. The oggy painted over the massive chasm of shiteness. He left Seamus exposed every attack, the same with Mirallas and McGeady.

I blame myself, as I gave us the kiss of death walking up to the game, I suggested that McGeady was looking good, Distin was close to being our Player of the Season, and that, apart from Liverpool and Man City, I was struggling to remember a team that scored more than one past us in the league.... doh!

Raymond Fox
41 Posted 17/04/2014 at 12:24:13
I posted before the game that Palace were not expected to get anything out of the tie and were therefore on a result to nothing, while we had a lot to lose. That to me, was how the game turned out.

Look at Man City: who saw that result coming? I thought they should win by 3 or more goals... it's pressure with a touch of complacency that sometimes occurs.

I'm disappointed but not that surprised. It looks like we've blown a top 4 finish now, but I think before this game we had it all to do, because Arsenal have much the easier fixtures.

Sorry to be so negative chaps, but what the hell... we've had a great season up to now with the future looking a lot brighter with Señor Martinez.

I also think that Pulis is proving himself a much under-rated manager.

Lenny Kingman
42 Posted 17/04/2014 at 13:31:43
# 932
Easier fixtures than Crystal Palace at home. Surely not.
Ste Traverse
43 Posted 17/04/2014 at 13:40:33
Can I just add Tony Christian is talking a load of old bollocks.

The team selection is what cost us last night. NOT Martinez visiting Anfield and our first team squad being at Goodison on Tuesday.

That's right up there as one of the worst posts I've ever seen on an Everton fansite.

Jackie Barry
44 Posted 17/04/2014 at 13:41:02
I think it goes to show that we just don't have enough winners in the team. Look at Arsenal and how they have picked themselves up, it's all in the mentality and sadly for us we are still trying to get rid of a "fifth is best" mentality that has been hanging around at Everton for the passed 10 plus years.

I hope Martinez can bring about that change and if players can't get out of it then they need to go. I am sick of Mirallas who keeps blowing hot and cold all the time and really don't see Deulofeu as the next super winger, he does a dance and gets a good ball in occasionally but for me loses it far too often.

As for Baines, well I have not been impressed by him for a while, he started going downhill a bit for me toward the end of last season in terms of his crosses and Oviedo is simply far superior at defending.

We certainly missed McCarthy last night and it shows why Barry and McCarthy play together. Osman is done as far as I am concerned, I like him but he simply isn't good enough if we are to break into that top 4. Buying Barry is a no-no for me too, unless we get a capable standby who can come on and perform equally well.

Ben Jones
45 Posted 17/04/2014 at 13:54:14
I think we have to get Palace credit here. Pulis set up magnificently and beat Martinez in the managerial duel. Offensively I thought we were better than when we played Sunderland, just shows how lucky we are.

On paper that team should have beaten them. And If McCarthy had a muscular problem, and wasn't fit to the start, then what else could Martinez do?

The only major mistake he did for me was those front three behind Lukaku. Talent wise probably our best attacking midfield trio, but they're all too similar and all too far inconsistent, without really keeping the ball very well. At least when Pienaar, Osman or Naismith are there, they can keep the ball higher up the pitch. Not saying they should all play, but one or two of them should.

I think we need to replace Deulofeu with a skillful Number 10 than a winger. A Lewis Holtby or someone with a similar mould would do the trick.

Jamie Barlow
46 Posted 17/04/2014 at 13:57:01
We've just been on a seven-game winning streak so I think we've got a fair few winners in the team. Whether they'll all be at Everton next season is another thing.

Its not that I don't think they're good enough because I know they all are. It's the effort and desire that some of them put in that pisses me off. One game, certain players look really up for it but other games they just look like they're going through the motions.

Lukaku has stunk the place out the last two games and that's after coming out with statements about making history with Everton. He should have come off last night about 5 minutes after he pulled up with an injury 10 minutes in. We might as well have played with 10 men for 75 minutes because he stayed on.

Totally the opposite to Naismith who might not be the best player but puts in a shift every game. I can't see why at the least players can't do as he does. That's why I don't mind Mirallas having a bad game as I think for a while now, he's put in a decent shift and never goes missing even when he's having a stinker. Something I wouldn't have said last season and earlier this season.

A perfect chance to put pressure on Arsenal was wasted because we couldn't break through a pretty solid defence, no matter how many flair players Martinez put out. It just looked disjointed and all over the place to me, apart from the first 10 which was great to watch. Nobody knew what they were doing.

Martinez swapped it about too much tonight when he didn't need to. Like I said before, we've gone on a seven-game winning streak so why change it so drastically?

Jackie Barry
47 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:24:18
A team that went on a seven-match winning streak and then bottled it, that's my summary.
James Marshall
48 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:09:20
Did anyone else notice that, with 20 minutes to go, Distin was utterly fucked? He was lame and we played with 10 men for the last 20.

Apart from that, Palace played really well, let's not detract from that fact. Football matches are about two teams, and we as supporters always seem to only comment or pay any real attention to the way the Everton players play. Palace setup perfectly to counter us in every way (and I don't just mean counter-attacking). Bolasie is a quality winger, direct, tricky, strong, pacey and really hard to deal with. In Puncheon they have a player with a great left-foot who gives their midfield real balance, and their defenders are giants in the typical Pulis mould.

We came up against a team who have now won four on the bounce, play hard defensive, counter-attacking football and we were made for them.

Martinez made a mistake in the starting line-up – way too attacking – and we were ripe for Palace to pick us off as they did. With McCarthy not fully fit, he should have started Osman alongside Barry – it was a glaring error which I for one could see as soon as I read the line-up half-an-hour before kick-off.

Still, we're only a point off Arsenal with 4 games to go. Will they win all theirs? I don't think they will so there's still much to play for despite the misery of a home defeat. We've just won seven games in a row and have much to be happy about once the dust settles.

Onward & upward.

Andrew Grey
49 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:25:40
A straw to clutch at?

Reports from the BBC regarding Cardiff's complaint about Palace obtaining their starting line up 24 hours before kick-off, if proved true, should be enough to relegate Palace for cheating and null and void all their fixtures this season. Arsenal lose 6 points we lose 3.

Nicholas Page
50 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:29:58
At least the fucking Southern media are all happy once again.
Patrick Murphy
51 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:47:18
Andrew, if that did happen wouldn't we only lose just the single point we gained at Selhurst Park? Would Palace being null and void make the other lot Champions? If it does, perhaps it will happen.
Mohammed Horoub
52 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:38:49
Andrew@949 I had the same thought when I read the headline but I doubt the punishment would be that severe. Wouldn't we only lose 1 point? (Hangs head in shame that we were only able to get 1 point off Palace this season)
Agree with most posts that Martinez tried to fix something that wasn't broken. 5 games left to get into the CL. Barry and McCarthy should have been running on Adrenalin alone till the end of season. They have enough time in the summer to recharge and relax while watching the WC.
Speroni made some big saves and Howard didn't (3 goals on 4 shots) Turning point was the save on Osman's shot, the crowd was behind the team and if we had got back to 2-2 the game would have been ours.
Not over yet though and while we all would have preferred to have our destiny in our own hands maybe this takes a little bit of pressure off the team.
I was criticized in December when I said that we lost to Sunderland because of the pressure (we were 2 points off 1st place at KO boxing day) but yesterday showed that we still don't have enough big game experience to play under pressure. That will come with time and while CL would be amazing Europa is just as good. Look at this year's semifinals for the Europa and you know that the top teams take it seriously. With the Europa champions qualifying for CL next year I think that will be an easier route than finishing 4th in the Prem.
James Marshall
53 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:49:41
That's a massive straw to clutch at, and even if something does come of the Cardiff thing, why would they void every match Palace have played this season? Can you imagine the complexity of the court case that would ensue? You're talking about many many millions of pounds resting on such things.

Seriously, I wouldn't pin a single hope on this happening.

Max Murphy
54 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:50:46
Dan #922, Tony #929, Deulofeu was getting behind their defence and crossing it on numerous occasions. Any decent centre-forward would've been able to read his game and position himself for the cross. He did it time and time against Sunderland, and we were just lucky with the OG.

Before you publish your ridiculous comments, try thinking of the game tactically, and the chances Deulofeu creates. The pair of you haven't a clue.

Linda Morrison
55 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:44:13
Andrew that is a straw and won't happen. I don't honestly know what people expect from the team. The players are not machines and the pressure certainly got to them; they knew what a win meant and they were awful due to this.

Most of the consistent players, Barry, Distin etc are completely knackered as they never get a rest and they are amongst the oldest in the team. They are not helped by the inconsistencies of some of the younger players.

I don't like the loan system and don't think it helps Premier League clubs at all. It should be kept to enable younger players to go on loan to get experience and for emergencies only. Lukaka is apparently off to Man City, and boy do they need him, and no doubt Gerad will be on the plane home at the end of the season. They are two players who are either very good or useless and, on bad days, other players, Coleman for one, suffer.

Yes, we are all disappointed, but we are not used to being in this position, neither are the players. This is a different type of pressure to trying to stay in the league for players and fans alike. The big clubs have had years to get used to it and we are just starting out. You only have to look at how Man City have bottled it.

My only concern is that I think the next few seasons are the chance for Everton to get into the top 4 with most of the usual suspects in a transition stage. I'm still not happy about the Europa League though as every team in that has suffered in the league.

I knew either Sunderland or Crystal Palace would be a loss. Let's see what Sunday brings; it will be a very different game, you see.

Andrew Grey
56 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:57:43
Patrick - Mohammed.
Yes just one point! For some reason I thought we beat them but as you say a miserable 1 point from them this season.

James -

A huge straw! Not sure what happened in Italy during the match fixing scandal where Juve where relegated but I don't think any results were affected but at the same time that didn't come out until after the season had ended.

If Palace are guilty then I think (little biased maybe) that is as serious as you can get, not for the fact they got the line up but the fact they went to all that trouble to get it, what else have they, would they be prepared to do?

Regarding the shite, they and City and Chelsea have taken 3 points off them with Palace still to play shite and city at home so that would benefit Chelsea at the moment.

Dreams help life move on. 7- 0 Sunday!

Michael Kenrick
57 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:08:57
People do come up with a lot of strange rationales when we lose, but this one has me puzzled: "they knew what a win meant and they were awful due to this."

A win meant 3 pts — just like the previous seven games... in fact, just like every game in the Premier League! I thought the main reason for playing the game was to win if you can? The idea that this knowledge somehow makes them 'awful' is just ridiculous.

They weren't 'awful'; Crystal Palace played better on the night. That was the difference, and that won them the game.

Dan McKie
58 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:08:13
Max, pipe down, he was garbage. He throws aimless balls in, regardless of whether anybody is actually in the box or box or not.

So basically what you are saying is it is his job to just kick the ball in a particular direction, and the forwards job to guess correctly where the ball is going to go (despite no 2 balls going the same way), rather than Del actually spot a man and aim the ball towards him? He reminded me of Aaron Lennon last night, it doesn't matter how many times he gets to the byline, there is no danger of a cross finding a man.

Matt Traynor
59 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:11:00
Jackie #942 "I think it goes to show that we just don't have enough winners in the team. Look at Arsenal and how they have picked themselves up,"

I really don't get where you were going with that. When we had a couple of bad away results, our last away defeat being the last minute sickener at Chelsea, we were 10 or 11 points behind Arsenal. These "losers" then went on a record breaking (since Sky invented football) run of seven consecutive victories, before coming unstuck against a team that was on four consecutive victories.

But the funniest thing of all is you're suggesting Arsenal are a team of winners?

Raymond Fox
60 Posted 17/04/2014 at 14:50:41
The usual suspects who take the CL places each year don't get there by chance, they're there because they go out and buy the best players available for £30m - £50m each year.
Whether this FFP will level the playing field some, remains to be seen, I'm not holding my breath though!

Our patched together team, by which I mean loan players + our contracted players, have done great so let's not start tearing them to pieces after this result.

To be in with a chance of the top 4 at this stage of the season is far above where I expected us to be, but in the end I think the difference is, we have to make do with players with some exceptions are not up to top 4 quality.

Dan McKie
61 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:21:20
I said to my pal as soon as the half time whistle went that Deulofeu wouldn't be out for the second half. I'm sure it was just coincidence though, and Martinez thought he played so well, that he deserved half the night off.
Patrick Murphy
62 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:29:23
This league table looks better without the Palace results:

Liverpool 74
Chelsea 72
Manchester City 67
Everton 65
Arsenal 61
Tottenham Hotspur 54
Manchester United 51

I know it won't happen but what fun if it did!

Jamie Barlow
63 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:22:41
Max, Deulofeu wastes 5 times more chances than he creates. The bloke is a fuckin nightmare. Plenty of talent but no brain. He's probably the fastest player in our side and breaks forward at pace but then fires the ball across the goal or 15 feet over the bar. Nobody could get on the end of his crosses.

The one time he pulled the ball back against Sunderland, we scored. I just hope, if he stays, because there's no chance whatsoever of him getting anywhere near the Barcelona team, he learns to lift his head up and find a blue shirt.

Dave Horne
65 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:37:44
Max #954 - you didn't include my #918 amongst your "ridiculous comments" post.

That's three of us who thought Deulofeu was rubbish plus, far more importantly, our manager (and he doesn't normally sub people at half time.)

Ever thought it might be you that could be overrating him?

Andrew Grey
66 Posted 17/04/2014 at 15:34:38
Michael 959 -

I read what Linda wrote to be what Roberto said - They wanted to win too much (strange on the surface I know) and this affected them.

They were not awful though as you say.

We have to remember that the team put together an amazing 7 win streak that put us in the position we are in. To get 4th 12 straight wins would probably have been needed and anyone who suggested that was possible 8 games ago would be ridiculed.

It's not over yet.

Michael Kenrick
67 Posted 17/04/2014 at 16:10:22
That has to be the explanation, Dan (#960); otherwise, it makes no sense having such a talented player as Deulofeu on the field. He can beat his man, but the direction of the resulting cross is a total lottery. The ball has to played within range of an incoming player or it's wasted.

The same arguement applies to our corners, which I must admit are the biggest annoyance for me. This is where I really have an issue with Martinez, and I wish I didn't. But for him to dismiss the scoring opportunity corners potentially provide is criminal indeed. Yet the team has demonstrated brilliantly how well they have adopted this baffling aspect of his otherwise 'phenomenal' phootballing philosophy.

Come on, Big Dunc... Put Roberto straight on this one, please!!!

Max Murphy
68 Posted 17/04/2014 at 16:08:37
Taking the ball to the bye-line and crossing it with pace is one of the most dangerous balls for a defence to deal with. No one can be off-side, and if our forwards are there, sitting on the line, it's a tap-in, or sometimes an own goal(last weekend). Lukaku lingers around the 6-yard box sucking his thumb - he should be making a run in front of the goalie or defender as the cross comes in. Martinez will sub players after they score, or if they're playing well - his decision is not necessarily dependant on form - as we've witnessed on numerous occasions this season.
Sorry Dave #970 for not including you - so based on 3 your opinions Deulofeu is absolute garbage - so it must be true!
Nicholas Ryan
69 Posted 17/04/2014 at 16:21:46
Paul Ferry 788 ... Very funny, ... and spot on !!
Jamie Barlow
70 Posted 17/04/2014 at 17:16:15
But he doesn't cross the ball Max. It's a cross shot that goes forward and is almost impossible to connect with. For anyone to connect, they'd have to be in front of him which would mean they're offside. He needs to start looking up and pulling the ball back or straight across goal, not forward. You can't expect Naismith to keep up with Dela when he's at full pelt and then to get on the end of a cross that's shot forward. If he can sort this side of his game out, he'd be lethal. At the moment, he's wasteful.
Patrick Murphy
71 Posted 17/04/2014 at 17:35:29
For God's sake the BBC just showed Wenger going on about Arsenal and fourth place in light of our defeat last night.

Do they usually do press conferences with a manager after one of his rivals has failed to win or is this a new way of promoting the favoured few.

Reporter: Well manager xxx that was a great result for your club last night wasn't it?

Manager xxx - "Yes we were all delighted when Joe A scored that wonderful last minute winner - it's something we had hoped to see and we weren't disappointed.

Reporter: What do you think will be the most important fixture during the run-in?

Manager xxx - It's very difficult to say but the Greens against the Yellows will be interesting and we're hoping for at least a point for the Green's in that game and perhaps if the Stripes can beat the Hoops we may well have a drink or two in the evening.

Jimmy Sørheim
72 Posted 17/04/2014 at 17:13:33
Lukaku is NOT worth buying for 20 million.

I think there are a few others that are better lone strikers then him, and they score more goals.

The biggest problem is not losing 4th place, the problem is next season and the weak squad we have.

I can pick two major mistakes Roberto has made during his time here.
1.
Gibson was supposed to have his surgery during the summer which our manager chose not to do.

2
When he sold Jelavic he should have brought in a like for like replacement, not a injured striker who has hardly played all season.

3.
He should have given Vellios some game time here and there to have him ready for this run in, and he probably should have given some game time to Matthew Kennedy and George Green as well.

The mistakes are there, but the biggest and worst is loaning a sick-note like Traore who was not even fit when we got him.

Roberto actually lives in a dreaworld sometimes, and the truth is he has cost us 4th place by not getting a fit and decent enough striker to help and push Lukaku.

I am angry at Roberto for making it much harder then it needs to be.

The best thing would have been to keep Jelavic since he knew his only option was a injured striker.

Somehow we now lose games we would have won against before, but we have won against United.

Are we even good enough to get into Champions League, we have the thinnest squad I have ever seen.

Why not start handing some of our best youngsters some game time?

I actually think Moyes was better at giving youngsters playing time then Roberto is.

After all Barkley is not a youngster, though Stones is.

Is that it? 1 young player all season, I would expect and wanted more then that from Mr.Martinez.

We are were we are because of Martinez not wanting to try new young players out.

I truly fear next season.

Jim Knightley
73 Posted 17/04/2014 at 18:11:45
Michael...a win is not just a win. Winning a final is not the same as winning a nothing game. We had pressure on us, because the eyes are on Everton now. We've pulled ourselves back into the top four race when we were out of it, and now we are under pressure, because Champions League football became/is a real possibility. The match yesterday was alot bigger, and a win meant alot more, than it would have a month ago.

Bill Gall
74 Posted 17/04/2014 at 20:19:04
All the negative comments on last night from the manager playing the wrong formation this player and that player should not be allowed on the pitch again to the most comical one regarding players and manager attending a memorial service the day before brings a smile to my face.

The manager and players could do no wrong while we are winning but loose a game and the knives are out.

My own thoughts are that the manager has got us a lot higher in the league that what most of us expected and the real culprits for the poor performances over the last couple of games are our inept chairman and board for not realising in January what a great position we had achieved and helping the manager in the market to strengen the squad to cover injuries and fatigue.

Tony Abrahams
75 Posted 17/04/2014 at 20:00:35
Strangest thing about last night was with so many attacking players in the starting line-up you would expect players to be getting in their box. This only really happened in the last 20 mins and takes away the notion that we was too desperate in wanting to win the game. Just felt we underestimated Palace and we’re maybe already looking past this game. It’s gone now anyway and alls we can hope to do is learn from it and win our next game.

Martinez for all his qualities is still a very inexperienced young manager and you only really learn from your mistakes in this game. Let’s hope it doesn’t cost us in the end and Arsenal or even City still have time to slip up.
Peter Z Jones
76 Posted 17/04/2014 at 21:58:52
I was crushed like everyone else was yesterday, but we'll bounce right back against United because our intensity level always rises with the quality of our opposition. Mentally, we are the exact opposite of Arsenal. Against the most talented teams, we turn it up a notch and give everything we've got, resulting in a very respectable record against similarly placed teams in the table. Against the bottom half, we drop far more points than anybody else, and this has been the case for awhile now. Arsenal's collective heart pumps kool-aid in the big games, while they mop up 3 points consistently against the crap sides. Martinez biggest challenge long term will be to make sure that we take the maximum points more often against inferior opposition, as it seems to be a problem unique to Everton. The first thing we need to address to sort this out is scoring from and defending set pieces. We've had a million corners and the last time I remember a header hitting the back of the net was Lukaku against Liverpool. Look at the table. The top 3 teams score the most from set pieces. When they play poorly, those goals provide a lifeline back into the game. We have to score everything from open play, which is so hard to pull off week in and week out. And as for defending them? I think that's just a manager philosophy thing that isn't specific to Martinez. Zonal marking just doesn't work. Stop employing it and we'll stop conceding goals, along with all the other European clubs that use the strategy.
Brian Wilkinson
77 Posted 17/04/2014 at 22:26:59
Martinez has got it right 19 times this season, 6 times wrong if that's fair to say and even throw in the draws it still 19 to 15 in Martinez's favour.

We have already got the most total points in our premier league history with 12 points still to play for.

We've seen the likes of Stones and Barkley given regular run outs, getting £27.5 million for Fellaini and picking up McCarthy for less than half that amount.

It was a bad result last night no doubt about that but some have too much high expectations for our first season under Martinez.

If we knew before the season started we would be 1 point behind a champions league place we would be doing cartwheels.

End of February, we were a good 8 points behind the 4th team, we've closed it to just be point and all to play for.

Just get over last night's defeat, no team has a given right to 3 points just because they are playing a side in the bottom half of the table, I have no doubt we will bounce back from this result.

The players will be hurting, make no mistake, so let's hope they respond on Sunday.

I can take a Palace defeat more than a Man Utd defeat so three points Sunday and everyone will be happy.

Chris Leyland
78 Posted 17/04/2014 at 22:27:29
Michael K - have to agree re: our corners. Anyone doubting the benefits of sometimes crossing the ball into the danger area from a corner need look no further than Palace's second goal last night.
Brian Wilkinson
79 Posted 17/04/2014 at 22:42:49
Look at it another way, had utd not come knocking for ofm the likes of Heintingha, Hibbert would be running our defence, ive no doubt we would not have got Lukaku, Barry, Del Boy or McCarthy, Naismith would still be playing right of midfield and Jelavic would still be in attack, Stons didn't get a single minute in all the time ofm was here.

Barkley would play half a game then dropped for three.

Things are certainly better now under Martinez and he looks the type who will not be dictated to for star players to be sold.

Harold Matthews
80 Posted 17/04/2014 at 23:11:05
Peter Z. Yeah. I'm also not keen on the zonal stuff. The opposition are able to run and leap. Our lads have trouble getting 4 inches off the ground.
Mike Powell
81 Posted 17/04/2014 at 23:32:11
Bad result bad performance. McGeady and Delboy were awful. Typical Everton - build us up with excitement only to kick the legs from under us.

Oh, well looks like Thursday night and Sunday football for us next season.

Ernie Baywood
82 Posted 18/04/2014 at 01:09:59
Tough to swallow a home defeat to lesser oppodition but it's still one defeat in 8 for a run that included some tricky away games and a game against a rival.

We've dragged ourselves back into it, though it will take a great run from here.

10 points might be enough. Two huge wins at home and a win and draw away - would be a great performance. If we don't make it with that we'd just have to acknowledge a great season and respect Arsenal's performance. Still think this Arsenal side will drop a game somewhere, though.

Harold Matthews
83 Posted 18/04/2014 at 03:06:41
Ernie. That was the trouble mate. They weren't "lesser opposition". They were quicker, stronger, better organised and wanted it more. Half of our lads weren't at the races, especially at the back. 3 goals against at home is not good enough. Players leaping out the way of shots, not challenging for headers, tackling with the might of a feather against a cannonball. Martinez may be outwardly upbeat but I'll bet he's blazing mad within. Injuries and a stiff fixture list caused him to shuffle the pack but Palace had all the aces.
Carl Davies
84 Posted 17/04/2014 at 22:55:37
In hindsight, Martinez picked the wrong team; too many individuals who were good with the ball at their feet, but completely static without it.

I feel sorry for the widemen who put in some great crosses but nobody looks alive or sharp in the box. And corners... well, we may as well just give them the ball back. We are desperately lacking some aerial threat when attacking and defending corners and set pieces and it is costing us.

Raymond Fox
85 Posted 18/04/2014 at 10:37:35
I see you've come out to play again, Jimmy 991, now we have lost a game. You have disappeared for weeks when we have had a winning run, no comment, no praise?

We lose 1 game and everything Martinez is bad again. You're obviously so biased that giving you facts and figures is a waste of time.

I will try one though, what about we have accumulated the most points in a PL season with still 4 games to play. Strange we are in this position now with such an incompetent manager!

James Marshall
86 Posted 18/04/2014 at 11:25:16
Just a point on Deulofeu. I would be quite surprised if Barça want him back... yet, based on his displays for us this season, they simply don't have any requirement for a winger who likes to cross the ball. Anyone who watches Barça play will tell you Deulofeu just doesn't fit their system.

He has bags of talent, we can all see that, but he's very young & inexperienced so he has to be cut some slack, given that he's playing in such a tough division for the first time in his career. Remember, this is a player who had only played for about half-an-hour in total for the Barça first team before he came to Everton. Give the kid a break.

He does resemble Aaron Lennon at times in the way he storms forward then either trips himself up, or slashes a cross across goal, but this is down to his inexperience more than it is to do with Lukaku (who also seems to get blamed for various things on here) not being in the box.

The Palace game went wrong for reasons beyond Deulofeu, and the fact he was taken off had more to do with team balance than personal performance. There is a bigger picture than just one player in every game, and the constant blame-culture on here is pointless.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb