Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In Sign Up
Text:  A  A  A

Spirited Blues Triumph in Eight-Goal Thriller

By Lyndon Lloyd :  05/02/2011 :  Comments (51) :

Goodison Park played host to a truly stunning game of Premier League football as Everton eventually came out victorious in a roller-coaster encounter that had it all ? eight goals, refereeing controversy, an incredible goal-line clearance, a four-goal haul for a striker on top of his game in every way, and a home win for a side that so desperately needed another galvanising display in front of their anxious fans.

Blackpool have made attacking football and a never-say-die spirit the hallmark of their first season back in the top flight and the manner in which they turned the match on its head in two lightning-quick minutes just past the hour mark was testament to that.

But they could not hold back an irresistible performance by Everton, one laced with some scintillating moments of attacking football, some superb finishing ? a rare commodity in Liverpool L4 lately ? and marred only by another episode of calamitous defending and more evidence of vulnerability to the counter attack.

There were signs early on that this could be a thoroughly enjoyable afternoon for the Blues as they signalled their intent with some sustained forward pressure in the early going and some lovely touches by Jack Rodwell who was again preferred as the man to play behind Louis Saha.

There were also as many suggestions that those familiar failings in the final third could again be their undoing. Three direct free kicks in the first 17 minutes, all within 25 yards of goal by three different players ? Mikel Arteta, Leighton Baines, and Diniyar Bilyaletdinov ? ended up rebounding off the defensive wall, John Heitinga drilled a good shot too close to the goalkeeper, and Bilyaletdinov couldn't get sufficiently above a Phil Neville cross and headed well over from close range.

But everything fell into place in the 20th minute with a wonderful move that ended with Saha ramming home the first of four goals from eight yards out. It began with a Seamus Coleman interception inside his own half, saw Marouane Fellaini spin out of trouble and find Rodwell via a deflection. He in turn fed Bilyaletdinov who played a one-two with Baines, skipped delightfully inside two defenders and cut the ball back for the Frenchman to do what he does best with the goal at his mercy.

Five minutes later, Rodwell found himself in space in the area but having done the hard part with a nice piece of skill to wrong-foot a defender, he air-kicked his shot before a deft chip into the area by Bilyaletdinov set up a chance for Saha but he was crowded out by a forest of white shirts before he could dig the ball out from between his feet.

Blackpool had barely figured as an attacking force but were level thanks to a slice of fortune after 35 minutes . Sylvain Distin was somewhat harshly penalised for handball on the edge of the "D" but Charlie Adam's free kick was deflected behind by Arteta. When Adam's corner bobbled to the near post, though, Evatt was the first to react and he thought he'd scored after turning a shot off the inside off the post and onto the goalline. Baines stopped it from going in but Baptiste was on hand to turn the loose ball home.

Four minutes later, the Blues would have been back in front were it not for a horrendous refereeing decision by Kevin Friend. Coleman had touched the ball brilliantly past his marker and, having muscled his way into the box despite being held back, he squared it perfectly to Saha. The referee ignored the obvious advantage and blew the whistle as the striker turned the ball past the 'keeper for what would have been his second goal of the game.

Baines wasted the free kick that was awarded and Goodison erupted into a chorus of frustrated boos, that continued as Bilyaletdinov's cute chip-shot forced Rachubka into emergency action at the back post and then reached a crescendo at the half-time whistle a couple of minutes later.

David Moyes's side retained their fire as the second half kicked off, though, and were back in front for real within two minutes of the restart in yet more style. Rodwell's slide-rule pass released the over-lapping Baines down the left and his perfect low cross served the ball on a plate to Saha who just needed the appetite to beat two defenders to it and stab it home. 2-1 and game back on!

Bily was then picked out in space on the left side of the box by Saha but his powerful shot was parried away and Rodwell showed yet more quick thinking in the area to touch a square pass in front a defender but then, with the angle closed down by Rachubka, poked wide.

It felt like one of those days when the floodgates would open and deliver one of those increasingly rare Goodison hammerings so what followed felt like a kick to the guts.

It started with an ill-advised chest back in-field by Coleman that was intercepted by Adam but when the ball came loose, Heitinga went into a 50-50 challenge in unforgiveably weak fashion and came off second best, allowing Grandin to release James Beattie who crossed for Puncheon to tuck a shot past Tim Howard and inside the opposite post.

Two minutes later, Blackpool were ahead. Fellaini had a shot cleared off the line in front of the goalpost that resulted in an Everton throw down their right. When the ball broke loose and Adam slipped just as the counter-attack was on, it looked as the danger had gone, but Distin dallied and was robbed near the centre-circle allowing Puncheon to race away and play in DJ Campbell who was sure to score... until his shot came back off the crossbar. Unfortunately for Everton, the ball bounced back perfectly for Adam who stooped to head into the empty net and make it 3-2.

At this point, with the crowd stunned and haunting memories of disasters past from earlier in the campaign, the Blues might have descended into panic but they stuck with what had been working and almost carved out an immediate response with a virtual carbon copy of the second goal. Rodwell fed Baines, he crossed low and Fellaini tried to turn it home but Rachubka saved and, in any case, play was pulled back for offside.

Two minutes later, Rodwell thought he'd delivered the equaliser. Rachubka went walkabout outside his area,and got away from Coleman but not Rodwell and was dispossessed leaving the net unattended and just begging to be bulged by the 19 year-old's well-struck shot. Somehow, though, Evatt scrambled back and hurled himself into the path of the ball, stretching out a despairing leg that steered it clear and left the defender in a crumpled heap in the Gwladys Street End net. Rodwell couldn't believe it and neither could anyone else.

With 20 minutes left, Moyes decided to change things up, though despite the scoreline it was hard to see who he could pull off as almost everyone had been having a storming game up to that point. Rodwell and Bilyaletdinov were the ones to make for Tim Cahill and Jermaine Beckford and five minutes later, the Blues were back on level terms.

Saha won a corner that eventually came out to Baines and yielded a second corner when his shot was deflected behind. Arteta stepped up to take the kick from the Everton left, Beckford challenged for the wicked inswinger inside the six-yard box and when the ball bounced up invitingly for the unmarked Saha at the back post, the striker made no mistake by burying the header to mark his hat-trick.

With Holloway having put two defensively-minded players on when the score was 3-2, the momentum was back with the home side and just four minutes later, Goodison was rocking once more as the Blues reclaimed the lead. Baines stepped inside his marker on the left touchline, picked out Beckford's run with an inch-perfect ball in with his weaker foot and the mercurial striker delivered the perfect finish, a left-footed volley that guided it clean past the advancing 'keeper.

4-3 in a spellbinding game and Everton weren't done yet. Surging away on a counter-attack of their own another four minutes on from the fourth goal, Fellaini sent Saha away with a well-time pass across the halfway line and the no. 8 simply took it from there, powering in on goal and burying his fourth goal past Rachubka with the outside of his right foot before wheeling away to milk the celebrations from the home crowd.

Moyes gave him the opportunity for a standing ovation by substituting him with four minutes left and the Blues successfully played out time with just a Beckford overhead kick that flew over the bar the only real chance that fell to either side in injury time.

The scoreline belies the quailty that coursed through this Everton performance, easily the most complete attacking display they have put in all season. But for Blackpool's unfortunate opener and some poor defending for their second and third goals, this would have been a romp for Moyes's boys. As it was, Goodison was treated to an absolutely thrilling match and though Moyes has persistent concerns over his side's susceptibility to lapses in concentration at the back and to being hit on the break, he'll take enormous satisfaction from what ended up being a terrific victory.

He also has something of a dilemma now that Cahill is back from the Asia Cup because Rodwell, despite all the predictions he will make a great centre half, made a very convincing case for retaining that advanced midfield role. Were it not for a loss of composure at critical moments in front of goal and, of course, that miracle stop by Evatt, he would have added his name to the scoresheet, but his performance was notable for some wonderful vision, threading a number of defence-splitting balls through the Blackpool rearguard.

Indeed, there were great performances all over the park. Fellaini was immense, Arteta energised and more creative than we've seen him in months, Coleman a terror, Bily an occasional magician, and Baines inspired with his delivery from the left.

But the bulk of the plaudits rightly belong with Saha who grabbed four goals and scored another that was disallowed but also put in the complete striker's display, chasing everything, chesting down long balls, holding up play and generally haring around the Goodison turf like a man possessed. For a player that many had written off as injury-prone, disinterested and past it, he lit up this match in the manner that persuaded Manchester United to pay Fulham £11m for his services all those seasons ago.

Like the stirring win over Spurs here a month ago, this should provide a platform for Moyes's side to kick on and start climbing away from trouble at the wrong end of the table but a tricky trip to the Reebok Stadium in their next fixture will fully test that new-found resolve. Having shown that they can get their attacking ticking and the goals flowing, this game should provide a benchmark for the last third of the campaign.

Player Ratings: Howard 6, Neville 7, Heitinga 7, Distin 7, Baines 8, Coleman 8, Fellaini 9, Arteta 8, Bilyaletdinov 8 (Cahill 6), Rodwell 8 (Beckford 8), Saha 10* (Jagielka 6)

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Terry Mcloughlin
1   Posted 06/02/2011 at 00:46:04

Report abuse

Neville 5 or 6
Aiden Doyle
2   Posted 06/02/2011 at 01:32:00

Report abuse

I know that people like to deride Moyes? tactical ability, but his set-up was very clever today. Blackpool like to play a 4-3-3 when they?re on the attack, so Moyes countered this by having Coleman dropping in to a right-back(ish) position when they were in possession, allowing Neville to act as a third centre-back when required. It seemed to do an extremely good job of disrupting their attacking fluency and, despite scoring three times, there was an element of luck in all of their goals.
Andy McNabb
3   Posted 06/02/2011 at 01:28:14

Report abuse

What a wonderful way to wake up this morning! Having watched extended highlights, two thoughts come to mind:

Firstly, before we get carried away, this Blackpool team will probably present the opposition with more space than any other side in the league.

Secondly, for all the hard-man image, am I right in saying that is the second vital 50-50 challenge where Johnny has failed this season? As a defender, you are first and foremost a stopper and the Jag, for all his limitations, would have put his body on the line in a similar situation.

Pete Gunby
4   Posted 06/02/2011 at 01:28:19

Report abuse

Finally we have a weekend we can enjoy! Watch it again, Lyndon ? I think it was the outside of Saha's left foot for the last goal... not that it matters. Great day.
Martin Faulkner
5   Posted 06/02/2011 at 02:06:31

Report abuse

Andy, For all the talk of Johnny bottling two tackles now and costing us two goals, how many goals has Howard cost us this season?

How many times has Baines failed to close down the cross leading to a goal? How many blunders did Distin have in his early season form?

I still think we should persevere with him ahead of Jags, did you see his first contribution when coming on? Hoofed it 60 yards from midfield over the byline on the far side.

With Heitinga in the side we have two centre-backs who can play it out of defence and we look much better for it.

Ian Tunstead
6   Posted 06/02/2011 at 02:54:13

Report abuse

Did anyone see the Wenger Interview after the Newcastle game? Couldn't help but laugh when they asked him about the Barton challenge and he used his classic "I didn't see it" response... haha. I know who I believe when they give their account of things.
Mike Gaynes
7   Posted 06/02/2011 at 03:13:44

Report abuse

Regarding Moyes' "dilemma"... I don't think he has one just yet, because Cahill won't be fully fit for a couple more weeks. But when he is, I would lobby for him to replace Coleman in the side. The young man has been brilliant, but the errors in his own end of the field are starting to pile up. The chest backpass today was a glaring blunder.

When Cahill's ready, plug him in behind Saha with Rodwell and Fellaini in support and Arteta moving wide right. Rodwell's burgeoning confidence should be encouraged, and I would hate to see him back on the bench.

PS... Ian, in the interview I saw on Sky, Wenger not only said he saw Barton's challenge, but that he should have been sent off for it.

Mike Gaynes
8   Posted 06/02/2011 at 03:24:56

Report abuse

Oh, and by the way, Lyndon... that was a nice bit of writing. Lovely summary.
Dick Fearon
9   Posted 06/02/2011 at 04:59:19

Report abuse

Good un' Lyndon. After watching the game 'live' on TV, all TW reports is akin to enjoying a delicious dessert after a most satisfying main course.
Dermot Ryan
10   Posted 06/02/2011 at 05:15:54

Report abuse

Wow Mike. Although I see your logic about Coleman, I can't agree. He brings so much energy and threat to that right-hand side. I agree he was guilty of shocking naivety in our own half today, but so was everyone else.

I'm not sure why we are struggling so much defensively. Heitinga has a howler nearly every game but I agree with Martin that it is so much better to watch him and Distin bringing the ball out than Jags. Frankly Jags and Neville look so much cruder than the rest of the team. I know ultimately it is all about results and it is no good looking good (which I think we do more often than not in the last number of games) if we aren't grinding out results.

I guess I think we need to address our defensive issues on the training ground rather than changing personnel. The only exception to that might be Bily. I was thrilled he had a good game and I genuinely want him to succeed at Everton, but I do think he does better against a team like Blackpool rather than a well-organized super-fit, super-pressing team like Chelsea or Arsenal. Sometimes he just doesn't look up to the pace. That said, I don't think Osman is the solution in that situation either.
Mike Green
11   Posted 06/02/2011 at 07:54:03

Report abuse

Great report Lyndon - fantastic to see player ratings of a 10 (!?), a 9, 6 8's and no one below a 6....... heady days indeed.

Let's hope we can take that form (Louis especially) into the Chelsea game and salvage something from this season.

Could the tunnel incident at the Emirates be the turning point in our season? If it is / was, why does it take a moment of controversy to wake our lads up to make them perform.....?

Just watching highlights again ? awesome match. :D
Tony Cheek
12   Posted 06/02/2011 at 08:44:14

Report abuse

Some really sublime football from the blues this time. If it was against better opposition then "School of Science" would be mentioned here a few times I am sure. Now we have three strikers that can score goals suddenly, and Bily is getting better and better and proving those doubters wrong.

Fellaini is looking world class whoever he plays against, and putting Mikel in the shade. Heitinga made one shit tackle yesterday, but otherwise was good and, overall, I think the defence looks much better without Jags.

Now, all we need is a keeper. Howard was terrible again. Yes, he makes some great stops now and then, but that's what PL keepers are supposed to do. His positioning is terrible and I feel it's time for Mucha to step up.

Ray Robinson
13   Posted 06/02/2011 at 10:33:44

Report abuse

Tony #12, the tackle by Heitinga wasn't just "shit", it epitomised the lack of commitment that this guy has for our club. For a "hard man" it was cowardly and one I would have been ashamed of playing in a Sunday League game. Not the first time either. And as for the sickening parading in front of the Gwladys Street at the end of the match, well the less said the better.

Just how was Howard "terrible again" yesterday? He has his faults but what did he actually do wrong?
Ian Tunstead
14   Posted 06/02/2011 at 11:28:33

Report abuse


It shows even more how much of a liar he is because that's not what he said on MotD.
Dave Lynch
15   Posted 06/02/2011 at 11:42:46

Report abuse

For god's sake, this was Blackpool. A team that has imploded big time, how many times have we been carried away with one result only to be bought down to earth next game? I enjoyed it as much as the next man, but it is now past.
Paul Gladwell
16   Posted 06/02/2011 at 13:07:13

Report abuse

Heitinga did a similar shitout tackle against Wolves that cost us a goal too this season, some hardcase he is.
Paul Gladwell
17   Posted 06/02/2011 at 13:10:07

Report abuse

And why does not our manager insist to Howard he has to have someone on the near post, as it has cost us again? Apparently he won't allow it, as the man on the near post gets in his way, well no-one did yesterday, Tim.
Mike Hughes
18   Posted 06/02/2011 at 13:15:43

Report abuse

I was particularly pleased with the combination of Baines and Bily down the left. Perhaps we won't miss Pienaar too much and Bily can get some form with a decent run in the team.

Ironic that, most of the season, our attack has been found wanting whereas now, our defenders are giving us cause for concern.

Nice weekend so far though for a change. Let's hope Chelski can keep the high-scoring theme up this afternoon :)
Paul Gladwell
19   Posted 06/02/2011 at 13:32:32

Report abuse

Too true Mike, how many goals came down that side?
Andrew Cunningham
20   Posted 06/02/2011 at 13:09:51

Report abuse

Wenger? Arsenal?
Who gives a flying fuck about them.
I,am just happy with a blues win.
Rob Hill
21   Posted 06/02/2011 at 14:41:15

Report abuse

Would those who were proposing a change of manager, and mentioning Di Matteo, would you still take him now he's free?

This is a genuine question, Im bringing it up because he's just been sacked, not because of yesterdays game!!
Tony Cheek
22   Posted 06/02/2011 at 14:35:54

Report abuse

Ray#13..Didnt see the parading after the game, what was that about? Just think the defence looks better with Heitinga there. I agree it was a cowardly tackle and hope he got a right bollocking for it, but we play so much better from the back with him there. He IS a good player and we should try and keep him there. Chelsea do not bid for crap I can assure you!
As for Howard yesterday, first goal, should have reacted quicker. Second goal, did you see where he was when the ball went in, in the back of the goal, WTF is he doing in there? Third goal, too far out when shot came..Sorry Ray, dont like to be critical when we really play well, but we are never ever going to win anything with him in goal.
Ray Robinson
23   Posted 06/02/2011 at 15:02:37

Report abuse

Tony, Heitinga made a point of walking the whole length of the Gwladys Street, hands aloft applauding the crowd. He should have been walking the whole length of the Park End, apologising to me and 4,999 others.

Can't agree with your comments on Howard by the way. It was actually a superb save by him to put the ball onto the bar before the 3rd goal. I'd put all 3 goals down to poor defensive errors rather than Howard.

Oh well, just differences of opinion.
David Hallwood
24   Posted 06/02/2011 at 15:26:23

Report abuse

Good report Lyndon: Although Bily isn't as quick as Pienaar or 'busy', I think he's got a much better footballing brain and his choices are so much better than pienaar in and around the box. BTW did you notice that Pienaar was on the subs bench yesterday, and Bale wasn't playing-get used to it kid.

Maybe it's grumpy old men time, but I must've been the only person in the ground that wasn't happy about the result, you can say what you like about great game for the neutral etc, but i would prefer us winning 1-0 or 2-0, and be in total control of the game. As it stands the last time we won and kept a clean sheet was the win over the RS, just not good enough and if we continue to make schoolboy howlers like like we did against Blackpool & Arsenal, we will be turned over by better teams than Blackpool.

Lyndon Lloyd
25   Posted 06/02/2011 at 15:53:28

Report abuse

Mike Gaynes: But when he is, I would lobby for him to replace Coleman in the side.

Thanks for the kind words regarding the report, Mike, but I'm going to disagree with you on Seamus :)

I don't recall too many glaring errors on his part recently in his own half and yesterday's mistake was a small one. It really should have been dealt with by Heitinga.

I agree with Dermot that the energy and the threat he poses down the right make him vital. Only a small percentage of what he does actually leads to anything directly (sometimes he needs to cross or release it sooner) but the free kicks, corners and throw-ins that he wins by charging at opposition defences do lead to chancs.

I love having someone of his exuberance and determination in the side and I think we'd be much the poorer without him.
Mike Gaynes
26   Posted 06/02/2011 at 17:22:35

Report abuse

All fair points, Lyndon, I note that you fail to answer the obvious question that follows. Who would you sit when Cahill returns? It certainly won't be Arteta, who probably deserves the bench more than any... we know Moyes won't take that step. So in yesterday's starting 4-5-1, if you add Cahill, who do you subtract?

Or do you leave Cahill out?
Mike Gaynes
27   Posted 06/02/2011 at 17:31:36

Report abuse

Tony Cheek, people like you who simply blame the keeper every time a shot goes in just make me shake my head and laugh.

I think you're 180 off about Howard... I consider him among the very best in the Prem. I certainly wouldn't trade him for any of the other so-called "top" keepers... I just watch Cech cower away from a cross and give up an ugly goal to the Shite, and that after screaming in the face of one of his defenders. Who would you prefer? Rank blunderers like Green and Foster? A fading legend like Van der Sar or Friedel?

I'll give you one name I'd trade Howard for... Joe Hart. That's it. Other than that, forget it. When the shots are coming in, give me a guy who stops shots. Brilliantly. That's Howard.

Mike Gaynes
28   Posted 06/02/2011 at 17:46:45

Report abuse

Sorry... meant "just watched"... past tense. As Chelsea now are, thanks to Cech's chicken act.
Tony Cheek
29   Posted 06/02/2011 at 18:05:23

Report abuse

Mike#27....People like me DO NOT simply blame the keeper every time a shot goes in. If you think Howard is one of the best in the PL, that's your opinion.

Howard has cost us a cart full of points so far, and I think he is our weak link and he is having a bad season. Sorry, but that's my opinion.

Col Noon
30   Posted 06/02/2011 at 18:28:51

Report abuse

More than happy with the 3 points and some good goals. Less than happy with conceading awful goals yet again. Do teams ever score good goals against Everton? and why are we so easy to score against. More positives than negatives obvioulsy and I am not nit-picking but some of Everton's defending this season has been diablolical. We must continue to be postitive and go at teams but at the back we have to improve drastically.
Christopher McCullough
31   Posted 06/02/2011 at 20:50:53

Report abuse

I once posted on here to suggest that Moyes was mad for declining an offer of £8million for Saha. But he is definitly the most gifted Everton striker since Rooney. I hope he stays fit, particularly for the Chelsea game.
Mike Gaynes
32   Posted 06/02/2011 at 20:26:39

Report abuse

Tony, I think overall Howard has SAVED us a bucketful of points, despite giving a couple away early in the season. He has had to make some breathtaking saves because, as Col points out, our defending has been miserable at times. Distin has had a brilliant year and is my current choice for player of the season (although Fellaini is coming up fast). However, Jags' performance level dropped off even before his injury, Heitinga does not coordinate well with Distin, the slowing Neville has been repeatedly roasted up the flank (he simply stopped running for some reason on Adam's goal yesterday), and Baines, for all his brilliance going forward, is a weak tackler and mushy-soft defender against crosses.

None of this is Howard's fault. I can think of a half-dozen saves he's made this year that nobody else in the EPL besides Hart could make. And most of them he wouldn't have had to make if his defenders were doing their jobs.
Mark Wayman
33   Posted 06/02/2011 at 21:33:50

Report abuse

Never been to a game like yesterday's. Being drenched in rain probably made it all the more memorable, crowd was fantastic (quiet to start off with though). Shame the game ended in the end!

Saha really rolled back the years. A 'perfect' hat trick and the best centre forward performance I've seen by an Everton player for a long time.

Like with others I did leave the stadium with worries amongst the joy. The goals we are conceding are just plain awful. Having dominated the first half I would have been gutted had we lost, but against a better team we would have. Going forward the midfield looks fine, if a bit impotent, but they are too slight defensively (contradicting myself here but Fellaini won almost everything today). I feel like I have seen teams walk through the midfield and defence to score on numerous times this season. We need someone nasty in there.

Oh well, guess we'll just have to score at least three to win every game :)

Mike Gaynes
34   Posted 06/02/2011 at 21:48:53

Report abuse

However, Tony, you're certainly entitled to your opinion of Howard as our weak link. So I stand by my question: Who would you trade him for if you could?
Roberto Birquet
35   Posted 06/02/2011 at 18:14:01

Report abuse

On the Heitinga bottle ? weak challenge that led to Blackpool's second. It was weak and I still have a sore head from stupidly whacking it with both my hands in frustration... we shoulda been about 3 up, not level.

But I thought at the time that he or the Blackpool player would dive in studs down for the dead ball. An extremely dangerous challenge and it looked highly likely. I think Heitinga went in timidly part fearing that a red may have come from diving in, part fearing too hard a challenge would leave him a broken leg.

It was the wrong call. But a tad understandable, but he shoulda maybe just belted the ball, while getting his legs outta the way. Not decisive enough. And could cost him his place.

But I like Johnny. Usually very cool on the ball and good linking with Felli.

Roberto Birquet
36   Posted 06/02/2011 at 23:54:07

Report abuse

And is having Felli as a main target man for corners not leaving us exposed to counter attack? I felt the same on Chelsea's goal in the cup. We're over-confident and up for another goal, and then get hit on the counter.

We need someone to do his sweeper job after corners.
Steve Smith
37   Posted 06/02/2011 at 23:57:15

Report abuse

Dave Lynch (15), I agree with the sentiment of your point, but if yesterday, or any other game was a loss, then there would be a lot more posts and comments on Toffeeweb, and talk of a poor game would go on for days after it had finished.

Let's enjoy the win, pick out and discuss the positives (and negatives) from it, and take heart from a great attacking Everton performance. It doesn't always have to be about doom and gloom.
Tony Cheek
38   Posted 07/02/2011 at 05:25:42

Report abuse

Mike, The thing with Howard is that I keep asking myself "how did that get in" all the time. Don´t you? If there is one person I would like to see him replaced with before the end of the season, then you do not have to look further than Jan Mucha.

Now, I am putting my head on the chopping block here, he might be a major let down, but I am beginning to wonder how Howard can keep David Moyes's trust.

Paul Carr
39   Posted 07/02/2011 at 09:18:28

Report abuse

Beckford deserves great praise for his brilliant goal ? surely this has removed all doubts about his ability. And he was involved in the other 2 goals ? his supporting run into the box allowed Saha a free route for the 5th goal. Play him with Saha and we will win more than most, especially at home.

DM has a few tough selection decisions to make for the Bolton game. I suspect he will name an unchanged team again with Cahill and Beckford still on the bench.

Paul Carr
40   Posted 07/02/2011 at 10:52:15

Report abuse

Who was our last player to score 4 goals in a league match?
Was it Bob Latchford?
Mike Gaynes
41   Posted 07/02/2011 at 15:12:15

Report abuse

Tony, the question I usually ask is more along the lines of "how did they give that up?" Being a defender myself, I always go looking for someone to blame, and I'm always happy to assign that blame to the keeper, but I'm rarely able to do that with Howard.

As for Mucha, talk about a blind stab and a prayer. Did you actually watch the guy at the World Cup? I did. He gave up seven goals in four games, including an absolute howler against Paraguay and an easy one to little New Zealand. He had a good game against Italy with several fine athletic saves, but then got caught hopelessly out of position on Holland's gamewinner. I saw no sign that Mucha is ready for the EPL or anything close to it. Also, he couldn't beat out Fabianski at Legia Warsaw, and despite his great game against us, I don't consider Fabianski a top EPL keeper by any means.

I can't believe you want to throw this unknown quantity into our goal. Obviously you really dislike Howard. I'm happy to know that Moyes has a different opinion.

Jon Cox
42   Posted 07/02/2011 at 14:53:48

Report abuse

I know it's fiction but relevant to this thread. I wouldn't mind if we conceded 4 goals every game as long as we scored six.

I saw this attitude when Keegan managed Newcastle and it only ended when they for some inexplicable reason had to (or were made) to sell Andy Cole. Their football up to that point was extemely entertaining and they had the title within their grasp.

Everton at the mermont (sorry couldn't resist) seem to be in a transitional tactical state of thought. Do we go with attack or defense. Moyes needs to get a handle on which way he wants to go and stick with it.

To many times this season Moyes has dallied with one or the other. If you can't do both, which we would like, either attack mega or defend mega and win games 1-0. Or do what you did on Saturday and win 10-8 every game.

I know which one I'd go for.
Jon Cox
43   Posted 07/02/2011 at 16:37:04

Report abuse

PS great match report Lyndon.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
44   Posted 07/02/2011 at 16:46:09

Report abuse

Jon, I'm afraid to show my ignorance... but ? "mermont"???
Jon Cox
45   Posted 07/02/2011 at 17:06:14

Report abuse

Michael, it's a BBC Lawrenson thing, yeah?
Jon Cox
46   Posted 07/02/2011 at 17:13:22

Report abuse

Michael, are you in the Antartica this week or are you trying, in South America, to suss out the Mayan Calenda?
Jon Cox
47   Posted 07/02/2011 at 17:23:34

Report abuse

PS Gary Moore RIP
Tony Cheek
48   Posted 07/02/2011 at 17:45:41

Report abuse

Mike, Last word on this one from me. If Mucha was so bad in the World Cup, why did Moyes want him at Everton? I mean Howard had a brilliant World Cup... didn't he?

The whole idea with a football squad is that players should be looking over their shoulders and producing good performances, to keep in the team. Maybe it's this that is sadly lacking at our club. Are they all playing well enough to keep being selected, week-in, week-out? Why has Beckford not been given a proper chance? Because our strikers have been top-notch this season... I think not. Has Arteta delivered this season? I think not... but he is selected every game.

So don´t panic, Mike, Howard will play every bleeding game, even though his positional play is shit, his only strength is stopping shots on the line, except shots taken from outside the box.

I just wonder how many points we would have if we had a good keeper like (this hurts) the Liverpool keeper. I reckon we would be sitting around 6th in the table... nuff said!!!

Mike Gaynes
49   Posted 08/02/2011 at 01:42:37

Report abuse

Tony, I'm sure Moyes had seen far more of Mucha than I have, and signed him for good reason ? as he did Howard, Pienaar, Jags, Cahill and the others who weren't considered top-class at the time (remember Howard had one brilliant season at Man Utd before falling from grace). But if you have faith in Moyes's judgement on signing Mucha, I wonder why you have no faith in his judgement on starting Howard.

In my view, Howard starts because he never gives up tricklers between his legs (Foster), little squirmers off his hands (Green in the World Cup), soft mushies under his arms (Gomes on Sunday), and he never pathetically cowers away from bouncing crosses as Cech did to lose to the RS.

If you think Hart is better than Howard, I agree with you. If you think Reina is better, I will consider the point worthy of debate. If you think anybody else in the Prem is better, I think you'd better have your eyes checked. Maybe with Hart or Reina in goal, we'd be sixth; maybe not. But with anybody else ? Robinson, Myhill, Foster, Green, Hahnemann, Friedel, Jaaskeleinen or anyone else down the league you'd care to name ? we'd be staring at a relegation battle. So I guess we'll have to agree to disagree.

Regarding Beckford, I thought the prevailing view was that Moyes pushed him too hard, too soon, not the other way around. But keeping in mind that Moyes tends to keep his new acquisitions on the bench for a while ? Cahill, Baines, Jags, Fellaini all had to serve extended apprentice time before breaking through ? I'm willing to trust him on Beckford. The Becks I saw in the last two games was far more controlled and confident than the guy who ran around like a headless chicken in the early games this season. I don't think that's a coincidence.
Bob Parrington
50   Posted 08/02/2011 at 12:25:38

Report abuse

Over analyse as much as you want, guys. This was an effin' great performance! Well done EVERTON!
Tony Cheek
51   Posted 08/02/2011 at 14:37:24

Report abuse

What games are you watching Mike? Howard has made so many mistakes this season it's unreal. One great season for United? They got rid of him because he was not good enough!!

And no, I do not have faith in Moyes'ds judgement. How did you you come to that conclusion? You are obviously a pro-Moyes man. Sorry, but I can not wait to see him go.

Beckford running around like a headless chicken!! Well, it's no wonder you are a defender, Mike.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to Column articles, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.