It's all about damage limitation

, 15 October, 163comments  |  Jump to most recent
Chelsea 3 - 1 Everton

Match Summary

David Moyes names an unchanged starting line-up for the third successive daunting match against the Premier League's moneybags sides. Osman, Rodwell and Cahill are all deemed fit enough to play... but no sign of the highly promising up-coming young attacking midfielder, Ross Barkley, or Magaye Gueye:

Everton: Howard; Hibbert, Jagielka, Distin, Baines; Osman, Rodwell, Fellaini, Coleman; Cahill; Saha.
Subs: Mucha, Heitinga, Bilyaletdinov, Stracqualursi, Drenthe, Neville, Vellios.

Everton tried to create something down the left in the first few minutes but Saha strangely dummied the cross and any chance evaporated. A poor pass by Fellaini encouraged Chelsea to mount an attack. Osman then looped in a weak cross that Cahill tried to head goalward rather than leaving for Coleman. Saha then made a couple of poor passes giving away attacking possession very cheaply.

Coleman won a corner off a superb diagonal free-kick from Baines, whose corner was just a little too close to Cech. A great play from Baines to Osman to Saha down the left, enabled the Frenchman to jink inside and have a poke at Cech, who fumbled the powerful shot a little. A good chance to move forward was wasted when Cahill, and Rodwell chose to play the ball backwards.

Fellaini got booked cheaply after 15 mins for slightly lifting his foot trying to save a lost ball and catching Ramieres. Jagielka almost got skinned by Drogba but recovered to thwart the Ivorian. Everton had done well in defence to keep Chelsea well away from Tim Howard for the first 20 mins, and an excellent ball in form Osman needed to be clipped first-time by Fellaini who wanted an extra touch. Everton were trying to be creative in possession, mainly down the left, but too often a poor final ball let them down, or they started to get caught offside too easily.

Another lazy piece of interplay allowed Ramieres to break and win Chelsea's first corner but thankfully nothing came of it and Howard could again roll out the ball to a defender for a more patient build-up (although Jagielka was determined to hoof at every opportunity).

It looked like Everton could defend like this all day but, out of nothing, Cole clipped the ball behind the Everton defence as Mata skinned a static Coleman and planted an easy cross for Sturridge to head home. Easy peasy.

Mata tried to do it again down the Everton right seconds later and almost beat Jagielka; then Everton put together a rather determined attacking move until Coleman inexplicably gifted the ball to Mata under no pressure, with a posse of vanilla shirts waiting expectantly for a far far better final ball.

Cole fouled Hibbert and was booked, allowing Baines to put in a looping free-kick that was far too high and consequently wasted. At least they were trying to implement some build-up play but the basic mistakes belied a mindset dominated by far too much emphasis on defence in training, rather than structuring intelligent attacking moves.

Baines went in the book for blocking Sturridge and Chelsea put together a flowing move that almost came off but Hibbert's hoof again found Cahill offside. As half-time loomed, Cole won a soft free-kick off Coleman and Lampard curled in a good cross that Terry rose to head past Howard who had failed to come out and claim a bog-standard free-kick, flapping and flailing at it. Easy Peasy.

No doubt Everton's more expansive forward play in possession compared to recent games was the reason why they now went in 2-0 down at the break, and with a no doubt impossible mountain to climb. Would Moyes stick with this line-up, or attempt a kick up the arse after the break with some exciting attacking changes now the team was two goals behind? No!

From the break, Osman got in a fairly good strike that beat Cech glanced off the outside of the post. But the game then settled into an all-too-familiar pattern with Chelsea dictating the pace, probing and poking at Everton who pent most of the time chasing shadow and doing little constructive until they all too inevitably lot possession.

A rare free-kick was wasted as Baines tried a long shot and Osman followed up with a shot off target. Cometh the hour-mark... cometh the all-too predictable substitutions, Drenthe on for the exceedingly poor Coleman.

Chelsea took that as a signal to raise their game, and swept the ball forward easily again, Mata crossing well for Ramieres to finish from 2 yards despite close marking. Game, set and match. Easy peasy.

Sturridge was booked for a clear dive, then, with over 20 min left, Moyes finally accepted that Cahill was not going to break his 2011 goal drought but, with two unused and untrusted strikers on the bench, he amazingly brought on Neville in his place! We have what we hold. A 3-0 defict was clearly enough of an embarrassment for the 'fantastic' Everton manager!

Ten minutes left... okay, why not bring on one of those strikers and go 4-4-2? Er... no. We'll just swap out Saha, who had been poor. First touch for Vellios on the end of a cross from Drenthe after just 18 seconds on the field... GOAL! Would ya credit it? But he's only young, he's inexperienced, he's not ready for the Premier League...

The game drifted on, more as a training ground match, with no real drive or passion, Lampard having a good shot at Tim Howard in the 4 mins of added time. And that was it, confirming a new Everton era where they are now completely unable to compete with the moneybag teams, and limiting it to a 2-gaol deficit is considered another resounding 'success'. After all, there are plenty of sides who will go way from Stamford Bridge with much worse scorelines...

» Read more



Reader Comments (163)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Andy Peers
1 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:28:30
7 points from 7 games, you know Moyes is chuffed about that as his tactics are to play for the draw. "Thought the boys did well other than the sloppy mistakes at the back" will be his comments. Bringing Neville on as a sub at 3-0 down has to be the last straw.
John Nelson
2 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:28:22
What a fucking disrespectful viewpoint of the Blues today. Yet again, I must have watched a different game to you.

I thought we were sound, just like the derby. The main difference today was some defensive lapses and a few £20m purchased players... You wouldn't think that would make a difference against a team that has spent £50k this summer would you???

We are gonna be fine. Play like this, shore defence up and play Drenthe from the start and we might just have a decent season.

Oh and yes, I want Kenwright out and Moyes gets on my tits sometimes (just before the wank "apologist" phrase gets bandied about), but, going back to my first point, now is the time to try to be positive. We still have a decent team, and believe it or not Moyes does get it right a lot of the time.

So let's stop with the glass half-empty viewpoint and GET BEHIND THE FUCKING TEAM. Slagging Moyes & Kenwright off is getting boring now.

COYB
Brian Waring
3 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:44:13
Jon, watching negative shite like this, virtually week - in week - out, is getting rather boring.
Brian Waring
4 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:46:02
Also John, that second half was like a training match for Chelsea.
Andy Crooks
5 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:43:19
John, "shore defence up and play Drenthe from the start". TELL THAT TO DAVID MOYES!!
The use of substitutes defies belief in its ineptitude. This coach is quite capable of seeing us relegated.
Tom Bowers
6 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:36:53
No surprise here. Moyes getting his selection wrong yet again. How many more times? Ferguson get's his wrong at Anfield but has the right subs and gets a result.

The 4-5-1 formation is absolutely banal with the players Moyes started with. We have 2 defensive midfielders (Rodwell and Fellaini) and three others who have absolutely no creativity (Coleman a fullback) and one forward who is too old to be left on his own and in fact spent more time coming back into his own half for the ball.

We transferred the only creative midfielder (Arteta) and replaced him with Drenthe who cannot get a start from Moyes. We have 2 young strikers who again cannot get a start as Moyes stubbornly persists with the same play and usual suspect players.

Okay, we don't really expect to win at Chelski but, after a bright opening 10 minutes, we went into defeatist mode and then it was a matter of time. The desperate measures of "Plan B'' came into effect ? and Moyes screwed that up too!
Colin Potter
7 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:39:07
I couldn't believe either, bringing on Neville for Cahill. Moyes is a complete embarrassment to this club. Let's pray this is his last season withh us, because I cannot see the likes of Barkley wanting to stay with us, not if they want to further their careers they won't.
Jamie Barlow
8 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:47:48
I don't think Chelsea got into second gear all game Brian. They didn't have to.
John Nelson
9 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:46:52
Brian I was up in arms against city the other week, I thought our gameplan then was terrible ? but today and 2 weeks ago I genuinely thought the team was sound. Bit strange bringing Neville on I'll admit like...
Andy Crooks
10 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:48:32
Tom. did you see a Plan B? Plan A is don't concede a goal. Plan B is don't concede a second and so on and so on. Negative, defeatist and utterly demoralising.
Ray Robinson
11 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:50:04
Start with Drenthe and Vellios and see what happens. Bringing on Neville was a waste of time. I'm afraid, Moyes's damage limitation mentality even before the game starts is getting on my nerves now.
John Daley
12 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:39:52
I don't see the point of persisting in playing purely to avoid defeat when it inevitably results in a defeat anyway.

I don't see the point of playing Hibbert against Chelsea after he got his arse shredded against them in the cup final and was dragged off at half time.

I don't see the point of starting Barkley in the first two games of the season and then subsequently binning him off for no reason. He's good enough to have attracted the attention of Utd, City and Chelsea but he's not good enough to even get on the Everton bench?

I don't see the point of persisting with the Distin/Jagielka combo when they've proven themselves incapable of forming a solid partnership. Both are decent enough players individually but ship far too many sloppy goals to continue together.

I don't see the point of Cahill continually holding the ball up and allowing every Chelsea player to get back into position when a rare opportunity to counter arises.

I don't see the point of a goalkeeping coach who in five years has failed to twig that Tim Howard needs some serious coaching in how to calm the fuck down and stop flapping hopelessly at crosses.

I don't see the point of Steve Round.

Fuck me. Watching Everton at the moment is about as appealing a proposition as Vannessa Feltz lifting up her flab and asking if you want a closer look at her Vajazzle.
John Daley
13 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:59:45
"now is the time to try to be positive."

Any chance you can let Moyes know?
Michael Kenrick
14 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:03:25
John, what the fuck? I am being positive!

The lads played well for long periods, we only lost by two goals... When you consider the massive gulf in player investment, this is a fantastic achievement by a fantastic manager.

Why, the entire English public must be proud of our effort. today. We didn't embarrass one of the top teams at their gaff. What more do you want???
Peter Murphy
15 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:58:12
If that stubborn defensive minded po-faced git won't start playing Barkley, Vellios, Drenthe and Gueye and actually making a fist of competing in some of these games this season, we are going to be in serious shit.

Our only hope is there are probably three worse teams than us this season. If this shit carries on past Christmas, Fellaini and Baines are gone and I wouldn't blame them at all. I have supported Everton through thick and thin for over 40 years but I am starting to get past anger and into despair.
Trevor Mackie
16 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:10:38
Moyes is a footballing pygmy ? a latter day David O'leary or John Gregory, circumstances gave him a break and he's eked every last penny from it.

Unfettered control beyond the dreams of any other Prem manager...10 years down the line, he's ended up with this two-thirds of a team playing anti-football rubbish, ie, defence, midfield and no attack.

We make him a millionaire every 4 months in gratitude ? simply ludicrous.
John Barnes
17 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:13:00
Surely Moyes can see some of his favourites are just not good enough any more?!? Before and after every game, opposition players and managers say 'you know what to expect from Everton' . Well, the line-up might be the same but the fight isn't there in too many of them now...
Jon Cox
18 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:10:56
Just sussed it. It's in Moyes's contract: "Be shite until Xmas and then go for it because it'll look great. Don't go for it before Xmas because we'll not be able to cry 'no money' and the taxman will clobber us if we get great crowd receipts." ? Oh,and you'll be sacked and wont get £3.5 mill a year.

I actually thought that this would be the way with the run of games, ie. Sky 4/5 that we've just had. I'm now starting to panic because I don't see any difference with the Stokes, Wigans, Accrington Stanleys of this world.

Moyes out ? BILIC IN.
Ian Tunstead
19 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:08:06
Don't know what Moyes was thinking, playing Osman on the wing; it's cringeworthy watching him trying to beat the full backs for pace. He did look more dangerous when he came more central but it was like men against boys watching him. Perhaps Drenthe should be starting for him now on the left or even Bily.

Rodwell was a disgrace. Moyes drops his captain for him and how does Rodwell repay his manager? By contributing nothing to the team, nothing defensivley, nothing offered going forward, no tackles. I can't think of a single moment of significance that he contributed.

Got to feel sorry for Moyes when you see Chelsea's bench of about £100m of talent with Torres, Anelka and the Fellaini wannabe. And even Essien sitting in the stands. They are in another league. It's like watching a heavyweight boxer taking on a featherweight or having to box blindfolded with one arm tied behind your back.
Andy Crooks
20 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:17:38
Trevor Mackie, perfectly summed up. The introduction of Neville today must be a contender for the the most bizarre substitution in the history of Everton FC.

Sorry, I forgot: Chelsea have more money.

Why did Osman start ahead of Drenthe? Shit, I forgot, Chelsea have more money.

Let's hear no more criticism of the great man; no other coach in the world could have achieved what he has done this season.
Shane Corcoran
21 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:24:44
Agreement on most of the posts. We might as well just concede the points.

The game was a non-event. No atmosphere, neither team really trying a whole lot.... Howard flapping, Jagielka hoofing, Rodwell sideways... Sounds familiar.

At least Neville's substitution gave me a bit of a laugh. WTF? I would love to hear Moyes's explanation. Steady the ship no doubt...

Barkley not even on then bench. Strac still coming to terms with training is he? Yawn... I'm not even angry anymore. We'll beat a few and hopefully stay up and then roll on next summer's gossip.
Brian Hill
22 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:20:32
An utterly embarrassing performance. No ambition, desire, gameplan. Is this down to money? No, it isn't. Norwich went to Chelsea and tried to win. Why didn't we?

Please, no more Moyes arse-lickers. He doesn't send us out to win ANY game. I am so sick of watching these pitiful capitulations.
Jon Cox
23 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:27:02
Ian T ? slight change in attitude, I see. Nevermind... everyone will see the light at sometime.

A great quote, "And no-one came from miles around and said MAN who's he?"

Moyes out; BILIC IN!
Martin Mason
24 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:29:51
I didn't see today's game at all and whilst I would normally try to be positive, Moyes is really doing some very bizarre things.

Barkley made a mistake and has been discarded since; bringing on Neville for anything is bizarre but to replace Cahill?

Why have such a potent threat as Vellios warming the bench for 80 minutes? We've had some tough opponents but three defeats on the trot is a bad run.
Col Noon
25 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:29:16
How on god's green earth does Osman start before Drenthe? When I was 8 years old:

1) I could Kick a ball harder than Osman;
2) I could run faster than Osman;
3) I had more upper body strength than Osman.

Moyes crapping his pants again today... so predictable and so tiresome. The man has given up;, today was a walk in the park for Chelsea.

I didn't expect much, I did however expect more than that today. Poor showing, no invention, pace, goal threat. And the usual defensive howlers which seem to be the hallmark of this current Everton team. Can the season just end now?
Andy Peers
26 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:32:31
Just heard Moyes comments and it mirrors what I said in post #1. We are in deep shit and he acts like we did well.

I agree, Ferguson got his team selection wrong today but he does that once a blue moon; Moyes does it every week!
Chris Halliday
27 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:30:17
It was painful to watch tonight but I didn't expect anything else to be honest. Same tired tactics.

Moyes has raised the white flag on the season and expectations.
Al Reddish
28 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:31:02
I am, for my sins, a Moyes fan. However, despite the very valid money argument and the piss poor chairman, even I can see it's time for Jags, Cahill, Saha and Osman to make way for Heitinga, Vellios, Drenthe and Barkley/Bily/Strac.

We can't persist with this defensive "keep what we've got" mentality with the players we got. They just haven't got it in them to keep possession so it is gonna be backs to the walls every time we play the big boys. Just give it a go; after all, the best form of defence is attack!
James Morgan
29 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:33:03
Poor defending cost us today and it needs to be addressed.

Interesting though that the two players myself and many others have been calling to start set up and scored the goal. Surely Vellios and Drenthe have earned the right to start.
Paul Carr
30 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:22:56
Really uninspiring and depressing performance. It is clear that numerous changes are required to avoid ending up in another relegation battle.

Coleman has lost his surprise element and Rodwell just hasn't developed ? what does he actually do? Shame we didn't sell him when United were interested.

Surely the exciting prospect Barkley should start, with Osman in the centre ? at least he tries to go forward. And now it's uncertain if Cahill has got a future? In attack(?) Saha would not have got in the box like Vellios did, but the two together will get goals.

The defence is also better with Neville in it and Heitinga may be a better bet than Distin.

Time to be brave DM!

John Nelson
31 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:26:22
"This is a fantastic achievement by a fantastic manager" ? forgive me if I'm being thick here, Michael, but it's comments like this that to me are sarcastic and piss-taking out of the performance. If indeed sarcasm on your behalf, I just think it's a bit disrespectful mate.
Jon Cox
32 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:40:02
Paul Carr, you would be much closer if you'd have said Heitinga may be a better bet than Jags.
Sam Fitzsimmons
33 Posted 15/10/2011 at 19:58:15
Another frustrating game to watch and an even more depressing result. Last season it was the results against teams like Chelsea, City and Liverpool that kept my spirits up, sadly it isn't happening this season and I can only assume that the moral and spirit of the players must also be getting effected as well.

Moyes's preferred starting eleven for today's game was what we would have expected: players with experience over form; a defensive mindset over creative flair; maturity over youth; and journeymen over technical ability. All very predictable for the fans and for opposing team managers.

I can only assume that the players left on the bench are so bad in training that Moyes has no other option ? otherwise, why would he start with Jagielka over Heitinga? Osman over Drenthe?? Coleman over Barkley??? Saha over Vellios????

Thankfully I'm not on £60k a week to make those decisions...
John Ford
34 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:42:44
Drop Rodwell, he's just not up to it yet. Cahill is either finished or so far from form it makes no difference. Jags is struggling so give Johhnny a go. Osman is underrated but again at the moment just not doing it. Fellaini has to do the work of three.

The real problem is we just don't have the players now to come in and make a difference. That doesn't mean they shouldn't be played but, even with changes, it's clutching at straws. We started with our best striker, something people have been complaining about, but it made no difference. So we'll move on to Vellios and Drenthe out left. I don't believe this will change things.

We need new players. No team can operate like this. We could be the next Sheff Wednesday or Leeds.

Kenwright's chickens are well and truly roosting.
John Ford
35 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:55:23
Agreed, the sarcasm in the report is just silly.
Ian Tunstead
36 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:46:43
Jon, I don't have any change in attitude, people call me an apologist as if I refuse to accept any citicism of Moyes; I am not blind or stubburn, I tell it as I see it.

I still stand by the fact that Moyes gets it right more than most managers in the Prem, and there is no better alternative. There is no shame in loosing to Man City, Chelsea, Liverpool or Man Utd who are operating on another level to the rest of the league.

No matter who Moyes played, we would have lost. Drenthe and Vellios would have made little difference if they started. The only reason Vellios scored was because Chelsea had switched off because they thought the game was over being 3 up.
Kieran Fitzgerald
37 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:50:19
The sickener for me is that as individuals, you can see some of these players go to other clubs and be amazing. You just know the potential is there if only Moyes would accept the obvious and apply it. The likes of Ferguson and Redknapp would not only realise their potential but would have their self-confidence back up in no time.
Andy Codling
38 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:52:39
The last 4 months of last season, Osman was brilliant for us, because he was played in his proper position in the centre. Unfortunately for Ossie, we have a piss poor manager who persists on playing people all over the place.

Same old predictable "lets get a draw" tactics. Neville for Cahill, what the fuck, Davey!!! Parking the bus and trying to nick one when you can't keep clean sheets is madness.

But he will play the same against Fulham, Chelsea and Man Utd because that's all he knows. Three defeats on the bounce with tough games to follow but it's okay for Moyes as he has no pressure to achieve results from his employer... unbelievably rumours are out about extending his contract, WTF.

If he succeeds he's a genius and if he fails its because he has no money; it's a win-win ? throw in 75 grand a week and that's the biggest result Moyes will ever get.
Ian Tunstead
39 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:57:18
Andy, it's hard for SAF to get his team wrong when he has top quality options for every position. Give Moyes the Man Utd money and players and I wonder if Moyes's team selection would only be wrong once a blue moon too. Maybe SAF should get you in as advisor, you should send him your CV.
Brian Harrison
40 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:49:27
Despite our record against Chelsea, I dont think too many Evertonians gave us much hope. But I do think that our mindset of late is not helping our cause, and maybe the lack of funds is now really starting to hurt us.

I would hope that, apart from Man Utd at home, our fixtures are a lot easier, and hopefully we can start these run of games with a more positive outlook. I am afraid that the problem we have is whoever makes up the 5-1 part of our team lack goals. Neither Cahill, Fellaini, Rodwell, Osman, Saha or Anichebe are regular scorers. This problem has been around for a few seasons, not just this season.

Maybe the system doesn't allow us to get into goalscoring positions enough, but I think if for whatever reason you are not scoring, then you need to change something. There is nothing wrong with 4-5-1 as long as you play it positively, in fact Man Utd played this system a lot last season with Rooney playing behind Hernandez or Berbatov. The difference being that they don't play with 2 holding midfield players, and quite often they have a midfield player running beyond their forward. I have to say I can't recall a time when any of our holding midfield players get ahead of our forward.
Phil Bellis
41 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:55:31
I am really concerned we may go into the Man U game on the back of four successive League defeats ? God forbid, I don't want that to happen.
I only hope if we are losing the 5th and they show Kenwright's mug on the big screen, the applause is in proportion to the level he and his fellow directors have taken the club during his chairmanship.
Ian Tunstead
42 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:03:31
Kieran who are these players who have left Everton to go on and be amazing? Every player I can think of has gone backwards since leaving Everton. Only Rooney and Lescott that I can think of have gone on to success but Lescott has fallen behind Jaggs in the pecking order for England and Rooney was the most feared teenager in the World until he started getting played LM for Man Utd.
Chris Downie
43 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:07:24
Slaven Bilic?? Who was as good a centre half as Glen fucking Keeley (look him up, kids).

A gobshite who cost us £27k a week either sitting in the stands/at home/or more often living in Zagreb. He robbed us blind, he was shite and... over my dead body. Get a fucking grip.
Sam Fitzsimmons
44 Posted 15/10/2011 at 20:59:29
Ian ? given your analysis of the gulf between us and the "wealthy" clubs and we accept that the result is all but a foregone conclusion before a ball is kicked, then why not try something new and fresh for those games, such as blooding young players?

Equally if we accept there is no shame in losing to the bigger clubs, is there any shame in losing to QPR?
Andy Crooks
45 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:08:59
Ian Tunstead, I disagree with much of what you say but you certainly don't hide. You are spot on about Moyes's tactics re Osman.
John Ford
46 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:02:27
Big assumptions there Keiran. Redknapp's record is nowhere near as good as Moyes's ? he's had a decent time recently cos he spent a shedload of cash two seasons ago. Even that's starting to look shaky.

I don't believe we have enough good players, and this, combined with key players being off form, is killing us. We have a weak squad with little depth. We brought a £250k(??) attacker on today. I'd like to see him start but can we really expect him to be a saviour?

We're just moving the deck chairs on the Titanic.
Andy Peers
47 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:03:31
Ian, you are missing the point. SAF should have started the 11 he finished with, albeit in hindsight. He, of course, will recognize that; Moyes would not ? no matter how much money he has to spend.

Moyes cannot recognize the bad form of his players and, if he does, he thinks they can just play through their slump. Jags, Osman, Rodwell, Cahill and Coleman are not playing well enough to be in the team. Try Heitinga, Barkley, Drenthe, Gueye and partner Vellois with Saha.

It is not like we don't have options, even with our small squad. I think against Fulham away we will go back to 4-6-0 because Moyes will be afraid of losing 4 in a row. Actually it might be losing 4 of 5 in a row after Utd...
Kevin Hudson
48 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:12:03
Typical hysteria from the usual suspects.

Got to admit though, the geological pace of integrating new players into the starting XI, the subsequent predictability & the mind-blowing decision to deploy Neville before Vellios doesn't help the cause of the Moyes supporter.
Phil Bellis
49 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:26:01
Didn't help Everton, either, Kevin
Steavey Buckley
50 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:09:19
I cannot understand why Everton did not start again without someone wide on the left to help with attacking options. Is Baines now regarded as superman who can defend and attack on the left by himself?

Besides the odd thread from Coleman down the right, there was little in the way of attacking options. The midfield of Osmam, Rodwell and Fellaini could not break forward enough to put the Chelsea defense under pressure.

A defense that would have buckled if enough pressure was put on them. Just the odd Saha shot from distance in the first half to show for Everton's attacking intent. And a header from Cahill that had no real goal-ward threat.

Does Tim Howard suffer with travel sickness after his excursions to the USA? He appeared to be badly positioned for the first Chelea goal and ''flapped'' at their second. The defending from Baines, Coleman and Hibbert leaves me wondering, do they know how to defend properly?

At 2-0 down at half-time, did Moyes really understand the importance of attacking options were needed at the start of the 2nd half?
Kieran Fitzgerald
51 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:20:33
Ian, could you see Rodwell doing any worse if he was played in his natural postion? He hasn't lost any of the talent that made him stand out a couple of years ago.

John, with Harry Redknapp, you could see him lifting players and keeping them motivated and confident. The way he seemed to handle the Modric saga over the summer seemed excellent.

Andy, good point. I don't see Moyes ever learning from his mistakes.
Richard Reeves
52 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:08:02
Why do people constantly use the "no money" scenario when defending Moyes? If Moyes had silly money to spend on world class attackers, he would coach the ambition out of them and then find reasons for not playing them.

And why the fuck is Cahill getting a starting place? All he can do when getting the ball is hold it up, pass back or to the side. He's good for a header in the box but if that's the reason for having him in the team then we're in for a scrap.

I guess that suits this stale, overpaid, overhyped average boss that we have. I wish people would wake up and smell the coffee.
Jon Cox
53 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:22:45
Chris Downie, and Wenger was Pele, Eusabio, George Best, all rolled into one.

And your point is?
Jon Cox
55 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:33:19
Kev, sorry mate but the more you comment, the more you dig deeper in your armeggedon type hole. It's not about hating Moyes, it's about understanding the mindset.

If you were the manager of our illustrious club, would you go for the negativity i.e. pinch a point or would you think that maybe we'll get beat but we'll sure as hell go down fighting, in an attacking sense or we'll show the white flag and be a team of limp wristed twats? And blame money!
Paul Holden
56 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:43:45
We conceded three soft Sunday League goals, never really looked like scoring, turned up at Chelski just to make up the numbers., Coleman, Jagielka and Rodwell waste of space so far this season. 3-0 down, striker off, defender on ? Championship football next season... we're fucked.
Chris Downie
57 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:56:13
Jon Cox 53.
Wenger is a clever bloke who didn't have a track record of robbing our club blind while being a shite lazy mercenary at the same time. By the way, Croatia didn't even qualify for the last World Cup. That's my point.
Fran Mitchell
58 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:04:15
Vellios can't start with Saha.
Drenthe can't play above Osman.
Gueye can't play above Coleman.
Barkley can't play above Rodwell.
Heitinga can't play above Jagielka.

Why?

WE DON'T HAVE ANY MONEY!!!
Noel Lynam
59 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:44:29
As is often the case, the Moyes debate detracts from some of the more prevalent issues among the players, especially those who in the eyes of some, can do no wrong. Some observations from today:

1. Coleman showed on the first goal why Moyes is reluctant (!) to use him at right back.

2. Howard yet again at fault for a goal by not commanding his penalty area. This guy inspires no confidence in his team and looks about as fearful of crosses as yer average vampire.

3. Launching balls onto the heads of Cahill or Saha from inside your own half is never going to be effective when Fellaini and Rodwell are 40 yards further back.

4. Straq looks every bit like he will go the same way as several other loan signings Moyes has made and not get used, such as Ferrari, Gardner, Senderos.

5. Rodwell is not going backwards, he's just at his level ? a decent athlete but an ordinary footballer. Not his fault he has been hyped by media, fans etc but it's apparent his confidence is suffering.

6. Moyes's cautious (I deliberately am not saying 'negative') approach will, in my opinion, hold back the development of Barkley and lead to Drenthe becoming disillusioned. I firmly believe both have remained on the bench due to their mistakes costing a pen vs Blackburn and a goal vs City.

7. Moyes's loyalty to certain players will cost us more points than it gains us, I'm talking about Jags, Cahill and to a lesser extent, some others.
Brendan McLaughlin
60 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:05:26
Of course Fran #57... & if they had... we would have given Chelsea a footballing lesson?
Jon Cox
61 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:01:46
Chris Downie, Moyes V Wenger?

Croatia always played the type of football that we'd die for at Goodison.

Problems with that? Also, England (it pains me to say) are going to win the Euros, you're a'vin a bubble.
Fran Mitchell
62 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:05:36
Let's at least try somethin different:

..........................Howard
Coleman......Heitinga.........Distin..........Baines
..............Fellaini...........Barkley
.......Gueye..........................Drenthe
........................Saha
........................Vellios

Subs from Bily, Cahill, Osman, Rodwell, Jags, Hibbert, Neville.

Play direct and fast counter-attacking football. Run forward when you got the ball, run back when you lose it. This "tip-tap, pass it sideways until you lose possession" football will get us nowhere.
Chris Downie
63 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:11:03
We are talking about Bilic not Wenger, I couldn't give a fuck about Wenger or England.

Bilic was a lazy overated greedy gobshite that everyone couldn't wait to to see the back of. To say "Moyes out, Bilic in" is hiliarious.
Andy Peers
64 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:14:06
Fran, that is a good line-up especially against Fulham. We could afford Coleman at right back as Fulham are not a powerhouse attacking team. Someone on the training ground needs to address the lack of chemistry that any of our midfielders are having with Baines. He is even losing his potency lately.
Kevin Hudson
65 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:03:31
Not sure I deserved that Jon, as I thought my comment was balanced; But please, you carry on shrieking.

"Taxi for Moyes." "We're all doomed.."

Etc..

You wanted us to "go down fighting in an attacking sense."

Paradoxical, pessimistic positivity.

Why don't you apply for Bilic's job, and send him this way?!
Joe McMahon
66 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:02:52
Ian (36) ? the problem is, in 2 weeks time, we'll be in the bottom 3. I may be wrong but haven't QPR been awful this season, and they did us at Goodison.

Last year we took 4 points off Chelsea, Shite, 6 off City... we won't this year, and we always struggle against West Brom, Bolton, Stoke. You should be very worried.
Fran Mitchell
67 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:14:01
Bredan at #59

Maybe not a footballing lesson, but what did we get today? It was crap, the set-up of the team is just wrong. We have options available, yet they are not being utilised. Our play is predictable. Our substitutions were predictable.

We wont get relegated, but I also won't pay to watch this crap.

People talk about the need to grow our 'brand'. Well, at the moment our brand is on the decline.

I used to think Moyes was a great manager... actually, no, he WAS a great manager. But now he aint.

In any business (and football, is this) a manager get's judged by his previous performance rather than that of his peers. If his own, personal performance drops then he loses his job. Moyes's performance levels in his job have fallen, it needs to be addressed. He either needs to adapt, or go.
Denver Daniels
68 Posted 15/10/2011 at 21:51:17
Agree with most of the above comments.

2-0 down at half-time and no subs at the break did it for me. The icing on the cake was bringing Neville on at 3-0 down... I almost fell out of my chair with laughter. Attendances will surely drop at both home/away games when you do things like that.

When is this guy ever gonna change? Talk about predictable. I wonder if he pooped his pants when Vellios scored with his first touch. That's what happens when you play actual strikers, Mr Moyes... they score!!

His insistence on playing the same players week-in, week-out beggars belief. He will argue that we are skint, and we are, but he still has a (small) squad of players he can use. Not just the same 12/13 for every single game.

I wonder if any of the likes of Howard, Jags, Coleman, Cahill or Hibbert are embarrassed every time they start a game knowing they don't deserve to be there, not on current form anyway, yet know they will be picked regardless. I certainly would be. Moyes doesn't help himself in this regard as he picks the team.

The club has stood still and others have gone past us. And Moyes has done the same this season with his dour tactics.

The sad thing is I don't even get excited or nervous watching Everton anymore. It's as if I'm just going thru the motions. Roll on next season!!!
John Daley
69 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:18:11
"Of course Fran #57... & if they had... we would have given Chelsea a footballing lesson?"

We'll never know, will we, Brendan? What we do know is that constantly playing the same struggling players, in the same safety-first system, has proved unsuccessful and provided us with piss-poor football so far this season.

It may make sense sticking with the same line-up if you've hit a rich vein of form and are picking up points, but not if you've hit the wall and have been struggling to even get out of your own fucking half for the majority of games.
Ian Tunstead
70 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:08:09
Sam, maybe we could start with the kids, but maybe we would be turned over and beat 7 or 8 nil, maybe it would destroy the confidence of a 17- and 19-year-old.

Yes, it was quite shameful that we lost to QPR but it was understandable considering we had to play central midfielders on the wings and 3 or 4 of our best players were injured<.br />
Keiran, I thought Rodwell was in his best position, what is his natural position? Does he have one? because I haven't seen him play well anywhere for any sustained period. When was he a stand-out talent exactly? I can only think of his goal against Man Utd which stood him out.
Brendan McLaughlin
71 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:33:28
John Daley #68 ? "proved unsuccesful"... so we haven't finished relatively well up the league in the last 4/5 seasons? Of course if Moyes had started the "also-rans" we'd have been Champions at least twice!
Luke O'Farrell
72 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:37:47
It's disgraceful that we keep relying on our defence, when we can't keep clean sheets to save our lives.

Moyes's defeatist attitude against the 'Sky 4' is killing us.

I'm a fan of what he's done but his new attitude that money is the only thing that matters is a disgrace.
Fran Mitchell
73 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:39:18
Who would you appoint?

For me, it'd be Martin Jol or Gus Poyet.
Brendan McLaughlin
74 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:40:49
Luke # 71
First time Chelsea beat us since the Cup Final.....but don't let facts get in the way of you sniping!
Fran Mitchell
75 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:44:23
Brendan.

What about this season?
Brendan McLaughlin
76 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:44:12
Fran #72
You hankering back to the old relegation battles with those choices?
Fran Mitchell
77 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:49:56
Jol:

Finished above Moyes twice with Spurs; criminally underrated, considering vast amounts of money have been spent since and his achievement only bettered once by the lauded Redknapp.

Poyet:

A great player, one who always seemed to have more in his head than most. Also seems to be doing the job at lower a level. A risk, but one I'd take.

If anything, this club needs some 'fresh eyes'.
Marcus Kendall
78 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:53:59
Martin Jol???? Underrated? In who's world? He's OVERrated ? especially by you Fran Mitchell. Finishing 5th with Tottenham's resources, big deal; his CV is underwhelming from what I see.

I agree with Poyet though, or Lambert; those managers would get my interest back but with Moyes at the helm I'm bored to the point that I don't care anymore.
Martin Paice
79 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:53:48
Fucking depressing. It's all very well getting a commendable point via defending well, but losing 3 in a row, and putting on Pip when you're 3 down. WTF?
Paul Ferry
80 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:44:08
Martin Jol? Good grief, no. His voice drives me nuts for one thing, but he is jaundiced and lacking inspiration as Mr Moyes.

Poyet is an interesting one, but he has just signed a new 5-year deal with the Seagulls and will cost. Paul Lambert for me, who however, would also cost... although the spectre of the last boss we poached from Norwich still haunts me.

It won't happen, needless to say, as the greatest crime of all right now is that the incompetence, short-sightedness, and characteristic drudgery of the men in suits and tracksuits at Everton has put us in a quagmire from which we cannot explore other options at this point in time. Their mismanagement from one week to the next means that alternatives can only be the stuff of toffee talk for the time being.

The way that pudgy Bill and his commercial cronies have run this club into the ground and squeezed morale and optimism from us like a drip-feed is a crying shame. But it is at least exciting to talk about replacements for Moyes. It gives us hope that one day in the next decade it will truly happen.
Simon Harris
81 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:39:31
I think we're nearing the point when Bill will invite the players to one of his, 'save our season' pep talks.

Maybe he'll also wonder up some money in January, so Moyes can try and replace Pienaar and Arteta. We're seriously lacking their guile, craft, composure and energy right now.

As that ain't going to happen anytime soon, it's time to dig in and start showing some dogs of war spirit. Gotta start getting some points on the board, and quick.
Fran Mitchell
82 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:58:16
How is he over-rated? I think he is a better option than Moyes at this moment. I don't think he is god, but a decent realistic option. He plays with wingers and 2 strikers.

Look at Spurs' performances after he left. It took them Luka Modric and a whole load of signings to return to that level.

We ain't exactly gonna be attractive to 90% of managers out there, are we?
John Daley
83 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:01:06
Brendan

If you bothered to read the rest of the sentence you'd see I was referring to this season, not the last 4/5 yrs.

As for the ridiculously smug "we'd be Champions, wouldn't we" comment? Hardly, but again we'll never really know will we because all we get to see is the same old faces no matter how desperately the side needs freshening up.
Marcus Kendall
84 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:07:43
He spent a shed load at Tottenham. I'm not sure why you think Tottenham only started spending when Redknapp took over. Also, Tottenham fans thought he was tactically inept and he lost out to Steve McClaren in the Dutch League with superior players at Ajax to what McClaren had at Twente. Now if you're being outdone by McClaren then you're not good enough for Everton.

Also, he did a poor job at Hamburg and he's hardly setting the world alight at Fulham (plus his style of football isn't as great as you suggest it is).

Realistic options:

Gus Poyet
Paul Lambert
Lee Clark

All better options than Jol.
Lol McNally
85 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:30:17
Big Nev in for Chris Woods to show Howard how to catch a fucking ball.
Fran Mitchell
86 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:12:09
At Ajax he lost the title by 1 point; he lost 1 game at home all season, and they scored shedloads of goals.

At Hamburg he got to 2 cup finals in 1 season and finished 5th.

At Spurs most of the players were signed by the director of football.

He consistently plays good, attacking football.
Fran Mitchell
87 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:16:34
*2 semi-finals in 1 season.

Quick Wiki-check corrected me.
Fran Mitchell
88 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:19:14
Anyway.

Point is, Moyes should be done at Everton. But we all know that ain't gonna happen.
Marcus Kendall
89 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:19:27
You seen Fulham play this season? I have, dull

Why did Hamburg sack him then?

And finishing behind a team managed by Steve McClaren even by 1 point is poor

You're free to your view about Jol, I just remember when he was at Tottenham and Spurs fans wanted him out for being tactically inept and spineless.
Brendan McLaughlin
90 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:13:35
John #81
Sorry if I came across as "smug" that ain't me (well it is a bit)... but John ? do you seriously think that we should play "different" players ahead of better players?
Wayne Smyth
91 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:50:15
#9 John hits the nail on the head, for me.

Aside from the Neville substitution, and the fact that players like Vellios and Drenthe can't buy more than a few mins on the pitch, the tactics today were sound.

The goals we gave away were cheap and we looked competitive in the first half. I was more annoyed at our setup at Man City and Blackburn, or at home to QPR & Villa, than I was with what we saw today.

In any case, I agree with many of the posters here; it's time for a change. Reason is that it doesn't matter who we were playing today ? Moyes will always play the same players, tactics and formation.
Derek Thomas
92 Posted 15/10/2011 at 22:43:33
Ian, one of your earlier posts stated, 'There is no shame in being beaten by City Chelsea etc.'

Nor is there if you tried your best, but the way Moyes sets out the team to 'keep it tight' and minimises his ( our ) attacking options.

Saha is past it, The Straq has had 6 weeks to get fit, Vellios is our leading goal scorer with a total of about half a game under his belt. Moyes's secret weapon is still just that.

A stale Manager with stale policies which in turn is leading to a stale team and results.

0.02% of us can't all be wrong.
Andy Peers
93 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:39:25
This dire form is also going to chase away some players come January and I am sure there will be no replacements. Not just because of the money but nobody good will want to come here. Fellaini will be gone and I am sure Baines will too. A good offer for Barkley may be to good to resist so we may lose him also.

It is pretty hard to think of anything positive about Everton these days, especially with Moyes acting like other than some errors at the back we are doing good with his team selections.
Jimmy Sorheim
94 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:18:55
Finally people are waking up. Vellios did great, as did Drenthe, and they have been the only goalscorers if you think back. Only after bringing on both Drenthe and Vellios do we seem to look dangerous up front scoring goals. Not just today but against Wigan also. Certainly I am not the only person seeing that simple fact!

You look at form and you pick the team, how hard is that Moyes? How do you justify not using Drenthe and Vellios from the start when they are the only ones who have scored this season? The argument of Moyes sees them in training simply does NOT fly anymore, as they both have performed where it really matters, on the field.

I am mad about this, but at the same time I can see that Moyes at least tried today with Saha and Cahill upfront. There is something passive about the players, like they are on drugs. I guess loss after loss can do that to you....
John Daley
95 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:45:33
Brendan, the smug accusation was a bit naughty on my part, so I apologise. No offence meant. Actually there was some offence meant at the time but I then felt immediately bad about it. Apologies.

If it makes you feel any better I've just been told off and informed that I sound like a sarcastic, nasty twat on here. I replied that I am a sarcastic, nasty twat and she said "yeah but you don't have to make it so obvious".

Anyway, my opinion is simply that if something isn't working you can't just keep persisting with it ad infinitum. Try something different. Do you really think we would've fared much worse today if we approached the game more aggressively and played, say, Barkley, Drenthe and Vellios instead of Osman, Coleman, and Rodwell? Not Bily though. Never Bily.
Steve Guy
96 Posted 16/10/2011 at 00:11:20
Derek #90 Lucky I didn't copyright "stale" for my mailbag contribution :-o !
Sam Fitzsimmons
97 Posted 15/10/2011 at 23:49:06
Ian, that may well be the reason why Moyes protects the likes of Barkley and Gueye. However, there is an argument that the confidence of genuine young talent is being damaged because they're not getting game time when they see senior players who are out of form getting selected ahead of them.
Brendan McLaughlin
98 Posted 16/10/2011 at 00:06:58
John
I never take offence from people that want the best for our Club..I might disagree but offence..anyway "she" should post more often than you....obbviously much more diplomatic & not so smug? You are a lucky boy John!
Cathal Naughton
99 Posted 16/10/2011 at 00:45:41
Well that was predictable, but I can do the job better, It looks so easy from where I was sitting on the sofa....

? Play Bily in the mythological 'hole'
? Play Vellios up front
? Play Drenthe and Gueye left and right
? Barkley and Fellaini down the middle
? Drop Jags for Heitinga

Well, pretty much what Fran@62 said actually. They will probably get smashed, but I'd enjoy the experience of watching balls out attack attack..... for a change......
Dick Fearon
100 Posted 16/10/2011 at 00:30:41
Why Moyes will never be good enough to lace the boots of SAF:

? Facing defeat at the Bridge, Moyes replaces an attacker with a defender.
? Facing defeat at Anfield, SAF replaces a defender and two midfielders with THREE attackers.

Kunal Desai
101 Posted 16/10/2011 at 01:53:47
Looks like and by the sounds of it I've not missed much, more of the same it is. I've taken a back seat in dedicating my efforts and watching this shite team and manager, but over the last couple of games I think my decisions have been rightly justified. It's all getting simply boring!
Steve Moore
102 Posted 16/10/2011 at 01:52:49
A few good points, but seriously ? do people really think Moyes has become a bad manager overnight? Yes, he is overly defensive; yes, he makes bad subs sometimes; yes, we would all like to see our new young talent getting their chance to shine.

I reckon the problem is we just don't have the players of the quality of Pienaar or Arteta anymore; from what I have seen so far this season, they are hugely missed. Only time will tell if our young lads will turn into class acts like the above mentioned two.

Also for those who think the money issue doesn't matter, cop on ? it is huge! The gap between the haves and have-nots is so evident, and it is only getting bigger... And, by the way, we're the have-nots.

Yes, we are bad at the moment; no, Moyes isn't the worst manager in the world. Yes, we have no money... but we will spend some in January.

Yes, it's annoying being an Everton fan; yes, it's great being an Everton fan.

No, we are not going to win the league... but hopefully we will see some great games, some young lads getting games and playing well, and two strikers. No-one on here has the answers but we live in hope.
Peter Fearon
103 Posted 16/10/2011 at 02:15:30
You have to hand it to David Moyes. Most managers, 3-0 down after 70 minutes might be tempted to bring off a defender and slide in a playmaker or a striker. But no.... He takes off an attacker ? albeit one with a new, exciting defensive role ? and puts on yet another defender!!!

And, having watched Drenthe and Vellios take just 18 seconds to team up and score our only goal in 270 minutes of play, some managers might be tempted to start them both next week. But not our Davey!

Back to the bench, you two ? and don't you expose the defense like that again! I know this was Chelsea away and all that, but a more pathetic impotent, toothless performance I haven't seen... since the last two!

This is why David Moyes stands out among his peers!

Gavin Ramejkis
104 Posted 16/10/2011 at 03:18:13
Steve (#100) ? the trouble with your argument is that the players that finally made inroads after just a few seconds of being on the pitch are already on the payroll yet get cameo appearances. 3-0 down and Moyes puts a defender on ? there's not an excuse in the book for that, no matter how much people think the sun shines out of Moyes's arse.

Are you really sure Everton will spend money in January given our history over the last two years? Even if Moyes was given money, would you honestly trust him to spend it wisely having already admitted he's interested in McFadden as some form of solution to the problem?

Moyes is the most predictable manager in this league, churning out the same dreadful shite week-in, week-out. Other managers are wise to this one-trick pony and he's getting a beating as a result.
Anto Byrne
105 Posted 16/10/2011 at 03:05:05
Lucky win at Blackburn, two late goals against Wigan and a point with Villa. To be honest, 7pts does not tell the story. Lost to City, the Shite, Chelski and QPR. This is going to be a long season of discontent as confidence erodes away.

I would have settled for a 5-0 loss had the team played with some intent, got players forward meaning attack with numbers and defend with numbers. We all want to see them have a go, we do have some quality players if you go thru the squad.

The team is set up to lose even before the ball gets kicked. Fellani can't be arsed, Rowell seems shackled, Coleman... I just don't know. Cahill at 31 seems over the hill; and Saha is not a lone striker. I would even give the job to Don Hutchinson as his comments are spot on.

I can't see us winning any of the next five games playing like this but that will be a new record for Moyes ? eight straight losses, and hopefully he will fuck off.
Thomas Williams
106 Posted 16/10/2011 at 04:49:35
Anybody else fed up with Jagielka's performances? Piss-poor again today, ably supported by Hibbert's achilles heel of going missing on the far post, although Baines did not cover himself in glory on goals 1 & 3, completely static. Virtually everytime someone breaks through the midfield this season, has ended up a goal, it is alarming.

We are not strong enough at the back, which is part of the reason for 3/4 of the midfield providing cover, Time for change is required.

Put Rodwell behind Distin and Heitinga, have Coleman and Baines as attacking wingbacks, a midfield 3 plus 2 strikers. I haven't named names in midfield (except Fellaini) and strikers as they are all much of a muchness, sadly.

Baines has hardly been over the halfway line this season, which is hampering us.

Things must happen in January I feel; get rid of Bily, Jagielka and probably Heitinga will want to go as well, and rebuild for next season.

Luke O'Farrell
107 Posted 16/10/2011 at 05:52:10
#73 Brendan

That performance, on the back of the recent woeful display at Man City is good enough for you then is it?

Moyes has done many good things at this club, but this season he seems to have adopted a defeatist attitude himself.

Before all games against the so-called bigger teams, he has talked about how we are skint and they've all spent money and we'll try and keep it tight.

Regardless of ability, he should instill some belief into the players and send them out there thinking that they can get a result, against the odds.

When Crawley played Man Utd in the cup last season, they had a go; they didn't just turn and accept defeat the way we seem to these days.
Christopher Kelly
108 Posted 16/10/2011 at 06:06:49
I'm not a Herm Edwards fan - Former NFL coach...

But David Moyes should have been at this press conference because clearly he hasn't gotten the message...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMk5sMHj58I


"You don't play just to plaaaay. YOU plaaay to win the gaaame."
Derek Thomas
109 Posted 16/10/2011 at 05:53:53
Steve (#100) ? you essentially say Moyes has not become a bad manager or changed over 3 or 4 years and that the loss of Pienaar and Arteta is a big cause... he though, is still the same... you miss the point. What if he was made to look better than he was, his over defensive mind set mitigated by the form of these players?

We can't bring them back, so maybe he has to go?
Wayne Smyth
110 Posted 16/10/2011 at 10:14:59
Steve (#100), let's assume you're correct and our decline is due to the loss of Pienaar and Arteta. Whose fault is it that the team is so reliant on just two players for its creativity and spark?

Who bought Heitinga and Bily who can't get a game? That's £15M worth of talent sitting on the bench when we would have been much better off getting in natural wide players with pace.

Why have we let good experienced proven Premier League players we paid another £15M for (Yobo and Yakubu) leave the club for a pittance? As far as I'm aware, they weren't causing massive dressing room unrest, yet Moyes decides they are surplus to requirements, rather than patching up any differences.

It's not a good idea to waste £30M worth of talent when you are skint. Either use them or flog them and buy the type of players we need, but you're a stubborn fool to let them languish on the bench or in the reserves till they are worth fuck all.

People laud Moyes for working well on a budget, but for every Cahill or Coleman, there is a self-made screw up like Yobo or Yakubu. I expect Moyes as manager of Everton Football Club, to put the Club, its needs and interested above those of his own. If he has personal issues with players he should work with them in a professional way until he can flog them for a decent fee. But no, those players are castigated by Moyes and other clubs have us by the knackers in negotiations.
Bobby Mallon
112 Posted 16/10/2011 at 10:12:18
I am sick of hearing people say there are no managers out there to take Moyes's place: Sam Allardyce, Mark Hughes, Martin O'Neill... ANYONE to bloody freshen things up.

If moyes would only go for it a bit more we have some fantastic young tallent that just needs to be given its head. Gueye Vellios Stracqualursi, Barkley.

How I would love to see this team played next week:

Howard;
Coleman, Heitinga, Distin, Baines;
Gueye, Barkley, Fellaini, Drenthe;
Stracqualursi, Vellios.

Bench: Mucha, Hibbert, Neville, Cahill, Saha, Osman, Bily

And just go for it.
Jimmy Sorheim
113 Posted 16/10/2011 at 10:19:20
Moyes said last year that he will leave only if the supporters are tired of him. Now is the time to start protesting against him and shout out that you want Moyes out of this club. That is the only way he will leave; he is stubborn so he will have to be forced out by fans' unrest and that is exactly what will happen after we lose again against Man Utd and again against Chelsea in the Carling Cup, plus don't forget we will lose against Fulham also.

Isn't it time you all voice your feelings during games? I think so.... You just cannot be pleased with anything that has happened this season, there is only more shit to come.
John Ford
114 Posted 16/10/2011 at 11:56:49
Freshen things up??? That glow, the initial 'new face' excitement lasts about a month and then you're left just with a manager's ability to put a good campaign together.

What we need is new players. No-one, Moyes included, should be expected to work under the current conditions. Moyes has his problems, including at present his outward persona, but he is the least of ours at the moment.

There is no chance of significant change without new faces coming in. That relies on cash.
Phil Martin
115 Posted 16/10/2011 at 10:43:21
Slaven Bilic... Allardyce... someone pass me my pills.
Joe Clitherow
116 Posted 16/10/2011 at 11:32:28
Jimmy Sorheim ? if you turned up for games where the supporters (i.e, the definition of which being those who actually support the club with hard earned wonga, time and commitment) instead of constantly telling people what to do from Norway (e,g. 'now is the time to shout out....YOU want Moyes out of this club'; 'Isn't it time YOU all voiced YOUR feelings') you may get more traction in your rabble rousing. You may also get a different set of opinions from the fairly predictable TW usual suspects. Thanks for your opinion, we all have one ? I'll give yours what it deserves.

In reality, due to a freak of the fixtures we have played three of the richest teams in the richest league on the trot ? the two richest we played away, and the other one we were criminally cheated by incompetence or whatever just as we looked to be getting on top in the game.

Statistically, individual games could go either way, but the super rich clubs pay £20M+ for individual talents because they can change games in an instant. Mata, for instance is a wonderful player as evidenced yesterday. We do not have those players for those moments, however good we think some of our individual players are ? though actually, compared to the remainder of the teams in the league they are not bad and generally generate results over them over the longer term.

Let's not let facts get in the way of a good rant though eh?
Ian Tunstead
117 Posted 16/10/2011 at 12:07:12
Shock horror, we lost to Chelsea's billions; shock horror we lost to Man City's billions; shock horror a ref decided the game against Liverpool... and Shock horror if we lose to Man Utd ? most teams will over the course of a season.

Finally Man City and Chelsea have managed to beat us at their own ground after about 6 attempts each home and away. They should be the ones who are ashamed for taking so long.

Now is not the time to panic, we have had worse starts to a season having lost to much worse sides and still turned things around. Let's see what happens over the next 6 or 7 games before people start throwing themselves off the nearest cliff.
Wayne Smyth
118 Posted 16/10/2011 at 12:20:32
Joe is right, people shouldn't get too fussed over what happens against the richer teams.

My worry (and it should also be the worry of every Evertonian) is that, when we play the less rich teams, there is absolutely no difference in our tactics and, often, the result.

When we played QPR at home, do you think Neil Warnock prepared his side by drilling into them how much more expensive Everton's side was, or how much more we spent in wages? Do you think he set his side out defensively in a 4-5-1 with a centre back in the midfield?

No, he played a 4-4-2 away from home and came away with 3 pts. Perhaps someone should go tell Neil Warnock where his rightful place is, based on the amount of money he spends on transfers and wages.
Alan Rycroft
119 Posted 16/10/2011 at 12:20:13
Dear All,

Agree with most on the dreadful state of things Evertonian. I haven't seen a game yet all season and finally I saw one on TV and I was utterly embarrassed! Chelski seemed like a bunch of huge collossi who barely had to break a sweat, they huffed and puffed a little once or twice! Yes, a training game for them.

Chelsea are a much stronger team than last year and could win the league, they are tough and skillful and even fast, Sturridge is brillig. What I would give to have him play for Everton!

But maybe too it was the sheer lack of class from the other Blues that made them look quite so good. I am not even sure of replacing the current players would trick it ? who with, pray? Vellios was the only bright spark in a horrid game where most of the time Everton couldn't get the ball!

I am almost run out of patience what is the point of supporting such a shower? Even Coleman looked out of his depth and Ossie surely can't be a whole midfield. Arteta going was a tragedy of epic proportions few even mention as, on his day, a world class player who was often the best player on the pitch in many games. Well, no more... I don't think this guy Drenthe is the mustard but I guess give him a chance ? hey wait, we can't afford him, even if he is any good!

I am effed off with all this football BS ? the same old clubs and faces, that awful Abramovich mafiosi smirking away! What a world. The current state of football like banks and bankers and most politicians turns my stomach inside out. Cumuppence time ? A Nemesis rain down on the whole bloody lot let's have a new world! Foootie just went south, way south on my list of priorities!
Joe Clitherow
120 Posted 16/10/2011 at 12:35:50
Wayne ? I'll agree with that.
Brian Dagnall
121 Posted 16/10/2011 at 12:50:24
I disagree with many of the views. I wonder how we can hope to beat Chelsea with Mata, by playing Hibbert, Neville and Osman against him. These are honest great Evertonians, but I just wish they could play better football. These three and now even Rodwell are quite cowardly in my view because they choose the side or backward pass, rather than play the ball forward. This gives responsibility to Jagielka or Distin and then they get blamed for poor distribution. Their distribution is indeed poor but they have to do so much more than other Premier League defenders. Midfielders have to grab the responsibility for good distribution, so if Jags is rubbish, take the damn ball off him.

Not sure Moyes can be blamed for defensive tactics away to Chelsea, but I share disappointment in his team selection... better men on the bench in my view. I watched Liverpool v Man Utd with loads of Man Utd supporters and the vitriol they had for Ferguson and his team selection for what he himself called the biggest game in the world. Even the most successful manager in the history of the UK game makes mistakes and so does Moyes. Get over it.

The BIGGEST problem with Everton for me is that a few players are playing well below par. Personally, I include Howard, Rodwell, Jags, Fellaini and sometimes even Bainesy. For me these are all smashing players who are temporarily struggling. Add to this Hibbert Osman and Neville who just can't play at the level needed and never mind what the manager asks them to do, the team just cannot perform against the top teams. To have a chance against these top teams, we have to play at our best. We simply are not.
David Bridge
122 Posted 16/10/2011 at 13:17:35
I have called for Moyes to be sacked for the past 3 seasons and have mostly been shot down; now, it appears the majority realise this needs to be done.

It is not new for Moyes to be negative with substitutions ? he has done it for years, bringing on a sub between 75-80 mins when we go a goal down. But Neville? It doesn't really matter if we get beat 3-0 or 5-0.

Saha is shit! Disillusioned, unfit, and not scoring ? send him home with his blackberry.

Tactics seem to be hoof a long ball to Coleman and hope for the best whilst forgeting that the defensive set-up doesnt allow Rodwell, Feillani or Cahill to support.

Agreed, Osman is shit it is embarrassing watching him run the ball over the line or being tackled ? nice to see McFadden has a direct replacement.

Ian, get real, will you ? we were shit.
Peter Cummings
123 Posted 16/10/2011 at 13:25:45
Never seen so many comments on a game on this site.

Like v City, all the pre game talk was about our record against both them and Chelsea but, once we came up against their billionaire squads with a team, and all-too-familiar tactics, the result was inevitable.

If anyone thinks Howard is a world class 'keeper then I'll wipe my posterior; yet again, he failed to get to a cross that was clearly his and gave them a two-goal advantage after another defensive blunder cost the first goal.

All three goals were preventable, that's not to say Chelsea were 'lucky'... in fact, for most of the game (that I saw anyway) only Osman had any ambition to shoot. Saha was completely awol, Cahill a lost soul, and the rest, Bainesy apart, lost and gave up possession time and again.

In the end, it was an embarassing 'training excercise' for Chelsea who hardly drew sweat ? a predictable Moyes balls up from start to finish.
Richard Reeves
124 Posted 16/10/2011 at 13:42:49
David Bridge, if only the views on this website and particularly this thread were representative of the majority of matchgoing fans. Like the planned march before the game against Villa, I become slightly optimistic that the tide might finally be turning but sadly most Evertonians have their heads buried.
Ian Tunstead
125 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:07:46
David, the majority of people who post on ToffeeWeb is not the same as the the majority who just read and don't contribute, or the majority who watch at Goodison and at away games.

I know we were shite, so are most teams against the top teams, but we get better results than most teams against the likes of Chelsea and Man City, we are called the bogey team for the like of Man City and Chelsea because they have struggled for years to beat us.

Tactics have little to with it, Chelsea's 11 are better than our 11 man for man, what do you expect? Get real yourself.
Brian Waring
126 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:26:30
Ian (#115) "Let's see what happens over the next 6 or 7 games."

Deja vu there Ian, because that's all what seems to be said at the start of most seasons lately.
Brian Waring
127 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:33:24
Moyes is untouchable:

? When he gets a result against the so-called top teams, he is hailed as the Moysiah;

? When they turn us over, and anyone dare criticise Moyes, they are shot down with the money excuse.
Denis Richardson
128 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:39:17
Joe #114 ? not many fans were expecting us to go to Stamford Bridge and give Chelsea a hiding. I think most people are more afraid of the fact that we play the same 'conservative' tactics regardless of the opposition.

Remember the perfomances against QPR and Blackburn (yes we beat the latter but it was daylight robery, the hammered us). Let see where we are after we've played the same way and lost to the Fulhams and West Broms of this world.

One thing is certian in my view, playing for a point is asking to lose. Luck may be there on and off (see Blackburn game) but, in the end, this won't last.
Ian Tunstead
129 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:38:31
Brian, Moyes is not untouchable. I have citicised Moyes myself post 19, but against sides with far superior players and vastly more resourses, how can we compete? Would you expect us to beat Barcelona as well or Spain if we had the chance to play them? Sometimes you just have to accept the better team won.

It's not quite déjà vu, either, this time around the fixture list has been very unkind, having to play all the big boys in succession.
Robbie Muldoon
130 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:57:06
http://twitter.com/#!/RobbieMuldoon/status/125569748107931648/photo/1
Brian Waring
131 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:47:01
Ian, I accept the better team won, and didn't think we would get anything out of the game to begin with.

The problem for me, is the dour negative tactics from Moyes, that say were not expecting to get anything from the game before a ball is kicked.

Chelsea didn't even get out of first gear first half, the second half was no different, it was like a training match for them. And FFS, needing to get back into the game, and he brings on Neville for Cahill! That showed his negativity up big style, let's not try and get back into the game, but just make sure we keep the score down.

Drenthe has looked decent when he has had a run-out, why not start with him? Vellios has looked decent, why not give him a start? Thing is, I bet it will be the same starting 11 against Fulham, and the same negative tactics.
Andy Peers
132 Posted 16/10/2011 at 14:52:59
Moyes has changed this season. He looks and acts like a defeated man and calmly proclaims that we are not doing that bad. Could it be the revelations Kenwright made via the Blue Union was a nail in Moyes's coffin for enthusiasm? Maybe Moyes was burying his head in the sand with the inept action of the board and now can't ignore it anymore when it came out in the public.

His goal seems to be not to take on so much water in the sinking ship but unfortunately nobody is thinking about plugging the hole.
Tony Christian
133 Posted 16/10/2011 at 15:16:18
Every man and his dog knows that Moyes will persist with the same shite next week against Fulham and even a one-nil win would only be papering over the cracks and disguise the fact we are perhaps the most boring, anti-football, slow paced team on the planet. Five changes required for next week: Neville for Hibbert, Heitinga for Fellaini, Drenthe for Coleman, Vellios for Cahill and young Ross for Rodwell or Osman.
Wayne Smyth
134 Posted 16/10/2011 at 15:08:13
Brian (#119) ? how can you call the players cowards??

You mention the sideways passing, but have you ever looked as to why they do that? Ever compared us to teams that pass it better? Leyton Orient for example?

From what I can tell it's mainly down to a few things:

1) A lack of movement.
2) Safety first attitude, with 10 men behind the ball meaning there is no sustainable out-ball.
3) A lack of confidence.

Item 1) should be coached into the players. 10 years on we still have no real movement so this is obviously something Moyes doesn't see as an issue.

2) is down to Moyes

3) is down to Moyes and his negative, defeatist attitude.

Yesterday on several occasions we broke out from defence with Cahill or whoever, then had to stop and pass backwards because the other 9 outfield players were still gingerly exploring the extremities of the 18-yard box.

We pass sideways and backwards because that is all that is on.... and it is certainly not the players' fault.
Ian Tunstead
135 Posted 16/10/2011 at 16:27:02
Wayne, put Leyton Orient in the prem and see how well they pass it.

It's very simple. Chelsea have better players. The only way to try to get a result is to try to stop them playing by packing the midfield but, with Rodwell and Osman allowing the Chelsea players to casually knock it about, we had no chance. If we go toe to toe with Chelsea all guns blazing, we would be destroyed about 8-2.

I blame Moyes for allowing Rodwell to stay on the pitch and for starting Osman on the left when for years he has done nothing from that postion. But, even if he made those changes, I doubt we would have come away with any kind of result. We would need most of their players to have an off day but if they did they can bring on 3 World Class players in their place.
Wayne Smyth
136 Posted 16/10/2011 at 16:38:01
Ian, did we pass it any better against QPR? Blackburn? No. Its not some issue to do with the technical quality of the players you have, or the resources available to you as a club. It's down to coaching.

Do you think people would be up in arms if we played differently against the "lesser" teams? I certainly wouldn't. I'd be annoyed with a few things, certainly, but I'd not be calling for Moyes' head.

The reason I'm so annoyed is because we're going to get the same stale crap next week and every week after that while Moyes is in charge. If the stale crap was effective and we got 3 pts, I'd be less fussed. That we can't win a game AND we have to watch this trainwreck in slow-motion is just too much.
Ian Tunstead
137 Posted 16/10/2011 at 16:59:42
Wayne, I thought we were the better side against QPR, although not great but they only had 1 real chance in the whole game and scored, add to the fact 4 or 5 of our best players were injured and 17-year-old and 19-year-old central midfielders had to play on the wings, we were never likely to play flowing football. Fair enough, the Blackburn game was shocking but look what they did to Arsenal the next week.

The stale crap that we are watching is keeping us in the top 8 every season and is a result of having a small squad with the same players every season and not being able to bring in new players with real talent to freshen the place up, Drenthe being the exception, but one player will not turn a team around overnight.
John Ford
138 Posted 16/10/2011 at 18:18:36
Andy Peers (#130) ? You could be right, but let's be honest ? could you blame him?
Col Noon
139 Posted 16/10/2011 at 18:05:30
Ian (#35)

"The stale crap that we are watching is keeping us in the top 8 every season."

Don't get used to it; your mate Davey Moyes is a man who has lost his way on a scale of epic proportions. He has quite simply given up, and this negative and morose outlook he has on football is impacting on the team.

Bury your head in the sand all you want and continue to defend what he is trying to achieve but I simply cannot. You seem to overlook the fact he has spent money ? not a lot, granted ? but still has JH & Bily on the bench? Also do you think any other manager in the league would start Osman over Drenthe? Or persist with an ineffective, aging Tim Cahill when he has young, hungry forwards waiting to make an impact?

He's lost whatever he had as a manager and is devoid of any self-confidence in his team. He cannot loose though; the man is bullet-proof. Lose and it's "knife to a gunfight" bollocks. Win (at a top four club???? Not as long as I have got a hole in my ass) and it's the "Moyesiah" crap.

The man give Anichebe a 5- (yes F-I-V-E) -year contract, and he gets slaughtered. He's shite but it's Moyes who 1) Sees him train all week; 2) Thinks he can do a job (mostly on the wing... genius) yet he gets off scott-free. The man has got it wrong too many times, and gets away with it with astonishing regularity. It's not ALL about money!!
Wayne Smyth
140 Posted 16/10/2011 at 18:07:31
Well, I disagree with almost everything you wrote, but Moyes does divide opinion. I think we play people out of position not because of necessity, but because of Moyes's choices and his complete lack of flexibility.

For the QPR game we had Saha available, who could've partnered Beckford in a pacy attack, or vellios perhaps? Instead of that, we choose to play a central defender in a 5-man midfield against a newly promoted team, and we lost.

Moyes constantly shoe-horns players into positions they are not used to; it screws around their confidence, their value, and vastly reduces our teams chances of winning anything.

I can't recall where Rodwell and Barkley played against QPR, but, if you're right, we had 3 players out of 5 in our midfield playing in positions they are not accustomed to. It's no wonder we created bugger all.

As for Blackburn they did do over Arsenal.....with our £11M striker we let go for £1.5M scoring twice if I'm not mistaken. Yak certainly didn't look past it to me when I watched that game.
David Bridge
141 Posted 16/10/2011 at 18:40:35
Ian

I am a match-going blue and can tell you this season the tide is turning. Everyone around me is complaining about Moyes; if we can all see the problem, how come Moyes and Round can't?

I appreciate the 11 Chelsea players are better on paper than our 11 and worth millions more; however, we have one of the potential best midfielders around in Barkley, who has attracted the interest of every top team sat in the stand watching.

We have an ex-Real Madrid winger, Drenthe, who is talented, fast, exciting and eager ? sat on the bench. We have a top goalscorer, Denis, sat on the bench watching Saha stroll around. Gueye can change a game but is sat in the stands.

We expected to lose, accepted... but let's lose fighting to win and entertaining the travelling massess who turned up.
Christopher Kelly
142 Posted 16/10/2011 at 19:12:47
On a deeper level... If you really think about that Neville - Cahill substitution, Moyes wasn't just trying to stop the bleeding yesterday, he was thinking about goal difference come the end of the season when he figures we'll be in a relegation battle...
Ian Tunstead
143 Posted 16/10/2011 at 18:55:06
Col ? "Davey Moyes is a man who has lost his way on a scale of epic proportions."

If loosing to two or three of the best and richest sides in the league shows he has lost his way then you are entitled to your opinion but that is nonsense. Lost to Man City and Chelsea for the first time in years; lost to Liverpool because of a poor ref as usual.

I just can't accept what you say. You can talk about all his mistakes but most of the other managers in the league make far more mistakes and with greater resources.

Wayne, how could playing Rodwell and Barkley out wide not be out of necessity if we had no wide players available for the QPR game? Fair enough, if you mentioned Osman against Chelsea when we had Drenthe on the bench, there are no excuses for that.

Saha was not fit to play against QPR, he is never fit, neither was Arteta or Fellaini but our squad is so small they had to be put on the bench and even forced to play when they were not ready. That's why they were crap when they came on.

David, I'm not suprised everyone is complaining, Evertoninas aren't used to loosing 3 games on the run under Moyes, I heard a stat before the Liverpool game that we hadn't lost 2 games in succession for God knows how many months, but it was quite a while from what i can remember, but it was always likely with the fixture list putting us up against all the top teams one after the other. The thing is Moyes always turns it around and the opinions of the match going fans will change as well.

We are all very pasionate and get very angry when we lose but most rational Evertonians when given time to reflect will not hold it against Moyes for losing against Chelsea.

As for Barkley, the correct word you used was 'potential'. That's all it is; he has done very little, was poor against Blackburn, West Brom and for the England U-21s. I do not begrudge Moyes not thinking Barkley is up to playing against the likes of Man City and Chelsea or the dirty thugs Liverpool. In fact, I think it was wise not to hype him up any further until he signs his contract. The last thing we want is him scoring against Chelsea and then they take him on the cheap in January.
John Ford
144 Posted 16/10/2011 at 19:31:02
Did someone say they were complaining about Moyes six years ago? Staggering! Was that just after we qualified for the Champions League. Revisionism isn't in it.

For a bit of perspective, Villa were completely mullered at City yesterday, totally outplayed, even with two 'name' strikers in their eleven. City also rested Nasri and Silva, their best two midfielders. This is the Villa who were unbeaten until yesterday.
Lol McNally
145 Posted 16/10/2011 at 19:19:12
Wayne (#116) ? spot on. Brentford... Shrewsbury... crap against lower leagues... Taxi for Moyes!!!
David Bridge
146 Posted 16/10/2011 at 19:45:32
John ? I forgot that Moyes really made us proud in Europe... I'm still paying my loan for the game in Athens!

Ian ? If it was just the fact we had lost against City, Chelsea and the RS, I wouldn't be complaining; it's the negative boring tactics Moyes has introduced for years ? the man knows no other way to play. We lost to QPR and should have lost against the worst team in the Premier League (Blackburn) ? have you forgotten they missed two penalties and we only scored a last minute penalty (that wasn't a penalty) scored by a player who couldn't wait to leave the week after! (And remains unreplaced.)

As for the game against the RS, we did not compete; they could have had 6 but for being wasteful.

And if Moyes had no wingers available; it is Moyes's fault; he has been here for years ? it's his team. Signing Anichebe on a long-term deal sums Moyes up quite frankly!
John Ford
147 Posted 16/10/2011 at 19:58:30
David, we certainly didn't set Europe alight but, at the time, we were the only team threatening the Sky four.

Re the loan, you should get a better interest rate now! ;-)

Thing with Anichebe... he really only became shite after signing his new contract! Absolutely no-one disagreed with signing him at the time. Remember the super-sub performances and all the strength and drive he had? Then he turned into a petulant childish buffoon.
David Bridge
148 Posted 16/10/2011 at 20:24:39
We beg to differ then but I feel the huge majority of fans are now turning against Moyes and even more so BK; the odd few supporters they have sticking with them (like you, I suppose) quote the same old rubbish ? Got us into Europe / Challenged the top 4 ? well, imagine our potential if we had people in charge who actually knew what they were doing or who were ambitious and positive.

Thanks for the advice, it's on an interest-free credit card with a huge balance I can't clear, mostly from watching this team, so I feel every right to comment.

I now know you are a joker when you tell me Anichebe only became shite after he signed ? come on, no fan wanted him in the team ? he was roundly booed!
John Ford
149 Posted 16/10/2011 at 20:35:29
Oh yeh, cos there's plenty of teams challenging the money elite, isn't there... especially those with no cash. Moyes has a better Premier League record than any manager outside the money teams. Fact.

That doesn't mean he's necessarily right for the job now but using his past record against him by claiming it would've been better if somehow he was more happy, positive or ambitious is completely self-defeating. You're actually arguing against your own point. No-one got/gets closer to breaking the elite. How wasn't he ambitious! It's laughable.

How easily people forget, or should I say they just don't bother thinking about our recent history.
John Ford
151 Posted 16/10/2011 at 20:46:58
Ian T

I actually think he's less likely to turn things around this season, more than any other. This is our weakest squad since he's been in charge.

Two reasons. We've failed to replace very good players; and key players are either finished (Saha, Cahill) or out of form (Jags, Osman, Baines).

The only saving grace is that it may force Kenwright's hand. The other concern is that Celtic are likely to get rid of Lennon soon. Exit Moyes.
Richard Reeves
152 Posted 16/10/2011 at 20:14:37
Ian Tunstead, just to clear things up, people have had enough of Moyes because of the overly cautious tactics and wrong team selections he goes with into most games ? not just the so-called big four... or five... or six, as it might be now.
David Bridge
153 Posted 16/10/2011 at 20:48:46
Granted he got us into Europe by playing shit negative football scraping odd-goal wins. As a spectator, it wasn't very good football to watch but it worked and I celebrated. But.... when he got us to Europe we were shit; when we got to an FA Cup Final we were shit ? you don't get prizes for being almost good in this game.

Moyes needs excuses of injuries / no money and players in wrong positions as an excuse for being a poor manager.
Ray Robinson
154 Posted 16/10/2011 at 21:20:17
If Moyes had been in charge of Blackpool last year, they wouldn't have been relegated. However, if he'd been in charge of United, they wouldn't have won the League.

There was a time when Moyes was exactly what we needed, it now depends on your philosophy whether you think he's still right for Everton.

If you merely aspire to stay up each season, then yep, he's probably as good as any manager. If you want expansive football, taking a few risks here and there, he has outlived his role. Which do you want?
Chris Butler
155 Posted 16/10/2011 at 21:25:54
I've have to say what worries me is the fact that we didn't look like we could keep a clean sheet. Defensive tactics are what made Italian teams great but they all had great strikers; we don't.

Moyes has got rid of Beckford and Yakubu without any replacement. Tim Cahill has prevented us from playing attacking football for years. Saha is useless he has no pace and doesn't seem to have any ambition of actually trying to score.

We are a club without any ambition of acheiving anything but mediocrity I do blame the fans for some of this. BK and DM are destroying the club with their attitudes.
Ray Robinson
156 Posted 16/10/2011 at 21:31:40
No Joleon Lescott, Michael?
Joe McMahon
157 Posted 16/10/2011 at 21:29:45
Michael ? with the exception of Ball, Weir, Jeffers, that's defo a better team than the one Moyes chooses to start every game with. Great isn't it, £3.5 million a year for a manager whose aim is to keep the negative goal difference down.

I think if Our David could have his way the starting 11 would be:
Howard
Hibbert, Weir, Stubbs, Weir
/>Neville, Weir, Weir, Osman
Weir
Cahill
Col Noon
158 Posted 16/10/2011 at 21:40:55
Ian (#141)

"If loosing to two or three of the best and richest sides in the league shows he has lost his way then you are entitled to your opinion but that is nonsense."

I take it you have condemned the QPR game to the realms of not happening then?

Richard (#148) ? Sums it up perfectly for me.

This is not a witch hunt or personal vendetta against Moyes. You constantly throw the "being skint" factor in there but there are far more underlining issues that need to be addressed in regards to Moyes.

Some of his tactics, team selections and footballing philosophy applied in not only this season but previous seasons cannot be soley down to lack of resources. What are your feelings on Anichebe getting the bumper contract, I am curious to know?
John Daley
159 Posted 16/10/2011 at 21:46:40
"If Moyes had been in charge of Blackpool last year, they wouldn't have been relegated."

If Moyes had been in charge of Blackpool the season before, they wouldn't have been promoted in the first place.
Trevor Mackie
160 Posted 16/10/2011 at 22:21:49
John Daley

Masterful.
Dick Fearon
161 Posted 16/10/2011 at 23:06:39
Steve (#100), it is true we do not have the same calibre players as Arteta and Pienaar yet, when we picked them up in the bargain basement, what calibre were they then?

In any case, prior to their transfers out, both had dropped off in performance. Arteta had not delivered a decent through ball for ages while Pienaar's reputation was built on Baines's attacking flair.
Andrew Laird
162 Posted 16/10/2011 at 23:17:00
Chris has changed his tune. The light hits you a bit later in time eh? What nonsense were you on about Cahill in a different thread?!!!
Andrew Laird
163 Posted 16/10/2011 at 23:26:20
Moyes is over-rated. So is having confidence and not shitting yourself at EVERY opportunity. Make no mistake, the manager is as arrogant as Bill. Cahill, as poor as he was, for Neville, should be a sackable offence.
Steve Moore
164 Posted 17/10/2011 at 04:51:44
Dick ? agreed. I would just like to see the potential given a chance, if they don't work out, so be it... but give them a go. I think there is one thing we can all agree on and that is Ossie should never play on the left wing again.

The Moyes question is different, there will never be agreement, it's like being married for 10 years and knowing what you're getting every week. Most days, we would all like to be getting something else, but we either won't admit it or we are happy with our lot. And then again, sometimes what the hell, take the risk.

So that's the real question because getting rid of Moyes is a huge risk; without him, we could be another Leeds or Sheffield Wednesday. Just like catching an STD really.
Ian Tunstead
165 Posted 17/10/2011 at 11:45:58
Col, I think the reason behind Moyes signing Anichebe was so he couldn't walk away on a free and perhaps Moyes could sell him on for a couple of million like Vaughan.

We are also short of strikers so we had to keep him out of desperation. To be fair to him, he did look fantastic in Europe and was out for a long time after the Nolan tackle. Perhaps Moyes was hoping for a return of the form he showed in Europe or some European team would be fooled into splashing £10M on him.
Ian Tunstead
166 Posted 17/10/2011 at 12:00:18
John, I know what you're saying, it is worrying when you lose two of your best and creative players on top of a bad run of results but we have had a worse team and finished 4th.

David, these negative tactics have kept us in the top 8 for years, and are part of the reason Man City and Chelsea haven't beaten us for years as well. The main reason that has changed recently is because we have lost players like Arteta and Pienaar and have no money to replace them. How is that Moyes's fault if they wanted to leave for money or for Champions League football and if we haven't got the money to bring in replacements?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads