Mason and Potters pull off a mugging

, 4 December, 202comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 0 - 1 Stoke City
The teams walked out to the sombre tones of the Welsh National Anthem before they gathered around the centre-circle and they were joined by a group of his former teammates from that era, along with Gary Speed's father Roger as a minutes's applause rang around Goodison Park.

And for the game, there is no Louis Saha so David Moyes has given Apostolos Vellios a rare opportunity to lead the line, with Drenthe still out injured.

There was plenty of good midfield possession for Everton in the first 10 mins but it didn't really lead to anything of note. Osman played in Bily nicely on the left and the cross looked good but ran through. A better move saw Coleman cross in well from the right and from a flick Bily had a very good chance at the far post but lashed at it horribly with his first-time volley.

A mistake by Baines was rescued by an excellent defensive header from Heitinga that led to Stoke's first corner. It was defended out to Whitehead, unmarked, whose fiirst-time shot was clipped past Howard at close range by Huth to give the vistors an undeserved lead.

Osman went down very easlily (okay, he divided) to win a very dangerous free-kick that that Baines took that deflected off the wall for an Everton corner that saw Sorensen flail at a punch but miss completely; however, there was no Blue shirts near enough to capitalise.

Everton continued to play their calm and patient build-up play in midfield, Osman and Fellaini catching the eye with some great balls, but Bily was letting the effort down sometimes with poor control and poor crossing.

Another Stoke corner out of nothing and so close to another Stoke goal, the flick-on header evading three well-placed Stoke strikers... something of a let-off for the Blues, whose initial confidence was visibly waning as Stoke looked more and more comfortable with their lead.

Osman threw in a pretty mean corner that Sorensen elected to punch away, which led to more laboured build-up and the hopeful cross clipped-in that had so far proved ineffective as the primary mode of Everton attack against a massed and bulky Stoke defence that was keeping its shape well.

A comedy moment with the diminutive Osman taking on the lanky Crouch in the corner and losing out to an unfair foul called by referee Mason that led to a dangerous moment for Howard, the ball flying past the angle. Baines delivered a really poor corner as the break loomed, and Fellaini looked to get on another corner but Shawcross had his arm around him, and was rewarded for his illegal play with a free-kick form Mason, much to the Belgian's very valid annoyance.

The pattern continued into the second half, with no changes to personnel or gameplan from David Moyes. It was increasingly obvious that Everton were going to struggle to make any impression on the big men in the Stoke defence but it took until the hour-mark of course before Moyes finally made a change, Bily off and Rodwell on.

A short corner and good cross found Cahill falling backwards and away from goal. Then another strange event, Cahil alert, trying to steal in on a shielded non-backpass and colliding with Sorensen, who collapsed in a heap while the Gwladys Street screamed for a penalty but all Mason gavee was a throw-in. Soensen required plenty of treatment and was roundly booed by the Blues crowd.

Everton were getting increasingly ragged as the quality of the football degenerated, one scrappy goalmouth incident with a poor touch from Osman came to nothing as Sorensen collapsed again, and finally went off, to a crescendo of boos form the rather mean-spirited Evertonians who had presumably decided it was all an act! On came Begovic with Stoke defenders continuing to foul Fellaini and others with impugnity.

Vellios was replaced by Stracqualursi for the last 15 mins, Moyes leaving Cahill on, convinced that a conventional 4-4-2 against the Stoke bullies was not going to work... Cahill's niggle factor may well be of value for the remaining period of this war of attrition.

Rodwell got the first half-decent shot of the game on target but it was inevitably blocked by the massed defenders as Moyes made the final change: Gueye on for Hibbert for the final 10 mins or so, and an Everton onslaught on the books.

A superb cross from Baines just evaded Heitinga who looked like he also was being impeded as Stoke started their time-wasting antics, compensated somewhat perhaps by 7 minutes of added time. But by this point, Everton had tried everything in the rather limited Moyes Playbook of Attacking Football.

The game again underlined Everton's paucity in the final third, although that was not helped by another dreadful decision from Mason, wrongly giving a corner when Coleman was clearly fouled. But Everton had failed to really test either of the Stoke goalies and their lack of bite up front was cruelly exposed in another horrible game for Blues fans.

Everton: Howard; Hibbert, Heitinga, Jagielka, Baines; Coleman, Fellaini, Osman, Bilyaletdinov; Cahill; Vellios.
Subs: Mucha, Neville, Rodwell, Distin, Stracqualursi, Gueye, Barkley.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (202)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kunal Desai
1 Posted 04/12/2011 at 14:10:30
Vellios starts, no Saha otherwise as you were against Bolton.
Marc Sansum
2 Posted 04/12/2011 at 14:26:12
Vellios Starts
Neville, Rodders and Distin on the bench.
Tom Bowers
3 Posted 04/12/2011 at 15:46:48
Okay we all expect Osman to be selected even if he has a broken leg but why is Cahill still in?
This is totally beyond me unless it is to ececute the only desperate ploy that Moyes knows and that is keep banging it in the air and hope that Cahill will finally score before the year is out even though he is not performing. Against Stoke's big defence we should keep the ball on the ground. Negativity get's you beaten!!!
Phillip Greenhow
4 Posted 04/12/2011 at 15:59:14
It is extremely difficult being an Everton fan ? thankless too!!
Roman Sidey
5 Posted 04/12/2011 at 16:04:34
Regardless of how this game finishes (currently 0-1), the play that Everton are showing suggests that Moyes and his team are very poor coaches. Every pass just looks laboured.
Phillip Greenhow
6 Posted 04/12/2011 at 16:15:07
I bet it's 84 mins before Moyes makes a change! Neville on for Cahill....
Phillip Greenhow
7 Posted 04/12/2011 at 16:21:22
I stand corrected! ... Only 60-odd minutes of watching this shite before he cottons on its not working and that Bily is a bag of shit!
Jimmy Stenn
8 Posted 04/12/2011 at 16:28:14
Really starting to lose my faith in Moyes these days.
Phillip Greenhow
9 Posted 04/12/2011 at 16:29:50
Now take off Cahill and Osman and bring on Barkley and Gueye.... go on... you know you want to.
Phillip Greenhow
10 Posted 04/12/2011 at 17:00:08
One word sums it all up... pathetic.
Wayne McNee
11 Posted 04/12/2011 at 16:48:05
Cahill, Osman, Hibbert shouldn't be starting anywhere these days in the Premier League. Loved Timmy but he's not up to it anymore. He's been an excellent pro & athlete for years but he should bow out with pride, although who is he to argue with DM's genius team selection. Neville on the bench even is a waste of seating when youngsters (our future) could be lapping up this experience. When the fortunes are favourable then these sort of players can hide but no more.

I took my daughter to see BK's Wizard of Oz last night... Better players, production & seating... Although DM would probably stick with Michael Crawford up front! "Ooooh Davey, you've just done a whoopsy on the team sheet!"
Roman Sidey
12 Posted 04/12/2011 at 16:57:52
What are you talking about, Jimmy? This performance has won me over and I now see that Moyes is world class as a manager. The way he set the side up and got the them motivated for this MASSIVE game against MASSIVE opposition was amazing. I wish that last contract he signed was for 20 years instead of five. Gee, we're so lucky to have such a great manager at Everton. We should be counting our blessings he hasn't taken one of the big jobs that gets thrown at him every other week!
Paul Ferry
13 Posted 04/12/2011 at 17:32:48
I don't Adam and Eve it: '1722: Everton manager David Moyes after the home defeat to Stoke: "We needed more creativity up front and some intelligence to finish the job."


It's just gone too far now. He has lost it. He has to go. It's his fucking job to make sure that we have the best possibility of having 'creativity up front'.

Rodwell for Bily was a disgrace; an abject impoverished imaginative streak from shithead, cave-in, track back Moyes. No width Moyes plus one up-front plus Cahill plus track back Drenthe equals pure fucking lack of creativity.

It is a fucking disgrace that you do not accept responsibility for that dire shit. You have decent players, Moyes, but you are not the manager to get anything from them. Please go Moyes. Go to Scotland, Spurs, Real Betis, anywhere... just fucking go, you responsibility-dodging self-righteous piece of ginger crap.
Ian McDowell
14 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:14:13
After 10 years we have that as our attacking options. Its really time to consider a change.
Dave Lynch
15 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:15:42
Take it you're not impressed by the prefomance then, Paul?
Sam Hoare
16 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:13:27
Paul...who was he meant to play?! Who is this saviour that he left out?

Don't say Barkley, a 17 year old kid with not even double figures games for us.

Moyes's tactics were not right today but the real problem has been a lack of investment in attacking players and in fact selling the likes of Beckford, Yak, Pienaar and Arteta. Whether these decisions were down to Moyes or not is debatable.

We miss Drenthe. I assume he is injured. His pace and flair is a ray of sunshine in an otherwise very predictable team when attacking.
Mick Davies
17 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:13:21
Wayne McNee, you've stolen my words exactly!! Thank God someone else can see how bad Hibbert and Osman are and how Cahill has burned himself out over the last 7 years of relentless club and international football and all that travelling without a summer break. What the other two have to excuse their shit play is beyond me. Just heard the odds on Tamworth to win the cup 5000/1. that's worth a fiver, especially with the easy draw they got
Ian Edwards
18 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:18:28
I think the title is wrong. We werent robbed by the ref. We werent mugged. We were just poor. Very very poor.

Poor team selection. wrong substitutions, poor tactics, no changes at half time.

If we had a Manager with any decency he would resign.
James Stewart
19 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:18:48
No Barkley or Drenthe and no points. Simple as that. We have no other players who can make a goal regularly.

I said at the start of the season Yakubu will outscore any of our players and that we would struggle to stay up under Moyes. Don't see any of that changing.
Phil Rodgers
20 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:19:43
Absolute garbage. Truly awful from start to finish. We are a sinking ship.
Alex Mullan
21 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:18:06
We can't even beat Stoke at home after their mid-week Europa game against tough opposition.

Today Stoke were like the Everton of a few years back. In Europe. Grinding a 0-1 with hard work and commitment. We were just a shadow. The only game our lads had midweek to tire them out was on their PS3's and they still looked utterly devoid of enthusiasm or energy.

No hiding behind referee decisions or injuries this time, we were just terrible. No real chanes to score. No ambition to get forward. A dire team with a sad, increasingly bewildering manager who has most definately not only taken this club as far as he can, but is beginning to drag it backwards.

Moyes, just go, your tactics and teams and now useless, the football is pathetically miserable and the entire place needs sorted from top to bottom, starting with the JOKE who runs us, right down to the manager who is sitting pretty on his 60k a week.

The management and board are PARASITES and NEED to go NOW. Its been at least 3 years too long for you all.
Lol McNally
22 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:13:01
Paul 13 yes, and take Chris Woods and Steve Round...

Time is up on Moyes, 4-5-1 at home, time for a change.
Thomas Williams
23 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:17:22
Yet again, the first shot on our goal goes in that's 5 times in 9 home games.

Yet again, we get no breaks whatsoever in the opponents' box, around 25 crosses into their box and it never fell to our player once.

Yet again, shafted by a referee ? this is getting beyond a joke; how Fellaini kept his cool today I don't know, dragged from pillar to post all over their area and yet no penalty.

People can moan at Moyes but the fact is we are not getting any breaks whatsoever.
Dave Lynch
24 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:21:53
It had fuck all to do with the ref.
He gave as many poor decisions for us as he didi for them.
Will people stop glossing over the truth and that is were shit and always will be under this board and menagement.
Alex Mullan
25 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:23:59
Also, the title of this piece is completely misleading. It comes across like we were hard done by. We were fucking SHITE, not mugged! A tired Stoke easily beat us in our own back yard.
Anthony Jones
26 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:21:21
Sam (#16), Moyes froze out Yakubu.

We could have kept him, and should have, and I am not merely reacting to his recent hatful of goals for Blackburn.

In spite of this dropped bollock, Barkely, who you condescendingly label a "kid" is widely regarded as a creative midfielder, the likes of which we do not possess an abundance of. To not give him some game time against a side sitting on a 1-0 at Goodision is beyond a joke.
Sam Higgins
27 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:29:00
Do you think we will beat Tamworth?

I'm not joking.
Ryan Holroyd
28 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:22:48
We were utterly dreadul.

No shots on target in 90 mins.

This is what happens when you spend the square root of fuck all in transfers and let your two creative players go.

I thought Vellios was supposed to be our saviour according to you lot. He is no way near ready to start. Not in the same level as Saha.

I just can't see any manager with ambition coming to club who are utterly skint, who are loosing money left right and centre, and a board who are unwilling/unable to invest.

Horrible times to be an Everton fan.
Paul Ferry
29 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:19:14
All fair points Sam, except that I'm saying that Moyes has to set us up creatively and then take responsibility when he gets it wrong. He never ever does this. I'm reminded of George Bush in 2008: "Have you ever made any mistakes, Mr President, in your two terms?" "I can't think of one, I really can't."

So: Cahill should not have started; Bily should have played behind Vellios; Barkley should have played wide (here I disagree with you Sam); Rodwell should not have replaced Bily; Gueye should have come on for Osman (65th minute).

I'm sorry, it's down to the manager and the manager alone to provide a platform for creativity. He can watch closely as the game unfolds and put his finger(s) on what is going wrong. He doesn't just set us up, he's paid silly money to react as the game develops at the RIGHT time.

Sam, It's not just a lack of investment. We have some decent players who, in the right position and the right sort of encouragement from Dour Dave, would give us a creative edge. So, please stop blaming investment and lack of.

We are what we are at this point in time, and there are coaches who would get something better out of the squad we have. And I do heap more blame on Kenwright than the ginger one, but not at the expense of evaluating Moyessiah by what he does with what we have.

You're right Sam, Drenthe has the potential to be a breath of fresh air. We all want the same thing. We all want a team and manager who this year and next (not in the past, I mean now, stop fucking saying all of you that we once finished 4th under Moyes) deserve to wear the shirt and give us something to be proud of. This will not happen so long as Moyes is ruling the roost.
Ray Robinson
30 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:29:22
Lee Mason has to be one ofthe worst refs I've seen but this wasn't the reason we lost today.

Why on Earth was Vellios taken off and replaced by Straq? Losing 1-0 at the time, why do we take off a forward? Sorry, I acknowledge that Moyes has worked wonders at Everton, but he has lost the plot and I've had enough.
Brian Waring
31 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:28:27
Sam (#16) ? "Moyes's tactics were not right today" ? It seems like that is the theme after every game, Sam.
Alex Mullan
32 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:29:44
@ Sam 24

I imagine so. We will go 4-5-1, contain their star midfielders for 75mins and lure them into a false sense of security, then we will strike. 1-0.

Of course this will all be after Moyes has kicked the shite out of our players confidence pre-match, claimed that Tamworth are going to be up for it and then added in a sprinkling of 'Oh, we are so very very poor and need money.'

Fuckin depressing being an Everton fan some days.
Sam Hoare
33 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:34:27
Anthony, Barkley is 17. In football that makes him a kid. Condescension has nothing to do with it. People hoping for him to be our saviour are kidding themselves. Putting that much pressure on him will save nobody. I'm not against giving him game time but he's not the answer...simple as that.

Moyes froze out Yakubu becaue he was useless for us. Moves rejuvenate players. Its not rocket science.
Michael Kenrick
34 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:27:12
What? Not negative enough???

Come on... we played some nice football in the middle of the park, we used the flanks, we got a number of crosses in... some good; many not.

But we play as if the manager and coaching team have one basic plan of attack: Get down the flank and swing the ball over. Then it's hope for the best. The crosses are rarely aimed at anyone, there is little coordination in terms of attacking the ball, and if it's against a massed forest of ugly brutish giants who know how to cheat, we just don't stand a chance.

Can't help wondering how much this 'effort' was helped by those cautious...? no... pessimistic..?? no... downright criminally negative pre-match pronouncements from our wonderful manager. "... putting on make-up." No doubt his supporters will point out how right he was...
Nick Armitage
35 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:31:26
Don't worry, Victor Anichebe will be back soon.
Andrew Presly
36 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:28:02
Don't understand what our Plan A is this season. Baines can obviously whip a good cross in but most of the time we're floating balls in 30 / 40 yards from the byline, hoping that Vellios / Saha / Felli will knock it down for Cahill or another on the non-existent runners coming from midfield.

Cloggers like Stoke can defend that pretty easily. We did the same vs Wolves and were lucky to get a late pen but I'm struggling to work out how Moyes thinks this is the most effective way to go with the players we have. This isn't about money, its about philosophy and a willingness to change this that aren't working. Moyes continues to rely on hit-and-hope / percentages football and not only is it soul destroying to watch, its not working! Next week will no doubt be another Man City-esque backs to the wall game, can't wait!
Tom Bowers
37 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:33:30
As usual, the predictable performance and result... but let's not kid ourselves: we are poor and although we always start off well, we deteriorate and after conceding first it's always the same.
Moyes and his rigid stubborness with team selection gifted it to Pulis and the Potters from the off.

We cannot possibly expect anything more than what we get as long as Moyes is here. Is not 10 years enough to change things? Do we have to suffer more years of watching the same players who have failed the fans over the last 4 or 5 years.

If Distin, Neville and Rodwell were fit then why were they not started? They are certainly better than the likes of Hibbert, Osman, Bily, Heitinga and Cahill. Timmie has been our saviour in many games but his time has come. Does Kenright not see this or has senility set in already?

Even if we had scored an equaliser late on, it would have meant nothing but another 2 home points dropped and now the Gunners coming up. Maybe a players strike is the only thing to save us from another miserable season.
Kunal Desai
38 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:40:52
The ref had a poor game, but he can't be blamed for a team who couldn't even muster a shot on target or force their goal keeper to make any noteworthy save. We're not going to be given pens every week.
Karl Meighan
39 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:38:33
A game where neither keeper had a shot to save sums that shite up.

Stoke have been twatted after every Europa League game but manage to beat us?

Stoke should have been 3-0 up at half time from 3 corners where every Everton player was back defending. If Moyes had left 2 upfield, the player who had the shot would probably have been on the half-way line. Newcastle left 4 up from corners to keep Stoke players out the box... I guess Moyes didn't see that game.

What did Vellios do wrong? The service was a joke and I'm getting sick and tired of a manager who has no idea how to break down a poor Stoke team. Barkley must be pulling his hair out that not average but poor players like Coleman, Bily and Osman get in the side before him ? in fact he would probably offer more than sideways Jack and elegant Felliani... what a joke that is.

Don't be surprised if the dickhead plays Heitinga midfield and brings Distin back for the Arsenal game, the negative twat.
Adam Baig
40 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:44:21
What a woeful game, with 2 teams playing the same shitty defend-as-a-team awful boring shite. This whole 11 in the area for a corner really needs addressing by the coaching staff - for their goal, we didnt have anyone further than 12 yards out ffs! And then when the ball got cleared to the edge of the area, no-one moved!!

I cant believe Moyes and Round havent had the decency to walk.
Jimmy Sørheim
41 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:36:16
I am just asking when will Everton fans had enough of this Moyes defensive crap?
It is a miracle, as he seems to escape criticism no matter how poor we are, or what players are picked. Have you not seen enough of this? I really wonder, because inside the stadium the fans whine about the players, but NEVER Moyes himself. I think it is high time that our fans start a protest against Moyes.
I for one have had enough of him, only because of his piss poor decisions in handing out Yakubu and selling our most creative midfielder because he wanted to protect Artetas feelings rather than the best for the team. Selling Yak and Arteta has killed us, and the re-signing of Anichebe just goes to show that Moyes has lost whatever ability he had when he first came here.
Kevin Elliott
42 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:38:25
Idon't think it really mattery who Moyes plays vin what position.The fact is that he has lost it. He has lost his motivation, both for himself and those around him .In any other job ,he would have been sacked.Be honest ,do you really trust him to pull us out of the shit?.I don't.And i find it increaasingly hard to support. the team that i hold so dear while he is in charge.Ifeel like i am supporting the whole regime while doing so.A boycott on a massive scale is the only way to get rid of him.or(dare i say it)face relegation .We can't get rid of billy bullshit too easily ,but we can rid ourselves of dithering Dave.Let's do it.
Ian Edwards
43 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:54:36
Hibbert, Osman, heitinga, Bily and cahill should all be dropped.

team next week should be:

Howard

Neville, Jagielka Distin Baines

Coleman, Barkley, fellaini Drenthe (if fit)

Vellios Saha (if fit- if not Gueye)
Paul Ferry
44 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:53:49
Karl #38 - 'Barkley must be pulling his hair out that not average but poor players like Coleman, Billy and Osman get in the side before him; in fact he would probably offer more than sideways Jack and elegant Fellaini ? what a joke that is'.

Do not put Fellaini in this company. Did you watch the game today. Fella bossed the midfield and looked a class act, and, along with Johnny today, was the best thing on the pitch, except for Gary Speed's dignified and grieving father...

And, for that matter, do not put Coleman and Bily in the same sentence as Osman: it's not Bily's fault that the ginger twat plays him out of position whenever he picks him; and Coleman is starting to remind me of the best little Spaniard we once knew, a very good attack-minded and creative player who is not allowed to play to his full creative potential under defender Moyes.

Rodwell was not 100% fit today, needless to say, but I agree with you, you can count his good games this season on a single finger: and that, by the way, was when he paired up with Fella (your absolutely inappropriate target).
Sam Hoare
45 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:52:06
Paul Ferry.

Fair enough.

I don't blame lack of investment but i do think you can't ignore it as a factor.

I agree with you that Moyes does not necessarily set us up to play creatively. He adopts a structural, everyone stay in position approach that limits us when it comes to breaking down teams. Particularly when they park the bus, so to speak. He is conservative and not prone to risk.

To be fair this is the same approach that has reaped reward for us in the past. But a good manager should be flexible.

Cahill aside i'm not sure my starting lineup would have been that different given the paucity of options. And i still believe that side, set up as it was could have won on another day. Stoke got the first goal and then defended very well against our limited attack. But then you look to the bench and think who is going to change this for us...a just back to training Rodwell? An on loan unheard of striker? A 17 year old kid with a handful of games? A weapon so secret that he started just one premier game? For me its debatable wether we need a new manager, i could be swayed either way (depending upon who the replacement was). Its not debatable that we need to freshen up this squad with some new attacking players. Goodison reeks of staleness...and it not just the lavvies.
Ray Said
46 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:59:29
The great Brasilian Socrates,died this week.

When Brasil were knocked out of the World Cup in 1986 he said these words; 'Titles are ephemeral. What matters in football is the passion, regardless of conquests.'

We have plenty of passion in the stands but where is our passion on the field and in the dugout?

Anthony Jones
47 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:55:37
Nice one Sam, but...

I didn't say Barkely was a saviour. You did label him a kid though to strengthen your already weak argument. I, along with many others would like to see him given a few chances to impress at least. How many chances has the not so impressive Bilyaletdinov had?

PS. Yakubu scores goals when supported by other players, such as strike partners, as he did for us on many occasions. Now that's not rocket science but your mate Moyes doesn't seem to get it either.

Ray Robinson
48 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:54:33
Karl, if Saha is unfit next weekend, I predict that Cahill will be upfront in a 4-5-1 format (aka 4-6-0) because Tim isn't mobile enough to play up front on his own. Distin will be back and Heitinga in midfield and we'll go for a 0-0, hoping to snatch it 1-0.

People will say, well, we can't do much else with the personnel that we've got - but who has allowed the situation to develop as it has? The manager. It's been the same for years - not enough attacking options, no flair, pace, movement and creativity in the team. Enforced transfers out of the club only do not fully explain the predicament.
Gerard Carroll
49 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:52:05
Well played Stoke City RUFC. They came and did what they had to do and we had no answer to it, we were well beaten. I know it was only 1-0 but sadly I could not see us even scoring.

Fellaini played the ball well, but at set peices he was well suckered! We know he has a bit of temper and the Stoke boys worked it to him. I'm sure it was part of their tactics and the ref give them a bit of a hand... I'm sorry to say but we deserved zilch!
Paul Ferry
50 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:04:32
It's a pleasure to chat with you Sam, a pleasure to read cogent and clearly expressed comments and there's so little in #45 to disagree with. We ain't that far apart mate! COYB
Sam Hoare
51 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:02:30
People talking about Moyes resigning are being ridiculous!!

We're 10th FFS!! With a game in hand. Its not great but its not like we are knee deep in crap. The footballs pretty turgid and we are all dissappointed with today but get a grip.

How many managers have ever resigned when midtable having been given no transfer funds for 3 years!!
Sam Hoare
53 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:07:53
Anthony, did Yakubu score goals in his last season at middlesborough when they played 442?

No. He didn't.

He starts well at new clubs and then fades. If he scores 15 goals next season, feel free to correct me.

I labelled Barkley a 'kid' because he is 17. Not unreasonable i don;t think. I too would like to see him get chances.
Phil Hamer
54 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:38:07
I don't know what you guys are expecting.

Sometimes it pays to step back and look at the bigger picture. In 2009 we had a VERY good squad. We were all hoping to kick on, add to the team and go for champions league...

David Moyes did not then think "I know, I'll slowly sell off the team (Lescott, Pienaar, Arteta and Yakubu) and replace them with a couple of loan signings, a £60,000 irish kid, a £50,000 greek kid and Jonny Heitinga.

This gutting of the team is just like in the mid nineties when a promising squad containing Speed, Ferguson, Kanchelskis, Hinchcliffe and Barmby destroyed Southampton 7-1, only to be steadily gutted out by a combination of desperate money grabbing board and bad injuries. Before long the list above had been replaced by the likes of Claus Thomsen, Terry Phelan, Mitch Ward, John O'Kane and Gareth Farrelly and we were fighting relegation.

This is what Everton Boards do, they hock us up to the eyeballs in debt then they rip the soul out of any good team we have just to stay afloat. David Moyes has not chosen this path. It has been chosen for him by the pathetic, amaterish and downright devious leadership of William Kenwright CBE.
Jack Wilkinson
55 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:55:08
Blaming the ref for this loss is weak. Granted he was despicable and we should have had at least two penalties, but we should never rely on getting a penalty to help us win a home match against (theoretically) a worse side after they played a game in mid week!

Bily should not be playing on the left. I thought people were over the top with their praise of him last week - he did OK at best. He is one of the most awkward footballers to watch and I think he isn't close to PL standard at the moment. That being said, if he is consistently being played out of position who can really complain but him? Meanwhile, Cahill is rewarded with starting berths in Bily's best position every week despite him going through his dryest period in front of goal to date. Love Tim, but he can not be starting at the moment. As with Osman, he's past his best and Moyes needs to stop his love affair with the two.

While Drenthe is injured I'd consider playing Baines LM and allow a youngster to try the LB position. He is undoubtedly our most dangerous player, which is pitiful really considering he's a left back. Him, Fellaini and Heitinga I thought had relatively good games today. I was genuinely impressed with Heitinga's pasing. Perhaps he could act as an anchor in CDM, allowing 3-4 midfielders to genuinely support our lack of strikers? I don't mind playing one striker up front if he has wingers to support him, but not if there are clueless wide players giving him minimal service.

This being said, I don't believe Moyes will make any real changes until Kenwright & Co. tell him he is under real pressure. Kenwright would rather get down on his knees for Moyes than tell him the truth. I'm more patient than most, and actually still have faith in Moyes, but that faith is quickly diminishing.

Would love to see Donovan back on loan, think that would make a real change. Perhaps another striker on loan? Defoe? Pavyluchenko?
Karl Meighan
56 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:04:23
Paul@44 Felliani couldn't strike a match never mind a football, i expect central midfielders to burst forward from 30-40 yards out play a killer pass or get a good strike on goal. Now remind me of the last time Felliani done either of those things?

That turn he does may look good but it creates nothing at all. Felliani is a half decent water carrier midfielder and nothing more if he ever bosses midfield for ten games on the bounce then i will apologise but comparing him to the likes of Parker or any other player worth £15m not for me in a million years.

Felliani dont score many goals doesn't create many and dont stop us conceding many and today he started ok then was more interested in wrestling with the Stoke players as the game wore on.
Paul Olsen
57 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:19:53
#50

Yakubu´s records



Pompey First season, 14 games 7 goals, second 43 games, 19 goals, third 35 games, 17 goals

Fading? Nah

Boro

First season: 55 games, 19 goals, second 45 games, 16 goals, third season 2 games no goals

Fading? Nah

Everton

First season 39 games 21 goals
second season 17 games, 5 goals third season 15 games, 1 goal

Fading? Sure, but somewhere in the middle here he got a horrible injury.

So if Yakubu fades after the first season it only has happened at Everton, under David Moyes.

All previous clubs and the current club are also clubs that have finished below Everton almost every damn season.

Oh and, Blackburn first season 8 games, 9 goals
Paul Olsen
58 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:25:07
Might add his record in Israel only showed that his goalscoring record improved each season.

Can someone please put this myth to bed once and for all?

Yakubu is a class striker, too class for a David Moyes side.
Kevin Corness
59 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:19:06
This was by far the worst performance from Everton this season. and theres been many bad ones.
For me the blame falls totally at moyes's feet. I for one am sick of coming to goodison to see the same old tactics we've played since Round turned up at EFC.
How much moor tribe are we expected to take befor he see's what we see.
Boring boring boring. every match no change of direction at all one striker only on the pitch regardless? Not good enough MOYES. Ive been coming to watch EFC for 30yrs and was thinking of giving it a miss until theres a change in tactics. But then i thought NO its my Team and i've been here longer than you and Mr Round so I think it should be you who should give it a miss.
Paul Olsen
60 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:26:57
Instead we´re stuck with stuck with a ageing striker with a worse injury record than Woodgate and David Hirst combined. Someone who can be relied on to play no more than 10 games pr season and has scored once every blue moon for the last couple of years. He will be paired with an icon that has burned himself out completely by trying to play every damn friendly for his country on the other side of the globe. A man who has clearly lost his mojo, hopefully not for good. Good times.

Everyone with half a mind could see that Yakubu was slowly finding his old self in his last couple of games last autumn, before getting axed. Apparently it is now Blackburn´s gain.

Steve Barr
61 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:28:16
We were not mugged. We lost because we were poor. We didn't create chances and were inept all over the field. Lost in in the middle, poor deliveries, poor finishing when we did get a sniff and poor defending when it mattered, as usual.

None of them looked interested. I couldn't believe what I was watching, surely this type of performance and poor attitude is the manifestation of a club in freefall.

Let's hope the cup tie against Tamworth is not televised. We'll be the laughing stock.
Chris Sillett
62 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:20:38
Its time for Moyes to leave at the end of this season. The man has given up and his negativity and stubborness has now infected the whole team.

Moyes' tactics and substitutions have stunk Goodison out all season and are gradually getting worse. After 10 years of doing a good job he should leave the club while the fans still have some respect for him.

Who would be my replacement? Mark Hughes or Nigel Adkins from Southampton.

Gavin Ramejkis
63 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:27:55
Another Gollium special today, a miserable affair from start to finish, hoofball and midgets versus a tall alehouse side, Bily like playing with ten men but stays on way beyond his sell by date, Velios in a Gollum special replaced like for like for a shite striker Leicester turned down, predictable hoof, huff and puff against a piss poor Stoke with a predictable defeat.

Mason was shite today but he didnt give Stoke their goal o a plate for them or make inane substitutions or provide such another anti football display all too common these days.

Moyes really is the Grinch that stole football from Goodison Park. The final rub of salt is that shite text from Everton saying thanks for coming today and would you like to come to watch Norwich and Swansea, really after that performance???? Likewise Tamworth, a body swerve or another miserable antithesis of football from Gollum?
Seamus Murphy
64 Posted 04/12/2011 at 18:52:38
Moyes is a disgrace at this stage. Same old same old shit all the time. So predictable. Not only does he start with the same stale formations (that hasny worked in forever) but still completely refuses to put two strikers up front to chase the game. Exact same against QPR - its inexplicable really.
And where is the sense of urgency? Why do subs take so long? Why couldnt straq have come on when the keeper was injured? He was standing there waiting. Why would he not take Cahill off? Why even with seven minutes injury time was there no urgency? Its absolutely dpressing.
There is an unbelievable air of apathy around Goodison currently. The constant negative spin and playing down of expectations, the negative tactics, the resigned atmosphere in Goodison (which is like a library), the same stale formations, the same out of form players. Its criminal. Wheres the fight? The place is in a mess from top to bottom. Kenwright has mismanaged the club to a point where we have to sell our players and Moyes has as good as accepted that we can expect nothing more now.

Unless something gives this is going to get worse too. The crowds will not continue to come and watch this shit. Revenue is going to drop further and escalate the problem.I despair. And it doesnt have to be like this. Look at Newcastle, there is no way their squad is that much better then ours but they are playing with belief - something that has been ripped out of Goodison.
Wayne McNee
65 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:28:43
The only way it could've been worse was if McFadden had came on? Where is he BTW? Beautiful piece of business that? Is he injured by any chance or just deemed shite. Strange as our esteemed manager saw fit to let him grace the first team on arrival having been outcast from not only the league but a club?
3rd longest serving premiership manager out of desperation, fear of change & back chat.. Well done Bill! I wouldn't walk away from that package either.
Steve Barr
66 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:38:37
Seamus,

Spot on analysis.
Chris Matheson
67 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:34:12
Our strategy is hopeless.

We only have one form of attack: played sideways out to the wings then a high and hopeful ball lumped into the middle.

Against most teams that is going give us few chances but against big lumbering Stoke we've no chance.

Never on the ground to space, never through the middle, always trying to "hold the ball up" - ie give the opposition time to re-group.

I am losing patience with Moyes and I can't see a way back for him.

Kenwright Out. Kenwright Out.
Chris Sillett
68 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:38:15
Seamus #60 - great post mate, agree with everything you said.

Its so frustrating knowing that no matter how bad things continue to get at Everton, we all know that nothing is going to change.

We will be moaning about the exact same things this time next year - mark my words!
Ian Edwards
69 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:46:10
Karl 52

Spot on analysis.

For those crying out for Dreary to be given money to spend. Just think: £25M spent on Bilyletyoudownenough and Fellaini.
Phil Rodgers
70 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:39:25
We are a joke this season. I am completely fucked off with it to be honest. The club is dying slowly and there doesn't appear to be a saviour out there. Moyes is not instilling belief in his players by constantly lowering expectations and I don't know what he says in the dressing room at half-time when we are losing because we rarely come out fighting in the 2nd half.
Mike Rourke
71 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:42:41
If Moyes goes I want Hiddink or Capello or Van Basten or Rijkaard or Klinsmann or even Big Phil Scolari

I reckon they would all do a great job or turning us around.

If Guardiola really does leave Barcelona at the end of the season I think we should definitely consider him too.
Sean Patton
72 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:49:14
Ah the sarcasm defence mechanism of the Moyes supporter. Having just thought about it Mike despite all those names you mention I think Gary Megson or Phil Brown should get the job as they are the only two who will come here.
Andy Roberts
73 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:50:09
Some people must watch a different game. If Fellaini is just an average ball carrier, the rest out there today must be absolute shite. He was literally head and shoulders above anyone elso on the pitch.
The buck stops with the manager who sets up the team to mirror his dire, negative demeanour.
The same negativity every week at home! Notice the ironic cheers when he finally left Strac up when Stoke won a corner towards the end.
Steve Guy
74 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:46:40
My only shout at the end was "Kenwright OUT" sadly I was a lone voice.. His reluctance to sell up means Moyes stays and the we have the crap we see on the field. I just hope we can stay away from the relegation zone by hook or by crook.
Vinny Garstrokes
75 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:59:15
Mike#66

You're obviously full of the Christmas spirit a bit early shipmate ! If Moyes were to go I reckon the situation at the club would mean us getting somebody like Stuart McCall who has proved albeit in Scotland that he can do a similar job with no money.
Ciarán McGlone
76 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:43:18
Fellaini was good?

No he wasn't.

Like everybody else on that pitch today, and the bloke standing at the side of it - he made constant mistakes.

Absolutely no creativity and persisting with the same players who've been abysmal all season.

And yet we've still got the same usual suspects defending our so called manager.
Joe Bibb
77 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:48:47
Moyes has had Johnson, Beattie, Yak, Anichebe, and countless others, he has never manged to get his midfield to play to a forward .

I have said it before on this site, the only way to get change is to walk away. I have been a Blue for 50 years but will not be renewing my season ticket next year if Moyes is still in charge.

Not one shot at home on target. Moyes is only slightly better than Walter Smith and Mike Walker and they both got sacked.

Make all the excuses you want but if you pay your money and go to Goodison, I defy you to tell me that watching Everton under Moyes is entertaining or even remotely exciting.

I am sure most of you who support him do not attend matches. TV and Radio are not reliable sources. I know some of you are not even in this Country, I know some of you are skint and can't get to games but please don't praise a man who is emptying Goodison faster than a Fire Alarm.
Anthony Jones
78 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:02:52
Sam, #50, please look at the FACTS, #53.

You might have to take off those ginger tinted spectacles, however.
Brian Alexander
79 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:57:31
Not beating around the bush here, that was the biggest load of shite i've watched in the last few seasons, The substitutions were negative for a home team chasing a result. Barkley must be used now, forget his age, it's a must. The phone in on Merseyside was like a throwback to the bad day's. David Moyes has a 15 million pound contract i'm led to believe, start effing earning it and stop whingeing David.
Kevin Corness
80 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:58:45
Its the lack or urgency in are play that gets to me.
we only seem to be able to pass the ball from left to right or back to Howard. the only ball forward is when Howard kicks it to the half way line.(which is a watse of time with only one striker who is far to light wieght to play against a phisical Stoke side)what a bad Decision by moyes to play the lad in this game on his own. I would love to come to goodison and see Everton play with 2 out and out stikers.
Not one playing on the left or one on the right.
Moyes get a grip and start playing attacking football before not only are best players leave but the fans do too.
Kevin Corness
81 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:11:41
Does anyone else on here think that Steve Round is the worst thing to happen to Everton. he must be themost negative coach in the prem. Moyes take note get shut of him before we get shut of you........
Andy Crooks
82 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:03:21
If something is repeated often enough some people assume it is a fact. Well done Paul Olsen for demolishing the Yakubu myth. The isolation and sale of Yakubu made today's failure to score a sign of what we can expect. It was down to Moyes as was the sale of Becford and the retention of Anichebe, We do not have a fit premier quality striker at the club and that is down to the coach.
Goodison Park; the strikers graveyard. I don't think Lineker would have thrived under David Moyes.
John Keating
83 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:06:14
Let me get in before anyone else. Bily is absolutely brilliant but that useless shit Moyes is playing him out of position. His best position is just behind the striker. Plus we need to give him a run of games. Plus the arseholes at the match don't give him a chance. All his wonderful fantastic goals (?) have been when he's been in the middle of the park. Absolutely wasted out wide. He's great and I think we should offer him an extended contract with a huge pay rise.
Tommy Heskrth
84 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:02:02
The annoying thing is he cannot see his own mistakes and things are going to get more frustrating once Victor comes back as he'll be another guaranteed starter.

The crazy thing is when his most avid supporters say who else is out there, well for 3.5m a year I'm sure the queue would be around the ground.

Very sad times to be a blue
Richard Dodd
85 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:58:47
Mike #66 - Want what you like but if Davey took a hike (BB will never sack him), I think you`d have to settle for Curbishley or Bruce. Hughes is well settled as a multi-millionaire with a mega pad in London and no-one on your list would be interested.

How scary is that? I say stick with the best we`ve ever had in Prem history!
Jon Cox
86 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:08:49
Mr Moyes, do you actually practice shooting at the training ground?

I mean, you wouldn't have thought so watching todays game.
Brian Alexander
87 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:18:17
John Keating #77 your either a red or that prick sitting behind me today, Upper Gwladys, row x seat 1, was that you? Billy is shite, end of.
Jamie Sweet
88 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:50:57
Moyes oozes negativity. From his formations and tactics, right down to his "it's going to be a tough hard tough season and we always knew we'd struggle with no strikers" bullshit interviews.

Fuck me - how some people can still defend him is way beyond me.

Yes, he did well for us in the past... the PAST. That's gone. Look what is in front of you NOW. It's becoming a joke. And it's so fucking boring. Grow a pair Moyes or get out.
Tony Twist
89 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:17:32
I bet there wasn't many of us that didn't expect that sort of result and that sort of performance today. As many people have said, Moyes really does have the safest job in football! But who would come in and replace him.....(I say him, Round needs to go also, don't know why he was considered for the job in the first place).....not sure about Mark Hughes, ex Everton player, hasn't worked wonders elsewhere. I can't see a solution with Moyes in charge just hope there are three teams consistently worse than us! God help us!
John Keating
90 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:30:44
Brian Alexander 80. No I was in the Park End and didn't have to duck when Bily had a shot first half which I think hit the Pukka Pies sign by the dug out.
Read my initial post you prick !!!
Jimmy Sørheim
91 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:15:27
He hasn't helped, just makes Moyes look that much dumber.
Tommy Heskrth
92 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:22:59
How Moyes still has anyone defedning him is insane, granted we finishe 4th and of course who can forget the magnificent 7th!!

He seems to have more support than HK II & HK III even though HK actually won trophies.

I fear for our next generation of blues fans as the club is on it's knees and unless Blue Bill's 24/7 search pays off we could be the next fallen giant plying our trade within the Championship in the coming months.

On a positive note can' be long before Victor & Jimmy Mac are fully fit...........
Phil Bellis
93 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:20:59
The Goodison barometer has traditionally been the Street End... this afternoon I noticed a definite sea-change in the beatification of Moyesey.

The most ironic cheer was when we noticed Straq stood on the half-way line, shepherded by 2 Stoke players when we were defending a Park End corner - basic, schoolboy tactics, not seen before under this regime.

We all knew what Stoke were going to try to do today. I know Moyes hasn't got a lot of on-field talent to play with (whose fault? ? take your pick), but, bloody hell, why can't he see what's wrong and, at least, react positively and quickly???
Ray Robinson
94 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:25:14
We've been in this situation before with lack of strikers. If I recall, we relied solely on Beattie for half a season. For someone who doesn't like risk taking, what sort of manager starts a season with Saha (a crock), Straq (unproven), Vellios (promising) and Anichebe (not even worthy of the title (striker").

Look at Stoke: Crouch and Walters starting, Jerome, Fuller and Jones on the bench.
Kevin Corness
95 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:41:50
its not the lack of strikers its how we use them and moyes and round dont like them.yakubu gone beckford gone....... and we can't score.
Michael Winstanley
96 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:34:19
How many chances did we create today?
Toothless up front, we badly need a striker in the next window.

Fellaini, Baines, Heitinga & Jags all played okay. The rest not up to standard.

Gueye, our secret weapon came on for 10mins. He made passes I didn't see and one that Jack didn't see. He has ability, so I'm slightly curious as to why Bily gets a game ahead of him? If I;m honest I was expecting a decent game from Bily today...shocking. A waste of time playing him on the left, either play him in the middle or sell him.

Velios and Straq did nothing, the usual suspects in Cahill and Osman offer little as an attacking threat. We need a striker badly.
Simon Atkins
97 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:42:13
That was utter crap today. From 3pm to 5pm I was actually bored silly.

Even the very basics have gone. No passing, movement, invention, creation ...

Something needs to change, is it Moyes, is it the board, is it both?

I am very depressed.
John Ford
98 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:40:19
Worse than bad.

Will people stop pissing about whether Vellios/Strac/Cahill/Saha should play up front and in which formation our lightweight midfield should be played, because ts all complete bullshit.

We don't have the players to put in a decent challenge for the top six.

You cant lose players and/or let them grow old and not replace them. It can't be done. Stoke let us cross the ball from wide, crammed the middle and cleared everything that came at them. Our attack was that simple. Void of anything worthwhile.

It's not fucking Moyes's fault despite him being a miserable cunt lately. If you don't have the players, you can't win enough football matches. Stop muddying the issue with crap about formation and player positions.

We dont have an 11, any 11 which is good enough.
Kevin Corness
99 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:52:44
Moyes picks the team and the tactics.
Bobby Mallon
100 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:32:17
Sam Hoare, you mention 'saviour'; our saviour would have been Distin and Rodwell starting from the off, because if Johnny H or Osman would have got injured in the 1st minute, then one of those two would have been straight on.

We were playing STOKE at HOME, for god's sake, so two up front would HAVE ? and Mike Rourke, Mark Hughes, Peter Reid, Gordon Strachan, Joe Royle would all do a better job till the end of the season! And for god's sake, let's get rid of Osman and Hibbert.

Guys, if Everton go down this season, I will be gutted, not because we have been relegated but because we have NOT put up a BLOODY FIGHT. We are guttless and clueless and it all falls on Moyes's shoulders.
Ray Robinson
102 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:55:09
John, I don't believe that lack of funds, handicap that it is, totally explains the lack of striking potential, flair, pace and creativity in the team. If something isn't working, then try something different - e.g. Barkley.

Also, if Moyes didn't have such a cosy relationship with BK, he'd have been banging the door down by now rather than accepting the situation so meekly.
John Shaw
103 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:55:19
John Ford - you are having a laugh right?

The last time I checked the responsibility for buying and selling players resided with the manager, or am I missing something !!

Tommy Heskrth
104 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:59:09
John #94

It's only Moyes Fault, he picks the team, trains the team decides who is sold, arteta,Yak/Vaughan/Beckford. He cannot hide behind the we haven't spent any money excuse as if he had an ounce of balls he would have shamed Blue Bill into investing or any of the other shareholders.

He has lost his mojo with the job, he looks like a man who knows his bird is getting knobbed but won't get rid as she looks great and does Anal.
Jay Harris
105 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:38:33
The side is totally unbalanced with very little quality.

Take Fellaini and Baines out and youre left with a championship standard of player.

Coleman is acceptable with a bit more quality around him but Billy "should be off" is a total waste of a football shirt.

Lads in the Sunday league have got more go than him and if one special shot every 20 games is the sign of quality player then I know nothing about football,

The stench from the boardroom is making it's way to the pitch.

KENWRIGHT OUT closely followed by his buddies and sycophants!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Rob Murphy
106 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:04:18
I agree Ray, we need something different & the answer is sitting on the bench week in, week out. Barkley must be given a run in the team now.
James McPherson
107 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:05:56
John Ford is partially right - there are players in the team that are simply not up to the task. In that regard, formations/combinations are immaterial as you are only as good as the weakest link - when the weak links are 3 or 4 in number, little wonder there is no fluency or end product as we just can't keep the ball, create space and make an oppostion think.

However, John Ford is wide of the mark in inferring that Moyes is a powerless bystander here.

My issue with Moyes is his lack of desire that is now so openly displayed. We are looking at a man that has it too easy and has become far too complacent. His pre-match dampening of any expectation has become ritualistic. This will have an effect on the players. Do not get me wrong, players have responsibility - but every manager (SAF included) has to have motivational skills in his kit bag, Moyes had this in abundance when he arrived - it went 2 years ago - he seems to be running the clock down on his contract - simultaneously driving our hope and expectation with it.

It's stale and time to freshen things up.
Brian Alexander
108 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:13:18
John Keating #89, prick? where's your initial post Elvis?
Andy Roberts
109 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:01:23
Moyes sets the team up. Coaches all the flair out of them. Tells them to drop back as soon as we loose the ball. Gets everyone back for any corner or free kick in our final third.
The utter shite we are served up every other week at Goodison is entirely his fault.
Yes the lack of financial backing from the board doesn't help much but the board don't dictate the tactics on the pitch. I'd rather watch kids giving 100% and trying to play the right way than watch this shite week in week out.
Tony Christian
110 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:08:18
In 10 years as a Premier League manager, David Moyes has only won three games in which we have been losing at half-time. That's three times in 64 ? not the statistics of a football genuis.

In 10 years as Everton manager, David Moyes has played Man Utd, Arsenal, Chelsea and Liverpool 41 times away from home. He has won none.

David Moyes is paid £3.5M per year and knows that he has the safest job in football and why would he rock the boat by putting some of the blame on Kenwright?

David Moyes appears to resent his job and his negative and uninspiring attitude is seeping its way throughout the club. For the sake of Everton and your own name, I urge Mr Moyes to do the decent thing and resign.
Mike Rourke
111 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:06:42
Sean 68.

The only other defense mechanism I have is to harp on about lack of funds, and I think you're probably even more bored of hearing that one.

Listen, plenty about Moyes is grating me at the moment. In particular this defeatist nonsense about getting to 40 points, etc and the complete and utter adherence to 4-5-1 - I know all our strikers are shite but at least 4-4-2 provides another backside upfront for the ball to bounce off of. So i'm with everyone who argues these points.

However.

Last season I threw my toys out of the pram during our slow start and at the time was particularly keen to see some continental manager whose name I can't recall - Villareal's one perhaps? - come and replace DM...and then he did what he always does and turned the season around ( having spent no money zzzzzzzzz ) and again I hauled myself back aboard the Moyes bandwagon and decided that the next time my faith was tested - and days like today are extremely testing - I would stay loyal to him for all the well worn old arguments that us Moyes apologists churn out.

So, for the foreseeable future i.e. The one with no money ( just can't shake that old chestnut ), I'm going to stick with what I consider to be the safest pair of hands for the job.

( Also, what if it was Phil Brown or Gary Megson who did replace him? Chilling thought. With BK could you rule it out? )
Simon Watts
112 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:17:31
It was a boring match. The referee was poor and boring. But like everyone else says we should have created something. Back to the point of fowling in the box though, I can not believe what players get away with in the box. Giving people bear hugs, in front of the referee, and placing your hands on an opponents shoulders so they cant jump Squaring up to them face to face, Mason allows it, some other referees dont. There is no consistency from one referee to the next. ie what is a dangerous tackle, what isnt. What warrants a penalty what doesnt. Any foul in the penalty area is a penalty. If you bottle it you are not mentally strong enough to be a referee, and not doing the job to the rules.
Peter Webster
113 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:06:37
People do realise that a mojo is a voodoo spell bag and not a euphemism for motivation/libido, don't they?
Stephen Kenny
114 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:05:37
Some very simple attacking principles that any half decent coach will be teaching 7 year old's are consistently ignored by our side.

Move into space - This is the simplest and the one we struggle with most. I'd hate to play CB or CM for this side, no one bar Fellaini ever shows for the ball. IMO you can teach movement and how to evade a marker, make a bit of space for yourself etc. None of our players ever show this.

Pass into space - The amount of times Coleman has to turn inside or play the ball backwards because he get's a slow pass behind him or to feet is criminal. I don't think he's a great winger but he can cause problems when he gets a run at his marker. It's the same for our strikers. When was the last time you saw one of our forwards get played in with a through ball?

Vary the play - Crosses into the box with one or two men attacking them are very, very easy to defend against. Every man and his dog knows we will work it left and swing it in. Usually our build up play is slow so the opposition are all in position and we are heavily outnumbered. We need to shoot from distance, go long at times and play short and quick through the middle, change the formation mid match to confuse the opposition and interchange positions.

As well as this we need to use substitutions to change the way were playing or the shape of the team, not just pathetic like for like swaps. It's pointless taking Vellios off because he hasn't had a sniff, if the midfield aren't creating then it's going to be exactly the same for the player who comes on.

Nobody can deny Moyes achieved a lot over his first 5-7yrs at the club, but anybody who hails him a genius when so much of the basics of the game are missing from our play is deluded!
John Ford
115 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:21:16
John Shaw, talk about missing the point!

Its the managers responsibility for buying and selling players.....but if you cant BUY players what the fuck can you do.


Tommy, you can polish turds so far, but if the only jewels you have are sold or allowed to get old without replacing them it doesnt matter what you do with the leftovers.

I was thinking ten mins into the second half that we should make at least two changes (any two..... Bily Ossie Cahill Velios...all dire!) but theres nothing to replace them with. Rodwell solid but cant see a pass, Drenthe (a source of hope) is out, and we have Strac the statue as our front plan B...fuckin nowhere to go with that one.

We're fucked because of Kenwright and because every other middle income team can replenish their stock, yet we're still supposed to compete.
John Ford
116 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:31:59
It was freezing today as well...misreable as shit.
Bobby Mallon
117 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:58:38
Moyes said in an interview this season that he would walk away from Everton if the fans wanted him to. Well is it not time for all us fans that get to the games to start shouting "Moyes Out!" till he lives up to his word?

And for all those fans who don't get the game, start a petition to get him out. It's ok for us all to moan, but to get real action, calling for his head and protesting is the only way.
Luke Dunn
119 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:38:50
Time to get rid of Cahill, he is useless, not a midfielder nor a striker, he unbalances the team. Just throwing yourself about is not enough at this level. It irritates me everytime I see him in the starting line-up, he hampers our attack, and has not scored for nearly a year now. Why did we gid of the Yak?

Cahill, do the hounerable thing and ask for a transfer.
Steven Bennett
120 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:40:41
went today on a freebie , reminded me of why I wont pay to go any more.
Ciarán McGlone
121 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:41:31
Aye, poor Moyes.

Old man Kenwright made him take off a striker when we were chasing a goal.

As for the temperature...
Tommy Heskrth
122 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:49:00
Peter 110# your far to intelligent for this website mate.
Ian Smitham
123 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:41:05
Bobby # 99 Utter total rubbish.

Lets make the dangerous assumption that the saviours are not quite fit to start but are willing to be subs, i accept the first minute arguament. Hibbert? I take it you do not go or watch the game because today Tony was really good, i nearly typed excellent.

"If we go down" FFS

Tom Bowers
124 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:49:37
Seems like the more we hope for change the more Moyes digs his heels in and says no way. The team is no better now and has no prospects of getting better than it was 10 years ago.
If he was an honourable man he would quit now. Taking money under false pretences is a crime. If he was working for my company he would have been fired years ago. Chances are we will struggle against Tamworth with Moyes still in charge.
Robert Penlington
125 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:50:07
As one ex- employee recently quoted" The club is heading for meltdown"

Take a bow Mr Kenwright and your "Friends"
John Shaw
126 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:54:01
John Ford - nah, not missed the point at all.

So are you honestly saying that Moyes was forced to sell Yak, Vaughan and Beckford in the summer ?

If the answer is no, that then suggests, in the opinion of Moyes, what we have upfront now is better than any of those three, which frankly is laughable !!

Mick Davies
127 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:35:49
Yakubu fading? The only one who is fading fast is Moyes, he always said that he needs to improve every season. Well them days are past. I was angry at the time with the cheap price we got for Rooney. I now realise that another couple of seasons under our 'progressive' manager and we'd have been lucky to get a six figure sum for him.
John Ford
128 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:15:55
John, Yak was great for a season or two but had done less than nothing for the last two seasons (detailed above) and Beckford was no less or worse than those we have now...i.e mediocre.

We just havnt got the players and theres no way Yak or Beckford would provide an answer. I pray we get a footballing attacker who can find space. hold the ball up and get into scoring positions. We're also dead from the neck up since Arteta left, not a brain to be seen on the pitch and only Felli has something about him.
Paul Olsen
129 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:16:03
#110

Being so clever, you should know mojo can refer to a vast number of things.

One of those related to voodoo, sure.
John Ford
130 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:25:03
Ciaran, that particular striker was awol pretty much the entire game....and....er.... as was the bloke who replaced him
Bobby Thomas
131 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:50:09
Well, it's time to face facts. We are a poor, declining side. The big players have left and what remains is a mish-mash of a squad, horribly unbalanced and struggling to put together a first eleven that can compete. There is virtually a complete lack of pace, invention and goals.

Whoever is in charge, it needs a shake up. What's going on with the tempo of the play? It's torturously laboured, predictable and uninspired. Thank god its only Tamworth in the FA Cup cos, if I was a manager of a Championship side on a decent run, I'd turn up and tell my players Everton are there for the taking.

What is most worrying, however, is the lack of urgency and belief. Belief and hope have been ripped from the stands, seemingly drained from our manager, and this has now transmitted to the players. There is almost a resigned acceptance of our fate.

The David Moyes of even 2 years ago wouldn?t have tolerated this display. It is now deemed not bad, understandable, the best we can expect... The club is dead from head to toe and we are sleepwalking to big trouble. Stoke City didn?t play well and cruised to an away win.
Jamie Sweet
132 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:23:11
Interviewer: ?So you?re looking a bit toothless upfront at the moment David. You seem to be devoid of any ideas going forward, a real lack of flair or invention. Your forwards look a bit isolated?.

Moyes: ?Well I think if I could just get the wingers to track back a bit more, I think we?d solve a few of our current problems?.

Interviewer: ?Ah, but my question was about ideas going forward David. Do you have any comments on the teams failure to get a shot on target??

Moyes: ?I don?t really know what you?re talking about. Although I admit we looked a bit exposed at the back when we left the lad up field for that Stoke corner. I won?t be making that mistake again?.

Interviewer: ?But what about in the final third David. Surely you can see that it?s just not working with Cahill up there and perhaps it?s time for something new??

Moyes: ? I?m sorry, I don?t really understand. But Tim Howard didn?t really have a save to make all game, so that?s pleasing?.

Interviewer: ?Your substitutions have come under fire. Do you think you could be a bit more positive with the changes you make??

Moyes: ?Hah, what rubbish. We?d already conceded one goal, so I brought on young Jack to steady the ship a bit. What could be more positive than not wanting to concede another goal??

Interviewer: ? I see Yakubu scored four goals for Blackburn at the weekend. Given your lack of options up front, are you starting to regret letting him go??

Moyes: ?Pfffft, you are joking no? So maybe he scored four goals blah blah blah, but where was he for the two they conceded? I?ll tell you, he was still in their half! THEIR HALF!!! Can you believe it?! Could never get the lazy bastard to track back. Glad to see the back of him?.
Peter Cummings
133 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:07:58
A fantastic tribute to Gary Speed by the club and fans but to describe the Welsh national anthem as 'sombre' is quite out of order, just wish we had a really uplifting England anthem instead of the royalty drivel.

Unfortunately the performance on the field was far from a tribute to a great Evertonian, once again it was flies banging rheir heads against a brick wall, even though we had the fans wishes answered with Vellios starting and some real attacking action until they scored...

Then we all realised what that meant: massed ranks and futile attacks coming to nothing. The treatment of Fellaini both by Stoke defenders and crap refereeing was a disgrace, but while Vellios has all the height and build of a bruiser, he was completely ineffective.

The least said about the rest ? Jags, Heitinga, and Baines excepted ? the better; a bloody pathetic display.
Ian Edwards
134 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:33:46
Where are the Blue Union while the Moyes Titanic sails towards the iceberg? Probably campaigning against the chairman of the shipping line rather than the idiot steering the ship..
Mike Rourke
135 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:50:15
Ian

If BK was chairman of the Titanic shipping line the people on that ill-fated cruise wouldn't have set off in the worlds foremost state of the art gin palace, instead they would've had to cram aboard a bamboo raft lashed together with bits of Les Miserables manuscript.
Tom Hughes
136 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:45:13
Ian..... the Blue Union warned about the iceberg long ago... they also warned about the incomplete bulkheads and the chronic shortage of lifeboats. It would seem some would still quite happilly offer the chairman a lifeline?
Ian Edwards
137 Posted 04/12/2011 at 23:02:41
Kenwright has his faults but he doesn't:

1. Pick the team
2. Decide tactics.
3. Decide formation
4. Make no changes at half time when it was obvious change was needed.
5. Decide substitutions
6. Waste money when given it (£25M on Bily and Fellaini).
Mike Green
138 Posted 04/12/2011 at 23:38:09
Let's face it ? we're shit aren't we. What's worse is we're made to look shit by a completely horrible, cheating, shithouse team like Tony Pulis's Stoke City. They should come with a Government Health Warning. People slagged off Allardyce's Bolton but they were Corinthians compared to Stoke.

I listened to Moyes after the game and he sounded completely washed out. I haven't got a bad word to say about him as a bloke but it's definitely time to go. Tear it all up and start again.
Phil Bellis
139 Posted 04/12/2011 at 23:48:39
John Ford..I presume you are are a Sky-soccer man
1 word..no, make that 2 words, Brian Clough

Ste Traverse
140 Posted 05/12/2011 at 00:00:36
I can't believe we still have a few beauts trying to stick up for Moyes. The guy has lost the plot. End of.

Why oh why he didn't put Denis on take the ineffective Cahill and go 4-4-2 for the last 15 minutes remains a mystery.

And the fact he's Kenwright's lapdog and blatantly refuses to put pressure on him endears him to me even less.
Richard Harris
141 Posted 05/12/2011 at 01:33:51
Stoke played a game on Thursday night and yet still worked harder than us for most of the game. Three wins from 13 games so far is dire (regardless of our lack of money).

As we are not good enough to win the FA Cup this season then maybe it's better to go out in the third round and then Moyes resigns (or is sacked) for failing to beat non-league opposition. Under Moyes we have rarely dominated weaker teams (and we have had players who are better than average) and seeing some of the high scores this season, I fear that we are in for a thrashing at some point.

If there really is no chance of Kenwright selling the club in the next few years, no money for better players, cut-backs and lowered expectations then at least get a manager who can give us more satisfying football and less predictable tactics. If we can figure out Plan A, then an opposition manager has an even easier task as he also knows the strength of his squad. Looking forward to seeing some old friends next week at Arsenal but dreading how the game could go. Maybe we will get lucky......
Jamie Sweet
142 Posted 05/12/2011 at 02:09:10
Richard Harris - Yep Plan A is pretty obvious, but the opposition don't always see Plan B coming in the form of a Moyes substitution.

"We're 1-0 up" thinks Pullis. "They're bringing on another striker. That might shake things up a bit. I'm a bit worried by this one. Those two up front might be a bit more of a handful. Hold on... no... they're bringing off a striker too. So it's basically exactly the same as before. Didn't see that coming. We'll stay as we are then I guess. Crickey, that was easy!"

The genius that is David Moyes.
Jamie Sweet
143 Posted 05/12/2011 at 02:18:02
As for away at The Emirates... I dread to think what we've got planned for that. Anyone for Cahill as a lone striker? I'm sure the Moyes Apologists will be simply gushing at the thought!
John Keating
144 Posted 05/12/2011 at 06:40:15
Brian Alexander. Initial post now numbered 82.
Ever heard of sarcasm ??? Prick !
John Ford
145 Posted 05/12/2011 at 08:35:18
Phil Bellis...dont have Sky sports. ...blood pressure cant take it, even with the sound turned down!

Clough, wonderful though he was, wouldnt have a cat in hells chance if he were in his pomp now. Money has killed any chance of a Notts Forest type boom.
Sam Hoare
146 Posted 05/12/2011 at 08:39:00
You'd think the apocalypse had come reading all the above. We lost a rubbish game of football because, as has been blatantly obvious for some time now, we have limited options up front and Moyes doesn't coach attacking football well.

We're 10th with a game in hand on most teams which if i'm honest is kind of where i expected to be. Not ideal but surely not that surprising. I wouldnt necessarily say that i'm a Moyes apologist and wouldn't be against a change of manager if the right man came in but there's alot of over reaction here.

As for all the people moaning about selling Yak and Beckford, i would bet you are mostly the same people who crucified them when they were here for being inept and a waste of space. As i recall most people were on here saying that we should give them away. Certainly when Yak went to Blackburn the majority were amazed we had got rid of him. Now he's on fire and everyone can get all self righteous about it?! Give me a break.
Tom Hughes
147 Posted 05/12/2011 at 08:43:35
I heard someone talking a while ago outside the ground.... the gist of his conversation was that we would need to lose a few home games before the majority would turn on the chairman vocally. People rarely see beyond the last few fixtures when it comes to their general mood towards the club...... his mate quickly interupted saying that they'd probably just turn on Moyes. How right he was......Apologists come in the BK variety too.

Ian, you are right, BK doesn't pick the team, but his and his boards incompetence has been instrumental in ensuring that Moyes can no longer pick the team that he had built on a shoestring. As far as plans A and B are concerned I don't suppose anyones noticed our average league placing over the past 10yrs...... I am in no way saying that moyes is the gretest manager ever (it is impossible to judge given the scraps he's had to work with), but to blame him for our current predicament when he hasn't had a transfer budget for yrs and he has had to sell so many key players is blinkered in the extreme. I've heard several potential candidates suggested over the yrs, normally after a defeat or 2. One by one I've watched most of these get relegated and struck off the wish list. Don't think I've seen any match Moyes in the same period given his net spend. Meanwhile on the boardroom front, I don't think I've seen any other clubs board achieve less in terms of increasing revenue streams and improving facilities to give the manager funds to compete....... yet its all Moyes fault?
Sam Hoare
148 Posted 05/12/2011 at 09:15:14
Tom, I agree. For me the majority of blame must lie with the board. In no way I am saying that Moyes is faultless but the master villain is BK.

Someone posted this on another thread yesterday.

http://www.sportingintelligence.com/2011/08/12/arsenals-net-spending-of-48m-in-a-decade-puts-them-9th-in-premier-league-120802/

I know money isn't everything but this net spend table pretty accurately represents the general shape of the Premier Leage. In it we are 14th over the last decade. So in fact we are doing slightly better than money alone might predict.
James McPherson
149 Posted 05/12/2011 at 09:28:08
Tom, (#144)

No one doubts that this is far from being solely Moyes' fault - if they don't, I agree, that's harsh in the extreme.

However, Moyes does have a choice here. To not accept the situation and walk away or stick at it, don't complain, be positive and motivate and coach his team as best he can.

I like Moyes as a person. However, the main reason for my admiration is the same aspect that causes me to question him most - his integrity.

I am getting so increasingly frustrated at the fact that he has accepted this difficult role, is taking the 4th highest wage amongst his peers yet persistently undermines the confidence of the players by this now weekly pre-match ritual of bemoaning the state of our finances and indeed the team's (his team!) capability to compete. This mental disconnect between his pronouncements and the effect it may have on his team strikes me as nothing other than creating a verbal "each way" bet for himself. Almost a constant reminder to the football world (and let's be honest, a potential future employer) that none of this is his fault. Tom for a bright guy (which he clearly is) and for a sincere guy that outwardly places high value in honesty and integrity - this is so out of order.

I am realistic - I don't expect him to pull of another miracle and get BK off the hook - but I expect postivity and motivation if he's elected to take the money!

Is that not a fair shout Tom?
Tom Hughes
150 Posted 05/12/2011 at 09:34:05
Plus you probably also need to remember that Arsenal were probably League Champions around the begining of that analysis.

15th in the spending league, and probably bottom of the league in terms of stadium spend, hardly equates to what we should be for the size of fanbase etc. As someone else said.... perhaps we shouldn't be surprised about being outmuscled by Stoke.... when we are now outmuscled by them in the boardroom too..... as we are by most other clubs.
Tom Hughes
151 Posted 05/12/2011 at 09:44:44
James, I agree that Moyes has been complicit, and that therefore should expect some of the responsibility in some respects.... however much of the criticism concentrates on the minutae of recent performances when the die was cast long ago. Did anyone seriously think that we would be anything but workman-like this season after selling our forwards and most creative players?

Perhaps you are right and Moyes should've just walked, and fans might finally focus on the real causes of our manageer's inability to field the side he built. A side that IMO might've had a decent chance this season. Even a modest injection of quality in the past 2 seasons would've seen us compete (especially if we didn't get it on the last day of the transfer window).

I don't know if Moyes is the answer, but I am certain that BK and this board isn't, and is far more responsible for our current position.
Jason Lam
152 Posted 05/12/2011 at 10:01:12
I'll be honest and say this: each season we are in the Premier League, we will continue to limp on as BK's Football Club. Yes, you heard it. This is not Everton. You are supporting BK FC.

This is not football being served either, it's shite by Moyes. Each season we will limp on with the Sky handouts. BK will never sell this club. The price will not go down.. unless... here it is: the club go down. It's a depressing vicious cycle that gets worse each year with our 'better' players (the best have long gone) leaving one by one to pay the debt interest. Until eventually we will not have the quality no more to say in this division.

Moyes, FFS, if you have any pride, dignity and soul left in you - leave this club. Each passing day you lose respect in your profession as an ambious young manager, multiple LMA award winner, and money grabbing mercenary.
James McPherson
153 Posted 05/12/2011 at 10:17:35
Tom,

I think if Moyes had walked a season ago then he would have gone with many fans' gratitude and good wishes.

Furthermore, and more importantly, it could have been the catalyst to really zone in on the central issue, which is the board's incompetence.

Glad you used the word 'complicit' - because in my view that really sheds light on where Moyes is in this now sorry mess. That's what frustrates me and yes although BK should go first, it is still nevertheless time to send a signal to Moyes that he can't 'take the coin' and simultaneously absolve himself. I fear that he and BK are mutually dependent on one another. That's just not right.

There is the faintest glimmer however and that is Moyes knows that investment is on its way and is hanging around for an opportunity he no doubt feels he deserves.

Mind if that's the case... then he better buck up his ideas none the less as new owners often equals new manager.
Mike Green
154 Posted 05/12/2011 at 09:54:15
Sam - no one can say that we're big spenders but if you put the money for Rooney and Lescott together that's just shy of £50m alone. There aren't many players we've sold at a loss and it's probable we slipped up with the likes of Pienaar and Gosling. These are some of the reasons our net spend is so low.

Much of the cash Moyes has generated has seemingly been haemoraged by the clubs debt and there have been some clangers too (Per Kroldrup, Shandy, probably Bily, some would say Fellaini but certainly not me.)

The major issue I think is he's simply had enough. He's got his 10 year anniversary coming up in March and I genuinely think he's now got to the point where he's ready for a change - and the fact that he's on £60k+ a week makes it even more depressing (as ridiculous as that sounds) as it's impossible for him to walk away.

The longer that goes on the worse its going to get for us. I bet a day doesn't go by without him looking over towards Manchester thinking "c'mon you auld fucker, pack it in and let me have a shot". A least that way he'd know if he's going to get the "big" job he's holding out for or instead should just look at a different club at the same level as us but with money to have another crack. The only other option is carry on holding out for a buy out of ours.

Either way, until one of those things happens I think we're screwed, and to be frank he's not going to get the Man Utd job, he's not going to walk and we don't look like anyone wants to buy us either, so we're going to stick with the status quo and stand by as all desire, passion and everything else money can't buy rapidly drains out of our club from the top down. Just listen to Moyes and you can almost hear the bells tolling in the background, which is why he should do the honourable thing - sit down with BK and tell him he's off in May and has 6 months to find a hungrier, cheaper, fresher successor who'd see Everton as a fantastic opportunity, not a millstone around their neck.
James McPherson
155 Posted 05/12/2011 at 10:35:20
Mike Green (#153)

Good thoughtful post. Agree with you. I see Moyes now as a frustrated individual who is possibly thinking why did I stay? His demeanour, statements etc all hang with gloom. It's so clear to see. He's had dark days before but bounced back...this time it's clear to me (IMO) that he's not going to get off the canvas - he's down and out, good and proper.

I so wish he would do the decent thing and walk - for us and yes, for himself. Each week that passes will only see further erosion of his achievements.

Fans frustration I think centres upon his salary in combination with this negative entrenchment that he now so readily passes off in what could be perceived as nonchalant arrogance and aloofness (in the sense that he sees no desire to change whatsoever - no fight - no acceptance etc).

The club is rotten to the core.

So sad that a man with high principles and ideals has been sucked in and adding to the malaise.
Adam Bennett
156 Posted 05/12/2011 at 11:03:43
The referee was appalling, like he always is with us. Ever since his first Everton appointment, at Hull City when James Vaughan got dragged all over the place in the area and nothing was given, every single time that twat has refereed one of our games he has been a complete and utter disgrace.

That said, I think the lack of investment over the years is really starting to bite. You cannot keep selling players and not reinvesting the money, and expect the team to carry on performing.

We are struggling to score - Vaughan, Beckford, Yakubu sold.

We are struggling to create ? Peinaar, Arteta sold.

Money re-invested from those sales? Zilch, nowt, nothing.

If Moyes was given even a quarter of that money, he may have been able to pull of a couple shrewd buys which would have gone a little way to replace those sales.

While Moyes has left me fuming on a number of occasions this season, for me it?s the total miss-management of our board over the years which has resulted in us having to watch this shite, and Moyes is starting to think ?what?s the fucking point??
Mike Green
157 Posted 05/12/2011 at 11:30:47
Adam - your final 9 words sum up what I was trying to say. Nice one!
Mike Green
158 Posted 05/12/2011 at 11:35:47
An inspirational man once told me that you can achieve anything you want in life providing you have three things. None of which are time, money, contacts, experience, etc etc etc.

They are a "Goal" - (two wouldve been nice yesterday..... :D) It appears our goal has dropped from Champions League qualification, to top half..... to staying in the Premier League...?

"Desire" This has evaporated as no one has the desire for the goals we now set ourselves. I also think the trouncing we got off Chelsea in the Cup Final has completely knocked our taste for the Cup competitions too.

"Belief". This has completely gone - as the only thing we seem to believe in now is that we can't compete and things are only going to get worse.

Ergo: We're fucked.
Chris Sillett
159 Posted 05/12/2011 at 11:46:04
Mike Green, if you think Man Utd would touch Moyes with a bargepole, then you're having a laugh, mate. Same for Spurs, their fans and chairman would not put up with the negative shite served up by Dour Davey for one season. The only teams I can see Moyes managing, if he ever does leave Everton, are Celtic or Scotland.
Peter Webster
160 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:04:25
@126. Er....it was a joke, Paul. Y'know, not to be taken seriously, like. A disappointing day for sure, but no need to get your knickers in a twist.
Jimmi James
161 Posted 05/12/2011 at 11:09:33
Okay fellas, I have read and reread all the above posts just to give me plenty of time to take it all in.

To be honest, what else can we do but remain as positive as we can because, to be fair, if Moyes goes, who the hell is going to actually want the job? Plus we will still have none or very little money to spend and a new manager would obviously want to buy who he considers capable of doing the job on the pitch. What if that didn't work? We'd be worse off probably.

However, I agree, the boss must try something positive for a change because, make no mistake, relegation now stares us in the face and it worries me that I can't see three worse teams at the moment. Like someone else said, God help us.
Mike Green
162 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:13:51
Chris (158) - what's your point? As I said in my post - "to be frank he's not going to get the Man Utd job"?
Chris Sillett
163 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:16:18
Mike, sorry I didn't see that part of your post but I read this bit: "I bet a day doesn't go by without him looking over towards Manchester thinking "C'mon, you auld fucker, pack it in and let me have a shot" and thought it was laughable.

Maybe it's Moyes who's having a laugh if he thinks he'll be replacing Fergie!
Tony J Williams
164 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:09:15
Chris, Moyes wouldn't need to be negative if he had a midfield like Spurs and good forwards, you know ones that actually scores goals.

The sqaud we have is miniscule, it shows it when we have to put on the donkey Straq.

I have said it loads of times, I would have bailed from this tired and penniless club ages ago. Moyes is a man of integrity and I imagine he will see his contract out and do one. Can't blame him.

Can you imagine being the manager yesterday losing 1-0 to a gang of cloggers, divers and time wasters and looking at the bench to change it up and seeing who we had?

The man is a spent force who has been shafted by his board. He has probably given up and if he was less of a man, he would do a Keegan and leave but he probably has a mis-guided illusion that he owes us something and wants to do the best with what he has.
Richard Dodd
165 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:06:02
As a serial optimist, I remain positive that the New Year will see us, as ever, climbing the league towards the top third.

My disappointment over Saturday`s performance was considerably lightened by the news this morning ? from an impecable source ? that `striking re-inforcements` are already `in the bag` for the upcoming window! Hence, I believe, Davey`s assertion that you can never expect to win if you don`t score goals. Admittedly a statement of` `the bleeding obvious` but one he can make confident that the cavalry is just round the corner.

Unlike so many on here ,I do not subscibe to the `Moyes is clueless` lobby, prefering to believe that virtually all our troubles are down to the lack of a goalscorer. Solve that ? as he is about to do ? and the customary faith in our manager will be restored overnight. I look forward to 2012.
Daniel A Johnson
166 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:27:30
Moyes is like a boxer whos took too many punches, he's dead inside with nothing but shattered dreams and aspirations.

Time to quit at the end of the season.
Tony J Williams
167 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:23:41
Mike 157, absolute bollocks mate.

Don't you think AFC Totton had a goal, desire and belief yesterday? What happened, they were twatted 6-1.

All this fancy schmancy idealism is bullshit. Our goal was to win the game, we had the desire because we were attacking pretty much all teh second half and we had the belief that we could win.

The problem was, our two forwards used cost about £100,000 between them.

We put in loads of crosses but the players weren't there to meet them. That's not tactics, that a forward/midfielder not keeping up with play, that's being lazy. (Maybe we did lack desire after all.)

The point being, if we did have money for transfers the last two years, our squad would be bigger and probably better and we might have actually had a decent forward to score goals instead of relying on a crock, a young kid and a loanee who failed to get a contract with a championship side.

I honestly don't buy the Moyes line of "It goes through me when we sell the players"... Bullshit Moyes, the leaked e-mails shows the banks dictate the sales.
Chris Sillett
168 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:27:33
Tony, if Moyes took over Spurs he would probably stick Van der Vaart in a defensive midfield role and put Defoe out on the right wing!

Joking aside, I would argue that receiving around £60,000 a week and having the safest job in football are the reasons Moyes hasn't had the guts to leave the club.
Mike Green
169 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:34:03
No worries Chris - and yes, I do think Moyes thinks he's earnt a shot at it, rightly or wrongly.

To every person who says to me he's in with a shout etc I simply reply "If you arguably had the choice of any manager on the planet - would you pick David Moyes?", to which each and every time I've had nothing more positive than a "hmmmm...."
Jeremy Benson
170 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:37:08
I agree, what complete and utter rubbish.

You can achieve anything you want in life if you have a goal, desire and belief?

No wonder we're in the shit that we are (and I mean the world, not just EFC fans), if people will believe such utter tripe. No wonder management consultants or motiviational speakers make so much money from the gullible.
Andy Codling
171 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:33:02
Tony, I think the huge salary and the fact that Moyes is under no pressure to achieve is the reason he stays; nothing to do with integrity, he has the best job in English football. This is his team and his players can't be arsed anymore, judging by their pathetic attempts at playing football.

Just like Moyes, his players are overrated and overpaid!!
Tony J Williams
172 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:41:05
No doubt that plays a part too Chris but the man now is a millionnaire so he probably has no foreseeable money worries.

Maybe it takes more guts to stay. You are given an impossible task because your best players are sold and not replaced yet the fan base expects you to do better than the year before.

He is now damaging his reputation as a manager so maybe it does take more guts to stay at a stagnating club?
Tony J Williams
173 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:44:59
"Just like Moyes his players are overrated and overpaid!! " - Amen Andy, Amen
Mike Green
174 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:43:34
Maybe so Jeremy - looking back on your life though, which of your achievements are you most proud of though?

Thought of it....?

Now tell me whether you could only have achieved it because you had loads of money, loads of time on your hands etc......? I'd take a wager that the fact that you knew what you wanted, really wanted to do it and believed you could achieve it had more to do with it. I might be wrong though, everything probably comes very easy to you.
Mike Green
175 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:57:08
OK, let's try it out.

Let's set ourselves a goal ? Champions League Qualification by the end of the season.

Do we as a club have the desire to achieve it? I don't think we do to be honest. Do we have the belief we can do it? Do we fuck!

So ? we're not going to achieve it are we.

These things don't just fall into people's laps.
Tony J Williams
176 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:02:52
Behave Mike, it simply doesn't work like that.

Each season you can pretty much confirdently predict the top 5/6 in the league........ and guess what? it is usually the teams that have spent the most money on players.

Look at the leaders and then look at how much they have spent in the last 3 season.....now look at our transfer buget is the same time. Are you seriously telling me that if the players and manager genuinely belive tyhey can do it with belief and desire...then by jingo, thay darn well will?

Listen to that.... a bell....that means another Angel has been given its wings.....there's no place like home, there's no place like home....etc
Chris Sillett
177 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:57:47
Another thing which has been getting on my nerves lately is all this bad-mouthing of Denis Stracqualursi.

He has made five appearances and only one of them was a start and guess what -he was alone up front. If he is as bad as most people say he is, is it his fault he was brought to the club? If Moyes signed a League 2 striker from say, Macclesfield (I wouldn't put it past him) would you choose to slag that player off or would you question why the manager had signed him?

The exact same thing has happened with Denis. Did Moyes never have this guy watched? Did Moyes know that Leicester rejected him? Did Moyes even know who he was when he turned up at Finch Farm?

People should be asking the manager why he thought this lad was a better option than Yakubu or Beckford and not constantly blaming the player for not making an impact in the last 10 minutes of every game he plays.
Mike Green
178 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:09:03
Tony

I can just about grasp the concept that the best players cost the most money, and if you have the best players you've got the best chance of winning more often. Money = Success then, yes?

So. What gives a player value? In simplistic terms I'd say it was being able to do something better than their peers.

How have they got themselves into this position? If you asked Tim Cahill why he was such a prolific scorer of headed goals, would he say "It's because I'm 6'5" and to be honest it's dead easy". Or is he more likely to say "Because I believe I can win every single ball that comes into the box and have the desire to get to it and hit the target."

If you asked David Moyes how he won three LMA Awards would be say "To be honest there wasn't much competition and it got handed to me on a plate", or something like "because I had the desire to get the very best out of the resources I had and believed that I could take Everton Football Club higher than any other manager in the country."

You've got to work out what you need to do to give yourself that belief and desire, but without it you simply cannot realise your goals.

I'm going into town later. Do I think I can do it? Yes, I do. Do I have the desire to do it? Yes I do. Am I going to do it? Yes I am.
Tony J Williams
179 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:43:46
Mike, is anyone trying to stop you going into town?

It's all well and good having your desire and belief for achievable goals, aim for the stars and all that.

It only goes so far, you can have all the desire in the world but if you don't possess the skill to take on a player/timing of a jump/speed/quickness of mind..... you are not going to make it as a "top" Premier League player.

Hibbert has all three but yet he will never play for England or be classed as a "top" Premier League player (especially not on here)

Moyes won the LMAs because he had a very good squad and the year he finished 4th, we were lucky that the redshite were distracted by the Champions League.

There is no evidence, none whatsoever, to show that "belief" will win out over the top players who costs money (Cup one-off game competitions aside).

Since the inception of the Premier League, the league title has been "bought", look at the first winners, Blackburm, the title bought with Jack Walker's money.

We were even called the Merseyside Millionnaires in the 80s because we could tempt the best players to come and play for us for a hefty wage.

Money makes the world go around? Possibly... but it definitely has a direct correlation with the top echelons of the Premier League and nothing you can say can dispute that.
Tony J Williams
180 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:52:36
Chris, do you honestly belive that Moyes would even look at Stracq if he had any money to spend on a forward?

Why would he look at a loan deal... because he has no money... and why are they being loaned out in the first place?

He took a gamble on a freebie, it didn't work.
Peter Warren
181 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:52:59
Tony, I hear what you're saying and difficult to argue (other than in the 80s I think most of are signings were peanuts ? Southall, Reid, Sheedy, Gray etc).

People are getting really annoyed with safe, mid- to upper-table mentality. Perhaps it's wrong and Moyes is right but many supporters, myself included, have wanted Moyes to have a real go for years now, instead of always being conservative (and that's why he gets called cowardly etc sometimes).

Perhaps Moyes is right, perhaps the best way to get results is way he has employed his team for years and the way he has bought and sold (I'm not talking this year when his hands are clearly tied). For me, he struggles to do the basics and is negative and his demeanour is doing my head in... and I wouldn't be upset if he left.
Mike Green
182 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:55:16
I'm not disputing that Tony, youre missing the point. The reason they cost more, is they are better players. How did they become better players.........?

Lets say I asked Bill Kenwright what his long term goal was for EFC and he said - to get us back to the top of English Football. I'd say, "fine". I'd then ask if he believed we could do that. I think he might say "yes, but not under the current conditions". Such as? "We've not got enough money". So how are we going to get that money if you dont have it? "I'm going to have to sell, perhaps on terms unfavourable to me, to someone who has the money to do it" Do you have the desire to do this? "I didn't but I think I'm getting there...."

Possible Buyer 1 - whats your goal for EFC? "To take them to the top of English Football" Do you have the belief that you can do this? "Yes, when we look at the resources we have at our disposal, we're sure we can" And do you have the desire to commit these resources to this goal "You're joking aren't you! We'll throw a bit at it but we dont want it that much".

Possible Buyer 2 - as above but "Yes, we're going to put everything we have into this until we get it".

Which of the possible scenarios above are most likely to deliver the goal of returning EFC to the top of English football.

Money is essential in the modern game, I just dont think BK has brought any in in meaningful terms because he's not had the desire to give up his train set.

Things can obviously get in your way but you do not achieve things by sitting around waiting for them to happen out of right.

I'm now off into town, anyone who tries to stop me will rue the fucking day :D

Nice having the debate.

Cheers
Tony J Williams
183 Posted 05/12/2011 at 14:14:38
Peter, I fear you are right. He looks like a beaten man and his "core" players aren't doing it anymore. The ones that are left.
Mike Green
184 Posted 05/12/2011 at 14:29:34
No belief or desire, see...
Tony J Williams
185 Posted 05/12/2011 at 14:17:10
"I'm now off into town, anyone who tries to stop me will rue the fucking day :D" - Good on you, let's hope the person trying to stop you isn't bigger and stronger than you.... then again, if you believe you can overpower a bouncer type fell, well done.
Tony J Williams
186 Posted 05/12/2011 at 14:50:14
"Possible Buyer 2 - as above but "Yes, we're going to put everything we have into this until we get it".

What happens if they have no money to "put" into it? Do you think Hibbert, Ossie and Bily will suddenly become world beaters because their employers "believe in them, you betcha!"
Sam Hoare
187 Posted 05/12/2011 at 14:51:11
Tony is right. All good and that having desire and belief but it has to go with ability to a certain degree.

Its irrelevant to be honest as to what makes the best players because the point is that only money can buy those players. Whether they brilliant due to ability in the Messi role or are players fired mainly by desire and belief in the Roy Keane mode. Either way bug money gets effective players and that is why Man City sit atop the league closely followed by the likes of United, Chelsea and Tottenham.

Danny Jones
188 Posted 05/12/2011 at 14:22:36
Poor show by players and manager.

Stoke were coming off a trip to Ukraine and needed reminding how tired they were. Everton passed well but never at the required pace to move the opposition around.

The ploy to get the ball out wide to cross into the box was never going to work against this team. In truth, it's unlikely to work if you don't get more than one man in the box anyway.

Moyes changed some personnel but not the game plan. Granted, we have sold our creative players and our experienced strikers but this was not good enough from him. I'm not an advocate of depending on young players but I think, once it was clear that the 'master plan' had failed, Barkley needed to come on to run at them. A change was needed. What's the worst that could happen?

Everton supporters, including me, came across as unsporting when booing their injured 'keeper. Sorry about that. BUT. Stoke are the most unsporting team I think I have ever seen. Last year they surpassed themselves at Goodison by starting their time wasting in the first half. This year their anti football tactics were allowed to flourish by a weak referee having a particularly bad day. His obvious dislike for Fellaini was proved time and time again during this game.

Having said that, it wasn't the referee who lost Everton the game, it was a lack of personnel (finance), poor tactics (manager) and, worst of all, a lack of application on the field. Stoke wanted it more than Everton which is the fault of the manager. I'm not anti Moyes. I don't want him to go but I want more than he and his players delivered on Sunday.
Tony J Williams
189 Posted 05/12/2011 at 15:02:44
Danny, there were so many shouts of "play it through the fecking middle, you dozy twats" in the Lower Gwladys.

They had the two giants at the back and we had the midget gems in midfield... 2 + 2 = ? Get at them in the middle, have a shot.

The ref was a joke but the manager and the players got it wrong yesterday. Bad tactics and woeful passing did us in.

Baines had one of his worst games for some time and Fellaini must be wondering why he agreed to sign his contract after his teammates not putting any kind of shift in. (The dosh probably helps him relax though...)
Tom Hughes
190 Posted 05/12/2011 at 15:23:18
According to a poster on another site...... Apparently our net spend over the past 5 years is approx £200k per yr, whereas mighty Stoke's is £12m per yr......... this despite our turnover being substantially higher than theirs.

If that's correct they have spent 60 times what moyes has. I'm surprised that we are even in the same league. That's our lot while the current ownership is in place and very little to do with anything Moyes can do.
Peter Laing
191 Posted 05/12/2011 at 15:45:38
In answer to Richard Dodd @162 'ever the optimist', did anyone ever remind you that the season begins in August not January. I'm glad that your 'source' has cheered you up and got you gloating about the prospect of the cavalry being just around the corner. Please ask your 'source' to have a word with Bill Kenwright and ask him to answer honestly why we have to endure his reckless stewardship and perennial poor start to the season due to the lack of support afforded to the Manager. But oh I forgot I suppose Bill will be unavailable as he and Bobby Elstone give the next assorted bag of potential investors the grand tour around Goodison Park hiding the safety certificate as he goes.
Tony J Williams
192 Posted 05/12/2011 at 15:53:13
Tom, the manager has to take his share of the blame too. The issue I have on this site is that the players seemingly get a free ride.

If they play badly, it's Moyes fault for not motivating them enough???

There are so many player apologists on here. Baines had a stinker but yet someone had a go at Hibbert. Probably our best defender on the day,

It's strange that in a match in which they score from their only real shot that hibbert gets blamed for a poor performance......where do the goal come from, right in the middle of the D. 11 back, whose watching the D? Surely the forward or a midfielder....definitely not the right back.
Steavey Buckley
193 Posted 05/12/2011 at 16:55:50
That was one of the most inept performances I have witnessed all season. Not just by the referee, but by the whole Everton team. According to one analysis report, Everton did not have one shot on goal. At present, Everton have nobody who can be regarded as a striker.

This is going to be a cold and hard season, not just because of the weather, but a lack of attacking options.
Mike Green
194 Posted 05/12/2011 at 17:23:23
So - we cant compete with City because their players cost so much money, because they are such good players.

One of them they bought for over £20m, a centre half, there's no way on earth we could afford a player of that calibre so how can we compete....?! Oh, hello.... we had exactly that player for a few seasons before...... and he cost us £5m..... oh.

I think we can compete but without the money we just have to work a damn site harder at closing the gap - and the board have to work a damn sight harder trying to raise the funds to close it too.

If it is all about bank balances why bother fucking turning up at all. Lets shut the club down for good, its totally pointless after all.
James McPherson
195 Posted 05/12/2011 at 17:25:03
Tony J Williams,

Bit of groundhog day for you an I here Tony...but here goes!

Yes totally agree, some posters seem to turn a blind eye to player responsibility on this site - they too have to share some of the blame. And yes, once they cross the white line, Moyes in many ways is limited.
It beggars belief that so many passes are placed behind a man, fired into to the collarbone area whilst marked etc etc...however, so many of our passes are made more difficult by the lack of movement and finding space..now that can be coached surely?

My main point however is (once again) Moyes' lack of personal motivation is now impacting upon matters on the pitch. We agreed last time that a key element of any successful manager is to motivate and inspire people (whatever walk of life). This is patently not happening. Worse still, given his now ritual pre-match dampening Moyes' is indifferent to even consider the effect he's having - else why does he perpetually put the players down?

This is why he has to go. I understand him having had enough. But he CANNOT continue to take the salary and gripe.

Do you agree on that?
Anthony Jones
196 Posted 05/12/2011 at 17:41:36
Christ almighty.

Having a relatively small budget and playing progressive, attacking football are not mutually exclusive.

It is perfectly reasonable to hold Moyes to account as the manager of one of the top clubs in the country, regardless of whether he has constraints to work within.

Moreover, he doesn't have "no money" as so many detractors point out. Fellaini has just signed a contract for over £60,000 a week, and he cost close to £15 million. If that's "no money" then the drinks are on you.
Jimmy Sørheim
197 Posted 05/12/2011 at 18:40:00
Bill and Moyes, Dumb, and Dumber.
Start a protest and get them both out.
Moyes first please.
Ian Tunstead
198 Posted 05/12/2011 at 19:27:31
Jimmy does that mean you prefer Bill to Moyes? You must be insane if you think fans will be protesting to get Moyes out any time soon. But if you are so passionate why dont you lead the march?
Brian Alexander
199 Posted 05/12/2011 at 19:43:48
John Keatind #141.............Ahh i get you John, less of the prick please John, my 8 pint intake has to be allowed for, cheer's.
Paul Wharton
200 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:36:33
Any manager who consistently picks Tony Hibbert in front of the likes of Heitinga is either smoking something very dodgy or has completely lost the plot.

Also we're nowhere near fit enough, Barcelona set the standard for fitness and they can also play a bit. Ginger ought to get them down training at St Helens Rugby League for a couple of weeks, Might toughen them up too.
Denis Byrne
201 Posted 05/12/2011 at 21:30:58
Sad to say that my admiration for the ginger one has faded and now gone for good. His approach to motivation is appalling, he has created a deep sense of low aspiration and gloom, and that in itself is despicable.

His video to the FA on Everton's 'non'-penalty decisions has backfired horribly, and it is plain we are being shafted by the custodians of the law. Moyes out, Big Dunc as caretaker, Bilic in after the Euro's. Everton forever.
Dave Rice
202 Posted 06/12/2011 at 13:29:19
Perfect time to gib Moyes now - Steve Bruce is available.

As is, as far as I know, Peter Reid.

And I'm sure we could tempt Big Sam from the Irons.

Just a sickener that Martin O'Neill is off the market.

Mick Davies
203 Posted 07/12/2011 at 01:46:00
Tony J Williams said 'We were even called the Merseyside Millionnaires in the 80s because we could tempt the best players to come and play for us for a hefty wage'. We were called the mersey millionaires in the 60's. The players who pulled us out of the shit and on the road to success in the early 80's were not signed for mega bucks. Southall, from Bury for £150,000. Stevens, youth player, free. Mountfield, from Tranmere for £30,000. Reid from Bolton for £60,000. Sheedy from Liverpool reserves for £100,000. Steven, Burnley £300,000. Ratcliffe, youth player, free. Sharp, Dumbarton £120,000. Gray £250,000. All these players hardly bank breakers, yet the hungry ambitious manager at the time turned them into Europes greatest team. How? With a determination to win, not to avoid defeat, by training them and coaching the right tactics and belief in their own abilities. Everton were in a similar position then as now, but a new man turned it around in just 3 years. Moyes has had ten and if the only reason he's still at the club is because 'No one else would come here' then why is he so highly paid?
Tom Hughes
204 Posted 07/12/2011 at 09:29:55
Mick,
While there were a fair few bargains in the 80's side...... £300k was a fair amount back then, and I think inchy was even more. The main difference now being that we can't even afford 80's prices nowadays....... we can't afford ANYTHING, and that despite offloading approx £20m worth. Whilst Moyes might be guilty of not rebelling against these sanctions..... he is not the cause of them! I have no idea if he will ever be the bringer of great footy. I think we have seen some good stuff during his tenure but I think it has always been one step fwd followed by the inevitable one backwards.... and more recently 3 or 4 reverse steps. I think it is most important for us not to lose track of the fundamental causes of our decline. We can barely field a full side let alone a balanced and talented one..... and I don't believe that is Moyes' fault.
Mick Davies
205 Posted 08/12/2011 at 02:43:43
Tom, I agree these prices weren't the lowest but remember, Trevor Francis had gone for £1.2m in 1979 and Brian Robson for £1.5m in 1981 so we weren't in the top bracket by any means with crocks like Reid and Gray.

Moyes has had big money and even admits if he needs funds he can get them from the supportive board, but, and these are his words, "there's no-one out there better than what we've got for a fair price". Well if he can't find a better right back than Hibbert for a decent price in 10 years, then he's not the right man for the job.

Jacobsen had to replace Hibbert in the most important game of the last 15 years because he was totally outclassed at Wembley. Jacobsen nullified the threat and we looked a lot better, though the damage was already done. What did our astute manager do? Got rid of Jaco and kept the man who wasn't fit to lace his boots. That is just one reason I want rid of Moyes.

10 years and we're back where we started. If 10th place is good enough for most on here, then I think they'd better wake up and remember we are not QPR, Swansea or Barnsley... WE ARE EVERTON, and only the best performance is good enough, or heads roll.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads