Drenthe goes from hero to villain

, 3 March, 126comments  |  Jump to most recent
Queens Park Rangers 1 - 1 Everton

Match Summary

No Jack Rodwell but at least Nikica Jelavic and Leon Osman were deemed fit enough to sit on the bench, with Neville and Cahill preferred. Drenthe and Pienaar on the wings to hopefully provide width and creativity as Everton continue without the mercurial inspiration provided by Landon Donovan's all-too-brief visitation.

Tim Cahill smashed one off the bar in the fourth minute, from an excellent header played back by Fellaini at the near post off a Neville throw. Everton had the first corner but it was defended away and the blues had to be alert at the other end as QPR responded with a corner of their own.

A soft Drenthe foul led to a good delivery that was thankfully behind the QPR attacker as the hosts kept getting in behind the Everton defence. Drenthe got to put in a free-kick of his own but it was very poorly executed; however, he won one on the other side that Baines put in well.

Wright-Phillips got clipped and Kevin Friend gave QPR a dangerous free-kick that forced a tremendous save off Buzsaky's curling effort. A far better effort from Drenthe found Heitinga on the far post and it was harder not to score, but the Dutchman failed to wrap his boot around it from 2 feet out, and he then completely wasted a free-kick from the half-way line. Pienaar's deflected cross forced a tip-over from Kenney resulting in a good corner from Baines.

Wright-Phillips got behind a couple of good attempts and failed but Drenthe showed hin how it was done from well outside the area, a tremendous shot from a good layoff by Pienaar, and an excellent Everton goal.

At the other end, danger was only just averted as another dangerous free-kick careened off the wall and seemed headed to the opposite side of Howard's goal and just over.

But it was hero to zero for Drenthe, making a poor tackle that got him booked and gave QPR yet another free-kick which was delivered well and Zamora got the final touch with Howard perhaps standing too far back.

Then Everton won a dangerous kick of their own that was delayed by the antics of a squirrel on the pitch! Enough to put off Drenthe who drove his kick into the wall. Pienaar made a tremendous run and fed Fellaini whose brilliant cut-back El Traca just failed to convert.

QPR then got behind the Everton defence yet again and manged to hit both posts in an attack that incredibly failed to put then ahead, while at the other end Fellaini seemed to conjour a good chance but could not convert. But a pretty entertaining game with lost of goalmouth action at both ends!

Fellaini should have done better when gifted the ball but he looked for a pass rather than pressing the QPR goal. Some good possession football from Everton on occasions but it only led down cul-de-sacs. They failed to get a grip on the game as the hour-mark passed and Howard had to punch away another corner, while the appearance of Nikica Jelavic from the subs' bench was accompanied by Leon Osman, replacing Drenthe and Cahill.

Jelavic looked to get involved at every opportunity but nothing was coming off, while Buzsaky had a poke form 25 yards that went over for QPR, and Taarabt drove across Howard's goal but past the far post. The changes were meant to enliven a flagging Everton side but it was QPR who got the bit between their teeth while the Blues were far too lackadaisical when they did gain possession from the marauding Rangers.

Osman won a dangerous free-kick off Wright-Phillips that Baines swung in but Fellaini was offside in the follow-up. Pienaar and Baines were doing their best down the left but QPR were holding firm and effectively denying them space and usually preventing a telling final ball to the pair of big strikers,Jelavic and El traca, showing signs of starvation in the middle.

Into the final 15 mins and this one could go either way, with both teams fighting and scrapping to gain the ascendancy. A bizarre free-kick from Buzsaky saw him scoop the ball high over Howard's goal from a standing position...

Moyes seemed to call it quits with 2 mins left, swapping Stracqualursi for Coleman in an admission that this attempt at 4-4-2 had failed to yield the required end product in a disappointing second half for Blues fans. Fellaini did get a shot on Kenney but play was pulled back. Jelavic tried to dribble through but couldn't as a late Everton corner came to nothing.

An eight-game unbeaten run for Everton but no revenge for that dreadful opening loss at Goodison Park.

Everton: Howard; Hibbert, Heitinga, Distin, Baines; Drenthe (62' Osman), Neville, Fellaini, Pienaar; Cahill (62' Jelavic); Stracqualursi (88' Coleman).
Subs: Mucha, Jagielka, Gueye, Barkley.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (126)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Richard Carton
2 Posted 03/03/2012 at 15:57:42
Neville to be replaced with either Barley or Jelavic, need to give these guys some gametime and Neville has done nothing to makeour defense secure in the 1st half.
Dan Schweizer
3 Posted 03/03/2012 at 16:55:35
I can't pick one player who played well in that game. Totally outplayed by QPR very frustrating to say the least.
Ernie Baywood
4 Posted 03/03/2012 at 16:58:58
I thought players coming back was supposed to make us stronger.

So how did we end up with Osman and Neville in midfield.

MOTM - Cyril
Stan Blood
5 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:03:47
Dreadful performance all around, once again struggling against lower league opposition.

442 an absolute disaster... but why wait til the last 2 minutes to bring Coleman on??
Phil McKeown
6 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:16:15
Shite .

Formation , style of play and loyalty to certain players not maximising our potential .

Time for Neville and cahill to take a back seat , were too one dimensional at times with no pace except for drenthe who should have stayed on for me as he is an outlet and can win games out of nothing .

Neville should have come off , another unhappy Saturday night . Wigan all over again
Phil McKeown
7 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:19:14
Ps

Tim howard flaps at another cross
Tom Bowers
8 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:16:28
I said here yesterday this would be a tricky game and so it proved. We can get the lead against the likes of City and Chelski and hold on but crap like QPR can peg us back and then outplay us.

Always happens, does it not?

If we win the derby match, we can be right behind the Redshite for the run-in but Moyes needs to get brave and start Jelavic and Straqs from the off but please keep Osman on the bench.

Let's see more of Barkley now.
John Crawley
9 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:23:05
Was it just me or did anybody else think that the wall for the free kick they scored from was very poor. Firstly Hibbert wasn't even in line with the ball and secondly surely there should have been two men in it?
James Martin
10 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:26:59
Osman should have come on in the middle, not his fault that Moys continues to think he's a better wide option than Gueye or Coleman. Fellaini and Neville were the reasons we lost, 2 up front and they didn't see the ball because those two held hands with the centrebacks all game and didn't win any second balls. They're so slow on the ball.

I'm sick of seeing Fellaini bringing it out of defence at walking pace before taking 2 hours just to roll it a yard sideways. The pair of them have no urgency, Fellaini is good in games were all he has to do is defend but again, like against Wigan, when we need attacking verve, he supplies nothing.
Luke O'Farrell
11 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:26:38
Can't blame Drenthe for their goal. Yes, it was a rash tackle but what followed was poor goalkeeping by Howard.

Neville offers nothing going forward or on the ball but we all know that anyway. However, he now offers nothing defensively; he doesn't mark up or close down.

Being a good leader is no longer a good enough reason for him to start, he has to be benched. He is more hinderence than help, these days.

Our problem, throughout, was poor ball retention and none of the changes did anything to alter that fact. Poor subs by Moyes, today. Overall, it felt like our lack of intent cost us. We only woke up, second half, when the injury time kicked in.

All things considered, we were fortunate to get a point so that is a bonus but we must improve against Spurs. Once again, we fail to deliver against the lesser lights and save our best days for the bigger teams. Heitinga MotM; one of the few who turned up.
Tony Twist
12 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:21:57
I am sure Moyes rubs his hands with glee when he on sufferance converts to 4-4-2 for part of a match and it fails. He needs to involve players like Barkley in the side as they try something new.

These types of opposition, even away from home, should be there for the taking ? not putting us under pressure and leaving us unable to create openings to score. Not good enough, Moyes.
John Crawley
13 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:31:10
We had three players centrally Neville, Fellaini & Cahill who have very little creativity and not one of them can play a ball to split a defence. I would have liked to have seen Pienaar moved into the middle where he would have had more space and time. It is inexplicable to me why Moyes is persisting with Neville & Cahill, two players who have played poorly all season in midfield.

We shouldn't forget Gueye who I thought played very well against Blackpool and who didn't get a look in today. He could have been brought on and Pienaar moved into the middle. There were options on the bench to change tactics and play a bit differently but they were not chosen.
Gavin Ramejkis
14 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:47:31
Neville nearly gifted Taarabt a goal with sloppy footwork, the shot Taarabt screwed wide and was smugly celebrating with his arms in the air, the midfield was piss poor today and when Moyes finally switched to 4-4-2 it was still being over ran on too many occasions.
CiarĂ¡n McGlone
15 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:47:07
Can someone please explain the reasoning behind replacing Drenthe with Osman?
Jamie Barlow
16 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:38:28
As well as the usual shite (Neville), too many players failed to turn up again today.

Baines and Pienaar had their worst game together since I can remember and I don't know what to make of Drenthe. It seems a lot of people like to watch him to see the moment of brilliance that we know he can do. I can't stand it. It drives me mad. It's no wonder he couldn't get a game at Madrid and it seems only us were interested in him.

Denis and Cahill didn't get a sniff after Cahill hit the bar and were starved of service for 90 minutes.

The defense looked as shaky as I've seen for quite a while and Howard flapped again for their goal.

All in all, a lazy, lackluster performance from a load of overpaid shite, again.
James Stewart
17 Posted 03/03/2012 at 17:53:39
Rather gutterpress headline I have to say. Yes Drenthe gave away a free kick but I fail to see how that makes him "hero to zero".

More costly mistakes from Howard and sloppy play all round. Once again no risk no reward.
Dan Schweizer
18 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:09:20
I think we need a keeper for lower table opposition. Howard just doesn't concentrate enough in these games. Having said that, everything was poor... Hoofball, to which not one of those balls was won, they then got the ball to which they attack. Repeat and we have Everton's poor performance.

The fact Drenthe scored a goal to me was a miracle as, even him playing poor, he was head and shoulders above everyone else, not an easy feat for him!

I'll get my coat!
Richard Carton
19 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:06:29
Moyes should tear them a new arsehole.... That was not good enough, just lacklustre really, no excuse for it.

I watched Liverpool's game and they press and hustle so much more than us, they don't give the opposition time on the ball. I think we are guilty of giving opposition too much time...

For christ's sake, squeeze them, harry them, they are QPR not Barcelona!!! We used to do that so well in Moyes's early days, this is what we are lacking.
Andy Crooks
20 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:10:24
Back to normal again. As soon as Moyes has options he reverts to the old favourites Neville and Cahill have been great servants to Everton but both are finished as 90 minute players. If there is any viable alternative neither should start again.

Still, the unbeaten run continues and there is still the cup. However, David Moyes still gets massive credit and I still believe that we have dropped too many winnable points this season for him to be as safe as he obviously is. Sorry, I forgot the Everton mantra;"be careful what you wish for".
Liam Appleby
21 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:16:20
I thought we played well first half where the ball was played mostly in their half. Second half wasn't great. But I still felt that we more likely to get the winner.

Fellaini dominated the midfield. I lost count how many times he nicked the ball off their players. It's a shame we didn't get the win, but a point is better than none... and the run continues.

We have some big games coming up over March... which will determine our season both in the cup and league. Hopefully today was just a minor blip.
Brian Waring
22 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:25:25
Just back from the game, and well cheesed off, that was piss poor today.

Liam, not being funny mate, but don't know what game you were watching, because I wouldn't say we looked the more likely to get a winner. Also, Fellaini was lucky not to have given a pen away, when he was climbing all over one of the QPR lads.
Brian Hill
23 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:22:44
Staggeringly bad. Apart from the goal, and Cahill's early effort, we created nothing against a team that is beyond mediocre. We had no imagination, no inspiration, no evident desire. It was embarrassing to watch an Everton team display such ineptitude ? what on Earth do the coaches tell them all week? Please, nobody defend such garbage.
Tony Cheek
24 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:19:07
Just to prove once more that Moyes is a "back to the wall " manager, who can get points when no one expects them when he has few options. As soon as he has to make choices it goes pear shaped and he ends up making all the wrong decisions.

He has to stop being so bleeding "loyal" to his long serving old boys and start using what he has got.

We have no longer got Arteta in midfield, but there are other creative options.......NEVILLE AND OSMAN are not amongst them!!
Barry Rathbone
25 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:27:21
This is Moyes's Everton ? an unfathomable lethargy where people go through the motions, players recently thundering around with purpose and energy strolling ? how many times have we seen this? Motivated? Don't make me laugh

The opportunity at one-nil to break a newly promoted side flirting with relegation, nervous because of their appalling home record, completely missed. It is unprofessional and the absolute hallmark of this "holiday camp" of a football club Moyes presides over.

MK's "lottery football" describes exactly what happens, if the wind is blowing the right way, we play at near 100%; if not, we saunter at 70% ? entirely the manager's making.
Mark Stone
27 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:53:19
'I am sure moyes rubs his hands with glee when he on sufferance converts to 4-4-2 for part of a match and it fails.'

Bet you he fucking doesn't.
Paul Doyle
28 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:58:32
No matter what, Moyes has to weld Cahill, Neville and Osman into the format, no matter what...

When is this arsehole ever going to learn???
Jon Cox
29 Posted 03/03/2012 at 18:15:10
It's really frustrating. Every time the shite screw up and gives us a chance to gain ground we always fail to take it.

An abysmal second half and when will Moyes work it out that Pip is now at best only a squad player.

Today was a great chance to play Berkley instead of Neville, at least for the second half.

No creativity in mid-field yet again did for us. Whatever the shortcomings of Drenthe at least he shows a bit of spirit that was sadly lacking in most of the other players.

To get into Europe we're going to need a lot more consistency and continuity to our overall game. It's not a whinge by the way, just an observation.
Phil McKeown
30 Posted 03/03/2012 at 19:15:52
Zingari league tactics
Peter Mills
31 Posted 03/03/2012 at 19:23:14
I hate criticising anything to do with Everton (although I do moan quite a lot about them). But I have to agree with Barry Rathbone here. 1-0 up against very shaky opposition - go and batter them.

On a separate issue - Richard Dodd, treasure your dad, and get him to explain to you what it was like watching those players. He sounds a top man.
Anthony Jones
32 Posted 03/03/2012 at 19:55:25
When we beat City and Chelsea hordes of morons came on here and mocked the Moyes critics: "Where are you now?" etc. Well, what a shocker today... desrved to be beaten and devoid of midfield control with yet another axis of boredom central trio in Pip ? the forever napping and tweeting donkey; Cahill ? the legend that fades with every match; and Fellaini ? the ball winner.

Where is the vision and pace? It's all on the fucking bench, again.
Gavin Ramejkis
33 Posted 03/03/2012 at 20:28:05
Thats the real rub Anthony, you can guarantee Everton will break your heart, today was another Jekyll and Hyde orchestrated by Moyes; today we had the shite version.
Richard O'Shea
34 Posted 03/03/2012 at 20:39:51
Well, that result today makes qualifying for the Europa Cup via league position look unlikely now. I say time to prioritise our next few games; rest players in the league games between the Sunderland game and make sure we beat Sunderland ? it is FA Cup or bust.
Matt Traynor
35 Posted 03/03/2012 at 20:36:19
After the amusement of seeing "8 mins" go up at Anfield, to the expectancy of them getting a late winner... haha

On to what was a frustrating game. Slow at the start, took some control, 1-0 up but quickly back on parity and fuck me backwards we were lucky to walk off with a point.

General observations:
- Surprised Drenthe started (I wanted him to, didn't think he would) - I make that 4 goals, all pearlers
- Pienaar - enjoying his football again after 12 months of better wages and zero gametime
- Fellaini - I just don't see it with this guy. Good harassing for the build up to our goal, but normally that'd be another foul

For them:
- Zamora - revenge for his missing an open goal for Fulham earlier this season, but where was the marking?
- Their chairman sitting with the fans. Go on Bill, go sit in the Park End for a match

Referee - very inconsistent for both I thought. Guess that perversely makes his performance ok.
Roman Sidey
36 Posted 03/03/2012 at 20:42:49
I actually fell asleep at 0-0 and woke up about three hours after the end, as it was such a shit game.

Once again though, Everton playing teams out of relegation.

34 points from 26 games - we should be so lucky.

Moyes, fuck off.
Trevor Lynes
37 Posted 03/03/2012 at 21:01:33
Don't take the piss out of Liverpool for losing to Arsenal... they at least played better football than we did in scrambling a very lucky draw at QPR. Concentrate on our team's lack of ability and don't be satisfied with what failings Liverpool have.

I cannot understand Cahill and Neville being played from the off, it smacks of survival rather than winning away. DM was obviously looking for a draw or a one-goal win with the set-up he started with.

Jelavic will probably start at home and I just hope that his goal scoring ability is not stifled by playing him with Cahill. We MUST start giving one or two of our youngsters a chance and leave Neville and Cahill on the bench... we need a breath of fresh air and a change from the spoiling tactics we seem to use in every game.
Wayne Smyth
38 Posted 03/03/2012 at 21:41:57
I thought some of the players played ok. Fellaini looked good, as did Pienaar. Drenthe did well, but given his pace and impact behind the striker for the goal, you'd think Moyes would play him up there more regularly and tell him NOT to track back.

Drenthe plays at 100 mph and isn't a great defender, so why force him to defend? Moyes must know he'll conceed freekicks.

Put him on the halfway line when the opposition have the ball and only ask him to do any closing down well outside our own area.

QPR do have some decent players, but I'll agree with everyone else that Neville in midfield is just asking to lose. He creates nothing, he doesn't close down, he can't pass forwards and his first instinct whenever he has the ball is to pass it back, or 3 yds sideways.

Matt; I'm disappointed you'd have a go at Fellaini for the work he does. He's hamstrung in part by his appearance which singles him out and part by his first season when he got his reputation for getting sent off with clumsy challenges and frustrations which probably came in part from language issues.

He did excellent work today; according to the stats he covered more ground than anyone in our side and set up Drenthe and all you can do is snipe? Wow.
Michael Winstanley
39 Posted 03/03/2012 at 21:44:19
Neville started in midfield so I knew it wasn't going to be easy on the eye. I watched the first half and thought we passed it better than them and on occasion looked good without really creating anything. There was a spell where we had players running all over the park and the ball was being passed and kept really well... shame it lasted for only 10mins.

Could've,should've, didn't.

Where was the passion and desire today?
Matt Traynor
40 Posted 03/03/2012 at 22:34:50
Wayne (141) fair comeback, and maybe I'm being harsh. I'm only speaking as a passive observer, but I do feel there's a good player in there, but he's not yet shown it.

? He's clearly got the ability to read a game, can pick a pass
? He appears slow, but when in possession he's surveying what's in front of him, and in this Everton side, that takes time! I agree he's not languid...

I do think part of his problem is not having a settled position. From what I've seen of him, I think he's best played as a defensive midfielder. Not advanced, and certainly not a striker.

He had a tough first season and a half through discipline (some of it self-inflicted) and injury. Everton fans are remarkably patient. I may have been harsh on him today, but I still am waiting to see the player others promise us he is.
Brian Waring
41 Posted 03/03/2012 at 22:42:31
Matt, you're spot on mate, I'm still waiting to see this top quality player that others seem to see. I've seen glimpses of what he could become, but for the length of time he has been here, glimpses aren't enough.

Wayne, Fellaini was non-existent in the first-half, was better in the second, but nothing special, also he was lucky not to give a blatant pen away.
John Ford
42 Posted 03/03/2012 at 23:27:26
I thought Fellaini was the only good point from today. He broke QPR down on numerous occasions, set all out attacks in motion and was again doing the work of two. Neville was basically absent with Fellaini was once again perpetual motion, contantly putting the oppo under pressure.

Its interesting to hear opposing views on this, but for me without him we have nil going on in centre midfield. He has the capacity to dominate games and in a team of limited ability he stands out, and does so repeatedly.
Noel Lynam
43 Posted 03/03/2012 at 23:33:35
Agree with James @ 094,

Presumably Fellaini and Distin are also "zero" for giving away soft free kicks, except in much more dangerous positions which we were lucky not to concede from.

As for Ciaran McGlone's question, that's for Osman to get some match practice before Moyes inevitably starts him in place of Drenthe vs Spurs next week ? presumably to use his pace and athleticism to counter the threat of Bale down our right.
Phil Brown
44 Posted 03/03/2012 at 23:41:04
FELLANI: quite simply the best defensive midfielder in the Premier league; exactly what both Man Utd and Chelski are missing.
Matt Traynor
45 Posted 03/03/2012 at 23:44:58
I want Everton to sign Drenthe. We're told there's "a deal in place" if Moyes decides to take it up - technically he's free, and could sign for anyone at anytime.

I watched MOTD just now, and was heartened that for at least the 2nd time, "Ricky" was put in front of the interviewer.

Clutching at straws, yep!
Noel Lynam
48 Posted 04/03/2012 at 00:04:45
Matt @ 151,

I was less heartened by Drenthe's celebration, when Moyes appeared to not even look at him while he ran to the bench. Hopefully a second look tomorrow will show I picked that up wrongly.
David Hallwood
49 Posted 04/03/2012 at 00:29:11
Drenthe is the heir apparent to Duncan McKenzie; frustrating and exciting in equal measure. Put him on the pitch where he can do his stuff he will either fall over his own feet or score a screamer.

If I was the manager he would be the first name on the teamsheet, because he is a gamechanger, and completely the opposite of the 'designed by committee' that so many footballers look like these days.
Derek Thomas
51 Posted 04/03/2012 at 01:12:06
Drenthe; If you play him, don't make him defend, he's a liablity.

Neville brings minus nothing to the team, should never play again unless we only have 9 outfield players (and I've forgot me boots).

Baines and Pienaar, not much interaction there as Pienaar was CM for most of the game.

Cahill nominally upfront but spent a lot of time with Fellaini and Neville infront of the back 4, but hasn't got the legs to do the box to box all the game (not many have).

Gibson (yes I know he didn't play) ? coincicdence we were poor in MF? Or was that due to Neville... maybe a bit of both.

Stracq; what is Spanish for flogging ze dead 'orse due to lack of service?

Somewhat proves my point about NOT trying to defend a 1-0 lead.
Anto Byrne
52 Posted 04/03/2012 at 02:55:54
In the words of Shankly, the best team drew. It seems as though Mark Hughes has got QPR playing like Moyes's Everton, all huff and puff.

Can't understand playing Cahill and Neville when over 90 minutes they contributed very little. The squirell looked a better option for us at least he was not back defending patiently sitting on the half-way line. The squirrel hares down the wing crossing for the El Traca to nod home.
Peter Barry
53 Posted 04/03/2012 at 03:03:31
Same old same old from a Dour Defensive Depressing Everton. The only way to change it is to change the man who chooses the team, the man who chooses the substitutes and when to insert them, the man who decides the Team Tactics and the man who cannot motivate them.

Now who could that possibly be? ? I'll give you a clue: it's not Kenwright.
Mick Davies
54 Posted 04/03/2012 at 03:53:23
Agree with most of the above but have to point out one thing here: the lack of criticism for Hibbert. Neville is getting pounded but he was helping our supposed right back out most of the time. He is better in that position than Hibbert and shouldn't be playing in midfield ? that's down to the manager who wants an eight-man defence. Ideally Coleman would be given a run at right back as it's been proven that Hibbert is shite going forward and the Baines-Pienaar partnership is our most creative outlet.

If Moyes wants to play Fellaini, Neville and Gibson in the middle of the park, it is a cowardly defensive midfield and to counter this with an offensive right side, it should be Coleman & Drenthe giving the opposition something to worry about. Cahill is burnt out, Osman not good enough, Hibbert? Nuff said... and Neville should not be in midfield. But I doubt if we'll ever change the stubborn one. Bye to Barkley, Bidwell, Duffy, Rodwell etc. as they don't stand a chance.
WT Looi
55 Posted 04/03/2012 at 04:10:59
My thoughts on the game:

I thought the defending for the free-kick conceded was rather questionable, anyone feel the same? There was no wall in front of Taarabt, everyone was marking zones in front of goal. As a result Taarabt had a good view to deliver a wicked whipped ball at a good height to the near post. I believe the Stracq was taking care of the zone and lost his man, but Howard really should organise his wall better. It's part of keeper's craft that, building a good wall!

Thought we just weren't good enough on the day, defensively in terms of mobility and closing down, and offensively in terms of movement, guile and obviously, passing. QPR basically showed us up with athletic, skilful players who can control the ball in tight areas, shake of their markers and execute simple pass-and-moves, coupled with take-no-prisoners, gutsy defenders in the form of Hill, Ferdinand and Derry.

In contrast, players like Neville ? who looked way off the pace ? and Hibbert looked so one-dimensional that it was hard to believe these players had decades of top-flight experience between them. Besides trapping the ball and looking to release a player either 5 yards or 50 yards away, they simply weren't capable of doing anything else. I'll cheer their tackles as loud as the next Blue, but these are the games where they are found out, so given the options in midfield it's strange others were not given a run-out. Thought Coleman did well when he came on, he really provided a good outlet with his movement and willingness to take people on.

And as to why the Baines-Pienaar dynamite didn't quite set off at any point in the game, I think it's quite clear that any opposition manager worth their salt will make plans to curb our main attacking outlets. Onouha and SWP had pace and industry to burn and this seemed just one of the days for Baines and Pienaar, who looked ponderous and one-paced in comparison. Especially for Baines, perhaps still feeling the effects of his England start, his deliveries weren't to their usual standard.

Oh well, rant over, at least we didn't lose the match! Count ourselves lucky that this Beckham wannabe Buzsaky fella, who really fancies himself with the direct free-kicks and long range efforts ? but couldn't do a simple tap-in on target, twice!
Roman Sidey
56 Posted 04/03/2012 at 04:38:01
Glad you mentioned Hibbert, Mick. The guy's cactus. Drenthe cops it because he concedes a free kick that they score off. Okay, so how come Hibbert never copped the same stick off the manager in public when he was conceding penalties every other game? Forgetting the fact that defending is his primary objective, whereas it is an extra duty for an attacking midfielder like Drenthe.
Ernie Baywood
57 Posted 04/03/2012 at 05:37:33
I feel for Hibbert. He's bog standard. Out and out defender. No-one pretends he's anything else. He's made his career out of it.

For a couple of months he's looked alright. Then you see him playing with Osman and Neville and he gets to made to look like a mug again.

Unless you have mega money you'll always have the odd average footballer in the side. It's when those average footballers outnumber the good footballers that you really see how average they are.
Eric Myles
58 Posted 04/03/2012 at 06:41:19
Roman "how come Hibbert never copped the same stick off the manager in public when he was conceding penalties every other game?"

Can you remind us when that was?
Graham Mockford
59 Posted 04/03/2012 at 08:19:27
Peter Barry you are nothing if not predictable. Same old same old as say City or Chelsea or Fulham?That's eight games unbeaten, quarter final to come.
I'm used to reading the utter shite you continue to post so I shouldn't be surprised. You question Moyes selection and substitutions. What would you have done different? No don't bother because it will whine on about playing Phil Neville. Maybe we should have gone 2-3-5! And who exactly in yesterday's team was not motivated?
Tony J Williams
61 Posted 04/03/2012 at 08:57:55
"so how come Hibbert never copped the same stick off the manager in public when he was conceding penalties every other game?" - My bullshit detector has just exploded
Sam Hoare
62 Posted 04/03/2012 at 08:45:54
Think we missed Gibson but a point away at a team with decent players and some real fire in their belly is not the end of the world.

Obviously the performance was down on recent weeks but that's what happens when Neville moves into cm and not sure who else he could have played with osman and rodwell not yet fully fit
Peter Barry
63 Posted 04/03/2012 at 09:27:48
@Graham Mockford #194 ? Strange Graham when what I say is proved true time and time again and is not "shite' as you so crudely put it.

Davey Boy can't get the team motivated enough to defeat the teams at the bottom of the table. It was QPR for God's sake ? a team that hasn't won a home game in 8. But then again it's fools like you who blindly swallow Davey's excuses and put up with him putting out a team that has given us nothing but DROSS all season with the VERY very occasional wins.

But I don't need even one hand to count the ENJOYABLE entertaining games Davey Boy and his tactics have provided the long suffering Everton supporters this season.
Steavey Buckley
64 Posted 04/03/2012 at 09:29:33
The goal conceded yesterday was coming. The opposition now target Howard as a weak link when it comes to crosses, free kicks and corners. They now have a player next to Howard when there is a corner after his howlers against the likes of Kuyt, who stood next to him when a corner was taken and was able to bungle the ball over the line at the derby match at Anfield a few seasons back.
Steavey Buckley
65 Posted 04/03/2012 at 09:29:33
The goal conceded yesterday was coming. The opposition now target Howard as a weak link when it comes to crosses, free kicks and corners. They now have a player next to Howard when there is a corner after his howlers against the likes of Kuyt, who stood next to him when a corner was taken and was able to bungle the ball over the line at the derby match at Anfield a few seasons back.
Mark Stone
66 Posted 04/03/2012 at 09:35:13
. What a fucking strike (again) by Drenthe, hey? It's so difficult to break teams down in the PL these days. You really do need a player who can do that. It's something we've never really had (ok Bily and Jimmiy Mc occasionally but not often enough and in relation to the rest of their game ...). In Gibson and Drenthe we have 2 now. Really hope we get him signed up.
Dick Fearon
67 Posted 04/03/2012 at 09:36:49
The usual whingers about Cahill yet after Osman came on QPR passed through our midfield like a dose of salts.
Knowing that Timmy is yet to reach full match fitness it was odds on he would be replaced.
Our bench contained some interesting options then I saw Osman getting the usual ten minute list of instructions and my heart sank.
Dear god I groaned, no no no! not him, anyone bar him.
Why can't Moyes see the gaping hole created by his pet?
Nick Entwistle
68 Posted 04/03/2012 at 09:54:24
Just shows how important Gibson is to the team, anything but Fallaini and Gibson and it all breaks down.
Jelevic looks eager and capable and could soon take Cahill's role.

Best team... ?

Howard
Neville Heitinga Distin Bains
Drenthe Fallaini Gibson Pienaar
Jelevic
Stracq
Martin Mason
69 Posted 04/03/2012 at 10:11:48
I didn't see the game at all so I can't comment and I did believe that we would struggle but I must say thaat the result was disappointing especially after going ahead. Moyes has a chance now to experiment and yet he starts with Neville and Tim and later brings Osman on. It may be that losing both Gibson and Donovan from what had started to look a decent side was a big handicap but still a disappointing result to those like me who saw the mmakings of better things.
Sam Hoare
70 Posted 04/03/2012 at 10:14:18
Agreed Nick. Who would have thought that Gibson would be the lynchpin?!

Think Rodwell could probably do a decent job in their when he's back or maybe even this Francisco Junior lad but not Neville and not Osman.

Am sure people would champion Barkley too but holding midfielder is not where he should be played. I've seen him in a few reserve matches recently and talented as he is he loses the ball too much for that role and should be further up the pitch, probably in the cahill role eventually.

George McKane
71 Posted 04/03/2012 at 10:41:48
For me it was yet another game that illustrated an absolute lack of bravery, dreadful decision making by players and manager, poor tactics and woeful lack of any inspiration or feeling of getting at a very very poor team.
Liverpool had just been beaten, we could have gone 3 points behind with the Derby to come and put pressure on them.
Even worse was QPR have been bottom of the Form League for a few weeks and we were praising them before the game. Thats 4 points off us by QPR - - they won at Goodison a week after being beaten 4-0 at home - - then yesterday was after a home defeat by Fulham in their last game and yet I never felt that the team were told to go at them.
It seems that we are unable to wind ourselves up and play well against very mediocre teams.
Like Wigan a few weeks ago, QPR were there for the taking and we not only didn't take either of them but in both cases we put up truly uninspiring, tepid, passionless performances.
Why?
John Audsley
72 Posted 04/03/2012 at 10:50:36
Gibson has made a much bigger impact than most of us have imagined. He allows Fellani to play and Neville did nothing in that role yesterday.

Neville is clearly a RB only and I don't think he should ever be thought of as a midfielder, I'd rather have Jags back at CB and move JH to The Gibson/Nev position. This has to be Nev's last season as anything near a regular for us, doesn't it???

Though I can't see that any time soon...
Phil Walling
73 Posted 04/03/2012 at 10:57:49
Very reminiscent of the Wigan game.Cautious approach as Moyes eases towards his bonus earning Prem survival target-not much ambition beyond that.
Ladies and Gentleman,I give you Everton FC 2012!
Urgh!
Brian Waring
74 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:05:38
Phil (#150) " FELLAINI: Quite simply the best defensive midfielder in the prem; Exactly what both Man Utd and Chelski are missing "

If thats the case then Phil, why aren't these teams kicking down our door to buy him?

Surely a player who is " World class "
Who would " Walk into Barcelona's midfield " " The best defensive midfielder in the prem " Would have teams queueing up to take him. "
Chris Smith
75 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:14:05
I like Leon Osman when he plays as an attacking central midfielder. Yesterday he was terrible on the right wing. It was noticeable that things tightened up considerably when Seamus Coleman came on for the last five minutes or so.

Royston Drenthe is a mix of the brilliant and the insane but I think we have to find a place in the team for him.
Jonathan Flack
76 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:10:39
People that are Fellaini bashing as far as I'm concerned haven't got a clue about football. If he was playing for Man U, City, Chelsea, Real Madrid he'd be the best defensive midfielder in the world.
What's holding him back is Everton. He just doesn't have the quality in front of him. He was silly to sign a new contract but I'm so glad he did.
He's got the physical part, the technical part and the engine.

If he had ball players in front of him with flair he'd be twice the player.
For his position he's still young also, Neville doesn't deserve to be in the same team and you moaners don't deserve to see him every week.

Read it back, sounds like a love affair....oh well I know a good player when I see one.
Phil Brown
77 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:13:28
Brian # 210 I never said that he would walk into the Barcelona team but he's just the player that Utd and Chelsea need. His work rate and ball winning is awesome but he needs to feed a creative player i.e. Drenthe/Barkley rather than Timmy.

We broke away at least three times in the last ten mins and if Barkley had been on we'd have scored at least one. He can't defend but he can deliver the killer pass in the final third (as can Tarrabt of QPR) - you need that type of player to win matches.
Stephen Kenny
78 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:09:52
Tim Howard has cost us points again. It was a poor foul by Drenthe but that's what happens when you ask a player to go well away from their natural game.

Drenthe is in the top 10 in the league for goals and assists. Surely we can find a way of accommodating him I.e. Cahill's position?

I was quite shocked when he wen't off and me Dad said out loud "why's he taking him off when were chasing the game" some fella stood behind us replied "were not chasing it lad it 1-1 away from home". Impossible to disagree considering the side we sent out and the way the game went.

It's time to see the back of Neville in midfield, Howard needs dropping or replacing at the end of the season and Cahill's status is rapidly declining in the eyes of Evertonians. It's not right. He should be managed the same way Duncan was, not hung out to dry.

All tough decisions that Moyes will avoid making no doubt!!!
John Ford
79 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:06:47
Nick, I agree thats about our best 11. If we can get a decent bung for Rodwell. id take it as im not sure he works with Fellaini who is infinitely more productive.

George/Phil we started with two attackers and two wingers/creatives yesterday so thats hardly Moyes being cautious.

The problem isnt the approach ....which was right, at least in terms of an attacking formation, its more about not having enough good players. When one or two arent on their game we do look very ordinary. Mark Hughes made sure Piennar and Baines were outnumbered, and when Drenthe went awol in the second half we we looked limited as an attacking force. Add to that the fact that Felli does all Nevilles running, it gets worse. Hopefully a fit Jellovic and Gibson will replace Tim and Neville.

Yesterday highlighted again that we dont have the players to perform consistently well as a team. The january sales gave us some hope but the long term is still a big problem
Mike Elbey
80 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:01:54
Sam,

The problem is do you think if Rodwell had been fully fit he would have played him instead of Neville ?

Moyes will not budge on picking Neville and Cahill when fit. Neville has some merit to be in the side but he has to be at rb never midfield where he is now hopeless. And as for Cahill, yes the bloke is a legend but he has played most games for us this season and has contributed absolutely nothing - why can Moyes not see this.

Having seen yesterday I fear that the cup game will see Neville in central midfield which is a major worry for me. Also I saw more in jelavic in 20 minutes than I have in Cahill in 20 games but we all know who will start in these big games. Fact is Moyes generally only picks the right side when he has an injury crisis. Let's not forget how shit we were before Osman, Cahill etc got injured, they come back and guess what - we are shit again !
John Keating
81 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:15:34
Drenthe a luxury we can't afford and Howard a liability !!
Thomas Windsor
82 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:19:17
Why oh why does Moyes keep on picking Cahill and Neville? They have played well for us in the past but this is now.

This has gone on too long now... surely he must get it in the end ? these two players are finished.
Sam Hoare
83 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:46:49
Mike, if Rodwell was fully fit he would definitely have started instead of Neville as demonstrated at the beginning of the season. He may have put Neville at RB.

Cahill is an issue. Ironic that it was him and Neville marking Zamora, with phil in front and Tim behind. Tim ran in front and mistimed/misjudged his leap leaving Zamora a free header. If we could have held on to that till half time i think QPR would have got more nervous and we may have left with 3 points.

If we could get Gibson and Jelavic into the team instead of Neville and Cahill i think we would be alot stronger.
Richard Dodd
84 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:47:59
Must admit I fell asleep watching the Football First edit last night although that had more to do with the ale I`d consumed than the quality of the football!
From the body language between Royston and Moyesey after the goal and the manager`s re-action to the tackle that cost us the game,I,too, can`t see him having a long-term future here however spectacular his goals!
With Pins,Ossie,Coleman and possibly Anichebe to pick from on the right,I suspect Drenthe will revert to an `impact` role from now on.
Richard Dodd
85 Posted 04/03/2012 at 11:58:13
Meant to say `wings` rather than `the right`!
Nick Entwistle
86 Posted 04/03/2012 at 12:22:04
Why has the title changed from Zero to Villain? At least zero isn't negative, its just a zero, neither plus nor minus. Villain implies he did something nasty with a pointy stick, when all he did was give away a free kick.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9yaam0p_BA
Steavey Buckley
87 Posted 04/03/2012 at 12:13:02
I do believe Drenthe is Everton's best attacking option. He can attack defences and shoot on sight. But he certainly is no right or left sided midfield player. These positions tend to restrict his attacking flair.

As for Howard, he just doesn't know how to deal with high balls into the penalty area. Southall would have barged into players to catch the ball, no matter if they were Everton ones or the opposition because he understood the importance.
Jamie Tulacz
88 Posted 04/03/2012 at 12:41:21
First game of the season I went to yesterday. I can see why Moyes would get frustrated with Drenthe, moments of brilliance, but also moments of awful play as well. Worth a place in the side for the moments of brilliance, but also needs to eradicate those poor moments- causing plenty of moans from those around me.

As for Felli thought he had a decent game yesterday, was the only player getting a foot in yesterday and getting really involved. Not really helped by a very poor ref yesterday though.

Think Cahill and Neville have their best days behind them now and need to be phased out now, not sure what other options Moyes had yesterday though particularly
Brian Waring
89 Posted 04/03/2012 at 13:23:33
Phil I wasn't saying that you had said those things. But these are the type of comments that have been said in regards to Fellaini.

As I say, he does show glimpses of the player he could become, but he is just to inconsistant, and to be worthy of tags like " World class " and " Top quality " You have to earn it, and be doing it week in, week out. He may be good at being able to win the ball, but he also has to be able to do something with the ball when he has it.

Also, probalby the best defensive midfielder in the prem this season has been Parker, that just my opinion though.
Sam Hoare
90 Posted 04/03/2012 at 13:38:54
Does Sessegnon red card today mean he will miss the FA cup match? Would be big bonus if he did!
Sam Hoare
91 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:00:08
And Cattermole sent off!

Amazing tyneside derby and maybe Sunderland two influential men down for the cup tie....
Kevin Sparke
92 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:09:36
Sessegnon will miss the cup tie as it's an automatic 3 match ban for violent conduct... not sure about Cattermole
Jamie Barlow
93 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:04:45
Thats right Sam. Hopefully they'll both miss it.
Lee Courtliff
94 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:06:08
If it wasn't for Drenthe it would have been nil-nil yesterday(according to those who blame him for their goal). Which gets you one point. The same as what we left with.

At least thanks to Royston we had something to get excited about. He is not a luxury we cannot afford.

He is exactly what we need. Or we could just put Leon back on the wing??
Lee Courtliff
95 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:15:37
Cattermole also recieved a straight red.
Kevin Sparke
96 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:17:54
Was it a straight red Lee? Wasn't he booked in the first minute (awful tackle - should have been off)
Sam Hoare
97 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:34:15
BBC reported it as a second yellow but have to say i didn't see the ref bring out a yellow second time round. Would have had to have been pretty bad dissent to be a straight red...
Richard Farrington
98 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:36:49
Although Cattermole had been booked, the incident after the final whistle led to a straight red card, so he and Sessignon will both be missing for the cup match. We should do it but will have to be a lot better than yesterday.
On another note, that stand we had to sit in yesterday at Loftus Road is a disgrace. £45 and a complete joke of a view and no leg room. Hopefully they will go back to where they belong - The Chumpionship.
Steavey Buckley
99 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:32:57
The defending yesterday, which brought more than expected free kicks around the penalty area and brought about QPR's goal, came about because of over eagerness on Everton's part to get the ball, when they should have realised, that once a player is touched, they will go down to claim a free kick, The best way, which I used to teach, when I used to be a coach to local amateur players, is to close players down, one defender in front of the other. I used to tell them, no matter how good a player is, with a ball, if a chair is put in the way, he still has to go around it, because it is still an obstacle.
Martin Mason
100 Posted 04/03/2012 at 14:51:53
Just watching fulham vs Wolves and Fulham have a tasty looking Russian up front called Progevnyak. 4 in his first 3 games and 2 today. He plays well with AJ up front .

Did I hear that Chelsea's manager has been canned?
Steavey Buckley
101 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:16:01
Former Chelsea midfielder Roberto di Matteo has been put in charge as first-team coach on an interim basis until the end of the season. - BBC

According to BBC stats., Cattermole had 9 yellows cards for the season before Sunderland's game at Newcastle.
Martin Mason
102 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:22:10
AJ has had a really good game for Fulham
Anthony Lamb
103 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:15:55
Just an interesting stat that Bolton had more shots ON target at Manchester City yesterday than Everton mustered against QPR (2). It appears that Everton seem generally capable of buckling down to compete against the better teams but seem singularly incapable of going out to WIN a match against supposedly inferior or equal opponents.

I also fail to appreciate Jonathan (212) thinking that Fellaini would be world class if he were in one of the top sides in the world ? that case might be made for any number of players. What would keep him out of those top sides among other things is his appalling inability to tackle cleanly. He is certainly one of the clumsiest, awkward, ungainly tacklers to be seen, often resulting in conceding free kicks in vulnerable areas. He has many good qualities, but I am afraid this aspect of his game needs to be eradicated sooner rather than later before his status in the game is inflated any further.
Lee Courtliff
104 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:28:32
Yeah it was a straight red. I saw no sign of the yellow card coming out. Foul and abusive language.

Great news for us.
Anthony Lamb
105 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:29:48
Sorry- that should read "FAIL to appreciate" Jonathan's point!
Phil Kennedy
106 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:32:10
Was it only me thought the free kick was taken about 2 yards off the line where the foul happened. That made a massive difference in the free kick for QPR's goal.
Stan Blood
107 Posted 04/03/2012 at 13:35:10
Fellaini also needs to stay away from injuries. The past two seasons he has been with us, he as seen 17 and 18 matches a season consecutively.

Further, he also needs to be more consistent on the ball. To highlight the importance of this. Fellaini plays 18 matches out of which he will play 2 good games if we are lucky, the other matches he is involved in are mediocre at the very best.

He still has problems with his temperment on the pitch, and will still give ridiculous free kicks away at the edge of the area.

At least for me, I don't think Fellaini will ever be 'world class' as described above by others... no matter which club he plays for.

As for why haven't Man Utd or Chelsea been banging the door down for him? I remember in summer Chelsea were trying to upset the apple cart and unsettle the player so he would not sign a new contract with us.

One only has to remember we are skint, so why pay top dollar for him when they can weasel him out of Everton for next to nothing, remember also they had just paid £50M for Ladyboy Torres.

Drenthe could be 'world class' material... and, for me, is the closest to it in our team of misfits and past-its. Give him the midfield to roam and keep him there (no defending) and I think we'd see a true quality player in him... Sadly he plays for Everton, which stifles players abilities, which means unless Royston moves on, he will eventually end up the next Ossie... lol!
Gavin Ramejkis
108 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:14:52
I thought Cattermole had gone for a straight red, his first yellow could have been, Sessegnon missing is a plus.

Doddy and anyone else daft enough to think the big sides would cream themselves over Moyes including take a moment and think why have they given the job to a manager pumped not too long ago by West Brom - didn't hear a peep about Moyes being on anyone's radar yet again.
Brian Waring
109 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:55:56
According to the BBC website, Cattermole was dismissed for a second yellow.
Jamie Tulacz
110 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:43:59
Lee (242)- yeah agree that Drenthe provides plenty of entertainment, and despite the mistakes that he makes will be worth more goals than he loses.

Just think he does need to eradicate those errors to take the step up to the next level, hence why Madrid probably didn't want to keep him. The goal was fantastic yesterday, but he also gave 3 or 4 bad balls away before and after it, which will sometimes undo the positive work from the goal.
Mark Stone
111 Posted 04/03/2012 at 15:48:11
Bit of an insular interpretation, Anthony. Notwithstanding the fact that Bolton got beat 2-0 yesterday, so it doesn't really matter how many shots on target they had. We have beaten many equal or worse teams than us this season (including Fulham, Bolton, Wolves, Swansea, West Brom, Wigan) and I'm sure there will be more between now and May.

All teams in the Premier League are good and, on any given day, any one team can beat another (and regularly do). What matters, is who picks up the most points in total over the course of the season. And I, for one, wouldn't have swapped places with Bolton at any point this season.
Jamie Tulacz
112 Posted 04/03/2012 at 16:02:25
Phil (261)- coudln't see it properly but wouldn't surprise me, the ref didn't have a clue what he was doing yesterday. The yellow card given to Pienaar for pointing out that the ref had only marked the wall about 6 yards back was particularly farcical!
Nick Waters
113 Posted 04/03/2012 at 16:03:32
Cattermole has now had 10 yellows (even before the 2nd yellow/straight red card whichever it was) and receives a 2 match ban, missing the cup game. The red card will probably mean a further 2 or 3 game ban on top.
Sam Hoare
114 Posted 04/03/2012 at 16:08:26
Sunderland minus Sessegnon and Cattermole for FA Cup. Their captain and then their most creative player. We must take advantage and get those tickets for Wembley!
Paul Gladwell
115 Posted 04/03/2012 at 16:36:56
Stan, no offence mate but what games have you been watching lately to come out with that comment on Fellaini will only Play two good games out of eighteen if we are lucky?
Gavin Ramejkis
116 Posted 04/03/2012 at 17:25:50
The ref defo didn't show Cattermole a second yellow

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/17252018
Thomas Windsor
117 Posted 04/03/2012 at 18:01:49
As i have said before, these next few months there is going to be plenty of good jobs becoming available: today, Chelsea... tomorrow, Spurs, England ? Moyes gets all the credit from all the tv pundits saying what a great manager he is but I bet he won't get any of the above jobs.

And it's because the crap we have watched at Goodison the last 2 seasons won't fool the boards of them clubs ? his tactics are a team of workhorses who play without flair.
Edward Robinson
118 Posted 04/03/2012 at 18:39:28
Where is Barkley? At least he does appear on the bench but still never gets a game! Why?
Dave Wilson
119 Posted 04/03/2012 at 19:12:02
Brian Waring

A "blatant" penalty QPR should have had?

I`m so glad you don't referee Everton's games.

At least your consistent.
Brian Waring
120 Posted 04/03/2012 at 19:32:46
Dave don't know if you were at the game?

I was in the South Africa road stand with a mate who is a QPR fan, who got me the ticket. I was virtually right in line with the incident, the ball is crossed over and Fellaini has the lad in a bear hug which stopped him jumping, so it's a pen.

I take it though, as usual, and with your consistancy, that you once again consider yourself to be right.
Dave Wilson
121 Posted 04/03/2012 at 19:48:11
I was in row B - which was right at the front, as Row A wasn't being used.

I wonder why no QPR players claimed... Why it wasn't even mentioned on Football First, why Sky Sports didn't mention it, why it wasn't in ANY of the reports I have read, Why the BBC didnt mention it on the way home, Why Michael, Lyndon or Ken didn't mention it... and more to the point, why Mark Hughes ? a man who moans if a throw-in goes against him ? didn't scream the house down.

I also wonder why somebody who consistently claims we have had the benefit of dodgy decisions is the man who claims it.

I accept I MAY have missed it, so you're wrong, Brian; I don't consider myself right "once again".

But I think everyone else is.
George McKane
122 Posted 04/03/2012 at 20:14:18
Interesting watching the replays this morning on Sky - - Zamora blatantly pushes Neville in the back before scoring. No complaints from Everton.
Ian Smitham
123 Posted 04/03/2012 at 20:14:09
Thomas #293 Just read the Sunday Times, Brian Glanville, re the game and Everton needing respect "much of it due to their inventive manager, David Moyes." Page 3. Sports section.
Brian Waring
124 Posted 04/03/2012 at 21:18:46
Well the QPR fans round me noticed it, Dave, because they were screaming for a pen.
Wayne Smyth
125 Posted 04/03/2012 at 21:31:22
I said it when we signed Gibson, that he would free up Fellaini and be more of a benefit to us than his personal abilities would tend to indicate.

Anyone who criticises Fellaini should bear in mind that he usually has to cover for 2 players, especially when Neville is playing, and Cahill/Osman to a lesser extent.
Roman Sidey
126 Posted 04/03/2012 at 23:30:12
Slight exaggeration on my criticism of Hibbert, but I do remember him conceding penalties and getting sent off in a few derbies, as well as quite a few other games. Not to mention him basically rugby tackling blokes in Europe one night.

Point being, because Drenthe is a flair player, as soon as he makes a mistake in defence, he gets jumped on. Yet, Moyes loves the shit out of blokes like Hibbo, Jags and Neville, who have collectively gifted opposition in excess of 20 goals over the last few years through free-kicks, penalties, and own-goals.

As I said, I only saw the first 25 minutes of the game because I fell asleep due to the mediocre attempt at football by both sides, but what I did see was a bunch of Moyes favourites struggle to do even the basics.

This team will not move forward until the likes of Hibbo, Neville, Osman, and Cahill are all put to rest.
CiarĂ¡n McGlone
127 Posted 04/03/2012 at 23:45:31
Roman,

You're taking liberties with facts.
Dave Wilson
128 Posted 05/03/2012 at 06:08:06
Brian

The QPR fans were screaming for everything all afternoon, especially were Fellaini was concerned. They are staring down the barrel of relegation . .its called desperation.

Zamora had gotten away with murder all afternoon backing into Heitinga and Distin.

"Blatant penalty" ? not even the QPR fans believe that
Dave Rice
129 Posted 05/03/2012 at 10:11:54
I must admit, I think Moyes has done a fine job at Everton. Everything is relative, and whilst it is easy to point at things which people think he should do, the fact remains that if (big 'IF') we win our game in hand then we are eighth. Which means that, with the exception of a Newcastle side having a season of their dreams, we are as high as it is possible to be. As has generally been the case throughout Moyes' 10 years at Everton.

Then I read all the comments from the geniuses on here ? Moyes's tactics are rubbish / he doesn't like flair / he doesn't want goals / he's negative / he has no plan 'B', etc ... etc ... etc ... ? and I start to think that he's actually quite useless.

But then the penny drops ? most people writing the sh!te on here haven't got a fuckin' clue what they're talking about. It's the old "empty vessels ... " adage I suppose.
Roman Sidey
131 Posted 05/03/2012 at 14:40:00
Dave Rice, we would be silly to think that Moyes doesn't like goals. But you must admit that he certainly doesn't set his team up to score many.

I'll make an ultimatum. I'll admit to knowing nothing about football and stop with the Moyes out shit on one condition - we win our remaining game against a current bottom three side (Wolves) by scoring 3 or more goals. Of the teams we have left to play, they have the worst defence, so that shouldn't be a tall order for a good manager with a relatively decent squad.
Gregory Kelly
132 Posted 05/03/2012 at 20:01:00
The lack of a mobile midfielder who can pick a pass was so evident on saturday. Looking down the field there was often a gaping hole in midfield with Fellaini too defensive and Pienaar and Drenthe on the flanks. No way Cahill can do the job. Not having or not playing or developing a 'new Arteta' lessens our capacity to keep the ball, deprives the strikers of creative service, means we dont have a reliable out ball from defence and ultimately leads to more pressure on the defence - the story of the second half on saturday.
Graham Mockford
133 Posted 05/03/2012 at 22:14:23
Peter Barry let me respond to #198. Then again I can't be arsed to even try to engage you on any sort of intellectual level. You are a one argument waste of oxygen or should I say OXYGEN

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads