Stymied Blues taken to unwanted replay

, 17 March, 176comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 1 - 1 Sunderland
David Moyes named exactly the same starting XI as had beaten Spurs on this ground seven days ago, fewer than half of them starting in the regrettable B-team line-up chosen for that dreadful midweek capitulation at Anfield. Confirmation, for any still doubting that Moyes deliberately dropped most of his strongest players for one of the most important league games of the season, and had no regrets for doing so. Only a win today would come close to easing the pain of that lasting embarrassment... but it was not to be.

The game got off to a lively start with Sunderland going out strong and putting Everton to the sword. The Blues responded in kind but were denied a penalty when Drenthe was blocked on the edge of the area. At the other end, a quick free kick took Everton by surprise and Bardsley drove a good low shot through a crowd of players, into the corner of Howard's net after just 12 minutes.

Everton were stunned but recovered with Drenthe making probing runs that were not really getting close enough. Fellaini slashed one in from distance but was guilty of giving the ball away too often. But Baines finally got some space to swing in a good cross that met Jelevic's head, and Cahill was alert to divert it in to the Sunderland net with his head for a vital equalizer.

Both sides kept up the pace but there were no further goals before the break, and the tie continued after break but at a somewhat less frenetic pace that dengerated into huff and puff when Moyes finally replaced the seriously flagging Drenthe with El Traca for the final 5 minutes.

Everton finally applied some pressure and created a couple of better chances, Heitinga forcing a vital save by Mignolet who somehow blocked Jelavic's close range follow-up.

In the end, the second-half was something of a non-event, which underlined Everton's perennial failure as an attacking side under David Moyes, lacking the guile to break down a stubborn Sunderland defence, and so to a replay that surely nobody in Blue wanted.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (176)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tom Bowers
1 Posted 17/03/2012 at 13:38:48
The Blues have come back well after a rather shaky first 15 minutes when Sunderland were much quicker breaking from midfield and referee Marriner giving Everton nothing. Everton completely asleep from the free kick which led to Sunderland's goal.

Jelavic is looking really good and why idiot Moyes left him and a few others out against Redshite was beyond me. In fact, I would say it was disgraceful to hand Redshite the game on a platter. It was bad enough the referee doing it in the Derby match at Goodison.

Anyway still a lot to do today against a battling Black Cats and Everton need to keep taking the game to them. Osman and Fellaini need to get more involved although there were signs that was happening in the last 10 mins of the half.
Dalziel Kane
2 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:23:15
Just over ten minutes in change left now and getting quite nervy now. I really did think, despite the horror show of Tuesday night we would win today, and still can, but time is not on our side. This really could be a make or break last 10 minutes of the season for us now. I can see some more frustration ahead today but really hope I am wrong, come on Blues for fucks sake.
Peter Barry
3 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:41:40
This is what you get when you have a Dour Dire Defensive minded Tactically Inept man with no motivational ability in charge. So we capitulated to the Red Shite for this did we, Davey boy?
Anthony Jones
4 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:47:04
I didn't see Drenthe flagging? He was our most dangerous player. Can't see Jelavic succeeding as a loan striker. Osman was absent when we needed him to take control. Fellaini was having to make up for the lack of legs in the old guard. We really missed Pienaar. I'd put Coleman in at right back now. Shit or bust! Doubt Moyes will have thought any of the above.
Phil Rodgers
5 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:54:09
For the first time this week I really feel we are not a big club anymore. Small fry mentality from Moyes is bringing me down.
Anto Byrne
6 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:44:59
What can you say after that? We had chances to win and were the better side. Not sure about the subs today but as expected they came on pretty late. It's a real shame Moyes didn't have a go at Anfield. We live to fight another day and at least we will know what the prize will be if we can can get past them in the replay.

Come on Stoke and Bolton.
Michael Kenrick
7 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:58:40
Drenthe was making some great runs in the first half... although to limited effect as we don't have the players with the mentality or coaching to play that pacey attacking game.

In the second half, Drenthe made fewer and fewer runs, dropped further and further back, and contributed less and less. Ran out of steam, methinks.
Dan Schweizer
8 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:58:32
To be honest the performance wasn't that bad, but I have lost respect for Moyes for the derby game; anything but a win wasn't acceptable. The ref was terrible, and I feel this result pretty much finishes our season. Everton will never win any silverware under Moyes.
Nick Entwistle
9 Posted 17/03/2012 at 14:58:46
Disappointingly easy excuse for more of a go at the club by some fans who want Moyes gone, but it was a competitive cup match so good football comes in a different guise. It was a great watch.

The ref wasn't on our side at all but we were the better team so its an annoying replay to take our schedule to 7 in 21.

ITV commentator said we were similar clubs in size, stature and ambition. Tosser.

Moyes obviously now put out a B team against the shite and it still rankles.
Andy Peers
10 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:00:24
Heitinga should be our Manager, he told Moyes and the coaches not to bring Jags on for him and almost scored the winner! Johnny has to hate playing under Moyes, I am pretty sure he can see right through all Moyes limitations, just like most intelligent Evertonians.
John Crossley
11 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:02:10
Moyes refused to be interviewed after the game according to ITV...

Come on, Davey boy, tell us what you think of the game ? we deserve to know.
Jackie Barry
12 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:04:05
Dan, we will never win any silverware, full-stop.
Lee Courtliff
13 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:00:11
Phil, we haven't been a big club for quite a while.

Shame about today. I had convinced myself we would win. The first half was an excellent cup-tie but we never really created anything in the second half.

Drenthe played well, despite moaning at the linesman when we were being counterattacked.

I think Jelavic will turn out to be a superb signing. He just needs more game time to build up his sharpness.

We have a decent record at Sunderland but I can't say I'm too optimistic. At least we are still in the draw.
John Sreet
14 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:14:00
We've not been a big club for a long time, decent club with a big history definitely but big club... not any more. Thought we played quite well today, little bit unfortunate not to go through.

I think Moyes will maybe go this season, so I am waiting with baited breath for Mourinho, or Ancelloti, or on second thoughts maybe big Eck as he'll get sacked or Stevie Bruce, or maybe if we're lucky Robert Martinez... really can't wait!
Rob Teo
15 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:18:08
I really cannot understand why Moyes decided to swap Cahill and Fellaini around when Fellaini was doing pretty well in his defensive midfield role in the first half.

If Cahill was not up to par (which he was, notwithstanding his goal), I'd rather have seen another attacker come in to support Jelavic than what Moyes did - move him into Fellaini's role where he (Cahill) was borderline shite.

Sums up Moyes' defensive mentality for me while keeping one of his "favourites" on the pitch.
Robbie Riddal
16 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:14:10
We're just not very good, that's the crux of it. It was just all so typical Everton. Surely the players should have been itching to get out there and come out the traps after the derby and what's been said about it, but no, like a gang of shitbags we were on the back-foot for the opening quarter and although we should have had a penalty before Sunderland scored, we were fortunate to get back in to it the way we did.

From that point Sunderland seemed to settle for a replay, they rarely threatened us again, yet we just weren't good enough to win the game. I would love to know what they players do in training, surely they must practice playing against XI men behind the ball? The only idea we had was to get the ball out wide and punt the ball into the box hoping for a knock down; not even getting to the by-line, actually just swinging it in from deep.

And then to throw Dennis on with 5 minutes to go? It's a cup tie for fucks sake, try and win it !!
Lol McNally
17 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:27:50
Not a lot of shots on target to day... I can't see us getting a win at Sunderland, Moyes is clueless.
Keith Glazzard
18 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:19:05
The first 20 minutes we were nothing like the team that beat Spurs because we were the club that surrendered to Liverpool.

Having said that, we should still have had a penalty before they scored, one for handball in the second plus the body-check on Stracq towards the end. Mariner was cowardly crap.

In the end, moving Fellaini forward means that he and Jelavic have to make something out of hopeful balls lofted up for the defence to win. Crap too.
Peter Cummings
19 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:28:28
Familiar scenario, sucker-punch goal, a lucky equaliser and a ref who blew everything outside the area when there were two definite pens, plus a borderline one in their area.

I said Sunderland wouldn't lie down and they could have won it, we had at least five good chances, but the usual finishing problems... I can't really fancy our chances up north now.
Dalziel Kane
20 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:36:34
All is not lost as we are still in the draw for the last four and it will at least be interesting to see who we may, or may not, face in the semi-finals.

The season is not yet over with, there is still some chance of glory ahead but I wish I could be more hopeful. Black Cats will be quietly confident with this replay, but hope that prick of a match official today is nowhere to be seen for that.
Kase Chow
21 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:42:27
Why dis Osman turn his back to the ball for their goal?

Why wasn't Drenthe's trip in the area a penalty?

Why did Cahill & Fellaini swap positions in the 2nd half?

So frustrating...
Suresh Gill
22 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:41:14
We don't have the players that have the capability to create anything when we go upfront. It's even harder if we always play with a lone striker. Our mentality has always been not losing rather than playing for a win. That's how Moyes wants his players to play.

I think I have crossed beyond the line of being patient watching my team play this way. It raises my blood pressure.
Mark Riding
23 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:41:27
Drenthe throwing himself to the floor at every opportunity I reckon cost us a penalty, when he was 'genuinely' fouled in the box in the first half. Yes, he is a liability, but often looks our best threat.
He seems to piss a few other players off as well... I can't see a deal being done. Jelavic looks a player.

Opportunity missed at home... Midweek gamble backfired.
Jon Cox
24 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:47:00
To often this season we lacked creativity and ran out of ideas in the second half.

Omens not good.
Brian Waring
25 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:44:19
Think the title of this thread is apt for the game today. It was a decent game first half, like a proper cup tie. Second half was poor, we just run out of idea's, and just kept hoofing the ball forward.

Deffo handball and a pen, thought the one on Drenthe, the ref probalby got it right, I thought Drenthe was playing for it.
Also in regards to Drenthe, whilst he is an exciting talent, I wish he would stop throwing himself to the ground everytime someone puts in a tackle.

Is Moyes vindicated after Tuesday's debacle?
Richard Reeves
26 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:42:10
It couldn't end soon enough for me. An overwhelming sense of repetitive boredom.
Viv Sharma
27 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:50:28
disapointing that moyes cant come out and tell us straight what he was thinking having been humiliated at anfield for no reward. he should respect the fans more
Peter Askins
28 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:49:17
Cattermole and Sessegnon will have served their suspensions, and in all likelihood will be brought back for the replay. That's the bad news.

The only good news for us could be the return from injury of Darron Gibson. He's not everybody's cup of tea, but in his limited time with us, I see an athlete, who understands his central midfield role 100%. His combination with Fellaini has been excellent from the start, which makes him the obvious first choice in this role, ahead of Rodwell, Osman, Neville, or anybody else in the squad.

This tie is still winnable, but we need more going forward, and to be more solid in midfield, which hopefully Gibson will provide.
Leo Foster
29 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:59:18
Around about 8th in the League and FA Cup quarter-finalists ? this is about Moyes's level. If Spurs come calling for him, he´ll turn them down. He's comfortable here at this level. He's got his cardie and slippers on: life's good for Davie.
Mark Riding
30 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:00:29
Viv.. 'Smithers' expected to win today and be justified in his midweek selection...

I'm sure he already had his post-match interview written out.
Viv Sharma
31 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:02:35
Ha! Thanks Mark, that's the first time I've smiled since TC scored!
Mike Gray
32 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:55:51
Can't see us winning a trophy under Moyes!
John Shaw
33 Posted 17/03/2012 at 15:58:12
So let me get this right, we have a dire first 5 months to the season, build up some momentum over a 9 game run, the manager throws it out of the window by surrendering to that shower of shite on Tuesday night, (all in the name of winning today mind), we then only draw at home to a significantly weakened Sunderland side, but Moyes is still the business Nick? Is that so? Really?

No, Moyes is a tactically inept negative bastard who has gone as far as he can at Goodison, he needs to fuck off at the end of the season, and take that blag Boys Pen luvvie bitch with him, a pair of Grade A shithouses!!

Tuesday's surrender still rankles? You fucking bet it does, he should have been sacked for that alone!! And we wonder why there's a lack of pride about the place?!? Fuck me, I wonder why!!!!!!!!!!
Brian Waring
34 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:07:00
We have a tricky away fixture at Swansea before the replay, wonder if Moyes will rest anyone?
Mark Riding
35 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:09:57
Brian.. Great point. He has made a rod for his own back now. Did you see his pre-match interview on ITV? No chance he would admit to a mistake against Liverpool... he was asked a straight question about it. Hence the 'no show' after the game today.
Leo Foster
36 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:14:17
After making a controversial selection vs L'pool, it's merely cowardice on Moyes's part to duck out of public discussion. It'll probably be leaked that he was too incandescent about the referee's performance to trust himself in the immediate post-match interview.
Brian Waring
37 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:20:37
Thats what I was thinking Mark. If he picks our first 11 against Swansea, fans will question the game against the Shite even more.
Mike Green
38 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:08:09
A typically pragmatic MO'N side who did a job on us today betting that a ref, even at home, wouldn't have the bottle to punish them for playing the percentages and taking us out when necessary. Stoke City in disguise. Mission accomplished, replay at Stadium of Light where they will put us to the sword, Captain and top scorer available and fresh?

Almost the entire second half played down the wings, which is great providing someone can a) deliver a killer ball and b) we can take the opportunity at the other end. Bad predictable crosses leaving stranded players to fluff their lines at he other end.

Where the fuck was our central midfield in the second half? Fellaini was moved up top and Osman was completely bypassed by his colleagues who just kept knocking it wide for more hopefull crosses.

If we had a commanding central midfielder who can control a game a drive forward, play balls through and pass wide to alternate attacks I think we'd have won the Escondido half but we haven't.

So - Rodwell out. And get someone in who can. Maybe that mans Gibson but over the past 5 days the only use Jack Rodwell is to us is money in the bank.

Everton 1 Martin O'Neill 1
James Martin
39 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:21:05
We'll never win anything with Fellaini in the team, what did he do today? Nothing, it was embarassing watching him trying to play attacking mid with his non existent pace and his 'crossing', like seriously why does he ever go out wide whats the point? All he can do out there is pass backwards. Coupled with Osman having a bad game we had no pace in the middle of the park and got ran over by that irritating schoolkid colback. I thought Jelavic looked good todat and made the best of what scraps he had to feed on. Cahill was also good. At the end of the day though the referee has denied us a place in the semi finals. If that's one of the big 4 teams then they get three pens and end up winning at a canter, not us though, we let them have one shot from 30 yards in the whole game and it flies in, typical of our bad luck in cups, but we didn't admittedly do anough to counter bad refereeing and bad luck.
Marc Sansum
40 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:24:06
Bunch of bloody whingers the TW forum goers. We play 4-4-2 a game you moan (after 90% people saying we should go 4-4-2), we drop players you all say we should drop and you moan. Give Sunderland a little respect, they've been in good form. Every game seems the same shit, win lose or draw. Just get behind the team
Mark Riding
41 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:30:14
Marc.. I reckon most TW posters are fully behind the team in the Ground on a matchday... and are fully behind the club with their pay packets.

Why not get the moaning out of the system on here?
Leo Foster
42 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:30:46
Fellaini is the only true class player in that side, even when played forward out of position. So, if Moyes apologists are looking for a scapegoat, they should look elsewhere. We'll never win anything under Moyes; Kenwright won't get rid of him, and Moyes acts as forewall for Kenwright.
Richard O'Shea
43 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:29:29
How can you say Fellaini was poor and we're never winning anything with him in the side? I thought he was everywhere today... definitely one of Everton's best players today.
Brian Waring
44 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:35:06
Sorry to upset you Marc. Right everyone, Its not as if we have anything to moan about, so stop moaning!
Terry Hayes
45 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:38:07
It's all good and fine saying the players should have been up for it today, the simple fact is they were up for it but are just average footballers at best... we just have no quality and our powder-puff shots are laughable.
Mike Green
46 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:33:18
Marc ? that Sunderland team were there for the taking today. Given we sacrificed a derby for that match, do you think our performance and players did it justice? I don't. The effort is there but the tactics and quality just aren't.

There's no way Sunderland deserved to win but I bet they throw everything at us in the replay. All we did in the second half was throw balls over the box hoping someone would get onto the end of it.

So, yes, I am having a moan because again we just weren't good enough. An FA Cup semi-final at Wembley was at stake today ? not some two bit nipple peep show in Rio de Janerio.
Andy Meighan
47 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:35:20
I don't care what anyone says, that derby defeat left a cloud over Goodison and that was reflected in that lacklustre performance today. Our whole midfield just didnt perform and what the manager sees in the likes of Coleman and to a lesser extent Gueye is beyond me. Apart from the odd half-chance, we created zilch... so Dave, thanks for bringing me back down to earth with an almighty bump.
Chris Davies
48 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:37:49
Today was slightly depressing but I'm going to go out on a limb now and say that I think we'll do them at The Stadium of Light.

We simply don't know how to break teams down when they park the bus, which I think they did in the 2nd half today.

They'll have to come out and attack at their place and Moyes's lottery football will pay dividends.

On the Swansea note... I'm very interested to see what Moyes does. He really can't win now. Either he fields the same shower of shite as against the RS, or play our best team and admit his failings.
Mike Hayes
50 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:45:25
Didn't listen/watch todays match, and to be honest couldn't give a toss until Moyes walks. He's shat on the loyal fans from Tuesday on and couldn't care less himself. So, until he goes, I've lost heart.

I usually wear an Everton shirt, especially at work. The people I work with were very suprised to see me wearing a white T-shirt two days (will be four) running. White symbolising the flag waved at the RS at Anfield.
Gavin Ramejkis
51 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:45:07
Marc did you watch the derby or just sit on the coat tails of the apologista shitehawks with that 4-4-2 bollocks? We started that game 4-5-1 with Anichebe on the wing, grow a pair and watch a game before making such nonsensical comments

Sunderland today were an alehouse side at times with long hit and hopes, Mariner was a prick but we didnt do ourselves any favour either crying for the whistle and an out of sorts Osman not having a good game, Coleman tiring and Drenthe having anothre Jekyll and Hyde appearance didnt help, but you've got to take your chances and make them count, the Sunderland keeper couldn't catch the ball but most of our shots were right at him and didn't test him diving to either side.
John Malone
52 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:28:30
I thought Fellaini had a poor game today; although he put himself about and won plenty of headers, his final ball/shot was poor.

I thought the referee was a total joke and wanted all the lime-light.

My main point of criticism is for David Moyes: for him to play a weakened team in a Merseyside derby, then adopt desperation panic tactics and play hoofball the whole second half, was shite. This year we are not great attacking through the middle so we need to get the ball wide and attack from there.

I don't know why on earth he instructed his players to play long ball persistently, we were the better team second half and just needed to keep our heads and play the ball up to the area then cross it or get to the byline. Instead Moyes played shithouse tactics, stopped Baines and Neville from overlapping and crossing from the final third, and insisted on hoofs into the box: bad bad bad management.

For me, I hate to say it, but the tie is over; they will have Sessegnon and Cartermole back and the home advantage. That's why you have no silverware, Moyes ? your tactics are shite!
Tony J Williams
53 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:51:25
"Marc - that Sunderland team were there for the taking today" - Oh for fucks sake!!!
Trevor Lynes
54 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:51:23
I watched hopefully and I must say that the two teams out there were diabolical to watch and I'm so glad that we are not playing in Europe. I saw a lot of so-called top players who could not pass or dribble and we ended up relying on long hopeful balls and set pieces. We are terrible entertainment and use effort to make up for ability.

I lost count of the times that we miscontrolled balls; after watching the Spanish teams, it was like we are playing draughts and they are playing chess!!

Neither of the teams on show today will win the cup !!
Marc Sansum
55 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:57:16
Gavin R to the rescue again.
Did I mention the Liverpool game?
John Crossley
56 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:53:22
Supported this club for over 50 years, never known the fans to be so despondent (including myself), even through all the shit we have endured over the years. Time for Moyes and Round to fuck off... sorry, but that's how I feel.
Gavin Ramejkis
57 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:59:25
Marc, you mentioned 4-4-2 the last people claiming the "told you so" line over "those crying for 4-4-2 and seeing their respective arses" was straight after that. Funny as it was only Tuesday and here you are with the same line... coincidence? Really?
Brian Waring
58 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:59:39
Marc "We drop players you all say we should drop, you moan" So your not refering to the Liverpool game then?
Marc Sansum
59 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:03:31
No Gavin, It's a recurring comment every week on TW. However every time we play 4-4-2 we struggle (yes, we may not start 4-4-2, and I'm talking about games where we get an early sub, not a 5mins to go switch).

Anyway, enough of bad banter.

Impressed with that McClean, not bad for £200k or whatever he cost.

Osman went missing today, game pretty much bypassed him. Distin & Heitinga were solid.

Jelevic was ok, didn't get a whole lot of support though.

Not entirely sure how i would have set up the team or changed it to make a difference. What would other people have done?
John Keating
60 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:58:28
Just in.

Thought the atmosphere ? our supporters ? was "dull"... certainly everyone still pissed off with Tuesday's debacle. I also taped the match and wanted to see the before and after Moyes interviews. Well, before the game he was asked straight out about the Tuesday team selection and only mentioned the 2 England Internationals put in ? nothing about them being out for God know's how long!!

The after-match? Well, many people will no doubt use the word "coward" and who is to say they will be wrong??

Had to laugh at Reidy taking the piss over the 3 games in a week, many of us have said the same over the last few days!
I mentioned him rotating the team prior to the league match against the mighty Sunderland ? looks as if he'll have to do it twice now, eh??
Keith Glazzard
61 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:37:09
Fellaini is a class player, as is Heitinga. Jelavic looks very good but it's early to be sure. Baines is up there and if we can keep Pienaar he'll do me.

I'm no Moyes apologist ? as the media embrace him as some sort of miracle worker, I get more frustrated with his tactics ? but, given the state of football today, sometimes I think it's amazing that we have these players on our books.
Michael Hegarty
62 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:02:45
Lacklustre at best. How many stupid over-hit crosses did we chuck in from bad positions? Drenthe, stay on your fucking feet... it's getting embarrassing.

Moyes has right royally fucked up this week. Did you see Reidy taking the piss about players having to play three games in a week and saying he'd have played his best team in both games. That's the attitude we need if we're ever going to win anything.
Gavin Ramejkis
63 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:12:42
Marc, give us all examples of Moyes starting 4-4-2. I think you'll struggle to find many over the ten years and even less if you go back over the last five. You could even go so far as to name a few examples in recent years where chasing a game he's finally gone 4-4-2 to salvage a point.

So again your point about 4-4-2 and the supposed clamour and repeated examples of it failing would be when exactly?
Marc Sansum
64 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:13:01
Aye John, it's gonna be a hard replay, with Arsenal bound to give us the runaround in between and make it a tough game. Plus they will have Sessengon back, who is class on his day.
Danny Kewley
65 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:56:54
Brian (760) ? stop being a sanctimonious nob, we were at best crap today. Maybe we need that oligarch or sheik you keep harping on about.
Mark Riding
66 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:13:11
Keith.. the class players you mentioned are paid top dollar by the way..
Eugene Ruane
67 Posted 17/03/2012 at 16:53:59
Marc Sansum (768) - You say...

"Bunch of bloody whingers the TW forum goers. We play 4-4-2 a game you moan (after 90% people saying we should go 4-4-2), we drop players you all say we should drop and you moan. Give Sunderland a little respect, they've been in good form. Every game seems the same shit, win lose or draw. Just get behind the team."

A whistful 'ffs'

Jesus, I bet you could have a team of professors allocated to you to explain how to peel a potato and you would still wear the expression of a colour-blind 2 year old with a Rubiks cube.

What fucking good is a forum if EVERY post is...?

"Dave Twonk - Think we'll batter them today, COYB!"

"Reg Twat - Agree Dave, COYB!!"

"Arthur Cheese - You're right lads, COYB!"

"Ronnie Trousers - Too right, let's get behind them COYB!!!!"

Etc.

Not telling you what to do but Bluekipper sounds MUCH more your type of thing.
Marc Sansum
68 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:15:20
Gavin did you not read my post at all?

Is there such a difference between 4-4-1-1 and 4-4-2? If the striker doesn't hold the ball up, the 2nd striker ain't gonna get it anyway.
Thomas Windsor
69 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:06:40
I thought Everton played well today but that extra bit of class that is needed costs money, full stop.

Jelavivc will be a good signing but you need better players round him to see him at his best; he won't like playing as a lone striker for very long ... and Cahill is not the answer anymore.
Mark Riding
70 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:30:28
Thomas.. the 'bit of class' you mention.. thats made a difference over the last few months was our very own 'Bullys Special Prize' - Landon Donavon.. Look at what you could have won...

I know all of us 'moaning TW posters' differ on 'The Dons' contributions... but christ.. he would have made a difference today..

Seamus just dosent cut the mustard for me..
Mike Keating
71 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:28:34
Crossing was pathetic ? especially in the 2nd half which we dominated but the referee and his linesman (on the Goodison Rd side) were useless. They now get their suspended players back and I can't see us winning the replay.

Another wasted season.... Not a good moment to send out ST renewals...
Keith Glazzard
72 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:28:11
Mark - ok, but that's our top dollar until daddy comes along. Without knowing the figures, I would suspect they could get paid more in a few other clubs who would be very happy to have them.
Brian Waring
73 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:31:35
Err... Danny, It was a genuine question, will Moyes rest players against Swansea, as he did against the shite?
Phil Brown
74 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:36:12
Thomas # 802 No he's not but Barkley is - where is he?
Jon Cox
75 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:42:21
Eugene, sorry mate ? I don't agree with Dave Twonk.
Adrian Seal
76 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:42:34
@ Eugene 800

'Ronnie Trousers'...fabulous!

For what it's worth I thought we played well today after their goal, should have had a penalty and have a decent chance in the replay.

Keep the faith!
Andrew Clare
77 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:43:02
Mid-table, forced to a cup replay with Sunderland, humiliated by our neighbours.Negative manager, poor board. Not much to cheer about nowadays is there? Nick @ 730 I hate to hear what the ITV guy said but that is how we are perceived by the media and the public and I think our manager and chairman.
Ian Smitham
78 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:50:39
Andy #731, i dont know where you watched the game from, but about 30 seconds befor the incident you refer to happened, Johnny had been falt on his back nursing a knee injury. Moyes called him over and from where I sat they seemed to agree he was hurt and they got Jags ready. JH made a recovery and then it developed as you say with JH making it clear he could go on.
Andy Meighan
79 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:42:57
Tell you what, Eugene... your mates have got some strange names, the best being Reg Twat ? I was pising myself at that... superb!
Ian Smitham
80 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:54:19
Brian #748 I thought drenthe was a disgrace today. He wont pass, he dives and leaves players behind him exposed. In the second half he did not get a free kick from one challenge and having stood still for 20 seconds he walked back to cover thier Left back who was pushing forward in empty space.

Back to my post a minute ago to Andy. I would make Johnny Captain because he spotted the sulking Drenthe and promtly ran over to him to "have a word"

Last bit for now, if I may,
while I have said to cash in on Jags before, which I would, but it seems DM wont so is there any case for JH going to RB? The present incumbent, well today anyway is simply no longer good enough
Gavin Ramejkis
81 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:58:17
Marc seems like you might need to read your own post - "Bunch of bloody whingers the TW forum goers. We play 4-4-2 a game you moan (after 90% people saying we should go 4-4-2), we drop players you all say we should drop and you moan. Give Sunderland a little respect, they've been in good form. Every game seems the same shit, win lose or draw. Just get behind the team " now where the fuck do you mention 4-4-1-1 and where do YOU mention 4-4-2, game, set, match, try the beef
Stuart Critchley
82 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:51:15
Moyes had run out of ideas, lacks belief... and, when the inevitable happens and we lose the replay, he should walk
Jim Harrison
83 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:04:28
Great cup tie. The team played well, imo.
Colin Malone
85 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:53:49
Ossie was poor today, never got involved. Oh for another Lee Carsley.

Every Martin O'Neill team puts in a full shift, 110% every game, that's what makes them hard to beat, it's not a lot to ask for from players.
Richard Dodd
86 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:46:28
Just back from an afternoon in the Freshy where all the talk was of Davey`s non-appearance on ITV after the game.

A guy who works at Goodison on matchdays told us that the manager is toally nonplussed and even hurt by the furore surrounding his derby team selection, although continuing to insist he did the right thing in the circumstances.

My own view is that if we had won well today, the healing process would have been well advanced by tonight... but, as it was, a fairly average display let him down. Just hope the whole business doesn`t hasten his departure!
Rory Slingo
87 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:11:45
Why Doddy? Looking forward to 5 more years of boring, percentage football? Under BK and Elstone we know we'll end up in the Championship in a couple of years anyway. What's the harm in risking a more adventurous manager who might be able to get more out this group of players than Moyes can?
Nick Entwistle
88 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:18:36
This manager Rory who has lost three in 17 games?
Ryan Price
89 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:26:41
Re: Nick @840 and also the manager, who forfeited one.
Barry Rathbone
90 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:08:58
Did a bit of work rather than watch any more Moyes guff.

Put the radio on half way through the second half to hear Ratcliffe (I think) saying pointless balls being knocked into Sunderland's box.

Switched it off.

Moyes has done the impossible and made me disinterested in whether we win an FA Cup Quarterfinal.

Dreadful to think the chump will still be here this time next year ? christ!
Mark Riding
91 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:34:30
Spurs been abandoned???
Mark Riding
92 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:35:42
Looks bad... prayers with the lad...
Gerry Quinn
93 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:36:35
Muamba of Bolton ? they spent 10 minutes trying to re-susitate him after he collapsed on pitch ? match abandoned. I am sure all our thoughts are with him.
Paul Holmes
94 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:31:37
Its not about losing 3 in 17 games, it's about trying to win games, being positive and getting the fans on your side with a "let's take the game to them" attitude!

Under Moyes, it's about not losing at any cost, even a 0-0 final result every week would suit him! Negative, boring, defeatest attitude before every game (especially the top 4)... I wish he could swop him for one of the managers who always says he's doing a great job!
Andy Meighan
95 Posted 17/03/2012 at 18:38:51
Ratcliffe got it spot on: pointless balls being knocked into the box but that's been mainly the story of Moyes's boring tenure ? shit to watch and no clue how to change tactics mid-game.

Can't wait for the next 5 years... I think not.
Brian Waring
96 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:10:21
Reports are saying Muamba is fighting for his life. Praying for the lad.
Jamie Barlow
97 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:15:50
Was it a clash of heads or did he just collapse?
Really hope he's ok.
David Barks
98 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:20:08
Oh God this is awful. Just sickening to see him down like that. It's not looking good at all or sounding good at all.
Kevin Naylor
99 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:21:30
Just collapsed with no one near him then was lying face down convulsing. Signs look very bad indeed.
David Barks
100 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:25:55
He just fell and then started convulsing as he was being attended to. Honestly sick to my stomach having seen that. A little bit of perspective on life today.
Danny Kewley
101 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:45:24
Brian, my apologies mate for my rude post (ref 760), I had you totally confused for someone else. By the way, you are spot on about the Swansea game
Rory Slingo
102 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:15:36
Exactly right, Paul Holmes. Since when did sport become about not losing rather than winning? Not losing is what losers set out to do. Winners go about trying to win!

Moyes has taken the club as far as he can with the current group of players. He can work no more miracles and there isn't the funds to freshen up the team. So let's thank him for what he's done and let him move on to pastures new. Give someone else a go.

Could be worse, sure. Could also be better. All Everton is doing now is the equivalent of a working-class family slogging day-in, day-out at work, long hours, coming home to the noisy bloody kids and buying the lottery on the weekend, hoping to strike the big one that'll suddenly give them the nouveau riche life they've always wanted! ... ie, it's never gonna happen!

You have to take the future into your own hands ? not wait for shit to fall into your lap, whether that be a buyer for the club or defending a point and hoping to nick it.

We can't afford better players, no one's buying the club, so we're stuck with the board. The one thing we can change is the manager.
Mark Riding
103 Posted 17/03/2012 at 19:56:55
Rory... "working class" ? we used to be 'the Mersey Millionaires'... I totally get where you're at though...
Brian Waring
104 Posted 17/03/2012 at 20:12:35
No probs Danny.
Andy Crooks
105 Posted 17/03/2012 at 20:52:46
I thought we played okay today and deserved to win. I actually thought Fellaini had a good game but Drenthe is the only thing a bit different that we have. Jelavic looks good as well. I think we will win the replay..
Guy McEvoy
106 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:08:47
Rory. That second paragraph of yours could've been taken from any Charlton message board just before they said Cheerio to Curbishley. Be careful what you wish for.
Phil Bellis
107 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:10:10
"I think we will win the replay.. "

Gordon Lee 1977

Agree about Marou, Royston and Jelavic, if he has the service
Jamie Barlow
108 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:09:59
I can't make my mind up about Drenthe. He does my fuckin head in but can be magical in flashes. He got a good bollocking of his captain today. I can also see why Moyes is wary of playing him away from Goodison.
Nick Entwistle
109 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:13:34
Has a few conflicting statements Rory's post.
David Booth
110 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:34:36
Dear David Moyes: so, what did Tuesday achieve please?
Mike Green
111 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:51:06
Tony J Williams #781 ? I made my point. What the fuck's yours?
Mike Oates
112 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:53:47
To me Coleman as a wide front player just doesn't cut it . When he gets past the full back he invariably shoots wide or totally misses with his crosses, he doesn't look up to see what's on ? as we progress through the season and invariably end up about 10th to 12th at least give him a go as a right back. He looked a far better player for Blackpool when they played him there.

As for Drenthe ? he's just too much of a liability, he goes to ground far too easily and refs just wont give free kicks against him and 5 sec later we are on the back foot as the opponents counter-attack.

Without the Pinnear and Baines combination we just dont create, and Pinnear is cuptied... bye-bye, FA Cup.
David Booth
113 Posted 17/03/2012 at 22:00:47
Anyone noticed what an influential player Heitinga is: both on and off the ball.

He pulls the strings in this team and we look so much more complete with him in it ? at CENTRE HALF Mr Moyes!

Interestingly, he does it is such an unspectacular manner too.

From the players' perspective, it must be great to have him in the team.

I do hope he doesn't get restless at the end of the season. Future Everton legend in the making?
Andrew Presly
114 Posted 17/03/2012 at 22:26:16
I can't bear to see or hear from Moyes now, that's me done. The guy is a thief and a coward.
Anthony Lamb
115 Posted 17/03/2012 at 22:17:20
Just thought that ? in all the justifiably negative reactions to the derby fiasco clouding expectations and perspectives on the match today ? our bemoaning our failure to win the game in spite of dominating much of the second half, and the criticisms (often justified) of certain players, that not enough genuine praise is afforded the man who I believe had an outstanding game today and remains an enormous credit to himself and the game ? namely Sylvan Distin.

I thought his display today was truly outstanding, showing yet again that age should be no bar to maintaining outstanding athleticism, technical skill, strength and attention to his responsibilities as a central defender. What a pity we have not had the benefit of his services earlier than the few recent years he has been here.

Just my opinion I know, but with a lot of critical negativity that abounds at the moment (with which I can readily sympathise), I just felt I wanted to say a big "thanks" to our centre back for such a superb performance!
Mark Riding
116 Posted 17/03/2012 at 22:53:11
Anthony ? Great shout about Distin today... pace, vision and a touch of class.

You say it's a shame we haven't had him longer. I said the same about Richard Gough... some players just read the game.
Eddy Bernard
117 Posted 17/03/2012 at 22:52:06
Brian @ 760 my thoughts entirely. Are we now going to throw away another 3 points ahead of the replay?

Moyes has got himself into a bit of pickle now so it will be interesting to see what he does.
Roman Sidey
118 Posted 17/03/2012 at 23:41:50
David Booth, bang on about Heitinga. My problem with him now is, I hold him so high, that, like Rooney, you know he can do better than stay at Everton, and hope that he goes on to lift the biggest trophies on offer. As long as Moyes is at Everton, I just can't see Heitinga staying longer than his contract. Really hope I'm wrong.

Good shouts on Distin. When he's got Johnny next to him, he's top class. These two need to be our centre halves. I am very glad I was wrong the other day when I claimed that I knew Jags would be playing this game. Good that Moyes can actually see this, at least.

Sean McCarthy
119 Posted 17/03/2012 at 23:39:40
Drenthe is too much of a liability to succeed I'm afraid and that's why Jose wasn't interested and why there won't be a large queue for him come the summer.

Coleman is Championship level at best. He has bags of pace and ....... well that's it really. When he runs with the ball is it ever under control?? So with those two meant to be providing our width, is it any wonder we struggled??

And when we needed something different it's a choice of gueye or McFadden for some unknown reason. Both not good enough by a long chalk. Where was Barkley??
Mark Riding
120 Posted 17/03/2012 at 23:53:32
Sean, Gueye looked a lot bigger and stronger today and played a couple of decent balls into the box. He has lost his soppy haircut and actually looks a bit of a prospect for me.
As for McFadden... if you saw any TV coverage, everytime the camera went onto the bench, he was laughing his head off, probably thinking of his wages...

Heitinga ? got to be the skipper.
Robbie Muldoon
121 Posted 18/03/2012 at 00:06:51
Brendan Rogers could replace Moyes IMO. His Swansea side are great to watch, get wins home and away, the Swansea fans brand his style of play 'total football'.

After beatin Fulham 3-0 at Craven Cottage today, it was a sign of how well they played that the Fulham fans applauded the side and Rodgers off the pitch.

In his post-match interview (I'm glad Moyes didn't bother doing one today), he stated how he hasn't and wouldn't set a desired points total to his players, unlike our Moyesiah who 10 years into the job was still spouting 40 points as the target this season.

Thank you for your work Mr Moyes, I don't know how you did it under Kenwright, but it's time to change things. Kenwright, here's a promising manager who will be a breath of fresh air and someone I would imagine would be willing to take on this massive task you have created for them.
John Malone
122 Posted 18/03/2012 at 00:00:39
I think people are going well overboard on the Johnny Heitinga bandwagon. I'll give him his due: he's been playing well and is a good reader of the game and has a good pass but he is being made to look better by in my opinion this season's top performer, Sylvain Distin. On the deck, in the air, shoulder to shoulder, no-one gets the better of him. Without Distin, Heitinga would get exploited for his lack of speed, height and strength.
Derek Thomas
123 Posted 18/03/2012 at 00:46:34
No name-calling, just opinion. Moyes's 'good' points have got us where we are today; his 'bad' points not only stop us from going further, but the built-in defensive caution, aka tinkering are putting the 'whole thing' more and more out of balance. The wheels are coming off and the cure is to STOP and start again with a new face, clean slate.

One day soon, I think and hope Moyes will wake up one morning and think... "I don't want to do this any more." As much for his own good as ours.

If it is in our own good, only time will tell. But all can't be good for Davey.
Roman Sidey
124 Posted 18/03/2012 at 01:18:32
John Malone, that is a good debate. On one hand, I think that it's Heitinga that is doing the improving, in as much as when Distin and Jagielka play together it's a write off. So, Distin is one from two with his partnerships. Heitinga has played this season with Distin and Duffy, and both of those partnerships have been between fairly decent, and excellent.

As I said, it's a good debate, as Big Syl has had a pretty good season too, but I do think it's Johnny bringing it out in him.
Lee Courtliff
125 Posted 18/03/2012 at 01:51:44
£17m plus Sylvan Distin for one Joleon Lescott. We got a real fucking deal there. Jags shouldn't get back in and Johnny could even be captain before long.
Marcus Choo
126 Posted 18/03/2012 at 03:10:51
I'd be interested to see if Moyes throws whatever League match that comes before the replay...

Things didn't turn out exactly to plan, did they, Davey?
Peter Barry
127 Posted 18/03/2012 at 03:05:46
Oh dear... what a Dilemma the Dour Dire Defensive Depressing Jock has built for himself. He must now either field a much changed and utterly useless team for the Swansea game ? and get tanked in the process ? or field a strong team with tactical changes.

Okay, I admit using 'tactical' with regards to Davey Boy is a stretch. Or he will be regarded as a complete tosser for doing what he did against the Red Shite.

What to do... What to do? It doesn't matter, Davey Boy ? the damage is done and we know the arrogant contempt you have for Everton supporters.
Peter Barry
128 Posted 18/03/2012 at 03:47:47
BTW, I see Swansea under Brendan Dodgers continue to play flowing attractive, positive football. Funny that... what a difference a positive, motivational attack-minded manager can make to a team virtually identical to the one that played in the Championship.
Martin Mason
129 Posted 18/03/2012 at 04:32:57
I watched the game yesterday and, for the first time ever, I saw no hope and a belief that we are doing fairly well despite our dreadful tactics. It was called hoofball and the only time the ball went into the area it was a hoof from 40m.

The game now screams for controlled build-ups which end up with players taking the ball into the area to create chances and for goals and, I hate to say it, penalties. Hoofball is easy for any defence.

I'm ashamed to be an Evertonian after seeing two spineless performances we have seen this week. That is the last time that I will even bother to watch them on any media until they get somebody at the helm who will stop this dreadful hoofball and play the type of ball that is needed in this day and age.
Rory Slingo
130 Posted 18/03/2012 at 04:48:54
Another one of the 'be careful what you wish for' clergy. Guy, scare tactics don't work on those who aren't afraid of change.

Nick, which statements?
Michael Kenrick
131 Posted 18/03/2012 at 05:04:33
Martin,

Is that for real? Or are on some sort of a wind-up? We've had hoofball for many seasons... I can't believe it's getting to you only now?
Martin Mason
132 Posted 18/03/2012 at 05:26:56
Michael, you mustn't mistakenly identify any comment from me as a wind-up, every comment I make is genuinely made.

This isn't a road to Damascus moment as I've always hated the EFC hoofball from defence which again no team claiming any ambition for progress does. What did it for me yesterday was that we have just had a period (perhaps I was blinded by the effect of Donovan and Pienaar) and we have bought a forward who is obviously very good on the ground and in the air who would be a revalation in a team that played in the final third on the ground. And what did we do yesterday?

We fucking hoofed the ball at him from 40m and their defence ate it up. Why waste £6M on a good player and then play such dreadful soccer for him? It is the tactics of madmen and an insult to our long suffering fans that having seen how to play and picking up points by doing it well, we immediately revert to hoof. If you want to breakdown EPL defences now, you have to have them running backwards ? not in a line looking forwards, just heading out hoofs.

I apologise to Johnny Heitinga and Leighton Baines who must be wondering what they got themselves into; I apologise to Jelavic who looks genuine class; I apologise to Distin who is brilliant but not the future... but the rest you can shitcan now. I'd sooner see Everton kids playing, I'd sooner we were in the Championship but proud of how we play.

I was always positive but, after the last two games, I have none and I'm ashamed to say I back this club playing unadulterated shite like that. We cannot under any circumstances accept a total raving idiot like Steve Round and his patently crazy boss somehow finding positives out of such a train wreck as we've seen this week.

Winning at Sunderland won't change anything neither because again it will be winning despite the dreadful anti-soccer that we play.

This doesn't change my views on the board and my overall opinion of the way the club may go. I have simply snapped and say enough is enough. Sure, I've watched Everton far worse than this but I wasn't supporting a manager making £3M a year and schoolboy level footballers making even more.

The answer to shite that is unwatchable even on TV is to stop watching it. You want change? Then stop paying for the rubbish. Stop buying your season tickets, stop watching on Sky (they monitor numbers). Do this and you will see immediate change because it'll be forced on them.

We give them life by accepting what was served up yesterday. This isn't EFC you are watching any more. It is a penniless board with mercenary coaching and playing staff that are bleeding it dry. Catch it before dawn and drive a stake through its foul heart. Deprive it of its life blood and let's see where the journey takes us.

One last thing, Moyes blames the EPL for his spineless capitulation at Anfield. He should be sacked on the spot for that. As fans we have pride and I'd have sooner won at Anfield and lost gamely against Sunderland. He is a fucking disgrace.
Peter Barry
133 Posted 18/03/2012 at 05:48:59
Know what is the worst thing about watching the DROSS Dire Davey has Everton playing season after season, game after game? It's that after 58 years of caring deeply and following the Blues, I no longer give a toss what happens.

I used to get depressed when we lost and sulked... now, I just don't care ? want to know why? Because, under this Tactically Inept Dour Defensive Jock who holds Everton fans in contempt, I EXPECT to be disappointed and that disappointment Dismal Davey's Tactically Inept UnMotivated Teams always supplies.
Michael Kenrick
134 Posted 18/03/2012 at 06:45:07
Martin, I can't really fault much of what you say, other than it seems a rather drastic over-reaction to the last two games of what I think has been a very challenging season for Evertonians.

On other threads recently, you seemed to be advocating a pragmatic accommodation toward the Board of Directors, challenging those who seek change at that level, and perhaps rightly pointing out that nothing is really likely to change.

I think that applies to the management team as well: Round, Moyes, and his cadre of defense-minded coaches. They are not going to change any time soon... so shouldn't we just get behind them and support what they are doing, no matter how much it might drive us crazy? (As it seems to have done to you!)
Dave Wilson
135 Posted 18/03/2012 at 07:55:05
Teams with better players than Everton will struggle to play decent football against this Sunderalnd side. It has MON stamped all over it, very organised and very difficul to beat.

We play better against better teams because their emphasis is on their game, not stopping the opposition.

Only one team wanted to win that game after half-time yesterday, Sunderland got bodies behind the ball and made it very difficult to play football.

The onus will be on them at the Stadium of Light.

We`ll do them there.
Martin Mason
136 Posted 18/03/2012 at 08:18:30
Michael, I believe the board issue is independent to that of the team. We have what we have as a squad mostly buying with money we got from selling assets and not investing and most would say that it is reasonably strong. What has absolutely galled me this week is with that squad we have played two games of what I can only call abject football and I'd say mainly as a result in one game of a Moyes fit of pique against the EPL and in the other the most elementary tactical naivety.

I agree that we should support the club in it's downtime but watching these two games is the worst experience I've had in 55 years of actively supporting the club. Two games of diabolical selection and tactics is one thing, for the manager and head coach to then blithely shrug it off as some kind of success is an insult to us all. I just can't stand to see their insulting posture, demeanour and comments. Moyes should go not because of his coaching abilities but because he is an arsehole

I know what is coming next too and that is the rehabilitation of Jagielka into the side and either dropping Heitinga of putting him into a position in which he can't play. I'd sooner blow a fuse now than be even worsthen. Moyes was going to bring Jagielka on yesterday - it is unbelievable.
Michael Evans
137 Posted 18/03/2012 at 08:35:11
Everton used to be synonymous with playing the game in the right way with passion and flair.

Whilst Royle tenure was perhaps unfairly tarnished with the "Dogs of war" label, I seem to remember him going to Anfield with Limpar and Kanchelskis in tandem and winning - 2-0 ?

Two out and out wingers with extremely limited "tracking back" ability away from home in a Derby match.Wouldn't that concept fry the current EFC coaches minds ?!

Perhaps we should see what adjectives would come out on top in a TW poll that fellow evertonians would use to describe the football served up in DM's decade ?

DOUR

Michael Evans
138 Posted 18/03/2012 at 08:46:12
DOUR

Are you allowed to vote more than once ?!

Graham Mockford
139 Posted 18/03/2012 at 08:31:37
Martin, there we will have to disagree. I would not prefer to have won Tuesday and lost yesterday. Obviously I would have liked to have won both but given we are still actually in the Cup there remains hope.

I also would not prefer to be playing winning football in the Championship over fighting in the Premier league. It gets quoted out of context on here an awful lot but it doesn't seem like NSNO.

By all means exercise your right to stop supporting the team but I for one won't be joining your ranks, I will be too busy getting my ticket for the Stadium of Light.

As for yesterday, I actually thought we did OK in parts. Poor first 15 minutes where they got out of the traps quicker but, after that, there was only one side going to win, just disappointing we got a bit desperate in the last 15 minutes when, with more composure, it was there for the taking.

And I'm not sure what benefit it is getting hot under the collar about something that hasn't even happened. I for one would be surprised if Jags got in ahead of Johhny given his current form, the evidence of yesterday's actual selection. From my fairly close position yesterday, Jags was warmed up because of a signal by Johhny to the bench.

Once it became clear he was able to continue, Jags was sat back down, but of course I even heard the ridiculous contention on here Johhny refused to come off after Moyes tried to replace him... Utter nonsense but hey let's not miss an opportunity to have a pop at the manager.
Graham Mockford
140 Posted 18/03/2012 at 09:07:17
Well that about sums it up!
Andy Meighan
141 Posted 18/03/2012 at 09:47:51
I totally agree with previous posters about Heitinga and Distin, the pair of them are quality but I always get the feeling with Moyes that he's sitting there thinking "I hope one of these two twats gets injured so I can get Jags back in the side."

Let's face it, everyone knows he's got his favourites, ie, Cahill, Neville, Jagielka, Hibbert, Osman, Rodwell and the like. I honestly think Cahill had a decent game yesterday but I'd hate to see the crowd turn on him because he's been one great servant. But I'm afraid he looks a shadow of his former self. Obviously he got the goal and the same goes for the others I've mentioned. We need a clearout at the end of season but, with Moyes, I won't hold my breath.
Phil Walling
142 Posted 18/03/2012 at 10:20:52
Now we've got a `proper` centre forward, the order has gone out to fire hoof-balls down the middle at every opportunity. That`s what they did at Shrewsbury and Cambridge and all those other crap clubs The Moyestro played for! I bet the poor bugger's got a neck ache this morning!
Robbie Riddal
143 Posted 18/03/2012 at 13:49:56
Richard Dodd #835 - Moyes is hurt by the reaction to Black Tuesday!? I doubt he's anywhere close to as hurt as thousands of us were after being subjected to the latest derby humiliation under his stewardship.
John Keating
144 Posted 18/03/2012 at 14:04:11
Martin.

You seem to have changed your tune.

I suppose your ranting over the previous two games is only your opinion and cannot be based on facts.

Too many Effes yesterday me thinks!
Eugene Ruane
145 Posted 18/03/2012 at 14:26:46
Be careful what you wish for?

Absolutely!

A few months back, I posted my wish to see an end to the lazy, can't-be-arsed-debating-actual-points response of 'be careful what you wish for'.

Since then, I've seen the 'this will pass as an argument and make me look wise in a nose-tapping way' 'warning' about a hundred times.

By the way, do TWers think we should play our strongest side against Arsenal, or do you think we should not put all our eggs in a bush that gathers no moss?
Sam Hoare
146 Posted 18/03/2012 at 16:20:25
I think moyes made a fair point after the derby that with this many games in short time he was always going to have to utilize the squad. It's just a pity that the players who came in did so poorly. Realistically he can't play the same 11 for 7 games in 20 days.

The good news is that Johnny and distin look great, jelavic looks like a real striker and fella and Gibson looked like forming a great partnership. Sunderland will be tough and i suspect moyes will rest players at Swansea, but everyone here agrees that we should prioritise the cup right?
Mick Davies
147 Posted 18/03/2012 at 16:40:40
Opening game of the season: a Championship side who had just been battered at home by one of the PL's strugglers... and we play 4-5-1. This was the benchmark for me and I was totally devastated, realising what kind of season we were in for again.

My question to the Moyesites is this: How is it that we can't beat shite at the bottom of the table yet every so often get a result against the top sides? Is this because the manager can't motivate them or is it his tactics?

It proves the players are capable enough. Why don't we start playing until halfway through the season, and why, after this has happened for years, can't our manager work it out?

And why, when he told us at the start of last season, he has the best squad since he's been here, does he still thrive on the "Poor old skint Everton" line, after paying £16m for a wooly headed and wooly minded defensive midfielder, £11m for a striker he let go for fuck all, and £6m for a striker he hardly plays?

Final question: why have we got Moyes, Round, Stubbs, Holden and now Weir ? all defenders ? and Lumsden, a defensive midfielder who have never won anything important between them, yet no first or reserve team attack-minded coach?
John Keating
148 Posted 18/03/2012 at 17:16:46
Sam
I personally wouldn't prioritise the cup. I wouldn't have prior to the derby either.
We pay good money to see our team win. As far as I'm concerned the Arsenal match is the most important and should be treated as such.
If we had beaten the shite we could have had an outside chance of 5th spot, now I think thats beyond us.
Footy is a crazy game, teams lose when its odds on they should win and vice versa. There have been some strange results this season for all teams.
If your lucks in its in.
Play your best team and see what happens.
John Audsley
149 Posted 18/03/2012 at 17:00:02
Ha Ha Eugene

Sharp as a razor as always

At the moment i am so flat i don't care who plays against Arsenal. Moyes will probably make loads of changes and we will get tanked

The fact that he sent the biggest "Yes Boss" idiot since Phil Neal out to talk to the ITV camera's yesterday rather than face the media himself says it all to me.

He shamed the club on Tuesday (He was still right though in his own mind) as did most of the players and he aint the kind of man to EVER apologise or say "maybe i got it a tad wrong against the shite" to the fans

I'm as flat as a witchs tit.....................
Jamie Barlow
150 Posted 18/03/2012 at 17:29:42
Mick, You'd probably class me as a Moyesite so a few comments of my own.

If you remember, we should have battered QPR. Only shite finishing and their 1 shot going in lost us the game. Not Moyes 451 or his tactics.

Felli didn't cost £16 million.

Who's this £6 million pound striker that we hardly play ( I hope you don't mean Jelly). Unless you want injured players to play.

I agree about the overly defensive coaches, I can't see how that can be good for us.

Also I don't think he thrives on the "poor old skint Everton" line. He doesn't use it enough for my liking and should be telling every fucker who will listen how much his chairman and cronies have shafted him. But someone with a different opinion than you ( apologist, Moyesite, Moyesaphile or the new one, the selected) would say that wouldn't they.
Steve Barr
151 Posted 18/03/2012 at 17:54:42
Everton does not have the luxury of deciding what is more important, the league or the cup.

What I know is that we were on a good run prior to the derby and Liverpool was not. I'm not saying we were playing well, just that we had found a way to grind out a win.

The kiddies guide to coaching would tell you to keep that run going.

Inevitably, we lose the biggest game of our season, I dare anyone to argue the derby is not that, and consequently struggle to beat a very average Sunderland team at home.

Conversely, Liverpool are over the moon at coming out of their piss poor run by beating Everton in the derby, and surprise surprise, they despatch Stoke in the Cup and reach the semi final.

What are we missing here? Where is the confusion, what is the logic?

It's simple, play your best team, subject to injury of course, and bloody win.

Stop this apologist shit and accept that Moyes is overated.

Everton deserve better than this. 60 grand a week to get it so wrong and people continue to defend him... oh we're so lucky to have Moyes. He's kept us in the Prem, any one else would have got us relegated blah, fucking blah.

I'm fed up.

Jamie Barlow
152 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:20:13
Steve, a genuine question.

Would you class the derby fixture as a bigger game than a semi final or final?

Would you rather beat Liverpool than get to a cup final?

Is it any wonder they call us bitter?
Steve Barr
153 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:26:09
Jamie,

I expect (sorry want) Everton to beat Liverpool in any derby and win any semi or final we are in.

I am not entertaining an either or or scenario.

My expectations have always been positive as far as Everton is concerned.

Unfortunately that is slowly being knocked out of me by the dour negative underperforming dross delivere of late.

You seem to be accepting we can't have both?

Sorry, I want both, or at least a manager that believes we can win everything. I know we can't but let's start out with that belief and you never know.

Jamie Barlow
154 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:37:41
I'm not accepting we can't have both.

I'm just saying Moyes might have to rest some players to have the best chance of winning both and in Moyes's eyes (and mine) the Sunderland game was more important.
Steve Barr
155 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:39:12
Sorry Jamie, in answer to your specific question. Strangely I do think a derby win rates higher than a semi final or cup final win. Unless the semi or final is against Liverpool.

I enjoyed the cup final win against Watford and Man U. but the feeling i had after those victories fades in comparison to a good/any Derby win.

I remember all our derby wins like they were yesterday, can't get too excited about beating Warford, Sheff Wed... or even the Man U win in 1995 for that matter.

Again, I want us to win the derby and the cup. Not either or.
Jamie Barlow
156 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:49:09
Fair enough Steve.
Steve Barr
157 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:49:01
Jamie, fair enough. I respect your point of view.

I don't personally agree that at this stage of the season we should have rested our 'form players".

I just wanted us to build on the winning run.
John Keating
158 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:49:52
Jamie, you asked if the derby was bigger than a semi or a final. Well Sunderland was a quarterfinal ? and we haven't got through that yet!!!

I agree with Steve. Why couldn't we have expected both? Why is it one or the other?

Defeatist, cowardly in my opinion.
Steve Barr
159 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:53:38
Jamie,

I don't know you at all but appreciate the fact that you disagree with my point of view and are not rude or personally insulting because I don't agree with you

I like this web site but do get very annoyed at people attacking other people in a very personal, insulting way, just because they put forward a point of view that differs from theirs.

Let's have a respectful debate.

We all love Everton, that is clear.

COYBs
Mark Stone
160 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:53:12
Steve, all the evidence points to you being in a minority though. Most people I have spoken to on here have repeated several times that they would rather finish 17th and win a Cup. Most will not judge the manager based on his record of decent league placings, they just say he's shite because he hasn't won a Cup.

It's not a philosophy I subscribe to, as league position is a truer reflection of the quality of the team you have built, but it does seem to be the position stand of a huge section of ToffeeWeb's regular contributors.
Jamie Barlow
161 Posted 18/03/2012 at 18:56:06
I know Sundeland was a quarter final John.

Steve said that the derby was the biggest game of the season and said he dares anyone to say different.

I was just using a semi final or final as an argument for them being bigger games than the derby.

I'm not from Liverpool (I've no idea if Steve is) so maybe that has something to do with our difference of opinion. Maybe not.
Jamie Barlow
162 Posted 18/03/2012 at 19:02:27
I agree Steve. Some of the name calling and abuse on here since Tuesday has very nearly put me off commenting, or even coming on here.
Steve Barr
163 Posted 18/03/2012 at 19:12:38
Mark,

Upon reflection I realise my stance/feelings are more idealistic than realistic.

I agree that the league position is more indicative of a teams standing than a one off cup win.

On that argument, then Moyes has done a good job delivering an average league position of somewhere in the top 10 over his 10 year reign.



Logically I should be pleased and appreciative of Moyes' contribution. To a certain extent I am... but I also want us to play good attacking football, and win the cup and challenge for the title. And beat Liverpool at every opportunity of course.

If all we can expect is to remain in the top half of the Prem, then let's do it in style and with a positive outlook. Let's start off believing we can win the lot.

I don't believe Moyes can take us any further and am optimistic that there is a manager out there who can deliver results, even if it is Premiership safety, but in style.

I love watching good football, particularly if it is played by Everton.

By the way Jamie, I am from Liverpool originally, Wavertree, but now reside in the USA.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
164 Posted 18/03/2012 at 20:14:05
Jamie #128, if there are specific examples of name-calling and abuse, please let us know and we will take appropriate action.
Jamie Barlow
165 Posted 18/03/2012 at 20:28:38
Nah Michael, the abuse that bothers me is the unnecessary names that Moyes gets thrown at him that doesn't concern how he manages Everton FC. He deserves criticism but some words go to far.

I can handle the abuse I get. Some of it's even quite funny.

Thanks.
Gavin Ramejkis
166 Posted 18/03/2012 at 21:28:19
Jamie regarding beating the RS or the Cup game, in context the extra impetus of beating them on the Tuesday could have been an extra spur to the players to make it ten unbeaten going into the Cup game against Sunderland with an extra eye on the next round draw which always had a good chance of drawing the RS again, two wins then and an eye on getting a potential double over the RS at Wembley be it in a semi or final itself.

Instead it was a really poor derby for many reasons already done to death but brushed under the carpet by the guy paid very handsomely to get results and a slow out of the blocks cup game and we now have to face them with the returned Cattermole and Sessegnon which will be a much harder game and then the RS still grinning like Cheshire Cats over the abject shite we served up at their place.
Michael Parrington
167 Posted 18/03/2012 at 21:55:40
Can't help feeling that the team looked a lot more balanced with Gibson on the pitch. Is he cup tied? And when's he due back from injury?

I was dissappointed with the loss against Liverpool mid week, but understood the reasons Moyes made his choices, even if I didn't agree.... Especially in regards to Heitinger!

Hopefully we can perform away from home and then have the chance to beat Liverpool at Wembley. Now that would be sweet revenge!

But again by the semi, if we get there, I would like to see Gibson back. I know he's not setting the world on fire with his play on the ball, but his positional discipline is excellent, and especially this really allows Fellaini to shine...
Jamie Barlow
168 Posted 18/03/2012 at 21:51:50
I agree Gavin. There was no reason we couldn't have won both.

If I could have chosen to win only one game though, it would have been the cup game. My opinion only.

Moyes obviously had the same thoughts. He wanted to rest players for what he thought the more important game.

In my opinion, half of the players he left out were justified:

? Jelavic went off in the Spurs game and sat on the bench with an ice pack on his leg.
? Ossie only just came back from injury.
? Drenthe is a liability at home, nevermind away at Liverpool.
? Two others (Cahill and Neville) get slated on here almost daily, as does Moyes for playing them. I would have played them both as well as JH (although somebody on this site said he might have been a yellow away from being suspended)

I don't think he bottled it and the team he did put out let him down just as much as he let the fans down. I've never seen so many half hearted tackles in a derby. Maybe a lot of the players had one eye on the cup game also.
Michael Kenrick
170 Posted 18/03/2012 at 22:36:44
Michael (#201), Gibson is not cup-tied, he's played in two of the four ties. Let's hope he's back for the Sunderland replay so he can continue to forge that understanding with Fellaini.
Roman Sidey
171 Posted 18/03/2012 at 22:48:09
Jamie, I acknowledge that people have different opinions, but this comment doesn't cut the mustard:

"If I could have chosen to win only one game though".

That statement, right there, is the problem. It is a hypothetical that does nothing but create insecurity and purvey a defeatist attitude.

We should have gone into both games to win both games.

I have stayed away from the Neville and Cahill debate this week, as, yes, I was calling for Cahill to be benched a long time ago, although I'll claim to favouring Neville at RB than Hibbert.

The thing that fucking gripes me about Moyes is, he plays Cahill to no end, out of form and fitness, and only decides to drop him for the derby ? a fixture that Cahill has one of the best scoring records in recent history (probably 2nd now to Gerrard!).
Jamie Barlow
172 Posted 19/03/2012 at 00:31:38
Roman, I agree with your comments on Neville and Cahill. Both would have played if I was picking the team.

I also would have tried to win both but it wasn't possible in my opinion to play the same team in both games.

Moyes picked a team capable of getting something out of the Liverpool game. It was certainly a better team than the performance they gave us.

Moyes was at fault for picking a weakened team but the players were a massive let down. As I said earlier, maybe too many players had an eye on the cup game too judging by some of the tackles they were jumping out of.
Dan Schweizer
173 Posted 19/03/2012 at 03:52:05
Sorry Jamie why was it not possible to play the same team Tuesday and Sunday? It's a joke, we did it in Europe and that was Thursday and Sunday! The team didn't perform in the derby because he picked a formation the team aren't used to and players who are out of form. The players, the fans and even himself knew this, the players didn't play with the whole hearted confidence because Moyes gave them none. Every competition we are in we should aim to win if he doesn't do that then he shouldn't be at the club.

Could you imagine what Arsenal fans would say if Wenger made six changes against Tottenham, or vice versa?
Martin Mason
174 Posted 19/03/2012 at 04:24:07
John@045

Of course it?s my opinion but based on actual events so it satisfies my criteria for opinion having some basis. We did base our tactics against Sunderland on hoofing the ball into the area; we were disgraceful in the game against Liverpool on the basis of selection and tactics. "Fact" is a very difficult concept and whilst, for example, a statement made at an enquiry and recorded officially is probably fact, events over two soccer games can never be stated as fact. Would you not agree?

Did you have a look at the timing of my posts? I do like Efes but not at 0800hrs when I?m working.
Rahman Talib
175 Posted 19/03/2012 at 05:05:15
I always thought the reason why our passing game stunk last Saturday was because Osman didn't turn up for the races. From 1st until the 90th minute, the dude was pedestrian. Might as well put Barkley there, we'd seen some activity.
Jamie Barlow
177 Posted 19/03/2012 at 07:14:18
Dan, I've explained in post 211 why I don't think it was possible to pick the same team.

Also, if you need your manager to get you worked up for a derby, there must be something wrong.
Tony J Williams
178 Posted 19/03/2012 at 12:41:02
"Tony J Williams #781 ? I made my point. What the fuck's yours? " - Just seen this, my point is that it's a fucking ridiculous thing to say.

"There for the taking", must be one of the most idiotic phrases on here. So Sunderland, who are above us in the league, had just beaten Liverpool and are enjoying a ressurgence under O'Neill.....let's get this straight... they were there for the taking where they? Why?

Pure idiocy.
John Keating
179 Posted 19/03/2012 at 13:01:20
Martin, I definetely agree. Statements made at inquiries are probable facts. It's a pty you can't accept that.

Regarding your posts. The reason I mentioned you having too many Effes "yesterday" (read my post) was that for some reason it appeared that you woke up at kick-off time on Tuesday and saw Everton play hoofball, similarly on Saturday. Are these the first games you've seen in the last few years?

There have ? on a very few occasions ? been times when we've played the ball on the ground, and a few times we've played half decent footy, but in general hoofball has been par for the course.

Now that observation, Martin, is not opinion but fact!!
Martin Mason
180 Posted 20/03/2012 at 02:23:17
John Keating

I accept any statement made as long as it is referenced as I referenced the bits that I quoted. I don?t accept the hand waving waffling of ?facts? raised that weren?t in the report (and I read it). Don?t invent facts please, demonstrate them.

I read your post thank you although I struggled to see any constructive points in it and whatever it may have ?appeared? to you, I didn?t wake up to watch Everton Tuesday or Saturday. No it isn?t the first game I?ve seen in the last few years; I get to see most of Everton?s games here and at home

I?m glad to see you agree with me on the hoof ball and I have never said that we have never played joined up football. If you?re struggling I can recommend good web based dictionaries that will explain to you the difference between opinion and fact.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads