Scintillating Second-Half Blues

, 24 March, 77comments  |  Jump to most recent
Swansea City 0 - 2 Everton

Match Summary

David Moyes strangely chose to make very few team changes despite an impending FA Cup Quarterfinal, and a repeat of the derby circumstances when he fatefully rested more than half of his team... and lost shamefully to a horrible Gerrard hat-trick.

Fellaini and Heitinga were moved onto the bench, with Gibson surprisingly slotted straight back into a re-jigged midfield featuring Moyes's old favourites, Neville, Osman and Cahill. Drenthe did not travel. Jelavić in the lone striker role once again.

Danny Graham got the first decent chance, getting behind Hibbert but his low effort was tame as both sides sounded each other out rather tentatively, not improved by a dreadful first-time cross from Hibbert.

Baines swung in a decent free-kick that Jelavic got to but could only head wide. Another excellent free-kick opportunity swung in by Baines fell to Gibson but his strike was more rugby than soccer. Baines then drove one in hard, deflected for a corner, but Everton were not really coming all that close despite having plenty of possession.

Swansea did make one good attack near the break, that needed firm intervention by Jagielka, as Allen went in far too high on Neville and got himself booked.

Lively forward moves from both sides hopefully set the pace for the second half, but defenses were still out-pointing attacks as neither side seemed capable of taking the lead. Jelavic went on a great little run from wide left, only to astoundingly pass the ball back poorly behind Osman rather than fire in a shot as Everton started to build up some head of steam, a fantastic strike from Gibson forcing a spectacular save.

Stirred by Everton's initiative, Swansea constructed their own good move, Routledge nodding over with Howard stranding himself. Pienaar, released down the left then tried a grass-cutter of his own but curled it agonizingly wide, while at the other end, Sinclair powered over as Fellaini readied himself to replace Cahill.

Baines drew a rather soft foul to earn a dangerous free-kick that he then curled up and over the wall, superbly away from Vorm and right into the top corner for a fantastic strike!!

With their tails up and the Blues contingent singing happily, Pienaar was released down the left by a superb ball from Gibson, but his strike was marginally wide of the far post, with Brendan Rogers stung into making a triple change to turn things around in the final 20 mins, as Gibson got a soft card for stepping in on Sinclair.

With Swansea stretched, Pienaar and Jelavic strode forward in style, a great move, a perfect feed to Jelavic, who astoundingly stroked his gifted set-up past the post! Horrendous miss!!!

Baines got forward well and played another excellent cutback to Jelavic but he was under too much pressure. Then it was Fellaini's turn with some excellent work on the byline, following a Hibbert throw-in and exchange pass on the ground to beat two men in the Swansea area and set up Jelavić just 5 yards out and he couldn't miss this time! Third go's a charm!!! Job done, and a few minutes later, Moyes swapped the Croatian out for El Traca.

Pienaar again broke forward in space, waited an age rather than shooting, and then laid it on a plate for Stracqualursi but the big lumox tamely passed it to the keeper!!! Pienaar set him up again a few minutes later with another excellent move into the Swansea area but it was behind Stracq and he tried to be too acrobatic with it. Still should have scored.

All the decent second-half stuff seemed to come after Everton decided they could play the ball on the ground, rather than lumping in a succession of useless aimless crosses that had dominated the first half stalemate.

3 points from a massive mid-table six-pointer gives Everton those magic 40 points Moyes has been focused on all season, and moves them up to 9th, above Swansea City. Not a bad day's work! And hopefully a great confidence booster for Tuesday big game...

Everton (4-5-1): Howard; Hibbert, Distin, Jagielka, Baines; Osman, Gibson (85' Heitinga), Cahill (58' Fellaini), Neville, Pienaar; Jelavić (81' Stracqualursi).
Subs: Mucha, McFadden, Gueye, Anichebe.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (77)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Domino Darkley
2 Posted 24/03/2012 at 15:40:03
Why is McFadden taking up a place on the bench?
Kris Boner
3 Posted 24/03/2012 at 15:55:06
Why is Neville in midfield? Where is Barkley? Where is Vellios? Some many questions, so few answers?

Please tell me Everton are not turning into the football equivalent of Lost (the tv programme).
Jim Knightley
4 Posted 24/03/2012 at 16:22:48
Are you watching the game? we've dealt with Swansea about as well as anyone at the liberty.
Kris Boner
5 Posted 24/03/2012 at 16:47:39
I wrote that post long before our second half domination and personally I thought in the first half we had no real attacking threat, probably due to neville's lack of creativity.

Second half performance was probably one of the better performances this year.
Phil Roberts
7 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:13:08
Most tweets seemed to say Moyes won the tactical battle with Rogers.

And some prats think Brendan is a better manager. Numbskulls
Richard Dodd
8 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:11:09
You can always trust Davey to bring a rabbit out of the hat. Position eight-just great!!!

Where are you now ,Tony Marsh?
Paul Foster
9 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:08:36
A fair few people on the Swansea vs Everton mailbag thread should be hanging their heads in shame. Wanting Everton to lose? Looking forward to being humiliated? Absolutely disgraceful comments.

Great performance today, fantastic win. Perfect response.

I know on Toffeeweb we're not meant to talk about money because, in the magical Toffeeweb land, the amount of money you spend doesn't actually affect how you perform. But all the same, I think some of you should take a look at this table of transfer fees:

2006 - 2011: http://www.transferleague.co.uk/league-tables/2006-2011.html (Average of 1.8m per year and outspent by Bolton, Stoke, West Brom, Fulham and Wolves, among others)

2003-2011: http://www.transferleague.co.uk/league-tables/2003-2011.html (Average of 1.9m per season and again outspent by all of those teams)

Consistently under Moyes, Everton have been around 15th in the league in terms of money spent. And consistently, we've been top 7 in terms of final league position. How this man gets so much stick is beyond me.

P.S. Amusingly, Liverpool have spent an average of 17m per season since 2003 making them the third biggest spenders in the league!
Anto Byrne
10 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:06:43
The game opened up after the Baines goal, they had no choice but to press for an equaliser and that created holes for Pienaar to exploit.

Gibson adds something and always finds a forward pass. It was a nice shot that the keeper kept out. Dreary first 45 with nothing clear cut.

It was nice to see some flowing attractive football for the last 35 mins and, with a bit more composure in front of goal, it could have been four, both the Stracq and Jelly missing absolute sitters.

Well it's all to do on Tuesday, not sure what the line-up will be, hopefull that Gibbo and Felli will start and Jonny back in the centre.
Ryan Holroyd
11 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:24:51
So Moyes has beaten Rogers twice, Lambert once, Mancini one, Redknapp once this season but he's tactically inept as far as most people on here say.

But we've also got shit players who are useless as most on here say.
Martin Mason
12 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:22:16
Fantastic performance today. As a squad though I still rate them as too weak overall to make any challenge to the top sides. I'd be churlish though to deny them their day today even though one game doesn't make a season. Gibson seems to be the catalyst. I feel a lot better about Sunderland now but still a mountain for us to climb.

Great performance from the team and from our manager today.
Rory Slingo
13 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:19:05
Er.. Phil @193, we're just one place above Swansea now, they've only lost 3 at home this season, we've lost six. They've played the more attractive football. I'd say Rogers is nicking it. Let's see how we end up after 8 more games? If the two clubs finish within one or two places of each other, then for the money Rogers must be the better manager.

Anyway, that was a little better from the boys and Moyes got it right today. Should've been 4-0 really but hey, I'll take 2-0! More of the same on Tues please!
Sam Hoare
14 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:29:59
Paul Foster... you should write a whole thread on those figures. It belies belief how often people sweep the net spend that Moyes has had under the table. His performance under such restraints is really what earns him such well deserved praise.
Kevin Sparke
15 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:29:51
"Clubs like Norwich and Swansea actually put Moyes's Everton to shame and that's what hurts most. Small minnow clubs putting the once mighty Everton in the shade when it comes to playing it right"

Swansea 0 Everton 2

To the numb-nuts on the match thread who call themselves Evertonians and 'hoped we got beat' today... how do you like them apples?
Keith Glazzard
16 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:22:07
Moyes won the tactical battle without doubt. The idea that Swansea can outplay almost anyone at home was put to bed in the first half - even with Neville in midfield.

But the second half was down to the players. Baines, Pienaar and, at the hour on the dot, Fellaini showed the them how to play. And Gibson showed how valuable he can be.

Jags played very well - even going forward! - which could be a problem if Moyes now disrupts the the back 4.
Sam Hoare
17 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:34:25
Great result! Is it coincidence we really started gelling after Cahill came off? Great servant but really believe he is largely responsible for our general toothlessness up front. Hope Moyes finds someone else to start playing in that position for the long run...
David Gunning
18 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:35:10
Come on Pete Barry, what you thinking tonight?
Phil Bellis
19 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:29:47
That's all us whingers have wanted - keep it on the deck, run about a bit, pass to a team-mate who has just made space by running about a bit, play in triangles but look for the forward pass, stop the oppositon from playing football by playing football ourselves

I keep asking why Moyesy doesn't let the players off the leash - today showed it can be done, even allowing for the Swansea ethos
Totally confused - why can't we do that more often; that's the first time in ages I've been happy with a Blues display for a reason other than showing 100% commitment against the rich clubs
James Kirrane
20 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:40:18
I feared the worst today against Swansea. What a great result. What is it with Gibson? We have not lost a game that he has played in! Wrap him in cotton wool and long may it continue! The Shite humbled by Wigan! Bring on Saturday night!
Danny James
21 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:35:37
I knew we would beat them. We play well against the passing teams this season. City, Spurs and Chelsea in recent weeks, all teams that pass the ball around have been despatched.

This could bode well for the Sunderland replay. I was worried at the return of Sessegnon but he will encourage Sunderland to come at us and they might spread the ball around a little more. If we can soak it up for a little while, we might be able to break through them second half ? like today.
Kevin Sparke
22 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:39:15
The big difference for me was the performance of Gibson - he doesn't do the spectacular, but his solid, short passing, spoiling game allows Screech freedom to roam and this helps out by providing an extra man on the flanks.

It's no coincidence that we're unbeaten in every game Gibson's played in. A very shrewd acquisition by Moyes.

Pienaar was shit hot today as was Jelly ? though he should have had one or two more.
Phil Brown
23 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:37:45
Moyes tends to do well when we play away. It's when we are at home and the team has to show some guile and invention that we're poor.

Purely down to our managers strengths and weaknesses and, in particular, that he retains Timmy as our main threat.
Jimmy Sørheim
24 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:40:50
Agree with you Sam. Cahill is not what he once was, he disrupts our flow of play as he is too slow.

Problem is that thiswas a one-off in terms of our whole crappy season. I expect us to draw or lose against Sunderland because Moyes ALWAYS manages to fuck things up by messing with the winning team. Putting the in-form players on the bench while letting out-of-form and players with no match practice.

I am not over confident and I blame that on Moyes. He just loves to juggle it around just enough to fuck it up.

Even still, as I am an Evertonian, I have a small hope of getting to Wembley, and getting revenge on Liverpool.
John Crossley
25 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:58:14
We have been so negative in all or away games, it was nice to see us controlling the ball and attacking for once. Let's hope we continue with the positive attitude against Sunderland. COYB
Keith Glazzard
26 Posted 24/03/2012 at 17:51:22
Kevin - I was about to write an essay to your guide dog when I thought you were saying that Pienaar was shit today. I'm glad I reread what you said - "shit hot" - and you are so right.

Jelavic is finding his feet very well, and today will have done him a lot of good. That thigh trap and overhead that so nearly went in is something we're not too used to seeing. He looks like a very good addition.
Chris Robinson
27 Posted 24/03/2012 at 18:00:18
HA HAAAAA! Oh ye of such little faith! Shame on those who expected a loss today! OK, so I got the scoreline wrong (neither 0-1 nor 1-2), but it appears that Abertawe created even less chances than I predicted and couldn't even get on the scoresheet. A great win for the Blues.

Moyes seems to have the measure of Rodgers, but what must he be thinking now after the bugger's last two results? If only he'd not bottled the Derby... I think we need to be practicing penos for Sunderland.
Kevin Sparke
28 Posted 24/03/2012 at 18:09:05
Cahill was so nearly on the end of that overhead kick - it would have been a spectacular goal.
James Morgan
29 Posted 24/03/2012 at 18:05:57
Ryan, he's also lost to Warnock, Pardew, Coyle, Dogleash, Ferguson and Wenger...what's your point?

I saw the second half and was pleased with what I saw apart from we should have scored about 6. I love Timmy he has been a great servant but I think it's time he got less minutes on the pitch now. We need quick thinking link up play between midfield and attack and he just doesn't offer it.
Ed Fitzgerald
30 Posted 24/03/2012 at 18:16:04
A really pleasing win today however the Moyes lovers need to tone it down a bit. The acid test is Tuesday and then if we do win will he have the belief to actually attack a very poor Liverpool team ? as he should've done the other Tuesday instead of shitting himself everytime we play them.

We are better at playing on the counter because that's his mentality; it worked today but let's not forget the absolute shite that we normally get served up at home. You can't win the Cup by defending can you? Unless its pens all the way and, let's face it, we aren't great at them.
James Martin
31 Posted 24/03/2012 at 18:33:17
Why all the Cahill bashing? Did he not keep Britton out the game in the first half and set the tempo for our closing down? Was he not the best player against Sunderland the other match? He's on the decline, yes and in a second half like this one he probably wouldn't have been much good, but at the Stadium of Light on Tuesday, if Everton have one of their lethargic starts, you want him there in the team because it's often him alone that the others copy their workrate off.

Actually Ed you can win the cup by defending, Liverpool did it in both legs against City and nicked their goals.

Rory, if Swansea have lost only 3 times at home and we've lost 6 then obviously their brand of superior football doesn't work away from home, does it, if we're ahead of them in the league? Over two matches, Rodgers has done absolutely nothing to us and couldn't change anything today, his subs were terrible, and he had no plan B when his first formation didn't work ? sound familiar?

I see Liverpool have also lost two on the bounce and thier fans have been in moaning about 4-5-1 at home. All football managers have their faults, including Moyes, the difference is that when Dalglish wins any game he's getting lauded as a messiah; when Moyes wins, people criticise it for being a negative win, or worst of all, just a lucky spin on the football lottery.
Jamie Barlow
32 Posted 24/03/2012 at 18:45:55
Need to tone it down a bit?

How bad has Toffeeweb become when you can't come on to express how pleased you are with a result.
Phil Rodgers
33 Posted 24/03/2012 at 18:58:11
Very good result today. Let's hope we can keep sessengon quiet and do them on Tuesday
Ian Glassey
34 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:11:40
Thought the game changed when Fellaini came on, he could be a world beater if he wants it. Praise to Peanuts, Jelly, Gibbo and Jags but Johnny has to play on Tuesday.
Al Reddish
35 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:16:57
Just off piste a bit here......Bluekipper seem to think Drenthe has been sacked and sent back to Madrid, anyone know anything?
Andy Crooks
36 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:30:18
Good result, good performance, Well done the players and David Moyes.
Dean Adams
37 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:26:22
So, it now seems to be that Everton fans cannot celebrate a win on Toffeeweb, as it upsets the MOB. Classic!!!

There are some really sad twats that post on Toffeeweb that cant bring themselves to chear a victory, in a game very few would have expected us to score twicw and frankly it could have been six. It is a sad enditement on the deluded people who call themselves "Everton supporters", that they actually dont "support" the team. Why are you always trying to segregate and divide our support? Any takers?
Mike Green
39 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:48:37
Too right Jamie. Call me fickle but the sun is shiiining, the birds are siiiinging! We've had a pretty dire season so call me a whore but I'm going to enjoy today. Fairs fair, if the manager and lads do the business then fair play. Let's hope it runs into Sunderland on Tuesday and we turn them over. All is not well across the park, what is there to be glum about....?!
Barry Rathbone
40 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:47:38
Dean

list those MOBsters behaving as you say.

On another post one of your ilk has just admitted wanting to put 2 fingers up to those not sharing his (and your) view about Moyes - that might explain why people are not as one.
Rory Slingo
41 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:05:54
James, we're ahead of them by ONE point. So Rogers is doing a comparable job to Moyes in getting results while playing better football. Moyes is on £3.4m a year. Rogers is on what, £700k? Maybe Rogers for Moyes would be a like-for-like swap, at least it would save the club £2.4m and we'd be a bit more entertaining to watch.
Ian Linn
42 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:53:57
#268,

Al I read the same thing - can;t find any confirmation.

To be honest, if it has happened, I don;t think it's a big deal, Drenthe is a loose cannon, runs into blind alleys, falls over a lot and gives away a lot of unnecessary foals. For me, he should never be a starter, just a 60 minute sub if the game ain't doing our way.

Great win today, it's on the telly over here in an hour or so, better get the lawn finished......
Phil Smith
43 Posted 24/03/2012 at 19:54:57
"...his strike was more rugby than soccer." I thought it was football but there you go.
Great win today. Could and should have bagged more in the second half. Swansea believing their own hype a little today.
Phil Smith
44 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:00:16
On Drenthe being dropped:
http://twitter.com/#!/RDrenthe10
Dean Adams
45 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:03:50
Barry Rathbone 281

"On another post one of your ilk has just admitted wanting to put 2 fingers up to those not sharing his (and your) view about Moyes - that might explain why people are not as one. "

One of my ilk!! Really Barry. I am just a fan of EFC and have been since the early 80's when my idols were the likes of the one and only "Big Nev", Rats and co. If I wish to be happy when my team win, in a manner that I enjoy, I will celebrate, regardless of my feelings toward our manager. (I neither love or hate him).

Normally we play such boring and unimaginative crap, but today I will marvel in what I saw. If you wish to see things differently, then by all means carry on. But don't moan like a cheap tart when others rejoice. It just shows you as a bitter and twisted loser.
Barry Rathbone
46 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:12:02
Dean

The more you speak the more unhinged you show yourself to be.

In a tantrum you claim something you can't prove (you never did provide the MOBster list, an' I don't mean Al Capone - couldn't resist it) then you list your fan credentials as though it's of any relevance before throwing more insults around.

You're unstable and need a glass of milk.
Richard Harris
47 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:11:21
Poor first half, some excellent moves in the second half, one sublime free kick, one well worked goal, some very good chances missed, tactics right, energy and desire from the players. But 12 losses so far and only 11 wins and a minus goal difference so improvement is still needed. We can't afford to miss out on European competition again so an FA Cup win or high league placing is the minimum we should demand. I'd prefer to have both, as we can't win the league, but maybe that's being greedy (or deluded?)
Dean Adams
48 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:21:50
Barry Rathbone 294

Why do I have to tell you who the MOB are? Is it that you are so stupid that you cant work out what everyone else on Toffeeweb knows, you know even the ones that you imply have no right to state their opinion.

If you feel you are so clever, then explain why once again Moyes has proved you wrong, after all you are always telling us how tactically inept he is.

Never mind, go take your tablets and run along little man. It really is sad that you fail to enjoy a victory, again.
Andy Crooks
49 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:23:13
Dean, I suppose I am one of the MOB. I am an Evertonian first, though, and have made my feelings known on post #271. I doubt there is an Evertonian anything other than well pleased tonight. Sorry, well pleased is pathetic. Fucking brilliant!
Chris Butler
50 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:35:05
Isn't it a shame Moyes didn't decide to play a full strength team at Anfield. I don't know whether to be pleased or annnoyed. It shows that he understands he has to play a decent team despite the cup game, yet he made the dreadful mistake at Anfield. Plus even Wigan beat those cheats so an in form full strength Everton could've easily got a result.
Dean Adams
51 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:37:32
Andy Crooks 298

I read your post #271, fair play you seem to be able to acknowledge a performance when you see one. I doubt though having seen some of the posts on this site that all so called Evertonians are as magnaminous as you. I beleive I share your enthusiasm for our result though.
Jamie Barlow
52 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:29:31
Andy, you've been both apologist and MOB member about 15 times each since I've been coming on here. I always look forward to your posts to see which way you're swinging.

I wouldn't be too sure about all Evertonians being pleased after reading some of the bollocks on the match day thread earlier today.
Mike Green
53 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:38:59
Good for you Andy Crooks, I'll be raising a glass with you tonight. I mean, that's the spirit isn't it? We won and won well - so if you can't enjoy that for a few hours after the game what is the point. Might as well take up darts.
Barry Rathbone
54 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:45:23
Dean

You commented thus:

"So, it now seems to be that Everton fans cannot celebrate a win on Toffeeweb, as it upsets the MOB."

A complete falsehood, nobody is stopping anyone doing anything (nor could they) plus every post I've read is happy with todays display.

What you're probably getting your knickers in a twist about is the lack of joyous vindication of Moyes as the Moyesiah, the slayer of the Brendan Rodgers rebel who dares to defy the "money excuse" with good football and progress - a "knickers twisted situation" shared by one or two other of the cult.

Try to remember you support Everton and not Moyes, he will go one day you and others will appear quite camp if you keep pining like a gang of lovesick chimps.
James Stewart
55 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:09:03
All the apologists out in force I see after a away win.

Very strange game as I really didn't see us scoring til Baines's moment of brilliance. Jelavic could have had a hat-trick! Great win over a very good Swansea side.

I hardly think this equates to Moyes's beating Rogers though. We have had a very poor season on the all and it's about time we started winning! Swansea on the other hand were supposed to be this season's whipping boys. If Moyes leaves in the summer, we would be lucky to have Rogers.
Dan Brierley
56 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:14:28
Good result, but we need to finish more of the chances we create. Its really killing us at the moment our lack of cutting edge in front of goal.

My heart bleeds for all those shithouses that 'hoped' we lost today. Hang your heads in shame. Whether you like Moyes or not, you should never spout crap like that about the boys who play in Royal Blue. Fucking disgraceful.
Andy Crooks
57 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:11:06
Jamie I have never been, to use your term, an apologist. In fact I wanted Moyes gone 3-4 years ago and was a small minority on this site. I still want him gone but I will always acknowledge his achievements and will enjoy and celebrate a win. I imagine that anyone who has been reading toffeeweb for the last few years will find your comments as amazing as I do.
Mike Green
58 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:12:14
Barry - seems to me your posts are more about Moyes than anyone else's. What did he do to you? WHAT DID HE DO?!?!
Alex Willett
59 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:18:43
Bring on tuesday, bring on the semi, and after we have crushed the SHITE!!!!! bring on the final. F.A. cup winners 2012.
Still, big changes needed.
David Edwards
60 Posted 24/03/2012 at 20:52:42
Firstly - I want to say how chuffed I am that we have made the 40 point mark - and before Easter too! I seriously, seriously, feared relegation earlier on - given the unpredictable nature of this season. Staying in the top flight isn't just a financial necessity - it's about the only thing our proud club can boast these days!

Moyes's attitude, ambition, tactics, choices and outlook was dreadful earlier on - and I honestly feared the worse. It would need a real turn around, and thankfully the January window, Donovan, a bit of luck for once and finally some belief with all concerned, got us on the run we needed.

Seeing my former Everton favourite Peanuts return was a difficult one for me to take - but his behaviour and attitude since then has gladly made me eat humble pie, and the string of good results of late has made ALL Evertonians extremely happy!

However, let's stop the sour grapes amongst the pro- and anti-Moyes posters. Everyone is over the moon about today - the second half performance was the club at its best.

So, it makes it so much harder to take what might have been this strange season if Moyes had started to act like the great manager the media think he is, and merely a good, but limited manager many of us feel he is (albeit a genuinely nice guy).

The Liverpool debacle was a real kick in the teeth for many of us and it leaves a taste in our mouths that maybe only an FA Cup Final win is going to remove. Sunderland away is going to be very tough, and I fear them more than the lousy Liverpool team we should have shown up over a week ago! I just hope Moyes gets the chance to redeem himself at Wembley against them.

So....a season of mediocrity, littered with dreadful performances, drab football and only occasionally lifted by the belief of old in some games - often against the odds againast the Sky big boys.

If you want mid-table solidity - stick with Moyes (unless Spurs are daft enough to want him) - but if you think we are worth more than that - then let's have less deriding Rodgers etc..- because given his vision of how football should be played (even if it doesn't always lead to points) - I just wonder what a manager like that could do with our club....given the chance.

After 10 years of relative stability, isn't it time to start thinking.....what if....rather than fear what might be?
Tim Kirk
61 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:14:28
Phil Smith (#290). Do you reckon that is the real Drenthe on Twitter? Not many followers, not verified and never tweets in Dutch - unlike the great Mr Heitinga...
Phil Smith
64 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:44:57
Hey TIm (#340), I think he has a few Twitter profiles. This one seems to have been set up just for his time at Everton. There seems to be another one with Dutch posts but hasn't used it since being with us. What makes me think it's him is the other people who have tweeted him.
Jamie Barlow
67 Posted 24/03/2012 at 21:55:33
I must have you mistaken gor someone else then Andy.
Tim Kirk
68 Posted 24/03/2012 at 22:05:48
That makes me feel better Phil (358). We need his energy and unpredictability so I hope these rumours are rubbish. Slightly concerned as living as I do near Alicante (where he played on loan for Hercules last season) he burned very brightly for the first half of the season and then self destructed and did get sent back to Real Madrid.

Digressing somewhat, one of the (many) advantages of being in Spain is seeing nearly all EFC games live (except when the Man United mafia get in the local boozer before me) so today´s result and (more importantly) performance compared to the games against the shite (unforgiveable) and mackems (lots of smoke but no fire) gives hope for Tuesday. Also, although 3 points against Swansea doesn´t seem much, we haven´t got much to play against in the League, bar the other red scum, until the end of the season and although probably out on a limb here, our traditional 6th or 7th place isn´t out of reach.

Finally, hope you all don´t mind but I´ll remain neutral on the Moyes debate - although the phrase be careful what you wish for springs to mind - both for managers and owners
Jonathan Steinmetz
69 Posted 24/03/2012 at 23:49:52
Watched the replay in the states.... Very hopeful over Jags play and Pienaar/Baines link up. To me Jelly looks like a fine signing.. yeah he missed some sitters but he gets himself into scoring positions and he showed a little skill on the ball. Got to get in position first, goals will come.

I'm quite done with Cahill, don't ever want to see him on the pitch again. Same with Distin. Johnny H + Jags should be our first choice here on out. Now if we could just get a good RB.

COYB
John Schrempft
70 Posted 24/03/2012 at 23:59:23
Well, Toffeeweb is never boring!

When Everton lose, Moyes gets called every name under the sun and quite frankly some comments are really over the top. On the other hand we win and euphoria seems to break out!

After supporting the blues for more than 55 years, I've been very lucky to witness the golden years and the "Golden Vision". Of course it's very hard to have been overtaken by Liverpool for so long and then the last derby debacle at Anfield after TEN years not winning there under Moyes!

What's more, living in Switzerland means many people ask where I come from. When I say Liverpool they invariably say : oh the Beatles and the great LFC. No, I reply, I'm an Everton supporter. "Oh, where's Everton then?" Is it on Merseyside?

Why am I mentioning all this? Well, having passionately supported the Toffees for so long, I've a number of wishes, before the finaly whistle blows on me:

1) That we stay in the top flight;
2) That we finally overtake the dark side and stay there;
3) We win some silverware again....
4) We play decent football as we did under Catterick and Howard;
5) We improve our financial and management situation.
So..... at the moment: frustration yes, but not boredom (except for some games!). Anyway, I live in hope things will improve.

Is Moyes that good or that bad? After 10 years, I'm still not sure quite frankly.
Peter Barry
74 Posted 25/03/2012 at 04:57:56
Here they come the Moyesophiles out in force and making ad hominem attacks by the score. Why is it that such types always resort to mob mentality and personal attacks? You disgust me. Let's remind you Davey Boy lovers what most of you said after the derby debacle: "it's only one game, GET OVER IT".

BTW, I really enjoyed today's game, the second half especially, but the question remains if we can do it for one game, why can't we do it for more and especially in the derby? I also have to laugh at all the fools saying, "Look, we are only two points behind Liverpool now," completely oblivious that, if we had won the derby, we would already have been above them.
Peter Bradshaw
75 Posted 25/03/2012 at 07:16:20
One of the problems with watching the match from so far away, 1:00am kick off, woeful first half.

Guess who fell asleep and missed the second half, and what has been pictured as one of the best second half performances of the season?

There it is guys, it's me: I am a friggin jinx, I will make sure I sleep through the Sunderland game on Tuesday.

COYB
Derek Thomas
76 Posted 25/03/2012 at 07:25:26
John 428: "...still not sure..." ? that sums up Moyes for me. Not sure of his best 11 or how to play them. Some would say, the more he has to choose from, the less sure he is; give him a bare minimum and his indecision is removed for him.

(I'm) Still not sure which Moyes/team is going to come out to play, the knife one ? the gunfight one; the one that dealt to City, Spurs and Chelsea, the one that rolled over vs the RS, or yesterday's one.

We have a seemingly decent Scottish bloke, whose 'good' points got us where we are (yes, I know all the mitigating factors, Bill, money, etc). But whose recurring 'bad' points seem to me to prevent us sometimes maximising what little we do have.

So what does that leave us in the 'not sure' section? ... Guilty, Innocent or the other Scottish verdict for the decent Scottish Bloke: NOT PROVEN.

What I am sure of is that, if he left tomorrow, the sky would not automatically fall as some of his more certain fans of the 'be careful what you wish for' ilk would have us think.

Sometimes it's just time for a change, for both our sakes. The odd swallow we have seen since the New Year may show what can be done, with a little less uber-caution.

Some people might call these swallows papering over the cracks... I'm not sure... [This is where we came in.]
Richard Dodd
77 Posted 25/03/2012 at 08:33:51
As an dedicated follower of Moyes,I spend much time trying to read his moods and predict his actions.I suspect I get him right about 50% of the time -a success rate I could probably achieve by merely guessing at the outcomes!
Be that as it may,I have been paying particular attention to his matchday reactions and general comments on Royston Drenthe.In the Arsenal game,he bawled him out for sitting on his arse to berate a linesman whilst when
asked about RR last Friday,the Moyestro said it had `been good to have him here on loan`and that` he`s made some impact at times`.He showed no warmth or enthusiasm for the Dutchman and I hereby predict the lad`s time at Goodison is coming to an end.
Of course, the player`s absence yesterday may well have been to ensure his fitness for `the big one`but whether or not he`s selected at Sunderland,I think his days here are numbered!
Lee Courtliff
79 Posted 25/03/2012 at 09:40:40
I hope not Richard. For all his faults, Drenthe at least provides some excitement. I think that unpredictable nature of his is the perfect foil to Moyes's rigid, well organised style. Otherwise it's just slow predictable build-up based down our left flank. I think every team needs a player like Royston. Unfortunately, I think you might be right.
John Crawley
80 Posted 25/03/2012 at 09:53:56
Ryan 199 - You might want to get your facts straight: we didn't beat Norwich.

A very good second half performance, why can't we play like that all the time? I thought Swansea lost their discipline and just threw men forward which created a lot of space for us on the counter. It was this which led to us creating so many chances to score.

From what I have seen with regard to Brendan Rodgers, he doesn't vary his tactics a great deal. He has a way of playing and sticks to it. The manager who has impressed me the most this season with varying tactics and adopting a positive way of playing has been Paul Lambert.

I was impressed with Gibson yesterday, I thought he had a good all round game. Fellaini and Jelavic seem to be getting an understanding. Not sure if this is a good thing or not as it takes Fellaini away from his best position in midfield. But you can see the difference when they played together against Arsenal and Swansea.

Let's hope we can take the confidence gained from this performance into the match on Tuesday and get to Wembley.
Martin Mason
81 Posted 25/03/2012 at 10:16:39
The great shame for next week is that Pienaar won't play. I really hope that we can find the cash to buy him back.
Chris Barnes
82 Posted 25/03/2012 at 10:21:11
I agree with Derek @ 449, I am a fan of Moyes but he has taken us from perennial strugglers to regular European finishes. His tactics and decisions have stopped us making those final jumps.

Every time I look at the table, I always take three points of the shite and put them on our total to see where we really should be. I do this regular throughout the season and have done for years. That suggests Moyes can't get consistency or makes stupid tactical changes when he shouldn't.

We are not a top four club so we don't need to rest players. When we are on a run, our team shouldn't be changed, we aren't used to rotation.

Would I replace Moyes? No. There isn't anyone out there good enough to replace him. It's alright saying Rodgers is doing a great job but so were Phil Brown and Paul Jewell at the same point in their first season!

Before the derby, I was confident we would get to the FA Cup Final. Moyes knocked that. Let's hope he's put us back on track with this performance.
Tom Bowers
83 Posted 25/03/2012 at 23:21:49
The Swansea game could easily have gone pear shaped after a first half which didn't see a shot at goal from the Blues.

Great performances by Baines and Pienaar saved the day, however, but Pienaar will be absent on Tuesday and the only likely change will be Moptop back in although Osman had another one of those games doing very little and almost set up something for them when he dribbled and stumbled just outside the box. Cahill may have twinged his back again and if that is the case I do hope Stracqs is the relacement.
Mick Davies
84 Posted 26/03/2012 at 03:47:00
For all those on here who are getting carried away with the great David Moyes and his tactical nous, just look at the two sides: Everton stacked with internationals, one a World Cup finalist on the bench and two present England players. Take a look at the Swansea side: any familiar faces?

Now consider the derby match: in the last six games, Liverpool have lost 5 and won one. The one they won? 3-0... against us. Two relegation threatened sides have turned them over, so that makes Hughes and Martinez better tacticians than Moyes then?

Dalglish hasn't been able to out-think many managers this season yet the two derby games have seen him get 6 points and 5 goals for and 0 against.

Playing Hibbert is just a joke and having a right back in midfield and a defensive midfielder moving up into attack is not the sign of a great manager.

Brendan Rodgers has done more this season against larger odds than Moyes has managed over the last 3 years with all the resources he has available and the ones he let go. Moyes is like a dog with a computer: he has the tools in hand but doesn't know what to do with them.
Tony Cheek
86 Posted 26/03/2012 at 09:10:56
The one big question now is will Moyes keep Jags in or will it be Heitinga against Sunderland. To tell you the truth, I dont think Moyes has the balls to keep Jags on the bench. Heitinga hasnt just played well, he has played brilliantly and it would be a great greta injustice if he now loses his place to "hoofer" Jags.
But somehow you just know its going to happen. If so, I think Johnny will be off in the summer break.
Rahman Talib
87 Posted 26/03/2012 at 09:41:13
Given the way things have developed, i say Darren Gibson is the best Irishman ever to play for us since Kevin Sheedy
Tony J Williams
88 Posted 26/03/2012 at 12:50:40
"Brendan Rodgers has done more this season against larger odds than Moyes has managed over the last 3 years with all the resources he has available and the ones he let go" - What's that then? What has he won?

"Now consider the derby match" - usuing your own logic, this is a recent Cup Winning team, full of internationals and European Cup Winners
Jim Hillier
89 Posted 27/03/2012 at 22:14:37
Fucking superb boys. Fuck, have I become one of the pro-Moyes bunch? How fickle can you get

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads