Relaxed goalfest great for confidence

, 9 April, 107comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 4 - 0 Sunderland

David Moyes made a number of team changes, as expected, but the new side dominated possession for the first 10 mins without really coming close.

James McFadden was given his first start since returning, and started out brightly on the right, with Pienaar behind Stracqualursi but they soon swapped places, with Magaye Gueye playing on the left.

Cattermole fouled Pienaar very aggressively and deservedly got the first yellow card but without Baines, Osman's strike got through the wall but was eventually cleared before Fellaini could have a crack. McFadden was well involved and keen but his touch and judgement were at best rusty.

The patient build-up finally gave Everton a scoring chance after good work down the middle by Pienaar and Stracq, but Gueye chose to pull it back when he could have taken a shot, and Pienaar was taken by surprise. Fellaini then lashed one over from a wider position.

A good Sunderland cross picked out Sessegnon but his header flashed thankfully wide. McFadden was a little slow in taking a shot but it was on target and forced a save from Mignolet.

Everton's first corner came after a firm but poorly directed cross by Neville and Gueye's corner was equally poor, too high and deep, swinging out of play. It led to only the second decent Sunderland attack before the break when McClean came too close for comfort.

Everton won a quick corner after the break but the corner was overhit by McFadden. Neville then got past Bardsley but his deliberative cross that picked out Stracqualursi was just far too weak and loopy. Another corner, better this time, but Jagielka got too much underneath what needed to be a glancing header.

But third time's a charm, McFadden's corner eventually coming out to Osman via a deft Pienaar header, Mignolet parrying the drive but only out to Magaye who struck it superbly, an excellent well-taken first goal for the Frenchman.

Everton sat back after the goal, and Sunderland came into it, as McFadden tired and was replaced by the returning Royston Drenthe.

A great break saw Everton pass the ball forward nicely but when shooting opportunities appeared, they overplayed the passing game and Jagielka's shot did not come off. Gueye got a good ball in to Stracqualursi's feet but he clipped it over. His next attempt was high and wide when he should perhaps have taken another touch after turning and making space for himself.

The Blues got caught out a little and it needed some deperaate defending from Heitinga, but that seemed to sting some more determination into the Everton stand-ins, with Gueye crossing along the ground to Drnethe, wjho then played in Pienaar and teh Soyuth African took a moment to place a superb curling shot beyond Mignolet, Great goal.

Osman then duplicated the Pienaar strike after bringing down a high ball from Gueye and controlling it superbly then clipping it over Mignolet and ion off the far post for an excellent third goal that really had the home crowd cheering. Anichebe then replace Fellaini.

And it didn't take long for him to get on the scoresheet, at first fluffing a great cut-back Pienaar conjured out of nothing, but turning on his own airball and volleying it in off a Colback to complete a brilliant 5-minute second-half 3-goal blitz that sets things up very nicely for Saturday's massive Wembley occasion.

A great relaxed display with some of the less favoured first-team squad playing some excellent football... and scoring goals that have been at a premium this season. Hmmm... so much for not playing your best players!!!

Everton: Howard; Hibbert, Jagielka, Heitinga, Neville (83' Coleman); Gueye, Fellaini (77' Anichebe), Osman, Pienaar; McFadden (63' Drenthe); Stracqualursi.
Subs: Mucha, Gibson, Distin,, Duffy.

Michael Kenrick

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (107)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nate Allen
1 Posted 09/04/2012 at 16:32:32
If the Sessegnon overhead kick goes top corner, it's one of the goals of the year.
Nate Allen
2 Posted 09/04/2012 at 16:42:29
Right as I finish e above comment, it's 4-nil. COYB
James Flynn
3 Posted 09/04/2012 at 16:51:08
I'm at work. Who got the 4th goal?
James Flynn
4 Posted 09/04/2012 at 16:53:45
OK. It's Vic.
Joe McMahon
5 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:01:50
Competition for places? Good to see Gueye on the scoresheet. What a feelin - 4 goals!!!. This must be our chance this year to finally shut up the Welsh, Norwegian, Cockney, we weren't to blame for Heysel, American Redshite!!!
Jamie Tulacz
6 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:03:24
Pienaar and Osman both excellent in central positions today. Think Gueye's probably done enough to seal the remaining starting spot in the final, though would personally prefer to see Drenthe if his head's right
Colin Wainwright
7 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:08:32
Lads were great today. Not one poor performance. Let's have these gobshites next weekend.
Rory Brennan
8 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:15:07
What a day. Love it.

Bring on the kopites!
Paul Foster
9 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:31:19
For those who didn't get to see it (and can't wait for MOTD) the highlights are here: http://www.footreview.net/home/viewvideo/2895/english-premier-league/everton-4-0-sunderland

Osman's goal is absolutely world-class.
Steve Brown
10 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:35:21
Great performance, let's play two proper wide men at Wembley. Pienaar superb so we'll miss him.

COYB!! Roll on Saturday.
Dean Adams
11 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:45:32
Not only will our first eleven be strong, we will have strength in depth on the bench. Moyes's luck seems to have changed for the good, long may it last.
Thomas Williams
12 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:40:06
Have to say none of us expected that, great result and just the tonic for saturday.

We can sit back and relax now knowing we are still above them going into the semi, that should give our players such a lift.

Question for you all is the one position most are struggling to fill the left side, Fellaini, Gibson and Osman will all play but will it be Gueye, Coleman or Drenthe?

Here is another suggestion Hibbert rb and Neville lb with Baines left wing, would anyone go for that?

Johnny and Distin for centre back for me.
Paul Mackie
13 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:47:31
Holy crap. Osman's goal was absolutely superb.

Nice to see our players shooting from outside the box for a change.
Graham Mockford
14 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:48:02
I find myself of being in the unusual position of being the pessimist.

Make no doubt about it, we will have to be right on top of our game and hope it's the Liverpool team of the last few weeks that turns up. But they have made a habit this year of saving their best performances (Cardiff aside) for the big games.

In the immortal words of Big Ron, tempo is the key. We need to be all over them from the off, the main reason I would play Tim even if form would not support my logic.

I never look forward to derby games because I never underestimate the capacity to make my life a fucking misery, let's hope Davey can instil a positive mindset in the team.
Trevor Lynes
15 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:50:55
An absolutely fabulous second half display! I just wish Magaye took more responsibility to take his man on ? he has plenty of ability if he only knew it.

Drenthe should defo make the bench for Wembley and start with Magaye, keep Drenthe for the later stages if we are struggling. BUT, Liverpool will raise their game against us and we will need to play at our best to beat them. Our defence must be really tight and the midfield must compete.
Ryan Holroyd
16 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:58:40
Pienaar must be signed up. He's pure quality. Wonderful performance from him and Osman today.
Colin Potter
17 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:50:36
It's great to see more shooting on sight and from outside of the box. A few of them are chronic, but if you keep trying something is bound to come off,as proved today.
Dan Slater
18 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:01:37
Moyes is shite. Isn't he?
Stephen Sullivan
19 Posted 09/04/2012 at 17:48:12
Great day with no injuries sustained and a boost for confidence.
Four points clear of the other lot too. Had we lost today Dogleash would have rested loads of key players tomorrow banking that we would lose at Man utd next game whilst they beat West Brom at home to go above us. He really needs something tomorrow now so has to play many key players.
I can see a twisted ankle or two for Stevie Me and Suarez? A sending off maybe?
Mark Riding
20 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:02:20
No Dan.. McFadden is shite. End of.

Great performances across the pitch. Spurs are going to need Pienaar back next season though..

If I didnt know better, I would be excited about Saturday !! Bring it on.
James Morgan
21 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:02:36
Dan, for the first half of the season yes. And that includes seasons gone by where we haven't added in January.
Nevertheless, great second half from the lads and can't wait till Saturday!
Colin Wainwright
22 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:06:41
Thought McFadden played ok tbh.
Nick West
23 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:06:25
Moyes out! What a load of crap that was. The man knows nowt about football. He's dragged our great club into the gutter with his unimaginative, negative football. He can't even pick the right team....etc, etc

Well, this is Toffeeweb, right?
Colin Wainwright
24 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:11:55
Don't get too carried away Nick. Won f*ck all yet.
Graham Mockford
25 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:04:31
Dan your ironic statement is well made however it also doesn't make him great either.
I have been accused of many things for supporting DM but the true fact is he is still the same manager he was three weeks ago post Anfield, the same manager he was at the start of the season. It's just that we live in an age of entitlement and quick fix mentality. A few bad results people are calling for his head, a few good ones and all in the garden is rosy.
He is an extremely effective manager at getting the most out of the cards he is dealt, but ultimately at some time we need a trophy to make the grinding out of results worth the wait.
Hopefully his destiny awaits....
Robbie Muldoon
26 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:15:27
I like the look of Coleman at right back for the last ten minutes. Royston Drenthe is worth 100 McFaddens.

Team for semi has got to be;

Howard
Neville Heitenga Distin Baines
Osman Fellaini Gibson Cahill Gueye
Jelavic

Drenthe to come on for Osman or Gueye.
Ryan Holroyd
27 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:14:54
People say Moyes hasn't won anything, which is fact. However, Alex McLeish won the League Cup and I wouldn't touch with with a shitty stick. Give me top 8 finishes in the Premier League than winning the League Cup and relegation.
Mark Riding
28 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:17:52
That team looks about right Robbie...

Surely there cant be any 'big' surprises ( Johnny in midfield etc.. )
Peter Warren
29 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:14:57
Confidence is key in football; we have it.. the Shite don't.
Nate Allen
30 Posted 09/04/2012 at 16:42:29
Right as I finish e above comment, it's 4-nil. COYB
John Ford
31 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:18:56
Robbie...im happy with that team, which I think is the same as played at Sunderland.. Drenthe to shake things up if needed.

My worry is Cahill and how he suppreses our passing. Hes got a decent record agasinst RS though and wil hopefully stick it to their centre halves.
Paul Johnson
32 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:22:01
Dan Slater mmmmm be careful. We are in a run of good form but prior to end of January we were shite. With the same players that we had out today, only Piennar was not available prior to then. Don't put the kickers on the team.

It was a great performance today that was totally alien before the close of the transfer window it is totally mystifying, but still feels good to be a blue at the moment.
Conor Skelly
33 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:27:10
I still think Jags is better than dust bin. For all Distin's attributes, the man is an accident waiting to happen and I hope he's not on the team sheet come Saturday. My nerves just can't take his heavy touch.
Stephen Sullivan
34 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:39:14
Conor 610
My nerves can't take Jagielka's sloppy balls if you pardon the expression
Andy Corrie
35 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:38:23
I take back what I said about Jags, total respect for the clean sheet for him and Jonny, well done lads
Howard Don
36 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:47:39
No chance Conner, has to be Heitinga/Distin for me.
Mike Gaynes
37 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:46:07
Robbie, that's the side, definitely. Love Jags but prefer Distin for his speed.

I'm still laughing at making an ass of myself... right after I posted that Gueye and Pienaar couldn't shoot, they both scored crackers. Anybody want to get a bet down on who scores our goals on Saturday, let me know and I'll be sure to insult them in the warm-up to help you out.
Jamie Barlow
38 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:34:33
Great result but a weird game. It almost looked like a pre-season game to me, first half. I thought Sunderland would have been more up for it than they were.

Lots of decisions for Moyes now.

Goalkeeper and left fullback sorted.

Who to choose between Jags and Distin to partner Johnny?

Who plays right back?

With Felli and Gibson both to start in the middle.

Who plays on both wings?

Who plays behind Jelly?

Who'd be a manager?
Mike Gaynes
39 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:50:11
Stephen, no personal hygiene comments about the players!
Mark Riding
40 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:52:26
Jamie.. 'who would be a manager ?' - for £65k a week Id try it for a few months !!
Mike Gaynes - slag em all off mate... a goalfest would surely happen !

Got to be Distin for pace as I reckon Bellamy will start for Reds. Isnt it nice to have selection debates for fit and 'in-form' players though.
Conor Skelly
41 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:42:27
You're okay, Stephen, I know what you mean. I only hope the readers are as understanding of my 'heavy touch' sentence haha. In all seriousness though, I think Distin's distribution can be just as risky and although he's very fast he takes longer to turn than the ferry. He was truly awful against the Shite last month and I feel he is way over-rated by most on this site.

If Moyes can just get Jags to play it simple into Gibson more often than not then his defensive qualities should get the benefit of any doubt.
Robbie Muldoon
42 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:54:10
Jagielka has had two appalling games up against that twat Suarez this season, I think Jag bottles it against him gives him too much space and then lunges in for the inevitable dive. No, keep Jagielka away from this one.
Robbie Muldoon
43 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:57:30
Which is strange as Jags used to have Torres in his arse pocket.
Mark Riding
44 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:59:34
Save Jags having Torres in his pocket for the final then Robbie !
Jamie Barlow
45 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:57:25
Decisions decisions.

I'm just glad he only made 5 changes for today's game.

Imagine if he would have made "6" before an important game!!
Jamie Barlow
46 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:01:07
I like your thinking Mark@623
Mike Gaynes
47 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:57:21
I think you're all alone on that one, Conor. Yes, Distin had a stinker against the RS, but he's been clearly our best at the back all year. And after a rough start, his partnership with Johnny has been superb. We didn't need the old man today, happy to see him rested. We'll need him on Saturday, for sure.
James Morgan
48 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:58:50
I think Heitinga and Distin are a shoo in, especially with the latter being rested. Hitting form right on time!
Bobby Thomas
49 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:56:39
Conor: The derby aside, when he was playing with a blatantly not match-fit Jags and the mid offered no protection, Distin has been superb for months, is great on the turn, is the quickest of our centre halves, economical and untroubled in possession and to be honest.... I don't know who or what you have been watching!!;-)
Jamie Barlow
50 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:03:25
I don't think it matters too much. Whoever plays with JH seems to play well. I just hope it isn't Jags and Distin together.

I can't see it happening though.
Paul David
51 Posted 09/04/2012 at 18:56:15
Dan (591) & Nick (596)... While I am made up we won with ease I would not be too quick to put the convincing win down to Moyes. You could just as easy say, "Look at what happens when Cahill is missing," and it's Moyes's fault he has played him in every game this season. There's times when he gets it totally wrong and times when he gets it right.
Conor Skelly
52 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:06:23
Mark-Good shout about Suarez. Like what David Villa did to him when he played for England, he turned him inside out!!
Bobby- Distin can't turn in a tight space when in possession, it takes him an age to get it onto his one and only foot. He is quick off the mark when out of possession but usually that's to compensate for being out of position(no rap intended). He flatters to deceive in my opinion. Jags is more intelligent and a better pro and stuff doesn't bounce of him like a pin ball machine. Surely I'm not alone in my view of Distin!?
Dean Adams
53 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:10:09
Robbie Muldoon 601

I would say that the chances of that being first choice are very high, at least with the fans. As for Moyes, he might just think this rotation stuff is what its all about and get carried away.......................only kidding, but you never know!!
Conor Skelly
54 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:19:22
Sorry, I meant Robbie when referring to Suarez/Villa
Andy Crooks
55 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:31:46
Good result and good performance. Nick West, you'd be best to say nothing unless you can come with a reason for the utter shite served up in the first half of the season.
Jon Cox
56 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:06:41
It has to be JH and Distin at least to start. Jag is far to much hoof and the last thing we need is the ball coming back at us time and time again.

Which ever way DM plays it he'll need to keep some real pace on the sideline for the last 15 mins/extra time. In either of these time zones we will be under massive amounts of pressure especially if we are one goal to the good. An outlet with pace will be essential and to have two players with this attribute would be a godsend.

I just hope Moyes doesn't bottle it and lets them play without shackles or too many instructions.

Nerves definately starting to jangle at this point, but I just know,

we can do this.

COYB-FTRS !!
Bobby Thomas
57 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:27:43
Conor i think we are blessed at centre half and i include the up and coming Duffy who looks a player.

Our main 3 are all top players and i am bigging up the Jag on another thread.

But i think Distin has been showing the best form of his career. Him and Heitinga reall dovetail well. In fact, are both in the form of their Everton careers and there is no need to go changing.

Cente half is all about partnerships and i feel their respective styles work very well. Combined with the extra protection and midfield balance Gibson has brought, defensively we look the best we've been for a couple of seasons. Heitinga has also helped with his organisation and leadership.
James Martin
58 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:30:51
Heart was in my outh when Heitinga went down holding his ankle, thought that was our semi-final down the toilet right there. Unlike other years though he got up and will surely play on Saturday, maybe our luck is changing for once. Here's to Agger, Gerrard and Suarez having a three way collision tomorrow.
Mark Riding
59 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:38:49
James.. a 3-way collision.. made even worse by the Yak landing on top of them and needing a crane to lift him off !!!
Derek Williams
61 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:39:18
Back comes Johnny, and back come the clean sheets. Not coincidence methinks, it doesnt matter which of the other two plays with him particularly (though I'd prefer Distin), he's become the first name on the teamsheet for me.
Conor Skelly
62 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:44:35
Only because Samba plays in Russia now Mark
Paul David
63 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:43:35
I just had a horrible thought about Saturday.The general thinking is its probably going to be Gueye playing left wing or a slim chance it will be Drenthe but what if Moyes opts for Anichebe.God i hope not.
Bobby Thomas
64 Posted 09/04/2012 at 19:53:15
No, im still going for the 3 way collision, with added Yak impact and Samba then being helicoptered in from Russia for some kind of precision bombing obliteration.

Wow. That'd be ace. Only Yak would survive, emerging with his typical grin and dusting himself off en route to order a pie dinner.
Mark Riding
65 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:02:55
Samba playing in Russia...

No wonder Bilyaletdinov looked good on the DVDs when we bought him!
Bobby Thomas
67 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:15:47
Fuck it throw Billy in the death collision as well, bag of shite!!
Rob Hollis
68 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:13:22
Great to have such a relaxed win. Under the circumstances I accepted we would not be flying into tackles, but Sunderland were very strange. I thought they would be out for some revenge but they allowed us to dominate.

If I supported them I would be disgusted with that lack of effort and complete submission. Some lovely goals from us though.
Stephen Sullivan
69 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:18:19
I have a real good feeling about Liverpool's game at Blackburn tomorrow. They have to try and win especially as their owners are flying in tomorrow for "talks" with Dogleash. They simply can't rest both Gerrard and Suarez as another defeat would crank up the pressure big style. Blackburn, as we know don't pussy foot around and are desparate for the points. Some bone crunching tackles are a certainty.
Sit back and enjoy it cos' it will be tasty. Regarding Gerrard; He can still be a threat but these days his legs can't take two 100% matches in such quick succession. I think he will start tomorrow which will play into are hands as they need him fully fit against us.
We really do deserve a break against Liverpool. A break of any sort will do.
Joe McMahon
70 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:30:26
Jamie Barlow - For 65k a week, we all would! Defo Johnny & Sylvain for me. Personally I would also bench Cahill.
Gavin Ramejkis
71 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:23:59
James #644 Heitinga went to ground holding his ankle to win a free kick, good simulation but nothing happened, he leaned back looking for the free kick and to run the clock down.

Heitinga and Distin to start for me on Saturday, best partnership we have, the midfield has to win the battle of being right in their smug faces and giving creasehead no room to breathe never mind pass the ball, breakdown their midfield and they are nothing but a mid table side at best.

The other cardinal sin Moyes mustn't make is to sit on a one goal advantage which will play right into their hands, its got to be daylight between us; two or three goals, they are playing with a mental disadvantage and we need to use every weapon going to beat the spawn of satan.
Paul Gladwell
72 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:37:17
Joe,Cahill is A big game player, you don't bench him on a game like this and start experimenting,especially when he has started looking his old self of late,you can bet you life he will run himself into the ground next week.
Joe McMahon
73 Posted 09/04/2012 at 20:45:52
Gavin - I always seem to agree with most things you say. Your paragraph about sitting on a one goal lead is vital.



Paul (683) I hope youre right!
Brian Lawlor
74 Posted 09/04/2012 at 21:13:54
Funny innit? When things are going well again, all the Moyes bashers (insane bunch) like to remind us what he's earning in some weird fucked up way of insinuating that because of this it's expected.

I see Ian Holloway devoted his whole newspaper article yesterday to Moyes and how he thinks he's the 'best manager in the world'. All these ex pros, pundits, the LMA etc are all wrong and all these armchair cyber fans on Toffeeweb are right.

Its fucked up, they are actually unhappy when we're doing well because they can't moan or stick the knife in.
David Hallwood
75 Posted 09/04/2012 at 21:42:20
Does anyone know if Ken Buckley is OK as he hasn't posted a metch report for a couple of weeiks
John Schrempft
76 Posted 09/04/2012 at 21:27:46
Brian (696)

Well, I've been pretty critical of DM lately and I believe SOME of the criticsm could be justified

Bashing the Moyes-Bashers as you seem keen on doing and calling them an insane bunch doesn't promote unity amongst blues fans.

I'm going to refrain from calling you insane because very few Toffees really are, if any. Moreover,I respect your views and you're entitled to them.

However, Moyes has been and will be commented on in a negative way and it can be justified.

I'm pretty certain I could take 62K a week just like banking directors do.......

,,,,,,,,,,,,and then be criticized




I somehow doubt that even the most critical Evertonian will be hoping we lose next Saturday, just to say afterwards that we told you so.





IF, there are any then they'll probably sit in the RS section at Wembley and cheer them on instead...
Kevin Tully
77 Posted 09/04/2012 at 21:50:19
Behave Brian,

Moyes deserves to be critisised when we are shite, unless you are North Korean ?
Jamie Crowley
79 Posted 09/04/2012 at 21:54:53
Paul all the way back at 582 -

Thank you for the highlights. Couldn't watch today - work. Greatly appreciated.

The players seemed very jacked up for Gueye. Nice to see.

4-0. Great victory and appears to have been a great effort.

Thanks again Paul.
Graham Mockford
80 Posted 09/04/2012 at 22:17:08
So John #704 you say SOME of your criticism can be justified. Fair enough but the obvious question is WHICH of your criticism can't ?
Trevor Lynes
81 Posted 09/04/2012 at 22:12:46
I must put my hands up about Heitinga..I thought he was dreadful when he first came..his tackling was poor and he gave away too many dangerous free kicks.

I even said he was the worst Dutch international I had ever seen..BUT, with an extended run he has turned things around and now he is a certainty to play in the semi final.

We have three fantastic centre backs and Distin is an absolute credit to his obvious fitness and work ethic...he has been an absolute bargain.

Jags is another totally 100% top player who blocks so many shots, does not get himself booked and reminds me so much of Dave Watson in his prime.

Unfortunately his injury set back has lost him his regular place..But he is still a very good English International centre back.

I wish we had Lescott back to cover for Baines and Rooney to partner Jelavic...but there you go!!
Just don't get too involved in the physical side of things against Liverpool because it will give the ref a chance to send someone off eg; Cahill, Drenthe or Felli
John Schrempft
82 Posted 09/04/2012 at 22:32:54
Graham (718)

Well, I said in a previous contribution that I thought Moyes should go as we'd more or less been lacking in progress.

I'm only too pleased to be proved wrong.

After all, we all make mistatkes. Even Moyes admitted to making one by not having even more reserve players on the pitch at Anfield.
Graham Mockford
83 Posted 09/04/2012 at 22:43:07
John it takes something to admit you got it wrong and you are dead right... We all do!
Derek Thomas
84 Posted 09/04/2012 at 23:14:03
Kevin 706; spot on. Brian all you are doing is giving out a bit of self indulgent ' I told you so' stick. Moyes makes mistakes, he gets picked up on it and when he appears to compound the felony by a) repeating them and b) then by going even more KITATTP1 he gets more stick back.

When he gets it right, nothing needs to be or should be said...after all thats his job and he gets paid for doing it...Our ' insane bashers ' silence should rather be seen as speaking immense volumes of praise, all a bit zen this sound of silence stuff, but hey this is Everton and Toffeeweb.
Roman Sidey
85 Posted 09/04/2012 at 23:06:21
Thomas Williams, if we find ourselves short on the left in future, can't see why Neville at LB and Baines at LM wouldn't work.

Absolute joy to watch today. I've wanted Gueye to succeed ever since he came and am over the moon he got his goal.

Team for the semi, for me, would look like this:

G - Howard - No brainer.
RB - Neville - Him and Hibbo were playing for the position today, and for me, Nev was good, and Hibbo was probably our weakest player on the day. Plus, Neville plays better in these games than Hibbo.
CB - JH & Distin - Also no brainers.
LB - Baines - As above.
RW - Drenthe - Only real option for wide right, and need his go forward from the off against the Victims.
CM - Gibson, Fellaini, Cahill - The two holding the midfield like they have been is a no brainer, and Cahill has played probably his best five games in his career all against Liverpool. Osman plays better against lower opposition, and hasn't proved to be a big game player.
LW - Gueye - Has earnt it, in my opinion.
S - Jelavic - Goals, goals, and more goals.

Paul David
86 Posted 09/04/2012 at 23:44:03
Brian (696)
Ex pros, pundits and the LMA give their opinion on Everton from the outside looking in and they're right. I have no real arguments about Moyes's results, it's the way he achieves them I don't like. Ian Holloway isn't paying money to be bored off his arse most Saturday afternoons like we do.
Kevin Sparke
87 Posted 09/04/2012 at 23:58:27
I see 'King' Kenny is getting his whinging in early about refs - even suggesting that there is a 'conspiracy against Liverpool'

This makes me laugh - 'we've got integrity' sayeth the manager with the biggest cheating scumbag in World football Suarez.

" Dalglish repeatedly questioned the integrity of referees, which will be of concern to the FA. "I know where we are coming from," he said. "I know we have integrity, I know we have integrity in bucketloads, but I can't speak for other people and whether they have integrity. What we have to do now, is ensure this football club maintains its integrity, that the players keep their integrity, and hope that people elsewhere have some integrity too. They [referees] have to look at themselves and ensure they are seen to have integrity" (The Guardian website 10th April)



Integrity... right - remind me again... when exactly was that?
Dennis Stevens
88 Posted 10/04/2012 at 00:04:36
Roman, Baines has been tried in left mid before & seems less effective there for some reason.
Roman Sidey
89 Posted 10/04/2012 at 00:16:38
Does he? Fair enough, Dennis. I'd never seen him played there, but it would be better than putting Osman or Cahill there, I'd assume, if we were short.
Dennis Stevens
90 Posted 10/04/2012 at 00:20:48
I know what you mean, Roman - although I thought Osman linked up quite well with Baines in the Pienaar role on the left a couple of times this season, & seemed less exposed than is sometimes the case on the right. The problem is that both Cahill & Osman really want to be in central midfield, which won't happen very often, Cahill is generally even worse out wide & Moyes seems loathe to drop either of them. The only way to accommodate both together with Gibson & Fellaini would be to play three at the back with Baines & Neville/Hibbert/Coleman as wing-backs - but I doubt we'll see that one from Moyes either.
Mick Davies
91 Posted 10/04/2012 at 03:41:49
Your assertion that McFadden is shite doesn't stand up to scrutiny. He had the first shot on target, his corner indirectly led to the first goal, he linked up well with Pienaar, Gueye and Osman and considering this was his first start for over a year, and he was subbed on the hour mark, that's not a bad contribution, as you yourself proclaim those "Great perfomances across the park".
James Flynn
92 Posted 10/04/2012 at 03:59:59
I know this is late after the game. I was at work here on the US East Coast while the game was played.

With that, I've seen the goal highlights since. Not even talking as an Evertonian, just a fan of the game; Piennar and Osman's goals were sweet. It's not like they were shooting into an empty net or not defended.

In my 3 years in, this is the best team we've had. Is it possible we won't lift the FA Cup? This is a great team I'm watching.
Mick Davies
93 Posted 10/04/2012 at 03:58:01
I hope Moyes plays the experienced and level-headed Neville at RB, especially considering Hibbert's last debacle at Wembley. We could do without Cahill starting too, given the performances of Gueye, Osman and Drenthe (possibly our Ballotelli). My choice of line up would be:

Howard,
Neville, Heitinga, Distin, Baines,
Osman, Gibson, Fellaini, Drenthe,
Gueye,
Jelavic.
Michael Kenrick
94 Posted 10/04/2012 at 04:08:39
Er... Jimmy-lad, that was NOT the team.

At best, half of those who defeated Sunderland in such admirable fashion will not be selected by Moyes on the day...

And that day comes a few weeks before they go out to play for the cup.

One step at a time. Or don't they think that way in Yankeeland?
Paul McGinty
95 Posted 10/04/2012 at 04:55:58
Pienaar was great today. Shame he is cup-tied. He is a huge miss for Saturday in my opinion. We have to balance the books but I do hope there's the will on all sides along with the cash to keep him at the club for next season.
Dermot Ryan
96 Posted 10/04/2012 at 05:00:44
Can I add my voice to David Halliwood (703?) question. Where's Ken? Brilliant posts. Hope their absence isn't for health reasons. Whatever the reason, I'd love to know why he hasn't posted recently. A veritable institution at Toffeeweb.
Tony Cheek
97 Posted 10/04/2012 at 05:23:07
What is a bit worrying is that the team that started the game yesterday, was no better than the team that played against Liverpool 3 weeks ago, and yet they wiped the floor with us. Believe me, it's going to be a very tight one, Moyes has to get it right!
Anto Byrne
98 Posted 10/04/2012 at 06:35:37
Conceded two goals v Norwich with JH on bench. WBA and Swansea? Fair bet that JH will start against the Shite.
David Hallwood
99 Posted 10/04/2012 at 09:21:51
4-0, best result of the season, Osman's been playing out of his skin, scores a great goal and had a huge hand in the first one, and this is yet another thread that has an 'Ossie is shite' slant.

FFS Drenthe for Ossie, that's a player who has been on 'compassionate leave', and you would prefer a player who blows hot & cold and who has obviously got personal issues to a player bang in form-for our most important game of the season.

I think if Ossie scores 6 on Saturday (and take it from me he WILL play) saves 2 off the line and gets 10/10 MOM from every paper in the land, we'll still be getting the imbecillic 'shouldn't be in a blue shirt and shouldn't even be on the bench for the final'

FFS gents watch the game without trying to reinforce your prejudices.
Carl Sanderson
100 Posted 10/04/2012 at 10:11:10
David #835

You're absolutely right. Osman is a superb player and why he is so under-rated is a mystery to me. His goal yesterday was superb, an excellent finish. The otherwise-excellent match report says that he "brought down a high ball from Gueye", which doesn't really do justice to a wonderful, one-touch passing move.
James Martin
101 Posted 10/04/2012 at 10:48:03
Osman has always been one of our better midfilders. It all depends what sort of football you like to see being played, The same people who come on here wanting to see attacking football the like that Swansea play (a claim looking a bit stupid now) are also the same people championing Fellaini/ Rodwell/Gibson over players like OSman and Pienaar. If you play Gibson and Fellaini you're going to get workman like performances defensively assured and very physical. If you play Osman and Pienaar you're going to get people pushing them off the ball and them missing headers, but you'll also get a variety of pass and move one touch football that the other two are not capable of. For the game on Saturday Fellaini and Gibson suit it better because we need to be solid and strong against them. For a relegation team at home they will not provide you with the cutting edge in the same way Osman and Pienaar will if they play in the middle. Oh for Arteta to still be here and a midfiled three of him Pienaar and Osman with a forward three of Gueye, Jelavic and Drenthe with Coleman and Baines as wingbacks and Johnny and Distin as classy ball playing CBs. That would be an attacking team capable of good football but the same people who moan about us not playing in that style are the same people who wanted Arteta out and consider Osmana nd Pienaar to have no end product.
Brian Harrison
102 Posted 10/04/2012 at 11:09:46
Think I might have a few quid on Cahill scoring first as I can see the shite's defence being more pre-occupied with Jelavic, giving Tim more space in the box
Brian Harrison
103 Posted 10/04/2012 at 11:20:43
I didnt realise there were 2 of us with the same name on this site, first time I have noticed.

Anyway I would just say that Leon Osman has always been a terrific footballer, I think he is probably the last player to come through who was coached by Colin Harvey. I think Jack Wilshire called Osman the English Inniesta, I dont think he is far off the mark.

He has a good football brain, is a good passer of the ball and has great awareness and vision. I think he should have been used in a central midfield position, as he is far more effective there than out wide. I think DM will start with Fellaini and Gibson in midfield on Saturday, just hope that we can get Osman on the ball in effective areas. He is the one player who can open opposition with a telling pass.
Anthony Jones
104 Posted 10/04/2012 at 11:41:35
Osman will most certainly play, as Coleman has stagnated (in a position in which he is not comfortable) and Drenthe has been away with the fairies at a critical time. No complaints there.

The critical question mark should be over Cahill. Loyalty is admirable, but having the resilience to make difficult decisions correctly and perhaps making unpopular decisions is potentially more admirable, especially if this means winning a cup semi-final.

Cahill is a legend, but he isn't offering enough. Why is it relevant if he buzzes around like a demented wasp if he can't contribute vision and clinical passing to enable Jelavic to shine? We aren't a Championship side, but Cahill is increasingly a Championship player. It would be great to bring him off the bench with 20 minutes to go if we need a goal, but he shouldn't start.
James Martin
105 Posted 10/04/2012 at 11:52:50
Anthony, Jelavic is shining when Cahill is in the team. In fact he looked at his worse when Cahill was taken off against norwich and we oculdn't get the ball to him as they swamped us. A bit like Gibson I think a lot of his work is oging unnoticced. He's on a long term decline no doubt but in a one off against that lot I'd rather have him than not. One of the few players who doesn't have a panic attack when in front of their goal and will not just roll over if it goes against us.
Mark Riding
106 Posted 10/04/2012 at 12:22:24
Mick #793..
I apologise for my lack of intelligence if it offends you so much.
I now realise the error of my ways, and I now agree that Mcfadden is one of our best players, well worth whatever it is we are paying him to keep young talent off our bench / starting team.. and indeed I just tried to buy a McFadden shirt from the shop, but they said demand was so high after his rasping 'shot on target' yesterday that I could only go on a waiting list for one.
Paul David
107 Posted 10/04/2012 at 12:19:47
Some fans just don't seem able to see Cahill for what he is now, a second-rate player living off past glories. Jelavic and the team would score more goals if we played with a second proper striker.

To say Cahill links up well with Jelavic is an out-and-out lie. I am struggling to think of a single time Cahill has set a chance up for Jelavic. Come to think of it, the only time Cahill links up with anyone is simple 5-yards passes sideways or backwards.
Sam Hoare
108 Posted 10/04/2012 at 14:33:58
Anthony, i agree in principle about Cahill and think that we have suffered from Moyes' over playing of him. However Saturday is not the game to make a change. He usually plays well against the shite and will lead from the front giving every ounce he has to win us that match. In fact if i were a betting man i would back him to score....
James Flynn
109 Posted 10/04/2012 at 14:40:40
Michael (797) - Not all of Yankeeland. Just us SoCal touchy, feely types.

And I am watching a great team.
Mick Davies
110 Posted 11/04/2012 at 04:02:19
Mark Riding, you still don't get it do you? If you have a problem with a player 'taking the place of a young talent' then why aren't you criticising the manager? Do you think any player says to the boss "Don't play me at all. I shouldn't be in the team"?. Your two faced attitude is an obvious inability to to interpret fact, and by praising DM yet slagging his selection you are riding 2 horses, so which one do you choose, before you fall of?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads