Everton secure seventh in style

, 13 May, 132comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 3 - 1 Newcastle United

Match Summary

A gorgeous sunny day and a packed Goodison Park, with a really big game to end the season. Newcastle United looking for a win to retain faint hopes of the Champions League, while Everton need he money that comes from 7th place rather than 8th or 9th... Rodwell and Anichebe are injured but Gibson, Baines and Neville all return; however, Distin is dropped to the bench, perhaps carrying a knock?

From an early Newcastle free-kick superbly taken, Ba almost scored, forcing a goalline save by Howard. Everton got into it, some hopeful forward moves, one where Osman overplayed what could have been a brilliant forward pass for Jelavic. Meanwhile, Ba tried to grab glory and skied a half-chance.

It was developing well as a competitive feast, when Heitinga made a bizarre two-footed lunge that won the ball cleanly but was awarded with a yellow card by ref, who then called Fellaini for a foul when the defender slipped and Fellaini avoided yellow for card. Tiote then came in heavily on Fellaini from behind and he rightly got a yellow card.

Fellaini came close with a difficult header driven in from deep by Neville that the Belgian tried to loop over Krul, but just wide of the angle, a good move as the slow build-up and wing play had not been making much progress against a well-disciplined Magpies defence.

Form a Howard clearance, Fellaini got space off an excellent piece of work by Osman, and ran forward playing across to Pienaar who saw his chance and struck it well but a nice deflection of Williamson's arse gave the ball a nice trajectory away from Krul and into the top corner for an excellent opening goal in the 16th minute.

A superb free-kick by Baines was played across the goal area by Osman at the far post, and Pienaar running in smacked his shot against the post. Everton's first corner was delivered straight to Krul by Osman. Cabaye then got a talking to for needlessly shoving a ballboy to get the ball for a throw-in.

A hoofball from the back gave Jelavic a fantastic opportunity as he beat Colucini controlled the bouncing ball on his chest and slightly with his left arm then lashed an Exocet at Krul, who saved magnificently, but the parry back to Jelavic was coolly lobbed over the Newcastle keeper and into the net for a superb second goal.

After Gibson had driven wide with a rare shot, Gutierrez at the other end looked to extract revenge but his shot was hopelessly wide in a very rare foray forward, such had been Everton's dominance. Osman went on a great run and really should have scored but pulled his shot just wide. Fellaini damaged an ankle but it didn't stop some fantastic play with Pienaar down the left and a beautiful move that ended with a powerful shot from Gibson, but straight at Krul.

Cisse came close with a snapshot that set up nicely for him but it was driven wide. Newcastle's half was summed when they won a lucky free-kick very softly off Fellaini, that Ben Afra smacked well wide. Everton had played some scintillating stuff but risked a response from visitors in the second-half, Pardew hauling off both full backs after the break, and Cisse getting an easy chance that scuffed wide with Howard beaten.

Newcastle won their first corner but it came to nothing; however, they continued to play in Everton's half, Taylor firing in a free-kick that Howard held comfortably, but still Everton laboured to get going properly again, poor defending setting up another Newcastle shot that was blocked.

The Blues did get another long ball forward to Jelavic and he did really well to control and turn but was off-balance and drove his shot wide. But the game was very different until Cabaye fouled Pienaar, setting up an excellent free-kick opportunity that Gibson got over the wall well and tested Krul at the near post.

Howard was struggling in the Everton gaol after over-stretching on an earlier goalkick, but refused to come off despite having Jagielka take them which he did rather well.

Everton should have had a clear penalty when Williamson dragged him down in a headlock, while Howard made a great stop off Cisse. Then a free-kick won out wide right of the Newcastle area by Jelavic was swung in well by Gibson and Player of the Season Johnny Heitinga was all on his own when he powered the ball home through Krull with an unstoppable header. 3 - 0!!!

Johnny Heitinga came off to a great round of applause, to be replaced by Sylvain Distin for the final 20 minutes, Cabaye taking a potshot from distance that Howard could only parry for a corner. Hibbert, then scored a great headed goal... but in the wrong net, as Howard came off his line to collect a simple ball. Neville then came off, giving Tim Cahill a chance for a runout.

Howard made a great one-handed save right under the bar to deny Cisse as Everton sat back on their two-goal lead and tried to play out the final 15 mins, continuously giving the ball away until Pienaar saw some space and played in Jelavic for a great forward run but the Croat delayed to shoot or pass to Fellaini in a good position and the chance was lost.

Krul made a double save off a great Gibsoin strike that he pushed straight at Cahill who could only return it to him rather than putting it around him into the gaping goal. Nikica Jelavic then came off to give Denis Stracqualursi a cameo that could be his last in a Blue shirt.

Everton looked at sixes and sevens at times with what passed for defensive football but still Newcastle could not score as the time ticked away on the 2011-12 season. Finally they got forward again, and Gibson struck another drive just wide. Then Baines and Pienaar created more magic down the left that was worthy of a goal but was blocked out for a corner.

Then from a throw-in, Osman almost ot the fourth, smacking his shot off the foot of the post after some lovely footwork had created the space. Osman got another chance that he smacked straight at Krul. And it was all over, bar the shouting, as Cahill was sent off!!! He somehow got into a fight with Cabaye just after the final whistle, that left a really strange taste in the mouth.

Everton: Howard; Hibbert, Baines, Heitinga (70' Distin), Jagielka; Osman, Gibson, Neville (74' Cahill), Pienaar, Fellaini, Jelavic (83' Stracqualursi).
Subs: Mucha, Coleman, Gueye, Barkley.

Newcastle: Krul, Perch, Williamson, Coloccini, Santon, Cabaye, Tiote, Ben Arfa, Gutierrez, Cisse, Ba.
Subs: Elliot, Gosling, Ryan Taylor, Marveaux, Shola Ameobi, Obertan, Ferguson.

Referee: Andre Marriner (W Midlands)

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (132)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Phil Smith
1 Posted 13/05/2012 at 15:59:34
Go 'ed lads! 7th is ours to throw away and when the history books are viewed the only important stat. will show that we had the better league team over the season, not the Shite.

See they're moaning over their new kit now. Had enough of their constant 'poor us' tag. You're a piss poor side ? deal with it!
Lee Courtliff
2 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:09:15
I predicted 9 out 10 of todays results in the Prem league.

The only one got wrong was Liverpool.

I would have won £500.

The only time I was unhappy to see Liverpool get beat.

Those bastards always find a way to stick it to us. One way or another.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
3 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:17:18
Come on, lads, let's not make this thread about them.

Some really excellent football from Everton today. To show how well we played, I even thought Osman actually made a fairly good contribution and really should have scored not one but three! However, for me, the fact that he scored none confirms really how ultimately useless he really is when push comes to shove....

Talking of which... Cahill ? WTF?!?!?

Can someone please explain what all that was about???
Bill Goodall
4 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:19:25
I think Cahill reacted to the incident in the first half where Cabaye pushed the ball boy.
James Martin
5 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:19:49
Come on Michael, let's not make this thread about bashing Osman. No idea what went on with Newcastle, something must have been said.
Jem Traynor
6 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:20:08
Get in!! Great football played by us today! Absolutely chuffed we finished above the RS!

Anyone know what happened with Timmy?
John Holmes
7 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:24:56
Micheal - I reckon Cahill was about the thing with Cabaye shoving the ballboy in the first half. Cahill went at him like he was making a point and there didn't seem to be any other provocation.
Jim Knightley
8 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:16:29
Fucking awesome! What a final day... incredible. Anyone watching MotD tonight?

Great to see us get 7th... especially after the pathetic comments of some of the toffeeweb 'fans' (looking at you Dick) who thought we'd lose, Liverpool win and that we'd even come 9th.

And yet again, Jelavic and Pienarr were so influencial.

Hard luck Lee. If it cheers you up, I lost £10,000 in a fantasy football game once after picking the wrong captain (I was conflicted between two, and picked the wrong one).
Mike Andrews
9 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:22:19
This seems random on here but did not log into matchday forum in time! I am just a bit confused by the City bashing on there. Their league win was, apparently, immoral as they bought it. So we hate City for having found a mega-rich owner and getting a new ground. At the same time we hate Kenwright for not having found us.....oh a mega-rich owner and a new ground.
Eugene Ruane
10 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:28:09
Could someone let me know who I can bash in this post - I'm VERY confused now,
Jim Knightley
11 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:32:24
You could bash Liverpool Eugene...or Cabaye. Or Drenthe, but then you'd risk Jimmy's wrath.

I really hope we keep Pienaar...
David Hallwood
12 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:31:00
There's always Ossie's kids Eugene apparently they're ugly fuckers
Mike Andrews
13 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:37:48
Probably me Eugene!
Paul Ferry
14 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:38:16
Redshite 16 points from relegation and 17 points from a champs league spot - Oh Nessie, Shanks will be turning in his grave - Ah Jessie, Bob Paisley will be turning in his grave
Pete Gunby
15 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:37:16
Sad to report that the Newcastle fans are rioting in Newcastle town center. Local authorities have placed the blame squarely on the shoulders of Hibbert.
David Hallwood
16 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:38:14
BTW to any stattos out there, how would we have finished if the season had started in January?
Dave White
22 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:37:52
Just don't bash Joey Barton 'cause you know you'll get it back!

Moyes to take Barton on a pay-as-you-play deal, break him down and rehibilitate into an England shirt?
James Morgan
23 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:36:02
Now that Bolton are down maybe we could poach Mark Davies on the cheap.
Kevin Sparke
24 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:47:23
David Hallwood - 3rd... I think

Dalziel Kane
25 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:35:28
I don't know where to start.

An absolutely fucking amazing day of soccer action.. I turned off the radio with 15 minutes to go when we were 3-0 ahead and Manchester City were 2-1 behind to QPR, still can't believe they have won the Title. Well Done to them really, I don't like United and hats off to City today, league champions for the first time since 1968, I don't care if they've had a bit of money to spend, genuinely pleased they did it today.

The shite had a defeat too today in Wales, it just gets better, an incredible day really. As for ourselves, well done to all involved, Jelavic gets back to scoring again, Newcastle miss out on a Champions League place, Hibbert scores his first Everton goal - at the wrong end! - and Cahill got involved in some unsavory action near the end, a very eventful afternoon at Goodison by the sounds of it. Well done to all involved today, seventh place and an FA cup semi-final with it, some would see that as not too bad a season. We finish above Liverpool again and I'm actually quite pleased right now. An absolute cracker of a day of soccer action today.
Joey Cannon
26 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:48:13
Haha ? good one, Pete 653 ... I did actually think about tweeting summit like that ... good minds think alike and all that.

Does this mean on MotD half the prog will be about Mancs?

Well in Blues and nice one for finishing above the Red and White Shite.
Dave White
27 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:51:25
I know we don't always get our due time on MotD Joey, but I think you can expect most of the show tonight to be Manc related!
Terry McLavey
29 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:42:31
Four goals again eh lads ! Some nice football played, maybe with a good start next season who knows?! Maybe Timmy's reach his sell by date ?! If it was over Cabye that was sorted with a hug ,and the ball boy was smiling,may be Tim's frustration boiling over ? not his best season was it ! I think we would have to see a coffin leaning against the post before Howard lets anyone in that goal but him!!Talk about stubborn !! No love for city but getting tired of hearing the mancs saying OUR title so reasonably pleased with that result, pleased even more with Swansea (is that red bashing by stealth?!!) Thanks for all your entertaining comments , have a good summer ! see yer again next season! COYB !!!
Kevin Sparke
31 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:58:10
Eugene - it's a shame Bishop doesn't still play for us - you could bash him
Brian Denton
32 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:57:44
Just back. God, how schizophrenic being an Everton fan makes you! We played so well (should have had 5 against a team theoretically going for a CL place) that I was really pleased for Moyes. Then I remembered the semi-final......

Pienaar was everywhere. It will be such a shame if he has to move on somewhere else.
Mark Riding
33 Posted 13/05/2012 at 17:56:43
Cabaye went over to a ball boy at half time over something.. looked like he was apologising to the lad.

Lee if it helps City cost me a fortune on a season long double ( Utd title winners and Van Persie top scorer ) Sick.

A huge well done to the lads... What a season it could have been though...
Iain McWilliam
35 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:05:41
Just to prove I'm not a total killjoy with regards to Moyes, I'll admit I enjoyed watching Everton in the first half. Some of the one touch football was great. Pienaar and Osman were even playing tikki takka stuff every now and then. For some reason even Cahill getting himself a red card made me happy, how many other players would stick up for a ball boy like that? Hopefully this is the turning point for Moyes!
Mark Riding
36 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:11:08
Dave #661 ? Barton is finished after today. Elbow was bad enough, but giving Aguero a dead leg as you're walking off is just mental.
Joey Cannon
37 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:11:47
MotD (10:25 -12am) ? I reckon I don't need to watch till about 11:17pm... any takers on the 11:17pm?
Michael Kenrick
38 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:18:31
Re Cahill, the bizarre thing though was that Cabaye took time out to run across at the end of the first half, apologize to the kid and give him a hug!!!

So Cahill came on the field still grieving about that, sufficiently to grab Cabaye by the throat and earn himself our ONLY red card of the season!?! Yea, what a top lad our Aussie talisman is, eh?
Tom Laskaris
39 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:09:47
A while back someone mentioned on a thread that we might be a chance to qualify for Europe if we finished 7th and Chelsea won the Champions League title? Was I dreaming or is that still a possibility?
Tim Locke
40 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:20:52
Great game and amazing atmosphere, "champions league, you're having a laugh", brilliant. Team played well, used the pitch well, lets hope the summer brings a bit more strength in depth and we can see some of the younger guys feel in the roles of the older generation.

Slight side note, people talking about losing money? What is that about, you mean you didn't win it, unless you really spent £10k on a fantasy football bet? Keep things in prospective boys you probably lost a £5 at most. Using your logic my gran being born on the wrong day has cost me the euro million not once but twice.
Graham Mockford
41 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:23:14
Michael # 678
We don't know what went on but don't miss the opportunity to take a pop why don't you.
Andy Crooks
42 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:29:31
Tony made the very pertinent point on another thread that today was about money. The win today was worth a Carling cup win financially. Still, no matter what, finishing above Liverpool was nice.

It could have been, it should have been better. But it was a good win today and a fine performance. As usual, David Moyes raises the hopes for next year.

By the way, Lyndon, I look forward to your summary of the season.
John Shaw
43 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:38:02
No, Cahill's reaction was because he was clothslined by Cabaye's elbow as he was running back from the Street End.
Michael Kenrick
44 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:40:39
That makes a lot more sense... Thanks, John.

Although still an utterly stupid reaction that will cost us a three-match suspension... Oh hang on ? that's actually a good thing if Moyes is prevented from picking him!
Frank Eardley
45 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:31:54
Anyone who says we should sell Fellaini now is an idiot, that is what we paid ?15million for.
Joey Cannon
46 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:42:12
@frank ...we paid 15m for an idiot?
Mark Riding
47 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:49:55
Frank #686 - Its a good job we havent got an idiot as a Chairman then eh !
Michael Kenrick
48 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:48:50
Graham, any professional knows retaliation and raising your hands grabbing the throat is a straight red card offence. There is no justification for that, but don't miss the opportunity for condoning such stupidity, eh?
Andrew James
49 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:41:50
I have not been online until now so my only way of knowing our score was on R5L where details of scorers and results outside the Manchester matches was limited. So imagine my disappointment when I read Hibbert and goal in the same sentence only to discover he put it in the wrong net!!!
Neal King
50 Posted 13/05/2012 at 18:41:46
Im happy for the win today but honestly dont understand Moyes bringing off Heitinga and replace with Distin? Why does he insist on getting his favourites on the pitch at all cost. its obvious Distin and Jagielka are shit together so why not take off Jagielka? and also why Cahill again
Iain McWilliam
51 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:04:06
I think he just wanted the players to get a round of applause. If Heittinga is made to feel wanted by the fans then there is a more likelyhood that he will stay surely?
Neal King
52 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:05:44
I think Heitinga knows hes wanted by the fans its the manager that needs to show him hes appreciated. as i said leave our player of the season on and take of Jagielka. For most of the season its obvious to me that Moyes favours Distin and Jagielka partnership when its blindingly obvious that they are shit together
Neal King
53 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:09:40
Iain i dont understand your post.... Heitinga started
Jim Knightley
54 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:08:52
Neal, way to turn a positive into a negative. We are 3-0 up at home, Distin has played very well this season, why not bring him on for the last home game? Many managers would have repeated such substitutions on final days around the world, I don't understand how it is indicative of Moyes insisting on getting his favourites on.
Lenny Kingman
55 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:20:32
Seventh is ours. Excellent..

How about Champions of the Also Ran League. Yes thats what we are. Well done to all concerned.
Jamie Barlow
56 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:12:34
Michael, you have no idea what was said or went on so give it a rest. Any excuse to have a pop.
Varun Rajwade
57 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:23:50
Michael, I am always amazed at your wonderful ability to be a perpetual PMS!!

Cheer up lid!!
Jack Okell
58 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:27:00
Moyes brought him off to get his well deserved round of applause for being Player of the Season. Stop seeing things that aren't there. I bet you shit your knickers when someone chats to your missus.
Neal King
59 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:27:22
Jim..... But why bring Heitinga off and not Jagielka? I dont understand it. and im not turning a positive into a negative, im asking a question on a discussion forum.

Why do people feel the need to jump to Moyes defence at the slightest critisicsm
David Hallwood
60 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:27:28
Andy Crooks#683 is looking forward to Lyndon's report on the season, why wait, just go and have a look at the last 5 seasons-started shit finished like a rocket.
Jamie Barlow
61 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:39:13
Neal, Heitinga was brought off so the crowd could give him a good reception and show their appreciation for a good season. How hard is it to understand?
Joey Cannon
62 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:42:53
we still havin a laugh?
Jim Knightley
63 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:32:59
Neal, slightest criticism? your comment is innane. Firstly, only Baines has played more games than Heitinga out of our defensive players this season. Heitinga was voted our player of the year...and Distin has been superb...why do you think Distin was taken off for Heitinga? Have you no experience of one player being taken off for applause and another being brought on for the same reason? and why bring Jags off instead of Heitinga?
Paul David
64 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:44:33
Good game,strange when you think back how many good chances Newcastle had even though I thought we handled them well.We should have scored a lot more but its good that i'm not happy with 3 goals when earlier in the season we struggled to create 3 chances.
Jim Knightley
65 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:45:39
Lenny...should only the top four/six be happy with their seasons in your opinion and then disappointment for everyone else? Lowest transfer budget in the division and mid-table wages, I'd say 7th and the signings of Jelavic and Gibson is pretty good going.
James Elworthy
66 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:50:35
Moyes spent the whole week plugging Jags for England so he was a cert to start and he played well and is good enough to be selected.
Joe Clitherow
67 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:36:47
Neal

How about because Heitinga had a yellow card and the game was pretty feisty, had scored and was guaranteed a good and deserved individual reception as player of the season with the game 3-0, and possibly had been carrying an injury which you and the rest of us don't know about? In fact you could pick one or any of those reasons or another one but you clearly prefer choose a preconceived one of your own because actually none of us know. That's not defensive by the way that's pointing out alternative possibilities.

It's not as if Jagielka was shabby today at all. I don't get this 'Moyes favourite' stuff at all where Jagielka is concerned. Not the best playing forward granted but the lad was immaculate for us in defence before he sustained a really serious injury which he still seems to be recovering from, and which will take game time, but for some reason he seems to have become a target.

Like I said, I don't get it.
Paul David
68 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:52:47
Jags has been a lot better latelly and is great at last ditch challenges,just still surprised to see him start ahead of Distin.
Iain McWilliam
69 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:52:03
Neal @696 I think Heittinga was took off early because we had the game in the bag. Moyes took off all the favourites (Jelavic, Neville, and Heittinga) so they got a round of applause. I think it was just a bit of psychological man management so the players felt appreciated. I agree Distin and Heittinga play better together and are better footballing centre backs than Jags, I just think Moyes was using the scoreline to show how much the player is appreciated by the fans.
Paul David
70 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:54:27
Joe its because Jag was crap for ages after that injury and was never dropped and meaning Heitinga was played in midfield were he is crap.
Neal King
71 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:52:12
Jamie and Jim... thank you for answering my query, it really is nice to know there are some top guys about.

For your information, I'm stuck in the Middle East and slightly drunk and didn't get to watch the game or listen to it so the only feed I had was the ToffeeWeb Live Forum. Jamie's explanation makes my little oversight explained... or, in other words, that fucking told me, didn't it?
Iain McWilliam
72 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:01:51
Neal, I also think Jags was played today to prove/or get him fit enough to be named in the England squad for the Euro's. I'm sure Moyes and Distin would understand that.
Mark Riding
73 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:05:21
Iain, are you sure he wasnt just in the shop window ? Fit for Euros ? Jones, Ferdinand and Lescott I reckon are ahead of Jags, and thats without the Chelsea gobshite..
Paul David
74 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:06:12
If I was a manager, I wouldn't want any of my players playing through the summer unless it was to put them in the shop window.

Is that why Moyes is so keen for Jags to go to the Euro's?
Iain McWilliam
75 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:10:51
Mark and Paul, you could be right. I'm probably in the monority though...I'd be quite happy to sell Jags and a few others as long as we can use some of the profits on new players. Jags, Cahill, Distin are gonna start depreciating alot soon.
David Price
76 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:19:03
The first half display was a joy to watch. We have our new Holy Trinity in Jelavic, Fellaini and Pienaar. The total football played was fantastic. Yet for me Gibson is a major factor in the way our flair players have freedom to attack. He is a superb reader of the game, sees potential danger and covers every blade of grass for the team.

Johnny and Jags were superb, that is the best partnership for sure. Pray for an injury free season for all these guys next year, because that was a top four performance, no doubt . Third best goals against and our goal difference has gone from -4 in January to +10. It's an amazing turnaround and we are a match for anyone.

Didn't stay for the lap of honour, still pissed off over the semi-final, but good job today boys, just don't forget how good you are when we play them lot again next season.
James Martin
77 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:36:02
Was there any money from the Lescott deal contingent on him winning the title with City?
Sam Hoare
78 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:35:03
Great win against a very tasty Nnewcastle team. It's no coincidence that, after Moyes was given some cash to spend for the first time in 2 years(!!), we have been pretty damn solid since January (derby disasters aside). Fingers crossed that the team looks stronger rather than weaker at the start of next season and we might genuinely have a shot at upsetting some odds...
Paul David
79 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:46:01
James I think we got all the money up front thats why we could buy Distin,Heitinga and Billy.
Joe Clitherow
80 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:31:39
Paul 716 he was coming back from a very serious injury FFS.

Throughout my life Evertonians have been noted for being knowledgeable about football - we even sing about knowing our history. It bugs me when we display the 7 second goldfish memory common to Sky Sports instant gratification.

Before Jagielka's serious injury he was rated as a 12m+ defender and we are not so flush that we can throw those aside. Therefore he needed game time to regain previous levels. He's been showing that recently and he was really pretty good today.

Then again a balanced view is not exactly that fashionable here with so many simple black and white opinions - which never ever change despite additional facts materialising. Where, for instance are the twin Fellaini bashers today (James and Eric)? The truth about player ability is somewhere in between those poles of crap and godlike and changes with time. That's called form.

If you want more evidence of that you can look back through the archives on this site and see the absolute vitriol directed at Heitinga not that many months ago.

Years ago we had a player called Adrian Heath who had a really bad injury and never really regained his prior form but the Goodison crowd cut him slack when he came back, as, actually, the crowd in the ground still tend to in those circumstances. I shudder to think of the abuse he would have got if the internet had been around then.
Mike Hughes
81 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:48:35
RM RUMOUR - Listening to the Radio Merseyside phone-in, Alan Jackson referred to a message that a player had put in a transfer request. I didn't know whether it was an Everton or LFC player as I had half an eye on the Man City celebrations. can anyone shed any light on the comment? I'm just hoping it was Suarez.
Joe Clitherow
82 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:47:30
By the way, one for Eugene - Big Bad Bob came on at half-time today and got a great reception in case you hadn't heard.
Mike Oates
83 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:46:12
It looked like to me that Cabaye must have said something to Cahill just minutes before the strangulation and Cahill blew at the full time whistle. Also Cabaye just apologised on NUFC site for comments he made to Cahill - he regets getting Cahill sent off.

Perhaps he called him Shirley or some similar Aussie/Samoan term (or perhaps something far worse - we'll bever know as I dont think Cahill will spill the beans.
James Martin
84 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:52:42
Joe I'm always ready with criticism of Fellaini, but I actually thought he played well today and I don't want to moan about certain players after what was a good send off for us when we all know that everyone on here could write mini dissertations on their least favourite players.

For what it's worth, I am with you on Jagielka, with Distin at the age he is, Jagielka and Heitinga should be our partnership next season and, if they carry on playing like they have been recently, then what a partnership that would be.
Paul David
85 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:48:59
Joe

Jag was my favourite player a few years a go so I'm not looking to get on his back but I do think players should be picked on form and not because a player used to be good. I'm made up Jag now looks like getting back to his best but he should not have been playing when he was poor when we had two other really good centre halves.
Iain Love
86 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:43:21
Some nice football played today, vital we get hold of Pienaar for next season, I'd be happy with a loan deal again. Let's just hope Chelsea keeps Spurs out of the CL.

So onto a summer of transfer speculation, see you all next season.
Joe Clitherow
87 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:51:34
Mike 733 I heard that too but I wasn't really listening as I was just getting in the car. I thought he said Fellaini actually but I'm sure it was scurrilous rubbish from disgruntled RS as Fellaini was on the pitch for the lap and laughing and joking. It certainly wasn't mentioned again
Joe Clitherow
88 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:58:27
Paul

How does he get form without playing?
Ian Bennett
89 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:57:31
Lescott according to the reports went for £22m, or £22m with add ons or £24m. Hope its an extra £2m for the transfer pot.
Bobby Thomas
90 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:50:40
Is right, Joe(732), I love the way the Jag is now shite, its his turn by the look of things.

The Jag was up and down before he got injured this season, but the whole team was suffering from a malaise as far as I could see. Before we signed Gibson, the midfield just wasn't doing it. There wasn't enough protection and the balance was all wrong. Fellaini/Rodwell doesn't work and in an attempt to get some solidity Moyes started the dreaded 2 defenders as holding players in front of the back 4. You know you are struggling to keep it tight when the manager tries that!!

The whole place was flat, manager, players and support. The Jag has already proved he is good enough to be an England squad player, he has already done that in his career and is, 100%, and on form a very, VERY good centre half.

In terms of trading players, we probably have lost our chance to maximise our fee for him. But after losing Lescott, the other centre half Moyes turned into an England squad player and who has just won a title medal today, I very much doubt he wanted to lose the Jag.

Cracking player, people have very short memories. Plus Distin is 35 so we may need the Jag sooner than we think.
Anthony Manning
91 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:47:05
Good finish again to the season and finishing above the afterbirth is a nice bonus too, now lets hope Moyes can prepare us proper in the pre season for once so that we can start the season well.
Paul David
92 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:05:00
Joe

If he was far better than the other two then there would be a case for trying to play him into form but as good as he is he isnt miles better than Heitinga or Distin so he should have to wait for an injury,suspension or loss of form from the other two.
Peter Mills
93 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:47:20
Michael Kenrick 641, you actually thought Osman made quite a good contribution? What's wrong with saying he was excellent, and some of the football we played during the game was superb?
Ryan Holroyd
94 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:09:14
Mike 734

The rumour was about the redshite centre half Martin Skrtel.
John Shaw
95 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:14:09
The transfer request apparently is coming from Skrtel.
Paul David
96 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:16:13
Skrtel?

Even the shit players think they can do better than Liverpool ha.
Dave Roberts
97 Posted 13/05/2012 at 20:59:16
The rumour was about a Shite player. Apparently it's two Shite players...Kuyt and Maxi Rodriguez.

The comment had nowt to do with Everton.
Ian Bennett
98 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:17:23
City are after him apparently.
John Keating
99 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:16:32
I know I shouldn't really have a go at Bily - again - as I critisised him almost from day one but I look at Jelavic at £5 mill and how he hit the ground running, then I look at that waste of £8 mill and he didn't run in all the time he was with us!

Maybe the moral of the story is Moyes shouldn't listen to other managers recommending players and just buy from bankrupt teams. There's a couple more at Rangers I bet we could get on the cheap: Whittaker and Naismith could do a job for us.
Dave Roberts
100 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:17:34
Personally I think Osman had a bloody good game today. I thought he was great, rarely gave the ball away and was a wellhead of creativity and invention in a sort of pint-sized sort of way. FFS leave him alone!

On top of that Tony Hibbert scored so what more can we ask?

I was particularly pleased with Jelly's goal today. Not particularly pretty and a hint of handball in the early stages, but it was the kind of goal that only REAL strikers score........ and now we know we have got one!
Paul David
101 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:27:47
Osman did play really well today but he really does need to sort his shooting out, he should of had at least two today.
Roberto Birquet
102 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:27:33
JK
I know I shouldn't really have a go at Bily - again - as I critisised him almost from day one but I look at Jelavic at 5 mill and how he hit the ground running, then I look at that waste of 8 mill and he didn't run in all the time he was with us !
--------------------------
He eventually paid for Jelli. So, I'd look at it as £9 m paid for thr hotshot Croat, who has arrived three yrs late...
Peter Askins
103 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:26:23
Skrtel? Nasty piece of work, and not surprised that he seems to have a high opinion of himself. You could say he's high on confidence, but low on consonants!

Rangers platers to be picked off? I've seen Sone Aluko a few times, and he seems to have something about him. given his recent dealings with Nigerians, however, maybe Moyes would steer clear this time.

Oh, and it looked like Big Bob Latchford was a lot leaner than I remember him when he trotted on at half-time today. He'd certainly be able to give Yakubu a few yards start....
Peter Mills
104 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:23:11
Joe Clitherow, at long last someone has pointed out the Evertonian weakness of writing off players who are "too old", "will never be the same again", "will never make it".

I'm thinking Dave Johnson, Steve McMahon, could have been Kevin Ratcliffe, was Peter Reid, Paul Bracewell. I'd hate Jack Rodwell to be added to that list.
James Flynn
105 Posted 13/05/2012 at 19:03:54
What a season. Jesus!

Anyone remember the names of those few fellows in here who, around the New Year, hoped we got sent down?

Anyone remember their names?
Shaun Lyon
106 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:30:49
Wasn't at the game today but just wondering where the sceptics and pessimists currently stand re Moyes, Kenwright et al. Seems to me that despite the (to me anyway) often justified complaints about the quality of the football (at least earlier in the season) finishing 7th with an FA Cup semi doesn't seem too bad given our financial situation. Who in that top echelon did better when you compare resources? I know it's horribly frustrating but it could be worse (though I wish to Christ Moyes would hand over to someone else for derby games...)
Paul David
107 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:51:02
Shaun

If you look at things in black and white then 7th and a cup semi final is a decent season but for me what I can not forget is the manner of the Anfield and Wembley defeats. Moyes will never win me back over and I'll always want him out after that ? especially because of Anfield ? fielding a weakened team against Liverpool is unforgivable.
Joe Clitherow
108 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:48:07
Peter

Dave Johnson haunted for sure, can't bring myself to talk about McMahon. Brace sadly was a shadow of his former self I think, given the medical technology at that time. But the shite given to Reidy I think was shameful just before we moved him on. People forget both him and Andy Gray were both written off when we got them and they weren't too bad for us.

John Ford
109 Posted 13/05/2012 at 21:57:48
Joe, Cahill is getting similar treatment by some here. He is clearly not the player he was, but rather than acknowledge his previous efforts, the criticism is without caveat., and sneering.
Paul David
110 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:05:22
John

It's not like Cahill is getting booed at the match; if he is playing shite then he shouldn't be exempt of criticism and he has been shite now for a very long time.
Joe Clitherow
111 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:11:15
John I've posted elsewhere that Cahill's treatment reminds me of Reidy.

Paul, no he isn't getting booed at the match. Some social regulation from peers operates within the ground and seems to act as a boundary. This obviously doesn't apply on t'interweb, where the rule seems to be any stream of consciousness just spews out. That's why I think the consensus views at the match are a much better indicator of general opinion than extremist views (either way) which often come out here from some.

Just my opinion like
Sam Hoare
112 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:15:11
Have been a big fan of Cahill and his unquestionable work ethic but is it awful that when he got his red a small part of me thought 'oh good, that means Moyes won't be able to start him for the first few games of next season'?

Think that his best contributions may be made from the bench next season with hopefully Fellaini or other starting behind Jelavic...
John Ford
113 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:15:48
I agree re his form Paul, and he's open to criticism because of it.

Generally TW is a cut above the usual forum dross, so personal insults, sneering ridicule and similar just turn me off. Lets be honest he's been a liability for some time, but there's a way to say so.
Paul David
114 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:20:34
Joe

I disagree. There's been times I've wanted to shout abuse at players or Moyes but I don't. Yes, I'll say things to the people next to me if I have to get something off my chest but rarely would I scream it at a player and I'd imagine others are the same.

John

I think I've only ever insulted a player's ability or form and I think that's fair game on here.
Ciarán McGlone
115 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:29:43
Mr Clitherow,

Are you suggesting we shouldn't discuss Cahill's footballing merit on a discussion forum?
Michael Kenrick
116 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:53:09
Peter (#748). Simple: because it would be wrong.

Osman was pretty much his usual self: some neat little bits of football, but no end product. In the final analysis, his contribution was lacking. If it wasn't, then he'd have one, two... three goals to his name in a massive win.

Guess what? He doesn't. Because he consistently fails to deliver.
Joe Clitherow
117 Posted 13/05/2012 at 22:50:58
Mr McGlone

Please indicate where such a suggestion has been intimated.

I am, however, suggesting that excessive abuse of outstanding club servants is unwarranted and unnecessary when it is clear to all that their powers have waned. The latitude for actual discussion of the veracity of that last point seems fairly limited to me.

It's especially loathsome when some individuals cannot distinguish the line between footballing efficacy and personal attacks.
Ryan Holroyd
118 Posted 13/05/2012 at 23:04:17
Agree with you Joe. We can all see Cahill is on the way down. Unfortunately, some people are more happy to winge and moan than cheer. I bet these people weren't calling Cahill names when his goals got us to 4th place. Or maybe they were cos some people are never happy. Fuck 'em I say.
Jamie Barlow
119 Posted 13/05/2012 at 23:13:05
Does anybody kn
Jamie Barlow
120 Posted 13/05/2012 at 23:14:32
Sorry, does anybody know who was commentating on the Everton game on Football First tonight?
Peter Mills
121 Posted 13/05/2012 at 23:07:06
Michael 780, it's all a matter of perspective, I saw Leon's performance as a significant contribution towards a very good win against opponents who who were above us in the table who badly needed a win.
Sean McCarthy
122 Posted 14/05/2012 at 01:02:24
Jamie, it was Gary Birtles doing the summary and talking shite!! He's paid to analyse yet some of the things he says makes you wonder if he's actually watching!! Totally missed Cabaye wind Cahill up to the point where he retaliates after the whistle and gets sent off. Claimed Jelavic handled it for his goal even tho the cameras showed it came off his chest, totally missed the deflection for 1st goal until his 4th view!! Maybe he was most interested in the City/Utd coverage on his monitor...

Great performance by the Blues tho. Finished in some style and let's hope (again) for a fruitful summer and a few new faces to replace the likes of McFadden, Anichebe, Stracqualursi, and other fringe players who are a drain on wages.
Bryan Wendell
123 Posted 14/05/2012 at 01:53:44
Everton supporter in Texas here (and posting for the first time after a couple years of lurking).

Watched every game this season (most via FoxSoccer.TV) and enjoyed almost every second of it.

Really looking forward to next season... Is it August yet?
Sagar Palikhey
124 Posted 14/05/2012 at 04:31:08
Yes!! We finished above Liverpool. We need to buy some quality players so that we can reach Europe next season. This season also we had a great chance but we blew it after losing in the semi-final of the FA Cup. If we look at the whole season, we did a good job and 7th is a great finish. We need investment, we need new owners, Kenwright Out!!

~ Evertonian from Nepal
Peter Thistle
125 Posted 14/05/2012 at 05:35:02
That was a pretty sweet performance, well happy with that. Bring on next season.

BTW...

After watching the City game I'm so glad we didn't sign Joey Barton when we had the chance. What a fucking idiot, we are lucky Moyes knew better than Neil Warnock, quoted at the time as saying "I'm surprised some of the bigger teams didn't come in to sign him". Now you know why, Neil...
Jimmy Sørheim
126 Posted 14/05/2012 at 07:43:51
Good result.
I fear a repeat of the last summer, in that we will lose out on Pienaar and Moyes will refuse to sign Drenthe, so take away both Drenthe and Pienaar we have no creative ability at all!

That is how things stand, Spurs will demand silly money and we will struggle to find a decent enough replacement for both Pienaar and Drenthe.

Moyes simply has to get a replacement for both Drenthe and Pienaar, if we are to have any hope of getting back to europe.

I can see the headlines and the downturn in moral for both fans and players when the newspapers write "Everton misses out on Pienaar as Spurs play hardball"

A realistic eye is needed, we do not have money to spend, plus Pienaars wages might also be too much to swallow.

Until we get two top notch wingers for our midfield we will struggle just as we did in the semi final.

The prize money will go to pay our debt, and the fall in average attendances.

The only other way we can buy Pienaar will be to sell a top player.
Forgive me for not jumping of joy just yet.

This summer will be a nervebiter, since we need to keep both Baines and Fellaini, or at least Baines.
We have already lost Arteta, Fellaini with 70.000 pr.week is most likely to go next.

We got 7th this season with Pienaar on loan for 6 months, what about next season, will we be missing more then Pienaar?
Leslie Wee
127 Posted 14/05/2012 at 08:17:39
Re: 829

Jimmy, will you ever stop talking about Drenthe?

Give it a rest, lad!
Sam Hoare
128 Posted 14/05/2012 at 08:22:28
Leslie ? Jimmy IS Drenthe. It's the only explanation.
James Bourne
129 Posted 14/05/2012 at 08:55:06
MK - usually shake my head when I read your comments but what a fantastic summary of our Ossie - sometimes neat feat with no end product - perfect. I can't hate him as he's a borm scouser but drives me made he gets so much play time as he's slow, gets knocked off the ball and can't shoot.

Enough of my moans - delighted with our finish, loved the goal spree, excited we have at last got a striker and believe we will get Peanuts as if we don't I wouldn't expect Moysie to resign.
Ciarán McGlone
130 Posted 14/05/2012 at 09:16:52
Mr Clitherow,

You'll be able to show me loads of these personal attacks on Cahill, won't you?
Peter Barry
131 Posted 14/05/2012 at 09:11:55
Seeing Felliani play in the slot behind Jelly it seems as if that is his best position . So the key to next season will be to keep Gibson fit so Felli does not have to drop back in to midfield , either that or get another creative midfielder so we can drop Neville to the bench. Astoundingly for once I find myself in agreement with Sam Hoare - Cahills red card is most probably the only way to stop Davey picking him automatically and perhaps just perhaps Davey will see that his best position now is LEFT OUT or at the most a SUB . I was going to write IMPACT SUB until I realised how ridiculous that was.
Joe Clitherow
132 Posted 14/05/2012 at 09:19:24
Jimmy Sorheim I find myself in agreement with you in that I don't think we'll sign Drenthe in the summer either.

Well worth posting that to start what must be a heated debate over the crucial 'will we won't we' issue - what are the odds? Thanks for that, this must be taking up a lot of thinking time from Moyes and his staff.

Anyone else got a view on this?
Sam Hoare
133 Posted 14/05/2012 at 09:49:01
And astoundingly I find myself agreeing with you Peter in that Felli should be playing behind Jelly next season with Gibson pulling strings behind. Perhaps with Rodwell if he has a good pre-season or maybe Diame from Wigan.

I wonder though after yesterday if you will for once admit that our football was not that DIRE and DOUR???
Steve King
134 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:40:53
Jimmy, How much is Drenthe paying you in agency fees??

They guy is a nobhead,

He is only outdone by Joey Barton in the "stupid idiot that doesn't deserve any more chances" stakes!

Well done blues, could never have imagined a 7th position finish above the shite before Christmas!

I agree the summer is going to be a difficult one, at least one big name will go.
The key is using the money we get from the sale well ,and not fighting it all summer and finally letting him go on deadline day, with no time to recruit!
Alex Doyle
135 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:39:16
Well done Everton. I think Jagielka and Heitenga will make a good pairing. There seems to be the argument that we should have a left footed defender starting, but although not always his fault, we seem more vulnerable with Distin playing. Perhaps a co-incidence and he's a good solid pro, but think the other two can offer more.

Obviously signing Pienaar in some capacity needs to be a priority. He has been excellent. Jelavic is pure quality. He looks a little scruffy, but has natural finishing ability. I think our chances next season depend on keeping him fit. Hopefully Croatia go out early of the Euros. Darren Gibson has been another great purchase. For the first time in a long time, we now look like we have a balanced midfield and are not relying on Pip, Osman or Heitenga to play out of position.

Big up to Felliani too. Has been brilliant in different positions and has managed to cut out most of the yellow cards. Plenty of reason to be optimistic about our chances next season and credit to Moyes turning around a difficult season.
Joe Clitherow
136 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:50:34
Mr McGlone

Quite possibly if I could be bothered to (I'm not)
Ciarán McGlone
137 Posted 14/05/2012 at 15:17:59
Quite possibly?

Possibly?

That's quite a climb down from insinuating that personal abuse of Cahill was reaching epidemic proportions - and stating it as a matter of fact!

People have attacked his footballing capabilities and/or selection, and nothing more.
Joe Clitherow
138 Posted 14/05/2012 at 18:36:01
Ciarán

Ooh hang on sunshine, "epidemic proportions"???

Where exactly did I say that, that you heard it clearly in your head?

Have you heard of a fundamental attribution error? It's quite an interesting concept.

As I said, I cannot be bothered to trawl to produce eveidence for your benefit (primarily) - make of that whatever you wish. I'm quite sure you will.
Kevin Day
140 Posted 14/05/2012 at 21:50:29
I remember the day Jelavic signed, I said, "I bet he gets in to double figures before the seasons out" on here........ just off to sit in my armchair with a big fat smug look on my face!!!!

Anyway guys 'n' gals, thanks for all the banter and all the chats this season, let's now sit back and see what the summer brings, roll on August!
Eric Myles
141 Posted 16/05/2012 at 03:32:16
Joe #732, I'm still here.

I thought Fellaini played well in the first half but returned to his usual form in the second, but then none of the team were outstanding in the second half.

I agree that his ability is somewhere between the poles of sublime and ridiculous and if he could maintain that 'form' as you call it throughout the season (or even throughout a whole game) then Fellaini could become the world class player that some fans on here think he is.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads