Martinez likes benefits of the loan system

, 10 April, 30comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez has been talking about the importance of the loan system for Everton as it allowed him to complete his squad for this season. However, he does recognize the problem created by glamour clubs stockpiling talented players.

"I accept everyone's opinion but the loan system has to be part of the game," he said.

"Clearly from our point of view the loan system was vital as we needed it to finish our squad and to criticise that would be ridiculous.

"If you can be creative with the way you can use your resources that is part of the game.

"The two young players (Romelu Lukaku and Gerard Deulofeu) needed the opportunity to develop and Gareth Barry has come in and his experience has been very important.

"Loanees will never be successful unless you have a strong core of players and that is what we have.

"What is difficult is finding a loan relationship which works because not all of these have been successful, so it has its pros and cons."

He said sometimes the root cause of the high number of available loans was a combination of big-spending clubs stockpiling players and poor choices by the youngsters in the first place.

"You could find many examples of players who have not been treated fairly just because they are not part of the club's long-term future and are seen just as part of a support squad," he added.

"Sometimes young players get attracted to the glamorous name of a club but you need to be realistic.

"Some clubs have very much in mind the idea of developing young players and giving them opportunities and we want to believe we are one of those.

"We have had, at times, four under-21s in the line up and two on the bench and that is an unknown quality.

"Other teams are very much about first-team affairs and development players are completely separate so it can be very difficult for a young player to have an opportunity in the first team.

"Your decision when you are accepting to be part of a club to develop your career has to be about the long-term possibilities of becoming a professional football.

"You will always get the top clubs investing a huge amount of money thinking about the progress of the first team and not a young player, which is a real shame."

Quotes sourced from ITV



Reader Comments (30)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dick Brady
1 Posted 10/04/2014 at 18:03:50
I don’t like the loan system myself. Don’t get me wrong; I appreciate the benefits to a team like Everton who could never afford the big-money transfers of players like Lukaku.

But I just cannot get attached to loan players. I cannot vote for them as Player of the Season, I cannot think of getting their names on the back of my shirt. I remain unattached to the loan players.

In truth, if a goal is going to be scored, I would rather Naismith than Lukaku who scored it. And if a youngster is going to develop into a great player, I would rather it be Stones than Deulofeu.

I do recognise the benefits of the loan players and I do appreciate their efforts in an Everton shirt but I just cannot get attached to them. They are not real Everton players. They have no future at Everton other then short term.

Paul Andrews
2 Posted 10/04/2014 at 19:27:52
Dick,

Would your opinion change if Lukaku's goals got us into the CL and he then signed permanently?

Peter Warren
3 Posted 10/04/2014 at 19:28:50
Dick - I thought I was like you...BUT Donovan changed my mind a bit as he seemed to have a real affinity with the club. MOST of all want changed my outlook was Lukaku on Sunday. Slamming that goal in, his celebration, him geeing up Gladwys St. I wonder if you where at Goodison. If you were I just can't see how you could not have an affinity with him and be made up he's here
Micky Norman
4 Posted 10/04/2014 at 20:44:52
I always felt the same, but a full season loan is a bit different. After all how long did Gary Lineker stay with us? And quite a few of our better signings under OFM did begin as loans, albeit usually with first option to buy. RM is right to point out that the rich clubs are often just stockpiling players with potential, often just to keep them out of the hands of their closest opposition. If anything needs looking into it is this. So if the only way to get Barry, Lukaku, Deleufeu in a blue shirt is via the loan system, so be it.
Jimmy Sørheim
5 Posted 10/04/2014 at 21:35:20
I feel it is best to have permanent players.

The way forward for Everton is to buy top young talent like Stones, Coleman, Green and so on.

It might take a little more time but at least you get to sell them for big money in the end.

Lukaku is different because he can get us in the CL, and if he does then we have the chance to buy him.

The only problem is if we do get into CL and miss out on Lukaku who is going to score the goals needed then???

Eric Myles
6 Posted 11/04/2014 at 01:30:47
Jimmy #274, isn't that exactly what the top teams can claim to be doing? Buying top young talent as permanent players to sell on for big money?
Paul Mackie
7 Posted 11/04/2014 at 09:01:04
I don't see how anyone can have a problem with the loan system. Remember that this is the same loan system that's given valuable experience to Barkley, Coleman, Osman...

While there is a lack of competitive youth/reserve leagues, there'll always be a need for loans I'm afraid. I could definitely get behind a "no loans within the same league" rule however.

Dennis Stevens
8 Posted 11/04/2014 at 09:35:35
I figure all players are transitory whether on loan or not - how long did we have Andy Gray, Gary Lineker, Wayne Rooney, etc? However, The current situation whereby wealthy clubs hoover up nearly all talented youngsters artificially inflates prices for those still available & necessitates the use of the loan system en masse in order to get game time for all these players. It seems to me that a limit on squad sizes is well overdue. Although further changes to players contracts could also help level the playing field somewhat.
Nicholas Page
9 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:07:00
Yet more shit from the Daily Mail!!

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2602289/Everton-near-Champions-League-without-loan-signings-table-proves.html

Michael Penley
10 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:13:51
Dumbest article I've ever read (339). Do they not know that without our loan players we would, like, maybe have other players on instead of them? If a team has a loan keeper do they subtract all the goals he saved to calculate their "rightful" place on the table?
Colin Wainwright
11 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:19:11
How very scientific. If we had played the majority of the season with 8 or 9 players we would be nowhere near the top 4. Who’d have thunk it. And the clubs who predominantly do the loaning, occupy the top places. Brilliant, insightful journalism.

Who buys this fuckin’ rag anyway?

Nicholas Page
12 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:32:43
It's unbelievable. We must have upset a few of TPTB.

funny how I've never read an article on where Chelsea and City would be without the Petrodollars etc etc.

Patrick Murphy
13 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:40:37
Uefa don't like the idea that Athletico Madrid's goalkeeper may not be able to face Chelsea and it seems they are saying it is 'illegal' or 'unfair' and don't believe it is proper for Chelsea to stipulate such a clause in the players contract. Stand by for a major overhaul in the loan market in the coming months. I wonder if we dare play Barry against City? Obviously there is an agreement in place for Everton not to choose Barry in that game but if it is not enforceable by Chelsea in the CL then will the FA be able to enforce it in the Premier League?
Kevin Tully
14 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:40:46
Nicholas, what a ridiculous premise to base an article on. What if Jelavic had stayed and scored more than Lukaku? We could be fighting for the title no doubt?

I hate these strawman debates, a complete waste of energy for all concerned. We could easily project Kone would have matched Lukaku's contribution, it's not like he's scored 30 goals this season, FFS.

Nicholas Page
15 Posted 11/04/2014 at 11:49:03
Patrick, I've just seen that and wondered how it might affect Everton but I doubt Scudamore and Co would want to upset their wealthy Arab sponsors given that they're already grieving over lost Asian revenues 'cos Utd aren't top of the pile. Wankers

http://www.uefa.org/about-uefa/administration/news/newsid=2088774.html

Jim Knightley
16 Posted 11/04/2014 at 12:06:36
I think there are different rules for Champions League and domestic competition Patrick... UEFA stipulates that players can play against parent clubs, and I believe the FA stipulates that they cannot in domestic competition.

The Daily Mail article is beyond stupid... it's not the first time they've done it either. I remember them doing one on RVP a few seasons back when he scored so many of Arsenal's goals. They made an amended table removing his goals, and then used it to create the proverbial strawman argument, claiming Arsenal were a one-man team. The journalists are not that stupid, but they are vindictive, and are trying to generate anger for a team who must compete with so much less than the rest.

It's strange because what we do is entirely within the rules. Whereas, is some of the spending we've seen reconcilable with fair play? What about Chelsea's use of feeder clubs? And what about Arsene Wenger, who has persistently robbed clubs of brilliant 16-year-olds, as he has made the most of rules elsewhere which prevent clubs giving players a professional contract at 16?

I'm also with Dennis re the transitory nature of players anyway. We could just as well lose Coleman, or Barkley in a couple of seasons. I support everyone of our loan players, and I get the same feeling from their goals. I think at least one of the three will be here next season, and perhaps all three. And whatever they do in the future, I will watch them a little bit more closely, and support them a little more than another 'neutral' players, because they've contributed to Everton, and are part of 'my' Everton story.

Dennis Stevens
17 Posted 11/04/2014 at 12:20:31
All newspapers are vile scum - The Daily Hate all the more so.
Tony J Williams
18 Posted 11/04/2014 at 12:49:41
Pointless article by a pointless paper.
Chris Leyland
19 Posted 11/04/2014 at 12:48:26
That league table produced by the Daily Mail showing Everton's supposed position without the loan signings is a bag of shite. I don't see them doing a similar table showing what Liverpool's position would be if they had sacked Suarez for being found guilty of using racially abusive language or for biting someone (which, if any of us had done either of in the workplace, we'd have been sacked for).
James Wong
20 Posted 11/04/2014 at 14:46:28
Dick just think of them as free transfers that you must return after a year.

Would you prefer to keep driving the Honda Civic or borrow a Ferrari every year?

Si Cooper
21 Posted 11/04/2014 at 15:11:10
Patrick (#346), I think the agreement Chelsea had with Atletico allowed Courtois to play but came with a ridiculous additional price-tag (£5 million) that means it doesn't make commercial sense as they would still need to overcome another team in the final to get the real pay-off. It may be that level of manipulation / extortion that has given the authorities an easy target.
Nicholas Page
22 Posted 11/04/2014 at 15:45:36
TalkShite getting in on the act now

http://talksport.com/football/liverpools-title-hopes-dented-premier-league-table-without-loans-14041187051

Patrick Murphy
23 Posted 11/04/2014 at 16:14:23
Everybody else's title hopes dashed by favourable officials in most matches for one team. But I thought that the Barry situation was the root to all of this crying and whingeing as Barry can't play against City and there is little doubt that Barry has become a very important member of the Everton team.

A certain team obviously believe that Everton without Barry are incapable of beating City at Goodison and are causing a stink about the loan situation - may I remind them that it was one loanee who took out another loanee in the derby game in January. Not too bothered about loan signings that night were they.

League title race without Everton in the division would mean that the other lot would have four points less than they currently have. Chelsea three less, City three less but still to play at Goodison.

If our original custodians had just paid the increased rent all those years ago- the other lot wouldn't even exist.

If it hadn't been for two world wars and a travesty of justice in the 80s Everton may have won a couple of more titles and a European Cup.

If the one city one rule situation hadn't have been in place in the 60s we may have won more than the one European trophy.

But we didn't and we have in the main just taken it on the chin and got on with it - like we usually do.

Steve Woods
24 Posted 11/04/2014 at 17:02:01
I think the club should commission a statue of an eye-masked, smiling Roberto riding a stallion and entitle it:

Roberto The Loan Arranger

Jimmy Sørheim
25 Posted 12/04/2014 at 07:21:31
I finally have found out that Vellios probably will never make it. Blackpool have played him twice and he is no longer in the squad.

Vellios really has bad luck because this loan should have happened during the first half of the season.

Drew Shortis
26 Posted 13/04/2014 at 00:46:10
I find the criticism of Evertons loan ’policy’ illogical and hypocritical. Is it fair that Man City and Chelsea spend many millions on players with money given to them by foreign billionaires? No, but that’s how football works. It is not a level playing field!

It smacks of excuse making when someone like Wenger complains about Everton having three or four loans when we beat them. They could loan players the same as us, it just happens that the teams loaning the players to us at the start of the season might not have seen us as a threat. Perhaps next season teams like Man City and Chelsea will think twice before loaning quality players to us again! If Arsenal were smart they would have loaned us a couple of decent players who could play against their rivals ;)

With regards to not feeling loan players are real Everton players, which players really belong to a club nowadays. There aren’t that many one club men any-more and most players go from team to team as it suits them or their clubs, whether that be because they get a better offer or we decide they are surplus to requirements. There is precious little loyalty in the modern game. Players like Lineker and Kanchelskis were owned by Everton and had great seasons but were soon on the move. I’m more than happy to embrace players like Donovan, Deulofeu, Barry and Lukaku if they perform in a blue shirt, even if it is only for one campaign. As Paul Andrews 253 points out, Lukaku would be remembered fondly by Toffee’s if his goals propel us into the Champions League, and if this convinced him to stay with us then the loan system would have worked well for us. Barry looks like he will sign at the end of his Man City contract and there is a good possibility that Deulofeu will come for another loan period, especially if we are in Europe!

I think us fans have to accept that we are no longer living in a bygone, chivalrous age where players belonged to the club. Results and money are what matter most now and we have to be pragmatic and use all means at our disposal to continue to compete in the cut throat world we now compete in! I still think the loans are a stop gap measure in Martinez’s bigger plan and the success the loan players help to build will put us in a stronger position to attract and keep hold of top quality players down the line.

Dennis Ng
27 Posted 13/04/2014 at 02:10:36
Steve, the name could be better:

Bobby the Loan Master

Drew, the whole argument against loans is pathetic to begin with. They want to create a monopoly of power (players and money) and cut out clubs such as ourselves. With all the clowns in media being from Sky 4 clubs (in fact mostly rs and mu), it is of no surprise to me. I usually skip the articles that even hint of bashing our use of loans. They know they cannot walk their talk but we know RM can.

Drew Shortis
28 Posted 13/04/2014 at 09:52:07
Just read the ridiculous Daily Mail article. What a flawed and biased piece of garbage. As one commentator replied, they are happy to pimp out our players week in, week out, but as soon as we threaten their elite clique they try to discredit us. Pathetic.

I have yet to speak to a non-Everton footy fan who has expressed any such concerns of our use of the loan system!

Eugene Ruane
29 Posted 13/04/2014 at 10:24:01
Nicholas Page (344) - "Funny how I've never read an article on where Chelsea and City would be without the Petrodollars etc etc"

And you won't as that would be addressing the REAL problem with the PL and what is REALLY wrong and unfair.

I hope RM is pinning these pieces to the dressing room walls before games.

Fuck Samuels and fuck the ever-disgusting hateful Mail.

By the way Chelsea would be around the top of the Championship/bottom of the PL and City would be in Div 1.

Gary Mortimer
30 Posted 13/04/2014 at 10:53:59
Song for Wednesday

He loans who he wants
he loans who he wants
Roberto Martinez
he loans who he wants


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb