07/07/2023 170comments  |  Jump to last
Done deal

Updated Ellis Simms has completed the formalities on his move to Coventry City after the Sky Blues struck a deal with Everton reportedly worth between £6m and £8m. once all clauses are met.

According to The Athletic, the Sky Blues were the first club prepared to meet Everton's valuation of the striker after Ipswich Town were said to have failed in a move to land him for around half that.

Simms had been chased by a number of clubs in England's second tier, including Swansea City and Sunderland where he spent the first half of last season on loan, but Coventry won the race to sign the 22-year-old.

Simms was signed by Everton from Manchester City's youth academy and, following successful loan spells at Blackpool and Hearts, looked to be building a case for breaking into the Toffees' first-team set-up in the near future.

Article continues below video content


He was recalled from the Stadium of Light by Frank Lampard in early January to bolster Everton's striking options while Dominic Calvert-Lewin tried to work his way back to fitness and was tasked by Lampard's successor, Sean Dyche, with leading the line as the lone striker at Anfield and Old Trafford in Premier League games in February.

The Oldham-born forward struggled in difficult circumstances against world-class defenders in those games but appeared to have announced his arrival in the top flight with a superbly-taken goal at Stamford Bridge against Chelsea where his strike earned Everton a precious 2-2 draw.

However, Dyche showed little faith that Simms had the ability or experience to effectively lead the line as Calvert-Lewin's understudy and he did not feature much in the run-in.

He was effectively put up for sale to raise funds this summer and has now secured a fresh opportunity to build his career at Coventry where he will likely replace rumoured Toffees target Viktor Gyökeres. The Swede is believed to be close to signing for Sporting CP.

 

Reader Comments (170)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Mike Doyle
1 Posted 06/07/2023 at 20:59:00
Another one heading for the Exit door?

Alan Myers reporting Ellis Simms is heading for Coventry.

Jeff Armstrong
2 Posted 06/07/2023 at 21:08:52
Simms to Coventry for upto £8M, couldn’t we have gone for Gyökeres with Simms as part of the deal?

Obviously not that keen on the Coventry forward. Unless he basically turned us down for Sporting.

Keith Gleave
3 Posted 06/07/2023 at 21:31:44
I understand the need to generate money but we'll need to buy a full squad at this rate and we will never afford that.
Kieran Kinsella
4 Posted 06/07/2023 at 21:34:09
Car boot sale Sunday at Finch Farm. Last season's pink shirts, signed photos of Kenwright, Gomes & Gbamin — buy one, get one free. Some real steals to be had…

Gavin Johnson
5 Posted 06/07/2023 at 21:38:17
£8m is the fee reported by Fab. I would hope we also attach 20% sell-on fee like Coventry have on Gyökores.

Now go and get Gnonto and Rodrigo.

Mike Gaynes
6 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:06:46
I will cherish the memory of him blowing through Koulibaly for that precious equalizer at the Bridge. Shrugged him off like he wasn't there. Loved it.

Best of luck, kid.

Jonathan Oppenheimer
7 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:14:17
Kieran, that should help raise the funds for some new water bottles and training bibs.

Looks like we're ready to go with a 13-man squad in August. But at least we won't go bankrupt as we wait for P&S penalties to be imposed, and Kenwright can't claim he's made any ridiculous overpays on second-rate Spanish strikers. This strategy is all starting to make complete sense.

Gavin, maybe to Gnonto, no to Rodrigo. Mike, that was a helluva single memory of the lad.

Si Pulford
8 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:21:34
If it's £8 million then I think it's a good deal. He'll be 23 soon and Dyche obviously doesn't rate him and he sees him, day-in & day-out. That doesn't make him a bad player, he could be a very competent Championship striker but maybe not Premier League standard.

I've always said it's not important how much you sell for – it's how you spend the money that counts.

If we bring someone in for £8 million who's better, then it's a good deal.

Problem is, we're woeful when it comes to how we spend money.

Will Mabon
9 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:26:08
Mike @ 6, agreed.

But not good enough for Everton apparently; even for further development. That goal must have been an aberration. Just how would £8M change our world anyway?

Mick Davies
10 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:28:00
Are there any lifeboats left?
Will Mabon
11 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:30:22
Mick, women and children only.
Gavin Johnson
12 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:32:47
Jonathan, I have reservations on Rodrigo myself with his age, but he scored 13 last season and he's available for about £3.5m and will give us more goals than any of our current squad, except a fit Calvert-Lewin.

I read yesterday that we haven't got the £70M that we brought in from Gordon and Kean sales (not really a surprise) but you would think with the P&S hearing and a possible transfer embargo on the horizon, we would spend £70M this summer, and then sell Onana, Richie-style before next summers 30 June annual accounts deadline.

We don't want to be in a situation where we don't buy enough players now, and then aren't allowed to when we're in the Bottom 3 in January.

Paul Kernot
13 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:43:21
If we're also focused on savings via getting the wage bill down a la Mina, how much do we pay Kenwright every year?
Jonathan Oppenheimer
14 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:46:28
Gavin, fair enough about Rodrigo. I didn’t realize he could be had that cheap. Why would Leeds sell when they’ll need goals to stay up this year? In any case, everything you said makes sense, but it’s become very clear that no one has any clue what our exact financial situation is, other than that it’s generally terrible.
Barry Rathbone
15 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:54:25
None of the Prem elite and none of the Prem makeweights in for him tells it's own story.

I mean Coventry!!!!

Lester Yip
16 Posted 06/07/2023 at 22:55:48
#14 Apparently there is a relegation release clause in his contract. Read news that Dele trained on the first pre-season training day. Good job for turning up Dele!
Gavin Johnson
17 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:01:05
Jonathan, there's a relegation clause and he's in the final year of his contract. He's also on around £100k a year which aren't Championship wages so they need to get rid.

The wages are a sticking point too, but the way I see it, losing Mina's £120k wages would offset it. He's also a Spanish international and can play anywhere across the line. He could also play behind DCL if he's fit in the Doucoure role, so he would give goals and options.

James Flynn
18 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:03:51
They missed promotion on a 6-5 penalty shoot-out to Luton Town.

4th best GA. GF was OKish.

Maybe he helps them out with goal-scoring.

Good luck to him.

Paul Kossoff
19 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:07:49
Paul Kossoff
20 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:07:49
So let me get this straight. We go after Coventry s striker, we don't get him because they won't sell to us but he goes elsewhere. Then they ask us will they sell our only other first team striker because they have sold the one we wanted to another team and now they don't have a striker, and we say oh ok, no problem.
Now what I would have done is ask them to sell the striker we wanted in a swap deal involving Simms going to Coventry and the player we wanted coming to us.
Isn't that what other teams do?
Don Alexander
21 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:10:27
Paul (#13), surprise surprise, but the Everton boardroom was openly reported at the start of this year as being the highest paid boardroom in the country!

Is anyone surprised though? I mean, buying silence can be expensive!

Jonathan Oppenheimer
22 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:12:15
Thanks, Lester and Gavin. Of course lots of players have relegation clauses. That said I’d hope if we went in for him that we negotiated a much lower weekly wage. I’m guessing we’re looking at younger players, but of course we can’t be choosers much at this point.
Shane Corcoran
23 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:17:13
Paul, are you certain that the manager and DOF were interested in the Coventry striker?

Ian Jones
24 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:18:16
If Simms is indeed sent to Coventry for the reported £8 million it probably represents good business all round.

Paul, re Coventry not wanting to sell to us, I never saw that, only that Gykires possibly preferred to go to Portugal. Player's decision.

Whilst it's a shame that we are losing some of our younger players like Gibson, Samuels-Smith and Isaac Price, at least we are getting reasonable sums in for some of them.

I also think that it's good that these players will get a chance to play regularly. Those who are 22/23 need to be playing. Although as has been said before by some posters Samuels-Smith if he goes to Chelsea will probably be loaned out, more than likely back to us so he can sit on the bench

Jay Harris
25 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:19:42
Don
I think you’ll find it was the third highest paid boardroom in the country which is still nevertheless disgraceful.

I’m disappointed that Ellis Simms has gone before Maupay and before we signed another striker and that we allowed a very promising LB to go without a fight given we have no cover in that position.

I just hope Dyche creates the fittest team in the league because woebetide us if we get any injuries.

Reports of Iwobi and Demarai Gray wanting away are also very concerning as I doubt we will replace them with better quality.

Ian Jones
26 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:30:45
If Dyche can get into Dele Alli's head and get him motivated, then we potentially have a player in the squad who is more talented than most. One concerning point is that I think Alli has one more year left on his contract so if he stayed with us for a year, I assume he becomes a free agent and can go for nothing. However, the more he plays for us, the more we have to pay Spurs.

Who'd be football manager/Chairman/owner?


Paul Kossoff
27 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:41:39
Have we or havent we?
Almeria chief executive Mohamed El Assy said the Toffees had made a bid for the La Liga side's 21-year-old frontman El Bilal Toure.
The Mali international reportedly has a 40 million Euros (£34.3m) release clause, but BBC Sport understands El Assy's quotes about a formal offer from Everton are wide of the mark.
Come on Bill not like you to keep us in the dark.
David West
28 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:45:12
Im all for having young players but if we look at Tom Davies if he wasn't out of contract, do we think anyone would be paying 6-8m for Tom now ? We need to cash in on these players at the right moment.

With due respect to Ellis he hasn't pulled trees up or made himself a definite first team player with his performances.
Yes Ellis may prove himself to be a decent player but if we can sell 2-3 young players who are on the perhifery of the first team to generate 20-25m to invest in players that will have an impact THIS SEASON. I'm OK with it.

I'd rather keep Branthwaite, who imo, is the one young player who stands above the others at the moment.

Dupont Koo
29 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:54:43
Rarely do we send our gratitude to a Rival on the Bidding Table (especially when we lost the bid).

But without Sporting paying Coventry the reported €15 Million (that's a big fat £12.8 Million that we don't have!) for Gyökeres, there is no way Coventry would have the cash to come over with a bid for Simms. Up until this, there has also been nothing else we can ponder on in the market, other than an aggressive Ipswich trying to low-ball us on Simms with opening bids of £3 to 4 Million.

(Quick tangent: Ipswich is going for back-to-back promotion, which gave Coventry added-motivations to out-bid a promotion rival and prevent them from strengthening. No hard feelings Tractor Boys!)

£6 to 8 Million is exactly the range I hoped we can get for Simms when Ipswich made the initial overture back in early June. An expiring contract with Dyche's indifferent opinon on him, this price should bring some smiles to some depressed Evertonians. If there are Add-Ons in addition to the amount above, I'll buy a round of drinks for my colleagues after work.

After some tidy work on the Samuel-Smiths deal, Thelwell continues trying his best to pull rabbits out of his hat.

As a founding member, I am inviting membership request for the #ThelwellBrigade.

Ian Riley
30 Posted 06/07/2023 at 23:59:46
Good luck lad!

Surprised he is leaving a club going places...

Mark Taylor
31 Posted 07/07/2023 at 00:11:13
Yep, it's probably a decent deal because he won't play here, because Dyche doesn't fancy him, and Dyche calls the shots right now. Imagine if he walked away. Club meltdown?

That said, we are running out of players, even average ones, yet we still have to pay the Invisible Threesome £15m a year. Can we not con the Arabs into taking them? Closing down sale, everything must go.

I'm thinking of dusting off my boots. I'm crap but that doesn't seem to be a problem and unlike Maupay, I'm available on a free and am cheap as chips on salary, so that should be music to the board's ears... that is, if we actually have a board.

Sam Hoare
32 Posted 07/07/2023 at 00:37:55
£8m for Simms is good business for Everton. Especially as Dyche didn’t fancy him.

To get £52m for Simms, Gordon and ISS is a good testament to an academy that’s failed to make much money in player sales since Rooney.

Good luck to Simms. I could be wrong but he looks like he might be the next Dwight Gayle, a player destined to flit between good championship teams and poor Premier League ones. Nothing wrong with that. He’ll make a good living.

Gavin Johnson
33 Posted 07/07/2023 at 01:16:05
So, we've actually brought in £18.5m once this deal goes through, with £8m on Simms, £4m on the kid to Chelsea, £2.5m on Nkounkou, £1.5m on Broadhead, and £2.5m on the John Stones CL money.

I'll seriously lose it if we don't sign someone next week now.

Kieran Kinsella
34 Posted 07/07/2023 at 03:50:11
Gavin

You forgot $400,000 on Price although minus whatever we “settled” with Carlo out of court.

Alan J Thompson
35 Posted 07/07/2023 at 03:55:02
So then there were three - Calvert-Lewin, Cannon and Dobbin and Mr Dyche will play the one who runs around the most when DC-L isn't fit. Maupay it is then.

Is this the wholesale shake up that is needed and when does it get around to the big money earners. Gbamin has walked but no word from the club and Gomes back for pre-season while Doucoure and Iwobi are in their last year of contract. Speak now or forever hold your piece.

Jerome Shields
36 Posted 07/07/2023 at 04:52:11
Good Luck to Simms. I am sure he will do well. Dyche seems to prefer Maupay. Maybe a main striker and backup is all that is deemed to be required?

Toure from Almeria looked a replacement for Simms, but he has lost 106 days last season due to a muscle injury and I found one report that he is not playing at the moment.

It seems that younger players are being sold rather than loaned out. Seems there is a threadbare strategy at the moment. It will be interesting to see who comes in on loan or bought. It now looks that the deals for Dele Alli and Maupay were robbery.

Dupont Koo
37 Posted 07/07/2023 at 05:50:42
Gavin@33,

Even if all deals are to come in at the lower end of the reported ranges:

Simms = £6 Million
Samuels-Smith = £3 Million
Nkounkou = £2 Million (€2.2 Million)
Broadhead = £1 Million
Price = £400K (thanks to Kieran@34!)

We actually got only £2.125 Million (85% of the £2.5 Million) from the Stones payment due to a 15% add-on clause when we got him from Barnsley. So, Barnsley got a Secret Santa too.

That's £14.5 Million so far in this calendar year (even though the full amount might take some time to be fully in the bank) to help balancing the book. Not too shabby compared to our endless Free Transfers of Youngsters in the past!

Dan Nulty
38 Posted 07/07/2023 at 06:07:10
This calendar year we also got the Gordon money Dupont.

Paul Kossof, how do you know we went for Gyokeres? And if we did, how do you know it was Coventry that wouldn't sell him to us? They were clearly up for selling him, possibly due to the fact he appears to be going to Sporting Lisbon. It looks to me like the lad has chosen the chances of winning things and playing European football over the chance to be playing in the championship again in 12 months time, can you blame him?

Peter Gorman
39 Posted 07/07/2023 at 06:33:55
In an ideal world, Simms is worth the reported fee and he is probably at the right level with a club like Coventry. Always had a soft spot for him but just can't see him getting 20-plus goals in a Premier League side so, other than cheap backup, no point hanging on.

And yet, the bloody RS when faced with a similar situation managed to get £23 million for Rian Brewster.

What the hell kind of team do they have negotiating for them? I mean, fair play, but bloody hell.

Tony Everan
40 Posted 07/07/2023 at 06:48:17
DuPont , Dan . And the balance of the £25M Moise Kean money Juve were obligated to pay.

There will be strengthening this window, as failure to will inevitably cost more. So at the moment I am remaining calm. Thelwell will have his targets lined up and will likely need every penny of money available to him to land them.

It's probably a minority view but I think there will be squad investment with an overall net spend of about £40M. Time will tell.

This is a good move for Ellis Simms and Coventry, at £6-8M, it is a good investment and probably the best Everton can get.

It would be pointless staying at Everton and spending most of the time on the bench. He needs to play and make an impact. He's scored goals wherever he's gone and, if he gets an injury-free run of games, he could easily come good for Coventry and score 15 or 20 next season, getting them into the playoffs again.

Best of luck to him, many Evertonians will be following his progress with interest next season.

Paul Armstrong
41 Posted 07/07/2023 at 06:56:29
Sam #32,

Spot on.

Tony Everan
42 Posted 07/07/2023 at 07:00:51
* That's not including the Gordon and Kean money which I think has a one-way ticket to the bank.
Tony Abrahams
43 Posted 07/07/2023 at 07:54:14
If the club has got any sense, then they should officially introduce MSP, get rid of Kenwright, and then sign three new players all in the same week. This would instantly take the mood away from its current state of absolute negativity, and might even begin to make people start believing again.

I'm not holding my breath!

Ian Bennett
44 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:04:09
Simms will do a better job than Gyökeres in the Championship, for half the money. Simms is a better scorer and is more mobile.

I think Coventry will do well out of both deals. I just hope we insert a decent profit % on the deal, as despite not being good enough for Everton now, you can see him going for £20M in the future if he bangs in 20 goals. £8M will not look like great business then.

Jeff Armstrong
45 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:12:12
Ian 44,

I don't think we do sell-on clauses, Kenwright can't be arsed with the complications.

Christy Ring
46 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:20:14
Wish him all the best, I hope it works out for him. I believe the Championship will suit him better and that Tom Cannon is a better prospect for us.
Danny O’Neill
47 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:22:06
Tony @43.

That says it all.

Communicate. Be decisive and tell, not just us mortal supporters, but the footballing world what is going on.

Uncertainty and indecisiveness is never a good thing.

The lack of communication and decisiveness is making those who tagged him as "Dithering Davey" look like an inspirational leader who made decisions quickly.

Alex Gray
48 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:22:12
To be fair, Ian, Simms isn't 19 or 20. He's quickly approaching the mid-20s mark and taking sentiment out of it this is a better fee for a young player who wasn't going to make it with us.

Saying that, if we don't replace all these outgoings, they're all bad deals.

Lee Courtliff
49 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:32:55
Decent fee considering his limited time in the Premier League. Much better than losing him for free in 1 or 2 years after he's sat on the bench doing nothing.

As someone said earlier, just imagine if Dyche could get a tune out of Dele?! For the sake of another £10M, it might be worth playing him this season considering his wages. I think we can play him another 6 or 7 times before the fee is due, could be worth sticking him in and seeing how he goes.

Yes, I'm clutching at straws, but he was a very good player at one time and stranger things have happened in football before.

Kevin Prytherch
50 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:33:42
Simms's career has followed the same trajectory so far. Every time he has stepped up a level, he has initially struggled but then eventually found his feet and performed. It is for that reason that I would have liked him to stay for next season.

However, £6-£8M for an academy player is the type of business we should have been doing for years.

Paul O'Neill
51 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:34:49
Kieran @4.

I liked your comment and it made me laugh. Lay off the pink away shirts though. I thought they were great and I got one.

Everton have a long history of using that colour in away jerseys and some of the very few good away performances last season featured it – including the mauling of Brighton!

Steve Brown
52 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:35:50
Bringing in circa £55 million in this calendar year (including Gordon), is the Academy system finally working?

Our mismanagement previously was putting young players on professional contracts, then ultimately releasing them without a fee when those contracts ended.

Alex Gray
53 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:43:51
Agreed Steve. Nailed it. This sort of business is actually encouraging. The timing of it being when we are clamouring for numbers in the squad is the hard bit to swallow.

Reality is the academy is either where players make it in rare cases for most clubs or it's a way of earning money from Championship clubs. For years, we just let our youngsters rot there (Luke Garbutt, anyone?) and then leave for basically nothing.

Being academy graduates, the fees we receive for Gordon and Simms alone are pure profit and help our books out a lot.

Christopher Timmins
54 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:46:39
You have to wish the boy well.

Added to the Gordon fee, that will help the profit figure for the year!

Steve Shave
55 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:47:27
I can't believe some are still pinning hope on Dele! No offence, Lee, you aren't the only one to say it on here. Dele checked out years ago.

Even if (and it is a colossal 'if') Dele stepped up and showed the desire and performed, it would still not be worth stumping up £10M to Spurs as he is out of contract at the end of the season.

I for one am (like others) praying we can get some chump change for Gomes and Gbamin, surely someone would pay £5M each given their improved performances last season and improved injury problems? Dele will have to be loaned out.

We'd better have some irons in the frickin' fire or there will be uproar after keeping Bill on. I want to completely lose my shit over Gyökeres slipping through our fingers whilst Simms goes there; however, I am going to maintain for now a small fool's hope that Thelwell is given free reign to do his job and has targets lined up.

Of the players out so far, none were regular first team players, I am much more concerned about who plays in midfield during the African Nations Cup!

Brian Harrison
56 Posted 07/07/2023 at 08:55:38
Tony 43, Danny 47,

While you are right about transparency, Moshiri has never wanted transparency – he has always wanted to operate at arm's length – and that's why he thought texting Jim White was the way to communicate with fans. I don't think he is alone – most owners of football clubs very rarely come out and address supporters.

The changes we have made at board level are purely cosmetic as the two people who need to be gone are still there, and getting shut of Moshiri will prove to be the most difficult. Makes you wonder why there is such a delay in MSP investing reportedly £130 million for 25% ownership, still leaves Moshiri owning 70% of the shares.

If Moshiri couldn't come out and address the fans after two successive relegation battles, I don't expect him to come out now and outline what going forward looks like. Let's not forget, this is the man who told us in January "If we need a striker, I will get one."

Since his boss has had to leave the scene, Moshiri has less interest and is only staying till the stadium is built and hopes a rich Arab state will offer him and Usmanov a way to reduce their debt.

Joe McMahon
57 Posted 07/07/2023 at 09:08:38
3 keepers and a pet dog to make up the numbers on the bench for the new season then.

I can't help thinking relegation is the least of our worries. Grand Old Team eh!

Lee Courtliff
58 Posted 07/07/2023 at 09:17:39
Steve Shave, I know, mate. I'm just sat here thinking about the new season and trying to be optimistic.

£10M might sound a lot for a player out of contract but it's small change compared to the cost of relegation! If Dele can weigh in with 10 goals then it's worth it.

Buy, like you said, he's checked out and couldn't even cut it in Turkey. It's just a pipe dream I'm having as someone challenged me on another thread yesterday to come up with some positive news and I realised just how little of that there actually is!

Besides finally bringing in some money for academy players. That's about it.

David West
59 Posted 07/07/2023 at 09:31:34
Im all for having young players but if we look at Tom Davies if he wasn't out of contract, do we think anyone would be paying 6-8m for Tom now ? We need to cash in on these players at the right moment.

Yes Ellis may prove himself to be a decent player but if we can sell 2-3 young players who are on the perhifery of the first team to generate 20-25 m to invest in players that will play THIS YEAR then I can live with that.

The big "if" is if Dyche gets to spend it on players.

Johan Elmgren
60 Posted 07/07/2023 at 10:07:36
Has been scoring goals for fun at every level and has proved he can do it at Championship-level. Only 22 and hasn't been given a real chance in the Prem. Why let go of a natural goalscorer before giving him a real chance to shine?

I'd be really disappointed if we sell Ellis...

Si Pulford
61 Posted 07/07/2023 at 10:31:44
Paul I doubt this had anything to do with Coventry not wanting to sell to us. More likely the player going to a champions league club. That’s if we even made a bid?!!

Also the ‘have we or haven’t we’ where you have a go at Kenwright for ‘keeping us in the dark?!!’ I mean, I hate Kenwright but I would never expect a chairman to comment on some other head the ball chairman trying to drive his players price up?

I’m all for slating the man and every bad decision he’s made but when we’re slagging the club off for not commenting on transfer bible or whatever we’re in a worse state than I thought!!!

Peter Hodgson
62 Posted 07/07/2023 at 10:43:46
Basically I'm pleased for Simms and Everton if the Coventry deal goes through as I've watched him since he went to Blackpool and did well there. After getting injured there, spells at Hearts and Sunderland were not as productive and I remained convinced that he hadn't done enough to warrant a place in a Prem League team. Not enough movement, too slow, not enough work etc, etc.

That is probably why only Ipswich and Coventry have enquired. He wasn't going to make it with us. I do wish him well though and he probably has found his level and will do okay wherever he goes at that level.

As far as Everton are concerned, if the £8m fee is finally agreed, it is an acceptable amount particularly if a sell-on fee can be included. Canon to step up then?

Jonathan Tasker
63 Posted 07/07/2023 at 10:51:08
Yet another short term desperation move by the worst run club in the country
Clive Rogers
64 Posted 07/07/2023 at 11:51:32
Joe, 57, the way we’re going it may be 3 goalkeepers and a pet dog on the pitch!!!!
Tom Bowers
65 Posted 07/07/2023 at 11:57:14
Obviously not rated as good enough and yet Maupay was ???

Whatever, we are still bereft of any decent strikers and one dreads what is to come yet again.

Steve Brown
66 Posted 07/07/2023 at 11:57:47
We have Tom Cannon and Lewis Dobbin back from loan, plus Dyche wants 1-2 more strikers.

Selling Simms makes sense.

Sam Hoare
67 Posted 07/07/2023 at 12:02:15
Many determined to see this as evidence of a poorly run club, whereas I (and others) see this as evidence of the club finally being better run!

Getting £8m for an academy player who the manager doesn't fancy is good news! Much better than endless academy talent leaving for peanuts.

We seem to be getting linked with some talented younger players (Bilal Toure, Gnonto, Summerville etc) and there will also be some good players available on loan (Danjuma etc).

Last summer (bar Maupay) was one of our most sensible transfer windows in a while and I'm quietly optimistic that we might make some decent moves this summer too.

Dyche has proven he can perform wonders on a shoestring and that may be what is needed till the stadium is finished. It will be ok. I think!

Ray Jacques
68 Posted 07/07/2023 at 12:31:33
Sam, I know where you are coming from as we are removing lots of dead wood.

However, we aren’t replacing them. Everton being linked with players means nothing.

I am very worried about the lack of activity and the usual silence from the owner and board.

Why for once do we not just act, get the players in, and have a proper pre-season where Dyche can get them fit and working within a system and getting our identity back?

Paul Tran
69 Posted 07/07/2023 at 12:47:47
This is good business. About time we got some money for a young player who, to me, doesn't look good enough. His biggest asset was not being Maupay. Good luck to Ellis, hope he does well.

The silence is fine by me. I am never assured by anything The Oligarch's Mate or Young Mr Grace say.

We'll bring in players, many of whom will see us as a good start in the Premier League, or a stepping stone to bigger things if they're good enough.

John Kavanagh
70 Posted 07/07/2023 at 12:48:53
I wish Simms well. His goal was instrumental in keeping us in the top flight and I don't think he was exactly given a fair opportunity, especially when compared to the useless French garden gnome Dyche preferred. Ellis has a good eye for goal and should do well.

If Chairman Bill has been involved in the negotiations then we will get the full £8 million conditional on Ellis winning the Champions League and being the first man to set foot on Mars.

Richard Duff
71 Posted 07/07/2023 at 13:01:31
This is good business as far as I can see. £6M - £8M for an academy product = full positive impact on the club's accounts.

Simms will be good (not great) in the Championship and may end up in the Premier League eventually but, for now, is not quite at the level we need. So, letting him go makes sense, getting some money makes sense, and at the very least, it ensures that next season's strike force will have to be different.

I expect Maupay to go also, even if it’s on loan and we cover some wages – he will want to get out while he still has some reputation intact (outside of our fanbase).

Finally, our form under Dyche over the last 10 games was delivering 1 point a game, that then rose to 1.6 over the last 5 games. even if we take a middle ground of 1.3 over 38 games, it brings us 49 points.

I'm not saying that's what we will get but with a few additions, Doucoure and the midfield looking more dangerous, McNeil chipping in and Calvert-Lewin for more than 3 games, I'm confident that Dyche will keep us out of the Bottom 3 pretty easily. So, sell, sell, sell, we'll be fine.

Tony Abrahams
72 Posted 07/07/2023 at 13:03:09
I thought that was a sensible post, Brian H, except I never mentioned the word ‘transparency’ because this is something that Everton haven't had for a very, very, very long time now, mate.

I agree with Sam H, and Paul T, to a certain degree because we are getting a lot more for Ellis Simms than we got for Jonjoe Kenny and Tom Davies, but I was just commenting on the negativity around the club, which hasn't been this bad since Mr T (transparency) sold Rooney, for half the price he said he would. But at least it kept him in charge.

Raymond Fox
73 Posted 07/07/2023 at 13:09:14
Dyche doesnt seem to fancy Simms much so getting £6 to £8M seems the right thing to do.

I lot depends on Calvert-Lewin’s fitness this season; if and it’s a big ‘if’, he can stay fit, it will make a massive difference.

I know Maupay is the current whipping boy but I think the absence of Calvert-Lewin was a large factor in his lack of form.

Moshiri will not want us relegated any more than we do so there will be some money available for replacements, I'm sure.

Looking through our squad, we have the basis of a mid-table side if we can strengthen up front and left-back.

I have every confidence in Dyche to get the best out of what he's got to choose from, it won’t be fancy stuff but we will be hard to beat.

Just looking at the betting we are 1/4 to stay up and there’s 5 other teams more likely to be relegated before us.

Frank Crewe
74 Posted 07/07/2023 at 13:12:03
Simms is 22. He has either been on loan or bench warming for almost all of his time at Everton. Benitez, Lampard and now Dyche doesn't really see him as the answer to our striker problem.

We can't keep hanging onto players in the hope that they will suddenly come good. Maybe if we had a stronger squad we could afford to wait a bit longer. But we need players who are ready to go right now and not at some unspecified time in the future.

We have had our fingers burned too many times waiting for some young player to get up to scratch already. Personally I doubt Dobbin or Cannon will make the grade either.

Even if Simms did turn out to be the next Rooney, we couldn't keep him anyway. We saw that last season with Gordon and Richarlison sales. We are simply not in any position to refuse decent offers for any of our players, especially fringe ones.

Michael Lynch
75 Posted 07/07/2023 at 13:26:17
Dele is a waste of a locker. In my ideal world, we'll palm him off on a Saudi club if they take his contract off our hands.

I think we've done decent business so far – especially if we get £8M for Simms – but let's see who we manage to buy. We need to bring in new players quickly because Dyche will want a full pre-season with them in order to break them into little bits and reassemble them.

Rodrigo is 32, so £3.5M and high wages is a risk for me if he asks for a 3-year contract or something stupid like that.

Sam Hoare
76 Posted 07/07/2023 at 13:50:57
Ray @68,

Yes its very frustrating. I can only assume that getting the players in so late every summer is to do with the financial restrictions at the club and need to shift other players first.

However, I'd rather get good players in late in the window than average players in at the start. If we have another window like last summer i'll be fairly pleased. Onana, McNeil, Garner, Gueye and Tarkwoski were all good moves (though Maupay was obviously poor and the loan move for Vinagre was wasted).

I'm hoping by the end of the window for at least 3 or 4 new transfers in and a loan or two.

Pete Gunby
77 Posted 07/07/2023 at 14:21:02
For the first time in my life, I can wait for the season to start.
Dale Self
78 Posted 07/07/2023 at 14:30:56
Good stuff Dupont. Put me on the other list with Sam.
James Flynn
79 Posted 07/07/2023 at 14:45:40
"Obviously not rated as good enough and yet Maupay was???"

If for argument's sake, we leave their output as a "push", one was on pennies for one more season. The other 2 more years at £70k per week.

Money made the former real easy to move, the latter might be tough to move this season.

Michael Pennington
81 Posted 07/07/2023 at 16:41:17
Thanks to The Brick lads who made that banner for Sharpy.

Much appreciated from Toffees who know what he did for our club.

Paul Kossoff
82 Posted 07/07/2023 at 17:03:39
Shane and Ian.

Everton reportedly offered Simms and Broadhead to Coventry in exchange for Gyökeres in January.

David West
83 Posted 07/07/2023 at 17:03:54
I think players coming in will depend on players moving around from teams operating above us in terms of finance.
Teams don't want to let players go until they have their replacement in place. Sides won't sanction moves until they know the make up of their squad.

Unless you are operating at the very top tier, with top budgets, it's hard to get your targets signed. There's a premium to pay to get things done early and Everton can't afford that premium.

Sides play hard ball, inflating prices until the last couple of weeks of the window when they have no option but to compromise or be stuck with bloated sqauds, bigger wage bills or unhappy players.

Be patient, I'd say. It's not what we want but it's our reality.

One thing I'm interested to see is the profile of player Dyche and Thelwell go for. As Sam Hoare states, last year's window was positive (Maupay aside). Another positive window with maybe another Onana out the bag would mean decent progress.

Denis Richardson
84 Posted 07/07/2023 at 17:11:44
In isolation, £6M-£8M is a decent fee for him as I don't think he'll become a regular in the Premier League. However, given all the action at the moment is one way with no players coming in, it's getting a bit worrying how thin the squad is.

If Simms leaves, I think that would make it 7 senior players out and none in...

We also currently have 9 senior midfielders listed but 3 won't play. Only one real striker and only one left-back in the squad. Whilst we can put out a decentish first XI, assuming everyone is fit, we have nothing in reserve.

5 weeks to kick-off — strange times.

David West
85 Posted 07/07/2023 at 17:31:04
Dennis 85 out of the 7 "senior" players who have left.
How many would you really say I'm disappointed we have sols them or they will be hard to replace ? ?
I can't think of 1.
I think Branthwaite will make more than a capable replacement for coady. Mina barely played so he's not going to be missed at cb.
He will be missed in A&E with his dry pasta legs.

Simms for Cannon is an upgrade I'd say. It's not like the sale of Richarlison so let's not get carried away.

We have been calling for the deadwood to be shed. When we start to shed the deadwood people fear the sqauds to thin.

James Flynn
86 Posted 07/07/2023 at 17:54:44
Gyokere is a 25-year old career minor-leaguer. He looks quick enough down there.

Sporting management is openly talking about him to the Press. I take that as an indication Coventry have given them permission.

Reading his own quotes, Gyokere's sounds like he's leaving to go somewhere.

I know and agree we need to sign some firepower, due to our lack of it.

Myself, I'm leery when a 25-year old career minor-leaguer is seen as the solution.

Clive Rogers
87 Posted 07/07/2023 at 18:33:43
David, 83,if last year’s window was positive, how come we finished a place lower than the previous season at 4th from bottom. Escaped relegation by the skin of our teeth.
Brendan McLaughlin
88 Posted 07/07/2023 at 19:41:01
Clive #87

Frank Lampard?

Tony Everan
89 Posted 07/07/2023 at 19:49:15
Brendan, Clive. Yep, Super Frank and one off the scale, mental aberration of a negative, signing Neal Maupay to deputise for Calvert-Lewin.
Dan Nulty
90 Posted 07/07/2023 at 20:35:34
Paul 82, reported by who? Even if true, it doesn't mean they didn't want to do business full stop, they didn't want that deal at that time.

Either way, no way a player in the championship turns down Sporting Lisbon for us.

Robert Tressell
91 Posted 07/07/2023 at 21:17:50
Probably a good deal all round this. I really do wish Simms all the best as he's worked hard to get himself into this position after being released by Man City. But £6 to £8m is a good deal. The Brewster to Sheffield Utd deal was overcooked because of his goals on loan (over a full season) and his England youth international credentials. Simms isn't in that league - but could yet exceed Brewster's career if he works hard.

Gyokeres isn't a great player by any stretch - but we're unlikely to sign a great player for striker competition for DCL. More like a player who will get 8 to 10 goals in Premier League. That sounds crap, but players like Isak and Nunez were in that category this season. Gyokeres would also be a decent (if unspectacular) all-round focal point for the attack. That said, I expect many fans would consider him crap for not banging them in left right and centre.

Denis Richardson
92 Posted 07/07/2023 at 21:19:27
David 85, not disagreeing that we've yet to sell the real family silver (I would say a fit Mina was our best defender though), however, we've not signed anyone and if we have injuries to first teamers, we don't have anyone to replace them.

Given our injury record, it won't be long before the treatment room is full again. Patterson and DCL are currently injured and it's not clear if either will be available for the KO. A striker has been top of the wish list for a long time, why have we still not gotten one in?

I'm not particularly sad to have let any of the players go that have gone, Mina aside if we could have signed him on much lower wages, but literally no one has been signed and we've saved a ton on the wage bill on those that have gone. Even if we don't have much money I would have hoped we'd at least have signed one or two on loan by now, perhaps with options to buy. The likes of Chelsea have tons of promising players who will likely never get a look-in with them. The near guarantee of first team football would have been a decent offer to put on the table, no? Even if the player doesn't fancy a permanent move now he would at least get playing time - like Lukaku.

Here's hoping something happens as the weeks tick down. Given last summers last minute waste of £15m on Maupay, I'm not feeling confident.

Matthew Johnson
93 Posted 07/07/2023 at 21:53:56
Coventry have paid £3.5m for Simms

rising to £5m based on appearances and goals, and £8m if Coventry gain promotion to the Premiership

Ben King
94 Posted 07/07/2023 at 21:56:54
Matthew #93

Source please?

Alec Gaston
95 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:02:12
Meanwhile we are monitoring, tracking, considering, pursuing, contemplating, weighing up, evaluating (insert other) various transfer targets 😮‍💨
Nick Page
96 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:05:09
Has a better chance of playing PL football next year than Everton
Geoff Lambert
97 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:12:49
Ben #94 https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/everton-transfer-news-live-simms-27273491
Barry Hesketh
98 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:13:50
In a report from Echo sister site Coventry Live, they suggest Ellis Simms' deal will rise to £5m after initially agreeing a £3.5m deal.

They claim: "Coventry City have completed the signing of Everton striker Ellis Simms who joins the club as a replacement for star front man Viktor Gyokeres...

"Simms signed a four year contract at the CBS Arena after completing his medical at Ryton, joining for an undisclosed fee, which CoventryLive understands to be £3.5million rising to £5m depending on appearances and goals in a deal that could be worth up to £8m if City gain promotion to the Premier League." Source: Echo

Previous record signings for Coventry City, include:

1 Wales Craig Bellamy Norwich City 17 August 2000 £6,500,000

2 Republic of Ireland Robbie Keane Wolverhampton Wanderers 18 August 1999 £6,000,000

Obviously, a fee of £6m 23 years ago, is a lot more in today's money than the possible £8m that Everton may receive.

James Flynn
99 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:14:49
Ben (94)

"Simms signed a four year contract at the CBS Arena after completing his medical at Ryton, joining for an undisclosed fee, which CoventryLive understands to be £3.5million rising to £5m depending on appearances and goals in a deal that could be worth up to £8m if City gain promotion to the Premier League."

Pretty specific to be just a SWAG. They must have an "in" with that club.

Link

Joe McMahon
100 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:15:22
What has Kenwright done to Everton with his arrogance and selfishness. His choice of billionaire and all the other terrible decisions.

I will not watch Everton again (in any division) while he's still connected to the club. There aren't enough words to describe this despicable parasite.

Brian Williams
101 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:15:41
They "suggest". Sounds like the Coventry rag is as bad as the Red Echo.

Undisclosed fee, so all guesses. Or true if you're naive enough.

Barry Hesketh
102 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:19:17
Joe @100,

For God's sake, it's Ellis Simms we've sold, not a 22-year-old Lionel Messi or Ronaldo.

Honestly, there is some need for context, otherwise, all Blues will be visiting the funny farm for long spells in the next few months, possibly not quite as bad as a long stretch at Finch Farm?

Ian Bennett
103 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:22:58
I maintain this is a great deal for Coventry. Upgrade on Gyökeres in time and £12M+ on the hip.

A good deal for them. He will be a good Championship striker in my opinion; that could still be of interest for a lower-level team like us in the Premier League.

Brent Stephens
104 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:35:59
Joe #100

"I will not watch Everton again (in any league) while [Kenwright is] still connected to the club."

Your love for Everton isn't that strong that it counters your feelings about Kenwright? Are you a season ticket holder? Do you attend home games? Did you attend games last season? Is your season ticket for next season available?

Kieran Kinsella
105 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:38:22
We are probably still paying his wages and it’s 5 quid up front
James Flynn
106 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:39:56
I see Tyler Onyango back from his hammy injury, training with the team.
David West
107 Posted 07/07/2023 at 22:58:16
Clive @87.

I do believe the players bought had a positive effect on the team. McNeil, Garner and Onana are young players with their best years ahead of them. Garner was unlucky with injury or I say he would have played a bigger part.

The loan of Coady worked out okay, Tarkowski was our best defender! Mina was good when he played but Tarkowski played week-in & week-out, probably playing through the injuries Mina was getting stretchered off with! You can't be our best defender sitting in the stands with a sore fingernail, mate!

We are not Man City, Chelsea or Newcastle Utd with unlimited funds to splash around. The money we spend needs to be targeted in the right way at the right players. It's not about when we sign people — it's about who are them people!

It's not hard to see the players who are not contributing a massive amount will not be missed. Yes, we need players in. But the likes of Davies, Coady, Simms, Mina, Vinagre are hardly irreplaceable. Players who can make an impact on the first team is what we need.

If we can trade 7 or 8 players who don't really contribute much over a season for 3 who make a genuine positive impact on the first team, then bring it on.

The smell of dead wood is being lifted from Finch Farm. Embrace it!

Ben King
108 Posted 07/07/2023 at 23:06:54
Geoff #97, Barry #98,

Thanks

If it's really only £3.5M, then we need to employ a specific negotiator for outgoing transfers.

The kid could easily get 15+ goals in the Championship next season and the season after. That's definitely worth £12M - 15M given how transfers have been going.

It does make one wonder whether Everton are competent at anything??

Gary Brown
109 Posted 07/07/2023 at 23:12:35
Clearly Dyche saw something in Simms he just didn't like. Attitude, lack of effort, who knows… but, if he didn't get a look in last season, he ain't getting one this season. So, all-in-all, a sensible call.

I am starting to believe though that our “lucky escape” might not turn out to be one. We've still got Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dee in charge, and I fear lack of signings is an impasse from a complex investment situation. Moshiri isn't putting anything more in, so who will be??

I think this season will all be about survival once again. West Ham won't be paying £60M for Onana and nobody is coming in for Pickford either. I think our best hope is a couple of signings on loan or the never-never.

We're at the stage now where our Iranian fool owner has bet it all on black – stadium built and clear 3 years on P&S and an investor comes in and bails him out. The issue is, who's daft enough to come in and compete with Saudi money (direct like Newcastle and indirect like Chelsea)? If Man Utd go to the Sheikh, it'd be a fool who comes in and buys now just to finish 6th to 10th maybe.

If the bet fails, the most palatable and likely option then is the Rangers model. Keep the name, start again… I suspect though that a fool stubborn enough to keep Bill in place this summer is a fool that'll spend 10 years thinking they can reverse it all.

Brendan McLaughlin
110 Posted 07/07/2023 at 23:36:11
Gary #109

I think this year will all be about survival once again.

Kin'l... splitting the atom comes close but... respect!

Gary Brown
111 Posted 08/07/2023 at 01:36:11
It shouldn't be, Brendan. The league is tight enough that 3-4 astute signings could get you top 6-8.

I just fear we've tied ourselves in knots at the top. We wished for a coup, but we got croup.

Jack Convery
112 Posted 08/07/2023 at 05:24:09
Good Luck, Ellis.

Ta for the goal at Chelsea. It helped keep us up.

Terry Farrell
113 Posted 08/07/2023 at 06:08:27
Really wanted Gyökeres from the list of names we were linked with and with Ellis lined up as his replacement you'd have thought it was more than possible unless he was hell-bent on Portugal.

Good look to Simms, we've messed him around these last 2 seasons and he's kept a dignified silence and worked hard when he finally got on the pitch.

I hope to see Godfrey, Branthwaite and Tarkowski as a back 3 and think James Garner and Onana will be more prolific and consistent. Onana is going to the top so keep him another year and sell for way more than what we will be offered now.

The crucial signing of a centre-forward is still yet to come!

Danny O’Neill
114 Posted 08/07/2023 at 06:15:50
There are a few with that sentiment, Joe, some who I speak to and I respect their views.

I tend to separate the team from the soap opera upstairs. But the frustration gets to us all.

I will comment and be as critical as anyone in my own style about the absence of leadership and mismanagement of the club.

However, come matchday, it's all about the team and I'll watch and support those 11 players on the pitch, just as I did last season. It's all I've ever done and, apart from a few glorious years, I've lived with near misses and false hope. It's all I know.

Terry Farrell
115 Posted 08/07/2023 at 06:27:26
Danny, love your attitude, mate and stance on most things discussed.

Forgot to mention also looking forward to seeing Cannon rejoin the squad as I think he will make an impact and knows where the net is!

Joe McMahon
116 Posted 08/07/2023 at 07:00:06
Barry, it's not so much about Ellis Simms, it's a culmination of how things have been under Kenwright for many decades.

Brent, I can't commit to a season ticket, so I attend when I can (I also have MS so need to manage that).

Danny, I 100% respect all regular match goers, and you imparticular due to the traveling that you commit to support Everton.

To everyone, I admit I was being melodramatic last night, I'd had a couple of Friday sherberts and I've just had it with Kenwright and his smugness. I've just a feeling (like many of us) that he ain't going anywhere. In reality, I couldn't stay away too long,

Peter Mills
117 Posted 08/07/2023 at 07:49:50
Joe #116, I think we can all identify with your frustration.

“I will not watch Everton again…”. I remember uttering the same words when we let Howard Kendall go to Birmingham City as part of the Bob Latchford deal!

It's a good job only my Dad heard those words (“Don't be so bloody daft, Son”) and TW wasn't around at the time.

Ian Riley
118 Posted 08/07/2023 at 07:55:35
Simms could get 15-20 goals in the Championship. The management at Coventry will bring the best out of him. Difficult to develop at a club changing managers, relegation scraps and fans unrest off the pitch. Coventry are stable looking for promotion.

For us, it's simply staying up. That's success for us. Sadly that's it. The squad lacks goals and attracting real talent will be difficult. Our history over the past 25 years has been successful in staying in the top league.

Everton is about survival and with our squad why anymore? Simply we have been very fortunate selling talent for big money and not replacing them. It's not the manager who will be at fault, just the lack of quality to go forward.

Hopefully a few players can be signed soon but I fear transfer deadline day will be the day. Remember, staying above the Bottom 3 is success next season.

Ernie Baywood
119 Posted 08/07/2023 at 07:58:43
The problem isn't so much that we've sold Ellis Simms. He's not that good.

The problem is that he was the best fit striker at the club.

Any argument for selling him that involves investing the money raised in the squad doesn't account for what's happened in the past. We know what happens next.

Last man out can turn the lights off.

Kim Vivian
120 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:11:28
Well, I hope someone has a plan because we now have one less striker to choose from even if he was only a 3/10.

Dennis (92) DCL and Patterson didn't look particularly injured to me in the back-to-training vids. Unless they've already been injured in the re-conditioning process.

Danny O’Neill
121 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:11:43
We all have had it Joe and the frustration gets to us all. That's why we debate and discuss about the thing that means so much to us.

There is no return for him. He is never going back to Goodison and will not grace BMD.

As I said on the Esk's own site and latest article, they've got rid of managers, they've sacked the board. Do they think that appeases the masses? That seems to have been their "strategic" approach.

No. It doesn't. Until he is gone, the pitchforks will remain out and the sentiment amongst the increasingly majority of supporters will not go away.

But, they don't have much room to manoeuvre now. The phrase I used is that the rats are cornered. Approaching the end of the runway, to coin a phrase used to describe our recent relegation fights.

Come August Joe, we'll be there for the team. Be that in person, watching from home or those overseas at ridiculous hours.

It comes with uncertainty, but we are getting there with a fresh start, we just need that last leech removed. Definitions of leech:

"Bloodsucking parasites"

"A person who extorts profit from or sponges on others. They are leeches feeding off the hard-working majority"

Terry @115, I saw Cannon briefly so would like to see a bit more of him. I think he came on against Norwich (don't quote me) and looked lively. I said last season, and I hope for this one coming, we see Lewis Warrington and Stanley Mills involved with the first team squad. I've watched more of those two.

Stick together Evertonians. It's the one thing that has kept us going during these past few seasons.

Tony Abrahams
122 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:40:25
I also admire Danny’s optimism, and unless things change very quickly then I think his level of fanaticism is going to be really needed, such is the lack of faith in this present regime.

Maybe I’m naive and just don’t understand why it had to be the other three leaving, whilst Chairmen Bill stayed on, but I believe it’s the people who believe he his staying on for the good of the club, who are the most naive?

I hope I’m wrong because I also want to go to Goodison, but I’ve stated that I also won’t be going into the ground if Kenwright stays, and I would love to see an empty Goodison, if the bastard remains, because if everyone stayed away, I’m certain this would be too much even, for the man who has no shame.

I wouldn’t expect this to happen but what a message it would send to certain parts of William’s sycophantic media. The liar who has only stayed away for his own safety, actually forced one of the most passionate fanbase’s in British football out the ground🤷‍♂️

Lee Courtliff
123 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:40:43
Good luck, Ellis.
Gary Wiffen
124 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:43:29
Why do we seem to always drag our heels ? Personally I would love to see us take a gamble on some championships players like Gnoto. The Young Swansea Striker ?Yes I know stepping up to the premiership is a big step but The likes of the Leeds lads ie Gnoto, Harrison have had premiership experience. I wanted us to go for Bowen when he was at Hull and he hasn’t turned out to bad ! Plus I’m sure we can get them for a reduced price. Unfortunately Our Shithouse of a board will go for some washed up has been ! But I’m hoping Dyche Will put his foot down and hopefully want to blood in some youngsters. We live in Hope have a great weekend Fellow Toffees and Toffettes
Andrew McLawrence
125 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:45:23
Imagine the irony (if that's the right word) when we can wave to Ellis on his way up with Coventry whilst we go down. Still that will never happen. I think.
Jason Li
126 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:54:17
I think the history of Simms development means he will be one of the top forwards in the Championship soon. Whether he becomes a 10-a-season Premier League player is obviously unknown. But has a decent chance after seeing that Chelsea goal.

On a positive note, without any data science skills, if you search League One youngest Players, you get a list of players who have played professional football. These players at their age are way ahead most clubs academy players in terms of professional football level ability. Most players in our academy will be hoping to play in League One at 19/20 years old. So if we rated these players then you can say they are at a lower academy level because they player in a lower league. However if you rated these players at this age for their professional football level, they are higher than most of our academy players. There must be plenty of gems here to buy and send out on loan again as they are all professional football ready.

It does have a mish-mash of data, but you can see League One has a history of lots of 16/17/18 year olds who have played professional football and by this fact alone are many of the best young players in the English league. Some of these won't be with a top 8 Premier League club.

https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/league-one/juengsteaelteste/pokalwettbewerb/GB3

Brent Stephens
127 Posted 08/07/2023 at 08:59:58
Joe #116, I think we all fell the same way about you know who. And a few sherbets can enhance the feeling! I hope you get to as many games as you can, Joe, and at least see us get a few points.
John Williams
128 Posted 08/07/2023 at 09:00:52
I can understand the concerns that Everton do not appear to be bringing players in, or even attracting any players.
When you look at the PL, it only appears to be the top six sides wheeling and dealing, with Arsenal making a big push to win the league.
Nothing seems to be happening with the sides that finished in the bottom 10.
Are they all waiting for the cast offs from the top six ?
Michael Lynch
129 Posted 08/07/2023 at 09:27:19
£3.5m sounds a bargain for Coventry, who will be flush when they sell Gyokeres, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they bought another striker with the rest of their money.

Simms was popular at Sunderland but he rarely played a full game or had a long run in the side. I seem to remember there was some doubts about his ability to focus for any length of time. That might come with maturity though of course.

Good luck to him anyway.

Ray Robinson
130 Posted 08/07/2023 at 09:52:13
Not sure I ever rated Simms. One goal and a pass at the Gwladys Street end apart, I can’t remember any significant contribution from him. Good luck to the lad though!

Worrying though that there are no new signings yet. As others have said, the bottom 12 are probably all chasing the same players while the top teams gorge themselves on the best takings as they go about their asset stripping and stockpiling.

Ian Bennett
131 Posted 08/07/2023 at 10:15:54
Never had a long run in the side? He played every game, bar missing out a couple with injury, so why the hell are we saying he didn't get a run in the side.

Simms joined Sunderland on a season-long loan for the start of the 2022/23 campaign and went on to score an impressive seven goals plus two assists in just 17 league appearances before 31st December.

The reports I saw, said they had a deadly combination with Stewart, who banged in another 10 goals next to him, and were one of the best scoring pair in the Championship.

He's not Premier League quality, that's clear. But give him a season or two, and it will be multiple times £3.5m.

Si Pulford
132 Posted 08/07/2023 at 11:47:38
Amazing how one source says 3.5 million and everyone is 100% certain it’s true.

The other 20 sources or whatever saying 6-8 million are now dismissed.

Because we’re Evertonians.

Here’s one saying 8 to make us feel better!

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/transfer-news/ellis-simms-speaks-out-after-27281952

Will Mabon
133 Posted 08/07/2023 at 12:50:19
Well, Si - "undisclosed" does rather lend itself to speculation of a shitty fee over a big one.

What's with this occasional use of the undisclosed thing anyway? Does this also mean they can keep it from the Inland Revenue :-)

Si Pulford
134 Posted 08/07/2023 at 13:27:29
Will 133 that wouldn’t surprise me at all with this mob.

On a separate note. I’ve heard from someone with links to the club that we’re seriously looking at Ashley Cole for LB cover.

He turns 38 tomorrow.

Let that sink in!

Could be BS and I hope it is.

Colin Malone
135 Posted 08/07/2023 at 13:33:48
Good luck lad. At 22 years of age, should be better. Let's move on.


Anthony A Hughes
136 Posted 08/07/2023 at 13:52:30
I think when Thelwell got the remit to bring Young talent in I think he misunderstood
Paul Davies
137 Posted 08/07/2023 at 14:14:57
Did I miss something. I thought we are still a Premiership club not one conducting a fire sale because we are now in the Championship.
Will Mabon
138 Posted 08/07/2023 at 14:23:15
Paul, you know "us".

Went kid-in-a-candy-store when not necessary from 2016 - now sort of correcting, finally; hopefully not an overcorrection.

"It's fast and furious in the ready money round."

Peter Roberts
140 Posted 08/07/2023 at 14:50:35
Before we went down the Director of Football road that we were better at buying & selling players. Occasionally we would make poor decisions, but now, we hardly ever make good purchases.
Si Pulford
141 Posted 08/07/2023 at 15:59:26
Peter to be fair the DOFs have never been allowed to do their jobs without Kenwright and Moshiri interference.

Brands had a list of fine players turned down including Dumfries.

Steve Walsh didn't want Rooney or Klaassen.

The DoF model can work fine if they're allowed to do their jobs. The jury is out as to whether Thelwell is the man to stand up to the higher ups regarding footballing matters and transfers. Hopefully he will but he was DoF when we had both Dyche and Bielsa on the same shortlist which is a worry.

Neil Carter
143 Posted 08/07/2023 at 16:33:17
Where's the new players, Thelwell? If you repeat January's transfer disaster, you can go as well. Director of Football my arse!!! More Director of Fuck-All at the moment!!!

Get your finger out — Fulham at home 5 weeks today with the Toffee Lady up front!!!

Paul Kossoff
144 Posted 08/07/2023 at 16:43:46
We will look pretty fucking stupid if Simms's goals send Coventry into the Premier League as we replace them in the Championship because we didn't score enough goals.

In Kenwright we trust! 🙄

Ben King
145 Posted 08/07/2023 at 17:03:18
Paul #145,

We already look stupid. No other club would have paid the stupid stupid amounts of money we've lashed out on journeymen players, eg, £30M Bolaise, £20M Walcott, £50M Sigurdsson, £20M Tosun etc etc.

We are as badly run as they come.

Paul Kossoff
146 Posted 08/07/2023 at 17:21:51
Ben 146.

If I wasn't the truest of blues, I would have given up by now, I really would. I have zero trust in Thelwell, Kenwright, Moshiri or the mythical MSP, I don't believe, not that we are being told anything, in anything that they tell us.

Thelwell should have been sacked by now for dereliction of duty. But at least we have Bill with his expertise on transfers and dealings. If we are still in the Premier League at the end of this season and still solvent, I will be happy with that. I expect nothing more.

Brent Stephens
147 Posted 08/07/2023 at 17:26:05
Paul #147,

"If I wasn't the truest of blues, I would have given up by now, I really would."

That's the spirit, Paul. Positivity. Beats all that negativity some people keep posting ad nauseum.

Anthony A Hughes
148 Posted 08/07/2023 at 17:41:17
What next? Earl Barret for right back cover for the youngster Coleman :)
Mike Hayes
149 Posted 08/07/2023 at 17:51:32
Rumour Brett Angell and Per Koldrup on their way 🤷
Paul Kossoff
150 Posted 08/07/2023 at 18:42:29
Si 61. I can't believe that we still have Kenwright supporters on here or anywhere. Anyone that critices someone having a go at that bastard really should rethink their logic. Unbelievable. I give up. Shame on you, and you saying you hate Kenwright? Sure you do, I bet.
Paul Kossoff
151 Posted 08/07/2023 at 18:42:35
Chris James
152 Posted 08/07/2023 at 18:45:55
Glad to see a majority of commenters appreciating that this is actually decent business and indeed I'm seeing a number of positive steps towards being a better run club - realising some transfer value from youth prospects who we don't think are quite good enough and getting rid of deadwood (sorry Davies) are actually the sort of building blocks we need.

This isn't exciting I appreciate, but it is sensible, as opposed to all the drama of recent years. On the pitch we need to go back to basics and build a solid ahrd-working squad that'll give Dyche a chance to progress with the project he's started (and not kneejerk if there are setbacks). My belief/hope is that he can be the new Moyesiah - who also did an incredible job on a shoestring. I was really proud of those days tbh and never really worried about the KITAP1 approach.
Generally I'd much rather see us cemented back in the top 10 with 50-something points each year (or top 7 with 60+) than trying to play beautiful attacking football and flirting with relegation. Obviously it'd be great to have both (which to be fair some sides are managing), but results matter more right now.

Behind the scenes we clearly need to balance the books to fend off FFP issues, but the moves we've been making (together with sales from last year) suggest we may be able to do that, which is precisely why I'm not getting overly agitated about the lack of transfer activity. I think we will buy a striker, possibly two in the summer and probably a couple more.

Meanwhile, in the boardroom, we've already had a bit of a cull and I suspect BK will follow soon enough as most on here are desperate for once investment money comes in and/or they identify an option Moshiri believes to be credible.

Ultimately I've seen a little glory and a LOT of adversity in my c.40 years as a fan and I can say that this is far from the worst situation we've been in. Pre-Moshiri we were on the verge of bankruptcy for years, so I don't think our finances are anywhere near the nadir, we'd also been flirting with relegation regularly pre-Moyes under the likes of Walker and Smith, this was not the first 'last day escape'.

Previously we didn't have an owner who'd been able to invest (or find) money and we certainly didn't have a fabulous new stadium on the way. My ambitions aren't crazy: a top 10 finish, a little squad development and continued evolution to a more sensible way of running things off the pitch, but I do go into the season with some optimism... there'll be plenty of time for moaning later on!

Paul Kossoff
153 Posted 08/07/2023 at 19:24:43
Chris 155. If a transfer embargo hits us in October and we haven't bought anyone this window, wouldn't that situation, having a threadbare squad, be the worst position we have ever been in.
Mike Hayes
154 Posted 08/07/2023 at 19:30:34
Chris - we’ve got a billionaire who doesn’t know how to fuckin spend it properly - yes new stadium on the way - if it gets the extra £350m funding and isn’t sold off and rented back - look good if when we move in we are looking at relegation - an accountant that can’t count his money FFS!
Jay Evans
155 Posted 08/07/2023 at 20:09:18
Goodbye Ellis and good luck mate.

Not even close to being good enough to cut it in the Premier League though. I've seen milk turn quicker.

Tony Abrahams
156 Posted 08/07/2023 at 20:16:52
By all accounts Ellis Simms struggles every time he goes up another level, but he has scored goals wherever he has played in his career so far. He doesn't look ready for the Premier League but he's still only young, so he might get there one day?

I think if he was better playing with his back to goal, then Sean Dyche, would have probably kept him, but I think he's got a chance because he has got a turn of pace, so I definitely can't agree with your last statement, Jay!

Neil Copeland
157 Posted 08/07/2023 at 20:23:35
Any player who can brush off a player of Koulibaly’s class and score has the ability to do well. Good luck Ellis and thanks for that fantastic goal!
Oliver Molloy
158 Posted 08/07/2023 at 21:14:41
I've just read that this Simms deal is an initial £3.5 million up front which could rise to a maximum £8 million if certain targets etc are met.

If true, my opinion is this is a fucking unbelievable deal for Coventry and quite the opposite for us.

I suppose we will never find out!

Bobby Mallon
159 Posted 08/07/2023 at 21:40:27
It's a fucking crime that he's been sold. He was never given a chance and he's fucking better than Maupay... fact!
Shane Corcoran
160 Posted 08/07/2023 at 21:44:01
Your opinion is not a fact Bobby, FACT.

Although I agree with your opinion.

Si Cooper
161 Posted 08/07/2023 at 23:47:05
On what I've seen, he's fairly one-dimensional in how he performs so doesn't surprise me if he's not seen as the long-term solution.

It doesn't matter if he's a little better than Maupay if he's much easier to sell and ultimately fairly easily replaced in turn. Hopefully, if he can't improve, Maupay will end up being third- or even fourth-choice by the time the season starts.

Jerome Shields
162 Posted 09/07/2023 at 06:35:09
Gary #109,

Yes, I agree that this coming season is about survival and the transfer policy will appear up to the last minute as you described. But Moshiri does normally pull a surprise near the end of the transfer window. The reason only known to him, with mixed results.

I don't know if you are aware of the Greater Fool theory, used to describe Trump's business dealing in the early 2000s. A fool buys a business and expects a greater fool to buy it off him at a huge profit. Any logical analysis of the situation is confounded by unknowns, pushing the limits, a myriad of borrowings, a legal quagmire and behind-the-scenes workings. In the world of Premier League football, fertile ground seems to be the order of the day for this theory.

David West
163 Posted 09/07/2023 at 10:47:29
Chris 152. I agree with most of your post about the team rebuilding.
We have to be patient and hope that Dyche and Thelwell can get a few players to impact the first team in exchange for those who are being sold or let go, that really are not having any impact over the course of a season. Just a small improvement to the team would see us easily safe imo.

Some will never be happy.
They ask for deadwood to be sold or let go, and as soon as a few squad fringe players are gone & high earners who don't contribute enough they moan the sqauds too thin.

Chris I don't agree though about your take on our finances. Kenwright never tried to invest when he was in control. Never tried to maximise the potential we had when he had a really good manager in Moyes. We were not nearly bankrupt under him, he never spent any money, we were run on what the club generated. He didn't invest a penny himself.

We now find ourselves in the opposite situation where the 100s of millions moshiri has wasted has effected us worse. Where its left us without a pot to piss in. With sections hanging over us, ffp tying our hands in the transfer market, players not wanting to sign for us.

From where we were when Mosiri took over to where we are now is how I look at it.
We were able to attract players like lukaku & Richarlison now we are looking at bargain bin signings to save our premier league status.
It's a million miles.

Danny O’Neill
164 Posted 09/07/2023 at 10:54:23
Neil, when he bullied Koulibaly and sent us into raptures in the Shed End was a magnificent moment.

I think he's only shown glimpses, but then was he given the chance? Did manager after after manager have the confidence in his ability?

I guess now we'll never know.

That night was a great moment, but in general I was on the fence from what I've seen of him.

Time will tell, but I wish him well.

Play football regularly. That is most important for his career development.

Neil Copeland
165 Posted 09/07/2023 at 11:12:22
Danny, I agree mate. Ability is one part of it, application and mentality and just as important if not more so.

I was never convinced either but like you I wish him well.

Bobby Mallon
166 Posted 09/07/2023 at 11:58:52
Virginia just signed a 2 year extension
Roger Helm
167 Posted 09/07/2023 at 13:56:01
He is 22 and has scored 12 goals in the Championship and Scottish Premiership. Surely he is worth more than that?
Justin Doone
168 Posted 10/07/2023 at 07:08:38
I thought Simms would be the route off Striker Dyche would to for and I we surprised he want used me postern past season.

I've heard he's sold for £4M plus addons if they get promoted etc.

If he wasn't our player, he seems the type if profile we would easily splash £10M on. Go figure?

Good luck to the lad, I think he's made a lot of progress last season and will continue to improve.

Si Pulford
169 Posted 10/07/2023 at 10:28:15
Paul Kossoff,

I don't where you're from or what your problem is but if you think someone saying they wouldn't expect a chairman to comment on transfer rumours means they support the chairman, you're either pissed, can't read, or are mental. Or a combination of all three.

Go and have a lie down.

Clive Rogers
170 Posted 10/07/2023 at 10:48:23
Calm it down, calm it down.
Jim Lloyd
171 Posted 10/07/2023 at 11:14:36
Chris (152) An excellent post. Maybe we've been in worse times but I doubt that it has been the perfect storm, that you describe so well.

We have a fairly reasonable first team though our major goalscorer is a doubt to play every week, we have a poor bench though some of the young lads might become men.

We have the financial situation and the Profitability and Sustainability chasms to cross, it could mean a disastrous experience but who knows?

What is very likely is that we are short of funds to buy expensive players but we might just get a goalscorer and a right winger. So I agree with you that there is one aim for us this season. That is to avoid relegation with the further hope that we are not dealt with harshly and we can get around mid-table.

I think Dyche is planning for the worst but hoping for the best. I hope we back him and the squad next season like we did last season. I couldn't think of a more suitable manager for the situatrion we find ourselves in.

Clive Rogers
172 Posted 10/07/2023 at 11:48:55
Chris, 152, you have ignored the biggest issue of the day: Who is paying for the new ground?

It was probably going to be Usmanov and Moshiri who had a vision of owning a Champions League club. Usmanov has now gone and it looks like Moshiri is going to put the debt on the club.

It's been reported he has said that EFC can't really afford the new stadium. If this happens, as it probably will, it will be a millstone around the neck for possibly decades. It may also prevent takeovers. The debt could be massive, possibly as much as £1.5 billion.

Clive Rogers
173 Posted 10/07/2023 at 12:53:30
Raymond, 176,

We do know what our finances are like, they are disastrous. We have been recording over £100 million losses each year for the past 4 years. Last year came down to £45 million because we sold Richarlison on the last day for £50 to £60 million.

If you want a complete breakdown read some of Paul the Esk's past articles. I suggest you have a stiff drink first.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.



How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb