05/08/2024 67comments  |  Jump to last

Youssef Chermiti has joined Jarrad Branthwaite as an injury doubt for the start of the new season after undergoing an operation to repair a foot problem.

The young Portuguese scored twice in the friendly at Sligo Rovers last month and played the second 45 minutes against Salford City but was absent from the trips to Coventry and Preston after injuring his foot in training.

That issue required what the Club have described as a minor operation and he will now begin his recovery with the hope of being fit as soon as possible as the kick-off to the 2024-25 campaign looms on 17 August.

Branthwaite also had a minor op in late July but Sean Dyche indicated at the weekend that the defender will be touch-and-go for the season-opener against Brighton.

“We will see," the manager told the Liverpool Echo. "He is making good progress all of a sudden. He had a bit of a slow spell and now it is beginning to move forward, so hopefully.

“He will certainly be in and around it, I am not saying he will definitely be fit but he will certainly be in and around it.”

In addition, all three of Seamus Coleman, Michael Keane and James Garner (muscular strain) are nursing complaints that the Club's medical staff hope will clear up before the start of the season.

 

Reader Comments (67)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Robert Leigh
1 Posted 05/08/2024 at 20:54:37
A blow, he looked sharp in preseason and towards the end of last season.

No one better than Dyche though to bring him back at the right time; he managed Calvert-Lewin well.

Mike Gaynes
2 Posted 05/08/2024 at 21:02:22
Minor foot surgery? Bunion? Ingrown toenail?
Peter Gorman
3 Posted 05/08/2024 at 21:09:42
Hopefully not as serious as Seamus Coleman's infamous infected blister.
Derek Knox
4 Posted 05/08/2024 at 21:24:54
Mike G, good job it was his minor foot, his major foot is his goal-scoring one ! :-)
Danny O’Neill
5 Posted 06/08/2024 at 06:27:25
Hopefully not too long out.

Minor surgery might mean something like metatarsals? I've done that myself, but the stupid idiot I am, I played on!!

Who knows.

Jim Bennings
6 Posted 06/08/2024 at 07:46:39
Foot problems can actually be the worst ones to rid yourself from...

Especially as athletes, it could be anything and the amount of time is usually anytime also because you can't take a chance on a metatarsal injury, for instance.

Denis Richardson
7 Posted 06/08/2024 at 08:14:45
Good job we signed O'Brien as it doesn't look like Branthwaite will be fit for next week.

Injuries already a concern and season hasn't even started yet.

Still no sign of a right-back… Patterson out until late September by all accounts.

Dave Abrahams
8 Posted 06/08/2024 at 09:18:04
Everton are saying they have a new policy on injuries, the players are being encouraged to disclose any injuries as soon as they feel they have one, the club can then start to sort the injury out immediately instead of the player carrying on playing with the injury, this is why a few players have missed games this close season but are ready to come back quicker and fitter.

Rodriguez would never have got off the fitness table under this policy, he would have disclosed his injury(?) five seconds or sooner after it began———mostly in his bleedin’ head!

Dave Williams
9 Posted 06/08/2024 at 09:47:10
Dave- I think with Rodriguez he’d have notified two days before the injury happened!!
Dave Abrahams
10 Posted 06/08/2024 at 09:52:21
Dave (9)Yes Dave I was being a bit lenient with James there, he couldn’t help it if he was born a little bit nesh!
Tommy Carter
11 Posted 06/08/2024 at 10:17:55
@7 Dennis

Branthwaite isn’t injured. He’s not playing because he will be moving to Manchester United.

Clearly he and Man Utd have agreed their terms and it is now just between Everton and Man Utd to settle and agree the terms of the sale and transfer fee.

It’s no coincidence that we have signed a player that is of the same profile as Branthwaite. Similar age, have played and performed in a top foreign league. Have lower league experience in England. Similar physical stature and both with pace.

Clearly Dyche has recognised that the strength of his team last season was the defence and hence why he is seeking to replicate the partnership that Tarks and Branthwaite had last season.

We will keep Keane and I even suspect that Dyche will try and do what he did last season which was to start with Tarks and Keane. Dyche thought that 12 months ago that this was a partnership that worked and I think he’ll persevere again until the lack of form from Keane forces him to play O’Brien.

Look, this is not what I would like to happen but all the hallmarks are there unfortunately.

I suspect Holgate may move on and therefore Dyche will seek to bring in one more for defensive cover. It wouldn’t surprise me if he moves for a player that can play a full back position as well as centre back.

Shane Corcoran
12 Posted 06/08/2024 at 10:31:29
Disappointing that your certainty trailed off towards the end of your message Tommy.

Anything else going on that you can tell us about?

Tommy Carter
13 Posted 06/08/2024 at 10:42:11
@12 Shane

Certainty trailed off because the club has to identify a versatile full back / centre back and then get the deal done.

That’s quite a complex proposition with many moving parts. That’s what Everton will try and do, whether they can achieve it is a different thing.

Branthwaite going may be unpalatable to you and others Shane, but it is what it is.

Colin Callaghan
14 Posted 06/08/2024 at 11:02:05
Could be getting ready to move on from Tarkowski as he's aging. Young right-footed centre-back to pair with Branthwaite instead.

Holgate will be gone before Jarrad.

Shane Corcoran
15 Posted 06/08/2024 at 11:15:14
It's not unpalatable in the slightest, Tony.

I'm just surprised how certain you are.

Danny O’Neill
16 Posted 06/08/2024 at 12:39:41
Tarkowski is hardly carrying a walking stick and is a decent age for a centre back.

I don't recall many slating Jagielka when he played well into his 30s.

Michael Kenrick
17 Posted 06/08/2024 at 13:19:39
Yea, Tommy, you're gonna look a bit daft if it doesn't happen.

Are you prepared for that? Because we are all set to pile on come the end of the window. We don't like fake news and right now, that's what you're pushing.

Dave @8 is referencing a piece in the Echo that included quotes from Mark Howard, the club's Head of Performance:

“When the gaffer says there are no heroes, he really means it because, if you do just feel something we have got a big group [so can deal with players being absent].

"So, when we're pushing reasonably hard, we know the lads are going to get sore. The challenge is just differentiating between soreness and the edge of an injury.

"We have got a great collection of staff that are all working together for that – that is through the medical staff, the insights guys, the analysis staff, and the sports science staff.

"We are talking together every day at the start and at the end, so communication and organisation is absolutely critical so that we're all aware of the things that are going on and looking at scenarios where we do maybe just need to pull someone out of part of a session or a full session so that we know they're ready for the next one.

“It is critical the players are involved in the conversation. They are the athletes – we can't feel what they can feel. That trust is what we're trying to build.

"If you've got a successful team, you really want that tight trust as a group where it's very open, it's very honest. Honest doesn't mean easy conversations all of the time. Sometimes the conversations are difficult – a player might be wanting to do a little bit more.

"We've got lots of information from all the different departments that will inform our decision-making process, and the manager and the players and the coach and the staff are all involved in that.

"And then we use it wisely to make a decision on whether someone does a little bit more or does a little bit less. We're a group of people trying to be successful, and sometimes it's difficult conversations that are needed to do that. But generally speaking, that is what we're trying to create here.

"That really strong work ethic and that real feeling of togetherness where people are very comfortable talking to each other about how they are and what they might think. And then we make a decision together rather than just telling people what they are doing.”

Basically sounds like common sense and hopefully explains what appears to be an extra-cautious approach to protecting the players from injury — that's of course right after busting their balls good and proper during Gaffer's Day!

Tommy Carter
18 Posted 06/08/2024 at 13:59:25
@ 17 Michael. That’s fair enough. That’s the way the situation is currently in my eyes. It’s not fake news. It’s simply an interpretation of the facts as they present. The reporting about Branthwaite and personal terms is reliable information, as is the fact that Man Utd have submitted bids for the player that Everton have rejected. As is the fact we have signed O’Brien and the list of qualities as written above is my interpretation of what has happened.

Many variables as previously stated. A football deal is never done until it’s very much signed and sealed. It also exists that the Branthwaite deal might not get over the line by the end of August in which case the situation changes again and Branthwaite remains an Everton player for the period until the deal can be done.

Again. Lots of moving parts - he’s available for section again until the January and will be a player Dyche will want to select. Then the club have to consider, the longer the deal remains incomplete, the risk of Branthwaite losing form / getting a bad injury etc and the transfer never getting done.

Therefore I think Everton will be keen to get it done as quickly as possible as soon as the minumum valuation is met.

As for succession planning for Tarks. I doubt Dyche is thinking that far ahead.

@16 Danny makes the valuable and obvious point. For a robust player, very rarely injured with all the qualities Dyche looks for in a player, a leader and a phenomenal statistics base in winning aerial duels - my guess is that Dyche will be looking at Tarks being the automatic starter for the next two years, and Dyche will be hoping he is still in the job at that point. He is not a player at his age who will be taken from us by a bigger club.

Brian Williams
19 Posted 06/08/2024 at 14:06:17
The reporting about Branthwaite and personal terms is NOT reliable news.
Somebody on here has about as good a source as you could possibly have and was reliably informed that the "agreed terms" claim was, to put it collouqially, a load of shite.
I trust the poster and I certainly trust his source.
Brian Williams
20 Posted 06/08/2024 at 14:22:18
*colloquially*
Ray Roche
21 Posted 06/08/2024 at 14:24:57
Isn’t Branthwaite missing following minor surgery? Not being protected from injury prior to a transfer but as a cautionary measure ?
Annika Herbert
22 Posted 06/08/2024 at 14:28:46
Could you tell us where you got this reliable information from Tommy? Cos it has a familiar smell to it for me.

Quite surprising how many people claim to be repeating reliable information, but can’t pass on where said information originated from

Tommy Carter
23 Posted 06/08/2024 at 14:40:36
It’ll be somewhere between £50m - £60m plus a series of add ons to £75m
Barry Rathbone
24 Posted 06/08/2024 at 14:46:14
I'll be astonished if Branthwaite isn't a Utd player by the end of this window for 3 reasons.

1. utd have made a bid

2. Branthwaite isn't being selected

3. We've bought what looks like a replacement

Phil (Kelsall) Roberts
25 Posted 06/08/2024 at 14:48:50
Barry, depends whether you believe the story about the minor op explaining #2
Mark Ryan
26 Posted 06/08/2024 at 15:58:39
Completely with you Barry I cannot see him staying. Things are stacking up in favour of him leaving and this is despite what some on here state as gospel or what is being suggested by Tommy C.
Man Utd are suddenly not in the market for a CB according to the press or Transfer chat.
I hope he stays but cannot see it. I'll be happy to be wrong
Tommy Carter
27 Posted 06/08/2024 at 16:19:56
@19 Brian

There is no such thing as a reliable source when it comes to football transfers. On a spectrum, some will be more reliable than others. But nobody will ever be able to give guarantees or predictions. Not even spouses or family members of those directly involved. Even sometimes those directly involved themselves.

A football transfer is so complex that it should be viewed as a massive achievement for any club to get a deal that they want done over the line and complete.

Simple things like what the player actually wants through to the complexities of the finances - absolutely nothing is straightforward

Denis Richardson
28 Posted 06/08/2024 at 17:00:02
Multiple sites reporting Branthwaite has a slight injury. He may well be off to Man U but I don’t think the club would lie about an injury.

O’Brian is a ready made replacement but also means we don’t need to panic buy if we sell Branthwaite and also could sell him next year instead.

I’d like him to stay but given our predicament if we sell for a decent fee then so be it.

Barry Rathbone
29 Posted 06/08/2024 at 17:42:01
Phil 25

That is the nub of the issue.

Furthermore he may have a slight injury which may not stop him playing in usual circumstances but is proving very useful in the present situation.

Everton drive me to cynicism

Raymond Fox
30 Posted 06/08/2024 at 17:48:18
Its better to let Calvert-Lewin go if thats what he wants, we might as well get some cash for him if we can.

The big question is what is he worth, its a difficult one, I suppose its a case who is the highest bidder.
Then does he want to go there and what his pay checks will look like.
Its got a bit messy.

I would much prefer for him to be playing for us, but if wants to go get the most you can.

Tommy Carter
31 Posted 06/08/2024 at 17:50:34
@29 Baz

It may be a condition of a transfer. United have asked that the surgery be done whilst he is at everton.

The other thing is, if expectation is that O’Brien is as good as Branthwaite then this may be very unrealistic and leave many disappointed.

The performances from Branthwaite last season, save for a poor spell of form just after the new year - were exceptional. To produce that level at such a young age in such a struggling team, exceptional.

Colin Callaghan
32 Posted 06/08/2024 at 21:08:08
Or Man Utd are out because they bought Yoro who is a young centre-back and spending £150M on centre-backs is ridiculous. I understand Yoro just got hurt but that team needs more than 2 young centre-backs.

Tarkowski is great but nowhere near as good of a footballer as Jagielka.

Tommy Carter
33 Posted 06/08/2024 at 21:22:24
Colin @32

Both top players. Jags achieved a level of performance and consistency that made him international class.

A very underrated player Jags. Seemed to me to lack a bit of self-belief that may have propelled him to the very top of the game.

When he first arrived, Moyes quite obviously signed him as a defensive midfielder / right back. It was another case of Moyes stumbling upon putting a player in their best position and then they flourished.

Very few signings under Moyes hit the ground running.

Jeff Spiers
34 Posted 06/08/2024 at 21:54:13
I chatted to a few Blue friends about the new stadium. Some would like the name The Park End behind one goal, and Gwladys Street behind the other. Keep the memory alive, a bit of Goodison shall we say. Other names like The Mersey End River View etc. One Blue came up with a beaut Terry's Timber End. Any feed back fellow ToffeeWebbers??
Tommy Carter
35 Posted 06/08/2024 at 23:07:49
@Jeff

I read an interesting piece about Leeds Utd and when Howard (Sgt. Bilko) Wilkinson took charge he got rid of all the old photos as he felt the club were living in the last and should make their own history.

As much as Goodison Park has provided us with the glory days, it’s also been there the host of some of the darkest times of being an Evertonian and some of them very recent / current.

I say move on. This is our new home and a spectacular one. Let’s start writing history now

Jeff Spiers
36 Posted 07/08/2024 at 07:18:41
Tommy. Agree, time to move on. What do you think will happen to Goodison when she is raised to the ground. Landfill ??. Just curious
Danny O’Neill
37 Posted 07/08/2024 at 07:31:15
Here you go Jeff

Link

Jeff Spiers
38 Posted 07/08/2024 at 09:14:11
Thanks Danny
Neil Lawson
39 Posted 07/08/2024 at 09:48:11
Clearly a slow news day with so much effort being expended above, debating " the Branthwaite Conundrum " moving then to suggestions for the designation of the various areas of BMD.

I would prefer to spend my time infuriated by the BBC coverage of the Olympics and constant race reruns, biopics, homages and analysis and interviews of neighbours, teachers, classmates, etc of Keely Hodgkinson. Perhaps the away end of BMD should be " the Keely End". Fantastic performance by her, but for goodness sake, give it a rest.

Eurosports channel 412 and Discovery + the channel of choice.

Rob Halligan
40 Posted 07/08/2024 at 10:09:55
Neil # 39… I agree.

Sick of these constant re-runs of certain races, interviews, gatherings in athletic clubs social bars etc. The channels you mention do show continuous live coverage but who likes gymnastics, equestrian, wall climbing, skateboarding, BMX racing, clay shooting… the list of boring events goes on.

All just my opinion of course. And yet I like events such as the rowing and cycling, events which some might find boring. I think we all love the athletics though.

Brent Stephens
41 Posted 07/08/2024 at 10:18:52
Rob, as you might guess, I like the water sports!
Rob Halligan
42 Posted 07/08/2024 at 10:30:26
Kayak!!
Jeff Spiers
43 Posted 07/08/2024 at 10:30:45
Neil sorry you are upset by the BMD namings. Just a bit of banter mate. You are right about the BBC shite though. It will be over soon.
Brent Stephens
44 Posted 07/08/2024 at 10:35:45
Pedalo racing!
Fred Charters
45 Posted 07/08/2024 at 10:40:59
Just learned that the iconic rugby ground Twickenham is to be sponsored by Allianz to the tune of £10m per annum & will be renamed after that Company.

There is no football ground in England sponsored by them, why not encourage them to do the same with our new ground?

Neil Lawson
46 Posted 07/08/2024 at 11:16:30
Great idea, Fred.

The " Keely Allianz Stadium". Does have a certain ring to it. 😁

Tony Abrahams
47 Posted 07/08/2024 at 11:21:00
My guess is that a lot of the younger Evertonians must absolutely hate Goodison Park, Tommy.

My son loves Everton but, when I spoke to him after Luton knocked us out the FA Cup, he said to me "Why do I want to bring my soon-to-be-born son, into being an Evertonian, dad, when alls I've had in my 24 years of being a crazy Evertonian is heartache?"

I felt his pain and said to him, "I can see the floodlights of Goodison now, lad, and I think the sooner we get out of that ground the better, because I think it's been cursed by Kenwright."

And his reply was that he had actually started hating going to Goodison, and sometimes he felt he was only going because Everton are in his blood.

Tommy Carter
48 Posted 07/08/2024 at 11:41:20
@ Tony

Booing the team off at half time. Lambasting players such as Stones and Lukaku in Everton shirts etc – this kind of culture can stay at Goodison as far as I'm concerned. I would much rather BMD be a place of support and positivity.

Yes, players may not always perform. And yes, the team may not always be doing what we hope it will and the club may not always be where we want it to be. But just some simple support and encouragement will make the new stadium a greater place to be.

Flares, greeting team buses etc isn't required. Create the atmosphere in the fan park for the 2 hours before kick-off as one united support and then get in the stadium and let the good feeling permeate onto the pitch. We have a manager who will not settle for less than 100% from the players on the pitch so we don't need to contribute towards that.

The board that many hated is gone or is going.

Yes, we may not want Ashley Young starting games or the next player we don't prefer. But if they have a jersey and are on the pitch, we are with them.

Danny O’Neill
49 Posted 07/08/2024 at 11:56:31
Rob, skateboarding. Honestly. I have enough trouble avoiding them on the local high street!

Leaving Goodison will be emotional for those of a certain age, Tony, but we've got something special to look forward to in the new Everton Stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock. Sort the ownership out and it's a new dawn.

My poor son, who had a season ticket during his 3 years at John Moores, has had nothing, like many of his generation and younger. But they keep going.

Paul Kossoff
50 Posted 07/08/2024 at 14:54:26
Here is your next England boss.
Lee Carsley is expected to be the interim manager of the England men's senior team when they play their Nations League games against the Republic of Ireland and Finland next month.

Carsley led England Under-21s as they won the European Championship in 2023 for the first time in 39 years.

Gareth Southgate resigned as England manager two days after defeat by Spain in the 2024 Euros final last month.

The path from under-21s manager to caretaker boss of the senior team is well trodden, with Howard Wilkinson, Stuart Pearce and Southgate all stepping up after taking charge of the Young Lions.
BBC sports.

Paul Kossoff
51 Posted 07/08/2024 at 15:07:46
Jeff and Danny, just an idea,

We are all talking about Goodison Park being demolished and what to do with the remaining area. Why don't we keep Goodison as a football ground, used for the WSL and all the Under-21s games and a training facility. Reduce the capacity to say 10,000.

The whole community benefits, fans, shops, businesses and Everton. We and future fans get to see the history of Everton and where all the greats played.

I'm sure we as fans would support a reduced refurbished Goodison Park. What do you think, any ideas? Shouldn't Goodison be a grade-listed building protected from a flash-in-the-pan money-making idea from some housing property speculator?

How about putting the keeping of Goodison to the new owners, because once it's gone will soon come, and it's no good saying we should have kept it, do it now.

Brian Williams
52 Posted 07/08/2024 at 15:22:48
The plans for the area that Goodison stands on have been in place for several years.
Paul Kossoff
53 Posted 07/08/2024 at 15:51:25
Brian 52, And?
Danny O’Neill
54 Posted 07/08/2024 at 15:55:51
Paul, I've said it for years.

Goodison is going to be demolished.

I'd like to have seen a new, down scaled stadium down at the Gwladys Street end. It probably only needed to have been a single deck, with a capacity of no more than 6,000 and used by the U21s and U18s.

There would still be room for the social housing up near the Park End side. There is plenty of land.

Brian Williams
55 Posted 07/08/2024 at 15:57:04
And it's in the public domain if you care to look it up online.

Or let my brother Barry do it for you.

Barry Williams
56 Posted 07/08/2024 at 16:01:24
https://ukgbc.org/resources/goodison-legacy-project/
Jeff Spiers
57 Posted 07/08/2024 at 16:06:39
Paul, I guess it's well out of our hands.

I would like to know what the cost would be to demolish Goodison and how much will be recycled.

Barry Williams
58 Posted 07/08/2024 at 16:09:43
Brian Williams @55,

One likes to give a helping hand sir, as the actress said to the bishop etc!

Danny O'Neil has already posted the link, and managed to actually post it as a link, which I have failed to do, despite being reasonably tech savvy! My link just went back to this page, despite it being the correct web address! Hey ho!

Brian Williams
59 Posted 07/08/2024 at 16:22:49
Haha. Barry, that's why I don't try because I always mess it up.

Someone did instruct me on how to do the link thing but, with a memory like mine, the ability was soon gone.

Brian Wilkinson
60 Posted 07/08/2024 at 23:38:37
Is Spirit of the Blues going to be changed to "Get down to Bramley-Moore Dock"?

Nothing like forward thinking.

Paul Kossoff
62 Posted 08/08/2024 at 14:15:20
Danny 54,

How about some sort of fans cinema that shows the Everton home games live at the redevelopment of Goodison Park.

I'm sure you would get 5,000 in every home game.

Brian Wilkinson
63 Posted 08/08/2024 at 19:52:01
Nothing up for the Roma game yet so will have to stick this on here for now.

Two questions: Are people heading to the Harlech Castle before the game? And second question: Do any of the locals know any pubs with other than horse racing on tv that show Betfred Super League Rugby live games?

Got Leeds Rhinos v Wigan Warriors at 3 pm, I know I will only catch the first half of the game but any heads-up on a pub that might have it on?

Paul Hughes
64 Posted 08/08/2024 at 21:32:20
Brian (63), if you ask nicely at the Harlech, they’ll probably put the rugby on for you on one of the tellys.
Brian Wilkinson
65 Posted 08/08/2024 at 22:36:22
Cheers Paul will give it a go, might give them a ring tomorrow try and get my feet under the table :-)
Brian Wilkinson
66 Posted 09/08/2024 at 11:08:30
Plan A not worked Paul, they have two phone numbers and both say invalid number, 01515231010 and 0151 5252336, so cannot even phone the Harlech Castle.
Bill Griffiths
67 Posted 09/08/2024 at 14:57:47
Hi Brian, I'll be at The Harlech and Neil Copeland is also calling there. I have seen posts from several others indicating they are going to call in there.
Brian Wilkinson
68 Posted 09/08/2024 at 23:31:21
Cheers, Bill, hopefully catch you at the Harlech before the match.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.



How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb