Season › 2024-25 › News Dyche sacked just hours before Peterborough tie Lyndon Lloyd 09/01/2025 500comments | Jump to last Sean Dyche has been relieved of his duties by Everton with immediate effect ahead of this evening's FA Cup tie against Peterborough United. Seamus Coleman and Leighton Baines will take charge of team affairs for the game against the Posh. The club issued this statement shortly after 4:30 this afternoon: Everton Football Club can confirm that Sean Dyche has been relieved of his duties as Senior Men’s First Team Manager with immediate effect. Ian Woan, Steve Stone, Mark Howard and Billy Mercer have also left the Club. Article continues below video content The process to appoint a new manager is under way and an update will be provided in due course. Under-18s Head Coach Leighton Baines and Club Captain Seamus Coleman will take charge of first-team affairs on an interim basis. Reader Comments (500) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Chris Allen 1 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:30:18 Thank God Mike Price 2 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:30:47 Dyche will be delighted. Paid in full without a relegation on his resume Dave Waugh 3 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:31:30 At last! Mike Hayes 4 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:31:49 Mike Price didnt he take Burnley down? Steve Shave 5 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:32:06 Wahoo!!!!!! Thank goodness for that, I thought they'd at least play the match but maybe they have information he'd lost the dressing room and feel we stand a better chance with someone else in an interim role?Lets pray the Friedkin group has a carefully curated plan and the new manager has been lined up. Michael Kenrick 6 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:34:29 Very strange time to do it... but hopefully it gives everyone a massive lift tonight!Yippeee! No more anti-football... no more horrible press conferences (although he was ironically almost bearable in his final one yesterday). Brent Stephens 7 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:34:36 Let's hope for an interim manager bounce and then a proper replacement manager bounce. And then I'll be bouncing. Colin Metcalfe 8 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:34:52 Wow wasnt expecting that but with his record it was only a matter of time, big question is who is incoming? Matt Traynor 9 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:35:00 Just heard it on Radio 5 at the tail end of an interview with Barry Fry...Interesting they sack him so close to the game.Also makes me think the recent media articles about how the squad loved him etc. were puff pieces by his own PR team. Lee Courtliff 10 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:35:09 Jesus Christ!! I wasn't expecting this so close to a game but I can't say I'm disappointed because for all his talk, he was never anything but a Hoofball merchant. Our performances have been embarrassing at times this season, no sign of synergy or any kind of link-up play or even anything resembling modern football. He has nobody to blame but himself for his sheer favouritism and stubbornness. Liam Mogan 11 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:35:12 We might have a few shots tonight! Brent Stephens 12 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:35:33 It perhaps gives Coleman and Baines a bit of time in a less important competition to get their act together and their message / tactics through to the team. Liam Mogan 13 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:36:29 Matt 9 - serendipity perhaps? Maybe Barry is the man. Out of the fry(ing) pan... Dave Lynch 14 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:36:40 Odds massively slashed on Mourinho by bookies Soren Moyer 15 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:37:29 Good riddance!Good! Good! As Darth Sidious used to say. Mick O'Malley 16 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:38:12 Thank f**k for that 🙏 Dean Williams 17 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:39:07 So whome do we think, or want to take the healm ? Anthony Hawkins 18 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:39:56 I totally get the decision, but why only hours before our next game? Surely wait until after? Unless the board considered we might win and cause further delay?I'm glad Dyche, the club and the fans have been put out of their misery. Peter Hopkins 19 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:40:08 What the actual?? Strange time to do it, thought he would at least get this get game, very strange Paul Armstrong 20 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:40:20 Please God not Mourinho. John Raftery 21 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:40:28 Doubtless our squad, replete with world class attacking talent, will now cast off the shackles of expediency and show us their true potential. Ian Bennett 22 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:40:36 about time, any other club would have pulled the plug long ago. Paul Hewitt 23 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:41:12 YiP FUCKING YEE. Peter Hopkins 24 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:41:42 Agreed Paul 20 but would be interesting times. I want a manager we can get excited about, some one with passion and new ideas Paul Smith 25 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:41:53 Ruthless I love TFG Rob Jones 26 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:42:02 So long, Mr Dyche. I'll always be grateful that you pulled our arses out of the fire in 2023, that last season was comparatively good (LONG, LONG winless run aside), but this year has been a disaster, and it was time for you to go.Best of luck in the next job. Liam Mogan 27 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:43:50 DCL finally off the leash. Jim Bennings 28 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:44:09 I just hope they've actually got a plan now.This is where we find out just how good the owners are going to be.Decisive action has been made in Dyche's removal, now the hardest part, get the next one right.I'd be concerned if it was just another big name, it's just being blinded by Hollywood status much like Moshiri was early on.For this reason as much as I admire what Jose Mourinho has achieved in his career it's all over a decade ago now, how many of today's players who are aged 20-25 are in tune with success of that period?Would the football be greatly different from that of Sean Dyche?Yes he'd have more money available, he'd also have more pulling power but I'm just rather cautious.If I had my choice Thomas Frank is a man that speaks positively and seems very in tune with the modern way of thinking but I can't see that happening not until summer if ever.Clearly the rumours that we were speaking to Graham Potter was true, if that was the case and he's chosen West Ham ahead of Everton then what a damn sorry state of affairs Alan McGuffog 29 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:44:14 Well get a proper idea of TFG now..how well have they done homework in having a promising manager lined up. Or not. Nick West 30 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:44:23 "The run isn't really that bad on paper if you add wins to it."I imagine that was the point the decision to bullet him was made. Kunal Desai 31 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:44:52 One game too late in my opinion. He should have been booted after the Forest defeat, nevertheless great news. We move on. Onwards and upwards Anthony Hawkins 32 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:45:05 Next permanent Everton manager odds (via Sky Bet)Jose Mourinho - 2/1Lee Carsley - 3/1David Moyes - 5/1Gary O'Neil - 6/1Steve Cooper - 10/1Julen Lopetegui - 16/1Michael Carrick - 16/1Thomas Frank - 16/1 Andrew Grey 33 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:45:48 Wow! Brent Stephens 34 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:46:02 John #21 - nice one! Peter Hopkins 35 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:46:53 Anthony at 32, Oh dear those names are depressing Jim Bennings 36 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:47:30 AnthonyWhat a depressing list.You not kidding us on there? Lol Brent Stephens 37 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:48:09 I wonder if Coleman and Baines were informed of all this (and sworn to secrecy) well before the announcement and before Dyche was told, to give them time to prepare for tonight?? Anthony Hawkins 38 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:48:41 I think we can discount the top 3, unless the view is to get either Moyes or Mourinho in until the end of the season.I just don't see Carsley opting for League over Country. Andrew Grey 39 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:49:07 Mike -4-No he was sacked before the end of that season. Geoff Lambert 40 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:49:19 Please God Mourinho. Peter Hopkins 41 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:49:26 Well the atmosphere for tonights game has just drastically changed Joey Cannon 42 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:49:30 no more Mr Dyche guy!!! Christy Ring 43 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:50:55 Why let him do the press conference and sack him today? It can't be Mourinho, Fonseca mentioned. Tonight under Baines/Coleman 'Now play Ball'. Peter Hopkins 44 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:51:21 Hopefully Rob Edwards losing his job at Luton is just a coincidence Andrew Grey 45 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:51:22 Moyes is odds on now. 4/7Klopp is 50/1 2% of all bets have been on Klopp. That's just weird. Alan McGuffog 46 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:51:25 Got to be Moyes, sadly and realistically Geoff Lambert 47 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:51:26 Process to appoint new manager is under way. Colin Crooks 48 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:52:01 John Raftery @21.Yep.Couple of observations.Dyche will not have relegation on his CV if we go down.And if we do fall into the drop zone after not being there all season. What will those who have been screaming he was definitely taking us down say ?... Oops ??? Colin Metcalfe 49 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:52:09 Risky I know but I wouldnt mind Paulo Fonseca Joe McMahon 50 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:52:33 I didn't want him to stay,but stunned by the timing. Lee Whitehead 51 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:53:01 I know things have gone pear shaped recently - but give the man some respect.He kept us up FFS !!! Brian Williams 52 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:53:07 I'm just preparing myself for the total turnaround on TW from what was predominantly "He's gotta go now." "Has he gone yet"?To."Awful timing." "What are we gonna do now"? "Harsh!" Andrew Merrick 53 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:53:12 Timing wise, tfg haven't actually held thr reins for long and are still appointing their staff...Baines and Coleman get short notice but good to give them this as a precursor to the next prem game if no-one comes in quickly.Notable that Dyche took trainig today, so short notice to change a lot...But i still hope to see some notable shift on personnel, shape and tactics.Interesting times Michael Lynch 54 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:53:20 I really hope they have a plan. And I really hope that plan doesn't include Jose. I'd like the new man to be someone I've never heard of who will revolutionise the way the game is played and lead us to world domination over the next ten years. John Reynolds 55 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:53:24 As one of the silent minority who was still supportive of Dyche, despite the quality of football recently, I hope we don't live to regret this. Dyche steered us to safety twice, against long odds both times given the mess he inherited from Frank and the points deductions. I believe he would have done so again, even if it wasn't going to be pretty. I'm afraid that a "progressive" systems-based manager coming in to try and change the way this squad play (think splitting the centre-backs and playing out of defence) is a recipe for relegation. At least Potter is out of the equation. Why didn't the Club Statement even have a word of thanks for Sean Dyche who worked in a toxic, uncertain environment and conducted himself with dignity throughout?Be careful what you wish for. Simon Harrison 56 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:54:07 Flippin'eck!I never expected that!Coleman and Baines; interesting? Nothing against the idea, just interesting.Maybe TFG do read TW as there were many posters suggesting this combo.I wonder if Thelwell, under instruction, asked to see Sean's team sheet and tactics, which may have been Plan A version 1.0.0 and when Thelwell reported back, the 'board' said enough, we need to win.And binned him!As AS_Roma_Fan on GOT said in his post there;""Out of nowhere decisions. Since they don't speak, journalists are clueless about their moves. Every time it's a big surprise. For example, nobody had linked Roma with Mourinho until the official statement was published on asroma.com.""It might lift the squad, I can't see how it wouldn't, but it may also come back to bite us, unless Baines and Coleman had been prewarned that this scenario may happen?Good luck to them both, and the team, and if this is Kevin's idea alone, good luck to him to.Thanks for all your work and effort Sean, you just kept going back to the well too often. Bon chance! Joe Bibb 57 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:54:21 We need someone like Mourinho to get back into the media spotlight just like when we had Ancelotti no more failed managers who have won nothing. Simon Harrison 58 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:55:29 Rob [26]Well said, and very gracious to boot.Chapeau! Geoff Lambert 59 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:55:40 John #55 Or they could have just said he was shite. Colin Malone 60 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:56:05 I want Jose. If it is, DCL and co will sign new contracts. Rather Jose than Potter. Jim Bennings 61 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:56:11 JohnI get what you mean but I'm not being careful what I wish for no.Failing to score in 11 out of 19 games this season, not registering a shot in many of them, giving him many of his own players in three transfer windows and progressively regressing since this time last year. No hard feelings on Sean Dyche, he came to do a job, did relatively ok in the first year but no, his position has been beyond tenable now. Dan Parker 62 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:56:12 Strangely his best period was immediately after the 10 point deduction. Fully expected to kick on this season and at least comfortably sit mid table. Ownership uncertainty aside, the performances and stubbornness have been shocking. Cant be a stubborn manager in the modern world whatever profession youre in, let alone “elite” sport. Hopefully the owners make a good decision as to whos next. Alan Williams 63 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:56:24 I cant believe some people are saying not Mourinho, seriously look at his record, profile for the club etc etc.I'm sorry but some fans are just stupid, we have had Dyche footy for nearly three years, yes he did a job but my god it was painful. I have only done one game this season at home, I give away my 2 Tickets FOC to family, they can walk to GP yet on occasions my tickets are not used because they cant be bothered, at least I have 500 mile round trip. I will go to Villa next week now that stubborn sod has gone! its the Faith that kills you :-) Mourinho would be a massive upgrade on what we had, maybe a bit too early for him but nevertheless the players would do what he tells them too. COYB Jimmy Carr 64 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:56:30 Crikey, strange timing. I thought the crisis had passed, this week anyway, for Dyche. To be honest, the run of results has been so poor he can't have any complaints. I don't begrudge him any of his compensation, he's probably as relieved as we are. He did well to keep us up for two years so fair enough, now we all need to move on. I just hope it's not Mourinho as that would give me deep concerns. That list of potentials back there is depressing. Kieran Kinsella 65 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:57:21 Timing surely indicates they already have someone lined up and that maybe Sean got wind of it? Either that or somehow his relationship with the club completely broke down in the last 24 hours cause nothing has occurred in footballing terms since the last game to warrant a change just hours before a game.Anyway, hopefully it is the right move. It's not just a matter of sacking him the bigger thing is getting the right replacement. TFG made of mess of managerial appointments at Roma with Mourinho, De Rossi, then the crap new Soton manager and now Ranieri. Doesn't fill me with much confidence but here is hoping. Brian Williams 66 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:57:29 Jim#28Clearly the rumours that we were speaking to Graham Potter was true, if that was the case and he's chosen West Ham ahead of Everton then what a damn sorry state of affairsHow so "clearly"? and then "if that was the case"?Bit of fence sitting there Jim.I've seen no hard evidence that the club offered Potter the job. Jim Bennings 67 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:57:41 ColinWhy would we want DCL to sign a new contract anyway?He's pissed us about for a year and frankly, no I'd been sending him on his way soon as possible.Again, been a decent performer but he's nowhere near good enough Andy Walker 68 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:57:52 This is not good and appalling timing. Bill Fairfield 69 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:58:29 Thanks for keeping us in the Prem. But it was an awful watch. Iam looking forward to going tonight now. Steve Shave 70 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:58:49 I don't think a list of Mourinho, Sarri and Fonseca is depressing at all, quite the opposite in fact. Amazing that people would turn their noses up at double champions league winning Jose! Of the above three (these are the ones i've picked out of the hat because I feel they have the most pedigree) there are plusses and minuses for each. On balance my choice would be Fonseca but I wouldn't sniff at any of them.The Jose hate I get but I think he would get us, I think the crowd would fucking love his passion and wind up tactics. Would he fancy a project? Let's see. His brand of football would be an easier transition for our limited players. Watch DCL score a brace tonight and for the crowd to be upbeat and really get behind Seamus and Bainsey. Robert Tressell 71 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:58:55 Wow. Let's hope the replacement is appointed very quickly. Jay Harris 72 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:59:15 Thank god for that. As someone said even spot the dog would have got better results.Fonseca or Moyes for me with Galtier a risky consideration. Dan Parker 73 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:59:27 The BBC poll as to whether we should have sacked Dyche is yes (practically all Everton fans) No (other fans) Christy Ring 74 Posted 09/01/2025 at 16:59:30 No one could fault Dyche for the job he did the last two seasons, but this season he has been shocking, and if at anyother club would have been sacked long go. Donal Armani 75 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:01:49 55 John ReynoldsIndeed, very curious that the club statement didnt express the usual platitudes…sparks must have been flying today Tim Michael 76 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:02:39 It has to be the right decision going forward as his position was untenable but very strange to make that decision just hours before the game tonight. Did his staff take training today? If so it suggests some kind of disagreement during the day. We'll probably never know. As for tonights game I would have fully expected EFC to win this game, with or without Dyche. Any interim managers "bounce" will only be clear as they begin to work with players in the coming days/weeks although it will be interesting to see what team they do put out tonight! Paul Armstrong 77 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:03:20 Am I naive in thinking that the announcement of the sacking was delayed by the new owners while they finalised securing the services of the new manager they believe will turn the club around? I mean they wouldn't just sack Dyche without the replacement lined up . would they? Craig Walker 78 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:03:55 I'll get kicked for this but... The football this season has been dreadful but I think Dyche deserves credit for keeping us up for two seasons in difficult circumstances. I thought we were buried when he took over from Lampard. I thought we'd had it when the news of the points deductions hit us last season. Another manager who has paid the price for sticking to his rigid principles. Martinez was the same. If he'd have focussed on defence a bit more he could have done stuff with us. Dyche was the opposite, with little work on attacking teams. Some times we looked good (Brighton away in 2023). Thanks for the memory of beating the RS at Goodison last season. That was the highlight.We need to get the next appointment right! Neil Lawson 79 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:03:59 At last. A match tonight where I suddenly feel passionate and excited again. Desperate for them to do well. Goodison will be bouncing. Geoff Lambert 80 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:04:02 I could smell that coming out to grass now. John Keating 81 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:04:07 Had to goBad timing should have gone after BournemouthBaines and Coleman in charge Kevin Emery 83 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:07:38 Hi all, long time visitor to ToffeeWeb but first time commenting. In an ideal world we could have kept our powder dry until the summer and parted ways with us still in the top flight, but I think it was time unfortunately. During the autumn I was hoping Newcastle's top brass would shaft Eddie Howe and we could nip in as he's a good coach, however he's suddenly picked up again. My shout for our new manager, even though I don't really like the guy, would be Brendon Rogers (I'll don my tin hat for my first post!!) I know he's ex-RS but he's not as synonymous with that lot as Benitez and I think new owners and a brand-spanking new stadium would play to his inflated ego, plus he might see it as one in the eye to them lot as they sacked him. He plays decent attacking football, did a good job at Leicester, the RS, and Celtic and he's used to the pressure. He's also proved he's got zero loyalty to Celtic, so I think he would be obtainable. I'm surprised I've not seen him name mentioned tbh Mike Corcoran 84 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:07:47 Happy that Potter wont get it. Leaky as feck and no goals in his teams. Coleman and Baines will have been tearing their hair out looking at our full back tactics. We were looking doomed so lets get behind them and whoever comes in and give em a chance. Jimmy Hogan 85 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:08:04 Good. Simon Harrison 86 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:08:57 John [55]Please can I say that I share your reservations too.I won't defend Dyche's tactics and selections, or his in game management and substitutions but - until this season (apparently as of now) they have effectively kept the squad insulated from the 'noise around the club', got us thru two points deductions, and kept us in the league twice.Good luck to him, he has his systems and footballing beliefs and stuck with them.Unfortunately for him, the margins kept falling on the wrong side this season.Just think of the first four games;What would have happened if we put those two big chances away in the first 35 minutes?Spurs, injuries and expectations saw the result we got maybe we conceded one or two more than we should have.Bournemouth, well enough has been written about that fiasco...Villa, DCL scores his 1v1 or Ndiaye passes to McNeil and we go on to win 3-1, 3-2 or what not.Well, we'll never know if he would have kept us up or not now...Good luck to the man. John Keating 87 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:09:02 Half the overpaid arseholes wearing the Blue should be off as well James Marshall 88 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:09:08 Get Mourinho in the door quick-smart!Yes, I'm a glutton for punishment but I can't help liking him. And yes, I know I'm in the minority. Kevin Edward 89 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:10:08 Good grief! Step away from TW for an hour and it all kicks off.Good sense tells me that TFG have someone ready to step in (oven ready).But I have to say seems a bit odd so close to kick off. Id love to know whats been said to Mr Dyche.Cum on feel the noize. This is good news isnt it? Stephen Davies 90 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:10:17 David Ornstein says Mourinho NOT in contention Pete Neilson 91 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:10:18 Looking forward to tonights game now. Strange timing and a brutally short statement from the club. Presumably something fundamental finally broke down between Dyche and TFG over the past day or so. Les Moorcroft 92 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:11:00 John 87They have. Stone and co have gone. Mike Keating 93 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:12:00 Will DCL suddenly discover he hasnt got an ankle injury?Hope so. Bill Gall 94 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:12:17 Though it was fairly predictable the timing was definitely unpredictable. Makes you wonder if they have someone else already lined up.Hope it is someone for the future and not just for the end of the season. Who ever it is he will have the same squad with very little time to add to it unless this has been a well kept secret.Wonder what Dyche will write in his memoirs Richard Starkey 95 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:12:29 Judging by the very curt club statement and Sean Dyches general attitude to life, Its quite possible he got ar*sy with the board and they had no option but to fire him immediately, even though theres a game tonight. Thanks for dragging us out of almost certain relegation the last two years but based on his negative style of football, its better hes gone now with the transfer window open and half a season left. Thats assuming TFG have a plan !!! Dennis Stevens 96 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:12:42 Does this mean TFG have now worked out they have a few bob available without breaching PSR rules? Whoever comes in will want a bit of a budget for players.I'm hoping it'll be a swift turn 'round, with an appointment imminent. Kevin Molloy 97 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:13:26 Mourinho would be so unhappy here. With Liverpool breathing down his neck, no transfer fund, and half a squad. He's already a moaner, imagine him with that? You'd have to think Fonseca is being lined up. Anthony Hawkins 98 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:13:32 I can imagine the conversation:Dyche: 'here's the team sheet - we'll be lucky to beat Peterborough as we can't score'.Board: WTF! Jon Hirshman 99 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:13:35 I don't wish to be pedantic but Dyche already has relegation on his CV. He took Burnley up to the Premiership in his 1st season there. They were relegated the following season but they came back as Champions the season after that and were there until the season he was sacked. Geoff Lambert 100 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:13:51 SKY bemoaning his demise. If only they had to watch his brand of football. Sean O'Hanlon 101 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:14:23 Was that Big Sam I saw leaving Lime Street Station? Ian Edwards 102 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:14:46 It's going to be Dreary Dave. You just know it. Sky saying he's out of work. Knows Baines and Coleman and we can save the money for a striker. Gaute Lie 103 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:15:09 Yes!!! Hopefully we will get a manager who has the ability to better our players. Liam Mogan 104 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:15:24 I've ghost written his memoirs for him Bill 94. Every chapter ends with 'went for 10 pints and a curry with Stoney and Woaney. Toilet blocked next day. Listened to Stereophonics. Top singer. Smell danger' John Graham 105 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:15:41 Strange timing, but great news.Some positivity and now let's hope for some positivity with the team selection. From the list of names in the betting there doesn't appear to be anyone decent available to replace him so keeping fingers crossed we have can poach a good young foreign manager with attacking ideas who hasn't been mentioned. COYB Robert Tressell 106 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:15:59 Mourinho: Categorically ruled out say Talksport? Even off the boil he is a huge personality and would surely keep us up. But is not going to launch us into the top 6 or even top 8 without massive investment in the squad.Sarri: might be a good bet. Has certainly built clubs up. Not sure about his track record about averting disaster at the wrong end of the table. Not sure what he'd make of our current squad.Fonseca: I think at least part of Dyche's downfall was his lack of glamour, and lack of big club look. Fonseca is handsome and foreign, so looks the part (tick) but is not an especially great coach (ups and downs). Quite high risk.But in all honesty, the Friedkin's appointments at Roma indicate we might be overly hopefully as regards these big names. I also think the fact we're being outbid by Ipswich for Philogene indicates how unattractive we might be to a manager right now.For this and various other reasons, I still think Moyes is overwhelmingly the most likely candidate - on a 2 year deal with an option for a 3rd season.Then I suspect the following will have been considered: - Steve Cooper - Edin Terzic - Graham PotterObviously Potter has gone to West Ham (currently the 16th richest club in the world).I don't think Kieran McKenna or Thomas Frank will feature in this at all - because they won't move until summer (each with an eye on the Spurs job).I know lots of other names have been mentioned, and good ones too, but I'm saying here what I think is likely - not what I want. Alan McGuffog 107 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:16:14 OK he's gone. And I'm not at all disappointed. Fascinating to watch later will the players be able to control a ball, pass and move, take a decent throw in ffs ? Because we can't blame him any more Soren Moyer 108 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:16:14 If those on Anthony's list are our only options, I'd re-hire Dyche ASAP!!!! Simon Harrison 109 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:16:34 Just been text a rumour;Ranieri to Everton as an interim, and one of the big names to Roma i.e. Sarri, Allegri or Fonseca!? Doh! Not Conceição....Apparently Fabio Paratici (DoF) going to AS Roma too Geoff Trenner 110 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:17:11 Huge respect to Mr Dyche for keeping us up for the last couple of seasons. I have always been hugely supportive but this season it does feel that all is not well in the camp.I for one wish him well, I have no doubt that hell be back in football, maybe even in the premiership, before long. Andrew Grey 111 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:17:29 I'd much prefer Carsley to Mourinho or Moyes. Martin Reppion 112 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:17:34 Its time to get positive.I'll be right behind the team whoever is in charge as always.Would be happy for different reasons with Carsley or Mourinho.But I still think that in the circumstances, Dyche has to be given credit for riding a headless horse for on long.Cars knackered so can't get over the Pennines tonight.But I'll be screaming at the Telly for 90 minutes. Mark Jensen 113 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:18:04 Two things:1. As he was already on thin ice (he alluded to this in his press conference) timing likely the result of some training ground comments of player issues today.2. Will be interesting team sheet tonight. Brent Stephens 114 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:18:21 Rumour has it that Dyche confronted the new owners this afternoon and asked if they were going to sack him. They clammed up and Dyche resigned because he can't stand people being so defensive. George Cumiskey 115 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:18:47 Gone backwards after supposedly strengthening in the summer should of gone in the international break for me let's hope it isn't too late, I wonder who will be first to say be careful what you wish for on ToffeeWeb 🤔 Tom Bowers 116 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:18:52 I think the new owners have a shortlist already which is usually the case when they fire someone.Sky (if you believe them) mentioned Potter had been contacted but that may have been just Sky and I don't think Potter would have done much but he did shape the Seagulls.Let's see what happens as it needs to be soon. Danny Baily 117 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:19:35 They better have a good manager lined up to replace Dyche. This is a bold move. Alastair Donaldson 118 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:20:19 Can you imagine how much The special one would cost, including when he gets sacked? Semi serious comment that he has the CV, but hes usually had unlimited money to blow. We dont. Dyche had to go, shame he couldnt change his approach but he managed us through chaos so something to thank him for.I understand the feeling from some against Moyes, but I think he might be our best bet to see out this season. His departure left a lot to be desired but I always thought he would have done well with the money Moshiri wafted about early on.Hey ho, no idea whos coming but agreed its a good early test for TFG, hopefully they saw the writing on the wall before the last two disasters.NSNO George Cumiskey 119 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:20:26 Brent Edwards, brilliant 🤣😂 Colin Crooks 120 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:21:27 Nice one Brent.I wasnt sure whether to laugh or cry at the timing. You made me smile instead.The thought of Davey Moyes fills me with a dread I have never experienced. The Mackems made that mistake and have never recovered. George Cumiskey 121 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:21:57 Sorry I mean Brent Stephens Andrew Merrick 122 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:22:51 There will be a buzz around the old lady tonight, enjoy all you going to this one 😀 Barry Rathbone 123 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:24:07 Jose Mourinho - come on down!!! Andy Duff 124 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:24:21 Is history repeating itself 30 years later? Everton only win things with ex players as a manager. 1994/95 we were struggling under Mike Walker. Joe Royal becomes manager, we are saved from relegation and win the FA Cup. Lee Carsley is listed as a candidate. Ex player becomes manager and 30 years of hurt is erased with an FA Cup win. You can but dream Peter Moore 125 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:24:50 I greatly respect the dedicated work done by Sean Dyche and his team.Thank you for keeping us as a Top Flight footballing entity, when the club above him was a vacuous shambles. An excellent custodian of the club in a role that was very different than the one sold to him by his employers. A classy human being Mr Dyche. Well done and sincere appreciation and thanks, from this evertonian. Tim Taylor 126 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:25:48 Peter Moore 125 - indeed was just saying same to my wife. But it really has turned to sh*t this season so I guess best for all concerned Paul Tran 127 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:25:56 Deserves thanks for his first 18 months with us. Deserved the sack for his performance this season. Excellent timing as I'll expect a raucous, celebratory Goodison tonight. Wouldn't surprise me if the interim period lasts the rest of the season. Unless, of course, someone's getting unveiled tomorrow!I do like the silence, followed by action. A much better way of doing things. Mark Jensen 128 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:26:46 Mike 93I guess tonight's team sheet will confirm if DCL was one of the players wanting Dyche gone. Simon Dalzell 129 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:26:50 Thank Goodness. Relief, bordering joy. Really didn't think it would happen on Match Day, so fair play. Friedkins. So it's a Belated Happy New year to all my blue Brothers and Sisters. Ian Edwards 130 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:27:16 Interesting tweet from Paul Joyce saying Dyche told TFG he had taken club as far as he could and that TFG felt he had given up. Ian Edwards 131 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:27:16 Interesting tweet from Paul Joyce saying Dyche told TFG he had taken club as far as he could and that TFG felt he had given up. Paul Ferry 132 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:27:43 Not the worst of news to wake up to on a coldish mid-west morning. Anthony Flack 133 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:28:03 Nicely put Paul @ 127Going to the home games this season expecting us to be shit - is the most damning thing Bill Watson 134 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:28:09 Perfect timing! I thought he would go after the game but this will certainly give the crowd and the players a lift. Jimmy Carr 135 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:28:14 The Friedkins may not even know who Moyes is, could be purely a fans' theory that one. That said, even though I don't particularly like him, he would make sense as a caretaker until the end of the season. But think he'd want a longer contract. James Lawton 136 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:28:38 @125 Peter Moore. Agree with your post. Shaun Parker 137 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:28:45 Bizzare timing.And why didnt we go we not go get Potter? Did we even speak with him?Sure Dyche had to go but the timing is very odd with a few hours until a game.We HAVE to get the right person in for NOW. We need to stabilise, get up the table, bring in some seasoned players to get us up the table.An interim manager would tick the box then appoint a full time manager in the summer.Sky are all over the Dyche sacking.Lepotegui got barely chip paper headlines.Whos the bigger club !! Brendan McLaughlin 138 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:28:49 Always seemed a matter of when rather than if this season but thanks Sean & good luck for the future.On the new man... the Sporting Life, as of 15 minutes ago, are showing David Moyes as odds on favourite. Neil Cremin 139 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:29:30 Saw Anthonys list earlier and though it was realistic if not ideal. Seeing the response only makes me smile.it was not long ago that Eddie HoweNuno Were totally rejected on this website. Now look at how they are doing.Realistically we need an interim manager who 1. Can win back the dressing room.2. Keep us up at all cost this season irrespective of they type of football he plays3. Entice players to join the club in the transfer windowWe can then look for a long term manager for BMD and begin or rise from the ashes of the last few years Simon Harrison 140 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:29:57 Alan McG [107]That's just being mischievous! You rascal you! Hehe Paul Armstrong 141 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:30:46 Peter 125Well said. Mike Corcoran 142 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:31:05 Lopetegui is available😂 James Hughes 143 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:31:28 So continues the shit show that is EFC. To sack a manager of the day of a game leaves too many questions unanswered. Hey ho can we just win tonight please, maybe. Brian Williams 144 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:33:34 I personally don't think Seamus and Leighton could do a worse job than we've seen recently and I'd be tempted to give them a chance and get the manager for the future in the summer.Anyone we bring in now is a huge risk, doesn't matter who he is.The two above will know what's wrong, having witnessed it every week, as well as in training, and will have as good an idea, if not better, of what's needed as any new manager coming in who knows little about the players. Billy Shears 145 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:33:54 Fire up the iPlayer!!!Correction...3-0 Blues. Kieran Kinsella 146 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:34:29 Paul Joyce claims TFG felt Dyche had "quit trying" and felt he had done all he could. Guardian claim he had a falling out with Thelwell. Rob Birks 147 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:34:58 In all honesty, can't say I'm one bit surprised or saddened by this news. Onwards and upwards. COYB Shaun Parker 148 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:35:04 Neil #139Did we not also dither when Arteta wanted to be a manager and leave City?Did we not believe he wasnt experienced enough for us.History tells us otherwise. Jimmy Hogan 149 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:35:36 Barry #127 I'm not sure why Maureen is the bookie's favourite? Didn't they fire him from Roma? Simon Dalzell 150 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:35:40 Ding Dong the Dyche has gone. I reckon Moyes will get the job. Not too excited about that. Brendan McLaughlin 151 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:35:58 Moyes now generally being reported as the favourite to replace Dyche, Ed Prytherch 152 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:36:20 Timing is perfect. Did not want to let him leave on a high note. Fred Charters 153 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:36:45 David Moyes + Lee Carsley for me. Anthony Dove 154 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:36:46 Alan@46. Where on earth does that thinking come from?Personally I will be incredibly stressed until I know for sure the Moyesasaur will not be coming back. Simon Harrison 155 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:37:03 Brendan, has there been any odds on Ranieri being appointed as manager? Shaun Parker 156 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:38:37 Im certain that Moyes will walk through the door.Mixed feelings yes.But we need that experience.We need that stability.We cannot be risky at this time of season and the position we are in. He would be a safe pair of hands (IMHO).We just need to get up the table. Soren Moyer 157 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:38:46 Fat Sam is on standby. Lee Courtliff 158 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:39:20 Someone on here knows someone who knows someone who said to "lump on" Terzic to be our next manager. He's 28/1 at the moment on Sky Bet so I've 'lumped' a tenner on it. And yes to whoever previously said that Baines can't possibly do worse than what we've been witnessing lately. Brendan McLaughlin 159 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:39:39 Simon #155Favourite to replace Moyes😊 Stan Grace 160 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:40:15 Hopefully Moyes is not being considered. Peter Moore 161 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:40:22 After TFG's managerial merry-go-round at Roma, I hope they have learnt from their painful experience in Rome.May they get things right with us, starting with the right manager for now and the exciting future too. Christopher Timmins 162 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:40:31 To allow him to hold the Press conference yesterday and then sack him today, is that better or worse than West Ham allowing their manager to take training earlier in the week?He kept us up two years ago and he provided us with a more than solid set of results last year but this year has seen a decline.An interesting few days ahead. Given the absolute necessity of staying in the league an experienced Manager is required. Whoever is chosen I will be behind him from day one!Good luck to our former full backs tonight, hopefully, they will get a tune out a mediocre set of players. Danny Baily 163 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:40:38 Mourinho is second favourite at the moment and is the only decent manager in the running. Mike Gaynes 164 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:40:49 When people talk about a manager being sacked in the tunnel, usually they mean right after the game. Not on the way in.I honestly expected our new owners to wait a little longer, but I'll say this for TFG, when they decide it's time, they move.PT #127 gets it right for me. John Hughes 165 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:40:56 If Dyche took training this morning then clearly the plan was to have him in charge tonight. I would conclude that an agreement has been made with his successor earlier today and they were concerned that it might leak prior to kick off. Might be misreading it completely of course 🙄 Stuart Sharp 166 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:42:50 165About taking training... that's not what happened at West Ham. Kevin Molloy 167 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:44:14 Joyce is saying Dyche wanted out without resigning and made this clear. So a bit of bad feeling there, they didn't want to sack him. Moyes now of interest apparently. Mike Gaynes 168 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:44:28 Agree John #165. Can't imagine they'd sack Dyche without having his replacement already locked in. Paul Ferry 169 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:45:40 The timing of this could not be more embarrassing for Dyche. Reports do say sacked rather than resigned.I have a pleasant image of the three hard-boiled eggs and bags and cases crammed into Woaney's 1999 Ford Fiesta driving back to Nottingham or, better still, thumbing lifts outside the Rocket.The book(s) will be interesting. Jimmy Hogan 170 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:46:34 Moyes will hold out for a long deal, knowing we have no option. We'd just be treading water again. No way do I want him back. It never works coming back to club. Look at Kendall with us and Mourinho with Chelsea. Terry Downes 171 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:46:57 Danny personally I would say Fonseca would be the best fit for us a change of direction completely instead of the same old boring style of walking football Shaun Parker 172 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:47:17 Moyes, Ferguson, Baines and David Weir and Tim Cahill !!!!Dream team!!! Stephen Davies 173 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:47:34 Board felt Dyche had “given up” Edward Rogers 174 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:48:54 Wow George @115 too late, already had a couple of "careful what you wish for's"Honestly,no idea who's right for the job, but 6/1 Gary O'Neil!!!!Are the bookies taking the piss? Paul Ferry 175 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:49:13 Well at least he made the players 'ten times better' and, he's right, the recent run of results does look better if we add wins. Ian Edwards 176 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:49:32 Paul Joyce suggests discussing pay off for few days so Dyche must have known before presser yesterday he was leaving. Bobble saying meeting with Dreary Dave tomorrow. Kevin Molloy 177 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:49:42 whoever we get will probably follow the same deal Potter's got. 2.5 years depending on any hurdles sorted. He's cost us there Dyche has. Its another ten million down the swanny to whoever we now appoint unless we keep them for the long term. Ben King 178 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:50:19 It might ultimately be the right decision but I feel like we could show a lot more respect to Dyche. He did terrific before this season - surely we can appreciate that with some respect. Jonathan Oppenheimer 179 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:50:52 Dyche was never going to take us to the promised land, but for keeping us (barely) afloat these last 2 seasons, Ill remain grateful. May he find his footing helping other clubs stave off relegation or helping them get promoted.Well never know what he couldve done with better players, and well find out what others will do with our below-average squad, but lets hope for a bounce these next few weeks. We sure as hell need it. Ed Prytherch 180 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:51:04 Mourhino's win percentage at Roma was 49%. Just saying. Martin Mason 181 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:52:02 Mourinho is old hat and a has been, Moyes is a never was. don't look backward with names like this, appoint dynamic and keen without big management pretention just coaching. Get out of the past Blues and into the present and the game has changed, the has beens just missed it that's all. Dan Parker 182 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:52:17 Wow, bbc:There have been a couple of days of talks this week between ownership and Sean Dyche with both sides feeling they had reached the end of the road. Denver Daniels 183 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:52:22 Damn! Just woke up to this here in NZ. Did not see this one coming, not the timing at least. Gerry Quinn 184 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:52:42 Apparently they have had 2 days of talks with Dyche and he stated that he had taken us as far as he could - no option but to tell him to sod off then, eh? Jimmy Salt 185 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:52:52 Please not Moyes Rob Dolby 186 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:53:00 Ian 176, The bobble is usually reliable. It would be just a very sad appointment imo.If Moyes is the height of the new owners ambition we are in for another long period of meh. Shane Corcoran 187 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:53:28 Fkn Moyes zzzzzzz Simon Harrison 188 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:53:56 Thanks Brendan.I know another web-warrior, a UK Blue working in Italy, so he's been following AS Roma.There is a very strong rumour going around that because Everton is currently 'unattractive' and our PL survival isn't secured yet, no-one of any note wants to manage us.However, it seems that other than paying relocation expenses for Ranieri, who knows and has won the PL, would be willing to firefight for us, while TFG will ask one of Sarri, Allegri or Fonseca to take over. Along with a rumour that Fabio Paratici, Spurs old DoF with Conte, who wanted Fonseca after Conte left will be joining Roma too...Who knows what will happen... I know I wasn't expecting this, and was calm about Dyche staying till the Villa game in truth. Stuart Sharp 189 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:55:39 Well I'm...- shocked by the timing- glad to be looking forward to going to Goodison tonight, for the first time in months- worried about the likely replacementsBonkers stuff. Shaun Parker 190 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:55:45 We shouldnt pay too much respect to Dyche, hell get his contract paid up. Not a bad days work. Derek Powell 191 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:56:08 Thank god he's gone he should never have been giving the job from the start I said when he came here we will become the Burnley of old and we did, but for gods sake chase Moyes as far away from this club lets look forward lets bring in the best out there my vote goes with Edin Terzic not Moyes allerdydce or any other has bean Kevin Molloy 192 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:56:10 Moyes is the perfect candidate for where we are. WE need some good signings, and to move up the table, Moyes can do that side of things better than Carlo in my view. Once we get to the promised land of eighth, we can boot him. That 'll take a couple of years minimum. So give him 2.5 years and off we go. Martin Mason 193 Posted 09/01/2025 at 17:58:38 Moyes will want a role in managing the club and that is not what is needed, that is for the board and DoF. We need a coach. Moyes will be a total disaster long term. Mike Gaynes 194 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:00:09 Gerry #184, yep, that would do it! Ed Prytherch 195 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:01:04 Moyes' transfer dealings at Sunderland were not impressive. Jeff Armstrong 196 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:01:24 Not my choice but Moyes till the end of season then becomes DOF ? Jay Harris 197 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:01:30 Moyes for 18 months should give time for Danny Rohl to develop and be ready for the job or Fonseca immediately.Cant really see any other options now Mourhino is ruled out. Joe McMahon 198 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:01:58 It won't be Mourinho. It's going to be bloody Moyes isn't it. 🫤 Stuart Sharp 199 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:03:13 Harsh Derek 191. He was a sensible option in dire circumstances, and deserves at least a bit of respect for the last two seasons. But yes, I shed no tear over his departure. John Keating 200 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:03:35 Wow said for days Baines and Coleman should take the team!!Really late in the day to be honestHopefully they will both read the players the riot act! Ian Jones 201 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:04:06 I've had a quick look through the posts and can't see anyone mentioning Wayne Rooney. Assume if BK had been around, Wayne would have made to any short-list by now.I don't really mind who comes in as long as they realise that players in the right positions helps, have an appreciation that defending a nil-nil and trying to nick a nil-nil meaning that 38 draws results in 38 points is never going to cut it among Evertonians, and also have an appreciation of the opposition half and especially the opposing penalty area and recognise this an area to be explored.I like Sean Dyche and believe he does generally talk a load of sense, have watched some of his master classes and they are really informative but his football leaves a lot to be desired. To be fair, he's just another manager that got worn down by the basket case of a club that we have become.Good luck to him. Will be interesting to see where he and his management team crop up next. Paul Ferry 202 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:04:34 Rob Edwards is available! Kieran Kinsella 203 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:06:49 Mike Walker always claimed he would have been "bomb proof" if he had managed won the next game. Let's give him a chance for redemption. Vinny Samways back too he is probably in similar physical shape as he was then. Andrew McLawrence 204 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:06:58 Hooray! Looking at the options tho, can I be the first to say, DYCHE IN ! Sean Kearns 205 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:07:05 People say no to Moyes or Mourinho but yes to Carsly or McKenna etc who are total gambles!! We are in a relegation scrap, we need a solid choice with PL experience. Anything else is a gamble we cant afford! Its not ideal but Moyes is the best candidate for our current situation. We have a solid back 5, just need to a good bounce of morale and Goodison can play its part too!!!!! Moyes always knew what we wanted, a big dirty tackle early in big games to get the crowd onside etc. Dyche never played to the Goodison faithful and shes a special place when shes rocking. Steve Dowdeswell 206 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:08:26 Genuinely wasn't expecting to read this when I logged in just now!Did they wait until Potter was confirmed at West Ham and then push the button.Hopefully the team can start to push on and play the way they need to now and get some much needed results on the board. Pat Kelly 207 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:08:33 Moyes would be a safe pair of hands in the short term. And a safe pair of hands in the long term. We need more than a safe pair of hands in the long term. But we are where we are and, for now, safety comes first. If its to be Moyes, the contract will be interesting. James Marshall 208 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:09:00 Please not Moyes. We need to look to the future not the past. He's another Dychian dinosaur, the very thing people have been complaining about!OK maybe Mourinho is a bit old hat as well. Ajay Gopal 209 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:10:22 I join those who appreciate Dyche for keeping us in the PL during one of the most tumultuous times in our history. I thought he represented us well and did his best despite being hamstrung by the financial misdeeds of the past. Everton FC has always respected for conducting themselves in a classy manner, so it is disappointing to see the club statement not having at least a token gesture of gratitude for his and his staffs work.Having said that, the results and performances had become stale and especially the lack of goals had gotten alarming. Will things get hugely better under a new coach ? Unlikely, unless TFG are able to bring in a couple of high quality players and the injured can get back quickly. Having McNeil, Garner and Tim Iroegbunam simultaneously unavailable affected Dyches attacking game plan dramatically and he couldnt adjust unfortunately.Looking forward, I had a secret name who I wanted us to consider as our next coach in the summer. But sadly, Jimmy Thelins (Aberdeen coach) has fallen as dramatically as it had risen. But, NO to Moyes please. Joe McMahon 210 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:11:16 Pat@207. If you are ever in Sunderland please don't repeat that. Denver Daniels 211 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:11:40 We don't have a Bowen, Paqueta or Kudus to bail him out so a big fat no to Moyes. Pat Kelly 212 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:12:09 But Joe, he gets us Ian Jones 213 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:12:14 James, I wouldn't be a fan of Moyes returning, partly for the reason you mention. However, he did win West Ham a European trophy - I'd take any trophy these days Edward Rogers 214 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:12:30 Talkshite ripping us to pieces. "Disrespectful to Peterborough" "Did a great job" Who do they think they are" etc.etc.W*****'s Anthony Flack 215 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:15:39 Talkshite - needs no further explanation - they'll get Simon Jordan on in a minute - another tosser Andrew McLawrence 216 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:16:01 Would we have Rooney in some sort of Assistant/Attack coach position? John Keating 217 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:16:33 See how Baines and Coleman do over the next few gamesIf they get the bounce and keep us up leave until the end of the seasonTake time to get it right and not a knee jerk reaction Robert Tressell 218 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:16:58 Sam # 205, I would say yes to McKenna in summer, after survival and after an injection of funds. There's surely no point talking about him (or Frank) now. Paul Ferry 219 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:17:28 You can be sure on. the Luton equivalent of ToffeeWeb that people are posting "Not fucking Dyche. Please not fucking Dyche!". Mike Hayes 220 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:18:10 Heard he told TFG hed gone as far as he could - limited as a manager or told theres no money for transfers? Given his stubbornness and refusal to bring in an attacking coach - then is he admitting hes reached his peak as a premier league manager 🤷 Derek Knox 221 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:18:43 Just heard Dyche saying he is now available !Luton Job up for grabs. :-) Martin Mason 222 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:21:02 With a DoF the system still has to be hierarchical. You can't have a big ego at DoF and Head Coach. The HC has to answer to the DoF not to to have a permanent personality clash. Young, intelligent and dynamic not another old bogey. Moyes and Mourinho aren't proven any more, they are massive risks. Kieran Kinsella 223 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:21:46 AndrewWhat makes you think Rooney warrants any type of coaching role? He has a miserable track record of failure as a coach and anyone less famous would never have worked after DC United much less got the Plymouth or Birmingham jobs in replacing lesser known managers who'd been doing well. Yes, he was a great player but the idea he might be a good attacking coach is based on nothing but his player reputation and that was the logic that saw him become a manager. Presumably, there are good experienced attacking coaches out there who'd probably cost less. Paul Smith 224 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:21:58 Looks like it's Moyes - it is what it is... Shane Corcoran 225 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:24:15 Moyes just went from 1/5 to 1:9 and back to 2/13 Annika Herbert 226 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:24:23 Pleased to see Dyche has gone as I think he had done all he could over the last 2 seasons. The football has been so poor recently.But a definite no to Moyes returning. Ok he won a Europeans cup for West Ham. But he was unable to push off from that. The Hammers fans certainly werent happy with him. Lets not forget how poor Moyes was, and still is, with strikers. He has mastered the art of how to ruin a striker.Mind you, he couldnt do much damage with our strikers, most of them have been ruined already Alan Corken 227 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:25:36 I admire the way on Tuesday Dyche manned up and faced the cameras, even though he clearly knew he was a dead man walking. By keeping us in the premier league until the new regime took over, he did the job that was asked of him when appointed. This current season however, was a season too far. Like soldiers holding the front, both he and his team are exhausted and in need of being relieved.The new manager, whoever that may be will need to bring some new recruits and tactics to see us through the rest of the season. Thanks Shaun, no hard feelings and good luck for the future. IMO you will always be welcome when you visit Everton Brian Acheson 228 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:26:04 Baz on Toffee TV said Baines was told on Monday that he'd be preparing the team for tonight. Jim Bennings 229 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:29:08 Looks like being Moyes The Bobble which is quite reliable is stating he's meeting the Friedkin's tomorrow Terry Downes 230 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:30:32 Serves him right lets be honest he wouldnt play Patterson or Dixon he woukd of rather kept Young there who was only bought as cover ? Then theres O,Brien bought as Keanes replacement I assume never given him a run ? Lindstrum in and out like a fiddlers elbow ? then Ndiaye given a run but on the left really ? I can also remember when Keane kept Branthwaite out for ages when we all knew it was bollocks ?? He got what he deserved fk him Scott Montgomery 231 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:31:21 Dyche shouldnt be pilloried here, he did a difficult job over the last couple of years but at the same time a decision had to be made and I feel its right for all concerned.I will be incredibly disappointed if the coach of choice is Mourinho however, we just dont need the circus that inevitably comes with him and if you think Dyches football was dour go chat to Spurs supporters about his tenure. It has been suggested that hiring Mourinho would convince DCL to sign a new contract….I personally dont want either. Go get Ange from Spurs please. James Marshall 232 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:31:30 Moyes full time or Moyes till the end of the season? I could just about stomach him for half a season. Shane Corcoran 233 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:32:46 Moyes said just last week that he didnt want to be joining a club thats fighting relegation. Denis Richardson 234 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:32:55 As noted above, v odd timing. Must have been something give behind the scenes.Either way, the squads good enough to win tonight and TFG have a few days to get a new man in by Villa.New chapter. PLEASE NOT MOYES! Kieran Kinsella 235 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:34:57 Moyes doesn't have experience of successfully managing a relegation battle. Remember that one year at Everton where we ended up on 39 points and survived only because everyone else was worse. At Sunderland he went in with his negative attitude and seemed to accept relegation immediately. He has never shown the ability to turn a team around in that situation. Even when he first arrived we weren't really in the relegation mix we were sort of the best of the rest mid tableish teams. Tony McNulty 236 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:35:54 No surprise here. A lot of us called this decision in recent days Rick Tarleton 237 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:36:46 Usually the statement contains at least a perfunctory thank you. This suggests that it was not in any way a mutual parting of the ways. God knows who'll come next. Paul Hewitt 238 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:39:51 Moyes meeting TFG tomorrow.👍 Steve Shave 239 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:40:09 Alan @227, classy post! You are right, as relieved as many are on here (myself included) I believe SD's legacy should be the terrific job he did up to this season, under possibly the worst circumstances faced by a PL manager. I feel no ill will towards him, it's just time. Neil Cremin 240 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:42:09 ShaunYou made my point. Thanks. Again stating the obvious what we need now is someone who can keep us in the PL and that should only be an interim appointment.Moyes may meet our needs until the Summer but long term for me no going back. Mourinho, he is good but needs a lot of money to buy players to get his success, Not sure he can work with limited resources whereas Moyes has proved he can.Potter was better with limited resources but couldn't handle the bid egos at Chelsea. Moyes had the same problem at United.I would like to take a chance with Carsley in the Summer but he is too much of a risk at this time.As for the other trophy managers, who would risk their reputation to come to us at this stage of the season. I said never go back but Ancelotti would do or maybe Davide with the guidance of his father. (Dream on) Chris Corn 241 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:42:14 Kieran 235, Moyes has turned Everton around on a number of occasions. 2005/6 we were bottom of the table at New Year and Cahill scored at the death v Sunderland and we finished 11th. Also in seasons we didn't finish in the top 6/7, he had a number of awful starts and finished in mid table safety. Go on the Everton stats website and you'll see that Gee, never thought I'd ever defend him after all them big game capitulations.Just need a crazy Dutch winger and it'll be full on retro. Paul Ferry 242 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:42:24 I'd rather have Moyes for a few months than Dyche but I don't want Moyes for a few months. Paul Ferry 243 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:43:55 The lack of a thanks in that bald statement verges on the astonishing. Colin Glassar 244 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:44:17 Im chuffed to bits that the Kettering ginger minger has gone. He might be a nice guy, and he did keep us up but, my god that was some of the worst “football” Ive seen Everton ever play.It was embarrassing to watch. The negativity. The lack of tactical nous. The mind numbing long ball tactics. Jack Harrison etc…Dyche leaves as an even richer man than when he came. This is a results based game and the results were, lately, pathetic. As for entertainment value, no comment.Looks like Moyes will return. More negative play but at least, imo, hell keep us up. Just hope its not long term James Marshall 245 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:44:26 If we get Moyes it'll just be another retrograde step as if Bill was still in the room.Unless the Friedkin's think it'll ingratiate then with the fan base. It won't. Brendan McLaughlin 246 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:44:28 Yes Shane #233But I predict it will be: "But when Everton contacted me via Jenny on Blue Bill's old mobile... I just couldn't say no" Martin Mason 247 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:46:01 Is it quantifiable that Dyche kept us up rather than kept us down in the weeds? Time will tell but because we stayed up doesn't mean that Dyche kept us up. We will know by the end of the season. Iakovos Iasonidis 248 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:46:16 Good news...Thank you Dyche for keeping us up last 2 years and good luck...Don't want Moyes, not excited about mourinho...we shall see... Paul Smith 249 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:46:31 Well it looks like those who have mooted Moyes return and those that were opposed are about to find out who was right. I was always against it but it will be an improvement on Dyche. Some reports that Dyche wanted out and had taken us as far as he could, hence timing of dismissal - all conjecture on X though. Gerry Quinn 250 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:46:41 Get Harry H in with this lot of "players"! Gerry Quinn 251 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:46:41 Get Harry H in with this lot of "players"! Edward Rogers 252 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:47:23 Apparently Jose has ruled himself out. Gerry Quinn 253 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:47:41 Houdini...that is Chris Corn 254 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:48:38 Dyche has been relegated with Burnley and was sacked just before they went down in 2022. This narrative from early posters he has no relegation on his CV is not correct. Merson also changed his tune when he backed us to go down last week because we're not set up to win games and draws are no good. He's now saying if any team is in the bottom 3 or 4, they'll go for Dyche as he'll keep them up. Go figure. Craig Scott 255 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:49:47 I sense that most posters are disregarding the obvious fact that it's our inept squad that are largely attributable for our piss poor form. Yes, the manager's tactics and training approaches are a big factor, but the manager isn't responsible for the endless misplaced passes and lack of ball control that our players frequently display. The manager departs but the same players remain. We've gone through how many managers over the years including the 'great' Carlo Anchelotti, and two of them have since been hired as managers of reputable international teams, so how bad were they really?I get that the manager has to take the rap for the failings of the team, but our main issue is getting in some decent players and that isn't happening overnight. Paul Ferry 256 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:49:49 verton XI: Virginia, Patterson, O'Brien, Keane, Branthwaite, Mykolenko, Gana (c), Mangala, Armstrong, Ndiaye, Beto. Subs: Begovic, Leban, Harrison, Doucoure, Young, Broja, Lindstrøm, Broja.Broja x2. Gerry Quinn 257 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:50:09 Big Dunc (on a temporary basis) might kick some really serious shit into this lot - anybody agree? Ian Edwards 258 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:50:28 5 at the back against Peterborough!!! Baines out. James Marshall 259 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:52:31 No. Can we just drop the obsession with ex players and managers. Paul Smith 260 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:53:27 Gerry - just no! Christine Foster 261 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:54:00 Relief. Liam Mogan 262 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:54:47 Big Joe Royle with Wayne Rooney, Big Dunc, Bainsey and Jose Baxter Paul Smith 263 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:56:23 Liam 😄 nepo babies Colin Glassar 264 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:57:28 James M, we have Moyes widowers on here now it looks like weve got a couple of Dyche ones and big dunc ones as well. No wonder other fans laugh at us with this sentimental, backward looking bullshit. Paul Ferry 265 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:58:56 Moyes, Dyche, the non-legend Duncan, Unsworth, much of a muchness Paul Hewitt 266 Posted 09/01/2025 at 18:59:59 Moyes I think with guarantee us Premier league football for next season. Christy Ring 267 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:02:23 Joyce said he had a falling out with the owners, maybe that's why there was no statement of thanks, and they had to sack him, because Dyche was never going to resign and lose out on the rest of his contract over £2m. Stu Darlington 268 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:02:33 Lots of names and opinions on this thread but the only important factor is the new manager must be capable of winning enough games with this squad to avoid relegation.That is the bottom line,non-negotiable.Not being in the Premier League when we move into the new stadium would be disastrous in terms of money,marketing,attracting better players,public relations and many other things.I personally dont want Moyes back,but if he is the best option to keep us up, then so be it on a short term basis.I know nobody can guarantee success but I really havent seen enough of the managers named to make other than an uninformed and therefore an emotive choice.Not good enough when so much is at stake.Robert @106Im intrigued by your statement that Mourhino would surely keep us up.what evidence do you have for that? Svein-Roger Jensen 269 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:03:37 Moyes has agreed to return to Everton. Derek Powell 270 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:06:08 Moyes's record since he bailed on us:Man Utd: 26 W 10 D 15 L, Win Rate 51%, 1 SeasonSociedad: 12 W 15 D 15 L, Win Rate 29%, 1 SeasonSunderland: 8 W 7 D 28 L, Win Rate 19%, 1 SeasonWest Ham: 9 W 10 D 12 L, Win Rate 29%, 1 SeasonWest Ham: 104 W 43 D 84 L, Win Rate 45%, 5 Seasons Sean Kelly 271 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:07:33 Thank god hes gone. Another positive is the friedkins are reading my posts. I along with a couple of others suggested Baines and Seamus in charge on an interim basis a few weeks back. Thank you Dan my man from Texas. Robert Tressell 272 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:07:34 Stu # 268 - no evidence at all. He's never managed a team in anything like this situation. But he is a huge personality even now and I think this would create a short term lift. Plus he knows how to organise a defence.However, I expect this is all completely academic because I'd be amazed if he is our next manager. Colin Glassar 273 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:08:13 Just rumours Svein Svein-Roger Jensen 274 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:08:41 There will be huge consequences if the wrong decision is made. Martin Mason 275 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:09:31 Over the years I've thought that the demise of Everton was becoming an inevitability. We may be converging on that point now like walking over a cliff with a blindfold on. Christine Foster 276 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:20:03 Martin, at least it's not as bad as walking off a cliff with the blindfold off led by the Pied Piper..."Sean, Sean, that's a cliff!""Noo, it's just a step, you'll be fine" Mal van Schaick 277 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:20:54 No shots on goal V Bournemouth. His big mouth got the better of him.No manager is bigger than Everton Football Club. The dawn of a new era. Michael Kenrick 278 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:20:57 Seems it's been in the works for a few days... disagreements over compensation...Oh, and where was The Bobble on this? Any other leaks before 4:30? Raymond Fox 279 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:21:30 Well, we will find out now if our position is down to the quality of the players which it is in my opinion, or was it all Dyche's fault.I just hope it doesnt go pear shaped. Denver Daniels 280 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:21:34 West Ham conceded 74 league goals in Moyes's last season there. Nearly 2 goals a game. I'm not so sure he'd be a safe bet to keep us up. Ray Mia 281 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:23:22 Im tired of this bullshit.Im happy Dyche saved our arses - I still cant believe we didnt get relegated, but we are shit and play like shit and even though we have a shiny new stadium and new owners - what did we do against Wolves and Bournemouth? Thats right, set up and play like absolute shit.Would you not want to impress your new rich American owners? Or would you sit there saying… its all money and pies and the quality of gravy and its a bit cold and we need to run around bleep testing and we need to aim low and grind out draws and not have a single shot on goal…Im hearing he didnt want to resign - so he and his team get 7 figure payouts… FairPlay…Moyes? Mostly played like shit, but very, very hard to beat… ugly… ugly… but hated playing top 4 teams. Supercharged Mediocrity…Dont want to look back.Still have Allardyce/Lee nightmares let alone Raf Beneathus…Id love Carsley, with Baines and Coleman - too romantic.Or German Edin…Or even Ten Hag… show everyone what he can do… because he won stuff with a shower of over paid shite…Whoever it is - someone who can kick the shit out of DCL so have start scoring again…“You can wear the skirt and the strap ons on your days off… but put the blue shirt on and score some fucking goals you little prick” Paul Ferry 282 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:27:40 According to Baines on 5Live it was Dyche who picked this team for tonight. Colin Glassar 283 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:28:42 Bainsey is fibbing Paul Ferry 284 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:29:12 What a nasty cretinous homophobic asshole you are Ray Mia:“You can wear the skirt and the strap ons on your days off… but put the blue shirt on and score some fucking goals you little prick” Paul Ferry 285 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:29:36 He's not CG/ Luke Welch 286 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:34:52 Was Dyche sacked? Or mutual termination? Michael Lynch 287 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:35:44 Moyes on a 2½-year contract, based on his success at West Ham. I could live with that if he keeps us up, gets into Europe, and wins a trophy. Which is what he did for the Hammers. Paul Kossoff 288 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:38:29 Well I've just read he's finally gone, surprised yes, thankful definitely. Bye bye, Sean Dyche, and good riddance.I'm sure some other daft get of a club will give you a few million to con the fans and put them into a state of dispair. Next!!! Martin Berry 291 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:43:19 Leighton Baines came across very well when interviewed prior to the game, it will be interesting to see how he and Seamus come through this difficult time. Daniel A Johnson 293 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:46:35 Thanks for for keeping us up in the last two seasons Sean. But honestly this season and his sacking is a disaster of his own making.Good riddance no premiership manager can survive with a record as bad as his. Justin Doone 294 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:53:56 As is often said in life and football, be careful what you wish for. I want the owners to demonstrate they are not a bunch of footballing charlatans. To achieve this surely a quick appointment to demonstrate some thought and planning has gone into this decision.I'm a patient person. I don't need or necessarily want a 'name' or an ego. Not a combustible type that will demands millions more whilst spending erratically on marmite players. We need someone who can harmonise and build a team and squad. Someone who is adaptable, who understands we need results and performances can wait. Get it wrong and we are a titanic club. Christy Ring 295 Posted 09/01/2025 at 19:56:09 Michael #278, If it's been in the works for a few days, they must have talked to Potter? Anthony Jones 296 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:05:46 Yeah, looks like we are still rubbish... Scott Hamilton 297 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:10:58 I just hope that Dyche's severance package prevents him from managing one of our ‘peers' for the remainder of the season. I'm not sure I could stomach seeing him turnaround one of the other contenders for relegation. It'd be the ultimate kick in the bollocks.Apparently Moyes is our number 1 target and I'm not sure how I feel about that TBH. The last time I consistently enjoyed watching us play was under his tenure but I would normally say that you should never go back. I'm also pretty certain that he wouldn't have been TFG's ‘number 1 choice' if matters hadn't come to a head over the last week. Hopefully they know what they're doing. Being frank, it would make a fucking change. Martin Farrington 298 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:16:44 Well wasnt expecting that tonight.I watched all our league games and we were without doubt getting worse each passing minute.Players who clearly couldnt be arsed, don't care, are poor and not PL standard, not following any plan that they might have been instructed to follow, out of sorts with themselves and each other etc I think, for whatever reason, he had lost the dressing room long ago (not that he has been here that long - just seems it)No way back when that happens Dyche is a saviour. Like it or not.He has now gone down in history, stopping us from doing so.His stats will be measured alongside other quality names like Allardyce, Benitez & Lampard in the Mike Walker book of Footballing Horrors at EFC.Ultimately, Dyche was offered a poison chalice.The club was / is in ruins thanks to the dead twat. But he took it on. With points deductions - twice !!!A squad that had to play 100% every game, no mistakes coz there were no goals in it.I maintain (to an opposing view of several wisened TW experts / veterans) that he was knee capped by DoF Thelwell. Incoming players being appalling in the majority, to an already threadbare (and kept threadbare) below standard squad. Considering Thelwell has written a book "Coaching The European 3-5-2", something his manager buddy was clueless in regards to both on the field and from Thelwells sainted texts, his acquisitions didnt back his own philosophy.Nor that of a 4-5-1 hoof it and hope manager.But that is all in the past.Well Dyche is.I didnt like his style of football. However I will always hold a high regard for what he did in terms of keeping Everton from falling into the abyss. A place we permanently teeter upon the edge of.Good luck wherever your journey takes you Sean Martin Farrington 299 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:21:40 Please NOT MOYES Ernie Baywood 300 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:28:57 Si, according to the Guardian there had been negotiations all week between Dyche and TFG regarding the pay off.'Relieved of duties' will typically mean he's been paid whatever he was due under his contract. No 'mutual consent' here. The Guardian also reporting that Dyche had told TFG that couldn't do any more with this team and TFG felt he had effectively quit doing the job. Joe McMahon 301 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:51:06 Alan Myers, says on twitter David Moyes has held discussions with The Friedkin Group and could make a return to Everton as early as this weekend. Bollox. Clive Rogers 302 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:53:22 Id sooner give Baines and Colman a run in charge than go back to Moyes. Too negative. Danny Baily 303 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:55:48 If Moyes is the answer, the question wasn't worth asking. Paul Smith 304 Posted 09/01/2025 at 20:58:53 Is the ghost of Kenwright in Friedkins ear ? Ray Jacques 305 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:02:06 Watching this game, can we get Dyche back pls? Lol Denver Daniels 306 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:02:47 Surely TFG had a replacement lined up before pulling the pin? The timing doesn't make sense otherwise.I hope the cutlery's been sharpened for all the gunfights if Moyes does come back. Peter Jansson 307 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:07:05 Not a second too late. This was going nowhere. Dyches anti football 70ies style of play would have gotten us relegated. Christy Ring 308 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:09:51 Personally I don't think bringing Moyes back is the way forward, I would support Carsley, who has a good backup team. Christy Ring 309 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:11:54 Ray#305 You do know Dyche picked this team? Mal van Schaick 310 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:16:47 Sky reporting that the TFG have held talks with Moyes ffs. He walked pit on us for Manure. No second chances. Simon Dalzell 311 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:22:16 Underwhelmed by the thought of Moyes. I'd much rather have Carsley or Fonseca Maybe. We've done the Moyes 'thing'. We need more ambition than that. Moyes with Carsley Certainly, but That doesn't seem likely. Mike Price 312 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:33:23 Joe McMahon 313 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:36:24 For those mentioning Carsley, he's said he want to back to 21s. He's not interested. Simon Harrison 314 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:38:19 Ranieri's interest in EvertonPosted six days ago... Peter Jansson 315 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:43:09 Moyes is about the same as Dyche. Can not be true Ernie Baywood 316 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:54:20 I wouldn't associate Moyes and Dyche. Moyes was pretty conservative in his tactics and selections. Dyche was just scared and tried to keep the score down. Andrew Clare 317 Posted 09/01/2025 at 21:55:47 Moyes will be a disaster. Do not appoint him. He is another dinosaur. Colin Glassar 318 Posted 09/01/2025 at 22:03:07 Dycheosaur Vs Dino Dave, Andrew? Denis Richardson 319 Posted 09/01/2025 at 22:03:22 Bringing Moyes back would be brave of TFG. A sizeable portion of the fanbase vehemently dont want him. Not as bad as Benitez but not far behind. A couple of bad results and itll get very ugly quickly. I really hope we get a fresh face in. Moyes 12 years on is not the answer. Andrew Clare 320 Posted 09/01/2025 at 22:08:28 Both awful Colin. Negative and tactically inept.Moyes is a loser, not all what we need. Svein-Roger Jensen 322 Posted 09/01/2025 at 22:48:21 Dyche relieved of his duties, he did well keeping us up when he arrived but has been terrible this season. TFG have been ruthless with their on and off the field decisions since being here. Wont be a given with Moyes, we need some good signings in or hes going to struggle too. Justin Doone 323 Posted 09/01/2025 at 22:55:11 Martinez, Koeman, Sam.Silva, Carlo, Raf, Frank, Dyche.A crazy list. Chalk and cheese. Play, don't play. No consistency. No best fit. Too attacking, too defensive or just WRONG!Through it all, player recruitment has been generally terrible and overly expensive. Fix that and we improve every next managers chances. Nigel Scowen 324 Posted 09/01/2025 at 23:07:40 Exactly Jim,We wont go down with Moyes, reset in the summer. Andy Riley 325 Posted 09/01/2025 at 23:16:29 I think the major problem from all sides is that Dyche's contract was up at the end of the season. With no appetite (rightly in my view) to extend it he's effectively been working his notice period since TFG completed the takeover. If we'd have been mid-table, that could have continued. I think possibly Dyche and his team may have said "Either extend us or sack us" – which brought things to a head? Andy Crooks 326 Posted 09/01/2025 at 23:37:48 Colin, surely it can't be Moyes. For me, it would be the lowest point as an Evertonian to see him back. Sean Kearns 327 Posted 09/01/2025 at 23:41:41 The new manager must have Premier League experience, no time to take chances… By giving up Dyche, we must also consider we may have strengthened another relegation rival and make our own job harder. He could walk into Southampton or Ipswich tomorrow and make them more solid. Anthony Jones 328 Posted 09/01/2025 at 23:49:55 I suspect Dyche wasn't happy with them talking to other managers after all. Why would he be? Then it is all over the news about crisis talks. How does that stuff get leaked?Dyche is pretty straightforward for a modern manager. I reckon he stood up for his coaches and told them to just pay off their contracts. Many fans seem to forget that managers and coaches are human beings with families. Nigel Scowen 329 Posted 09/01/2025 at 23:51:09 Sean There is no way Ipswich are taking Sean Dyche over McKenna and Southampton have just appointed a new Manager. Ed Prytherch 330 Posted 09/01/2025 at 23:54:27 I doubt that Dyche will coach another Premier League team. The whole football world now knows his limitations. Tim Greeley 331 Posted 09/01/2025 at 00:05:25 Moyes is better than Steve Cooper The Odious. I became an Evertonian during the last 5 years of Moyes and I did really like most of that time, especially compared with the insanity post-Martinez. The last two seasons of Moyes were fun! Is there a Fellaini 2.0 anywhere out there?! Crazy that Seamus was playing under Moyes and is still going! Seems sooo long ago. Moyes can do his thing here for 5 months, grind out more wins than Dyche seemed to be able to and get us ready for the new stadium. So says I! Lester Yip 332 Posted 09/01/2025 at 00:09:06 Dyche, thanks for keeping us afloat in the most dire time. Even though it's ugly to watch, you've brought back fitness and hardworking mentality into the team and becoming harder to beat. I can't blame you for we can't score goals as we've been shit in that area for so many years. I hope the incoming manager is not a playout from the back coach. Not the time when money is a constraint. Just maintain the good defensive structure, work on the 2nd ball and set-pieces tactics. The xG should turn into goals. I wish. Ernie Baywood 333 Posted 10/01/2025 at 00:10:00 Ed – I think you'd be surprised. Dyche was pretty good at 'changing the story'. A quick look around the media today and it seems like plenty buy into his stories.The commentator we got for the game tonight was amazed we had sacked him. He rolled out the usual 'saved them ', 'worked miracles' stuff. Then considered that the players and supporters would be a bit flat as they all supported him.Dyche will sell his low goals conceded, his xG (when it suited), the limitations of the squad he had. Basically he'll do what he always did – focus on the things that benefit him and blame others for everything else. Dan Parker 334 Posted 10/01/2025 at 00:11:38 Moyes is divisive amongst the fan base which is concerning. If his coaching team included Baines and Coleman, would that give more confidence I wonder? The surprise sacking might have been a free game so to speak to gain some first-team coaching experience quickly. I hope whatever happens we have better days than weve seen this season. Mike Price 335 Posted 10/01/2025 at 00:27:07 Why do so many want Evertonians to be part of the management and coaching set-up? Can we just stop with this small-time attitude and just get best in class???None of the top teams or currently successful outfits like Brentford, Bournemouth, Brighton, Fulham, Newcastle or Villa operate like this. The whole ‘they get the club' thing is embarrassing and will just perpetuate the "jobs for the boys" failure ethos that runs right through the club. Si Cooper 336 Posted 10/01/2025 at 00:59:31 Tim, I thought Martinez showed where Moyes had (consistently) been going wrong but unfortunately he couldnt reproduce what Moyes (consistently) did right.He wont sign on just to beat relegation this season so, as I dont want him long-term, its a firm "No, thanks" from me. The last 2 years of dithering Davey just seemed like so many of his previous seasons and a big step down from where we have previously been.Nil satis nisi optimum has to be the target all the time. Josh Horne 337 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:06:50 Mike Price, I agree.There is nothing about the past 30 years of supporting this club that I want to revisit. Glad we have got new owners in, depressed at the prospect of them returning to a safe, dull appointment. The game has moved on, why can't we? Colette Black 338 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:07:07 Clearly Dyche's number was up. The football he was dishing up was dire. But the timing of his dismissal is bizarre. On the face of it, it seems quite disrespectful so I would assume there is some truth in the rumours that he fell out with TFG or felt he could do no more. If so, TFG wouldn't want to see us humiliated in the cup before dismissing him.However, I am concerned that we have sacked a manager seemingly with no-one else lined up. Perhaps they will surprise us tomorrow with an appointment we can all get excited about.However, if Moyes is really under consideration, it's a massive red flag for me. John Reynolds 339 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:09:56 Leighton & Seamie will keep us up. Dont hire a manager until Summer. Steve Oshaugh 340 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:10:10 I woke up a bit late this morning in New Zealand and missed the game and the sacking. My phone was chock full of notifications so I guessed that we had been beaten, Dyche was gone, or Trump had somehow managed to invade Greenland… :) Luckily it was just Dyche. Mixed feelings: gratitude for seeing us through two tough years and acceptance that he had clearly run his race with us. No idea who will come in next but hopefully we can get a bit of verve and vigour into the team again and start enjoying supporting the team again. Steve Oshaugh 341 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:11:07 So happy we dodged Potter though! Steve Brown 342 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:16:21 If TFG choose Moyes, then they are dividing the fan base within a month of taking over and will lose goodwill. It will be a regressive move. Pete Clarke 343 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:20:15 So we finally get rid of a manager whose limitations were greatly exposed… and yet Moyes is the potential replacement! TFG have not done their homework if that's the case and we're in for more of the same with the dour Scot who accepted another job before leaving us years ago. Hope it's not true despite our situation because it smells too much like desperation and we haven't shed the Kenwright past. Steve Brown 344 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:22:30 Moyes is a mediocre, Kenwright-loving loser who thought he was too good for Everton. Do you think that will fit on banner for his first game?A ridiculous and divisive hire if it goes ahead. Mike Gaynes 345 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:29:34 Ed,If Fat Sam can get nine jobs in 16 years amidst ugly football and multiple investigations, Dyche can have a long and fruitful career ahead of him. Personally I will always consider last season to be one of the most inspirational managerial performances I have ever seen. With two points deductions, the entire English league structure stacked against us, and a lame-ass roster including schlubs like Danjuma, Gomes, Godfrey and Holgate, Dyche not only pulled us to survival but did it with room to spare. And the RS left the league title at Goodison, a memory we can cherish forever. He will be back in the Premier League, maybe the next time somebody is in relegation trouble and needs a kick up the ass. Steve Brown 346 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:35:57 Dyche will hopefully be seen more positively with time. He led us through the most difficult period in the club's history on and off the field, when we faced bankruptcy unless we were sold. Absent owner, board resigned, 2 PSR points deductions, all saleable assets in the squad sold, he was the sole voice of the club in the storm when everyone else had left the building. The performances were efficient in 2023-24, but unacceptable this season with a stronger squad. I genuinely don't think we would still be in the premiership today, and therefore a going concern financially, without him. Good luck to him and his team. Eddie Fazal 347 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:37:59 It was clearly time for Dyche to go, perhaps even a few weeks ago, but the club statement is very disappointing.Failing to acknowledge that Dyche (and Pickford) kept us in the Premier League 2 season ago, and Dyche did a very good job last season even after the outrageous points deduction.A simple thank you for your service and well wishes for the future should have been included.I certainly wish him well.Time to move on, hopefully to better things. Mike Gaynes 348 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:44:55 John, that's the worst idea I can imagine. There aren't two footballers I respect more than Bainesy and Seamus, but hundreds of millions of pounds are at stake and this is not a job for raw managerial rookies. Bainesy just got his pro licence a few months ago and has never managed a first team until today.What we need most right now is an experienced manager with a solid record of success under tough circumstances. (And no, I don't mean Moyes...) Don Alexander 349 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:54:14 Due to our decades long absolute fall from grace in attracting managers, coaches and players who demand success on the pitch, I can only see our next manager being of the same ilk…Either an old, tarnished, play-it-safe-forever mundanity of a bloke, or a relatively young, unproven, bullshitting gob-shite a million miles away from being able to even converse with the many very limited players long since coining a fortune for fuck all on the pitch for us.Did Brian Clough have a bastard son with Peter Taylor perchance? Here's hoping! Josh Horne 350 Posted 10/01/2025 at 01:59:14 Dyche inherited an awful team and then had to sell its better players without replacement. He did a truly remarkable job in keeping us up. I am sorry that the football club lacked the grace to recognise this and thank him for his service. Ed Prytherch 351 Posted 10/01/2025 at 02:02:38 Mike, I was closer than you on when Dyche would be fired. Sam's teams played much better football. Were you watching when he turned around Bolton Wanders with Jay-Jay Okocha and Co? Dyche could not dream of coaching like that. Steve Brown 352 Posted 10/01/2025 at 02:34:20 There are successful managers available right now – Sarri, Terzic and Allegri to name 3 off the top of my head.Personally, I want Thomas Frank – I like his structure, planning and attention to detail. But, the timing of this announcement makes that very difficult.Not impossible though. This is the Premier League and the main language is money. Andrea Jacobs 353 Posted 10/01/2025 at 02:47:57 Dyche is an out-of-date manager who has not adapted to the changing nature of football.He gaslights the naive and uninformed football supporters that he is doing a good job. Hes not a terrible person, but anyone with any football nous knows his stubborn style of play is unsustainable; it slowly drains supporter and squad confidence and leads to inevitable relegation.Yes, I do believe football is all about players. And managers. Its not one being more important than the other. Its a combination. A relationship. How do the players respond to him, and how much belief and encouragement does he give them?If it was true that football was all about players, then why have a Coach? Trying to make them feel like theyre in the best position and mental space to perform is the Managers job.Players do improve under certain coaches: Kalvin Phillips would not have any England caps if it wasnt for Marcelo Bielsa, and Jack Harrison would not be ‘playing in the Premier League. (He actually looked quite good when he came on tonight…. L1 Posh, oh yeh.)Just so relieved that the garrulous bald fuck has gone, he should have gone in the Summer. Credit for the last-day survival, obviously,.I actually think the points deduction last season helped him focus in a strange way, it wasnt a hindrance or something ‘really difficult to navigate, without the points deduction, he would of taken us down(controversial opinion!).But, shame on you for your fearful and cluelessly out of touch stubbornness that has made us one of the worst teams in the division this season.Just so relieved hes gone, thank Christ for that… Wait a minute —whos coming back in? Oh……….for fuck's sake!! Steve Brown 354 Posted 10/01/2025 at 02:53:05 Hopefully Moyes will hold out for the United job. Mike Gaynes 355 Posted 10/01/2025 at 03:10:28 Ed, yes, you certainly were, although I'm not sure I was wrong about Friedkin's intentions. From the reports that have leaked out, it seems TFG had no intention of sacking Dyche immediately. Nobody plans to do that the morning of a game. Something appears to have gone very wrong in their conversations with him this week. We'll never know for sure.As for Fat Sam, it has been a very, very long time since he coached attractive football. He left Bolton 18 years ago. Most of what he has put on the pitch since then has been butt ugly.And if he can make a lucrative living in the Premier League, so can Sean. He'll be back. Don Alexander 356 Posted 10/01/2025 at 03:19:43 Our next manager will be decided in an interview scenario but, given the miserable state of the club for decades as trophy contenders, I'm hoping any viable, talented contender is willing to pose way more serious questions to Friedkin on the future of our club than Friedkin can ask of the contender.That ain't Friedkin's fault by the way – no, the fault was implemented decades ago by the most bogus owner/chairman/share-holder in our otherwise proud club's history. David Nicholls 357 Posted 10/01/2025 at 03:48:33 I think Moyes is nailed on for a 2½-year deal. Im fine with this and not convinced it would divide the fanbase as some have suggested. Ideally, I wanted us to hold off until summer and bring Iraola in but results made a change necessary. Moyes to steady the ship for a couple of years before Arteta is ready to step in… 😀 Ernie Baywood 358 Posted 10/01/2025 at 03:55:33 Steven, I feel like going in for Frank is just trying to grab the name rather than what put his name there in the first place. Frank came from within the club. He had a role working with development teams. Then he moved to the manager role.Maybe that's why he has had success? He's worked at different levels of the club, he's come through the ranks, and he gives a shit about developing different levels of playing staff. Maybe. I still think the Director of Football role is the one that needs sorting first. It sounds obvious, but we should figure out what we want in a coach before we hire one. Do we just want a coach? Or do we want someone to drive everything? That's why I still believe Moyes is such an obvious interim option (if he'll come). He's a very solid coach, he won't be phased by the job, he's probably not trying to climb the managerial ladder anymore, and he's experienced enough to actually help the process we need to go through. Ernie Baywood 359 Posted 10/01/2025 at 04:03:09 You can probably infer from the announcement that Dyche had made himself unpopular in at least the last few days of negotiations. Even shit coaches usually get a thankyou. Paul Ferry 360 Posted 10/01/2025 at 04:05:34 David, I think that Moyes might well split the fanbase (I have a hunch that many of the "Moyes no" persuasion will have been around in 1984-87), especially if it is for 30 months as you say, and I have also heard.I could just about stomach Moyes on a clear-cut season's end deal with no frills except a 50P bonus, but (1) I don't think that he would sign it, and (2) he has the fecking gall to come back.If it is to be Moyes, that is not the best of starts for TFG in my opinion and another sign of Thelwell's shortcomings. I do agree David that a short-term deal with a properly costed and scrutinised permanent manager in the summer is the best thing for us. Scratching my head to think of someone who is not Moyes who might sign that deal who is below 60 with no historical/romantic ties to us?Or, in true Sean Kearns "mole"/Princess Diana assassinated JFK style, can it just be a mere coincidence that Rob Edwards left Luton on the day that the three hard-boiled eggs left us? Hmmmmmmm.Agree Ernie, a new DOF is a top priority mate. Ernie Baywood 361 Posted 10/01/2025 at 04:16:49 Steve Brown #331 - I always felt that he was brought in (and remunerated very well) exactly for the reason that we were going into this kind of period and the owner and chairman needed someone to roll with the punches on their behalf.You can call that taking one for the team, or displaying leadership in a difficult time, or you could say he took his 30 pieces of silver in exchange for betraying Evertonians.Even the timing - delayed so he was appointed just as we sold Gordon and it was too late to sign anyone else screamed setup. It wasn't just a coincidence and it provides insight into what he knew.Dyche used to be a bit coy over what he knew before he signed. In recent weeks he's got a bit bolder and started declaring that he was misguided in his understanding of the club's situation. Conveniently those statements have come after the two main protagonists are not involved with the club, for one reason or another.Along the way, he's defended his reputation. And he'll leave with it intact in the eyes of most of the media.I've never thought we would go down in this period. I don't even think Dyche would take us down this season, as poor as we are. I guess he did his job, but he definitely lowered the standards at the club. One or two shots a game would feel like Brazil '70 at the moment. Christine Foster 362 Posted 10/01/2025 at 04:30:49 So, Dyche has departed, Moyes looks like he may be on his way in; something I said had to happen back in early December, still does. However I reiterate, not on a long-term contract. Do it to the end of the season and then have the real discussion on the way forward. First things first, stay in the Premier League. It's a shame the departing does not seem to have been an amicable one; Dyche deserves the thanks for the two seasons' graft he put in to keep us in the Premier League but, according to The Guardian, The Friedkin Group thought that his comments constituted that he had effectively resigned in saying he could do no more with the team... and therefore was not entitled to the 6 months left on his contract. A bunfight ensued and, by the sound of it, a fair bit of ill feeling. Perhaps it's a culture thing. (I have experienced exactly the same as a VP in a Texan company, blunt, ruthless and unforgiving attitudes towards rights and expectations normally given to European staff.) No matter why, it's obviously been a contentious and acrimonious parting for it to happen when it did, how it did and without any niceties. It had to happen but I thought the moment had passed when it didn't — but the Bournemouth loss and its nature made poor reading for the Friedkins and subsequently the trigger was pulled probably sooner than they wanted…We are in limbo at the moment, treading water until a new manager is appointed, a restructure needed but the order of the day is win first, points on the board. Annika Herbert 363 Posted 10/01/2025 at 05:18:08 David, I think you should have said Moyes to bore us to death for for a couple of years and extend his winless away record against the top 6 sides by another dozen or so games.Because just the thought of seeing his ugly mug in the Everton dugout again fills me with dread. I will be extremely disappointed if the TFG group take the Moyes route.He is one of the last people I want to see in charge of us when we walk out in the new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock for the very first time. Ernie Baywood 364 Posted 10/01/2025 at 05:37:10 Steve, the only way I see it working with Moyes on a 6-month deal is if there's a carrot on offer. At his age, he may well fancy a move upstairs. We could be the club to give him something on his CV that helps him along that path. There may be something other than money that motivates him. Paul Ferry 365 Posted 10/01/2025 at 05:44:53 Moyes does not deserve Bramley-Moore Dock. He does not deserve Everton after the way he treated us before and after his joyful exit. "Just run down your contract, wee Davey"; Marouane deserves the chance to play for a big club.Lytham-St-Annes is an Everton retirement home, for fuck's sake… but the six-faced one has the gall to come back. What was it, 74 goals conceded in his last season at West Ham? Makes Silva look tight at the back. Denver Daniels 366 Posted 10/01/2025 at 05:55:34 I watched a fair bit of West Ham in their last 2 seasons under Moyes. The football for the most part was dire, and they relied on individual brilliance to get them out of trouble. We don't have that calibre of player. The Premier League now compared to when he was last here is way different. Even the likes of Ipswich are spending £100M on new players. I don't trust he had evolved enough to get us to keep us up. Steve Brown 367 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:02:41 Paul /Ernie, my main hope is that Moyes's ego will not allow him to accept a 6 month deal... and that TFG are not daft enough to offer him longer one.It will be the first test for Friedkin on the "MoshMoronMetre" - if he offers Moyes a 2-year deal then he can put on his dunce's cap and go sit in the corner. Pete Clarke 368 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:18:56 David Moyes had run his race at the end of his days with Everton and in my own eyes should have been sacked or at least stepped down long before he left. He changed our motto from NSNO to Knife to a Gunfight. Not much has changed with him. He has not been close to any major silverware (Uefa Conference apart) with much better players than we have. Hes boring as fuck and has basically took the piss out of us with his remarks about our players joining Man Utd so why on earth would we even consider him? If we went down, he would not be the one to lead us back. TFG need to show some intelligence in this appointment rather than desperation measure as weve all seen too often in the past. I cannot stand the man anymore. Lets just move on and get somebody in who can move us forward. Andrew Clare 369 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:25:25 Moyes is a defence-minded manager who achieved nothing at Everton. He is not a winner. Don't go near him. We don't want him here.It was he and Kenwright that led to us being where we are now. Bob Parrington 370 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:30:56 Please – No to David Moyes!!!!!! We'd had more than enough of him when he moved on to Man Utd. Andrew Clare 371 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:40:04 All this stuff about Moyes steadying the ship is rubbish. He is past his sell by date. He has never been successful so why appoint him? They say he gets Everton! Harry Catterick, Howard Kendall and Joe Royle got Everton. I don't think David Moyes was anywhere near getting Everton like they did.This is so underwhelming, I am very disappointed. Paul Ferry 372 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:40:15 Dan Friedkin is in a decent position at the moment simply because he is not Moshiri and there is some mellow optimism among us fans. The new gaffer will be in a decent position simply because he is not Dyche and there is some mellow optimism among us fans.Let's see how it goes. Paul Ferry 373 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:41:38 Hey come on Andrew, 122, ''The People's Club"!!?? And how many of we cheered .... Paul Hewitt 374 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:45:03 Can we put the bloody violin away for Dyche, please? He was paid £5M a year (the sixth highest paid in the Premier League) to have us play the worst football I've ever seen. So he couldn't say goodbye to the players, who cares? I'm just happy he will never manage this club again. Derek Knox 375 Posted 10/01/2025 at 06:59:24 As for Moyes possibly coming back, I have always believed that either players, or managers returning rarely works second time around. I would also be surprised if he accepted a short-term stint, so basically, a No from me, but surely there is someone out there. Other clubs seem to find the likes of Iraola, Thomas Frank etc, so why can't we? Paul Smith 376 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:10:23 Who knows the truth? The facts – 3 wins in 19 games – he would have been sacked long ago if we had a board and owner. Colin Glassar 377 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:15:20 Big Sam, Moyes, Dyche – they are all from the same school of pre-historic football. If ginger is appointed (and I understand the reasons behind this – survival) then it's showing a complete lack of vision and ambition and our utter failure to make a clean break from the Kenwright - Moshiri years.It's now quite obvious that Friedkin hasn't prepared for this. No CEO, no board, no new manager lined up etc… Eric Myles 378 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:19:08 Gerry #251 & 253, I thought you meant Corbett. Steve Shave 379 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:34:11 Please for the love of God can this talk of Moyes coming back just go away. I feel like hiding in a cupboard and putting my fingers in my ears for the next week.I am one of a few voices on here who can sit back and say openly I think Moyes did an excellent job for us and have consistently said so, I remain confused by those who think not. It's possible to believe that and support that notion AND be opposed to the idea of re-appointing him. I do not think going back is ever a good idea. I also think he is outdated and as some have said already, the appointment would lack some serious vision. That's why it would disappoint so many because after Kenwright and Moshiri, we had really hoped for owners with vision.Of course the Friedkin group may still have a vision and Moyes' name is just lazy journalism. Sacking Dyche (with his survival expertise) wasn't without its risks, the appointment of a new manager is also not without its risks, including divisive Dave. Therefore, let's really fucking go for it from the off. If it's not Sarri (now my first choice) or of course Allegri, then let's buy out someone's contract and get it right. Whether that is Jose (people turning their noses up to a 2 x winning Champion's league manager is laughable) Frank or even McKenna. A mate texted me to say Fonseca has had 8 clubs in 8 years so that has put me off the idea. I do agree with a couple of the above comments that McKenna won't come until the summer but I am less sure about Frank. I know they are a better team, better run club and doing well but he has surely hit a glass ceiling there?If the new owners are capable of representing themselves and the vision of the club, there will be a very good manager out there who would fancy it, surely? Eric Myles 380 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:37:46 Kieran #235, "Even when he first arrived we weren't really in the relegation mix we were sort of the best of the rest mid tableish teams."Yeah, we were doing so good that we sacked our manager and appointed another. Paul Ferry 381 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:55:22 Paul H 347, who exactly is playing violins for Dyche? I see exactly no one. Phil Roberts 382 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:55:35 Kieran #235Remember the year when we finished with 39 points. We had 39 points and lost the last 4 games having drawn the previous 2. In fact we had enough points after 28 games to have been safe.Of course we did have an awful start to the 05/06 season thanks to Collina's phone call from UEFA with 4 points from the first 9 games but we still finished on 50 points.And I think his job (twice) at West Ham of managing a regulation battle should just be ignored because that was not at EvertonBut as I always say, never let the truth get in the way of your prejudices. Colin Crooks 383 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:56:25 I didn't think there was a cat's chance in hell of us being relegated under Dyche, but his intention of nil-nilling his way to safety clearly didnt sit well with TFG. He's gone now. He joins Rafa, Sam, Carlo and Frank in an exclusive club of people who got very, very rich serving up abject anti-football to the long-suffering Evertonians.To the here and now: Leighton Baines was a Rolls-Royce of a player. One of the few who wouldn't draw sniggers if you compared his left foot with that of James and Sheedy. I have heard very good things about his coaching ability but, whenever I hear of him being suggested as a manager, my mind always goes back to the game were he stepped aside for the less-talented Kevin Mirallas to take a penalty. Lovely man, but perhaps a little too humble to be a leader ?I was sat above him last night. Watching how him and Seamus. While Seamus was up and down looking desperate to get on the pitch. Baines was motionless. very calm. I watched his interview this morning and he spoke exactly the way I hear he coaches. simple, Calm, thoughtful and clear. No shite – "It's not that complicated. Players play and coaches coach". Baines did a good job under difficult circumstances last night, but with all the craziness going on yesterday, there is a danger his work will go under the radar.Unfortunately reports suggest that us Evertonians are going to have to kiss a few more frogs before we find our prince… Please don't make one of them Ginger – but I would love to think we were seeing the future manager of Everton FC last night. The mature, less humble, Leighton Baines. Derek Knox 384 Posted 10/01/2025 at 07:57:52 Yes, I hope TFG keep their powder dry a little longer, playing staff reinforcements are more of a priority than a manager at the moment, in my opinion. I am also aware of the proverb "Procrastination is the Thief of Time" … but equally "Look before you Leap" too is pertinent in our case. Stu Gre 385 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:04:26 My preference would be either and experienced manager who has a history of winning, or a manager who has been successful without having the real opportunity of winning.That actually rules out Sarri, Moyes, Fonseca who haven't won much despite being given the resources a few times to do so.BTW, Moyes, given the stability he had at Everton, should have won at least 1 trophy for us. He isn't a way forward but he might do til the end of the season.Given TFG want Premier League experience, that rules out Allegri (although I doubt he'd come, you would want to rule him out because he hasn't managed in the Premier League).Mourinho fits the bill as 2-year transition manager. I don't want him but then again I do! He'll win a cup, turn the club round and make it better for the next manager. Plus raise our profile. Eric Myles 386 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:16:58 George #115, you missed it, it was John at #55. Danny Baily 387 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:18:15 Look at the odds. Moyes is at over 75%. It's a matter of when Moyes will be announced.Honestly, providing the sentiment in the dressing room was supportive, I'd have backed Dyche and his team over Moyes and an old boys club of Baines & Coleman.The real winners last night were Ipswich. Jack Convery 388 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:19:43 No to the cheesy grinner. Seated in that Limo grinning like a Cheshire cat as he made his way to sign on at Man Utd, back in the day. His remarks, when we said no to the Fellaini transfer – he deserves to play for a big club. That remark, tells you everything about his feelings towards Everton. Two-faced – and with a knife that must surely be as blunt as an Everton centre forward. No, No, No to Moyes. Bill Fairfield 389 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:20:09 If it's Moysie, it'll do for me. Perhaps he can sign us some more Everton legends of the calibre of Baines and Coleman etc, like he did last time he was here. Anthony Flack 390 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:22:53 I'm anti Moyes My ropey metaphor for how he treated Everton is- he left his longstanding wife for a hottie, then tried to persuade the families favourite children to join him, when the hottie discovered he was shit in bed, he went off piste and off to her older less attractive sister who lived in London. She has a couple of nice trips to Europe, but often on a Thursday night. Soon she found out he wasn't very exciting, maybe a bit dour- now he's on his own, he wants a romantic reunion with his first wifeI'd definitely advise that first wife to give him a wide berth Mal van Schaick 391 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:24:52 Moyes will be another Dyche. Lone striker and no supply.The whole point of sacking Dyche is to change how we play, with different tactics and fresh enthusiasm from the players.The next appointment could be short-term, but we do need long-term stability heading into the new stadium, but the first priority is to maintain our Premier League status. Danny Baily 392 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:28:12 Bill 373, at Sunderland he signed the same 'Everton legends', at a time when they were well past their sell by date, and ultimately got them relegated. At West Ham, fans hounded him out twice for dour, negative football and getting them dragged into relegation scraps. He's from an era that predates Dyche's old school of football.I'm of the opinion that the likes of Seamus and Baines aren't particularly helping the situation, and haven't done so since the start of the Rafa era. You can imagine them subtlety undermining managers and banging on about the 'good times' under Moyes back in the day.If (big if) we survive this, I'd be in favour of a clear out of the old boys. Matt Traynor 393 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:33:56 Anthony #374, I don't blame Moyes for leaving for Man Utd - they were one of the best teams in Europe, certainly the dominant team in the Premier League (albeit on the wane) and we were occasionally "best of the rest".If he'd declined the opportunity, you'd have to question his ambition, hunger and desire.I'd wanted him gone 2-3 years before mind, so maybe my opinion is coloured by that!The way this has unfolded is typically Everton - and surrounded by intrigue, hopefully some facts will emerge in due course:- Did Dyche really say he'd taken the team as far as he could?- Did TFG have a plan for the summer?- If so, what sort of interim manager did they want?I can't believe for 1 second Moyes will take a short-term caretaker role. His ego won't allow it. Maybe there'll be a transition plan for him to be DoF in the future - I doubt he'll work under Thelwell.If Moyes comes in on a longer deal, and it's as manager, with no transition plan, then it rather suggests TFG have panicked.I see West Ham have put a 6-month break clause in Potter's contract – hopefully Everton will do similar – and we avoid an Allardyce situation – wanted him on 6 months, but we eventually ended up paying for 18 months. Jack Convery 394 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:38:55 Thomas Franck has won one away game this season – at Southampton – Won 1, Drawn 2, Lost 7. The home record is excellent: Won 7, Drawn 1, Lost 2 – but you need to win away games to prosper. Last season, they finished 16th, a place below us and we had 8 points deducted! Won 10, Drawn 9 and Lost 19. I do like the way his team plays but we need a coach who can move us up the table, play attractive football and have our hearts singing. Brentford staying up is an achievement, for us Evertonians, it's a given. Eric Myles 395 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:42:11 Danny O'Neill is surprisingly quiet on this.Has he been tipped the wink that a distant cousin of his is soon to be our new manager and has been told to keep it under his hat? Alan McGuffog 396 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:46:55 Derek, 369. My favourite is "Never give a sucker an even break". Dunno what it means and has nothing to do with the thread. I just like it. Sorry... just woken up, is it Moyes? Jerome Shields 397 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:47:26 Hooray for Hollywood.Only found out.Good Luck on your travels Sean.Thanks for saving Everton from relegation twice , pity you were not able to move on with Everton.I sort of knew Seamus overlapping into space was a statement Christine Foster 398 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:48:08 Whoever, and I do mean whoever, is appointed as manager, they will have a very real and significant problem with the depth and quality of the squad. Much like Allardyce's arrival, it will be the results that matter for the rest of this season. As an immediate goal, winning is everything this season. Just how that will be achieved will be down to how players are used, where and when and if we can bring in a few players in the next three weeks to create enough going forward to make a difference.Should that manager be successful, then next season is a totally different prospect, building a successful team is the emphasis, not the immediate game by game results and battle out of relegation areas. A better base to build on may take a season or two to fashion, but thats not where we are now, right now we need to get the best out of what we have or what we can get. Are there any managers out there who can do both? I am sure there are, but usually they are good at one or the other, not both, that requires money, trust, expertise and time. Difficult to associate Everton of late with all three. Which is probably why we are where we are. Hence the probability if we cannot find or afford the best solution to deliver both, a split decision is likely, short term fix, long term strategy. Squaring this circle is going to be difficult for TFG but there immediate focus is protection of assets and that means avoiding relegation, so we may have to expect that some unpalatable decisions to some fans may have to be made. Its where we are, the road back will be bumpy, but TFG are nothing if not ruthless in its determination to succeed. Paul Ferry 399 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:48:32 So on church/ecclesiastical/moral/10 commandments grounds Anthony Flack Whitehouse 375?What a fucking bizarre post!You cannot manage Everton because you had extra-marital sex.I know that we were founded by Methodists but fuck me; can we work and play and drink on Sundays?NO you can't be a politician or a footy manager because you had extra-marital sex.This is a reading from the holy gospel of Flack. Steve Shave 400 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:52:40 Jack are you really turning your nose up at Frank? There are some lofty expectations on here as per, we'd be lucky to even get a conversation with him. Let's see, i've calmed down a little, if its Moyes then I hope only till the end of the season, if not we HAVE to get behind him whatever. An interesting few days ahead. Jerome Shields 401 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:53:26 Hooray for Hollywood again. Robert Tressell 402 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:53:26 For the rest of the season we are going to play fairly defensive football regardless of who the manager is. This is not a new dawn.Delighted to be proved wrong - but it's more likely that the manager after the new appointment heralds the new dawn. Paul Ferry 403 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:55:02 In 30 months time Robert? Jerome Shields 404 Posted 10/01/2025 at 08:59:24 Dyche taking his whole team with him.So much for his contribution to succession planning.Relegation was to keep him in the job first. Robert Tressell 405 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:02:43 Maybe 18 months Paul? Dyche is our recent record holder at 2 years in situ. Would be surprised if the next guy lasts longer than that. Bill Fairfield 406 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:03:22 Danny 383. Sorry just dont recognise your description of Moyes time at West Ham. Paul Ferry 407 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:05:41 Fair point Robert. And TFG seem to love managerial roulette. Brian Williams 408 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:13:22 Ah the Moyesia, who will no doubt be welcomed back by the great and gullible who roundly cheered another divisive figure when his mug was shown on the screens at Goodison. When he oversees the sort of football that WHU fans couldn't wait to see the end of, despite them winning a trophy, maybe the penny will drop, but I doubt it.I believe Baines and Coleman could do just as good a job until the end of the season.There's talk of Moyes being offered a contract until the end of the season with a "bonus" of a contract extension should he avoid relegation.Judging by Leighton's answer when asked about Moyes's possible return he doesn't seem too keen either, although he was very diplomatic.It'll be a sad day indeed if Moyes comes back, IMO.I just hope that if it is to be him, and there's ANY chance of him managing the club beyond the end of this season, that it's announced before the season ticket window opens for me. Derek Knox 409 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:15:14 " Dyche taking his whole team with him."So no more 40 minute Rock, Paper, Scissors discussions after half time as to making a sub/s ? :-) Gary Mortimer 410 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:20:00 I've been a season ticket holder in the Top Balcony for 22 seasons, so apart from the first of Moyes's seasons I have witnessed everything since.The best football that I have seen in that time was Roberto Martinez's first season, where, by adding Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu, he gave the solid defensive team that Moyes left the freedom to attack teams. The home and away victories over Moyes' Man Utd and the home thrashing of Arsenal stand out. We finished in 5th on 72 points and up until a late disaster at home v Palace in April were well in the hunt for Champions League footy.The year we finished 4th on 61 points had some great moments, but also a lot (9) of KITAPI 1-0 wins. Our final goal difference of -1 also shows that we didn't go out and dominate teams.Our worst footy played in all those years has easily been this season. Even "good" results were a result of backs to the wall defend at all costs performances where the result could easily have gone the other way - City and Arsenal sprint to mind. I'd like to see some up and coming manager come in to get the best out of midfield and attackers. . . . our defense is still solid - obviously we're short in both full back positions (Patterson needs a long run of games and fitness), I think Mykolenko is probably too limited going forward and his heading is as good as mine. Anthony Flack 411 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:21:13 Paul sorry it was a rubbish post - just light hearted (and introduced as a ropey metaphor)He shit on his own doorstep, then did it again, so I would not want him back. I know he was leaving for a 'bigger role' and many would do the same. But maybe with more grace and manners.I am still laughing at your retort, sorry my post did not entertain !I just hope my deeply Roman Catholic Irish mother is not reading this, as I have never been referred to as either teetotal or methodist Have an excellent day, and lets all hope we make a good choice, and if it is Moyes, I am proven utterly incorrect ! Roger Helm 412 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:21:43 Paul 395, it was a metaphor. Anthony Flack 413 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:23:15 PS for clarity I know he did not actually "shit on the doorstep" Colin Crooks 414 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:36:42 Glad you cleared that one up Anthony. He would probably have demanded photographic evidence Anthony Flack 415 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:40:37 Colin that brings back grim memories of managing an Abbey National (Santander for any youngsters) in Peckham in the early 1990s - I'll not eleaborate as it is close to breakfast Josh Horne 416 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:40:41 Anthony@413 on the basis of this witty clarification, I am sorry that I missed the original metaphor which now seems sadly missing. Craig Walker 417 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:49:47 The club Moyes left is not the club he would be rejoining. To his credit he brought in some good players during his time; Cahill, Jagielka, Baines, Lescott, Arteta. He was less good when he had money to spend; Beattie. He used to be good at beating the teams around us at home but not being able to get wins against the better teams. That'd be an improvement on the past few years but it isn't a given he could achieve this without investment. Can he improve us with the calibre of player at his disposal? He did a decent job at West Ham but they have more player of a better standard than we've got. His Sunderland record worries me more.The other thought I had was whether this would be another manager who would give Michael Keane a chance to see what he can do. As others have said better than me, why can't we find the next big thing? I hate that lot across the park but there is some grudging admiration from me about how they do things. I'm not a European football expert but I'd never heard of Slot. He comes in and does an arguably better job that his so-called legendary predecessor. Alan McGuffog 418 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:50:37 Anthony, my missus was a manager for the Abbey at that time. She'd love to hear that story. Liked your metaphor btw. Paul Hewitt 419 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:51:07 Well if Moyes isn't the answer. Who realistically could we get?. Would love to hear some of these. Stu Gre 420 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:54:12 Paul Hewitt 419 I think those 2 are mutually exclusive.Moyes isn't the answer but the who else would come?So he might be the only answer, right or wrong. Josh Horne 421 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:56:20 Do you think Moyes is the answer Paul? Brian Williams 422 Posted 10/01/2025 at 09:56:24 Paul#419.Paul, that for me is the scary part.I really, really haven't got a clue who could come in and turn things round for the rest of the season.I'm just sick to death of the situation we find ourselves in yet again. James Marshall 423 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:09:44 My fear is the Friedkin's have seen what bringing Ranieri back to Roma has done in galvanising the fanbase, and believe that Moyes is our Ranieri.There's a feeling in Rome among the Roma fans, pundits and even journalists, that Ranieri has revived the team and brought the fans back onside - my fear as alluded to above, is that they envisage Moyes strolling back into Goodison, the fans all bowing at his feet while he pulls Everton up the division into mid-table obscurity and keeps us up.Then next season (and this is the bit that really galls me) he rides into Bramley Moore on a golden chariot to the acclaim of the 52,888 and the circle is complete.I do not want Moyes, though I don't really know who do I want either. Answers on a postcard. Mike Price 424 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:10:58 Ive thought Dyche was angling to leave with a payoff for a while now. The crowd had turned, he knew he was going in the summer anyway, so wanted out with a payoff. Sounds like he was exasperated with TFG not sacking him and downed tools to force their hand. He then had the cheek to say he wouldnt resign and wanted paying in full, hence the bad blood.We all know we need a clear out and a reset but we have to stay up.TFG know this and so are hamstrung; we need to survive and it appears DM is a slightly better version of Dyche and so gives us a slightly better chance.I think were all praying its only until the end of the season and then we can revert to TFGs original plan. Paul Hewitt 425 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:12:12 Josh, I do. Staying in this league is all that matters. I think Moyes does that. Like I've said before Danny Rohl would be my first choice, just not mid season. Anthony Dove 426 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:15:21 If Moyes is appointed it will show that Friedkin has as much understanding of modern football and EFC as Moshiri. If it were possible I could understand supporters wanting to bring back Catterick and Kendall, but hankering after Moyespasses all understanding. I feel even more depressed than when we appointed Benitez. Come back Dyche, all is forgiven. James Marshall 427 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:15:52 Moyes also took over from Allardyce at Sunderland, and got them relegated bottom of the league in 2017 remember. He also said he would stick with the club and then promptly resigned when they went down.He's not the messiah. Anthony Flack 428 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:16:27 Alan @418 - I managed (maybe another metaphor) branches in South London, including Elephant and Castle - I used to do extra hours on a Saturday in Pechkam. All I will say is the customer 'left a deposit' on the counter, and it was not cash.I loved South London, but hated Peckham, needing to call the police often to walk me from the front of the branch to my car to get home.It's apparently much nicer now - with Elephant and Castle referred to as Elegant and Castle Where was your wife based? Brian Williams 429 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:18:48 According to Alan Nixon Moyes won't accept a short term contract and is looking for a two and a half year contract.The prospect of that breaks my heart, it really does! George Stuart 430 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:21:26 I can't help thinking about HK II and HK III.I thought Moyes did a good enough job. But, never go back.Except, maybe, has Joe Royle retired? I quite fancy another FA cup. Ernie Baywood 431 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:21:42 Craig #417 - the only thing I'm confident of is that we can't find the next big thing right now. If we appoint a permanent manager this month then we're a bigger shambles than even I thought. It has to be an interim appointment until the club organises itself at the leadership level.We don't have a CEO. We don't have a Director of Football who is more than likely to go past May. Everton might really surprise me here and this whole thing has been a well thought through masterplan. Thelwell is the man for the job with everyone's full support. They weren't really looking at both Bielsa and Dyche at the same time, it was just Dyche to help cut costs and carry the can until the new owners were in. They've spent the last two years building up a footballing strategy that can be implemented by a shortlist of managers that the club's staff have been painstakingly scouting and taking to over the last year. TFG have arrived and been pleasantly surprised by the work that's been done prior to the purchase and are ready to execute on the plan.Anyone think that's likely? I don't for one second think it's even a possibility. Dennis Stevens 432 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:22:18 I'd rather have Allardyce back than Moyes Ray Jacques 433 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:23:40 Moyes it looks like then.The last 12 years just a chaotic memory and we are back to square one as if it never happennedThey say never go back we shall see.At least we know we wont be winning at Anfield, Old Trafford, Etihad or Emirates for a while. Unless he has swapped that knife for a gun? Ray Jacques 434 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:24:56 George at 430, Howard had other problems unfortunately when he came back. Ernie Baywood 435 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:26:32 George, I keep thinking of Big Joe. And I've said it for a while on here. Where is our 2025 version? Because that's exactly what we need right now. His impact is so underrated when "Dogs of War" gets rolled out. It underestimates what he achieved massively.Possibly the best time of my life. What an inspirational Evertonian. Rick Tarleton 436 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:27:30 I wouldn't want David Moyes back, even on a short term contract. Tony Marsh, we need you. Alan McGuffog 437 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:34:46 Anthony...I had a horrible feeling that was the explanation. 'Er indoors managed Huyton and Allerton before being Area Manager for Stoke, Tamworth, Wolverhampton region. Pre Santander. Paul Hewitt 438 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:35:09 I can see why people say they don't want Moyes. Finishing 5th, 6th, or 7th. Bloody disgraceful. Laurie Hartley 439 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:37:37 Paul # 419 - David Moyes could do a job in the short term but I would have thought that there is nothing David Moyes could do that someone like Massimiliano Allegri could do at least as well then kick on from there.David Moyes could do a job in the short term but I would have thought that there is nothing David Moyes could do that someone like Massimiliano Allegri could do at least as well then kick on from there.https://www.soccertutor.com/newsletters/download/Massimiliano-Allegri-Creating-and-Exploiting-Space-in-Final-Third.pdfThis guy is a winner and available.This guy is a winner and available. Allegri in! Barry Rathbone 440 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:38:53 Whatever the right or wrong of the matter Dyche has been gone for weeks, if not months, it had become an obvious case of putting him out of his miseryNow presumably the new owners knew this and called upon their collective experience at Roma and knowledge of european togger to scour the footballing world for a redeemer, prophet and miracle worker,the wilderness to no longer concern us.The new man is aiming for the sun filled uplands of the promised land.And I'm reading it's Moyes.*packs suitcase Sam Hoare 441 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:40:46 I've been an Everton fan since around 1997, all of my adult life. In that time no-one has progressed Everton as a manager more than David Moyes and I'm always confused by the animosity towards him. Yes, he said a few silly things when he left to Manchester United but he moved Everton from relegation fodder to European contenders. He deserved a bigger job and if anything he stayed too long.Having said that, I've never wanted him back and believe that going back is generally a bad habit that doesn't end well. I would have taken Potter in a hearbeat over Moyes. But that ship has sailed and looking at the options now I don't see one that makes more sense than the Moyesiah, on a short contract.The team is poor. We are very much in another relegation battle and the players look fatigued and anxious to me. To change style dramatically mid-season could re-invigorate them but it could also terrify them and go horribly wrong given their low confidence etc. Moyes offers a similar pragmatism to Dyche but with a slightly better balance between defense and attack. He knows the club and might also help find some affordable options from the championship or elsewhere as he did so often in his first spell. The likes of Allegri or Sarri would be intruiging but we have no idea whether they would fancy drinking from such a poisoned chalice, more likely they could be contenders in the summer.It's not what anyone dreamt of, but it might just be what we need. Get us safe this year and then this summer is the time to appoint someone to move us into a new phase, with a shiny stadium, funds to spend on players and hopefully a more entertaining style to watch. Brian Harrison 442 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:42:00 My mantra is never go back as a player or as a manager, but I might make an exception in this case. Moyes is a good manager and I believe will get a lot more out of this group than Dyche ever could. If he does get the job we thankfully wont hear the term back on the grass or the noise or the details, we will hear an honest appraisal of how things are. Again its all speculation but if Moyes is appointed I wouldn't be surprised to see Baines and maybe Coleman as his assistants. The good thing about Moyes is he never takes an entourage of coaches around with him.While it seems he will want longer than 6 months, but lets wait and see what is and isn't agreed. Those who don't want him back I understand but tell me one person who we could get today who could turn this club around. Yes there are plenty of managers who we all might prefer, but if they are with a club, going to a club on the edge of relegation isn't one many would take.Just finally I did hear from a quite reliable source that Dyche rang Friedkin after the Bournemouth game, and said I think I have taken this club as far as I can. At which point Friedkin said I accept your resignation, but Dyche said I am not resigning which gave friedkin little choice but to sack him. the guy who told me this was also definite that Baines and Coleman would be in charge for the Peterboro game. Paul Hewitt 443 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:42:51 I'd take Allergri. But I doubt an aging Italian manager would come to a struggling Premier league club. In fact I'm certain he wouldn't. Michael Lynch 444 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:47:04 Nobody really wanted this, did they? I mean, Friedkin would have expected Dyche to work til the end of his contract, at which point the club would be rebooted with a cool young manager with floppy hair and big ideas, playing progressive football in a brand new ground. A few transfer windows in mid table, then a push for European places.But Dyche has clearly reached the end of his tether. He has looked and sounded more and more defeated and defiant, constantly returning to his refrain of "this is not the job I was sold". There was really nowhere else for the ownership, or the manager, to go.But I can't agree with anyone who is diminishing Dyche's contribution. We are the only club with a negative net spend in the Premier League during his time at the club, he's had to deal with points deductions, ownership battles, constant money problems, and the demands of one of the most hard to please fan bases in the country. Our squad is almost totally devoid of quality and pace.I listen to Seamus and his unyielding devotion to the club and I can see why Dyche can't go on. Everton remains a religion in an era of fickle, world-wide audiences for football. While the likes of Liverpool became an international brand, we are still a corner shop competing in a world of supermarkets.And now we are looking for a new manager at a time when there are very few available, and even less who would take on a club in our position - yet again battling relegation, with a tiny squad of pensioners, rejects, and bad buys.So, thanks Sean, you really did do your best, and I doubt that anyone would have got more out of what has been available to you in a league where even the smallest clubs are outspending you. Personally, I have absolutely no idea where we go from here. Short term or long term? High risk or low risk? Proven or unproven manager? A lot depends on whether the ownership are prepared to dip into the transfer market this month, or if anyone is even available to buy.So, relief that Dyche has gone maybe, and possibly the only decision that could have been made. But the chances of us going down have been increased in my opinion. Because, if Dyche hadn't just been sacked, he'd be exactly the man we'd be turning to. Anthony Flack 445 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:47:27 Alan (437) - in that patch there used to be a an excellent lady running things called Sue Willis (sorry all if going off piste) Anthony Dove 446 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:54:47 Paul@443. Forgive me if I am missing your subtle sarcasm but have you forgotten Carlo? Laurie Hartley 447 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:56:36 Paul # 443 - as a soon to be 76 year old I would just like to point out to you that the “aging Italian manager” is 4 years younger than the “aging Scottish manager”. 😉If any manager is good enough, this job is a great and lucrative opportunity. However, TFG as Christine has pointed out somewhere, will probably make a short term “commercial decison” so it in all likelihood it will be David Moyes.If that happens Ill just have to swallow it like a necessary stepping stone because one way or another, by hook or by crook, we will be great again. Paul Hewitt 448 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:56:58 He couldn't wait to get away if I remember. Christopher Timmins 449 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:57:02 Folks, we can have whatever opinions we want but we have not invested £400 million in buying the club. When you make that kind of an investment and something happens that was not predicted which might put your investment under pressure you act with caution!I have no idea what went wrong between close of business on Saturday and the sacking 3 hours before last night's tie but something that was not planned for occurred. The new manager will be someone who the owners feel will best protect their investment by getting the most, in points terms, out of the current squad.Mike G has said that the owners usually delegate and so in the normal course of events they would set out for the relevant person that they have appointed what the priority(s) is/are and let that person crack on with the task of hiring the new manager. It's too early in the ball game to have that person in place so they may well be depending on the current DOF to find the new manager. Given the circumstance in which the club finds itself in this morning, none of the aces are held by the owners in the bargaining process which will now be taking place with the various candidates. Those who do not want Moyes can console themselves with the possibility that he may not take on the job as the owners may not be able to meet his demands. In my opinion, after a successful spell at West Ham, actually two successful terms there, he will be in no rush to take on an assignment where the talent available to him might not be much better than he had at Sunderland and did not go well for him. John Daley 450 Posted 10/01/2025 at 10:57:46 For now, Ill take the ‘nailed on second coming of David Moyes with a considerable pinch of salt. According to his mates in the media hes been ‘set to be appointed ever since Sam Allardyce was sent packing to sniff his own pants and pontificate about how he would shit all over Pep if the press would just let people forget he fucking loves a Walls sausage roll.Every single time the job has come up in the last 8 years, Moyes has instantly been chucked in with the favourites with ‘insiders supposedly claiming he is in talks, being considered, about to be confirmed, already holed up in the building like Hans Gruber and stalking the halls with a sharpened spork…on the verge of blowing a blood vessel after some “silly wee bastard” from one of the ‘big clubs sent the lift down with a dead body inside and a note velcroed to its chest saying ‘Now we have a machine gun. Ho Ho Ho. Yesterday, nobody at all knew Dyche was about to be dismissed mere hours before a match was due to be played….not even a hint of it happening…but half an hour later everybody knew for sure, from impeccable ‘sources, that Moyes was in for a meeting with Terry from TFG first thing in the morning and defo about to be named as the new Everton manager ‘as soon as tomorrow.Its like simple length of tenure means the sensationalist twats will never let it lie.While Kenwright was still around it was kind of understandable. It was a lazy shout that provided the press with an easy headline which, regardless of proof, always carried with it the possibility of perhaps coming true, due to the sentimental way the old tit prattled on about their long-term partnership and the fact he was loathe to end it in the first place. Now though? Who would there be remaining in and around the club advocating for his return? Josh Horne 451 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:00:22 Paul@425 I'm in complete agreement that staying up is top priority. Moyes did that and more in his previous tenure. But, that was a long time ago and he has not changed whilst the rest of the PL has. His brand of football didn't save Sunderland. We are on a downward trajectory this season and have forgotten how to score goals, not his strength as a coach even at his peak. I don't really care about the way he left, humiliating as it is to be so desperate to be considering his return in spite of those circumstances. I do think we should have enough to stay up with a mood change at the club, can he do that though? Even his recent interviews raise questions about his suitability for the task in hand. It looks like we are going to find out and I hope that you are right about him and that he is no more than a stepping stone towards a manager who can sustain entertaining, competitive football. Jim Wilson 452 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:03:20 At the moment we are in a worse mess than a day ago.This is not what I wanted from the Friedkins.Where is the plan? Where are the immediate couple of signings the team needs? It is all off the cuff and just as bad as it has been for years.If someone had told me in 2020 that Everton will have 4 managers in the next 4 years named Benitez, Lampard, Dyche and then Moyes I would have been seriously worried about their sanity. Meanwhile Ipswich have made a couple of good signings and have shown they can now beat a top side.I have never been so depressed. This is a nightmare. Laurie Hartley 453 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:03:33 Paul # 448 - you mean like Moyes? 😉 Kevin Molloy 454 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:05:16 I understand why you say that Dennis but surely there are better candidates for the Everton job than Sam Allardyce. He had his chance, and the footy wasn't that great. And he'd also want another ten million. It's a no from me. John Raftery 455 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:06:01 Michael (444) I agree with you. If as reported Dyche said he had taken us as far as he could, it will not be long before the new manager is saying exactly the same unless there are a couple of additions to the squad this month. One scapegoat has gone. We await the new Messiah. I think deep down we all know there wont be one until the club is in a position to compete in the transfer market. Oliver Molloy 456 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:13:36 Somebody has probably already said it.There is no doubt many do not want Moyes back for obvious reasons, but unfortunately for us I would argue he is the "safest" bet to stay up and this is the most important factor right now for the club and us.Any of these other "experienced" and up coming "fancy" football guys would be a huge risk in a relegation battle in a league that would frighten the life out of many of them - they will come alright - for the money.Realistically we do not have the players to play "fancy" football and we have no money to spend so unless we sell.Moyes wants three years they are offering eighteen months -only a matter of time folks and I do believe it will give us all lift, unless we get hammered by Villa !! John Keating 457 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:14:31 Dont want MoyesI would sooner leave Baines and Coleman in charge and reassess at the end of the season Dennis Stevens 458 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:22:21 I'm not suggesting Allardyce would be my first choice, Kevin, I mentioned him really to emphasise how much I don't want Moyes back. Especially if it isn't a short term contract up to the end of the season. I'd actually prefer John's suggestion of letting the interim arrangement roll on to the end of the season unless or until the right appointment can be made. Michael Lynch 459 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:25:23 I don't entirely disagree John @ 457, but it's not just Dyche gone, it's his entire coaching staff. That's a lot of work for Baines and Coleman - and it's not like we can promote from within without putting my nan and the bloke next door in charge of the U21 and youth set-up.And, to be honest, Baines doesn't strike me as the managerial type. Seamus, though I love him, is a great cheer-leader but probably not much more than that yet. As far as I'm aware he has done no coaching at all, and has yet to sit for any of his badges. James Hughes 460 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:26:28 I do not want Moyes anywhere near the club. He treated us with contempt when he left. Ran down his contract after being tapped up by whiskey nose. Gushing about how he was only wearing jeans when he popped round to Fergie's house. The club doing nothing about the illegal approach either. Talking about Felliani and Baines should be allowed to join a big club. This is after he spent 11 years talking us down and saying we were punching above our weigh, glass ceiling, knives in gunfights Yada FUCKING YADA. The wanker made us being best of the rest acceptable and the standard we should be aiming for. Whilst all the while he was being paid good money to serve up shite and convincing everyone he was making a silk purse out of sow's ear. Despite the gloom I still believe that we have a half decent squad and should avoid relegation if applied properly. Please be positive guys, watch Kelly's Heroes and stop with the negative waves, or rre-read some of George Mc's old posts and look for cosmic waves This and the new stadium next year when we will be playing on the banks of the ROYAL BLUE MERSEY in front of 52,000 fans. I am betting a few managers would want a slice of that pie. Dycheosaurus, many thanks Sir, you did your upmost but you have looked a beaten man this year. I wish you well sir. But a big fat Fuck Off to Dour Dave. Sorry for the vent/rant but UTFT + COYB Jim Wilson 461 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:30:18 There is the difference between a good manager and a true blue and an overrated manager and a fraud.Royle jumped to take on the Everton job when he got the call. He didn't even talk about his wages.Moyes will haggle over his contract, and that is all he is concerned about. Would take Michael Carrick over Moyes, without hesitation. Martin Clark 462 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:31:09 Wonder if it would have been cheaper to put them on gardening leave! Brian Williams 463 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:32:00 James#460Well said mate. Stephen Meighan 464 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:33:04 Don't this club ever learn? Why on earth are they thinking of hiring Dithering Davie??? I'm sick of the boring drab management we've had to put up with for years: Allardyce, Koeman, Benitez, Dyche… now Moyes – all cut from the same cloth. I personally would leave Baines and Coleman in charge for the rest of the season then try and go for a young forward-thinking manager. Plenty out there if you do your homework. Plus the fact Moyes isn't going to take less than an 18-month contract. Oliver Molloy 465 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:40:54 Nobody will give a toss who the manager is if we could win games; that's where this club is at. Baines & Coleman would be out of their depth – just like Duncan Ferguson was.Moyes is on his way and I will bet he will get a great reception. Alan McGuffog 466 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:56:37 Yeah Anthony... Area Manager. Vanda said she was nice. Raymond Fox 467 Posted 10/01/2025 at 11:59:40 Here we go again talking about managers. Moyes will be our safest option by a mile, anyone suggesting keeping Baines on as manager is having a laugh.What we really need is six new very good players – not another manager; problem is, we know we won't get them.How many times have we tried this approach, it's top players that win you games – not managers.I suppose something had to change because it got to the point where we seemed incapable of scoring a goal, it all comes down to who do you blame for that.We will see soon enough. Christopher Timmins 468 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:24:43 Raymond # 467Six might be slightly overstating it but only slightly, what concerns me more is that the task of acquiring them just got that bit more complicated with the sacking of Dyche.Talking of Dyche, he deserved better from the club than the statement that issued yesterday evening. I was giving out about West Ham and the way they treated their former manager earlier in the week but were we much better truth be told. What can't be taken away from Dyche is that with a major negative spend over his period in charge and with two points deductions he kept us in the division. I can't help but think that things really turned for the worse after the defeats at home to Bournemouth and away at Villa. That left its mark on the team and manager. He became ultra cautious after those defeats. Ian Wilkins 469 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:28:31 Lets face facts. Dyche played his part in our survival post Frank and post points deductions. We owe him some thanks. His football was dire ( worst Ive seen from an Everton team in 50 years of watching). This season, hed reached point of Groundhog Day and in his words apparently ‘an inability to do any more with this squad.Change therefore inevitable. We are in a relegation fight, it is not obvious there are 3 worse teams. Major squad change isnt happening in January ( tho a couple of new faces are essential). In our current predicament we need an experienced head who knows the league, the club, the task. Only candidate for this moment is David Moyes.Best bet would be Moyes with Carsley as his no 2. Sadly unlikely. Moyes is no expansive manager. He, his footballing style not what we want to see long term in Bramley Moore. But right now, in this moment, with this squad, hes our only sensible option. Keep options open in his contract. Survive this season and start to build for better times. Ernie Baywood 470 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:31:06 Raymond, who would you trust to sign a player or two this month? Personally, I'd have more faith in Moyes than any of the other cast that might have been mentioned.If he'll do the job, he's a certainly as an interim appointment. I'd be disappointed if it was anything more than that. Robert Tressell 471 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:31:16 Christopher, I don't believe prospective signings will be hugely concerned by the managerial situation. Moyes v Dyche v Potter - why would, say, a 21 year old RB playing in Brazil (eg Wesley who we are linked with) give a monkeys. He won't have heard of any of them. The bigger issue is that we have been outbid (again) by Ipswich - for Philogene. As ever the problems in the transfer market come down to money. John Gall 472 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:39:32 I love how everybody just seems to assume the new stadium is going to magically transform our fortunes. Like all of a sudden we start playing like Barcelona and winning trophies, after Carlo comes running back to walk his dog on Crosby beach. By August this year it will be the same team with the same problems on a different patch of grass, and Moyes as the manager again, grinding out results with a bunch of mismatched grafters. And that's best case scenario, if we manage to stay up. Ian Pilkington 473 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:40:31 The thought of Moyes returning is depressing beyond words, so I wont be adding any more. Danny Baily 474 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:41:41 Odds on Moyes have gone up to between 80-90% from around 75% earlier today. It's happening. Les Callan 475 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:52:16 According to sky sports, its Moyes. 2 year deal. Colin Quayle 476 Posted 10/01/2025 at 12:52:46 Too depressing if Moyes comes back. It's new players we need and even Bainsey is ok until May. Not Moyes..seriously...sinking sand...i don't see him being welcomed with the things he said and the stunt he pulled at Manu. What does he have in his skillset that Dyche doesnt have?? We need players... Jerome Shields 477 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:00:36 Dyche had to go he had run out of road.Last Summers outcomes eventually sealed his fate.I expect TFG to bring in their own Manager and backing him with the immediate season and the future being the template in mind.I don't expect any of the usual speculatives to be in the hat. Dan Nulty 478 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:02:55 It was always going to be Moyes. It was going to be risky to appoint anyone else who didn't have premier league experience. This is where we are at. We've got 16 players probably leaving the club in the summer and the reality is the best person we've had evaluating the mentality of signings in the last 20 years is Moyes. We can't afford to try for someone exciting when we could still go down. Danny O'Neill 479 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:03:18 I'll wait until it's announced.Moyes, the ghost of Everton past.A big no thank you for me. He will cut a decisive figure amongst the supporters. It's already starting to. Brian Denton 480 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:04:42 Ian (Wilkins) 469. If the rumours are to be believed, Moyes definitely won't come on an interim basis, but will request at least a 3 year deal. TFG would need to think very carefully about that, as any 'flexibility' in their thinking will lead to compo costs down the road. More money down the drain. Dave Abrahams 481 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:06:50 Ian (473) Ditto. Bobby Mallon 482 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:07:39 My mate has just left our whatsapp group because of that Danny . He wants Moyes I don't says he's what we need. He also said we needed Benitez 😂 Danny Baily 483 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:09:18 Two plus year deal Moyes if Sky Sports are correct. Genuinely don't know what to make of it. If things were rotten behind then scenes then Dyche had to go, and Moyes is a serviceable manager at this level. I can't escape the feeling that we're just rubbish, and Dyche was getting just about the best tune we could reasonably expect him to have gotten out of this squad.If the dressing room was happy enough with Dyche, and he was up for the challenge, then I would suggest results thus far were not sufficient grounds for a change in manager.The defining characteristics of Moyes' time at West Ham was poor results from a talented side. What's he's coming in to here is closer to what he inherited at Sunderland. I don't think there's much prospect of an upturn on fortunes under Moyes.Ipswich fans will be delighted. Let's just hope there the financial headroom to bolster the squad, because last night (in particular, Young's brief cameo) highlighted how little quality we have. Colette Black 484 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:09:37 So, after all these years of hell we are going to go back to Moyes - a manager who won sweet FA for us in 11 years? This would be it for me. I wonder how long until the grim reaper returns. Terry Downes 485 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:11:27 Well if its Moyes again looks like some of us will be dead before we win a trophy talking about standing still ? Similar vein to Dyche KITAP and hope ? Hopefully hell find a couple of gems like Cahill & Arteta wouldnt bank on it, very poor choice we had a chance to change Evertons direction in football but no well stay the same walking football till eventually we get relegated ! Raymond Fox 486 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:12:01 Ernie, it would be Moyes- problem is its not easy to sign players with that bit more quality that we need in this window.Its going to be a struggle but I have faith that we can stay up. Alan McGuffog 487 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:16:37 I just feckin give up ! Really thought things might be different but I guess its Everton isn't it. Kevin Edward 488 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:17:10 Im not sure how Moyes returning is likely to work if the strong rumours are true.After all the toss and dross of the Mosh years what we really need is a united EFC.We may have been the peoples club but that was a long time ago now and things have changed. I think Moyes is taking a big risk if happy to take it on again.Regardless of the way he moved on, and the poor results return when opportunities did arise during his spell here, Im surprised that TFG are also prepared to take the risk.Without much choice our fans will be divided unless a new manager can unite, and Moyes is on a hiding to nothing before he even starts. Of course I would get behind the team to keep us up, but then what? If he can deliver a trophy then Im happy to sing his name. Dyche had to go, but incoming Moyes with baggage just feels wrong to me. New owners, same old Everton it seems. Paul Smith 489 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:18:35 Moyes on a 2 year contract... wtf. 6 months maybe but 2 years...it's like the last 10 years never happened, so fucked up. Fred Quick 490 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:18:47 There are two distinct reasons for TFG acting in the way they have, the immediate spectre of relegation and the financial affairs of the club. Both are obviously linked, Everton relegated equals a massive fall in revenue, via merit payments and potential sponsors. The money will be the main driving force for TFG, they won't worry too much whether we as fans are happy or unhappy, as long as we keep turning up in large numbers. A two year deal for Moyes makes more sense than a six month deal, as that will underpin his authority with the playing squad. A Six month deal would leave Moyes in the same situation as Dyche, with the clock running down and current first-teamers not having to give 100% and having an eye on the exit door. I can't say that I'm at all happy about the return of Dour Davie, and even less happy that he'll be the guy to lead us into the new stadium. However, if he is appointed and he successfully keeps us in the top division then it will be mission accomplished, but a bright new dawn for Everton will have to be put on the back-burner for a good while longer. I hope that when Moyes is replaced, if he comes at all, Everton and its leaders don't continue to be trapped in the mid 2000s and begin to cast their net further and wider for a manager who will transform the club to where we'd like it to be. Stability could be the word, for stuck in the mud and Everton has been stuck in the mud, for what seems to be forever, and it will take more than a stick-in-the-mud personality to lead us out of it. Robert Tressell 491 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:23:12 I don't believe our list of transfer targets will change materially regardless of who the manager is. Particularly in January. It's more about who is being made available - then fee, payment terms (ie willingness to accept payment on the drip) and wage demands.Other than longer term development players (like Kinsky at Spurs and Soler at Bournemouth) there isn't a particularly big pool of players to go at. Barry Rathbone 492 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:23:44 Is there a therapy group where I can practice "I'm right behind whoever gets appointed - even Moyes" ?I need to sound convincing at parties. Brian Denton 493 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:36:45 Time to dust off Eugene's brilliant 'On Holiday with the Moyes Family'. I will try and find it as soon as/if the appointment is announced. Rob Halligan 494 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:36:57 We give Moyes a two year contract, so what happens in two years time, do we replace him mid-season? Fred Quick 496 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:38:53 Rob @494It'll probably be two-and-a-half years to prevent the contract ending mid-season? Whatever length of contract, it will be good for Moyes' bank account. Brian Williams 497 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:40:45 Definition of madness.Doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.OrBringing Moyes back. Derek Knox 498 Posted 10/01/2025 at 13:59:21 A six month contract would be understandable, though not necessarily welcomed, but any longer is a retrograde step in my opinion. Bill Gall 500 Posted 10/01/2025 at 14:07:32 I wonder what went on yesterday before the game before it had even been cleared to play. As Mike G. has previously explained the Friedkin Group are a very successful business organization that have made their fortune on steady planning and not with snap decisions.We still have not got a board set up yet with a search still going on for a C.E.O. There has been no hint that Dyche was about to leave but there was an inevitability that it was going to happen. So what burst the bubble yesterday. that the Friedkin Group's steady planning made a snap decisionwithout a backup in place.Basically we are now looking for another S.Dyche to save us from relegation with a previous manager one of the favorites. Regardless of who they bring in they are going to have to work with the squad that is available with maybe 1or 2 players brought in. So why don't we go with a more progressive manager instead of "someone who knows the club ". All managers have different tactical styles of play but during the course of their career must study both defensive and attacking styles of play in preparing for a game. I suppose to put it in a military term, You don't advance your club in retreating. Being safe or overly safe does not always work that is why we have accidents. Should have put this on the never go back article Paul Randall 501 Posted 10/01/2025 at 14:34:52 It seems that our fanbase is 50/50 on a David Moyes return. Personally, I would like to see D Ferguson with Bainsy as his assistant in place until the end of the season, with a real carrot of a longer contract if results improve. Or, at the end of this season, safe in the premier league, we then look to appoint a younger, successful, ambitious manager who relishes the job. Jeff Armstrong 502 Posted 10/01/2025 at 15:53:05 Paul 501, is that the same D.Ferguson who got sacked at Forest Green Rovers and won 1 in something like 15 at Caladonian Inverness Thistle, or the D.Ferguson who managed Peterborough last night and has been stuck managing in the lower leagues for about 15 years?…. Neither thank you.Moyes? no thanks, unless Carsley came too with Moyes moving upstairs in 6 months. Ajay Gopal 503 Posted 10/01/2025 at 18:06:28 Oh my God, not Moyes please! It feels like a rewind of the Moshiri years - chaos, zero strategic planning, being a laughing stock. Our fans deserve so much better in terms of leadership, but tragically, it feels like another false dawn.We needed to freshen things up and Dyche had to go, but he had got us 17 points from as many games. I doubt that Moyes will get us to 38 points by end of season. I can already see the excuses from Moyes- “the squad was threadbare when I came, ‘no money to spend, ‘the team was demoralised, etc, etc. Just too depressing to even think that it might be dinosaur David Moyes who will lead us into our fantastic new stadium. I feel like crying. Dan Nulty 504 Posted 10/01/2025 at 18:43:33 Ajay, I fully understand your thought process. Not ideal but we needed to make a change and I'm just not sure putting an unproven manager in the Premier league is the answer in our position. Dyche threw the towel in by all accounts. Svein-Roger Jensen 505 Posted 10/01/2025 at 21:15:11 Not Just rumours #Colin 273 Pete Clarke 506 Posted 11/01/2025 at 00:13:08 If we appoint a manager with a plan, brains and hunger for success then we could live with relegation. If we go down with Moyes, then what ? Its just endless torture with this fucking club of ours. Terry Nulty 507 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:26:03 Very well put, Peter @125 and Micheal @444 and similar from others – I agree fully with your sentiments.It's all been said already here, re the impossible circumstances he operated in while miraculously keeping us in the Premier League etc, but in short, without Sean Dyche, we'd already be in the Championship – and near the bottom of it.I see mentions and fears here of us now becoming the next Sunderland and that was my real fear before the Dyche appointment; we were definitely headed on that downward path.Irrespective of all the views on Sean Dyche and managers, and that banter and exchange is still one of the good things across football, my view is that Thursday goes down as one of EFCs worst days.To sack a manager within hours of an important game is just unheard of and impossible to justify; it shows scant respect for the club, the team, and the fans.Likewise, irrespective of rumours and what did or didn't happen, not to include a word of thanks to the man after what he's done; I think someone here used the word ‘astonishing' – I'd go with disgraceful, petty and crass. A bad day for our great club and ominous if this is the way the new owners operate. I remain a committed fan of Everton FC, regardless of who the owners that come and go are, but I genuinely feel, aside from the likes of Leicester City and Ipswich Town, who'll take great heart from it, that this diminishes our survival chances.It's basically up to the players now to step up and give everything as a group to make that survival happen. COYB Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb