The Mail Bag
Big Vic
Comments (45)
Great result tonight, obviously. We played tight and patient and competed physically without seeing any red mist.
But I am worried about Big Vic. Where is the player who 2 years ago was coming off the bench and muscling his way to important goals left, right an centre ? especially in Europe? Power, passion, commitment and impossible to knock off a ball??? Now ? and maybe he spent too much time with AJ ? he goes down like a sack of spuds as soon as anyone breathes on him in the box.
I know this kind of stuff is just part of the game today ? but Vic is doing it when he has good goalscoring opportunities, and doing it pretty unconvincingly. Two years ago, I thought there were signs he could develop into a mini-Yak. At the moment, that looks impossible.
Gregg Ainsworth, Posted 19/01/2009 at 21:04:49
Comments
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Your thoughts are correct though, we do have another yak in the club ? the diving.
(I thought he had an overall good game, apart from falling down half the time)
Personally looking at him presently, I don't think he will make it, his control is clumsy and his size seems to be a hinderance. James Vaughan is a different player altogether, a potential star ? but that another thread.
Great performance last night COYB?s
Gutsy effort from the boys, I fear though that they will come all guns blazing at us this weekend with Gerrard playing up the field a bit more. We will need to carve out more opportunities. Also removing Hibbert from the field if we are to have better continuity and a real crack at winning. COYB!
If he keeps on playing like how he did today, he will improve for sure. His next 3 games (Shite, Arsenal, ManUtd) would give him some further valuable experiences......
Come On You Blues....
I could hardly believe what I was reading when I saw these posts.
Despite being played out of position, Vic did very well, his passing was accurate, he won headers all night, he tracked back well, he forced the Liverpool keeper into a desperate save with a 25yarder in the first minute ! It was his brilliant cross from the right that Cahill got on the end of to force the same keeper to make another save,
The incident your referring to when Vic went down looking for a penalty wasnt a result of a slick move, it was all his own work, he ran to close two men down 45 yards from goal, he rag dolled one, powered past the other into the box, he was knackered and it was on his week foot, so yes, he did go down easily, but there are plenty of referees who would have pointed to the spot at another ground.
What do you want from this kid ??? he was making his 4th prem start this season - third out of position
In the alehouse, after the game, all the RS were saying he was our best player by a mile - probably because he was involved in nearly all of our meaningful attacks
I despair at the need to find a whipping boy amongst our ranks - even after a good result.
I half expecting another post blaiming Hibbert for their goal
Secondly, once our striker injury crisis is over, I think we should sell Vic to a stoke,or championship side and get a couple of million for him while we can
He showed heart, strength, pace and composure. He was a nuisence and him coming inside from the right was great for us. Liverpool couldn’t handle it.
So he went down a little easy....so what? He made up for it by winning the freekick that we ended up scoring from.
Well done Vic, keep it up. If he plays like that week in week out then he should stay in the side.
How many 19/20 year old strikers in the League force there way into a Premier League side and stay there? Not many if any at all to be honest.
He’s been at the club for a few years yes but he’s still only young and he’s still only made about 25-30 starts, in those he’s scored 11 goals. He’s still very inexperienced in terms of football.
We have a tiny squad, we don’t have the money to add to that squad. No we shouldn’t be getting rid of players like Victor. He’s a squad player and he’s proven he can chip in with goals and he can be useful (on the right) for us.
He did have a couple of flashes of promise though and if he could do more of that and less of the other we would have a great player on our hands,
I would like to see more performances like that. Although i dont really think he’s suited to playing up front on his own
When Vaughan and Vic first broke in to the team I was like others and thought Vanghan was the more talented. Now I think Vic could make it and not Vaughan. Vaughan plays with his head down too much and just tries to knock it past a player and use his pace.
Vic surprised me tonight, strong in the air and his footwork and composure is getting better. I dont think he will become a worldbeater but could grow to be an important player for the remainder of the season. He just seems to need constant encouragement. Cahill keeps providing this aand Vic tries harder.
As for the dive he did well to get there but didn’t know what to do when he was there, a decent striker would have played for a corner or waited for the tackle or shock horror shot at goal. I would expect him to retain his place for the cup match but unless he does better he’s out when Screech is available again.
As a footnote did he do well last night because " he did well " or "he was better than our low expectations".
Well done Vic, you did a good (but not great) job last night.
Just a thought.
Up the blues, roll on Sunday!
Victor = the black McFadden.
My favorite moment when he headed the ball in a challange with Alonso & carried through & gave Alonso whiplash of his neck ! I did not see Alonso do much after that!!!!
I just wonder what fans would be saying if in the firs minute when he chested it down & volled it if it had screamed in to the net ??????
This lad will make the grade, Joe Royle was picked on for ages before he became a very good striker as he was young & raw, but he put him self about just like Victor did for us last night!!!!!!
His half volley with his weaker foot, his cross onto Cahills head, holding off two reds to supply Baines, making Alonso and Skrtel look like sunday league players as he went past them (yes he shouldn’t of dived but look how well he did to get there), and winning the free kick from whence we scored.
Now I’m not saying I’m convinced Vic will ’make it’, but I do think alot of these negitive comments were premeditated, and if you anaylise his performance you will see he played his part last night. Also, Jay Campbell, I dont know what you think gives you the right to call someone you’ve never met a twat, if you’ve got criticisms about his performance then say so, but by resorting to abuse you only weaken your own argument.
I was fuming at that big lad on his knees with his hands in the air all game, or on his heels when we broke into the box.
Although he performed better than I expected, he is not good enough.
Our financial situation doesnt look like improving anytime soon, Vic cost nothing, he’s an apprentice. Of course if he is to become a long term asset - saving us a fortune - the coaching staff have a lot of work to do, but a blind man can see they have something to work with.
Les Ferdinand and Ian wright were both about 5 years older than Vic is now before they could even get a club to take them on, look how they turned out ?
I fear the seemingly endless stream of ignorant comments will destroy this lad.
The shite had about 60 million quids worth of attacking talent on the pitch last night, our boy puts a full 90 min shift in, outshines them all . . . then gets slaughtered
you couldnt make it up
I can’t offer much myself other than he annoys me but I feel he could make the grade if he gets out of his "laxy" streak.
I expect a "anti Hibbert" rant soon, a slight one already in this one and I expect Tony Marsh to stay quite quiet. Does anyone else find is coincidental that he turned up to do an article just before the run of 4 atrocious games?
Respect to Dave Wilson for the first accurate post regarding big Vic.
He quite clearly played a good game out of position. He worked hard (try watching players off the ball!). He did NOT got down easy, I mean hench players of his mould only have short bursts of energy and having already made up ground/beat a man I think he can be forgiven for being caught off balance.
Dont get me wrong, last night was sadly an exception for big Vic and I would be pleased with/for him if he could produce such effort/performance more often.
Moyes should have a word with Irvine, and see if he would be intrested in taking the lad.
For a youngster who has recently been injured and hardly started a game in the last 18 months, he did great.
Some of yu people are never happy.
Give him a run in the team and he’ll prove you wrong.
He was had his chance to imprint his name on Merseyside Derby Blue Folklore when he chased 2 liverpool defenders down giving them a 10 yeard head start, charged one defender, left him on the ground eating dirt, (was it Carragher?) and then easily went through another (was it Skrtyle?), he was 1on1 with the keeper, my heart was in my mouth with excitement, "open up your right foot and put it through Reina’s legs and make a hero of yourself tonight" i thought...and he bloody dived.
I nearly punched the wall with pure frustration, if he had buried that instead of going down far too easily, then we would still be talking about THAT goal in 20 years time, i hope he realises that and if he does that again just buries it in the net and thinks about it after that.
Naturally Liverpool went straight up the park and The Accused buried it. That made my frustration with Big Vic so much much worse!!!
But i’m not having any of this get rid of him crap, he’s one for the future, i reckon him and Vaughany (if he stays fit) will be a cracking partnership in the future, we just need a bit of patience with and fully support the both of them.
P.S. Anyone else notice Jags and Lescott being bear hugged on our equalising goal (God Bless you Tiny Tim, love you to bits wee man, you’re a legend my son and you made this working week so much better for so many of us!!!)?
You are spot on.
We must be the worst club in the league for never being happy with our own.
Whether it be Hibbo,Ossie or now big Vic.
The lad has hardly had a chance.
Give him a run of 5 or 6 games like we are now doing with Baines and you’ll see the difference.
Vic has no fear and to see Hypia and Skrtl terrified of him was a joy to behold.
I thought him and Baines were outstanding last night and should be encouraged not criticised.
Get behind the lad and see what confidence does for a player.
You all have very shor memories remember a certain useless James Beattie a guy who could not trap a bag of cement & cost 6 million pounds & went 12 months with out a goal in open play!
Victor cost us nothing & last night I thought He & Tim on their own ran the LFC defence hard when they got support. both Osman & Piennaar imo were both poor last night in supplying any support to them, but not one mention of them having an average game!
I live in Canada and watched the game with different commentators... who gave the MOTM to Pienaar. Funny olde game hey!
Quite often players work hard to do a selfless job in tracking back etc and dont get the credit they deserve. WIth all the effort the players put in last night I hope also that they dont read the shite written on here - it’s a good job they seem to believe in themselves hey and they dont have to rely on us lot for it.
Ask the Koppites what they thought of him and I bet that the much vaunted top class Liverpool defence were damn glad to see the back of him.
Everyone is praising Cahill and completely forgetting the local lad who showed a lot of ability on Tuesday night and he will definitely prove the better prospect than Vaughan. 0I couldn?t see the likes of Owen or Defoe upsetting Liverpool as much as big Vic did. You must have no knowledge of football at all to just hero worship one or two players who can do no wrong in your eyes... he best players on the pitch for me were the local lads... Jags, Baines,Vic and even Hibbo... the defence were magnificent against a first class Liverpool team... give Vic a break !!
His attitude, effort and performance against the RS last night was a major factor in us getting something from the game. He put himself about and caused them trouble consistently.
So fair play to him and well done last night he had a good game and reminded us of the good displays he put in last season.
But why can’t he show desire and attitude like that every week. I accept that he can’t perform like that every week given his age and inexperience but attitude and desire should be a given. Quite simply it has’nt been.
More of last night Vic and you will make it impossible for David Moyes to leave you out. Look at what Leighton Baines has done - grabbed the chance he was given culminating in a superb display last night.
Vic is still raw material but he showed last night that he can be a premiership player - if he wants it enough.


1 Posted 20/01/2009 at 03:44:20
Report abuse