Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In Sign Up
Text:  A  A  A

Moyes's Problems Multiply

By Lyndon Lloyd :  27/11/2010 :  Comments (27) :

Everton 1-4 West Bromwich Albion

Everton's erratic and increasingly frustrating season plumbed new depths this afternoon with a 4-1 home defeat to newly-promoted West Bromwich Albion that saw the Baggies win at Goodison Park for the first time in 31 years and David Moyes lose one of his key players to a three-game suspension just as another was serving the last game of his own ban for picking up a straight red card.

12 minutes into the second half, with the Blues battling to recover from an almost unthinkable 2-0 deficit, Mikel Arteta was given his marching orders by the appallingly inconsistent Lee Mason for an apparent stamp on Gonzalo Jara, becoming the second Everton midfielder after Marouane Fellaini to pick up a red card this season.

That turned a hill that Moyes's side were attempting to climb into a mountain and though substitute Jermaine Beckford had more chances to perform heriocs and salvage the game, the Blues ended up on the wrong end of a thrashing, leaving themselves and their manager with nowhere to hide.

It's hard to know where to begin with the post-mortem on this ugly result. It seemed like business as usual when Everton started the stronger side, Sylvain Distin coming within inches of connecting with Leighton Baines' early in-swinging cross, Tim Cahill taking advantage of space to unload from 25 yards but blazing over, and Victor Anichebe, thrown straight into duty wide on the right at the expense of Seamus Coleman, producing the first of a number of impressive saves from Scott Carson all inside the first seven minutes.

But Albion scored from two of their first three attacks and all of a sudden Goodison was overcome by a seething hush punctuated by the chants of the jubilant visiting fans and increasing groans and shouts of frustration from the home faithful.

After a quarter of an hour, Phil Scharner ? of course, who else? ?easily got in front of Phil Jagielka to meet a corner from the WBA left and power a header in off the hands of Tim Howard.

Then, after Cahill had needlessly bundled Youssouf Mulumbu over in a dangerous area outside the Everton box, Chris Brunt despatched a free kick so unerringly accurate that it flew into the one area of the goal that Howard couldn't reach, despite flinging himself across his goalline and into his left-hand post in an effort to do just that.

Two efforts on target ? Brunt had earlier blasted a left-footer wide after an awful giveaway by John Heitinga in midfield ? two goals and Roberto di Matteo's men were 2-0 up.

Everton were back in the hunt four minutes before half-time, though, when Cahill rose superbly to meet Baines' corner from the left side and steer an unstoppable header back into the top corner to make it 2-1.

A second corner, this time from the other side, flashed agonisingly across the face of Carson's goal and Heitinga couldn't react quickly enough to get the vital touch top turn it home by the far post so the Blues had to be content with 2-1 going into half time.

After 10 minutes of the second half without so much as a shot on goal, Moyes finally opted for an early change to his team, making his now familiar double-switch in the 55th minute, bringing on Beckford for Heitinga and Louis Saha for Yakubu.

The Nigerian had been below his best, certainly, but he could hardly be blamed for the drought of scoring chances. Continuing his mystifyingly poor form of late, Arteta was sitting confusingly deep, leaving the abysmal Heitinga as the more advanced of the two central midfielders for much of the first 57 minutes and putting the creative burden once more on the shoulders of Steven Pienaar.

The South African had accepted the situation and, together with Anichebe, was one of the best Everton players on the pitch in the first half, that is until the pair switched flanks and everything seemed to grind to a halt.

If Arteta is carrying an injury, he'll get some time off to recuperate thanks to an ill-advised act of retribution on Jara in the 57th minute.

In a beautiful moment of precision and smooth link-up play, Pienaar had put Beckford in on goal with a perfectly-weighted, defence-splitting pass that the striker latched onto and tried to slip under the advancing Carson with a low side-foot shot. The 'keeper got a hand to it and as the ball skipped on its way to goal, Gabriel Tamas' overhead kick prevented it from crossing the line.

As Baines jumped to challenge for the clearance on the edge of the box, he was poleaxed by Jara's elbow right in front of referee Mason who didn't even blink. Play continued as Pienaar bounced off the Chilean's next robust challenge and when Jara went to ground in a third tacke on Arteta, the Everton man appeared to deliberately attempt to bring his foot down on his opponent's leg.

As a number of players squared up to each other, Mason eventually flashed Arteta a red card after consulting his assistant and the Blues were down to 10 men. Jara escaped censure altogether...

Moyes responded by withdrawing the tiring and isolated Anichebe in favour of Jack Rodwell and, with a Goodison crowd fueled by a burning sense of injustice behind them, resumed their search for the equaliser with renewed vigour.

And they made a pretty decent fist of it for the next 15 minutes, with Beckford, for better or worse, in the thick of the action. He dragged a decent chance badly wide from 18 yards in the 63rd minute and after Cahill had bounced an ambitious half-volley a yard the wrong side of the post, Beckford looked to be in on another slide-rule Pienaar pass but it was slightly overhit and Cardson swept it clear.

Two minutes later, Beckford tried to go it alone despite plenty of support either side of him and just one defender for company and wasted a great chance before he spurned one more gilt-edged opportunity in the 72nd minute. Tony Hibbert chipped a peach of a ball to the far post which Beckford met but he skied it embarrassingly over the bar from close range. Full marks for movement, for anticipation and for being in the right place time after time, but the new boy's profligacy would prove costly.

That's because WBA, having absorbed that spell of pressure from their hosts, suddenly took a grip of proceedings and killed Everton off with two excellent goals. First, with Hibbert backing five yards off him, substitute Somen Tchoyi turned inside, fooled both defenders in front of him with a shimmy before curling an impressive shot around Howard and inside the far post to restore Albion's two-goal lead.

The Cameroonian then skinned Hibbert again two minutes later but could only belt it straight at the 'keeper from a tight angle as the Blues wobbled.

Still, though, after Mulumbu had somehow escaped a yellow card for chopping down Pienaar with his umpteenth foul and Beckford had been booked for dissent, Everton could have halved the Baggies' lead again with six minutes to go. Beckford was on hand to collect Saha's flick-on into the box but, with no one around him, he over-elaborated with the finish, electing a scissor-kick that flew wide rather than a dinked shot over the advanced 'keeper.

Three minutes later, it was all over. Back at the other end, Tchoyi tormented Hibbert one last time, handed it off to Mulumbu who collected a one-two from the Cameroonian winger before clipping a shot in off Distin's chest to make it 4-1. The Congolose was finally booked for an over-elaborate celebration and was sent off 30 seconds later for a second bookable offence when he caught Beckford in full flight.

That was cold comfort for Everton who had played over half an hour with ten men and ended up being soundly beaten on home turf for the third time this season, their second home defeat to newly-promoted opposition this season.

Beckford's chances aside, it's quite possible they would have lost anyway even without Arteta's dimissal. The Spaniard had offered little to the game up to that point and where the Blues were again struggling to keep the ball and to make the final pass tell, Di Matteo's charges looked, on balance, sharper, fitter, stronger, faster and hungrier.

Albion chased everything that moved for the most of the game and Everton were eclipsed by individual brilliance while their own players, Cahill aside, failed to produce in front of goal. Where Baines and Arteta failed from direct free kick attempts in the first half ? Baines put his over and Carson acrobatically palmed Arteta's second kick away ? Brunt was inch perfect; and while Anichebe and Pienaar played well enough, they couldn't unlock the opposition defence with such devastating efficiency as Tchoyi did.

And that was the difference. With the same personnel as last season, Everton remain perplexing ineffective, the answers to their malaise seemingly as intangible as the form that lit up much of the second half of last season.

Moyes's team selection was sound enough; Hibbert was disappointing but Coleman may have been torn apart by Tchoyi in the same manner had he replaced Phil Neville at right back; Anichebe was energetic and a handful for the first half hour and forced a great save from Carson; and Cahill proved that he deserves his place in whatever formation you call it with yet another headed goal, though the attacking threat was clearly amplifed with Beckford's introduction, perhaps making a strong case for two out-and-out strikers at home, with Cahill accommodated somehow in midfield.

Chelsea away next and an equally daunting trip to Eastlands to face Man City on the horizon with a home game against fellow strugglers Wigan in between, the challenges are going to be coming thick and fast for Everton as the festive season approaches. Moyes has shown resilience and surprising powers of recovery in the past but there is a worrying sense this time around that this season is running away from him and that he doesn't have the answers to his team's current malaise.

Fellaini returns next week, an obvious straight replacement for Arteta, but it's in the penalty area at both ends that the real problems lie right now ? a shortage of goals and a shortage of clean sheets are turning a chase for Europe into a battle to avoid a relegation dogfight... with no transfer funds to provide fresh blood to a stale-looking side.

Player Ratings:
Howard 6, Hibbert 6, Jagielka 6, Distin 8, Baines 7, Arteta 5, Heitinga 5 (Beckford 6), Anichebe 7 (Rodwell 6), Pienaar 8*, Cahill 7, Yakubu 6 (Saha 6)

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Peter Barry
1   Posted 28/11/2010 at 07:23:56

Report abuse

This season is already over as far as I am concerned. A run in the FA Cup not a hope, I am afraid. No, it's going to be a relegation fight for us... and one which we already seem resigned to ? well the "players" (??) at least do.
Liam Reilly
2   Posted 28/11/2010 at 08:37:14

Report abuse

I think you missed out on rating Cahill, Lyndon, the only player who deserves to keep his shirt, IMO.

Moyes on Beckford: "When chances come like that, whatever level, that's it. It is very rarely you get as many. You have got to score."

Couldn't agree more. A championship striker at best.
Christopher Marston
3   Posted 28/11/2010 at 09:43:58

Report abuse

This season is far from over... we have a relegation battle to contend with.
Ray Robinson
4   Posted 28/11/2010 at 09:47:30

Report abuse

I must give priase to Distin who I thought was immense as all about him collapsed.

Also, please don't let's have, "We have no money for January signings" crap. The sale of Heitinga and Bilyaletdinov would generate some useful income with minimal impact on the current setup.
David Holroyd
5   Posted 28/11/2010 at 09:44:42

Report abuse

Why did Anichibe start yesterday? He has only had one reserve game. He did well while he was on but he can't be fit.

Heitinga was total rubbish, Moyes should not have started him for both the last two games; sell him in the transfer window.

Moyes needs to look at his tactics, we seem to be going backwards. Boring football... the only time the crowd get excited is when Coleman gets the ball because he hasn't had the lack of fear coached out of him, YET.

Look at what Bolton are trying to play 1 attacking football. It's still three points for a win... we have won three games all season.

MOYES HAS GONE AS FAR AS HE CAN. Its all gone stale.

Wayne Smyth
6   Posted 28/11/2010 at 09:54:36

Report abuse

Sorry, Liam, but no matter how bad Beckford is performing, it's bad form for a manager to openly criticise his players, unless of course Beckford isn't giving full effort, but that patently isn't the case.

Once Beckford's out the door, then Moyes can say what the fuck he likes about him but, while he's a Everton player, he should get full support from fans and manager alike.

I reckon he has the ability to play at this level. You look at the runs he makes, the positions he gets in, and the fact that he can score a variety of goals, including some very good ones. All that's missing far too often is the end product, which is down to confidence... and I'm just glad I don't have to rely on DM to instil belief and confidence in me when I'm feeling down.

Even if DM is right about Beckford and he is Dhampionship quality like you say, he is OUR asset ? someone we can sell on for a profit, but we certainly aren't going to get much for him when his ability is being talked down by our manager!
Andy Crooks
7   Posted 28/11/2010 at 10:47:55

Report abuse

Well said, Wayne.
Paul Moreton
8   Posted 28/11/2010 at 10:44:48

Report abuse

I really wish everyone (including Moyes) would stop singling out Beckford for criticism. Seriously how many chances have Yakubu and Saha had yesterday, how many runs did they make... yep that's right none! How much are both these players paid, how many years have they played in the PL!?! ... exactly.

Beckford gives it his all but the reason we lost yesterday and didn't win against Sunderland isn't because Beckford missed those chances ? and for Moyes of all people to say it a disgrace!!

We lost because our big players Howard, Arteta, Saha and Yakubu aren't performing. They are the highest paid with the most experience and therefore should carry more blame. Arteta's petulance yesterday was ridiculous and isn't acceptable.

Seriously, get behind Beckford, people... apart from Pienaar, Cahill and Coleman ? he's the only one trying!

Ian McDowell
9   Posted 28/11/2010 at 10:57:09

Report abuse

Paul, you're spot on there. I can forgive a player for his failings as long as he is trying. Recently, apart from Pienaar, Distin, Baines and Cahill, the rest need a serious kick up the arse.
Chris Bolesta
10   Posted 28/11/2010 at 10:48:31

Report abuse

I'm sick and tired of listening and reading about the pressure and good Everton passing in every single game. What comes of it?! It's shit. We can put some passes together, yes... but this all happens at the speed of an advancing snail.

The best example was Hibbert yesterday. Instead of running or crossing quickly, he was turning back, passing short, without any intent whatsoever to create a chance.

Arteta seems like he doesn't care anymore: slow, running away from the ball, hanging out by the back four. And don't get me even started on Beckford. He should try to play for the reserves. Every single decision he makes is just bad.

But the player who is really not fit to play in the first 11 is Heitinga. He is just thick, clumsy and slow. Every time the opposition attacks, I'm at the edge of my seat expecting a card for Heitinga for a stupid challange.

Anyway, players can have a day off, sure. But it seems that this season they are not motivated at all. Every game is exactly the same. They give all flat out when the score is against them in the last 10 minutes of the game... Shameful and pathetic.

John Ford
11   Posted 28/11/2010 at 11:02:43

Report abuse

I agree re Beckford. If he can keep his confidence (or what's left of it after Moyes's comments) and keep getting himself into those positions, he will hopefully start to become the player we hope for. It's a skill in itself to give your colleagues a good outlet up front and he was the only one to do it.
Richard Tarleton
12   Posted 28/11/2010 at 11:16:24

Report abuse

I think it's interesting to compare Moyes's handling of Rodwell with Wenger's handling of Wilshere. Wenger has given his youngster responsibility and shown trust in his talent, Moyes continues to gently nurture Rodwell and it reminds me of the same nurturing he gave to Rooney. That nurturing was part of the reason for Rooney's disaffection at Goodison. Let's hope we don't see Rodwell getting similarly disaffected.
Brian Wilson
13   Posted 28/11/2010 at 11:11:40

Report abuse

Hawwy to get the England job and Spurs to come calling for Moyes... we go for Coyle ? well, I can dream, can't I?
Joe McMahon
14   Posted 28/11/2010 at 11:32:34

Report abuse

Richard, I'm glad you touched on this, I've been thinking exactly the same for a while. Wilshere has/is growing under Wenger, as you say this was part of Rooney leaving by only playing bit parts. It pains me to say this, but Rodwell will have to leave for the sake of his own career. I know it won't happen but I just want Moyes to piss off. CL manager???, I don't think so.
Terry Hayes
15   Posted 28/11/2010 at 11:49:44

Report abuse

Chris (10) absolutely agree with every word.
Denis Richardson
16   Posted 28/11/2010 at 11:51:41

Report abuse

Everyone seems to be slating the players' efforts ? which, based on the performances, you cannot probably argue with. However, I wonder how much of the players 'not giving a fuck' is down to the fact that DM consistently keeps playing so many of the team in their wrong positions.

After a while, the players must be getting sick of it and so no surprise they start not to care anymore. For example:

JH is NOT a midfielder, so why expect him to give great performances in the middle of the park?

MA is an ATTACKING midfielder, why oh why is he playing so deep, just in front of the back four?

What on earth is Rodwell doing on the wing?? He's a CB or DCM, not a frigging winger!!!!

Etc etc. Maybe MA is playing deep because of the problems caused by JH being in the middle ? again this would not be an issue if JH was playing in DEFENCE!

DM should simply play the players in their correct positions. I think this would make an immediate impact and also allow the players to play with more confiidence and hence play better...

Chelsea away next ? cannot really say am looking forward to that. One thing is for certain, no way DM will have a go at Stamford Bridge like Sunderland did.
Stephen Kenny
17   Posted 28/11/2010 at 12:04:23

Report abuse

Pienaar feeding Beckford seems the only way we will see any decent forward play. A radical overhaul is needed in terms of players, attitude and style of play. I don't think Moyes will do any of the three and, for that reason, I would like to see him go.
Andy Codling
18   Posted 28/11/2010 at 12:13:05

Report abuse

Moyes's "nurturing" of Rodwell seems stupid, play the arse out of him now ? after all, he'll be gone next summer in another long drawn-out saga, with the usual propaganda and character assasination tactics employed by our twat chairman, and Moyes will go along like a sheep, because £65 grand a week means you toe the line.
Paul Gladwell
19   Posted 28/11/2010 at 13:48:17

Report abuse

I could not agree more on these comments on Beckford and Rodwell. He also likes to critcise Coleman whenever he plays, well, he puts him down. Against Huddersfield, he slagged him off when the reporter praised him and he did so again I think after the Blackpool game when he was MotM, he then decided to drop him, then he does so again for an unfit striker.

Imagine how this goes down in the dressing room when he is at the same time creaming over anything Neville does. The man is too stubborn and I bet those home truths Freguson told him were about similar issues.

Leon Perrin
20   Posted 28/11/2010 at 14:14:59

Report abuse

The biz with Coleman and Beckford is par for the course, a cowardly manager like Moyes will always pick on the younger, less-experienced players. Hard nosed experienced pros will tell him to fuck off.
Tommy Meehan
21   Posted 28/11/2010 at 14:29:47

Report abuse

Damn right, Dennis... pity Moyes never seems to have gotten any jig-saw puzzles for Christmas as a kid.
Guy Wilkinson
22   Posted 28/11/2010 at 15:02:22

Report abuse

Lyndon ? the team selection was NOT sound.

Moyes ? turns Heitinga, World Cup Finalist centre-back, into a little-boy-lost midfielder.

Maintains faith with out-of-form Arteta.
Lyndon Lloyd
23   Posted 28/11/2010 at 16:31:40

Report abuse

Guy, I completely agree regarding Heitinga but even with him played out of position and Arteta's dismissal, that team shouldn't have lost like that. "Sound enough" was my assessment, that doesn't mean I thought it was ideal by any measure!

On Beckford, I have to agree with those who think he deserves credit not victimization for yesterday. He made some terrific runs and I've got to hand it to Carson for coming out quickly to close down the angle for his first chance and getting a crucial hand on the ball to allow Tamas to prevent the goal.

As long as he keeps getting into scoring positions and the likes of Pienaar keep picking him out, the goals will come.
Dean Adams
24   Posted 28/11/2010 at 20:05:17

Report abuse

Beckford has the right instinct, is getting into the right positions and has proved in the past he knows where the net is. All he needs is the encouragement of his manager. For that reason alone, I am annoyed with Moyes. Everything else is just waiting to click.
Larry Boner
25   Posted 28/11/2010 at 23:15:28

Report abuse

The best finisher I have seen playing for Everton was Gary Lineker, it took him 6 games, I think, to get off the mark, then he scored 40 for the season. The main reason why he was such a good finisher was that he was not frightened of missing and, let me tell you, he missed a lot that season he was here.

Beckford got himself free at least three times on Saturday, as he did in the last minute at Sunderland... he kept looking for the ball, even after some horrendous misses, and did more in that little 10-minute cameo than Saha has done since his last goal, whenever that was.

His performances at Leeds were similar: lots of chances, lots of misses, lots of goals... but he looks like a goalscorer, he has that turn of pace ? if DJ Campbell can score in the PL then Beckford certainly can.

The overwhelming issue, though, was being totally outplayed by WBA, if Beckford had scored those goals and we had not lost, the paucity of our general play would still be apparent. What worries me the most is the loss of Cahill in a few weeks and possibly the exit of Pienaar, just who is going to step up and fill the shoes of these two players?

Jason Lam
26   Posted 29/11/2010 at 09:38:32

Report abuse

Agreed with the Beckford opinions, he should be told that he will get a run in the team and not subbed. He's not afraid to shot and who knows it might ricochet of someone's bum and end in the net. Saha has been appalling and Yak is not fit. COYB
Paul Sullivan
27   Posted 29/11/2010 at 14:05:30

Report abuse

"A seething hush" - brilliant - I know that one well!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to Column articles, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.