Season 2011-12
The Mail Bag
Pienaar
A thought occured to me the other day that if a club was going to take someone on loan with a view to buy, wouldn't you agree a fee on the proviso that it worked out with the club?
I would hazard a gues that the deal has already been agreed. What are your thoughts?
Michael Mcloughlin, Posted 17/05/2012 at 18:43:58
Comments
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Also I am sure that if a deal had been agreed the press would not be reporting Sunderlands interest in the player.
Someone jog my memory, whats the score with Saha at Spurs? Was that not a loan till end of the season?
Can we not use that in some kind of deal?
Everyone knew he would fit in well here and raise his profile again. Needs to be signed at all costs
Having a fee agreed in advance usually benefits the buying club more so I think Spurs didnt want an agreed fee in place,knowing that Pienaar would play every game for us puts him in the shop window and his performances will push the price up that clubs like Sunderland and QPR will be willing to pay.
The Pienaar deal happened right at 11th hour and only beat the deadline by the slimmest of margins.
It also wouldn't surprise me if any permanent move to us was delayed until later in the summer so that we save on the wages. The Club's used that cost-saving tactic in the past and, given our financial position, it makes a lot of sense.
Should have originally sold him for around £15 million, ended up getting 1/5th of that and now he's worth about £15 million again!!
Does that mean the two deals were not dependent on each other and Saha was leaving regardless?
There is the money side of things but he went to Spurs for money and look what happened there. It's only a thought but maybe Pienaar could dig his heels in?
That is my understanding. Maybe one deal helped grease the wheels of the other because the Saha deal wasn't concluded until late in the day as well but I think Louis would have gone anyway.
Tony: "What if Spurs want rid but Pienaar says he only wants go home to Everton?"
He could but if (and I'm not lending the reports any credence here, just speaking hypothetically) Sunderland were to offer £5m and we only offer £2.5m, then he'd be faced with digging his heels and not getting a game at Spurs or moving to their preferred buyer and at least playing first-team football.
I cannot see Everton paying £5m for a 30 year-old given that we have no money...
Just because theres a clause,say for £5m that doesnt mean we have to bid for him or even offer that much.I dont really see any benefit for the selling club to have a buy out clause?
The benefit for the selling club is that they are nearer to selling an older player they don't want back.
Only if the buying still wants the player for that price, the Yobo situation shows the agreed price don't mean shit if the buying club don't want to play ball.
Let's say Pienaar had a buy out clause and by the end of the season he proved that the fee agreed was too little, well Spurs would have no choice but to accept the bid even though they know they could sell for more to another club.
I would have him back because he is creative but we should be blooding fresh talent or searching for better and moving on
The Turks, the Italian club (matterazzi) are a little different to premierships clubs. I would think agreements would stand up better here than abroad
Since we have had better form than Spurs since then you can only asume Appy Arry might want to keep Pienaar whose wages we would struggle with anyway.
Our club is so shortsighted. If we would have given him a reasonable increase originally he would now be on a 5 year contract with us and worth over 10 million.
But I also think having Arteta in the side might have been a factor. All the creativity went through him, he was the one always given the ball, taking the set pieces etc. (I'm not saying he was particularly good at them however) so perhaps we weren't seeing the best of Pienaar.
The Everton he returned to suited him. He was fresh and keen to impress, Baines was in the form of his life and Arteta was no longer about so he could be the main creative outlet. If we do get him back, he has to be made the main man in midfield in terms of creativity and he can complement Fellaini who is our midfield general. However, to do this, we might need to give him the deal he once demanded.
I suspect he'll wait and see what happens re CL and Spurs and also whether the likes of Modric, Bale etc are still around .
He states that things are moving along but payment plan was the sticking point. He fully believes he wil be ours by the end of June. He is usually spot on with Spurs info and it was he who broke the news that Spurs had hijacked the Kyle Naughton deal at the time
Shame this guy wasn't working there in 1994 when we bought Vinny Samways. Prior warning would have meant a mass demonstration against the move.
As far as Stevie going to the highest bidder? God knows how many mouths he's feeding in his SA township. Can't blame him for looking at the highest wages as his career is heading towards the downward slope.
One way or the other, Kenright, make a decision. Just get it done right away.
So, at 30 years old and growing fast how can we as a club pay 5 million or more for him, when we only paid 3, plus he is older now.
To me this is a joke.
A deal should have been agreed before.
Now we are left desperate for creative players, and it will only get worse because we are ALSO losing Drenthe!
This is serious, how the hell are we going to create goals without Pienaar or in worse case Drenthe?
We can not afford to think about feelings here, the only question relevant is who is gonna create the goals when we lose Pienaar? Drenthe then becomes an alternative again, just like he did before this season started.
I really do not mind keeping Drenthe, as then we at least have ONE creative winger, who is also free of charge.
IF we get Pienaar then we are in a luxury position, but UNTIL we do then we are in the EXACT same position we were before this season started, in fact even more deperate because we now know we have a decent striker, but we are ONLY missing that creative winger.
The fella is a fucking waster and you are championing him as if he is some kind of demi-god. (look what you have made me do now, I usually don't like swearing on this board)
As in the other post about Pienaar, the lad who speaks to someone in the know (I know, I hate these rumours too, but he has some credibility with me) suggest that Pienaar has prettty much told Old Arry that if he doesn't let him go, he will be on the first plane back to South Africa.
The sticking point is the money they want, not the wages.
The other rumour is that Moyes has had a falling out with Jags. Hmmm
Apart from a few super sub 15 minute spells.
His attitude and off field conduct are not what we want at Everton FC
I know Pienaar is a better alternative, but I really think 5mil is too much for a player who will only be good for us for another 2 seasons. Drenthe is free and has the potential to be better. It won't happen though. Still we truly need one of these players but 5mil is ridiculous.
As I recall his contract was running down so its highly unlikely that even Harry would offer top dollar.
He now has a full contract at Spurs so if we want him we have to pay the going rate.
I would be happy if we paid +/- £5m for him as our main outlay this summer with no-one leaving!
He is worth a hell of a lot more than £3m to Everton and Spurs know this.
"he messed up, but I think this time it would have got to him" - how so Ryan? If arguably the best manager of the world kicked him out of Real, what makes you think Moyes could have turned him?
I can understand where you are all coming from, but it's not like Pienaar is a saint! Drink-driving? Not saying I wouldn't take him. I would take both of them if I could, I just think Drenthe is a better option, and should have another chance.
"Ok Royston, We`ll give you 65k a week, but nothing at all if you screw up off the pitch.
Or "Yes, Tim we`ll pay you 60k a week, but if you are beaten from outside the box because you were in a coma . .you get Zilch"
Or how about "sign here Jags, 75K a week, but everytime you aimlessly boot the ball down the pitch, YOU owe US £xxx. "
We would only have to pay Moyes from January till May
The sticking point as always is how we pay.
He reckons the move will go through a week or two before the player report back for training.
I reckon we will get him back for no more than we paid.. I don't think Moyes could stomach that.
Just wanted to point out that from my memory almost none of our transfers have ended quickly with an agreed fee paid out. There always seems to be some negotiation at the end.. its the Everton way.
The only one I think I remember going simply was Tim Howard.
God I hate the summer. Role on August and the start of the season
I've every faith that Moyes could probably find someone cheaper and younger given enough time. In the mean time, we know Pienaar works, will improve the team and has at last started chipping in with more goals. Yeah he's 30 but there's a good few years left in him yet as pace has never been what he's all about.
(hint: It's not Rodwell)
"Role on August and the start of the season"
I thought the season started in January...
Growing fast? I'm sure that's one bit of criticism Pienaar has to face all the time. "Bloody hell our Stephen, you're getting so big you've nearly grown out of those He-Man pyjamas I bought you when you were eight." etc.
Did you mean ageing fast? If so, how is he ageing quicker than anyone else? He's 30 and a veritable bundle of energy going off the evidence of his displays since January. It's not like he's on his last legs is it? I'd also back him to outrun, outwork and outfight Drenthe any day of the week, despite the fact he's the elder of the two and doesn't have a one man cult championing him on here at every opportunity ( before streaking naked into the night, slaughtering goats, smearing himself in blood and beseeching Satan to "make Moyes sign him up").
Great piece of business that is! Swap a 21 year old England international who has captained every age group on the way up, is a true Blue, dominated a Man U team when 18 but who might have struggled with injuries recently preventing a good run in the team this season, for a 30 year old Saffa (I'm one) who was great for 3 months even even though his season before his left was distinctly average and left us for the bright lights of London. Yeah I'm sure Arry would hate that piece of business.
We have had this before John, apparently we have a rapidly ageing squad, that Moyes, he's fecking useless, not doing a Cher and turning back time
A deal should have been agreed before"
Jimmy honestly lad you live in a dream world. Everton can only agree a deal with Spurs if Levy is amenable to it. Takes two to tango. Then again, you think that a 30 year old Pienaar is still growing, so.
I prefer Pienaar first because he does not need time like Drenthe does, even though he is 30 he is worth the money.
Problem is that I fear we will lose him, because we will not be able to come up with the money fast enough.
If, and I say IF Pienaar goes to Sunderland or QPR then we are out of options.
We can deny it all day long, but it does not change the fact that we have no options on either wings right now.
We have no creative ability at all without Pienaar.
Drenthe is an option to us as he knows the club and can start to perform right away.
Moyes got him here, he knew his history, but he still opted for him.
He did it because he was desperate.
We will be just as desperate if we lose Pienaar, so it makes sense to go for him if we can not find anyone better.
I understand the ill feelings towards Drenthe, but I maintain they come second to what is best for this club.
We need to create chances to score enough goals to get back into Europa League again, with no creative input on either wings we are lost.
My feelings towards Drenthe is mixed, both good and bad, but the greater good is what matters here, nothing else.
Certainly not ill feelings towards a player.
If Mancini had not gone back on his word regarding Tevez then City would probably not have won the league.
I will maintain my wiew on this no matter how much some might complain and try to influence.
What is important to me is that Everton improves, and right now we need wingers, we have found the striker.
Having said that, regarding Stevie P and his ageing, as he is smaller than average a higher percentage of his body is nearer the centre of the earths mass compared to taller people. This means that time, on average, will run slightly slower for him, This is due to the fact that the nearer you are to a more massive object the greater the curvature of spacetime!
Jimmy Sørheim 978
You say,
"Drenthe is an option to us as he knows the club and can start to perform right away"
It is exactly that reason why we dont want him. His performing is the problem!!!!
Shame that he isnt as persistant as you, it might be a quality that would improve him.
Hmmm.
So if you're a dwarf aged 70, does it actually feel like you're 126 or... something.
(Sorry, science was never my strongpoint, I'll admit to being a little confused.)
Easy really, the dwarf who is 70 will still feel 70, because in his frame of reference he will still be 70. though to us he will appear to be 70 minus a tiny tiny fraction of a thousandth of a second, because our frame of reference is slightly different to his...but in both viewpoints we'll never get enough money off Kenwright!
So if I'm ever with a dwarf and the clock strikes midnight and he says "It's now my birthday!"
I'd be within my rights to say "Actually, you jumped in a bit quick there mate..NOW it's your birthday -all the best"
So if you stood next to the Yak, would he get all the pies, due to the same effects?
The world is not flat and certain places are much higher from sea level than others.
So in certain cases a Leprachaun could be much older than a giant.
Or if he was on a "stool" he could be a pain in the arse.
One or two to lighten things up:
1. A tall woman met a midget at a party. The midget was barely three feet tall but they were attracted to each other. After a few drinks they went back to the tall woman's apartment.
"I can't imagine what it will be like making love to a midget," said the woman, "especially with the size difference and all."
"Just take off your clothes, lie back on the bed, spread your legs apart and close your eyes," said the midget.
The woman did as she was told and soon she felt the biggest thing she'd ever experienced inside her. Within a few minutes the woman had climaxed eight times.
"If you think that was good," said the midget with a smirk, "Just wait till I get BOTH legs in there!"
2. Every day, a male co-worker walks up very close to a lady at the coffee machine, inhales a big breath of air, and tells her that her hair smells nice.
After a week of this, she can't stand it anymore, takes her complaint to a supervisor in the personnel department and asks to file a sexual harassment grievance against him. The Human Resources supervisor is puzzled and asks: "What's sexually threatening about a co-worker telling you your hair smells nice?"
The woman replies, "It's Doug. The midget!
Apologies in advance to our smaller brethren, only joking.
If something was going to happen on this deal, it will only be very late on in the window when Spurs can assess whether they truly need him. I think Pienaar himself knows this, and possibly one of the reasons he got upset as he knows he is loved at GP, yet only a standby at WHL.
I personally hopes he comes back, but if there is some money there available, I don't think Moyes will gamble by waiting to see if Spurs will release him. It also depends if Magaye Gueye will be able to step up to the left side birth next season.
As regards what Spurs want, less important these days as if a player wants to go then nine times out of ten he will. The only player Spurs really took a stand on is Modric and he will go this summer.
It will be interesting to see how much he goes for, only then we can see how much money we have lost from the original breakdown in contract talks.
He's absolutley vital to us, he makes the side tick and dictates how we play. Some of his performances since he come back were sensational.
Let's face it, he's not going to fit into the Spurs style of play (whatever the fuck that is). His home is Goodison Park and let's hope we keep him here.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.


789 Posted 17/05/2012 at 19:13:28
Report abuse
Under normal circumstances, yes, EFC would surely have tried to agree a fee at the time the loan was arranged but 10 minutes before the transfer deadline doesn't allow for much negotiating time. Who knows, though...?