Season 2011-12
The Mail Bag

Desperate for the Reddies?

 45 Comments: First  |  Last

The news that Cardiff are changing their shirt colour from blue to red for commercial purposes is both sad and begs the question: how much would you do it for?

If a billionaire came along and said we should play in red (although the logic of this would be strange given our neighbours) would you accept it for a larger ground and a bigger transfer kitty?

I suspect none of us would and I also expect Cardiff City to be in blue by the 2013-14 season. To me this is one step too far.
Andrew James, London     Posted 06/06/2012 at 23:18:53

back Return to the Mail Bag  :  Add your Comments back

Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Laing
633   Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:01:37

Report abuse

Why not go the whole hog and change our crest to a Liver Bird, our anthem to you'll never walk alone and sign a 100 year pact with beelzebub ?
Paul David
635   Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:12:34

Report abuse

Never.Peter it was Liverpool who copied the Liver Bird off us.
James Stewart
640   Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:41:52

Report abuse

I personally find it sickening a club could do that. The game as really sunk quite low if this kind of thing becomes more frequent.

What I did find interesting was the number of Cardiff fans in support of it.
I think that has something more to do with red being synonymous with Wales though. I can never imagine it washing here thank god!

Mark Riding
642   Posted 07/06/2012 at 00:46:53

Report abuse

How the 'Bluebirds' could become some sort of Welsh Dragon styled club is beyond me as a fan. Business wise, yes, I get it.
The Swansea fans have been pissing themselves over it all. I think I know who will be laughing longest here though, as money talks.

As for the Liver Bird.. It annoys me no end how LFC have got the 'rights' to this iconic image of the city.
A small Blue Liver Bird on the white home socks ? Now that would cause some raised eyebrows ?

Jamie Sweet
654   Posted 07/06/2012 at 01:49:30

Report abuse

It just goes to show how little this glut of foreighn owners which are infiltrating English football really understand about the history and tradition of the sport.

In any other business, this kind of move would be applauded. On paper it looks like a decent re-branding exercise and I can understand the thinking behind it if you look at it from a purely marketing perspective.

It does however, make a mockery of 100+ years of tradition, and I certainly wouldn't support anything like it happening to our club. I'd rather stick with Blue Bill than some foreign investor who was keen to make us the "Everton Red Sox" no matter how much better off we would be financially.

Adam Fenlon
655   Posted 07/06/2012 at 02:18:50

Report abuse

Bring on the blue Liver Bird. Seriously is time that was reclaimed.
Eric Myles
656   Posted 07/06/2012 at 02:19:26

Report abuse

Mark, I seem to remember a few years back when Liverpool applied for a patent on the Liver Bird they we told NO.
Jarrod Prosser
683   Posted 07/06/2012 at 08:52:01

Report abuse

It's not ideal, but it's not the end of the world.

Leeds went from yellow to white. Brazil used to wear all white. Chelsea used to wear sky blue. Juventus used to wear red. Real Madrid used to wear bue. Even we sported a red strip for a while. I hate seeing tradition being torn down in this game, but those clubs kept on keeping on & so will Cardiff.

Quick 'devils advocate' question: Would we, as Evertonians, be bringin this up if Cardiff traditionally wore red & were changing to a blue shirt & white shorts?

Scott Hamilton
684   Posted 07/06/2012 at 08:53:46

Report abuse

Apparently red is a lucky colour in the east. Maybe this is one of the reasons why we're struggling to find a buyer?!
Tony J Williams
692   Posted 07/06/2012 at 09:29:16

Report abuse

I would seriously think about dumping my season ticket if we started to play in red....I would feel dirty shouting, come on you re.... come on you r........ no, can't do it!
Terence Leong
695   Posted 07/06/2012 at 09:55:31

Report abuse

I personally won't want the change... Too much associated with the colour etc. However, two interesting observations (unrelated to each other).
1. The colours never seemed to bother the Manchester clubs. Man U often donned blue as an away colour (even though their nickname) is red devils; likewise for Man City, who has donned red as an away colour before.
**And pls don't say that these two clubs have no history. They do.

2. Whenever u look at red vs blue rival clubs across the globe, the red ones seem to be more successful. Cue merseyside, Milan clubs, Manc clubs, London clubs etc. why? Coincidence perhaps, or that people act upon their beliefs ... Self fulfilling prophecies.

Matt Traynor
696   Posted 07/06/2012 at 10:08:50

Report abuse

Yes because obviously that's what any new owner would do if Everton were bought. It's also worth bearing in mind that Cardiff have no city rivals, their nearest rivals play in White. Some of you will also know that in Asia, amongst mainly the Chinese-origin but also Malay-origin peoples, red is an auspicious colour, and if they think that such a move will lead to investors dropping their readdies, having lived in SE Asia for 8 years, I'd believe it.

As Paul mentions above, Everton did play in the Liver Bird originally.

But relax, we've got Blue Bill from the Boys Pen, not some foreign type who would put the money to buy us onto the club, borrow against season tickets, borrow against broadcast revenue, sell the old training ground, sell the new one and lease it back.

Eugene Ruane
697   Posted 07/06/2012 at 10:15:46

Report abuse

Bill (doing 'that face') "Believe me, NOBODY wants us to stay blue more than me!


But..."

Sam Morrison
712   Posted 07/06/2012 at 12:15:00

Report abuse

I would follow the team if we played in stockings and suspenders, red or otherwise. Feels like I have no choice in that. But I would rather we played in blue (ideally blue football kit, not female undergarments). History shouldn't dictate terms on the future, but neither should it be ignored - especially if doing so alienates the fans. I take Jarrod's point about practicalities, but this kind of business decision, to me, contributes to the hollowness of modern football.
Phil Martin
719   Posted 07/06/2012 at 12:54:46

Report abuse

LFC only own the trademark on a specific derivative of the liverbird.
The liverbird featured on old EFC shirts looks very different. So I believe could be used again in some manner.

If some billionaire offered EFC the chance to be great again and rid of the current mob- on the condition we wore red. I'd accept on the understanding it was a our away shirt and the concept was based on our 1891-95 shirt. In which we won our first championship. Yes, wearing red!

Steven Scaffardi
722   Posted 07/06/2012 at 13:08:14

Report abuse

Unfortunately I can see this sort of thing creeping into our game more and more as money continues to take over. This has been happening in American sports for years as clubs are re-named, re-branded, and re-allocated. And the really sad thing is that I think fan power wouldn't make a difference.

Look at the Cardiff fans - they were up in arms about this, and even though the owners backed down for a short time, they still have ended up in red!

I'm not sure an owner would be dumb enough to make us play in red, but don't be surprised if one day a big American owner jets in, decides we need to play in aqua green, orange, and white, and calls us the Evertonian Dolphins! Yee-haw!

James Marshall
730   Posted 07/06/2012 at 14:30:19

Report abuse

In our case, yes, it would be dreadful as we all associate red with the obvious evil over the park, but for a club to change it strip is nothing new. Cardiff used to play in amber & brown originally. The RS wore green (I think) and we wore black & blue (I think). so what's the big deal?

If a bloke came along with £2billion to spend and said we had to wear another colour, would it be so bad? Cardiff still have a blue 'away' kit. You have to balance this stuff out with modern economics - I mean if a company takes over another and decides as part of the deal that they want to re-brand it, who can stop them? Football is business like any other, and although I would be 100% against us wearing red, I very much doubt you'll see any Cardiff City fans complaining if they win the Championship next year with all the cash they'll have at their disposal.

A new ground, training facilities, new players.....these things don't come cheap and if wearing another colour is the kicker, then so be it.

Don't fear it, embrace change.

Forever Blue.

Andrew Ellams
734   Posted 07/06/2012 at 15:52:51

Report abuse

Obviously red has totally different conotations for us than Cardiff. But who would accept a change in colours to something other than red if it meant a considerable increase in commercial and financial input into the club.

As for Swansea pissing themselves, their new 2nd kit for next year is pretty much identical to the Welsh national kit. Perhaps they see themselves as national ambassadors now that they are in with the big boys

Barry Rathbone
735   Posted 07/06/2012 at 15:56:28

Report abuse

I really don't think it would cause a ripple.

Fans aren't as passionate about tradition as they were (nil satis ...., anyone remember?).

The american "franchise model" where teams at the whim of an owner move to different cities, change names and all that old pony will happen eventually.

You only have to read posts on the BU thread a good portion of the posts delight in stating the owners can do what they want 'cos it's fuck all to do with us.

Kit changes are neither here nor there.

Andy Callan
736   Posted 07/06/2012 at 16:19:41

Report abuse

The difference in Cardiff and Everton is that they don't have rivals that already play in Red......

C'mon this is a silly, if hypothetical, argument; it'll never happen.

I'd have a bight orange kit with green fuckin' spots if a Sultan came along with an open cheque book.

Andrew Ellams
738   Posted 07/06/2012 at 16:22:38

Report abuse

I not sure the franchise model would work as well here. In the NFL there are only 30 teams in a huge country so there are areas without a team local to them so there are plenty of options to move teams to football starved areas, whereas here we have teams in pretty much every major city.
Keith Glazzard
739   Posted 07/06/2012 at 15:43:41

Report abuse

My MC mates here in Manchester, some of whom are still drunk, were quite shaken by the news from Cardiff last night. Yes, they've loved the money and all it has brought, but the realisation that something like that could one day be the cost was very sobering.

A change to red for them or us would seem to be impossible because of the two-team city situation (Bar Codes beware), but owners are owners - they can do what they like. Fan power? Sky sets whatever kick-off time it wants, and we still have to pay to get in!

Brian Waring
741   Posted 07/06/2012 at 17:02:21

Report abuse

As has been mentioned, its no big deal for them to change to red. Also, incorporating the Welsh dragon into their badge, the thing is, they are a Welsh club. Also, didn't the club give the fans a vote, and the majority voted in favour? Now, where have I heard that before....?
Tony Waring
742   Posted 07/06/2012 at 17:10:44

Report abuse

The fact is gents that we and other clubs already have three different kits every season anyway and I would like to know how often we get to actually play in blue. It used to be that clubs had a change kit to avoid colour clashes when playing away. Nowadays kits are merely a way of extracting more cash from fans' pockets and the "away" kit is used irrespective of whether or not there is a colour clash with the opposing team. Having got that off my chest I still would be very disappointed if we had to change our primary colours.
On a related matter I saw a TV programme in Germany recently about Borussia Dortmund who won the Bundesliga. Seemingly they have adopted "that tune " which the RS fans are always singing. What will really annoy RS fans however is that the Germans actually sing it more tunefully and together.
Mike Green
745   Posted 07/06/2012 at 17:23:39

Report abuse

Tony - I'd say we play in blue every home game and pretty often away too. I love seeing us in the home kit when playing away but personally would rather see us in a full away kit than 'all blue', which happens at United, Arsenal etc quite often. Just doesn't look right.
Steve Smith
764   Posted 07/06/2012 at 19:34:17

Report abuse

Never ever ever ! no matter how much is offered.....irrational I know, but that's how I feel about it.
Dean Adams
773   Posted 07/06/2012 at 20:12:30

Report abuse

Changing to a red strip is not the end of the world for Cardiff fans. That happened when the Swans reached the Premier league. They moved from Ninian Park in 2009 and so have started the process in small doses.

The worst part for me would be the changing of the club badge. For me that one thing does symbolise the club and to radically change it would be a real stretch. But when the money is on the table, you realise that the only thing that really matters, is that your club can afford to be competitive. If you dont agree, just read toffeeweb most weeks. We are always wishing for a few quid to buy a new player or keep one, or whatever the flavour of the day.

No matter what happens you can always be safe in the knowledge that we could never stoop as low as the redshite.

Frank Duffy
788   Posted 07/06/2012 at 21:18:16

Report abuse

Over my dead body. The day we wear RED is the day Everton FC loose my support. Money is not the be all and never will be.

We are known as the Blues & Toffees.

Andrew Lawrenson
791   Posted 07/06/2012 at 21:57:18

Report abuse

It will never happen....but if it did, well thats me done and dusted with the club.....I could never ever put a red scarf around my neck or wear a red shirt or sing "come on you reds". I honestly mean this but I would sooner we dropped down shit loads of divisions.
Roman Sidey
811   Posted 08/06/2012 at 02:49:44

Report abuse

Jarrod Prosser, very good DA's question.

As a foriegn supporter, I don't expect my opinion to mean much, but if it was for the good of the club, and made us compete financially with the big boys, get the dye out. You could still call the team the Blues - Queensland Reds only just started wearing red a few years ago after changing from maroon and blue.

Does anyone think that the people supporting the club during the red stripe mosquito fleet jerseys kicked up a stink when a change was suggested? If they did, would they still be upset now?

Ian Pilkington
826   Posted 08/06/2012 at 09:52:08

Report abuse

Terence@695
Manchester City have never played in red, but frequently used a maroon and black striped away kit for many years. Manchester United have only used a dark blue kit, totally different from City's sky blue.
The concept of Cardiff City -nickname the Bluebirds-changing to red is totally ludicrous.
David Torley
827   Posted 08/06/2012 at 10:59:23

Report abuse

Gain some Chinese fans with 20p a year to spend on fake merchandise and lose me
Matt Traynor
829   Posted 08/06/2012 at 11:22:21

Report abuse

David #827, it's more gaining sponsors with millions of $ to spend to increase their profile in the countries where the Premier League is broadcast.

Do you really think Everton care how many Chang beers are sold in the UK or elsewhere? Do you think Thai Beverage really care what Everton fans think of Chang Beer?

I think if Everton fans knew how we ended up being sponsored by Chang it might open people's eyes a bit as to how business operates in sponsorship.

Ray Roche
831   Posted 08/06/2012 at 11:45:16

Report abuse

Matt,

Do you have any insight into how "we ended up being sponsored by Chang it might open people's eyes a bit " and in what way peoples eyes would be opened.
This is a genuine question, as I have no real idea as to how that happened, and not a snide comment on your post.

Chris Hockenhull
832   Posted 08/06/2012 at 11:56:43

Report abuse

Tony Waring/Mike Green. I was told by our CEO that we nearly went for ALL blue as our first choice kit next season! Evidently our 'manager thinks we look good in it'. When I asked why they didn't go for it they decided at the last minute to pull back as they feared a fan's revolt!. Got me thinking would people have revolted?? I'd never want us to go ALL blue. I'm still miffed about the loss of all white socks (I think blue makes us look cumbersome) but I think we had that little discussion a few weeks ago.
Matt Traynor
835   Posted 08/06/2012 at 12:29:30

Report abuse

Ray, #831, I'd like to say it was due to our proactive commercial operation with agents acting for them across the globe.

But I heard (from 2 different sources, in different sectors, in different countries) that actually Thai Bev had a marketing tie-up with Carlsberg to cross-promote each others crap in Asia and Europe, and Carlsberg did the dirty on them.

Their response was to go sponsor the team nearest to Liverpool, and that was us. They used that tie-up as a means of launching the product throughout the UK (which Carlsberg hadn't done).

If you look at the font used in the Chang packaging, and the colouring, it's remarkably similar to Carlsbergs.

There's a lot more to the story, but that's it in a nutshell. A nutshell that also shows "the biggest sponsor deal in our history" or however it was lauded actually fell into their lap, thanks to the sponsors of our rival being a bunch of twats to do business with. Or something like that.

Steve Smith
884   Posted 08/06/2012 at 21:55:25

Report abuse

Not sure I'll go with that Matt, considering the deal has been extended on improved terms, although having said that, I can't for the life of me see what Chang are getting out of this, I have only ever seen their product on the shelves of one shop {a Bargain Booze close to the ground} I travel quite a lot around the country work wise, and have never seen it anywhere else.
Mark Riding
889   Posted 08/06/2012 at 23:54:02

Report abuse

Matt #835, I have also heard the Carlsberg story, and for what they are paying us, Im sure its not that bad a deal for them really.

Steve #884, Pictures in the US of Landon, Howard, pictures in Australia of Cahill all wearing Chang logo's.. Im sure its beneficial to them. All Tesco Extra, and most superstores now stock Chang ( in the world beer sections, usually 3 big bottles for a fiver by the way !! )..

Matt Traynor
891   Posted 09/06/2012 at 00:20:47

Report abuse

Steve #884, as I said it's what I heard. The deal could've been extended as it was a positive business relationship. Last season Villa far overtook us on shirt sponsorship, and possibly WBA. I'll post a full list when I get the breakdown.

Mark #889 Thai Bev also made a big splash about it in Asia a few years back. Buses fully-wrapped with the Chang - Everton tie up. Sadly we'd just sold Beattie as they launched the campaign (he took up most of the space on the ad!)

Steve Smith
928   Posted 09/06/2012 at 10:23:15

Report abuse

Mark #889, I'm more of an Aldi man these days, maybe that's why I haven't spotted it, I've been to a few corporates at Goodison over the past couple of seasons (Brian Labone suite), it doesn't even get top billing in there!

Matt #891, This new Nike deal does look to be a bit controversial, how could it be anything else when we're talking about Everton? Although I go along with another poster on a previous thread, I'd rather have a tick on my shirt than a cock.

Ed Fitzgerald
050   Posted 10/06/2012 at 09:46:05

Report abuse

The RS have no patent on the liver bird. In recent times I am sure we had it as some type of 'watermark' on one of our home kits early 90s (I am sure I bought this for my son) and we have certainly had it on a kit from way back when. As regards the red question we did wear ruby red shirts with blue trim when we won the league at Anfield in 1891-92.

I think it is terrible that Cardiff have sold out their history and heritage and I wouldnt want us to do the same. Rebranding does sometimes work but sometimes works for a short period of time, remember new labour? We already have a strong brand we just need a marketing strategy that capitalises on our history such as being the team that has more top flight seasons in Englands top divisions than any other and therefore the world, the 4th most successful club in terms of league titles, one of the original 12 clubs in the football league. And for much of the 20th century it was Everton who led gound breaking developments so this can be achieved again if we can attract a investor who has empathy and respect for our past and at the same time is forward thinking. I am sure there is a global brand out there who would want to benefit from being linked with us. The problem is Bill Kenwright!

Joe Bibb
150   Posted 10/06/2012 at 21:32:20

Report abuse

Better Dead Than Red
Michael Brien
233   Posted 11/06/2012 at 07:14:23

Report abuse

Jarrod - Chelsea have never had sky blue as an official colour - they were always royal blue shirts with white shorts and in the 1960's they changed to the royal blue shirts and shorts style that has become identified with them today. And as regards the red shirts as it's a "lucky" colour in Asia - presumably all the Asian club sides play in red do they ???? If so they must sell shed loads of change kits !!!!!!!!!

It's always good to get financial backing and support - but Cardiff City have been going long before these new owners arrived on the scene and hopefully they will be going for a long time after these guys have sold on to somebody else. Tradition should count for something in sport - clubs do have a history and I believe that it is a foolish club that takes little notice of its history.

Eric Myles
238   Posted 11/06/2012 at 07:43:35

Report abuse

Michael #233 "presumably all the Asian club sides play in red do they ???? If so they must sell shed loads of change kits !!!!!!!!"

Yes they do http://www.myfootballtops.co.uk/national-teams-football-shirts-asia-c-5_268.html

You'll see all the ASEAN countries except Malaysia all have a red home kit, except Thailand which just changed it this year.

Michael Brien
408   Posted 12/06/2012 at 14:26:05

Report abuse

I thought Japan play in Blue. At least they did in the World Cup.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb