Brain damage from multiple concussion

, 28 November, 29comments  |  Jump to most recent
Could the tragic and untimely death of Gary Speed be linked to his superb skill as a header of the ball? This article on a US website raises a concern regarding the link between multiple concussions sustained in the course of a career that includes repeated impact to the head, and brain damage that can lead some professional sportsmen to commit suicide.
Gary Speed was, as The Guardian noted in its obituary, ?an exceptional header of the ball.? Expertly meeting a gun shot of a cross with his forehead and guiding it in his chosen direction was one of Speed's special talents. And he demonstrated that talent for longer than almost anyone: indeed, there are only two players, Ryan Giggs and David James, who played more games in the Premier League.

Although [American] football and boxing have been getting most of the attention lately, we have known for years that there is evidence of chronic traumatic brain injury in professional soccer players. Indeed, when researchers from the Netherlands looked at a population of professional soccer players in the Netherlands in 1998, the found that they:

exhibited impaired performances in memory, planning, and visuoperceptual processing when compared with control subjects. Among professional soccer players, performance on memory, planning, and visuoperceptual tasks were inversely related to the number of concussions incurred in soccer and the frequency of ?heading? the ball. Performance on neuropsychological testing also varied according to field position, with forward and defensive players exhibiting more impairment.
We will never know for certain why Gary Speed decided to take his own life, but my hope is that attention will be given to the possibility that the effects of his chosen profession may have contributed to his death. At present, no one is writing about the role that brain trauma might have played in the tragedy on Sunday, but maybe they should.

Quotes or other material sourced from Opposing Views



Reader Comments (29)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Laing
2 Posted 29/11/2011 at 17:23:45
God help Tim Cahill then, he must by this crazy rationale be immediately sectioned and placed under 24 hour observation in the fear of his potential for self-harm ?
James Flynn
3 Posted 29/11/2011 at 17:37:29
Agree completely with the OP. Almost 1,000 games, plus training, plus the elbows to the head, heads clashing.

I hope there's an autopsy and brain damage is looked at. That sounds ugly, but there might be something "good" to come out of this tragedy; a heavier focus brought to bear on the effects of undiagnosed/untreated/repeated concussion.

Antony Matthews
4 Posted 29/11/2011 at 17:44:29
Good job footballers dont play with the old footballs that Dixie used to head. Dixie must have had an head as hard as his statue!
Denis Richardson
7 Posted 29/11/2011 at 18:17:33
Mmm, so thats why Moyes keeps doing the same things with no better result....

(Sarcastic for you Moyes fans before I get the usual abuse....).
Michael Coville
8 Posted 29/11/2011 at 18:03:21
I believe this is an excellent point. According to reports Gary Speed showed no signs of depression, was excited about the future and still chose to commit suicide. He chose that route presumably in the full knowledge that either his wife or God forbid one of his young boys would find his body in the garage, yet he still went ahead. He went ahead with the knowledge that his wife and boys would have to live the rest of their lives with the memory of the way he died. He had to be suffering some type of mental problem which could be the result of brain damage.

The sad thing is that nobody was able to diagnose his problems and give him help before this tragedy occurred. Hopefully the football authorities will take notice and monitor players and retirees more carefully. In the meantime we can only give praise for his footballing accomplishments and hope that his wife and children can move forward and lead a full and happy life.
Alan Sherrard
9 Posted 29/11/2011 at 18:52:01
Micheal, I agree with your comment completly. A person would need to be in such a dark place to consider this act. I have four daughters and the thought of any young person witnessing such a scene would have an adverse effect on them for a lifetime. I could not believe it when i saw the BBC website report it. Considering I watched football focus on Saturday morning and he was talking with Gary Mac and there was not a hint of anything being wrong.

I guess we will never know why but the one thing I always think it that it it such a waste of extrodinary talent.
James Flynn
11 Posted 29/11/2011 at 19:19:28
Michael (5) - "Hopefully the football authorities will take notice and monitor players and retirees more carefully".

The sliver of silver in a very dark cloud of a tragedy.
James Morgan
12 Posted 29/11/2011 at 19:47:15
A mate of mine says he heard of a reason why but I don't think it would be fair to say it as it could be completely unfounded and untrue.

Such a shame for his family, a great guy and a top footballer, he will be missed by all.
Simon Templeman
13 Posted 29/11/2011 at 21:06:54
@James Morgan, so why even post that remark. This isn't a "tabloid" website.
Derek Thomas
14 Posted 29/11/2011 at 21:26:55
Stan Cullis was a similar case Re Brain Injury, read up on his Daughter's(?) comments. So this Info is not 'new', but it takes time to get accepted and acted upon by the Medical world.

But where do you start and stop, do you ban everything.

Free will, the right of free will (should) bring with it responsibility... [feels himself slipping in to ethical minefield and ends]
James Flynn
15 Posted 29/11/2011 at 21:55:26
Derek (9) - It's not to do with banning anything. It's about medical attention to players while they're playing, instead of doing nothing and players playing through a skull fracture.
Dick Fearon
16 Posted 29/11/2011 at 22:14:27
Doctors around the world are increasingly aware of problems caused by head trauma. That has lead to football authorities here in Oz putting a ban on heading by young children.

In adult ranks there is a growing prevalence of serious injury caused by raised elbows. This is another reason to support of my argument that use of elbows in heading duels should bring a mandatory yellow card.

Elbows may be useful to assist in elevation yet if they are banned players will have to rely on balance, timing, upper body strength and leaping ability. It would also mean less head injuries.
Steve Ferns
17 Posted 29/11/2011 at 23:04:15
Football has been played for well over 130 years. The likes of Dixie Dean used to head balls heavier than medicine balls for playing careers of over 20 years. Players went on to play for longer than that as the likes of Sir Stanley Matthews was playing Top level football after 50 years old.

Footage of the game in the 20s, see Pathé for some excellent footage of Dixie himself, and you notice how it's all high balls up into the box and there are some many more headed duels.

Now I'm not medically qualified to say this is a load of rubbish, but I just feel that there has been no prior evidence in footballs long history and no high profile players in the past have exhibited symptoms that have led others to come to these sort of conclusions.

I have also read with dismay that Americans perceive football as a dangerous sport for the reasons outlines and so have advised caution in allowing children to play it or want to alter the ball used or the ability to header the ball.

I feel that because of the past history of the sport I need more concrete evidence than what has emerged and take it all with a pinch of salt and would encourage my kids to take the sport up.
Nick Entwistle
18 Posted 29/11/2011 at 23:26:09
James #2, I don't think autopsies happen for deaths of 'no suspicious circumstances' and they're certainly not going to look at his brain as some kind of macabre football experiment.
Ray Robinson
19 Posted 29/11/2011 at 23:32:53
Let's face it, persistent heading an over-inflated bladder can't do your head any good can it? However, I do think that the author may have an agenda to prove that is perhaps best suited to another time. I'm sure that clinical depression has numerous reasons - head trauma may (coincidentally) or may not be one of them.
Jim Knightley
20 Posted 29/11/2011 at 23:31:26
Suicide is increasingly prevalent in everyday society, to associate it in Gary Speed's case with possible head injury is a tad tenuous and seems to be a way of looking for an excuse. I'm not dismissing it as a possibility, but why, when over a million people suffer with depression in England alone, should we look to associate it with the heading of a ball because a footballer is concerned? Depression hits everyone, footballers included.
Derek Thomas
21 Posted 30/11/2011 at 01:14:41
James; in too many cases 'overhere' that is exactly where it IS heading ( pardon pun ).

It's not about players who are injured, it's about years and years of week in week out medium-ish reapeated blows to the head.

It hasn't done me any harm ( gives poor twitchy tim howard impression )

It was my choice to play, but I don't think for one minute there whole swathes of ex player zombies in waiting walking around ( not too sure of the MotD panel and anyone who supports teams other than the Blues)

But there is a huge 'elf and safety mob making work for themselves on nannying the whole world, throw in the trend for sueing at the drop of a hat...it must be somebodies fault, I'm a victim, pay me.

Any way sod them all. I wouldn't have missed going for one header, even if it does do you in in the long run, everything does you in in ther long run, do ya wanna live for ever??

Shouts, 'Derek's Ball', rises like a tin of salmon, elbows at the ready, purely for balance reff.,,thud!,ball goes back up field, picks up sprawled opponent, sorry mate going for the ball
Eric Myles
22 Posted 30/11/2011 at 01:31:47
"Among professional soccer players, performance on memory, planning, and visuoperceptual tasks were inversely related to the number of concussions incurred in soccer and the frequency of ?heading? the ball."

Surely the correct word is "directly related to" the number of concussions? Meaning the more you bang your head the more likely you are to suffer a problem.

Inversely related means the less you bang your head the more likely you will have a problem, or the more you bang your head the less likely you are.
Jason Lam
23 Posted 30/11/2011 at 01:42:25
Heading a ball can cause a person to consciously hang themselves? How many footballers in history have done that? Those scientists need to have their heads examined.
Martin Mason
24 Posted 30/11/2011 at 02:39:36
Absolute unfounded conjecture by somebody looking to fill a space in a paper. Total garbage.
James Flynn
25 Posted 30/11/2011 at 02:43:12
Nick (14) - "look at his brain as some kind of macabre football experiment".

Macabre? What the fuck?

Head trauma on soccer players has been studied for years. I'm saying Speed's suicide should include an examination of his brain tissue at the time of death.
Pat Finegan
26 Posted 30/11/2011 at 03:11:49
Ever seen those (usually asian) guys that smack through bricks and stuff with their fist? They are able to condition their hands to become harder and able to punch through anything. They start with a bag of rocks or something and move their way up to harder things like wood and eventually bricks.

Similarly, footballers heads are conditioned to head balls without sustaining any damage.

I, personally, have taken a baseball (roughly the size and weight of a cricket ball) to the forehead at about 70 miles an hour but, because my head is conditioned to getting hit, it didn't effect me. These guys have played a lot more football than I have so I think they're fine.
James Morgan
27 Posted 30/11/2011 at 09:14:43
Simon, that's why I didn't say what it was.

My point was that it wasn't related to brain injury as suggested. Let's leave it at that.
Andrew Ellams
28 Posted 30/11/2011 at 09:59:55
So I take it we are going to be reduced to 'My mate says' rumours until the truth comes out.

As Gary's lads are Evertonians, I hope they don't read any of this. Maybe it's time to leave it alone.
Thomas Windsor
29 Posted 30/11/2011 at 10:01:55
I am sure this subject came up before when Jeff Astle died.
Chris Jackson
30 Posted 30/11/2011 at 09:52:59
Micheal, Alan, #5 & #6. Though I agree with parts of what you have written, you need to understand depression as an illness. In order for him to consider how his boys would feel, you would have to assume that he was thinking in a rational way. The mindset of somebody in stages of depression is completely different to that of most. In some cases, they actually consider their loved ones to better off without them.

I do not for a moment believe that this is anything to do with heading the ball; I believe that the man was just very ill. People in the very deep stages of depression do not always show anything to the outside world, in fact, they rarely do. I have no idea what demons he was struggling with, I'm not so sure that I ever do want to know. I want to remember the man as he was, a leader of men.

With RE the OP, I'm not sure what to think on this, but I do know that statistics are able to prove just about anything. I do not believe that this will be much of an issue now, with the lightness and make up of the balls that they use. When I was younger, my dad used to soak a casey in water and get me heading it in the back garden, his belief being that, if I could head that, I could head anything. At least.......... I think he did..........
James Thomas
31 Posted 30/11/2011 at 11:12:13
I think one should be very careful of just writing off heading the ball as not having an effect. Passion, commitment, etc are all things that we desire in English football, often extolling these virtues over technical ability.

Whilst we don't know the causes of the depression that caused Speed to take his life (and I mean the medical causes as this is a clinical condition) one cannot rule out repeated blows to the head as being a cause. The Guardian published a piece recently on the damage done to the brains of American Football players, the link to which I include.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2011/jul/19/nfl-star-brain-injuries-destroyed?INTCMP=SRCH

Whilst I understand that grid-iron is a massively different sport to football and the trauma received is obviously far worse, it does repeat what we frankly all know to be true ? that repeated blows to the head are damaging!
Daniel A Johnson
32 Posted 30/11/2011 at 12:06:04
Outwrads signs of depression?

Sometimes depression can be a distintcly personal thing.

Individulas can battle depression all their life and not have any famliy or friends aware of the issue.

Gary speed could have been battling this all his life and, given the bloke that he was, it's possible he kept it to himself all his life.

Either way he must have been in a very dark place to do what he did.

I'm still shocked.
Ant Ellis
33 Posted 30/11/2011 at 15:47:42
I'm not sure if anyone else has heard these, but I've been told of some rumours (lots of which I'm sure are doing the rounds at a time like this) that a well known lying tory rag of a paper were due to reveal something very personal about Gary.

As I say, just 1 of a 100 different rumours.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads