Elstone attempts to clarify the numbers

, 13 January, 75comments  |  Jump to most recent
In his latest blog, Everton CEO Robert Elstone tries again to answer the continued question of "where does the money go" with another breakdown of the Club's income and expenditure.

Having previously described Everton's latest accounts as "healthy", Elstone unavoidably paints a picture of extremely tight finances and acknowledges that falling gates and the potential for reduced TV revenue from reduced exposure will make the situation even more trying.

He includes a season-by-season overview of Everton's finances for the past five years, including a £35m net spend on players (somewhat at odds with this table, financed by "Bellefield and more borrowing", income (the vast majority of which is from the BSkyB revenue-sharing deal) of £368m but a well-publicised annual shortfall of £5m.

While the CEO's continued openness and willingness to address supporter concerns is laudable, it is unlikely to appease critics like the Blue Union whose scrutiny has always been centred on the "other operating costs" for which no breakdown has been forthcoming. Even if there is nothing nefarious hiding in those numbers, while the issue remains unresolved it's clear that the inquests won't stop, neither will the pressure on the Board while there is no obvious plan for increased revenue and investment.

And Elstone's hints at a deliberate campaign by supporters to suppress attendances will also raise a few eyebrows, particularly given David Moyes's more accurate assessment that the poor level of entertainment on the pitch is probably the number one driver behind the reduced gates at Goodison Park.

"Sadly, and despite a lot of hard work, £9m could become £7.5m by the end of the year with gate revenues dropping below budget (made even sadder by rumours of the sabotage of ticket sales, programmes and other matchday income)."

Quotes or other material sourced from Everton FC



Reader Comments (75)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Steve Smith
1 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:17:06
Quite interesting, but not as interesting as some of the comments on this thread are going to be!
Andrew Fair
2 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:24:39
Wow im looking forward to the abuse he is going to recieve. I actually think that he has made a good case. One thing i have an issue with though is 3 million on lawn mowers? That either alot of lawn mowers or one huge lawn mower.
Dean Adams
3 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:23:37
So glad that you have managed to clear that up Mr Elstone, love the bit about it being the fans fault that our finances are not as good as they could have been, due to falling attendances and that the Arteta money is vanishing because of us!!
Andy Peers
4 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:26:14
The big picture is that the boardroom is getting caught out and they are scrambling for excuses. I have read the report and can pull it apart just browsing over it. I am going to enjoy this thread as the truth is in there and it will be brought out. You will notice certain digs in there about how the fans are also to blame for our current situation. At least we know it isn't the Board at fault!!!!
James Ford
5 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:46:49
What are 'timelines'? I can not believe the cost of whatever they are would be significant enough to get a mention in this summary. Perhaps they tell the club when contacts run out or need renewing?....... Gosling
Paul Gladwell
6 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:47:31
Notice there is no mention of the money the pricks wasted on the balls ups of KD, Kirkby and The Park End cock up, how much did these three cost us alone? Shall be interesting what others drag up who read it more in detail, why does he think he will get away with it? They genuinely don't realise there are people with brains who support us.
Karl Parsons
7 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:37:45
But what about the Vaughan money, Pienaars pennies, the Beckford millions, the Yak cash? There is another £10 million that has gone intentionaally unnoticed.

Obviously the threats of haemorrhaging ticket sales and season ticket holders turning their backs on the club is beginning to rattle the corridors of power.

Of the 9 season ticket holders I know and my son and I are 2 of them only 4 have said they will buy theirs no matter what. 2 are walking next year and the other 3 are waiting to see what happens in January. If this these statistics run pro rata with our fan base the Club will be in deep shit.

The boardroom stinks to high heaven and I blame them entirely.
Jackie Barry
8 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:49:09
Bloody hell he's full of it! what about mentioning the fact that Everton fans are sick to death of being lied to time after time after time. It was just a few weeks ago that we were told there would be money, now there isn't???? It really stinks of desperation and shows they don't have a clue what their doing. I feel so sorry for the newer Everton fans that have so far not experienced any kind of successand then have to hear this guy blaming the fans for the lack of money! Pathetic!!! Grow up you bunch of fools and take responsibility for the state this club is in.
David Hallwood
9 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:59:53
Karl(566) don't forget about the wages they have saved getting thiose players off the wage bill
Mick Gallagher
10 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:02:50
Dont both to email him if you have a problem over this. As they dont get answered, but he's to busy with his blog these days
Peter Mills
11 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:05:33
It would be very helpful if Toffeeweb could collate the most pertinent points and questions raised on this thread and then formally address them to Robert Elstone.
Ian Bennett
12 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:15:10
My personal favourite is that he chooses to start exactly after the club banked £10-20m on the Rooney deal before Beattie was signed.

I also like the fact the selling Yak, Arteta, Vaughan, Pienaar, Beckford, and Turner plus Yobo loan fee saved wages bit style - with Landon for 2 months, James Mcfadden on a pay as you play and the Yank goalkeeper. If we are not saving over £200k in wages a week i would eat my hat.
Lyndon Lloyd
13 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:23:36
An accountant's take from someone whose opinion I respect greatly, for what it's worth.
Thomas James
14 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:15:35
Elstone is full of bullshit - he is trying to do a Jedi mind trick "these are not the pennies you are looking for".

He is like an annoying pushy salesman who will continue to try to sell you a car even when you have pointed out the problems and why no you aren't interested. He refuses to see sense, he refuses to listen and accept the problems. I bought a new(ish) car recently and encountered just such a bloke, I was very rude at the time (without swearing) and my blood is boiling reading the transcript above.
Paul Olsen
15 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:25:30
Good read Lyndon, thanks!
Ian Bennett
16 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:26:50
Good article Lyndon. One thing it does fail is that as a CEO what has been achieved in developing the business?

Part of the United story hasn't just been the success on the pitch, but the fantastic job that they have done off the pitch. Quite what do we get from Elstone? Moyes picks the players, gets the league positions and the transfer funds, whilst Sky pay the tv money.
Thomas James
17 Posted 13/01/2012 at 20:38:52
Everton sold Arteta to Arsenal 18 weeks ago. It is well documented that he was on £75,000 a week and took a £15,000 paycut to push through the deal.

The club have saved £1,350,000 in salary payments to Arteta. Today media outlets are confirming that the club bought Gibson for £1m up front....to my maths that saving would have paid for Gibson.

So what has happened to the fee recouped for Arteta and the fees and salary saved for Yakubu, Beckford, Vaughan and Pienaar....? Well over £10m
Anthony Jones
18 Posted 13/01/2012 at 21:11:15
Like all salesmen he selects the facts that support the sale. If the arteta money was spent in the fashion that he states, and the tv revenue increase went on new deals, what of the money brought in and and saved in wages from the sales of beckford, yakubu, yobo et al? Such a short article would always struggle to paint a balanced picture, in his defence.
Anthony Jones
19 Posted 13/01/2012 at 21:11:15
Like all salesmen he selects the facts that support the sale. If the arteta money was spent in the fashion that he states, and the tv revenue increase went on new deals, what of the money brought in and and saved in wages from the sales of beckford, yakubu, yobo et al? Such a short article would always struggle to paint a balanced picture, in his defence.
Gavin Ramejkis
20 Posted 13/01/2012 at 21:30:21
Elstones latest blag has holes big enough to drive a truck through as usual, utter bullshit
Jamie Tulacz
21 Posted 13/01/2012 at 22:44:29
Sorry £35m net spend, run that one past me again?!!!
Kevin Freaney
22 Posted 13/01/2012 at 22:56:32
"Everton accepts the close scrutiny of its fans. Contrasting with others, we stand up to that accountability. Fans have a right to know about their Club and we respect that"

Really!

"And almost all our fans respect there's a right way to go about getting the answers they want."

And that's just a childish remark!

That paragraph alone wound me up. They're so self righteous and condescending.
Steavey Buckley
23 Posted 13/01/2012 at 22:59:21
The problem lies with the Everton chairman and board of directors, who are unwilling, or can't, be benefactors. As a business model, Everton will have carry on selling their better players to fund less expensive ones, or loan them.
Peter Laing
24 Posted 13/01/2012 at 23:10:08
Elstone is shitting himself because the tsunami that he and Kenwright have created has smashed into the club this season and fans such as myself are voting with their feet because they cannot stand the charade and pretence that they have peddled for far too long.
Steve Smith
25 Posted 13/01/2012 at 23:32:34
Lyndons link @581 is worth a read, it gives a balanced response to Elstone's blog, in my opinion.

One thing I would say about Elstone's latest blog is that he seems to be coming across as a bit of a patronising twat, and also seems to be trying to create a "them and us" atmosphere amongst the fanbase (eg: only proper 'real Evertonians' understand the figures, but if you question them then you're a troublemaker).

In general terms, I have always respected Elstone for the way he goes about his job; just lately, it seems he's adopted the siege mentality that affects people under enormous pressure to do and say things they they don't really believe.
Peter Warren
26 Posted 13/01/2012 at 23:36:21
Wow the board have managed to get into more debt of circa 8m or so every year despite huge player sales and unprecedented increase in tv money ....oh yeah I forgot with owners investing no money and having no money to pay it debt off.

The funniest part is that they increase debt every year and then say we make a profit . Interesting blog
Gavin Ramejkis
27 Posted 13/01/2012 at 23:46:02
Interesting link on all clubs net spend

http://www.transferleague.co.uk/league-tables/2006-2011.html

£35m my arse, like his 85p in the pound, utter horseshit
Peter Laing
28 Posted 13/01/2012 at 23:50:46
Steve Smith @ 648 according to Ian Ross, Elstone has been losing the plot since the summer, siege mentality is probably true - tucked away in his bunker creating a divide and rule mentality a hallmark of every despot who knows that he has had his day.
Lee Gray
29 Posted 13/01/2012 at 23:50:55
THE TIME HAS COME. If you all want to save the mighty Everton then go to the Blackburn match and protest. This is not good enough for Everton.

We must stand together and fight for our club. Don't give up the fight. We are Everton, the best club in the world!
Steve Smith
30 Posted 14/01/2012 at 00:00:36
Peter 656.
Probably right mate, the sad thing is, that out of the current regime, he was probably one that I wouldn't of minded staying on, but with this latest piece of {fuck you lot, it's all your fault not ours} shite, it confirms he's getting too used to the sirloin being served on the top table at our expense no doubt.
James Martin
31 Posted 13/01/2012 at 23:59:07
First of all Elstone's hardly a despot, people have called for more clarity and this is what he's trying to provide - whether he does this to people's standards on here is another question but quite frankly I can't be bothered to go over the last 5 years of accounts in a greater detail than many of you think Elstone has or hasn't. What does seem pointless is absuing him for pointing out the fact that falling attendances mean a lack of revenue. What is wrong with this? He hasn't made any comment about why they are falling, no plea for this to be reversed, and yes his follow up about campaigns to reduce the attendance may also lead to reduced income which is sad for the club. These are all facts, why have people got so paranoid about these?

Whether you support the Blue Union or not, I doubt the chief executive of Everton does. Why would he want his employer hounded by people outside the match? He's within his right to allude to this subtlely in his message just as everyone here are within their rights to senselessly abuse him. Credit should be given to him for not actually openly criticising the BU and at least attempting (whatever the accuracy of it) to answer the 'where did the Arteta money go?'

For those too bent out of shape to accept that anything from the board isn't personally patronising them, then at least take solace in the fact that this statement is a response by Elstone to outside pressure that the board are clearly feeling and are looking to dissipate. At least this shows that they are beginning to feel the mounting tide - or maybe Elstone just had the misfortune of accidentally finding toffeeweb and reading a bit of it.
Ernie Baywood
32 Posted 14/01/2012 at 00:28:03
Thomas James #598

They are savings, not income. You can't buy players by decreasing expenditure on things you couldn't afford in the first place.
Nick Entwistle
33 Posted 14/01/2012 at 00:53:11
Met a red in London tonight, a proper scouse one and that's rare. He said to another guy 'they haven't got a pot to piss in and can't wait to see them slide down into oblivion'.
Told him 'good luck not qualifying for the champions league again' and the look on his face told me he fears the same for their future.
James Flynn
34 Posted 14/01/2012 at 00:55:00
James (665) - It's not about "paranoia" or "hounding" or "bent out of shape" or the Blue Union.

Current ownership is done. Done! We just want them out. That's all.

KENRIGHT OUT!
Mark Wilson
35 Posted 14/01/2012 at 00:38:56
I got a wee bit emotive on Twitter last Thursday and basically said I had supported BK to a degree for probably too long and as Moyesey announced to the world how broke we are, and yet another shameful transfer window was in the offing, I did use the sentance "feel betrayed". I've calmed down a bit since and have tried to view the CEO's attempt at clarity in a reasonable manner. I'm still desperate about the inability of the club to compete but some of the responses here are incredible. Of course my use of emotive language was jumped on by BU who retweeted to 5000 or so folk and it always helps to have one of the horrid sheep-like fans in distress. But I still think its worth sticking out my neck again....

1. The CEO is getting slaughtered for telling it as it is, and in many ways highlighting what most know ie that there's a vicious cycle that he inherited. No substantial new money, no investment in new players for three years, gradual if slower than expected failure to perform, crumbling inadequate stadium, and finally no assets to cash in. All of which equals "an utter nightmare in terms of increasing commercial revenue streams". Sponsors pay comparably little, outsourcing is reasonable but not a pot of gold and corporate match day income is one of worst in league.
2. The CEO seems to be getting blamed for this failure to up the commercial revenue and amazingly Man Utd are quoted as comparators. I'm sorry but it's just wrong. I may complain at the shops pathetic failure to stock more than a few items in 4 XL and the catering is better but still sad, yet the failure to do wonders off the pitch commercially is linked to the failure of the Board to get the right person to invest. Blaming the CEO doesn't stack up.
3. It's true he hasn't washed all the dirty linen, not quite, but I agree with Lyndons expert friend that expecting him to do this was daft.
4. The link to the open letter from Grand Old Team should be read very carefully, it's pretty well as good a shouted statement from the majority or middle ground or sheep as we are also known. I don't quite agree with it all however as I never at any time read the CEOs blog as "blaming Evertonians" because attendances are down. He simply drew obvious attention to the fact that crowds are lower and that is costing us, fact.
5. I find it fascinating but not surprising that apparently we are to believe that crowds are down solely because some in BU say they won't go the game whilst Bill is chairman, or that this has in essence led to some form of mass boycott. It hasn't. Gates are dropping because people cannot afford to go during one of the worst recessions in living memory and that is now clearly Bering seen on Merseyside in stark terms. In addition, and it's a significant add on, many seem to be fed up with what they rightly in my view see as unnecessarily negative football with a squad that's better than the results this year. This is not the CEOs fault, in the main our previous brilliant saviour of a manager has finally succumbed to the dire situation and frankly I think he's let the whole thing get to him in ways that show pre and post match and in hugely over cautious tactics. We are dull, aweful to watch and never seem to be prepared to take risks to win.
6. The CEO is someone I know a little, just a little and he is an astute and clever guy who may himself be feeling the pressure. His blog was needed and mostly reasonable but I think some of the language was loose and has led to some of these responses. I don't think he intended to insult fans at all, I think he's amazed at their dogged loyalty in dire times.
None of this makes things much better. We still cannot find a pot to piss in apparently and basically things are, to be fair to some very well penned BU articles, getting much worse and each year the vicious cycle will bite harder. The BU are surely right to suggest that something has to change ? But how, what, when and under whose leadership are the questions most of struggle to answer as we genuinely see little we can do to force a buyer for our club. I cannot berate BK in the street, or spit on him or wish him harm. I think some of his mistakes are rightly highlighted and BU should not be criticised for their desire to voice the frustration. I don't think marching behind clowns or shouting at the chairmn through railings will give us the outcome we crave and frankly I'm just not sure what will, and I believe many feel the same way.
More importantly right now is that we avoid relegation and somehow rediscover the dogs of war spirit that has deserted us all, team in particular, over the last few weeks. After that, who knows but am I scared of what's going to happen to this club that has been an integral part of my life? Yes I am, very scared.
Steve Smith
36 Posted 14/01/2012 at 01:13:25
James 665,
That's an interesting take on Elstones blog and also your opinion of how he'd feel about fans or fan groups such as Blue Union.
His Employer by the way is us, not Kenwright, without us, he'd be redundant wouldn't he?
I'm not sure where you think Elstones been senselessly abused on this thread, if you look through it, you will find his take on the figures don't really stand up to forensic scrutiny, but don't let that stop you defending him.
And just for the record, I am not Blue Unions biggest fan.
Mike Elbey
37 Posted 14/01/2012 at 01:25:25
If press figures are to be believed the incoming transfers that RE notes as being 90 odd million should be nearer 60m. Significantly RE includes in brackets ( including agents fees). Does that mean we have handed over around 30m to agents over this period - surely this cannot be true, but if it is is it any wonder football is in the shit it is currently in?
Steve Smith
38 Posted 14/01/2012 at 01:32:16
Mark 682:
It's all about opinions mate, not sure I agree with any of your's but so what, lets just hope for three points tomorrow with wankenburg sending off six villa players and still getting booed off the pitch by us !!!!
James Flynn
39 Posted 14/01/2012 at 01:43:16
Mark (682) - Good stuff.

We just want good ownership. Nothing more. No professional sport club in any sport is horse shit while producing a great competitve team on the field/pitch/court.

It doesn't happen. Our current plight the template.

KENWRIGHT OUT!
Roberto Birquet
40 Posted 14/01/2012 at 02:57:04
James Martin and Mark Wilson

Well said both of you. For all our gripes, no-one is swiping money; that report is as comprehensive as anyone could demand, added to the annual accounts, we know our financial situation. No-one is getting rich at Everton.

No-one is happy or content with our position and I fear it is desperate. Falling matchday income: it was down 20% before this season - see the accounts of the last two years - and of course it's gonna be down again.

Without TV income we are screwed. And people should not assume it will always be there. I work in media and know that the Internet is causing uge concern in the industry. If people can get the games for free (and we all can on via Site's Matchday Forum), why pay for Sky? And if people stop paying for Sky, whatdo u think Sky will do? It ain't rocket science.

We have a virtual recession - unemployment is rising. And Liverpool has a fairly high public sector employment - and that's where the jobs are gonna go this time round. Add to that a banking crisis, in which banks are gonna be calling in debts, then we've no wiggle room.

Since the sale of Arteta, it has felt like a siege. And the players are not standing up well to it. For all the calls of Kenwright out, that is no answer. What we need is someone in. And that means finding an incredibly rich sugar daddy - they are very few, and tend to perfer those with great locations, and L4 ain't it.

For Everton to stand a chance, we need urgently at least a site for a new ground. And there's little sign of it.

Why the Hell not? Is Liverpool a teeming city with barely elbow room? I thought the bloody population had halved in the last 50 years.
Eric Myles
41 Posted 14/01/2012 at 07:43:38
What's this twats email address?
Ciarán McGlone
42 Posted 14/01/2012 at 08:38:04
No one is getting rich at Everton? Nonsense. They just haven't realised the asset yet.
David Moorcroft
43 Posted 14/01/2012 at 08:34:38
More LIES. They can't admit even glaring mistakes, ie Gosling.

As I said a couple of weeks ago, as was published in the Daily Mirror before the season started, "How the fuck has Kenwright's personal wealth gone up to £11M ? from a million and having to remortgage his house to buy the shares to take control of the club??? He also borrowed money from Gregg's wife which was paid back by the club. So you could say he was skint when he took control.

Now where the fuck has the £11M personal fortune come from while, by Elstone's own admission, we are losing money every season??? Before anyone says it's from his theatre productions, why wasn't the theartre productions makeing that kind of money before he took control?

Look at the other directors keeping schtum; they are all as guilty as Kenwright. They know what's happening so I can only assume that they are getting their big payoff every season.

By the way, Elstonem, I am one of those disgruntled Evertonians who has Everton blood in their veins, and who for 45 years has spent god knows how much I have spent following the club and cash on merchandise mainly for my younger family members. Kenwright and the rest of you are not getting another fucking penny of me.

None of them, by their own admission, have put a single fucking penny of their own money into the club so where's their commitment?

So dont blame the supporters, you dirty lying twats.
Richard Jones
44 Posted 14/01/2012 at 09:34:04
So if you add in the money for Rooney, Yak, Beckford, Vaughan and Yobo. The Groundsman has had a bigger net spend than Moyes, interesting that because I bet watching him mow the grass on his £3,000,000 lawn mower is more enterning !!!
James Martin
45 Posted 14/01/2012 at 09:39:37
Steve Smith we're merely the consumers of the business that Elstone is the executive of, not his employers the same as any other company. If the customers of M&S stop buying their clothes then their chief executive comes under pressure for the company's poor performance which may ultimately lead to the shareholders/owners of M&S firing him/her. Unless you are lucky/unlucky enough to be a shareholder at Everton then you are not Elstones employer. The board led by BK will have hired him and they'll be the ones firing him before any one on here does, so in theory yes it was his boss being qquestioned by the BU and as such a response to that, whether right or wrong, is to be expected.

Nowhere in my post is there a defense of Elston'es figures - like I said I have no idea if they match up or not, from what people are saying on here they don't seem to. There's no issue with having a go at the integrity of the figures, what does seem to have little point is berating him for pointing out a few facts like falling attendances equals less money.
Chris James
46 Posted 14/01/2012 at 09:43:59
We all know that the club is in a bit of a state and trying to essentially steady the ship in the eyes of the banks after years of mismanagement.

Whilst I totally understand the anger, I do think that Elstone isn't really the correct target for it. Whilst he's by no means a superstar CEO I think he's a broadly competent and honest one and personally I like the guy and feel he's doing the best job he can in the circumstances he's placed in.

Naturally everyone's free to an opinion, but as has been expressed above, in making these blog posts and statements he's being more far more open than he has any obligation to (much more so than the majority of club chairman) and trying to at least keep the fans broadly in the loop.

No the news isn't good and yes he's going to put as positive a spin on it as he realistically can (in exactly the same way any poster on here criticising will be selective in their language and facts to make their point).

Whilst he can tinker around the edges and make sensible strategic decisions (I don't really have a problem in selling players to appease the bank if it makes the hole we're in shallower and doesn't land us in the relegation spots), the big decisions that effect the club's immediate future are elsewhere:
i) Kenwright and shareholders - Why won't they sell the club at a reasonable price?
ii) Moyes - what formation and strategy will he use based on the players available? The fact that DM is not prepared to change the 4-5-1 tactics (that have admittedly served us well but are no longer working) or play creative midfielders from the start (Drenthe, Gueye, Barkley) and/or 2 up front (Vellios and Straq haven't had a proper run) but persists with Neville and Heitinga in midfield (even when he has options) has fuck all to do with Elstone or even Kenwright.

I suppose what I'm ultimately saying is that maybe there is a CEO that could be doing a better job, but even if so, that's really not our priority any more than buying a central midfielder is for our playing squad. We need a new owner prepared to invest and (I do say this regrettably) a new manager prepared to attack rather than contain if Everton are to move forward.
Eric Myles
47 Posted 14/01/2012 at 10:12:54
^Chris, Drenthe has played from the start when he's been fit.
Denis Richardson
48 Posted 14/01/2012 at 10:52:36
Thanks for the link Lyndon and good post Mark Wilson.

I think the CEO is getting too much stick for basicly telling it like it is, yes he has not explained everything but he's explained quite a lot. For me the real question is wtf is the plan going forward and not what happened in the last 5 years. We all know we're currently up the creek with no paddle but none of the people in charge seem to know what to do about it (have not heard or read any specific plans about taking the club forward by either reducing cost or increasing revenue).

The current model is not viable (as everyone knows). We have senior players coming to the end of their careers on high salaries, to get cash in the club can only either sell our more prized players or (god forbid) take on more debt! And revenues dont cover costs.

One (maybe over simple) suggestion I would come up with (although not sure how hard this would be) is to offer the players less money and ask them to take a bit of a pay cut. If the top players took a 10% pay cut, the wages saved would be enough to cover all our interest! Am sure Fellaini could get by on 67k a week instead of 75k, likewise our 'fantastic' manager should be able to feed his family on 59k a week instead of 65k etc.

The general problem with the whole game is that the players (and sometimes managers) simply get paid too much. Somewhere in the region of 70% of our revenue goes just on staff costs, of this almost all relates to the players and manager! If the players and manager really 'cared' could they not give a little back? Its not like they would be in the poor house if they did.

The above is by no means letting the current management off the hook for the past fook ups like KD, Kirkby etc but we need to start coming up with some ideas going forward. I was amazed to see that staff costs in 2011 were 58m and in 2007 were 38m - thats over a 50% increase!! Is the squad we have today really that much better than it was 4-5 years ago? Then we were finishing 5th or 6th and now only luck is keeping us from the drop zone - something doesn't stack up.

We need to go back to a structured wage scale with say the max being paid to any one player being no more than 50k a week and this only going to a max number of say 3 players etc. 50k a week is still 2.5m a year, thats 10m over 4 year contract ffst!! We're in a global recession and governments are having to sack thousands and increase taxes to help the economy. Likewise the private sector is laying off thousands - why should footballers be immune and receive ridiculous pay increases during these hard times? The crisis started in 2008 but our wage bill just kept shooting up each year.

If we cant afford some 'top' players because they are too greedy then get cheaper but hungrier players in until the costs have been controlled. On current form this season neither the manager nor Fellaini have come anywhere near to justifying their ridiculous wages. Surely we can find young hungry players from lower down the leagues or abroad who can do just the same if not much better kind of job as a Neville, Cahill, Anichebe etc for between 10-30k a week. I just dont understand why clubs in the premiership continue to pay such ridiculous wages to players when they obviously cannot afford them. Also WTF is up with our scouting. People rave on about Moyes being great at unearthing talent but Cahill and Arteta wre signed 7 years ago ffs - since then, which great talents have been 'unearthed' from outside?

As I said, above is very simplisitic but we need to start somewhere - reduce the wage bill. Get youngsters in, or hungry pros who would kill to play in the premiership and move on the likes of Neville, Cahill, Saha... who are just sucking too much cash we dont have out of the club

There, rant over. Onto the villa game.
Jamie Tulacz
49 Posted 14/01/2012 at 12:16:08
Main headline on the BBC sports section now. At last it's starting to get a bit of attention
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/16560253.stm
Kevin Tully
50 Posted 14/01/2012 at 12:00:59
If I remember correctly, Mr. Elstone was promoted when Wyness resigned.

A business in this state requires a troubleshooter, with a track record of proven success, not someone who is in the job by default.

Before you ask what that man could improve, the corporate offering from the club is a shambles.

They actually refuse business, and there is going to be a mass exodus from the lounges next season.

So don't be so quick to defend a CEO who is failing to address he most lucrative side of the club's income stream, EPIC FAIL.



Karl Parsons
51 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:37:45
But what about the Vaughan money, Pienaars pennies, the Beckford millions, the Yak cash? There is another £10 million that has gone intentionaally unnoticed.

Obviously the threats of haemorrhaging ticket sales and season ticket holders turning their backs on the club is beginning to rattle the corridors of power.

Of the 9 season ticket holders I know and my son and I are 2 of them only 4 have said they will buy theirs no matter what. 2 are walking next year and the other 3 are waiting to see what happens in January. If this these statistics run pro rata with our fan base the Club will be in deep shit.

The boardroom stinks to high heaven and I blame them entirely.
Karl Parsons
52 Posted 13/01/2012 at 19:37:45
But what about the Vaughan money, Pienaars pennies, the Beckford millions, the Yak cash? There is another £10 million that has gone intentionaally unnoticed.

Obviously the threats of haemorrhaging ticket sales and season ticket holders turning their backs on the club is beginning to rattle the corridors of power.

Of the 9 season ticket holders I know and my son and I are 2 of them only 4 have said they will buy theirs no matter what. 2 are walking next year and the other 3 are waiting to see what happens in January. If this these statistics run pro rata with our fan base the Club will be in deep shit.

The boardroom stinks to high heaven and I blame them entirely.
Lee Preston
53 Posted 14/01/2012 at 12:40:35
Interesting to read that the remaining ''£5.5million'' would be largely used to fund the new deals for Fellaini and Barkley, it was my understanding that Fellaini took over Arteta's deal, meaning an approximate £40,000 per week was available, which no doubt would have been utilised to fund an increased deal for Barkley.

It's interesting that the McFadden and Hahneman deals were mentioned, the latter being possibly the most pointless deal I've ever witnessed as an Evertonian! Did we/do we really need a back-up keeper for the back-up keeper?

Robert Elstone is a man clutching at straws, he knows the majority of the Everton faithful are on to him and his web of deceit.
Steve Guy
54 Posted 14/01/2012 at 13:03:26
Patronising in part, defensive in part and about as factual as Star Trek. Digs at the BU, digs at fans who dare to question. Paranoia that it's a conspiracy that is seeing gates drop.....couldn't be the dross served up on the pitch by any chance ?

A busted regime fighting for it's life to keep the lid on a pot that has just started steaming.
Richard Tarleton
55 Posted 14/01/2012 at 13:24:26
Steve Guy is absolutely right," the ring fenced money" for the King's Dock is where we all realised what a shambles Everton's Board and Everton's finances were.
Kevin Tully
56 Posted 14/01/2012 at 13:23:47
Someone needs to explain to our C.E.O. it's not about where the money is spent, I have never thought there were fingers in the till.

The problem is the way the club is run, not one penny of investment from the board, 11 executive boxes FFS, a tent instead of real facilities - and they managed to fuck that up, and the ground is in the same state since since these short sighted imbeciles have been in charge.

In short, they are trying to explain away why the club is fucked, but don't believe it is their fault.

They are a laughing stock. Just fuck off please.
Steavey Buckley
57 Posted 14/01/2012 at 13:37:41
If supporters want more transfers into the club, they should consider setting up a transfer fund that is 'ring fenced.'
Colin Taylor
58 Posted 14/01/2012 at 13:31:19
Does no-one on here think the greedy bastard players are slightly to blame? They play shite every week then jump in their Bentleys to Alderley Edge laughing their plums off.

We are slowly heading out of the Premier League... fuck all these high earners off and start again with young hungry players, pay them all £20k a week and have a bigger squad. If they do well, sell them to the Citeh.

Football as a whole cannot go on with all these spiraling wages, the bubble will burst. Everton need to act now and be first to do so. COYB
Gavin Ramejkis
59 Posted 14/01/2012 at 15:41:24
Steavey the supporters already provide over 20% of the club's income through ticket sales plus whatever they add in merchandising, the board and majority shareholders all add a cumulative fuck all, £0 and 0p and have done for 12 years and counting, if the supporters chipped in even more money to fund players then all they'd be doing is providing the already scrooge fuckers something else to sell or make their investment a slightly more attractive purchase.
Greg Lambden
60 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:32:14
I cannot believe the fucking cheek of the man! So let me get this right, the board blame the fans for not turning up and spending enough money. How much money have the board invested Robert?? Cheeky twat!!
Steavey Buckley
61 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:55:24
Gavin, the income Everton receive from ticket sales, merchandise and pay to view to watch tv is not enough for Everton to pay salaries (by far, the largest ticket item) and buy good enough signings. I do believe a special fund could be set up by those who want one, to donate money for transfers. Everton have supporters here at home and worldwide who have deep pockets and want to be benefactors, not shareholders. The only next alternative is a new issues of shares, to increase investment into the Everton club, if the present chairman and board of directors agree to.
Bobby Thomas
62 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:08:41
Steavey, yes, a share rights issue.

There are ways out of this mess. There are Evertonians who desperately want to help the club and who want to feel part of it again, especially after the alienating spin tactics employed by the club in the last few years.

A share rights issue could be used for many things, towards a new Park End, transfer cash for Moyes or, try this, to buy Finch Farm.

What a way to heal the wounds of the fan base and re-engage fans with the club. By giving them the opportunity to help Everton buy back Finch Farm. Everyone involved would feel part of the club, it would be a contribution from each individual that would last decades.

But something like that can never happen. They just wont do it, despite the potential benefits.
Martin Mason
63 Posted 15/01/2012 at 05:10:48
I think that he explained it very well except for the bit about sabotage by the fans. The dire performances have put many off and many fans are struggling to afford to go to the games because of the cost. I believe the fans should be praised for turning up in such relatively large numbers. I can genuinely see how the club could be dismayed byt the reaction of some fans
Steve Brown
64 Posted 15/01/2012 at 06:17:38
Revenue has increased year on year, but so have operating costs due entirely to tying players into long-term salaries. This is a lot of logic in this, see Simon Kuper's brilliant book "Why England Loses' which uses data analysis to identify the drivers for improving team performances (page 60). This demonstrates that there is a direct correlation between paying players bigger salaries and league position, while there isn't a correlation between paying huge transfer fees and league position.

That is except for Everton, where the form of every player tied into a long-term contract has turned to shit - Cahill, Arteta, Fellaini etc! Therefore, the only way for us to get out of this is to get the bigger (and usually older) players off the books quick and invest in emerging younger players who are hungry to make it in the premiership.

The sabotage claim about the fans is breath-taking, because he puts nothing forward to back it up and if he has direct evidence I suggest he calls the police rather than put it in a blog!
Garry Martin
65 Posted 15/01/2012 at 09:17:23
Have just read the comments on the article at the official EFC site from supporters. It turned my stomach to read some of the creeping comments made, 95% praise Elstone for a good article, the other 5% vaguely mention the Yak & Beckford money. Its sad to see how the official site is controlled & does not represent the REAL SUPPORTERS..........a bit like the Echo really!
Robby Daniels
66 Posted 15/01/2012 at 09:07:48
Flymo Bob's blog, in my opinion, is a direct result of the stick Kenwright has been (and still is) receiving.

He fails to mention the £4M they wasted trying to move us to a cowshed in Kirkby? Flymo then goes on to blame us, the fans, who pay his wages!

As we have seen in the original post, the figures regarding transfers don't add up... more spin.

Flymo would be better off explaining... why he didn't include the money wasted on the Everton Place failure. Flymo and Bullshit gave us three different excuses, why they moved the Dixie Dean statue, knocked a big fuckin hole in the wall, and then did nothing? When the real reason was that they had applied for and received full planning permission to develop the land, had drawings made etc, when in fact, the land owners (which is the Prudential, I believe, who they forgot to ask) told them to do one in case they had to repossess the land.

Flymo and his mate should explain to us why Philip Green brokered the Rooney transfer? Stretford was Shrek's agent, what's Green got to do with it?

Flymo and his mate couldn't lie straight in bed...
Roger Trenwith
67 Posted 15/01/2012 at 13:52:21
Mark 682 says it all.

As we all know, it is virtually impossible to separate the emotional element of being a fan from the hard commercial reality of running a business. Elstone is not a fan, he is an appointed CEO inheriting the kind of financial mess that would make your average business owner's eyes water.

He has to be applauded for being as honest as he can. Lyndon's link to his accountant friend explains in terms anyone can follow why Elstone cannot be as open as some of us would like. With some folk the emotional element of fandom stops them seeing the wood for the trees as it were, but, as another accountant, I can tell you that Elstone simply cannot reveal any more than he has.

He has a thankless and nigh on impossible task and no money to carry it out. Expecting us to compete with the likes of Man Utd, and even, God forbid, the neighbours on commercial terms is like asking your local corner shop to take on Tescos!

To sum up, he confirms what we all know anyway ? we're getting deeper and deeper into the shit and the only way out is a sale, and it's not Elstone who is the problem is it?
Eric Myles
68 Posted 15/01/2012 at 13:54:23
Bobby #995 you are right that there are Evertonians who desperately want to help the Club but we will not give a penny to the charlatans that have not put a penny of their own money into the Club.

TrustEverton is the way to go if you want to help the Club.
Ste Traverse
69 Posted 15/01/2012 at 16:57:15
Trying to put blame on the fans for our financial situation.

Unbelievable.

I can't get my head around why there are some who believe this joker is good at his job.

He isn't. He's part of the problem.

The sooner this bumbling idiot is out of the club the better.

In life you get back what you give out and the board treat the fans with comtempt. So it's hardly suprising some have chosen to return the favour.
Alasdair Mackay
70 Posted 15/01/2012 at 18:11:03
Okay - so we have no money!

1) Get Kris Boyd to help us out on a 6 month contract. If he does well we can give him a longer contract in the summer
2) Try and get a deal in place to take Solomon Kalou from the summer.
3) Try and get a similar deal for Nicky Maynard.

That's potentially 3 new forwards in and no money spent. Saha has not earned a new contract and is the wrong side of 30, with injury problems. So he can go in the summer (which frees up the wage bill). We can sell Bily for £6m, which gets some money for the bank and frees up more space on the wage bill.

Our forwards for next season - Kalou, Maynard, Boyd, Cahill, Anichebe, Velios, McAleny.
Our options on the wing will include Drenthe, Coleman, Gueye and Osman
In the centre we can play Fellaini, Rodwell, Gibson, Barkley
And our back four - Neville, Hibbert, Jags, Duffy, Distin, Heitinga, Baines
With Howard in goal - we have a strong squad with a few minor tweaks!
John Keating
71 Posted 15/01/2012 at 18:48:10
Alasdair,

We couldn't afford the Pukka Pie invoice to keep Kris Boyd going for 6 months.

Why would Kalou and Maynard want to set their careers back by coming here? Plus we couldn't afford the robbing bastard's agent's fees to do those deals, never mind Kalou's wages.

6 mill for Bily!! We would be dead lucky just to give that useless shite away!!
Thomas Williams
72 Posted 15/01/2012 at 23:38:51
A couple of things stand out on that report.

In 2006, where they chose to start, convenient since the bulk of the Rooney money is not included, there is no mention of other operating costs, then suddenly the following year it appears out of thin air at £22M, I was given the impression this was including the interest on the loans, but no, that is separate and another £19M.

Where did that sudden increase come from? What went on in 2006-07 to justify this massive increase in outlay? If you are going to mention Hahnemann, Donovan and McFadden why no mention of the sales of Neill, Vaughan, Pienaar, Yakubu, Beckford, not to mention the monies received for the loans of Yobo and Yakubu.

Wages are down 4% in ratio of wages/income.

In 2006 we had income of £58M of which £38M went on players, 2010 income 79M and wages were £58M, so in effect the increase in income has gone on wages, but in 2006 we received £26.3M from broadcasting and 2010 we received £50.2M, so that is an extra £24M from broadcasting whilst wages went up £20M.

In 2006, sponsorship and merchandise were separate items of £5.24M and £7.62M, total £12.86M, in 2010 these two items are combined and totalled £8.06M, that is £4.8M less 5 years later!! This item is a shocking indictment of how the club is run.

In 5 years the gate and programme income has only increased £1M, again not a good enough return.

Analysing the figures, the elephant in the room is the operating costs, how did they suddenly increase to 29% of our turnover?
John Roberts
73 Posted 16/01/2012 at 07:17:59
Next he will be saying that there's money available for Moyes in the summer!! Oh... that's when it's season ticket renewal time!!!
Amit Vithlani
74 Posted 16/01/2012 at 10:22:35
Three points stand out:


1. Interest costs appear huge. Our average debt balance was something like 30m. Interest averages at 4m per year or an average rate of 13.3%. That's 13% over base rate. The interest rate might be reasonable considering our parlous financial state, but it is nonetheless an expensive rate and a significant amount of money to be bleeding: GBP 4m a year on the existing debt would go a long way towards strengthening the playing squad. Being so dependent on expensive debt for so long is one of the reasons why this current management regime needs to re-think its strategy.

2. The net spend on transfers make no sense. It looks as if the figure is based on instalments. The true picture on net spend will not emerge until all the instalments are paid. This means its difficult to tell whether we are net spenders or net sellers on the existing pool of players. The picture would be completed if Elstone showed the balance of payments still due to and from other clubs on the transfers (also because we may have borrowed against these proceeds).

3. Anyone else here think that these guys don't get it? Fuelling expenditure using debt was never going to be sustainable. Eventually the banks were going to stop lending, unless we consistently qualified for the Champions League our income wen t to another level. The strategy is on a smaller scale to Leeds. The lessons of the past were not there. So where is their Plan B? How will they reduce the debt?

Answer to 3 is probably in selling the playing the squad, which Elstone has made a big point in showing how much investment has gone in.

Amit Vithlani
75 Posted 16/01/2012 at 10:45:42
Finger gliches. Point 3 should say "and our income went to another level" also "lessons of the past were not learned"

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads