Everton vs Sunderland

, 16 March, 85comments  |  Jump to most recent
FA Cup 6th Round Preview

The Quarter Finals of the FA Cup. With a trip to Wembley as the prize for the victors this was always going to be a big game but in the aftermath of the derby debacle at Anfield on Tuesday night, Everton's clash with Sunderland this weekend has taken on an entirely different and unexpected dimension.

It's ironic that the man who struck such a chord with Blues fans on day one with his "People's Club" proclamation should have marked his 10-year anniversary in charge at Goodison Park by damaging his stock so badly with a sizeable proportion of the fanbase.

Few actions by Moyes over the past decade have angered fans to such a degree as his decision to make six changes to a winning team at Anfield, not to mention, of course, his astoundingly blasé post-match interview after the crushing defeat. What was clear from his comments, however, was that the manager, in his quest to finally land a trophy after 10 years in the job, had definitively made the FA Cup his priority. The further irony that it was an ill-advised selection decision in the League Cup against Chelsea, namely dropping Tim Howard for a very ring-rusty Jan Mucha, that probably cost him a chance at silverware in the competition earlier this season might have been lost on him.

Truth be told, while the most wounded of Blues won't ever forget what transpired on Tuesday, they'll probably forgive Moyes if he can steer his team to victory in the Final in May. It's just that he has arguably heaped more pressure than was necessary on this Saturday's occasion and it's up to him and his players to rise above the rancour and book passage to Wembley with victory at the first attempt.

With Steven Pienaar cup-tied, the obvious course of action for the manager to take would be to simply reinstate the team that started against Spurs last week. Restoring the Heitinga-Distin partnership and putting Nikica Jelavic back into the starting XI should be the very least Moyes does but it would be a surprise if the likes of Leon Osman, Tim Cahill, Royston Drenthe and perhaps Phil Neville didn't find their way back into the team for the visit of Sunderland.

Darron Gibson is the only other confirmed absentee as he recovers from a knee injury so there will be plenty of depth on the bench.

The derby defeat represents Everton's only defeat in their last 10 games in all competitions and, as such, could be regarded as a bump in the ever-smoother trail that the Blues have been blazing since the turn of the year. The psychology of the players and home faithful will surely have been affected, although another home tie — the Blues' seventh successive home draw in the cup this season — and their recent record over Sunderland can only help on that score.

In their last four home games against the Mackems, Everton have a 100% record, scoring 14 goals and conceding just one and Moyes has yet to taste defeat against Sunderland. His record against Martin O'Neill is poor, however, with just win in nine but that solitary victory came in the FA Cup Quarter Finals against Aston Villa three years ago.

Having set his stall out to go all out for the FA Cup, Moyes now has to deliver with outright victory in front of a packed house at Goodison. It's a must-win game in many respects, one that will set the tone for the next few weeks of the season.

Lyndon Lloyd

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeWeb



Reader Comments (85)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Simon Harris
1 Posted 16/03/2012 at 06:00:00
Yep, probably same team that started against Spurs.

The only one from that team he may have looked at changing, would have been Rodwell for Coleman and pushing Osman out wide. Both were poor on Tuesday, but I would stick with Coleman as we need to get at 'em.

I'm expecting a tight game, as i'm sure Sunderland will be content with a replay. But, with the crowd behind us, at a packed Goodison on FA cup quarter final day, I'm confident we'll do it.

Can't wait for tomorrow, and hopefully another trip to Wembley..
Nick Entwistle
2 Posted 16/03/2012 at 08:43:57
Maybe the cup isn't best timing, but I hope there would be some fan backlash against Moyes with what transpired Tuesday, but still remain supportive of the team.
Tommy Coleman
3 Posted 16/03/2012 at 09:57:22
The whole squad/fans have somehow got to forget 'Derbygate' for one day and try to get us to Wembley.

We need that FA Cup Mr. Moyes.
Scott Hamilton
4 Posted 16/03/2012 at 10:18:18
Nick - I agree but it's difficult to do both.

Let's just hope we utterly blitz Sunderland, win by a decent margin and can in future refer to the d***y as the game we lost intentionally in order to win the Cup!
Nick Armitage
5 Posted 16/03/2012 at 11:26:51
Jagielka to start, nailed on.
Brian Waring
6 Posted 16/03/2012 at 11:42:24
I'm with you Nick, I can see Jags starting.
Shane Williams
7 Posted 16/03/2012 at 11:56:18
I really hope he does not go with Jags over Heitinga as he's been solid as of late. I have a feeling he will though.
Tony Rutherford
8 Posted 16/03/2012 at 12:10:38
Let's hope Jags doesn't start as he's not ready... that was blatantly obvious on Tuesday. Distin and Heitinga need to be the central pairing...

I know Distin had a bit of a mare the other night but how much of that was down to the partnership rather than just his individual performance? Team selection is critical tomorrow... let's hope Moyesie gets it right!!
Peter Cummings
9 Posted 16/03/2012 at 12:03:58
Sunderland have been weakened by suspensions and injury to key players so we should attack from the kickoff... even though they beat you know who last game.... like Liverpool, they were absolute rubbish, but we can't afford to take them lightly because they won't lie down,
Andy Codling
10 Posted 16/03/2012 at 12:15:43
Agreed Nick I wouldnt be suprised if he starts Jagielka and slots Heitinga into midfield, the man is an imbecile so I expect these decisions from him. Only Moyes could unsettle a partnership that was looking good and getting clean sheets.
Jagielka.. lets hope Arsenal come back in the summer!
Ciarán McGlone
11 Posted 16/03/2012 at 12:24:03
Jesus, imagine he started with the same team as Tuesday... I'd laugh (and by laugh I mean try and learn the rules of cricket).
Alex Willett
12 Posted 16/03/2012 at 12:30:34
Jags to start, AND Anichebe on his own up front.
Andrew Clare
13 Posted 16/03/2012 at 12:57:56
Johnny Heitinga has been one of the stalwarts of our team over the past few months.
So yes Moyes will probably pick Jagielka and move Johnny. Exasperating!
Adam Bennett
14 Posted 16/03/2012 at 13:10:27
With Gibson injured, Rodwell still not fully match fit etc... I hope to god Moyes doesn't start putting defenders in midfield.

I've got a horrible feeling Jags and Distin will be centre half, with Heitinga in midfield.
David Booth
15 Posted 16/03/2012 at 13:05:28
In line with the last few threads above me, I thought it fit to repeat a post I made on another thread yesterday:

Mark my words, now that Jagielka is fit, Moyes will be dying to move (and therefore re-marginalise), Heitinga to the defensive midfield role against Sunderland.

I think he is incapable of appreciating the extent to which Heitinga has underpinned our recent good run and tightened the defence up immeasurably.

Personally, I think Jagielka is a great defender, but Heitinga ought to be the first name on the teamsheet - as whether he plays alongside Jagielka or Distin, both look settled and we defend much better.

Jagielka and Distin spend half their time covering for each other's mistakes. Like Rodwell and Fellaini, the whole is less than the sum of the parts. They cannot really play together.

Moyes now has to re-build his team's confidence from scratch after a 3-0 thumping and lift/re-motive players who were part of that, or dropped.

If, as we all imagine, that all or most of the 'six' are re-instated. How are the others, who are now clearly second-choice, going to feel? Dreadful, short-sighted, cowardly, de-motivating management.

Talk about creating pressure totally unnecessarily. The Sunderland game has gone from a quarter final tie we should be anticipating with relish, on the back of a run of good form and confident players, to a hyper-pressure game we MUST now win in greater style than Barcelona!

Anything less than a convincing three or four-nil victory will not now be acceptable.

And should we draw - or, heaven forbid, be defeated - Moyes stands to lose the majority support he has enjoyed in all his time here overnight. Me included. He will have completely sabotaged our season and his reputation, in five days.

What a huge, huge, huge mistake he made on Tuesday. There are NO positives.

No, there is one: getting to Wembley and beating the gobshites 4-0... but we all know how likely that is, don't we?
Tim Locke
16 Posted 16/03/2012 at 12:47:05
A poor article I have lost count of the number of people on this site asking, pleading, begging Moyes for 4-4-2, and then they get their wish and that was wrong, Moyes should have played 4-4-1-1, and when asked to explain their love of 4-4-2 and why it didn?t work Tuesday the reply comes back, it was the wrong 4-4-2, he should have played Heitinga and should have played Jelaviã, should have played Drenthe, poor selection from Moyes.

The side he played Tuesday was a good side, the midfield was quality, a central midfield worth £30-40m, a winger in Colman who was compared to Bale in the Guardian, and Pienaar who is quality. Jaielka is hardly a second rate defender, and sure Heitinga has been playing well but I don't think that switch can be considered poor, only a little hard on Heitinga.

Changes where made with 30minutes left and we still went onto concede and make little impact, for some reason the players on the pitch didn't perform, and that is partly because of how well Liverpool played, pressing us and not allowing us time on the ball. This is not to mention historically our record at Anfield is poor. The blame for Tuesday night is placed firmly at the players door, lets hope Saturday brings a better performance.
Ciarán McGlone
17 Posted 16/03/2012 at 14:22:22
Tim,

We didn't play 4-4-2. No cigar. Poor post.
Richard Reeves
18 Posted 16/03/2012 at 14:28:40
Tim, of course the players must take some sort of responsibility for Tuesday's performance but are you saying Moyes is not to blame in any way?

You must've noticed that when we were in possesion of the ball nobody had a clue where to move to in order to help the player on the ball; you must've noticed the ball was in the air a lot when we had it; and you must've noticed these things have occurred a lot in the last 10 years.

Do you not think this is anything to do with coaching?
Brian Waring
19 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:04:49
Tim, it was ridiclious Coleman being compared to Bale, because Bale is a better player by some distance.

Also, so its the players that were at Fault, and no blame lies with Moyes?
Stephen Kenny
20 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:10:56
The people who compared Bale to Coleman aren't the same ones who compare Moyes to SAF by any chance were they?
Stephen Kenny
21 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:10:56
The people who compared Bale to Coleman aren't the same ones who compare Moyes to SAF by any chance were they?
Ross Kerry
22 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:16:40
I wonder what team Moyes wishes he would have started with on Tuesday now? I?m sure he had a team in mind for tomorrow, but the result would now require him to have balls of steel to send it out.
Graham Tansey
23 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:40:20
Team should be:

Howard, Neville, Heitinga, Distin, Baines, Coleman, Osman, Fellaini, Drenthe, Cahill, Jelavic.
David Booth
24 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:45:41
Amazing isn't it how, by thinking he was pulling some sort of tactical masterstroke that would have him roundly applauded by all and contribute towards making tomorrow's game a virtual forgone conclusion... how Moyes has now made it a complete make-or break match for our whole season and his reputation.

What an absolute planning, playing and PR disaster.
Ross Kerry
25 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:49:02
...the anniversary from hell
Norman Merrill
26 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:53:49
After the Tuesday debacle, I sincerely hope whoever is chosen is ready for a battle, because Sunderland gave Liverpool one last week. Even without the two stars missing, they are a handful, and after watching the boys playing the men at Anfield, I fear that we may not rise to the occasion. I really hope I'm wrong.
Richard Reeves
27 Posted 16/03/2012 at 15:47:44
There are two reasons for that performance on Tuesday:

#1: Moyes does not have a winner's mentality.
#2: Moyes has poor coaching methods.

If he sent out the same team used against Spurs, we would've had a better chance but I still wouldn't have had much hope of getting a result. It's too shortsighted to blame players, formations and team selection although he did fuck up on the later big time. The problem is Moyes's footballing philosophy.
Andrew Ellams
28 Posted 16/03/2012 at 16:19:31
The only similarity between Bale and Coleman is that they have both gone backwards this season because teams have worked out that they are one trick ponies.

Coleman is neither a winger or a full back and I reckon is next in line to become the crowd's whipping boy.
Richard Reeves
29 Posted 16/03/2012 at 16:17:33
I expect whatever team he puts out on Saturday we will see 100% commitment, crunching tackles, a few elbows in people's faces etc. You know that's the very least we expect from Everton... but under Moyes that's normally the most we can expect. Should satisfy the herd though(sadly).
And if we get a result, the deluded will be on here talking about passion and how he's got the best out of them and how this was a managerial masterstroke. You know it's coming, don't ya.
Anto Byrne
30 Posted 16/03/2012 at 16:21:06
Moyes is pinning everything on this game, fuck the league and possible 6th place and ticket to Europe. The cup is a lottery and can go either way. The sensible approach was euro qualification from 6th and given we still have Newcastle to come we could have been right in the mix. We surely have enough players to turn Sunderland over even with 6 enforced changes should that have been the case. If we lose the prick should call it a day an go
John Audsley
31 Posted 16/03/2012 at 17:02:44
Poor post Tim 457

Moyes sulked on the bench all game then pretty much admitted in interviews afterwards that he really wasn't too bothered

The players take blame clearly but Moyes actions and comments after match were a disgrace to our great club

I don't actually remember 4 4 2 being the formation either, Vic was on both wings from memory...

Coleman like Bale....HAHAHA
Mick Gallagher
32 Posted 16/03/2012 at 17:57:12
Tim Locke

There's been enough articles to comment on the derby and this isn't one of them. It pissed me off enough wasting £48 to watch and im still pissed off.

So lets hope we win tomorrow and Jags is left on the bench as the Johnny was doing fine.
Howard Meakin
33 Posted 16/03/2012 at 17:58:48
Jags, Coleman & Rodwell were nowhere near match-fit for the derby game... and why does Drenthe keep falling over the ball? Moyes has to go with Distan & Johnny against Sunderland. I think we will just nick a win but it won't be pretty. Come on, Moyes ? pick a strong fully fit team.

ps: Please leave Neville in the dressing room.
Mark Riding
35 Posted 16/03/2012 at 18:37:15
I have NEVER heard an anti-Moyes chant at Goodison.. if Im honest, anti-Kenwright chants / shouts are very rare...

Goodison will be totally behind the team tomorrow, even if going behind etc..

I just think if it goes tits-up.. it may get a bit nasty for Moyes tomorrow come the full time whistle..
Nick Entwistle
36 Posted 16/03/2012 at 18:44:57
Graham 492,

You've picked the best team that Moyes could pick for the cup.

Of course we'd all like to see if Drenthe could play behind Jelavic while Pienaar took his place on the wing, but for a cup match with Moyes in charge that's the way to go.

Cloggers Anichebe (16 goals in his entire Everton career), Jags, Hibbert must be benched.
Tim Locke
37 Posted 16/03/2012 at 18:29:55
Ciarán McGlone four defenders, four midfields, two forwards? Yes well done you, clearly not 4-4-2.

Richard Reeves - Well Moyes choose the team, and gave instruction, along with other coaches, but it the players on the park and they have a lot more responsibility than the original article said and most post since, the team out there was full of good players who didn't perform. I am not sure I agree with your assessment of the football, I think there are one or two players who hit the ball in the sky but we do get the ball down and play.

Brian Waring - As outlined above, sure Moyes has to hold his hands up to the team selection but I don't think it is as bad as people made out. You read the posts on here and it sounds like Moyes pick people from the crowd and someones gran, he picked some good players who didn't perform.

Graham Tansey - If he had picked that team and it had lost then all the complaints would have been why did he play Cahill and Neville, why does he play 4-4-1-1.
Nick Entwistle
38 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:00:46
Yeah Tim, but you wouldn't get people asking for their money back if he did. He dropped six from a form team, and re-introduced cloggers who never performed when fit this season. In the derby! He obviously had something in mind regarding the run of games we've got coming up which will possibly stretch to 7 in 21 if we go to a replay, but that was not the game to do something about it.
Mark Riding
39 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:08:10
Nick... needs to get games into Jags so he has a blinder against Arsenal next week and maybe we can get a few quid for him off them a la Arteta?
Kevin Sparke
40 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:20:26
So, if by some fluke we win tomorrow; I guess all you Moyes haters who go the match will be boycotting the semi in protest?

Thought not...

But it you are, I'll have your ticket...
Mark Stone
41 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:13:20
He didn't drop 6 from a 'form team'. The squad was in form and most of the players who came in on Tues have played a role in that. Are you saying that Jelavic who made his full debut last weekend was behind the 9 game unbeaten run? Same for Osman who made his return first start since the defeat to Bolton, against Spurs. Jesus people were kicking off that Osman played against Spurs now they are kicking off that he was rested for the next game! Are you saying you think Pienaar shouldn't have been brought back in? Are you saying Stracq hasn't been instrumental in our recent good run? I would have put a different team out compared with Moyes, but it's not as though it was a weak team.
Michael Bates
42 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:39:29
Mark, it was a weak team....because it lost.
Jamie Barlow
43 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:42:51
It wasn't a weak team, it was a weakened team.
Michael Bates
44 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:45:06
So it was weak then...
Mark Riding
45 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:47:12
Mark Stone: I agree. The team selected could have done a job on what is a very average Liverpool side. Giving Gerrard so much space (Rodwell) and Drenthe falling on his arse at any given moment didnt help !

If it finished in a 1-0 defeat, it wouldn't be such a big issue. It's the fact that Gerrard got a hat-trick and so many players played without looking bothered is what grates with me (my opinion only).

Johnny in midfield tomorrow would be a mistake, but I can just see it.
Mick Gallagher
46 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:49:28
So Kevin, what makes a Moyes hater in your eyes? I would love to know.
Ciarán McGlone
47 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:54:35
Can someone please explain football, and Moyes approach to it, to Mr Locke.

He's clearly never seen Moyes use strikers out wide before.
Kevin Sparke
48 Posted 16/03/2012 at 19:58:48
Why?
Mick Gallagher
49 Posted 16/03/2012 at 20:02:44
I would like to know if you class me as one in case I've got to give you my ticket.
Ross Kerry
50 Posted 16/03/2012 at 20:34:13
Tuesday makes his selection tomorrow much harder than it might have been. If he doesn?t bring Heitinga back then he was dropped despite MOTM reviews. If he drops Rodwell, as he should, then why was he thrown in on Tuesday night?

Heitinga must play, the question is whether he is shoe-horned in so that he can also play one of his England internationals.
Richard Dodd
51 Posted 16/03/2012 at 20:30:26
I`m sure it will be Jags and Johhny in central defence tomorrow with the skipper as defensive mid,
Ossie and Pins wide with Felli and Tim.
Jelly up front on his own.
Should ensure a 2-0 win with Tuesday just a memory.
Gavin Ramejkis
52 Posted 16/03/2012 at 20:43:00
The squad should be exactly the same one that played Spurs with a ready and waiting Barkley and Strac waiting on the bench, Rodwell should be at home or in the stands as should Jags
Bob Willis
53 Posted 16/03/2012 at 20:51:22
Any odds on Moyes walking should we lose by a couple of goals tomorrow?
Ross Kerry
54 Posted 16/03/2012 at 20:57:42
Bob, lets just hope we win!
As for the manager walking, I think Tuesday proved that he ain't gonna do it.
Love or loathe him, he's as tough and stubborn as it comes.
Anthony Jones
55 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:02:17
Comment removed. Less of this "genuine fan... closet redshite" or you will be banned.
Kevin Sparke
56 Posted 16/03/2012 at 20:34:08
Fair enough; I'm bored enough, so I'll let you know - 'Moyes Hater'

Person who espouses the view that Moyes is the worst thing to happen to Everton Football Club since Alan Ball was sold and will use any evidence; however tenuous to back up their pet theory; whilst disregarding any evidence to the contrary.

Typically saying stuff like:

'Lack of money doesn't matter' - ignoring the fact that the only four teams who have accumulated more Premier League points since David Moyes was appointed manager of Everton are Manchester United, Chelsea, Liverpool and Arsenal... coincidentally the four clubs who before the rise of Manchester City have spent the most money... other teams that have spent more money than us over the same period... Sunderland, Newcastle, Spurs, Aston Villa, Stoke City, Bolton, QPR, Fulham, Wolves, West Ham, Birmingham are bigger net spenders per season than Everton* - If money doesn't matter - why is it that the trend over the last 11 years is for the richest teams in terms of spending to finish almost exactly in the same order every year... apart from one team... David Moyes's Everton

"Moyes plays negative football" - Despite the fact that since the start of Moyes's taking over at Everton - only five teams have scored more Premier League goals and only four have conceded less... I bet you can't guess who they are? (If you guess the top 4 plus Spurs... you're right... but money doesn't mean anything)

Moyes haters - people who come out with shite like 'we're a big club - we should be competing with the top four and we would be if it wasn't for Moyes' Well - to me, there is no bigger club than Everton - but that's romanticism - we live in the 'real world' and in the real world, you spend lots of money - you get a good team. How else do you account for the rise of a shower of shite like Manchester City.

Now, this doesn't mean that Moyes is above criticism - I'm deeply critical of Moyes's team selection, his occasional slips into maudlin introspection, his tactic of bringing all back for corners and yes, his team selection on Tuesday - which I thought was fucking barmy...

However, you get a type of poster on here who has clearly set his stall out - Moyes is a twat - despite any evidence to the contrary...

Sorry - nowt in life is black and white to me... he's not the devil incarnate - neither is he a plaster saint.

He's a good manager, with massive big flaws and he's probably been the difference between us playing championship football and higher mid-table - despite his flaws.

I worry about the fact that when he goes - if we don't get a huge injection of cash, we'll drop down the table quicker to where our spending would naturally have us... relegation.

Feel free to disagree, this is what life is all about, debate and whilst there are some who will call me a Moyes lover for trying to take a balanced view and using unfashionable stuff like evidence and statistics - I reserve the right to call out "Moyes Haters' for their choice to use emotion over evidence.

I'll be in the Spellow for my ticket the Saturday before the semi ;-)

*http://www.transferleague.co.uk/league-tables/2003-2011.html
Gavin Ramejkis
57 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:07:26
Kevin, interesting use of the black and white statement and that money doesn't count - Athletic Bilbao cost approximately £15m and spanked the shite out of Man U home and away, other teams have beaten the seemingly undefeatable Man U, Chelsea, Arsenal and RS on their own turf by teams that cost less than theirs. So fair play it isn't black and white but the tedium of ten years of shite against the so called greater teams cant be ten years of bad luck surely?
Kevin Sparke
58 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:12:17
Gavin - when was the last time Athletic Bilbao won the Spanish League?

Which two teams have won it more time than other?

How much money did they spend in comparison to Bilbao

Using you logic Blackburn Rovers should be Champions of Europe... as they turned Manchester United over at home.

Money counts in the long term - don't take my word for it - name me a team in the last 10 seasons that has finished in the top four in England that has spent less than the team who finished fifth...

I can think of one...

I'll give you a clue... Their name starts with an 'E'
James Martin
59 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:12:32
Gavin, a lot of people have been using the bilbao example and bemoaning why Everton aren't more like them. I remember watching David Unsworth's testimonial against them and to be hoenst I haven't heard them do anything from then until this season. They're 7th in La Liga, so what they had two good games against United, they obviously have their own annoying brand of inconsistency the same way that we can't beat big teams away from home otherwise they wouldn't be 7th in the league. Yes they've managed to assemble a really good team at this moment and for little money because all their players are from the basque area but this is the best team they've ha din ageas and could arguably be just down to a good generation. Ten years of not winning away at the top four involves a combination of bad luck and psychological issues, the latter of whcih is Moyes fault as we've had no problem winning away at Spurs or City in that time. Doesn't negate Kevin's argument about money though.

There's also the issue that we are largely victims of our own success. The old top four could often get complacent when 'lesser' teams visited them and could (Liverpool often did) slip up against them. It5 might only be once in a period of ten eyars but they've got that elusive away win on their sheet (despite a whole host of crap league finishes). When Everton come thoguh, they know they have to be at a certain standard to win the game because w're a standard above the bottom 13 teams in the league. Liverpool will always scrap extra for the draw that would usually be a loss against any other side. Some of the other sides in and aorund us like Villa, Spurs and Newcastle also have terrible records away at the old big four over the years. The big four are always up for these games.
Anthony Jones
60 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:21:52
Kevin, he is not suggesting that money doesnt' affect league position. He is stating whey many fans have before: Lack of funds does not excuse giving up or adopting an extreme ultra-defensive approach to vital games.
Gavin Ramejkis
61 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:22:56
Kevin, your argument was based upon money wins everything, in two broadcast games a cheaper side beat Man U hands down in a league dominated by sides who would also spank the so called demi gods of the epl, dont fall for the histrionics and myths that the cash flowing Man U, Arsenal, Chelsea, RS and Man Citys of this world are unbeatable

My logic didnt claim Blackburn or anyone else would be champion of Europe or anywhere else, try reading the post before you fill in the gaps with your own lines, a clear and clean statement, money doesn't always count by your reckoning it does as it has bought the league and other silverware for years, how do you explain those two games or any other defeats of the Sky darlings on their own turf down the years? Flukes? The Bilbao games weren't flukes, even old whiskey nose was man enough to admit it.
Ross Kerry
62 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:23:00
Money counts in the long term ? don't take my word for it... name me a team in the last 10 seasons that has finished in the top four in England that has spent less than the team who finished fifth...

I'm hoping this is us?

I can't get my head round this but if it is us then did we get a cup for it or something?
Jamie Crowley
63 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:30:02
Graham all the way back at 492, and Gavin at 577 -

spot on. That's it in a nutshell.

Had my own game Wednesday night. Friend of mine - born and bred Evertonian - and I sat at the bar post game just lamenting Tuesday's horror show. He's been very positive regarding Moyes, but was simply beside himself at the team selection, as was I.

We gave up in the tunnel - against Liverpool for the love of God.

Anything other than Graham's and Gavin's starting 11 and I'll be simply speechless - win, lose, or draw.

I'm simply in knots. I feel like I'm about to watch a train wreck - and I'm powerless to do anything about it.

Pray I'm wrong.
John Keating
64 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:36:19
Hopefully Moyes will revert to the starting 11 against Spurs.
But now that we are so much in awe of the mighty Sunderland will he then put out a weaker team for the 4 games we have until we meet Sunderland again in April ??
I'm not sure what match is more important than the other for the remainder of the season though I'll no doubt find out which is - according to Moyes - an hour or so before kick off.
Suspense is killing me !
Kevin Tully
65 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:29:37
Kev Sparke, please don't peddle the myth we would probably be relegated without Moyes.

Player wages have the most relevant correlation to where you finish in the P.L.

I can't be arsed looking for all the links, but they are there. I think we had around the 8th highest wage bill in the league, and are now around about 10th, since we off-loaded the likes of Arteta & Yakubu.

I agree Moyes is a good manager, but I also believe we could do better for £3m a year. Also, no pressure on the manager from the board is not always a good thing - look at our recent starts in the League.
Derek Thomas
66 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:08:25
Moyes Haters, tickets in the Spellow, bit emotional eh Kev, I know what I am, what are you?? pot or kettle.

What makes a Moyes hater? I think you're using a spraygun here to paint all who get angry at the fuckups as Moyes Haters/MOB.

We get angry and go off not because he does A or B rather the fact that he keeps on doing L,M,N,O,P. season after season and at the back of our minds is the fact ( yes fact not emotion ) that we pay out good money for shite and he gets paid extremely excellent money for serving it up, but lets be logical about it eh.

It's the school report thing... CAN DO BETTER.

We know he's not perfect, that we live in an Imperfect World, but the word it seems is we have to cut him some slack for this Imperfectness. All the while we perfect onlookers have to deny our own Imperfectness and assess him with Spock-like detatchment and unemotion as a result of our most emotional game of each season.
James Martin
67 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:39:19
Surely a better barometer to measure Moyes by is a breakdown of the number of points Moyes has gained home an away against the top four sides compared to other teams in the league. 3 points is 3 points whether it comes at home or away, in the name of consistency the total point haul is all that matters. Then your Blackburns who have one season of beating Man U away will be put into comparison with Moyes' Everton. I don't know what the results would be but if its antyhing like the rest of Moyes' results they'll probably be more consistent than most.
James Martin
68 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:44:48
Kevin, who assembled the squad to earn those wages? Just because we can afford (barely) to pay those wages is no safeguard against us going down. No can say either way that we would or woudln't have gone/ go down under Moyes, but its not improbable that a lesser manager could have coem in and failed during the tougher days of Moyes 10 year reign.
Kevin Sparke
69 Posted 16/03/2012 at 21:45:40
Kevin - we're 11th highest*

We pay high in comparison with other non top 4 Premier League clubs (top 6 including Spurs and City) but we tend to keep the players we've got for a bit longer than average.

Under Walter Smith our wage bill was higher as a percentage of turnover (in real terms - and as a comparative measure with top earners at other clubs).

And your point is... ?

Derek - 'Everton Supporter' suits me - ta very much.
Kevin Tully
70 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:03:20
My point is Kevin, that wages have a proven & direct affect on league finishing positions. So, when we had the 8th highest wage bill, I would expect us to finish around that position in the League. if you take a competent manager and apply those stat's, why would we be relegated under a different manager ? Especially when you are paying a £3m per season salary, the fifth highest in the League.

http://onfooty.com/2011/05/financial-breakdown-of-the-english-premier-league.html
Kevin Sparke
71 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:17:08
Anyway, it's obvious why Bilbao turned over Manchester United twice - seeds sown by Howard Kendall 25+ years ago..
Noel Lynam
72 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:12:10
Kevin @ 583,

"Person who espouses the view that Moyes is the worst thing to happen to Everton Football Club since Alan Ball was sold and will use any evidence; however tenuous to back up their pet theory; whilst disregarding any evidence to the contrary."

I can see where you are coming from with that definition of a "Moyes hater". I'd agree on the previso that by changing "worst" to "best" in the above that then constitutes a "Moyes lover". I've seen people on this site who could fall into those categories.
Simon Harris
73 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:25:08
Derek, or you could just call him a prick like some posters on another thread.

His stock's definitely dropped significantly since Tuesday, and obviously everyone's entitled to vent, but some of the shit flying around on here to anyone who doesn't agree he's the anti Christ is just childish.
Tommy Coleman
74 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:00:06
There are numerous examples were teams with less money have overcome bigger spenders; Barca v Real M, Birmingham Cty winning league cup, Athletic v Man U etc.

But one or two people just utterly refuse to accept any reasonable facts that condradict their undying devotion in their belief that Moyes is the best thing that Everton can get.
Kevin Sparke
75 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:20:23
But Kev - you have to take into your calculation the amount of money spent in transferring said players in the first place.

EG - we might just be able to pay Carlos Tevez 200K per month; but there's not a cat in hells chance we'd be able to afford to pay the 40 million plus to buy the fucker in the first place...

If my memory serves me right the most we've paid for a player if for Screech breaking the club transfer record... Arteta cost us next to nothing, as did Pienaar, Howard, Jagielka, Gibson...

We pay over the odds to keep them...

And where Flash Harry and Dalglish can afford to blow millions on turkeys - we can't! So when we do get a player who fits the way we play, we pay not quite top dollar but above the odds.

Surely that's a point in Moyes favour?

Nick Entwistle
76 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:12:27
Anyone who uses the word Haters to draw a simplified divide between a supposed two camps is talking valley girl drivel. It offers no discussion, just infantile distance from someone who has an opposing view. Shows probably an unhealthy interest in Justin Beiber too.
Kevin Tully
77 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:42:19
Kevin, I am not saying Moyes is not a good manager, I have always been consistent in my opinion of the man. He makes mistakes as we all do, but the likes of Tuesday negate his good points sometimes.

My point is, we won't be relegated if we get someone half-decent to replace him; this myth is for Bluekipper and the blind only.
Kevin Sparke
78 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:44:32
Justin Beiber is well fit you old hippy

Actually, once people stop using terms like 'lovers, apologists, Moyesites' etc to describe people who don't want to fully jump on the wagon to Salem re Moyes - I'll refrain from using 'haters'

Criticism is best wielded with a scalpel - not an axe.

And, I promise that my last word on this If the site wants to encourage debate and not hate wanks - it should discourage dichotomies and encourage the proliferation of differing viewpoints.

Pigeon holing people into 'for' or 'against' - 'lovers' or 'haters' is just going to leave no room for discussion.

So, in the spirit of Evertonian oneness - I apologise for calling the haters haters. It's been a shit week - lets hope tomorrow makes it a bit better.
Derek Thomas
79 Posted 16/03/2012 at 23:07:31
Kevin 557... I guess all you Moyes haters, you are doing the calling so that makes you 'pot'. If you, and then by definition me (we) are Everton Supporters, stop with the 'Moyes haters' to people who see Moyes's derby capitulation as a bit more than ... "we never get much there anyway"...

Simon 618. I never mentioned (unlike Kevin 557) any 'name'; I'm still wound up in the anger of what could have been and the fact that the man can do better, but manages with depressing regularity to do worse.
Tim Locke
80 Posted 16/03/2012 at 22:48:28
Kevin Sparke - 583 great post.
Simon Harris
81 Posted 16/03/2012 at 23:37:24
Derek, apologies if that's how it read, I wasn't implying you did, just that all this labelling of fans who disagree with someone is nonsense.

Kevin Sparkes's last post sums it up nicely.

Let's hope for a happier end to this week, tomorrow.
Ian Smitham
82 Posted 16/03/2012 at 23:10:19
Good debate, my feelings are to support Mr Sparke.

Couple of questions to all:

1) Where will you be at 12.30 GMT tomorrow?

2) At around 5 mins before kick off I imagine that around 35,000 paying supporters of the club will begin a rendition of the "We are on the march we are Moyes's army" Will you join in? And why?

Please answer both questions if you reply, easy enough. Not complicated, simply answer the questions. To help, my responses will be :

1) On the front row of Top Balcony
2) Yes

Keep it simple, please answer the questions only, if I may respectfully ask that.
Dean Adams
83 Posted 17/03/2012 at 00:12:02
Derek Thomas

Dont try the holier than thou crap. About a month ago you put me in a trio with Dodd and Wilson for not wanting to call Kenright and Moyes all the names under the sun. You are no more than a school yard bully. Just because people dont agree with your extremist crap.
Ciarán McGlone
84 Posted 17/03/2012 at 00:35:30
I guess the choice of appropriate instrument used to 'wield' criticism depends on the size of the fuck-up.
Mark Wilson
85 Posted 17/03/2012 at 00:43:53
Tim way way back at 457 and a cery few others !
I genuinely can't believe that you thought the team Moyes put out on Tuesday was a good team ? At least in comparison to what it might have been? It's days later and I'm STILL besides myself after watching that shameful mess and feel even worse reading Moyes' "explanation" in the pre cup tie presser. We were humiliated thanks to a managerial cock up the likes of which I've never seen before in a derby game or much else if I'm honest. So does this mean I'm a Moyes hater ? Guess what, it doesn't. The guy has been here for ten years. He's done better than ok and yes lack of money IS a factor but even if we had it the very best would still be going to Man Utd or Chelsea and probably even the RS before us.
Moyes has been awarded iconic status by the media because our club has clearly punched way above its weight for most of the ten years he's been around. True, a trophy has eluded us, but then that's the same for most in and around the Premiership over the last decade. The carling cup HAS produced the odd surprise, like Birmingham, who then show how well that went by getting relegated. But the reality is only four clubs win things in our league and that's it. So Moyes has done really well on pathetic funding to give us some good moments. Hating him is daft. But this year I've hated his tactics, his ultra cautious approach and overall a standard of football that even the man himself says he wouldn't like to have to watch ! Then he and the players, with a small boost from the transfer window, started to turn it all around. But Tuesday has in my view forever damaged Moyes in the eyes of thousands of bluenoses, whatever the cup run brings. Why ? Because we will NOT win the cup because we threw a game against the RS. Tuesday didn't need to happen. Moyes knows it. He knows he made three more changes than was ever going to work. He may argue not so in press conferences etc but my gut tells me he knows he should have "rested" no more than the pensioners he seems to think would have collapsed at (unusually) having to play three games in a week.

I will praise him if he gets it right tomorrow and we win. There's nothing strange in that despite what I've said. This game isn't about ten years of history it's about the NOW and the next ten weeks or so. That's football. But I will say this, thousands of Evertonians believe their manager made the biggest team selection error they have EVER seen against the RS and will never forget how they felt at the result and more so, how unnecessary it all was.

We need a win tomorrow far more than we needed it seven days ago.
Cheers, Mark (Rusty Man)
Derek Thomas
86 Posted 17/03/2012 at 01:01:07
Dean 639; check again matey, especially on this thread, spot one name I've called Moyes, plenty of adjectives about how I feel. I did mention pot and kettle to Kevin about him getting all emotional about my/our emotion at the manner of the failure with his Moyes hater tag but I see that as a nil-nil noscore draw.

I HATE some of Moyeses playing methods. I may have dabbled in dour and defensive the odd time, but never coward, twat, cunt etc

I don't hate sinners, I hate the sin.

So right back at ya with High Horse. If you think I'm a bully then you must roll over for a balloon on a stick.

Ian Smitham: a very black (blue or white question, obviously no shades of grey whatever (or blue of a different hue) in your world. Even if you don't realise it, I pick up a vague hint of... you're not a proper Evertonian if you don't do, think and act exactly like me...and as Kevin said earlier Evertonian will do for him and by association me and you.

We all, you, me, Kevin, Marshy, Doddy, uncle Martin Mason and all have our own personal highways to hell/ trueblue nirvana/redemption.

Whatever Saturdays result it will change everybodies perception of Tuesdays events.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads