Fellaini being groomed for 'Cahill role'?

, 30 May, 31comments  |  Jump to most recent

Marouane Fellaini could become the first-choice starter in the "hole" behind Nikica Jelavic as David Moyes looks for Tim Cahill's successor in that position.

Cahill has made the "hole" behind the lone striker his own for almost all of his eight years at Goodison Park but at 32, the Australian's effectiveness as a regular starter has started to diminish and Moyes is planning for that new reality.

Though Fellaini cemented his reputation as one of the most impressive midfielders in the Premier League in a more defensive role, Moyes had great success in the latter part of this season pushing the Belgian into more advanced areas.

It was a move that coincided with an increase in goals, not just for Fellaini but for the team as a whole and that may prompt Moyes to deploy the Belgian in the hole routinely next season.

"Marouane is probably seen as more of a defensive midfield player," Moyes says on the official site, "but he's far better when he's joining in and getting forward because he can do a bit of everything.

"I've always known that Marouane can do [the Cahill] job. We had just been looking at the right time to do that.

"It's difficult to put him into any one box," Moyes continued. "He's got a goal in him, he does get forward and causes problems, but he's also very good at breaking the game up and doing other things. He's quite good at both jobs."

It's that versatility that makes Fellaini so valuable to an Everton side that is short on depth and Moyes has been highly encouraged with Fellaini's development in his time at Goodison.

"Young players mature. The decisions you make as a young player are sometimes different than when you get a bit older.

"His form has been good. He's been getting us a couple of goals in recent games, and long may that continue."

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (31)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


James Flynn
1 Posted 30/05/2012 at 18:29:13
Fella!! Love him. Gets better every year. Can't see any controversy in him taking Tim's spot. He shifted forward so easily once Gibson and Jela arrived.
James Stewart
2 Posted 30/05/2012 at 18:35:47
I think we need to bring someone in if he is gonna be mainly playing off Jelavic. Fernandes/Gibson would be my ideal partnership. Plus he's on a free.
David Chait
3 Posted 30/05/2012 at 18:38:37
I feel only Yaya Toure comes close to Fella as a defensive midfielder in the EPL. So I do think this is his best position next to Gibson. If we could get a Hoillet or preferably someone in the league of Moutinho then I would rather him stay there. But offer me Fernandes I would be more than happy he shift forward.

Thing is to fit Rowell in Fella must move forward... And I would rather have them than keep Cahill in the hole. There are a few options for Moyes though once you include Barkley and Baxter. But if they decide to move Fekka forward we can't hope to see to much of those 2 this year.

Aidy Dews
4 Posted 30/05/2012 at 19:00:41
So if Felli is going to get pushed forward next season more often than not then for me we need to find a midfielder to come in and play alongside Gibbo!

Two things I'm not keen on seeing is Cahill pushed deeper and swapped with Fellaini or Rodwell in there. Both when deep in midfield play crab like football and that's no good. Gibbo will be the screen infront of the back four and were going to need someone with energy to go box to box and someone who can pick a pass and get things ticking over and get the likes of Felli involved further forward.

Now I wouldn't mind seeing either of Diame or Fernandes in there tbh, and there both free! Diame is more of an energetic, box-to-box type player and would be the legs in midfield to support Gibson and would do a good job IMO. Fernandes would be the midfielder that links the play from defence to attack and would add creativity and I wouldn't mind him either and if I had to choose I'd probs go with Fernandes but either would be a good signing for nothing!

Kevin Sparke
5 Posted 30/05/2012 at 19:57:43
If you look at Jelavic's goals scored last season for Everton; Fellaini has a big part to play in over half of them (There was an excellent You Tube link to them all that Lyndon put up)

I think the lad is first class; and after a shaky start to his Premier League career is now firmly established as a top performer - as a defensive midfielder he's very good, but give him a bit of space and a roving commission - he's superb. The strength and not flashy but effective play of Gibson allows him much more freedom and it's no coincidence that our attacking play is much improved since Fellaini was allowed to get forward more often.

I'm just hoping Moyes can keep hold of him - because people (Chelsea, Spurs, Manchester United) are beginning to notice just how good he actually is.

However, (two howevers) he still has flaws. Firstly, he quite often snatches at chances in front of goal and doesn't have the cool head of a prolific goal scorer... secondly, his awkward style and size leads him to be penalised much more often than is really merited - refs talk - and I've a feeling Fellaini has become a marked man as a niggling 'foot in' type footballer.

Let's hope he's still with us next season - let's hope they all are.

CiarĂ¡n McGlone
6 Posted 30/05/2012 at 20:47:54
For me Fellaini didn't play the Cahill role at all during his good spell at the end of the season. He was box to box. Allowed to get forward more than if he'd Benn playing as the holding player... but he certainly wasn't playing the Cahill role.

I would say that's a position for Barkley.

James Morgan
7 Posted 30/05/2012 at 21:09:49
Kevin, I agree. I like Felli as a box-to-box midfielder, I don't think he should just sit deep and protect the back four, he's got more to him than that.

I'm actually quite interested to see how the young Portuguese kid Francisco plays, sounds like he has a bit of class about him.

Anyway, we should see how the big man plays against England on Saturday. Would love to see him bend Gerrard!
James Martin
8 Posted 30/05/2012 at 21:17:19
How sad that the top teams all have number tens in the mould of Juan Mata, David Silva, Wayne Rooney, Messi, Ozil, Sneijder, Van der Vaart... and who do we have playing there? Fellaini. Can everyone not see the difference between these players? All of the above are fast, agile and have a goal threat. Fellaini has none of this apart from aerial prowess.

Our goal scoring in the second half of the season improved because of Pienaar and Jelavic. Against the top teams we will have to resort to going long to Fellani's head because he does not have the pace to play on the break and we will not be able to manouvre him into the box to barge over defenders like he did against Swansea.

In what way is playing him in this position conducive to the attacking football that everyone wants to see? I'd argue that our improvement with him upfront is due to his vacation from the central midfield, to be replaced by players who actually got the ball forward with purpose and tempo to Pienaar, Jelavic and Osman.
Ian Bennett
9 Posted 30/05/2012 at 21:28:24
Harsh James.

I find myself agreeing with most of your posts but not this one. The united game showed that he brought it down on his chest and played it.

Yes, he is not the quickest, but he can play far better than you give credit. If you are looking for that type of player - look to pienaar if we sign him.

Robbie Muldoon
10 Posted 30/05/2012 at 21:38:55
No, no, no, no. Fellaini is awesome as a defensive mid, THAT'S HIS POSITION. Moyes has already been swapping Cahill and Fellaini, no more evidently than in the semi. It doesn't work.
Mike Gaynes
11 Posted 30/05/2012 at 21:53:56
Fellaini is the best defensive midfielder in the Prem and, based on his ballwinning statistics, one of the best in the world. (Yaya Toure is really an attacking mid, not a ballwinner.) So moving him forward is odd at first glance. But the fact is that a good supporting attacker is much harder to find than a replacement defensive mid. If Rodwell is healthy, this is his chance... and with Gibbo and Fellaini in front of him, Rodwell will have maximum opportunity to get forward instead of hanging in front of the back four.

Fellaini is clearly the best alternative Moyes has right now for the "hole"... if Hoilet or somebody truly creative can be signed, terrific, but if no attacking options are added this summer, this move makes sense.

Paul Mackie
12 Posted 30/05/2012 at 22:00:13
Robbie, it didn't work in the semi because he just swapped him with Cahill. Fellaini is actually pretty good in the "Cahill role" as long as Cahill isn't in the team. He's a fantastic passer of the ball and I can see him providing many, many assists for Jelavic next season.
Robbie Muldoon
13 Posted 30/05/2012 at 22:10:40
Fair point Paul, Cahill should never be put in that position. How come we know this but our super manager doesn't? Anybody else gutted Rodgers has gone to the Red Shite?
Tony Twist
14 Posted 30/05/2012 at 23:10:57
We need less jack of all trades players, fellaini needs to play in his strongest position which IMO isn't just behind the one and only striker. In the perfect world it would be Dempsey or a make do if he fully recovers Naismith of Rangers. I think Fernandes would be perfect for us, he can certainly find the unexpected forward pass that we are desparate for. I would also be nice to have someone who is quick on the break but god knows who!
Ryan Holroyd
15 Posted 30/05/2012 at 23:14:54
The lad can play anywhere and gave Ferdinand absolute shit v United.

We played Newcastle off the pitch again with Fellaini up front, Sunderland we scored 4 with Fellaini up front.
James Flynn
16 Posted 30/05/2012 at 23:25:06
James (475) - "In what way is playing him in this position conducive to the attacking football that everyone wants to see"? Um, he was in the mix of our goal-scoring improvement? What didn't you see?

Rooney and Messi excepted, I see Fella as an impact player the equal of the others you named. You know, once he was surrounded by really good players like the others are.

Mata, Silva, Ozil, Sneijder, and Van der Vaart? Do you watch every game they play or did you list them because of watching highlights on TV? Fine players all, but like me you only watched Fella play game in and out. How do you know they're all better? Because their teams get on the Telly more, right?

Fella's 24 years old, he's special, and he's ours.

Paul David
17 Posted 31/05/2012 at 00:01:37
Why is Moyes talking like Fellaini's place in the team is either deep or off the striker? Why cant he do both as a box-to-box midfielder which I think he is best at?

I will be very disappointed if Fellaini is deployed off the striker for most of the season. He is simply not clever or creative enough to do it long term. It will be typical Moyes though to value physical presence over technical ability.

CiarĂ¡n McGlone
18 Posted 31/05/2012 at 08:48:23
James,

The only thing you prove by stating that Fellaini is the equal of those players is that you don't watch much of other teams' football.

Fellaini is a good Premier League midfielder... at this stage, he is nothing more.

Stephen Kenny
19 Posted 31/05/2012 at 11:08:43
There is a way we can play that allows us to utilise both sides of Fellaini's game.

He is clearly capable going forward but he is also capable of dominating a midfield with his physicality, Aerial ability and ground he can cover.

For me we now need to move the whole team forward 10 yards and start pressing high up the pitch and harrying teams out of possession in their own half. A tactic Barca use to great effect. With Pienaar in our side and the others likely to play, a high energy game shouldn't be a problem.

Having Fellaini also allows us to play Gibson and Rodwell who both cover ground well and in Gibsons case, gets his tackles in early.

There is so much potential for us to improve on last season with even just the one signing.

Gareth Fieldstead
20 Posted 31/05/2012 at 11:27:55
Totally off the subject but the obscene amount being touted for the imminent bid for Rooney from PSG got me wondering, does anyone have any idea if we have a sell on clause with Utd? Please let it be so.
James Martin
21 Posted 31/05/2012 at 11:23:01
James (499)

How is Fellaini in any way the equal to these players? Mata and Silva are at the top of the Premier League assists chart. I don't watch Messi every week but I still know he's better than Fellaini, the same way I know all those players are better in that position than Fellaini, I don't need to watch them every week.

Obviously all their managers think they're better as well because they went out and bought these players rather than Fellaini. All these players have pace, guile, flair, shooting ability and dead ball ability. Fellaini does not have these qualities, however much people blindly love him.

In that position he is good for winning flick-ons, causing trouble in the box and holding the ball up, these are all qualities that lend themselves to the long-ball game. I know everyone wants to have a truly world class player at Goodison but world class players can run fast, can shoot, and can beat men. They're not heralded for being able to bring down high balls on their chest well or passing sideways.

I'd bet the majority of Evertonians would swap Fellaini for any player on that list (perhaps Rooney aside due to his previous), and I'd also bet that any of the fans of those clubs would not swap their star number tens for Fellaini.
Tom Owen
22 Posted 31/05/2012 at 11:23:21
He's had great impact coming into the 'Cahill' role in the second half of games, like Swansea and Sunderland away. But for me, he's better in the midfield. He breaks up play so well, and makes the simple pass. He's the clear boss when he's in that midfield.
Lee Preston
23 Posted 31/05/2012 at 11:25:17
To be honest, people can say what they want about this, but the fact is, Felli was immense in the advanced role just off Jelavic.

The short sightedness of some people on here is bewildering, sighting that Fellaini only offers an aerial threat? Yet, he prefers to chest the ball down and play, rather than head it. I think this is simpy because he is tall people jump to these conclusions.

The other point is that people are saying we'd need to sign another midfielder if we moved Felli forward, but this just gives license for Moyes to play Neville there, or as happened quite a bit toward the end of the season Cahill. My personal opinion is we played some of our better attacking football with Fellaini in this role.

Paul David
24 Posted 31/05/2012 at 12:21:10
Lee

I dont think Fellaini is the best in the air and does prefer to bring the ball down on his chest which he is excellent at but theres still no doubt in my mind that the majority of chances created by Fellaini will be made by his physical presence.

Number 10's should be able to beat a man before feeding in the striker or shooting himself,something I cant imagine Fellaini being able to do often.More like holding the ball up then laying off a simple pass.

Your plan of then putting Neville or Cahill in Fellaini's old position is laughable.

Robbie Muldoon
25 Posted 31/05/2012 at 12:37:16
Lee Preston are you fucking insane!? You want to include Neville in midfield? You are happy to play Cahill in Felli's position!? Both are poor midfielders, albeit great motivators and leaders.

I respect diverse opinions and all that, but some have got to be wrong... surely Lee you are wrong on this mate!

Lee Preston
26 Posted 31/05/2012 at 12:47:00
At what point did I say I wanted to play Neville or Cahill there? I merely said playing Felli up further forward would free up the space for Moyes to play Neville, which will likely happen.

Putting words in my mouth.

For the record, I wouldn't play either there, I'd play Rodwell, but we all know it will be Neville there.

Andrew Ellams
27 Posted 31/05/2012 at 12:44:53
Gareth I wouldn't worry about the Rooney sell on clause because it ain't gonna happen
Tom Bowers
28 Posted 31/05/2012 at 12:46:14
Fellaini's play improved in the second half of the season as did a few others. He is still maturing though and needs to bring a little more discipline to his game and I am not talking about his tackling which has improved.

His form certainly helped Jelavic but he is better as a free range midfielder. He cannot shoot very well so I would prefer he stays deeper. Gibson has the better shot but niether can be considered as a forward to partner Jelavic. I still think we need to bring in someone with experience and speed for that position.
Thomas Windsor
29 Posted 31/05/2012 at 13:29:26
Cahill should be moved on, we have had good service off him, and so should a few others: Osman, Neville, Anichibe...

Regarding playing Fellaini in the Cahill role, I would leave him in central midfield myself and try and buy a good forward to play with Jelavic. I hope we can get Pienaar and keep all the other players as well.

I miss Goodison already... roll on the pre-season games ? I hope we have some in Europe this summer.
Denis Richardson
30 Posted 01/06/2012 at 11:05:10
I have to disagree with most of the posts. For me his best position is a central or defensive midfielder and not a number 10. This is just Moyes trying to fit another densive player into a forward role. We need someone creative with quick feet and a bit of pace in that role - something we have never had, even when Cahill was no top form.

I wish we could just have an attack minded player playing in a forward role next to our striker for once, not one striker with a midfielfer defending from the front behind him. The goals at the end of the season came from having two attack minded players joining us in Jan (pienaar and jelly) and not moving Fellaini into a number 10 role. He's played that role before Jelly and Pienaar came without success.

When the going gets tough,having him in a forward role will just lead to us playing the old Wimbledon way.

Derek Williams
31 Posted 01/06/2012 at 11:51:13
Fella and Gibson in centre-mid from January was the reason why we started winning matches again and why we stopped leaking (too many) easy goals. Having Jela banging them in the other end helped a bit too.

Keep Fella where he works best and let's find a number 10. Saying that Fella is being groomed for the hole just says to me that we're not spending a fucking penny again this summer.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads