Hilarious pundits

 Comments (66) jump to end

If any proof were needed that the so-called football pundits talk through their hats, this absurd article is it. The pundit in question is Garth Crooks and the article is last week's "Team of the Week" from the BBC website. The goalkeeper of the week was ... believe it or not ..... Tim Howard!

"If ever there was a goalkeeping performance that kept a team in with a chance, then this was it. All the headlines will go to match-winner Nikica Jelavic but had it not been for Tim Howard who produced a string of fine saves, including one from Clint Dempsey, the outcome would almost certainly have been different. Instead, Howard's performance was the catalyst to an amazing turnaround."

Now, Tim Howard did produce some decent saves (none really out of this world), but he was beaten twice (one hit the cross bar), and the modest man that he is, would be embarrassed to claim that he "was the catalyst for the amazing turnaround".

Keep those gems coming, Garth. It would be nice if you actually sat through one of Everton's matches.


Ajay Gopal, Bangalore, India     Posted 11/12/2012 at 17:21:17

back Return to Talking Points index  :  Add your Comments back

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dave Lynch
604 Posted 11/12/2012 at 21:47:48
By far the biggest knobhead is the tool that fronts the Anfield rap on CityTalk. He is a total twat who talks the most utter shite ever. His latest being that this is a very poor league and the reason for this is the Man Utd only ever top the league when it's poor.
Andy Crooks
607 Posted 11/12/2012 at 22:06:41
Ajay, Garth is just one of the utterly inane pundits who earn big money by sitting on the fence. Does anyone recall the days when Malcolm Allison and Brian Clough actually offended people. When Allison said that Alan Mullery wasn't good enough for England. When pundits actually said something interesting?
Edward Simpson
623 Posted 11/12/2012 at 22:52:29
Andy — I'm far to young to know anyone you've just mentioned (except Clough of course.)

But Crooks is one of the worst pundits on the BBC, and as much as we can praise Howard for putting some good saves in at the weekend he clearly didn't watch the game as Pienaar would be in that team.
Kenny Jones
624 Posted 11/12/2012 at 22:54:28
The pompous windbag's self-important droning bores the life out of me.

He's Diazepam on short, fat little legs.

Ciarán McGlone
625 Posted 11/12/2012 at 23:01:12
Crooks really winds me up with his faux intensity.. the man's a fuckin halfwit..

He was once doing a run down of our pre-match team and he said our big problem was that we would be missing Thomas Gravesen who had been our top player in recent games.. it was after Gravesen had come back from Celtic, and he hadn't played for us in about a year...

Fuckin shambles of a man..

Nick Entwistle
626 Posted 11/12/2012 at 23:08:45
Lawrenson and Shearer on the same sofa. How did that ever come to pass?

As for offending pundits, Hansen lost the BBC their England rights because he laid into them big time during a live broadcast. ITV magically were gifted rights from then on. And the Amazing Townsend got even more screen time. And don't get me started on Southgate!

Thankfully Savage is kept to the radio.

Drew O'Neall
627 Posted 11/12/2012 at 23:17:01
Was it just me or did Michael Owen answer "Liverpool" when asked who he thought would finish fourth, on MotD 2 on Sunday?

Don't mind Garth Crooks, yes he's clearly unstable in the same way Chris Eubanks or Roy Keane is but he's no Andy Townsend... Now that guy is a five-star chopper.

James Flynn
632 Posted 11/12/2012 at 23:51:37
Was reading an article on Sabotage Times and the writer refering to the MotD team as a "Cabal of Wundercunts".

Laughed out loud at it, but sad hearing TV coverage over there reduced to what we Americans having been suffering for years.

On the other hand, you get to watch HBO fights without suffering the Heavyweight Champion of ruining watching; Jim Lampley.

David Hallwood
636 Posted 12/12/2012 at 00:40:28
So Garth Crooks recons that Howard kept us in the game against Spurs. Just remind me who did Crooks play for? Ah yes... Spurs!! Why do people get so wound up at blatantly one-sided match reports; ask yourself how would your Everton reports read?
Jim Knightley
638 Posted 12/12/2012 at 00:53:41
Crooks is an idiot (a tad harsh, but I think it is easily authenticated). He consistently disagrees with any sensible suggestions, over-exaggerates absolute everything, and his teams of the week are beyond hilarious. Seriously, if anyone wants a laugh, check out Crook's team of the week...he will always pick goal-scorers, irrespective of their general level of performance.
David Barks
645 Posted 12/12/2012 at 03:19:13
People come on here and bitch that pundits never give Everton players enough credit. Then one gives one of our players credit we bitch about that. No wonder football owners don't take supporters seriously.
David Ellis
646 Posted 12/12/2012 at 04:20:00
I'll never forget Garth Crook's admirable composure back in the late 80s when he was on a panel with England World Cup hero Geoff Hurst (for younger viewers, the guy who scored a hat-trick in the '66 World Cup final).

Geoff managed to use the phrase "Player X (who was white), well yes... he's the nigger in the woodpile isn't he?" Camera then pans to the impassive Crooks who responds. "Let's talk about Player Y...."

Again for younger viewers the word "nigger" is banned from all public use since at least the late 1960s as being about as racially offensive as you can get. But the phrase "nigger in the woodpile" was a legitimate metaphor (i.e. someone who causes unexpected trouble) up until that time. But by 1989 this was seriously not cool. And now would lead to a lifetime ban despite it obviously not meant to be a racial slur against any individual.

There was no fuss about it at all at the time. Hurst is still a national hero.

Anto Byrne
649 Posted 12/12/2012 at 06:22:11
I think it was a certain Mike Bernard that took Garth out in a home game against Stoke in the late 1970s.

I remember that game as he was showered with bananas and ape-like grunts until Mike put him on a stretcher and he was carried off. It was a particularly sad day for football at Goodison that day as he was among the very few black footballers at the time and racist chants were the norm. How times have changed in the last 30 odd years? He was a good player, quick and an eye for goal.

I thought Howard did have a good game and made some good stops and looked a bit more confident. A few clean sheets will do him no harm.
James Morgan
652 Posted 12/12/2012 at 07:06:32
Garth Crooks is an absolute dickbag. End of.
Derek Thomas
654 Posted 12/12/2012 at 07:21:36
He might've had admirable composure in the 80s but now he's as doolallie as Tommy "the auld oinion bag" Smythe.

His Gravesen comment was probably a result of poor research. The then Sky 4 no doubt had their own 'script writers' but the other 16 were all compiled by the tea lady in between lunch and afternoon tea.

Matt Traynor
660 Posted 12/12/2012 at 08:55:13
Ajay, I think in the current climate you need to be very careful in how you describe certain members of the football fraternity, lest you be accused of prejudice. I mean, I'm sure you've nothing against midget hunchbacks, but you can't be too careful...

Yes, he does talk shite. He is funny though as he does it in a way that makes his points seem so well thought out, so considered.

Simon Atkins
662 Posted 12/12/2012 at 09:07:44
Crooks = halfwit. Nothing more to add
Andy Crooks
665 Posted 12/12/2012 at 09:28:59
Would everyone please use Garth Crooks's full name. I find this thread a bit disturbing...
James Martin
666 Posted 12/12/2012 at 09:48:42
Garth Crooks is autmoatically better than the majority of pundits purely because he didn't play for Liverpool. They are just everywhere. Hansen and Lawro on Motd. Jim Beglin on ITV. John Barnes formerly on channel 5. Phil Thompson on Sky Sports. Jamie Redknapp absolutely everywhere. So annoying listening to them droning on and on with their inherent arrogance and their inability to contain their glee when Everton mess up.
Steven Telford
669 Posted 12/12/2012 at 10:03:33
I reckon Alan Hansen is not bad, and actually he is often pretty complimentary towards Everton.
Trevor Thompson
671 Posted 12/12/2012 at 10:34:43
Hansen is not bad. I find him quite unbiased, to be fair. I don't like Lawerenson. Smug git! Garth Crooks is a pseudo-intelligent prat.
Trevor Lynes
672 Posted 12/12/2012 at 10:35:08
Everton this season are getting plenty of praise for their entertaining football and spirit. This is basically from virtually every pundit including ex-Liverpool and Man Utd players. Gary Neville appears to make the most sensible remarks and I have no problems with Hansen either.

Unfortunately our play in previous seasons tended to be dour and unentertaining. We were possibly one of the worst teams in the league to watch. This season has been a revelation and we are playing our best football for years. Entertainment value has rocketed and we score goals from open play which we hardly ever did in past seasons.

I just hope that our board recognise the improvement and invest in the team squad to enable DM to build on the improvement in fiuture. The biggest indictment of Everton in my view, is that in past seasons when we have won trophies and titles we have broken up our successful sides and lapsed into also-rans.

Shankly paved the way for Liverpool's conveyor belt of success by keeping his team of winners intact and adding to it. That's what we could and should have done, but our board/s have tended towards business decisions rather than footballing ones.

I just do not believe a lot of the poverty twaddle; we consistently finish high in the league, have better gates than most, and now we have unloaded our top earners, yet STILL it's a case of small investment and hoping for the best!

DM has continually been asked to turn pigs' ears into silk purses and now he should be encouraged to bring our great club the success the fans deserve.

Paul Mackie
673 Posted 12/12/2012 at 10:37:53
Lineker and Hansen are the only decent people at the BBC in my opinion. Hansen has become a bit of a parody of himself but he's the least biased.

Lineker incidentally is actually pretty funny on Twitter and often has good things to say about Everton. Someone asked him the other day what the best side he ever played in and he answered "Everton, without a doubt".

Tony Waring
676 Posted 12/12/2012 at 11:13:39
Actually IMHO one of the best pundits on TV is Gary Neville. For an ex Man Utd player I find him refreshingly impartial and he never fails to give credit where it's due and when you think of some of the things he used to say during his playing days, that's really quite a transformation.
Andy Meighan
678 Posted 12/12/2012 at 11:19:25
Can't remember Howard having a shot to save. Spurs were ordinary. But then what do you expect from Crooks? — a Grade A Bellend if ever there was one.

But the worst of the lot has got to be Pinocchio — one false bitter bastard. The amount of times Merson has wound him up on Soccer Saturday is unbelievable. And the gobshite falls for it every time. One thing baffles me though, it's the amount of ex Red Shite players on these panels now.
Tony J Williams
683 Posted 12/12/2012 at 12:25:03
Crooks is a fuckwit whose team of the week starts with him trying to shoe horn any half decent performing spuds player in.

Also, this is the scrote who tried to justify Adebeyor's winding up of the Aresnal fans by running the full length of the pitch to slide in front of them......he's a bellend. I have nothing more to say....

Steven Telford
688 Posted 12/12/2012 at 12:37:33
Gary Neville ........... no, no. no Tony, are you having a laugh?
Linker is good now, although took some time to settle as at first he was terrible.

I think Leonardo (Brazilian ex-Milan and ex-PSG coach) gives very good Analysis. He only appears now and again. Seedorf gives very good analysis too.

Guy Wilkinson
693 Posted 12/12/2012 at 13:21:25
Lineker is fucking dross, he is seen as the inoffensive magnolia silk paint everyman but he's a useless dimwitted media whore. Joey Barton shut the fucker up on twitter when he threatened to rattle the skeletons in Lineker's closet. Lineker puts no challenge on Lawrenson's smart arsed assertions and has gargled the spunk of Chiles in a dickheaded race to the bottom.

Crooks is a equality box ticking exercise for the BBC.

Gary Neville is superb. David "roll slow homey" Pleat is the best tactical analyst, James Richardson the most interesting anchorman. Hansen is unbiased and accurate.

James Martin
695 Posted 12/12/2012 at 13:38:12
To be honest its often embarassing watching our pundits at the World Cup or Euros. They're often sat next to a foreign ex-player or manager who not only knows a whole lot more about the game, but can articulate it in English better than the English pundit can.

According to most English pundits, the key to winning any international game is to 'play at our tempo, let's turn this into a Premier League match or cup tie' — absolutely no tactical analysis whatsoever.
Guy Rogers
696 Posted 12/12/2012 at 13:40:06
I had to listen to a Liverpool fan bleating about how Hansen had come out publicly and criticised Rodgers for letting Carroll go to the Hammers... er, excuse me that's his job!

Maybe Hansen is unbiased and accurate...
Guy Rogers
697 Posted 12/12/2012 at 13:44:13
Tony Cottee is the absolute nuts — only overshadowed by the Sharpe!
Guy Rogers
698 Posted 12/12/2012 at 13:45:50
I saw the old Don Hutchinson crop up the other day... he doesn't half look like a diamond geezer but probably needs to think about a quick wash of 'Just for Men'!
Conor Skelly
700 Posted 12/12/2012 at 13:40:10
Guy Wilkinson, take a bow son!

"Lineker puts no challenge on Lawrenson's smart arsed assertions and has gargled the spunk of Chiles in a dickheaded race to the bottom".

"David "roll slow homey" Pleat".

I must admit I find Pleat very articulate in his co commentary and Gary Neville still has great enthusiasm for the game which seems to come through. Same can't be said for Hansen who to my mind seems totally disillusioned with football and just goes through the motions.

Best commentators are Tyler and Tylsley who are both like poets.

But the best panel for entertainment by far are the RTE panel over here in Ireland with Johnny Giles, Liam Brady & Eamon Dunphy. These lads hold no punches and call it exactly how it is with none of the shackles that the British channels like Sky, BBC or ITV might be put under.

My favorite anchor is Adrian Chiles.

Mike Allison
707 Posted 12/12/2012 at 14:21:32
I'll do it then...

"People come on here and bitch that pundits never give Everton players enough credit. Then one gives one of our players credit we bitch about that. No wonder football owners don't take supporters seriously."

David, praising the goalkeeper for keeping the team in the game directly implies that the rest of the team were outplayed by the opponents, and is thus a criticism of them. That wasn't true in Sunday's game, Everton in fact having more shots on target according to Crooks's employer, the BBC.

I think everyone else figured that out, hence the unhappiness.

Mike Hughes
708 Posted 12/12/2012 at 14:18:24
Believe it or not, I've warmed a bit to Garth Crooks as he seems to have some respect for EFC. I agree his Tim Howard comments are way off-the-mark and that he is self-important and loquacious (to be polite about it). But there's a lot worse than Garth Crooks.

I'm personally offended by every ex-RS who appears smugly sitting on a BBC sofa and getting a fee from me, the license payer.

Then there's Lineker – personality of the year... I think not.

On the radio, Alan Green makes Garth Crooks appear modest. The man is so far up his own fat arse-hole, you can't see his ears.

Then there's Robbie Savage who makes Alan Green appear modest. Another one so far up himself he can probably lick his own bollocks. A 100% gold-gilted twat.

All of this is on the BBC national radio.

On local, we have Jimmy Shithouse Case, the most bigoted, thick gobshite who ever walked the planet. Famous for the catchphrase "...er, and that type of thing" when he can't think of anything relevant to say – which is often.

Mind you, the BBC does have one thing going for it – it's not Talk Sport.

Money for old rope.

Norman Merrill
711 Posted 12/12/2012 at 14:30:04
Conor, and you know the home of anchors?

The deeper the better...
Trevor Thompson
713 Posted 12/12/2012 at 14:37:20
I used to love Motty. He made football, especially FA Cup games, seem so exciting. He went downhill years ago, unfortunately. Tylsey is his modern day equivalent in my opinion.
John Ford
714 Posted 12/12/2012 at 14:35:42
I watch televised football with the sound off, including highlights and match of the day. The 'expert commentators,' usually ex footballers are every bit as predictable, dull and miss as the pundits.

Having seen a game in silence and to then hear or read the views of experts highlights how pointless they are. Why would anyone assume that an ex player is going to be astute enough to make a worthwhile assessment of a game. and then articulate it in a way that interests the viewer/listener. It's just banal.

For what its worth the one bloke ive heard in recent years who's probably worth listening to is Gordon Strachan.

..... I did turn the volume up recently on MOTD when our very own Mr Neville was on, complete with obligatory fitted casual/smart shirt. His punditry is very much akin to his playing style.

John Ford
716 Posted 12/12/2012 at 14:51:09
Trevor, Motty reminds me of another bloke worthy of our great game - Barry Davies. He only spoke when it was needed. No bullshit.

Actually another from that era, on radio, was Peter Jones. He was outstanding. I was a skint teenage dad in the 80s and couldnt get to the game much (well, this was Birkenhead!) Again he avoided irrelevant bulshit but he could make a throw in sound like it would change the course of a game. His commentary was the soundtrack to the blues golden period.

Conor Skelly
722 Posted 12/12/2012 at 15:30:46
Sorry Norman you've lost me there mate
James Bernard
724 Posted 12/12/2012 at 15:34:56
Does anyone else think he looks a bit like Yoda? As far as his punditry is concerned, absolutely clueless!
Chris Hockenhull
726 Posted 12/12/2012 at 15:42:58
If there was a man who annoyed me most in the late 60's/70's it was none other than Granada's finest Gerald Sindstat. He could annoy me from a mile away...so pro City it was no suprise when he was featured in the TV Times one XMas in a piece about how he stays 'on the fence' re his reporting of games and there is the brazen beast wearing City hat & scarf!!!. Never gave Everton any credit and thankfully went from Granada thus giving me a break on Friday nights and our Sunday highlights...but just when it was safe it seemed he crops back up again on BBC. I thought he was the poorest commentator full stop. Wanker. And this came to be proved in the late 90's when there was a fire in a gay porn cinema in SoHo. The brigade arrives and gets everyone out into the street to safety from the smoke and ooh...look who was pulled out amongst the chaps..??/none other than our wonderful Gerald!!
Steve Brown
730 Posted 12/12/2012 at 15:59:56
The worst has to be Steve McMahon on MIO TV in Singapore. Inarticulate knucklehead trying to be controversial.
Ciarán McGlone
733 Posted 12/12/2012 at 16:28:59
"But the best panel for entertainment by far are the RTE panel over here in Ireland with Johnny Giles, Liam Brady & Eamon Dunphy. These lads hold no punches and call it exactly how it is with none of the shackles that the British channels like Sky, BBC or ITV might be put under"
------------------------

Most times, better than the football...

Who can forget acerbic rants like Dunphy calling Niall Quinn a creep...and "I wouldn't let that clown drive the train to Cork"...

Unmissable!

Eugene Ruane
741 Posted 12/12/2012 at 16:36:05
- Ciaran, it's one of the things I miss most about living in Dublin. Those on the RTE panel understand that the idea of 'pundits' only works if they're honest and say exactly what's on their mind (or conversely, it's pointless just to sit there and agree with each other). Dunphy is (imo) the classic arsehole bar-room lawyer and I have a feeling that 10 mins in his presence and you'd want to swing for him, however he's not afraid to say what's on his mind and it sometimes makes for great telly. Giles and Brady (and occasionally Sourpuss) all have comments worth listening to. What we get here is a fucking disgrace. Lack of insight, lack of bottle, speak but say nothing. Lineker: "Alan, a 4-0 win, it was a good performance by Spurs wasn't it?" Hansen: "Ayewuzzaverraguidperformance..." etc blah.
Bobby Thomas
749 Posted 12/12/2012 at 16:38:37
Well we all have our own take however there appears to be broad agreement that Gary Neville has raised the bar recently.

He has a modern, bullshit free take on the game and it’s been very refreshing to hear the views of a man who only stopped playing top European and international football a few years back. I’ve never heard anyone say they miss Keys/Grays chummy, long winded self-indulgence and the shenanigans with those two actually did Sky a favour.

Sky have a plethora of pundits on the Champions League with Souness probably being the pick, regularly taking resident Redknapp, who is blandness personified, to school. As for Ray "Absolutely chaps" Wilkins, he is a cure for insomnia. there are others, Hoddle, and others who I tend not to be arsed about. Someone mentioned Seedorf earlier in the thread, unsure if he has worked on BBC/Sky or both but, he is excellent.

Soccer Saturday is feeble. Hey fans, these pundits feel just as passionately as you........"GOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLL!" Stelling is a brilliant anchor however.

This brings me to Match of the Day...............its dying on its arse. The show, just like Super Sundays with Keys and Gray before the harassment rumpus, is trapped in a chummy, clubby, self satisfied matiness and its short comings are being severely exposed by Gary Neville’s forthright excellence on Sky.

Hansen, a once vibrant and interesting pundit, descended into self-parody years ago and needs fucking off. Lawrenson shouldn’t do TV at all and should stick to, or be made to stick to, radio and co-commentary where he is much more comfortable.

Shearer is plain awful and is up there with Peter Schmeichel in failing to convey the impression they had even been a professional footballer, never mind played at the highest level, such is their inability to illuminate the action they are describing. Coherent sentences seem to be achievement enough. Strachan is always watchable for me but does seem to have a marmite quality to him. He did however, appearing to completely blank the granite thick Dane, never engaging in conversation or even looking at him when on the MOTD2 sofa years ago and that’s enough for me.

Lee Dixon brought something to MOTD however I remember Hansen being rather bolshy towards him on more than one occasion. There was a genuine sense, for me anyway that Hansen viewed him as a threat.

Liniker is cheese on toast, feeble and Partridge-esque. Do one.

MOTD2 pisses all over its big brother at the moment.

Andy Hegan
782 Posted 12/12/2012 at 20:21:16
Drew 627, I take it you disagree with Owen then? Why?
Alistair Strachan
787 Posted 12/12/2012 at 21:11:22
Can't believe discussion of hopeless pundits has got this far without mention of the execrable Paul Merson.
Trevor Lynes
796 Posted 12/12/2012 at 21:47:44
Ali (#787)... I disagree; I reckon Merson is brilliant, he cannot pronounce players' names and gets lots wrong. He could do a double act with virtually any comedian!!

Motson did my head in... he would come out with lots of absolutely pointless rubbish during a match, eg, Harry Redknapp's father used to be in competition with 'Del Boy ' on the markets and his mum was a bookie's runner... Oh, it looks like we've missed a goal!!

Kammy is another great comic without even trying; Stelling is busy concentrating on Hartlepool's result and how Pompey will be down with them when they are docked their 10 points.

Ben Patchesa
815 Posted 12/12/2012 at 23:59:45
Worst pundit must be Shearer - literally just describes what is in front of his eyes using the vocabulary of a slightly backward seven-year-old.

Best ex-pros: I like Pat Nevin who after initially trying to dazzle with long words (though not to such a laughable extent as Paul Elliott) has settled into an articulate and insightful pundit. I like Steve Claridge's enthusiasm, no matter what the level of match he's watching. Stan Collymore (despite Shite connections) comes out with often unusual, controversial viewpoints which he argues for persuasively, adding to the match he's discussing. Chris Waddle started off strongly but has tailed off.

But top for me is the aforementioned Lee Dixon: I genuinely learnt things about tactics and formations from his insightful analyses that showed up the comments of the salaried-for-life Hansen / Lawrenson / Shearer crew for the lazy, complacent gruntings that they are.

David Ellis
827 Posted 13/12/2012 at 01:49:39
Thank goodness that in Hong Kong all the punditry is in Cantonese (as opposed to the games which are broadcast live in English as well as Cantonese). Although the local pundit shows do seem to feature a lot of female presenters in short skirts leaping around.
Patrick Murphy
829 Posted 13/12/2012 at 02:03:48
I think that Robbie Fowler is far and away the worst of an exceptionally bad bunch, he can barely string a sentence together and he mumbles throughout his 'analysis'... how do these guys get these gigs?


Dave Lynch
865 Posted 13/12/2012 at 10:12:33
Chris Kamara is a legend.

Best I heard was this:

"Geoff, Geoff, Geoff, oh my god Geoff"! Geoff!!!"

Over to Kammy: "What's happened, Kammy?"

Kammy: "I dunno Geoff, I wasn't watching but it's all gone off here!"
Jim Potter
984 Posted 14/12/2012 at 09:31:47
Garth Crooks portrays himself as some deep thinking pseudo philospher - hand on his chin at a jaunty angle, furrowed brow, throwing intense looks at Gabby Logan.

All she's asked him is his name. To which of course Garth the answer is Knobmeister General.

He has all the interlect of a freshly laid cow pat.

Brent Stephens
992 Posted 14/12/2012 at 10:40:38
Jim, do cow pats become more mature with age?!
Shane Corcoran
999 Posted 14/12/2012 at 11:22:49
Ciarán and Eugene have it bang on. What's the point in punditry if you're effectively censored in saying what you think? All the British pundits water down their thoughts. Sky, strangely, is better than most although Roy is always worth a look on UTV for the laugh.

Dunphy lets himself down by going too far to make his point but it's worth tuning in at 9:30 after a Champion's League game, (especially if City are on cos they're the new pet-hate for Giles and Dunphy) just to hear their rant.

I remember Souness commenting on one of his first nights working with them on how he couldn't believe that they were allowed to say what they wanted, and he made these comments live on air. Bill O'Herlihy, the greatest TV host ever.
Jim Potter
001 Posted 14/12/2012 at 11:48:24
Brent - ask Garth Crooks.
Martin Scott
022 Posted 14/12/2012 at 13:52:25
I used to find myself replying to Ray Wilkins exuberant "Good afternoon everyone" out loud in a warm drunken haze whilst a game of killer was under way during a early 90s stay behind watching C4 Italian Football, with the excellent James Richardson....
Andy Hegan
061 Posted 14/12/2012 at 17:12:12
Shane, is UTV available in England? I'd like to take a look?
Mick MacManus
070 Posted 14/12/2012 at 18:05:43
Here's a few you tube clips of the RTE football pundits in action. Great craic and banter at times but they hold no punches in their analysis...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KHTM-abNEyk

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbsNn9qACOQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNtS9DpzklM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EqjQSk1PQ4o

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3y9Sx7t5N8

Julian Wait
073 Posted 14/12/2012 at 18:36:15
I agree with Lee Dixon being the best at post match analysis. McManaman is quite good on the "colour commentary" during the match, i.e. as co-pilot, except the guy he is with doing the commentary is such a sycophant it's a bit nauseating at times. I can't get MOTD1,2, or 3 over here any more and even though it was crap, I miss it....
Shane Corcoran
075 Posted 14/12/2012 at 18:47:49
Andy, UTV is just Northern Ireland's regional version of ITV. Sorry for the confusion. I'm pretty sure Roy is on ITV's Champions League coverage.
Andy Crooks
081 Posted 14/12/2012 at 19:14:46
The best were Clough, Allison, McNabb and Venables. The worst commentator/pundit in the history of the world is Jackie Fullerton from BBC Northern Ireland. Seems a decent enough bloke but he is beyond belief as a commentator.

"Ireland (the men in green)... Iceland (the big men in white)... The big man with the left foot, the wee man with the right foot. The big man with red hair, the wee man with curly hair" — Say what you see, why don't you, Jackie?

One can only assume that Giant Haystacks saw one commentary too many when he pole axed him. Check out "Giant Haystacks and Jackie Fullerton" on YouTube. Then imagine your least favourite person in his place.

Brian Waring
164 Posted 15/12/2012 at 14:52:38
The worst pundit of all is John Barnes, has not got a fucking clue!
Noel Early
338 Posted 16/12/2012 at 09:22:52
Hansen = Pretty good
Shearer = On the fence dickhead, seems to forget he kicked a player in the head not so long ago and threatened to not play for England
Lawrenson = The king of all dickheads, he even exceeds Phil Thompson in my opinion who for a long time was the biggest clown on TV.
Townsend = Loves everybody
Burley = Has potential
Keane = Tells it like it is but then again, he grew up listening to Dunphy and Giles, the kings of football pundits in my opinion.
Andy Gray = Missed but not as much as I figured
Gary Neville = Very insightfull and the new darling of pundits
Wilkins = Recently said that he predicted Celtic to finish 4th place in Champions League group and would be lucky to do so, so enough said about him.
Kevin Clarke
753 Posted 17/12/2012 at 22:21:42
Do what I do: record MotD, watch the matches & fast forward through the banal, boring, sit-on-the-fence, I don't want to say anything that'll lose me this cushy number, dogshite licking, turd breaths when they puke out their analysis. It's getting worse & worse with each passing year.

Michael Owen is the Gary Fuckin Barlow of football. Wanker. 1st class. Knobbie Savage is a cunt & would be even if he decided to stop turning up on my telly dressed like the biggest twat on Pop Idol & devote his time to helping the needy.

Jamie fucking Redknapp?? Don't get me started on that twatbag.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb