Season 2012-13
Opinion
Talking Points
Speed of Signings
One of the things that irritated me most during the Moyes years was how long it seemed to take the club to complete signings, as well as how we often seemed to be caught on our heels at the start of each transfer window, as other clubs swiftly and decisively did their business.
There was often speculation among fellow ToffeeWebbers that this was, variously, due to Moyes dithering and taking too long to scout and decide on targets, Kenwright refusing to sanction signings until near the end of the window to save on wages, the economic reality of prices dropping as the window drew to a close, etc.
I don't suppose any of us can say for sure whether any of those factors were in play, but I think we would all agree that, for whatever reason, virtually every signing we did make was always a traumatic up and down and excessively lengthy drama.
Let's hope that this will change under Roberto Martinez. He seems a business-like character who will identify his targets quickly enough. Of course, it's a little early to judge as he's only just been appointed, but even if you ignore the rich elite already spending big, I noticed yesterday that teams like Villa are busy tying up signings of Bulgarian international midfielders.
Pointedly, the BBC gossip column also has a rumour today suggesting that Chelsea have stolen a march over Man Utd towards signing a defender they both want, because Moyes is on holiday and nobody is holding the fort in his absence. I would not, of course, begrudge a manager his end-of-season break, but that was another thing that often seemed to happen at Everton. Moyes would be away and such was his total level of control, that we could not take signings forward in his absence.
I would like to see RM conclude a signing or two by the end of June at the latest, just to show that we really are dealing with a complete culture change at the club. Time will tell if that is just wishful thinking...
Mark Boulle, Posted 09/06/2013 at 12:11:14
Reader Comments
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
554 Posted 09/06/2013 at 15:18:34
I think with Bobby M in charge, we could be seeing more flair and exciting players being bought. One question: Where has BK suddenly found money from?
555 Posted 09/06/2013 at 15:22:13
561 Posted 09/06/2013 at 15:42:52
565 Posted 09/06/2013 at 15:45:59
594 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:03:11
Some early signings would be a boost for supporters and would also offer the chance for Martinez to show he means business. Having said that I would like his first signing to be Baines on a new contract.
Personally I've always held the view that our lateness in transfer dealings was partly to get the lowest price as the window closes but also to ensure we didn't get involved in a bidding war (more likely early in a transfer window) and which I suspect, more often than not, we would lose!
595 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:23:49
600 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:23:13
We might shave weeks off transfer negotiations with a manager who doesn't go through bins, ask for stool samples and conduct a personal smear test on wives and partners before committing to 'talks'.
603 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:33:00
MOYES: Usually. We went 24 times to watch Joleon Lescott before we signed him from Wolves. People called me ‘dithering Davie’ because I watched players so many times but I couldn’t afford to get it wrong. When you’re looking in an alternative market, you’re not going to find someone who you’re sure about straight away and is ready to come into the team. If he was that good, he would have been taken by the others. We watched Phil Jagielka a lot too. I saw him play badly for England B but we went for him. I liked Leighton Baines after seeing him for the England Under 21s. But neither player got straight into our team once they arrived. It took time.
604 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:34:20
608 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:38:09
609 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:39:05
The first is to assess whether he's someone who's worth having.
In this respect I can't criticise Moyes looking at Lescott 24 times. Lets face it must be easier when Lionel Messi is the target!
Secondly having made the decision to go for a player there needs to be some sort of strategy as to when; how much; and how is it to be moved forward.
Some of this second stage may well have been in someone else's hands e.g. Robert Elstone's. This may have contributed to the apparent fall out between DM And RE.
614 Posted 09/06/2013 at 18:59:58
Remember Fellaini`s deal was concluded `after hours`,probably because BK was waiting for incoming cash `for the deposit`.
So,given that the payment rules in respect of Premier to Premier deals are exceeding strict,don`t expect too many Wiganners to `be following their master`!
615 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:00:13
Roberto Martinez does not become Everton manager until 1st July. How is he going to make signings in June when he doesn't even start the job until July?????
Plus I think David Moyes is still currently Everton manager. At least he's still being paid until July. Do you think Moyes is going to allow Martinez to change things while he's still in charge?????
Personally I don't want Martinez to make any signings in June. I would prefer the following happen.
1. Martinez becomes Everton manager on July 1st.
2. Martinez spends a few weeks working with the current squad.
3. Martinez gains knowledge and understanding of his squad.
4. Martinez identifies any weakness in the squad.
5. Martinez looks for new players to strengthen the squad.
6. Martinez starts signing players in August.
Personally I feel it would be stupid for Martinez to start signing players before he's even started the job. Before he's even had one single training sessions with the squad.
We all want new players but lets be practical and give Martinez a chance to work with the current squad and assess it. At the very least lets give him a chance to actually start the job first.
Demanding transfers from Martinez a full month before he even starts the job seems unfair and silly.
616 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:15:20
618 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:13:37
I tend to agree, but how do you expect Martinez to spend a few weeks with the squad in early july and gain knowledge and understanding?
Firstly, I doubt he'll get more than a few minutes with each one in the first couple of weeks pre-season (some won't even be there for it - those who have international duties probably wont even have to report in until mid july I would guess).
Secondly, you gain nothing from looking at few training sessions with players who've been on their holidays for a few weeks.
Thirdly, with all the scouting and analysis of opposition, and having played the everton team many times, I would imagine he'd have a good enough view without even having to see them roll up to the training ground.
Most early pre-season schedules are simply about building fitness backup to match level, Nothing to see there...
619 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:17:00
621 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:14:42
This managerial contract situation is an interesting one - it was obviously discussed at length when Moyes left as he appeared to be working for Man United prior to his official start date, in that he was there assessing which staff he would keep on, dealing with the Rooney situation etc.
Equally, Martinez (incidentally, I forget who but someone on here mentioned the pronunciation recently - I was in Spain last week and am reliably informed the stress is on the 'i') has signed a contract and has been 'appointed' Everton manager. It may have a start date of 1 July, but I imagine he is already working. Indeed, we know he is because he has been responding to speculation about Fellaini and Baines. If Moyes were still in charge and Martinez weren't, surely he wouldn't be asked those questions. Football, in that respect, seems different from other lines of work. There are contractual start and end dates, but they seem very loose.
I take your point that RM might perhaps want to see first hand what he has to work with once the players return to training. However, as has been alluded to by other posters at some point, he is an experienced Premier League manager who must already have some idea of our squad and areas where it might be improved, in the same way you or I could probably offer reasonably well informed opinions about what positions other teams than our own might need to strengthen.
622 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:23:21
623 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:15:24
624 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:17:47
Martinez is already operating as Everton's manager. Just as Moyes is already operating as United's manager. We're not talking about jobs at Spar here! We're talking about people paid millions a year!
To believe that Martinez doesn't already know everything he needs to know about Everton is naive in the extreme. He will also know who he wants to bring in. If we were to follow your programme we will end up with last minute chaos as we did last January!
626 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:26:29
Incidently, by the way, isn't Roberto's accent funny? He says 'Club' with a real northern accent but other words sound very Spanish.
630 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:43:20
I also thought we signed Bilyaletdinov on the recommendation of Hiddink?
http://www.tribalfootball.com/everton-boss-Moyes-hiddink-recommended-bilyaletdinov-297881
631 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:53:22
632 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:56:33
Lets say for example he pushed through a transfer for Victor Moses. Then on the 1st of July he trains for the first time with the squad and realises that actually he's got Ross Barkley who is better then Moses. OH DEAR ROBERTO YOU HAVE JUST WASTED ALL YOUR BUDGET ON A PLAYER NOT AS GOOD AS THE ONE YOU ALREADY HAD.
Now I'm not suggesting Barkley is better than Moses. Just that he or maybe somebody else could be. And Martinez should work with the squad before making decisions like that.
The Everton transfer budget is a very limited thing and should be treasured and spent VERY WISELY.
The only way for Martinez to spend that money wisely is to first work with his current squad and identify where that money should be spent.
If Martinez spends a single pound before even a single training session with his current players then I will be pissed. I don't want any transfers until after July 1st.
635 Posted 09/06/2013 at 20:17:43
637 Posted 09/06/2013 at 20:27:51
640 Posted 09/06/2013 at 19:31:11
653 Posted 09/06/2013 at 20:35:34
As for likely signings. I'll bet he and his scouting network have more than a few surprises in store.
679 Posted 09/06/2013 at 22:54:40
726 Posted 10/06/2013 at 06:45:26
752 Posted 10/06/2013 at 10:25:35
781 Posted 10/06/2013 at 14:58:57
My issue with the tardiness of our movements is the failure to have sufficient time to sign alternative targets if our choices fall through. For example the Ofoe and Fer situations. Ironically we seem to be able to offload players and loan out with much more alacrity and efficiency.We actually loaned out four players including Gueye and Barkley, so effectively weakened our squad instead of strengthening it.
I am certain that Moyes was as frustrated as us fans and I'm sure that, had he signed two or three players during the January window, we would have made the top four.
823 Posted 10/06/2013 at 18:12:52
YES, because Billion pound clubs are run like this.
The reason we don't sign players early is because the sky money isn't available until August.
939 Posted 11/06/2013 at 10:43:41
945 Posted 11/06/2013 at 11:33:34
I expect our first signing (Alcaraz?) this week or next. The new players need to be on the pre season tours not in August ffs!!
P. S. We are supposed to have a BoD's who can handle transfers aren't we?
971 Posted 11/06/2013 at 13:23:00
So you want Martinez to make a couple of signings by the end of June, just to prove a point????!!!!! Is that a sensible strategy to move our club forward???!!!! Get real mate.
Martinez will sign players when he is good and ready – and not before. Let the guy get on with his job.
Incidentally, if there is a need for a 'culture change' as you so put it, you can't change the culture of a club overnight. It takes time. Martinez and his backroom staff need time to bed in. Honestly... this country...
982 Posted 11/06/2013 at 13:39:54
What is the point of signing a player then thinking shit a had this lad in the ressies what a waste of money.
McAleny for instance 10 goals in 11 games coming back from injury.
does he just neeed a chance? Or should Martinez just go and buy? Moses?
Barkley we all think he is good enough, does he need a run of games or Martinez go and buy a attcking Midfielder?
Lundstrum Will he get a chance.
Kennendy is another one rave review's for the U21's never got a look in does Martinez go and buy McManaman?
Hey if it is the 21st July and Martinez pays £20 Million for a striker and turns round and said "I looked at the squad and there are players who 18,19,20,21 years old that good enough for the sqaud but we needed a striker"
What would your thought be?
984 Posted 11/06/2013 at 14:20:12
Same goes for Martinez, right?
Don't be surprised if things this summer are just as traumatic where signings are concerned - I can't see how we will suddenly have millions of pounds to spend willy-nilly on players, regardless of the TV deal and possible sale of Fellaini.
Chances are we'll pick up a couple of Wigan players (God help us) for about £10m the pair and that will be it.
All these links with players in the papers are mostly bullshit to fill column inches (we all know that), and various talk of this player & that is fabtasy manager stuff.
I'll wager we don't sign anyone until July at the very earliest.
986 Posted 11/06/2013 at 14:28:14
Until Fellaini is sold, how can we make moves for players if we don't have any cash?
These are massive multi million pound transactions for human beings - it's like the slave trade in some ways and not the same as buying a car off eBay for example. There's a lot to consider when you're spending millions of pounds of someone elses money and the way people talk about transfers seems to miss these points.
Just because £5m sounds like a low amount in the grand scheme of football transfers, doesn't stop it being £5m, which is a LOT of money to throw away without doing your research first!
993 Posted 11/06/2013 at 15:08:46
And before anyone mentions the Jan window (last). We didn't buy anyone, with the supposed money available. Well I think that was a load of shite. Just a sweetener, BK, said we could have bought Fer, one problem he was injured. How long were they following him? And now there is talk of buying him again. But he's injured isn't he? Has I've said a load of shite.
994 Posted 11/06/2013 at 15:08:46
And before anyone mentions the Jan window (last). We didn't buy anyone, with the supposed money available. Well I think that was a load of shite. Just a sweetener, BK, said we could have bought Fer, one problem he was injured. How long were they following him? And now there is talk of buying him again. But he's injured isn't he? Has I've said a load of shite.
002 Posted 11/06/2013 at 15:53:36
Funny, he played the rest of the season for them, and even played a few Internationals - nothing wrong with his knee at all.
016 Posted 11/06/2013 at 16:44:10
If Fellaini doesnt go then we will be waiting for the t.v. money again this year because I cant see us having much money before that date
019 Posted 11/06/2013 at 16:50:15
If I remember, there were 2 years worth of TV money borrowed against. I don't know if they renewed the 2nd year last season.
129 Posted 12/06/2013 at 00:18:07
131 Posted 12/06/2013 at 00:32:11
132 Posted 12/06/2013 at 00:46:13
199 Posted 12/06/2013 at 13:32:13
OK so he talks bollocks a lot of the time, but to say he wants to do things to deliberately make the club worse for his own gains is nonsense in my opinion.
It's not as though he's tried to sell our best players every year. Arteta left for good money at the right time, so did Rooney, Cahill etc etc. I don't think we've once sold a player just to make money.
We don't have as much money as many in the Premier League, but we compete on the field as best we can within our resources. Would you prefer us to do a Leeds and spend beyond our means for a couple of seasons in the sun? Be really careful what you wish for.
332 Posted 12/06/2013 at 23:23:38
We have paid compensation to the pie eaters to buy him out so we can flaunt Bobby M officially as our gaffer!
096 Posted 24/06/2013 at 21:27:40
He's not sorted out his staff yet, not met his players yet, starts playing friendlies in USA on the 14th July I believe... bloody hell, he's going to have a nervous breakdown before the Prem starts!
This is why you're only as good as your staff, but as I say, they're not in place yet.
104 Posted 24/06/2013 at 22:08:04
So why are fans writing articles defending the board and making excuses for them.
Let them spend the money that is already in their coffers since nothing was spent this year.
We have offloaded Neville, Hitzelsberger and Mucha plus young Bidwell has transferred OUT.
Gueye is still away and Barkley was loaned out last January for a period.
Without the SKY money we should still be able to provide funds for early business so that any new player/s could be bedded in before the season starts.
Money was supposedly available for the acquisition of Fer plus the loaning IN of Ofoe.
FFS stop giving this miserly board excuses.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


550 Posted 09/06/2013 at 15:11:48
I think it will be difficult to know who to buy this Summer before the Fellaini issue is sorted out too. I see RM has said that he is staying but I'm not convinced it will be that simple. Hopefully not another Lescott saga.