Bobby's last season. A blessing in disguise?

by   |   23/06/2016  12 Comments  [Jump to last]

This is NOT an article about Roberto Martinez... but possibly an argument to offer him thanks.

As I was sitting in London's outer orbital car park — known to many as 'The M25' — killing my time by catching up on ToffeeWeb, as one does, and taking in the view (I think it was an R8 in front and Norbert Dentressangle alongside, open countryside to my right), and with an aimlessly wandering mind, centred on football in general and and things Everton in particular, I got to thinking...

Off the back of a pretty lacklustre season which, with a slightly more favourable rub of the green over about 40 weeks, might have looked a fair bit less of a debacle, but from which thankfully we survived, we find that our top players' stock has dropped somewhat leading to a noticeable (so far) lack of clamouring for them from other top clubs.

Allied with the arrival of Farhad Moshiri and his obvious influence around the place — his appointment of Ronald Koeman as manager and Sasha Ryazantsev to the board, comments about plans, projects, stadium, signings and so on — the excitement around the place is nigh on tangible.

We have a thoroughly classy core squad of players — some with immense potential with the right mentoring which is going to be further strengthened with the possible arrival of the likes Sneijder (a good move IMO) and/or others, but which could been dismantled (and would have been if Martinez had remained).

If any of Lukaku, John Stones, Barkley, Coleman, Deulofeu and Funes Mori (this is not an exhaustive list), all whom are very definite potential targets for the big-shot clubs to move on, they will clearly not be easy to replace. Had their stock been higher off the back of a stronger season, there would have been a free-for-all for their signatures, particularly under Roberto Martinez.

However, and this is where my thinking led, has last season's difficulties resulted in a situation whereby it will be easier for the club to persuade these guys to stay (assuming Koeman has a plan for them, of course)?

He has probably (hopefully) done us a massive favour, working himself out of a job, paving the way for Koeman and sparking the positive vibe around the club right now.

I said on another thread that any player wanting out now might look back with some pretty major regret. Greener grass and all that, and I for one, cannot wait for the new season to start and also see what the close season (is it still called that?) brings.

So... thank you, Roberto Martinez, for engineering an optimism (a GENUINE optimism) about Everton that I have not felt for some time.

back Return to Talking Points index  :  Add your Comments »


Reader Comments (12)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Michael Kenrick
1 Posted 23/06/2016 at 23:53:11
Yes, I'll accept a case can be made for saying that, had Martinez been less inept, had our players played better, and had Everton been more successful, then we could be facing more demands for the services of our better players.

But this is certainly not something Roberto 'engineered'.

I actually think in many cases there's an opposite argument: a season (or two) of progression for some very talented key players have been clearly wasted while those players have fallen behind rather than advancing their careers.

Everton 2016 should be in a much better place than we find ourselves; if that were the case, you could argue that our better players would be doing far better for us and happy to continue, for an upwardly mobile, successful club in the Premier League, irrespective of the covetous eyes of others.

All that aside, the determination is that we keep our better players — something we have largely continued to do in recent years (eg, John Stones).

Andy McNabb
2 Posted 23/06/2016 at 00:04:21
Kim, I think there may be a lot of truth in what you have written. My Deputy at school uses the expression, "Short term pain, long time gain."

That's not to say the pain doesn't hurt and I won't make your M25 experience worse by talking of my view right now but if you have ever been to Port Douglas in far North Queensland that will suffice. Being up here helps to put things in perspective and too often, when we are close to something, we lose that skill. After living in Melbourne for 15 years, I now regard this time of year as Winter and a bit miserable when in actual fact compared to other places on the globe I should be counting my blessings. Maybe that's a bit like supporting Everton?

And so I would also like to offer a word of thanks to the much maligned Bill Kenwright. Despite being vilified on a regular basis, if things really are as positive as we think they might be (and I reserve judgement there), then maybe Bill's "24/7 search" really did pay off? Despite the clamour to be sold to anyone and everyone, he waited and waited until the right person came along for his beloved Blues.

So, as I sit with a coffee watching the waves role in, wrapped in my new sense of perspective, I have to say - "Thanks Bill and maybe even, thanks Roberto, too!"

Tony Draper
3 Posted 24/06/2016 at 00:54:10
I am grateful to Roberto, seriously, I'm grateful.

Why?

Because, even briefly, he DID deliver entertaining positive football. We ALL saw that "The School of Science" was on it's way back. We did... We really did.

In doing that, Everton smashed the myth that the turgid, sterile and unimaginative dross we had been continually peddled was in any way justifiable; it never was. Never.

Our mindset now is entirely positive and hopeful. Not by any stretch of the most creative imagination is this solely down to "Bobby Brightside", but he DID, albeit briefly, demonstrate that our cap-in-hand, grateful-for-merely-existing attitude was over. He was the agent of his own destruction.

Did he let us down? Yes, yes he did. Thankfully he didn't take 11 years to achieve that.

Andy Crooks
4 Posted 24/06/2016 at 00:54:48
Kim, looking for a silver lining in the reign of the hapless Martinez, for me,brings up nothing. In my view not only the worst coach in our history but the worst coach I have ever seen at any level. Truly wasted years in which he dragged every player back. It will take time to recover from the damage he did.
Patrick Murphy
5 Posted 24/06/2016 at 01:40:39
I tend to agree with Andy (#4), we went backwards far too rapidly and so did the players. Not only that, but Roberto managed to turn Goodison from a bear-pit into a library and, worse still, had many long-standing match-going Blues contemplating giving up for good.

Whether Ronald can do something with the players in the coming months is open to debate but the optimism of the fans is back and most of us have a sparkle in our eye – long may that be the case.

Everton FC did Roberto far more favours than he did for the club. He wasn't all bad; he just wasn't good enough... not a crime, but not what we needed. Hopefully we won't have to employ somebody so far out of his depth in such an important position in the near or far future.

I shudder to think where we might be if Bill hadn't have found his 'Fairy Godfather' – it would have been very very different and not at all pleasant.

William Cartwright
6 Posted 24/06/2016 at 03:53:20
Kim / Andy; They say every cloud has a silver lining. . . . . . . .

The eternal optimist in me hopes the silver lining will be as bright as the cloud was (very) dark. The early moves so far are give me a feel of confidence.

Jay Harris
7 Posted 24/06/2016 at 04:24:38
I would be happy to never hear Martinez mentioned again.

He took us backwards when the opportunity was there to break the glass ceiling

Now we have to start rebuilding all over again with the loss of Ossie and Pienaar and age catching up on Barry, Jags and Bainesy never mind the potential loss of Stones, Barkley and Lukaku.

Eugene Ruane
8 Posted 24/06/2016 at 07:08:31
If it was a blessing in disguise, it was a very very very good disguise.
Niall McIlhone
9 Posted 24/06/2016 at 10:38:49
Whilst the Martinez years will undoubtedly be remembered as fruitless, and characterized by our inability to defend, he did, nonetheless completely overhaul the U21 and junior team set up. We now have a structure which is the envy of many, and that legacy is probably the best thing Roberto has left in his wake.

I do hope the likes of Dowell, Davis and Browning make the grade, for sure, Mr Koeman will cast his expert eye and make his judgement.

Damian Wilde
10 Posted 26/06/2016 at 00:34:38
An odd post, well, ridiculous.

And Tony:

"... the turgid, sterile and unimaginative dross we had been continually peddled..."

You're talking about the most boring football ever served up by Bobby, yeah?

Going back to the original article. It's a bit like if you had Aids and then you were cured and life then seemed so much better, would you think 'so pleased I had Aids for a bit'? No I don't think you would.

I feel optimistic now, yes, but that useless buffoon ruined two seasons of my match going experience. This post is an insult.

Barry Jones
11 Posted 05/07/2016 at 17:46:07
I have to agree with Andy's (#4) concise and accurate summing up of the ability of Martinez. Jay, Damian, I feel your pain also. For years I have heard Stephen Hawking talk about black holes and I have always had trouble in establishing a tangible visualization of the topic, until the last two seasons under Martinez.
Andy Meighan
12 Posted 08/07/2016 at 20:57:25
Yes, Kim, sure I'd like to thank him for two 4-0 defeats at Anfield in three seasons; the dismal home record of last season; his insistence on playing players who were woefully out of form, ie, Howard and Alcaraz; his ability to talk utter drivel about certain players, eg, Cleverley after his goal at Newcastle.

Lukaku &#!50; I'd have paid £100 million... yeah sure and other diatribe that's escaped my notice. It was two-and-a-half seasons of complete and utter trash and really, Kim, you want to thank him?!? That clown has just walked into the sunset with a monumental pay-off. He must be pissing down his leg at the club. Oh I'd like to say something to him but it wouldn't be 'Thanks'.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads



© ToffeeWeb