Share this article



Reader Comments (22)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Bill Watson
1 Posted 16/08/2018 at 18:08:06
Brands will probably turn out to be our best signing of the summer.
Moshiri said he was always the target but was unavailable 2 years ago.

I wonder how Koeman would have panned out if Brands had been in place last year?

David Ellis
2 Posted 16/08/2018 at 18:38:44
I like this guy. Obviously he’s doing a bit of a PR job on us but it sounds authentic. It feels very different to last years recruitment, particularly the age profile and quality of the players. None of the signings leave you scratching your head as to why we got them or paid what we did.

Ashley Williams and Bolasie were both head scratchers... and others followed .

Frank Kearns
3 Posted 16/08/2018 at 20:08:17
Ashley Williams a head scratcher? I doubt he could find it to scratch
Peter Gorman
4 Posted 16/08/2018 at 20:20:11
Brands doesn't need to do any PR, his record at PSV speaks for itself.

TW was very giddy when he signed on, if I remember correctly, and first impressions are that the faith has not been misplaced.

You can't beat a man with a plan.

Jeff Armstrong
5 Posted 16/08/2018 at 20:36:36
What a difference from the the dormant mute that was Steve Walsh,who couldn’t even utter a word of encouragement ( or any other word!)whilst travelling in a car with an under 23 player, who explained not one of his, (or others) baffling signings.
Brands has been here 5 minutes and we already know more about the intricacies of the Mina deal and the plan going forward,lower average age,reduced wage bill to give us a bit of scope next window etc, than Walsh ever divulged in the time he was here.
John Pierce
6 Posted 16/08/2018 at 20:37:58
A professional, long time since that happened at Goodison. It puts others to shame.

Superb appointment.

Paul Birmingham
7 Posted 16/08/2018 at 22:05:14
Yes I agree, that Marcel Brands is the general overseeing the restructuring of EFC, and long may he continue.

There's a fresh feeling of optimism around Goodison Park and let's build on it daily.

Early, days but it's a good start.

Steve Hogan
8 Posted 16/08/2018 at 22:33:15
There is a quiet confidence (not arrogance) about Brands, even in the short time he's been with us. The interesting thing to consider was, did Moshiri already know about his profile at PSV a number of years ago, or did one of his advisors tip him off?

I only ask, as we may underestimate Moshiri's knowledge of the real mover's and shaker's around the European football scene.

I must admit, prior to the appointment of Brands, I'd never heard of him. Moshiri is clearly not an owner who wants to hog the media limelight (Jim White's best mate apart), but we'll forgive him for that.

I feel cautious optimism that the club has finally appointed astute people from a strong business and commercial background who can move the club forward on and off the pitch.

Onwards and upwards.

Les Green
9 Posted 17/08/2018 at 09:00:27
Brands has been a revelation, and he's done it all in such a small amount of time. I'm now waiting to be amazed at what he can do over a couple of seasons.

On the point of having a Director of Football, I noticed in the press that Man Utd are now pursuing the idea of employing one for the first time. Which I assume is partly down to what they see as a disastrous transfer window, the impending meltdown of Moaner-inho, and perhaps a glance over at Goodison Park to see how a professional does it.

Chris Brennan
10 Posted 17/08/2018 at 13:21:48
About a week after he joined us, I was in a restaurant on the Wirral and he came in with his wife. Despite protestations from my Mrs, I went over excused myself to his Mrs shook his hand (he could see I was a Blue cos of a tattoo) and said I hoped he and Marco would bring the good times back for us. He was charm personified even on his way out, making time to say goodbye. Top man in my book (and yes he has got a very firm handshake).
Derek Taylor
11 Posted 17/08/2018 at 13:48:55
Soundbites apart, Brands has done nothing, as yet, to deserve such outright praise. A Director of Football stands or fails on the degree of success his signings attain and given that Richarlison was a self-confessed disciple of Silva, I'm not giving Brands the credit in that signing (and we were fleeced, anyway).

So let's wait for the late signings to kick a ball for us before we start doing the handstands, not fall into the trap of last year when Walsh was seen as a genius before we saw his donkeys play!

Trevor Powell
12 Posted 17/08/2018 at 14:05:12
Going back twelve months, what did happen with the hapless Walsh's trip to Italy? Was he checking out a pasta maker for Rupert Tower shapes for the club shop? Clearly, there were no dud signings to be ripped-off with.
John Hoggarth
13 Posted 17/08/2018 at 15:00:28
You're right, of course, Derek, that Brands will ultimately be judged on the way his signings perform. But it's not unreasonable (or a sign of over-optimism) to look at his transfer activity this window and to compare it to earlier seasons.

In my view, Brands has been a breath of fresh air. Under his watch, the positions that supporters were screaming to be addressed have been filled with players who have some pedigree and/or great promise. We'll see how they do, but he got them in.

You overlooked his outbound activity which again matches what fans were asking for. A lot of deadwood has gone and probably one or two more to follow. Once the window closed, Brands has given lengthy interviews to the media, not just sound bites, explaining the strategy and giving rarely seen insight into the negotiating process.

I think we're seeing Denise's better communications pledge coming to fruition – I very much doubt Brands decided off his own bat to explain the intricacies of the transfer market.

Dave Abrahams
14 Posted 17/08/2018 at 20:18:13
John (13), I agree with you, Mr Brands has been brushing away the old methods while bringing in his tried and proven way, which was why he was brought here. He looks and sounds like he knows what he is doing.

I doubt very much he needs help from Dr Barrett-Baxendale to put words into his mouth; I think he more than knows the score.

Jay Wood
[BRZ]

15 Posted 17/08/2018 at 20:49:21
It strikes me that since Brands joined us on 1st June - ahead of Marco Silva's confirmation as manager, remember - he simply got his head down and got on with a very difficult task.

Given the bloated underperforming squad - some of them on equally bloated wages - and the situation he inherited I think it is impressive how transformed and refreshed the squad now looks in such a short time.

With no manager in place to consult with, in a World Cup year and a much fore-shortened transfer window, we now have just 2 first team players over 30, four of the five outfield players recruited are full internationals, and together their median age comes in at 23 years old.

I don't need to list the ageing or fringe players that have been moved on when many feared it would be impossible to find any interested parties for them. There is a couple of weeks yet to see a couple of more out of the Goodison door.

Yes, we need to see evidence if the new recruits can cut it at Everton, but already it looks like being a lot more fun than what we've endured in the last two years.

On another thread Brands was called out for 'bigging himself' up following his media interviews this week.

Given these same day interviews for several media outlets is the one and only time he has uttered anything for public consumption since his and Marco's joint 'Welcome to Everton' gig, I thought such charges were both unfair and unfounded, based on what he did say.

I would have thought his words were both intriguing and informative for the bulk of Evertonians for their insight into how our transfer business was conducted this year. Equally, his earthy 'shit' and 'double shit' comments in the presence of owner Farhad Moshiri whilst watching Mina score against England probably resonate with many a Scouser as well.

This is just the start. And in my eyes it has been a very good one.

Andy McNabb
16 Posted 19/08/2018 at 07:12:08
"Williams as a false 9"?

Maybe you are onto something there, Adam. Perhaps that's where we went wrong?

Adam McCulloch
17 Posted 19/08/2018 at 15:05:36
Derek (11) – I agree, as I mentioned, that it is very early days for Brands. It is important to remember that his remit is not just to sign players. It's to shape the squad in terms of incomings, outgoings and promoting academy talent, the overall philosophy of the club. He also arrived before Silva, so must have signed off on that. It's a far-reaching role – one for which Walsh was clearly too inexperienced to really make his own.

The season is only two games old but so far, I would say the work he has done, the manner he has conducted himself with, and the general feelgood factor around Goodison should be encouraged. Not that a healthy dose of cynicism is ever far from my thoughts either.

And Andy (#16), Williams was often a false 5 for us in all honesty!

Dominic Tonge
18 Posted 20/08/2018 at 03:27:13
Ashley Williams as a false nine?

Well, he managed 18 months as a false number five, so why not?

Gavin Johnson
19 Posted 25/08/2018 at 02:24:37
I think this is now the best squad we've had in years (at least on paper). We had a big bloated squad before, but it was completely unbalanced and weak in some areas. We now have strength throughout the squad, with perhaps a marquee centre-forward being the missing piece of the jigsaw if the new signings integrate into the team.

It might take a couple of more windows but, at that point, I don't see why we couldn't be in the top 6 and overtaking Arsenal.

We are now starting to act like a big club. Something changed this summer and I think Brands has been a huge part of the newfound optimism. He got rid of all the deadwood, albeit a few of them being loans, but he's certainly got us going in the right direction. His moves buying and selling in only his first window with us, look amazing, although it is still early days.

Karl Masters
20 Posted 26/08/2018 at 13:41:17
I can't really understand why you're bigging him up — yet. We are only 3 games in, we've had another massive turnover of players, and although I'd agree the signs are encouraging, we have no idea yet how the transfers will pan out.

The Martinez and Koeman eras started with 6-game unbeaten runs, but they and Walsh turned sour in the end.

A lot of assumptions that Koeman and Walsh had no plan. That they were outmanoeuvred etc, but a year ago nobody thought that. Their plan, and they surely had one, even if it now seems they didn't to some, didn't work. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

I'm optimistic, but only Richarlison has played so far of the newcomers, and we've seen sublime and ridiculous so far from him. Next year we might just be wondering why there was so little cover for Tosun, especially if Niasse goes to Turkey this week as an example that you can always make a case for signing more players.

Time will tell.

Adam McCulloch
21 Posted 27/08/2018 at 17:40:42
Karl (20) - I totally agree that it's VERY early days, and based on the opening three games (Watford looking good/Man U struggling/etc) it's painfully obvious that there is a lot more football to play.

My own (cautious) optimism about Brands' work so far is based on more than the players bought in. Walsh and Koeman may have had a long term strategy: yet the former very rarely gave any public statements to back this up, and Koeman certainly didn't strike any of us as a forward thinker.

The players they bought in were, on the whole, older, “proven,” Premier League players like Bolasie, Rooney, Williams, with little success. They also failed to forge any kind of identity, failed to move on high earners who had consistently flattered to deceive (Mirallas an obvious example) and so we were lumbered with an expensive squad of mistakes, misfits and players on contracts which did not match their ability or contribution. Our disjointed performances on the pitch may well have been down to managerial upheaval and poor appointments, but it's not a massive stretch to say that the lack of a cohesive plan resulted in the stagnant football witnessed last year.

Brands has – so far – managed to move on a good number of the deadwood. Okay, we've loaned out some players we would rather be shot of completely, and made big losses on others. But this ruthlessness, coupled with some investments that on paper look sensible, suggest that we can at least build this year.

Tony Everan
22 Posted 28/08/2018 at 19:09:24
Brands has played a blinder, now it's up to Silva to follow it up.

My Nan could have done better than the Koeman & Walsh recruitment fiasco, but Brands has definitely gone a good few steps better than even she could.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb