12/09/2024 139comments  |  Jump to last
Match Preview

Seamus Coleman is an unlikely starter, leaving Dyche with a decision to make at right-back

Everton go into their first game since their nine-minute nightmare at the end of their match against Bournemouth before the international break, hoping to make immediate amends in Saturday's televised clash with Aston Villa.

Sean Dyche's team somehow let a 2-0 lead slip by conceding twice in stoppage time and lost 3-2 before heading into a two-week hiatus from Premier League action with plenty of time to ruminate on what went wrong and how to fix it.

The manager was asked during his pre-match press conference how he explains an implosion like the one his team suffered in that match and how he and his staff go about picking the players up after such a psychological setback.

“I’d like to think after [my] 20 months here, the players would have learned to deal with those situations," Dyche replied. "Obviously, we didn’t on the day; we didn’t do the things that were necessary to see the game through and we’ve got to continually learn from that.

Article continues below video content


“You know, the game’s never over. I’ve been asked many times about not celebrating goals, and that’s why — the game’s never over. Until the game’s finished., then you can have a quiet celebration in my case, but that’s why I don’t go running up and down the pitch and that sort of stuff because the game [can] change.

“Against Bournemouth was a good example of that when the game should be dead, we know that. [A] very strong performance for 87-ish minutes and then we all saw what went on next.

“That was a really hard one to take and it happens from time to time. Fortunately not very often but it did happen, so how we deal with that and we talk to the players [is important] but most of them are mature enough to see if through and we just didn’t do that.”

Seamus Coleman has been described by Dyche as "touch and go" for this one after sustaining a knock on international duty with Ireland last weekend.

The Club captain had to be withdrawn from the Nations League match against England after taking a kick to the ankle from Harry Maguire but he has a small chance of being involved at Villa Park.

Dyche said that he will be assessed during the team's training session on Friday morning before any decision is made but the manager reiterated that Nathan Patterson and Jarrad Branthwaite remain a way from match fitness after recovering from their respective hamstring and hernia surgeries.

Both players have returned to training with the first-team in the hope that they can either figure in the Carabao Cup tie against Southampton next Tuesday or against Leicester the following Saturday.

Meanwhile, Orel Mangala is poised for this first involvement as an Everton player after arriving from Lyon on loan on transfer deadline day.

The Belgian went straight to join up with his Red Devils team-mates for their international fixtures over the break but arrived at Finch Farm "bright and breezy and wants to be part of the group", in Dyche's words and he is expected to be in the squad for the trip to Villa Park.

The former Nottingham Forest midfielder will wear the No.8 shirt vacated by Amadou Onana who joined the Villans over the summer in a £50m deal and if Mangala is handed his debut, the two compatriots could face off in midfield this weekend.

Onana, who made his own debut off the bench for Everton in this fixture two years ago, has made a strong start to life in the Midlands with two goals in his first three Premier League games but the Blues will be hoping for a repeat of their performance in the EFL Cup on this ground last season as opposed to the 4-0 drubbing they suffered against Unai Emery's men 13 months ago.

Everton ended Villa's long unbroken sequence of home wins by defeating them handsomely in the third round tie, with James Garner and Dominic Calvert-Lewin on target in a 2-1 victory.

Coleman's likely absence this weekend leaves a problem once again at right back where Ashley Young is Dyche's preferred option when fit again, even if James Garner might be better suited due to his comparative youth and versatility. It's almost inconceivable that the conservative Dyche would consider young Roman Dixon, despite his strong debut against Tottenham last month.

Assuming the manager doesn't opt for a back five, the central-defensive pairing is likely to be unchanged with Branthwaite still out. Michael Keane has been preferred to Jake O’Brien and almost certainly will again given the fact that the latter has yet to play a single Premier League minute for the club since arriving from Lyon.

The game will see other reunions, with Tim Iroegbunam returning to his old stomping ground and Lucas Digne going up against his former club once more. And, regrettably, this match will also reunite the referee/VAR double-act of Craig Pawson and David Coote who oversaw the hugely controversial Anfield derby last season.

Iliman Ndiaye is surely a shoo-in after his revelatory display against Bournemouth and will likely be deployed in the same front attacking as against the Cherries with Jack Harrison and Dwight McNeil.

Villa come into the game having won two of their opening three fixtures, with their only defeat coming to title-chasing Arsenal at the Emirates. They will be strong favorites based on their excellent 2023–24 season and Everton's horrific start to the current campaign.

However, they no longer boast the awesome home record that they did when the two teams last met at Villa Park — they have only won a third of their last dozen home fixtures and have the added distraction of their first Champions League match looming on Tuesday.

Nevertheless, they have attacking talent in abundance even with Leon Bailey almost certain to miss out. The Jamaican winger, who scored this game last season, has a hamstring injury and will be sidelined but Emery is hopeful that summer Everton transfer target Jaden Philogene could replace him if he is passed fit.

Matty Cash and Diego Carlos are also ruled out along with longer-term absentees Boubacar Kamara and Tyrone Mings but there had been no news about Ollie Watkins, who came back early from England duty with an unspecified issue, until Friday morning.  

The striker netted a penalty in a 2-0 Villa win at Goodison Park in February last year and, as such, wouldn't be missed by Dyche and company this weekend but Emery has confirmed he is available.

First and foremost, the Blues fans who will be travelling down en masse to Birmingham will want to see a response in terms of the performance from Dyche's men. A positive result of any kind would be warmly received but avoiding the kind of hiding the Toffees suffered here last season is a must.

Kick-off: 5:30 pm, Saturday 14 September 2024
Referee: Craig Pawson
VAR: David Coote
Last Time: Aston Villa 4 - 0 Everton

Predicted Line-up: Pickford, Young, Keane, Tarkowski, Mykolenko, Gueye, Iroegbunam, Harrison, McNeil, Ndiaye, Calvert-Lewin

 

Reader Comments (139)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Paul Birmingham
1 Posted 12/09/2024 at 20:32:58
Villa and get the 3 points on Saturday..

Everton, please do the doable this Saturday.

Danny O'Neill
2 Posted 12/09/2024 at 20:45:34
It will be interesting to see what team Dyche puts out, especially the defence.

Branthwaite and Patterson training, but not ready.

Seamus "touch and go".

Mangala available, midfield we are okay.

No Chermiti or Broja.

I wonder who will partner Tarkowski? The manager has two choices: Keane or O'Brien.

Paul Kernot
3 Posted 12/09/2024 at 22:12:30
Dixon. No brainer.

Start him this week and give him a run.

James Marshall
5 Posted 12/09/2024 at 22:55:52
We're going to get battered by Villa.

At least 3-0 I reckon.

Derek Thomas
6 Posted 12/09/2024 at 23:07:33
Play Dixon - close thread. Sorted.
Laurie Hartley
7 Posted 12/09/2024 at 23:14:49
I thought Dixon played very well against Spurs and can’t understand why he didn’t start against Bournemouth.
Andy Crooks
8 Posted 12/09/2024 at 23:35:01
That's the spirit, James.
Si Cooper
9 Posted 12/09/2024 at 23:38:59
I’d play Dixon but we all know Ashley Young is most likely starter.
Hoping to be pleasantly surprised by the line-up on Saturday and then ecstatic when those thrown together despite the manager’s normal reticence to deviate from his ‘tried and trusted’ picks, repay it with a show-stopping victory!
Ajay Gopal
10 Posted 13/09/2024 at 04:55:43
I would play James Garner at right back – remember, he played that position very well in that crucial survival game against Bournemouth. Mangala should be fine partnering Gana and Iron Tim in midfield.

Pickford

Garner Tarkowski Keane Mykolenko

Iroegbunam Mangala Gana

Harrison Calvert-Lewin Ndiaye

Subs: Beto, McNeil, Lindstrøm, Doucoure, Armstrong, Young, Dixon, O'Brien, Virginia

Peter Moore
11 Posted 13/09/2024 at 05:11:35
As we know, it's 11 vs 11. The ball is a round bag of wind. We did not perform properly in the corresponding fixture last season, duly battered 0-4.

Then, shortly afterwards, a chance for revenge in the League Cup. A rare home defeat for a strong Villa side, we showed more fight and togetherness and victory resulted.

May there be fight and togetherness for the entire match this time, not less than the entire match til the final whistle.

I am sure the magnificent away support will give their all throughout and may the lads match the spirit, fight and quality. May the best team on the day win. May that team be us. 🙏 COYB

Danny O'Neill
12 Posted 13/09/2024 at 06:26:57
I'm not one for predicting lineups as you never know what the manager will do.

Lyndon is never too far off the mark and glad to see Ndiaye; he has to feature in my opinion.

I would rather see O'Brien than Keane… So now watch Keane go and score the winner!!

Who cares as long we get something?

Kunal Desai
13 Posted 13/09/2024 at 07:19:44
I'd like us to at least see some kind of performance away from home but we know Dyche is likely to play Young and Keane in defence and sit back and defend the entire 90 minutes.

I'm sorry but this will be one to write-off. I'm expecting a similar result to Spurs. Leicester away is the big one and one we need all 3 points from.

Andrew Clare
14 Posted 13/09/2024 at 07:33:29
Villa are going in the opposite direction to us. Hopefully we won't spend the game chasing shadows.

I remember waiting 15 years for our time to come after the excitement of the sixties. Then Howard Kendall delivered an exciting time in the eighties.

Somehow 37 years since our last league championship seems far too long – are we 'out of the picture'now?
Another gruelling season ahead, me thinks.

Neil Lawson
15 Posted 13/09/2024 at 07:54:48
Dyche is fighting for his future. If he is as conservative and intransigent as always, then he has only himself to blame when he is sacked.

Perhaps he will sub himself off in the 87th minute (but not his fault if things go badly thereafter).

Lee Courtliff
16 Posted 13/09/2024 at 07:55:09
We haven't beaten Villa in the League since they came back up 5 years ago, they've got their first ever Champions League game in a few days and a few injuries to contend with... hopefully Watkins is one of them!

This is the perfect set up for us to go and get an unexpected victory, typical of Everton to win when nobody outside of Goodison gives us a chance.

I'm going for 2-nil.

Paul Ferry
17 Posted 13/09/2024 at 08:01:42
“I'd like to think after [my] 20 months here, the players would have learned to deal with those situations," Dyche replied. "Obviously, we didn't on the day; we didn't do the things that were necessary to see the game through and we've got to continually learn from that.

He still accepts no fucking responsibility 12 days later. So what do you "continually learn from", Dyche?

Lyndon's team looks about the best in current circumstances with don't-blame-me-yer-wazzack-twats in charge.

Not picking Ndiaye to start will be footy insanity, but the three hard-boiled eggs are capable of anything.

Danny Baily
18 Posted 13/09/2024 at 08:17:51
“That was a really hard one to take and it happens from time to time."

But it doesn't, Sean. That was the biggest collapse in Premier League history.

As for tomorrow, eyes might as well be on the end of the month and the visit of Crystal Palace. Everything in the meantime is a distraction.

Mal van Schaick
19 Posted 13/09/2024 at 08:23:56
Play Dixon. Pack the midfield and counter attack.

Dogs of war for a 1-0 away win.

Rob Dolby
20 Posted 13/09/2024 at 08:25:04
Pickford
Young Tarkowski Keane Mykolenko
Harrison Gana Iroegbunam Mangala McNeil
Calvert-Lewin

Sit deep and hit them on the break, no other tactics will work.

A betting man would go all in on Villa to win this.

Not sure I get the fascination with playing O'Brien, he can't get in the Ireland team.

Paul Ferry
21 Posted 13/09/2024 at 08:25:59
I have always hated and still fucking hate the 'Dogs of War' tag.

I was at Elland Road, as so many of us were, and we played the cocky twats off the park.

Nigel Scowen
22 Posted 13/09/2024 at 08:52:01
Rob @20,

I also would go for Mangala – but no Ndiaye, Rob? He wouldn't dare surely!

Brian Harrison
23 Posted 13/09/2024 at 09:20:38
I read the comments Sean Dyche made in his press conference yesterday. He said he has watched the Bournemouth game back 47 times and, in his opinion, his substitutions made no difference to the outcome.

So, after watching it an unbelievable 47 times, he couldn't see that both Iroegbunam and Coleman were struggling – yet most of us inside Goodison could see they were both struggling after 75 minutes.

Seamus hasn't played much and Tim is still getting used to playing regularly in the Premier League, so it was understandable that both would struggle to see out the 90 minutes, in Tim's case he covered acres of ground during the game.

I think Dyche knows that, when the takeover happens (if it happens), his days are numbered; he is talking like somebody who knows the writing is on the wall.

So again he takes no responsibility for the defeat; instead, he blames the players. Yes, they have to take responsibility. But for me, the players played well for long periods.

If he can't realize that taking off your two main attacking threats gave Bournemouth the green light to throw men forward, then it's very worrying.

Daniel A Johnson
24 Posted 13/09/2024 at 09:21:28
The biggest kicker is Coleman.

He can barely string 2-3 club matches together as it is yet at his age he insists on still playing international football. As a result, he gets injured 'again'.

He is now taking the piss. Supposedly a great bloke but one who is now stealing a living off Everton. If he had any respect for the club, he would retire from international duty.

Robert Tressell
25 Posted 13/09/2024 at 09:27:55
Although Dixon did himself plenty of credit against Spurs, it did unbalance the side – and obviously we still got thrashed.

The radio commentators for the game made the point that Dixon was playing very narrow and close to Tarkowski, so the latter could help him positionally – and also to leave less space available to beat Dixon one one-on-one.

However, this left a lot of space to attack into on our right flank – and Harrison therefore did his dutiful but boring job of tracking back and becoming an auxiliary RB instead of any sort of attacking threat.

To put in another way, the team and tactics adjusted to make sure Dixon was not hung out to dry on his debut. This helped Dixon, but exposed all sorts of weaknesses across the rest of the side.

I think Young's value (to the extent he offers anything) is now to play a bit higher up the pitch in later stages of games to keep hold of possession. He can't be used as a full-back.

So the options are to go with Dixon in the usual 4-4-1-1 – and maybe trust him to look after Philogene or Rogers without Harrison as Chaperone. Or go 3-5-1-1 and put Garner and McNeil or Mykolenko as wing-backs.

Neither of these options really get us past the fact that, even with Coleman in the side, we have the weakest right flank in the Premier League. There's no tactical solution to overcome that.

However, I quite like the wing backs option because we can then have the aerial threat of Keane, Tarkowski and O'Brien at corners and set-pieces. During open play, the three big lads can sit deep and hopefully repel whatever Villa hit us with.

Dave Abrahams
26 Posted 13/09/2024 at 09:28:12
With all due respect to Seamus, I don't think him or Young are big losses anymore,

If Dyche doesn't trust Dixon, then play Garner there; if he does trust him, play Garner in midfield and utilise him there along with Iroegbunam, Gana and Mangala during the game.

Dyche has five substitutions to use during the game — let's hope he has a good look at using them all if necessary.

Nigel Scowen
27 Posted 13/09/2024 at 09:32:55
Brian @23,

He doesn't seem to get the correlation between players being spent and then making mistakes such as in midfield and defence.

Also, having watched it 47 times, he still can't see the consequences of taking Ndiaye and Calvert-Lewin off and the subsequent loss of momentum that caused.

He just makes it worse for himself.

Dave Abrahams
28 Posted 13/09/2024 at 09:42:01
Robert (25),

I thought Mykolenko was more of a problem v Spurs than Dixon's performance was and he was even poorer v Bournemouth. He certainly doesn't add very much going forward as a wingback whereas Dixon's pace and willingness to get up the field, attack and get crosses in will improve the more we play and with players moving back to cover his position when he goes on these raids upfield.

I realise Mykolenko is the only genuine left-back on the books and that makes the problem huge. Maybe play the young Irish lad there, at least he will be useful at corners both ends of the field.

Jimmy Carr
29 Posted 13/09/2024 at 09:58:55
Whilst I thought some of the comments here following the last game were way over the top, it will still be interesting to see whether Dyche is more proactive with his subs in this match. That will tell us whether he's learnt anything from the last game, not what he says in a press conference.

It will also be interesting to see how the players react in this one; a subdued performance will tell us they may have felt they were 'thrown under the bus' by Sean Dyche after the Bournemouth debacle. I don't for a minute believe they were, but let's see what happens.

I think we should take some positives going into this one. We scored two and created other chances in the last game. We have more creative players for Dom to feed off. A point at Villa would be good, three would be dreamland but we have players capable of hurting them, I hope to see a positive reaction regardless of Dyche's team selection.

COYB.

Jimmy Carr
30 Posted 13/09/2024 at 10:03:48
By the way, I didn't watch the press conference but did he really say he watched the game back '47 times'?

If that's correct, he's having a laugh, and/or trolling the journalists in the room. There wouldn't be time to watch the game back 47 times, that has to be Dyche's somewhat obtuse sense of humour.

Mark Murphy
31 Posted 13/09/2024 at 10:16:10
I'm a big fan of Mykolenko but Dave is right – he's bang off it at the moment. How about a back three of O'Brien, Tarkowski and Keane with McNeil and Harrison as wing-backs?

Or (as I agree with some with doubts on O'Brien and haven't seen enough to judge if he's the answer), bring Mykolenko inside so he's not exposed to the pacey winger?

Anyway, I stupidly agreed to an early meal out with my missus and sons before checking the kick-off time so I won't get to watch this – probably a good thing... UTFT

Robert Tressell
32 Posted 13/09/2024 at 10:19:02
Dave, that's sort of my point. Dixon was protected from putting in a poor performance and the adjustments exposed others. There's no easy solution to any of this without Branthwaite in the side – because his pace, quality and left foot probably make Mykolenko and Tarkowski more effective (they've both been poor so far this season).

O'Brien, being 6ft-6in and right-footed, is a bit of an unlikely shout for the left-back slot if that's what you mean.

As for Dyche saying he watched the match 47 times, I presume it's not meant to be taken literally and just means "lots".

Eddie Dunn
33 Posted 13/09/2024 at 10:29:05
Strangely those criticising Keane should focus on Tarkowski, who went on a terrible run last season and seems to escape the same scrutiny.

Mykolenko has been roasted at times and his forays down the wing have seen him gift the ball for counter-attacks.
McNeil is so ineffective and yet gets picked every game. It's baffling.

I would start with Keane and have Dixon at right-back. A point or three would do wonders for us and shut the carping from the media. I fancy us to bounce back and win.

Jim Wilson
34 Posted 13/09/2024 at 11:02:13
Playing Young is utter madness. He is too old and he is a liability.

I said it before the Brighton game and I will say it again. How many minutes will pass before he is sent off?

People can nitpick Dixon's performance against Spurs all they like (actually an admission that he did well) but he is a far far better option than Young.

To be clear: Young is finished. It is an embarrassing nightmare selection, yet again, if picked.

Christy Ring
35 Posted 13/09/2024 at 11:07:34
Looking at Dyche's press conference and trying to justifying his substitutions, saying Ndiaye hasn't played a lot of football and Dom with his previous injuries to me was total crap, both players were the stand-out performers.

It was Coleman's first Premier League game of the season and he left him on for the full game. Tim Irooegbunam was gone after 70 minutes, if he watched the game back 47 times, he must have seen that?

Against Villa he has to add Mangala or Garner in midfield or they'll slice through us, two in midfield is a disaster and play Garner or Dixon at full-back, but knowing Sean, he'll stick to his Plan A.

Jim Wilson
36 Posted 13/09/2024 at 11:12:54
Christy @ 35 – I agree. We need a strong midfield with Dixon or Garner at full-back or it will be another shambles.

If Dyche plays Young, that is the end of him for me.

Steve Brown
37 Posted 13/09/2024 at 11:15:01
Robert @ 25, I attended the Spurs game and that is not what happened at all.

Both full-backs played narrow and it was evidently under instruction – not to protect Dixon but to set up in a fairly defensive shape away from home for Dyche.

Dixon was not given “protection” by Tarkowski at all. He had to independently manage his position when facing Odbert in the first half and Son in the second half – he did it excellently. Harrison did not track back any more than normal and Dixon's pace and athleticism helped our attack.

Your contortions to justify why Academy players would weaken the team are getting more elaborate by the week. And comical.

And your answer? Repeat the disastrous error of playing Ashley Young at right-back that failed so badly at home to Brighton.

Honestly.

James Marshall
38 Posted 13/09/2024 at 11:27:34
To my mind, this has all the hallmarks of another twatting.

Anything better than a 3-0 loss will surprise me.

Robert Tressell
39 Posted 13/09/2024 at 11:50:39
Strange post # 37, Steve.

I've said the options at right-back are Dixon and Garner. I've said specifically that Young can't be used as a full-back (although I can see why he was in earlier games).

And as per lots of articles I've written and comments in threads over the years, I'm very keen for us to use academy players. I'd sincerely like us to become an academy led club.

The main point I made a few weeks ago is that, when the shit hits the fan, there seems to be an expectation that youth can dig us out if only we'd give them a chance – when sadly we haven't invested enough in the academy to provide the requisite quality.

Hopefully Dixon kicks on and bucks a trend.

Jim Wilson
40 Posted 13/09/2024 at 12:02:34
I see the bad refereeing will now kick in.

Pawson, all so predictable…

Dave Abrahams
41 Posted 13/09/2024 at 12:20:40
Robert (32),

I think Branthwaite actually benefited by having Tarkowski next to him when he first came into the team as did the whole defence, this season I don't think Tarkowski is fully fit, he has not been his usual dominant self.

As for O'Brien being 6ft-6in and, being right-footed, not being suitable for left back, I don't think it's stopped Dan Burn at Newcastle being an adequate full back at 6ft-7in – plus O'Brien is not useless with his left foot.

Steve Brown
42 Posted 13/09/2024 at 12:38:01
Strange post indeed, Robert @ 25 & 39.

An in-depth analysis based on what you heard on the radio.

Danny O'Neill
43 Posted 13/09/2024 at 12:43:54
Some sensible comments.

I can see Garner playing there, but we have options in midfield.

We don't have many forward options, so a lot will rely on support to Dominic from the midfield. Take your pick from Ndiaye, McNeil, Doucoure, Idrissa, Iroegbunam, Mangala and, depending on the right-back decision, Garner.

We've been getting targeted on the flanks for the past couple of seasons and the defence has played narrow. Tarkowski has been trying to do everything, which is an impossible task. Young Dixon is still learning, Mykolenko off sorts and Branthwaite out, who Tarkowski struck up a good partnership with.

Let's see what the manager does. We don't have any control over it.

Christy Ring
44 Posted 13/09/2024 at 13:21:18
O'Brien is right-footed, but he's always played as left-sided centre-back.

It would give us a better balance if he played with Tarkowski.

Andy Peers
45 Posted 13/09/2024 at 13:33:26
If he plays Young, then he hasn't learned a fucking thing!!!
Danny O'Neill
46 Posted 13/09/2024 at 13:43:33
That is a good shout, Dave.

I called it a few weeks ago that Tarkowski looked like he was playing with an injury and wasn't fully fit.

Danny O'Neill
47 Posted 13/09/2024 at 14:09:37
Go with confidence tomorrow, Blues. No fear.

If you need to, take your inhalers. If not, you can borrow mine.

We go into any match believing we can win. The manager will pick the team. We will support those players on the pitch as always.

Mark Murphy
48 Posted 13/09/2024 at 14:15:47
And don't give them shite at the train station if we lose.

And for fuck's sake don't boo Calvert-Lewin off if he's got a face like Peter Beardsley…

John Raftery
49 Posted 13/09/2024 at 14:16:44
I expect a reaction from the players. We are due to beat Villa in the league. Losing sequences must end at some point. No better time than tomorrow.

We now have better options in midfield plus more pace and threat in attack. With improved defensive shape, this is a game in which we can gain control from the outset and win.

Tony McDonald
50 Posted 13/09/2024 at 14:19:17
We know his mind by now. He'd play the same team if he could. Which means the only possible change will be at right-back... take your pick.

For me, it's Dixon, but he could play Garner. I don't think he'll risk Young. Forget these calls for O'Brien. In an abysmal back 4, Keane has stood head and shoulders above the other three in every game.

It's not a high bar though. He'll definitely play 4-2-3-1 and be prepared to change it to 4-5-1. We have a chance.

Rob Halligan
51 Posted 13/09/2024 at 15:24:14
James # 5 & # 38…

It looks like a lot of thought went into those posts, as opposed to next to no thought whatsoever for the 3000 fans making the journey to Villa Park tomorrow.

I seriously wonder why some people bother calling themselves Evertonians?

Mark Murphy
52 Posted 13/09/2024 at 15:24:26
Tiny, only because he’s taller..
UTFT
Brian Williams
53 Posted 13/09/2024 at 15:30:46
What's up, James @ 5 and 38?

Did you not get the attention you're obviously seeking in post 5 so had to follow it up with post 38 saying the same thing in a different way?

I just don't get some people, I really don't.

Sure we're all allowed and encouraged to have an opinion but why the fuck any Evertonian would actually put in the effort to typing posts like that before a ball is kicked rather than posting nowt is truly beyond me.

Jay Harris
54 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:01:16
For me, Garner is a shoo-in at right-back and I would certainly give O'Brien a run out in place of Keane who turns like the Titanic and always lets players run in behind him.

I also think this is a game for Mangala so I would play 4 across the midfield: Gana, Mangala, Iroegbunam and McNeil, with Calvert-Lewin and Ndiaye up front.

This should beef up our midfield and enable us to hit them on the break.

Mark Murphy
55 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:12:04
Ahh Brian, there you are….

I missed you on the other thread mate….

Anyway, I don't know about you but I don't understand why people like @38 bother.. why predict a loss? Anything can happen on a match day.UTFT

Dale Self
56 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:22:58
For what it is worth, my opinion that is, James 38 doesn't do the doom thing. When he posts an opinion it is genuine or clever irony. Worthy of consideration every time, even if it goes against one's own opinions.
Mike McQuaid
57 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:26:45
Sorry to change the subject. I've been travelling from Scotland to Goodison since I was a teenager in the 80s and this is the first time I've been unable to get a ticket as they're all sold (for the Crystal Palace game). I'd already booked accommodation for the weekend. Is there any chance of the club putting extra tickets on sale before the game? I'm thinking maybe some hotel+ticket packages might be unsold.
Mark Murphy
58 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:34:25
Mike, I too have to travel a long way to Goodison, in the other direction, so I got a membership.

In the past, this has served me well but this season I've applied for tickets so far for 3 games as soon as I got the alert but there were no tickets available each time.

I get that this is the last season at Goodison Park so I'm really concerned I won't get to enjoy at least one game.

Serves me right for marrying a bloody southerner, I suppose. UTFT

Colin Callaghan
59 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:41:24
Hey Steve @42,

What radio station said all the stuff that Rob said??

I agreed with most and would like to tune in.

Mike McQuaid
60 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:42:36
Thanks, Mark. Yes, I'm worried too!

At least my last game was a win: 1-0 v Brentford last season.

Steve Brown
61 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:43:08
Colin, I think it was Deluded FM.

I would have tuned in but I was at the game and actually watching it.

Simon Harrison
62 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:43:15
Looking at the current squad, we are pretty much the most threadbare in the Premier League.

With the current injuries to Branthwaite, Patterson, Chermiti (if not deemed fit) don't help our last season's 4th ranked defence.

The announced knock to Tarkowski has been showing in his appearances thus far. As is the probable situation with an obviously not fully fit Mykolenko.

Keane has been the 'obvious' target of abuse by fans who can't actually see that he has been the most effective defender so far this season (ignoring the one-off show by Dixon, who still made mistakes and really should have taken one for the team and stopped the 3rd Spurs goal by fouling van den Ven).

Mykolenko has repeatedly felt his ankle in every game this season, and I personally don't think he's fully fit yet, plus for some reason, this season the same as last, he doesn't seem to shine (or look confident) when partnered with Keane (pretty much like Tarkowski, to be honest).

Therefore, I would hope that Dyche either picks O'Brien or goes with a back three of Tarkowski, Keane and O'Brien.

If a back four, stick with Mykolenko at left-back, and keep Young on the bench to cover him, with Garner or Dixon at right-back.

Midfield would be Harrison, Mangala or Gueye, Iroegbunam and McNeil, with Ndiaye at No 10 and Calvert-Lewin at No 9, 4-4-1-1:

Pickford,
Garner (Dixon), Tarkowski, O'Brien, Mykolenko
Harrison, Mangala (Gueye), Iroegbunam, McNeil
Ndiaye
Calvert-Lewin

Or play a 3-5-1-1, or 3-5-2

Pickford
Tarkowski, Keane, O'Brien
Harrison, Garner, Mangala (Gueye), Iroegbunam, McNeil
Ndiaye
Calvert-Lewin

Tarkowski, Keane, O'Brien
Harrison, Garner, Mangala (Gueye), Iroegbunam, McNeil
Calvert-Lewin, Beto

I would just like to see a proper 95+ minute performance, some proactive subs, or at least the correct reactive ones, some sports analysts on the bench, some proper attitude from the players, and I hope 1 if not 3 points.

Dyche really is in need of a 'statement' performance tomorrow, which includes his selection, subs and game and player management during the game.

If we go 0-4 tomorrow with a -10 GD, that is a big hole to start to gain momentum from, and might even arouse Moshiri from his hands-off approach...

Good luck and good wishes to all the travelling fans tomorrow. (And those watching from afar!)

COYB

Christopher Timmins
63 Posted 13/09/2024 at 16:50:44
If we get the first 87 minutes of the last game for all of tomorrow's game, we will get a positive result.
Rob Dolby
64 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:03:54
Nigel 22,

I'd forgotten about Ndiaye...He has to start after his debut.

Maybe Mangala will be on the bench.

Raymond Fox
65 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:14:17
We had the 4th best defence in the league last season, but looking at the likely defensive players tomorrow doesn't fill me with much confidence now.
Right backs a problem, I'm not a big fan of Mykolenko but he's all we have. We appear to be missing Branthwaite greatly, we are all over the place in defence.

I do think we will be better going forward, we look much stronger now in the middle, Ndiaye and Iroegbunam also look more of a threat. When we get all the new players settled in I think we will fine but the defence is looking like our achilles heel.

I think we will score tomorrow but we will probably need 2 or 3 to win.

Nigel Scowen
66 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:15:11
Rob@64

Rob, I’d start with Mangala and Tim in centre mid and use Gana as back up, if any of the midfielders tire.

I would also play Dixon at right back with Garner covering, or the other way round.

I think Coleman, Gana and Young should only ever be used as cover for fatigued players now for the last 20 minutes.

Andy Crooks
67 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:22:18
Good post, Brian@ 53. The least we can do is give attention seekers attention
James, take a fucking red neck.

Billy Shears
68 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:27:11
The good news...we will score.
The bad news...The Villains will score a few themselves!.

We're on Sky...low on confidence,with key players still missing.

3-1 home win methinks & the misery continues...sigh.

Bill Hawker
69 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:46:11
2-0 to Villa and I think I'm being generous to this Everton team that currently has a weak defense in front of Pickford and a lack of threat up front.
Stu Darlington
70 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:47:27
Christopher @63
Good shout.We played them off the park for that 87 minutes and could have scored 4 or 5,playing some good positive football.
If the players can put that nightmare behind them and play like they played last week for the whole game I believe they can get a result at Villa.
However if they come out with their heads down it could be another story.
Using a football managers old cliche,we can take a lot of positives from that performance.Lets hope we do.
Steve Brown
71 Posted 13/09/2024 at 17:49:25
I always think we will win - though I am disappointed more often than not.
James Marshall
72 Posted 13/09/2024 at 18:13:16
I completely forgot I'd already posted on this thread - I'm not completely mental.

I'm realistic - we've been shite this season and they stuck 4 past us last season as I recall? Apologies for the repeat post to those who got offended. Clearly I'm not a real Evertonian despite following Everton for 42 years.

Shame on me for having an opinion - and the 30,000 people going to the game must be desperately upset with my shameful comments.

I will now go away and self flagellate with a piece of birch tree and say 30,000 hail Mary's which I hope will go some way to recompensing those I have so horribly saddened.

Please forgive me.

Rob Halligan
73 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:17:28
And there was me thinking football matches were decided by what happens on the day, not what happened 12 months ago!!

You learn something new every day!

James Marshall
74 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:23:05
Oh come off it, Rob. It's just an opinion based on recent results and them hammering us last season.

I hope I'm wrong but I don't see any reason to think otherwise.

Rob Halligan
75 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:28:25
So why didn't we beat Bournemouth comfortably the other week, James? After all, we comfortably beat them last season.

I agree, our recent results haven't been good, in fact bloody awful, but certainly the first half against Brighton I think we were the better team, and we definitely weren't shite against Bournemouth.

As I say, it's on the day what matters, and hopefully it's our day tomorrow.

Derek Powell
76 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:29:46
My fear is, knowing Dyche, he will revert to defend defend defend:

Pickford
Young
Tarkowski
Keane
Mykolenko
Garner
Gueye
Doucouré
Harrison
McNeil
Calvert-Lewin

Hope I am wrong but that's what my gut says.

Dave Cashen
77 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:32:34
I'm dying to see Dixon given a run, but not tomorrow.

We're not playing well enough to stop the inevitable Villa waves of attack and when they get in full flow the Holt End can produce as intimidating a noise as it gets. It is not just about introducing youngsters because you don't like the alternative.

You have to choose the moments. Not throw them in to see if they swim. I suspect most Premier League managers would believe they were acting irresponsibly if they threw a kid into a team playing this poorly.

Tarkowski has been poor this season but, if I remember rightly, he took a few games to get into his stride last season too. If he defends well, we defend well. I expect our boys to stand firm and defiant tomorrow. I also think we will score.

Still 105 points to play for. For the life of me, I don't understand why any Evertonian would want to concede any of them before we even get on the bus.

Alastair Donaldson
78 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:33:42
When did we last win at Villa?

I dream of Kevin Sheedy's volley, 85? We could do with similar brilliance now eh. 97 goals, #legend.

Praying for an upset!

Dave Cashen
79 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:36:02
Last time we played there, Alastair.
Fred Quick
80 Posted 13/09/2024 at 19:49:30
Of course Everton can win tomorrow… and if they don't, they can still survive in the Premier League. All good or bad runs come to an end sometime, it depends how the team play and whether they're up for the challenge.

Recent form and past performances will have many selecting Villa as a banker for tomorrow, but that doesn't mean that will definitely happen.

There's no point in giving up before kick-off, and hopefully the manager and players don't take that sort of attitude on to the pitch with them.

The pundits and so-called experts are almost gleefully predicting our demise, let's hope the players rise to the occasion tomorrow and in all of our future games and shove it right back in their faces.

Ernie Baywood
81 Posted 13/09/2024 at 20:31:19
I'm trying to focus on how good and enjoyable that first 83 minutes was.

We might actually be worth watching.

We've probably all got unreasonable expectations of Ndiaye now but not picking him would surely be managerial suicide.

Jay Evans
82 Posted 13/09/2024 at 21:30:56
What an incredibly tough read this thread is.

So far.

Cue George McKane. 💙

James Newcombe
83 Posted 13/09/2024 at 22:23:29
Sorry to say it, but Young was dreadful in this fixture last season. They'll be targeting him for sure. I'd play five at the back, personally.
Tom Bowers
84 Posted 13/09/2024 at 23:20:13
Football was and still is a funny old game.
Teams win games that they are not favoured to win and lose others they should win.

Meltdown's happen and players make hairbrained errors which cost teams points.

I, like everyone else hope the last game was a one off and that Dyche has got the mental problems sorted for the next game tomorrow.

Sadly some arguably key members of the squad are still injured and that means people like the aging Young may still be in the starting eleven.

Villa have some very quick players and that could be too much for the creaky Blues defence to cope with.

It's going to take a big showing defensively to get anything from this game as we all know but anything can happen on any given day so let's hope it's one of those days.

Dale Self
85 Posted 13/09/2024 at 23:39:44
Relax. I just bought some Lagunitas Maximus and it rells me 1-2 Everton is the result. It's the beer talking and I believe it. UTGDMFT!

xG!xG!xG!

Si Cooper
86 Posted 13/09/2024 at 23:53:31
“If he can't realize that taking off your two main attacking threats gave Bournemouth the green light to throw men forward, then it's very worrying.”

That isn't what happened though, Brian. Bournemouth didn't ‘accelerate' in the final 10 minutes of that game – they simply ‘sustained'.

I'd agree with Dyche that his substitutions didn't cost us the game as they were (near enough) like for like. It was the substitutions he didn't make that enabled Bournemouth to ‘overtake' us simply by keeping their work rate up whilst, throughout our midfield and defence, players were ‘hitting the wall'.

I hope Dyche has learned something about how the game is (still) progressing – even if he isn't broadcasting it – but I need to see evidence of it starting from tomorrow.

Bill Piscass
87 Posted 14/09/2024 at 00:42:33
Pub manager at the old dog, what we going to get tomorrow, not much interplay, tactics all over the place… another hard-fought depressing day ahead.

By the way, the dog is fed up with it. My shouting at the laptop. I have given up with positivity, turn it off after 2-nil.

I wanted Bielsa, now I want Moyes, because all the trendy options with nice hair and now the three buttock-ed mooners have failed.

Steve Brown
88 Posted 14/09/2024 at 03:55:36
Bill, 50% of Everton fans will instantly reject Moyes so that is a non-starter.
Tim Greeley
89 Posted 14/09/2024 at 03:57:41
Yeah, I still hate every single one of them with every goddamn molecule of my motherfucking body for the way that last one ended, and what it meant to me for other reasons.

Nothing short of a Chet Hanks sized shocker right through Villa's fraudulent rectum will get me back on board. Any chance that happens!?!?! Nope!!!

Jack Convery
90 Posted 14/09/2024 at 06:41:13
With regards to Mykolenko, last season was his best in a blue shirt. Tarkowski too had a great season. Could it be, that both perform better with Branthwaite between them?

At least they don't have to worry about him and know he's got their back when the pressure comes on. Whereas…

Danny O'Neill
91 Posted 14/09/2024 at 06:46:01
Well Moyes is irrelevant about today and as Steve says if the second coming did happen, it would be decisive. If we do end up changing, then look forward, not to the past.

Sean Dyche is in charge today and he will pick the team. Any game is winnable.

Go out on that pitch with confidence and belief blues, because those travelling 3,000 supporters will do.

And wear blue!!

Derek Thomas
93 Posted 14/09/2024 at 07:40:30
Touch and Go?

Gone is the correct answer and Dixon it is then, every game, until, taken over the whole game, there is somebody better – and, up to now, there isn't.

Paul Birmingham
94 Posted 14/09/2024 at 07:54:40
I'm hoping the break has helped the manager, coaches and squad recharge their batteries and mindset.

Villa, like every team, can be beaten, and today Everton can earn the right to play and take their chances and win.

Jimmy Garner at right-back if he is available, else Dixon.

But believe and believe. Forget the press, the vultures and focus on the game.

A cracking stadium at Villa and hopefully a perfect weather day for football.

Now is the time Everton, to deliver. Turn up and play and win.

UTFTs!

Danny Baily
95 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:05:48
Can't see anything other than a defeat today.
Paul Ferry
96 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:20:58
What was the point of that deeply thoughtful and nuanced post Danny - 95? Why not keep that negative shite to yourself? It helps no one. We don't need it.

I'm off to bed here in Chicago after perhaps too much dry white. Thank Sheeds it's an 11:30 AM kick-off for us over here.

We will not lose, Danny, but if we do, congratulations to you and you will deserve your 'Fecking told yer so, I called it'.

Meanwhile, Danny O, Rob, Neil, Brent etc. Thanks for being there. We can get something from this. Be loud and proud.

We have a result in us after the 87 minutes vs Bournemouth, but that would mean the three hard-boiled eggs would have to get it right this time. Dyche, start Ndiaye and keep a fucking eye on your flagging midfielders and defenders.

Mark Murphy
97 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:23:12
Danny
Why?
Why do you feel the need to write that?
UTFT
Danny Baily
98 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:27:57
Fair points, just saw the predicted lineup and that was my gut reaction.

Let's hope we see some of the attacking play from a few weeks back, some calmer heads on and off the ball when defending, and that we're pleasantly surprised this evening!

Kevin Edward
99 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:30:21
Looking at the positives of the first 85 mins a couple of weeks ago, then we have a chance of getting something at Villa. Realistically a draw and a point would be a good return.

Can Dyche organise the team to shut out Villa and create the chances to get ahead, and/or stay in the game? That's what we need to see.

I don't blame ToffeeWebbers going into this one expecting another defeat. It's up to Dyche and the players to put in a shift, keep the ball and not fold.

If they can't put the Bournemouth debacle behind them quickly, then could be messy.

Up the F Toffees and the travelling blues!

Paul Ferry
100 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:52:29
Great response, Danny B - COYB
Ted Roberts
101 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:52:46
My wishes for a great day to all our travelling fans. I am hopeful that your travel will be rewarded by a good performance by the team and a positive result.

Bournemouth was the low; now let's experience the high. Go get 'em, Blues!!!

Danny O'Neill
102 Posted 14/09/2024 at 08:57:43
Paul, keep a good glass of dry white next to you to calm the nerves!

I enjoyed Chicago, not just because we happened to be there for the 4th July, but my son took us to Gibson's as he'd watched a TV series. Smart place.

Well, soon I'll be off to my first trip of two to Birmingham this coming week. Very different reasons, but today is all about the Blues.

Kim Vivian
103 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:02:24
The mindset of this squad really bothers me. We've definitely got a win in our tanks if we can get the basics right and a little luck favours us, and as many point out every game is winnable at the start. ManC/Wigan cup final is testament to that.

However...

the squad knows they put together a pretty good showing for 90% of our last match, and no reason they can't do that again, but they will, consciously or subconsciously, be thinking "...we still fucking lost...!" - and how long actually is it since we put together two enjoyable to watch, winning performances (we should have won) on the bounce. Some time I reckon.

We are away to Aston Villa. Dyche will set us up to try not to lose. Villa know where our weaknesses lie. Fucking sods law says Onana will have a worldy. Watkins gets to start (might be a good week to have him captain your FFL team, lol) and we revert to type.

As always I am hopeful, and pray for the points, but with very supressed optimism this week. I'll probably only be able to catch the first half due to social commitments unless I can engineer a delayed start so hopefully we can get our noses in front by then, and hold onto the lead for the remaining 45.

Good luck to the travelling faithful - UTFT and I wish you all a happy weekend.

Praying...!

Paul Birmingham
104 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:23:03
That's the spirit Kim!

All going the game, take care and here's to victory!

"What's Our Name?"

Robert Williams
105 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:26:24
If Calvert-Lewin gets the service he got against the Cherries and takes his chances, we will win this.

Ndiaye is pivotal and with Iroegbunam and Mangala in midfield we should surprise a few people today.

C'mon the Toffees! Dyche —sort yourself out, mate.

Sam Hoare
106 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:27:02
Tough game. I wouldn't be surprised to see him drop Iroegbunam who's been a breath of fresh air in possession but not always reliable positionally. Gana and Garner ended the season as our central midfield last year and have Dyche's trust.

I'd take a dour draw today. Perhaps a 0-0 to show we've recovered some defensive stability. We'd have to play well to achieve that against a very good Villa side.

Martin Farrington
107 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:45:06
Okay, like me, I am guessing all TW Blues... well most… are excited and looking forward to getting away from the fukkin failure franchise of internationals. Back to the Premier League and something from "out of the blue" will do nicely Everton, thank you.

I am still livid with Dyche. He lost a fair few respect points from the Bournemouth debacle. A performance isn't managing to last 90 minutes plus 10 minutess added time before flaking out. The game has radically changed.

When a team can put out a different 50% of its side at any given moment, that is a major tactical switch. One that the dinosaur managers really have to get out from under the meteor and adapt to a new world.

No one can cope with 5 fresh players bombing about when they have jelly legs. That, Mr Dyche is where you come in. Where you do the hard yards in your head. Like for like the opposition. Stimy them. Wind out of their sails etc.

Let's see you put out a side that wants to kill the Villains and make those incredible away fans proud. COYB!!!

Andy Meighan
108 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:50:59
Tough, tough game, and – apart from the League Cup win last season – not a happy hunting ground for us. But if – and it's a big 'if' – he gets his selection right, I don't see why we can't cause them problems.

Get Ndiaye on the ball as much as possible and he'll give them food for thought, I'm sure of that. I'd like to see Lindstrøm given a run out for 25 minutes or so to see what he can do.

Bournemouth's gaffer showed a couple of weeks back what the use of fresh legs yields. Without the risk of repeating myself, there's a coach or coaches out there who could do something with this squad. Streghten the full-back positions in the next window and we are better than the results will have you believe.

But for fuck's sake, Dyche — no Doucoure or Young!!! — and bring your baby McNeil off if he's struggling.

Paul Kossoff
109 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:58:09
I am sure, if Negadyche tells them to keep the shape of the team, stay in your positions, don't be a wanna score player – do your fkg job, in other words – we can frustrate Villa and at least get a point. Especially keep the defensive structure and don't lose shape.

A draw for me if we stay disciplined. Oh and don't play Young!

Alan J Thompson
110 Posted 14/09/2024 at 09:58:40
Having read some of the arguments, it seems either Young, who might cock up or get sent off, or Dixon, for whom other players want to help out.

My opinion was that Dixon's teammates became a lot more confident as the game went on. Perhaps we should just look to the future?

Michael Kenrick
111 Posted 14/09/2024 at 10:03:37
Negadyche…

Buzzinga!!!

Kunal Desai
112 Posted 14/09/2024 at 10:11:28
Sky Sports News doing a sit down with Lewis Cook on that Bournemouth comeback.

All Dyche had to do was get O'Brien on in that backline and perhaps Garner to settle things down in midfield and we probably cut one or two of those goals.

Still hurts. Donkey Dyche will he haven't learnt? probably not.

Steve Brown
113 Posted 14/09/2024 at 10:30:06
If we have the 87 minutes performance, then we have a good chance.
Ray Roche
114 Posted 14/09/2024 at 10:32:48
There's no way Dyche will play Mangala, from what I read yesterday he's only had a couple of training sessions with the squad. And Dyche doesn't do risks.

I believe it'll be the same horses being flogged for 80 minutes before he brings on one sub.

Derek Taylor
115 Posted 14/09/2024 at 10:41:35
Just be prepared to write off today as another game nearer to Dyche's demise.

His attempts at excusing himself of any blame for the Bournemouth debacle was yet another bad tactic on his part that did his cause no good at all.

Raymond Fox
116 Posted 14/09/2024 at 10:58:31
Looking at our likely defensive players for this game doesn't fill me with much confidence. I think I have said much the same earlier in the thread.

We do look more dangerous going forward so it's swings and roundabouts, we are second favourites though.

Are the anti-Dyche gang giving him credit for the first 87 minutes against Bournemouth when we played well, or the players? It's very easy after the event to blame the manager and say he should have done this that and the other, and let the players off.

He was in charge last season when we had the 4th best defence in the league; he proved he knows how to defend a lead, shit happens sometimes.

The difference is the players are not the same due to injuries and one or two leaving; all the coaching staff are the same.

He won't get credit off some, whatever he does, it seems.

Mark Murphy
117 Posted 14/09/2024 at 12:11:00
Steve,

I know what you mean but, if we have the 87 minutes performance, we'll probably lose again. That's the point – we need a 90+ minutes performance.

Here's hoping they've learned that harsh lesson.

Brian Hennessy
118 Posted 14/09/2024 at 12:16:37
The real worry for me is what Dyche said in his press conference, that he watched back the last 10 minutes of the last game countless times, and that not making substitutes didn't contribute to the result.

That's a level of stubbornness that ends up costing a manager his job eventually – when he can't see what all of us can see plain as day.

Dyche's record in the early games of each season at all of the clubs he has managed is really, really poor. I wonder is it down to over doing the physical stuff in pre-season and that the players start the season over-tired and not "fresh"?

Jeff Armstrong
119 Posted 14/09/2024 at 12:36:02
Dyche will prove he was at fault against Bournemouth by taking Tim and or Gana at 75 minutes, betcha.
Jeff Armstrong
120 Posted 14/09/2024 at 12:48:20
Steve Brown
121 Posted 14/09/2024 at 12:56:47
Agreed Mark, come on boys give us something to cheer abput.

UTFT!

Dave Cashen
122 Posted 14/09/2024 at 13:06:42
The late kick-off has me a little concerned for the catastrophizers.

It's going to be a long day for them.


Mark Frere
123 Posted 14/09/2024 at 13:22:30
Our victory last season, at Villa Park, in the Carabao Cup, has to be the blueprint. We changed our formation to 3 at the back against a strong Villa side and won comfortably. We should do the same again.

Something needs changing after conceding 10 goals in our last 3 games. I'd like to see Garner in a right-wingback role... a position he's played well in the past and maybe McNeil on the opposite flank.

3-5-1-1

Pickford
Keane Tarkowski O'Brien
Garner Mangala Gana Iroegbunam McNeil
Ndiaye
Calvert-Lewin

Jim Wilson
124 Posted 14/09/2024 at 13:28:06
How the hell can Pawson ref an Everton game without complaint?

Whoever plays at right-back needs to be careful, as do all the players. Then again… fair tackles will be penalised too!

Mark Taylor
125 Posted 14/09/2024 at 13:43:55
Given Villa are heavy odds on to win, and we are closer to 5-1, I don't think pessimism is misplaced.

However, unlike the Bournemouth game, where nerves as well as fatigue got the better of us, this is to some extent a free hit, so poor are our prospects, and sometimes that makes players perform better and more freely.

And with that optimistic thought, I'm getting the sofa set up to hide behind...

Rob Hooton
126 Posted 14/09/2024 at 13:49:20
Mixed feelings about this, I'm always excited before a match and look forward to it but also don't want another weekend ruined!

Hope Young doesn't start; if he does, then I hope he puts in a MotM performance…

We played some great stuff against Bournemouth, the players need to keep striving for that. There were times last season when we were creating loads of chances but just couldn't stick it in the net, there's always hope.

Nigel Scowen
127 Posted 14/09/2024 at 13:50:13
Raymond @116,

I'll give him credit when he wins some football matches, which is what he's paid vast amounts of money to do, not just perform well for 87 minutes.

Bill Gall
128 Posted 14/09/2024 at 14:27:32
There is no such thing as a certainty in a game.
The last game was poor to say the least, but there is and was, to much emphasis spent on the collapse in the last 10 min of the game rather than the improvements in the quick passing and off the ball movements that led to the goals, that definitely showed improvements were being made.
This is the time to for Dyche to show if he is learning, or goes back to a more defensive role. From the start it is still 11v11,and If you are frightened of using newly signed or young players why are they their ?
Managers should be judged on improvements not the past, and there was some improvements in the last game but were overshadowed by past mistakes.
Paul Kossoff
129 Posted 14/09/2024 at 14:33:20
Michael 111, What's a bazinga?😀
Michael Kenrick
130 Posted 14/09/2024 at 14:36:30
Errr... Big Bang Theory?

[Perhaps I spent too long in Yankeeland...]

Paul Kossoff
131 Posted 14/09/2024 at 14:41:00
Yes Micheal, The Big Bang Theory explains how the universe began 13.7 billion years ago. But what's a bizanga???😀
Phil Smith
132 Posted 14/09/2024 at 14:41:46
If he starts Young and we get battered, he’s finished for me. Play Dixon and give the lad a chance!
Paul Kossoff
133 Posted 14/09/2024 at 15:06:55
Buzzinga, bizanga bazinga. Oh vey, enough already!
Brian Williams
134 Posted 14/09/2024 at 15:33:56
What if he starts Young and we don't get battered Phil?

What if he starts Young and we win?

Dave Cashen
135 Posted 14/09/2024 at 15:50:16
Gets swept under the carpet Brian
Brian Williams
136 Posted 14/09/2024 at 16:05:08
I must be bored Dave because I can't help thinking about the original post. I think "Well if he does start Young and we win" I reckon Dyche wouldn't then be finished for Phil Smith because he stipulates he'll be finished IF he starts Young AND we get battered.

What if he doesn't start Young but we still get battered?

Is he ok in his relationship with Phil?

What if he starts Young and we go behind until Young is substituted and after the substitution we equalise and then we go on to win?

The permutations have my head spinning I tell yer!

What do you reckon Dave?

Michael Kenrick
137 Posted 14/09/2024 at 16:08:28
By Jove, Paul…

I think you've got it!

Brian Williams
138 Posted 14/09/2024 at 16:10:12
That's what's wrong with TW Michael, not enough posters know the relevance or importance of "Bazinga."
Michael Kenrick
139 Posted 14/09/2024 at 16:13:27
Maybe scope for daily video links to old re-runs, Brian — always available on YouTube!
Paul Kossoff
140 Posted 14/09/2024 at 16:19:24
Michael 137,

Okay, Professor Higgins.😀

Frank Thomas
142 Posted 14/09/2024 at 16:58:33
Really… Keane and Young in today's team? Dyche is really sticking his tongue out at the fans and the club,

We have lost the last 4 Premier League games that Keane has played for us. Perhaps he will make it 5 today.

Anybody know the odds of another red card for Young?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.



How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb