Everton release Accounts for 2010-11

, 9 December, 63comments  |  Jump to most recent
Sale of Bellefield masks biggest operating loss
Everton have returned to a more timely schedule for the release of their Annual Report to Shareholders, which includes the Accounts for the year ending 31 May 2011. The Accounts show an operating loss of only £½M thanks to the sale of Bellefield, with still over £23M in "Other Operating Costs" that are unaccounted for on turnover that increased marginally to £82M. And there was a similar increase in wages to £38M (71% of turnover), with the net debt listed as steady at £44.9M.

Joe Beardwood has kindly provided us with this quick overview of the key highlights:

At the risk of being accused of putting a spin on this year's accounts then the numbers can speak for themselves:

  • Turnover of £82m is the highest in the club's history
  • Media revenues (new TV deal) up 5.4% to £53m — up from £27m five years ago.
  • Gate receipts and catering down for the second consecutive year by 9% (down 11% year before)
  • Wages and salaries up by 7% to £58m (£38m in 2007)
  • Record operating loss of £13.8m excluding the one-off sale of Bellefield training ground for £8.4m
  • The level of borrowing is static at £47.6m (£9m bank overdraft, £14m bank loans, £24.6m Bear Stearns loan
  • The balance sheet is the weakest ever — net liabilities of £33.6m versus £28m last year.
  • Total finance charges for the last ten years now over £32m (Bear Stearns loan was originally £30m — point at which the selling assets and taking loans strategy started).
For those who want to make direct comparisons with previous financial performance, Joe has prepared these excellent tables (in pdf format) analysing Profit & Loss over the last 11 years, and Cash Flow over the last seven years.

The underlying message from the club is one of relative stability in contrast to other clubs that show massive losses but boast massive investment, and this hides the real financial constraint — that Everton must continue to sell their better/younger players.

While the take-home message from Robert Elstone via the Echo is that the undisclosed asking price for Everton is not what's preventing investment/sale of the club:

"I would again go on record to refute any claims or assertions that the reason the club is not being sold is because the shareholder or owners are asking too much money for it. That is 100% not the case."

Everton's Annual Report and Accounts can be viewed in full at Scribd.

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (63)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Matt Traynor
1 Posted 09/12/2011 at 13:45:01
A quick question, the debts are listed, but do they include the short-term "pay day" loans (like the Vibrac) one which are short-term, and borrowed against future income? I realise that whilst the Vibrac loan was after the period of these accounts, it was a replacement for another short-term loan.
Michael Kenrick
2 Posted 09/12/2011 at 13:52:07
Matt,

Take a look at the link I added to the pdf that Joe prepared, and especially the Cash Flow table on page 3 of 4. There are line items on New Loans and Loan Repayments.
Steve King
3 Posted 09/12/2011 at 13:53:40
Doesn't mater what spin they put on these accounts... it's bloody worrying to see the fine lines on which the club is operated!

What a mess!!
Brian Denton
4 Posted 09/12/2011 at 13:59:33
I notice our 'Other Operating Costs' are still at the £23 million level of last year. Obviously the relevant Accounting Standards don't require a detailed disclosure of the make up of this figure, but it would be nice to have one!
Matt Traynor
5 Posted 09/12/2011 at 14:17:28
Michael #2, thanks - that link wasn't working when I first tried it.

From memory, one of the readers posted an analysis of our debt where he also mentioned off-balance sheet debts (like Finch Farm), which are, I guess, part of other operating costs, but not shown as a liability as the asset is sold and leased back (hence the other debt owners can't put a lien on it).

Interesting to see that in the accounting period, we've spent £11.6m bringing players in. Granted, loans now have fees to clubs, agents, but so much? In that period we didn't pay a transfer fee for a player right?
Michael Kenrick
6 Posted 09/12/2011 at 14:23:05
Yea, sorry about the links being bad. I think I've fixed them all now.

I was surprised by those numbers ? perhaps to show continued net player investment despite everything else?
Calle Nilsson
7 Posted 09/12/2011 at 14:12:52
Do anyone know what the sales of players this year 2011-2012 actually entails for future accounts? Are the operating costs going to "swallow" the income from sales? This year we have sold the Yak, Beckford, Yobo (on loan), Arteta and Vaughan which would add up to around £18 million. I hope this is not the way we have to do business every year because there will be no players left to sell.
Danny Broderick
8 Posted 09/12/2011 at 14:24:05
Matt,

Some of that will be because we buy players on the 'never-never'. For instance, I don't think we paid £15 million up front for Fellaini - we have probably arranged to pay them £3 million every year for 5 years. I imagine it was the same for Heitinga, Billy and Distin.
Peter Laing
9 Posted 09/12/2011 at 14:38:53
Interesting to see that there continues to be a drop in catering and matchday / gate receipt revenue, is that anything to do with the fact that the catering / Chang is shite and the football on offer is even worse?

What happens next as we do not have a Bellefield to sell every year to try to balance the books? ... oh I forgot: there is always a Barkley or Rodwell to cash in on.
Matt Traynor
10 Posted 09/12/2011 at 14:48:42
Danny #8, schoolboy error on my part!
Nevermind. In another 3 years, all of those should be off the accounts at the rate we're "progressing".
Paul Melarange
11 Posted 09/12/2011 at 14:50:07
Unless we can attract a wealthy buyer or someone with more money than sense that's the way it's going to be for the future till we get new owners players will no doubt be sold. It's a good thing we have had players to sell and the Rooney cash as the present board have brought zero investment in over the last few years. Sad to see players sold and the squad getting slowly dismantled but unfortunately unless some mega rich evertonian or group of investors steps in this will be the norm.
Tony J Williams
12 Posted 09/12/2011 at 15:53:56
Paul, they will be able to buy us for buttons when we get relegated in a few years time with an entire squad of 17 players.

Peter, the catering has never been the same since they stopped selling Budweisser on draught and done away with teh chicken chilli pies. I hate Everton sometimes.
Rich Williams
13 Posted 09/12/2011 at 16:37:40
So what is Everton worth? £50m? £60m maybe? So with the debt at £45m the asking price for the club should be £15m at most right Robert?.........I didn't think so. Bullshit artist.
Simon Magner
15 Posted 09/12/2011 at 17:21:22
Net Debt remains a "steady" £45m in the red despite the sale of Bellefield as well as an increase in TV revenue.

The bottom has fallen out. As predicted by KEIOC in 2008, the business model has failed Everton. Bellefield represented our last non-playing asset. Is it any wonder we had to sell the likes of Steven Pienaar and Mikel Arteta to appease the banks?

Who's next and when? January or the Summer? Jagielka, Fellaini, Barkley, Rodwell or heaven forbid Leighton Baines? When will the vast majority of Evertonians wake up and smell the coffee?
Richard Dodd
16 Posted 09/12/2011 at 17:23:08
Nowhere near the tragedy we were led to expect. Everything seems to be well in hand and I`m betting we are as healthy (or no more unhealthy!) as virtually any club in the Prem.

Only the existence of benefactors and or more understanding banks keeps most of our `superiors` in the top places, anyway. For certain they borrow more.

Well done Bill, Robert et al!
James Flynn
17 Posted 09/12/2011 at 17:31:28
Simon (14) - Ugh.

Too true. Too sad.
Thomas Williams
18 Posted 09/12/2011 at 17:26:24
The elephant in the room and still remains at £23M at around a 28% of turnover. Having been asked numerous times to clarify the "other operating costs" they still remain tight lipped. Until we find out what the other operating costs are then suspicion will remain.

I have to question the player purchase costs; yes, I know they are spread out over x number of years, but £24M, £18M, £28M and £11.6M over the last 4 years? Who was this spent on? £82M when we haven't bought a player for near 3 years? Wages have gone up but that was paid for by the increase in tv revenue.

Yet again I find something is radically amiss with what is going on at Everton where accounts are concerned, we must find out what 'other operating costs' are.

The other question is the correlation between our figures going astray (last 4 years) and the involvement of Green and Earl.
Jeremy Benson
19 Posted 09/12/2011 at 18:50:31
To be fair, our debt looks pretty healthy compared to the majority of the Premier League. Last year's league table of debt was (from The Guardian):

Chelsea ? £734M
Man Utd ? £590M
Fulham ? £190M
Newcastle ? £150M
Arsenal ? £136M
Liverpool ? £123M
Aston Villa ? £110M
Bolton ? £93M
Wigan ? £73M
Sunderland ? £66M
Spurs ? £65M
Everton ? £45M

I would imagine that Man City are now pushing for the top 2 spot.
Sean Edwards
20 Posted 09/12/2011 at 18:10:13
Bang on Simon but do we even have a business model? Until not so long ago, we didn't even have a presence in our own city centre! And even when the childishly named Everton 2 did arrive, it was immediately overshadowed by Liverpool's new shop.

The board needs to face up to the fact that commercially we're an absolute joke and not one of them has the necessary business acumen to take us forward. Why else would they have sold our matchday catering to an outside company? Because they're a gang of amateurs. Now we don't even sell food and drink to our own fans, we're letting someone else make money of us. It's infuriating.

Where does short-term thinking get you in 5 years time? League One... and it's only Moyes's resolve and determination to work with whatever he's given that's kept us where we are for this long. Could you imagine if we'd had another manager like Walter Smith instead of Moyes? It's frightening.
Gavin Ramejkis
21 Posted 09/12/2011 at 19:46:06
Jeremy sorry to point out the glaringly obvious fatal flaw to your premise but our debt is far from being "pretty healthy" as our ability to service our debt is pretty much the wholesale asset stripping of anything not screwed down, we are left with quite literally nothing but the smallest squad in the EPL left to service the debt with falling gates and match day revenues as people vote with their feet which will accelerate the need to sell players until the next bill arrives and so on, a drop from the league and/or administration as the inability to service debt grows will loom then what?
Mark Rankin
22 Posted 09/12/2011 at 20:20:33
Re #18 - Jeremy Benson: if that Spurs debt figure is accurate then they are sitting pretty.
Paul Carr
23 Posted 09/12/2011 at 20:41:08
There are also two very interesting but worrying figures shown in the accounts.

Under post balance sheet events, it states that transfer fees of £13 million were due ? this is strangely low for Arteta (a bargain for Arsenal), Beckford, Yak (a bargain for Blackburn), Vaughan, all widely reported to have been sold for a total £18 million! What happened to the missing £5 million?

The next piece of bad news is that, under Borrowings, it states that the Bank loan was repaid in August 2011, presumably from the transfer proceeds. This loan would appear to be the 11 million quoted in last years accounts as being due within 1 year, so the repayment was actually 3 months late. If this is true, then almost all the transfer sale proceeds have gone to the Bank (as rumoured at the time) and DM is going to get a pretty small budget to spend in January. There is now a new loan for £14 million due within a year ? which player sale will pay for that? And where has this money gone?

With the overdraft also increasing and no sign of any new owners the only real solution regretfully will be to make another big sale or two... Jags, Rodwell, Barkley etc. With Man United looking to strengthen their squad to compete with City, don't be surprised to see some departures in January.
Jeremy Benson
24 Posted 09/12/2011 at 20:53:30
Re: Gavin,

That's the same for most other clubs too, is it not? When you are £200 million+ in debt, servicing that debt becomes a problem for a club of any stature, as we saw with liverpool changing hands. Some of those clubs have more assets, but some of the debt is frightening.

If the rich owners move on, then Chelsea, Man City will have unserviceable debts too. Same with Fulham.

All clubs are having trouble raising funds in the current financial climate. The bubble will soon burst.

Ian McDowell
25 Posted 09/12/2011 at 21:04:43
Man City's owners aren't going anywhere. Look at that there building with regards to regeneration of the area and youth development. They are in it for the long haul.
Gavin Ramejkis
26 Posted 09/12/2011 at 21:11:40
Jeremy

Spot the odd one out from your list:

Chelsea ? £734M
Man Utd ? £590M
Fulham ? £190M
Newcastle ? £150M
Arsenal ? £136M
Liverpool ? £123M
Aston Villa ? £110M
Bolton ? £93M
Wigan ? £73M
Sunderland ? £66M
Spurs ? £65M
Everton ? £45M

now the easy part
Which one hasn't bought a first team player in a few years?
Which one's players only direction relating to current playing squad is outbound?
Which one has no assets left to service debts OR board and chairman who hasn't invested their own money beyond their purchase of shares?

Answers on a postcard...
Tom Hughes
27 Posted 09/12/2011 at 20:59:59
Jeremy,
Perhaps we should compare debt with revenue, and other factors before judging. The thing is, some of those clubs have had leveraged buy-outs, and/or have had the expense of having already built new stadiums/stands. We have done neither, and have also spent amongst the lowest year on year, yet still have debt we cannot clear.... and practically all of those clubs have, and will outspend us for the forseeable. When (if) their bubble bursts, who is going to pay us the extortionate amounts we need for our key players, that we need to survive?
Sean Patton
28 Posted 09/12/2011 at 22:13:06
I heard Elstone on Radio Merseyside earlier talking about the "operating costs". He said that the figure compares favourably with our competitors!

Also he gave an explanation of sorts about what makes up the cost and put it down to running the stadium from day to day ,policing costs,light and fuel bills and the fact that Finch Farm has state of the art equipment including top notch medical supplies.

So there you have it there must be a room full of those 100K beds that are keeping George Michael alive.
Jimmy Sørheim
29 Posted 09/12/2011 at 22:36:44
It seems to me we are operating well above what we can afford.
We need to sell Felli in order to start reducing wages. Saha and Cahill is next unles they agree to a pay cut.
Seems stupid to obtain Felli on such a contract when the hard truth is that he needs to be sold. I guess they did it to secure his sale value.
We need to buy a striker and a midfielder, but we have to take in that we need to reduce some of our wages and also Moyes is on a 65.000 a week contract, that is 3.120.000 a year.
Wow that is a lot of money, add Fellaini and his contract you have 70.000 a week, in a year that is 3.360.000.
Nearly 6.5 million pounds a year on Fellaini and Moyes alone.

We are living beyond what we can pay, that much is crystal clear.
Richard Dodd
30 Posted 10/12/2011 at 00:42:01
Jimmy #27 ? You've got it in one. But the trouble is that so many expect the club to match the extravagances of our rivals by living EVEN FURTHER beyond our means. It's easy to run a football club from the safety of these columns.

On the question of operating costs, you can be sure that they are all pukka or the auditors ? top-level firm ? would not pass the accounts without comment. So cease with the irregularity suggestions, please.
Eric Myles
31 Posted 10/12/2011 at 01:57:13
Jeremy #22, when the rich owners of City or Chelsea sell the club it will be to other rich owners. They will have no worries and can easily reduce their debt with player sales.
Ged Simpson
32 Posted 10/12/2011 at 07:05:34
"The Group?s current overdraft facility expires on 31 July 2012".

Oh bugger - they'll send the bailiffs to seize Goodison and we'll have to buy our next striker through a loan from the Provy.
Tom Hughes
33 Posted 10/12/2011 at 07:54:16
Richard,
The point is, (as you well know) the club has failed to increase those revenue streams by the complete lack of investment. NO-ONE is saying we should've gone further in debt..... they are just saying that a proper strategy over the past 12yrs would've provided those additional finances.... as opposed to waiting for the mystical stadium for nothing, and selling off everything to stay afloat. KEIOC and several others predicted the current senario several yrs ago...... we are completely unsustainable at the moment and the goodwill of the fans is diminishing with every home defeat..... all Moyes relative "on pitch progress" has now gone into reverse and has been for what? While he has been doing his best on a shoestring and with money he has been able to generate....... what have this board invested? That is why we are now outspent by minnows with a fraction of our fanbase and turnover. They have nearly all maximised their revenue streams and can service their debts......... we have done none of this!
Tom Hughes
34 Posted 10/12/2011 at 07:54:16
Richard,
The point is, (as you well know) the club has failed to increase those revenue streams by the complete lack of investment. NO-ONE is saying we should've gone further in debt..... they are just saying that a proper strategy over the past 12yrs would've provided those additional finances.... as opposed to waiting for the mystical stadium for nothing, and selling off everything to stay afloat. KEIOC and several others predicted the current senario several yrs ago...... we are completely unsustainable at the moment and the goodwill of the fans is diminishing with every home defeat..... all Moyes relative "on pitch progress" has now gone into reverse and has been for what? While he has been doing his best on a shoestring and with money he has been able to generate....... what have this board invested? That is why we are now outspent by minnows with a fraction of our fanbase and turnover. They have nearly all maximised their revenue streams and can service their debts......... we have done none of this!
Andy Riley
35 Posted 10/12/2011 at 08:29:12
The quote from Robert Elstone - "I would again go on record to refute any claims or assertions that the reason the club is not being sold is because the shareholder or owners are asking too much money for it. That is 100% not the case." would become far more meaningful and serve to foster better conditional interim support for the current regime if he would only indicate in a ball park figure how much money the owners are actually asking!
Dennis Stevens
36 Posted 10/12/2011 at 08:33:22
" ... so many expect the club to match the extravagances of our rivals by living EVEN FURTHER beyond our means ... " - do they really, Richard? My impression is that most are dreadfully alarmed at the financial plight of the club & would happily see the current Board replaced, not in the expectation of a multi-billionaire on a white charger, but merely in the hope of the arrival of some competent businessmen who can run the club more successfully. The current Board have not been a success, other than we have not been relegated or gone into administration, yet.

As for the operating costs, I'm sure there is nothing illegal going on, but there will be speculation as to what they consist of until there is a convincing breakdown of the figures. Hence people speculating as to whether an element of this large figure could be the Board effectively recouping the cost of their share purchases, which probably isn't the case at all.
Stephen Kenny
37 Posted 10/12/2011 at 10:34:36
£23.8m equates to about 450 thousand pound a week!!!

Does anybody honestly think that what Elstone has suggested costs this amount to run?

Based on absolutely nothing other than a guess we may be paying back some directors loans made through a third party?
Richard Dodd
38 Posted 10/12/2011 at 10:59:07
Whilst there is no legal/accounting requirement for the Club to detail `other operating expenses` ? which seem to be held at a totally reasonable level to me ? I know it would please many if they could be party to every last detail. Then, of course, we could be having a reasoned debate over whether £5k for paint or £8k for whitewash was reasonable, couldn`t we?
Stephen Kenny
39 Posted 10/12/2011 at 11:13:42
Intersting that Barry Horne is in the Echo today suggesting the club must lower the asking price.

The first ex player to break ranks and comment about it.

Personally I think the BU need a respected figurehead such as Horne to get the attention of the wider Everton fanbase and add a bit of legitimacy to thier campaign, one looking more successful by the day.
John Keating
40 Posted 10/12/2011 at 11:32:36
Stephen. I think Barry Horne has always said what he thinks. Unlike Sharp, Gray et al he seems a bit more switched on to the important issues at the club and more than happy to say it as he sees it. Good on him I say, and if Bill and Elstone withdraw his free cups of tea next time he's at Goodison I'm sure he'll call them all the miserable bastards under the sun. Pity he doesn't work for the Echo full time !
Stephen Kenny
41 Posted 10/12/2011 at 11:39:18
John, I always got the impression he avoided the bigger issues to be honest. I hope he calls it as he see's it.

I wonder whether this was prompted by the letter sent to the Echo and the reactions to a few of Dave Prentice's articles recently?
Sam Hoare
42 Posted 10/12/2011 at 12:13:01
All of this makes very sad reading. Bellefield was sold for £9m which same figure is effectively therefore our current operating loss.

That means that barring an investor coming in we will have to raise £9m a year just to keep our debt at its current level. With no off field assets left to sell that means our transfer dealings will have to take the hit.

I'm an optimist (apologist) but Kenwright and Elstone are clearly leading us up the garden path. If they weren't then why the clear lack of transparency.

As Andy Riley says why don't they come out and tell us what the ballpark sale figure for the club is?! Why can't they post the results for the operating costs? If everything is above board and as honest as they claim then show it. Its not difficult.

With the mysterious investor no closer to fruition and clearly no plan B whatsoever i fear that this club is being slowly strangled to death. The only other option i can see is to try and cut back costs hugely whilst staying in the premiership. Selling the likes of Cahill, Fellaini, Heitinga and Saha and anyone else on prohibitive wages. Put in a wage ceiling of £50k for one or two top players and then £40k or below for the rest. Hope more of the kids break through and try to stabilise the finances that are otherwise going to condemn us to a slow death. Perhaps the sale of Arteta was the first step in this plan, i can't see any other way forward.
Tommy Heskrth
43 Posted 10/12/2011 at 12:35:14
This has to be the first article that Ian Tunstead hasn't made a impassioned defence of all things Bill & Moyes, The figures are truly worrying as again these are out of date already with all the goings on since the accounts were audited.

From the 1 - 31st Jan it wil be like every other transfer window utter torture, no new players the money will be as elusive as Lord Lucan.

At least Big Vic should be back by then.....

We are becoming the Italy/Greece equivalent of the premiership and it won't be long before we go under.

Richard, honest anwer to this question please, do you think under the current board or manager we will ever win or challenge for a trophy again?
Brian Denton
44 Posted 10/12/2011 at 13:00:41
Doddy, all the auditors are certifying is that the £23 million 'other operating costs' was spent legally and related to club activities. The auditors (unless someone can point me to the contrary) have no duty to comment on the efficiency of that expenditure. And we can't comment because we don't know the detail.
Richard Dodd
45 Posted 10/12/2011 at 14:34:36
Tommy #41. Honest answer: NO! But I don`t think we have any chance of doing so under new ownership/management unless we can attract a billionaire!

So the devils you know........
Matthew Lovekin
46 Posted 10/12/2011 at 15:41:30
The two main points I got from this were:

1. Record operating loss was £13.8m before the sale of Bellefield.

Does this mean we will lose a similar amount next year as we don't have another Bellefield to sell? And the year after, and the year after that?

2. Our debt is recorded as £45m. Therefore the minimum figure to buy the club should be £45m plus whatever the shareholders are asking. BK shouldn't receive a penny as he is not supposed to be interested in making money out of Everton, afterall his has said several times that he doesn't take a wage out of the accounts.

The share price should be low considering all financial predicament aa well as Premier League status concerns. Therefore the selling price of the club should only be about £50m.
Dennis Stevens
47 Posted 10/12/2011 at 18:36:14
That's a silly comment, Richard. At a time when the club is strapped for cash & the accounts show a very sizeable percentage of the clubs money is swallowed up in one charge such as 'other operating costs' it's hardly surprising that people wonder what they consist of. Where there is a lack of information people will fill the void with speculation, much of it wide of the mark, no doubt. Your comment on spending a few grand on paint make it seem as though you consider the amount trifling at about £23 million. By the way , what is your expertise that enables you to conclude this level of expense is 'reasonable'? I honestly wouldn't know whether at that price we're running a tight ship or wasting money at every turn - especially as there's no breakdown of the figures to even give an inkling!
Barry Jones
48 Posted 11/12/2011 at 12:33:41
Dick #15

?Nowhere near the tragedy we were led to expect.?

It?s exactly what we were led to expect, those exact figures were presented at Zeligs by the Blue Union ? TWO MONTHS AGO! All they confirm is the stagnation of a club that has sold everything to keep afloat, including its ability to raise revenue; it hasn?t worked so we?ll just keep slipping down the league.

The club's explanations on these highly mysterious ?other operating costs? are really dubious, they?re being systematically ripped apart. 85p in the pound ends up at Finch Farm? Work it out, that means it?s costing the club £70m, staff costs and the lease payment amount to £59m, so that leaves £11m to run Finch Farm and the academy? I don?t know about you but that?s bullshit if I?ve ever heard it.

As Brian (43) points out, the auditors are just looking that everything is above board, they?re not looking at the validity of payments, they?re just making sure that no misappropriation is taking place and obviously it isn?t.

After Zeligs, because he?d been sussed out, Elstone started talking about costs such as scouts, coaches, trainers, conditioners and medics, yep, they?re all in the staff costs Bobby mate, it?s all in the £58m, it?s not just the players, that?s why it?s called ?staff costs? in the accounts.

The explanations have now been expanded to include ?expensive medical equipment and supplies?. So over the last four years we?ve spent £40m on medical equipment and supplies? I know Vaughany was, and Saha is, a bit of a sick note but that?s a joke surely.

No, we haven?t spent that amount on that, but we?ve spent that money on something and I know for definite that it wasn?t given to the manager for strengthening the squad, these excuses are as bad as Ian Ross with his "unable to move furniture and computers" lie about the Park End.

Finch Farm will always be more expensive than Bellefield, everybody knows that, but, even when you add on the costs of running the academy there, it still looks to me, and a lot of other people, that it?s being used as the excuse to cover up the fine details of the £11m increase in operating costs. The explanations simply don?t add up.

At Zeligs I heard the guys give the figures and they were right on the money. These are the same guys who told us Tesco weren?t giving Everton £50m; that Everton?s finances for Kirkby didn?t add up; and why the Park End project ultimately failed six months before Elstone told the fans why it did ?and they were right every single time. I know who I believe when they tell me Bellefield cost less than £1m to operate and that Finch Farm, admittedly much larger, can?t be the only source of the £11m increase in other operating costs.

I have the advantage over most if not all of the posters on ToffeeWeb, I have had the opportunity of meeting Bill for three hours. You only know what he said for about an hour; I know the rest. It?s scary.

If you want my opinion, I think Bill is between a rock and a hard place, he can?t get out and doesn?t know how to get out and all the time Everton are going down the pan. His last attempt to bring investment into the club was Robert Earl, all we got was Rocky, can we really trust him to get it right next time?

Believe me, Bill was ready to sell to the guy in the bedsit ? not just willing to talk, he was pestering him to come over to sign the documents that were ready, everything was in place, the deal was done, the story is unbelievable ? and that?s why I know it?s essential we get some professionals into the club to conduct the sale.

The recent e.mails confirm the mayhem going on in there, even Elstone has lost half his job, check out last week?s programme, Barrett-Baxendale has been brought in to do some of his work, she?s now the Chief Operating Officer, it?s in the list of club officials, but have you heard it in the Echo or anywhere else? Not a chance.

It?s about time everyone and not just a few really did wake up to what?s going on.
Eric Myles
49 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:42:03
Richard, the accountants Arthur Andersen (top level firm) passed the Enron accounts without comment.

Are they the Club accountants too?
Eric Myles
50 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:45:09
Ged #31, the Club don't own Goodison. Remember the owners objected to the Club taking down the tent and knocking a hole in the wall?
Paul Carr
51 Posted 11/12/2011 at 16:29:20
Eric, according to the accounts the club does own the stadium. It is now valued (along with some other properties) at a net figure of £5.5 million, based on a valuation performed in 1999. I am surprised that a more recent valuation hasn't been done as this would probably improve the balance sheet.

It is clear from reading the accounts that the club is in a dangerous financial position ? both the Director's Report and Note 1 of the accounting policies together contain over a page of justifications for preparing these accounts on a going concern basis, no doubt prompted by the auditor's concerns.

Relegation would tip us into financial oblivion so the boys had better start picking up some points and a few new strikers have to arrive in January.
Eric Myles
52 Posted 12/12/2011 at 01:43:45
Paul explain then why the Club were not allowed to build on something that they already own?

Maybe because they have securitised the freehold and have no rights to do anything with the ground without the security owners agreement?

Maybe that's the reason why redevelopment is a non starter for the Club as they will have to buy back the freehold first?
Paul Carr
53 Posted 12/12/2011 at 10:07:06
Eric, possibly, but this is not shown in the accounts. However, I doubt if a security holder could prevent a small development. For instance having a mortgage on your house does not stop you from adding a conservatory. The more likely reason is funding issues again.
Denis Richardson
54 Posted 12/12/2011 at 13:21:23
It's clear that the only 'plan' the board have is to sell assets to fund operating costs (note not actually paying down any significant amount of debt). For any rational person this is obviously not a sustainable position as your assets are going to run out at some point, (assuming we don't unearth a Rooney or Barkley every year).

The going concern principal only looks at the next 12 months so as long as we have assets (players) of value to sell that will cover short term costs, the auditors can sign off the accounts year on year. Also, the players that came through the academy (Rodwell, Barkely, Hibbert, Osman, Anichebe etc) don't figure in the accounts at all as there is a ridiculous accounting rule that says that only purchased players are assets on the clubs balalnce sheet, and even these assets are amortised over the life of the players' contract. In effect, the true value of the playing staff is never reflected in the accounts, it is usually much higher in reality.

All in all, the current balance sheet is not as bad as it seems. If you were to include the value of academy players and revalue the ground, it would look a lot more healthy. So the 'true' current purchase price of the club is not as low as people make out (the 40-45m based on the share price is IMO about right). The whole squad does have a relatively high value when you look at the likes of Baines, Rodwell, Fellaini etc.

The biggest worry is the income generating side. Simply put, if you don't earn enough to cover your costs, you're living on borrowed time. Player sales can probably pay the bills/keep us afloat for another 2-3 years but after that you run out of road and then no auditor is going to sign off on the accounts and we go into administration. Issue is, if we can all see this then so can a potential buyer. It would then make sense for said buyer simply to wait a little longer until the situation became critical in order to get us at a knock down price. Trouble is this a little like russian roulette (for us anyway) as the only thing the club has going for it now are a handful of quality players (who will slowly be sold) and its premiership status (which will increasingly become harder to maintain as players are sold). How does the potential buyer wait?

I am in both the BK out and Moyes out camps (for different reasons) but do appreciate the fact both are stuck between a rock and a hard place. Unless the club is sold at a really low price, I cannot realistically see anyone buying us in the near future due to the above mentioned reason. (On the Moyes front I just think we need a fresh face/approach to lift the players and fans - money or no money).

So where does that leave us? To be honest in a pretty depressing state. One hope is that gate revenues keep falling until the banks start getting very worried and force the board to sell at a low(er) price, or we embark upon a clear strategy of buying hungry quality players and selling them at a profit, ala Arsenal (issue is its probably too late to put into place number two...).

Am at a loss myself, just cannot see an end in sight. I just hope and pray we dont get relgated, if that happens the house of cards falls down. So for now, I am truly grateful for every 3 points we get, regardless how shite/lucky we are on the field.
Ian Smitham
55 Posted 12/12/2011 at 14:39:17
Though building say a conservatory may be ok on a commercial mortgage the mortgagors may well prevent certain works being done without permission. The danger is that they may also seek to vary the terms of any loan outstanding and this is common in Banking right now where lenders are looking to increase margins on any variations. In our case they may well want fees and variations which seems counter productive but when did logic win out?
Eric Myles
56 Posted 13/12/2011 at 03:27:22
Paul, the Park End Development was not going to be funded by the Club, it was to be funded by Kitbag so no financial concerns.
Eric Myles
57 Posted 13/12/2011 at 03:57:39
"It would then make sense for said buyer simply to wait a little longer until the situation became critical in order to get us at a knock down price."

So Denis, the choices really come down to

1. sell now for a knock down price to get out

2. sell later for a knock down price when we're in dire straits.

We can't carry on as we are.
Martin Mason
58 Posted 13/12/2011 at 04:14:15
Simon Magner @14

Right Simon, we've woken up and smelled the coffee, what now?
Martin Mason
59 Posted 13/12/2011 at 04:19:02
Are we in dire straits or just operating within our means? A couple of points; the club can't fix the price for sale, the market will do that and the board have no moral obligation to invest their own money in the club. They would be stupid to do so without return on the investment. They're a football club not a charity. Lastly, the chances of us being bought by a sugar daddy who'll solve all of our ills from the goodness of his heart are minus zero and there is no guarantee that any other type of purchase will offer any improvement. Saying it will or wishing it would doesn't make it so. Like sacking Moyes the risk is virtually all downside.

When I look at Everton I see a club in terminal decline, a once giant reduced to pygmy status by time and the modern game. When I look at the management I see no evidence of any malfeasance or even incompetence other than poor communication (yes, misinformation) and an offering of far more hope than we have any right to expect. I believe that they have tried to buy success by selling assets and this has failed. All we see now is the inevitable result, pay back time, and it could well mean our descent into perhaps inevitable mediocrity is accelerated. The fact that we have a sometimes successful history, a silly motto and a fan base with often irrational expectations doesn't mean that we should be in the top 4. We are what we are and where we are.

I despair for our wonderful fans who still give massive support to the club, they are the best and they deserve far better as John Moore said when he sacked Carey. The difference was that he had the resources to ensure that we got far better. Now we have nothing except a reducing revenue stream and sales of our best players to look forward to. From a supporter's point of view what happens now will sort the wheat from the chaff.

From my seat EFC has finally given up the illusion of being a club on the fringe of joining the top tier but one that has finally accepted that its only measure of success is to not be relegated. In other words we are now no different to Wolves, Bolton and Blackburn or any other City club with a more powerful neighbour. One thing that is true is that we are increasingly living up to our handle of "bitter" blues. I sincerely believe that by our virtually ceaseless negative commentary we are also contributing to the downward spiral that the club seems to be in. Please let us try to be constructively critical where necessary but otherwise supportive. That's what supporters do. Fans of the rich clubs tend to support them because of the reflected glory that it bestows on them, we've never really had the continuous success for this to apply to use.
Richard Larnder
60 Posted 13/12/2011 at 09:18:02
Martin, it's interesting you point out return on investment. You can only generate an ROI where your total returns are greater than your initial outlay. In the case of Everton, the cash generated by the business is less than when Kenwright bought his shares, the Board has chosen to fund the 'business expansion' through debt and there has been a chronic underinvestment in the club's infrastructure excepting some off-balance sheet finance with regard to the training complex.

You don't need to be an investment banker to realise that all of these things are negative value indicators. Perhaps the Board think differently?

If I were advising somone on the purchase of the club tomorrow, I'd tell them to seek a massive reduction in the cash outlay for the amount of debt on (and off) the balance sheet and I'd also want a deduction for the amount of capex required after sale. Add these things together and you arrive at a very low number for purchase consideration.

I'd struggle to recommend a purchase price of greater than £1.
Eric Myles
61 Posted 13/12/2011 at 09:40:53
Not misinformation Martin, outright lies and deceit.
Andy Riley
62 Posted 13/12/2011 at 17:57:42
Martin - no. 58 - I don't really understand your point about the club not being able to fix the price for a sale. This is true only to the extent that for a successful sale there has to be a willing and able buyer and a willing and able seller who agree upon a fair price for the transaction. As this has not occurred it can only be presumed that the market has spoken in that potential buyers are unwilling to enter discussions at the ball park figure indicated by the seller. Which brings me back to my earlier point that Robert Elstone's statement that the price is not deterring buyers is meaningless without additional information indicating what the ball park figure indicated by the buyer.

If you are looking to buy a house and know your limit is £250k you will probably look at properties listed at up to about £300k in the hope of possibly being able to agree a deal with the seller, you wouldn't realistically look at something listed at around £1 million even if you thought it was priced at four times it's market value.

The seller in such a case is clearly not living in the real (market driven) world but until the price is either voluntarily reduced to a realistic level or third party action (repossession) takes place then no sale is likely. Therefore surely the key to any sale is the price being asked by the seller.
Marc Sansum
63 Posted 13/12/2011 at 21:02:34
Anyone know how much we make from merchandising? I would just be interested to see how much we make through the shops compared to other clubs.

With little to no corporate facilities (bar the tent in the carpark), one of the lowest ticket prices in the PL, attendance figures and catering down by a great deal, it's no wonder we are losing so much. Factor in we've just sold our last asset, it's certainly not good reading.

Even if BK left tomorrow, and someone with at least some business knowledge came in, I wonder how quickly they could turn our finances around? With the lack of assets, I would imagine it'll be a few years at least.
Ian Smitham
64 Posted 15/12/2011 at 19:14:51
Sorry for the late addition to this thread. I have only just had chance to look at the Report and Accounts.

May I draw your attentions to Page 9 and the Shareholdings.

Bill actually BOUGHT 290 more in the past year, that is hardly sign of a seller (they will have cost over 300 Grand GBP)

Since a small number makes no material differences to his to his power base, why would he do it?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads