Season 2014-15
Opinion
Talking Points
Rob Sawyer's Harry Catterick biography
As someone whose introduction to all things Everton co-incided with Harry Catterick's reign as manager, his massive contribution to our history has always held a special place in my heart and memory.
Rob Sawyer's long-overdue tribute lays bare the man as well as the manager and recounts 'the untold story' — warts and all.
As a kid, I thought little and cared less about the background trivia that so occupies us these days on ToffeeWeb – all I wanted to concern myself with was how My Team was doing. That the manager was a complex and testy character who hated the Press – and the fans more – mattered not one iota.
What really mattered was that, for many years, his Everton teams 'purred' like few have done since. Perhaps that was appropriate for a man known everwhere as... "The Cat"!
For anyone who had the privilege of living during those years – or just wants to get 'a taste of perfection' – I commend Rob's studiously researched tome as an absolute must.
Harry Catterick – The untold story of an Everton great by Rob Sawyer. Published by De Coubertin Books. Available via Amazon.
Return to Talking Points index : Add your Comments
Reader Comments (62)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 25/10/2014 at 19:06:13
Catterick was a shrewd man and although not a great tracksuit manager knew his players and how to put together a winning team playing attractive football.
He did not court the media at all and I often wonder if that's why to this day we're not acknowledged in some quarters.
Looking forward to another great read from Rob Sawyer.
3 Posted 25/10/2014 at 20:31:17
I feel saddened when I hear the younger blues talk of this season's "raised expectations".
Can you imagine The Cat, or indeed his boss, ever tolerating the bar being set as low as it is today?
4 Posted 25/10/2014 at 20:40:02
I remember Catterick playing and he was pretty poor. The man he played second fiddle to was Jock Dodds.
John Carey was one of the finest fullbacks of his time and actually won the Player of the Year award twice which must be unique for a fullback. I think he also captained the FIFA side which represented the British Isles against the Rest of the World team. His first signing for Everton was Roy Vernon.
5 Posted 25/10/2014 at 20:56:42
6 Posted 25/10/2014 at 21:10:35
One of the things that makes Catterick fascinating is that he more than held his own with Shankly, a major feat. Unlike Phil, I think, it is my view that Martinez will in the end bring us back to the days when we were beautiful. If that doesnÂt happen, thanks anyway for reminding us.
7 Posted 25/10/2014 at 21:52:55
People like Catterick, and to a lesser degree Gordon Lee, deserve all the stick they get as they helped stunt our development and growth as a club. No book will make me change my mind about either of them.
8 Posted 25/10/2014 at 22:49:21
9 Posted 25/10/2014 at 23:00:00
10 Posted 25/10/2014 at 23:13:32
11 Posted 25/10/2014 at 23:28:13
If he was around now, he would be astounded that we kept a manager like David Moyes for over ten years...
12 Posted 25/10/2014 at 23:28:52
The fact remains that Catterick took no shit and created the most aesthetically delightful side we have ever had, right in Shankly's face. There is no comparison with the ruinous dullards who came after him, even if his own demise was a sad one.
13 Posted 26/10/2014 at 00:46:15
14 Posted 26/10/2014 at 01:05:18
Patrick#13, yes you are correct, including his 5th and 2nd place with Sheff Wed.
He was, as stated, a bit of an introvert...well compared to Shankly, most were and as reported else where only got the track suit out for the odd press Photo Op.
His fall out with the media, mostly TV, was in part, his own fault. He was Interview in depth by I think David Coleman and I got a bit seduced by the whole thing and said more than he meant to ( good interviewing technique by Coleman?). He then complained that the TV gave away too much of his 'Plan' ( which led to the alphabetical team sheets ). He also damned Sandy Brown with faint praise, which, added to the famous O.G. did Sandy no favours in the confidence dept. This I think led to the quick Jan. signing of Keith Newton.
Harry's Teams would be my first destination If I found a Tardis, but he did have his faults. He didn't like Players with a mind of their own, this, coupled with a tendency to get rid of players at the magical 30yrs or so ( which may not be so daft given the Pienaar Osman fall off of effectiveness we see now ) led to early exits for Collins, Young and Vernon. He didn't ( couldn't?) see that the game was changing and for some 30 or 26 or 27 for that matter.
This, IMO was why Ball was sold, 5 or 6 good years, not getting any younger, doubled his money ( low inflation then ), plus Ball did, as they say very much 'know his own mind'... I'm off to Amazon to order it now
15 Posted 26/10/2014 at 08:49:19
I was too young to know but my dad used to say Catterick hated Evertonians. My point is, he achieved a lot but with the teams he had he could've done so much more.
ps: I mentioned Gordon Lee as he had built a potential title-winning team and then, like Catterick, decided to break it up. So if that's not stunting our development, I don't know what is.
17 Posted 26/10/2014 at 17:03:03
Perhaps Catterick did me a disservice, as my formative years saw us slugging it out toe to toe with Liverpool and Man Utd (not to forget Don Revie’s Leeds). I simply cannot accept that we can’t do that now. As I say, spoilt!
18 Posted 26/10/2014 at 19:36:39
Johnny Carey was a very nice man and a great player... I’m not so sure he was a great manager.
21 Posted 27/10/2014 at 14:04:34
Does anyone know is the interview referenced above, the one which is featured in clips on the official history, video from the late '80s? I also remember from that the bit about Catterick unusually allowing cameras into the dressing room prior to the '66 (or might've been '68?) Cup Final. Seems odd for someone known to have been so anti-press, or did his stance change after having allowed them such access?
Anyway, can't wait for my copy of Rob's book to arrive – needless to say, if his work on here is anything to go by, it promises to be a terrific read.
Editorial Team
22 Posted 27/10/2014 at 15:24:51
We've had a couple of posts over the years from fans who were there (Blackpool, January 1966 – the day Catterick dropped Alex Young and introduced Joe Royle) and who were pretty angry the Blues had lost (no change there, then!); they say they saw the incident and there was no 'kicking'. Catterick slipped on the wet pavement and the fans helped him back up.
It will be interesting to see if and how Rob Sawyer reports this event... as our account Everton Myths suggests that is indeed how the papers blew it out of all proportion (no change there, then, either!).
[Are there any more Everton Myths people can think of?]
23 Posted 27/10/2014 at 15:36:55
Pat Van Den Hauwe had his legs slashed by some jealous husband or was injured due to gambling debts? I don't know the truth about this but is oft brought up in the boozers.
Andy Van Der Meyde was celibate and tee-total?
Yakubu is a 106 years old?
There are probably loads more but I can't think of any at the moment.
I'm not saying this is a myth but I was a tad surprised that the great David France claimed that he coined the phrase "the Holy Trinity" as recently as 2001 but I may have mis-read the article in the Echo recently and he may well have coined the phrase some years earlier.
24 Posted 27/10/2014 at 17:31:19
Catterick brought Ball, Harvey and Kendall together after his first Championship-winning side and that second side had even more flair imo.
To me, he was in the same class as Shankly, Revie and Busby. He certainly achieved as much and created two very different champion winning sides with an FA cup success in between.
What we wouldn't give for that today.
25 Posted 27/10/2014 at 17:55:07
Regarding the "kicking" Catterick got at Blackpool, I was as close to him as I am to this computer. He wasn't kicked, he stumbled on the kerb as he approached the coach, sure, their were a lot of unhappy fans jostling each other, but he definitely wasn't assaulted or kicked.
26 Posted 27/10/2014 at 18:02:41
27 Posted 27/10/2014 at 18:43:51
And didn't Brian Labone once say something or other about Mike Trebilcock and the Beverley Sisters...
28 Posted 27/10/2014 at 19:37:32
29 Posted 27/10/2014 at 19:51:10
Personally I think Howard's side was the best of all given European success but it's probably a generational thing given I lived it.
Derek #14 you win the prize for managing to get an Osman dig in a thread about a manager from nearly half a century ago.
30 Posted 27/10/2014 at 20:21:34
31 Posted 27/10/2014 at 20:29:10
32 Posted 27/10/2014 at 20:31:42
33 Posted 27/10/2014 at 20:54:25
34 Posted 27/10/2014 at 20:46:40
Agreed it was a great opportunity missed but ultimately it was missed. I think you may be getting your years mixed up however. Feyenoord Celtic was 1970. The final the year you mention was Panathaniakos vs Ajax, the first of three they won.
I still think the defining line between the 60s side and the 80s side is a generational thing. My old feller (67) will swear the 60s side was the better, I (49) will argue the other way.
35 Posted 27/10/2014 at 21:54:04
36 Posted 27/10/2014 at 21:54:43
You may be right about it being a generational thing about which was the best team, CatterickÂs or KendallÂs? IÂll go with CatterickÂs in 1963. And also in 1970.
Howard gave us our pride back in 1984 and for a couple more years after that but the 1963 team was the best for me.
However, IÂll always be grate full to Kendall for his teams, but he will never in my opinion be anywhere near as good as Catterick... but, as you say, it could be the age thing.
37 Posted 28/10/2014 at 02:14:06
38 Posted 28/10/2014 at 08:37:26
IÂm not having that, CatterickÂs teams played Dour football with Young, Vernon, Bingham, Scott, Morrissey, Gabriel amongst others in the team? I think the 1963 team was full of attacking football and the 1970 team was the same.
Catterick seemed to be a miserable man and maybe he was but his championship-winning teams were most certainly not.
You are having a laugh if you think those teams played dour football.
39 Posted 28/10/2014 at 09:25:17
Dour? The football we played in 1968-69 was as good as anything I have ever seen on a pitch... sorry, it was not "good" – it was feckin amazing. Class, speed, swagger, and bags of goals.
Then again, someone said once that, if you can remember the Â60s, then you werenÂt there.
40 Posted 28/10/2014 at 10:50:58
Only in his last couple of years – when he was often ill – did his teams ever reflect his dour image. Sacrilege even to suggest such a thing!
41 Posted 28/10/2014 at 13:43:35
As far as I know, Catterick was the only Everton manager who created two separate Championship-winning sides. And, although I understand he may have added the steel to the side he inherited, without doubt the second side was certainly all his.
42 Posted 28/10/2014 at 13:41:43
Catterick admired hard working players who did not argue with him and that is why he got rid of Collins, Vernon and Young. Collins went on to be Don RevieÂs best ever signing (RevieÂs words). Catterick took over the Carey team when Carey was infamously sacked against the fans wishes.
One clown on here actually rated Catterick with Shankly!! I have been an Evertonian since 1948 and even I have to say that Shankly was a genius. He brought a pretty average Liverpool side up from the 2nd division to become the side that absolutely dominated football without foreign players or bags of money.
Catterick could and should have left a legacy at Goodison in the same way but we were a selling club and profits ruled even back then. We could have had a conveyor belt of Championship-winning teams if the board and Catterick had not been too ready to break up a great side when it had the nucleus to continue its progress.
IMO we missed the boat big time and Liverpool became the top team in the country for years. Talk to people who were around then and you will find they agree with me.
Catterick could have been the equal of Shankly if he had used his brain and not been so stubborn. If anyone suggested anything to him that was contrary to his ideas then they were wrong. I have always said that if someone cannot change his mind then he is an idiot!!
Shankly handed over a great side to Paisley who was clever enough to continue to keep what was not broken. Catterick did not!!
43 Posted 28/10/2014 at 16:39:22
Gordon West – lost form, had to be replaced.
Tommy Wright – forced into retirement by injury in 1972 aged 28.
Keith Newton – never showed his best form at Everton so had to be replaced.
Howard Kendall – became captain after Bally left and carried the team for a couple of years; survived Catterick, sold by Billy Bingham as part of the Bob Latchford deal.
Brian Labone – injury forced him to retire in 1971.
Colin Harvey – increasingly injury prone but survived Catterick, sold by Bingham.
Jimmy Husband – even more injury prone than Harvey but still survived Catterick - Billy Bingham sold him early in the 1973-74 season.
Alan Ball – his big mistake.
Joe Royle – struck down by a back injury when in his prime and never the same player after that. Survived Catterick and sold by Bingham.
John Hurst – Survived Catterick and way into the Bingham era.
John Morrissey – Age and injuries caught up with him; sold to Oldham where he played something like six games before having to retire.
Alan Whittle – I think he was mishandled by Catterick, who sold him in December 72 to raise money for the signing of Joe Harper – Sir John Moores liked to balance the books!
Mentioning Harper brings me to where I think he went wrong: the players he brought in werenÂt good enough. Harper flopped, Henry Newton, signed as a midfield player, ended up battling for the left-back slot with another flop, John McLaughlin. Mick Bernard as BallyÂs eventual replacement! Dave Lawson a record fee for a keeper in those days. Some of those signings were before his heart attack but I definitely think his ill-health had an effect – I canÂt believe he scouted players as thoroughly as he did before.
44 Posted 28/10/2014 at 17:49:56
Oh Liverpool dominated the 60s 70s and 80s... total myth, they never. Bitter? Moi? You bet your sweet life I am.
45 Posted 28/10/2014 at 19:22:34
Catterick brought us two Championships, one FA Cup, another Cup Final appearance. We rarely finished outside the top six and were denied Inter-Cities football on a few occasions because of the one team/one city farce.
Avuncular Matt Busby won two leagues and a cup and, fair play, the European Cup.
Genial Joe Mercer / wide boy Malcolm Allison won one league and one cup.
Sinister Don Revie assembled the most unpleasant bunch of psychos and won... one league.
Rent a gob Shankly... two leagues and a cup
Genius Bill Nicholson, three cups and a league.
In the process, from 1967 onwards, Catterick developed a team that was widely acclaimed as a true footballing side. In the seventies, it went tits up.. as it did for Man Utd. Neither Leeds Utd nor Man City kicked on to dominate in that decade. Spurs? ... well, they were Spurs. All these sides spent time in the second, and indeed, third division..
Yes, the Cat suffered from a total lack of charisma and was never a media man but he didn’t do too badly. A bit of credit / respect due!
46 Posted 28/10/2014 at 19:37:55
Catterick won it in 1963 and 1970 with the FA Cup in 1966 and all this whilst attempting to play the game in the correct manner, not the kick anything that moves type of teams that Leeds and Liverpool were at the time.
One of my relations said it was the best time to watch Everton, and he should know as he's been going to Goodison for more than 60 years. Catterick may well have lacked the communication skills in relation to the press but he knew what type of football Evertonians wanted to watch and he provided it and more... If the Cat's not to be mentioned in the same breath as Shanks et al then obviously some of the older generation must have blue-tinted memories.
48 Posted 28/10/2014 at 20:22:26
The other name he was called was "Fish and Chips" because he was never out of the paper.
Catterick knew the score; he would say "IÂm not Rob Roy" in relation to ShanklyÂs act with the press.
49 Posted 29/10/2014 at 08:14:48
Great post.
50 Posted 29/10/2014 at 13:58:17
But if you look at the sixties, they were pretty much on a par in terms of trophies except Shankly inherited a team he needed to carry further as the RS were lower than Everton but that should balanced against the fact that Catterick won trophies early/mid and late 60s. Whereas Shankly only produced one side.
Shankly was a great manager, of course I do accept that, and he went onto create another side in the 70s but who knows what Catterick would have done if his health hadn't failed?
51 Posted 29/10/2014 at 15:42:06
Catterick was every bit as good as Shankly.
Shankly was the first Liverpool manager to be given any money to spend, he bought Yeats, St. John and other players to get them out of the second division and of course he was a very good manager, but a genius? Give it a rest.
Was he a genius at Carlisle, Grimbsy and Huddersfield? I donÂt think so.
52 Posted 29/10/2014 at 17:46:37
The odd thing was that I only met Catterick once – long after he had retired – and he exuded charm totally at odds with the image I had always held of him. A true great.
53 Posted 29/10/2014 at 19:33:25
I have to say I never had an inkling of any such disparity in opinion as regards Harry Catterick. I'd always just assumed he was lauded by anyone who witnessed first-hand what will pretty much remain a mythical era to the likes of me born in 1979, a time brought to life only by a handful of archive clips, whatever reading matter I've ever been able to get my hands on and stories passed on by family and friends of more advanced years than myself.
Sure, I'd picked up over the years that Catterick was widely regarded as a dour, 'cards close to his chest' sort and knew of the unrest caused by certain decisions he'd made (e.g. dropping Alex Young, selling Alan Ball) but would never have imagined I'd read of people who were there in the '60s effectively talking down his achievements or comparison with those contemporaries of his that still manage to get a mention in popular circles and even labelling his teams workmanlike and a reflection of his inherent dourness.
I'm not criticising these opinions at all; as I say, I wasn't even born yet, I just find it so interesting to hear the range of accounts and hope more people find time to chip in with their thoughts and reminiscences...
Look out, Rob Sawyer, you might require a few extra pages for the 2nd edition mate!! Thanks again, folks.
54 Posted 29/10/2014 at 20:05:09
To have been a part of that scene was to have known football at its very best. Truly honoured just to have been in the crowd. We all accepted that Carey had laid the foundations but to Catterick went the glory... and rightly so.
55 Posted 29/10/2014 at 22:03:31
I hope those who read the book enjoy it. Jamie (53), my publishers would be ecstatic if it sold enough to warrant a reprint but your idea of a memories section is a good one!
56 Posted 29/10/2014 at 23:05:16
I’ll tell you one thing though – watching Everton say from 1972 to 1974 hardly made me feel I was part of a lucky generation....
57 Posted 30/10/2014 at 08:54:32
Brilliant work on putting this book together – I just got the email saying my copy is en route up to a very stormy Argyll where I live these days. Can't wait to get stuck into it on what promise to be several rainy days over the coming weeks!
Thanks also for your fantastic series of interviews with some of our past heroes, you've got a real talent for asking the right questions and put it all together in a very engaging final draft. Keep up the good work and UP THE TOFFEES!
58 Posted 30/10/2014 at 12:05:51
59 Posted 30/10/2014 at 13:22:48
Catterick very generously lifted the FA Cup from the rope luggage holders above the seat and let each of us hold it for a moment or two. Wonderful moment and one which I shall never forget. He was anything but dour.
60 Posted 30/10/2014 at 16:30:59
I agree wholeheartedly with you, Ray, about Catterick at Blackpool. I was near the team coach and there was a lot of shouting abuse at him. We asked Alan Ball to sign for us and he replied, "See your manager."
Harry had dropped Alex Young and Gordon West for a 16-year-old Joe Royle and an unknown Geoff Barnett. Losing 2-0, the fans were upset.
61 Posted 13/11/2014 at 10:02:38
In those days, John Moores put money in to buy players but I don't think the directors ever ran it as a business, unlike say Man Utd or Liverpool for that matter. If it had been, I feel we would have had far greater success over the years and I believe it still holds true to-day (kit sponsorship, etc.)
There was a TV program (dead cool) 1966-67 – T.H.E. Cat – T. Hewitt Edward Cat – Look it up on IMDb, that's where he got his name from.
The players were a bit frightened of Catterick, and wanted obviously to play for the first team; in those days, you got more money for first team appearances than the reserves. When they were training, they used to watch his office windows to see when the Venetian blinds moved, as they knew he was in then and watching them. The level of intensity went up.
As an Evertonian, you never knew that the club were ever interested in a player, no speculation, nothing. You just read that Everton had signed 'so and so'.
Everton and their style of play was held in great esteem, not just by fans but by players also. Jimmy Greenhoff was a great forward. He was signed by Man Utd. His club (Sheff Utd?) told him, after he had put pen to paper, that another club had also wanted to sign him – Everton. He was very upset and miffed as he would have preferred us.
Everton had some great players. If an opposing player had the ball and was running at full tilt, Roy Vernon would run alongside and hook the ball away. To this day I still don't know how he did it!
Bally, his football brain was so quick! He had the ball and an opponent came to tackle him, he played a one-two off his shin and was off with the ball!!
Often on a Saturday night (late on) I would go to the Royal Tiger, on Manchester St (do you remember it?) – long gone!! – to stand alongside your heroes, as they would often go there after a home game; to see them with a ciggy and a beer was surreal. You would often see them in The Beachcomber, they were always very approachable.
Happy days, great football, great players, great supporters, and still a great club.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

1 Posted 25/10/2014 at 18:42:21
Could this early education at the feet of the great man account for your rather high standards when judging the contributions of more current incumbents of the Goodison hotseat?