25/05/2025 49comments  |  Jump to last
Newcastle Utd 0 - 1 Everton

A fine win at Newcastle brings to an end another season — this one obviously historic as the final one at Goodison Park… but we did all that last week.  

Winning the last three games of the season is not something Everton can usually manage to pull off. And especially considering the extenuating circumstanaces of recent seasons which have seen too many prolonged relegation battles going down to the wire, it was something of a relief to reputedly have "nothing to play for…" that is, nothing except pride in the Royal Blue shirt of Everton Football Club. 

For this was a game where the priveleged few who were there, way up high in the stands, would have gained so much pleasure from that very special moment when Vitalii Mykolenko picked out Charly Alcaraz with a peach of a corss, the Argentinian rising like a transatlantic Salmon to connect perfectly with it and power his header past a static and staionary Nick Pope in the Newcastle goal.

This was on the back of yet more resolute defending, despite the absence of centre-backs James Tarkowski and Jarrad Branthwaite, with two other aging exponennts of the defensive game in Ashley Young and Idrissa Gana Gueye putting in massive performances despite their advancing years. 

All the more impressive from Young, who has been derided by many fans simply becuase of his age, and the conviction before so many games this season that he would be torn asunder by younger nimbler faster feet — like those of former Blue Anthony Gordon, who didn't even make it into the second half against his former team with Young pretty effective on that flank. 

And in goal, it was another fine perfromace by Jordanm Pickford, who had is own special reason to clebrate the promotion of his home club Sunderland, by  pulling out all the stops with some fine saves to prevent crucial goal attempts that could have seen an entirely different scoreline. 

Three fine wins to take us to the new Hill Dickinson Stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock, and a new era under new management. David Moyes has set himself a high standard to maintain when the new season starts. He described today's win over Newcastle United as "as good as we've had this season", while insisting the monumental effort of his players was a sign of the standards that should be expected moving forward.

“I think it said more about the players who are playing for Everton today, in terms of what they put in and the character they've got.

“Since I've come in, I can only tell you that the players have been brilliant – their effort, their commitment, their drive.

“Today, we tried to work out how we could make it difficult for Newcastle, because they're coming to qualify for the Champions League today but I thought the players’ mentality was so good.

“If they keep that up, then it will give us every chance. I've said many times we might lack a bit of quality, but it's not the heart, it's not the commitment.

“Some of the players today were immense, they really were. There's quite a few players there who may not be here next season and they didn't flinch once, which is a credit to their professionalism. 

“I think that’s a little bit of what this club does to you. You can't give in, you will not give up on it. It's not accepted.

“So what I want them to do now is I want us to take this absolutely into the new stadium.

“I want us to bring good atmosphere in. I mean I have to say the atmosphere inside St James' Park today was incredible, it really was. I hope that it's us who in the future, we're the ones who are challenging for Champions League and we can show them exactly what we've got.

“The away support was brilliant again and we’re thankful we've been able to give them something. We’ve won a few away games and they can travel home today and have a few drinks and enjoy it. 

“The support has been magnificent, I've got to say, whether it be at Goodison or away from home, I think it's been great. So now we need to all come together and make sure this is going to happen at the new stadium because we're going to need it.”

But before then is the small matter of half the squad on the point of leaving this summer — we already have four confirmed departures in Young, Doucoure, Begovic and Virginia, with decisions on the remaining players expected as early as Monday.  

And the first part of the new transfer window, which opens in less than a week, with Everton's new owners strongly expected to show some key decsion-making when it comes to rebuilding the first-team squad with an eye to having them perform in the upper half of the Premier League next season. 

 

Reader Comments (49)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Neil Cremin
1 Posted 25/05/2025 at 21:55:35
I’ve been attacked by saying that I was in the “never go back” camp but did admit at the time that, given our predicament and the managers who were available with premier league experience, Moyes was the safest option.

I did have faith that he would keep us up but the results have been incredible. However today was a masterclass on motivation.

The performance we got from all the team (staying and going or in limbo) was nothing short of incredible.

It may not all be down to Moyes but something has definitely changed in the Everton mindset since Dyche departed. Take your pick.

Paul Kernot
2 Posted 25/05/2025 at 21:57:12
Firstly, brilliant write up Michael. Well done sir.

Second - wow! Moyes and by extension the lads today made more than a few of us think twice. I love his rallying cry for the start of next season in the new stadium - giving up is not accepted. He also praised the supporters. Just words? Just players who are leaving knowing they were in the shop window today? Maybe, but we can't argue with the fact that they've made a habit of these results since Davey's return.

Peter Moore
3 Posted 25/05/2025 at 22:00:37
Wonderful to read that.

UTFT.

If, 'NSNO', is an apt description of our transfers incoming this summer, we can hit the ground running at Hill Dickinson and do something special next season.


Good luck TFG in securing the talent we need.

COYB!

Jeff Armstrong
4 Posted 25/05/2025 at 22:01:38
This season is over, Moyes did what was asked, he now has to keep it going moving forward into the new ground.
He’s only as good as his last game.
If he keeps the progress going and actually wins a cup, then fantastic well done.
Or we could get Ange and be guaranteed a cup the season after next😜
Neil Cremin
5 Posted 25/05/2025 at 22:08:21
Cheeky Jeff and finish 17th just above relegation zone

We’ve had enough of that over the past number of years. It is now time for a brand new dawning whoever leads us to the promised land. For now I put my trust in DM and hope the Friedkins.

Colin Glassar
6 Posted 25/05/2025 at 22:08:48
For the away fans to out-sing the geordies was epic, almost biblical. Our away support is the best in the land. Well done to you all.
Jeff Armstrong
7 Posted 25/05/2025 at 22:17:50
Well Neil, we’ve done 16th and thereabouts with no cup,

I’d take a cup no problem, whats the point of 7th-15th with no silverware?

I’d love to become a cup team, FA cup next season, League cup the next, Europa plus a domestic the year after,

Dreamland.

(Oh and BTW Weve got 9 league titles to go with them)

Neil Cremin
8 Posted 25/05/2025 at 22:39:39
Let’s just dream of a bright future where we no longer wake up Sunday mornings with a knot in our stomach and wonder where the next victory will come.
I
Tony Abrahams
9 Posted 25/05/2025 at 22:41:59
I think the biggest fault, (possibly the only real fault) with David Moyes, first time around, was that over the years he never tried hard enough in way too many cup competitions, imo.

I’d take seventeenth and a cup, over seventh, sixth, fifth, seventh, fifth and sixth, and another six years without winning anything, because trying to win trophies, is what Everton’s primary existence should always be about, imo, and winning trophies is the only thing that is going to make Everton, a proper relevant football club, outside of our own fanbase.

Moyes has got loads more experience, and Moyes already understands almost everything about our club. The only bit he hasn’t experienced is watching us celebrate winning a trophy, so he will only truly understand everything about us if he can finally make this happen!🤷‍♂️

Mick O'Malley
10 Posted 25/05/2025 at 23:57:31
Tony agreed, Spurs fans shouldn't care were they've finished they won a trophy, I'd love to see us lift a cup, my first was 84 and I loved it more than any trophy cos it showed we could win things
Paul Kossoff
11 Posted 26/05/2025 at 01:00:51
Dosnt it feel like no one give a flying fk about the red shite #*"#* the league? Well done Moyes and the boys for pulling the socks up after Dino went and getting us safe early. We can all look forward to next season with some excitement and believe. Top half a must, possible European place would be nice and a few good signings to bolster our under strength squad. All the best to all you blue boys and good health be upon you and yours.
Michael Coville
12 Posted 26/05/2025 at 01:33:31
Over the last few years, our objective has been to stay up, so the cup games have taken second place. No good winning a cup if you get relegated.

Palace showed that it can be done but the Top 6 have won the cups most years. It all comes down to having a strong squad, which we don't have at present. And with so many players leaving, it is unlikely that will change next season.

Hopefully we will have a better team but strong back-ups is going to take more than a season. I believe that the first objective is to get into Europe, then the increased revenue (and the fact that the best payers want to play for a team in European competitions) will allow us to get a stronger squad.

Having said that, I was at Wembley in 1966 and 1995 and would love us to win another cup, maybe miracles do happen.

Dupont Koo
13 Posted 26/05/2025 at 02:52:08
If Moyes' dithering costs us the chance of signing Charley permanently, it will be as close to utterly criminal and malpractice as one can imagine.
Mike Gaynes
14 Posted 26/05/2025 at 03:04:26
How do you know Moyes is dithering?
Ernie Baywood
15 Posted 26/05/2025 at 04:47:19
I was very much in the Dyche Out/Moyes In camp.

I always saw his appointment as targeting stopping the bleeding, restoring some pride, getting us competitive again, and then handing over to someone who could take another step.

He'll obviously get a chance to do more if things go well, but he's made a good start to the first bit of his job. It feels like we're watching Everton again - not that cowardly dirge that was served up week after week. I actually look forward to watching us nowadays and it feels like a shame that the season is done.

Mark Andersson
16 Posted 26/05/2025 at 06:28:20
What a great win, hats off to Moyes, I'm no fan. It's going to be a interesting summer.

No doubt the debates of who goes and who comes in will keep us occupied on here.

Most importantly the fans need to be behind the team and bring the Goodison roar to BMD.

Tom Sellick
17 Posted 26/05/2025 at 06:48:33
Both Everton and Newcastle lost a total of 12 league games this season. They sneak into Champions League.
That’s got to be a positive message to take into the summer - quality and clinical striker to make those one-points three-points and fingers crossed…
Alan J Thompson
18 Posted 26/05/2025 at 07:13:07
I was and said at the time that I thought Moyes was the best immediately available until the end of the season but after his achievements so far he has to start, at least, next season and so we move on to next season's expectations.

As someone old enough to think that challenging for honours was a given at Everton, do we wait to see what signings we make or is a top half finish the minimum expectation for next season.

Is it forever as they say in other circles a case of;

"The King is dead, long live the King", or was that killed off by the last pretender of which there has been several under the previous proprietors.

Danny O'Neill
19 Posted 26/05/2025 at 07:39:26
It is a positive Tom, anything is possible. The biggest difference is that they won 20 games, we only 11.

Back in January, I doubt there were many who thought we would finish on 48 points and be above Manchester United and Tottenham.

So, job done, mission accomplished, but now the real work starts for Moyes and the club.

Marc Hints
20 Posted 26/05/2025 at 08:41:24
We need to get this recruitment right, although it will tough with no European football to offer players.
Hope the project, new owners and amazing stadium will be enough to convince some decent players to join.
One thing is for sure the rot has finally stopped and the first coat of varnish is on, new owners, new ambition and a club which will be finally run professionally.
The future is certainly bright and next season watch us finally fly.
Above all the noise from the best fans in the world in a new stadium will be something else.
David Bromwell
21 Posted 26/05/2025 at 09:20:56
Who would have thought that we would have got anything from that game, with key players missing and Newcastle seeming to need a win to secure their place in Europe. But we did it in style with everybody playing their part.

Key now will be, how things work out during the summer, because as things stand at the moment we only have about 14 players with first team experience signed up and ready to play. So no respite for the Manager and the Support Staff, and in the circumstances I think we will see a number of the loan players and those out of contract still on the books next season.

I think the planned trip to America, will add to the pressure and make the summer break that much shorter. It's no easy job Managing in the Premiership, and for Moyes and Co they will have the added pressure of securing almost a whole team of new faces. So starting today I expect we will see some announcements some good, some surprising and some controversial. But given the circumstances that is inevitable. So the football news will still be headlines, no summer recess for us and no doubt lots of points for discussion.

Daniel A Johnson
22 Posted 26/05/2025 at 09:37:59
I'm not a Moyes fan and was actually gutted he came back.

I was wrong.

The David Moyes we have today is a much better experienced manager than the one who left us.

He's a perfect fit for us, the rebuild starts in the summer and I think we have the best man for the job.

Martin Reppion
23 Posted 26/05/2025 at 09:40:16
Brilliant end to a season. As one in the 'who the hell do they think they are' brigade, I'm just annoyed that the referee at Old Trafford denied Villa the chance to really piss on the barcodes' chips.

But to more important matters.
We all know that we need a minimum of 7/8 new faces this summer. Or at least the resigning of some of the better older ones.

One back up keeper plus one of the young ones, Harry Tyrer?
At least 2 full backs.
One centre back or a new deal for Keane.
Gana Gueye or a replacement.
Pace and creativity. And a decent centre forward to replace or complement what we have.

I hope that by next Monday the names on the roster start appearing. We can't leave it until late in the summer when clubs will have us over the barrel.
A 'name' signing or two now will show we mean business. I hope this is what the backroom have been planning. That may encourage other players to join our party, rather than sign for the usual suspects.
Whatever happens. Have a great summer. Come back fit and ready to cheer, moan, laugh and cry. Its Everton after all.

Martin Mason
24 Posted 26/05/2025 at 09:42:42
Interesting that we don't really seem to have a best 11, that substitutes rarely improve or make us worse and that non-availability of players doesn't seem to affect the quality of play overall. Moyes seems to have a preference for Harrison to start but strangely we don't seem to miss Tarks in fact we seem to have been better using defenders like O'Brien who are better players. Overall we seem to have a fairly decent squad now which has the potential to perhaps see us top ten but we need to find quality players to improve our potential now or our current improvement could peter out. RB is a serious problem but I trust the club to retain players that we need to and to find players that we need in a very difficult market. Well done Everton for the turnaround, all that I ask are to build on our very good defensive shape and fluidity and be a little more adventurous once we have players who can produce it. How can we replace Gana and Picks though?
Brent Stephens
25 Posted 26/05/2025 at 09:49:19
Martin #24 "Interesting that we don't really seem to have a best 11, that substitutes rarely improve or make us worse". I think generally you're right, Martin. So it becomes a matter of opinion who should start, and it doesn't make too much difference. Ditto with subs, as you say.

Having said that, I guess many other teams are in the same situation - the difference being that changing their starting line up, or making a different decision about which subs to bring on, doesn't weaken their relatively superior strength as a team.

Neil Cremin
26 Posted 26/05/2025 at 09:58:08
I know this may be unpopular but too many new faces into a squad can be disruptive to team morale
Yesterday was an unbelievable example of how this team is bonded particularly when you consider the number that were either out of Conor would not have their contract renewed. The unity in the dressing room and the professionalism of the players. Not sure if another loan spell is possible but I would retain Harrison. The team needs tweaking with
1. A clinical strikers but would definitely retain Beto
2. A young holding midfielder to replace Gana in time
3. A box to box player with big engine and good ball control to replace the departing Doucs
4. A RB and cover to replace Young and Patterson.
5. Back up keeper
What is most important is that we bring in team players and not egoists who could derail the whole momentum
Raymond Fox
27 Posted 26/05/2025 at 10:18:44
I think you have hit the nail on the head there Neil, I couldn't agree more.

I think we will be a much more attractive destination for players next season. Add to that there are a record number of teams having to play 3 times a week which takes its toll on their performances over a season.

Next season will be our chance to get much higher up the League.

Jerome Shields
28 Posted 26/05/2025 at 11:22:20
Moyes organised the team to nick a win and had the players geared up to do so. He gave Howe a bit of a lesson.

Moyes will do what it takes to maintain the existing squad.
Moyes has a different type of midfielder than Doucoure in mind, who was hitting his head off a brick wall in negotiations.

Harrison will be kept and Calvert-Lewin's negotiations will be given more time. Alcaraz will be the big buy of the window and a right back to replace the aging Young.

Ryan Holroyd
29 Posted 26/05/2025 at 11:42:51
If Alcaraz at £12M is our big buy of the transfer window. then we will be lower bottom half next season.
Neil Cremin
30 Posted 26/05/2025 at 11:50:08
Ryan
Please justify your reasons
Ryan Holroyd
31 Posted 26/05/2025 at 11:54:31
Well, it's ridiculous to say Alcaraz will be our biggest buy of the season at £12M.

We need goals all over the side and keeping more or less the same team will not get enough goals.

Thankfully it's only Jerome and he talks utter shite.

Danny O'Neill
32 Posted 26/05/2025 at 12:22:47
Have you watched Alcaraz play Ryan? Did you watch him yesterday?

Mate, you're better than your one liner throw away comments. Add substance to your thinking. Which you probably can do.

David Bromwell
33 Posted 26/05/2025 at 12:35:18
I have just re checked the numbers of players we now have with first team playing experience, which I make to be 14, 15 if you include one of the young goalkeepers currently out on loan. So that means we need to recruit something like 7 extra players to give us a fair chance of finishing in the top half of Division. We will need some quick fix solutions, to supplement a number of hopefully key additions. That's a lot of work and I am sure it will not be easy and straightforward.
Neil Cremin
34 Posted 26/05/2025 at 12:50:40
Ryan

Biggest buy should not be measured in monetary outlay but in value for money

See O Brien, Ndiaye for example

I am not yet totally convinced on Charly being the player everyone raves about but should be bought because he does add quality going forward.

I have already outlined my thoughts above where many of the back up buys are young hungry players who can fit easily into the current Everton mindset

Going on a spending spree this summer without careful consideration of whethe they are a good fit for the TEAM will have us back in the Koemann/Walsh era which was the start of the current demise

Mark Murphy
35 Posted 26/05/2025 at 12:55:32
I’ve always been concerned at the lack of goals from midfield over the past few seasons.
With Ndiaye and Alcaraz I think we can improve that.
Neil Cremin
36 Posted 26/05/2025 at 13:03:52
I would be a bit more confident in our Summer signings if Thelwell were looking after sourcing bargain players
Will be interesting to see who he brings into Rangers
Martin Mason
37 Posted 26/05/2025 at 13:05:34
This board would be mech better without the personal insults. They demean the site but mainly the people doing the insulting.
Raymond Fox
38 Posted 26/05/2025 at 13:16:30
I confidently predict we wont be dicing with relegation next season.

Although it might depend if our owners back Moyes who is certain to want to splash out on some players. He's not getting any younger and will want to stay here for another 2 years at least.

We do need a right back, but defence wise there's only 3 teams that have conceeded less goals than us which is pretty remarkable.

Yes we have not scored enough to get us higher but as Mark above says we do look more threatening from midfield now.

Danny O'Neill
39 Posted 26/05/2025 at 13:31:01
Totally Neil @34. How you spend can be equally as effective as how much you spend.

I agree with you and others who are reserved on Alcaraz. He's not the finished article, but in the right team, and at 22 years old, we would be buying potential as well as talent.

Regardless of budget, I agree with your last paragraph. We need to avoid spending recklessly and spend wise.

Over to the scouting and recruitment team.

Sorry to labour the point, but Ryan, why label a fellow supporter as talking "utter shite"? Maybe just challenge their opinion if you don't agree with it.

Sean Kelly
40 Posted 26/05/2025 at 13:52:21
Ryan have a bit of manners lad. everyone's opinions are welcome here whether you agree with them or not. Yours are also welcomed here whether we agree or not. Give yourself a rest lad. Things could be worse lad. If you live in the city you might have to deal with the devil's spawn celebrating. CHEER UP
Andy Crooks
41 Posted 26/05/2025 at 14:02:57
Neil, top post @26.
Raymond Fox
42 Posted 26/05/2025 at 14:13:07
We would all be a lot richer if we could see into the future.

Its ok to talk about value for money, but that's all down to who's making the final decision to buy to decide.
They wouldn't make the decision if they didn't think the price was right, how it turns out is all in the future.

Tony Abrahams
43 Posted 26/05/2025 at 14:13:33
I thought it was only a good post Andy, because Neil, didn’t highlight that we need more pace on the flanks!
Phil Roberts
44 Posted 26/05/2025 at 14:17:12
Sean - the good news is it looking like it is going to absolutely chuck it down and in the words of the song rain on my parade. It also a howling gale, 14c and feels like the middle of winter.
Liam Mogan
45 Posted 26/05/2025 at 14:18:51
It's crucial that any recruitment adds real quality and pace. I'd rather 3/4 quality additions than 7/8 average players.

The team has proven since January that with solid management and renewed belief they can win games. More quality and not just more of the same pls, if we want to add another 10/12 points to this seasons total, which should be achievable.

Neil Cremin
46 Posted 26/05/2025 at 15:04:25
Thanks Andy and Tony

Thought I was getting ahead of myself and didn’t go on. 😀

How’ever I would be fearful of too many changes which would disrupt the spirit of the dressing room particularly if some of the new signings started to get disgruntled if not selected. There is also the January window to make further improvements

I believe we have the building blocks of a decent side, the task is to fortify and future proof the defense, and build a more clinical midfield and attack,

Remember Rome wasn’t built in a day.

Edward Rogers
47 Posted 26/05/2025 at 15:11:21
Agree with most on here, players with pace & a bit of a mean streak are what we need. Let's not get too carried away, next season will surely be one of transition, but with the right additions we may ( hopefully) surprise a few people.
Ryan Holroyd
49 Posted 26/05/2025 at 15:23:48
I like Charly but I would be very disappointed if he was our biggest signing this summer.
James Fletcher
50 Posted 28/05/2025 at 10:12:11
Richarlison looked shit in the Europa final, not sure he's got it anymore.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb