20/04/2025 139comments  |  Jump to last

Everton boss David Moyes has opted to focus on the positives following his side’s 2-0 defeat to Manchester City at Goodison Park on Saturday. Late goals from Nico O’Reilly and Mateo Kovacic sealed the job for Pep Guardiola’s side.

The Blues gave a strong account of themselves against last season’s champions. James Tarkowski struck the woodwork from a corner while Jarrad Branthwaite missed a golden opportunity to give the hosts the lead.

"We've done an awful lot of good things and we're getting better. It says a lot that we're disappointed to lose 2-0 against Manchester City. I'm sort of smiling that people think we should be disappointed. I am, but we've got to remember how good a side they are," Moyes told Sky Sports after the game.

Everton had to make a massive change to the backline after Tarkowski was forced off the pitch following a hamstring injury just six minutes after the interval. His replacement, Michael Keane, didn’t cover himself in glory and had an afternoon to forget.

"It is probably quality. Their subs came on and helped them. I'm not sure we had the same. We needed to find a way to get a goal but I genuinely think the injury to James Tarkowski was a big blow to us. It looks like a hamstring injury but what it is we don't know at the moment.”

Keane entered the referee’s book minutes after coming on and failed to deal with a bouncing ball, inadvertently directing it onto Omar Marmoush’s run instead. He was also caught on his heels and failed to cover O’Reilly’s near post run which broke the deadlock for City in the 84th minute.

"I thought for 60 minutes we did a lot of good things. I thought we played well in the first half but the injury to Tarkowski affected the side. Ultimately we didn't do well enough in the last 15-20 minutes and that cost us,” Moyes signed off.

 

Reader Comments (139)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Derek Powell
1 Posted 20/04/2025 at 18:00:20
What positives
Colin Glassar
2 Posted 20/04/2025 at 18:02:20
The only positive is the season is almost over and we survived
Jim Bennings
3 Posted 20/04/2025 at 19:05:52
Not many positives yesterday, maybe the first half we had it compact but the game was compounded by Tarkowski getting injured and Moyes making his first real blooper since he returned in bringing a rusty Michael Keane on in a game against Man City.

Nothing personal against Michael Keane, he seems like a class fella, but every time he's on the pitch in defence, bad things seem to happen. It's always been that way, whether it's been partnering Holgate, Godfrey, Mina in the past, or Tarkowski more recently.

We need this season over. It's been a bit of an upturn since Moyes arrived, we've definitely looked more attacking than the first half of the season when Dyche was killing us, and not softly either.

But the same old problems always seem to rear their head at this club. The lack of goal threat, the lack of striking credentials, the inability to find anyone anywhere in the squad with any real pace.

It's been a poor final season at Goodison. We have given the fans very little to shout about in the majority of the 17 home games played thus far, with only the late euphoria of the equalizer against the Redshite being the standout highlight.

The Cup ties at Goodison saw us go out on a whimper at home to Bournemouth and Southampton way back in September's League Cup tie.

We need to seriously reset things this summer and as I said a while ago, I want to see what the Friedkin Group are really made of.

Gerard Hogg
4 Posted 20/04/2025 at 20:43:56
Disappointing how a lot of fans felt they had to leave just after we went 1-down.

I'm 67 years old and never felt I should leave the game any time before the final whistle. Believe me, I've wanted to, I've seen some dire stuff.

But I've never insulted the players by walking out on them.
At least it meant the train into town from Kirkdale was only half-full.

Martin Berry
5 Posted 20/04/2025 at 20:52:00
A thank you to David Moyes who took over when Everton were in a perilous position, 1 point above the drop zone, taking over a squad that he inherited and did a miraculous job to get us where we are now.

Yet sadly we still get the ungrateful moaners, who seem to have a vendetta against him and try to suck the life out of the relief that we have of securing yet again Premier League status.

Yes, it's unsatisfactory to be celebrating survival, but survival we have; we can reset, bring players in, and let the Manager have a pre-season.

If there is no progress this time next year, then I can understand the moans… but right now, how about a bit of gratitude?

Paul Hewitt
6 Posted 20/04/2025 at 20:55:43
Moyes has my total gratitude.
Danny O'Neill
7 Posted 20/04/2025 at 20:57:48
I don't think we need to go down that route Martin @5.

He get's credit for doing well and if we perform well, even when the result go our way. The recent derby was a good example of that.

If we don't play well and the performance isn't what we want, he will get criticism, just as any manager or player(s) will.

It's not moaning.

Jeff Armstrong
8 Posted 20/04/2025 at 21:01:10
For fuck's sake, it's groundhog day on ToffeeWeb these days.
Danny O'Neill
9 Posted 20/04/2025 at 21:11:36
**even if the results don't go our way.
Derek Knox
10 Posted 20/04/2025 at 22:04:20
Now we are mathematically safe, and looking forward to another season in the Premier League, I feel a lot will hinge on what happens with signings and transfers etc. I hope we retain those worth retaining, and clear the rest of the deadwood out!

No sentimentality. Players who are right for Everton and the right age!

Mal van Schaick
11 Posted 20/04/2025 at 22:31:41
Colin #2.

That was exactly what has happened, and it made me laugh.

Josh Horne
12 Posted 20/04/2025 at 22:31:50
The team occupying our current league position for net spend in the past 5 years is Ipswich Town. In that period, they have spent £160M more than us and, for that amount, their solitary season in the top flight is about to end in failure.

We are the only team to have made a player trade profit over that time. It is a miracle we are in the Premier League at all, and results since January are far better than we can reasonably expect given the staggering disparity in team investment between us and our competitors.

13th and short-lived cup runs are not good enough for a club like Everton… but the reality is we are significantly overachieving relative to player investment. It would have been absolutely heartbreaking for Everton to play out the final season at Goodison in the Championship, or for it to end in relegation from the Premier League.

So well done to Moyes, Dyche, Thelwell, and all of the players and staff at the club for their remarkable achievements. I really hope that match-going fans are treated to a few final triumphant Goodison memories to cherish in the remaining games.

Everton supporters are the best and we have gone a long time without much reason to hope for better things to come. I have got faith in Moyes to strengthen the first team and squad depth so that we finish higher next year, even if the outlay on players is still under some, hopefully reduced, constraints. I'll take any improvement next season, alongside the return of belief that Everton really are on their way back.

Losing to the Premier League Champions from 4 of the past 5 seasons, with a net spend of £320M isn't a particularly meaningful point of reference.

There is lots to be positive about.

Brendan McLaughlin
13 Posted 20/04/2025 at 22:32:59
Danny #7,

It doesn't come across as moaning... but there's a not too far buried dislike of Moyes on ToffeeWeb that doesn't want him to do well and it surfaces more often than it should.

For the life of me... I don't get it.

Danny O'Neill
14 Posted 20/04/2025 at 22:50:48
I don't know many who don't want him to do well, Brendan, even the most vocal.

I think it's a different conversation in person, certainly the ones I have, be that with family, friends and at the match.

Most want Moyes to do well. Some, myself included, harbour reservations, but ultimately, if he does well, Everton do well, and that's what we all want, whoever the manager is.

What's important to some, is less so for others, and vice-versa. When I watch Everton, I want to see us compete, perform well, and excite the crowd and supporters. Do that and the results usually follow – as well as maybe a trophy or two and European qualification.

I can't remember many successful teams who did so by setting up not to lose. And like most, I do accept where we are right now. I'm just impatient!!

Very good balanced perspective, Josh.

Jim Bennings
15 Posted 20/04/2025 at 23:18:39
I'm desperate to see David Moyes do well.

I was one of those in January that backed the return of Moyes: right man at the right time… and I'd love that see him get this club a trophy to end the trophy drought.

Brendan McLaughlin
16 Posted 20/04/2025 at 23:18:42
Danny #14,

You've never read a post and thought... "He just doesn't like Moyes"?

Tom Bowers
17 Posted 20/04/2025 at 23:27:05
I agree Moyes has done a great job with the squad he inherited and has made them competitive as shown in the games against Forest, Liverpool, Arsenal and City.

Yesterday was unfortunate and I am sure the injury to Captain Tarkowski lost the game. However, I think we all agree that, until they get some real class up front, they will continue to be a mid-table team.

At the moment, Moyes has a very moderate bunch to choose from up front and we all hope that funding will become available to change that situation.

Danny O'Neill
18 Posted 20/04/2025 at 23:29:15
Posts yes Brendan. It was the same with Dyche, Ancelotti and a lot of Everton managers since Howard Kendall Mk 1.

The only ones that seemed to unify the majority in their discontent were Allardyce and Benitez. Once I got over the shock when we appointed him, I was willing to give Benitez a chance. It didn't last long and it went toxic early. As for Allardyce, I like to try and forget he was ever our manager and associated with the club. I think the feeling is mutual.

As I say, away from the keyboards, we can have a more sensible conversation even if we agree to disagree. Same with players.

I hope so Tom, and he will be given the opportunity to prove us wrong. If he wins us a trophy, I won't care if he's David Moyes, Carlo Ancelotti, Pep Guardiola or the spirit of Howard Kendall. Do that and I am just going to sit back and watch this city erupt.

Brendan McLaughlin
19 Posted 20/04/2025 at 23:49:42
Danny #18

None of those guys have come back for a second bite nor got it in the neck so early?

Danny O'Neill
20 Posted 20/04/2025 at 00:08:59
I said at the time Brendan, that Moyes coming back was going to be divisive and the fact we're having this conversation mate and the posts we have both read, it is proving to be so.

Unlike Kendall, who unfortunately and sadly, came back for a third bite, when the club was starting its descent from grace, he mostly retained the fans' backing because we remembered what he achieved as player and manager.

Moyes won't be held in that regard by a large section of the support base or have that level of sympathy or, dare I say, time.

He's got a chance. I just genuinely hope he grasps it and does not, repeat does not, play down expectations, like he did previously. The slightest sniff of that will be pounced upon, as we saw recently.

I hate it when Evertonians are divided. Of course we won't always agree, but want the same outcome for our club. And we should never forget, it's our club. Long after managers and custodians have been and gone, we and our descendants are still here and always will be.

I honestly understand both sides of the Moyes divide. I've got it amongst close family. And it is a divide. It splits opinion. The best thing that can happen is that the owners and recruitment team (or whatever they're going to call them), provide better players to improve us and he takes us to the next level and beyond. Otherwise, he'll be gone sooner rather than later. I hope not, because that will mean he failed. None of us want that, because it means Everton will have failed. And Everton is most important.

Sorry for the late volley. I've had about 8 hours sleep in 36 hours, so my body clock is all over the place.

Mark Andersson
21 Posted 21/04/2025 at 02:39:28
I will give credit to Moyes, I didn't want him back but he has done a good job.

The Freakin group played it safe. Moyes will be gone as soon as we have a bad run. The squad is not that good, and will take a few years to strengthen. I will be surprised if next season we finish mid table. It's imperative that we get off to a good start in the new stadium.
I'm back in the UK next week so intend to see BMD and say good bye to the old lady..

Paul Ferry
22 Posted 21/04/2025 at 03:31:35
I like that Mark (21): "The Freakin group".
Jerome Shields
23 Posted 21/04/2025 at 04:08:17
I just think that after Safety was achieved this season Moyes and those around him relaxed.From the Man United game to be exact.

Keane was thinking of his Summer Holidays when he unexpectedly was called upon.It showed when he played.

I have no comment to make on Moyes nothing after game presser.Expecting a reset in the Summer is a long shot, Everton should be on the front foot now.Hopefully TFG is , because Moyes isn't.

There are eight games till the end of the season and they should be made use of in terms of preparation for next season

Ernie Baywood
24 Posted 21/04/2025 at 04:15:00
I very much doubt any of that, Jerome.

Keane is a pro. He's just an aging, slow pro who hasn't played much Premier League football in a while and had to join a right game against one of the top teams in world football.

Why doubt his professionalism when there's already a completely obvious answer?

As for the team relaxing after Man Utd... they didn't look relaxed at Forest last week?

Mike Gaynes
25 Posted 21/04/2025 at 04:43:13
Ernie #24, heartily agree.

Josh #12, good perspective. There are certainly positives to take from the season, first and foremost the fact that we have real, credible, financially stable ownership for the first time in decades.

I would also highlight the influx of youth into the team. O'Brien, Alcaraz and Iroegbunam appear to be core players for the near future.

The most positive thing of all, however, is that it's April and my guts aren't in a knot fearing what might happen in May. It feels so good not to feel so bad.

Danny #14, agreed.

Eric Myles
26 Posted 21/04/2025 at 05:00:58
Danny #20 "Otherwise, he'll be gone sooner rather than later. I hope not, because that will mean he failed."

It will depend on TGFs KPIs as to whether he's failed.

If they expect him to win the league in his 2.5 years contract and he doesn't, then he's failed.

If they expect him to come in, steady the ship, achieve top 10 next season and be in European places the season after, i.e. do what he did last time, then achieving that will mean he's been successful, for TFG.

He will only have "failed" in the eyes of the supporters, and as you've witnessed in many posts there are many that will berate him for that...again.

Steve Brown
27 Posted 21/04/2025 at 05:35:27
13th is the better than the sleepless nights as we tottered around 16th and 17th for 3 years. For now.

There are a lot of comments here wondering what TFG’s goals, investment and KPIs will be - their corporate comms strategy seems to be based on telepathy so don’t expect any quick answers to these questions.

Steve Brown
28 Posted 21/04/2025 at 05:52:10
If TFG plan to remove the DoF role, then they had better get the key appointments in place before the end of the season or David Moyes is on a hiding to nothing next season.

I would anticipate that 8-9 players minumum will depart - DCL, Lindstrom, Broja, Keane, Holgate, Young, Begovic, Harrison with Mangala already departed. There will be decisions on Gueye, Doucoure, Seamus and Alcaraz.

That is a lot of change to a playing squad that is already weak.

Ernie Baywood
29 Posted 21/04/2025 at 07:33:36
Is it strange that we're hearing nothing on DCL?

I figured he'd probably played his last game but you would expect some updates, rumours, news.

Beto and Broja have probably improved the offer Everton would make. Or has he already signed for someone? That would slip out wouldn't it? It all seems a bit odd.

Jerome Shields
30 Posted 21/04/2025 at 07:36:05
Ernie#24

It was unprofessionalism that caused the goals. Last week Everton nicked a win against a under strength Forest side that allows teams possession.Though any win is welcome.

Everton do look improved in attitude and effort, but it going to take more than that to progress next season. I do grant you it is a improvement on Dyche though.

But after over 30 years of underachievement

and with a new well financed and professional regime , we all should be expecting more.Moyes is amongst the top five Premier League Managers in pay terms.If we settle for that performance from Moyes and the team against so called top teams that will be the performance we will get.A defeat which Moyes cherry picks.

Steve#28

It will be more a structural change.There will be some semblance of a DOF set up.

Moyes objective will be as little change as possible.He isn't a Manager who has dealt with alot of change.He will be aiming for what he knows in the face of so many changes.It was mismanagement previously that allowed so many contracts to end at the same time.Joe Royle was not able to cope with a lesser situation in the season after winning the FA Cup.

Tony Abrahams
31 Posted 21/04/2025 at 07:43:17
If you know your history Brendan, Howard Kendall, took as much stick as “any Everton manager” just before he began to turn us around at the beginning of 1984.

KENDALL AND CARTER MUST GO; FORTY THOUSAND STAY AT HOME FANS CANNOT BE WRONG - said the leaflets, and there was also a bit of graffiti on display.

Everyone wants Everton to win, (I usually write, imo, but don’t feel it’s necessary on this subject) and I think it’s ludicrous to suggest anything different Brendan, no wonder you often keep your thoughts to yourself when you’re sometimes asked for examples because coming out with statements like that on an Everton website, genuinely doesn’t make any sense (imo) mate!

Mike Gaynes
32 Posted 21/04/2025 at 07:49:57
No, Jerome, it wasn't "unprofessionalism" or "Summer Holidays" thinking that caused the goal. It was simple poor play by an aging, rusty player who wasn't all that good even before he was aging and rusty.

Keane can be blamed for a lot, but never, ever unprofessionalism. For months he played through a foot infection so severe it could have crippled him and had to wear a boot two sizes too large -- never missed a game and never mentioned it publicly until the following season. And he came back from a skull fracture in less than a month and immediately stuck his head in fearlessly.

He ain't much of a player, but he's 100% pro, and IMO you're flat-our wrong to say otherwise.

Robert Tressell
33 Posted 21/04/2025 at 08:06:02
Ernie # 29, DCL continues to be linked with Man Utd, Newcastle, Forest and West Ham plus a few European clubs. He might get offers from Saudi too. It looks like he’s leaving.
Tony Abrahams
34 Posted 21/04/2025 at 08:06:26
I still find it hard to believe a professional footballer could play in a boot two sizes too big whilst playing with such a dangerous injury Mike, so if that story is genuinely true then I shudder at how unprofessional the whole club had suddenly become?

Michael Keane has definitely shown his bravery at times but I’m definitely not taking that story as gospel, and believe it’s got to have had a few bevies thrown onto it!

Sam Hoare
35 Posted 21/04/2025 at 08:25:28
Mike@25, O’Brien certainly has done well but have Alcaraz and Iroegbunam done enough to suggest they are core players for the near future?

Iroegbunam in particular looks to me like he’s not at PL level yet, at least not in any deeper midfield role where he seems unaware and prone to letting runners past him regularly. I’d say he badly needs a loan move and a run of starts to up his level or maintain his sale value.

Alcaraz had a great start in our win over Palace but has not done a great deal since. £12m would seem like a good deal for him and personally I think he has talent but Moyes hasn’t started him in last 3 games and with McNeill coming back too it may not be obvious where the Argentine fits in.

Tony Abrahams
36 Posted 21/04/2025 at 08:36:17
Imagine being DCL, reading ToffeeWeb,, and smiling to himself with some of the criticism he receives?

They say I’m shite but wait until they see how much money I’m going to earn out of my next contract!

It wouldn’t surprise me if Dominic gets himself a £20 million signing on fee, and a £7.5 million x 3year contract on top,, but maybe I’m delusional and I’m just talking telephone numbers.

If I'm wrong and I am being delusional, then my belief is that the lowest he will earn for himself is £25million over the next three years? The money in football is absolutely obscene.

I have thought that Moyes, might not fancy Alkaraz, as much as a lot of Evertonians, Sam, because I don’t believe he has given him enough trust or game time when I look around our team. The kid Tim, shows little glimpses of talent but is miles away from being a consistent midfielder in the EPL, at the minute, imo

Mal van Schaick
37 Posted 21/04/2025 at 08:49:17
The lack of uncertainty is beginning to show from players who may be leaving as their contract may not be renewed, so there aren’t any positives for them.

The ins and outs will define any positive effect for the remaining players and incoming players, but these are pivotal moments for the future of the club in terms of progress and challenging for European places and trophies. Let’s hope that Moyes and co get it right.

Robert Birks
38 Posted 21/04/2025 at 08:56:56
All.out for Brentford pair Wissa and Mbeumo
Colin Glassar
39 Posted 21/04/2025 at 08:58:59
DCL must be Everton’s most vilified, attacked, slandered, libelled, smeared, denigrated, defamed, misunderstood, derided player since Lukaku.

A man who for years was played out of position (winger). A man who has always given his all on the pitch. A man who has been consistently starved of any kind of adequate service to play to his strengths etc…

I hope the lad leaves and, like Lukaku, goes on to better things. If he can stay injury free I can see him getting his England place back and winning trophies., something which is unlikely to happen anytime soon at Everton.

Robert Tressell
40 Posted 21/04/2025 at 09:14:01
Moise Kean also got pelters on here Tony - and is again one of the most highly sought after strikers in Europe after hitting 17 in 29 for Fiorentina this season.

How many would Wissa have got for us this season Rob B #38. About 8 is my guess.

Until there is a style of play which suits the striker - and players of pace and quality across the team - our strikers will continue to disappoint

Rob Halligan
41 Posted 21/04/2025 at 09:14:23
Jerome # 30…….So apparently we nicked a win against an Under Strength Forest team last week. Who exactly was missing from their starting eleven and subs bench that would normally be available? I know the likes of Yates and Elanga, both regular starters as far as I know, were on the bench, and both came on, but every one else of their starting eleven last week are regular starters. Unless, of course, I’ve misinterpreted your definition of Under Strength!

And nicking a win…….well I suppose it was “Nicked” in the sense that it was deep into injury time when we scored, but, in my opinion only one team wanted to win that game last week, and it most definitely wasn’t Forest.

Danny O'Neill
42 Posted 21/04/2025 at 09:17:24
The Everton winter of discontent Tony. The pressure on Howard was intense. It's famous for coming to a head at the Coventry home game with not much over 13,000 present, but there was bad feeling around the club. Poor performances, toxicity towards the manager, the prospect of being sucked into a relegation battle. Dark times, and not just the long winter nights.

All against the backdrop of difficult economic times, which hit the city of Liverpool particularly badly.

Fortunately, the club held it's nerve and when we got into the New Year, we never looked back. "tell me ma to put the champagne on ice" as the song went. Five months and two cup finals and a trophy later, we were in blue heaven. And it was only the start.

That's why I never stop believing Everton can rise again, now that we have the obvious off our back.

Totally Rob. Nicked maybe in the context of time of goal, but without stating the obvious, no game of football finishes until the final whistle has gone.

Colin & Robert, as a collective (not everyone), supporters of all clubs seem to have targets.

Calvert-Lewin right now. Moise Kean you mention. He was 19 years old in a foreign country in the glare of the Premier League at a struggling club. His CV includes Juventus, PSG, Everton and now Fiorentina, who are pushing for European qualification. He's still only 25.

We've done it over the years. Tom Davies came in for a lot of stick, as did Leon Osman and Tony Hibbert before him.

I don't mind criticism and criticising a player for performances, but it should never get personal.

Kunal Desai
43 Posted 21/04/2025 at 09:30:19
#Robert 38 - I was clamouring for us to look to get Mbeumo before Brentford got promoted. He and Watkins had a formidable partnership going.

I think he'll stay at Brentford for now, sadly if he leaves it'll be for a bigger club.

Robert Tressell
44 Posted 21/04/2025 at 09:49:03
Mbeumo is a genuinely good player, Kunal, and ‘gettable’ when we were more focussed on has beens like Rodriguez and massively overpriced players like Zaha.

He won’t join us this summer. We don’t have the money. I suspect he’s too expensive for anyone to seriously consider - about £50m to £65m. But may well leave next summer on a free for a Champions League club / contender.

Neil Lawson
45 Posted 21/04/2025 at 09:55:01
All the above provides an interesting read on a grey morning here in Devon and allows me an excuse to delay the planned long run around the lanes.

Moyes won't change. His team will always be well organised, hard grafting and safe. Flair players will be the exception. However, that should allow is to be competitive in all matches and always retaining the prospect of a positive result. I don't think it will ever be especially pretty, but if gets us up into the top half with the prospect of decent cup involvements, it will be a huge step up from recent years. Not for everyone; many of you understandably want to see more expansive play, but that requires a radical revision of the playing staff and, almost certainly, a new manager. I am reasonably content for solid progress, stability and more than a fair share of good results so that I can get back to looking forward to and enjoying matchdays and the conversations afterwards. Onwards to BMD and the end of miserable footie.

Howard Don
46 Posted 21/04/2025 at 10:00:58
Martin 5 spot on. Danny (7) also spot on, we ARE entitled to criticise any manager’s decisions if things don’t go well, eg) as soon as Tarks went down I said move Jake inside and bring on Patterson. I think Kean was the wrong call. However, that is worlds away from what Martin accurately calls a “vendetta” against Moyes. We all know where it comes from and it’s unpleasant and at times frankly irrational.
Brian Harrison
47 Posted 21/04/2025 at 10:18:59
The good thing for Moyes is he has had a good chance to asses the whole squad, and will know who he is keeping and who he will let go.
Moyes like the rest of us know that there arent enough goals in this side, defensively we are fine but the most expensive side to fix is the attacking third. So how much he will have to spend will be key as to how quickly he can solve the lack of goals issue.
The big plus will be with so many players who will be let go it will certainly allow him to use the money from the salaries of those let go to pay new players without it effecting our PSR to much.

I would also suggest we need some pace in midfield and definitely in attack. With the new stadium will come increased revenues and that will also give us a chance of putting together a decent squad. I would love us to be able to get Watkins from Villa and Bowen from West Ham, yes I know if either move it will be to one of the top 6. But for me they are exactly what we need pacey and both have good goal records. Mind I wouldnt turn my nose up at Mbueno or Wissa but again 2 probably destined for higher clubs than us at present.

Dave Williams
48 Posted 21/04/2025 at 10:27:21
The worst thing DCL ever did was pose for that photo wearing a skirt- so many on here turned against him after that.
When fit he is a quality player and needs a fast winger to supply him. Sadly he seems to be on his way and Beto or Broja don’t look to be the answer.
We cannot make wholesale changes even if we had the funds as that would destabilise the squad. We need to keep a decent core and add a few buys, couple of loans and young Armstrong.
We need a steady season to gradually make changes and gear up for a push for the top section of the league which will most likely be when Moyes maybe moves upstairs and a younger more progressive manager comes in. This type is no good for now- Moyes can steady the ship, sort out the youth teams and lay solid foundations again. He is the right man at the right time.
Jeff Spiers
49 Posted 21/04/2025 at 10:45:18
Jerome. 5 games left, mate
Steve Brown
50 Posted 21/04/2025 at 10:50:24
Robert @ 40, the season Moise Kean has 17 goals, Lookman has 18 goals and Iwobi has 9 goals.

They all had potential but did not thrive here, and earned the TW "championship at best" tag from many.

Phil Roberts
51 Posted 21/04/2025 at 10:51:24
I am in shock. Football Insider are reporting Everton will not be offering Michael Keane a new contract. I never saw that one coming.

A mid table team either needs a 20 goal striker or a midfield who scores 7-8 each per season. We have neither. A top side like we were in the 80s needs both. We have neither.

With Moyes' teams he had Cahill, Osman, Fellaini, Gravesen, Artera so it was a bonus to also have Yakubu or Saha (and Coleman, Baines and Lescott)

Somehow I think Moyes prefers the goals from everywhere model as the striker option is more expensive. Going the goals from everywhere route will (with the same tight defence) take us to the fringes of CL, and then the added money and profile will allow the purchase of the £75m 20 goals a season striker.

Still can't get my head around they are going to let Michael Keane leave 🤭🤦‍♂️🤣

Dave Abrahams
52 Posted 21/04/2025 at 11:17:54
I’ll absolutely guarantee that O’Brien will be better than Keane, whether he’ll be good enough to make that position his own I will have to wait and see especially when Tarkowski’s isn’t in the team with him.
Alan McGuffog
53 Posted 21/04/2025 at 11:19:18
We aren't going to be able to buy ourselves out of this very long standing malaise. Added to which why would good, established Premier League players want to come here ? It's a vicious circle. We need to players to create a side that attracts good players.
As many of us have moaned about for years, why aren't we picking up the players, from foreign parts, as the likes of Brrntford Brighton etc do ? Is it the scouting system ? Are players put off coming here ?
Anyway, here's hoping we aren't given a bag of magic beans in exchange for Jarrad.
Raymond Fox
54 Posted 21/04/2025 at 11:31:06
Some managers are better than others, that goes without saying, but the most important part of a club is the quality of the players.
Pickford and Branthwaite apart, is any of players wanted by your top 4-6 clubs, I doubt it. Maybe add Ndiaye in there.

The manager cant really be expected to challenge those top clubs consistantly without elite players.
I think we place too much importance on who is our manager at the time. Ok it makes for good discussion but I think we are looking in the wrong place for our shortcomings.

Colin Crooks
55 Posted 21/04/2025 at 11:44:37
"but there is a not too far buried dislike of Moyes on ToffeeWeb that doesnt want him to do well and it surfaces more often than it should

For the life of me I don't get it"

Well Why would you ? if ToffeeWeb is the prism through which you view Everton, you will have no clue about why so many Evertonians have a deep resentment of Moyes and his caution.

Its easy to get carried away with the propaganda surrounding who the media portray as "plucky Everton" The club which has no right to expect anything better than a manager who has achieved respectability and even won several manger of the month awards. Not for winning stuff mind, but for getting the club to "punch above it's weight".

Moyes and his now departed chairman had not only convinced the media that this great great club was a plucky little outfit doing better than it should do. They convinced many of our own fans all over the world of it too. A prophesy which was to become self fulfilling.."Good old Davey. he has restored pride"..."How on earth can fans not be grateful ?"...Grateful ???? Get me that fucking bucket again.

Those who missed family occasions. Regularly upset the Mrs and and spent all their hard earned cash travelling around the country to watch an Everton side fail to take a single big scalp at any of the top grounds in well over a decade will see it differently. They couldnt just shrug their shoulders and switch on BGT or strictly come dancing. They couldnt go to the local pub and have a few drinks with their friends. They were stuck on a train, a coach, or in traffic and were often not going to get back well after midnight. They had plenty of time to reflect on the disappointments of following a manager who has badly let them down by being less than brave.

I'm not saying that ALL Moyes's critics are match goers, or that the fans who cant be there arent as crushed by a defeat, but it would seem to me that the majority of his critics are people who have attended too many defeats where their team has capitulated all too readily.

A Manager of the month award and the ensuing praise from RS supporting pundits can cloud and sway a fans judgement, but a long miserable journey home after another surrender will always focus the mind.

Its ok saying give him a chance, but in the absence of a Crystal ball we only have Moyes's previous by which to judge him. The notion/claim that Evertonians want him to fail is beyond stupid. A Davey Moyes success = An Everton success. We all want it.

He's got a second chance The ball is in his court

Joe McMahon
56 Posted 21/04/2025 at 11:48:11
Steve@50, very good points. Kean and Lookman were young when they came here, neither were given time or patience. Iwobi was regularly slated. I really don't know why.
Brian Harrison
57 Posted 21/04/2025 at 11:54:53
I would just ask given that we have a dozen or so players out of contract and if we believe the rumours the manager will only get £50m to spend. Irrespective of who the manager is where do you think given that scenario we should finish next season?
Colin Glassar
58 Posted 21/04/2025 at 12:27:33
Great post, CC. My problem with Moyes is, I don’t trust him. Yes, he’s a top half manager. Yes, I think he will guarantee us safety next season, and the season after. The problem is, I think, that his own self-imposed ceiling limits him.

He’s a pragmatist before anything. Safety first then let’s see

Ian Bennett
59 Posted 21/04/2025 at 13:01:56
Then it's up to the Friedkins to manage.

He's two years left on his deal, and if he's hitting 'the glass ceiling', he will be moved on.

Second guessing if he's going to be great or shit is a bit of a waste of time. We need some stability & green shoots that is bringing in a better class of footballer. The first 4 months has been better, and the summer window should indicate where we are.

If it's then him or someone else that takes the club forward, then at least we have broken the previous cycle.

I think you have to buy into the Friedkins getting it right, and buy into them knowing what they're doing. This isn't Kenwrights trainset of Moyes or nothing, and no money/no vision.

Rick Tarleton
60 Posted 21/04/2025 at 13:36:00
The good thing is it took 80 plus minutes for City to break us down. Perhaps if Tarkowski had stayed on we might have managed to hold on, I emphasise perhaps.

Branthwaite was denied by an instinctive piece of goalkeeping and if that had gone in we may well have been celebrating a draw or even a win.

I was against Moyes coming back. He's a man for the relegation struggle, but, as last time, I can't see him taking us up to challenge for a European place.

This team is solid, but creativity is at a premium, and as for the strikers, they aren't likely to turn into fifteen goal a season men.

The transfer window will be interesting. Who will we attract and who can we afford? Everton's status, except to those of us who can remember league titles and cup wins, is fairly low.

Moyes has taken us away from the relegation zone, whether he's capable of advancing us to the top six is very debateable.

Danny O'Neill
61 Posted 21/04/2025 at 13:39:01
Steve @50, that's what happens when good players are surrounded by better players. The few good ones we have now will look even better when they have better players around them.

Phil @51, I think a 20 goal a season striker will get you higher up the table than mid-table. But as with any striker, they have to have the supply and support.

Dave @52, without really seeing him at centre back, I think O'Brien is better than Keane already, but I've not rated Keane since he signed for us. I've given him credit when he's played well, but it's not been often enough.

I agree with your point on seeing what he and Branthwaite, and Mykolenko for that matter are like without the leadership and organisation Tarkowski brings to those young players. That's my only concern for them now, but with any lingering relegation fears confirmed, now is the time to give them the last few games to stake their claim.

Be it centre backs, a forward pairing, centre midfield or the full backs and their wide midfielders, football is about partnerships and understanding, as well as those pairings being able to connect with the rest of the team and play between the lines, as they call it now.

They are still young for central defenders, but the prospect of Branthwaite and O'Brien together for several seasons to come is as good as any team in the top flight could wish for. I don't say that lightly and they are still learning, will make mistakes, but the potential is without question. When announced, we need the new Pontiff to anoint them in Holy Water to keep Satanic forces and any other would be suiters at bay.

Alan @53, I am quietly optimistic that we now have tougher talking negotiators at the helm should we need to sell or simply get an offer we can't refuse.

You did make me think of Manchester United post-Ferguson. For years he built teams. Yes, he spent, but spent wisely with a good blend of youth development. He left and they abandoned those principles and tried to buy their way back to success, which has steadily not worked for them compared to where they were.

Derek Knox
62 Posted 21/04/2025 at 15:15:52
Danny, you are right there regarding spotting talent early and developing them, doesn't happen overnight either so we will have to be patient. I have always maintained that these 'superstars' didn't start out being so. Definitely need a wise rebuild but retaining some experience and youth.

Hope Tarks isn't out for too long, brilliant leader and reader of the game, he will be sorely missed. Scant consolation but better it happening near the season close, than at the beginning !

Christy Ring
63 Posted 21/04/2025 at 15:26:54
I was watching Big Nev on YouTube yesterday, not sure if it was toffee tv, but with a studio audience. It was very interesting, and he said Moyes should be in charge short term. He cannot believe how far a massive club like ours has fallen, and totally slated our previous owners. He was asked to name the best player he ever played with? He said you could replace any player with Richardson and Harper, but the one player who was irreplaceable was Kevin Sheedy, the most skikful outstanding player he ever played with, he said imagine if he was playing today, no one would touch him!
Eric Myles
64 Posted 21/04/2025 at 15:44:02
Rick #60 are you saying you can't see him taking us to challenge for European places like he acheived last time? Or ommitting the fact that he did acheive European places, four times?
Christy Ring
65 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:10:49
I was listening to Moyes, who said he left Chermiti out of the squad against City, because he had Beto on the bench? What about the 3 fullbacks in the squad? Strange
Jim Bennings
66 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:11:49
Much will depend on the backing that Moyes gets this summer.

I hope we don't go all sentimental and start dishing out new contracts to players that are done now at this level or start trying to coax DCL into a new deal, for me that's something else which is dead now.

There are better strikers out there than DCL and we've been too loyal now to the injury prone one for too long.

We need to speculate to accumulate and I'd be disappointed if we are not studying players in the Spanish, German and Portuguese leagues as well as in South America where hidden gems are often found.

Brian Williams
67 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:15:34
Which of those better strikers would you go for Jim?
Rob Halligan
68 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:20:34
Beto will be starting on Saturday against Chelsea as Broja will be ineligible. Chermiti on the bench and will get a 20 minute run out.
Eric Myles
69 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:21:36
Christmas #65, at least it wasn't so's he could have a third goalie on the bench.
Christy Ring
70 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:40:17
Jim#66 I know you're not a DCL fan, but for me he's a lot better than Beto and at 28 can still do a job, and save us spending £20m+ on another striker? Hamstring injuries are normal football injuries
Robert Tressell
71 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:44:30
Jim, I expect the only striker in the whole of South America who is ready for regular games in the Premier League is Yuri Alberto who we've been linked with regularly. Maybe Igor Jesus (again strongly linked) although he's somewhere between a striker and a wing / forward.

Other South Americans tend to need some time to acclimatise in a weaker league - like teenager Kaua Elias who joined a large number of Brazilians at Shaktar Donetsk in Ukraine in January. He's another one we were strongly linked with.

In Germany, the main options include Kliendienst (linked) and Burkhardt (just back from serious injury). There's a few more with reasonable but unspectacular goals records this season - like Harres (Kiel), Machino (Kiel) and Hollerback (Berlin) but they don't scream Premier League quality. We've also been linked with Woltemade of Stuttgart but he doesn't look like a good fit for us (he's a very tall, lanky dribbler / support striker).

In Portugal, the main options are Pavlidis of Benfica (linked in January) but I think he'd be a poor fit for us and expensive too. The only other strikers of Premier League quality are Gyokeres and Samu - but both are miles out of our league.

In Spain, only Thierno Barry of Villareal looks remotely Premier League quality of those available to us. He's likely to cost £30m or more.

The point I am making is that our scouts will be well aware of all of these players and more. There's aren't really any hidden gems hiding in these major leagues - and the ones in more minor leagues take time and patience to develop (often on loan for one or more spells). Almost all of the good players from age 16 onwards are hiding in plain sight in international youth tournaments and well know to anyone who watches too much YouTube, let alone professional scouts.

The reason we don't sign them is primarily lack of money / pulling power. There's also been a very muddled recruitment strategy although Thelwell had been sorting that out.

Personally, I doubt we we can find a striker who could score more than 12 goals next season. The best "gettable" option for this is probably Evan Ferguson - although his 1 goal in 20 games this season suggests it could take him some time to hit form, despite being talented.

There is a small handful we could get that might start slowly though - but within 3 years develop into 15+ goal strikers and maybe break the 20+ barrier. Ferguson is one of them.

Jeff Spiers
72 Posted 21/04/2025 at 16:54:18
Just seen on You Tube, a City fan, at Goodison posting how Everton fans' reaction to Kevin De Bruyne coming off. He praised those fans and on the way home City supporters spoke highly of us. RS would never do that he said.
Paul Hewitt
73 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:02:37
Why should rs fans clap an opposing player?
Christy Ring
74 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:12:36
Paul#73 They won’t even clap one of their own, Alexander-Arnold if he confirms he’s off to Real Madrid before there last game. Do you remember when Mourinho was on the brink of signing Gerrard, didn’t they burn his jersey in the Kop, and he changed his mind, bitter b…….
Rob Halligan
75 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:16:09
Christy……Gerrard also received death threats from his own fans, simply because he was on the verge of joining Chelsea. What a horrible, vile bunch of gobshites they are…..

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-308410/Gerrards-U-turn-threats-family.html

Tom Bowers
76 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:16:59
Robert Tressell # 71 good reporting. Obviously there are some quality strikers in other countries who are anxious to make better money here in the Prem. and hopefully Moyes has a good scouting crew to weed out those who are pretenders and those who really have something to offer better than we already have.

DCL is better in the air than Beto but quite honestly I don't think either has what it takes to get Everton to the next level.

Chermitti may come good next season but it appears Broja is not required along with a few others. We shall learn soon of those who will be up for offers etc.

Danny O'Neill
77 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:18:06
I wouldn't say they have to Paul, but a lot of supporters recognise a quality player when they see one and De Bruyne has been top drawer for seasons.

It's happened over the years at Goodison, likewise, when the opposition score a "world".

Sportsmanship and recognition.

Jeff Spiers
78 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:20:25
Paul. Because the RS pricks keep harping on about how they are the only supporters who have class and every one else know nothing about the game. They will never give credit to any team. Personally I would have applauded De Bruyne off the pitch. A class act. The kopites will always be scum, no matter how many trophies they win. I still have'nt heard any feedback from them re. threatening Tarkowsky's family.
Robert Tressell
79 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:43:54
I think DCL, Beto and Broja have a range of qualities (and weaknesses) that would deliver goals - maybe 5 to 8 each - if we could keep them all fit. That is not unlike having one 15 to 20 goal striker.

I think RW, RB and Attacking Midfield are the key positions that will be decisive if we are to score more goals - because it allows us to create chances (and weigh in with goals too).

Mark Murphy
80 Posted 21/04/2025 at 17:54:36
Am I correct in saying Alcaraz needs to start ALL the remaining games to be our player?
Or do we have first dibs even if he doesn’t??
Danny O'Neill
81 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:06:11
One eyed supporters Jeff. Engrossed in their own self-obsession. Class isn't in their vocabulary as a support base unless it's about their own players. Didn't you know that Stevie G is the best player there has ever been? Better than Messi, Maradona and Cruyff.

Our day will come again.

That's how I read it Mark. He has to start 9 games to trigger the compulsory transfer or he's up for grabs. I was hoping we could add up minutes played to make the sum tally.

Jeff Spiers
82 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:15:34
Danny. Spot on.
Andrew James
83 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:37:44
Rob@75

I recently had a run in with one of their delightful fans on social media and - following chemo for a brain tumour - quite a lot of my hair has gone. He wished me a painful death.

Always the victims.

Martin Mason
84 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:44:15
The RS fans have had too much success to be decent. Success at that level attracts garbage and day trippers and that is why the following of the the two RS's have zero class in the main but still a small hard core of knowledgeable fans who knew the hard times too. RS fans were decent once but I will always despise them for stealing that wonderful song of the City as their Anthem, it elevated them kilometers above their true station. We never developed an equivalent although we tried that dreadful and grossly inferior, When You're Smiling? Meowl Man was a Koppite who stopped watching them after a season in D1 when they came up because he was disgusted by the fans it dragged in.
Brian Williams
85 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:51:29
Mark#80.
Mark if he plays/starts the required number of games we HAVE to buy him.
Pretty sure if he doesn't we can still buy him at the "have to buy" price.
My fear is that we don't play him in enough games and try to negotiate a lower price and then lose him to another club.
Martin Mason
86 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:55:19
Brian, this is where Moyes adds any value that he may have.
Rob Halligan
87 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:56:31
Andrew, what a disgusting vile thing to say. Hope you are ok mate. 🙏🙏🤞🤞
Danny O'Neill
88 Posted 21/04/2025 at 18:59:17
Andrew, I am sure you are big enough and have enough class about you to ignore the ignorant.

It doesn't excuse it from any human being.

Same city, different breed, as they say.

Mark Murphy
89 Posted 21/04/2025 at 19:05:23
Cheers Brian - I wasn’t clear. As we only have 5 games left I guess the next one will be significant.
I personally, having seen him play live in 3 games, hope we do sign him. But I am seriously worried we’ve put him in the shop window.
Martin, I know what you mean. I had lots of good friends who were koppites. The modern koppite is nothing like they were, good lads, proud of their team, but never the gloating, nasty bastards that they are now. Even my brother in law, who was an “evertonian” when I knew him at school, has become a twat.
Andrew, that’s fucking horrible. I despair of any human being that can stoop so low. But in this case, “even little baby ones” is apt. They are horrible cnuts and I just wish they would get called out for what they really are.
Arrogant, win at all costs, intolerable and shameless bastards.
Every fcuking one of them.
UTFT
Robert Tressell
90 Posted 21/04/2025 at 19:15:46
Likewise Andrew - we all wish you well on here. Take care of yourself and try to pay no attention to such arseholes.
Paul Ferry
91 Posted 21/04/2025 at 19:50:37
Sub-human Andrew (83), and I hope that you are not giving that piece of animal scum a second thought mate.

More importantly, I (we all on here) wish you the very best for a full recovery mate. Make sure to let us all know when you get your cancer-free diagnosis.

Neil Copeland
92 Posted 21/04/2025 at 20:04:05
Andrew, just ignore them, horrible bastards the lot of them. If it helps, you are in good company though with Tarks and Douc.

I hope your recovery continues and wish you all the very best.

Jeff Spiers
93 Posted 21/04/2025 at 20:12:19
Andrew, get well soon
Christy Ring
94 Posted 21/04/2025 at 21:11:48
Andrew #83 So disgusting and vile, but why am I not surprised sadly, wishing you well🤞
Paul Kossoff
95 Posted 21/04/2025 at 23:20:20
Jim 3. Dyche has took a lot of flack for killing us not softly.😀
Mike Gaynes
96 Posted 21/04/2025 at 23:48:50
Andrew #83, what a horrible experience. You're a brave man. Unfortunately there are some human cancers walking around out there too.

I will be wishing you the very best in your continuing fight. Please keep us posted.

Derek Knox
97 Posted 22/04/2025 at 06:25:13
Andrew, my wishes for a successful and speedy recovery too. I can't say I am surprised by the R S comments, but nevertheless, totally out of order, like many have said, mostly, they are an arrogant and vile bunch !
Christine Foster
98 Posted 22/04/2025 at 07:30:15
Andrew, don't let the prat upset you, they are just not worth it, I gave up trying to reason with some of my family after the abuse I got. I don't think I have ever come across a worse lot than them. Other fans can be ignorant, stupid or crass, but the average RS fan is the nastiest piece of work. They are beyond bitter, I wish them nothing but ill wind.
But thankfully you're a Blue so chin up and know that you have a few thousand people on here rooting for you! Stay well !
Gerry Quinn
99 Posted 22/04/2025 at 07:35:56
Andrew, chin up, laddie - always think of it this way:
1878 The birth
1892 The Afterbirth
We built this city
Jeff Spiers
100 Posted 22/04/2025 at 08:50:06
Andrew. Speedy recovery, mate. If it gets a bit dark, go back and read the comments on here from decent, civil human beings. Stay strong. As for the shite across the park
Jeff Spiers
101 Posted 22/04/2025 at 08:50:06
Andrew. Speedy recovery, mate. If it gets a bit dark, go back and read the comments on here from decent, civil human beings. Stay strong. As for the shite across the park
Jeff Spiers
102 Posted 22/04/2025 at 08:50:06
Andrew. Speedy recovery, mate. If it gets a bit dark, go back and read the comments on here from decent, civil human beings. Stay strong. As for the shite across the park
Michael Connelly
103 Posted 22/04/2025 at 08:53:52
Flew over from Dublin with my 14 year old daughter for the game. A final pilgrimage before the old lady shuts her doors. Took the train up to Sandhills to see the new stadium, which looks fab in the flesh. Walked back into town from there, had a pizza in Rudy's, which was fab. Walked up to Goodison. Enjoyed the match, despite the inevitable conclusion once Michael Keane came onto the pitch. My daughter was enthralled to see the players and managers in the flesh. Walked back into town. Clocked up nearly 30,000 steps overall, and was surprised that despite the mileage we ran up, we saw precisely zero people wearing Liverpool shirts?! Great to get over.
Peter Mills
104 Posted 22/04/2025 at 09:01:07
Andrew #83, best wishes for a full recovery. Pay no heed to the words of a fool.
Dave Williams
105 Posted 22/04/2025 at 09:25:31
Andrew- some people are vile creatures and their utterances should be ignored and dismissed as unworthy of decent people to even contemplate. Gain strength from the comments on here from decent people and get yourself better. We’re all with you !!
Martin Mason
106 Posted 22/04/2025 at 10:04:47
Not the right place I know but congratulations to Burnley and Leeds. Parker was one I always wanted to see at Everton as Player and Manager. I have a feeling that Leeds under Fark could be a real surprise package; they look really '69'ish
Dave Abrahams
107 Posted 22/04/2025 at 10:17:36
Andrew (83), I hope you make a good and complete recovery from your illness—— don’t give that Rednose another moments thought except to feel sorry for him——such a sad man.
Brian Harrison
108 Posted 22/04/2025 at 10:36:02
Speedy recovery Andrew. The worst part of the internet is it has given rise for vile idiots to make comments from behind a keyboard.
Just on the applause for KDB I thought the pundits might have passed comment on it, mind if it had been the other lot doing that they would have spent 10 minutes telling us how special they are.
Laurie Hartley
109 Posted 22/04/2025 at 12:12:00
Robert # 79 - would Kevin de Bruyne be a good fit in our midfield. He is out of contract and “open to staying in the premier league”.?

We got a good couple of years out of Gareth Barry. I think de Bruyne would have a big impact on our whole team.

Robert Tressell
110 Posted 22/04/2025 at 12:52:41
Laurie # 109, Kevin DeBruyne would be a wonderful addition to our midfield on, say, a two year deal.

However, two stumbling blocks.

1. his current wage is £400,000 per week.

2. he could take his pick of Champions League royalty across Europe - include Real, Barca, Bayern, PSG etc etc - and any club in Saudi.

Taking these two things together, I think you can pretty safely conclude he won't be joining Everton.

As a club, we need to shifting our attention to players age 16 to 22 who could be the next Kevin DeBruyne. This is hit and miss, of course, but starts with buying players with Champions League technical ability - albeit no track record to point to.

Indeed, we could very easily have competed for Kevin DeBruyne when he was stuck in Chelsea's reserves and went to Wolfsburg.

Jeff Spiers
111 Posted 22/04/2025 at 12:53:25
Brian, there's a piece on You Tube "Kevin de Bruynes sends heartfelt message to Everton fans and Davy Moyes". My comment about the RS will get me banged up for life!
Anjishnu Roy
112 Posted 22/04/2025 at 13:01:29
#83 Andrew, wishing you a speedy recovery and hope you get well very very soon! Also about that other lot - offended at everything, ashamed at nothing. Shameless bunch, best not to pay heed.
Stephen Davies
113 Posted 22/04/2025 at 13:25:17
Burnley V Everton.
In Court today
Stephen Davies
114 Posted 22/04/2025 at 14:10:17
Robert.
KDB is on a Free.
How much would you be prepared to pay him, say for a 2 year Contract?
Put this into context..how much would you pay for Transfer of Delap and his wages for 3 year contract?
Danny O'Neill
115 Posted 22/04/2025 at 14:17:02
I would take De Bruyne tomorrow. Age doesn't concern me to be honest as long as the player still has it and has looked after himself. He has both.

But, as Robert say, his wages would be a stumbling block.

I think he'll go to the continent, probably Germany, although the strongest rumour I've heard is Beckham's Inter Miami.

Whilst we're on the subject experienced players (I prefer experience to "old" looking for a club in the summer, Thomas Muller is leaving Bayern.

Robert Tressell
116 Posted 22/04/2025 at 14:28:29
Stephen # 114. TFG won’t sign KVB and rightly so. It is a daft idea that works on the false premise that we might seriously compete for trophies over the next 2 seasons. We are miles off that even with KVB in the squad - more so because he now misses large periods due to injury.

Also it is a moot point because for any number of reasons KVB will not be remotely interested in signing for Everton.

It is much, much better to recognise where we are as a club - and sign players with a view to competing in 3 to 5 years. There’s no shortcut.

Michael Kenrick
117 Posted 22/04/2025 at 20:15:45
Robert,

I know you're firmly locked in to your "Squad value equals footballing success" model, but you claim:

"… with a view to competing in 3 to 5 years. There's no shortcut. "

So exactly why can't we do a Nottingham Forest and leap up the table in just one season?

Tony Abrahams
118 Posted 22/04/2025 at 20:38:44
Robert talks a lot of sense Michael, but my own view of Everton, is that anything is possible, especially if the premier league continues to have so many very inconsistent teams, and we can hit the ground running in our new home!
Danny O'Neill
119 Posted 22/04/2025 at 20:50:56
Tony, Michael,

You know you're going to start me off.

Chicken and egg scenario. Do you keep chasing the rainbow pot of gold? Or be brave, believe and go for it? I know which way I lean.

Why can't we go quicker? Relegation "certainties" Forest just have. Tony and I, along with others of our generation witnessed us come from nowhere to dominate for those 3 glorious years.

We can compete and noone will take my expectation away.

To bore you with a military analogy, speed, aggression and element of surprise always wins, even when the odds are stacked against you.

I told you this would trigger me. I'm already in next season!

Ian Bennett
120 Posted 22/04/2025 at 20:53:08
I'd imagine it's pretty tricky with Psr. Forest smashed their psr losses by £34.5m, sold Brennan Johnson for a load and sold an unknown keeper for a lorry load.

If you've burnt through a load of losses, id imagine an expansive transfer policy is harder for a club like Everton than someone starting with a clean slate.

I love Southall, but he was advocating buying players instead of a new stadium. Great in theory,but practically impossible to implement.

Ryan Holroyd
121 Posted 22/04/2025 at 20:53:28
You could argue Forrest have taken 3 years to complete on the back of heavy spending
Danny O'Neill
122 Posted 22/04/2025 at 21:06:38
Robert is better qualified than me to comment Ryan. Quick glance, £70m net spend the past two seasons. About £270m if you go back a 3rd. Still not massive if you consider who they are mixing it with.
Robert Tressell
123 Posted 22/04/2025 at 21:37:04
Michael # 117 you've missed all the clever nuance that makes my theories what they are (for good and bad). Anyway, I guess where there's a chance there's hope, though right?

Forest are still competing for top 5 at the business end of the season, so that keeps the dream alive for those outside the Rich 8.

But as others have said, Forest have been building up to this (like Bournemouth) through substantial year on year spending over a sustained period. Fair play, good managerial performances too (especially from a failed Spurs manager).

Us? I don't think we've been building to anything really. The building starts this summer and, like Forest and Bournemouth, will probably need to include some heavy spending over a sustained period.

I don't believe there are any shortcuts - but if there are, I'll be delighted.

Eric Myles
124 Posted 23/04/2025 at 05:23:03
Colin #55 "even won several manger of the month awards. Not for winning stuff mind,"

Every Manager of the Month wins stuff, games, more than any other manager that month, hence the name of the award.

Nigel Scowen
125 Posted 23/04/2025 at 06:13:02
Andrew @83

All the very best for a speedy recovery Andrew. If there is a God then rest assured that he won’t be on the side of that lump of excrement that’s for sure. Sad, twisted, bitter, excuse for a being. Use his pathetic and cowardly words as your inspiration to a fast and full recovery mate.

Anjishnu Roy@ 112

‘offended at everything, ashamed at nothing’

Like it mate, you are learning fast.

Colin Crooks
126 Posted 23/04/2025 at 07:30:51
Gibberish, Eric.

Who told you the MotM award automatically went to the manager who won the most games?

Colin Crooks
127 Posted 23/04/2025 at 07:47:55
Andrew @83,

God bless you mate. You have enough on your plate to be worrying about fucking idiots.

Go fight the fight. For every idiot hiding on the internet, you will find ten thousand decent people rooting and praying for you.
I know from experience that support like you are receiving on this thread can be an absolute game changer.

Jerome Shields
128 Posted 23/04/2025 at 08:01:20
Andrew #83,

Good luck and get well soon.

In my experience they troll Social Media. Particularly the Red Echo.

Christy Ring
129 Posted 23/04/2025 at 12:14:39
De Bruyne is 34 in June, the top clubs in Europe won't take him; USA or Saudi if he wants big money, but if he still enjoys the competition and Premier League instead of an old folks home, why not us?

I also don't think Delap is worth taking a chance on for big money: before Ipswich signed him, he was average, on loan in the Championship. One season in the Premier League, because you stand out in a few games, is a big gamble?

Frank Thomas
130 Posted 23/04/2025 at 15:33:38
The positives I take from this game are that with 11 positions to cover and with 9 reserves allowed on the bench why did he select 3 full backs and played none of them ?

Why did he play a centre back who played against Spurs earlier in the season and watched the ball sail over his head resulting in a goal against us?

Why did he blame, the only player in his squad that he actually signed, for a loose pass as the key reason for conceding a goal?
I am positive that the owners will ask him these questions. These are not Moshiri the new owners know football and expect decisions based on good football sense.

I don't dislike Moyes and he has a lot of positives he has also learnt a lot since his last term with us but there is still a massive gulf between Moyes and Guardiola. The key important thing is that I have never heard Moyes take the blame for a bad decision it has always been some one else's fault. Bad passes, not the possessing the right players, injuries, poor player performance etc.

Last Saturday Moyes made the wrong substitutions he should have moved O'brien to centre and brought on Patterson.

Branthwaite, Mykolenko and O'brien have all played with Keane and I think they do not trust him. So when the first goal was conceded Garner and Gueye stopped attacking and concentrated more on defence. I would be amazed if O'Brien is not played in the centre against Chelsea.
There is still a lot to play for we can still finish in the top 10 and this would mean an extra £16M+ or we could equally drop to 17th if we decide to try and go for draws for the remaining games. Either way I am positive he will be asked on his results and final position. Moyes is now on over £12M so he is not cheap.

I also positive that Moyes does not realise that Chermiti is a lock opener just like Naismith used to be for us. So just like Naismith he could force a penalty or even get a goal from nothing. He is very creative and against Chelsea he is worth at least a 25 minute chance.


Frank Thomas
131 Posted 23/04/2025 at 15:43:38
Christy (129) How much do you think he will want to join us £150K+ week and how many games do you think he would play in a season?

Too expensive.

Consider DCL 7 goals in 23/24 for £5M means £700K+ per goal and 24/25 goals 3 goals and 1 assist means £1.25M per goal. De Bruyne would probably top that.

Stan Grace
132 Posted 23/04/2025 at 19:38:44
All the best to you Andrew. Wishing you a speedy and full recovery. 🍀

Peter #104
Andrew #83, best wishes for a full recovery. Pay no heed to the words of a fool.

Isn't that a bit contradictory? 🤔

Eric Myles
133 Posted 24/04/2025 at 15:05:31
Shoe me where I'm wrong then Colin #126.
Jay Harris
134 Posted 24/04/2025 at 16:15:35
I have watched a lot of City games this season and the KDB's decline in performance has been very apparent.

While he might have been a great player in his prime he is definitely not one to inspire us to greater things IMO, irrespective of the cost.

Paul Hewitt
135 Posted 24/04/2025 at 16:25:43
If we did end up signing KDB, then the clubs learned nothing from the past.
Danny O'Neill
136 Posted 24/04/2025 at 16:33:30
Why Paul H?

How would you rate the 35 year old Gana-Gueye this season? I'd say he is odds on for player of the season.

De Bruyne is still only 33.

Let's not kid ourselves, as it is not going to happen, but recruitment should be about whether a player can improve the squad and is better than what we have. De Bruyne ticks both of those boxes.

A squad is always a balance between emerging potential balanced with experience.

Ian Bennett
137 Posted 24/04/2025 at 20:10:07
Jay - he still leads the Premier league in chances created per 90. More than Saka, Palmer, Salah etc - thats pretty decent for a faded star. 3.15 chances created per 90, in a city side that's not properly functioning as well.

He's not the player he was for sure, but on a free transfer any team in the top 6 would take him.

If I was Arne Slot, I'd take him all day long as a better James Milner. Still good enough against most champion league sides, and play him in the Premier league to rest others, win games you expect or change a game you need to.

Steve Shave
138 Posted 24/04/2025 at 20:24:13
There is no way De Bruyne would come to us, he is blatantly going to go to US or Saudi I reckon, while his stock is still relatively high and he can contribute significantly. Some player that lad.

I'm not saying I wouldn't want him btw :) I think Charlie will be our 10 next season and I think he is going to become a bit of a cult hero for us.

Ian Bennett
139 Posted 24/04/2025 at 20:44:10
Agree Steve. I hope he goes to Spain or Italy. Play a good level, he's earned plenty.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb