
The much-discussed rebuild of the Everton squad has not picked up the pace most expected or wanted so far this summer. As David Moyes’s squad prepares to begin their pre-season campaign at Accrington Stanley on Tuesday night, just two new arrivals have been confirmed through the door.
In a summer that has seen seven senior players depart at the expiration of their contracts, and a further four return to parent clubs after loan spells last season, the need for players in the door is clear. The thirst for new signings surfaces at every club each summer, but there’s no need for alarm bells just yet.
Nothing generates excitement quite like a new signing, though Everton’s biggest of the summer was already here last season. Jarrad Branthwaite’s commitment to a new deal was a statement from The Friedkin Group, tying down the club’s most valuable asset for the long term. Manchester United came knocking last summer, while Spurs were heavily linked this time around.
Instead of a summer of unsettling speculation, Branthwaite put pen to paper to recommit to the project. With the evergreen Idrissa Gueye also re-signing, and new deals for Seamus Coleman and Michael Keane to retain experience and continuity, the foundation Moyes started to build during last season’s run-in remains. Everton have, publicly at least, received no interest in star names and, crucially, none appear interested in an exit. For the first summer in a long while, it’s a refreshing feeling.
The two signings that have arrived also offer encouragement. Carlos Alcaraz’s positive loan move has been made permanent, while Thierno Barry has been prised from Champions League qualifiers Villarreal.
At 22, each has been signed with the long-term in mind and are players of rich promise. The most successful sides sign players on an upward curve and both Alcaraz and Barry appear to be that.
Given the need for quantity this summer, expect Everton to utilise the loan market. It’s one that will perhaps not unveil its cards until later in the summer.
As teams finalise their own incomings, market opportunities will present themselves. For context, last season’s three new loanees all arrived on 26 July or later. Chelsea and Manchester City are among the teams whose squads need to be dramatically decreased in size before September’s deadline. James McAtee or Oscar Bobb, anyone?
Add in the pre-season opportunities that will naturally arise for the likes of Harrison Armstrong, and the wave of excitement for the move to a new state-of-the-art waterside home, there’s plenty to be positive about.
Sure, the transfer window can make us all pull our hair out, and a senior squad of 17 players in mid-July is far from ideal. But until all of the dominoes fall, there’s no reason to panic. If you can’t be optimistic in pre-season, when can you?
Reader Comments (53)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()
2 Posted 14/07/2025 at 14:23:13
Last seasons pre season was woeful and we had a poor start to season.
That said, loan signings will be determined by the pace of the club doing the lending.
And cash and PSR mean that we have to duck and dive in the transfer market, getting best value for our money.
Whilst wed like things to be quicker our current financial position means things will inevitably be slower and more pragmatic. Well just have to be patient.
3 Posted 14/07/2025 at 14:32:40
Of course there's match fitness and tactical awareness that come with playing a full pre-season together but it was always going to be a tough ask to get everyone in before the start of pre-season friendlies and it's something that most teams haven't achieved yet.
The nature of the market now dictates that more is done towards the end of the window than the beginning, our first match is against Leeds who are in a similar position in terms of players waiting to see who else comes in for them.
I'm not worried for the first time in years.
4 Posted 14/07/2025 at 14:35:29
I am not disputing your statement, for one cotton-picking minute, as I know you are well connected and do diligent research, as opposed to some purveyors of detritus we see on these pages.
Who are these key members? It seems very lackadaisical, as we have so many areas to address in the transfer market that to leave it to either the last minute, or down to Moyes himself.
The manager has many tasks to perform to get ready for the new season as it is. I can't believe if we are to be a serious contender in the forthcoming season, that this has been allowed to happen!
5 Posted 14/07/2025 at 14:51:29
6 Posted 14/07/2025 at 15:13:05
7 Posted 14/07/2025 at 15:13:42
But a few preseason injuries, plus the fact we're not negotiating from a position of strength with so many needs, and my fear is that we're forced into panic buys in the coming weeks and month as the season nears.
Things could get scary very quickly in that situation.
8 Posted 14/07/2025 at 15:34:17
The point I'm trying to make, probably very badly, is that all contributors to this site have known for at least 2 years where the deficiencies in the squad are.
My question is therefore, why are we not, as a club, identifying potential replacements that fit the age, talent and price profile before the season ends?
That way, we could have a portfolio of possible targets to pursue with all the relevant financial and fitness details prepared beforehand and ready to go as soon as the window opens?
This would seem to indicate due diligence and preparation to me, but there is very little evidence of it happening at Everton.
As for a measured and cautious approach from our new owners, how can that be when Roma and Everton are said to be in competition for the same player?
Competition can only force up the price. So our savvy owners are in effect bidding against themselves and their own interests. Crazy economics.
9 Posted 14/07/2025 at 15:42:23
My reasoning is it's better to have players to start the friendly part of the season, to get fit and gel with the rest of the team.
For me, this is more important for those not aligned to a club as they are unlikely to be as fit.
10 Posted 14/07/2025 at 15:47:55
Hopefully Everton have bolstered the squad a little bit before we go to America and play against three other Premier League teams in 8 days.
This might put unnecessary demands on a squad that seems very limited in numbers, so early into our pre-season.
11 Posted 14/07/2025 at 15:51:42
12 Posted 14/07/2025 at 16:03:44
I agree with your last paragraph entirely.
The amount of duffers, lousy and useless players this club has regularly signed could be scribed into a collection of encyclopedias and fill a small shelf in the Smithsonian.
I was not expecting much in the way of balancing the transfers in with a mass exodus out. But I was expecting more than one (Charly was here already) by now.
The new owners have had more than sufficient time in gauging this particular problem (out of the many others we don't know about).
I hoped they would hit the transfer window with a hammer and smash a few in especially as they are needed and Moyes had this function bolted to his role at his insistence
However. I am not surprised. I am sad the club is as it always has been with transfers since way before the millennium. But it remains to me as No Shocks shock.
13 Posted 14/07/2025 at 16:14:47
Only surmising based on lack of activity, Ryan.
They weren't shy in publicising their pursuit of Barry, were they? Ran in the media for weeks.
14 Posted 14/07/2025 at 16:20:16
Maybe the clubs they want to buy players from need to get replacements in first!
This is why transfers happen towards the end of the window.
15 Posted 14/07/2025 at 16:25:13
Do you honestly believe the club ‘publicised their interest in Barry….'?
16 Posted 14/07/2025 at 16:34:41
As long as we've got a couple more in by the US tour, that's what's important. As we've just seen with the Club World Cup, the conditions will be relentless and unforgiving.
I'm not concerned about Accrington and Blackburn. We'll likely see a second string and a few young players feature.
There will be players lined up. Discussions are probably ongoing as we debate.
The club publicising our pursuit of Barry. There was no announcement from Everton until after he signed and was paraded for the cameras. Prior to that, it was media guesswork, X and other Social Media.
It's how football transfers should be handled.
17 Posted 14/07/2025 at 16:45:28
I am really hoping that Harrison Armstrong comes good and that Tarkowski has regained full fitness.
Other than that, we have to pray that we don't get any injuries in these friendlies and that the powers that be will surprise us with some quality additions at full-back, midfield and up front.
The order is getting taller as the days go by and legitimate targets are signing for other clubs.
I remain one of the impatient ones who is used to getting things done.
18 Posted 14/07/2025 at 17:11:23
- target players, agents and selling clubs will be weighing up options
- many transfers are contingent on one player moving which is like being in a chain in a house purchase
That is why it all comes together at the 11th hour. True positions are revealed after the game of brinkmanship and the deals all go through.
I expect / hope we will get a new RB, RW and midfielder at least.
19 Posted 14/07/2025 at 17:13:57
Or
Theres nobody lined-up and were in for a rollercoaster of a ride (again).
20 Posted 14/07/2025 at 17:32:08
I would say judge in 7 weeks, not today.
21 Posted 14/07/2025 at 17:33:45
I get that it's important to integrate players before the season starts, but equally we don't want to be settling for third of fourth options and if it takes a little longer to bring in our first and second choice targets then so be it.
There is probably lots going on behind the scenes but like the Barry deal I expect the club to be negotiating and possibly waiting on other club transfers to get over the line (domino effect)
Nothing to worry about. If we're short going into Leeds game then questions will be raised.
22 Posted 14/07/2025 at 17:50:04
The thing I don't understand is why are we going to America ? This pre season was always going to be difficult with such a small squad of players, and for my money the trip to America is ill timed and in our circumstances not a good idea.
23 Posted 14/07/2025 at 18:43:01
24 Posted 14/07/2025 at 18:57:18
American owners, commercials and an opportunity to spread the Everton word.
If you go on the official website, there are a lot of activities planned, with Moyes, current players and former players meeting with US supporters clubs. There is also a 2-hour sight seeing cruise on Lake Michigan exclusively for Evertonians.
As well as matches against competitive opposition, it's a commercial and marketing activity.
25 Posted 14/07/2025 at 18:58:12
The promotional appearances for the fans in New York, Chicago (the cruise and the supporter's party at Jamie Lenard's pub on the North Side sound great!) and Atlanta are part of that exposure.
(Edit: Danny #24, great minds thinking alike.)
Obviously it makes little sense from a competitive standpoint, but congrats to you and your boy that you're going. Also my condolences that it's a rush-hour 5:30 kickoff at Soldier Field. Just eat before the game and get there early. Both the heat and the traffic will likely be a bit... unpleasant.
26 Posted 14/07/2025 at 18:59:42
27 Posted 14/07/2025 at 19:52:14
Nick Cox (Technical Director) is still employed at Manchester United at least into August, and James Smith (Director of Scouting and Recruitment) remains in his job at Manchester City until September 1.
I wouldn't call it lackadaisical... Kinnear got the executives he wanted, and considers them worth waiting for.
But in the meantime, it's just Kinnear, Moyes and Hammond bringing in new recruits like Barry and making important signings like Jarrad and Gana. Can't be easy but I'd say they're doing well so far.
And I like the philosophy in signing execs and players -- be patient and wait for the good ones. Don't just rush in and settle for less to fill the empty places.
28 Posted 14/07/2025 at 23:55:05
Due diligence is necessary but the careful planning may go out the window anyway if we start playing preseason games with a bare-bones squad and end up with avoidable long-term injuries because of it.
Other clubs may also lose first-choicers during pre-season and we could end up with serious competition for key targets.
We dont want early but awful business, but brilliant early business should still be the ideal.
Hopefully everything is in hand and pretty imminent, but I wont be able to relax until a full and promising squad is a done deal.
29 Posted 15/07/2025 at 01:18:42
30 Posted 15/07/2025 at 05:33:09
Fortunately I can get there early and stay with my sister in Chicago, maybe even take the train down there early so its not too stressful arriving in time. Then buy my kid the overpriced and stale hot dog/pretzel and me the one overpriced beer to get me through the match(es).
Now I have to see about this lake cruise. Feels a bit too touristy, but maybe worth it to party with fellow Blues. Not often you get to hang on a boat with fellow Evertonians!
31 Posted 15/07/2025 at 07:06:19
Details are on the club website.
32 Posted 15/07/2025 at 07:57:28
Dont panic! Dont panic!
33 Posted 15/07/2025 at 08:13:26
But I urge you to forget the crap food at Soldier Field. Take your boy out for deep dish pizza (I suggest Lou Malnati's or Giordano's, both legendary with multiple locations) before the game and just buy bottled water when you get there.
34 Posted 15/07/2025 at 11:24:05
Get in there, Bobby, make 'em have it! I'm sick of posters telling us on here:
“I expect/hope we will sign a new x, y or z"
“There will be players lined up."
“Discussions are probably going on behind the scenes."
“There is nothing to worry about yet."
“We don't want to jump in too early and buy a load of duffers
“Most action doesn't take place until the end of the transfer window anyway."
“Don't worry, be happy — we are making progress as a club."
Blah, Blah, Blah etc, etc.
Doesn't hack it for me. Whatever people say on here, other clubs are making moves at home and abroad and our efforts are either non-existent or inadequate.
How many times over the last few seasons have we been scrambling around for leftover loanees at the 11th hour?
It's high time we became more prepared for the transfer window and more pro-active in the market!
Tick, tock, tick, tock!!
35 Posted 15/07/2025 at 11:47:13
As ever, we can only judge by the end of the window and these things take time but lots of other clubs have already made multiple moves on good, affordable players. We've known the situation for a long time and ideally would have had some concrete moves lined up at the start of the summer.
Rushing has its drawbacks, of course, but so does leaving things too late. Let's hope they find the right balance (and the right winger!).
36 Posted 15/07/2025 at 11:54:56
The reality may be rather underwhelming. UTFT.
37 Posted 15/07/2025 at 12:18:43
Maybe the fact that the CF position is very costly made that the priority. Somehow those decisions will drive the decisions on the cheaper positions.
38 Posted 15/07/2025 at 12:21:24
But I worry that it's because they do not see RW, CM and RB as priorities because Moyes has faith in McNeil, Garner and O'Brien to fill those spots. Personally I think that could prove costly this season.
All supposition of course but interesting to muse upon.
39 Posted 15/07/2025 at 12:36:09
All players have agents who, at the first expression of interest, will look to sound out alternatives. That in itself extends the process.
Of course, if you are offering Sky 6-sized salaries that very few can compete with – plus European football – deals can be completed quickly.
40 Posted 15/07/2025 at 12:51:40
Of course Moyes invented O'Brien as right-back and he did very well in that position. However, he is not a natural fit and will never become an offensive right back like Moyes would like it to be.
So I would be very surprised if Moyes did not have a plan for that position.
41 Posted 15/07/2025 at 13:02:25
Most supporters would agree with your positional priorities and the danger of not filling them adequately. I agree with you that we have known the situation for a long time and ideally should have had concrete moves in the pipeline as soon as the window opened.
We desperately need a new right-back and pacy right-winger.
If Moyes thinks we can get by with the three you mention without quality in depth cover in these positions, we really do have problems.
Maybe he does have plans and all will be well, but it is very frustrating for supporters who can identify what needs to be done and yet see so little movement.
I think I need a holiday or a drink, or maybe a holiday and a drink!
42 Posted 15/07/2025 at 13:39:45
43 Posted 15/07/2025 at 13:41:56
44 Posted 15/07/2025 at 14:11:59
Personally I'd have gone into the summer saying we need new starters at RW, RB and CM. They should encompass our biggest expenditures and ideally be in by the end of July at the latest.
But I appreciate it's complex thing buying players and rebuilding squads. Lets see how we look when the window closes.
45 Posted 15/07/2025 at 14:39:57
It is clear that the new owners are not the ones to make hasty decisions. We will have to learn to be patient.
46 Posted 15/07/2025 at 19:51:04
What Sam says makes sense,it just isnt obvious that the club sees things the same way at the moment and thats the frustrating part for some supporters.
47 Posted 15/07/2025 at 20:29:57
However, let's say the top targets are:
- right back: Wesley
- right wing: Bakayoko
- centre mid: Onyedika
All three are heavily courted by clubs across Europe (and possibly Saudi too). To buy them all might cost about £75m to £90m. That might be more in total than we can afford. So we might get two of the three or only one or possibly even none - and then have to figure out Plan B options too.
So we're probably having to juggle a handful of "Plan B" players too like:
- RB: Walker-Peters, Coufal and maybe Tchatchoua who we were after last summer.
- RW: Hutchison, Doak, Kubo, Weah and Fellows
- CM: O'Riley, Gallagher, Dewsbury-Hall and Hackney
There's probably combinations of these players we would and wouldn't want. And possibly some Plan C players who could make it all happen as late loan options etc
There are still some scenarios where we do really well out of this window - given how few of our genuine targets have actually moved (and how little business many of our rivals have done).
48 Posted 15/07/2025 at 20:37:35
We haggled on alcaraz, haggled on Barry, and walked away from tete. In total we've probably saved £5m plus in cashflow.
A lot more care being taken.
49 Posted 15/07/2025 at 20:47:08
None of us do.
We just need to see how it plays out.
Then we can have a great big moan on 2 September when the window shuts and boo the players weve bought in then ! (Joking)
50 Posted 15/07/2025 at 21:58:43
Youve identified 15 or 16 players all of whom could do a job for us in the right combinations.
Id scratch Bakayoko,hes probably going to Leverkusen,and probably Gallagher,but the others are all good options if we could land some of them.
Maybe Im just getting jumpy with a sense of Deja Vue from past seasons.
Time will tell.
51 Posted 15/07/2025 at 22:10:22
It's bloody brilliant BUT if anyone tells you a deep-dish pizza is a thing to be cherished, think again.
Check Tripadvisor out for a full review by many diverse people, and then go to a full-ish eatery nearby with more than a deep-dish sloppy expensive pizza on its menu accompanied by expensive drinks. Chicago has great food, great people and great soul - but their much-fabled pizza is a myth from the most famous outlets, and I've been to more than a few of them.
Local is best!
52 Posted 15/07/2025 at 22:13:54
53 Posted 15/07/2025 at 00:19:39
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
How to get rid of these ads and support TW


1 Posted 14/07/2025 at 14:22:53
Some folks here are well into "where are the signings?" mode, but I'm actually pleased to see the club showing patience and not rushing into signings we might regret later just to fill out the ranks.