Martinez prepared to be patient through period of transition

, The Guardian , 21 September, 80comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez says that he accepts mistakes will be made as his Everton side adjust to the "big changes" he is making to their style of play, ones he believes will lead to "big results" at Goodison Park.

The manager admitted that he "impressed with the patience of the crowd," against Chelsea last weekend as the Blues carved out a 1-0 win over Jose Mourinho's much-vaunted side.

"I know you'll get the odd reaction because it's something new but if you want to have big results there has to be a big change," he continues, "otherwise if you don't change things you're not going to have big changes. We know as a football club that if we stick together in this transitional period we're going to get the benefits. That's clear.

"At Swansea it took six or seven months to get the crowd to understand what we were trying to do. We had a period of seven months in League One where we were getting booed off but once you assimilate the concepts and the way of playing, the crowd understands it and I don't think the crowd at Swansea would accept any other way of playing now.

"At Wigan it took us a long time but allowed us to stay in the Premier League for three seasons and win an FA Cup, and I think the crowd is intelligent enough to see why we're doing certain things and will always support the players when they're trying to be brave for a reason. It's one thing to be stupid and another is being brave and trying to see the end-product."

The Spaniard is resistant to resorting to the long-ball game for the sake of it, saying: "Maybe you will win a game [with that tactic] but you're not going to achieve your aim over the season. You're always looking at the long term. One thing is winning games but there is also knowing how to win games and that doesn't happen overnight. The football concepts and the way of playing is very clear and you have to be quite stubborn.

"It has happened at many other football clubs where you have an easy way of playing," he goes on, "which is short-term, trying to be solid, getting through 90 minutes, not getting out of the comfort zone as a squad and not getting better. But what's important is that over the course of the season you end up a better team than you were at the beginning.

"As a team we need to get better and it will take time and a bit of understanding, but what we've done in 12 weeks is incredible. I don't think you'd be able to do that with any other team in that short period of time."

Quotes or other material sourced from The Guardian



Reader Comments (80)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick Entwistle
1 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:47:55
Shut up Robbie. Just get on with it. I've seen nothing this season to be excited about and see its business as usual half time v WH. I'll look forward to those big changes, but why change means going backwards I do not know.
Paul Doyle
2 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:09:07
Nick, you need to shut up.

Guess what, sunshine — do you think we would have won today under Yoda?

No fucking chance ,

Jimmy Sørheim
3 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:01:41
I think Roberto Martinez needs to understand what matters at a top club is WINNING, and nothing else.

So far, I feel that RM has the most to learn at Goodison Park, the players are doing what they are being told, but it does not always work to just keep passing the ball without passing it forward to the forward players and creating chances.

RM has not yet understood what it means to be a Everton manager, you can not compare us to Swansea and Wigan. We all know that, but so far RM seems to live in the past a little too much.

I will not accept a change for the worse, and if we are only to play one certain way we will lose that vital edge that Moyes instilled in the players.

RM made a terrible choice in his first eleven today, he held back the team by not starting with Lukaku, McCarthy and in part Oveido. We all have to be honest about RM, he has a lot to learn about being a manager for a top club expecting 3 points every game you play, this is his first job at a top club and it might not work out for him if he is not adaptable and able to be more aggressive.

So far overall, I rate him as just okay, though his transfer dealings have been much better.

Duncan McDine
4 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:14:04
Make your judgement in Jan/Feb regarding his philosophy... I'm still on the fence, but quietly impressed with his man management and ability to make changes during the match.
Brian Waring
5 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:18:31
Jimmy, 4th in the league and the only unbeaten team in the prem.
Ross Edwards
6 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:20:01
Michael, I think the people who constantly bring Martinez down because he was relegated are either idiots or know nothing about football.

The bloke won the FA Cup for God's sake.

Michael Kenrick
7 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:32:15
I've tried not to comment on OFM but there's some really good digs in this piece that warm the heart; to hear Martinez between the lines condemning the 'pragmatic' bullshit we had to put up with increasingly under the other fella is indeed so wonderfully refreshing.

He talks about winning games... and when I first read this, the devil on my left shoulder kept shouting two words: Wigan relegated. But, each time we score a win, like today's excellent second-half display at Upton Park, then these fears and associations become more and more distant.

Great progress in just five games so far this season! Keep up the forward momentum, Roberto!

David Ellis
8 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:33:08
I thought Moyes was a great manager. But to say that Martinez does not know what it means to manage a top club like Everton is ludicrous - arrogant even.

To say that the team has not changes this season is also ludicrous.

You have to accept that change involves risks. You can't say you won't accept any move backwards - to set up an objective of not going backwards involves taking no risks - which means stagnation, and long term no ability to improve. We don't have to go backward (and we haven't), but we have to accept its a risk that we will do so as we transition to a new style of play - a style which I am hopeful will be more successful.

We got ahead today and we kept the ball. Its a big change Nick. Credit where its due!

Ross Edwards
9 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:41:35
Nick, you can shut it now. Even before he walked through the door you said he was "a shit manager."

If you are missing your lover, you can salivate all over him when they play against City tomorrow.

Ross Edwards
10 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:43:32
If Moyes would have said this Nick, you'd have been licking his backside with glee wouldn't you?
Simon George
11 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:49:24
@Nick Entwistle, If business as usual, is 4th in the Premier League, the only unbeaten team playing great football, dominating matches, dominating possession and being one of the teams in the league with the most shots on goal, then I for one, would love to continue with business as usual.

Or what did you have in mind?

James Stewart
12 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:56:55
The biggest change we need to make is getting rid of Jelavic. Complete liability. 45 mins of Lukaku was all it took to show what a difference a side with an actual striker can do.
Nick Entwistle
13 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:55:45
Ross, you ever come up with something original, keep it to your self.

We're not playing great football, Simon. We haven't all season. Didn't against Chelsea, and only got going once WH went 10 down.

That said, we're not playing bad.

My comments were made at half time, I'm sure everyone here wasn't feeling as rosy as they are now with a win. Hindsight, hello?

Ross Edwards
14 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:06:28
"We're not playing great football"

Nick, but you'd put up with Moyes' boring hoofball?

God, you'd think we'd just lost 9-0 at home to Vauxhall Motors the way you are going on Nick

Simon George
15 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:09:22
@Nick I appreciate your comments were made half time mate, and I'm sure there would be tons of people on here moaning if we'd lost. But I have to disagree, we're playing good football from my point of view. Of course we can get better, but bar the Chelsea game, we've been by far the better team and deserved more.

So the way I look at it is, we've been unfortunate and yet we're still 4th and we are doing it in style with class. I'm not really sure how I could ask for more right now.

Michael Brooks
16 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:18:08
I am not sure what big changes are needed, I thought last season’s team did well and played some great stuff, some of the best I have seen in my 30 years of following the team. I also don’t think quoting the great work you did a Wigan is a good idea, unless you were planning to get relegated! Yes I know FA cup win.

I like pretty football but call me what you like a much prefer winning football and I think we should all be honest with ourselves because the four games I have been to haven’t been great, I know I know the team beat Chelsea but from where I was sitting, if Chelsea could finish it would have been a very different game.

Still, the team is undefeated so far, so I am looking forward to match of the day and trying my best to be optimistic.

Paul Jones
17 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:13:58
@Nick. Hindsight hello? Perhaps your mantra should consider the word 'foresight'. If you had the foresight to consider how Martinez would react to such a poor first half performance then you could have avoided that egg on your face.

Mind you, a performance like that under your hero would have led to no changes until the 70th minute when we would be 2-0 down and a swap of Naismith for Anichebe would be made to set the pulses racing (or not!).

Simon George
19 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:21:42
@Michael Your trying your best to be optimistic? Are you serious? We're 4th in the league and have just won and your moaning and you think you are being optimistic?
Andrew Clare
20 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:20:51
The big change that is needed is spending a lot of money on a world class striker.
Andrew Clare
21 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:26:02
Once Lukaku’s loan has ended.
Nick Entwistle
22 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:25:09
Simon, we're keeping possession and that's great to see. But it's been laborious in its build up. But Lukaku is really something else, whereas Jely, as we've seen, would just go missing.

But we need to move on from pass pass pass pass pass, then pass again only this time into midfield.

It's funny actually, that our two worse performances have brought the victories and obviously 10 men had something to do with it.

Hoof ball or not, the team mixed it up last season and all this swapping of formations Martinez goes on about, a bit of edge, a bit of hustle, will sometimes be needed more than a high pass-completion percentage.

Simon George
23 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:31:44
@Nick I suppose we'll just have to agree to disagree then mate. Basically, I'd like to see Everton become one of the world's great passing team, where teams know when they play us they won't get much of the ball. Whereas it sounds like you'd prefer a bit more of a direct approach just to get the goals. Everyone's different I suppose. No harm with a difference of opinion.
Nick Entwistle
24 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:37:58
Too right. But having seen Man Utd this season I don't miss those punts from the centre backs.

I wouldn't call it a preference for direct approach, but 'all action' is one way I heard Everton described under Moyes and when we played our best that's what it was.

Ben Dyke
25 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:37:38
Nick no matter how hard you try to sound objective you just sound miserable! What more exactly could we expect from Martinez? We do not have the personnel to regularly beat the richer teams with a pragmatic approach like under Moyes, so what's the harm in attempting to be better with the ball? Its surely worth the risk to teach the players to be more confident on the ball even if it backfires every now and again.
Michael Brooks
27 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:34:04
Simon George# I am trying my best to be optimistic, for two good reasons we are five games in and three of those games the draws weren’t pretty and the Chelsea was very lucky. If Everton are 4th in January or even next month I‘ll be over the moon.

Secondly, I am still not convinced by RM and before you say he won a FA cup and I say he took Wigan down, I just have an uneasy feeling that he might be a lucky manager and not a good/great manager and we all know as Wigan fans do luck tends to run out.

Ross Edwards
28 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:50:50
Michael, I get what you are saying, but surely you must be delighted being 4th after 5 games, ahead of Man U, Chelsea and City.
Simon George
29 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:47:03
@Michael. Who knows, time will tell. I for one wouldnt call him a lucky manager. He changed Swansea's reputation from absoultely awful football club, to one of the classiest in the country. Not much to write home about with Wigan, relegation but then a cup.

But you say you'll be happy if Everton are 4th in January, that's a what if scenario, the fact is we're currently 4th and that's fact, so maybe you should just try and be over the moon right now.

And yeah, if your right and he's a bad manager, well then we'll deal with that when the time comes. But not now.

Nick Entwistle
30 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:52:16
Because Ben, there is not one game so far this season where I can say we've played well. Yes, we've gained three great points v Chelsea, and came from behind twice today. But overall we've been dull and pedestrian, with a very high possession rate which is enough for some people to think the second coming has arrived.

Where does Martinez go from here is another question all together. Hopefully he can build on this and make us supreme passers, but I'm still on the fence (even if I wasn't before he arrived, but you got to give the new man a go...)

Tony Sullivan
31 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:05:08
I'm really pleased at how well Martinez is doing. Change of manager/style was always going to involve risk. However, RM has proved to be a breath of fresh air. He took risks today with the changes at HT, but they paid off, and we remain unbeaten, and confidence can only be growing as a result. When dealing with the media, he is articulate and talks a great deal of sense about his players and their performances.

Rather than telling RM to shut up, I think we need to hear more of his positive comments regarding his players and their efforts. It really is a refreshing change which I welcome. Perhaps others should do the same.

Barry Rathbone
32 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:33:28
Nick, I think your problem is you expect it to be running at top speed from minute one.

Regardless of results this polar opposite change of style will take a season to sort presently we are still practicing the gear changes.

One thing about the positive nature of RM is we don't seem to be moaning about "bad luck" all the time neither in the transfer window or in the games - you should try it.

Phil Walling
33 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:08:22
The best footballing sides I've ever seen were those of Catterick in the sixties.They certainly didn't play tippy-tappy neither did they resort to hoofing it. I don't think there was even 'a philosophy'. Just very good players able to adapt to differing teams,tactics and conditions.

Sometimes they played it short, sometimes long... Sometimes they got in hard on the opposition (Leeds, Liverpool) whilst at others they just matched teams with pure skill.

Catterick bought players who could play and blended them into a force and a joy to watch. He never talked about what he did or how he did it because that would tell the other managers what he was up to.

He just delivered League trophies and Cups – and he did it with style. That's all I want from any manager. So, Roberto, just do it!

Patrick Murphy
34 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:00:05
Even the special one said somewhere today that it is difficult to alter a teams way of playing in the short-term and there will be bumps in the road. RM may be lucky - good - he may be overrated - time will tell. But can we not just give the guy a chance. Everton are a completely different beast to the other clubs he has managed.

If we fail to get behind this guy when his team are getting good results god help him if those results go against him.

Danny Broderick
35 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:04:37
Nick,

Very fickle comment at half time. You now look a bit silly after 90 minutes.

There is no quick fix. The time to judge Martinez is at the end of the season. The facts show that we have made a decent start. Let's see how we get on between now and May.

Simon George
36 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:04:54
@Phil To be fair though mate, Everton did that whislt being one of the richest teams in the country. Sadly that is no longer the case.

Also, we really cant compare a team from the 1960's to a team playing in 2013. It's still 11 v 11, but things have changed a fair bit.

Although I do agree with your last sentence.

Wayne Smyth
37 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:58:47
Jimmy, your comments are harsh on Martinez. We can all be wise after the event. I'm sure the same things were said about Jelavic and Naismith before the chelsea game, but you none of us can argue with the 3 pts.

Don't forget, he's come in to a new club and had to use someone else's squad.

He spent the first 2 months of his tenure dealing with incessant speculation and advances for his two best players from OFM, one of whom handed in a transfer request and was sold. He's having to deal with idiot employees like Stubbs destabilizing the team further.

He's adjusting the way the team is playing to something he thinks is more progressive and likely to achieve results in the LONG TERM.

He's brought in quite a few very good players either on loan or permanently.

He's attempting to give the younger players like Barkley the room to learn while still being able to get the results we need to compete near the top of the league.

Personally I'm delighted in how things are going. The football isn't great and we're not converting the chances we are creating, but its early days and we're still picking up points.

I'd actually written this season off as one of adjustment, but the very astute signings of Barry and Lukaku give us a real chance of going one step further than OFM was able to take us in all the years he was here....to actually win something!

Anyone who is thinking of complaining about him should remember that before today we'd gone 11 away games previously without a win.

Simon George
38 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:10:05
To any blue that isn't very happy right now, just go to any website showing the league table. Open it up and take a long look. If you cant be happy about that then I don't know what would.

To the some that say Martinez has been lucky, you could also argue that Di Canio has been a touch unlucky. Then take a look at the table again and see where his team are.

It's all ifs and buts, but the facts right now show that we are sitting pretty.

It's also kinda nice we're sitting above utd right now too. :-)

Phil Walling
39 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:11:20
Simon: I am merely making the point that you don't need philosophies and an addiction to a particular style to be successful. I wish the guy all the luck in the world but just wish he'd shut up and get on with his job.

He's made a good start,that's for certain.

Darren Hind
40 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:55:09
Nick your right, we are' nt playing good football yet, certainly not as good as we were playing this time last season, but we made up for some sloppy play by displaying the sort of passion Moyes always prided himself on.

I believe it'll take 4-5 transfer windows before RM can field the team he wants, until then he has to do what he can with somebody elses players


If, in the meantime we have to put up with winning 5 goal thrillers, I'm more than happy to suffer

Michael Brooks
41 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:17:53
Now Simon George, I never said he was a bad manager I said I was unsure about him.

I know Everton are 5th but it is still after only 5 games, so let’s not get carried away.

Tony Draper
42 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:18:55
Nick (805)

"Shut up Robbie. Just get on with it. I've seen nothing this season to be excited about and see its business as usual half time v WH. I'll look forward to those big changes, but why change means going backwards I do not know."

Bad case of "premature expostulation"

Simon George
43 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:34:59
@Michael mate I'm not arguing with you, just think you gotta enjoy the good times because sure as hell there are going to be bad times.

I'm not even saying Martinez has convinced me he's world class, all I know is, I feel real good when Everton win, and even better when we're technically now the 5th highest ranked club in England and Wales.

Andy Crooks
44 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:36:53
Nick # 925, you make a good point about just how laborious our build up play has been. To succeed this style requires every player to be comfortable on the ball. With our squad I believe we really need to mix it up more. I think, though , that we will get better and better as the season goes on and I am confident that Roberto will bring us success.

I wouldn't have Moyes back under any circumstances but it would be churlish to deny that we played , on occasion, some scintillating football last season. I am happy that Roberto is building on this rather than starting all over again. It's the philosophy I like now. It looks like every one is getting a chance and the manager is fair, patient but tough when necessary.

Ultimately, though he is doing what Moyes did. Keeping the heat of Kenwright. I believe he will do it with more style.

Eddie McBride
45 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:15:47
Nick if your going to sit on the fence, sit on it a little more quietly will you. As you are seriously getting on everyone's tit's

Just let us get on with feeling good about our team. If you can't do that I have contacted Man United and there are tickets available for their next home game

Raymond Fox
46 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:34:07
Jimmy 833, if your comparing RM with the beloved Moyes, Moyes was here 11yrs and won fuck all.

Its become pretty obvious that if RM won the Prem and all 3 cups certain gentlemen would find some aspect to complain about, its getting boring.
Wait till we get beat, which we obviously will sooner or later, then have a good moan among yourselves!

Al Reddish
47 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:00:26
Sorry to hog the thread.......but just to add I thought McCarthy looked a decent player when he came on. Shit tackle for the penalty but did well after that and helped boss the midfield. He seems like he might be one that stays under the radar (like Gibson), but could be a very important player for us, whilst not getting the headlines Baines, Lukaku and a few other players will attract.
Chris Jones [Burton]
48 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:52:05
Where to start?

We're football fans and, typically, 'we' want it, all, and we want it now. End of. Well that's certainly what many are like. Realistically though, we need to be patient and keep a sense of perspective.

I saw plenty of games under Kendal Mark #1 where we were disappointing, yet won, other times we played well but lost. I'm acutely aware that results matter but they are not the B-all and end all of things. I want us to play well. And it's where you are at the end of the season that matters. It's only in the Cups that you truly have to worry about the result of each game.

At the moment we're moving in the right direction. We're unbeaten in five games and won our last two. We're conceding less than a goal a game but scoring better than one a match. We've new players to fully bed-in and realistically can perhaps only get better. And a player who was something of a talisman has gone and yet he has not been missed, has he?!

I'm satisfied at the moment. I'm pleased even. Well Done to ALL at Goodison, to the players, staff and manager, and a hat tip even to OFM for signing most of them!

As for today, yes at times in the first half we looked a bit toothless – almost like we wanted to walk it into the net – and some players were a little disappointing (young Ross is still learning, and was annoyingly dispossessed a number of times in the first half) but we overcame a bad 45 minutes, like good teams do. I mentioned the team of the 80's when I started – sometimes we were shite but still won. A mark of a good team that!

COYBB

Tony Sullivan
50 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:55:54
Phil 014
Catterick was a martinette who believed in the Sgt Major approach, who didn't even coach his own side, that was done by Tommy Egglestone. He would be lost in today's PL, part of the reason is he was not a communicator, whether it was his teams' or the press.
David Munro
51 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:19:46
Chris 059 I agree with most of the points that I made but I think your comment on Ross highlights Robbie's point. He have to take risks, run at players and make mistakes if we want to improve, something he has given Ross license to do, with good effect so far.

I think the early tic tac we endured in the 3 draws is to be expected as our players become used to the philosophy. And Phil, every team has a philosophy, they just didn't articulate it like we do now.

As for the starting XI you have to show faith in the team that performed for you in the previous win, that is Sport Psychology 101. This isn't Rodgers we are talking about, Robbie is a true professional and I have all faith in him.

Keep calm, trust in Robbie and the boys and COYBB!

Peter Warren
52 Posted 21/09/2013 at 23:17:07
Swansea dominated Liverpool second half on Monday. I've seen us play really well under Moyes but never seen us play that good passing in the middle – I would love to see us play like that in middle.
Ed Fitzgerald
53 Posted 21/09/2013 at 23:39:31
Nick

If you can't get excited by that second half performance I don't know what you want. A question how many times have we come from behind at half time to win away from home in the last 11 years?

It was a great attacking performance in the second half yes we took some chances but you need to if you are going to win. As a famous Scot said you'll never win anything with kids, hmm

Jackie Barry
54 Posted 21/09/2013 at 23:49:12
I'm more interested in the football we are currently playing than the dull stuff we were previously. In the past not sure we would have come back like we did today. Not that I care much but even the media has started to take more notice of us.
Tony Draper
55 Posted 21/09/2013 at 23:51:26
Work in progress, and I AM seeing progress

But progress is what I'm seeing, not a finished article (whatever that might be)

So far we are still able to win all 3 of the trophies for which we had pre-season possibilities, we sit 5th in the Premier League and are the last unbeaten side in the top flight

Considering that our new manager can't be expected to have fully settled in yet, I find our state of affairs encouraging

I'm expecting no comment whatever from "those so blind, who will NOT see", seems their rules are "far to early yet after 11 years"

However, I would suggest (early tho' it is) to compare that Roberto despite inheriting "our best ever squad in the PL" may appear (to the less deluded) to be progressing better that "The Chosen One" appears to be doing with the squad of "The Reigning Champions".

But

As I say, still early days for all in the PL

Sidenote:
Our lad Wayne has 200 PL goals for MUFC, well done mate, go on and score 250 for 'em.
Then whip up your red shirt to reveal your "Once a Blue, Always a Blue"
Now that I'd LOVE you for !

Trevor Lynes
56 Posted 21/09/2013 at 23:54:05
Joined-up football is really great when it is played quickly but Southampton showed how it can backfire today against Liverpool when defenders and goalkeepers are hurried. I don't want the same thing happen to us and sometimes the way to play must be varied to stop teams setting out their stall to upset our methods. Teams soon adjust to different systems and it takes a really top manager with top players to be able to adapt when the system is going wrong.

I don't know if we have the players with enough ball control to be able to carry out the passing game from the back efficiently and above all safely! We struggled today against a pretty poor West Ham team and, but for two world class free kicks by Baines, we would probably have drawn at best.

If we cannot move the ball quickly, we will definitely struggle against the Manchester clubs. I have always enjoyed top football and the best exponents of top football at Goodison Park was the 60s side who were all comfortable on the ball with three or four star players to orchestrate things. Pace is just as important as possession and it must have an end product.

Chelsea did a job on Barcelona by letting them have the ball and defending really well. Southampton did it on Liverpool in a different way but it was still highly effective. I seem to remember us outclassing the Swansea passing side a season or so ago and so far none of the teams who insist on playing the ball out from the back have broke into the Champions League spots.

Today, our game was drastically changed in the 2nd half once Lukaku was brought on together with McCarthy. But I am still not yet convinced that we have the players ready to just pass their way to victory.

Harold Matthews
57 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:58:27
Scrappy game but a great win. Big Sam set out to disrupt our passing game and for 45 minutes he succeeded. Of course, the subs helped up our performance and I hope Martinez developes a more ruthless streak for future Premier League line-ups.

Personally, I've enjoyed every minute so far but I'm not so niaive as to think the unbeaten run will go on and on. All the top clubs find themselves on the wrong end of shock results sooner or later.

Our main weakness is the number of times we surrender possession far too easily. Dwelling a little too long on the ball, a careless pass, hoofing the ball out of play, etc etc etc. We're all aware of it and if we have ambitions of a high finish it will need to be rectified.

That said, roll on the next game. This is a brilliant time to be Blue.

Particularly pleasing today was the obvious delight of the lads on the bench who didn't get a game. Maybe their chance will come in the Cup.

Paul Smith
58 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:35:03
Nick Entwistle your comments are worse than a kopites
Robin Cannon
59 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:34:22
Surprised to see negative comments on what I thought was a hugely positive interview with RM. I was delighted by his comments, that he wants to build foundations for long term success built on attractive football, and his desire to do so means accepting that players will make mistakes and that short term quick fixes aren't the answer.
James Martin
60 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:19:32
I think Moyes and Martinez view the game very differently. Nick I disagree with you that we haven't played well, but I also don't think that the football has been out of this world despite the large possession share. We were very poor in the first half today and against Cardiff for example. To counter that we were excellent against Chelsea and the second halfs of Norwich and West Ham.

I think Moyes tries to build a football machine with his teams. They play the same way in most games in the same formation and it gains you a level of consistency that goes with the quality of the parts you have in that machine. For a lot of his tenure the parts weren't that good but towards the end I think he underestimated the talent at his disposal. We were always limited in what we could achieve - consistent though it undeniably was. At Man U this approach may be what is exactly required because they have all the top componenets for Moyes' machine - who knows. Man U can justifiably go into every game looking to make all the play and have the sharpest attack in the league to finish it off combined with a good defense. We always looked a bit stupid under Moyes attempting to control the game away at Stamford Bridge/Old Trafford when we had a blunt strikeforce and a leaky backline.

I think Martinez is far more willing to trust in the individual talents of players and tries to give them a platform on which to show it as well as being able to adapt systems allowing us to play counterattack agianst Chelsea. Some games you'll win if a talent like Lukakau decides to show up. Others you'll draw like the first three when Jelavic decided not to fire. I don't think any sort of pre-ordained system of football like Rodgers sycophanticly bleats on about has won us the last two games. The defensive resilience of Barry Jagielka and Distin nicked us the first one whilst the quality of Baines won us this one.

Its good to know though that if our players play to their best we can win anywhere in the league against any opposition - something that didn't happen under Moyes. Only time will tell if its as consistent, but in a funny way I think Martinez was practising methods at Wigan that would have been perfect at Everton and Moyes was practising methods at Everton that might be perfect at Man U. Both might have ended up exactly where their footballing methods might work best.

Milos Milenkovic
61 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:56:41
Signing of Kone and McCarhty is something that puzzles me. While I like our ball control and think that Deulofeu and Lukaku are fantastic players, to spent 20 million pounds on two players who are totally opposite to the style of play which he (Martinez) wants to set, is confusing and worrying. I would like to believe that we will not need to sell Barkley or Mirallas to pay our debts, knowing that we spent 20 million on players that are hardly going to improve us.
Jackie Barry
64 Posted 22/09/2013 at 06:20:04
James, no disrespect but since when did we go to the likes of Stamford Bridge/Old Trafford with even the notion of trying to control the game? I have a lot of respect for Moyes and his 11-years but I am not blinded by the fact that the guy had no idea when it came to tactics, it was one way or nothing and he certainly would not have thought about making the changes we have seen RM make over the last few games.

Do I know how it is all going to turn out? No... but I'm not going to judge the guy after 5 games. All I know is that the football I am watching right now is some of the best stuff I have seen in years and I am someone who watched us win League Championship trophies and a European Cup-Winners Cup.

David Munro
66 Posted 22/09/2013 at 06:56:54
Milos, I'm going to have to disagree with you regarding McCarthy not fitting the ball-control style of play. He completed 87% of his passes last season and made 76 interceptions. And he did it for Wigan. How does that puzzle you with the type of football we are aiming to play?

As for Kone, how many goals did he score last year? 13 in all competitions, 11 in the Premier League. Which was more than Fellaini scored. And once again he did it for Wigan.

Have you really thought about this, or are you just saying this because they both got relegated with Wigan last season (in which case you aren't going to like who our new coach is...)?

Joel Andersson
67 Posted 22/09/2013 at 07:29:07
Simon George, So you would rather lose your soul in the top of the league (as Man Shitty) instead for holding on to a real teamspirit and be in the middle?

Overall, I am not happy with the appointment of RM and I will keep telling that. You people in here looks to search for tici-taca all over. I don't get it. We have been feared for our physical play over 10 years and I have loved every minute of it. You just want to throw it over for some boring passing football?

Now we go into something totally different, which in my Eyes is very very worrying.

Mick Long
68 Posted 22/09/2013 at 07:34:25
Milos, why do we need to sell barkley and mirrales to pay of our debts when we made nearly 34 mil on deadline day from felli an vic
You would like to think that RM is already planning what to do with the rest of the money already (or at least the 2 mill the luvvie will make availible to him)
Mick Long
69 Posted 22/09/2013 at 07:47:50
What impressed me more than anything yesterday (and not for the 1st time this season) is that bobby had the bollocks to change it when it was needed....this is were we suffered under dithering dave
Gwyn Roberts
70 Posted 22/09/2013 at 08:40:25
Some of these posts are unreal! Can you imagine if Roberto is reading this, which he probably is, how would he feel that even after an emphatic win we still slate him?
Laura Haseman
71 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:03:50
Milos

Spot on pal. Players like Arteta, Rodwell and Fellaini can do McCarthy's job better and have the skill to keep the ball under pressure. They can get out of tight situations and play a forward pass. He's less quality than his predecessors. When Barkley matures, he will be the one to play alongside Barry.

Greg Mckerracher
72 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:11:21
Roberto Martinez is the new Jurgen Klopp. He has a modern outlook on the game and has the philosophies and balls to back it up. Going back to Graham Sharpes stupid comment in the Cardiff game "this is a game that Moyes would have won". David Moyes would not have had the moxy to rip Jelavic and Naismith off at halftime like that. We would have trudged through the 2nd half to a draw at best. When Osman went down injured, Phil Neville would have been on to sure up the midfield and you know it.

Two words to sum up that second half - "sin mierdo". I wouldn't swap Roberto for anyone in the world.

Colin Grierson
73 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:27:03
I doubt very much whether RM is interested in this site and the comments made on here. Everybody has the right to express their opinion, however, some of the comments regarding Ossie and a serious injury during yesterday's game were a step too far IMO. To wish ill of a player of any club betrays a dark side to fanaticism but to wish injury on one of your own!?!? There really are some sad clueless fools around and I don't like standing shoulder to shoulder with them. If you wish to spout your bile then the kopites will welcome you with open arms! You know who you are!
Nigel Gregson
74 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:20:28
I cannot believe we are actually defending Roberto. He doesn't need any defending - the numbers (at the moment) speak for themselves. Come January if we are sitting on 15th, we might need to defend his methods. The moaners can moan all they like, but the table isn't lying.

As far as philosophy is concerned, I am 150% behind Roberto. To take a step forward, you need to take a step back and try to get better that things that you are poor at. This means that you will, do poorly in the short term. Change is hard. Getting better at what you aren't good at is also hard.

But this is where our great club can differentiate from all the other pretenders who want short term quick fixes, but will stagnate in mediocrity forever.

NSNO

Anto Byrne
75 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:40:25
I was impressed with WHU, they wanted to win and went 2-1 up. We didn't park the bus looking for a point and even at 2-2 we were looking to win it.

In the last seven minutes of added time we had two very good chances to make it a very interesting score. In recent seasons, a forward would come off and we would invite teams to attack us and try and hang on for the result.

This manager has a less then dour approach, will take a gun to a gunfight and the word 'capitulation' is not in his vocabulary. City 4 Utd 0 today.

Trevor Lynes
76 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:28:02
I really don't think that anyone is slating Roberto, most of the comments have praised the 2nd half performance against a pretty poor West Ham side.

As I have said I doubt whether we have the players who are comfortable enough on the ball to play the passing game in our own half. After watching Southampton's methods against Liverpool I am a little concerned that teams may do the same things against us. Soton pressed high up the pitch and fed off hurried defensive mistakes due to Liverpool not clearing their lines.

What I could see was the fact that if a longer ball were used in those situations the pressing sides may well be hit on the break by having so many players high up the pitch. This should be a good way to counter those tactics. Liverpool however continued to play across the back and were punished.

In the 2nd half against West Ham we played at a much higher tempo and it paid dividends. I still want to see Kone used from the bench if Lukaku starts with Jelavic left to work on sharpening up around the goal.

Looking at McCarthy yesterday I did not see his worth. He looks no better than what we already have and I for one would be delighted to take Mata on loan from Chelsea if he remains surplus to requirements this season. He is just the type of play maker we need to provide really good ammunition for our front men. I'm afraid that Ozzie is beginning to look more and more fragile in 50% situations and we need Pienaar in his position in front of Baines as soon as possible. Gibson looks like he will be vying with Barry for a first team spot.

God knows where McCarthy will fit in??

I also want to see Delly played from the bench especially in home games initially. If we are chasing the game, surely he would be a better option than Oviedo or Naismith, otherwise why did we take him on loan?

Ian Burns
77 Posted 22/09/2013 at 11:05:24
Back from walking the dog and settled down to my favourite website and can't believe the negative comments about RM. I was one who didn't want him to come, as I so wanted Laudrup. However, he is here, he is encompassing what EFC is all about and he showed that his mantra "sin miedo" means something when he made the changes after 45 mins yesterday and didn't wait for the 70 minutes mark.

5 games in - give the guy a chance - he is doing OK, certainly making progress and the biggest plus for me is the role he has given Barkley further upfield where he belongs and where he can learn from his mistakes.

He is the boss of EFC - let's get behind him and take on board the old "School of Science" philosophy he is trying to bring to our great club.

Harold Matthews
78 Posted 22/09/2013 at 11:01:07
Trevor, as a fellow veteran I'm always interested in what you have to say and agree totally that we don't have the players to comfortably pass the ball around in our own half. Teams like Southampton and United will catch us out.

Unfortunately Trev, after that you lost me.

Robert Collins
79 Posted 22/09/2013 at 12:42:11
Trevor Lynes @ 100

Hello Trevor,

Wise words of which I agree with, I am an RM supporter and wanted him 2 years ago (and I am very happy with the progress so far), but I have also have a few nagging doubts about him and our new style.

I fear Roberto has too much belief in his system and will adopt Moyes's attitude, "This is the way we play and I will never change it. Win or lose!". Sometimes as you highlighted with Saints vs Dark side, teams can be pressured into critical mistakes when playing it out from the back (regardless of how good the are (Barca vs Chelski)). I just hope Roberto realises this and is prepared to tell his back line to hoof it if need be (or do something different?).

If he shows the flexibility I believe we need to succeed, then I think the good times will roll (at last!!!).

Derek Knox
80 Posted 22/09/2013 at 13:31:59
Harold I agree with what you are saying, with regards to teams hitting us on the break. I remember your previous thread also regarding Jags and his role of Captain ( which a lot slated you for) and you are right. Out of all the defenders Jags does not seem to be on the same wavelength as the others for some reason. I would even go as far as saying he contributed towards their first goal, instead of blocking the shot, in Toreador fashion, turned side on to deflect it past Tim.

Despite my comments I really do like Jags, but does not seem to be able to adjust to RM's system, and has been found out of position on numerous occasions so far. Distin on the other hand, is the one you would think would struggle, but has coped really well, and continues to be Mr. Consistent.

Simon George
81 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:24:07
@Joel Andersson — What the hell are you talking about? Since when does playing passing football make you soulless? All the great sides EVER passed the ball around well, including us when we won 9 league titles.

And I really can't understand why you'd be really worried because we are trying to play good football.

Jackie Barry
82 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:41:54
Southampton catch us out? seriously some people are becoming desperate in their attempts to discredit Roberto Martinez. I'm baffled by some of the utter BS being spouted here and to be honest all I have to say is that you just simply don't have a clue about the beautiful game. I'm leaving it at that because I don't want to read anymore of this trash.
Robert Collins
83 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:51:15
Jack Berry @ 262

"Southampton catch us out? I'm baffled by some of the utter BS being spouted here and to be honest all I have to say is that you just simply don't have a clue about the beautiful game."

I'm just as baffled by what you've just said above?

Did you make the same statement the night Chelsea beat Barca in their CL semi?

You sound a bit like some Kopites I know, win a few games and full of confidence, but basically full of BS !!!

Brent Stephens
85 Posted 22/09/2013 at 17:05:44
Harold, he speak wisdom. I like his perceptive comments on football (he's played a bit). Likes of Southampton could catch us out for the very reason he says. No BS there.
Harold Matthews
87 Posted 22/09/2013 at 17:03:14
Yes Derek, Distin is a true professional. Let's hope he can keep going for another year or two. His tremendous pace has saved our bacon on many occasions.

As for the team. Well it appears that Mr Martinez has raised the bar quite considerably and, judging by his comments, is a little bit ahead of schedule. He is not seeking a solid style of play which will keep us consistent and give us our usual top 6-8 finish. He wants more than that, but it will take time. We're not a rich club. We can't buy superstars and even lesser players are now demanding Champions League football. It ain't easy.

For him, it's all about putting a squad of loyal players together and getting them to play as a team in such a manner that their performances will gradually improve. In turn, he is asking us to try to understand what he is seeking to achieve for our club and to allow him to do it his way. We've had a couple of decent results but he knows our style of play is a million miles from what he has in mind and I, for one, am prepared to stick with him. I admire anyone who tries to follow a dream because few things in life are tougher. So come on you Blues. Let's get behind this nice gent and enjoy the ride, no matter what.

Mick Davies
88 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:46:16
Did anyone else watch the 'Swansea City' story last week?

That impact RM had in his time as manager was similar to Shankly at Anfield. He changed the whole style and ethos of a struggling club around and his footballing philosophy has been maintained by Rodgers and Laudrup, with the club winning its first trophy and playing attractive football in the top flight and not looking out of place. Given time, I hope he can put the Blues back at the top of English and European football, and living up to our 'School of Science' tag.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads