Blues' stars are going nowhere this month

, 8 January, 105comments  |  Jump to most recent
Martinez reiterates stance for January transfer window

Roberto Martinez remains insistent that Everton will finish the season with the club's most coveted players in place, telling attendees at a special supporters event at Finch Farm last evening that "everybody should be very assured that we are not going to lose any of the top performers that we have this season."

Though speculation linking Leighton Baines with Manchester United has simmered somewhat from its peak over the summer, there remain plenty of media outlets intent on pushing stories of a move by David Moyes for the 28 year-old.

And Ross Barkley's impressive form under Martinez this season and consequently rising profile have also made his name fodder for speculation in the red tops, with United and Chelsea said to be circling the 20 year-old with an eye on whisking him away from his boyhood club.

Martinez, though, remains focused on improving rather that destabilising his team during the January transfer window. He openly admitted that only bids for John Heitinga and Nikica Jelavic would be entertained this month.

"For me, the priority is not to lose any of the dynamics [of an in-form squad] Maybe we'll bring [in] one, two, very specific players that are going to help the ones we have [but] we're not going to lose any of the top performers.'

The manager was speaking with many of the Everton fan sites prior to Director of Communications, Alan Myers' Everton Tea Party where a select group of supporters were invited to an evening of talk about the club which included a Q&A session with Martinez, Alan Stubbs, David Unsworth and Darren Griffiths. [Full audio of the interview is available courtesy of the Followtonians podcast.]

The Spaniard spent over an hour discussing his footballing influences, philosophy and impressions of his new club after seven months in the job during which time he has ushered in some significant changes on and off the pitch.

Most notably, of course, is Martinez's emphasis on possession football, a change in style influenced by Johann Cruyff's revolution at Barcelona in the early 1990s and one he has implemented in all three of his managerial tenures to date. The 40 year-old described how impressed he has been with the speed at which Everton's players have adapted to the change.

He admitted that the Norwich, West Brom and Cardiff draws at the beginning of the campaign were frustrating but said, "it evolved and we haven't looked back since Newcastle," a game in which the 3-2 scoreline did not tell the true story of the Blues' dominant display.

"It took me six months at Swansea to change the philosophy to a possession team," he continued. "At Wigan it took two and a half years, five windows, because of financial situation to change the whole style and be effective with it. At Everton it took seven weeks.

"We were so impressed with the staff. I was so amazed how quickly the players took those concepts on, particularly the older players. [Often] it would take one [training] session."

Martinez cited his relationship with Bill Kenwright as another reason why he has settled so quickly into the role of Blues' manager:

"The relationship between the manager and the Chairman of the Board is really important. I knew I could trust the Chairman. I always felt excited having that strong relationship. It's important when you have a chairman who thinks the same way."

Quotes or other material sourced from Followtonians



Reader Comments (105)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Patrick Murphy
1 Posted 07/01/2014 at 22:51:23
We are now at a point where the club allowed the MANAGER today to be interviewed by all the main Everton fans websites for nearly 90 minutes! Not just a snatched 10 minutes... not just half an hour.... but an hour and a half!

How come TW didn't get an invite for this event? Regardless it is nice to see the club being a little more open with its supporters – just have to get them to open their wallets next.

John Daley
2 Posted 08/01/2014 at 01:50:58
Essential listening. Even the wife gave up fannying about on her 'farming' app to listen to Roberto hold court for nearly 90 mins.

Love his thoughts on the academy and the way he can just reel off the names of numerous youth players and what 'stage' of development they're currently at.

His surreal detour into the correct shade of brown shoe and how they can't ever be lucky if they lack laces just serves to illustrate how at ease he is in such situations. Moyes would've probably just gave them the 'Presbo's Eyebrow'.

Patrick Murphy
4 Posted 08/01/2014 at 03:19:17
I'm currently listening to the podcast of Roberto, he is so so different to any other manager – his personality is so open and honest. So far, his best quote was to say we are not overachieving in fact he has been very disappointed by the points we have dropped, he also admits to being a dreamer and that Everton FC should aspire to be challengers for the league. It might take time but that is what he believes a club such as Everton should be aiming for.
Dennis Ng
5 Posted 08/01/2014 at 03:40:50
Patrick, fully agree! I worry that Man Utd will try to snatch him should they axe OFM. Or Barca in a few years to come. But listening to that makes me feel that he will resist those temptations as well! Fingers crossed!
Dennis Ng
6 Posted 08/01/2014 at 05:47:29
The School of Science is back in full swing!

Interesting interview. Great insight to his vision of the club. The shackles are still on but the part where he mentions the youngsters going out on loan is very encouraging. I look forward to them blooding the youngsters. Only thing I find disappointing is that he didn't hint of any transfers, only sure thing, probably a forward as the first or both signings.

Machiel Barnard
7 Posted 08/01/2014 at 06:15:24
Did it only take 7 weeks to adopt to the new style because the players we have are of better quality or is it because the players were open to change, or is it both?
Geof Thompson
8 Posted 08/01/2014 at 06:42:33
Before we first were linked with Martinez I wanted him to be our new manager. I'd always thought he seemed tactically clever and good at getting the best out of players. I also thought he had a good eye for spotting talent. But even in my wildest dreams I didn't realise how good he would be for our club.

The man is already a legend in my eyes. I know some may say he has achieved Nothing yet. But he has. What he has achieved already is to make Evertonians the world over excited! I mean seriously, I'm like a school kid with a free pass to the tuck shop! Lol. I believe in us again. If we go behind in a game I still think we'll win. If we go in front I don't think we are going to park the bus!

And more importantly I don't even care about the score anyway, I'm just loving watching us play. Being a bluenose hasn't been this much fun since I was going to stand in the Boys Pen in front of St Domingos to watch Howard's team winning leagues and cups galore. And if I'm being honest we playing much better football now than we ever did then. Viva Roberto. :-)

Chris Morris
9 Posted 08/01/2014 at 07:09:42
Must admit I never thought the Martinez impact would have happened so quickly. I did want him when Moyes buggered off but I thought it was going to take him about 12-18 months to make his mark.

A few of my RS mates have also noted how quickly he has changed Everton's play and one (in typical RS fashion) said "he's nearly as tactically astute as Rodgers!?!?!?!?!?!" But that's for that lot to rub themselves over.

What is obvious to me though is that this style would never have been adopted by Moyes. There were odd flashes now and again but never a system based on it. The personnel have helped immensely, Barry, Lukaku but more so McCarthy. (I still maintain he's the best centre midfield player in the league & was last year.)

Now..... where did I put my brown brogues?

Paul Gladwell
10 Posted 08/01/2014 at 07:32:10
Love the fella me, one thing that said so much about how he trusts his players and makes them feel ten feet tall was in the Goodison derby. When we were chasing the game, he had already startled us all with his substitution after Baines was injured; he then decided to drop Ross Barkley back into a deep centre mid position, a position that never in a month of Sundays would Moyes have put him in and a position last year where everyone on here would have flinched at too due to how he apparently gave the ball away to much. The response he got was Barkley ran the show, he was even better than his advanced centre-mid position, it just showed that a bit of faith and a bit of balls pays off far more than constant caution.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
11 Posted 08/01/2014 at 07:21:02
He's just fantastic to listen to, and kudos to the other lads and lasses for pulling this off. Unfortunately, work commitments a long way from Merseyside meant that we would not have been able to participate.

It's a a great sign that things at the club have changed tremendously in terms openness. I suspect there were some ground rules but it was a great discussion. His philosophy is simply so endearing. a great focus going forward combined with a comprehensive assimilation of our history and traditions... just loved that he's quoting Alan Ball.

Fantastic.

Simon Hermansen
12 Posted 08/01/2014 at 07:44:29
Looking forward to listening to this but just reading his words in this piece makes me feel emotional and positive, imagine how the players feel being around him all day, no wonder the belief levels are through the roof and improvement can be seen game to game.

I think the '7 weeks' mentioned is mainly down to the talent within the existing pool of players. So a positive nod to ofm for that but it also reinforces the fact he had them playing in 'shackles' and not to full footballing potential.

Chris Morris
13 Posted 08/01/2014 at 08:25:37
If we can't afford to keep Lukaku then we can't afford to let Jelavic go. We need a replacement in and raring to go before anybody leaves.

Also that Jelavic that turned up against QPR was like a flashback. I'm not too fussed about the penalty miss, I was happy to see him have the confidence to try it

Dan Hollingworth
14 Posted 08/01/2014 at 08:35:46
I have just finished his book. His Mum owns a chain of shoe shops in Spain. Hence why he always has a new spotless pair on.
Mike Green
15 Posted 08/01/2014 at 08:46:22
What a fantastic way to start the day listening to that.

Intelligent, passionate, witty, knowledgeable, insightful, honest, ambitious, optimistic, respectful. I wouldn't swap him for anyone - plus great credit for the questions and contribution from the other side of the table.

Absolutely brilliant.

Steven Telford
16 Posted 08/01/2014 at 08:41:12
Alan Stubbs being at the question and answer session, somebody should have asked, "Alan why were you so fucking dumb and disrespectful to manager, the player and the club, to have stated publicly that Baines wanted to leave?"

If I was there I guarantee it would have been my question.

Peter Bell
17 Posted 08/01/2014 at 08:53:16
The thing that always impresses me, is that he always talks about Everton as if he is here for the long term, has identified a massive club with great fans and wants to be the person who puts us back were we belong, among the elite.
Kevin Tully
18 Posted 08/01/2014 at 09:10:02
Let's hope Baines has seen the light, great to hear no star players will be leaving this January. My main concern is how we can keep this guy at the club. Arsenal fans are already convinced he is the rightful heir to Wenger.

It's funny how fans of other clubs think they can pick the bones of Everton, be it players or our manager. Hopefully Martinez is made of different stuff. After all, we can afford to pay him as much as these bigger clubs.

Tony Waring
19 Posted 08/01/2014 at 09:58:52
Chris (021) Agree 100% with all you say. Jelavic is one we should hang on to because Lukaku will not be around next season.
Pat Waine
20 Posted 08/01/2014 at 10:15:01
I wanted Moyes out. Always thought he was conservative. We played our best football under Moyes when we were a goal down. We never really went for teams and played with confidence. I now feel if we concede no matter we will keep our heads up and have a real go. We can't ask for more, but Blues are dreaming again – Viva Roberto!!!
Patrick Murphy
21 Posted 08/01/2014 at 10:20:59
Peter, fully agree with you - while I was worried that one of the other monied Premier League teams could / would try and tempt him - there are only a few if any of those clubs where the manager has full control over playing policy etc I lam more confident that Roberto will resist that temptation. The only club I can see him leaving for are Barca but even they might not suit RM as they are a political force as well as a football club. Maybe, just maybe Goodison is his football heaven and he has no desire to go anywhere.

I have a new nickname for him Bob the Builder as I think that is what he sets out to do, he seems to enjoy the prospect of getting all levels of the playing staff to improve and buy into his project - a refreshing change and let's hope he can produce the required results over the coming months and years.

Jim Bennings
22 Posted 08/01/2014 at 10:40:09
It is fascinating just listening to Martinez. It is educational and instantly you realise you are listening to a man who has immense footballing knowledge yet is also willing to learn and get better.

When you contrast that to Moyes who forever seemed as though he almost wanted to be held back by the financial restraints just so he could say 'Oh well we are plucky little Everton and if we finish 6th its over achievement'.

We spent years being brainwashed by Moyes and his 'play us down' demeanor and frankly it's so refreshing to hear a manager talk about Everton as though we are still a major club, not just off the pitch but on it, something for me that eventually got lost on Moyes.

You almost felt that because Everton were in such dire straights when Moyes first took over, that the man himself always thought he was punching above his weight with a club expecting relegation battles, year-in & year-out. I regularly used to say even when Moyes was here, the reason we used to fail in so many big games and never learn our lessons was because Moyes never rid himself of the mentality he had at Preston. It was always a shrug of the shoulders and "Oh well, they have spent more than little old Everton".

We can rest assured that this club is in good hands.

Peter Bell
23 Posted 08/01/2014 at 10:54:11
Patrick, totally agree with your views on Barca. Would RM want to go there with all the politics that goes on and last a couple of years, or stay with a club with mighty traditions and history, make them a force again, competing with the best, and make yourself a legend.
Ciarán McGlone
24 Posted 08/01/2014 at 11:07:44
Good positive manager = happy fans.

The change in the mood on this site is fantastic. Long may it continue.

Phil Bellis
25 Posted 08/01/2014 at 11:05:27
How strange that Bill has apparently left the building! No soundbites or interviews taking credit.

It's as if he's seen how our manager performs and is happy to let Roberto front the whole operation; a wise move, I think

Paul Mackie
26 Posted 08/01/2014 at 11:08:53
That was a really good interview, I recommend everyone listens to it.

One thing I found particularly interesting was Martinez's stance that he wouldn't have taken the job if we didn't have a chairman who understood the club and that if we were run by overseas investors he would have said no straight away. Pretty obvious with hindsight that that's why he turned down the RS job.

I'm more and more impressed with him every time he speaks.

Dennis Ng
27 Posted 08/01/2014 at 11:23:10
Phil (036), me rubs hands hoping BK is out making signings happen soon!

Patrick, Peter, yea, it seems to me the exact same feeling. Managers come and go these days but our man seems happy to have found his rightful place.

Michael Wylie
28 Posted 08/01/2014 at 10:11:27
He is brilliant. Good questions from the panel too!
James Stewart
29 Posted 08/01/2014 at 11:44:51
Listened to the whole thing. Great link thanks for posting.

I am firmly a believer in Martinez whatever happens for the rest of the season. His eloquence and understand of the game and long term planning is exactly what this club needed. I started supporting Everton in 93-94 season and never has it felt so good.

Linda Morrison
30 Posted 08/01/2014 at 11:45:47
I'm not too worried about Roberto going abroad. His wife is I think from the North West and wants to stay near her family especially now they have a baby.

We should keep Jelly, even if they sign a striker. You need 2 good strikers to compete at the top as relying on 1 is asking for trouble.

Don't forget Roberto has introduced a number of new faces, and also given the youngsters the chance they never got under the previous manager.

I think we'll get at least 2 signings although the paper today states we will have to pay £1.5 million for the Dundee lad.

Tony J Williams
31 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:08:45
What youngster would they be Linda?

Barkley? He was getting game time, although not enough of it
Oviedo? He wouldn't be playing if Baines wasn't injured
Stones? The same as above, injuries brought him into the side.
I can't think of any others.

What I do like is that Martinez is sending loads of our youngster out on loan to half decent lower league clubs to bring them on.

Chris Morris
32 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:17:30
I like Martinez, always have done, but if he suddenly loses the next 6 games then the pressure will be on him. Right now, while the going is good everybody is happy, but a manager's job is never safe from the sack
Ryan Holroyd
33 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:20:58
Tony, you can bet your last pound Moyes would have played Heitinga/Hibbert or Barry at centre half v QPR.

Martinez trusts in his youngsters. Barkley would have been out on loan if Moyes was still here. Maybe this is why Barkley can't stand Moyes.

Brian Harrison
34 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:14:36
There is no doubt that RM has been absolutely brilliant for us, and I hear that he has put pictures up around Finch Farm of our Championship winning sides to remind them what a big and successful club Everton is. He is so positive in everything he does and says, I bet he makes the players feel unbeatable, which apart from City and Sunderland games they have been.

I wonder how his comments about the Chairman went down with the fans group, maybe he does let his managers manage unlike many Chairman in the Premier league. Lets hope with this new positive approach that maybe the investors we need might now come forward, as that would be the icing on the cake for this season.

Linda Morrison
35 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:24:19
I agree Chris, football fans are difficult to predict at times.

There's no way apart from a complete collapse in most of the 1st team we will lose a lot of games on the trot.

The problem may be when, and if, we get a prolonged run in the cup, have injuries, and don't bring in people to add to the squad numbers.

We will lose games but Roberto has a positive attitude and looks for a way around things. You only have to see how he manages the substitutions for that.

Onwards and upwards!

Paul Columb
36 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:29:44
Delighted to see the end to the Moyes era and ecstatic at how Martinez has embraced the club, its history and expouses a desire to push for trophies and a place of meaning in Everton's history books. Every time I see Moyes' face in the media I am literally overcome with relief that he no longer represents our club. The cloud has risen and we're having a go....that's the important thing. Nil satis Roberto y muchas gracias para todo.
Chris Morris
37 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:49:32
I noted last night that Moyes did his usual last 4 minutes for the striker to rescue the game substitution. Hernandez has become the new James Vaughan!

I contrast that with the substitutions that Martinez makes and they seem worlds apart. I liked Moyes (before people think this is another attack on him) but his substitutions were always his biggest fault I thought. He never seemed to trust his team and when I see Martinez making positive changes all the time its quite refreshing.

Players like Osman are coming on and changing the game like at Stoke, while players like Oviedo are coming in and looking almost undroppable. (I'm not sure undroppable is a word)

Mike Hughes
39 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:56:21
A really great interview.

As I've stated before, RM comes across as a real class act. He's a cut above the rest and therefore Everton FC must be his natural home. I can't imagine him even swearing - except perhaps a couple of years ago after being interviewed for the rs job when I can imagine him leaving Anfield muttering, "What a bunch of gobshites! They can stick it up -"

I really want this to work out and feel we're on the verge of something special here - like in 1983. In fact, I don't just want him to do it for us - but for him as well.

Two notes of caution:
1. We haven't won anything yet so let's not get too carried away - support as always.
2. I hope he didn't give too much away when they asked him about training tactics.

Let's build momentum before blitzing the rs at their place later in the month.

Michael Wylie
40 Posted 08/01/2014 at 13:01:20
Wonder if the style of football and the managers outlook has an impact on the type, amount and quality of players that may want to play for Everton. You'd think so??
Charles Brewer
42 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:58:21
Martinez has some interesting decisions to make in the next few years. If, as seems quite possible, the era of unlimited deficit spending ends in the Premiership, there may be something of a return to the much superior time when a good manager in a good club could have an equal chance with anyone.

Martinez has the opportunity to take a club with a great history but a relatively poor recent record (since HK version 1), to being a possible world power in the game. I have much sympathy for Moyes who left a club which he had turned around from being regular relegation fodder to a "just below the CL" team, to go to a clapped out wreck with just two decent (and frequently injured) players. Martinez walked into a club with a good internal situation and a much improved external environment, and has an attitude consistent with success.

Martinez will need to think very hard about whether he wants to go to a "bigger" (Barcelona/Chelsea etc) team which may well be on the verge of ManU style collapse, or building a globally recognised success which will have his name all over it.

Bill Griffiths
43 Posted 08/01/2014 at 13:14:14
When appointed I was not too sure whether he was/is the right man for the job but was prepared to give him time to make his mark. Other than our performances on the pitch, I have to say I have been more and more impressed every time I have heard him speak in interviews, and having listened to this podcast, I have to say I am now convinced he is the right/only man for the job.

Given that in the main on this site most are pro-Martinez I am intrigued as to how all these pro-Martinez/anti-BK fans reconcile the fact that he has such a high opinion of and support for our Chairman and has stated more than once that this was one of the main reasons for him taking the job.

Tom Bowers
44 Posted 08/01/2014 at 13:12:49
It is kind of easy to say at the moment that we are all glad Moyes isn't at Goodison anymore but the truth is Everton haven't yet achieved anything.
Without doubt however things have changed somewhat and everyone really looks forward to the next match as RM has gotten the team playing with a confidence that was never apparent under Moyes.
The difference in young Barklay is amazing and is all down to RM in my book.
Obviously changes still have to take place to strengthen the squad.
The loan situations may be up in the air at the end of the season and so if they make Champions league they will need to be prepared.
Ian Burns
45 Posted 08/01/2014 at 13:21:09
I have just listened to the full 1 hour 22 mins and was struck by the honesty with which RM dealt with the questions and his open attitude with regards to how he sees his team (EFC) playing their football. Other managers could learn a lot from that interview, it was both fascinating and relaxing listening to somebody who has fallen in instant love with our great club; its history and the hopes of the fans.

On the purely human side I loved the moment when he was embarrassed caught out swearing after Ross's goal at Swansea - lovely moment.

I have been an EFC supporter since the late '50's and I am certainly not looking to tempting fate but there is a feeling about the coming seasons which is eerily like the time of the Holy Trinity and mid-80's. I know he has it all to do but he gets my vote if asked if he will deliver.

EFC; RM and brown brogues - love it.

Craig Walker
46 Posted 08/01/2014 at 13:28:57
Brilliant interview. Listening to it now when I should be working.

Currently reading Kendall's book which is a decent read but it's interesting the parallels between the two managers in terms of training methods. Howard states in his book several times that training should be based around working with a ball and that's what he applied at Everton. Hope RM can have the success that HK had in his first spell. The training methods described in this Martinez interview are a breath of fresh air compared to the conditioning philosophy of OFM. In my opinion, he over trained players and got injuries as a result. I think someone at United described him as "a dinosaur".

So proud to have this fella as our manager. He's been a revolution thus far. Agreeing to do this interview and being so honest in his answers is a measure of the bloke. Superb.

Roman Sidey
47 Posted 08/01/2014 at 13:27:15
While it's good that he seems so confident that we won't lose any players this season, and without tempting fate too much, I would love to know what other clubs value our fullbacks at. It's been said, but I think the form of Oviedo means that a bid for Baines around the 12-15m mark could be acceptable, and I really think Coleman is worth more than that at the moment. Definitely the best right-back in the league at the moment. Oviedo would have to be worth a bit more than what we paid for him, which I seem to remember it being 4m (please correct me if that isn't true).
James Marshall
48 Posted 08/01/2014 at 13:48:04
I wish people would stop feeding the paranoia about our players leaving, and concentrate on the players we might bring in. This thread is about the positive nature of our club, so we should really try & keep that in mind when thinking about transfers.

Speculation about players coming in is a lot more fun & interesting than worrying about who might leave.

The manager says no top performers will leave, so lets take his word for it and look at talk of McGeady & Ince to name but two.

Noel Early
49 Posted 08/01/2014 at 14:01:53
Brilliant and refreshing interview, the man just oozes positivity. Earlier on in the season, I remarked how odd it was to hear Phil Jagielka say they wanted to win the league and he sounded so convincing. It's not hard to figure out were this belief is coming from. It's like night and day compared to our former manager.

What struck me most was from it all was how excited he sounded about the youngsters coming up through the ranks, Ty Browning must be glowing after hearing what Martinez said about him.

Harold Matthews
50 Posted 08/01/2014 at 12:26:01
Enlightening interview with calm, sensible answers to one or two well meaning fans who tended to complicate things.

I hope TWs heeded his warning about the dangers of expectancy. Putting us in a position where we have something to lose. He came across as being very strong on this particular issue. Even citing it as one of the reasons we lost to Wigan in the Cup.

David Ellis
51 Posted 08/01/2014 at 14:55:57
Absolutely stunning interview. So much better than mainstream media. Its like sitting in the pub discussing Everton tactics with Roberto.

I have seen a lot of young players hyped up before only to never make it to the first team (or anywhere else). But I was encouraged by the sheer number of young players he mentions as coming through - at least 9 or 10 - some of them will make it with the right handling and Roberto seems to have the right nurturing approach - and great to have a classy ball player like Alan Irvine running the youth set up (and an experienced manager in his own right).

I think we may well hang on to Jelavic. Roberto says that after the QPR game he realised the squad was stronger than he thought - i.e. Jelavic can do a job for us and Lukaku can be rotated when the need arises.

Also love him being so relaxed about Delafeleu and Lukaku leaving at the end of the season - its OK, if it happens we will just bring another loaned player in to replace them. The confidence he has is so re-assuring.

Harold Matthews
52 Posted 08/01/2014 at 14:36:46
Incidentally, the business of getting lads out on loan is mainly a Stubbs thing. He will consult with Martinez of course, but the U21s are in his care and he has spoken many times about his efforts to get them loaned out to decent clubs. Whenever this occurs he says he feels a great sense of achievement. ( Everton official site.2013.)
Pavel Ivanov
53 Posted 08/01/2014 at 14:58:46
When they were on the topic of strikers I was hoping somebody would ask him about Mirallas - I wanted to hear whether the manager saw whether the manager saw him as an alternative to Lukaku, Jelavic, Kone.

Also, as he is probably the one first team player whose performances this season are markedly off what the fans believe him capable of, I would have asked Martinez whether he thought this had something to do with the position he was played in.

Jeff Gwilliams
54 Posted 08/01/2014 at 15:48:14
I am living in OZ now but was lucky enough to see Everton great, then dire, then great again in the eighties, then dire, then a great spell with joe, (the dogs of war label was crap and haunted his side).

Then we fell through the floor. Moyes did turn us around but by the end watching Everton in the early hours was more like having to tahn wanting to. I would feel really guilty if I didn't but did not look forward to most of the games.

We (I speak for all my Perth mates) are like kids again, we are great and fantastic to watch.

Roberto was asked at one point, is it "The People's Club" or the "School of Science"; he said, "The School of Science, definitely."

Enough said.

David Chait
55 Posted 08/01/2014 at 15:54:34
Just finished listening and the part I was really interested I was the conversation of youth. Interesting he feels Green is quite far from the top but excellent observation that he needs to find his specialized position... Loved that as players who do a bit of everything cos they can often fall behind I believe so so happy to hear that.

He clearly rates Browning... But he is always so positive it's difficult to tell when he thinks someone won't make it.

Also very professional in no slagging off our OFM. I wonder if he told BK to keep his gob shut as this is the quietest I have ever seen him.

This guy's personality is infectious.

On the note of players not going I just don't fear it at all. Yes it may happen, but will be on our terms. I hope we get Ince, btw.

Geoff Freeman
56 Posted 08/01/2014 at 16:07:08
I know as much as anyone the poor decisions BK has made over the years, but we have to praise him getting Roberto to manage our club and to allow him a free hand in running it.
Michael Kenrick
57 Posted 08/01/2014 at 16:10:00
Fabulous, Jeff (#099);

My biggest wish is that we could finally confine that "people's club" tag to the dustbin where it belongs. The club themselves stopped using it years ago; now we have a manager who embraces a wholly different philosophy — but most importantly one that is rooted in the tremendous history and tradition of the club. A history and tradition that the man himself has obviously immersed himself in, taken on board and is determine to reinvent for the 21st Century.

The School of Science is being reestablished after a long hiatus. What better tagline could there be for the new Martinez era?

Ross Kerry
58 Posted 08/01/2014 at 16:29:46
Interesting interview, Martinez is superb at answering questions positively. I'm not surprised at the confidence he has inspired in his players this year, and the instant allegiance of some of the Everton faithful. I think that has much to do with his initial success at the club and is vital for any prospect of long term success. His compliance in the rewriting of facts about his Wigan tenure is interesting, but not welcome.
Craig Walker
59 Posted 08/01/2014 at 16:55:00
Michael #110 - I don't like the People's Club tag either. When it was coined by Moyes, I thought it captured the positivity of a new manager trying to get the fans on board in a relegation dogfight. I thought it served its purpose for a couple of years but added to the 'plucky old Everton' image. These days it comes across as embarrassing. I would prefer us to use the 'School of Science' from now on.

I'm not sure you are right that the club have stopped using it though Michael. Sure, it is no longer plastered on every bit of promotional or marketing activity but in big letters on the side of the main stand it says 'Goodison Park. The home of the People's Club' immediately above this season's crest.

Jeff Gwilliams
60 Posted 08/01/2014 at 17:02:04
Craig #128
Maybe it's time someone should tell them to get shut
Dennis Ng
61 Posted 08/01/2014 at 17:00:24
Michael (099),

I totally understand the stand for "The People's Club". Sad that it has to more to do with OFM than RM. When I first heard of it, I was very pleased because it "means" a willingness to listen to fans. Of course, history showed otherwise until now.

It's ironic that the manager that really feels the passion of the club and the fans don't like the tag, so I'll go along. In my mind, RM's current handling of media and fans fit more of TPC than OFM ever did. But I'll stop using it to avoid comparisons to OFM.

As a number-crunching person though, "School of Science" is a great tag! Finally its back in session!

Craig (128),

I never liked the term 'plucky'. It's not like we're the only team to not win trophies through the years. There are like 100 teams below us every year. Plucky sounds like bottom feeder-ish. I find it completely insulting to our status as a EPL club. Sure, we smash and grab some wins. You can say that about 1 million other teams in the world.

Andy Osborne
62 Posted 08/01/2014 at 17:38:07
Being relatively new to ToffeeWeb, I am not sure what OFM means. I have an idea but please enlighten me.

Regarding RM, he is a leader, with a great PR perception. However, he is different. I have experienced many PR experts in my time, but most feel shallow, RM does not. He has substance and passion behind his words. I'm a convert,

I think he he is a great fit for our club, I am enjoying every one of his interviews. He obviously has the personality to bring out the best in everyone of his players.

In the podcast, he mentioned Alcaraz as one who took on a project, he would work for four years and move on to another club for free. He also mentioned then after four years he was ready for another challenge when he was at Wigan.

I don't think we need to be paranoid about him being poached anytime soon. I think he is here for a few more years and if we can back him up with transfer funds he will be here for a lot longer.

Craig Walker
63 Posted 08/01/2014 at 17:45:01
Dennis. I agree about the term 'plucky' but it's not often we are actually called it as such. It's more a perception in the media that we are seen as 'punching above our weight'. This season we have confounded our critics by playing attractive football. It's a return to the principles that defined our successful periods in the past. For that reason, let's plaster 'School of Science' on the Main Stand and remind people of our heritage and our current playing style.
Andy Osborne
64 Posted 08/01/2014 at 17:49:50
Craig. I agree, Peoples Club was a distraction, School of science is what we really are.
Sam Morrison
66 Posted 08/01/2014 at 18:04:21
Not had a chance to listen yet but from all the posts here looking forward to it.

Ross@118, what are you alluding to here re: rewriting history?

Dennis Ng
67 Posted 08/01/2014 at 18:14:39
Craig (147), I guess we can't change RS and MU leaning media. I like the part where he said we're on track to produce 2 first team players from the academy in x (2 I think he said) years. That's way more than MU's golden era I think, especially given their dearth since! School of Science suits us more in this era for sure. May it long continue!

Sam, Ross, I thought what he said about his Wigan tenure is true, though the part about survival might be speculative. He spoke about changing the mindset of Swansea and Wigan for the most part and I can see that's as his most important contribution.

Tony Draper
68 Posted 08/01/2014 at 17:40:46
Superb!
Utterly superb!

Roberto, with every single word, demonstrates his complete and thorough understanding of "The Beautiful Game" and his delight at restoring "the School of Science"

88 minutes of pure Blue Paradise, or to paraphrase well known Evertonian verse — "Those who have heard need no explanation......."

Brian Waring
69 Posted 08/01/2014 at 18:35:04
Andy, it means 'our former manager' Can't remember his name.
Ross Kerry
70 Posted 08/01/2014 at 18:30:31
Sam@159.

Martinez is asked about how he picked up Valencia and Rodallega for Wigan, neither of whom he signed. Rather than correct the interviewer, he agrees with him.

He's a very smart bloke, OK with capitalising on a mistake rather than pointing out the inconvenient fact that the previous, very unfashionable Wigan manager was actually the one who brought a number of notable South American signings to Wigan.

Andy Osborne
71 Posted 08/01/2014 at 18:44:51
Thanks, Brian. I had all sorts of expletives going through my mind.
John Daley
72 Posted 08/01/2014 at 18:45:02
Ross, I listened to it late last night so my memory might be playing tricks but I thought he was asked about having previous experience of managing South American players, not specifically signing them?
Dennis Ng
73 Posted 08/01/2014 at 19:02:11
John, Ross, I don't remember the specifics but I do remember how he mentioned why he feels he can work well with South Americans, in fact to the point of what to look for in particular countries. So he did talk in terms of signing as well, just briefly.
Peter Falconer
74 Posted 08/01/2014 at 18:59:35
When Moyes joined Everton he was the right man at the right time. He did a fantastic job but became the wrong manger to take us on to the next stage and should have moved on sooner. Even a Roberto in those dark days would probably have seen us relegated.

Roberto has joined us at the right time for the Club and for him. Moyes left Roberto a heritage of excellent players who can move to a higher level under a much more sophisticated management style.

Ross Kerry
75 Posted 08/01/2014 at 19:10:09
John/Dennis,

44 minutes in;
"in the past at Wigan you picked up a lot of central/south American players like Valencia and Rodallega"
RM "yes"

He didn't, either of them.

Dennis Ng
76 Posted 08/01/2014 at 19:19:30
Ross,

I see what you're saying. I didn't know who signed those for Wigan (Steve Bruce?). I do remember a latter part he talked about managing them though.

Jamie Sweet
78 Posted 08/01/2014 at 20:11:26
"I've met some of the finest individuals you could possibly meet in football - the finest of which is sitting next to me now..."

Bill Kenwright at the press conference where Martinez was unveiled as our next manager.

At the time I thought that line was just a touch of theatre from Bill.

Now I believe he was absolutely spot on.

Ross Edwards
79 Posted 08/01/2014 at 20:22:36
He did Ross. Valencia played in his first season, Rodellega was signed in his second season.
Adam Luszniak
80 Posted 08/01/2014 at 20:33:25
My favourite quote - "Messi or Ronaldo?"

Martinez - "I'll take Ross Barkley"

Ross Kerry
82 Posted 08/01/2014 at 20:49:50
Yes Patrick, it would.
Ross Kerry
85 Posted 08/01/2014 at 20:54:14
OK Barry, what's the experience of dealing with South American players that Martinez is drawing upon in his answer?
Neil Steele
92 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:09:36
Absolutely delighted how well this has been received, it was a real privilege to be involved..awe inspiring in fact!

It was Steve Jones of Kipper who asked the question about Valencia and Rodallega, and I did realise at the time that Roberto hadn't signed them (I was actually unconvinced about him in the summer... so I'd looked over his transfer dealings!)... but nobody was going to pick up on something like that, because (if I recall correctly) the main point was really about the adaptability and value of South American players... so Roberto just real concentrated on that, immediately citing Alcaraz as his own example, rather than try to claim credit for those players. Personally I think Rodallega is pony anyway, so who cares!

What a man though... I'm not one for being taken in by people or being awe struck, but I have no shame in saying that I felt as though we were in the presence of greatness. Everything David Moyes never was... he's School of Science and traditional Everton values to the core. Better than that, he dares to dream!

Ross Edwards
93 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:12:03
Ross,

Wigan's South American signings:

2009-10 season:
Marcelo Moreno
Hugo Rodellega
Antonio Valencia

2010-11 season
Di Santo
Boselli

2012-13 season

Antolin Alcaraz
Angelo Henriquez
Jean Beausejeur

Barry Rathbone
94 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:14:38
Ross, clearly not - just your conclusion.

Look I am offering another opinion on your assertion, you may well think Roberto sniggered to himself thinking "got this interviewer on toast I can claim all sorts no one will ever know!!" .

But given the breathtaking directness, honesty and humility we have all enjoyed (sorry, that should read "most of us") since his arrival do you really think this is what he was doing?

Ian Burns
95 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:21:45
Neil (#229) — many thanks for that qualification. It was a great interview (meant in the nicest possible way) – but not very journalistic; simple conversation asking the sort of questions we fans would like to ask. Well presented; well done — look forward to Series 2!!

Gavin Fennessy
96 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:16:40
Ross K seems to be courting controversy on a few threads tonight. I see no issue whatsoever with RM's response.

I agree with Barry, the manager was having a very open and warm discussion with representatives of the fans. The point about signing South American players was raised and he took the opportunity to praise the qualities of Alcaraz. To pick the amateur interviewer up on his lack of research would have been pedantic and unnecessary.

Michael K summed up a lot of fans feelings listening to a really encouraging hopeful and thoughtful Q&A. Thanks to all involved.

Kevin Tully
97 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:18:02
It was quite unreal to hear a manager speak so openly about Jelavic and Heitinga possibly leaving.

He just told it like it was, no skirting around the subject or deflecting questions. I imagine the players already have huge respect for his honest approach.

Well done to the fans in attendance BTW - represented the fanbase as one of the most knowledgeable out there.

Dennis Ng
100 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:29:55
Kevin, I certainly feel the players being openly respectful of him as well. I feel the Jela and Heitinga situations are more straightforward than many said. They prob approached him on the issue of their WC aspiration, and he prob also told them where they stand in his team. I imagine both actually didn't have problems being benched behind players who better fit the strategy. After all, its one more WC for both of them I imagine.
Ian Burns
113 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:59:10

Report abuse Ross, the following was written earlier today on another thread by Mr. Michael Kenrick (editor) referencing discussing on Mr. Moyes - I am just an ordinary member of the TW Site - I have absolutely no say whatsover on what is said or not said - - - - - - My point is this is a thread about the RM interview . . .
"I deleted most of it off the QPR match thread because I thought that at least should be about a great performance, brilliant goals, and a superb result for Everton, not sullied by thoughts of OFM.

I tried to keep it off the Stevenage thread but that went up at about the same time as Swansea were winning at OT, so the flood became a torrent.

Then, this piece by Elliot Bretland and there was no stopping a full-out orgifest of Moyes 'naustalgia'.... [see what I did there ;) ]

This thread was a goodie... but 300+ comments?!?! Hopefully that's it for a while; having rehashed many of the same old and frankly boring arguments, the usual suspects will perhaps let it drop now.

But it's up to the posters to either move on, and rejoice in Roberto's path forward... or... well. you know what."

James Martin
121 Posted 08/01/2014 at 22:22:25
Brilliant interview. The only bit I took umbrage with was the interviewer saying Stracqualursi could have been hauling Coal.

In a dark time, Stracq gave us some small moments of joy. He gave absolutely everything he had in a blue jersey and if only we could say the same of his more talented counterparts we might have own something in recent years. His header against Fulham was class and so was his build up against Chelsea. I believed there was a player of some form in there but he was dropped for the woeful Saha.

I'll never get on the back of any player giving every drop of sweat for the blue shirt.

Graham Mockford
123 Posted 08/01/2014 at 22:26:56
The final proof for me about the measure of Roberto as a manager was the Southampton game.

Three days earlier Leon Osman has a mare and effectively costs us the game, our unbeaten record for the year and gets hooked for the substitution.

Many on here would have had him publicly flogged, predicted the end of his career etc.

What does Roberto do next game, gives him the captain's armband. A public display of confidence in the player.

The reward another five days later, a point saving display from the bench. That my friends is man management.

Jim Lloyd
124 Posted 08/01/2014 at 22:04:42
Ross, whatever point you are trying to make, I think you are rather sad, as you seem to be intimating that our Manager is a liar.

The manager of the School of Science gave a wonderful interview, at least I thought so and except for you, every other Evertonian appears to have got the same vibes.

I have not been as excited about Everton's prospects since Howard Kendall's first coming and before that, the wonderful team of Johnny Carey's that graced our club in the early sixties. School of Science indeed!

One of the many points he talked about was the transfer windows and the use of on loan players, both points he covered excellently, I thought.

I think we can get a bit bogged down talking about OFM every time we discuss Roberto's philosophy, his decisions and his vision for Everton but, for what its worth, I think Moyes did come into Everton when we were relegation bound and not only kept us up, he improved us over the years.

He made some awful signings (that centre half who couldn't head a ball) some decent signings and some excellent signings. The last couple of years of Moyes I felt we were in Groundhog Day, and I gave up my season ticket. His behaviour for the last six months at the club and during the transfer window, certainly consigned him to history as far as I was concerned.

I think we've got a wonderful manager. Whether we get into the Champions League or win cups, well, Martinez answered this himself. He said he wants our players to be themselves, go out and play beautiful (my word there) football always.

I believe he will attract footballers with great skill because they will want to play in an attractive skillful side. That is what Roberto is building here at Everton and I'm bloody glad I got my season ticket back as soon as he became our Manager.

I have no worries about players leaving. If he says they are not leaving, then they are not. If they do, it will be on his terms and when it is best for our team. I love what he said about Jellyfish. He said he wanted him to stay but that he understood Nic's wish to get in the frame for the World Cup. So if we are going to get a forward in, I think Roberto said it would likely be a loan signing and that, only if Nic goes.

I can't think where else we are in desperate need of a player so, unless he sees some young players, I think he will wait until the Summer to bring in permanent players.

Along with the excitement, I think he's giving Pride back to Evertonians... something I don't think we've had for many a long year. To know that we are going to go out, whether at home, away; and especially at any of the top teams, and go out TO WIN (sorry Michael).

That bunch over the road might have SOS, well so have we: School of Science!

Roman Sidey
125 Posted 08/01/2014 at 21:29:22
Brian Waring, I honestly thought it meant "Old Fella/Fart Moyes". I've been walking around for months confused! Ha.
Gerard Carey
135 Posted 08/01/2014 at 22:54:38
Patrick 207. Whats really getting to me is what beer, brands C and D were??!!,,, I am getting a terrible thirst on me. By the way great to be hearing of the School of Science again, missing for too long
James Martin
136 Posted 08/01/2014 at 23:01:43
Sorry, couldn't help but notice a couple of things. First of all the entire interview was class, couldn't wish for anyone else to be in the hot seat right now.

But two things did make me laugh. Firstly his reaction to the question about Fellaini against Wigan: "I knew immediately there is a certain profile of player that does not fit at Everton". Saw through the fraud in no time didn't he.

Secondly, I know you all love it "Obviously getting 41 points is nice it is one target and it guarantees you another year in the league" (or something along those lines)

Maybe it's not what you say but how you say it......

Tony Draper
138 Posted 08/01/2014 at 23:01:50
Jamie @ 294 Spot On

To Everybody, I'm suggesting watching
http://www.followtonians.com/?p=10020
Again or for the first time

Paul Smith
141 Posted 08/01/2014 at 23:17:52
Well would you 'Adam an Eve' it? — a positive buzz around Goodison Park and it's not because the RS have just lost.

The feel good factor Señor Martinez has instilled in the team has permeated through to the fans and if we're not careful the tabloids are gonna get hold of it and start writing complementary and sensible things about us.

As for the "people's club" tag, I thought it was a clever move by OFM at the time – 'a rallying cry to a weary bunch of fans' if you like – and it served to galvanise, but has run its course.

I'm too young to remember the Holy Trinity or the original SoS, but remember the 80s only too well. Exciting times! Can't wait for the match on Saturday.

Jamie Crowley
143 Posted 09/01/2014 at 05:45:55
I don't think there is one disingenuous fiber in this man's genetic make-up.

And that is why I love the guy.

Jim Lloyd
144 Posted 09/01/2014 at 08:14:01
James, Paul, Jamie.Spot on!
Ben Mackenzie
145 Posted 09/01/2014 at 09:04:25
There's also a great video on the os. An interview with Alan Myers called The Tea Party. RM just oozes class. Love the bit where he explains his reasons for putting pictures of our past successes on the wall up the stairs at Finch Farm, leaving the last position blank.

You just can't help but love this man. I think Whelan was right when he told us RM would take us to places that we've (recently) only dreamed of.

Jason Lam
146 Posted 09/01/2014 at 09:57:12
Just want to say a big thank you to all those involved in making the interview happen. We are very, very fortunate and privileged to have Roberto at the helm, even though as they say no one person is bigger than the club.

I don't see Roberto as putting a positive spin on things, for example the Sunderland loss, we completely dominated the 2nd half and had what 15 shots on target?

That was a loss that I didn't feel at all disheartened but even enjoyed as a football game in itself and immensely proud how we reacted in a positive manner i.e. no hoofball, desperation, no ideas, kicking players, getting yellow/red cards out of frustration etc. All that tiki taka is not fannying around but creating chances. COYB!

Sam Morrison
147 Posted 09/01/2014 at 11:57:55
Finally listened to it; as impressed as everyone else. As I said above and others have alluded to here and in the interview itself, it's not necessarily about where we finish but the style of play, the approach, the atmosphere - The Pride.

@Ross Kerry I can't agree that RM was being duplicitous regarding South American footballers - he's saying "Yes" as he's waiting for the question to finish, then the question itself is about managing rather than transfer-dealing, so it would be fairly nit-picky to go back and correct everything at that stage.

Eugene Ruane
148 Posted 09/01/2014 at 13:57:37
"I'm a dreamer"

Me to.

Up the Toffees!

Timothy Blanshard
149 Posted 09/01/2014 at 16:46:41
Geof 014,

Ditto mate I am so on the same page as you, I have experienced lots of highs and lows with our team but I can just feel that the good times are on their way back, I believe in RM.

Phil Bellis
150 Posted 09/01/2014 at 17:01:48
With you and Roberto all the way, Eugene
You know I've always been a dreamer
(spent my life running 'round); and it's so hard to change
John Crawley
151 Posted 09/01/2014 at 20:05:52
Graham 283 - great point about Martinez and man management skills with Ossie.

I thought the whole interview was excellent. I also thought that the questions and points made by the various fans were intelligent and interesting. Nice to hear about Roberto's football philosophy and interesting to hear him talk about the influence of Johan Cruyff. The players have obviously responded very well to him and the point he made about the goal conceded in the Austria friendly and the way the players responded was extremely insightful.

Hats off to Roberto but also to Alan Myers because I think he has introduced a new level of openness with the communications department at the club and we are reaping the rewards of that now. The Tea Party was another example of that and its great that not only does he appear to be doing an excellent job but he's also a blue!

Anthony Lamb
152 Posted 09/01/2014 at 20:29:44
I began listening to the interview very late last night and can only say a very sincere thank-you to Mr Martinez and to those who conducted the interview. What an inspiration it was to hear this man speak in such an engaging, informative and respectful manner. As a supporter for almost 60 years, like perhaps many of my generation, I have been in almost despair of late at the lack if integrity both on and off the pitch which characterises so much of the modern game.

This interview was inspirational. It has helped restore some hope and optimism not only as regards the quality of football being attempted by the manager at Everton but someone who stands for, and is committed to, what is best about the game. A simple test I have is, if I had a grandson with ability to whom would I entrust him? Mr Martinez would be at the very top of the list - in fact in the higher orders of the game he would be the only one!
His coverage of training and tactical approaches; about the needs for new structures to develop particular age-related player development; his thoughts on such ludicrous FIFA imposed regulations such as the mandatory sending off of goalkeepers and the issues of diving; his perspectives on individual players and his personal approaches to solving problems/difficulties etc were a joy to listen to.

In listening to this very impressive man and football manager perhaps we could spare a thought for the poor fellow fans of clubs such as West Ham who have to endure the insult of such characters as the ludicrous "Big Sam" in order to reinforce how fortunate we are to have Mr Martinez at the helm. Perhaps he will not bring "instant" success back to the club but he has certainly brought back a genuine desire to watch Everton not only out of life-long loyalty but because the football could once again be a genuine joy to actually want to watch.

What we need is to find his philosophy and genuine professionalism permeating all the elements of the club which at present, in some instances are seriously amiss e.g Club shop, merchandise availability, match day facilities etc. Let us hope that the Board realise what a jewel they have unearthed and ensure they respond adequately, particularly of course regarding team matters. How telling it was, however, to hear him say that money, while important, is not the sole arbiter of "success"

One final point - Ross' earlier point about the Wigan players seems to suggest that Mr Martinez was not telling the truth in some way regarding the signing of certain players. None of us know him that well but a question for Ross could be that in the light of what we do know would you think it in his character to deliberately seek to take credit for something that was not his due? I may be wrong but it could be that the question put to him mentioned "When you were at Wigan you....." which could mean that the first "you" refers to the person (Mr Martinez) while the second "you" inserts Mr Martinez into the collective "you" which is Wigan as a whole - if you catch my drift!
However, let us wish Mr Martinez every possible success, support him and appreciate him in the process.

Ian Bennett
153 Posted 09/01/2014 at 21:47:19
I was hugely sceptical when we hired him I have to admit. Probably like many, I hadn't appreciated his achievements at Swansea, nor really paid huge attention to his Wigan outfit under represented by the media.

Really interesting him talking about the Juventus friendly, and how quickly the senior players adapted.

Great listening, well done to those involved. Some star struck souls involved, although I think I am in love myself. Up the blues.

Dennis Ng
154 Posted 09/01/2014 at 21:59:07

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb