Coleman snatches victory with stoppage-time strike

, 15 March, 134comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 2 - 1 Cardiff City

Everton snatched a win in dramatic fashion thanks to Seamus Coleman's stoppage-time goal, just when the heroics of Cardiff's David Marshall looked like they had earned the Bluebirds a point.

The two sides went into the half-time break goalless thanks almost entirely to Marshall in the visitors' goal who made three outstanding saves to deny the Blues in the first period.

The 'keeper set the tone for his first-half exploits with an early save to deny Kevin Mirallas, palming away the Belgian's attempt to bend the ball inside the far post as Everton started brightly.

Then, after a series of wayward shots from distance and some inviting crosses that didn't find their mark by the home side, Juan Cala's sliding block prevented what might have been a certain goal for Mirallas after excellent work by Seamus Coleman and a neat layoff by Romelu Lukaku.

At the other end, with Cardiff occasionally threatening on the counter, Tim Howard had to be alert to save with his foot from Fraser Campbell as the former Manchester United striker capitalised on a fortunate bounce.

The Blues remained the more likely to break the deadlock, though, and another fine move created a great chance for Gerard Deulofeu but Marshall got a hand to his shot to guide it behind.

And the 'keeper saved his best moment of the first 45 minutes with an acrobatic one-handed save to push Lukaku's superb shot over the crossbar at the end of another quick break by the home side.

Both sides had chances within three minutes of the restart, Juan Cala again on hand to block Lukaku at the near post and Howard making a one-handed save by his own upright to put Campbell's low shot behind.

The game had stagnated from the home side's point of view in the second period but Gerard Deulofeu squeezed a deflected shot home just before the hour mark to break the deadlock.

Poor defending at a free kick, though, 10 minutes later allowed Cardiff back into it. Seamus Coleman was adjudged to have fouled Campbell outside the Blues' box and Juan Cala bundled home Peter Whittingham's set piece.

With Roberto Martinez having withdrawn both Deulofeu and Mirallas for Aiden McGeady and Steven Naismith, the Blues had lost their impetus a little and they laboured as the half progressed, finding Cardiff increasingly difficult to break down.

Osman almost restored the lead immediately but flashed a half-volley wide and Marshall was on hand in the 79th minute with another stunning save, finger-tipping Lukaku's deflected shot around the post.

Cardiff were growing in belief and an error by John Stones almost let Zaha in but the young defender recovered to block the winger's shot and another strong display by Sylvain Distin kept the visitors at bay on the counter-attack.

The game was ebbing away towards an unsatisfactory draw in stoppage time when Everton grabbed what could prove to be a priceless winner, though. Constant pressure in the closing minutes had Cardiff penned into their area and the Welsh side's defence coped with everything until a deep McGeady cross was headed back by Gareth Barry and Coleman sliced a half-volley that arced into net and sent Goodison into bedlam with 93 minutes on the clock.

A vital victory for Everton that looked like it had eluded them thanks to Marshall's heroics but persistence and a slice of luck paid off in the end.

Full coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (134)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kevin Rowlands
2 Posted 15/03/2014 at 16:59:20
Sometimes you need luck and that goal was that but then again we have had more than one fluke scored against us this season. Plus points, McCarthy (again), Stones, Coleman, Barry and definitely McGeady (he needs to now play more). Minus points, Mirallas (overated), Lukaku (overated) Del Boy (definitely overated), also if Cardiff get relegated our very first move should be to sign their keeper up.
Steve Cotton
3 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:07:32
Kevin Rowlands exactly right on every point.
Linda Morrison
4 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:06:32
Kevin couldn't agree more. Also there are lots of good players, especially strikers, in the EPL and Championship so I don't see why the scouts can't get us another Cahill etc

Good win let's hope the RS do us a favour tomorrow

Bill Gall
5 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:10:19
Sorry Mr Martinez but regardless to the score Osman should be replaced between the 45-60mins.
Patrick Murphy
6 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:08:35
Del Boy is a complete waste of space - I know he scored but come on he his a headless chicken. As for the game well if we could have been any more laid back we'd have been horizontal. Roberto really has to get into one or two players to demand a greater sense of urgency in these type of games. It looked a draw all day when they equalised. Coleman's game has gone completely off the boil - hopefully the goal will boost his confidence. Next week against Swansea I think Barry should be on the bench and Barks played instead. Osman had little luck today but the number of times he got caught in possession was unreal.

We'll have to play a damn sight better than today if we are to get that European place.

Anto Byrne
7 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:06:01
I thought Andy Gray summed it up perfectly. "Most Fortunate"
Peter Foy
8 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:17:06
I wouldn't say Del was a complete waste of space, Patrick. He's a young lad with immense talent. Didn't have his best game today but the goal was class.
Patrick Murphy
9 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:20:59
Peter - I'm sorry I just can't see anything in the lad apart from his pace and I also don't think he has the correct mindset for the Premier League - I hope when he does get picked he proves me wrong - but I don't expect him to.

Two draws tomorrow will be a decent outcome as it will mean all four teams dropping points.
Yair Kaye
10 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:16:15
Linda - I don't want any favours from the RS tomorrow . I hate them and I wish they lose in OT . Nothing will give more pleasure ( and I have nothing against the Mancs - they are City's problem - though not this year ) .
Kevin Rowlands
11 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:19:34
I agree about Del Boy Pat, if anyone thinks this lad is ready for the Barcelona 1st team then I've got a bridge to sell them in San Francisco, as for Lukaku I think we can now all see why Mourinho sent him out on loan, absolutely no way in hell should we be considering spending big money on him. Also someone like Distin should have a word in Mirallas ear an tell him he's not quite as good as he seems to think he is, I wouldn't be the slightest bothered if all three were not at Goodison next season.
Mike Powell
12 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:19:55
Another terrible display against one off the worst teams in the Prem. I'd love to get back in Europe but I think we would get embarrassed, we need a clear-out for next season and at least six players in but, with Martinez's track record in the transfer market, I worry for us.

Kone, Alcaraz,Traore, Del boy – waste of space... Barry will be off to the Arse... Osman, Naismith, Pienaar not good enough. I don't think I can watch much more off this crap this season.

Tahir Abdullah
13 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:26:51
Our defence today, looked more secure with Howard as the last man standing. Baines had a below par match; without Pienaar he looks flat. Nevertheless a win's a win and well done to our blue boys for chasing the winner until the near-death. NSNO!
Martha Richardson
14 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:14:30
Not sure if we’re running out of steam, or some players are a little too comfortable in their roles and their place in the team, but we were a little lethargic at times today.

I knew that we would miss Bryan, and we do miss his pace, endeavour and enthusiasm, but I can’t help thinking that if some of the other players had stepped up then perhaps his absence would not be quite so apparent. Very relieved that we won though, I think we deserve a little bit of luck.

Good luck Bryan hope it all works our for you this summer and for us with you in the team next season.

Wayne Smyth
15 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:30:25
So apart from his pace, his goals, the number of chances he creates by putting balls into dangerous areas, yes I'd agree Deulofeu is a waste of space.

Certainly no-where near good enough for Barca's first team, but very much good enough for ours. Definitely needs to improve on his decision making in terms of when to take someone on and when to pass, but that will come with experience.

Could work harder, but then the same can be said for most players of his ilk and some others in our team.

Why is it that if a player is not a world-beater or making all the right decisions, he's somehow branded a complete waste of space, useless, shite?

Judging by the fans reaction when he was subbed, most match goers actually think he's quite good.

As for McGeady, quite impressed with what I've seen from him. Another one branded a fat, useless good-for-nothing by some on here and as he approaches full fitness and sharpness I think he looks probably our best wide player.

I thought we got a bit lucky today. Subbing Mirallas and Deulofeu and bringing Naismith on, almost cost us. It weakened us, gave Cardiff a bit of lift and limited how well we could respond when Cardiff equalised. One goal is never enough and I thought the subs were premature. Perhaps Barkley for Osman I could've understood as Osman was tiring.

Jamie Barlow
16 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:35:25
We seriously need to work on our dead balls. It's a complete waste of time to carry on doing what we are doing. I know Martinez has said he doesn't really like scoring from free kicks and corners ( or words to that effect ) but the amount of crosses we are wasting is unbelievable.

I don't think we showed enough urgency today. It's a shame we didn't play the whole game like we did the last 10 minutes. We would have murdered them. In saying that, if their goalie had had an off day, we would have.

Only 2 behind Spurs with a game in hand. Two draws for me tomorrow and I'll be a happy bunny.

Deulofeu is young and raw and exciting but he does wind me up. I hope he stays another year. He's probably the only one that gets the pulse racing at the moment.

James Byrne
17 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:38:56
Their goalkeeper was outstanding today.

I don't agree on the analysis of Delboy; I don't think we've seen enough of him yet and I believe he is a potential match winner, a player who can work a bit of magic when you need it - the disjointed player is Mirallas. I also think Osman should be benched for Barkley.

Full credit to the Cardiff City fans for bringing down a huge crowd today; we were sitting right next to them in the PE and they looked mental!

Chris Jones [Burton]
18 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:49:10
Laughable report on the BBC. I wonder if the journo is a red?!

"By Alistair Magowan BBC Sport

Cardiff were cruelly denied a point by Seamus Coleman's injury-time winner as the Bluebirds slipped further behind in their bid for Premier League survival.

Goalkeeper David Marshall looked to have earned a draw with a string of saves after Juan Cala had equalised Gerard Deulofeu's deflected effort.
But, after another stop to deny Romelu Lukaku's shot, Marshall was beaten by Coleman's miscue.

Cardiff fell to 19th and are now three points from safety."

Their keeper made some superb saves. Our goals involved a deflection (from a great individual effort) and a miscued shot (after a good move). Their goal, described as an 'equaliser', came from a dubious free kick, courtesy of a scruffy miscue off the Cardiff player's thigh and hand!

The tale of the tape shows we deserved the win. 19 shots to 10, 6 on target compared to 3. 10 corners to 5. 68% possession to 32%. I bookings vs. 3, Théophile-Catherine was lucky not to get a red in the first half!

Ah well, LFC supporter or not Mr Magowan, all three points are ours.

Kevin Rowlands
19 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:41:35
Wayne, he's scored two/three goals all season? todays goal was a deflection, if he hadn't scored when he did nobody would have been questioning the subs. As for Mirallas, he contributed sweet FA today so how we were supposedly weakened by taking him off is beyond me, the lad comes across as a legend in his own mind. For me when McGeady came on we looked a lot more dangerous, he now looks match fit, he made much better decisions than Del Boy when he had possession and should start ahead of them two, as for Lukaku, Chelsea can take him back.
Brian Denton
20 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:48:44
Just back. Well, a win's a win but it was hardly glittering. I thought Seamus's shot was going to join me in the Upper Gwladys, and I was amazed when the ball ended up in the net. Lukaku very disappointing, but in fairness their goalkeeper made four outstanding saves.

I think, on balance, I want Man United to win tomorrow. I did originally think a draw would be best for us (to want an RS win is unthinkable, whatever the circumstances) but even a point for Liverpool is too much. They must not get anywhere near that title.

Keith Glazzard
21 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:43:51
Deulofeu, you may have noticed, cut in from the left to get his chance on goal. Coleman didn't have to get past two or three men to get his chance. So, the opposition weren't set-up to defend what they knew would be thrown at them, and hey presto. Roberto needs to get more variation into what we do.

Clarence Yurcan
22 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:53:16
Linda, let's hope Man Utd do us a favor, you mean, I'm not giving up on 4th yet!
Paul Mackie
23 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:53:31
I thought RM cocked up the subs today but we got away with it. About time that we beat someone with a spawny injury time goal rather than the other way round!
Ben Dyke
24 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:47:58
It feels much better to be 3 points ahead of united, 2 behind spurs in 5th with game in hand and with a favourable fixture list. The season isn't over yet, but it would be nice to achieve a clear victory in a game and come out easy winners for once!
Paul David
25 Posted 15/03/2014 at 17:50:28
We have far to many players under performing or just playing to an acceptable level, we've hardly had any players in great form over an extended period this season.

We are still too slow and predictable and its getting a bit boring now. The tempo needs to be a lot higher and we need to take more risks, everything goes wide (the safe option), we never attack through the middle.

Paul Thompson
26 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:01:44
Del hadn't played well, though taking him off just after scoring was odd. He at least has the excuse of not playing much, whereas Mirallas was his usual erratic, frustrating self. McGeady should be given a run from the start. He's smarter, can beat a man and then get a decent cross in.
Phil Walling
27 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:14:44
I’m just glad that all our loan players are just that - loan players - although we might struggle to replace them if all are unavailable to us next season. Just wish that Robles,Alcarez and Kone were on that arrangement too!

On the evidence so far, I suspect BK will want more of the same having seen some of the duffers he’s brought in for good money!

Karl Parsons
28 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:12:45
We need to rebuild the confidence that we've have had kicked out of us of late, so I'll take today's performance and result. Get off Del's back you gang of beauts, he's a kid learning has craft FFS. No one said he was the finished article.
Phil Walling
29 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:20:15
PS. Was Delboy’s substitution a punishment for sticking the ball in the net rather than ’risking’ a square pass?
Patrick Murphy
30 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:18:41
Wayne obviously Del Boy doesn't have to be a world beater to be in the Everton side. Del Boy is a very very ordinary push and run type of player who has shown very few glimpses of being a star for Everton. It's one thing doing wonderful things in Barca's second string but quite another attempting them in the cut and thrust of the Premier League. I personally wouldn't want him back next season because as is the case with Mirallas he isn't a team player.
Patrick Murphy
31 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:24:48
BTW Wayne that last post of mine was from a match going supporter of many years.
Paul Smith
32 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:23:31
I must be living in a parallel universe were Delboy was one of our most dangerous players going forward and scored a goal.

He looked more dangerous than Lukaku & Kev and was pissed when getting pulled.

Cardiff are fighting for their life on the back of a win last week and had a brilliant keeper between the sticks.

Well done blues not a classic performance but far from a bad one either.

Rich Williams
33 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:43:51
I think RM should start to consider the 3-5-2 he employed at Wigan, particularly when we are at home. We just don't get enough volume centrally up front. When Jags is back I would like to see:

TH
JS PJ SD
SC GB JM LB
RB
KM RL

Subbing in AM, SP, LO, SN as we see fit.

Jim Bennings
34 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:38:31
Jesus tonight that was hard work.

We were shit awful in that first half and thank God for the substitution of McGeady and Coleman's shank..Luck of the Irish or what??

Lukaku was bright all game I thought, unlucky in the first half with that great effort on the charge.

Miralllas??? I am struggling to stay patient with this fella, I am sorry but he has been bloody awful lately..Such a frustrating player if ever I saw one, fast becoming the new McFadden for me. Some wonder goals but in the main too many 'For Fucks Sake' moments with him.

As soon as McGeady came on we saw what a PROPER winger is supposed to do, go past your man and whip in some delightful crosses which eventually won the game.

I am going to forgive Roberto today for his 'David Moyes' moment in playing Leon Osman on the left..Roberto ARRRRRRGHHH DONT DO IT TO US.

I thought we were over that once Moyes left.. Nothing against Osman but even when he was 7 years younger he has NEVER been a wide midfielder so please when McGeady is on the bench don't use that square peg in a round hole again.

Scrappy game, nothing that I did not expect though, great crowd including Cardiff's support and anyway three points in the start of what I call our winnable end to the month of March.

Timothy Blanshard
35 Posted 15/03/2014 at 18:46:48
Agreed Paul, and as has already been stated he is still learning, but he put the shits up Cardiff every time he was on the ball, I for one hope he stays another season with us.
Eric Myles
36 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:03:44
Jim#901, you tbought we were shit awful in the first half?

Did you watch the home game against Spurs?

And Osman had a great first half and a pretty good second besides a couple of times he ran into dead ends, about the same as Delefeou did.

Jim Bennings
37 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:15:54
Eric

I wish I could have a glass of whatever you have had tonight lad!

Osman a great first half??
Our left side of Baines and Osman never clicked all day, Baines was poor again I though and Osman was the square peg in the round hole that we always saw when Moyes selected him for wide berths.

Deulofeu was quite lively I do agree with that.

Phil Walling
38 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:13:47
Whilst I agree with Paul’s comments above regarding McGeady- in whom I was pleasantly surprised today - I recently read a critique of OFM which accused him of imposing AN OLD FASHIONED style on Manu which relied on constant crosses by wingers and effective set-pieces.

Like any other tactic performed properly they can both be most effective but being seen as ’last year’s’ approach to the game, I don’t think they figure highly in Roberto’s philosophy.

If only we could combine the best aspects of these two managers we might just have a good one!

Iain Johnston
39 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:05:21
I would of like to have seen Deulofeo stay on... I think he and McGeady switching flanks would have been well worth a look at.

As for the tempo of the game, I think we played too slow, we left it really late today before the players went up a gear...

Clearly RM has been on TW...! He started with an eleven many have been shouting for and I did notice more shots from outside the box.

But I'd have to agree, Osman and Mirallas for Barkley and McGeady were the subs for me, I thought Nais was a little lightweight for their defenders.

I know the Stones attempted headed backpass could have been a howler but he recovered well and he beginning to really settle in...

In past times this fixture would have had draw written all over it, so well in Blues, good three points...

Eric Myles
40 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:22:02
Jim, rewind your video of the game and you'll find some good 'Bainaar' link ups between Baines and Osman and Mirallas.
Gary Mortimer
41 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:35:26
A scruffy win, but their keeper kept them in it longer than was necessary.

The media still have it in for us though.

Graham "Red Shite Beaky" Beakcroft (Talkshite Radio) in the after match interview - What do you think about the nailed on penalty that Cardiff should have had?

BBC Muppet on Radio5 - Cardiff will pushing for the win when Everton scored a very lucky winner.

What game where they watching?

Kevin Rowlands
42 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:42:20
Phil, serious question, why do you keep bringing David Moyes into every thread and conversation? We just beat Cardiff 2-1, we are all discussing and debating the match and players performance and you have to, as per usual, bring OFM into it, Why? in a few weeks he will have been gone a full season, move on for god's sake.
Brent Stephens
43 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:30:58
Osman takes some unwarranted flack at times on TW and I always defend him when I think he's played ok / well. But today, to also be fair, he stank. Could hardly do a thing right.

Paul Smith #899 "I must be living in a parallel universe where Delboy was one of our most dangerous players going forward and scored a goal." Paul, I and others around me today at GP, were saying we thought he was our main goal threat today and hey-ho he gets the first goal. Mirallas stank, I thought, so greedy, and deserved being taken off; but Delboy's substitution I agreed with less. And Barks should have been on before 70 mins not 80. So, for me, Roberto again today had some strange sub decisions. But Aiden did look good coming on.

We still have all 11 back at corners! With Delboy's pace, he should be held upfield, keeping a couple of their defenders occupied.

And still oh so many fluffed crosses and corners.

Still, 3 points. And lots of passing.

Jimmy Hill
44 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:50:33
I can't believe the rubbish on here about the young players all three pulled brilliant saves from the keeper . Anyone who does not see thinks that Deloufeo is overrated needs to go watch netball. Suggest you watch the game again and the 1st half particularly almost score , great save by the keeper. This boy is going to be a super star. Lukaku will be another he's we need to get him running more at the defence. He learning to play with his back to the goal.
Never understand why Osman is slated on here played well today. Mirallis is the only one I would have concern. He seems to playing for himself.

We won and deserved to even though we almost end cheated out of it again.

Andy Crooks
45 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:59:55
Did anyone listen to Alan Green on final score. He no longer makes even the slightest effort to disguise his loathing of Everton. The Liverpool bias on tv is appalling.

Colin Metcalfe
47 Posted 15/03/2014 at 19:33:51
Well guys, what can I say, I am working away at the moment and yes I turned my link off with 5 mins to go, said fuck several times and went for a jog so you can imagine my surprise when I got back we had nicked it - so apologies all round for my lack of faith !!

However..., okay, 3 pts is 3pts but Jesus again we look so toothless and pedestrian! It's quite clear RM is not suddenly going change the style of play (I agree with many of the comments about dead ball situations especially CORNERS!!) but he must realize its pretty easy to defend against.

I think we are going in the right direction we limited resources, if only we could speed up our play – I was furious with the substitutions , made no sense to me because as we all know defenders don't like being attacked at pace and that's what Delboy does, he has got a lot to learn but personally I would love to see here for another season – he reminds me a bit of Sterling of the RS but his decision making has got to improve.

For anyone who has seen my posts in past you will know I am not a big fan of Lukaku and I for one would not be bothered if he goes back to Chelsea, I would prefer a smaller player with pace making clever runs and a good first touch ! Because I am sure Lukaku wears rubber boots!!

The positive thing is once again we dominated possession, our problems lie in the final third and I think it's solvable ( as long as BK opens his purse strings), I think if we can get that sorted we are going to be fucking awesome!

Okay, well that's my 2 cents worth, lets just hope for 0-0 tomorrow !

ps – What's with the RS writing on our live feed? Wankers!

Geoff Evans
48 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:06:06
Nice to hear McGeady getting positive comments for the first time since he arrived. Good business by RM he's going to be a top buy.
Patrick Murphy
49 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:08:41
Jimmy - can you please tell me where my guide dog has gone - I am one of the people that thinks Del Boy is vastly over-rated and that he makes Peter Beagrie look like Maradonna. I'm glad that Ossie had a good game coz god knows what a bad game would look like. I am by no means an Ossie basher but he lost the ball so many times today it was getting ridiculous.

I want every player in a blue shirt to excel but I think it is only fair to point out when a player is not playing to their full potential or when they have reached their sell by date.

Paul Smith
50 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:14:23
Brent @(912) I hope you got the theme of my post (sarcasm) the lowest form of.....I know.

Anyway, it was meant mainly for the previous posters, who were giving Delboy a hard time for today's performance.

I concur with you and those around you at the match today. The young Spaniard was indeed our biggest goal threat.

Peter Mills
51 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:09:04
Gary #910, I thought Cardiff should have had a penalty.
Brent Stephens
52 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:20:38
Paul, yes, I saw where you were coming from (whatever the name of that universe was!) and was agreeing with you.
Jim Bennings
53 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:13:57
Astonishing that as soon as we started showing more urgency in the last 10 minutes of the game and actually putting in quick crosses that we scored the goal.

Everton are a better team when they play at a tempo.
We are about quick football and getting the ball in the box, I don't mean alehouse balls but good quality crosses that McGeady was sending over in that last 10 mins.

Thats is what we need to see more of, not all this Baines to Mirallas, then to Osman, back to Baines back to Stones to Distin blah blah.

Get early crosses into that box, Lukaku wants those types of crosses and we need to make defences work harder.
We did that in the last 10 minutes and we got the slice of luck we deserved because of it.

Eric, I have nothing against Osman, but if he is going to play then its down the middle where Barkley plays or nowhere for me.
He is not and never has been a wide player in 10 years of watching him.

It was a very strange decision by Roberto when he had been talking up McGeady all week, and perhaps even more so when we saw what the Irishman could do when he did come on..But we won so lets just hope lessons learned for future reference.

Brent Stephens
54 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:31:54
Jim #922 "Everton are a better team when they play at a tempo.
We are about quick football and getting the ball in the box, I don't mean alehouse balls but good quality crosses that McGeady was sending over in that last 10 mins."

Absolutely! Our number one failing. That, and not shooting enough when the opportunity arises just outside / inside the box but trying to walk it in.

Kevin Rowlands
57 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:28:53
I think the problem some of us have with Lukaku and Del Boy is how both of them have bigged themselves up in the press, one saying he's looking forward to playing for Barcelona next season and the other telling everyone he needs champions league football. Reality is their on field performances for Everton this season have been nowhere near good or consistent enough to earn them what they feel they should be doing next season. Don't get me wrong, both are huge prospects and good, potentially great players, but both need to show more on the field before gobbing off in the press.
Paul Smith
58 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:36:38
Cool, Brent. Only usually when somebody copies & pastes a post, it's normally to counter it.

Nice to have some agreement for once.

Anthony Washington
59 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:37:05
I only watched the first half on a live link but Everton should of had a penalty when GD was brought down, but no mention of it by our friends in the media.
Damian Braithwaite
60 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:12:06
I'm just weighing up the comment about Roberto not wanting to score from corners because we can lose possession. Surely he must have been misquoted or his words were lost in translation because I believe the amount of draws we have had this year could have easily be turned into wins if changed his policy. I hope he has seen this and this is why he got the big lad Traore from Monaco and he has changed his policy for the better. I can only remember Lukakus goal against the shite as the only goal we've scored from a corner all year.
Today all the corners never beat the guy on the near post and we had quite a few so it's frustrating as it could mean the difference of our squad actually lifting some silverware.
Mike Hughes
61 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:34:45
Linda Morrison #867 - WHAAAT? I nearly choked on my chips when I read your post.

I'm 100% Evertonian but I want Man Utd to absolutely stuff the rs tomorrow - especially after the Chelski result.

My only prediction tomorrow is that WR will get sent off. Odds on.

Back to the Mighty Blues - we made hard work of things today. It's that time of the season when I could actually care less how other teams get on. I hope The Arse win tomorrow as well.


Jimmy Hill
62 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:40:25
Brent #926

What game were you watching mate. Today we were shooting from every where, not great quality I admit. Mirallis would have tried 5or 6.

Kevin's I think Deloefeo was misquoted I don't know why you are harping on about them. They are to talented young lads learning the game.

Must have been a bad feed you guys were.

Peter Mills I thought Del Boy should have had a pen didn't go down rolling enough.

Patrick Murphy
63 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:49:39
Mike - totally agree mate especially when Brenda warns Man U that missing out on CL could see them fail to attract top players. WTF does Brenda know about CL I hope Moyes' wins tomorrow but I won't hold my breath.
Mike Hughes
64 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:51:46
Patrick - to be honest, I'd be happy with a draw tomorrow, just to stall their momentum. Mind you, I'd be even happier if the rs season completely derailed (and let's throw a couple of key season-ending injuries in as well for good measure.) Surely even DM can get the Mancs up for this one? Chainsaw to a gunfight, perhaps?

Kevin Rowlands
65 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:51:47
Jimmy, I've been hearing for most of the season that the lad is supposed to be the next big star in Spanish football, you may have seen that but I haven't, him, Barkley and Lukaku are far from the finished product. He's at best inconsistent, loses the ball far to much, makes some awful decisions and without stating the obvious is nowhere near good enough for Barcelona right now, maybe that will change as he matures.
Jimmy Hill
66 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:51:24
Patrick

It all about opinions friend. I do struggle with the way sometimes it appears no matter what a player does he gets slagged by some people.

Mate, I wonder sometimes what people expectations actually I've watched Everton for very long time now, this season has been one of the more enjoyable for sometime.

I have feeling that next year we will see a much better team. For me today we were the best team by miles and deserved to win, some great efforts on goal but we win by a deflection and a mishit.Both after some great football BTW, after some of the in justices we suffered this year Ill take it and the3points.

I have say also that it will be Liverpool for once that can do us a favour by beating the Manure. We won't catch RS so I want a bigger gap between us the Mutd. Then we can go after the spuds and Arse. Realistically the others are out of reach.

Jimmy Hill
67 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:05:09
Kevin
Yes of course you are going get that with young players. If you could get some footage of Ronaldo's early games at Mutd I think you would see something similar.
It's the frustrations you get while they learn. The thing that frustrates me more is that we living with that's for the benefit of other teams. Having said that I'd rather have them than not.

I'd urge you have another look at him in today's game, he was dangerous. I wasn't surprised though when he was subbed the game need some creativity and we got that.

Raymond Fox
68 Posted 15/03/2014 at 20:48:27
Come on chaps give the team a break, their in 6th place, 3pts in front of Utd!
Were work in progress, of course we are, RM has only been in charge months.

I do agree that we need to make more of corners and long dead ball situations, seems daft not to, although you can leave yourself wide open to the quick break!
I do think on balance though we should try harder to score from corners.

How many of our players will get in a 'top 4 side' not too many I would suggest, were doing ok nevertheless.

Wouldn't it be great if RM could afford to go out and buy a top class ball playing midfielder along with a couple of £20m forwards.

There lies the only reason why we wont break into the CL places any time soon.

Brent Stephens
69 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:21:15
Jimmy #934 "What game were you watching mate. Must have been a bad feed you guys were."

I had the best feed, Jimmy - I was at the match.

Brin Williams
70 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:18:30
Kevin Rowlands 874, I've not read down any further than your post – no need to really 'nuff said – but I agree with you entirely on all points.

Not good enough – all three!!

Jimmy Hill
72 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:29:28
Brent Stephens lucky you. Then you must have seen the goal keeper make a number of class saves that kept Cardiff in the game. May you have a restricted view .
Wayne Smyth
73 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:26:29
Kevin, Deulofeu may have only scored 2 or 3 goals all season but how many starts has he had? How many minutes on the pitch? He's still coming back from a long lay off having been patient to earn a starting berth, don't forget.

The quality of the goals he's scored to single handedly get us a point at the Emirates and today to break down a really stubborn Cardiff side with a keeper playing a blinder also deserves special praise. He looks really dangerous when he gets the ball in the centre of the pitch because he can go either way with pace....a defenders nightmare.

How many dangerous balls does he play into the middle with NO-ONE on the end of them?

Its also unfair to criticise his performances, because he says he wants to break into barca's first team. His performances on the pitch are what matter 100%. If I recall rightly the question to Deulofeu was from the spanish press and something like "do you want to play for barca next season". He's still a barca player, of course he wants to play for them.

He's certainly not the complete player or a quality player, but like Barkley, he's going to be in a few years. Hopefully we can retain him for next season, and perhaps longer. I'm not entirely sure he'll end up being quite good enough for Barca and with Roberto's spanish influence he could end up transferring here permanently.

Brent Stephens
74 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:35:03
No restricted view, Jimmy (unless "may you have a restricted view" is your wish for me!

Yes, of course I saw those shots, and today, as I said to the guy sat next to me, we were shooting more than we normally do. But still wasting opportunities to do so.

Nigel Gregson
76 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:29:28
@RaymondFox - exactly !!!

This our second best points haul after 28 games in the last 20 years !! I'm not quite sure why people are not elated with this ? I suppose the OFM (as much as I don't want to bring him into this conversation) was better at expectation management of the fans. Last time we had 51 points or more after 28 games was in 2008 when we finished 5th. Before that was in 2005 when we finished 4th. The time now is to get behind the team and push them to the finish line.

BTW our best ever points tally ever in the premier league era is 65 points. We need to get 14/30 to equal that.

Brent Stephens
77 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:39:13
Wayne, a very fair view, mate.
Steven Telford
78 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:36:59
We run well at goal and take decent shots, but a big issue to be a addressed is why crosses and corners seem to deliver so little.

Wasted opportunities, are one of the big stories of our season.

Colin Grierson
79 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:29:37
Two things!

1) It is NEVER a favour if the RS win a game! I support two teams, Everton and whoever the shite are playing.

2) The only thing I took from today's game was the name on the back of their keeper's back. Buy him RM he is top notch!

Jimmy Hill
80 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:34:19
Brin it doesn't take a brain surgeon to realise that Deleufeo and Lukaku aren't good enough at the moment for Barcelona and Chelsea, strangely that's probably the reason why they are both on loan to Everton.

The question everyone who is having a go at them on here is would we be better with out them. Ask yourself how many games did we win without Lukaku when he was injured. Then take away his goals see where we are then.
There is more to being a front man than just scoring goals.

I for one hope both of them are back next year.

Jimmy Hill
81 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:47:22
Colin so you would rather finished 7th. Well I suppose then a lot people could say told you so.
Graham Mockford
83 Posted 15/03/2014 at 22:04:23
We were garbage today, but fair play we ground out a result.

The big plus point for me was McGeady, every time he got the ball he looked dangerous. He's undoubtedly put some hard work in, looks in much better shape. Could be a really good buy.

Tony Byrne
84 Posted 15/03/2014 at 21:58:50
If Delboy had started as many games as Mirallas this season then I would also be questioning his ability/contribution to the team but he clearly hasn't!! It's only my humble opinion but Mirallas is so overrated & I hope somebody comes in for him in the summer. Get shut — he's shite for me.
Peter Mills
85 Posted 15/03/2014 at 22:04:51
We've won our last 7 games at Goodison, 9 out of 10 since the derby.
Richard Harris
86 Posted 15/03/2014 at 22:17:23
Good in the first half, poor in the second half against a relegation threatened Cardiff who played some good football. Slow in the build up when we needed a winner, terrible defending for their equalizer but at least some luck with our goals and last gasp elation.

Certainly uplifted my mood for the journey home. Cardiff were unlucky today, if Zaha hadn't gone down so easily Cardiff could have had a penalty but I'll take a ground out result over fine play (Martinez statement vs Spurs and Chelsea) and a loss :0)

Brian Denton
87 Posted 15/03/2014 at 22:20:20
958 Jimmy Hill, I couldn't follow all of your post, but if the question is "Would I want us to lose if it stopped them winning the League" I think the answer is probably.......probably.
Jimmy Hill
88 Posted 15/03/2014 at 22:19:46
Brent #948 agree with your last comment. Decision-making in front of goal is poor, to make half chances in to sitters is the problem and is something we need to fix.

My own view is our support in to the box arrives to early and we end up with the box full of defenders. Probably a symptom of us changing to a passing game and too many passes. We need to learn to transition the ball much quicker. I'm sure RM will make that happen.

At least today we were having a few shots that we're causing the keeper a few problems.

Alex Carry
89 Posted 15/03/2014 at 23:25:57
I think that we really need a quality striker that is a real hazard for defenders. Maybe Wilfred Bony would be a good target for summer depending on the balance RM has...

If you think that most games we get off 15-20 shots with around 6-8 hitting the target, having someone who hits the target 90% of the time is much more beneficial than shoddy loan deals that never get real game time at all over the course of a season... in my opinion anyway.

If we did have a quality striker, I think we would definitely be 4th edging 3rd.

Jack Wilkinson
90 Posted 15/03/2014 at 23:12:16
Can't believe the bad reviews Deulofeu and Lukaku (especially) are getting on here. Fair enough the moaning at Mirallas, one of the most frustrating players I've seen in blue. He's clearly got the talent but he's like that half decent kid on your team who thinks he's better than everyone else and goes it all alone. He needs to have it drilled in that the best players know when to pass. Losing patience with him.

Remember that this is Deulofeu's first season in senior football. He's shown that he's got that spark where he can make things out of nothing. Like Mirallas he needs to learn to pass and when he should take on a player, but he's young. It's not like he's constantly putting us in trouble and in reality he works hard to win the ball back. I doubt the best academy in the world would rate him as their best prospect if he was "nothing special".

Lukaku is also young, 27 goals in two seasons by the age of 20 is not bad. We're all moaning about our football being slow and the prior players I've mentioned not providing enough for others. Sort that out and Lukaku will score. Remember it was the same with Jelavic and the same with Saha before him. Something needs to be sorted in out style of play.

John Malone
91 Posted 15/03/2014 at 23:42:01
Well done Tony Bomber Bellew looked a lot better at cruiserweight the power is back.
Kieran Riding
92 Posted 15/03/2014 at 23:47:48
John #975
Bang on.

Get him at Goodison for a summer fight night.

Old Lady would be bouncing for Bomber.

Eugene Kearney
93 Posted 16/03/2014 at 00:37:47
I'm jumping straight in here ( can't be bothered reading 90 comments) - thank God we have a goal-scoring right-back.

P.S. I have just had a night subtilely annoying French people about rugby ;-)

Gareth Fieldstead
94 Posted 16/03/2014 at 00:59:52
I thought for 70 minutes we played well. There goalkeeper kept them in it, end of. I thought his substitutions were strange but Aiden was superb, reminded me a little of Anders! Osman, sorry I just cannot understand the lads regular inclusion, he just consistently loses the ball. I like Naismith but he is not a wide player. Good win and fully deserved. As for results, I would love two draws tomorrow We stay in 6th and we have the chance to start clawing back points from those above us. We realistically need 7 more wins for CL but it can be done. We can realistically lose 2 to 3 games but we need to win those 7! Draws are no good!
Jamie Crowley
96 Posted 16/03/2014 at 01:56:41
All this season over crap...

If Man Utd beat Liverpool tomorrow and we win our game in hand, we are only 5 points adrift!

Are we playing well enough to get 4th? No. But if we keep squeaking results so be it - 4th is in play!

And this stick about Delo is nonsense. I don't think the boy is Ronaldo but he helps Everton to be sure. Little rough this criticism.

Patrick Murphy you are one of the TW gems - always enjoy your thought provoking posts. But lay off Delo. The kid is a good footballer and he took his goal well. That run after that nifty quick ball by Osman was great.

Put it simply - when he's on the ball I get excited. The kid makes things happen.

Jim Harrison
97 Posted 16/03/2014 at 02:48:22
Great over the top comments as normal. Del Boy stinks, Osman useless, shit performance bla bla bla. Osman had a decent game but tired. Del ran hot and cold but made the initial break through and should probably have stayed on. Kev needed to come off, not a stinker, but he will have finer performances.

Realistically,it was an average team performance. But an average performance that saw the team outperform their rivals in every way!! Stats can be manipulated, but they can also be a good indicator of what actually happened. Possession, shots, corners and shots on target figures virtually treble that of Cardiff's. In fact, their only real chance other than the goal was a fairly routine block with legs by Howard from Campbell. Their keeper had a blinder. Had one of those first half chances gone in it would have made a huge difference. They would have had to attack for longer, creating more gaps behind, and with the pace of Mirallas and Del I would have expected more goals.

The thing for me at the moment is that other teams are packing their 3rd of the pitch against us and looking to hit on the break. There wasnt one instance yesterday when Cardiff were high enough up for us to try and get around the back and use the pace of our wingers and striker. How many times this season have you seen Everton passing around the opponent's area ( And our own unfortunately!!) looking for a way in, where there are 8 or so defending players sitting in front of the goal?

I thought he game cried out for a central midfielder who could burst through the middle and upset their defenders. Osman is not that player (although I think he had a good game, in fact I think he should have started with Ross and Barry should have sat out), Barkley is yet to reach the heights of his pre injury form but can still carry the ball forwards and draw players to him. Pienaar is our only other midfielder that actually runs at players with the ball frequently with any real level of success.

Another point, I wonder whether the quality of our set plays has fallen away due to there being little emphasis on them? Baines is a great dead ball hitter, Mirallas too. But from my view, it seemed they had very little to aim at. Other team turn up at corners with what looks like well exercised drills and tactics. We seem to just have a load of players hanging around in their area. How many goals have we scored from corners this year?

Tony J Williams
98 Posted 16/03/2014 at 02:59:09
It seems that a lot of posters perception of Osman it's based on his final ten minutes where he was knackered. You could see he was spent and should have come off earlier. He had a great first half, him and Barry were really pushing the team forward.

What can you say about Del Boy, apart from it amazes me how a professional footballer, one from Barcelona no less, it's unable to judge how far ahead of himself to put the ball.

Mark Andersson
99 Posted 16/03/2014 at 03:31:57
Once again, I read all the posts above before making any of my own comments. I too was going to say Lukaku is a waste of space... but, then again, what do I know? A win is a win; yes, we would all love to see a comfortable win, with brilliant football being played; however, their keeper played a blinder in the first half.

What ever the result at the Theatre of Dreams, let's just hope we still win as many games as possible, but do it with a bit more style and conviction.

NEXT GAME, please!

Jimmy Hill
100 Posted 16/03/2014 at 05:19:58
Colin fair enough mate. Let's hope that situation doesn't come about. I hope Coleman keeps slicing them for the rest of the season. COYB
Matt Traynor
101 Posted 16/03/2014 at 05:03:41
Jamie #989, you're absolutely right, we're nowhere near playing well enough for fourth.

However, I would refer people to season 2004/05, when our 2nd half form for the season was absolutely dire. We crawled over the line for 4th place, only because the rest of the league didn't seem to want it! Of course that had to be spoiled by RS fluking their win in Istanbul (so yes, I would rather lose a game if it stopped them winning the league, as they would us as others have said).

Football is full of half-witted truisms like referees decisions evening themselves out over the course of a season (they don't) etc. but the only adage that seems to stand the test of time is you finish where you deserve to - and it's all relative to the other teams' performances in that regard.

Jay Richo
102 Posted 16/03/2014 at 08:01:34
The changes right after we got our goal completely baffled me. The shackles was about to come off an we would of got 1 or 2 more. The changes completely changed the dynamics of the team and we had to get going all over again.

Leaving Osman on so long was a strange one too when everyone could see he was running on one lung. I would’ve taken the scoreline before the game but drastic improvement needed if we want 5th! Have faith! COYB

Steve Brown
103 Posted 16/03/2014 at 08:09:26
Surprised by all the stick the younger players are getting on here. Deulofeu, Stones, Barkley, Lukaku are all learning that hardest thing of all - judgement on the pitch, when to make a run, when to play a pass. To make out that they lack talent is plain nonsense. Does anyone remember Ronaldo in his early Man U days? He was exactly like Gerard. I think it is great to see Martinez showing his faith in youth.

I'd also like to see McGeady start as a wide main with Deulofeu next game, with Miralles dropped. I'd also stick with Osman, but playing behind Lukaku and definitely playing no more than 65 mins. His performance is like a Pirelli F1 tyre, it falls off a cliff about two thirds of the way through!

Chris Henderson
104 Posted 16/03/2014 at 09:28:42
I have been reading this site for ages but never comment; I just like to hear the opinions from other blues but the negativity lately on here is unreal. Did we lose yesterday or something?

Last season, we would have scored, sat back, let them score then try and hold on for a point. Although we have roughly the same points and goals scored as at this point last season, I for one am overjoyed at how we play now as it's been so long in the coming.

As for the players, Delboy is frustrating but he's a kid and leaning all the time and will one day be a world class player. I'm glad I got to see him play in the Royal Blue. Mirallas has and always be that greedy player but, when he fires, he's electrifying, and who else would we play instead of him?

Buy Lukaku now as, when he matures, he will be unplayable; after only half a season and a bit, you can see RM's vision, the kids get a chance, play attractive football and always play to win. Let's not be moaning at everything including our own and crack on. Hell, if we lose a couple or get lucky at times then, hey ho, I'm enjoying watching us play after a hell of a long time. NSNO.

Denis Richardson
105 Posted 16/03/2014 at 09:23:10
This website really does have some 'interesting' people on it. We lose people moan, we win people moan.

I moaned for years regardless of the result because I wanted Moyes gone. Now we have a new face in the dug out I am not going to moan if we win a game. No matter how shite we play, the result is what matters. For those crying about the performance, get over yourselves, we WON ffs! Be happy we got the three points and the manager has a chance to learn from the game.

Also Delboy is not 'shite', the kid is only 19 and has more often than not been our most exciting player, when he's actually played. Give the lad a chance and support the team, bunch of Victor Meldrews on this site.

Rob Halligan
106 Posted 16/03/2014 at 09:07:07
Quick analysis of the game. In my opinion it was Everton versus Marshall. All of his saves were excellent, particularly the two from lukaku which were world class. Stone wall penalty on del boy and and never a free kick for their goal. Also listening to solskjaer you'd think Cardiff were unlucky, going on about the pen they "could" have had but no mention of how well his goalkeeper played who for me was MOM, or the pen we should have had.

At this stage of the season it's all about results and I don't care how we win as long as we win. And no way do I want any favours from the R.S. If anything a draw with the manc's equalizing in the last minute.

See told you I was biased towards our team!!

Oh yeah, and don't play osmam. For me he is too weak on the ball and always seems to run into trouble and usually ends up on his arse acting like a dying fly flapping his arms in the air!! The last few games he's had more of an impact when coming off the bench, so lets keep him there!

Jermaine Jennings
107 Posted 16/03/2014 at 09:36:13
It was an average performance but a win is a win!!! Our play in the final 3rd is sometimes dire...instead of a straight pass into lukaku we play square passes..its pathetic..

I think Stones is going to be awesome he stepped forward with the ball to try and get moves started in the first half..That is brilliant and takes courage..he will make mistakes but he courage to come back stronger and so next season it has to be him and jags..

Deulofeu is hot and more cold and basically cannot start a game as he is an impact player!! He needs to learn more about his game when to pass and to take on opposition..He'll learn in time but we don't need that luxury player now in our team..he will never get into the barca team ever and he will move on to an average team.

RM will get one more season from me to see how good he is when he buys his own players. RM is to soft.. our performance wasn't great but I just would like to hear him after a game to say this wasn't good enough and we expect much better..

Wayne Smyth
108 Posted 16/03/2014 at 10:35:24
Graham Mockford, we were not "garbage". Read what Rob Halligan(012) wrote. Their keeper played a blinder and we could've easily won that game by 3 or 4 clear goals had he not kept them in it.

In spells we didn't play well, but for the majority of the game we did okay. We didn't play great, but we certainly were not shit.

We need to do better on set pieces (both defending and attacking), and the players are probably short of a bit of confidence after our recent run of tough games and undeserved defeats.

Graham Mockford
109 Posted 16/03/2014 at 12:08:11
Wayne,

Yes we could have won by 3-4 goals, we could have also lost had the penalty shout on Zaha been given. Any balanced view of yesterday would say we were in the end fortunate to come away with three points.

The positive is we are grinding results out at home, which says something about our attitude. However since Christmas our performances have been really patchy, especially in terms of creating chances. That's eleven goals in the last eleven PL games.

Still we are still in with a shout of Top 5 finish but that doesn't stop me thinking we were 'garbage' yesterday. It was the second bottom team in the league we were playing yesterday.

Sean Picton
110 Posted 16/03/2014 at 12:33:17
We need to be realistic here. Deulofeu is just 20 years old and his first season in top flight football is the Premier League, the best league in the world. Ross Barkley is in the same position and has suffered a horrific injury in the past. Lukaku is playing only his second season in the league and is also 20 years old. Imagine what these players could be like in 2-4 years should we keep them, or even just two if them!

Other players like Stones, McCarthy and Oviedo are also playing their first full seasons at Everton - a big step up from Wigan, Barnsley and Coppenhagen. We have a LOT to be excited about. RM has only had one summer window and has used it well - some signings still up for debate I admit.

Also to consider, this is Everton's FIRST season playing in this style and still has some of DM's favourites. The only way is up and I have full faith in RM and look forward to summer signings and unearthing European talent and gems.

Sean Picton
111 Posted 16/03/2014 at 12:33:17
We need to be realistic here. Deulofeu is just 20 years old and his first season in top flight football is the Premier League, the best league in the world. Ross Barkley is in the same position and has suffered a horrific injury in the past. Lukaku is playing only his second season in the league and is also 20 years old. Imagine what these players could be like in 2-4 years should we keep them, or even just two if them! Other players like Stones, McCarthy and Oviedo are also playing their first full seasons at Everton - a big step up from Wigan, Barnsley and Coppenhagen. We have a LOT to be excited about. RM has only had one summer window and has used it well - some signings still up for debate I admit. Also to consider, this is Everton's FIRST season playing in this style and still has some of DM's favourites. The only way is up and I have full faith in RM and look forward to summer signings and unearthing European talent and gems.
Frank Crewe
112 Posted 16/03/2014 at 12:04:09
I cannot understand the criticism that Delo is getting. If he's good enough for Barcelona to sign then he is certainly good enough for us. I wish we had another half a dozen just like him. At least he tries to be different.

The fact is our attacks are predictable. The opposition simply pack their defense watch us pass the ball around in front of them and wait to hit us on the break. Our problem is we don't score enough goals.

If you look at Evertons stats you will see that Coleman, a fullback, is our second highest scorer with 6 goals. Barry has scored a measly 3 and McCarthy our £13 million quid midfielder hasn't scored any. In fact he's only had 4 shots on target all season. We cannot continue to play both Barry and McCarthy in the starting 11 if we wish to score more goals and win more games.

We need more creative central midfield players and two pacey forwards. Of course this is easier said than done and will cost money that we don't have so we will have to continue to do the best we can with what we have until we get some real cash into the club or RM manages to unearth some world beating gems on the cheap.

Robert Workman
113 Posted 16/03/2014 at 13:06:50
Deulofeu always seems more effective to me when he comes inside. When he is stuck out on the wing he is so close to the touchline that it is difficult often to engineer anything. All his goals, including yesterday and his near miss, have been taken from the old "inside forward" (showing my age) position.

McGeady, on the other hand, plays like a natural winger and does manage to create space and engineer crosses.

It would be interesting to see Everton line up against Swansea with those 2 players playing in those positions.

Incidentally to counteract all the negative media comments mentioned earlier, try reading The Guardians balanced review of yesterdays game titled "Everton's Seamus Coleman gets lucky for deserved win against Cardiff"
http://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/mar/15/everton-cardiff-city-premier-league-match-report

Wayne Smyth
114 Posted 16/03/2014 at 13:07:42
Graham, I disagree entirely about our performances being patchy since christmas. Or a lack of chances created. What has been poor are the results and perhaps our finishing.

A balanced view of those game would tell you we lost at the RS because on injuries and lack of match sharpness which resulted in a poor overall performance and shocking result against the form side in the league.

At Chelsea a last minute own goal when we absolutely deserved something, at Spurs through an individual error when we had again done well enough to get something, at Arsenal again we looked to be doing very well till Barrys trip to give the pen.

In addition, how many of those results would we have got historically? Away to teams who've spent vastly more than us for many seasons? Teams where we used to go away to hope to scrape a draw, we now go to get a win and play positive football.

We didn't get the results on those occasions, but the performances we gave justified far more than what we got in all cases except for the RS away.

All things considered I think we easily did enough to justify a win yesterday. We were not fortunate. We had 2/3rds of the possession, twice the number of shots on goal, twice the number shots on target and twice the number of corners than Cardiff. Yes they could've had a pen(thought it was a pen personally), but equally they could've easily had a man sent off for the challenge on Barry.

Wayne Smyth
115 Posted 16/03/2014 at 13:18:00
Robert, I agree completely about Deulofeu. When he's in a central position, he can use his quick feet, pace and ability to change direction to maximum effect. A defenders nightmare.

He hasn't got fantastic pace over a distance to out-sprint a lively fullback who can pen him in to a confined area, but against lumbering central defenders who don't have a clue where he's going to go and can't risk a foul, he's dynamite.

Against a team like Cardiff at home, I'd love to see Deulofeu given Osmans role behind Lukaku, McGeady and Mirallas on the wings and Barkley alongside Barry or McCarthy to give us a bit more invention and drive from the centre of the park.

Robert Workman
116 Posted 16/03/2014 at 13:21:59
If Solskjaer is unhappy at the non-penalty award yesterday, he should look at the video of the reverse fixture when Baines was felled in the area and nothing was given. Cardiff gained an undeserved point in that game due to the referee.
What goes around come around, mate!
Graham Mockford
117 Posted 16/03/2014 at 13:34:58
Wayne,

Fair enough if you want to take a positive view, after all you are only saying what Roberto has been saying.

My take is still that our performances have dipped, we are not creating or scoring enough goals especially away from home, two in our last five. Defensively we are a good team, a good back five allied to two effective holding midfield players. But due to injury and form our most creative players in the first half of the season have dropped off in their performance.

Anthony Lamb
118 Posted 16/03/2014 at 13:22:46
On the particular subject of Mirallas like Kevin, Jack and others I must say after giving him countless "benefits of the doubt" over the past months my patience has just about run out with this prima donna. In what other so-called profession would a guy be tolerated for so long when he constantly chooses to do the wrong thing? Of course he is quick and has ability but he is just a reasonably talented footballer who is little better (if at all) than quite a number of middle ranking players who populate most of the premier league. What prevents him from moving up in the ability and affective stakes is his willful selfishness and lack of awareness of the first basic understanding of football is that it is a team game.

Players of the ilk of Messi, Ronaldo etc can be forgiven if they indulge their ability from time to time for the end products are usually in line with their actual abilities, but even they are usually aware of their role and responsibilities in team play. Mirallas of course is not in their league so why on earth he adopts an attitude and an approach such as he does is beyond me. How or why this cannot be drummed into him is also beyond me. If he frustrates the majority of supporters to the point of despair then even in the hard-bitten world of professional football selfishness it must not endear him to "workmates" any more than it would to "mates" who play the game in the park on a Sunday. In Everton's supposedly cash-strapped circumstances if he does not fundamentally change his ludicrously selfish approach to his game than I would get shut in the summer for some inflationary figure and start again. At the moment the man is simply ridiculous.

Kevin Rowlands
119 Posted 16/03/2014 at 14:42:31
Frank #037, I'm sorry I just can't let you make them statements about Barry and McCarthy go unchallenged, both of them have had tremendous seasons and have been the backbone of everything good we have done this season. You do realize that the reason the fullbacks can get forward so much and be in a position to score, like Coleman is because of these two as they pick up their defensive responsibilities.

To say that either one should be dropped is utter garbage, and to suggest you would rather have 6 Del Boy's in the team? jesus we'd be getting tanked 9-4 every week, but hey at least we would score a few more, right.

Jim Bennings
120 Posted 16/03/2014 at 15:23:59
Manc bastards murdered by Liverpool at home practically handing them two home games against City and Chelsea to win the title.

Unbelievable..

Dont want to turn this into another Moyes rant but yet again thats what the man is all about.

You inherit a team that has just won the league with Rooney and Van Persie plus spend 64 million piund on two big name players and yet Moyes manages to make United look worse than Everton to be honest.

I cannot believe how far United have fallen behind Liverpool this season.

Forget the pens that Kopenburg gave them, United were light years behind the Shite..

I am starting to fear the very worst for this season now in terms of who the Champions are going to be.

James Martin
122 Posted 16/03/2014 at 15:37:10
Kevin, a 'tremendous season'?

Out of both cups, the worst derby in most people's living memory, hoping to scrape a Europa League place, no wins away at any of the top 7 apart from Man Utd. Is that a tremendous season?

Barry and McCarthy are both good at being defensive mids but Frank is right: you have to drop one of them. Liverpool are showing everyone the importance of quick transition. They play two attacking mids, we play two defensive ones, you saw how it worked out when they faced off.

Frank Crewe
123 Posted 16/03/2014 at 16:14:40
Kevin (#093), Presumably you just watched the RS v Manure game? Fellaini and Carrick playing in front of the defense. Raphael and Evra getting forward. What was the final score again?

Basically you are saying we should play with 4 fullbacks. Maybe if our midfield players got forward more our fullbacks wouldn't have to.

As much as I hate to say it, Liverpool are showing the way here. Movement, pace, mobility and accurate, incisive passing. These are the qualities needed to win matches – not whether your fullbacks can get forward and toss in the odd cross.

Tony Abrahams
124 Posted 16/03/2014 at 16:10:44
That's it, Jim, but I think it's better to forget about Liverpool and just prey they fall short. Glad Moyes has gone because of how limited he is and, although Martinez is IMO light years ahead of him as a football person, I'm not sure it's what everyone wants.

Some people thought Cardiff were unlucky yesterday despite Everton making most of the chances and their keeper being MotM by a country mile. The reason being is Cardiff were a lot more direct than Everton and therefore had a better tempo to their game.

Pragmatic people us Evertonians and sometimes all this possession can drive us crazy and can even be a bit boring on the eye. I remember Barcelona having all the play at Chelsea but their first shot didn't come until Iniesta got the winner in the 90th minute?

Imagine being in the Everton end in such an important game and watching us play like that? Cunts the fucking lot of them... but, no, hang on a minute, we've just scored! Not saying we're Barca, just saying how difficult it is trying to implement such a style on a shoestring and wondering if it's what we really want?

Kevin Rowlands
125 Posted 16/03/2014 at 18:25:52
Frank, if we had Sturridge and the rat in our team we would be in their position today, it's not rocket science, that is the area we have been lacking quality, not midfield.
Jackie Barry
127 Posted 16/03/2014 at 18:34:39
I saw nothing to say that Cardiff deserved anything from the game; direct maybe but deserving of a draw or victory, no way! For me, this is all part of the building process and a true representation of where we are at under Martinez will come next season. Oh, and yes, if we had Sturridge and Suarez, we would probably be running away with the league, seriously!
Paul Smith
128 Posted 16/03/2014 at 19:16:55
To call Deulofeu anything but a fantastic talent is unbelievable. In little time, he's still come through with more effect than Pienaar and Mirallas. The kid maybe only on loan but he's a good part of the squad. He will make mistakes all the time but he can be so dangerous and thrives on confidence.

I am fed up of groaners in the crowd having a pop and piling pressure on youngsters. This kid is possibly the biggest fresh footballing talent any Evertonian has ever seen so get off his back an let the kid learn.

Paul Smith
129 Posted 16/03/2014 at 19:25:28
Frank 037 you're spot on mate and anyone who can't see it is miles behind. No drive from midfield equals no success in attack. No matter how you feel about Barry and McCarthy (and they have given everything) the system is sluggish and nowhere near creative enough. This theory that we are now attacking is slowly dying.
Kieran Riding
130 Posted 16/03/2014 at 19:28:11
Paul Smith #275
I look forward to him becoming one of the best players in the world.. And I'll buzz of the fact we helped him get there.
Patrick Murphy
131 Posted 16/03/2014 at 19:33:37
I think the older Evertonians may have seen better talents at a younger age than Del Boy who by the way has recently celebrated his 20th birthday...

May I suggest Colin Harvey (18) and a certain Wayne Rooney (16). If Del Boy can have as good a career in football as those two then I apologise for being harsh on the lad.

Kieran Riding
132 Posted 16/03/2014 at 19:39:04
Patrick #282
Billy Kenny.

Deleoufeu will turn out a worldie.

Wayne Smyth
133 Posted 16/03/2014 at 19:37:31
Patrick, I think had Deulofeu not been injured and been regularly given more than the odd 15 minutes he usually gets, we'd be seeing far more. I think we'd have seen a better player had Martinez kept him on after his goal.

I always get the impression with Deulofeu and Barkley that they are trying too hard to impress. I think a lot of it is expectation and a lot of it is them wanting to show in the few minutes they have on the pitch that they deserve to be there next week.

Need to also bear in mind the culture shock that comes from leaving a city and team like Barcelona for Everton in Liverpool. I'm not so sure a teenage Rooney would've looked so hot taken away from his familiar surroundings and plonked into another country and culture.

Jackie Barry
134 Posted 16/03/2014 at 20:00:19
I like Deulofeu but sorry – for me, right now – he is anything but world class. He has a long way to go before he can create the delight I remember when Wayne Rooney came onto the scene and going back further a few other young ones I remember... phew, I am feeling old now. I'm sure he will become a big hit but right now I'm not sure all this loaning players stuff is truly good for the club, we need new heads but new heads who are going to become part of the furniture.
Frank Crewe
135 Posted 16/03/2014 at 20:04:27
Kevin #255 Are you sure about that. Under our present set up to accommodate both Barry and McCarthy in the starting 11 one of them would probably start on the bench.

Personally I think having 2 defensive midfielders in front of a back four shows a lack of faith in both the defense and attack. It's saying we won't score enough and the defense isn't strong enough to repel attacks. So because we have de facto 6 defenders on the pitch it becomes a self fulfilling prophesy and we don't score enough goals and the opposition will still get through at least once or twice. so we end up drawing or worse losing by the odd goal. Especially if the opposition gets in front.

It's like we've replaced 1 Fellaini with 2 Fellaini's but without the goals he occasionally scored. Next season I don't want to see both Barry and McCarthy in the starting 11. I want to see a more creative midfielder in place of one of them because if we carry on as we are then next season will be a carbon copy of this one.

Brent Stephens
136 Posted 16/03/2014 at 20:33:43
At the start of the season many predicted we'd possibly see a lot of goals scored by us, with us shipping a shed full of goals, but that would be not bad to watch, an entertaining way to get wins.

That's not what we've seen, wither end. At this point in the season there are only two teams with better defensive records than us, so I'd now like to see us get that all-guns-blazing, attacking football out of the bag, risk shipping some goals, and get some in at the other end.

To hell with all this fucking possession, possession keeping it tight, pass, pass, hoping we nick one.

Colin Malone
137 Posted 16/03/2014 at 21:32:00
Dellboy on the wing, Nooooooo.
Mirallas on the wing, Nooooooo.
These are not providers, these are in or around the box players.

McCarthy has got to support the forwards when we attack, otherwise as we see, we are out numbered when we attack the oppositions box.
Distin was my man of the match.

Paul Kelly
138 Posted 17/03/2014 at 00:35:41
Paul @ 275, we’ve always been that way, many were groaning when Ross got tackled before he had the chance to win the ball back, which he gave to McGeady, which led to the goal. It’s always been this way, it won’t change anytime soon I’m afraid.

It’s our paying supporting right but out can’t be good for player confidence.

Trevor Lynes
139 Posted 17/03/2014 at 10:52:20
With the results on Sunday, we now have a great chance to finish 5th. Perhaps the slice of luck we had will kick start our final push.

I hope that Traore is fit for the last few games and even Gibson and Kone may have outside chances to figure.

Roger Sunde
140 Posted 17/03/2014 at 11:43:25
We won the match, their goalkeeper was Man of the Match by far, even by conceding 2 goals.
David Price
141 Posted 17/03/2014 at 13:59:53
To induce a faster attacking flow to our game, there is an option to have the Pienaar/Baines partnership on the left, McGeady/Coleman on the right, centre midfield would have Barkley instead of Barry with Deulofeu behind Lukaku. It would encourage quick ball either through the middle with the wide players tucking in, or out wide with overlapping full backs.

It's a change that them lot made by not playing Lucas and Gerrard together and they now pump the ball up quick. If we did that to Lukaku and Deulofeu, Pienaar, McGeady and Barkley push on to close down a second ball or link up with support play.

I would like to think Roberto has employed these tactics in his first season to get us comfortable with the passing game before expanding his options in season two.

We did make massive progress under ten years of Moyes; ten years of Roberto could be magnificent for the club. Time will tell as ever...

Geoff Evans
144 Posted 17/03/2014 at 18:09:38
David Price 408

Top drawer thread.

Ian Burns
145 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:08:27
David Price - 408 - there is a job for you at Finch Farm - surely!
Andy Walker
146 Posted 17/03/2014 at 21:36:02
Frank, you are so right on this and it's been bugging me for weeks, since we went gung-ho against the RS. We are one-dimensional, that is, get the full backs ahead of the ball attacking and have either Barry and/or McCarthy covering. In effect, we are sacrificing two midfielders simply to let two fullbacks attack.

Now this would be okay if we didn't do it every week and were a bit smarter tactically and chose the tactics to fit the opposition, but we don't. Every match we play the same tactics and Martinez doesn't seem to be able to recognise when we need to play a different shape. The opposition know exactly how we will play every week as it's the same every week.

How about setting up every now and again so that Baines and Coleman don't play like wingers and we do drop McCarthy or Barry and play an extra attacking midfielder? Fuck me, what a shock this would be to the opposition?

If we had drawn against the RS, Chelsea and Spurs, we would still very much be in the mix for top 4. If we had done the same against Arsenal in the FA Cup we could have got them back to Goodison and then probably gone on to win it. But Martinez couldn't adapt the tactics to the situation; instead, he went for the same ludicrous set-up against teams which could tear us apart if we tried to play with full backs ahead of the ball for most of the match. It's so fucking obvious, it drives me nuts, yet we have apologists for Martinez saying how great it is to see us attack all the time. It's great at the right time but it's proven naïve in recent weeks. I do admire Martinez's gambling instinct to attack, attack, attack, but it needs to be reigned back; he should know this, he is a Premier League manager being paid a fortune.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb