Big spending can only get Everton so far

Sunday, 17 March, 2019 10comments  |  Jump to last
Marco Silva's side welcome Chelsea today in desperate need of some stability — and return on their investment

» Read the full article at The Times

Reader Comments (10)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Martin Mason
1 Posted 20/03/2019 at 17:27:22
A good article. In the end, purchasing power doesn't do much nowadays. Well-managed clubs that buy well will do well in the long term. Spurs are well managed at every level but didn't buy at all last summer window. Their position reflects that.
Ken Kneale
2 Posted 20/03/2019 at 19:45:00
Good assessment, Martin. It explains why we are where we are.
Alan J Thompson
3 Posted 21/03/2019 at 05:17:02
More of a warning of precaution for those wanting their own team but doesn't seem to go deep enough in the case of Everton.

It has been said at levels that make it more than believable that the wage bill is to be reduced, read playing staff numbers lowered, before any more will be hired.

So where are we at; Jagielka, Baines, Ashley Williams and Martina I believe are at the end of their contracts, Browning has already gone and I suppose one or two of those younger players on loan may be more easily moved on for the "undisclosed fee".

I don't know what we'll do with younger talent like Vlasic, Dowell, Joe Williams, Besic and Lookman and it must be getting near the time when the idea of a work permit for Onyekuru is seen for the improbability it has always been, we may have been better paying a smaller fee just for first refusal. I doubt that Anderlecht will cough up for Bolasie but hopefully Fiorentina will pay the rumoured pittance that will see Mirallas become one of their own.

So, assuming that the money saved is not immediately paid to any incoming as it seems reasonable that a ceiling on wages has been decided, then shall we see anymore than 2 or maybe 3 new players and it appears only one from anywhere near the top shelf.

We should remember also that the man splashing the cash, or more likely just standing guarantor, is an accountant of some standing who apparently has never considered an apprenticeship at lion-taming but has had a grounding at a properly run football club.

Kevin Prytherch
4 Posted 21/03/2019 at 09:11:00
There's another article in the Mail today about finances from Accrington Stanley's owner.

'Football is bust, in crisis': Accrington Stanley owner Andy Holt horrified by skewed finances and he says clubs have been coerced into gambling

Worth a read and puts some of what Sky have done to football into perspective.

Dave Abrahams
5 Posted 21/03/2019 at 15:23:10
Kevin (4), as you say Kevin, well worth a read and it sums up the state of football today and the way it is run and accepted, especially at the top by most of the people involved, directors, managers, coaches and most of all by the players in just two words, Pure Greed, and it will get worse.
Martin Mason
6 Posted 21/03/2019 at 19:21:06
Kevin, very good article and thanks for sharing.

Everton has also been run like a gambler on the verge of bankruptcy for years but we have been lucky and now have the chance of the financial stability needed to progress. Our top priority is to unload the dead wood that we've accumulated at virtually any price.

How a high turnover business like EFC allowed some of the signings we made is financial insanity. Buying is a really dangerous proposition now because the cost/benefit is insanely negative with talentless players going for obscene prices.

Buy infrequently but buy well and realise that our strength is our academy. Don't look at how to waste money on a new star but how to get Lookman and Davies into the first team. We have to become a well-run club first and then develop from there. Purchase of stars alone will never work.

Thomas Lennon
7 Posted 22/03/2019 at 08:48:35
Whatever way you look at it, Premier League football is a lottery, and a very high stakes lottery, especially with the rise of very highly priced agents controlling player availability.

Costs always have to be balanced against a conservative estimate of reward, and Champions League is the biggest differentiator between top clubs and the rest, also the most unpredictable, highest risk with not that much in prize money relatively speaking.

The key to success is financial stability and performing consistently above your paygrade.

Business builds the club, the club builds the business. Ignore what our opponents can do, they have earned their status over many years.

Make sure we are always getting the best results we can from year to year.

Derek Knox
8 Posted 22/03/2019 at 09:54:54
Dave @5, very valid point there, which basically we have to 'thank' Sky for, they have created a Prometheus, which is surely unsustainable with an eye to the future.

Although we are at the sharp end of all this (well, almost) it is basically by virtue of being the club we are, that we have been carried along on this Financial Tsunami, of which we had little say in.

I always think of those clubs in the lower leagues who, unless some miracle occurs, have little or no chance of getting a foot in the door. Yet they have support week after week, which is admirable, that supporters turn out to rally for their local team, when it would be much easier to plump for one the 'big clubs' and even if not attending in person, have a more than even chance of seeing them on the TV.

Thing is, while as you say it will get worse, where will it leave those smaller clubs? The worrying thing too is I can't see any solution, wages and transfer fees are not likely to become less, and there is a very real danger of it spiralling out of control, if it has not already done so for many clubs.

Eric Myles
9 Posted 22/03/2019 at 10:12:44
The problem is that we have not just suddenly become a mis-managed club, the mismanagement has been endemic all through Kenwright's reign and, as Martin says in #6, the chancer got lucky that someone came in to bail him out.
Jim Harrison
10 Posted 22/03/2019 at 11:55:13
And then we only go and beat Chelsea!! In a match where all our new players put in good performances and the manager made an impact at half time. Football hey!

Nothing new here really. And the article doesn't point out that the net spend, up until Koeman arrived, was very low. The squad needed investment, just like your house does if you don't keep work on it up to scratch. Man City did it big time. They pumped millions in early in the new regime as they knew they had to make big strides fast. It didn't work out for them immediately.

There have been bad signings no doubt. Niasse and Tosun in particular are bad investments for me as they added nothing. At least Morgan Schneiderlin started well!! But, since Brands has come in, the signings have all looked decent, with maybe only Mina having a question mark for me. Even he played well at Chelsea and it will have been a big culture shift for him in particular, making the move from South America to Spain and then ending up in Merseyside!!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

About these ads