The fact is that David Moyes appears to have run out of ideas and that is reflected on the field. Everton are stagnating and so is he. A period of intense focus after dropping to the bottom of the league has diminished and we remain just another defeat or two away from the drop zone.
How many times have we seen Sunday?s drama played out? It has the familiarity of an old black-and-white movie. One striker, a tentative, overly defensive opening period, some missed chances and the inevitable giveaway. Following a brief moment or two of optimism before the break, a killer goal early in the second half. You could predict what happens next and not get even-money. We finally take the lost game to the opposition, bring on additional strikers and dominate for a pointless consolation goal.
It is time for David Moyes to move on to a fresh challenge ? and good luck to him for he has done a good job up to a point. It?s time for Everton to seek new leadership too. It?s like the old line from Woody Allen?s Annie Hall: 'A relationship is like a shark. It has to constantly move forward or it dies. What we got on our hands is a dead shark.'
I see David Moyes's after-match comments becoming more resigned and complacent by the week. ?I thought we created one or two chances which on another day we might have scored,? he said Sunday. "If we'd got the goal a bit earlier then, who knows?" ... "And who," he might well have added, "gives a flat-footed flying fuck?"
A new manager would provide fresh inspiration and a new perspective ? identify the dead wood without the personal baggage Moyes has gathered over the last several years. Just two examples: Having nurtured Osman and given him his first break, he has an exaggerated sense of his worth and cannot see his flaws any longer. And having shelled out £11 million for Yakubu ? yet another failed record signing ? he refuses to accept that the Nigerian isn?t the answer to the goal-scoring conundrum. Feed the Yak and he just gets heavier, clumsier, and less and less interested.
Everton is in danger of coming full circle from the old Walter Smith days in terms of our place in the Premier League. Moyes took over when we were mired in what was likely to become a relegation fight; demoralized, stagnant and unlikely to make much progress, with goals hard to come by and the rest of the league salivating at the prospect of playing against us. We had held on to Walter Smith for two seasons too long, with a malleable media constantly singing his praises in the face of all the reversals and our free-falling league position. Any of this sound familiar?
We are approaching a similar position with David Moyes. We cannot afford to wait for yet another season of stagnation and disappointment and treading water and, in a way, neither can he. Despite his reputation, he will be lucky to land an elite job if he continues to steer Everton into the shoals of the bottom third.
I know some will argue for Moyes continued presence if only because there are few other managers available. The same fatuous argument was used for keeping Walter Smith. I agree it will take effort to find the right man, but we must find him. We need fresh eyes, a fresh mind and fresh blood.
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
1 Posted 14/11/2010 at 18:42:58
Moyes, please go, you're negative and tactically naive and have reached your ceiling...
2 Posted 14/11/2010 at 19:42:47
But you make a very compelling case; ... I'm wavering... (Or should that be 'Dithering'!?!)
3 Posted 14/11/2010 at 19:51:41
At no point did we ever look threatening, game after game it's the same boring shit... why can't we be more like Blackpool, Wolves and other sides who give it a go ? Just baffles me...
It's about time we started with the Yak and Beckford up front from the start and see how it goes; time to be brave ? not boring.
ps: If we can get £2 million for Saha, get rid soon as...
4 Posted 14/11/2010 at 19:44:36
Moyes hasn't run out of ideas, we are just missing chances on the field. I think the post maybe knee jerk, yet the length of content suggests not. Moyes is getting some stick for losing to Arsenal and for me it's wrong.
5 Posted 14/11/2010 at 19:55:31
How are Celtic faring these days?
6 Posted 14/11/2010 at 19:52:02
Too many players have been at our club too long, and I would include Pienaar, Arteta, Osman, Hibbert, Howard and maybe even Cahill. In the Catterick and Shankly eras, they sold what were thou?ght to be good players because they saw that they had 'lost' their game before even we fans could see it happening. With Moyes, he can still can't see that many of the players at the club are long 'past it'.
And he's certainly not managing our club well ? distinct from the team. He has let a few players run their contracts down and leave for nothing rather than sell them to maintain the bank balance, and it's about to happen now with Pienaar. Looking at Billy and Heitinga, are we really likey to recoup the cost of their recruitment - disregarding their salaries and pay-offs? We all think not.
If all the papers ? and Owen Coyle ? think that Moyes is destined for Old Trafford, then let's test the water... he wouldn't last a full season under the spotlight with his dodgy and negative tactics and substitutions. No, Moyes has done well stabilising us, but it's time he moved on. His successor will have a lot of work to do with what Moyes leaves behind ? a lot of dead wood ? if we are to get into the top four in my lifetime.
7 Posted 14/11/2010 at 20:00:06
How many times has Arteta taken any game by the scruff of the neck and dictated like Pienaar did today? Most of last season, we were winning games in style until Arteta came back and then the draws started, because the play is too slow when he plays. He also hampers Pienaar, whose first instinct is turn and go forward, Arteta goes back and sideways and kills the move.
We would have been better giving the £75k a week to Pienaar rather than Arteta, he has been a great servant but maybe its time to sell him on and keep Pienaar.
8 Posted 14/11/2010 at 20:13:07
To be honest I don?t think we should get rid of Moyes. I feel it would be the biggest mistake the club could make. I am not saying everything is perfect, but I don?t know what the answer is and probably neither do the majority of us fans. As my grandfather used to say if your not sure what to do, do nothing, because...
9 Posted 14/11/2010 at 20:29:39
Personally, I'm sick to the back teeth of his negative mindset.
I paid £540 for my season ticket and have enjoyed 2 games. It was like a morgue today because there is nothing to shout for (apart from when Coleman attacks). It's just boring.
Why is Arterta playing so deep?
Why can't we ever start with two forwards?
Why did he buy Billy and then have no idea where to play him (that's £9 million there, doing nothing)?
Why has he never brought a pacey Winger?
Why did it take him so long to play Coleman at right midfield?
Why is Arteta taking most of our set pieces?
Why are we playing a centre -half in midfield?
10 Posted 14/11/2010 at 20:50:48
11 Posted 14/11/2010 at 20:44:48
Moyes has done a great job of stabilising the club but the same issues constantly rear their ugly heads. Dreadful starts to the season, not really knowing his best starting eleven when everyone is fit, having his most effective eleven forced on him by injury, and his constant inability to change games effectively from the bench.
Can anyone explain the final substitution. Beckford, the Yak and Saha up front, Pienaar, Cahill and Rodwell in midfield??? Moving one of our main threats Coleman back to right back? Don't tell me that formation is ever going to work with those personnel, or is ever worked on in training. I know we scored eventually but for the first ten minutes after the change clearly no one had a clue on their role.
We clearly have a talented squad but at the moment everything is too predictable and things need freshening up sooner rather than later.
12 Posted 14/11/2010 at 21:06:00
Quite frankly we were poor in patches but Moyes was too dismissive of the efforts of Fabianski who had a terrific game and was Sky's MotM. Together with poor refereeing from Webb, which should have seen at least one Arsenal diismissal and a penalty... We could have won this.
Ferguson and Wenger are both longer serving managers but does any one accuse them of running out of ideas? No, but they do evolve. 5 years ago everyone complained about our grinding out dull 1-0 wins. Moyes is now trying to evolve the team into one which plays attractive football. We are in the birth pains of this new team emerging. Patience will bring its reward.. I steel myself for the incoming flak...
13 Posted 14/11/2010 at 21:25:24
I have had my concerns about Arteta since Villa away when Pertov had him off throughout the game. He is now very one-paced and cannot find that bit of pace to beat a man and pass the ball forward. I can only put this down to his cruciate injury; we may well have to accept he is not the player he once was ? I hope I am wrong.
The ground was like a morgue today, the fans where not up for it ? and unfortunately neither where a lot of the players.
14 Posted 14/11/2010 at 21:35:51
15 Posted 14/11/2010 at 21:33:54
There seems a feeling around a lot of supporters of this being the best we can expect in the circumstances. Are we destined for nothing better or will something change? I have been a Season Ticket Holder for over 40 years and this is the worst feeling of hopelessness about Everton that I have ever experienced in that time.
16 Posted 14/11/2010 at 21:58:17
Well, there's always Gary Megson....or maybe we could entice big Sam from Blackburn. Mad Roy Keane even.
Fair makes your mouth water eh ?
17 Posted 14/11/2010 at 22:04:01
What gets me is that at the next home game we win, they'll still be a large section of muppets chanting Moyes' name. We, the ones wanting some change, are in the minority, I feel. It will take a relegation battle for something to change but Moyes will always keep us around mid table and that now seems good enough to most. It's this feeling of total stagnation that is worst.
I agree with Andy (16), we are hopeless. There's no hope of investment, no hope in a change of manager, no hope of seeing some attacking football and no hope of us ever winning anything.
18 Posted 14/11/2010 at 22:13:06
19 Posted 14/11/2010 at 22:16:05
20 Posted 14/11/2010 at 21:52:14
Make no mistake Ferguson and Wenger have critics among their own but they've won stuff and always compete plus their teams play decent football.
Moyes' attempt at playing on the floor is only showing his and his assembled squads limitations.
Arsenal did'nt break sweat today we don't know what to do with the ball and give it up cheaply, deadly against teams with pace and ability.
21 Posted 14/11/2010 at 21:34:05
We have to remember a few things namely that Fellaini was unavailable (I know thats his fault) as was Osman, Arteta and the Yak have only come back from career threatening injuries and may never reach the same heights and Rodwell is not fully matchfit yet.
IMO (and a number of experts) David Moyes does a great job in extremely difficult circumstances.
The league is very different this year as a number of "smaller" clubs (I hate that word but need to make a point) have strengthened their squads and learned the "Everton" way (strong team spirit, extremely fit and press the opposition throughout the game.) therefore rsults are more erratic. Who would ever have forecast that Chelsea would lose to Sunderland at home for example.
Our squad for today was pretty threadbare and I personally would have gone for a more attacking formation with the Yak and Beckford up front to exploit Arsenal's back four but if we had been thrashed because of their superior MF we would have all been singing an even worse tune.
Also I feel the decision to give Arteta 75k a week and not reinforce the squad in the Summer was a major mistake as is the prospect of losing Pienaar on a free (surely if we would have given him an increased contract we would have recovered it from the fee).
I always say we should leave it to the professionals but when we look back at all the failures in the game maybe thats not correct because I do now start to see Moyes running out of steam and patience and our famous team spirit vanishing up Goodison Road.
22 Posted 14/11/2010 at 23:03:37
23 Posted 14/11/2010 at 22:29:24
We didn't lie down and surrender when 2 nil down, we created the same number of chances and shots as Arsenal, and Moyes showed a willingness to gamble on 3 up front.
We also saw gutsy performances in midfield from Pienaar, Coleman and Cahill - the latter of whom, is getting more and more stuck into the oppositon in the buildup these days. Coleman retrofitted as a pacey winger has been a sight to see and Pienaar is fundemental to our future and should be retained at all cost.
Our biggest problem at present is the defensive midfield role - Hetinga is not cut out for it, it's not fitness that is his problem its instinct. Fellaini when fully fit has at times been a revelation in the role, but he's taken himself out of the equation. Rodwell may be an option to consider, but we've seen him out of his depth there at points in the past.
The other is the strange case of Dr. Distin and Mr. Sloppy-Sylvain. Sometimes he can be immense in one to ones, but when we conceed it tends to be due to judgment lapses or poor positioning on his part.
It's also pretty clear that Louis Saha is having a poor run of form, and though Moyes is right to believe in his quality, he'd be better to use him as an impact sub until he's recovered his full fitness and hunger.
The Yak should be leading the line, and against weaker teams we should be blooding Beckford in a 4-4-2, and I'm sure Moyes will try this option in the next month.
On Moyes himself, I get why people are frustrated, but he's shown in the past that he's the master of the turnaround and I think he still has the grit, authority and drive to take Everton forward.
We have been playing more attractive football this season in the past, there is more passing in our build-up play, and Distin aside, we seem to be consigning hoof-ball to the past.
We're right to be disappointed we're not further up the table, but as Jay Harris says, the Premier league is more competitive than ever, and there's a long way to go yet. We should keep faith with Moyes and give him the resources he needs to balance the squad in the summer.
24 Posted 14/11/2010 at 22:46:50
Over the years, Moyes has done a good job for us. I'm repeating an earlier post but Moyes has the best record outside of the Sky four. No-one has been closer to breaking the monopoly of those teams. We haven't got the cash to break into the top tier so his job is incredibly hard, every year competing against teams who are able to reboot their weaker areas because they have the cash to do it. So if they have an Arteta not performing, there's always someone to replace him.
Teams like City and Spurs now coming into cash make it all the harder. We're not far off top six at the minute and with a fit squad and maybe a Donovan loan we can push for better things. We've done it before so why not again?
The sickening taboo of top level football in England ? no-one outside the sky four wins anything, Sky and CL money has seen to that. The exception being the League Cup when Sky's favourite sons leave a few scraps for the rest by fielding kids and reserves.
Moyes isn't the problem, it's more a chairman who won't let go of his favourite toy.
25 Posted 14/11/2010 at 22:43:15
I was a big fan of what Moyes did early on both off & on the pitch and Everton do owe him a debt of thanks.
However, like many others I quickly saw his limitations & certainly don't believe his media hype.
For those who want him gone, I think they'll get their wish as I've just got this feeling he knows it's time to now go. Don't think it will be a top job & have always had a feeling it would be Newcastle. Maybe I should put a tenner on it.
I'd certainly wish him "all the best" but we certainly need something to freshen things up.
From a personal point of view this season has been a body blow for me & for the first time in 32 years I am becoming ambivulant about our club.
I didn't fall for the hype at the start of the season but did feel we needed to finally push on or our chance would be lost for the forseable future.
The combination of Kenwrights lies/mis-managment & Moyes negativity have now taken it's toll on me though. I was offered good tickets for today's game but just couldn't be arsed anymore.
I guess I still care or I wouldn't come on here but 3 weeks ago I went to a none league ( 9th tier of English Football ) game. I then followed them last week as they made the FA cup 1st round rather than try & get tickets for Blackpool away. I'm going again Wednesday night & the great thing is it's all about the FOOTBALL. It's free from all the Money/celebrity nonsense of the PL & the stagnation I feel at Goodison.
I guess there will be many on here who'll think " well just fuck off then" but I'm no good time fan. Believe me in 32 years I've seen some dark days at Goodison but I've never felt as apathetic about my club as I do this season.
26 Posted 14/11/2010 at 23:44:02
Nice Woody Allen reference btw...
27 Posted 15/11/2010 at 00:07:27
After 3 wins from 13 games the 'vultures', Jackals, Coyotes and inbred cannibal killers should be ripping the decomposing flesh off the crippled carcass. Top 5 my arse.
28 Posted 15/11/2010 at 00:19:50
29 Posted 15/11/2010 at 01:19:08
He will never take a risk and he is almost always easy to predict. He has good players and does not know what to do with them. If you are happy with simply being so safe with guaranteed PL football then you may as well be dead.
I could have outlined the match report without going. I would rather enjoy a bit of tension and risk rather than this stifling and frustrating rubbish.
Life is really too short. Have a go or go away. Thanks for everything Mr Moyes but stop wasting our time and money. The only thing I trust Moyes with is to keep us in the PL. So what!?
30 Posted 15/11/2010 at 01:02:51
Moyes is making too many negative and/or uninspiring comments generally and this cannot help. Perhaps he needs to pull his head in a little - after all, that is what he would tell his players to do.
31 Posted 15/11/2010 at 08:01:07
Any regular match goer will tell you our football is aimless, we lack pace and have no clue how to score. You can look at your stats and say Moyes is doing a good job but the fact is he isn't. Take the Stoke game as an example. You can look at the result and say well done to Moyes but if you were at the game, you will realise we were utter shite. We were lucky not to be a goal down and we didn't really create a chance before Yakubu scored.
Like Peter says in his article, it's all too predictable. We are not vultures, we just want to be entertained. Outside of the odd 5 or 6 games a season, we are not.
32 Posted 15/11/2010 at 09:03:38
It got so bad yesterday, if you were in the Park End, I was the bloke in the fur hat ripping the piss out of their fans and standing up in response to the "who's the cunt in the hat". It's like a morgue at Goodison as we are so bloody predictable and dreadful to watch, why put on a fight for the last ten mintues instead of starting a game and getting ahead and then defending?
33 Posted 15/11/2010 at 08:41:59
Watched the Chelsea v Sunderland game when we got home: Chelsea without both CBs, similar to Arsenal; Sunderland went for them from the start, with two strikers and should have won 5-0.
If it was prudent to go all out when 2-0 down, why don't we ever do that from the start? Stoke went all out against Liverpool and won; Wolves have been doing it for a few weeks now and have been really unlucky, creating several chances; West Brom did it against Arsenal; Aston Villa murdered Man Utd; Blackpool do it... the list goes on.
I would love to see Everton attack with all guns blazing, shoot when within 20 yards, spin crosses in, vary the corners, the keeper throwing the ball out quickly to eager midfielders, Arteta left on the bench for a couple of games, Pienaar given CM role, play 2 up front ? just change a few things, play our secret weapon, Gueye.
"Insanity ? doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results" ? Albert Einstien... can't remember who he managed.
34 Posted 15/11/2010 at 14:08:40
35 Posted 15/11/2010 at 14:07:29
Yeh sure, I think we can play negative sometimes, especially against teams like Blackpool and Bolton, and we seem to score everytime we put on 2 strikers... name a team where the fans on forums aren't asking for a replacement manager (with the exception to Ancelotti ? just!).
it's all the same in any club. Moyes HAS been great at stabilizing our club, and that's what I hope for the future, without a new stadium or investment, a REGULAR top four spot is out of a reach under any manager. FACT. In Moyes I Trust.
36 Posted 15/11/2010 at 17:32:31
In the meantime, though he may not be the most radical manager, he has built an extremely solid squad and personally I think with a little more luck and firepower we would be sat in the top 3 or 4. As it is, the league is extremely tight and the table looks bleak.
He's not going anywhere for now as there aren't really many viable replacements and, even if there were, I don't believe we have the cash to afford a new manager or transfer budget.
So back the man. And the team. I think (hope) we will turn the corner and a few wins in this league will see us zoom up the table.
37 Posted 15/11/2010 at 17:22:38
We didn't lie down and surrender when two-nil down, we created the same number of chances and shots as Arsenal, and Moyes showed a willingness to gamble on 3 up front.
That is positive indeed, finally a remark that made me feel a little bit better. However, for Moyes that boldness is so far more of a one-off. If he can do that more often when we need it, maybe we can move forward.
38 Posted 15/11/2010 at 18:06:44
39 Posted 15/11/2010 at 18:26:23
40 Posted 15/11/2010 at 19:40:11
41 Posted 16/11/2010 at 07:48:39
The only thing left would then be to wait for Man City-like cash, which higlights the real problem: Moyes's lack of funds.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment to Fan Articles, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.