Keane reveals injury horror from last season

Monday, 29 October, 2018 45comments  |  Jump to last

Michael Keane has revealed the extent of the foot injury that only temporarily sidelined him last season but which would have lasting effects on his first season at Everton and his England prospects.

Speaking in The Sunday Times ahead of last weekend's clash with Manchester United at Old Trafford, the defender describes a nasty gash he sustained playing in a Carabao Cup tie against Sunderland in September last year, one that resulted in an infection so severe, there was a possibility he could have lost his foot had it not been treated in time.

“I played on,” Keane recalls following a hard tackle by James Vaughan in that game (one for which the former Blue apologised afterwards, “but I knew that something wasn't right and I had a hole straight through the top of my boot from his studs.

“I went in at half-time and my foot was aching but I didn't do anything about it and played the second half. When I took my boot off again there was blood everywhere. I found the skin an inch apart, split away, and a nasty gash.”

He was given stitches in the wound but woke up the following morning, “in absolute agony. I couldn't put any weight on it. I took 10 minutes to get to the end of my bed.”

Rather than kept out of action for recommended three weeks, Keane was pressed back into action against his former club, Burnley and played for England — on both occasions he wore padding on the foot and boots two sizes too big — before turning out again in what would be Ronald Koeman's last match in charge, the 5-2 defeat to Arsenal at Goodison Park.

His foot ballooned in the aftermath of that game and the infection started to spread so he was quickly hospitalised and given antibiotics. But he was on the pitch again within a week on painkillers which, he admits, began to severely affected his ability to concentrate.

He describes how he felt in the away defeat to Southampton, which, coming in the wake of a home thrashing at the hands of Atalanta in the Europa League, instilled the panic in the club hierarchy that led to the final approach to Sam Allardyce to take the reins from David Unsworth.

“I think that the pills I was taking were making me very drowsy,” he says. “I felt that I couldn't concentrate. It was weird for me. I've always been one who's really focused and to be in a game and find concentration hard. I was trying to follow Charlie Austin and couldn't. I was seeing things and not reacting.”

Keane's form during that period — he would open the wound up again on New Year's Day this year when Anthony Martial landed on his foot with his studs — was alarming to many Evertonians and it also cost him a place at the World Cup in Russia after he dropped out of the England reckoning.

It hasn't been until the last few weeks when, finally settled, fully fit and able to play his normal game, that he has been able to start showing why the Blues paid what will likely be £30m for his services the summer before last.

“I developed a thick skin,” the 25-year-old said of the criticism aimed at him for a spell of form that clearly had mitigating circumstances. “Naturally, when things aren't going well, you get stick from fans and there were times I didn't want to go out in public.

“You come through that and never want that again. And you want to prove people wrong. You get an inner determination.”


Reader Comments (45)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Tony Abrahams
1 Posted 29/10/2018 at 22:00:32
The story about Michael Keane explains a lot. He looked really poor last season but is now beginning to look better every game. It just shows you how bad it can get in football once a team begins to struggle...
Brent Stephens
2 Posted 29/10/2018 at 22:12:43
Strewth, that's a terrible story about Keane's injury. Who on earth let him continue to play? Criminal.
Michael Kenrick
3 Posted 29/10/2018 at 22:17:58
Just astounding that he would play on, not even look at his foot at half-time, despite it feeling odd.

A gash from a stud, requiring 8 stitches in the top of your foot, so risk of infection is high. But so much must be down to the player saying he's okay. Incredible that it could have led to amputation! Never take anything for granted! Guess I'm too much of a wimp, which is why I never amounted to much as a footballer.

Full interview is at The Sunday Times website, but requires a subscription.

Jay Wood

4 Posted 30/10/2018 at 00:27:42
Astonishing revelations. Explains a lot about his form last season.

For me, his performances all season under Silva have been top-top drawer.

I fancy Mina will replace Zouma against Brighton ahead of the away game against Chelsea as the Frenchman cannot play against his contracted club.

Keane and Mina could then take some shifting from the centre back positions.

Mike Gaynes
5 Posted 30/10/2018 at 00:42:29
This is extraordinary. I remember speculating on TW several times about the foot injury because he looked so much slower with us than he had when playing against us the previous season.

No question the lad has a huge pair on him to keep going through that, and I admire his old-fashioned toughness, but I find myself wondering what in the hell our trainers were thinking. Why was he even allowed on the pitch in that situation? Why was he not fully examined by the club physicians and set down until it healed, rather than run back out on the pitch with a mis-sized shoe and a bloodstream full of opioids? This is the stuff of legend, all right, but it's not supposed to happen in this day and age.

I'm glad he didn't destroy his own career and health with his bravery. And I think the club has something to answer for.

Kieran Kinsella
6 Posted 30/10/2018 at 01:51:42
Adds a different complexion to last season. I feel bad for the guy, struggling in pain while being roundly mocked by fans and the media for his performances.
Jay Harris
7 Posted 30/10/2018 at 03:37:18
I owe the lad an apology as I was highly critical of his lack of awareness last season.

This has explained a lot and I'm glad he came out with it.

It will make a lot of us reconsider our opinion of him.

Tony Abrahams
8 Posted 30/10/2018 at 07:34:10
Mike, everything changes in football, once people are under pressure, which is something that Everton were this time last year.

I remember talking to someone who had told me that one Everton player had been vomiting all afternoon before we played Atalanta at Goodison, but instead of being told to stay away, he was told he had to play. In an absolute dead-rubber as well.

James Flynn
9 Posted 30/10/2018 at 11:16:02
Mike Gaynes, I remember this time last season when he was being torn to shreds on here and you brought up the fact of his foot injury.

I agree with your and others' incredulity at the medical staff letting him go out there with such an injury. I thought that sort of thing left us when Roberto did.

Mark Tanton
10 Posted 30/10/2018 at 11:41:42
Shows two things to me – firstly Keane deserves our respect and sympathy, and secondly that it illustrates the complete lack of leadership and club responsibility that also allowed Niasse to be ostracised.
Ernie Baywood
11 Posted 30/10/2018 at 11:55:31
Shocking tale and of course would explain why he was so poor last season.

It strikes me that it means one of three things:

- The leadership at the club were a shower if shite who put a young man's career at risk.
- Keane kept it to himself because the culture at the club was so poor that he felt he couldn't communicate his injury
- Keane's a nutjob!

What does all of this say about Rhino? It was him in the job then wasn't it?

Mike Gaynes
12 Posted 30/10/2018 at 12:54:01
Ernie, I'd say that IF he kept it to himself, it was because he felt such pressure to perform and was afraid of losing his place. And if so, it's still a failure by the club because sometimes young men need to be saved from their own warrior mentality.

But I truly believe that scenario is unlikely. Players are monitored and analyzed on a sophisticated basis today. The manager, be it Rhino or Koeman (I'm uncertain on the timing here) would have noticed his dropoff in performance. The training staff would have noticed his limp. And since the players don't shower or dress in a private closet, Keane's teammates would have noticed that his foot looked like it belonged to another species.

I think Tony's scenario is far more likely, that he felt pressured to play because we were performing so poorly, and he embraced that pressure because he's a fucking warrior – as he has shown since the skull fracture.

Either way, he is certainly owed apologies from us and the press, and the club needs to step up and address this. Now.

Finally, it makes me wonder what other players may have found themselves in the same situation over the years. Players we derided because we didn't know what was really going on.

This makes me a little sick.

Mike Gaynes
13 Posted 30/10/2018 at 13:16:07
James #9, I remember the phrase "turns like an aircraft carrier" was popular here then.

Makes me wince now to remember it.

Don Alexander
14 Posted 30/10/2018 at 13:32:24
Given the cojones now made known about this lad, might he be skipper material, or is he too quiet?
Kieran Kinsella
15 Posted 30/10/2018 at 13:37:52
Tony Abrahams 8

I believe it. I recall last season Allardyce in a presser insinuating that McCarthy was having mental issues and missing games because of perceived injury versus actual injuries that would prevent him playing. The timing was terrible because it was a couple of weeks before his horror injury.

But the point being that there is pressure on people to "tough it out", "man up" etc. Yes, I am sure there are some cry babies out there (maybe Daniel Sturridge) but I also think there are a lot of reckless managers.

Eddie Dunn
16 Posted 30/10/2018 at 20:01:58
Absolutely dreadfull. Plenty of questions for our club staff to answer.
Peter Gorman
17 Posted 30/10/2018 at 22:32:20
Initially I thought, he must have been hiding the extent of the injury as I find it hard to believe the club would play him under such circumstances, if not for the complete futility of doing so, but then again they couldn't wait to thrust Coleman back into the fray.

As awful as the story is, let's not swing all the way to the other side and praise him and his private bits. He was utter shite last year; slow to react, clumsy, weak and constantly caught out – smacks as much of his poor judgement as a banjaxed foot.

I'm one of those who has been impressed with him so far under Silva and I'm enjoying seeing the difference but I can't exactly forget how bad he was last season; as if he and Williams were going head-to-head in the oaf-stakes.

James Flynn
18 Posted 30/10/2018 at 23:19:53
Peter (17) - I applaud your determination to bring more attention to this thread. Little over the top for me, but hey.

Someone, not me, but someone else would read the article, then read your comments, and conclude you have a problem with reading comprehension for typing:

"As awful as the story is, let's not swing all the way to the other side and praise him and his private bits. He was utter shite last year; slow to react, clumsy, weak and constantly caught out - smacks as much of his poor judgement as a banjaxed foot."

Now me, I appreciate you pretending to be so openly stupid as to type such drivel. Hopefully, it will inspire more ToffeeWebbers to come in with a enlightened take on Keane's difficulties last season.

Lawrence Green
19 Posted 30/10/2018 at 23:54:48
Keane was probably partly responsible for playing on when he shouldn't have done, but somebody at the club must have known about the initial damage and they should have insisted he didn't return to the fold before he was physically ready to do so.

I'd rather have a player who would try to play through the pain barrier than one who yearns to be in the treatment room to avoid training / playing in the tough times. However, I don't recommend that any player should risk themselves physically and it is up to the medical staff to protect their patients and not to succumb to the manager or others within the club, no matter how much pressure they may put on them to do so.

If Keane had have lost his foot, who would have been responsible? Would the Insurance have covered him and or the club? No wonder last season looked like a circus and we can only hope that the players are treated properly and aren't asked to play when they are obviously injured.

Frank Wade
20 Posted 30/10/2018 at 23:57:53
I read that article in the Sunday Times and was amazed at the recklessness of the Everton medical or coaching staff. Michael Keane could have lost his career. At half-time in the Southampton game, he advised the staff that he was not well but they pushed him out again.

The autobiographies of Tim Cahill and Leon Osman contained many situations where these players had pain-killing injections to play. The Irish management team get a lot of stick, rightly so, for playing players who are not fully fit. Well, it looks as if Everton management have been worse.

Hopefully, Marco Silva takes a longer-term view of player welfare. Michael Keane is one brave player. I was amazed at how quickly he came back from his skull fracture, throwing himself into aerial duels, with no thought of injury.

Peter Gorman, do you think you would pass muster with the ToffeeWeb brigade, playing in a size 12 on one foot and a size 10 on the other, playing with a swollen foot, a boot full of blood, playing in pain etc? I know I wouldn't. He should have been rested until fit.

Jamie Crowley
21 Posted 30/10/2018 at 00:06:37
I missed this.

Just WOW.

I personally used the phrase, "turns like a barge" more than once. Had no clue about the foot. Explains the difference in speed and form this year.

I constantly bleat on about this "football" sport, and how I feel the diving, acting, and general "poo-swah" drives me apeshit. I've made more than one reference to the sport of my talent and youth of hockey in comparison.

Keane was playing on a fucked up, club foot. Never said boo about it. He also dove into a header that I'd have backed out of 1000 times out of 1000 and cracked his skull.

Keano has gained hockey-locker room-respect.


And someone at the Club should be quartered and hung for allowing him to play last season. Absolutely criminal.

Jamie Crowley
22 Posted 31/10/2018 at 00:15:05
Oh, and Peter at 17 -

I'm swinging all the way to the other side and praising him and his private bits.

It takes some awfully, awfully large private bits to play through something like that.

Peter Gorman
23 Posted 31/10/2018 at 01:12:39
Frank – of course he should have been rested until fit. The club shouldn't have played him under such circumstances but I'd question his own wisdom in not dealing with the injury.

James – I don't get the tone of your post, must be my lack of reading comprehension. At a guess, you've swallowed the story as deep as your throat allows and have somehow managed to airbrush last season from memory (good for you).

Feel free to enlighten me, James, but I think the article mentioned the foot injury occurring during the cup game against Sunderland, so that would be some time after we were linked to his signing from Burnley, when the unflattering comments about his turning-circle first surfaced.

Also, assuming he is not still doped up to the eyeballs, is it 'openly stupid' to point out the lapses of concentration that cost us goals, such as away to Wolves, that spoil an otherwise improved level of performance?

On second thoughts, I've no idea why I'm asking you – just cheer and boo as you see fit.

Brian Murray
24 Posted 31/10/2018 at 03:50:38
All very admirable in his attitude but he's another Jagielka. Too quiet to even get near the armband. That honour should go to a leader. Hopefully Feeney before long...
Justin Doone
25 Posted 01/11/2018 at 10:32:55
It's the kind of honest truth that fans love to hear but used to throw back in their faces and are criticised for being too honest and negative against the team he still plays for.

It simply highlights poor judgement, poor management, and poor character by playing on when clearly impacted by an injury and now using that as an excuse.

I'm sure many teams will try and target him to test how well healed his foot actually is. He's still not the most mobile of defenders but he's still learning and adjusting to another manager's tactics and does appear to be improving. He needs to be stronger in aerial duals and learn to pass forward quicker but, like most things Everton this season, lots of improvement all around.

Jim Potter
26 Posted 01/11/2018 at 11:02:06
I think his early form last season was poor - before the injury.

But, like many joining a new club he had to adapt to a new manager, team mates and style of play (and it can't have helped having Williams besides him).

To then get this injury and play on through it is both alarming (re our medical staff) and enlightening - towards Keane's will to succeed.

He has been playing very well (especially considering his head injury) and must be re-assessed by the many who wrote him off when not being aware of the facts.

Good luck to him - he may not be the mouthy leader some want - but with determination like this he surely can lead by his example.

John Hammond
27 Posted 01/11/2018 at 11:11:53
Just goes to show you never know what's going on behind the scenes that can affect a players performance. There's nothing wrong with criticising a player as long as it doesn't become nasty and personal. We can only go by what we can see on the pitch.
Harry Hockley
28 Posted 01/11/2018 at 11:37:14
Not sure all the bad form was due to the foot injury but yeah miles better now looking a different player, rock solid, very happy for the lad, I did say he turned like an 18 wheeler too.
Phil (Kelsall) Roberts
29 Posted 01/11/2018 at 11:47:08
The irony is that the injury was caused by James Vaughan - who suffered a injury to the same part of the body back in April 2007 caused by the same thing.

And P.S. look who was the opposition manager

Tony Abrahams
30 Posted 01/11/2018 at 11:48:51
I was actually embarrassed for Michael Keane, during that Southampton gameFrank@20, especially when he was brought off during the second half, and looked like he was crying.

He had joined Everton, to better himself, and found himself in a situation where it was every man for themselves, and he definitely looked to be sinking.

It’s a question of personalities really, some tell the manager to go and get fucked, whilst some feel that they have got to go and have ago, even though they know they are only damaging themselves, and therefore the team.

Catch-22, but that’s exactly were Everton found themselves last season, simply because Koeman, didn’t appear to care, and Steve Walsh, was totally out of his depth, and once the panic sets in, then people can make really stupid decisions, which is obviously what happened here?

Tony Abrahams
31 Posted 01/11/2018 at 11:58:55
Was that the Bolton game Phil? I was proud of young James Vaughan, that day because you could see the blood spurting out of his ankle, from the stands behind the goal, but you could see the lad just wanted to carry on.

Different scenarios, but I don’t care who you are, nobody should be playing football when they have got a big hole in their foot.

We’ve all heard the shouts, “get on with it - that’s what we used to do in our day” but the reality is, nobody can perform with such an injury, and only a man under pressure would expect him to even try?

Barry Williams
32 Posted 01/11/2018 at 12:23:25
I have spent time, as a fighter, referee, corner man and sparring partner in both kickboxing and boxing and I have met some right tough unassuming hard cases. Even considering that and dismissing this news about last season's foot injury, to come back from being ko'd and a a skull fracture like Keane did, that takes a large set of cojones right there, regardless . I thought the same of Rideout when he came back after cracking his pallet by heading the back of someone's head! It takes balls to do that! I am the biggest critic of football players being a bit namby pamby, but sometimes one has to doff one's cap when it is warranted! I salute you on that score Mr Keane !

Sometimes young tough men need saving from themselves!

John G Davies
33 Posted 01/11/2018 at 12:32:34
Tony, 31,

Unlucky kid, James Vaughan. His problem was he was too brave. Seen the ball and would go through a brick wall to get it.

I met his dad on one of the away games in the Europa League. He was telling us James loved Everton, and it was a genuine remark.

Barry, 32,
Great post and all of it very true.

Stephen Williams
34 Posted 01/11/2018 at 13:08:57
What a tart! (before I get vilified, my tongue is firmly in cheek). However I can remember when men were men!

Extract from The Minute Books dated 27th October 1959 courtesy of The Everton Collection:

'It was reported that an X-ray had shown that B. Labone had broken a bone in his foot, but should be fit to play in two weeks time.'

This and subsequent minutes track our pursuit of a certain D. Law from Huddersfield Town which would eventually be blocked by a certain B. Shankley because our increasing offers weren't high enough!


I highly commend The Everton Collection website to all.

Liam Reilly
35 Posted 01/11/2018 at 17:11:58
Where were the senior players (Capt Jagielka and co) who should've noticed this in the dressing room and his performances in training.

Seems like the lad had no protection from Management and staff who insisted that he turn out despite all evidence pointing towards keeping him out and protecting him.

How can he possibly play in boots two sizes larger than his feet and expect to turn in any decent performance.

Strong character, proving his worth now and good on him.

Kristian Boyce
36 Posted 01/11/2018 at 17:40:52
A fractured skull and nearly losing a foot! Nothing like putting your body on the line playing for Everton.

Unfortunately, stories like this have been pretty regular over the years concerning some of our players and medical staff. The Michael Ball account of the shocking issues he had with his knees and the amount of painkilling injections he had springs to mind. It goes to show the lengths clubs and players themselves go to, to ensure they keep playing.

Andy Meighan
37 Posted 01/11/2018 at 18:22:32
Contrary to what some are saying on here, Keane doesn't deserve an apology off any fan.

We seen him playing shite... and so naturally, after paying good money to watch him play shite, we voiced our opinions. How were any of us to know he was playing with this injury? He's picked up this season but I for one ain't still fully convinced.

If anyone owes him an apology, it's the cretins on the medical staff who allowed him to play on with this nasty injury. I mean, it's the not the '60s or '70s, when these type of things were the norm, but the game has moved on, what with the technology the clubs have now... Isn't that why they employ these specialists???

Stephen Brown
38 Posted 01/11/2018 at 21:53:34
New found admiration for Keane! Good lad and hope he becomes next Dave Watson!
James Stewart
39 Posted 01/11/2018 at 22:19:37
Find this very strange, an injury that serious should have been taken more seriously by the club. We had other centre backs so why was he put at such risk? Especially considering his form.

A Keane/Mina partnership would never work. Too similar and neither has any pace. Zouma is fast becoming our key cb.

Ajay Gopal
40 Posted 02/11/2018 at 09:40:49
Phil (29), I was about to post a similar comment - that it is ironical that this injury should have been caused by Vaughan while he himself suffered almost the exact same injury while the opposition manager was none other than SA!! Truth is stranger than fiction. I don't exactly remember but I remember feeling so frustrated because I (didn't we all?) had such high hopes on James Vaughan. Sadly, his career never took off and he dropped deeper and deeper into the lower leagues.

Meanwhile, I believe that Keane will be our CB for many seasons to come - good lad!

Tony Waring
41 Posted 02/11/2018 at 16:23:44
Talking of injuries has anyone read the report by a certain RS centre half, name of Ruddock, who has openly admitted going out purposely to break Andy Cole's leg .actually both legs, merely because Cole and Sheringham - a mate of Ruddock's - didn't see eye to eye on most things ? What a plonker and what an admission.
Billy Roberts
42 Posted 02/11/2018 at 20:31:35
I have to admit I was moved by Michael Keanes story, the reality of his injury against our idea of his performance must have been a personal trauma in itself, but against all this the lad seems to be improving weekly. OK he's well paid and so on but I genuinely believe if Michael Keane is given time he will become a proper Evertonian favourite,
Kieran Kinsella
43 Posted 02/11/2018 at 21:13:05
Tony Waring 41

I saw that. I am hoping the worthless sack of crap is just talking to make himself look like a tough guy to his legions (?) of fans (?).

Andy McNabb
44 Posted 03/11/2018 at 06:23:23
I was hoping the days of Michael Ball's career being shortened by having to play with pain-killing injections were over. Obviously not.

Will this news temper some of the criticism of Coleman recently and I now wonder what sort of state Seamus is really in, physically? Maybe there is no way he should be near the pitch right now? They strike me as similar personalities.

Pat Waine
46 Posted 05/11/2018 at 11:39:11
The more I hear of the Koeman era, the more I detest the man. To have a player play in those circumstances is just plain bad management. Koeman done his best to wreck Everton and spent a fortune doing it.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

About these ads