02/12/2025 28comments  |  Jump to last

Everton picked up an important win against Bournemouth on the road, with Jack Grealish’s strike being the difference between the two sides.

Grealish lined up a shot from the edge of the box that took a big deflection off Bafode Diakite before beating Djordje Petrovic at his far corner 12 minutes before the end. It was his second goal for the club after he previously scored the winner against Crystal Palace at Hill Dickinson Stadium.

Everton became the first team to defeat Bournemouth at the Vitality Stadium in the Premier League this season. A 1-0 victory here puts the Blues into the top half of the table momentarily before tomorrow’s round of league games.

David Moyes will be delighted with his team’s effort following the disappointing 4-1 loss to Newcastle United at home in the previous round. He had to start Jake O’Brien at centre-back to replace Michael Keane, who was unable to play through an injury. James Garner took up O’Brien’s spot at right-back instead.

Here are the player ratings from Everton’s 1-0 win over Bournemouth:

Jordan Pickford: 7

Bouncing back from his howler against Newcastle United, Jordan Pickford seemed more like his usual self in Dorset. He provided a commanding presence inside the box and made a good save off Antoine Semenyo.

James Garner: 8

Garner has hardly put a foot wrong this season and he showed his excellent standards at right-back once again. He was a constant threat going forward and whipping in crosses from the flank. Garner was also unlucky to hit the woodwork and he was just as immense in defence, winning tackles and retrieving possession.

Jake O’Brien: 7

Thrust into the centre-back role after Keane couldn’t make it to the starting XI, O’Brien delivered a composed performance. He was aerially dominant and had a 100% success rate in duels tonight.

James Tarkowski: 7.5

With Keane missing, the onus was on Tarkowski to lead the backline. He was alert and ready to snuff out chances and put in a no-nonsense shift. The Everton vice-captain made seven clearances and won four duels against Bournemouth.

Vitalii Mykolenko: 6

Mykolenko was the least involved player in the game for his side. He looked out of sorts on a couple of occasions and entered the referee’s book for a cynical foul.

Tim Iroegbunam: 7

It was a tricky start to the game for Iroegbunam after he saw a yellow card for a late challenge on Semenyo. It was his fifth booking of the season and will miss the clash against Nottingham Forest, which further compounds Everton’s midfield misery

However, Iroegbunam redeemed himself with a strong display as the anchor in midfield. He made the most tackles and won the most duels in the contest. He also tracked back well and showed a lot of commitment.

Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall: 7

Dewsbury-Hall played in a deeper role as an 8 with Alcaraz taking up the summer signing’s usual role as a number 10. He was extremely involved in the game and always tried to make things happen. His passing and movement was clever but some of his actions lacked the final product.

Charly Alcaraz: 7 (replaced by Dwight McNeil at 80’)

Alcaraz has struggled for game time this season but he looked lively in the number 10 role. While some of his ambitious passes didn’t quite come off, he was a creative spark and did well to set up Grealish’s winner before coming off.

Iliman Ndiaye: 6.5

It was a frustrating night for the Senegalese magician who had a quiet performance for his standards. While he was a willing and hard-working runner for his side, he didn’t have a major impact in the final third and also lost possession more often than usual.

Thierno Barry: 6 (replaced by Beto at 80’)

Thierno Barry did well to impose himself physically and looked sharp in aerial duels and contests. However, his efficiency in front of goal is largely off the mark as many of the big chances and half-chances aren’t just working out for him.

Jack Grealish: 8

Grealish was a constant thorn in the Bournemouth backline, operating from the left. Andoni Iraola’s side tried to keep him at bay with physicality and making constant fouls but Grealish had the last laugh with a strike from distance that took a big deflection before nestling into the net. 

Another fantastic performance from the loan signing and the moment of him kissing the Everton badge while celebrating is bound to make fans smile.

Substitutions

Beto: N/A

Dwight McNeil: N/A

 

Reader Comments (28)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Ben King
1 Posted 02/12/2025 at 23:42:16
Superb win - have to say I'm a bit of a fickle fan at the moment: pre Fulham, I was really annoyed. Post Man Utd, I was delirious. Post Newcastle, I was proper irritated. And now post Bournemouth, I feel that Top 4 is achievable with proper reinforcements in January!!!

The reality is 6th - 12th is a very achievable realistic target. Moyes 2.0 has impressed me. Admittedly it's fine margins and we need to find ways to score goals – if we'd conceded first today, that would have been the game done.

But fair play – we've won again and coped with a threadbare squad.

Charly was poor tonight and so was Jack and Iliman.


Tim and KDH were excellent and O'Brien did well.

We need to sign Garner up asap!!!

Mark Murphy
2 Posted 03/12/2025 at 00:03:27
“I feel that Top 4 is achievable”

I'm a positive Blue but that's absolutely, certifiably, mad!

We'll finish between 8th and 12th and kick on next season.

Celebrating then bed. UTFT

Jay Harris
3 Posted 03/12/2025 at 00:16:09
I thought Jake was majestic today and by far the MotM. If I didn't know better I would have sworn Jarrad is back.

James Garner put himself about all over the pitch. I just hope he does not pick up another yellow before the deadline as that will leave us embarrassingly short.

Up front I would sooner have a lamp post than Barry. He is just as clumsy as Beto and totally ineffective against the opponents back line.

Thought Myko and Tim both had an ok game but Ndbiaye seems to be saving himself for Afcon.based on his last 2 performances.

We will need to perform better than this against Forest with no Ironbaugham.

Gaute Lie
4 Posted 03/12/2025 at 01:35:10
Why not include the manager in your ratings, Anjishnu?

Otherwise, I am always a happy camper reading your analysis.
Thanks!!

Jim Bennings
5 Posted 03/12/2025 at 06:57:49
We are definitely better suited to playing away from home where there is less expectancy and pressure on us winning.

We've just had two immense away results at places which, let's be kind, are not happy hunting grounds for us.

Forest will, as we know under Dyche, come here on Saturday and camp very deep, so that's another kind of test completely. We need to find a way to break them down, a win on Saturday and the belief really will start rolling in.

Danny Baily
6 Posted 03/12/2025 at 07:02:03
Positives were KDH and Grealish going forward, Garner and O'Brien at the back. Tim was less conspicuous midfield, although that booking means he's suspended next time out.

Illman was ineffective. Barry got closer to scoring but still doesn't look like he's got goals in him. McNeil looked well off the pace after coming on.

All in all, who cares? We need wins, and this side are delivering them. And, I'm n all but the final third, it's pleasing on the eye.

Martin Reppion
7 Posted 03/12/2025 at 07:26:09
Not surprised the defence looked fit and fresh, they hadn't played at the weekend.

I feel the comment on Mikolenko was harsh. He seemed composed on the ball and defended well.

Those still having a go at Barry should look harder during the games.

He won balls all night, his aerial presence gives us an outlet and he links well. Too good saves and a block on goal bound efforts last night was positive. When Beto replaced him, he failed to win or hold up the ball. He chases around, but the ball, if he gets to it, bounces off him.

Paul Griffiths
8 Posted 03/12/2025 at 07:37:58
8 my shapely arse.

"I don't think I played that well," said Grealish afterwards."And then Pickers [Jordan Pickford] came up to me and said, 'that was your worst game and you got the winner'.

How on earth do O'Brien and Dewsbury-Hall end up with 7?

If Grealish was 8/10, then they are both 12/10.

I know that you are not an Everton fan Anjishnu and that your commitment to this site is driven by financial and commercial priorities, but do you actually watch matches all through or do you rely on secondary comment?

I'm not sure that you are the right person to give us thought through ratings. Sorry MK, you have many balls to juggle, but please take over these ratings.

Ray Jacques
9 Posted 03/12/2025 at 09:09:54
Jim at 5.

Just to prove your observation that we do well away from home.

Since Moyes returned in January only Arsenal with 30 have more away points than Everton on 27.. No side has won more away games in that time than Everton on 8. (from the BBC app)

Oh for the days when an away win came as often as a birthday!

Top 4 is unrealistic and daft as we don't score enough goals, if we finish between 8th and 12th then that is progress without the usual checking the fixtures and trying to see where we will pick up sufficient points to survive. We will continue to have a few wins followed by disappointments such as last Saturday, so its best not to be too expectant as someone on here once said 'its the hope that kills you'

Beat Forest and hopefully pick a point up from the following two games and we will be looking upwards with a centre forward to arrive in January, but god knows from where.

I was ambivalent to Moyes coming back, but take the emotion out of it and the spiteful comments that appear demanding he be sacked after a defeat and I must admit it is beyond doubt that he has improved the team performances and results considerably.

Craig Walker
10 Posted 03/12/2025 at 09:31:00
KDH was my man of the match, closely followed by Garner. Dewsbury-Hall consistently carried the ball forwards and I thought he was the most effective of the three Holy Shinity lads. Not getting too carried away with this win, just like I don't think we could read too much into the Newcastle defeat. I think we've the nucleus of a good team but we definitely need better options up front and at right back.

I think the Forest game will be difficult because Dyche will have them fired up and I expect them to beat Wolves tonight.

Dave Abrahams
11 Posted 03/12/2025 at 09:38:56
Paul (8),

You saved me from writing my post you sent if for me. Thank you.

Clive Rogers
12 Posted 03/12/2025 at 10:01:53
I thought two players whose positions were changed played much better for it. O’Brien looked far more comfortable at CH than he does at RB and Dewsbury Hall dominated the midfield from a deeper position without losing any attacking input. Iroagbunam had an outstanding game also.
Paul Griffiths
13 Posted 03/12/2025 at 10:08:11
Dave, 11, you are always one of my go--to voices on here your approval matters to me.
Brian Harrison
14 Posted 03/12/2025 at 10:13:44
Take a bow David Moyes, since he returned I think only Arsenal have more away wins, we have won at Man Utd which is rare as hens teeth and won at Bournemouth a place no Everton manager has won and both achieved in successive away games. When I saw Tim was to start and Jake was to play his first game at CB I feared the worst, but apart from 1 shot from Bournemouth we never looked liked losing and created he better chances.. Also Moyes has done this without a striker, and is yet to play our record summer signing, I think I have seen more of that Reindeer that escaped on Southport beach, than I have of Dibling.

We are 3 points off 3rd and we haven't had our best CB on the pitch all season. Yes Moyes has his faults but what manager doesnt, I for one am delighted he came back.

Mark Murphy
15 Posted 03/12/2025 at 10:53:25
"O’Brien delivered a composed performance. He was aerially dominant and had a 100% success rate in duels tonight."

yet you gave him a seven?

What does he have to do to get a 10?

And Mykolenko a 6? Did he shoot your pet dog?

He had a more than decent game.

Apart from possibly Ndiaye every player earned at least an 8, in my opinion.

KDH, O'Brien and Garner a 9.

Paul Hewitt
16 Posted 03/12/2025 at 11:09:18
Imagine where we would be if our strikers started to score.
Dave Lynch
17 Posted 03/12/2025 at 11:13:26
Ndiaye is a marked man atm.

Teams know his creativity and double up on him, I would move him to the middle, he'd cause havoc in that position alongside KDH.

Great win last night, thought KDH was MOM and as mentioned Miko had a great game as well.

Alan McGuffog
18 Posted 03/12/2025 at 11:22:01
Paul, imagine where we'd be if we had a striker
Andrew Grey
19 Posted 03/12/2025 at 12:06:37
Thought Jack had a bit of an off night to be honest — more of a 6.5.

Tim did really well to lift himself out of the gloom and criticism from Saturday's game and played a good game.

No Deesbury-Hall, Garner and Jake 'my favourite Diabetic' O'Brien were stand out.

Jake is a bit of an Icon to me as a Diabetic as he gives me hope that I may make it to the Premier League one day! :)

Raymond Fox
20 Posted 03/12/2025 at 12:44:43
A few ratings are wrong in my opinion, but we mostly see things differently.

I'd award O'Brien an 8, Dewsbury-Hall likewise 8 and downgrade Grealish to a 7.

None of them had a bad game and the performance was a credit to them all. The manager deserves a pat on the back also, credit when its due. I'll give him a big 8. Were

Anthony Hawkins
21 Posted 03/12/2025 at 12:50:39
A few odd ratings, with the one standout being Mykolenko who, for some reason, has been berated. He did really well last night, alongside the more balanced back four. How Mykolenko only got a 6, I don't understand.

O'Brien looked way more composed and happy at centre-back.

I'd love Barry to score and been willing his shots to go in over the last two games, just to give him something go with his effort. The header against the upright was sooo close. The attempted chip over the keeper lacked the subtlety required. Beto just isn't close by comparison.

The subs of McNeil and Beto were presumably for fresh legs but neither added anything.

Ndiaye is being stifled out of games at the moment, which isn't all bad as it gives Dewsbury-Hall and Grealish space, but the team has to work out how to get Ndiaye back into the games.

Grealish had a good game but not his best. A score of 8 might be reflective of his goal, but 7 might have been closer to the mark.

Ian Wilkins
22 Posted 03/12/2025 at 13:14:22
We must sort out the Garner contract situation. I think his contract expires next Summer, he could depart on a free.

He plays several positions, some argue he's a better right
-back than centre-mid. He certainly gives us options.

He is also a saleable asset. Sort a contract out before he departs for nothing.

Frank Worrall
23 Posted 03/12/2025 at 13:25:55
Very happy and a little surprised at the result given our record at Bournemouth. Moyes probably scared the pants off a couple of the players following the Magpies horror show.

I thought Mykolenko deserved more than a 6 for his efforts and big Jake was in his element at centre-back. I have to agree with previous comments about Ndiaye, who could do with a rest rather than slogging it out in Africa. A move to an inside position might suit him better with Dibling on the wing.

Wiser heads are beginning to suss him out and he needs more space to perform his magic. Tim Iroegbunam didn't need another yellow but was at least an improvement on the his last outing. Beto useless again and McNeil remains a shadow of his former self while the rest of the team were generally okay.

If they can hold out against the big boys and not suffer more injuries, a mid-table outcome will be more than welcome.

Edward Rogers
24 Posted 03/12/2025 at 13:41:44
I thought McNeil was okay in the limited time he was on.

We're going to need him the next few weeks (although I've a feeling he may go elsewhere come the January window).

Like many, look forward to seeing how Jake & Jarread 'gel' when the opportunity arises.

Martin Farrington
25 Posted 03/12/2025 at 16:11:14
Paul and Dave. Get a Room!

ps: I agree at 8

Ian Bennett
26 Posted 03/12/2025 at 16:16:53
Ian,

There is a year option on Mykolenko and Garner. I very much doubt either are leaving on frees.

Mike Gaynes
27 Posted 03/12/2025 at 17:22:25
Paul #8, agreed.

Danny and Murph, to me, Ndiaye just looked tired. He has worked so hard this season... did you know he's the only player across Europe's top 5 leagues to lead his team in both goals and tackles?

Edward #24, I thought McNeil did great except for being muscled off the ball once. He circulated around taking passes and dishing them off, and he contributed greatly to the composure we showed in keeping possession and protecting the lead.

Ian and Ian, there is also a 1-year club option on Gana. None of those three are candidates to depart on frees. Paddy Boyland reports that contract talks with Garner are ongoing.

Si Cooper
28 Posted 03/12/2025 at 23:51:57
Echo the comments about Jake. His little bit of extra pace also effectively neutralised some instances when they tried to get attacks going.

I think Beto deserves some comment even if he can't be awarded a score. He pestered their defenders very effectively and gave them enough to worry about that they couldn't commit to a proper final push to force the equaliser.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb