Distin in apparent confrontation with travelling fans

, 10 November, 131comments  |  Jump to most recent
'They don’t seem to be happy when we don’t win or only draw'
An exchange of words between Sylvain Distin and an Everton fan at the conclusion of Saturday's frustrating draw at Crystal Palace is receiving increasing media coverage after the incident spilled over onto Twitter. The scene was captured by photographers with the player and supporters gesticulating at each other before the Frenchman was escorted back down the tunnel.

Though Distin denies there was anything to the confrontation, another supporter appears to flash him an offensive sign before the player is led away, while Jamie Daniels, the fan at the centre of the exchange, complained on Twitter that the player had accused Everton's travelling fans of a lack of support.

Distin is quoted in The Express as saying: “They don't seem to be happy when we don't win or only draw. They have to realise that we have a new manager and a new style of play and they need to be patient.”

Those comments offer a different interpretation than his immediate posts to his Twitter account after the game where he said that he could "understand the reaction of some fans," and accused the Daily Mail of mis-representing the situation.

"I know my English isn't perfect," he continued, "but I found it funny how people try to twist my words.

"And for the record, I was speaking to one single person and he knows who he is as I spoke to him face to face.

"And then people wonder why players interact with the fans. This is why, Because people twist your words and a simple chat is turned into fight."

In his tweets, Daniels told the defender not to question the support of Evertonians and claimed that Distin had compared the away fans unfavourably with the vocal Crystal Palace fans supporters.

More of the Twitter exchanges can be found at Talk Sport

Quotes or other material sourced from Sunday Express



Reader Comments (131)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Phil Walling
1 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:46:29
I've just read 'Distin went up to the barriers at the away end for what appeared to be a confrontation with a small section of the 3000 Merseysiders gesticulating in his direction.

He said later, 'They don't seem to be happy when we don't win. THEY HAVE TO REALISE WE HAVE A NEW MANAGER AND STYLE OF PLAY. THEY HAVE TO BE PATIENT.'

So there we have it. It's getting to the players as well as the fans. Just what is this 'new style' supposed to achieve except to get on every body's tits and provide a ready excuse for a piss-poor performance.

Michael Kenrick
2 Posted 10/11/2013 at 23:24:44
I recall Distin making a few uncharacteristic mistakes during the game... maybe he knew he'd had a poor one.

It does puzzle me though how they can't hold up their hands and admit, "Yes, we played poorly, we could not break them down, even though they are the poorest side in the Premier League. We need to do a helluva lot better if we are going to be worth anything this season."

Those fans pay a lot to follow the club and most of that money ends up in the pockets of the players. Methinks he should be a tad more circumspect and definitely a little more professional than to be drawn into an unseemly touchline spat with his own fans.


[ps: Lyndon — Why are we calling this an "apparent" confrontation? Isn't it blindingly obvious there was a confrontation? Or are you buying Distin's 'spin' that he was merely having a friendly chat with one of the team's adoring travelling fans?]

Derek Williams
3 Posted 10/11/2013 at 23:34:11
Much ado about nothing. The man himself says his English is not perfect and that he was talking to one specific fan (who said we know not what to Distin)

Who cares?

Typical media storm in a teacup!!

Move on

Kevin Tully
4 Posted 10/11/2013 at 23:37:37
Good - the players at this club have been earning fortunes and delivered nothing.

About time they realise that more of an effort is required.

Matty Williams
6 Posted 11/11/2013 at 00:14:16
Yeah it's all true, Mr Distin... & we hate losing derby matches as well!
Bill Gall
7 Posted 11/11/2013 at 00:03:41
Regarding Distin's comment on a new manager and style. You players are not 8-year-olds — you are professional football players who, over the years, have played under different managers using different styles.

No matter what style is used, surely you do not expect the supporters to listen to this as an excuse for poor play.

The supporters are asked to be patient while the manager brings in a new system — but don't ask them not to be critical of poor play by the team who should be comfortable with the style after pre-season training, numerous friendlies, 11 league games and a couple of cup games.

Andrew Keatley
8 Posted 11/11/2013 at 00:19:49
I think Distin has been terrific for the last 18 months or so. Some may think that he was misguided in his post-match reaction, but I like his passion and the fact that he will stand up for himself, his team and his manager. We don't have a divine right to go to Selhurst Park and win, and a draw is not a disgrace or a travesty - especially when their side shows a marked improvement from earlier performances this season. And while the team performance against Palace was lacklustre it certainly wasn't as abject as the first half against Spurs the week before.
Sean McKenna
11 Posted 11/11/2013 at 01:41:18
Because you pay money to watch a team, it does not give you the right to abuse players, no matter how badly they perform.
Paul David
12 Posted 11/11/2013 at 02:05:50
So having a new manager is the excuse for playing shite against the worst side in the league? Palace have no manager, ffs.
Colin Williams
13 Posted 11/11/2013 at 02:18:34
Distin, you were out of order big time! Do you expect our loyal fans to salute you when your shite? You make a feeble excuse about style of play and new manager, that's bollocks! Please don't hide behind a shit performance, then to blame the fans support on the day! Our fans are the most loyal you can get! There is no better!!!
No respect!!!
Drew O'Neall
15 Posted 11/11/2013 at 03:42:50
Michael and others,

Very easy to be circumspect from your keyboard, miles (hundreds/thousands of miles) away - probably a tad harder when you're walking off the pitch knowing you've had a stinker and failed to get three points from the worst team in the league.. On top of your personal disappointment and 3,000 giving you shit, you've got individuals shouting personal comments aimed at you directly.

I congratulate any player prepared to break from the safety of the group who cares enough to engage a fan.

I'll also back up Distin at every opportunity because I think he is a loyal, passionate and brave servant of the club who is on the whole circumspect, considered and humble in his public opinion making.

Darryl Ritchie
16 Posted 11/11/2013 at 03:37:41
Define loyal. I'm really not sure what you mean. If we win or play well against a club above us, it's very easy to be a Toffee. It's when we struggle that "loyalty" is needed. Every player, coach, trainer is trying to win. To believe otherwise is completely nuts.
David Pearl
17 Posted 11/11/2013 at 04:32:40
I actually respect Distin for having the bottle to speak face to face with fans like that.

The thing is that we have played shite all season and happen to find ourselves in a comfortable if not flattering position. If we are going to play a passing, possessive game then surely we should do it in the oppositions half and not on the edge of our own box. Howard to Disin or Jagielka... then back again (breath held in). It's pure luck that we haven't conceded a goal with a few near misses and last ditch tackles. Waist high back passes from Distin to Howard. Barry bailing us out. Jags nearly giving the ball away.

It's plain to see it's not working. We lack intensity and confidence in what the game plan is. I'd say we are going to get spanked against the RS as their strike force wont let us off the hook. One bright side is that the team must play with more passion and vigour - the derby might be the turning point. Last year we created chance after chance but didn't have a striker to put the ball in the net. This year we do but... we have 70% possession and only 2 shots on target.
I know which I prefer.

Jackie Barry
18 Posted 11/11/2013 at 05:21:34
Blimey, I'd been wanting a reaction from the fans for the past few years, then when we get a new manager after a few games they finally speak up? Why won't they grow a pair and question BK on the way our club is run, does my frigging head in it really does!!!!
Darren Hind
19 Posted 11/11/2013 at 05:20:48
I couldn’t agree more, David.

The Palace fans saw their team play with drive and passion, creating several clear cut chances, the Evertonians (most of whom were soaking wet and had travelled nearly 500 miles) were rewarded with a passionless performance from a team showing no desire to get forward and threaten the weakest defence in the league.

New style or no new style, nothing excuses this negativity or lack of adventure,

Many of our fans would have spent money the could’nt really afford on this miserable experience. Rather than confronting them, the whole team should have been appologising to the them for such an inept negative performance and the man who orchestrated it would have done well to have led the way.

Paul Andrews
20 Posted 11/11/2013 at 06:13:59
His English is perfect.

Fair play to him though,you get ripped and you have a go back.

At least he didn't blank it and skulk off the pitch

Tony Farrell
21 Posted 11/11/2013 at 05:53:32
You can't blame fans venting their anger. They pay a lot of hard-earned money to travel to away grounds Considering the amount of money the players are on, we as fans expect and demand our team to show passion for the shirt.

Distin has been brilliant for us over the years... clearly this system isn't suiting him or Jagielka or even Baines and Coleman.

I find it hard for anyone in the football world to criticise Everton fans away from home If the players showed half the passion the fans portray, we would be a far better side.

Phil Sammon
22 Posted 11/11/2013 at 06:23:46
Great to see some passion from the big man. And let's face it the two centre backs and the keeper are probably the three players above criticism. It's the other 8 who couldn't create jack shit for 90 minutes.

Fans have every right to an opinion - and we don't know exactly what was said here - but if they were giving him stick then he has every right to stand up for himself.

Derek Thomas
23 Posted 11/11/2013 at 06:41:15
Disclaimer; Distin doesn't seem to be the worst ever stereotype of a thick as a brick football player but...

'They don't seem happy when we lose or only draw'...

No shit Sherlock!

When you're not on 30, 40, 50K PER WEEK!

Been there rain or shine, win lose or draw for...20, 30, 40, 50, 60+ yrs.

AND schleped all the way to the depths of South London, all to watch a seriously ordinary ( the only plus being we didn't lose ) Howard excepted ( don't get many chances to say that ) across the board performance.

You're allowed to be less than best pleased.

As is said; Me thinks the lady doth protest too much.

Cure?? play 'kin better

Jim Harrison
24 Posted 11/11/2013 at 07:01:05
Howard excepted? And the last game he was crap too?

To be fair, my initial reaction at seeing the result was not publishable ( I was out and unable to watch the game ), but in hindsight the result isn't too damaging. Still only 5 points off top. The form is a bit iffy, but its really important that we don't lose when playing poorly.

Steve Pugh
25 Posted 11/11/2013 at 07:40:52
To be honest I thought the away support was rather quieter than normal. It's when the team are not performing that we need to really get behind them and give them a verbal kick up the backside. Something that Palace fans have been doing all season. Maybe that is the comparison he was making.
Brian Williams
26 Posted 11/11/2013 at 07:41:29
I can see merit in both sides of the argument.

The team were, on the whole, woeful. Lacklustre doesn't really cover it. It seemed that almost everyone had an "off day" with some "appearing" to be giving less than 100% especially when things went wrong.

The Palace fans DID drown out the away supporters most of the time but some might argue that you'll only get the fans "up for it" if the players show the same sentiment.

When people pay a good chunk of their weekly wage and give up half their weekend they expect to be able to see that the players are "knocking their pan in" at least.

From what I saw that didn't seem to be the case. A couple stood out especially (in a negative way) and what was really worrying for me is that one of them was Baines.

Oliver Molloy
27 Posted 11/11/2013 at 08:15:22
So Distin is a striker or a creative mid field general is he?
If fan,s are going to have a moan,at the very least they could get it right.
Fair play to the big man for having the balls to chat in the first place.
When you look at the results from the weekend it shows all this is no easy league.
Oh, and I,d say his English is a lot better than most of us fan,s French!
Lewis Barclay
28 Posted 11/11/2013 at 08:26:46
I was in the home stands watching the game on Saturday and for the first half I forgot there were any other Everton supporters at Selhurst.
It sorted itself out a bit towards the end of the second half but I'd say that if Distin was comparing the vocal support to the Palace fans, he might have a point.
Mark Palmer
29 Posted 11/11/2013 at 08:30:48
Everton were very ordinary bordering on poor. It was nothing to do with RM - we had all the possession but our players decided not to have a go or even shoot! Distin was wrong. The fans reaction was for the performance. We turned up but half the players didn't. Palace fans would sing and cheer at anything. I found it irritating, actually - none stop noise unrelated to what we were watching.
Can't fault their support though - and the variety of songs!
Phil Walling
30 Posted 11/11/2013 at 08:39:08
Bloody hell! If every player who'd ever taken stick sought confrontation with his critics every ground would be a bear pit.

'Having the bottle to confront fans' ? Lack of personal control, more like. But so many think the sun shines out of every player's arse. Except Ossie's, of course.

Derek Thomas
31 Posted 11/11/2013 at 08:32:20
Ollie #513...Merde!, Fat White at the Collegiate would agree with you.

Jim #503...did I say Howard was crap, did I?...no.

Martinez... My opinion, if you are arsed ( or not ) see my #509 in the Frustration Thread

Eugene Ruane
32 Posted 11/11/2013 at 08:40:02
I don't blame supporters AT ALL for venting their anger/disappointment, I certainly do/would.

That said, I imagine it'll be a long time before any player engages with supporters again after a cack performance.

And just to play Shankly's advocate - maybe the question we should be asking is why didn't the other 10 come over and attempt to explain what was going on.

Chris Ashton
33 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:07:12
Looking at this wothout rose tinted spectacles it seems the general feeling is that Distin had a below average game at times. Could this be a genuine sigh of his age catching up? At what point does Robbie drop him out of the team ala Phil Neville against Wigan last year?

Personally I think the players will be fustrated at the current performances as well. They are working hard to implement the training ground instructions and when it doesn't come off then they are bound to be aggrieved. I know it doesn't mean anyhting buut a win on saturday and a win in a fortnight and we would have been top by 3pm Saturday, or even a win last week and this week would have seen us joint top now, above the other lot and probably loking at the next 10-12 games as how far can we go. Instead we are what 7th? Lost momentum and dare I say a defeat in our next game could prove to be a gut punch if there ever was one if the teams above all win. Personally I hope the team can pick up a win because if not, it could be a very long WInter.

Trevor Lynes
34 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:20:10
If one looks at the stats, the fault does not lie with our defenders. We have lost one game so far which is less than every club except Southampton.

As usual, Distin and Jagielka have been the stalwarts of the team but do not get the glory of scoring winning goals. When a team plays badly and gets a draw, then that is an element of success. We have played better and lost games!!

It's a storm in a media teacup and should be forgotten.

Barry Rathbone
35 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:11:49
For Palace this was a monumental game, just lost their manager and looking certs to go down.

The choice is cave in or get right behind their side a classic case of defiance in adversity the stuff fans always react to.

Compare that to our fans arrogance not only were we guaranteed a win but posters on forums demanding a cricket score.

If you dish it out be prepared to have it back - well done Dizzy should have clocked the mouthy git.

Sam Jennings
36 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:29:59
So all the fans spend a fortune trekking down to London to watch Everton pass it around at the back for 90 mins and not create a single meaningful chance against effectively an upper mid table championship team. I'm a big fan of Distin but he needs to wind his fucking neck in on this one.
Steve Burgess
37 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:31:12
Distin oozes integrity and professionalism. He doesn't hide and held his hands up for the mistake in the FA cup semi final - "I take full responsibility for that goal. I think it changed the game, so I have to accept it."
The performance was poor on Saturday and whether or not he was right to address fans there and then it shows that he has the bollocks to stand up for himself and his team mates.
Pride and strength of character was key under Moyes and it will be key in this period of transition when not everything will go our way. Martinez is a bright young manager who will need time to change our style of play and build on the virtues engrained in the DNA at Goodison. Lets have a bit of patience.
Jim Bennings
38 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:48:37
I actually applaud Distin for having the guts to actually interact with fan criticism. How many times do we hear that players totally detach from what is happening on the stands?

He was big enough after his semi final cock-up to openly apologise, something I would have liked to hear the great David Moyes do after that particular game — or the time before that when he blatantly threw the Anfield Derby on a plate to them when Gerrard stole the show.

Some fans do dish out shit for no reason though. It was hardly Distin who was to blame for our lack of killer instinct on Saturday. I wonder would our skipper Jags have come out and got engaged in a discussion like that? Or the invisible Kevin Mirallas?

That is exactly what it was, a discussion. The media want to blow everything out of proportion in this country, in fact does any other country in the world do drama quite like Britain? It's the mentality of being British. Can you imagine the state this country would be in if it was hit by the typhoon the Philippines got? No, we will get a bit of snow in January and the whole place will fall to a fucking standstill again with the media going on about it being some sort of warning sign to the end of the world bla bla bla.

Distin and some fella had a few words after a heated football match... big deal. Get over it, lads.

Sam Higgins
39 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:04:29
One person we should be thanking this week is the guy that operates the prem league fixtures computer - cause I honestly don't think the derby could have come round at a better time after the dross of the last 2 matches.

If the players can't put in a shift for that one - then we will know exactly what to expect from the season ahead.

It comes to something when the highlight of those 90mins on Saturday was my very own Jimmy Savile quip - gratefully received at half time by the live matchday forum.

James Lauwervine
41 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:57:01
I am 100% behind Distin on this. I am sick to fucking death of the abusive negative shite that constantly gushes from the terraces. Well done Silvain, you've clearly had enough too.
James Brand
42 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:15:16
I like Distin and whilst I've forgiven him for handing the FA Cup Semi to Rat Boy and Liverpool, I do think he of all should people should remember it and he should be the LAST person berating the fans!

I was sat very near the altercation though couldn't hear what was said.

Put simply we were AWFUL on Saturday and if I was a player I would have done what most did, turn and walk straight down the tunnel - didn't deserve a "clap off".

Nobody was interested on Saturday - EVERY player was woeful and this passing it back to the keeper from the half way line just to "keep the ball" is infuriating!

What has happened to Mirrallas and don't get me started on Pienaar and Osman??!!

Colin Glassar
43 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:22:52
Distin, along with the rest of the team, was rubbish against palace. The fans paid good money to travel to watch that dross and have every right to complain. If Distin and the rest of them had any sense of pride, they'd get together and refund those fans out of their own, enormous, pockets.
John Zapa
44 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:15:21
Out of order Distin. A declining player who doesn't fit the way Roberto wants the defence to play. MLS next year for you son.
Liam Reilly
45 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:47:08
There are no bankers in this league this year, which is only good news. On paper we should be beating Palace, but a team that loses a Manager is always likely to get a reaction.

It wasn't a good performance but Palace didn't allow the flair players to play and to be fair there could be little argument if Palace had all 3 points with their chances.

A point gained, only one defeat all season, up there with the teams with most possession and three points off second. A little perspective is required here.

Raymond Fox
46 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:56:44
It all depends what was said and how often by 1 or more individuals.
Paying to watch the match doesn't give you the right to spout any sort of obscenity you like.

I don't blame Distin for having a word with the offenders!
What about Cantona when he fly kicked one spectator or attempted to, I forget where it was.

Justin Harvey
47 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:12:58
Having been at the game, I shared the sentiments of many fans which were utter frustration and to some extent anger at what was a lethargic performance.

I didn't think our support was that quiet, I've heard it a lot less vocal in the past and I don't agree with the whole "fair play to the big man for having a go back" idea.

Distin is a professional and in that sense needs to behave professionally. If he was being abused personally and in a way unrelated to his performance, then yes, okay, he has a right to bite back. However, in this case, I'm sure what was said was related to the team's performance and in that case as a professional he should have applauded us and walked away... maybe even taking the criticisms on board.

Steven Telford
48 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:23:46
If "ambition" pisses Distin off — he is at the wrong fucking Club!!!!!

Palace have a shite team, and our supporters have every right to make their displeasure felt. Two shots on target!

It's not 0-0 against Spurs, it's 0-0 against Palace, which is a very different story.

James Lauwervine
49 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:24:59
Actually Raymond, by coincidence it was at the same ground (taking your last comment as genuine). I was telling my boys about it on Saturday during the game (anecdotes/diversions were required). I remember at the time Cantona rocketed in my estimations. I have never bought into the idea that just because you pay to see something it gives you the right to be dish out abuse.
Chris Fisher
50 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:27:59
Once Alcaraz is fit he will be out the team any way. Martinez likes to play out from the back and of all our defenders Distin is the one struggling with this the most, he doesnt look comfortable on the ball at all. He can be a good defender but Martinez wants both a good defender and a good ball player, thats why Alcaraz was brought and thats why when he is fit Distin will be dropped.
Tony J Williams
51 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:36:10
Seriously?, 3rd clean sheet in a row and the defenders are getting the grief???

As already stated, what about the other 8 slackers who couldn't get a shot on target all game?

I appreciate that the crowd would have been baying for blood, but it's the wrong target.... perhaps it was universal and only Distin decided to speak up for the team.

Unbelievable the people on here with their faux indignation. You can bet that the fan wasn't giving suggestions on how to make the killer pass, it would have been something like, "Fuck off Distin, you fucken nugget, what the fuck are all playing at you fucken knobeads...etc" followed with the obligatory hand gestures.

Should have aimed his ire at the rest of the players

Brian Harrison
52 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:45:18
Obviously the frustration is getting to players as well as fans, is the frustration caused because we didn't win a game that we were expected to win or because of our new style of possession football. I see Pienaar stated before the game on Saturday that watching from the side he had noticed the edginess of the fans having an effect on the players. I also noticed in the Spurs game a few of our players having a go at one another if this is the case shouldn't manager look to compromise so everyone buys into the new style.

I genuinely think people want RMs style to succeed but it may have to be tweaked a little in places.

Tony J Williams
53 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:09:38
Brian, Moyes used to get grief for having no plan B. Nothing has changed. we pass, pass, pass, pass then lose possession. get it back and pass, pass, pass etc etc.

Look at Lukaku's foal against Citteh, hoof upfield, he wins the physical battle and scores. Nothing wrong with mixing it up every now and again.

Our painfully slow build up play is slower than last season, so we can tap it around the back for a while and all this does is allow the opposition to get their defence sorted and then watch our attacks fizzle out.

Martinez said he would advocate different styles, he should stick by his words because this tippy tappy shite isn't working

Brent Stephens
54 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:15:39
When I trek to an away match, I know we can win, lose or draw - generally speaking, you just have to accept that sometimes it will be lose or draw.

But maybe you don't have to accept it if the players aint giving their all. So did they give their all on Saturday? Well, a lot of poor passes etc - which might be an "effort / attitude" thing on the part of one or two, or just poor play (it happens)

Or was it down to still learning to play Roberto style, which is what some are saying - give the manager time must also mean give the players time.

Ah, shit, I've no idea.

Mark Williams
55 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:43:17
I've generally thought Martinez has done most things right. But Saturday's line-up was the first time I thought he'd got it wrong.

Starting with same line-up who were flat against Spurs (until the 2nd-half changes) who oddly enough were then were flat and slow against Palace.

Hope he learns. I'm not looking forward to the derby.

Steavey Buckley
56 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:42:03
Where Everton are going wrong that caused a confrontation with the Everton fans and Distin after the final whistle at Crystal Palace, was that the Everton fans are fed up with Everton drawing so many games this season with 3 midfield players, especially, Osman, sitting in midfield passing the ball sideways and allowing the opposition to 'park the bus' without any real effort to get at them.

The only 2 players who have showed any real desire to take the attack to the opposition and support Lukaku have been Coleman and Barkley. But that is not nearly enough. Lukaku desperately needs a strike partner to give him some space to take on just one defender. Not 2 or three, which is happening every game. That's why he has not scored for 2 games.

Andrew Ellams
57 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:58:12
Has to be Barkley and Naismith for Osman and Pienaar. We looked a much better attacking side a few weeks ago when that was the line up behind Lukaku
Colin Glassar
58 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:14:00
Andrew, I would play Mirallas up with Lukaku in the derby and start Delofeu on the right. Mirallas isn't a winger and is lost out there. My team against the rs would be:
Howard
Coleman
Jags
Distin
Baines
Barry
McCarthy
Del boy
Barkley
Mirallas
Lukaku

Let's see what happens and just go for it.

Nick Entwistle
59 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:24:23
Reminds me of when McFadden got stick because he gave back as good as he got from an Everton fan. No big deal, why deny passions?
Jackie Barry
61 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:26:22
I saw players hoofing it quite a bit on Saturday only problem is that they were so inaccurate that most of the time they were sailing out of play. I agree with mixing it up but it's no good when you can't even get the basics right.
Bill Gall
62 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:55:43
Comments on here are not disputing Distin's commitment — what they are mad about is a team that has 73% of the ball and only 2 shots on goal.

The problem seems to be with all the possession in two thirds of the pitch — there did not seem any ideas in the final third.

As in a couple of previous games (Newcastle is one that comes to mind), the system was effective. What the supporters are upset about was the lack of commitment in the final third of the game and what seemed like no enthusiasm from the team overall.

My original comment was not to use new manager and style as an excuse for the team's overall poor performance.

Tony Fearns
63 Posted 11/11/2013 at 14:20:26
Distin says the fans are frustrated in only getting a draw. No, we're not — it's the crap performances that we seem to be churning out more often than not.
Kevin Rowlands
64 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:17:14
Colin #567, serious question, why are you and others calling for Deulofeu to start in the cauldron of a Merseyside derby? The lad has had one decent run out against Stevenage 2 months ago, he came on on Saturday and was frigging awful. The couple of occasions he tried to take on a man he just simply ran into them and gave the ball away and his decision making is poor. I'm afraid he's a luxury we can't afford in such a big game, he's nowhere near ready for prime time.
Colin Glassar
65 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:33:30
Kevin, 20-30 minute cameo roles are hardly likely o bring him up to speed. The lad can at least keep the ball, something most of our players have forgotten to do, and is excellent in the counterattack.

I remember a young Wayne Rooney bursting on the scene as a 16-year-old. Deulofeu is a product of the La Masia school in Barcelona, these kids are made for 'cauldrons' like the derby. Give him a chance.

Tony J Williams
66 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:41:23
I would say that it's not the right time Colin.

The lad will get kicked everywhere and needs to be up to have a go at defending too.

He may have been brought up in the La Mesia school, but I bet you he hasn't played in the Madrid games.

Bring him on near the end, it's the best way.

Kevin Rowlands
67 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:45:37
Col, he couldn't handle the 'cauldron' of selhurst park, when he loses the ball he basically gives up and takes a leisurely strole back(see Baines and Coleman screaming at him) As you know most derbies are very physical and for the most part defensive and tight, he's nowhere near ready for that imho he'd be a complete liability.
Dave Lynch
68 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:44:29
Tony@550.

Nail squarely on head.............

Darryl Ritchie
69 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:40:32
Professional footballers are mercanaries! The club they play is just their employer, nothing more. If a certain player develops a passion towards the club — bonus.

Perhaps the solution to the "problem" is to pay each player based on his performance during a game. Kind of like a golfer or tennis player. You play poorly, you don't get paid as much. A set amount for each goal, completed pass, tackle etc.

A manager's job in the modern game is to somehow get 20 or so players, from 15 or so countries to play in the the style he wants, for 90 or so minutes.

Colin Glassar
70 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:49:37
It's a risk Tony J I know but we've been so flat lately I'd take the risk. The kid likes to showboat I know but he's the type that will get the crowd going. Remember Mirallas was having a stormer until the biter took him out of the game.
Darryl Ritchie
71 Posted 11/11/2013 at 16:13:29
What if the fans paid for the games after the final whistle; like a tip. No service... No money. That would make the directors sit up and take notice, not just the players.
Kevin Rowlands
72 Posted 11/11/2013 at 16:13:21
I dearly hope he proves me wrong Col, I agree he needs more playing time, I doubt whether his contract allows it but he'd be better off getting game time with our under 21's rather than sitting on the bench every week. Its no coincidence that our best football this season has been played when Barkley and wait for it, Naismith are starting, benching Osman and Pienaar, that would be my starting eleven.
Paul Andrews
73 Posted 11/11/2013 at 16:29:29
Mirallas is sulking playing out wide. I have thought for a long time he should be playing behind the forward in a free(ish) role.

The majority will disagree with this one: I would play Naismith wide right in the next game. Mirallas behind the forward. Leave Ossie out and play....

Howard
Coleman Jagielka Distin Baines
McCarthy Barry
Naismith Mirallas Pienaar
Lukaku.

Colin Glassar
74 Posted 11/11/2013 at 16:46:43
I hadn't really thought of Naismith Kev. Despite all his shortcomings he is a battler, maybe we could've done with him against palace. Someone who gets stuck in.
Tony McNulty
75 Posted 11/11/2013 at 16:43:46
Tony J (550) and others,

Do you remember what that lad claimed he said to Cantona at the time of the Kung Fu incident? Apparently (according to him), he ran towards Cantona and said:

"Off you go, Cantona. An early bath for you."

If anyone believes that please get in touch (I'm on Linkedin) and I can let you have some real estate in Florida at a knock down price.

Matt Traynor
76 Posted 11/11/2013 at 16:53:46
Tony M #615, the lad in question, Matthew Simmonds, may have claimed that, however when he was subsequently found guilty in a court of law it was clear he wasn't believed!

We should be grateful for the foul-mouthed yob, for the subsequent ban ruled Cantona out of the 1995 FA Cup Final. The following season he of course scored the winner!

Raymond Fox
77 Posted 11/11/2013 at 16:10:48
The first priority in the derby is to stop 'chomper', if we don't he'll destroy us the way he's playing.
I think were going to have to score because I doubt we can nil them!
Start with Barkley and Naismith instead of Osmon and Pienaar, bring them on later.
Give Mirallas a huge kick up the backside and then play him.
Caution McCarthy before game, because I can see him getting sent off.
Form usually goes out the window in these games so fingers crossed.
Steve Pugh
78 Posted 11/11/2013 at 17:38:55
What would people class as the best games/halfs that Everton have played this season. Everyone talks about the first half against Newcastle when we had a midfield of Barry, McCarthy, Barkley, Mirallas and Osman.

The last half hour against Villa with Barry, McCarthy, Pienaar, Mirallas (replaced by Nais on 80') and Osman.

The other one I keep noticing is the second half against West Ham, that time we had Barry, McCarthy, Barkley, Mirallas and Osman (replaced by Oviedo on 56')

Steve Foster
79 Posted 11/11/2013 at 18:08:51
At least the man shows passion, if he would just of laughed and walked off the pitch at the end maybe he deserves some of the grief aimed at him on here.

But some of the comments here are a total joke. Talk about glass half empty. A real nightmare of a season this aint it. Struggling at the bottom and all that.

Get over yourselves, maybe you do what you claim to do and 'support'. Seems to be far too many folk just ready to snipe and moan and groan.

Media Storm in a Teacup, get over it and move on.

Wayne Smyth
80 Posted 11/11/2013 at 18:29:57
Steve; spot on. You think we'd be in last place with no wins and having conceded a hatful the way people moan.

I've read some real grade 'A' shite posted by people in the last 48 hours. Judging by the comments, it seems many would like to see us have our manager replaced with Tony Pulis and get rid of all this 'tippy tappy shit'.

Yes, Saturday's performance and result against the league's bottom club was poor, but we'll probably play worse and get far worse results this season. We're not the only club losing points to poorer teams. This is a transitional season. New manager, new coaches, new midfield new striker, new philosophies. The fact it's been so seamless and pain free is actually quite surprising given the disruption with Fellaini/Baines a few months ago.

I think Roberto understands our play wasn't fast or incisive enough at the weekend, as he admitted in his post-match comments, but supporters should give him a chance to put it right. Obviously some people aren't prepared to give him more than 10 games to have us playing like a well oiled machine... and I find that attitude disappointing to say the least.

I don't think I'm alone in believing in what RM is trying to achieve in the medium/long term. So far as I can tell he will be buying 'footballers' who can play, not just a 6'4" beanpole for percentage football, and hopefully he'll be trying to get us to control the game. Some of our players will adapt, some will be discarded. This season is about finding out which are capable.

I for one am prepared for us to have a bit of a shitty season this season (and even next) if what he's doing sets us up for the next 5 or 10 years. When Martinez came, he said he can take us further (than Moyes did) without additional cash. He said cash only speeds up the process and that people need to be patient. Well I'm glad we have such strong supporters who are getting right behind the players and manager.

6th place after 11 games? 1 point off 4th spot? 5 points off the leaders? Ahead of Spurs who spent £100M in the transfer window, having a had our own net spend of -£13M? Get him the fuck out of here, and let's get someone in who understands what he's doing before he gets us relegated.

Ian Dickson
81 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:13:03
Very well said, Wayne.
Phil Rodgers
82 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:32:19
Cannot believe some of the utter garbage being spewed on this thread. Talk about loyalty. What about a bit of respect for a player at the age of 36 is one of the most consistent defenders in the Premier League. He has been outstanding since he has been here.

We were poor Saturday fact, but we have only lost one game all season. Let's have some fucking perspective for Christ's sake. Of all the players in the entire squad, Distin is the last person who deserves criticism.

Scott Jones
83 Posted 11/11/2013 at 18:53:24
Palace were far better organised under the caretaker manager than at anytime this season:10 men behind the ball for most of the match.

Do people really believe that Palace should go 38 games without picking up the odd point at home? Better teams than us will drop points at Palace occasionally.

Man City have lost four times this season; it's a tough league... points will be dropped. We're Evertonians — the road should be long and hard — otherwise, what's the point?

Clive Rogers
85 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:14:53
You can't teach an old dog new tricks, and obviously Roberto intends to gradually change personnel more in tune with his style of playing. Therein lies the problem. With our board there is never enough money available. Greg O'Keefe has already said there will be little available in January. He presumably has some inside knowledge. If this proves to be true, where has the £24M extra TV money and the £14M surplus Fellaini money gone?

No matter how much money comes into EFC, it seems to disappear into a black hole. The board's pockets no doubt.

Bill Gall
86 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:47:40
We are led to believe that Mr Martinez likes the set up of 3 centre backs.-- why not go 3-4-1-2 formation:

3--Jagielka--Distin--Stones 4--Coleman--Barry--McCarthy--Baines.
1--Barkley
2--Lukaka--Miraless

Joe Bibb
87 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:59:22
i like Distin I think he has been a stalwart at the club but some of those fans down in London paid nearly half a weeks wage to be there.

Would Distin or any other player pay £20,000 (roughly half their wage) and not complain if they thought what they had paid for wasn't good enough?

Mike Jones
88 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:04:19
Could be worse; we could be Man City
James Brand
89 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:19:06
All those spouting the "we didn't lose" line and "we've been beaten once this season" line will do well to remember that in my honest opinion, we should have lost 3-0 on Saturday and the scoreline would not have flattered Palace!

Yes they did play 11 men behind the ball but not when they were attacking - there was no counter attack from us, no urgency. It was so easy for Palace to defend.

I like Roberto but always knew that his over-positive spin on everything would come under scrutiny from fans annoyance when a couple of bad performances were put in.

Anyone is allowed a bad day at the office but at the very least TRY harder – there's no excuse for a lack of effort and I would single out Mirallas and Pienaar for this... I said at half time, at least with Naismith he tries hard and has a goal in him...

And whilst we are at it, can we finally put to bed this fairy tale fantasy that DelBoy is a Premier League footballer... HE'S NOT! Didn't even want the ball (McCarthy had a pop at him for this), just ran straight into the left back... like Barkley, he should be learning his trade in the Championship not at us!

James Brand
90 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:33:30
For what it's worth my line up for the Derby would be this:

Howard
Coleman Jags Distin Baines
Naismith Barry McCarthy Barkley Pienaar (only coz there's no one else!)
Lukaku

Most notable absentee: Mirallas (for me VERY over-rated player). Never thought I'd say this but at least with Naismith you get passion (handy in a derby!) and he's got a goal in him...

Kevin Tully
91 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:45:11
I'm going with Naismith for the derby - Mirallas couldn't tackle a full breakfast the way his head is at the moment.
Kevin Rowlands
92 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:39:54
Totally agree about Deulofeu, James(see my earlier posts)To even think he should be getting his first start in a derby of all games after the shite we've witnessed him serve up so far, is quite frankly laughable. My starting eleven is close to yours, my only change would be Pienaar and Mirallas, not that that fills me with much confidence though.
Phil Sammon
93 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:48:50
I don't get how people can criticise Pienaar's effort.
Andy Crooks
94 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:56:09
I like and have supported Naismith. Who'd have thought a few weeks back that some might consider him to be the answer for the derby. Amazing how a player's reputation can be enhanced by being out of the side.
Ross Edwards
95 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:06:15
I know how this will work. Some will suggest Naismith to start against the RS. If he does play and is crap, we'll have the same people going "Why did Martinez play Naismith, he's absolutely crap."

You could suggest any player you want, but if they don't play to your standard, the manager gets the blame according to some.

Steven Telford
96 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:57:31
If – big "IF" — we manage to get into to Europe, it will be by a very thin margin, a point or 2 – that's what Distan seems to not get. The hunger has to be there!

Nobody is criticising the defence for a clean sheet; however, the fact that we had a clean sheet against them is as much to do with their lack of attacking prowess than it is our defending. A carefully positioned dummy would have had them 2 up by half-time.

And our corners are Sunday league quality. 2 shots on target, lethargic play, lethargic attitude, and now this bullshit excuse that it's because we are adjusting to a new manager. Matrinez needs to drop players who don't get that every point is gold dust.

Ray Robinson
97 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:00:49
Haven't read this thread in full so apologies if I go over old ground. I can understand both points of view. Distin to my mind is a thoroughly likeable and professional blue who always gives 100%. He is right to state that Evertonians are disappointed when we fail to win matches that are deemed eminently winnable but then he is also right to point out that there are no guarantees in this league are there (e.g. Sunderland v City)?

On the other hand, the reason why we have 3,000 at every away match is that we are so passionate. It may not always be evident but, having been to about 100 away matches now, I never witness the same disappointment and anger in other supporters when the home team has dropped points against us, as I do when we have fail to win matches. It sets us apart. I came out of Villa Park a fortnight ago and Villa fans were laughing and joking. I tell you that I'd have been spitting and, when Everton lose, I sometimes feel like perpetrating some act of wanton violence - just out of frustration and disappointment. Fortunately, I don't and, being a more mature 60 years of age, the feeling soon passes and I realise that there's always the next game.

I'm sure that Distin realises the depth of feeling amongst the fans - he is intelligent and articulate. At least he has the bottle and cares enough to state his case. Now if only I were convinced that Mirallas cared as much!

Tom Bowers
98 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:01:26
It seems pretty evident the squad will not improve the league status over last season. Whilst appreciating they are still well up there after 11 games, I suspect somehow it won't stay that way.

The injuries to key players, the Baines question and the apparent lack of impact from some of the bench players (except that one glow from Osman in the Villa game) are contributing to some iffy games against lower teams.

Okay some of the other, shall we say big names are slipping up also but Everton's lack of offensive prowess is going to be a problem.

In the Derby match I cannot see much changing as RS are defending as well as the Blues but they are way ahead with scoring and so I see a 4-5-1 formation again.

Mirallas is sub-par at the moment and Naismith may be a viable option to start. However, it goes without saying that the Blues have to protect the back four from breakaways in order to contain Ratboy and company.

They need a reliable quick-footed tackler to help Barry but don't seem to have someone available to do that.

Mark Dunford
99 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:09:17
I find it odd how these threads often drift into another round of team picking.Apart from Osman/Barkley which is a fine dividing line - this was our best side. We were all frustrated on Saturday, Distin was wrong to get into a squabble with an idiot but these things happen - and like others on this page, I applaud him for having the gust to come to the crowd and then engage with people on twitter in a really sensible way. Howard made a very good save and a couple of telling interceptions. Barkley looked like our best player when he came on, but that was too late. Mirallas had a hissy fit when he was rightly subbed. From what we've seen, the boy wonder isn't especially wonderful and I'd rather have seen Naismith or Jelavic. Apart from Howard, no one comes out of this with much credit and - I have to add - Palace were awful, worse than us. Much, much worse than us. Look on the bright side, McCarthy wasn't booked - and could easily have been near the end.
Colin Grierson
100 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:24:11
A storm in a tea cup. Least said the better. End of.
Conn Prosser
101 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:40:20
Surprising for such a resolute professional to get embroiled in a handbags row with a fan. How was it going to end? "Yes Sylvan, I see your point, you are all trying to adapt to a new playing style and it isn't working, thanks for coming over for a chat, on your way..."

Martinez needs to speak up with another PR gem and say none of his players will be getting involved with sideline alterations in future and that fans have every right to vent their frustration within reason.

Craig Mills
102 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:41:15
668 & 670, James and Kevin could not agree more, Mirallias hasn't had a decent game all season, walks down the tunnel sulking because he gets subbed again against Palace. He needs dropping for someone who give a fuck, and at least shows some passion on the pitch. Step up Steven Naismith, we need a derby hero - again
Brent Stephens
103 Posted 11/11/2013 at 22:00:01
Something of a bandwagon effect, maybe, but the slowly-increasing calls for Nais to play against RS are based for some on what they see as his willingness to always run his arse off.

Roberto, screw his arse back on and get him in there.

Oliver Molloy
104 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:39:11
Can we beat the other crowd? That remains to be seen... but one player we can count on if he's picked will be Distin. If some of our more talented players played at the same level of consistency as him since we signed him then we would have much more about us.

I predict a big game from young McCarthy in this coming derby. No doubt, in this coming international break he will get a few tips from a guy who loved playing against Gerrard. A number 16 telling our number 16 how to sort him out. Ye ha!

Colin Glassar
105 Posted 11/11/2013 at 22:06:11
I've had a go at Distin on this thread as he, like the rest, was crap against palace. That's not to say he's not been one of our best players in recent years and still looks as fit as ever.
Drew O'Neall
106 Posted 11/11/2013 at 22:17:11
Expectations are dangerous, we went in to the game expecting to win and it became more and more frustrating, as many of our games against 'lower standard opposition' do, when we couldn't make the breakthrough. Anyone crying out for our exciting tactics of last year (I have no axe to grind either way) should remember this is just the type of game we were also failing to win last year under Moyes.

If you look at the game of football on the pitch without being influenced by the league standings and the media etc, we were clearly the better side and played the better football.

Palace did a good job of parking the bus and their manager has to take a lot of credit for not pressing us, like others have ineffectually recently, and playing on the counter attack.

There will be days like these, try not to get caught up in the hysteria..

Steven Telford
107 Posted 11/11/2013 at 23:34:15
"They don't seem to be happy when we don't win or only draw."

There are his words, and they portray an attitude that is indefensible for any serious club with serious ambition.

Remember when Pip said something similar about finishing 7th being an achievement for EFC – same category of attitude.

The Palace game left an open wound, and rather than facing the music by owning up to being shite, Distin comes out with this shite – salt in wound is how I took it. Pass the a guy a calculator so he can add up all the dropped points. How many draws should we have won...... it's painful to think about.

James Marshall
108 Posted 12/11/2013 at 00:07:56
To be fair to Distin, he's a defender and kept a clean sheet - what more can HE do? Not much in my eyes. The man has been a rock for us, and good luck to him confronting supporters. At least he has the bollocks to return fire.

It's not as if he's in the team to create anything or score goals.

Palace have played well in their recent games, and they defended well on Saturday. I like the fact he dared say something - I wasn't there but footballers do take a lot of stick at times which must be hard not to react to if it gets personal - 3000 pissed off Evertonians were probably pretty vocal (like I say, I wasn't there) so why shouldn't he say something back?

And what has the money he earns got to do with the price of fish!?

I don't understand why people are saying Distin was crap - I didn't notice Palace scoring any goals.

Ciaràn McGlone
109 Posted 11/11/2013 at 23:56:48
So the end game of this thread is that Naismith is a good option for the derby... Lord help us.
Kevin Rowlands
110 Posted 12/11/2013 at 00:36:38
Ciarain, its absolutely no coincidence that some of the best football we've played Naismith has been in the team, he's played in many high pressure derbies in Glasgow,and he's a far better option than a very green Deulofeu who would be a complete liability.
Mick Davies
111 Posted 12/11/2013 at 00:21:42
One idiot was making wanker gestures at Distin while the rest were applauding him; it was one so-called fan and every club has these, so it's been blown up by sewer journos who fight each other for the most lurid stories to sell their rags.

Well done, Distin, for showing he cares about our club and its fans.

James Flynn
112 Posted 11/11/2013 at 23:35:46
Brent (691) – Regarding Naismith. I appreciate it's watching-thru-my-fingers time, when the ball's at his feet. I rather him for 90 minutes than when I feel like it Mirallas or (especially) this Barca teenager we're paying to baby-sit.
Doug Nestor
113 Posted 12/11/2013 at 01:43:08
@Steven Telford (704).........Spot on..........I don't think most of these players understand that there are a lot of our Support who don't think 5th is a fantastic achievement, we remember when we were winning Titles and Cups not happy with being in the top 6.

It seems to me sometimes they are just happy to turn up and collect their wages and we should just turn up and support this......I know were not going to win every game but what you cant defend is not giving 100% commitment and effort and I don't think some of them have this season..

John Ford
114 Posted 12/11/2013 at 09:48:48
Naismith seems to have upped his game in recent times. I'd be ok with him replacing Miralles. I'd be quite concerned about Miralles leaving Coleman exposed. Miralles needs to do the boring stuff like shift his arse back into his own half when needed.

Re Mirallas and Deulofeu... does anyone else think they've been given carte blanche to just run at defenders..... seemingly in any situation, regardless of numbers/position. I'm all for our attacking players having a go, but running into two/three defenders or cul-de-sacs is just headless. We're back to the chicken scene from Rocky again. A bit of thought please, Blues.

Rob Dolby
115 Posted 12/11/2013 at 10:05:58
We have had our expectations lowered for 11 years. Roberto comes in with a positive attitude and raises hopes and all of a sudden we are getting slammed for not winning away.

People need to get a reality check. A point away from home isn't a disaster. Getting beaten at home by a relegation threatened team is. Man City, Arsenal, Man Utd and Chelsea have all had shock results this year — what makes us any different?

Trevor Lynes
117 Posted 12/11/2013 at 11:05:15
The people who moan should look at the alternatives we have. Talk of dropping Distin as he is getting older is way premature. He cannot be compared to Phil Neville who really was ready for retirement.

We have the most enviable defensive record in the division, not just this season. The defence has carried the team for years! It's the midfield that has let us down and that should be obvious to any real football fan with eyes and a brain.

Money is the difference between the teams and we are in the position of only having seven reasonable midfielders to choose from. The fact is people spout about dropping this player and that but there are no alternatives suggested apart from throwing in players who are obviously not up to it.

The youngsters we have apart from Stones and Barkley have not shown enough to warrant inclusion. Del Boy cannot be included as he is not our player. The fact is we have three players injured who are owned by us and that is not including Hibbert who could probably make the bench at a pinch.

All these fans who are so critical should look at where we are in the league and then take a deep breath and examine what money we have spent so far to support Martinez. We actually took more money in than we spent and I really cannot see any other club in the division who have done the same.

Distin is a player I really admire. He has integrity, is always super fit, consistently plays his part in the most miserly defence in the division, retains his pace and most importantly hardly ever gets booked.

The midfield we have is pretty average at best and we do not have a proper top-class playmaker. None of our midfielders would get a game at any of the top four or five teams in the league.

Our strikers do not get sufficient service in open play to be able to score consistently. That is a fact and has been for seasons. Free-scoring strikers come to our club and dry up pretty quickly. We are crying out for a really creative, ball playing inside forward who would get Lukaku, Jelavic and Mirallas scoring more often.

The defence is as good as any other team's and, to Martinez's credit, he has not tampered with it. Perhaps Alcaraz when fit will be a decent acquisition but I am sure that Martinez knows what we lack and hopefully he will be able to fix the problem/s in January if given money.

Ciaràn McGlone
118 Posted 12/11/2013 at 14:10:58
Naismith was atrocious the last few games he's played - if that's him 'upping' his game then he's worse than I thought.

Absence makes the heart grow fonder eh...well, there appears to be no other rational explanation for this up-turn in support.

Poor player.

Ken Crowther
119 Posted 12/11/2013 at 15:09:28
Most of you youngsters / Johnny-come-latelys will not be aware that we've always had this sort of "they're never satisfied" comment from our players.

Trevor Lynes (whom I saw play... once) and whose opinion I always value, and others of a similar age group may remember that the great Brian Labone once said – and I don't claim that this is a verbatim quote – "Other fans complain when the opposition get a goal, ours moan when the opposition get a kick."

Distin was probably insulted by the reaction of a disappointed travelling fan. Firstly, respect to the fan for making the trip (but that doesn't mean it's okay for you to be personal to the player) but also respect to the player for tackling the fan (in English – not his native language) to try to explain the team's point of view.

This DEFINITELY isn't the first time this sort of thing has happened, and it WON'T be the last.

Ged Simpson
121 Posted 12/11/2013 at 16:59:22
Because you earn a lot you should not speak your mind......but if you, and only you, decide to spend a load of cash travelling to a game (to keep paying the players the huge wages) you have the right to shout what the hell you want. Football in my mind doesn't give you an excuse to abandon all reasonable behaviour that you have all week.
Brent Stephens
122 Posted 12/11/2013 at 17:11:54
Ged, (and I think you're also saying this?) I'd say we've all got a right to speak our mind, regardless of what we earn or what we pay at the gate wherever the game is. But being reasonable in behaviour.

Otherwise we could end up saying "I don't think you've got a right to speak your mind on TW because you earn a lot"! Michael and Lyndon will want payslips (or evidence of banker's bonus)!

Mike Gaynes
123 Posted 12/11/2013 at 18:12:44
Doug Nestor (714), I think you and Steven are simply off target on this. Distin is a class player -- not a great one, never a star, but a pure professional -- who puts in his absolute best effort every single time he puts on the Everton shirt. I'm not sure who you're accusing of being "happy to turn up and collect their wages"... but Distin has never for a moment belonged in the category.

I would also say he's a class human being -- obviously I don't know him personally, but I've never seen him lose his composure on the pitch, always under control. So whatever that supporter said, if Distin thought it was out of line, I'm inclined to give Distin the benefit of the doubt.

Raymond Fox
125 Posted 12/11/2013 at 18:10:42
Trevor 757, couldn't agree more.

We need to see who RM brings in, in January, or should I say allowed to sign.

We do require urgently, a midfielder whose a quality footballer with an ability to score a few goals, they don't grow on trees and are liable to cost plenty, so we will have to wait and see!

Mike Gaynes
126 Posted 12/11/2013 at 19:02:23
Raymond, we have that footballer already. But he's 19 and still inconsistent, so we have to be patient with him.

Hopefully in the eight games before the window opens he will step up and prove we don't need to splash cash on another goalscoring midfielder.

Come on, Barkley.

Raymond Fox
127 Posted 12/11/2013 at 19:13:03
Mike you are correct in saying Barkley sounds just what we require, but with Gibson on the side lines, again, at the very least we need a replacement for him.

Barkley is destined to be a regular International in time, but he's not there yet.
Also Osman's best days are behind him, so unfortunately we do have a vacancy.

Steven Kendrew
128 Posted 12/11/2013 at 19:24:08
I am amazed at the fickle attitude being displayed by a number of Evertonians on this board. Here we are with a new young manager with a different style of play having just taken over a squad of players he didn't know before....and we are 6th!

Some of you sound like spoilt Manc fans, the way you carry on. Yes, it was disappointing not to have beaten Palace and our last couple of performances have been patchy and little lucky at times, but we are not doing badly and RM is learning about the team every week. I'm sure the manager and players are as disappointed as everyone else when we don't quite perform.

So lay off Distin (especially the abusive and probably drunk tit in the crowd!) and let's have some support and constructive criticism. You can't play well every week FFS!


Lenny Kingman
129 Posted 12/11/2013 at 19:30:37
Distin is most fortunate to be playing for our historic club. He's a journeyman back who has some sauce taking umbrage with Evertons fans who put real money into following their team around the country.
Eric Holland
130 Posted 12/11/2013 at 20:05:13
Well said Lenny.

Steven Telford
131 Posted 12/11/2013 at 20:11:14
Steven Kendrew #829

You say: "I'm sure the manager and players are as disappointed as everyone else when we don't quite perform."

Can't you see that the problem is precisely that some of them are "not"???


Albert Perkins
132 Posted 12/11/2013 at 20:25:59
Chelsea, Man City and Spurs went down to much lower teams. Man Utd have had the same problem. There are no really easy games in the PL. We played badly and got a point. That's my point.
Steve Pugh
133 Posted 12/11/2013 at 20:37:37
In which games did Naismith Barkley and Mirallas look good? Please tell me, I think I must have missed a game.
Mark Dunford
134 Posted 12/11/2013 at 20:44:34
Lenny (830) and Eric (832) come across like the Statler and Waldorf of ToffeeWeb. Moaning from the sidelines with nothing of any substance to contribute Perhaps, Lenny was simply on the sauce when he felt the urge to post. Who knows? Or really cares?

Mike hits the nail on the head in post (814) and - like him - I've never met Distin, but I've no doubt he has been a very good player for Everton over the years. More than worth his fee. . Doug Nester (714), Steven Telford (704) et al may just as well be the man who Distin had a go at.

We played badly. It was extremely frustrating to watch - and no doubt to play in. Time to grow up and move on from this one

Andy Crooks
135 Posted 12/11/2013 at 20:55:29
Ciaràn, it's simple really: Naismith's poor technical performances are fading in the memory. However, some think (and I intend to agree) that there was a lack of commitment from some on Saturday. Whatever his limitations, Naismith will give 100%. Now, I'd like us to have a squad in which Naismith can't be seen as "the answer"... but we are some way short of that.

Incidentally, if say Osman was to be dropped for four or five games, many (myself included) would fondly recall all that he brought to the side and how we were much better with him playing.

Finally, I don't think we are too far away from being very good. I would love to see Arteta in this team playing this style. Arteta and Lukaku would be something special. So where do we find a replacement?

Kevin Rowlands
136 Posted 12/11/2013 at 21:38:05
Steve #839 for the most part Barkley has been everything we could have asked for, I have to ask what's Roy Hodgson seeing that your not? Naismith admittedly is no world beater but the lad always gives 100% and he's improved a lot from last season, we need that commitment in the derby, as for Mirallas its a mystery, we all know he can be great and just have to hope he regains his form, I would play all three against the RS.
Steven Telford
137 Posted 13/11/2013 at 00:22:36
Mark, #840

It's unfair to classify that people who are criticising Distin may as well be the same person that "had a go" at him at the game.

I actually quite like Distin; while if I was at the game I would not have offered a round of applause for the pathetic effort we witnessed last weekend, I certainly would not have had a go at Distin personally.

My reaction has been based on his post-match comments, in which he implied we (the supporters) should appreciate draws. Draws against teams as crap as Palace no less. These sort of results are costing us European football, and if you're not willing to be a gladiator for 90 mins, Royal Blue and Price Rupert's Tower isn't for you......... is a message all the players need to be aware of.

Tony Stanley
138 Posted 13/11/2013 at 01:03:29
I was very upset with that performance, and I don't want the players criticizing the supporters for voicing their frustration.
Peter Knight
139 Posted 13/11/2013 at 06:05:56
We had a chance to go 2nd and then 4th but we could not score a goal in both games. If that had been the last two games of the season, none of us would have been happy in 6th place.

The Distin incident — I don't think he has the right to complain about the Everton fans after the FA Cup Semi-Final.

Steve Pugh
140 Posted 13/11/2013 at 07:58:45
Kevin #848, I'm not questioning them as individuals. People keep talking about the three of them playing together in the last few weeks and it being the best football that we have played, I would like to know when that was.

The best football that I have seen featured a midfield three of Osman, Barkley and Mirallas (Newcastle 1st Half), Osman, Miralles, Pienaar (Villa Last half hour), and Barkley, Mirallas, Osman/Oviedo (West Ham 2nd Half)

James Flynn
141 Posted 13/11/2013 at 12:37:43
Steven (704) - "There are his words, and they portray an attitude that is indefensible for any serious club with serious ambition."

The old Ronald Reagan "Trickle-down" theory of business. The workers creating the money should be happy with their crumbs off the table and that's that. Substitute "EFC supporters" for "workers". Same thing, right? Be happy for what we give you, Evertonians.

Roberto has talked about patience. Fine for him. He's on a big, 4-year contract. We've now had, what 5-6 players echo his remarks about said patience? Not to mention the many in here calling repeatedly for the same.

So, here we are at a point where expectations have been, openly by EFC, down-sized. For the foreseeably future, (Roberto's 4-year contract length), and we'll just have to go along. "Hold on Flynn", someone says? I say, I want the Club I support full-on to show me the same full-on with 90 minutes of effort. The scoreboard shows what it does game ending. Have to accept that. It's the way it goes.

But effort isn't a physical gift or technical skill. It's the simplest thing all of us have experienced; hard work.
Have any of us witnessed 90 minutes of that since Roberto took over? I haven't.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb