Niels Nkounkou loan ends as Liege finish 14th

Being 21, is he able to play this season without being preregistered?

Either way, with Mykolenko starting to find his feet he might find it tough again now (as Mykolenko is only 22).

It would be good if he could offer genuine competition for places on the left side. I'm not going to pre-judge. We have an expert backroom staff who know what to look for, and whom one hopes will have been keeping an eye on his performances.

He has a bit of spark and personality but doesn't look anywhere near good enough, unfortunately.

He won't improve playing 2nd or 3rd fiddle as left-back either behind Mykolenko and probably Godfrey.

For every Calvert-Lewin and Branthwaite, there will always be a few more like Sambou, Nkounkou, Gibson etc who fall short.

He's only a year younger than Mykolenko so the two of them could spur each other on next season to be better. It would be interesting to get an in-depth review of his time at Standard Liege rather than just bare statistics, ie: Are there any positives or green shoots or was he regressive?

I want to see that left foot firing some perfect crosses in next season, but not at the expense of serious defensive weakness. Has he got it in him to be better than Mykolenko, who is now looking better each game he plays?

Not sure where you're getting that from, Clive.

His stats are at Transfermarkt for all to see. He was not picked for only 2 of the last 10 games (plus one suspended for 5 yellow-cards)... so not picked to be in the squad for only 3 games of the entire season, if you include that.

The odd time he and Gordon played, they linked up very well on the left.

I know Carlo saw him as a left-back so did not fit his criteria, but I see him like John Stones, who is a natural centre half, but looks so comfortable when he plays in another position, in midfield for City.

We may still have Mykolenko, and he has come on leaps and bounds, under Cole's watch, maybe Cole can coach Niels at left-back, if Frank does not see Niels as a left-sided midfielder, there is certainly a player in Niels, still young and learning.

Like others have said, forget July, get him back to Finch Farm, get some one-to-ones with Ashley Cole, and a couple of run-outs for the U23s.

But if he has any hunger he’ll ask to come in

Can he play for us this season? Surely he could take up a spot on the bench/be an option?

Just saying...

Rules is rules. They don't always make sense.

Is he a fullback who can't defend? A midfielder who can't score? Or just an unfocused talent who needs coaching up? It was obvious before he left that there was talent there, but whether he can actually play is an open question that the loan did not answer. I agree with the general consensus -- don't wait, get him back to Finch Farm now for an intensive tutorial at Ashley Cole University and see what we've got.

Like I say that rule may have changed since last season, but going off the player only returning in July, sounds like it might still be the ruling.

I think he has something that can be worked on, with our coaching staff, now with the new 5-sub rule, could be worth keeping hold of, and let's not forget, we have just brought a professional in, for the academy.

As for scoring goals, his strengths are getting down the wing and supplying crosses, Ronnie Goodless only ever scored 2 goals for Everton, Dave Thomas 4, but both excellent crossers of the ball, and taking players on, on the wings.

Not that I am stupid enough to compare Niels in the same breath with the above two, but that he could be a very useful addition as either a left-back, or old fashioned left-winger.

With our sailing close to the wind on FFP, it's a no-brainer for me to try and work on the player and coach him, rather than allow him to go out on loan again.

Given our potential financial situation, it would be foolish not to try and develop this lad. For all we know, he could end up being a decent left mid.

We have 2 young full backs, who both I feel can also play wing back.

A shame we didn't keep Digne to provide experience, but in Ashley Cole, there are fewer modern full backs that 2 young players can learn off. Likewise young Patterson once he settles and gets a pre-season under his belt.

I'm actually content with the full backs. Now to sort out the centre backs. I've only been going on about it for 2 years or so.

We have a light squad and will be in need of some young legs with occasional upside in his movement going forward. If he claims to want to come back, he could be a valuable backup if we figure out how to cover his moves forward on the left. Godfrey seems interested in that role if he can mature into a clever covering left-centre-back.

And I should add two things on general football news: Freddy Rincon was an exciting footballer and deserves a moment of thought from anyone who loves the game. And I have lost all respect for Diego Simeone, hoping he never comes to the Premier League to practice the dark arts.

Brian #22, agreed, definitely worth the minimal gamble.

Michael #19, the rules may say he can't play, but are you aware of any that would prevent him from training at Finch Farm?

But does he still have a locker at Finch Farm?

On the training front, I don't know the rules but the likes of Jack Wilshere have floated about getting pick up games at various training clubs while not being in the squad or eligible to play.

As for Simeone, he couldn't care less whether he's respected or loathed by the world. For 11 years Atletico has been the most relentlessly motivated, overachieving club in the game. Not that he'd ever come to the Premier League, but I'd swim the Atlantic to see him manage us. We'd never be in relegation danger, that's for sure.

The Under-23s is a crap team to play these lads in. Dobbin must be bored stupid playing other teams' 16-, 17-, 18-, 19- and 20-year-olds. Especially after having first team experience and not doing badly in any of his appearances.

Get them back out on loan and let Nkounkou get a rest then back into it.

In his last 10 league games, he played in 6. in 4 of those games he played the full game. In two games he played 17 and 11 minutes respectively, presumable as a sub. Of the four games he did not play - he was not in the squad for 2 of them and twice he was an unused sub.

His contract with Liege ends 30/06/22. EFC may well need to get permission to bring him back to Finch Farm. It would be ludicrous in the extreme if he didn't train until July. I hope to see him back at FF asap.

Sad news about Rincon. On Simeone, my first view of him was negative when he made a meal of Beckhams kick although I was more annoyed with Beckham. Beyond that, as far as the “dark arts” go. Somehow these days we seem to say it’s OK to fake a foul and “earn a dive,” but on the other side of the coin we don’t tolerate an elbow, shirt pull, time wasting etc. in truth it’s all the same: cheating. Trying to push the boundaries and see what you can get away with whether it’s Maradona’s handball, Salahs diving, Terry chatting up the ref, or Athletico beating the shit out of people.To me they’re all the same and our players do it too, cynical fouling - Gomes very poorly. Gordon and Rich diving - poorly. So I don’t think we should single out Athletico because the way the way they play is boring versus say Liverpool cheating in a more aesthetically pleasing way. I’d prefer zero cheating but if it’s good for the goose …

However, unsuccessful loans does not mean a bad player. Lampard and Cole will be well aware of his talent and progress. If there’s a decent player there then they shall get it out.

If the worst happens and we fall to the Championship then squad players on very low wages like Nkounkou will become more important.

If Niels can play, it would be foolish to not have him back at (previously sponsored but now lacking sponsorship) Finch Farm, initially for the simple reason: Mykolenko could get injured in our next game.

Whether he develops depends on his ability to learn. Getting him to Finch Farm immediately would be beneficial; no reason why he cannot train with the first team that I am aware of. Lampard can make a decision on him before the start of next season, but just what I saw in his fleeting appearances with us, he has potential.

Ed #24 agreed, Gordon semi-flopped at Preston and I for one had no expectation that he was anywhere near good enough for EFC this season. In fact, if it wasn't for our financial problems last summer I don't believe Benitez would have retained him. All players are different but I hope the staff give Nkounkou a fair shake at Finch Farm before binning him off.

Bobby #31 is correct in that the U23s would add nothing to players that are good enough to play senior football, such as Nkounkou + those from our academy such as Dobbin that are training regularly with the first team.

Some may recall the example of an 18-year-old who, when he joined Tottenham Hotspur as a left-back, was, in his early days there, probably the worst player in that position in the Premier League.

He didn't do too badly after he was played further forward. His name? Gareth Bale. Who's to say young Niels won't turn out in the same way a couple of years down the line?

We can but dream, but we'll never know unless he's given a chance.

I hope Lampard has a good look. He is quick, direct, happy to beat a man wide and take the ball to the touchline. I hear the chat about defensive vulnerability, but in Lampard's 3 at the back and him as a wingback, he is defensively protected and the focus is on what he does moving forward.

However, with the signing of Patterson and Mykolenko, he has a lot of competition to go along with Coleman and Godfrey.

From a wage standpoint, he could be let go or sent on loan again which is a pity as he did show good promise.

Surely that's a good thing to keep all players on their toes knowing that they have competition for their places, none of this 'shoe in if/when fit' approach. Besides, Seamus won't be sadly to maintain fitness/availability for much longer, and he has lost a bit of pace already.

There are still questions however over Niels' defensive qualities, if they exist, of the few appearances he did make for us, he was brilliant going forward, but looked suspect when forced to defend.

But get him back into Finch Farm and training for the three months, not sitting back doing nothing – that would be lunacy. There's talent there, 2 to 3 months for Ashley Cole to teach him what is needed, and who knows?

A shame because he's a talented lad but I agree, like most modern attacking full backs defending is a weakness. However, if he's willing to learn and work hard, then he could be a real asset.

That last sentence could be said about all of our average, inconsistent players.