Tyler Onyango completes a permanent move to Sheffield Wednesday

Former Everton Academy midfielder Tyler Onyango has completed a permanent move to Sheffield Wednesday on a three-year deal following his release from Finch Farm this summer.

The 23-year-old product of the Everton Academy, who spent over a decade rising through the Blues' youth setup, secures a permanent home in South Yorkshire after a successful trial spell with the Owls.

Academy Promise & Youth Career

Joining Everton's academy in 2011 at age 8, Onyango quickly made a name for himself across the youth ranks. His imposing 6ft-5in frame, athletic build, and versatility made him a standout in Paul Tait’s U18 side before he progressed to become a regular fixture in David Unsworth's Under-21s (and Under-23s).

Representing England at the U17 level, Onyango stood out as one of Finch Farm's brightest midfield prospects, capable of driving forward from central midfield or adapting to wider defensive roles, including right wing-back. His progress was rewarded with a long-term professional contract in 2020 as he transitioned smoothly into senior squad training.

First-Team Action & Bench Appearances

Ironically, Onyango’s senior competitive debut for Everton came against the very club he has now joined. On 24 January 2021, Carlo Ancelotti handed a 17-year-old Onyango his debut as an 85th-minute substitute replacing André Gomes in a 3–0 FA Cup fourth-round victory over Sheffield Wednesday at Goodison Park.

In total, Onyango made 4 senior appearances for Everton's first team:

• 1 FA Cup appearance vs Sheffield Wednesday (January 2021)

• 3 Premier League appearances: His Premier League debut as a late sub against Manchester City at the Etihad (November 2021), was followed by brief substitute appearances against Chelsea and Aston Villa during the 2021–22 campaign.

While his pitch time in the top flight totalled under 20 minutes, Onyango was a frequent inclusion in matchday squads under managers Carlo Ancelotti, Rafa Benítez, Frank Lampard, and Sean Dyche. Across all competitions between 2020 and 2024, Onyango was named on the bench as an unused substitute approximately 25 to 30 times, missing out on further match action largely due to fierce competition in central midfield and a series of frustrating injury setbacks.

Loan Spells & Experience Away

To gain senior match experience, Onyango underwent four separate loan stints in EFL League One:

• Burton Albion (2022–23): Joined on a season-long deal, making 24 appearances in all competitions (16 in League One) before being recalled in January 2023.

• Forest Green Rovers (Jan 2023): Rejoined former Everton youth coach Duncan Ferguson, but was restricted to just 3 appearances before a serious hamstring injury prematurely ended his season.

• Stockport County (2024–25): Spent the first half of the campaign at Edgeley Park, making 10 appearances in all competitions before another hamstring injury interrupted his progress in late 2024.

• Stockport County (2025–26): Returned to Stockport on loan for a second campaign, racking up 13 appearances in all competitions, racking up 13 appearances in all competitions before this loan spell was ended by a serious hamstring injury in February.

With his Everton contract expiring in June 2026, the club opted not to extend his deal, allowing him to search for regular first-team football as it became increasingly clear he was not going to make any kind of mark on the game at the highest level.

He joins a very long line of Academy prospects who have worked their way up through the ranks only to reach a ceiling that is well below the standard required for Premier League football.

The only question for Everton is why wasn't this realized after his senior exposure 4 or 5 years ago? Why was he kept on the books of the Academy if it was obvious back then that he was never going to make the grade as a Premier League footballer?

Reader Comments (5)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()

How to get rid of these ads and support TW