Everton's comeback at Old Trafford was illustrative of a change in mindset that is underway under Carlo Ancelotti
Take yourself back to Saturday night, somewhere around 7 o’clock. You’ve just been given the Everton team news with kick-off at Old Trafford approaching.
How are you feeling? Nervous? Dreading it? Confident?
It felt different to years gone by, didn’t it? It felt a bit different to the crippling anxiety and dread pulsating through your veins that you’ve probably felt half-a-dozen times a season for most of the last 3 decades.
Even a hint of a slightly different feeling you felt is very important. And you were right to feel it.
I don’t think Everton deserved anything from that game against Manchester United. But I felt vindicated in the feeling I had pre-match that this wasn’t going to be the white flag job of years gone by. Mental fragility, inferiority complex – call it what you will, but visiting the elite in the Premier League doesn’t have anywhere near the bewildering stench it used to under Carlo Ancelotti.
The proof of that is in how the 14 players that took to the field felt a defeat wasn’t a good reflection of what they can do, rather than what they did do throughout the course of the game. Everton haven’t had that belief in themselves for a long time.
They put a stagnant narrative to one side, even the one that enveloped the game in which they didn’t perform well in. They demanded more of themselves. They battled, they tried and they didn’t dwell on what they once thought couldn’t happen.
I tweeted at 2-0 down that the team stood at a crossroads. The dilemma was playing out a feeble damage-limitation game, or actually having a go at getting back into this. How many times over the years would they have chosen the former? Every time.
To me, it felt there was a group of players that collectively felt they hadn’t done themselves justice or performed in a way that was an accurate reflection of a really good season to that point. You need only listen to Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s post match interview with Sky:
“For me we’re capable of so much more. I feel every team we come up against we can compete, we can beat them.
“When we don’t lay a glove on early on and let teams get away from us, it’s frustrating. I think the spirt and confidence we showed to get back into the game is what we’re all about and that’s what we need to show more of.”
I’m not one for the platitudes or clichés footballers usually find very steady to come out with after the event, but you believe him here, don’t you?
Everton are still enshrouded by those things that have blighted attempts at progression for many years, there’s no doubting that – see performances against West Ham, Newcastle and Leeds for proof.
However, what can’t be argued is Carlo Ancelotti is vigorously chipping away at the conventions and modern traditions we’ve depressingly grown to understand as the status quo. This is different.
Dave Downie is a sport journalist and producer at BBC 5 Live and the founder of The Blue Room podcast and website. You can get daily content, including pre- and post-match analysis and general chat about all things Everton, at The Blue Room and The Blue Room Extra.
Reader Comments (15)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
1 Posted 09/02/2021 at 16:30:44
The other thing which I noted, which is also tied to this mentality change, is the amount of rotation that Ancelotti has done in the team. In times past, our previous managers only rotated (i) out of necessity, because of injuries, and (ii) in cup games where we invariably lose the rhythm, and then the game.
Ancelotti rotates his squad, regardless of injury - some could argue that he's got a bigger squad, but he's also shown that he's prepared to give the youngsters a run-out.
And yes, we still lose the rhythm, but we are more likely to scrap by and get a result (even a win). And that comes down significantly, to mentality i.e. even if we are struggling to get some rhythm, the team is becoming harder to beat.
2 Posted 09/02/2021 at 17:04:40
We deserved a draw and whilst it would have been harsh on them we had the better chances to win via DCL and Richi.
3 Posted 09/02/2021 at 17:33:41
4 Posted 09/02/2021 at 17:35:48
Like an Aretha Franklin song.
5 Posted 09/02/2021 at 18:04:28
Watching Everton with a knot in my stomach is my default position and I suspect I would miss it.
In fact at the Easter Sunday hammering of Man Utd I only relaxed when the fourth went in. Honest to God, I seriously believe I am more drained than any of the players after the final whistle.
6 Posted 09/02/2021 at 18:26:45
Having got off to a flying start, Everton was on a poor run and had slipped to 10th with 16 points on the board.
This left us 5 points behind the joint leaders, Spurs and Liverpool, on 21 points. 3 points behind 3rd and 4th placed Chelsea and United. 2 points adrift of City and Leicester. 1 point behind WHU, Southampton and Wolves. All having played 10 games.
Many on TW were looking over their shoulders and down, rather than up.
In game 11 we drew 1-1 at Burnley. Four consecutive wins followed with home wins over Chelsea (on a 17 game unbeaten run) and Arsenal, away wins to Leicester and Sheffield United.
By game 15, this was the league table:
In the most congested fixtures of the season, we had leap-frogged to 4th. As things stand today, we are 7th but with 1 or 2 games in hand over every other team but Villa.
From the end of November to date with lesser games played, this is the points turnaround against all the teams mentioned after game 10 (+ points gained, - points lost). The number of stars against each club indicates how many games in hand we have over each one:
Spurs +6 *
Liverpool +2 **
Chelsea +1 ** (beat them in this time)
United -5 ** (drew on their patch)
City -11 * (on a club record breaking run of 13 consecutive wins)
Leicester -4 ** (4 points off them in this time)
WHU -1 ** (cough!)
Southampton +9 *
Wolves +11 ** (beat them on their patch)
Villa +1 (equal games played)
Our PL results since the end of November read:
P 11 W 6 D 3 L 2 Pts 21
You could add two FA Cup wins to that.
Carlo has achieved this with some key players missing, yet not once whimpered about his misfortune.
Very quietly, he talks up the players. Very quietly, he is instilling belief in the players talking up their qualities. His honesty is refreshing, telling the players that quality alone is not enough without spirit.
He knows when to bark. The first game after the Newcastle debacle, within 30 seconds of KO Leeds won a throw-in close to our left corner flag. Digne turned his back on the ball and Leeds almost took advantage from it. Carlo ripped into Digne, waking up the whole team.
Before half-time when DCL ran through on goal, taking the shot on when Richarlison had bust a gut to take a better position alongside him, Dom took the shot on rather than pass. Again, Carlo left him in no doubt about the play, with Dominic glancing nervously towards the touchline.
Saturday v United, all evidence is that he was calm at half-time as we trailed 2-0, asking the players to stick to the game plan, believe in their qualities and play forwards, nor backwards. Within 5 minutes we were level.
This is an extremely seasoned manager. He has possibly managed his (depleted) resources by rotation through December and January better than anyone else in the league. Gradually, he is instilling good habits, belief and spirit to a squad that previous managers in recent years have failed to do.
Whatever language he is using, it appears to be working.
7 Posted 09/02/2021 at 20:17:50
It's interesting and I'm sure we all have our own take, but the Burnley game was something of a turning point for me. We didn't get the best result and many focussed on that, but I just saw something turning. I wasn't necessarily disappointed with the performance. We went on a good run after that. Something changed. Maybe that was another occasion when Carlo barked as Jay (BRZ) puts it. He certainly did at DCL in the recent Leeds match when he had the opportunity to seal it. If not vocally, through the look in his eyes.
There is most definitely a good feel about the players; they seem happy as a collective. That is generated from the manager down.
A good point is raised in this article though; 14 players. Really we are relying on a very thin squad. We improved the quality of that squad in the summer, but with a lot of the deadwood out on loan, we are still a very thin squad. But my word they are giving us more than the thin squads of recent seasons.
Work in progress. Inevitable depressing blips like the 2 Newcastle matches and West Ham at home. But bigger picture, this just feels better on and off the pitch.
Shame the fans aren't there to see it, but then no-ones are so let's not revert to our cousins' tactics!!
8 Posted 09/02/2021 at 20:34:03
9 Posted 09/02/2021 at 21:29:47
Keep yourself in the season and in reach of the pack and you give yourself a chance. That's what we've been doing and we have a chance.
10 Posted 09/02/2021 at 22:00:35
More like Etta James, " At last "
11 Posted 09/02/2021 at 22:20:17
Those are the next and most telling steps. I will fully salute Ancelotti if/when we take them because that is what all Everton sides have failed to do for a long time, of course.
12 Posted 09/02/2021 at 22:41:50
You wont believe this mate.
I was listening to that song earlier.
13 Posted 10/02/2021 at 10:10:04
Thomas and David: Della Reece with Its Magic after the Derby game!!!
14 Posted 10/02/2021 at 15:09:36
Ferguson (not that one) could get his team up 5 places just by being there, having won everything. The team knew he could do it and believed they could.
This team are beginning to see it too - players are improving all over the pitch. Tonight is a big test - home teams are under pressure this season. Lets see if we get closer to the cup.
15 Posted 10/02/2021 at 15:35:15
What a voice that girl has got.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.